Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV
No. 023-2021-SMV/10
Summary: Renta 4 Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of four (4) UIT equivalent to S/ 16,200.00 (sixteen thousand two hundred and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred in three (3) infractions: two (2) of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 and Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.13; and one (1) of a minor nature typified in Annex XVI, numeral 3, subsection 3.8 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the date of the events, for not observing Article 31 of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, the last paragraph of numeral 7.4 and subsections c) and d) of numeral 7.5 of Article 7 and Articles 30 and 31 of the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Financing of Terrorism, respectively.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Renta 4 Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2020043988 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
HAVING SEEN:
Administrative file No. 2020043988, and Report No. 413-2021-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, as well as the discharges and arguments presented by Renta 4 Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.;
CONSIDERING:
- In accordance with Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. FACTS
- Through Report No. 824-2020-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities communicated to the General Intendancy of Compliance (hereinafter, IGCP), the indications of a possible infraction by Renta 4 Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. (hereinafter, Renta 4 SAB), for having failed to comply with the provisions of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Old RAI), the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, Current RAI[1]), in force at the date of the events, the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Financing of Terrorism, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments (hereinafter, Plaft Rules);
- Under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of the Law of the General Administrative Procedure, Law No. 27444 (hereinafter, TUO LPAG), approved by DS No. 004-2019-JUS, through Official Letter No. 4425-2020-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), notified on December 7, 2020, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against Renta 4 SAB regarding the facts evidenced in the investigation carried out;
- By letter of December 15, 2020, Renta 4 SAB requests the extension of the term granted by the Letter of Charges;
- Through Official Letter No. 4548-2020-SMV/10.3, notified on December 17, 2020, the requested term was granted;
- By writing submitted on January 8, 2021, Renta 4 SAB presented the requested discharges, which were expanded on January 12 of this year;
- The charges formulated against Renta 4 SAB and the discharges of the latter have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 413-2021-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, subsection 2, of the TUO LPAG, through Official Letter No. 1465-2021-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 413-2021-SMV/10.3 was made available to Renta 4 SAB for its review;
- On April 26, 2021, Renta 4 SAB presented additional written arguments;
II. ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED
- In the present administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether Renta 4 SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.20 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter Previous Sanctions Regulation), in force at the time of the events, for non-compliance with Articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Rules;
- Whether Renta 4 SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Previous Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with observing Article 31 of the Current RAI.
- Whether Renta 4 SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Previous Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with observing the last paragraph of numeral 7.4 and subsections c) and d) of numeral 7.5 of Article 7 of the PLAFT Rules.
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on Renta 4 SAB;
III. ANALYSIS
-
- First Charge: intervention of the internal auditor in the customer due diligence procedure (CDD) – Non-compliance with Articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT RULES
Of the Regulations
- Article 59, numeral 59.2 of the Old RAI establishes the following:
Article 59.- Responsibilities of the Internal Control Officer.- The Internal Control officer of the Agent is responsible for the following:
(…)
59.2 Evaluate compliance with the provisions governing the Agent.
(…);
- For its part, Article 115 of the Current RAI regulates the following in Title VII “Of the Agent's Control System”:
Article 115.- Organization of the control system
The organizational structure regarding the control system must contain the following units: i) a regulatory compliance unit, ii) a risk management unit, in accordance with the pertinent regulations, and iii) an internal audit unit;
- Likewise, Articles 120 and 121 of the Current RAI provide the following:
“Article 120.- Of the internal audit unit
The internal audit unit supports the board of directors in its responsibility of evaluating and improving the effectiveness of the entire control system, including policies, guidelines, procedures, among others, which includes risk management and regulatory compliance.
The internal audit unit is independent from the operational areas and reports directly to the board of directors or, if it exists, to the audit committee.
(…). The work of the internal audit unit is governed by the provisions of this Regulation and supplementarily by the standards issued by the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA)”
Highlight added
Article 121.- Functions of the internal audit unit
The objective of this unit is to add value to the organization by verifying the correct functioning and effectiveness of the control system, including policies, guidelines and procedures.
To fulfill this task, the internal audit unit must at least:
a) Propose to the board of directors, for its approval, an annual internal audit work plan, which includes at least all the activities of the Agent in the securities market. This plan must be capable of generating conclusions and recommendations on the functioning and effectiveness of the control system and the functions of regulatory compliance and risk management.
b) Carry out a duly documented evaluation on the correct functioning and effectiveness of the control system, including the regulatory compliance function, risk management, information systems, accounting and others it considers relevant.
c) Evaluate the effectiveness, functioning, validity and compliance of the control policies, guidelines and procedures established by the Agent to safeguard operational functioning, protect own and third-party assets, ensure the settlement of operations, correct allocation and management of orders, safeguard information systems among others.
d) Contribute to the improvement of processes and correction of the system by making recommendations and following up on compliance with the improvement and correction measures adopted. Likewise, the internal audit unit must evaluate the effectiveness of the improvement and correction measures adopted.
(…);
- Finally, Article 30, numeral 30.1, and Articles 31 and 33 of the Plaft Rules establish the following:
“Article 30.- Internal audit
30.1 The design and application of the money laundering and financing of terrorism prevention system is the responsibility of each obligated subject and must be evaluated by its Internal Audit in order to verify compliance with said system, as well as with the norms established in the Law, the Regulation and other provisions related to the prevention of money laundering and financing of terrorism, based on the general principles of internal control and applicable auditing techniques.
(…)
Article 31.- Minimum tasks of Internal Audit
(…)
a) Execute the necessary actions for the verification of compliance with the money laundering and financing of terrorism prevention system in a timely, permanent and documented manner, including the evaluation of the design and adequate functioning of the system.
b) Verify compliance with the provisions established in the Law, the Regulation, this norm and other provisions related to the prevention of money laundering and financing of terrorism.
c) Carry out permanent monitoring of the implementation of the observations and recommendations formulated as a result of the evaluation of the prevention system.
d) Design an Annual Special Audit Plan for the money laundering and financing of terrorism detection system, with the minimum content established in the following article of this norm, as well as comply with the provisions of said Annual Plan.
e) Present to the Board of Directors of the obligated subject the reports it prepares and a copy thereof to the Compliance Officer.
Highlight added
Article 33.- Minimum content of the Internal Audit Report
33.1 For the preparation of the report referred to in Article 30 of this norm, the Internal Audit or whoever performs internal control functions, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 30.2 of Article 30 of this norm, must consider at least the following aspects:
a) Objective and description of the scope of the evaluation carried out.
b) Basis of evaluation, specifying the period evaluated.
c) Audit procedures and techniques applied for the verification of compliance with the money laundering and financing of terrorism prevention system implemented in the obligated subject, as well as compliance with the norms on the matter.
d) Description of the results obtained in the verification of compliance with the money laundering and financing of terrorism prevention system, especially the deficiencies observed.
e) Compliance with the tasks programmed for the respective period, according to the Annual Special Audit Plan.
f) Report on the actions taken by the obligated subject regarding the observations and recommendations of internal or external audits.
g) Conclusions and Recommendations;
Of the imputed facts
- During the inspection visit to Renta 4 SAB carried out by the IGSE from November 9 to 28, 2017 (hereinafter, the Inspection), an internal control questionnaire was applied to the internal auditor[2]; who, when asked[3] whether she was involved in carrying out intermediation operations and/or activities, stated “Only in the case of the review of the Intermediation Contract, annexes and additional documents, it is done before the registration as a client of Renta 4 Sab, the representative is responsible for gathering all the information referring to the client's file (intermediation contract), so that said client can be entered into the system, it must have the approval of the Internal auditor as a sign of review and the signature of the compliance officer, only then can the client be registered as a client and start operations in Renta 4 SAB”. (underlining added);
- Likewise, when asked[4] whether the Annual Special Audit Plan for the money laundering and financing of terrorism detection system (PAAE)[5] includes the evaluation of the Customer Due Diligence (CDD) policy as well as its proper implementation and application, the official stated “Yes, it is done in the review and evaluation of the Intermediation Contract, annex and additional documents, each time a natural or legal person wants to register as a client of Renta 4 SAB”;
- Finally, during the review of the documents supporting the CDD carried out by the personnel of Renta 4 SAB, the Inspection verified the intervention of the internal auditor since said official placed her signature and seal on some documents;
- In this regard, Table No. 1 shows the participation of the internal auditor (IA) with her signature and seal on the documents client registration form (FRC) or intermediation contract (CI) and sworn statement of origin of funds (DJOF) of the sample of five (5) clients selected in the Inspection;
TABLE No. 1
PARTICIPATION OF IA IN CDD PROCEDURES
| | | | | |
|---|
| No. | Client | Date of registration or update (FRC or CI) | Date of DJOF | Signature and seal of IA on FRC or CI | Signature and seal of IA on DJOF |
| 1 | Lima Marcela Sierra Arbelaez | 1/24/17 | 12/19/16 | ND | YES |
| 2 | Smith Birsayit Flores Pariona | 1/3/17 | 1/3/17 | ND | YES |
| 3 | Avla Perú Cía. de Seguros S.A. | 2/16/17 | 2/15/17 | YES | YES |
| 4 | Yoselin Patricia Rojas Castañón | 4/10/17 | 4/10/17 | YES | YES |
| 5 | Coemco Servicios SAC | 10/5/17 | 10/4/17 | YES | YES |
- In this regard, it should be noted that Article 59, numeral 59.2 of the Old RAI in force at the date of the IA's participation in signing and sealing the DJOF of Mrs. Sierra Arbelaez, provides that the audit unit evaluates compliance with the provisions governing the intermediary, that is, it participates by supervising the observance of the norms, in this case, the LAFT regulation of the SAB, but not with an operational or first-line function that implies its participation from before the commercial relationship with the client began;
- Likewise, for the clients cited in numerals 2 to 5, and for Mrs. Sierra Arbelaez in relation to the FRC or CI, Articles 120 and 121 of the Current RAI in accordance with Article 115 of said norm, stipulate that the internal audit unit is independent from the operational areas, which defines the limit with respect to the other areas of the agent precisely to make clear its autonomy and its legal nature with respect to the other organs of the stock brokerage company; as well as, carry out a duly documented evaluation on the correct functioning and effectiveness of the control system;
- It should be noted that the cited Article 120 states that the tasks of the internal auditor are governed supplementarily by the standards issued by the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA);
- In this regard, the Code of Ethics of Internal Auditors[6], among others, states that internal auditors exhibit the highest level of professional objectivity when gathering, evaluating and communicating information about the activity or process to be examined and that they will not participate in any activity or relationship that may impair or appear to impair their impartial evaluation;
- In the cases analyzed, it is important to note that the participation of the IA at the time of performing the CDD by signing the FRC, DJOF or CI implies non-compliance with Articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Rules;
- Indeed, Article 30 of the Plaft Rules states that the internal auditor must evaluate the design and application of the money laundering and financing of terrorism prevention system (hereinafter, Splaft) in order to verify its compliance;
