Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV
No. 038-2017-SMV/10
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Inversión y Desarrollo Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV No. 036-2015-SMV/10 is declared unfounded.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | Inversión y Desarrollo Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C |
| Subject | : | Reconsideration appeal against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV No. 036-2015-SMV/10 |
| File No. | : | 2015002924 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2015002924, the appeal filed by Inversión y Desarrollo Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C., Report No. 346-2016-SMV/10.3 issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, and arguments; and
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal provisions shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
- Facts
- By Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV No. 036-2015-SMV/10 dated December 22, 2015, Inversión y Desarrollo Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C., hereinafter Inversión SAB, was sanctioned with a fine of 3.57 UIT equivalent to S/ 13,209.00 (Thirteen thousand two hundred nine and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred one (01) minor infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), for having submitted the Basic Financial Statements and Control Annexes corresponding to the close of January 2013 outside the deadline established by Article 94 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, hereinafter the Regulation;
- By document presented on January 13, 2016, Inversión SAB filed an appeal that it classified as an appeal;
- On May 20, 2016 the intermediary presented its oral report;
- Formal requirements
- In accordance with Articles 207 and 211 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amending provisions (hereinafter, LPAG), appeals must be filed within fifteen (15) business days of notification of the administrative resolution, duly authorized by counsel;
- In the present case, Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV No. 036-2015-SMV/10, hereinafter the Resolution, was notified to Inversión SAB via MVNet on December 22, 2015, so that, the corresponding appeal having been filed on January 13, 2016, it is concluded that it was filed in a timely manner. It should also be noted that said appeal is signed by counsel;
- Classification of the appeal filed
- As indicated above, Inversión SAB filed a document appealing the Resolution which it classified as an appeal; however, it should be noted that numeral 17 of Article 32 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, hereinafter ROF, establishes that in the case of the imposition of sanctions for the commission of infractions of timeliness rules, as is the case here, the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, hereinafter SASP, acts as the sole administrative instance;
- In that sense, in application of numeral 3[1] of Article 75 of the LPAG, the appeal filed by Inversión SAB must be considered a reconsideration appeal;
- Arguments raised by Inversión SAB
- According to its appeal, Inversión SAB requests that the Resolution be declared null and void based on the following arguments:
a) Inversión SAB states that according to considerations 24 and 25 of the Resolution, the SMV's late response to its extension request is not taken into consideration as a valid reason for the submission of said financial information after the SMV's response, such criterion being based on the provisions of Article 94, numeral 94.1 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, hereinafter the Regulation, Article 136, numeral 136.2 of the LPAG and because it is not a procedure subject to the TUPA[2];
b) It adds that if with considerations 18 to 20 and 23 of the Resolution, the SMV suggests that responsibility for the late submission lies exclusively with Inversión SAB, because Article 136, numeral 136.1 of the LPAG establishes the existence of deadlines without extension and in that reasoning Inversión SAB should not have requested an extension, this does not undermine the right provided in Article 106 of the LPAG. Thus it considers it contradictory that the SMV has implicitly applied said Article 106, by responding to the extension request and in that framework it should have responded within the deadline established in Article 132, numeral 3 of the LPAG (seven business days);
c) Therefore, Inversión SAB states that the SMV bears responsibility for the questioned timeliness of the submission of the financial statements for the close of January 2013, especially considering that in accordance with Article 16[3] of the LPAG, the denial of the extension took effect from the response of April 23, 2013 and the SMV is obliged to carry out its duties in a timely manner, to facilitate the administered entities the timely exercise of their procedural acts (subparagraph 5 of Article 75[4] of the LPAG) and it is their right to demand compliance with deadlines by the authorities and to demand responsibility when applicable, which from its perspective falls on the SMV for the timing in which Inversión SAB submitted said financial information;
d) Consequently, having not taken into account the regulations expressed in the preceding numerals in accordance with Article 10, numeral 1 of the LPAG, the Resolution is vitiated by nullity not only because its aforementioned administrative action contravenes the regulations mentioned above, but also because it constitutes a contravention of the provisions of Article 145 of the LPAG, in that it did not apply it when resolving;
- Evaluation of the arguments presented by Inversión SAB
- As a preliminary matter, it should be noted that although in its appeal Inversión SAB argues that there has been a defect of nullity of the Resolution, the case analyzed will be evaluated and resolved by the SASP, subject to the provisions of Article 11.2[5] of the LPAG, since for the purposes of imposing sanctions for the submission of periodic information and material events in accordance with Article 31 of the ROF, the SASP constitutes the sole administrative instance;
