Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV
No. 013-2017-SMV/10
Summary: CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. is sanctioned with a fine of 4 UIT, equivalent to S/. 14,800.00 (Fourteen thousand eight hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred in two (02) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not timely submitting the file of intermediated amounts; and, for not timely submitting its information on margins and liquidity and solvency conditions and the real-time basic data files. The charges referring to compliance with prudential limits and submission of material events are archived.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. |
| Matter | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2016029012 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2016029012, Report No. 779-2016-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, and the defenses submitted by CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C.; and,
CONSIDERING:
- In accordance with Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
I. Facts
- Within the supervision and control activities assigned to the SMV, the timeliness of information submission by CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., hereinafter CA Perú SAB, was evaluated in order to verify compliance with the applicable regulations for the development of its functions related to compliance with its financial indicators and others;
- Through Report No. 011-2016-SMV/10.2 and Memorandums No. 261-2016-SMV/10.2 and No. 1222-2016-SMV10.2, the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities forwarded to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance the results of the evaluation of the indications of infractions by CA Perú SAB;
- As a result of the foregoing and under the provisions of the Law of General Administrative Procedure, Law No. 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, Lpag), through Official Letter No. 4333-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), notified on July 27, 2016, the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance of this Superintendency initiated a sanctioning procedure against CA Perú SAB imputing charges for having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, Lmv); the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Rai); the Manual of Technical Specifications for the submission to the SMV of Information of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 026-2012-SMV/01 (hereinafter Manual) and its amendments; and, General Management Resolution No. 041-2008-EF/94.01.2, for not having complied with:
- Timely submitting to the SMV the file containing the intermediated amounts corresponding to the month of May 2013.
- The prudential limits from May 20 to 23 and from May 31 to June 28, 2013, for having exceeded five times the net equity of the agent company regarding the limit of positions in purchase operations with deferred settlement.
- Timely submitting to the SMV the information on its margins and liquidity and solvency conditions from May to July 2013; the real-time basic data files from May 31 to August 2, 2013; and, the real-time basic data files from August 5 to 21, 2013.
- Timely communicating the material events of the company of March 5 (three events on said date), May 28 and December 5, 2015;
- It should be noted that the non-compliances indicated in literals (a), (c) and (d) of the preceding recital constitute an infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), according to which it constitutes an infraction of a minor nature to "Not timely provide, or do so incompletely, the documentation or information, other than that indicated in numeral 3.1 above, that they are obliged to provide by the regulations or by requirement of the SMV or not submit it in accordance with the technical specifications, when applicable";
- Likewise, the non-compliance indicated in literal (b) of the fourth recital constitutes an infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction of a very serious nature: "Not complying with the limit of positions in purchase operations with deferred settlement, the limit in uncovered positions or the limit of positions in foreign accounts";
- Through a writing received on August 26, 2016, CA Perú SAB submitted the corresponding defenses;
- The charges formulated against CA Perú SAB and the analysis of the facts have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 779-2016-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, item 2, of the Lpag, through Official Letter No. 6120-2016-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 779-2016-SMV/10.3 was made available to CA Perú SAB for its review;
II. Issues to Determine
- In the present administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 196, literal f) of the Lmv, Article 70 of the Rai, and Annex 16, numeral 1.2 of the Manual, for not having timely submitted to the SMV the file containing the intermediated amounts corresponding to the month of May 2013;
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 172 of the Lmv, Articles 116, 118 and 135 of the Rai and Article 1 of General Management Resolution No. 041-2008-EF/94.01.2, for not complying with the prudential limits from May 20 to 23 and from May 31 to June 28, 2013.
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 117 of the Rai and Annex 16, numeral 1.1 of the Manual, for not timely submitting the information on its margins and liquidity and solvency conditions from May to July 2013 (as detailed in the Letter of Charges); and the real-time basic data files from May 31 to August 2, 2013 and from August 5 to 21, 2013.
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Articles 97 and 98 of the Rai, for not timely submitting the material events of the company;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on CA Perú SAB for the aforementioned;
III. Analysis
3.1. Applicable Regulations
- Article 172 and literal f) of Article 196 of the Lmv provide that:
"Article 172.- Liquidity and Indebtedness Margins.- Intermediation agents must comply with the indebtedness margins and other minimum liquidity and solvency conditions that CONASEV indicates in relation to the type of operations, the term, the amount or the nature of the instruments traded and the class of intermediaries.";
Article 196.- Obligations and Responsibilities.- The obligations and responsibilities of agent companies are:
(…)
- Provide to CONASEV, with the periodicity it determines, the information concerning its activities and operations, as well as its financial statements, duly audited by auditing firms.
(…);
- For their part, Articles 70, 97, 98, 116, 117, 118 and 135 of the RAI state:
"Article 70.- Specifications.- For supervision and control purposes, the SMV shall establish through general provisions, the form, means and other specifications that the Agent must comply with regarding the preparation and presentation of the content of its information system";
"Article 97.- Definition of Material Events.- The situations, acts, facts, decisions, agreements or contingencies that affect or may affect the agent or its economic group are considered material events of the Agent. Likewise, information of the agent or its economic group, which by its nature is necessary to be reported to CONASEV for supervision and control purposes, has the qualification of material event, unless it is a matter of importance of any company of its economic group, whose information obligation corresponds to the same."
"Article 98.- Communication.- Agents must inform CONASEV of their material events within the following business day of the occurrence of the fact or act or of having become aware of it, as appropriate, in accordance with the means and forms established by CONASEV.
The General Manager is responsible for timely communicating the material events of the agent.
(…)"
"Article 116.- Margins and liquidity and solvency conditions.- In accordance with the provisions of the Law, the margins and liquidity and solvency conditions are the prudential levels and limits that Agents must comply with regarding the following concepts:
116.1. Share capital.
116.2. Net equity.
116.3. Liquidity and Solvency Indicator.
116.4. Limit of positions in purchase operations with deferred settlement.
116.5. Limit in uncovered positions.
116.6. Limit of positions in foreign accounts.
116.7. Others established by general provisions by the General Management of CONASEV.
This title establishes said prudential levels and limits, as well as the other aspects related to the same intermediaries."
Article 117.- Control and Presentation.- The Agent must keep timely control of its margins and liquidity and solvency conditions, in order to prove compliance with the prudential levels or limits established for each of them. For this purpose, the Agent must implement in its information system the necessary mechanisms and procedures.
For the respective compliance control, the Agent must present to CONASEV the final position of each day of its margins and liquidity and solvency conditions, until the following day, in accordance with the general specifications on information presentation established by the General Management of CONASEV.
If for a given day, any of the concepts or variables used for the calculation of the margins and liquidity and solvency conditions is expressed in United States dollars, it must be converted to national currency using the closing selling exchange rate of the previous day published by the Superintendency. In the case of conversion of other currencies, the General Management of CONASEV shall establish the exchange rate to be applied."
"Article 118.- Reversion period.- The Agent's non-compliance with said prudential levels and limits must necessarily be reversed within three (03) days of occurrence, except in the case of net equity deficit.
Pursuant to the provisions of the Law, the net equity deficit of an Agent must be remedied within a maximum period of thirty (30) days. In this case, the verification by CONASEV referred to in the Law shall be the sole communication of equity deficit that the Agent must make, or any control action of CONASEV".
"Article 135.- Operations with deferred settlement.- The position of an Agent in purchase operations with deferred settlement, for its own account and for third parties, results from the sum of the amounts of all operations of this type. These operations include all those whose settlement of funds must be made by the Agent within a period greater than three (03) days from execution.