- In this sense, the participation of the internal auditor in the CDD activities in the Splaft leads to the inability to maintain the independence and objectivity required by its function of evaluating the design and application of the Splaft in order to verify its compliance, since those CDD activities may impair its impartial evaluation of the design and application of the Splaft and the objective of evaluating its compliance in its capacity as reviewing organ, precisely, to objectively verify whether the areas of the intermediary complied with the regulations;
- It should be noted that auditors are independent and objective when they are able to give impartial and neutral opinions when performing their work, therefore they could not assume an operational responsibility and then evaluate its compliance;
- Therefore, Article 31 of the Plaft Rules establishes as minimum tasks of the Internal Audit of the obligated subject, the verification of the Splaft, as well as carrying out permanent monitoring of the implementation of the observations and recommendations formulated as a result of the evaluation of the prevention system, among others, which are not referred to operational activities, which are the responsibility of the commercial and executive areas, that is, those that have the first contact with the potential client and decide its acceptance;
- In this way, the IA of Renta 4 Sab, by participating in the CDD tasks of the Splaft in the cases indicated in Table No. 1, did not maintain its independence from the operational areas of Renta 4 SAB and this did not allow it to comply with its task of inspection or objective evaluation in accordance with Articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Rules, with the required independence; according to the standards governing the activity of internal auditors, such as the Code of Ethics of Internal Auditors, which states that this independence is required in order to guarantee their objectivity and impartiality in the tasks of evaluating the design and application of the Splaft in order to verify its compliance;
- It is important to mention that the participation of the IA in the CDD process in the cases referred to in Table No. 1 would also imply that it does not allow it to carry out an objective verification of compliance with the Splaft, which is also reflected in its annual report referred to in Article 33 of the PLAFT Rules, which is precisely the objective of said legal provision, which is that the IA be a reviewing organ of the other organs of the intermediary in the CDD process and in this way said process is carried out with all the guarantees of the case;
Of the discharges presented
- In its discharges, Renta 4 SAB states as preliminary issues the following:
Situation of concurrence of infractions
- Renta 4 SAB requests that for the three serious infractions Article 15 of the Previous Sanctions Regulation be applied as the assumption of real concurrence of infractions is configured and therefore be sanctioned only for one of said infractions;
Principles of administrative sanctioning law that it requests be taken into account
- Renta 4 SAB requests to take into account and be applied at the time of resolving, the following principles that govern the exercise of the sanctioning power of the Administration, which it states have been recognized by the Constitutional Court which has also indicated that the principles governing criminal law are applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure;
- Principle of typicity or taxativity, which prohibits interpreting extensively and less by analogy the norms for the imposition of sanctions;
- Renta 4 SAB adds that according to the provisions of numeral 4 of Article 248 of the TUO LPAG, the imposition of a sanction based on a norm that does not determine the scope of the infraction committed, whether directly or by reference to another norm, in which the infringing conduct is described, is not in accordance with the legal order; or in a norm that, directly or by reference, does not precisely establish the conduct that, if verified, generates the configuration of the infraction imputed, as an expression of the fundamental right to punitive legality recognized in subsection d) of numeral 24 of Article 2[7] of the Constitution as well as the right of defense and due administrative procedure provided in numeral 3 of Article 139 of the Political Constitution and in numeral 2 of Article 248 of the TUO LPAG;
- Renta 4 SAB cites ground No. 12 of the judgment in Exp. No. 01873-2009-PA/TC of the Constitutional Court:
“This requirement (referring to typicity) derives from two specific legal principles; that of freedom and that of legal security. According to the first, conducts must be exactly delimited, without indeterminacies, while in relation to the second, citizens must be in a position to predict, sufficiently and adequately, the consequences of their acts, so that general or indeterminate clauses of infraction that allow an action left to the arbitration of the administration are not allowed, but rather it must be prudent and reasoned.”;
- Renta 4 SAB adds that derived from the legal mandate of typification, the requirement of normative predetermination of infraction types arises, that is, for a norm to determine the existence of an infraction, it must predetermine it normatively, in order to comply with the principle of lex certae, according to which “the law must describe a determined factual assumption considered by the legal order as an infraction;
- Renta 4 SAB cites the author Ruiz Robledo, who in turn cites the jurisprudence of the Spanish Constitutional Court:
“STC 133/1987, of July 21, the Spanish Constitutional Court has given a mandate of typicity to the General Courts: “the mandate contained in Article 25 CE of lex certa or of taxativity in the description of criminal and infraction types, a mandate that obliges the legislator to carry out a description of the conducts, actions or omissions constituting a crime that complies with the requirements of the principle of legal security.”;
- Likewise, Renta 4 SAB again cites author Ruiz Robledo, who states that the guarantee of objectivity of punitive law, the foundation of legal certainty, implies that the assumptions and consequences of a given conduct must be determined with precision and certainty; and that the mandate of typicity requires that criminal law itself describe the conducts (actions or omissions) that constitute a crime, misdemeanor, or administrative infraction. The legislator cannot punish indeterminate behavior or draft offenses so openly that (...) their application or non-application depends on a practically free and arbitrary decision of the courts;
- Accordingly, Renta 4 SAB specifies that in the case of the infractions attributed to it, the regulations intended to describe the imputed conduct, due to their generality, ambiguity, and imprecision, present serious deficiencies that make it impossible to impose sanctions based on them; therefore, it considers that the infractions imputed by the SMV violate the principle of typicity because they are absolutely generic, open, and imprecise typifications and, consequently, clearly contrary to the legal system;
- Principle pro homine, in the context of an administrative sanctioning procedure, if there is doubt regarding how a given legal provision should be applied, the Administration must always prefer the one that is favorable to the accused, and Renta 4 SAB cites for this purpose ground 6 of the judgment in Case No. 2005-2009-AA of the Constitutional Court;
- Renta 4 SAB concludes that the Administration bases the imputations on unclear provisions and that, in contravention of the aforementioned principle, it interprets them inconsistently with the meaning and text of the norms, which is contrary to the administered party;
- Principle of lawfulness of the conduct of administered parties, as an expression of the principle of presumption of innocence, which, it states, translates into the Administration's burden of proof;
- Renta 4 SAB mentions that the referred principle has been recognized in literal e) of numeral 24 of article 2 of the Political Constitution and in numeral 9 of article 248 of the TUO LPAG, which states that “entities must presume that administered parties have acted in accordance with their duties as long as they do not have evidence to the contrary” and cites for this purpose the judgment of the Constitutional Court in Case No. 1768-2009-PA/TC*;*
- Renta 4 SAB adds to its defenses the principle “in dubio pro reo” developed by the Constitutional Court in the judgment in Case No. 728-2008-PHC/TC and states that for the TC the presumption of innocence gives rise to the principle of “in dubio pro reo” that governs criminal law and this, in turn, corresponds to the principle of lawfulness recognized in numeral 9 of article 248 of the TUO LPAG, since “if in the course of the administrative procedure the conviction of the unlawfulness of the act and the culpability of the administered party is not formed, the implicit mandate of acquittal that this presumption entails (in dubio pro reo) is imposed. In all cases of absence of necessary proof to destroy the presumption of innocence, including reasonable doubt, it obliges the acquittal of the administered party”;
- Renta 4 SAB states that, in any case, it will correspond to the Administration the burden of proof or evidence that proves, without any doubt, the responsibility of the administered party, since if it does not exist or is insufficient for the subjective assessment of the judge, the obligation to deem the conduct of the administered party lawful will prevail;
- Renta 4 SAB concludes that in the present case the Principle of Presumption of Lawfulness is contravened, since in the face of doubt as to whether the administered party incurs a breach of the current legal framework, it chooses to conclude its culpability, and not the opposite, as required by the application of the indicated principle;
- Principle of material truth, Renta 4 SAB cites numeral 1.11[8] of article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO LPAG to indicate that the imputations made do not follow the Principle of Material Truth, since they are based on assumptions that do not correspond to the actions adopted by the SAB, as it will explain in the respective sections;
- Principle of causality, Renta 4 SAB cites numeral 8[9] of article 248 of the TUO LPAG to point out that the facts on which the imputations are made are a consequence of unclear legal norms, and not of the intent or negligence of the agent company;
- Principle of reasonableness, Renta 4 SAB also cites numeral 3[10] of article 248 of the TUO LPAG mentioning that such principle allows imposing sanctions corresponding to less serious infractions;
- Renta 4 SAB states that the proportionality between the infraction committed and the reaction that the Public Administration must apply as a sanction is exercised according to the following assessment criteria, which are fully applicable to Renta 4 SAB:
- The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction: There has been no benefit in these proceedings for Renta 4 SAB. On the contrary, it states that it has been harmed by the initiation of this sanctioning procedure.
- The probability of detection of the infraction: it considers that the imputed infractions have no degree of difficulty to be detected, since Renta 4 SAB acted with full transparency when consulted regarding the facts of the case.
- The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest: it considers that there is no damage to the public interest or protected legal interest since Renta 4 SAB has acted completely transparently and has complied with the applicable norms, in accordance with the meaning that, in accordance with the aforementioned Principles, must be given to them.
- The economic damage caused: There is no economic damage whatsoever.
- Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from the final resolution that sanctioned the first infraction: Renta 4 SAB states that it has no recidivism, nor does it have a record of sanctions, which reflects its company's line of conduct, absolutely committed to compliance with the legal framework that governs it.
- The circumstances of the commission of the infraction: Renta 4 SAB states that the imputed infractions refer to norms that lack clarity or precision, which has led Renta 4 SAB to develop the acts that the Administration considers constitutive of said infractions.
- The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender: Renta 4 SAB affirms that it had no intentionality whatsoever;
- Renta 4 SAB mentions the third paragraph[11] of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Prior Sanctions Regulation), to request that, in the denied event that it is determined that Renta 4 SAB committed the infractions imputed to it, the judge order the application of sanctions provided for minor infractions, even when those imputed to Renta 4 SAB are serious infractions;
- Therefore, Renta 4 SAB requests that the SMV must appreciate the imputed conducts from the prism of reasonableness, that is, (i) choosing and interpreting the norms applicable to each case, (ii) developing the concrete elements for each imputation by assessing the conducts of Renta 4 SAB, and, (iii) if the need to sanction is established, adopting the most suitable measure with the least possible impact on the rights, in this case, of Renta 4 SAB;
- Principle of application of the most favorable norm in time, Renta 4 SAB cites the principle of non-retroactivity contemplated in numeral 5[12] of article 248 of the TUO LPAG, to point out that two of the imputed infractions have been subject to subsequent modification. In one of the cases, reducing the type of applicable sanction, and in another, eliminating the typification used and, with it, the legal power of the Administration to impose a sanction for the repealed typification;
Analysis of the defenses
- On this matter, it must be indicated that what Renta 4 SAB argues will be taken into account when evaluating the facts imputed as charges, as well as when determining the sanction to be imposed, if applicable, an analysis in which the principles of the sanctioning power contemplated both in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV) and in the TUO LPAG, in the Prior Sanctions Regulation and in the Current Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Current Sanctions Regulation), as applicable, will be observed;
Of the defenses presented to the first charge
- Renta 4 SAB summarizes that the first imputed charge refers to the SAB's breach of the provisions of articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms because its internal auditor included her signature and seal on the documents that the clients indicated in Table 1 must sign when initiating their relationship as clients of Renta 4 SAB;
- Renta 4 SAB states that, from the review of the text of the aforementioned articles 30 and 31, it cannot in any way be concluded that such action is contrary to the provisions of such norms, since the articles specifically indicate the following:
- Article 30 establishes that the design and application of the SPLAFT must be evaluated by its Internal Audit in order to verify compliance with said system.