- Taking into account the request for nullity formulated by Inversión SAB, it is necessary to issue a pronouncement on said aspect;
- In this regard, it should be noted that the LPAG establishes in its Article 10 that: "The following are defects of the administrative act that cause its nullity by operation of law: 1. Contravention of the Constitution, laws or regulatory provisions; 2. The defect or omission of any of its validity requirements, unless any of the cases of preservation of the act referred to in Article 14 occurs; 3. Express acts or those resulting from automatic approval or positive administrative silence, by which powers or rights are acquired, when they are contrary to the legal system, or when the requirements, documentation or essential procedures for their acquisition are not met; 4. Administrative acts that constitute a criminal offense, or that are issued as a consequence thereof";
- As follows from Article 10, numeral 1 of the LPAG, for said cause to be verified it must be evident that the act was performed contrary to the provisions of a normative disposition, that is, it implies that the challenged resolution was issued contravening express norms;
- Regarding the argument raised by Inversión SAB that although Article 136 of the LPAG establishes the existence of deadlines without extension, this does not undermine Inversión SAB's right to exercise its right of petition under the cited Article 106 and the SMV's obligation to comply with the deadline established in Article 132, numeral 3 of the LPAG, it should be noted that regardless of whether the deadline to respond to the requested extension was seven (07) or thirty (30) business days, what is relevant in the analyzed case is that Inversión SAB did not comply with submitting the financial statements for the close of January 2013 within the deadline provided by Article 94 of the Regulation, that is, March 4, 2013. It should also be noted that the cited norm has expressly established these maximum submission deadlines without providing for any extension, so that in accordance with the provisions of Article 136 of the LPAG, this deadline is non-extendable;
- Regarding the claim by Inversión SAB that the SMV would bear responsibility for the questioned timeliness of the submission of the aforementioned financial information, since the denial of the extension took effect from the response of April 23, 2013 and the SMV must carry out its duties in a timely manner, to facilitate the administered entities the timely exercise of their procedural acts (Article 75, numeral 5 of the LPAG), it should be noted that the timing in which the SMV responded to the request for extension of the deadline does not justify the action of Inversión SAB in the analyzed case, since it was obliged to submit said financial information within the deadline established by Article 94 of the Regulation, that is, March 4, 2013;
- In that sense, the aforementioned brokerage firm not only failed to comply with said submission, but also on said date, with full knowledge that Article 94 of the Regulation does not contain extensions or deferrals regarding the deadline for submitting said information and of the provisions of Article 136 of the LPAG which establishes that deadlines set by express norm, as is the case of Article 94, are non-extendable, unless there is an enabling provision to the contrary; it requested an extension, which as a consequence of the cited articles could not be granted in any way, so there is no basis for Inversión SAB to have failed to comply with its obligation within the deadline established in the applicable regulations and even less for the response to said request to be set as a prior condition for compliance with the deadlines for timely submission of information that are clearly and expressly contained in the applicable regulations;
- Regarding the argument raised by Inversión SAB about the right of administrative petition (Article 106 of the LPAG), the deadline in which the SMV may have incurred in responding to the extension requested by Inversión SAB and from that establishing the effectiveness of the administrative act (Article 16 of the LPAG), it should be noted that said aspect is not admissible to attempt to justify the non-compliance in question and in that sense does not exempt Inversión SAB from complying with the deadline to submit the financial information expressly established in Article 94 of the Regulation;
- Without prejudice to the provisions of the preceding consideration, addressing that argument would imply maintaining that the mere formulation of a request for extension of the deadline already supposes obtaining the requested extension and that this supposed obtained extension would only lose effect at the time of notification of the denial of what was requested. As is evident, the obligations to submit information within the deadlines established by the regulations are not affected per se by the mere formulation of extension requests. These requests, only if granted, will have the effects of an administrative act intended to vary the maximum established deadline and provided that in those cases there has been an enabling norm to grant said extension;
- Finally, regarding what was stated by Inversión SAB in the sense that in the present case the provisions of Article 145 of the LPAG have been contravened, it should be noted that this norm regulates the so-called "Ex officio impetus" in charge of the Public Administration, according to which, among others, the competent authority must promote any action necessary for its processing and overcome any obstacle that opposes the regular processing of the procedure, determine the norm applicable to the case even if it has not been invoked or the legal citation is erroneous;