At all times, the position in purchase operations with deferred settlement of an Agent must be less than 15 times its net equity. The SMV may vary this limit through a general provision.";
- On the other hand, Article 1 of General Management Resolution No. 041-2008-EF/94.01.2 changed the limit that an intermediation agent must have regarding the total amount in purchase operations with deferred settlement from 15 to 5 times its net equity, as indicated below:
"Article 1.- Provide that the position in purchase operations with deferred settlement of an intermediation agent, referred to in the second paragraph of Article 135 of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, must be at all times less than 5 times its net equity."
- For its part, Annex 16, numeral 1.1 of the Manual establishes that agent companies must submit the following files in real time: Registry of clients with basic data (when a new client is registered) and Registry of orders with basic data (The maximum period for submitting the order to the SMV with basic data, once the immediate registration in the Order System of the intermediation agent has been made, is ten (10) minutes after it is made);
- Likewise, Annex 16, numeral 1.2 of the Manual establishes as the maximum period for submitting the file of intermediated amounts monthly to the SMV, the fifth (05) business day following the close of each month;
- Preliminary issues raised by CA Perú SAB and their analysis
3.3.1 Conclusion of the present administrative procedure by application of the Principle of Opportunity
- CA Perú SAB states that the present administrative sanctioning procedure must be concluded by application of the Principle of Opportunity; this based on the reasons set forth below:
- The current administration of CA Perú SAB has contributed to overcoming the situation of disorder and illegality generated by the administration of Mr. José Eduardo Castillo Carazas (hereinafter, Mr. Castillo) former general manager and former chairman of the Board of Directors of CA Perú SAB, having requested the intervention of the SMV in order to overcome said situation.
- Due to the aforementioned intervention, the eventual damages and effects on the market have been timely neutralized and overcome, since it has proceeded to make the corrections and changes required to adapt the structure, operation and operations of the company.
- In this sense, CA Perú SAB requests that the principle of opportunity provided in Article 2 of the Criminal Procedure Code be applied supplementarily and analogically to the present administrative sanctioning procedure, in order for the SMV to archive said procedure to the extent that there has been no affectation to natural or legal persons or legal assets protected by the securities market regulations and, there has been no affectation to the public interest, to the extent that no negative impacts have been generated on the trust and credibility of the securities intermediation system.
- As support for its request to archive the present procedure, it states that the SMV's sanctioning norm does not oblige it to punish all administrative infractions, for which it states that specialized doctrine provides that it is possible not to initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure citing the authors Manuel Gómez Tomillo and Iñigo Sanz Rubiales, who state:
"From a legal point of view, a distinction must be made in the treatment that cases deserve in which the Law does not provide for the duty of the administration to sanction and those other hypotheses in which there is a norm that expressly imposes such duty.
In the first hypotheses, the validity of the principle of opportunity is unquestionable since there is no norm of a criminal or disciplinary nature that sustains the duty to pursue and sanction each and every one of the administrative infractions. Therefore, if the Administration detects their commission and does not proceed to sanction, nothing happens, nor can anything happen. Even if it were maintained, as some sector of specialized literature does, the existence of a legal duty to promote the effective sanction of each and every one of the infractions detected, since it is a duty not backed by the imposition of disciplinary or criminal legal sanctions, in case of non-compliance, finally said duty is completely diluted".
- CA Perú SAB cites that Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 034-2016-SMV/10 (hereinafter, Resolution 034-2016), which recognizes the application of the Principle of Opportunity in the form of "corrective measures" and "abstention from initiating the administrative sanctioning procedure", but that it has not applied them to the sanctioning procedure matter of said resolution since the infractions matter of such procedure were not classified as minor.
- In this sense, CA Perú SAB considers that in the present administrative sanctioning procedure, when evaluating the commission of three minor infractions, it requests the abstention from continuing with the administrative sanctioning procedure regarding such infractions since the requirements established in Article 33 of the Sanctions Regulation are met;
Analysis of the preliminary issue raised
- Regarding the fact that the present administrative sanctioning procedure must be archived by supplementary application of the principle of opportunity regulated in Article 2 of the Criminal Procedure Code, added to the fact that the SMV's sanctioning norm does not oblige it to punish all administrative infractions and other arguments indicated by CA Perú SAB, it must be indicated that the Sanctions Regulation establishes a figure similar to that of the cited Procedural Code referring to the possibility of not initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure, which implies, in light of administrative sanctioning law, not sanctioning an administered entity for the infraction committed by it;
- In this regard, the cited regulation regulates the figures of corrective measures and abstention from initiating the administrative sanctioning procedure. In the first case, they are those destined to remedy or reverse, within a determined period, the situation altered by the infraction, for which three requirements must be met jointly: a) immateriality of the infraction; b) the infraction must be typified as minor in the Sanctions Regulation; and c) the non-existence of repercussion in the market;
- Regarding the infractions observed to CA Perú SAB, it must be indicated that, in accordance with the Sanctions Regulation, corrective measures can only be issued before the initiation of the administrative sanctioning procedure, so that, having initiated such procedure in the present case, the application of such measures is not possible, especially considering that this corresponds to a power assigned to the General Intendancies of Supervision that has not been exercised in due course;
- Regarding the abstention from initiating a sanctioning procedure, the Sanctions Regulation regulates such legal figure indicating that it is a power of the general intendancies of prudential compliance to abstain from initiating the administrative sanctioning procedure, which occurs when at the time the infraction is detected it meets two requirements: a) that it has been reversed or remedied and b) that the assumptions required for the application of corrective measures are met (immateriality, that it is a minor infraction and non-existence of repercussion);
- Therefore, the request for said abstention does not correspond to be applied by the sanctioning body to the extent that it is a competence of the instructing body that has not been exercised in due course;
- In this sense, since the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation for the application of corrective measures or for the abstention from initiating the administrative sanctioning procedure are not met, it does not correspond to archive the present procedure regarding the minor infractions imputed according to the request of CA Perú SAB;
3.3.2. Concurrence of infractions
- CA Perú SAB states that having imputed one very serious infraction and three minor infractions, in application of Article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation, it requests that in the denied event that it is considered that the company should be sanctioned, the assumption of "concurrence of infractions" should be applied;
Analysis of the preliminary issue raised
- Regarding the request presented on the application of the assumption of concurrence of infractions, it must be indicated that this will be evaluated at the time of imposing the corresponding sanction;
3.3.3. Necessary consideration of the facts and circumstances indicated in its defenses
- CA Perú SAB indicates that in order to apply the lowest possible sanction, in application of the third paragraph of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation which establishes that by reasoned resolution, considering the sanction criteria indicated in said article 6, a sanction corresponding to the classification immediately lower than that provided may be imposed, the facts to which the charges imputed refer can only be explained in the context of the following circumstances:
- CA Perú SAB points out that the circumstances referring to the fact that on September 28, 2012, Credit Andorra S.A. became a shareholder of the intermediary with 51% participation in the share capital and that between that date until May 2013, under the exclusive administration of Mr. Castillo, in his capacity as Chairman of the Board and General Manager of the SAB, is when the vast majority of illicit and illegal acts that motivate the present administrative sanctioning procedure were committed.
- CA Perú SAB indicates that Mr. Castillo was responsible for the immediate and direct administration of the corporate business, being his obligation and responsibility to act within the framework of his attributions, and that only in May 2013 did Credit Andorra S.A. integrate into the corporate administration of CA Perú SAB.