- For its part, article 31 states that the internal audit of the obligated subject must verify compliance with the SPLAFT in a timely, permanent, and documented manner;
- Renta 4 SAB indicates that it is not possible to conclude that, by the mere fact of placing her signature and seal on the aforementioned documents, the internal auditor was prevented from evaluating or verifying compliance with the SPLAFT.
- In Renta 4 SAB's opinion, the action carried out by the internal auditor can well be understood as consistent with said verification work, since what it demonstrates is that said official has reviewed that Renta 4 SAB has complied with the duties incumbent upon it at the time of initiating the commercial relationship with its clients, precisely to avoid cases of money laundering or terrorist financing, which is the ultimate purpose of the PLAFT Norms and the SPLAFT;
- Likewise, Renta 4 SAB states that the signature included in the indicated documents does not denote that said internal auditor had assumed the operational responsibilities of Renta 4 SAB, but rather that she has verified that the officials who have such responsibilities have indeed complied with them;
- Furthermore, Renta 4 SAB indicates, as can be noted, despite the fact that the imputation refers to the breach of articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms, which only state the duty of the internal auditor to verify the functioning of the SPLAFT, the Charge Letter must make an interpretive effort that clearly consists of a prohibited extensive interpretation of said articles 30 and 31, resorting for this purpose to legal provisions and documents outside the scope of the PLAFT regulation, which in no way have been referred to by said articles 30 and 31 as applicable to provide them with content and provide the certainty required by the legal system that governs the exercise of the State's sanctioning power;
- As a result, Renta 4 SAB states that the bulk of the support provided in the Charge Letter regarding why Renta 4 SAB incurred a breach of said articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms actually consists of arguing why it is considered that the internal auditor breached the Old RAI (which also did not contain further provisions on the matter), or the Current RAI, or the Code of Ethics of Internal Auditors, that is, why she breached norms different from those imputed to Renta 4 SAB as breached (the PLAFT Norms);
- Clearly, Renta 4 SAB opines, an imputation made in such a way, based on the alleged breach of highly generic norms (articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms), resorting for this purpose to arguments regarding the breach of other norms that are not even within the normative scope of the PLAFT, and have not been cited or referred to by the allegedly breached norms (there is no reference whatsoever), fails to comply with the Principle of taxativity cited in its defenses;
- Renta 4 SAB states that the imputation really refers to the non-compliance with norms that have not been established in the PLAFT regulations, as required by the type used by the Charge Letter to make its imputation, but contained in other legal bodies, of a different nature (e.g. the Current RAI);
- Renta 4 SAB considers that, moreover, the typification used for this purpose, contained in subsection 2.20, numeral 2, of Annex XIX of the Sanctions Regulation, consisting of “Incurring in acts or omissions that constitute a breach of any of the provisions established in the regulations for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing”, also fails to comply with the aforementioned principle of taxativity, since it does not precisely describe the conduct that, if carried out, constitutes the serious infraction referred to, but rather deals generically with any breach of the PLAFT Norms;
- In addition to the foregoing, in its arguments, Renta 4 SAB states that the imputed charge does not comply with the Principle of Typicity provided in our legal system, since the imputed type mentioned and the alleged breach on which said imputation is based is that of articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms, such articles referring to the obligations to evaluate the design and application of the SPLAFT, and related regulations, which is not related to the certainty and clarity required by the mentioned principle. Additionally, the agent company considers that the very description of the infracting conduct, both in the type of the imputed infraction and in the referred articles 30 and 31, lacks the level of precision required by the Principle of Typicity;
- Finally, Renta 4 SAB states that, as the Charge Letter itself points out, the indicated conduct is now covered in Annex XVI, numeral 3, subsection 3.8 of the Current Sanctions Regulation, which qualifies as a minor infraction: “Incurring in acts or omissions other than those set forth in the types of infraction contained in this annex, which, in accordance with the provisions established in the regulations for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, are enforceable against administered parties”;
- Therefore, in accordance with the principle of application of the most favorable norm in time, Renta 4 SAB states that, at present, in the denied event that a sanction should be imposed for the commission of said conduct, it could only be qualified as a minor infraction, and not as a serious infraction;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, it is important to mention that Renta 4 SAB, to date, has adopted the criterion indicated in the Charge Letter, so its internal auditor no longer participates in the review of the documents signed by new clients of our company. Therefore, we take this opportunity to indicate that our company is aligned with the position expressed in the Charge Letter, and that will be the line of action that our internal audit will maintain;
- Having said that, in the denied event that the SMV considers that it should be sanctioned based on the described facts, despite the solid arguments that would exist against such action, Renta 4 SAB considers it pertinent to mention the following:
- It has obtained no benefit whatsoever in relation to such facts.
- Renta 4 SAB has had a conduct of absolute transparency regarding the facts of the case, so any denied infraction would be easy to detect.
- There is no damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, since aside from the parameters expressed in the Current RAI regarding how the internal audit work should be developed, requesting that it be taken into account that the actions of our internal auditor derive from assuming a position whose purpose is precisely to prevent in advance situations of money laundering, asset financing, and similar, by making an exhaustive review of the analysis carried out by the competent officials regarding potential new clients.
- No economic damage has been verified in relation to the facts.
- There is no recidivism on the part of Renta 4 SAB, not even a record of infraction.
- The facts occurred in relation to compliance with a norm that imposes an obligation described in an absolutely generic manner, and that in no way states what norms of a different nature (i.e. the Current RAI) that are not even referred to by the norm whose breach is imputed to us establish, so that said norm may admit more than one interpretation. It is precisely this lack of definition, and in no way the negligence or bad faith of Renta 4 SAB, that leads to the development of the facts of the case;
Analysis of the defenses
- On this matter, it should be noted that the defenses presented have not demonstrated whether the action of Renta 4 SAB's AI in the DDCC process specified in the Charge Letter constitutes an observance of articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms;
- Indeed, from the foregoing it follows that the AI's action in the imputed DDCC processes means that it does not have the required independence and objectivity and distorts its legal essence as a reviewing body, since participating and giving its conformity, as a condition for a person to be admitted as a client, reflects non-observance of article 30 of the PLAFT Norms, which expressly requires that the AI's participation is to “Evaluate” the design and application of the SPLAFT in order to “Verify” compliance with said system and not to admit or not a client as has been set out in the imputation of charges;
- Indeed, Renta 4 SAB's own AI in its statement before the officials who carried out the Inspection stated, without expressing doubt, that its intervention is a condition for admitting or not a client of the intermediary, since only with its approval can it begin operations in the SAB, that is, it does not affirm that its participation is to review what has already been done by the other organs of the intermediary as it states in the defenses:
“(…) for said client to be entered into the system, it must have the approval of the Internal Auditor as a sign of review (…), only then can the client be registered as a client and begin operations in Renta 4 SAB”;
- What the AI declared does not constitute, as is intended in the defenses and arguments, a review in accordance with the PLAFT Norms, nor less a review under the provisions of the Intermediation Regulation, nor in accordance with the legal nature of the work of an internal auditor; to maintain otherwise would imply a modification in all contexts of what constitutes an internal auditor, which, moreover, and in the extreme, has not been duly supported with a legal norm that reflects the position put forward by Renta 4 SAB, but only with its statement and as a conjecture in order to evade its responsibility;
- Consequently, what is stated in the defenses regarding the fact that the AI signed documents used in the DDCC giving its approval does not denote that said internal auditor had assumed the operational responsibilities of Renta 4 SAB, but rather that she has verified that the officials who have such responsibilities have indeed complied with them, is not consistent with the statement of the AI itself, who states that her approval is a condition for a client to be registered and begin operations in Renta 4 SAB, which constitutes a direct participation in the company's operations, in the first line of defense of the intermediary that is responsible for knowing and accepting the client; which means that, as part of her functions, the AI ends up evaluating and verifying her own work and activities, which is contrary to the principles of independence and objectivity proper to the work of internal auditors;
- It should also be noted that the non-observance of articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Norms (whose compliance is specifically expressed in the Charge Letter) is not only supported by the cited articles of the Intermediation Agents Regulation, but also by the Annual Special Audit Plans for the years 2016 and 2017 of Renta 4 SAB, which state as the AI's program of activities and evaluation the following:
“Program of activities and evaluation
The evaluation tasks necessary to fulfill the function of verifying compliance with the money laundering and/or terrorist financing prevention system, as well as to evaluate the design and adequate functioning of said prevention system, are the following aspects:
1. Verify the existence of procedures and policies that ensure adequate knowledge of the client, and whether these cover what is required by current regulations, as well as knowledge of the market.
2. Evaluate the implementation and functioning of the Manual in accordance with the
current legal provisions, which must include the policies, mechanisms, and procedures established therein.
(…)
4. Verify compliance with the provisions established in the Law, the Regulation, this norm, and the other legal provisions on the matter.
(…)”
- That is, in none of the indicated activities is the participation of the IA in the DDCC procedure to admit or not a client observed as such, which is consistent with the main purpose[13] of said plans: to identify deficiencies in the internal control system and to prevent or detect criminal operations, in correspondence with the internal auditor's own work;
- It is clear then that the work observed in the Letter of Charges to the IA is the fact that it participated in an activity that does not correspond to it; that such participation goes against its independence and the very nature of its functions;
- Assuming, as Renta 4 SAB states, that the internal auditor's participation in the limited DDCC process does not prevent it from evaluating or verifying compliance with the SPLAFT at the same moment of the beginning of the commercial relationship, implies going against the legal nature of the figure of the internal auditor, an interpretation without legal basis that has not been duly supported by Renta 4 SAB.
- On the other hand, it is appropriate to note that the PLAFT Manual of Renta 4 SAB does not establish that the IA of Renta 4 SAB participates in the DDCC process, in accordance with numeral XII.1 "Criteria for establishing knowledge of the client and the market, in accordance with the LA/FT Standard"[14], which demonstrates a lack of knowledge of the IA's function as well as its supervision work of the SPLAFT, which has also not been explained or evaluated in the defenses presented.
- Moreover, regarding what Renta 4 SAB states in its defenses that the Letter of Charges fails to comply with the principle of typicity because it makes an interpretation (relying on legal provisions and documents outside the scope of PLAFT regulation) to sustain the non-compliance with articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Standards, which it considers generic and that they only refer to verifying the SPLAFT, when in reality, in its opinion, the charges sustain non-compliance with other standards and not the cited articles 30 and 31, we must indicate that such affirmation constitutes an interpretation of these two articles without foundation and with the purpose of evading its responsibility.