- In that sense, it should be noted that in the case under analysis this principle is not applicable, since the request formulated by Inversión SAB for an extension of the deadline for submitting the financial information for the close of January 2013 does not exempt compliance with the deadlines legally established for the submission of the financial statements for the close of January 2013, as well as it lacks foundation to invoke that the administration did not respond to its request and rely on that to justify its non-compliance; especially since Inversión SAB was fully aware, as indicated in considerations 15 and 16 of this resolution, that according to the provisions of Article 94 of the Regulation, the deadline to submit said financial information expired on March 4, 2013 and that the aforementioned Article 94 did not admit extensions or exemptions to said deadline;
- For the foregoing, it is concluded that in the analyzed case the Resolution does not contravene any express norm;
- Regarding Article 10, numeral 2 of the LPAG which establishes as a cause of nullity the defect or omission of the validity requirements of the administrative act, it should be noted that in accordance with Article 3 of the LPAG the validity requirements of administrative acts are competence, object or content, public purpose, regular procedure and motivation;
- As for competence, it should be noted that the Resolution was issued by the SASP, in regular exercise of its functions and subject to the provisions of Article 31, numeral 17 of the ROF, which provides that the SASP is empowered to impose sanctions in the sole administrative instance for the commission of infractions regarding the timeliness in the submission of periodic and occasional information;
- In order to determine whether in the analyzed case the object of the challenged resolution complies with the provisions of Article 3, numeral 2 of the LPAG, it must be verified whether from said resolution its legal effects can be unequivocally determined and whether its content conforms to the legal system, a situation that is verified in the present case, since from its review it is clearly apparent the commission of the infraction imputed to Inversión SAB, as well as the sanction imposed and it has also been issued in accordance with the applicable regulations and in accordance with the powers held by the SASP;
- Regarding public purpose, it should be noted that the Resolution satisfies a general interest; and, as developed in the preceding considerations, it has been issued in accordance with the applicable regulations, so we disagree with Inversión SAB's statements on this aspect;
- Furthermore, the act contained in the Resolution is duly motivated, as follows from the review of its fifty-six (56) considerations, in which it pronounces on the charges imputed to said brokerage firm, the defenses and arguments presented, the commission of the infractions and the imposition of the sanctions;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the Resolution was issued within a regular procedure, such as the one followed in file No. 2015002924;
- It should be noted that Article 10, numeral 3 of the LPAG refers to express or presumed acts, by which powers or rights are acquired that are contrary to the legal system or lack established requirements and numeral 4 regulates the case of administrative acts that are not only unlawful, but issued as a consequence of a criminal offense, cases that are not applicable to the administrative act contained in the resolution under analysis;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that it is not possible, as Inversión SAB intends, to discard the application to the analyzed case of the provisions of Article 136 of the LPAG, since it is a norm of public order and mandatory compliance, for any administered entity, including brokerage agents such as Inversión SAB, supervised by the SMV with valid authorization and furthermore it is clear that the infraction incurred by Inversión SAB was as a consequence of not submitting within the deadline set in Article 94 of the Regulation the financial statements for the close of January 2013;
- For the reasons set forth, it is concluded that the present case is not included in the causes of nullity contemplated in Article 10 of the LPAG, so that the arguments contained in the appeal filed by Inversión SAB have not disproved the grounds indicated in the Resolution that served as the basis for the imposition of the sanction applied to said company;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 27, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- To declare unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by Inversión y Desarrollo Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. for the reasons set forth in this resolution.
- To declare that the administrative remedies have been exhausted since Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV No. 036-2015-SMV/10 has become final.
- This resolution shall be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
- To transcribe this resolution to Inversión y Desarrollo Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
"Article 75.- Duties of authorities in procedures
The duties of authorities with respect to the administrative procedure and its participants are the following:
(…)
3. To direct the procedure ex officio, when it detects any error or omission of the administered entities, without prejudice to the action corresponding to them." ↑
-
(…)"
In this line of reasoning it also considers that it is exempt from responsibility for the effects of its late response, included within the scope of numeral 143.1 of the LPAG. ↑
-
"Article 16.- Effectiveness of the administrative act
16.1 The administrative act is effective from the time the legally made notification produces its effects, in accordance with the provisions of this chapter.
(…)" ↑
-
"Article 75.- Duties of authorities in procedures
The duties of authorities with respect to the administrative procedure and its participants are the following:
(…)
5. To carry out their duties in a timely manner, to facilitate the administered entities the timely exercise of their procedural acts.
(…)" ↑
-
"Article 11.- Competent instance to declare nullity
(…)
11.2 The nullity shall be known and declared by the superior authority of the one who issued the act. If it is an act issued by an authority that is not subject to hierarchical subordination, the nullity shall be declared by resolution of the same authority.
(…)" ↑