- In the general shareholders' meeting of May 8, 2013, of CA Perú SAB, several agreements were adopted: to replace Mr. Castillo as general manager and Ms. Solange Ramírez as head of operations, among others; the composition of the board of directors of the company was modified, appointing new directors and leaving Mr. Castillo and Mr. Angel Buenaño Gonzales as members of said body representing the other shareholders of the company.
- On May 30, 2013, Credit Andorra S.A. hired KPMG to perform the financial review of the company at the close of May, a service that was extended on June 19, 2013, in order to include a review of the corporate accounts, aimed at evidencing fraudulent acts of the resources delivered to CA Perú SAB by its clients.
- Credit Andorra S.A. took various measures in order to strengthen CA Perú SAB patrimonially, among them, the forgiveness of debts it had for US$ 270,524.76; having requested on July 2, 2013, from its banking authority (Institut Nacional Andorra de Finances or INAF) authorization to capitalize in CA Perú SAB, financings previously granted to it for US$ 755,000.00, among others.
- On June 20, 2013, representatives of CA Perú SAB together with its legal advisors, and its auditors, KPMG, held a meeting with SMV officials in which the situation detected and actions that would be taken were reported.
- By general shareholders' meeting of CA Perú SAB of July 8, 2013, the removal of Mr. Castillo from the position of director of the company was agreed.
- CA Perú SAB and Credit Andorra S.A. provided at all times to the SMV and its officials who carried out the inspection ordered by Office No. 2873-2013-SMV/10.2 of June 25, 2013, the facilities required for their work and the required documentation.
- By general shareholders' meeting of CA Perú SAB of October 2, 2013, it was agreed: (i) to initiate legal actions against Mr. Castillo due to the serious irregularities detected in his management; (ii) to reduce the share capital of the company to zero to cover losses; (iii) to capitalize credits for S/. 4,600,733 that they had against Credit Andorra S.A.; (iv) to approve a second capital increase for S/. 4,420,312; and, to completely modify the Social Statute.
- Given the irregularities committed by Mr. Castillo, Credit Andorra took necessary actions in order to strengthen the patrimony of CA Perú SAB, such as remedying the patrimonial situation, first through a capitalization agreement and later through capitalization commitments, which immediately resolved the patrimonial situation of said agent company.
- As a product of the review of Mr. Castillo's actions, contact was made with the clients of CA Perú SAB, having signed agreements with such clients to whom the sums of money delivered to CA Perú SAB were fully reimbursed.
- CA Perú SAB has filed a criminal complaint against Mr. Castillo which led to the respective fiscal accusation, initiating a criminal process currently in progress before the Fifth Criminal Court of Lima (Exp. 2193-2015), taking into account the criminal illicit acts found according to the documentation gathered and the forensic audit report prepared by KPMG.
- CA Perú SAB states that as a result of the irregularities in Mr. Castillo's administration and the time it took for the corresponding internal reorganization process, it was inevitable to incur the deficiencies that motivate the imputations formulated in the present administrative sanctioning procedure.
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB points out that it has collaborated with the clarification of the facts and provided its greatest willingness for the correction of the facts caused by Mr. Castillo's bad administration and requests that the good faith conduct on the part of the intermediary and collaboration for the clarification of the detected irregular facts be taken into consideration.
Analysis of the preliminary issue raised
- Regarding the facts cited by CA Perú SAB which it considers determined that it incurred in the infractions subject to charges, which it also indicates were the direct responsibility of its former general manager and director of the company, Mr. Castillo, it must be indicated that according to the provisions of article 12[1] of the General Corporations Law, the company is obligated towards those with whom it has contracted and towards third parties for the acts of its representatives even when such acts compromise the company in businesses or operations not included within its corporate purpose. Likewise, it must be remembered that the subject obligated to comply with the regulations is the stock brokerage agent, regardless of the natural person who, on behalf of this, has executed the acts or generated the infractions;
- In that sense, the circumstances alleged by CA Perú SAB do not exempt from responsibility for the acts carried out by its representatives or the consequences of these, which constitute an infraction of the legal person, in this case the stock brokerage agent, supervised by the SMV, under the protection of what is imputed in the Office of Charges;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it is opportune to point out that at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed, the circumstances of the commission of the infractions will be taken into account, in particular, the fact that for these no claims formulated by clients have been presented;
3.3.4. Principles of administrative sanctioning law that the judge must take into account
- CA Perú SAB develops the principles of administrative sanctioning law contemplated in the Lpag, to which the Administration must adhere, adding that the principles that govern criminal law are applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure, as indicated by the Constitutional Court (hereinafter, the TC) in the Judgment in File No. 2050-2002-AA/TC;
- Regarding the principle of typicality or taxativity of infractions, as an expression or variant of the principle of legality, it points out that it obliges the administration to expressly and taxatively describe the material aspects of the conduct to be repressed, also prohibiting interpreting extensively and less by analogy the norms for the imposition of sanctions;
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB requests the strict application of the principle of typicality recognized in numeral 4 of article 230 of the Lpag (in accordance with literal d) of numeral 24 of the Constitution), and the observance of the right of defense and due process provided in numeral 3) of article 139 of the Constitution and in numeral 2) of article 230 of the Lpag;
- CA Perú SAB also cites the Judgment in File No. 0010-2002-AI/TC, and reiterated in the Judgment of File No. 2050-2002-AA and File No. 00156-2012-HC, which has established that the principle of legality requires not only that crimes be established by law, but also that prohibited conducts be clearly delimited by law, prohibiting both application by analogy, as well as the use of general and indeterminate clauses in the typification of prohibitions;
- Likewise, regarding this principle, CA Perú SAB cites the Spanish author Ruiz Robledo indicating that the guarantee of objectivity of sanctioning law, foundation of legal security, implies that the assumptions and consequences of a certain conduct must be determined with precision and certainty;
- On the other hand, CA Perú SAB refers that Resolution 034-2016 in its recitals 145 and 146, recognizes that in the case of those typifications of infractions, whose content must be developed by other norms, which describe the conduct that the administered must follow, in default of which it incurs in infraction, such norms describe in a precise manner the conduct to follow.
- In that sense, citing Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, CA Perú SAB considers that it presents serious deficiencies that lead to the impossibility of imposing sanctions based on them, which would incur in a vice of nullity. It states as support that the imputed infractions are not adequately typified, whose development norms suffer from deficiencies that prevent the administered from being able to know the obligation required under penalty of sanction, as it will support for each of the infractions subject to charges.
- Regarding the principle of presumption of lawfulness of the conduct of the administered, as an expression of the principle of presumption of innocence, which translates into the duty of proof of the Administration, CA Perú SAB cites literal e) of numeral 24 of article 2 of the Political Constitution of Peru, through which the Administration is imposed the obligation to presume the lawfulness of the conduct of the administered as long as there is no evidence against it, which expresses one of the aspects of the presumption of innocence.
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB cites numeral 9 of the cited article 230 of the Lpag, which recognizes the principle of presumption of lawfulness of the conduct of the administered; adding also that the presumption of innocence has given rise, in criminal law, to the recognition of the principle "in dubio pro reo", that is, that in the face of doubt or insufficiency of the evidence that does not generate certainty of responsibility in the judge, it must always favor the accused or administered, in administrative venue.