- This is supported by the documents issued by Renta 4 SAB itself in which this Superintendency has not participated, since the PLAFT Manual and the Annual Audit Plans are prepared by the agent company itself in observance of the PLAFT Standards, positioning the IA as a review body; to maintain the opposite is opposed not only to the text of the standard itself, but to its spirit, which is to be a supervisory body and subsequent action that ensures compliance with an action or omission already carried out.
- Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the statement made by Renta 4 SAB is incorrect in the sense that the cited article 30 refers that the IA only verifies the SPLAFT, since that "verification" must be made on the basis of the general principles of internal control and applicable auditing techniques, which are precisely the standards applicable to due internal control regulated by the standards issued by the SMV, among them, the Regulation of Intermediation Agents:
Article 30.- Internal Audit
30.1 The design and application of the anti-money laundering and terrorist financing prevention system is the responsibility of each obligated subject and must be evaluated by its Internal Audit in order to verify compliance with said system, as well as with the standards established in the Law, the Regulation and other provisions related to the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, on the basis of the general principles of internal control and applicable auditing techniques.
- In this sense, it is not appreciated that the imputation of charges has been made based on non-compliance with generic standards or that it has been made to standards other than the PLAFT Standards, thus not observing non-compliance with the principle of typicity.
- On the other hand, regarding that the imputed legal type[15] does not comply with the mentioned Principle of Taxativity, for being generic to any non-compliance with the PLAFT Standards, since it does not in any way comply with describing in a precise manner the conduct configured as an infraction, it must be indicated that in administrative matters, the description of infracting conducts must allow knowledge by the administered of the obligations they must comply with and the consequences derived from their non-compliance. In this sense, this knowledge can occur through the substantive norm and the corresponding sanctioning norm, which has occurred in the present case.
- Indeed, on this aspect Moron Urbina[16] specifies that "(...) the use of indeterminate legal concepts in the definition of the sanctionable conduct would not be contrary to the principle, by itself, as long as the concretion of such concepts is reasonably feasible by virtue of being referred to logical, technical or experience criteria, which allow foreseeing, with sufficient certainty, the nature and essential characteristics of the conducts constituting the typified infraction.
The unity of solution underlying the indeterminate legal concept makes its use in sanctioning norms, in principle, admissible, since when there is only one solution, the application of the norm does not entail a margin of discretion for the official in the definition of the sanctionable conduct".
- From the foregoing it follows that the principle of typicity admits a certain degree of indeterminacy, lesser or greater depending on the case, as long as there exist in the legal system previously established criteria, such as legal provisions (as occurs in the present case), that provide clear and sufficient information about the behavior intended to be sanctioned, allowing foreseeing with sufficient certainty the nature and characteristics of an infracting conduct, not leaving the administration a margin of discretion, since the elaboration of these criteria only allows a single solution and not several possible solutions;
- It is in this sense that the Constitutional Court has ruled in File No. 2050-2002-AA/TTC, since it has recognized the possibility of resorting to regulatory "elaboration" in order to eliminate the risk of legal insecurity, provided that independent regulations are not created and not clearly subordinate to the law, as expressed in the following text:
"The principle of legality in sanctioning matters prevents attributing the commission of a fault if it is not previously determined in the law, and also prohibits applying a sanction if it is not also determined by law (...).
The principle of legality should not be identified with the principle of typicity. The first, guaranteed by ordinal "d" of subsection 24) of article 2 of the Constitution, is satisfied when compliance with the provision of infractions and sanctions in the law is met. The second, however, constitutes the precise definition of the conduct that the law considers as a fault. Such precision of what is considered unlawful from an administrative point of view (...) is not subject to an absolute reserve of law, but can be complemented through the respective regulations (...) ";
- Apart from the indicated jurisprudence, doctrine indicates that the legislator selects the most intolerable and most harmful unlawful behaviors for the most important legal goods;
- Thus, for Muñoz Conde[17], "From the wide range of unlawful behaviors that occur in reality, the legislator selects, in accordance with the principle of minimum intervention, those most intolerable and most harmful for the most important legal goods and threatens them with a penalty, describing them in the factual assumption of a criminal norm, thus also fulfilling the requirements of the principle of legality or legalized intervention.";
- Likewise, doctrine also refers that it is impossible to detail all legal types deserving of sanction, as indirectly raised by Renta 4 SAB, since that is materially unsustainable, so much so that not even the intermediary itself could regulate in its internal manuals situations that cover any type of administrative fault by its workers;
- On this matter, Muñoz Conde[18] states "This does not mean that the legislator has to describe with all exactness and even its most intimate details the behaviors that it deems should be punished as a crime. That would suppose an exasperation of the principle of legality that, taken to its ultimate consequences, would lead to an overwhelming casuistry that, in any case, would always leave some factual assumption outside the legal description";
- In this sense, continuing with the analysis, for the principle of legality and the principle of typicity to be complied with, it is enough that from the norm, the one that contains the general description of the factual assumption, it is reasonably possible to extract the infracting conduct;
- Thus, in the present case, the infraction type established in subsection 2.20, numeral 2, of Annex XIX of the Prior Sanctions Regulation is validly complemented with the PLAFT Standards, which contain provisions that regulate the obligations, functions, requirements and other aspects referred to the obligated subjects, among them, stock brokerage agent companies;
- Consequently, in the present case it is indeed feasible to know what the sanctionable conduct is, since it is based on a totally objective criterion. Indeed, in accordance with the provisions of articles 30 and 31 of the PLAFT Standards, it is the obligation of the intermediary that its internal auditor verifies compliance with the SPLAFT and the PLAFT Standards and other standards related to the prevention of LAFT, on the basis of the general principles of internal control and applicable auditing techniques;
- Therefore, non-compliance with this obligation is a non-compliance subject to a sanction previously determined in the Sanctions Regulation, since it is classified as an infraction of a serious nature. In this way, the discretion of the administration is limited because the determination of the infraction and the corresponding sanction are previously established in the norms;
- Thus, once the scope of the norms under analysis is specified, they present a sufficient degree of determination to delimit the scope of non-compliance and its consequence and in this way to communicate to the obligated subjects its scope, so the violation of the principle of typicity or the other principles mentioned in the defenses is not appreciated;
- Finally, regarding the other arguments indicated in the defenses that request to be evaluated at the time of determining the corresponding sanction, it must be indicated that this will be taken into account and analyzed in the section of this report "On the evaluation of the sanction";
- According to what is indicated, Renta 4 SAB has not disproved the imputed charge, so it has incurred in the infraction classified as serious typified in subsection 2.20, numeral 2, of Annex XIX of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the events, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Incurring in acts or omissions that constitute non-compliance with any of the provisions established in the anti-money laundering and terrorist financing prevention regulations ";
- Second charge: Subscription of the Intermediation Contract – Failure to comply with article 31 of the Current RAI
On the regulations
- Article 31 of the current Rai establishes:
"Article 31.- Intermediation Contract
The Agent must sign a contract with its clients prior to the provision of its intermediation services. The contract must establish the rights and obligations of each of the parties. The contract must contain at least the following:
a) Sufficient identification of the client;
b) Indication of acceptance and submission to the Client Policy;
c) A prominent notice indicating:
1. The client, in no case, must deliver cash to the Agent or its Representatives for the realization of its operations. The client must make its payments only through the Agent's intermediation accounts;
2. The client is aware of the risks of its investments and assumes them, including those made through an attorney-in-fact;
3. The Agent does not assume responsibility for the solvency of the issuers of the Financial Instruments or for their profitability.
4. The SMV is the institution in charge of supervising the securities market. The address of the Securities Market Portal and the address and telephone number of the SMV must be recorded;
d) Means of communication by which the client will instruct orders to the Agent;
e) Obligation of the client to send the information requested by the Agent in order to verify the client's identity, its investment profile, origin of resources, among others; and the obligation to send to the SMV any information it requires for supervision purposes or to any other national authority with the corresponding competence;
f) In the case of clients who issue orders by telephone means, authorization from the client to record all communications and telephone conversations in which the client issues orders to the Representatives. These recordings may be sent to the SMV and used as evidence in judicial processes, administrative procedures or arbitrations;
g) A special section, in the case of intermediation of Financial Instruments traded abroad, in accordance with the provisions of article 66.
h) Indication of the means through which the name of the entity that performs the custody of the physical Financial Instruments will be disclosed; and,
i) The means by which the client will receive the account statements.