- CA Perú SAB adds regarding the principle "in dubio pro reo", the judgment of the Constitutional Court in file 0728-2009-PHC: "...37. Now it should be noted that both the presumption of innocence and the in dubio pro reo affect the evidentiary assessment of the ordinary judge. In the first case, which is something objective, it supposes that in the absence of evidence that has not been disproven, it remains intact, and in the second case, which is something subjective, it supposes that there has been evidence, but this has not been sufficient to clear the doubt (sufficiency does not refer to the quantity of incriminating evidence, but to the entity and quality that these must meet). The sentence, in both cases, will be acquittal, either due to lack of evidence (presumption of innocence), or because the insufficiency of the same – from the subjective point of view of the judge – generates doubt of the guilt of the accused (in dubio pro reo), which gives rise to the so-called acquittal sentences of first and second degree, respectively".
- In this regard, referring to the reasons described above, CA Perú SAB points out that in any case, it will correspond to the Administration the burden of proof or evidence that accredits, without any doubt, the responsibility of the administered, since if it does not exist or is insufficient for the subjective assessment of the judge, the obligation to repute as lawful the conduct of CA Perú SAB will prevail.
- On the other hand, in relation to the principle of proportionality, CA Perú SAB cites numeral 3) of article 230 of the Lpag, indicating that the proportionality between the infraction committed and the reaction that the Public Administration must apply as a sanction, is exercised according to the criteria of appreciation contained therein, which are fully applicable to CA Perú SAB.
- The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good. CA Perú SAB points out that there are no serious or irreparable damages to the legal goods protected by the securities market regulations.
- The economic damage caused. CA Perú SAB states that in its case there was no economic damage or any damage to its clients or to the securities intermediation system, having even communicated to the SMV the events that occurred committing to lift them and provide the greatest collaboration to correct the situation, so, in its opinion, it makes no sense to severely punish these infractions, including some merely formal ones.
- Repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction. CA Perú SAB points out that it is the first time it incurs in these kinds of infractions, so they must be evaluated in light of proportionality.
- Circumstances of the commission of the infraction. CA Perú SAB indicates that this has been linked to the existence of a manager who surprised and defrauded the trust placed in his management and also as a strategic shareholder partner due to his knowledge of the Peruvian market by Credit Andorra, and that it seriously affected the internal organization and control systems of CA Perú SAB which originated the infractions that are imputed.
- Illegally obtained benefit. There has been no economic benefit in favor of CA Perú SAB.
- The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender: CA Perú SAB specifies that it had no intention of disobeying the normative mandate.
- CA Perú SAB also cites the judgment of the Constitutional Court in file No. 2192-2004-AA which states that the principle of proportionality in matters of administrative sanctions:
"It implies a clear mandate to the administration (...) so that, at the moment of establishing an administrative sanction, it does not limit itself to carrying out a mechanical reasoning of application of norms, but also carries out a reasonable appreciation of the facts in relation to who had committed them; that is, it is not only about contemplating the facts in abstract, but "in each case" (...). Therefore, a reasonable decision in these cases supposes, at least:
-
-
-
- The adequate choice of the norms applicable to the case and their correct interpretation, taking into account not only a particular law, but the legal system as a whole.
- The objective and reasonable understanding of the facts surrounding the case, which implies not only a contemplation in "abstract" of the facts, but their observation in direct relation with their protagonists (...).
- Once the necessity of the sanction measure is established, because the law correctly interpreted in relation to the facts of the case that have been known and valued in their entirety so orders it, then the third element to take into account is that the measure adopted be the most suitable and of least possible affectation to the rights of those involved in the case";
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB points out that the third paragraph of article 6[2] of the Sanctions Regulation is applicable to its case, and to impose a sanction provided for minor infractions, "...even when those imputed to CA Perú SAB are serious or very serious sanctions. (SIC)";
- CA Perú SAB adds that the SMV must appreciate the conducts imputed from the prism of proportionality, as interpreted by the Constitutional Court, that is, (i) choosing and interpreting the norms applicable to each case, (ii) developing the concrete elements for each imputation valuing the conducts of CA Perú SAB, and, (iii) if it is established that sanctioning is necessary, adopting the most suitable measure and of least possible affectation to the rights of the administered;
- Finally, CA Perú SAB cites the principle of "application of the most favorable norm in time" which is recognized in numeral 5) of article 230 of the Lpag, indicating that if the typifications used for the purposes of the imputation formulated, or the norms that give content to said typifications (in the case of typifications that require such norms to describe the conduct that, if infringed, will be subject to sanction), are modified after the conduct that gives rise to the imputation, and the subsequent modification is more favorable to the accused, the administration will be obligated to resolve based on the new norm that typifies the infraction or that describes the mandatory conduct that, if breached, configures the infraction, and not based on that which was in force prior to the indicated conduct.
Analysis of the preliminary issue raised
- On the matter, it corresponds to point out that what is argued by CA Perú SAB will be taken into account at the time of evaluating the sanction to be imposed, an analysis in which the principles of the sanctioning power contemplated both in the LMV, in the Lpag and in the Sanctions Regulation will be observed;
- Charges, Defenses of the Administered and Evaluation thereof
- Of the remission of files of intermediated amounts outside the deadline
- On the matter, CA Perú SAB sent in physical form[3] the file of intermediated amounts corresponding to the month of May 2013, on June 13 of that year[4];
- According to the provisions of the Manual, the maximum deadline for remission of the monthly intermediated amounts file for May 2013 was until June 7, 2013, however, it was presented on June 13, 2013, so it would not have observed the maximum deadline indicated in the Manual for the remission of the aforementioned information;
- Therefore, CA Perú SAB was imputed the non-observance of the provisions of article 196, literal f) of the Lmv, article 70 of the Rai, and Annex 16, numeral 1.2 of the Manual;
Of the defenses
- CA Perú SAB presented its defenses on the matter indicating that it recognizes that the information subject to charges was presented on June 13, 2013, that is, outside the maximum established deadline;
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB states that the imputation formulated suffers from nullity since it is based on infractions that do not comply with the principle of legality or taxativity of infractions according to numeral 4 of article 230 of the Lpag;
- CA Perú SAB indicates the lack of typicality in the present case since the cited type requires a legal norm that establishes what information must be sent, how it must be sent and when it must be sent;
- CA Perú SAB points out that the legal norm that develops the content of the typification and that together with it describes the sanctionable conduct, requires complying with the same requirements of clarity and precision in the description of the scope of the obligation to send information that, if breached, merits the imposition of the infraction referred to in the typification under comment;
- In that sense, it states that article 196, subsection f) of the Lmv in no way refers to the report on the amounts intermediated by the agent, and less, indicates the deadline in which said information must be sent;
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB specifies that article 70 of the Rai also does not refer to the fact that the report on the intermediated amounts of the agent must be sent to the SMV, and less the deadline in which it must be done;
- CA Perú SAB specifies that, although the cited norms clearly indicate that the SMV must issue norms that establish the obligations of remission of information that the agents must comply with, which evidently must clearly describe what and when must be presented, which, in its opinion, never happened, since in the present case it is intended to sanction it with a table contained in the Manual, which only seeks to regulate technical aspects for the compliance of a previously created obligation, such as the file to be sent, the form of remission in the electronic system created by the SMV, but which, in its criteria, in no way can comprise the substantive aspects of the content of an obligation such as the presentation deadline since said deadline is not nor can it be a technical specification;
- According to CA Perú SAB, the SMV intends to sanction it for not complying with the Manual which in section 1.1 of its numeral 1, does not contain substantive obligations, but regulates the technical aspects of previously established obligations;
- CA Perú SAB concludes indicating that in case of doubt regarding the form in which the sense of the legislation must be interpreted, the interpretation that results most favorable to the accused must always be adopted;
- Likewise, it refers as circumstances to be considered as mitigating of a denied eventual sanction that CA Perú SAB lacks a record of infraction; that the facts occurred during the period immediately after the administration of Mr. Castillo, since the company sent the documentation in physical files because upon the withdrawal of the administration of this person left the company without means to send its information electronically, as was informed to the SMV;
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB points out that any deficiency occurred in the transition period has been completely overcome prior to the initiation of the present procedure and to Resolution 034-2016; that the delay of 4 business days in sending the information has not generated any prejudice; such omission has had null repercussion in the market; that it was the first to detect the irregularities and report them to the SMV; that it has not obtained any benefit for the facts subject to observation; that it has fully contributed to the clarification of these besides there being no intentionality on its part;
Analysis of the defenses
1. On the matter, it should be indicated that CA Perú SAB recognizes that it submitted the information that motivated the charges outside the maximum period established by the regulations and that the delay in submission was four (04) days beyond said period;2. Regarding the argument that the legal obligation contained in the Manual that supports the charges constitutes an infringement of the principle of legality and specificity, as it prevents clearly knowing the scope of such obligation, it should be indicated that said provision is regulated not only in the Manual but also in the Lmv and in the Rai;3. Indeed, the obligation to submit information to the regulator arises in the Lmv, expressly indicating that brokerage firms must submit to the SMV, among other things, information related to their operations and activities with the periodicity it determines, a provision that is consistent with what is stated in the Rai, which indicates that through general provisions, the SMV will establish the form, means, and other specifications for the preparation and presentation of the content of its information system;4. In accordance with the foregoing, the SMV, through a general provision and in concordance with the express faculty contemplated in article 196, subsection f) of the Lmv, by Resolution SMV N° 026-2012-SMV/01, published in the Legal Norms bulletin of the Official Gazette El Peruano on June 29, 2012, approved the Manual, whose internal provisions were published on the SMV's internet portal (Legal Norms, Intermediaries Section), and in article 2 of said resolution it was expressly indicated that:“intermediation agents must submit their information to the SMV in accordance with the provisions of the technical specifications of the Manual (…). For the submission of the files established in the aforementioned Manual, intermediation agents will have the adaptation deadlines detailed in the Annex, which is an integral part of this resolution.”;1. That is to say, the legal provision containing a mandatory and imperative obligation is fully regulated and was issued by the competent body of this Superintendency in use of the attribution contained in its Organic Law (article 1 literal a)[5]), it not being valid to affirm that the provisions of the Manual cannot establish legal obligations, since supposing this would imply that nothing stated in such manual can be considered of mandatory observance for intermediaries;2. In this sense, since a legal obligation of mandatory compliance for intermediation agents is regulated in a norm issued by the Regulator, in use of its normative attribution conferred by its Organic Law, which is also publicly known, and whose non-observance is established in the legal type contained in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, no infringement of the principle of legality and specificity alleged by CA Perú SAB is evidenced;3. Accordingly, CA Perú SAB's arguments have not lifted the
charge formulated, so it has been accredited that it has not observed article 196, subsection f) of the LMV, article 70 of the Rai, and Annex 16, numeral 1.2 of the Manual, for which it has incurred an infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes a minor infraction to “Not provide documentation or information, other than that indicated in numeral 3.1 above, in a timely manner, or to do so incompletely, to which they are obliged by regulations or by requirement of the SMV, or not to submit it according to technical specifications, when applicable”;4. Regarding the mitigating circumstances that CA Perú SAB requests to be taken into account, it should be indicated that this will be considered when evaluating the sanction to be imposed;1. On the non-compliance with prudential limits5. In accordance with the data for the calculation of corresponding indicators from May 20 to 23, 2013, CA Perú SAB incurred an excess of the limit of positions in forward purchase operations with settlement because the total amount of these operations exceeded the limit of five (05) times the net worth of the brokerage firm during the indicated days, without reversing said excess within the three (03) day period provided for in articles 118 and 135 of the Rai and article 1 of General Management Resolution N° 041-2008-EF/94.01.2;6. What was stated in the preceding numeral was observed to CA Perú SAB by Official Letter N° 2855-2013-SMV/10.2 of June 27, 2013, in which it was required to immediately report the reasons that caused the aforementioned prudential indicator to be breached;7. On July 02, 2013, CA Perú SAB reported that these excesses originated because, by error, they considered a limit of fifteen (15) times their net worth as a parameter for forward purchase operations with settlement and that once said non-compliance was detected, it was immediately corrected on May 24, 2013. On this point, CA Perú SAB indicated that from that date, the indicator for forward purchase operations with settlement remains below the limit of five (05) times the net worth. Finally, in said communication, CA Perú SAB declared having taken the necessary measures with the purpose of strengthening the firm's capital. It should be mentioned that on May 24, 2013, the aforementioned indicator was corrected;8. Likewise, it was observed that from May 31 to June 28, 2013, CA Perú SAB again exceeded the limit of positions in forward purchase operations with settlement. This non-compliance was only remedied as of July 01, 2013;9. The foregoing evidences that CA Perú SAB would have contravened article 172 of the Lmv, articles 116, 118, and 135 of the Rai, and article 1 of General Management Resolution N° 041-2008-EF/94.01.2;Defenses1. CA Perú SAB states that it indeed exceeded the limit of positions in forward purchase operations with settlement because the total amount of these operations exceeded five (05) times
the net worth of the brokerage firm from May 20 to 23 and May 31, 2013, and from June 18 to 21, 24 to 28, 2013, and that it never reached six (06) times the net worth;2. However, CA Perú SAB requests that the present charge be archived in application of the principle of benign retroactivity contemplated in article 320, numeral 5 of the Lpag, given that article 112 of the new Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by Resolution SMV N° 034-2015-SMV/01, establishes that the exposure indicator for forward operations must be less than or equal to ten (10);3. Likewise, CA Perú SAB requests that the following be considered as mitigating circumstances for a denied eventual sanction: that CA Perú SAB has no history of infractions; that the events occurred during the period immediately after Mr. Castillo's administration, any deficiency that occurred at that stage has been completely overcome as of today; that the excess never was one point above the limit of five, that is, it never reached 6 times the net worth, not being significant, so it has not generated any harm; such omission has had no repercussion in the market; that it was the first to detect the irregularities and report them to the SMV; that it has not obtained any benefit from the observed facts; that it has fully contributed to the clarification of these, and there was no intentionality on its part;Analysis of the defenses1. In this regard, it should be indicated that the new Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by Resolution SMV N° 034-2015-SMV/01, establishes in its article 112 that the exposure indicator for forward operations must be less than or equal to ten (10);2. In this sense, taking into account that the limit of positions in forward purchase operations with settlement subject to charges did not reach six (06) times the net worth of CA Perú SAB, and that the aforementioned article 112 of the new Regulation of Intermediation Agents establishes that said limit must be less than or equal to ten (10), a more favorable situation for the administered party is observed;3. It should be mentioned that although the referred article 112 came into force as of December 31, 2016, this is still a more beneficial situation for the administered party;4. For the reasons stated, it is appropriate to apply the principle of benign retroactivity contemplated in article 320, numeral 5 of the Lpag to the present case, and consequently archive the formulated charge under analysis and declare that CA Perú SAB has not incurred a very serious infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes a very serious infraction: “Not complying with the limit of positions in forward purchase operations with settlement, the limit in uncovered positions, or the limit of positions in foreign accounts”;5. In relation to the other defense arguments, it should be indicated that their analysis is not opportune in view of what was