The contract must be signed in physical form or through electronic signatures, in accordance with the corresponding norms, by the client and the Agent. This contract must be in accordance with the provisions of the Client Policy. A copy of the contract must be delivered to the client, together with the Client Policy;
(Highlight added)
On the imputed facts
- In the Inspection, the operations of a sample of clients of Renta 4 SAB were reviewed, identifying, within that sample, that the client Ceelimp Group S.A.C. performs foreign currency purchase and sale operations (exchange rate) without having an intermediation contract that complied with the conditions indicated in the Current Rai;
- It must be specified that the operations with the client Ceelim Group SAC were carried out in the months of July, August, September and October 2017. Indeed, it was verified that the mentioned client only signed a "Foreign Currency Purchase and Sale Contract" in which clauses were established on the formalities of foreign currency purchase and sale operations, such as general conditions, terms, non-compliances, among others;
- On this matter, article 31 of the Current Rai establishes that prior to the provision of services, the stock brokerage agent company must sign a contract with its clients and that said contract must meet certain minimum conditions that the "Foreign Currency Purchase and Sale Contract" does not comply with, so it could not be considered as an intermediation contract and consequently it was imputed that Renta 4 SAB would not have complied with the obligation indicated in the aforementioned Rai article;
- It should be added that the importance of said contract is precisely that the client knows, among other documents of the intermediary, its client policy;
On the Defenses Presented
- On this matter, Renta 4 SAB states that the imputation formulated does not comply with the Principle of Taxativity, since the citation that the Letter of Charges makes of article 31 of the Current RAI, supposedly non-complied, is incomplete, being that, according to its full text, Renta 4 SAB has not incurred in non-compliance with what is established in said article 31;
- Renta 4 SAB states that article 31 of the Current RAI, whose non-compliance is imputed to them, occurs when a contract is signed with clients if they are going to be provided intermediation services, which clearly does not include the realization of currency exchange operations;
- Renta 4 SAB maintains that there is reasonable doubt regarding whether the concept of intermediation services includes currency exchange operations. Thus, for example, Annex Q of the Current RAI, referring to the "Tariff of Services Related to Intermediation Activities" does not include currency exchange operations among intermediation activities;
- Likewise, Renta 4 SAB cites article 6 of the LMV that defines "Intermediation", which clearly does not include currency exchange operations:
"Article 6.- Intermediation.- Intermediation in the securities market is considered the habitual realization, on behalf of others, of purchase, sale, placement, distribution, brokerage, commission or negotiation operations of securities. Likewise, intermediation is considered the acquisitions of securities that are made on own account in a habitual manner in order to subsequently place them in the public and perceive a differential in price." (highlight added);
- Therefore, Renta 4 SAB considers that in order to determine what constitutes intermediation activities, we must inevitably resort to the definition of "Intermediation" established in the LMV, and no regulatory provision could contravene or distort the definition contained in the LMV, as it is of lower legal rank;
- Renta 4 SAB states that said definition of intermediation, according to the LMV, refers to that carried out with respect to securities, which clearly does not apply to its case;
- Thus, Renta 4 SAB specifies that when an intermediary carries out foreign exchange operations, it is not performing the intermediation activity, which is an activity that by its nature and implications is regulated, requires the signing of an agreement for the protection of investors and is supervised by the SMV. Likewise, it indicates that it is not a mere primacy of the concept of intermediation established by the LMV that the Current RAI could not modify, but rather that such position is accompanied by a logical basis; for that reason it states that it did not require the intermediation contract;
- Renta 4 SAB points out that the imputation made by the Letter of Charges assumes that currency exchange operations do not constitute intermediation, since otherwise they would have been charged with the infraction contained in numeral 1.18 of Annex X of the Sanctions Regulations, consisting of "1.18. Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations.";
- Therefore, Renta 4 SAB indicates that according to our legal system, the definition of intermediation is the one established by the LMV, and such definition could not be distorted by any other lower-ranking norm. Even in the denied assumption that it is valid to resort to a provision of different rank to change the meaning of the definition established by the LMV, in application of the Pro Homine Principle, the regulation in question should be interpreted in a manner favorable to the administered party, and it should be considered that the infraction imputed has not been incurred;
- On the other hand, Renta 4 SAB states that the infraction type used is completely contrary to the Principle of Taxativity, for using an absolutely vague and generic open type in the "description" of the infraction conduct, as is evident from its text: "Fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations". Therefore, as the Constitutional Court has made clear, it is not in accordance with our legal system to sanction based on the indicated infraction type. Such sanction would be clearly null;
- Furthermore, Renta 4 SAB states that, even in the denied assumption that it is considered that said infraction type can be used, and that we breached the provisions of Article 31 of the Current RAI, it must be taken into account that said infraction type is currently repealed, since it has not been included in the Current Sanctions Regulations. Therefore, in attention to the principle of application of the most favorable norm in time, it must be concluded that, having repealed the infraction type that would support the imputed infraction, it is not appropriate to sanction them;
- Renta 4 SAB specifies that the open typification used in the Letter of Charges consisting of: "Fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations" is no longer included in the Current Sanctions Regulations, so it could not be used in any case;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, Renta 4 SAB considers it important to note that the current text of Article 31 of the Current RAI has now been modified by Superintendent Resolution No. 108-2020-SMV-02, to include the obligation to enter into the contract referred to in said article before the provision of any service that the operating authorization granted by the SMV empowers the intermediation agent, which confirms that, prior to the modification of said article, its application was limited. Likewise, it specifies that the provisions of Article 45 of the Current RAI are not consistent with the definition in Article 6 of the LMV, and according to our legal system, a lower-ranking norm, such as the Current RAI, cannot change the concept of intermediation defined by the LMV;
- In accordance with the foregoing, Renta 4 SAB adds that to date it signs an intermediation contract with all its new clients, before the performance of any service that its authorization allows it to develop, and in attention to the modification in the Current RAI, said way of operating will be the one it maintains;
- Without prejudice to the aforementioned, Renta 4 SAB declares that in the denied assumption that the SMV considers it appropriate to sanction it based on the facts analyzed above, it considers pertinent to mention the following:
- It has not obtained any benefit in relation to such facts.
- Renta 4 SAB has had a conduct of absolute transparency regarding the facts of the case, so any denied infraction would be easy to detect.
- There is no damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, since our company followed in good faith the provisions of Article 31 of the Current RAI at the time the facts occurred, which only applied to the performance of intermediation activities that, according to the definition included in the LMV, refers only to activities with securities, which does not correspond to the facts of the case.
- No economic harm has been verified in relation to the facts.
- There is no recidivism, nor antecedents of infraction.
- The facts occurred in relation to compliance with a norm that it considers should be interpreted as applicable only in the case of carrying out operations with securities and not currency exchange. Even so, it should be noted that Renta 4 SAB did act with all the formalities that were reasonable, as evidenced by the fact that, prior to carrying out such operations, a contract had to be signed between our company and the client;
- According to the described, in the denied assumption that it is considered that sanctions should be imposed for the indicated facts, according to the described mitigating factors, a lesser sanction than the typification used should be applied, in accordance with the provisions of Article 15 of the Sanctions Regulations;
Analysis of the defenses
- According to the observed case, Renta 4 SAB was questioned for the fact that, within the sample subject to supervision, with respect to client Ceelimp Group S.A.C., said intermediary did not enter into the intermediation contract referred to in Article 31 of the Current RAI prior to the performance of the foreign currency purchase and sale operations carried out in the months of July, August, September and October 2017, taking into account the definition of "intermediation activities" established in Article 45 of the Current RAI;
- On the matter, it should be noted that the foreign currency purchase and sale operation is regulated in Article 194, literal o)[19] of the LMV, which states that brokerage firms are empowered, among others, to carry out the aforementioned operation;
- Accordingly, Article 45 of the Current RAI establishes that intermediation activities are those contemplated, among others, in subsection o)[20] of Article 194 of the LMV;
- In that sense, considering the provisions of both norms, Renta 4 SAB was questioned for the fact that with the observed client it had not signed the corresponding intermediation contract with the characteristics contained in Article 31 of the Current RAI, a situation that in its defenses said intermediary has not disproved;
- Indeed, the contract signed on June 23, 2017 by client Ceelimp Group S.A.C. with Renta 4 SAB does not include among its clauses the following literals of Article 31 of the Current RAI: b)[21], c) numerals 1 and 4[22], e)[23] and i)[24];
- On the other hand, regarding the alleged non-observance of the principle of taxativity argued by Renta 4 SAB with respect to the cited Article 31 of the Current RAI, it should be noted that, as stated in the preceding recitals, the aforementioned Article 31, which provides that the agent must sign with its clients prior to the provision of its intermediation services the intermediation contract, is consistent with Article 45 of the Current RAI, which expressly indicates that it is an intermediation activity, among others, the operation contemplated in literal o) of Article 194 of the LMV, that is, it expressly considers the purchase and sale of foreign currency as an intermediation activity, so such non-observance is not observed;
- Although Article 6 of the LMV, which defines "Intermediation", does not include currency exchange operations, it should be noted that the cited Article 194 of said norm does include it as an operation that the stock brokerage firm can carry out, an operation that has also been clearly included in the referred Article 45 literal a) of the Current RAI as an intermediation activity, in attention to the express regulatory power of this Superintendency according to literal a)[25] of Article 1 of the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of the SMV;
- It should be noted that the imputation of charges refers to the foreign currency purchase and sale operation regulated in Article 194, literal o) in accordance with Articles 45 and 31 of the Current RAI, so it is not admissible to consider this fact under the application of the infraction type named in numeral 1.18 of Annex X of the Previous Sanctions Regulations, 1.18. Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations", which refers to the intermediation of securities and financial instruments itself;
- On the other hand, regarding that the infraction type used is completely contrary to the Principle of Taxativity, for using an absolutely vague and generic open type in the "description" of the infraction conduct, we refer to the analysis and development carried out on the matter in the section "Analysis of the Defenses" of infraction number one of this report, which disproves such argument;
- Regarding that the imputed infraction type contained in subsection 2.13 numeral 2, of Annex X of the Previous Sanctions Regulations ("Fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations"), is repealed in the Current Sanctions Regulations, it should be noted that, as stated in the Letter of Charges, this infraction type has been included in numeral 2, literal 2.33, Annex I, of the Current Sanctions Regulations, which states as a serious infraction: "Not complying with its functions or any of the other provisions contemplated in the regulations or those provided or required by the SMV in the exercise of its functions, specifically to the Participants", so such affirmation has been disproved;
- Regarding that the text of Article 31 of the Current RAI imputed was limited and that only with the modification made by Superintendent Resolution No. 108-2020-SMV/02, it is extended to any service that the operating authorization granted by the SMV empowers the intermediation agent, it should be noted that, as explained in the recitals of said Superintendent resolution, said modification has not had the purpose of specifying Article 31 in the sense of the defense formulated but rather adapting it, like other articles of the Current RAI, as well as other articles of various regulations[26], among other aspects, to the digitalization in services and activities by entities regulated by said regulations, all oriented to the intensified use of electronic and telematic means, in order to achieve efficient processes that result in better service to its clients and its sustainability;
- For the foregoing, the defenses presented have not disproved the charge formulated, having demonstrated that the contract signed by Renta 4 SAB with its client Ceelimp Group S.A.C. has not complied with the provisions of Article 31 of the Current RAI;
- Finally, regarding the sanction criteria developed by Renta 4 SAB, these will be taken into account in the Sanction Evaluation section of this resolution;
- In that sense, Renta 4 SAB has incurred in the infraction qualified as serious typified in subsection 2.13 numeral 2, of Annex X of the Sanctions Regulations, in force at the time of the facts, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature: "Fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations."[27]
- Application of the intensified DDC procedure – Failure to comply with Article 7 of the Plaft Rules
Of the regulations
- Article 7, numerals 7.4 and 7.5, of the Plaft Rules, establishes:
"Article 7.- Customer Due Diligence by the Obligated Subject.
(…)
7.4 The obligated subjects, based on the information obtained through their policies and procedures for the adequate knowledge of their clients and with a risk-based approach, must identify those cases in which it is warranted to intensify their due diligence procedures in customer knowledge, among which they must consider:
a) Non-resident clients, national or foreign.
b) Clients that receive transfers from countries considered as non-cooperative by the FATF, with risk related to money laundering and terrorist financing, with scarce banking supervision, or from countries included in the OFAC list.
c) Clients that act through a representative or clients whose shareholders, partners or associates have directly or indirectly more than 5% of their share capital, contribution or participation, as the case may be, are foreign natural or legal persons.
d) Trusts: In this case the obligated subject must identify the identity of the settlor, trustee and beneficiaries."
e) Non-domiciled companies.
f) Politically exposed persons (PEP) or those who administer public resources. Obligated subjects must have appropriate risk management systems and must reinforce their customer knowledge procedures when one of their clients becomes a PEP or an official who administers public resources, as the case may be, after having started commercial relations with the obligated subject.
g) Legal persons in which a politically exposed person (PEP) owns at least 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation and that, according to the obligated subject, has a high risk of ML/TF.
In the file of each client it must be indicated whether it is a client to whom the intensified due diligence procedure in customer knowledge corresponds to be applied.