stated in the preceding consideration;1. On the submission of information on margins and liquidity and capital solvency conditions and real-time basic data files.6. In accordance with article 117 of the Rai, brokerage firms have the obligation to submit the final position of their margins and liquidity and capital solvency conditions for each day no later than the day following the calculation date;7. In the case of CA Perú SAB, it was evidenced that it submitted information on its margins and liquidity and capital solvency indicators physically and extemporaneously, as detailed below;| No. | Period Reported | Maximum Submission Date | Date submitted by CEA Perú SAB | No. | Period Reported | Maximum Submission Date | Date submitted by CEA Perú SAB || --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- || 1 | 05/31/2013 | 06/03/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 20 | 06/27/2013 | 06/28/2013 | 07/01/2013 || 2 | 06/03/2013 | 06/04/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 21 | 06/28/2013 | 07/01/2013 | 07/03/2013 || 3 | 06/04/2013 | 06/05/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 22 | 07/01/2013 | 07/02/2013 | 07/03/2013 || 4 | 06/05/2013 | 06/06/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 23 | 07/02/2013 | 07/03/2013 | 07/03/2013 || 5 | 06/06/2013 | 06/07/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 24 | 07/03/2013 | 07/04/2013 | 07/08/2013 || 6 | 06/07/2013 | 06/10/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 25 | 07/04/2013 | 07/05/2013 | 07/08/2013 || 7 | 06/10/2013 | 06/11/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 26 | 07/05/2013 | 07/08/2013 | 07/08/2013 || 8 | 06/11/2013 | 06/12/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 27 | 07/08/2013 | 07/09/2013 | 07/11/2013 || 9 | 06/12/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 06/13/2013 | 28 | 07/09/2013 | 07/10/2013 | 07/11/2013 || 10 | 06/13/2013 | 06/14/2013 | 06/17/2013 | 29 | 07/10/2013 | 07/11/2013 | 07/11/2013 || 11 | 06/14/2013 | 06/17/2013 | 06/20/2013 | 30 | 07/11/2013 | 07/12/2013 | 07/16/2013 || 12 | 06/17/2013 | 06/18/2013 | 06/20/2013 | 31 | 07/12/2013 | 07/15/2013 | 07/16/2013 || 13 | 06/18/2013 | 06/19/2013 | 06/20/2013 | 32 | 07/15/2013 | 07/16/2013 | 07/16/2013 || 14 | 06/19/2013 | 06/20/2013 | 06/20/2013 | 33 | 07/16/2013 | 07/17/2013 | 07/18/2013 || 15 | 06/20/2013 | 06/21/2013 | 06/26/2013 | 34 | 07/17/2013 | 07/18/2013 | 07/18/2013 || 16 | 06/21/2013 | 06/24/2013 | 06/26/2013 | 35 | 07/18/2013 | 07/19/2013 | 07/19/2013 || 17 | 06/24/2013 | 06/25/2013 | 06/26/2013 | 36 | 07/19/2013 | 07/22/2013 | 07/23/2013 || 18 | 06/25/2013 | 06/26/2013 | 07/01/2013 | 37 | 07/22/2013 | 07/23/2013 | 07/23/2013 || 19 | 06/26/2013 | 06/27/2013 | 07/01/2013 | | | | |8. Likewise, it was verified that from May 31, 2013, to August 02, 2013, CA Perú SAB sent the real-time basic data files with Mr. Castillo's signature, despite the fact that, according to the communication from said brokerage firm submitted physically on June 12, 2013, Mr. Castillo resigned from the position of general manager of CA Perú SAB on May 31, 2013. Therefore, said information is not considered as submitted, given that it was not presented and signed by an authorized representative, for which
reason it would have breached Annex 16, numeral 1.1. of the Manual.9. Similarly, it was verified that from August 05, 2013, to August 21, 2013, CA Perú SAB would not have reported the real-time basic data files as indicated in the aforementioned numeral 1.1 of Annex 16;10. The foregoing evidences that CA Perú SAB would have contravened article 117 of the Rai because it would not have submitted its margins and liquidity and capital solvency conditions in a timely manner; and Annex 16, numeral 1.1 of the Manual because it did not submit the real-time basic data files in a timely manner;On the defenses1. CA Perú SAB presented its defenses on the matter, stating that it recognizes that the information subject to charges was submitted extemporaneously, that is, outside the maximum established period;2. Likewise, CA Perú SAB states that the imputation formulated regarding the submission of real-time basic data files and daily files at the close of trading corresponding from May 31 to August 02, 2013; and the sending of real-time basic data files corresponding from August 05 to August 21, 2013, lack legal validity since they are based on norms that do not comply with the principle of legality or specificity of infractions in accordance with numeral 4 of article 230 of the Lpag;3. CA Perú SAB indicates the lack of typicality in the present case since Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation requires a legal norm that establishes what information must be submitted, how it must be submitted, and when it must be submitted;4. CA Perú SAB states that this is only met with respect to the facts related to the submission of margins and liquidity and capital solvency indicators for the months of May to July 2013 (in accordance with article 117 of the Rai, which does establish the submission deadline), however, it does not do so with respect to the obligation of timely submission of the aforementioned real-time basic data files and daily files at the close of trading, since it considers that such obligation is not defined in any norm and that the Statement of Charges only indicates that they are in numeral 1.1 of Annex 16 of the Manual, which is not published, reiterating furthermore that said manual only aims to establish technical submission specifications, so it cannot be sanctioned;5. On the other hand, CA Perú SAB invokes the principle of presumption of lawfulness, since in case of doubt regarding how the meaning of the legislation should be interpreted, the interpretation that is most favorable to the accused must always be chosen;6. Likewise, CA Perú SAB requests that the following be considered as mitigating circumstances for a denied eventual sanction: that CA Perú SAB has no history of infractions; that the events occurred during the period immediately after Mr. Castillo's administration, any deficiency that occurred at that stage has been completely overcome as of today and that it submitted its information physically since the
latter, upon leaving, left the SAB without means to submit its information electronically; that the described facts have not generated any harm or damage; the facts have had no repercussion in the market; that it has fully contributed to the clarification of the facts; that it has not obtained any benefit from the observed facts; and, furthermore, that there was no intentionality on its part;Analysis of the defenses1. In this regard, it should be indicated that CA Perú SAB recognizes that it submitted the information that motivated the charges outside the maximum period established by the regulations, however, it questions the legality of the substantive norm subject to obligation and observation, with the exception of the facts related to the submission of margins and liquidity and capital solvency indicators for the months of May to July 2013;2. Regarding the argument that the legal obligation contained in Annex 16, numeral 1.1. of the Manual that supports the charges constitutes an infringement of the principle of legality and specificity, it should be noted that, as indicated in the analysis of the defenses related to the charge of submitting intermediated amounts files out of time, the obligation to submit information, its content, and its timeliness of presentation, concerning the activities and operations of brokerage firms, is expressly established in the Manual, in accordance with the provisions of article 196, subsection f) of the Lmv, and it should be indicated that its provisions (which, as already stated, was approved and published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on June 29, 2012) are published on the SMV's internet portal;3. In this sense, since the obligation to submit real-time basic data files is fully regulated, it is not valid to allege the supposed infringement of the principle of legality and specificity, for which reason, CA Perú SAB has not lifted the formulated charge, so it has been accredited that it has incurred an infraction. In this sense, it should be specified that the intermediary did not submit the daily information corresponding to orders with real-time basic data in a timely manner for 40 dates; that is, for dates between May 31 and August 02, 2013; and furthermore, it failed to submit the indicated information corresponding to 13 dates; that is, from August 05 to August 21, 2013; which means that CA Perú SAB failed to submit the information corresponding to 63 dates in a timely manner;4. It should also be indicated that the non-compliance with article 117 of the Rai has been demonstrated, regarding the untimely submission of its information related to its margins and liquidity and capital solvency indicators subject to charges, which CA Perú SAB has not questioned its non-observance; it should be indicated that the lack of timeliness corresponded to a total of 37 dates;5. Consequently, CA Perú SAB has incurred the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation,
according to which it constitutes a minor infraction to “Not provide documentation or information, other than that indicated in numeral 3.1 above, in a timely manner, or to do so incompletely, to which they are obliged by regulations or by requirement of the SMV, or not to submit it according to technical specifications, when applicable”;6. Regarding the mitigating circumstances that CA Perú SAB requests to be taken into account, it should be indicated that this will be considered when evaluating the sanction to be imposed;1. On the communication of relevant events7. As a result of the supervision actions carried out by the SMV regarding the timely submission of information to the Public Registry of the Securities Market, CA Perú SAB was observed for not having complied with reporting the following within the period established by article 98 of the Rai:8. The relevant event of March 05, 2015, referring to the agreement of the universal shareholders' meeting of the firm regarding the cessation of three directors of the firm. The deadline for communicating the relevant event was March 06, 2015, however, it was submitted on March 18, 2015.9. The relevant event of March 05, 2015, referring to the agreement of the universal shareholders' meeting of the firm regarding the appointment of three directors of the firm. The deadline for communicating the relevant event was March 06, 2015, however, it was submitted on March 18, 2015.10. The relevant event of March 05, 2015, referring to the agreement of the universal shareholders' meeting of the firm regarding the decrease in the share capital of its represented entity. The deadline for communicating the relevant event was March 06, 2015, however, it was submitted on June 08, 2015.11. The relevant event of May 28, 2015, referring to the registration in Public Registries of the agreement of the universal shareholders' meeting of the firm of March 05, 2015, regarding the decrease in the share capital of its represented entity. The deadline for communicating the relevant event was May 29, 2015, however, it was submitted on June 12, 2015.12. The relevant event of December 09, 2015, referring to the agreement of the board session of the firm that approved the Organization and Functions Manual of its represented entity. The deadline for communicating the relevant event was December 10, 2015, however, it was submitted on December 16, 2015.On the defenses1. CA Perú SAB states that it does not agree with the facts subject to charges as it submitted the observed relevant events in a timely manner, for which it attaches documentation that accredits such affirmation;2. Likewise, CA Perú SAB requests that the following be considered as mitigating circumstances for a denied eventual sanction: that CA Perú SAB has no history of infractions; that the described facts have not generated any harm or damage; the facts have had no repercussion in the market; that it has fully contributed to the clarification of the
facts; that it has not obtained any benefit from the observed facts; and, furthermore, that there was no intentionality on its part;Analysis of the defenses
1. On this matter, and after evaluating the documentation and information submitted by CA Perú SAB in its defense, it must be determined whether or not the timely submission of the observed relevant facts was complied with;
2. Regarding the relevant facts of March 5, 2015 referring to the cessation of three directors of the company and the appointment of three new directors that are the subject of charges, it must be noted that according to the letter of March 6, 2015 (file 2015008287), it is observed that CA Perú SAB informed the SMV that at the General Shareholders' Meeting of March 5, 2015 it was agreed, among other things, that the number of directors for the 2015 fiscal year of the company would be four, proceeding at that act to the designation of such directors;
3. Likewise, by letters of March 6, 2015 (files 2015008291 and 2015008293), CA Perú SAB informed of the cessation of one director and the appointment of his replacement;
4. After evaluating such documents, it is observed that although CA Perú SAB did not expressly inform the dates of cessation and start of duties of its directors, as required by Annex 9, numeral 12 of the Rai, it is inferred that of the four directors designated for the 2015 fiscal year, three of them were, in reality, ratified in office since they had been serving in that position since the 2014 fiscal year, while only one director change occurred, with Mr. Percy Yamamoto Kamida joining as replacement for Mr. Angel Alberto Buenaño Gonzales;
5. On the other hand, regarding the relevant fact referring to the agreement taken at the General Shareholders' Meeting of CA Perú SAB of March 5, 2015 on the reduction of the company's share capital, it must be noted that in the aforementioned letter of March 6, 2015 (file 2015008287), CA Perú SAB informed the SMV of such agreement in which it indicated the reasons for such reduction and compliance with the minimum capital for brokerage firms established in the Rai;
6. As for the relevant fact of May 28, 2015 referring to the registration in the Public Registries of the reduction of the share capital of CA Perú SAB, according to the agreement of the universal shareholders' meeting of the company of March 5, 2015, it must be noted that although said brokerage firm qualified such registration as a relevant fact, the content that generated it was already known to this Superintendency through the aforementioned letter of March 6 of that year, in addition to the fact that it was subject to evaluation and issuance of the Resolution of the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities No. 049-2015-SMV/10.2;
7. Finally, regarding the relevant fact of December 9, 2015 referring to the agreement of the company's board of directors that approved the Organization and Functions Manual of CA Perú SAB, said brokerage firm has submitted a copy of the letter received on December 10, 2015 (file No. 2015047926) by which it informed the SMV, among others, of the approval of the aforementioned Manual, that is, the day after such approval occurred;
8. In this sense, given the considerations indicated above, CA Perú SAB has disproved the charge formulated, so it has not incurred an infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction of a minor nature to “Not communicate relevant facts or not do so within the period established by the regulations”;
IV. Evaluation of the Sanction
- According to article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the Lmv and numeral 3 of article 230 of the Lpag, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the contribution of the offender to its clarification, and the exemptions and attenuating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A of the Lpag;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Background of the offenders; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, which includes the repercussion on the market; c) The economic damage caused; d) Recidivism; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegally obtained benefit; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender; h) the probability of detection of the infraction; i) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender to its clarification; j) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to the notification of the corresponding charges; and k) The error induced by the administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision;
- Regarding the background of the offender, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the current Sanctions Regulation, sanctions imposed by the SMV that have become final within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction constitute background. From the review carried out in said period, it has been verified that CA Perú SAB does not present a sanction background;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, it must be noted that there is an affectation to the public interest insofar as CA Perú SAB has violated the provisions of the Lmv, the Rai whose purpose, in addition to the protection of investors, is to provide information to the regulator about its activities and operations to be carried out in the securities market. On the other hand, it has not been possible to notice that there has been a repercussion on the market;
- Additionally, it should be noted that not providing in a timely manner the file corresponding to the intermediated amounts; the information on its margins and liquidity and solvency indicators; and, the basic data files in real time prevents the performance of the supervision work by the SMV, and may even affect the protection that the regulations provide to the investor, in particular having entities that comply with the minimum standards required for their equity;
- It should be noted that compliance with liquidity and solvency margins aims at the orderly and sustained development of the securities market through the presence of intermediation agents that have sufficient equity and financial backing, which allows them to face the risks inherent in their activity and avoid harm to their clients, in particular, and to the market, in general; therefore, not providing the SMV with information on the levels and prudential limits established by the regulations affects its supervision and control work, which limits the achievement of objectives linked to the protection of investors, as well as the stability of the securities market;
- The importance of the foregoing can be seen in the new Intermediaries Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01, which in its article 103 establishes that in the case an intermediary does not submit information on its liquidity and solvency margins within the established period, it is understood that it does not comply with said limits, which would lead to the agent being automatically prevented from carrying out the intermediation process;
- Likewise, in the present case it must be noted that between May 31, 2013 and June 28, 2013, a period in which information on liquidity and solvency margins for 21 dates was not submitted in a timely manner, CA Perú SAB recorded a negative net equity, which, being an indication of the intermediary's capacity regarding its liquid resources, in addition to not having been timely submitted to the regulator, was also not timely disseminated to the market; insofar as for dates such as May 31 and June 28, 2013, such information is published on the SMV portal, www.smv.gob.pe, as it is submitted to the SMV; therefore, the principle of transparency of information has additionally been affected;
- On the other hand, information such as orders with basic data that must be submitted to the SMV in real time constitutes a source from which the regulator aims to timely detect possible situations of market abuse practices, so the non-submission of such information or its lack of timeliness in sending affects the fulfillment of said objective and therefore, the integrity of the market;
- Regarding the economic damage caused, it has not been possible to evidence that the actions of CA Perú SAB have caused a concrete economic damage to market participants;