(Highlight added)
7.5 Obligated subjects to reinforce their customer knowledge procedures must at least carry out the following additional measures, as applicable:
c) Carry out at least once (1) a year a review of the profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, of the client, as well as, if domiciled in Peru, carry out a visit to their domicile or offices, when deemed necessary, in case the review of the client's profile, background, documentation does not correspond with what was declared.
d) The decision to accept the client will be in charge of the highest managerial level of the obligated subject, who in turn may delegate this function to another managerial position within the organization, retaining, however, the responsibility for the acceptance or not of the client.
e) Carry out inquiries or obtain additional information from the client, even if acting through a representative.
f) Update the client's information, additionally in the case of legal persons, said update must be carried out at least once a year, and includes that of its shareholders, partners or associates, who have directly or indirectly more than 5% of its share capital, contribution or participation, as the case may be";
facts occurred
- In the Inspection, through Memorandum No. 001-2017-INSP.RENTA 4 SAB, in numerals 6 and 9, the following information was requested: "6. List of clients with indication of the ML/TF risk profile with details of the fields: name, identity document, RUT No., ML/TF risk level and date of incorporation as clients. (in Excel file)"; "9. List of clients to whom intensified due diligence procedures are carried out in accordance with the provisions of Article 7.4 of the NPLAFT, with details of the fields: name, identity document, RUT No., and others enabled. (in Excel file)";
- In response to numeral 6 of said Memorandum, Renta 4 SAB sent an Excel file and in response to numeral 9 of the same it stated "They are those qualified with AGGRESSIVE Investment Profile (indicated in the Excel delivered by point No. 6)";
- Taking into account the information provided by Renta 4 SAB in the Excel file, indicated in the previous paragraph, in the Inspection an Excel file was prepared with the information obtained from the client files, which is attached to the file corresponding to this administrative sanctioning procedure. Based on this Excel file, Table No. 2 was prepared with the intensified DDC procedures;
TABLE No. 2
INTENSIFIED DDC PROCEDURES
| CLIENT | Date of registration (FRC) | It is indicated in the file that the intensified DDCC procedure corresponds to be applied | Acceptance of the client by the highest managerial level | Annual update of profile, background, documentation, among other aspects |
|---|
| José Víctor Moreno Carrera | 8/4/15 | - | - | NO (as of 8/4/17) |
| Carlos Braulio Salazar Bolívar | 20/5/15 | - | - | NO (as of 20/5/17) |
| Cleto Guevara Sosa | 1/3/16 | - | - | NO (As of 1/3/17) |
| Fernando Rodolfo Huerta Mendoza | 21/3/16 | - | - | NO (As of 21/3/17) |
| Patricia María Castañón Rivas | 15/3/17 | NO | NO | - |
| Yoselin Patricia Rojas Castañón | 10/4/17 | NO | NO | - |
- As shown in Table No. 2, in the Inspection, from the review of each of the client files to which intensified DDCC procedures are carried out, as indicated by Renta 4 SAB, it was detected that the SAB had not indicated, for each of them (clients Patricia Castañón and Yoselin Rojas), that the intensified DDCC procedure corresponded to be applied, thus failing to comply with Article 7, numeral 7.4 of the Plaft Rules;
- Likewise, it was detected that in the FRCs (clients Patricia Castañón and Yoselin Rojas) the approval of the general manager or of any management to which such function has been delegated does not appear, and, finally, Renta 4 SAB did not demonstrate having complied with the review and update of the client profile and corresponding documentation (clients José Moreno, Carlos Salazar, Cleto Guevara and Fernando Huerta), failing to comply with Article 7, numeral 7.5, literals c and d), of the Plaft Rules, which establishes that to reinforce the DDC procedures the decision to accept the client will be in charge of the highest managerial level of the obligated subject, who in turn may delegate this function to another managerial position within the organization and, likewise, a review of the profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, of the client must be carried out at least once (1) a year, and update the client's information;
of the defenses presented
- Renta 4 SAB states that the response provided to the SMV was not suitable, which led the regulator to consider that, effectively, the clients included in the cited table have the characteristics of those who warrant the application of intensified DDC, when this did not correspond to reality;
- Renta 4 SAB adds that the response given to the query made by the SMV regarding the clients for whom intensified DDC corresponded was "They are those qualified with AGGRESSIVE Investment Profile";
- As is clear, Renta 4 SAB states that the type of investment profile (in this case qualified as "aggressive") is not related to the assumptions in which, according to current regulations, a client should be qualified as subject to intensified DDC. On the contrary, Renta 4 SAB considers that such assumptions are described in numeral 7.4 of Article 7 of the PLAFTM Rules;
- Renta 4 SAB confirms that from the analysis of the characteristics of the clients, none of them is in the assumptions included in the indicated numeral 7.4, as can be verified from the documentation attached as Annex 1 to its defense brief;
- Therefore, despite the imprecise response given to the SMV, Renta 4 SAB states that the truth is that none of the mentioned clients qualifies to be subject to intensified DDCC, and that is the reason why the measures that the Current RAI[28] establishes should be followed in such cases were not adopted;
- In that sense, Renta 4 SAB requests the SMV that, beyond said unsuitable response given by it, it consider that what should be applied is the principle of material truth, so it can be verified that the stated corresponds to the facts that must be taken into account at the time of deciding and therefore, conclude that such infraction was not configured;
- Without prejudice to the aforementioned, Renta 4 SAB considers it pertinent to call attention to the obscurity of the assumption indicated in numeral (iii) of the cited numeral 7.4, which has evident drafting defects and, therefore, is susceptible to inducing confusion, for which it analyzes its wording:
"Clients that act through a representative or clients whose shareholders, partners or associates have directly or indirectly more than 5% of their share capital, contribution or participation, as the case may be, are foreign natural or legal persons";
- Renta 4 SAB points out that a simple reading makes evident the deficient drafting, insofar as it is confusing to what the phrase "whether natural or legal persons, foreign" applies. To the clients' representatives? To the shareholders, partners or associates of the clients? To both cases?;
- Trying to determine the logical meaning of the text included in said numeral, Renta 4 SAB considers that it should be understood as referring to: (i) clients whose representatives are natural or legal persons, foreign; and (ii) clients whose shareholders, partners or associates directly or indirectly hold more than 5% of their share capital, contribution or participation, as the case may be, are natural or legal persons, foreign;
- Renta 4 SAB indicates that the foregoing is the most reasonable because why would the fact that a client acts through a representative make them subject to intensified DDCC, and if they act directly, not? On the other hand, all legal persons act through representatives;
- Therefore, Renta 4 SAB considers that the only logical meaning that could exist is that the client acts through foreign representatives, since it is in that case that an intensified DDC is warranted, as could be inferred from the cited numeral (i). The intermediary further specifies that said numeral (iii) is not even consistent, since instead of natural or foreign persons, it should have referred to non-domiciled persons, as is done in numeral (i), which confirms the deficient drafting of the norm in question;
- In fact, Renta 4 SAB points out that such a conclusion is in turn consistent with the provisions that the Superintendency of Banking, Insurance and AFP has issued on said matter for its supervised entities. Thus, Renta 4 SAB states that none of the assumptions of Article 32 of the Regulation for the Management of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing Risks, approved by SBS Resolution No. 2660-2015, which regulates the same matter, in which supervised entities must apply the "Enhanced regime of due diligence in customer knowledge"; include persons merely for having a representative;
- Notwithstanding this, Renta 4 SAB notes that in the denied assumption that it is considered that it should have carried out an intensified DDCC procedure with respect to its clients, merely for having appointed a representative, the exemption from liability contained in Article 257, numeral 1, subparagraph e), of the TUO LPAG would be applicable, which establishes that administered persons are exempt from liability if the infracting conduct was generated by confusing regulations, referring to the cited subparagraph iii) of numeral 7.4:
"Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following constitute conditions exempting from liability for infractions:
(…)
e) The error induced by the Administration or by confusing or illegal administrative provision."
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the denied assumption that the SMV considers that it corresponds to sanction it based on the facts above, despite the arguments presented, Renta 4 SAB considers it pertinent to mention the following:
- Renta 4 SAB has not obtained any benefit in relation to such facts.
- Renta 4 SAB has had a conduct of absolute transparency regarding the facts of the case, so any denied infraction would be easy to detect.
- There is no harm to the public interest and/or protected legal right, since Renta 4 SAB has not breached the PLAFT Rules, given that they were not applicable to the facts of the case.
- No economic harm has been verified in relation to the facts.
- There is no recidivism on the part of Renta 4 SAB, nor antecedents of infraction;
- The facts occurred in relation to compliance with a norm that is not applicable to the facts of the case and that, in any case, has evident deficiencies susceptible of inducing error, so they cannot support the imposition of sanctions;
- Renta 4 SAB adds that in the denied assumption that it is considered that sanctions should be imposed for the facts set forth, according to the mitigating circumstances described, a lesser sanction than the classification used would correspond, in accordance with the provisions of Article 25 of the Current Sanctions Regulation;
Analysis of the defenses
- According to what is indicated in the defenses, the qualification given by Renta 4 SAB itself to said clients as "AGGRESSIVE Investment Profile" has been disproven in light of the documents presented by the intermediary; it should also be indicated, based on said information, that the qualification "Aggressive" given to said clients is used more to determine their investment profile, so it is reasonable that it would be a terminology error used by Renta 4 SAB;
- However, after evaluating the documentation presented in its defenses by Renta 4 SAB regarding its clients Patricia María Castañón Rivas, Yoselin Patricia Rojas Castañón, José Víctor Moreno Carrera, Carlos Braulio Salazar Bolívar and Cleto Guevara Sosa, and the one in the Excel file named "Control de cédulas de clientes", prepared by the team in charge of the Inspection, in relation to the mentioned clients and the client Fernando Rodolfo Huerta Mendoza, it is observed that the clients José Moreno, Carlos Salazar and Fernando Huerta do not meet the assumptions established in numeral 7.4 of Article 7 of the PLAFT Rules, applicable to natural persons, due to the following:
- They are clients residing in Peru.
- They are not Politically Exposed Persons (PEP) or who administer public resources.
- They are not clients who act through a representative.
- They are not persons who receive transfers from countries considered as non-cooperative by the FATF, with risk related to money laundering and terrorist financing, with scarce banking supervision, or from countries included in the OFAC list;
- Therefore, it does not correspond that these persons be considered as clients for whom it warrants intensifying the DDCC procedures;
- On the other hand, regarding the clients Patricia Castañón, Yoselin Rojas and Cleto Guevara, it is observed that they do not meet most of the assumptions established in numeral 7.4 of Article 7 of the PLAFT Rules, applicable to natural persons, due to the following:
- They are clients residing in Peru.
- They are not Politically Exposed Persons (PEP) or who administer public resources.