- With reference to recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within one (01) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction, it must be stated that it is not observed that in the present case the assumptions that could constitute recidivism of the infractions subject of this resolution are present;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it must be mentioned that the infraction detected to CA Perú SAB referring to the submission of intermediated amounts files arose in attention to the supervision work due to the lack of presentation of said information referring to the month of May 2013, which originated the respective requirement, a situation that was attended by the brokerage firm but extemporaneously. In this sense, the probability of detection of the infractions committed was possible as a result of the supervision and control actions of the SMV;
- In particular, regarding the infraction on submission of information for the calculation of liquidity and solvency indicators and presentation of basic data files in real time, in 37 and 63 occasions, respectively, it should be noted that this superintendency, in its supervision work, observed the presentation of such information, evidencing the delay incurred;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, regarding the fact that the infractions subject of charges were incurred in the period immediately following the end of the management of its former general manager and director of the company, Mr. Castillo (occurred on May 23, 2013), it must be noted that this does not exempt them from the responsibility incurred, especially considering that the events occurred between June and August 2013 when Mr. Castillo was no longer managing the brokerage firm;
- In this sense, the circumstances alleged by CA Perú SAB do not exempt it from responsibility for obligations generated by the Lmv, the Rai and the Manual;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, it has not been accredited in this procedure that CA Perú SAB has obtained any benefit by incurring the imputed infractions;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, it must be specified that no intentionality has been evidenced in the conduct of CA Perú SAB regarding the infractions under analysis;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infractions and the contribution of the offender to its clarification, it must be noted that CA Perú SAB in its defense has recognized the facts that led to the commission of the infractions imputed as charges, that is, it has recognized that the sending of information was late, and has contributed to the clarification of the facts by indicating the circumstances in which the infractions were committed; which constitutes conditions of attenuating circumstances of responsibility for the infractions committed;
- As for the exempting condition of responsibility for the infractions committed by the voluntary correction of the presentation of information prior to the notification of the charge letter, it must be noted that the recognition of the exemption will depend on the constitutive elements of the infraction type, insofar as literal f) of article 236–A of the LPAG establishes as an exemption from responsibility the voluntary correction of the act or omission imputed as constitutive of infraction; that is, what must be corrected is the imputed act or omission itself, not the consequences of the regulatory infraction
- In this regard, in this sanctioning procedure, the infractions on timely presentation of periodic or eventual information correspond to the infraction type contained in numeral 3.6 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation which states that it constitutes an infraction of a minor nature to “Not provide in a timely manner, or do so incompletely, the documentation or information, other than that indicated in numeral 3.1 above, that they are obliged to provide by the regulations or by requirement of the SMV or not submit it in accordance with the technical specifications, when applicable”;
- In this sense, the constitutive elements of the infraction on timely presentation (without prejudice that the referred numeral 3.6 contains more than one infraction type) refer to the delivery of information and/or documentation within a determined period, therefore, in this specific type of infraction the lack of timely presentation could not be corrected with an extemporaneous presentation; therefore, as mentioned, the norm does not contemplate as an exemption the correction of the damage caused by the infraction; but rather requires the correction of the facts or omissions that constitute the imputable infraction. Therefore, it is not possible to apply the exemption from responsibility contained in literal f) of article 236-A of the LPAG to the extemporaneous presentation of periodic or eventual documentation or information;
- In addition to the foregoing, regarding the damage caused, it must be specified that in the case of lack of timeliness in the presentation of information, it is not possible to correct the damage caused insofar as the omission of presentation of information within the maximum period provided is not susceptible to correction because the protected legal right has already been affected;
- Likewise, it must be noted that in the present case it has not been evidenced that the infracting conduct by CA Perú SAB was generated by an error induced by the administration by an act or administrative provision, confusing and illegal;
- As for the other[6] exempting conditions contemplated in article 236–A of the LPAG; it must be noted that they are not observed in this administrative sanctioning procedure;
- Therefore, CA Perú SAB has committed two (02) infractions classified as minor, as indicated in this Resolution.
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Organization and Functions Regulation of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has committed an infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for failing to observe the provisions of article 196 literal f) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments; article 70 of the Intermediaries Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments; and, Annex 16, numeral 1.2 of the Manual of Technical Specifications for the submission to the SMV of Information of Intermediaries, approved by SMV Resolution No. 026-2012-SMV/01 and its amendments.
Article 2.- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has committed an infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for failing to observe the provisions of article 117 of the Intermediaries Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments; and, Annex 16, numeral 1.1 of the Manual of Technical Specifications for the submission to the SMV of Information of Intermediaries, approved by SMV Resolution No. 026-2012-SMV/01 and its amendments.
Article 3.- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has not incurred an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by not having contravened the provisions of article 172 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments; in articles 116, 118 and 135 of the Intermediaries Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments; and, article 1 of the General Management Resolution No. 041-2008-EF/94.01.2.
Article 4.- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has not incurred an infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, by not having contravened the provisions of articles 97 and 98 of the Intermediaries Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
Article 5.- Sanction CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. with a fine of 04 UIT, equivalent to S/. 14,800.00 (Fourteen thousand eight hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions referred to in articles 1 and 2 of this Resolution.
Article 6.- CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. may request a 30% reduction of the amount to be paid, if compliance with the requirements established by article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, is accredited.
Article 7.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal before it, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 8.- In the event that this resolution is not subject to challenge by reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on Advertising of Regulatory Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 10 A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
Article 9.- Transcribe this resolution to CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
Article 12.- Scope of Representation
The company is obligated towards those with whom it has contracted and towards third parties in good faith for the acts of its representatives celebrated within the limits of the faculties conferred upon them even if such acts commit the company to businesses or operations not included within its corporate purpose.
(…) ↑
-
Article 6.- Criteria and attenuating circumstances to consider for the imposition of sanctions
(…)
When the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria and attenuating circumstances allows concluding that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, by exception and by reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided may be imposed.
(…) ↑
-
In this regard, article 18 of the Regulation of the MVNet and SMV Virtual System, approved by Superintendency Resolution No. 010-2013-SMV/01, states that the information and all documentation that obligated entities must present to the SMV must be digitized or converted to electronic support for submission through the MVNet, except for the exceptions provided in articles 27 and 28 of said regulation and in the norms issued by the SMV. ↑
-
In file 2013022294 is the letter from CA Perú of June 13, 2013 indicating that they submit in physical form (on CD), among others, the file corresponding to the intermediated amounts in May 2013. ↑
-
a) Dictate the legal norms that regulate matters of the securities market, products market and collective funds system. ↑
-
Fortuitous event or duly proven force majeure, acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense, mental incapacity, and mandatory order of competent authority. ↑