- They are not persons who receive transfers from countries considered as non-cooperative by the FATF, with risk related to money laundering and terrorist financing, with scarce banking supervision, or from countries included in the OFAC list;
- However, the mentioned clients do meet the assumption established in numeral 7.4, literal c) of Article 7 of the PLAFT Rules, applicable to natural persons, because they are clients who act through a representative**;**
- Indeed, Mrs. Patricia María Castañón Rivas and Yoselin Patricia Rojas Castañón have appointed Mr. Julio César Bravo Valentín as attorney-in-fact to act in their name in the instruction of purchase and sale orders of national and foreign securities before any stock brokerage firm, among other powers, whereby it is accredited that these persons act through a representative in their commercial relationship with Renta 4 SAB;
- On the other hand, Mr. Cleto Guevara Sosa has appointed Mr. Mario Roberto Benavides Guzman as attorney-in-fact to act in his name in the instruction of purchase and sale orders of national and foreign securities before any stock brokerage firm, among other powers, whereby it is accredited that this person acts through a representative in his commercial relationship with Renta 4 SAB;
- In that sense, given the mandate contained in the cited literal c) of numeral 7.4, by having three clients who acted through representatives Renta 4 SAB should have identified them and intensified its DDC procedures, however, it did not, in addition to not having accredited the approval by the general manager of the SAB in the case of Mrs. Patricia Castañon and Yoselin Rojas, nor did it carry out the review and update of the client profile in the case of Mr. Cleto Guevara;
- Regarding whether literal c) numeral 7.4 of Article 7 of the PLAFT Rules can be interpreted in other senses or that said norm is confusing, it should be indicated that the assumption of mandatory observance contemplated therein referring to that if a person acts through a representative, is clear and express, so if a client acts before the intermediary through a representative, the brokerage firm must identify them, and apply an intensified DDC and initiate the procedures for such purpose, however, as mentioned, in the observed cases this did not occur;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, it should be noted that the grounds for which a client who acts through a representative makes them subject to intensified DDCC supported by a risk-based approach, is in attention to international standards on the fight against ML/TF, collected in the Plaft Rules, insofar as in customer due diligence according to Article 7, numeral 7.1, literal ii, obligated subjects must "identify the beneficial owner, adopting reasonable measures to verify their identity to the extent that due diligence permits";
- In relation to the foregoing, it should be indicated that Renta 4 SAB is a regulated and supervised company, which receives in custody funds of investors to whom it provides financial intermediation services in complex markets, so being a specialized and technical entity, the duty of diligence obliges it to know and consider the referred international standards, as is the case of the "International standards on the fight against money laundering, terrorist financing, and the financing of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction" of the Financial Action Group of Latin America (GAFILA), which in its recommendation No. 10 states that among the DDCC measures to be taken is "Identify the beneficial owner and take reasonable measures to verify the identity of the beneficial owner, in such a way that the financial institution is convinced that it knows who the beneficial owner is". Likewise, recommendation No. 25 establishes that "Countries should consider measures to facilitate access to information on the beneficial owner and control by financial institutions". In that sense, at the local level, norms have been issued such as DL 1372, "Legislative Decree that regulates the obligation of legal persons and/or legal entities to report the identification of beneficial owners";
- In that sense, international standards, the PLAFT Rules and related local regulations, within the framework of the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing, aim to know who the beneficial owner is; a situation as mentioned, given the duty of diligence that obliges it, is known to Renta 4 SAB, whereby Article 7, numeral 7.4, literal c) is framed in said context, seeking that measures be adopted that reinforce the SPLAFT, in particular in cases where the action of a company or entity is through a representative;
- As for the other assumptions contemplated in numeral 7.4, literal c) of Article 7 of the Plaft Rules, it does not correspond to evaluate the defenses presented on the matter, given that they have not been subject to imputation to Renta 4 SAB;
- Therefore, having accredited that three (3) clients of Renta 4 SAB, at the time of the observed facts, acted through a representative, and that this is an assumption contemplated in the Plaft Rules in which it warrants identifying said clients and intensifying the DDCC procedure, as described in Table No. 3 below, it is concluded that Renta 4 SAB did not indicate in the file of the clients Mrs. Patricia Castañón and Yoselin Rojas that, in attention to an evaluation based on a risk approach, it corresponded to apply the intensified DDC procedure, thus breaching Article 7, numeral 7.4 of the Plaft Rules; whereby it is also not appreciated that in its defenses it has presented evidence of such analysis;
- Likewise, it is concluded that it is not recorded that the decision to accept these clients was in charge of the highest managerial level of the obligated subject, or that this function was delegated to another managerial position within the organization, breaching Article 7, numeral 7.5, literal d), of the Plaft Rules;
- Consequently, it is concluded that Renta 4 SAB did not demonstrate having carried out at least once (1) a year a review of the profile, antecedents, documentation, among other aspects, of the client, and update the client's information, corresponding to Mr. Cleto Guevara, breaching Article 7, numeral 7.5, literal c), of the Plaft Rules;
- For the foregoing, Renta 4 SAB has incurred in the infraction classified as serious typified in 2.3, numeral 2, of Annex XIX of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the facts, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Not carrying out the customer due diligence process, in accordance with the regulations for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, in cases where according to the provisions of said norm its application corresponds.";
TABLE No. 3
INTENSIFIED DDCC PROCEDURE
| CLIENTS WHO ACT THROUGH A REPRESENTATIVE | Date of registration (FRC) | Indicates in file that it corresponds to apply the intensified DDCC procedure | Acceptance of the client by the highest managerial level | Annual update of profile, antecedents, documentation, among other aspects |
|---|
| Cleto Guevara | 1/3/16 | - | - | NO (As of 1/3/17) |
| Patricia Castañón | 15/3/17 | NO | NO | - |
| Yoselin Rojas | 10/4/17 | NO | NO | - |
- Finally, as for the sanction criteria developed by Renta 4 SAB these will be taken into account in the Sanction Evaluation section of this resolution. Likewise, as for the regulations issued by the SBS referred to by the intermediary as part of its defenses, it should be noted that they are not applicable to the present case;
IV. SANCTION EVALUATION
- In accordance with Article 348 of the LMV and Article 6 of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with Article 248, numeral 3, of the TUO LPAG and Article 257 of the aforementioned body of norms, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria set forth in the LMV, the Prior Sanctions Regulation and the TUO LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The harm caused and the repercussion on the market; d) Recidivism[29]; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; h) The probability of detection of the infraction; and, i) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification;
- In accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, the offender's antecedents are considered to be sanctions that became final within the four (04) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction; it should be noted that Renta 4 SAB does not present a record of sanctions in the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infractions subject to charges;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, in the present case it has not been possible to prove that the actions of Renta 4 SAB in the commission of the infractions analyzed in this sanctioning procedure have caused damage to the public interest;
- However, since the internal auditor did not comply with its functions related to the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing and since its independence was compromised because Renta 4 SAB assigned it tasks corresponding to the operational or first line of defense of the intermediary, the transparency of the securities market is harmed, because by affecting the performance of adequate internal control of the activities carried out by the intermediary, the minimum caution that agent companies must comply with in order not to harm, through their actions, not only the interests of their clients, but also those of the company itself, is neglected;
- The Internal Control Auditor, as responsible for the evaluation of the intermediary's internal control system, must seek that it provides reasonable assurance to achieve the stockbroker's objectives regarding the effectiveness and efficiency of its operations, reliability and sufficiency of the information generated and compliance with applicable norms; therefore, it constitutes a first line of control whose observance contributes to intermediaries being able to comply with their obligations arising as a result of their own intermediation activities, which in turn contributes to market integrity, its transparency and investor protection; therefore, since Renta 4 SAB did not adopt the measures required for its internal auditor to comply with its functions linked to verifying compliance with the money laundering and terrorist financing prevention system in a timely, permanent and documented manner, it has affected the aforementioned principles;
- Regarding the infraction concerning the failure to sign the intermediation contract, Renta 4 SAB has put at risk the protected legal interest referring to investor protection, since by not signing the corresponding intermediation contract, the client did not know all the contracting conditions that correspond to it, among them knowing the intermediary's client policy, among others;
- With regard to the infraction referring to not applying the intensified CDD procedure to three clients of the intermediary, it should be noted that within the framework of the norms for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, the principle of knowledge of the client allows intermediaries to collect information from their clients, which in turn allows comparing the characteristics of their clients' transactions with those of their economic activity, continuously monitoring client operations, and having elements of judgment that allow analyzing unusual transactions of those clients and determining the existence of suspicious operations;
- Given the foregoing, it should be noted that the process of due identification of the client is a key component within the regulatory framework of the securities market, which allows the achievement of its objectives such as investor protection, ensuring that markets are fair, efficient and transparent; as well as the prevention of the illegal use of the securities market, which helps prevent the occurrence of fraud and market abuse practices; as well as money laundering and terrorist financing. In this sense, effective client identification and procedures for that purpose are necessary for market transparency, investor protection and to maintain market integrity;
- As for the economic harm and the repercussion on the market, it has not been possible to evidence that the infractions incurred by Renta 4 SAB have caused concrete economic harm or that they have had a repercussion on the market;
- Regarding repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it is not observed that in the present case the assumptions that could constitute a repetition and/or continuity of the infractions subject to this administrative sanctioning procedure are present;
- With reference to recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, the final sanction imposed by the SMV within one (1) year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned is taken into account. It has been verified that Renta 4 SAB does not present final sanctions for the commission of the infractions under analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure, so recidivism is not configured;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that Renta 4 SAB, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, with operating authorization of April 10, 2014 by Superintendency Resolution No. 041-2014-SMV/02, must know the norms that regulate the securities market, the specific regulation for agent companies, in particular, the regulation of intermediation agents, as well as the AML/CFT Norms, their mandatory compliance in relation to the case evaluated in the administrative sanctioning procedure, that is, the obligation to grant the internal control officer the necessary conditions of independence and not allow its participation in activities outside this, such as the first-line or front office work carried out by representatives or those who have first contact with clients;
- In the present case, Renta 4 SAB allowed its internal control officer to participate in the evaluation and admission of some of its clients, that is, at the beginning of the commercial relationship when said officer must review such evaluation and admission once they have been concluded, precisely to confirm or not whether the work carried out was done effectively and in observance of the norms that regulate the securities market as set forth, such requirements not being established in a broad and generic manner, nor imprecise as the intermediary attempts to argue in its defenses;
- With regard to the failure to sign the intermediation contract, Renta 4 SAB, although it signed a contract with its client, this did not contain the legal clauses or stipulations established in Article 31 of the Current RAI, so its client did not adequately know the conditions of its commercial relationship with the SAB, among them, knowing the intermediary's client policy;
- On the other hand, in the client knowledge procedure carried out continuously, Renta 4 SAB, knowing the obligations contained in the AML/CFT Norms, with respect to three clients with whom, through a representative, it had a commercial relationship, did not identify said clients nor apply an intensified CDD, in order to acquire sufficient and updated knowledge of these clients and beneficial owners, and thus manage the ML/TF risks to which it is exposed in its commercial relationships;
- For the foregoing, the norms breached by Renta 4 SAB are evidenced, whose infractions have been duly accredited in this procedure;
- As for the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, it has not been accredited in this administrative sanctioning procedure that Renta 4 SAB has obtained any illicit benefit as a result of having incurred the infractions under analysis;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, no intentionality has been evidenced in the conduct of Renta 4 SAB with respect to the infractions under analysis;
- Regarding the probability of detection, it should be noted that these infractions could only be detected within the framework of the inspection carried out on Renta 4 SAB, where it was requested a series of information and documentation referring to its activities as intermediary in which compliance with its obligations contained in the AML/CFT Norms was evaluated;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification, it should be noted that Renta 4 SAB has not acknowledged the commission of the infractions subject to this administrative sanctioning procedure, limiting itself only to the presentation of its defenses;
- Finally, it should be noted that in the present case none of the assumptions that constitute exempting and mitigating conditions of responsibility established in Article 257 of the TUO LPAG have been configured;
- It is appropriate to recall that Renta 4 SAB, with respect to the imputed infraction referring to non-compliance with literal c) of numeral 7.4 of Article 7 of the AML/CFT Norms, in whose defenses it has requested the application of the exemption from responsibility referring to a supposed confusing or illegal administrative provision[30], it should be noted that said literal c), referring to the action of clients through representatives, is express and clear, so it has not been evidenced that such exemption applies to the present case;
- Consequently, the arguments of Renta 4 SAB and the evidence presented in its defenses have not disproved the charges formulated;
- As for the infraction referring to non-compliance with Articles 30 and 31 of the AML/CFT Norms, such non-compliance constitutes an infraction classified as serious according to Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.20 of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the events occurred;
- However, in application of the principle of non-retroactivity contemplated in Article 248, numeral 5 of the TUO LPAG, which establishes, among others, that the sanctioning provisions in force at the time of incurring the infraction are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable, it corresponds to consider the infraction incurred as one of a minor nature since the legal type indicated in the previous paragraph has been included in Annex XVI, numeral 3, subsection 3.8 of the Current Sanctions Regulation which classifies as a minor infraction: “Incurring in acts or omissions other than those enunciated in the types of infraction contained in this annex, which, in accordance with the provisions established in the norms for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, are enforceable against the administered”;
- On the other hand, with respect to the infraction for non-compliance with Article 7, numeral 7.4 last paragraph and numeral 7.5, literals d) and c), of the AML/CFT Norms, such infraction is classified as serious according to Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the events occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature “Not carrying out the client due diligence process, in accordance with the norms for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, in the cases that according to the provisions of said norm its application corresponds”;
- For its part, regarding the infraction by Renta 4 SAB for not having complied with observing Article 31 of the Current RAI, it has incurred the infraction classified as serious typified in subsection 2.13 numeral 2, of Annex X of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the events occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature: “Breach its functions or the provisions contemplated in the norms.”;
- Finally, it should be noted that since there are three infractions committed by Renta 4 SAB, the sanction for the most serious infraction must be imposed, as indicated in the second paragraph of Article 29[31] of the Current Sanctions Regulation;
- In accordance with Article 21 of the Prior Sanctions Regulation, in force at the date the events occurred, said infraction is punishable with a fine greater than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) Tax Units (UIT) or with suspension of the operating authorization for up to twenty (20) days;
- It should be noted that the Current Sanctions Regulation states that said infraction is punishable with a fine of not less than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) UIT or with suspension of the operating authorization for up to twenty (20) days. It should be noted that said norm will be applicable to the present case as it is more favorable;
- However, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in Article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO LPAG, which states that sanctions must be proportional to non-compliances classified as infractions, and, considering that Renta 4 SAB has no record of infractions, it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed have caused damage to the public interest, nor that they have had a repercussion on the market, or that the intermediary has obtained any illicit benefit from their commission, that no intentionality was evidenced in its actions, that the agent company is not a recidivist with respect to the referred infractions; this Deputy Superintendency considers that it is possible to impose on Renta 4 SAB a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided for serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of the last paragraph of Article 25 of the Current Sanctions Regulation;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that Renta 4 SAB S.A. has incurred a serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, in force at the date the events occurred, for failing to observe Article 31 of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/10 and its amendments.
Article 2.- Declare that Renta 4 SAB S.A. has incurred a serious infraction typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, in force at the date the events occurred, for failing to observe the last paragraph of numeral 7.4 and literals c) and d) of numeral 7.5 of Article 7 of the Norms for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments.
Article 3.- Declare that Renta 4 SAB S.A. has incurred a minor infraction typified in Annex XVI, numeral 3, subsection 3.8 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, in force at the date the events occurred, for failing to observe Articles 30 and 31 of the Norms for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments.
Article 4.- Sanction Renta 4 SAB S.A. with a fine equivalent to four (04) UIT equivalent to S/ 16,200.00 (sixteen thousand two hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions referred to in Articles 1, 2 and 3 of this resolution.
Article 5.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal before it, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 6.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
Article 7.- Transcribe this resolution to Renta 4 SAB, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
In force since December 31, 2016. ↑
-
By File No. 2017025422, Renta 4 SAB notified the SMV that Ms. Roxana Yaquelina Pimentel Martinez is responsible for the Internal Audit Unit, according to Board agreement of June 27, 2017. ↑
-
Question 8 of internal control questionnaire No. 002-2017-SMV-INSP.RENTA4 SOCIEDAD AGENTE BOLSA S.A. ↑
-
Question 12 of internal control questionnaire No. 002-2017-SMV-INSP.RENTA4 SOCIEDAD AGENTE BOLSA S.A. ↑
-
Annual Special Audit Plan for 2017. ↑
-
The Code of Ethics of Internal Auditors states the following:
CODE OF ETHICS
(...)
PRINCIPLES
Internal auditors are expected to apply and uphold the following principles: (...)
2. Objectivity: Internal auditors exhibit the highest level of professional objectivity in gathering, evaluating, and communicating information about the activity or process being examined. Internal auditors make a balanced assessment of all the relevant circumstances and are not unduly influenced by their own interests or by others in forming judgments.
RULES OF CONDUCT
(...)
2. Objectivity: Internal auditors:
2.1 Shall not participate in any activity or relationship that may impair or be presumed to impair their unbiased assessment. This participation includes those activities or relationships that may be in conflict with the interests of the organization.
2.2 Shall not accept anything that may impair or be presumed to impair their professional judgment.
2.3 Shall disclose all material facts known to them that, if not disclosed, may distort the reporting of activities under review.
(...).
(Highlight added) ↑
-
No one shall be prosecuted or convicted for an act or omission that at the time of its commission is not previously qualified in the law, in an express and unequivocal manner, as a punishable infraction; nor sanctioned with a penalty not provided for in the law ↑
-
Article IV. Principles of the administrative procedure
- The administrative procedure is fundamentally based on the following principles, without prejudice to the validity of other general principles of Administrative Law:
(...)
1.11. Principle of material truth.- In the procedure, the competent administrative authority must fully verify the facts that serve as the basis for its decisions, for which it must adopt all the evidentiary measures necessary and authorized by law, even if they have not been proposed by the administered or they have agreed to waive them.
(...)” ↑
-
“Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(...)
- Causality.- Responsibility must fall on whoever carries out the omissive or active conduct constituting a sanctionable infraction.” ↑
-
“Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
- Reasonableness.- The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria that are indicated in order of priority for their graduation:
a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction;
b) The probability of detection of the infraction;
c) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest;
d) The economic harm caused;
e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final.
f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and
g) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct. ↑
-
“When the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria and mitigating factors allows concluding that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, by exception and by reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided for may be imposed.” ↑
-
5.- Non-retroactivity.- The sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered incurred the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable.
Sanctioning provisions have retroactive effect insofar as they favor the presumed offender or the offender, both with respect to the classification of the infraction and to the sanction and its prescription periods, including with respect to sanctions in execution upon the entry into force of the new provision. ↑
13. Objective:
General: The Special Audit Plan of the Money Laundering and/or Terrorist Financing Detection System has as its main purpose to identify deficiencies in the internal control system related to the prevention
of money laundering or terrorist financing, with the purpose of preventing or detecting criminal operations that go against the company's policy and applicable regulations.
Specific:
- To have the greatest possible controls with respect to the operations involved in the Money Laundering and/or Terrorist Financing Detection System.
- To achieve the participation of all persons involved in the company in the control, so that they are co-participants in the Money Laundering and/or Terrorist Financing Prevention System. [↑](#footnote-ref-13)
14. XII.1. Criteria for establishing knowledge of the client and the market, in accordance with the LA/FT NORMA.
a) No investor may carry out operations if their identification information is not presented and reviewed by the Compliance Officer, whether said person is a natural person or a legal entity.
(…)
b) Every investor, to the extent possible, must meet with the General Manager and Compliance Officer of Renta 4 SAB, in order to know them personally, after which and according to the results of said interview, Renta 4 SAB will make the decision to accept or not accept the investor.
(…) [↑](#footnote-ref-14)
15. Subsection 2.20, numeral 2, of Annex XIX of the Previous Sanctions Regulation ↑
16. Juan Carlos Morón Urbina, Comentarios a la Ley del Procedimiento Administrativo Sancionador, Fifth edition, page 629. ↑
17. Francisco Muñoz Conde, Teoría General del Delito, Second Edition, page 31. ↑
18. Francisco Muñoz Conde, Teoría General del Delito, Second Edition, pages 31 and 32. ↑
19. Article 194°.- Operations
Securities agent companies are empowered to carry out the following operations:
(…)
o) Carry out foreign currency purchase and sale operations in accordance with exchange regulations and the general provisions issued by the SMV. [↑](#footnote-ref-19)
20. Article 45.- Of the activities to be developed by the Intermediation Agents
The Agents are empowered, in accordance with the provisions of articles 194 or 206 of the Law, as applicable, to carry out the following activities:
a) Intermediation Activities. These are those operations contemplated in subsections a), b), o), p), q) and s) of article 194 or in subsections c), d) and e) of article 207 of the Law. The Agents may carry out the operations indicated in subsections a) and b) of article 194 and subsections c), d) and e) of article 207 of the Law, with Financial Instruments. Likewise, it includes the activities contemplated in subsections c), d), e) and f) of article 194 and in subsections a) and f) of article 207 of the Law. [↑](#footnote-ref-20)
21. b) Indication of acceptance and submission to the Client Policy; ↑
22. c) A prominent notice indicating:
1. The client, under no circumstances, must deliver cash to the Agent or its Representatives for the performance of its operations. The client must make its payments only through the Agent's intermediation accounts;
(…)
4. The SMV is the institution in charge of supervising the securities market. The address of the Securities Market Portal and the address and telephone number of the SMV must be recorded; [↑](#footnote-ref-22)
23. e) Obligation of the client to send the information requested by the Agent in order to verify the client's identity, its investment profile, origin of resources, among others; and the obligation to send to the SMV any information it requires for supervision purposes or to any other national authority with the corresponding competence; ↑
24. i) The means by which the client will receive the account statements. ↑
25. Article 1.- Definition, purpose and functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV)
(…)
To issue legal norms regulating matters of the securities market, product market and collective fund systems. [↑](#footnote-ref-25)
26. Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01, the Regulation of Price Providing Companies approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 101-2009-EF/94.01.1 and the Norms for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1. ↑
27. It should be noted that said infraction type has been included in numeral 2, letter 2.33, Annex I, of the Current Sanctions Regulation, which states as a serious infraction: "Not fulfilling its functions or any of the other provisions contemplated in the regulations or what is provided or required by the SMV in the exercise of its functions, specifically to the Participants." ↑
28. In reality the applicable norm is the PLAFT Norms. ↑
29. The sanction criteria referring to Recidivism and the Probability of detection of the infraction were introduced by article 2° of Legislative Decree No. 1272 which modified, among others, article 230°; numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
30. Literal e) of numeral 1 of article 257 of the TUO LPAG. ↑
31. Article 29.- CONCURRENCE OF INFRACTIONS
(…)
Likewise, when several conducts qualify as more than one infraction, the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction is imposed. [↑](#footnote-ref-31)