Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision SMV
No. 040-2015-SMV/10
Summary: BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa is sanctioned with a fine of one (01) UIT amounting to S/ 3,700.00 (Three Thousand Seven Hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred in one (01) infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation by not obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the operations in which they intervene.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2014027807 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2014027807, Report No. 408-2015-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, as well as the defenses presented by BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (hereinafter SMV), so that any reference in legal norms to CONASEV shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
- Background
- Through writings sent to the SMV on December 27, 2013 and February 10, 2014, Mr. Jonathan Joseph Eskenazi Markewitz (hereinafter, Mr. Eskenazi) files a complaint against BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa (hereinafter, BTG Pactual SAB) because, according to the writing of February 10, 2014, said stock brokerage firm would have carried out in his name and without his authorization the operations detailed below;
Table No. 01
| | | | | | | |
|---|
| No. | Date | Type | Security | Issuer | Quantity | Price (US$) | Market |
| 1 | 06/07/2013 | Purchase | TZA | Direxion Daily Small Cap Bear 3X (ETF) | 1,000 | 31.389 | NYSE |
| 2 | 06/07/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (ETF) | 1,000 | 10.54 | NYSE |
| 3 | 06/07/2013 | Purchase | RIO | Rio Alto Mining Limited | 3,000 | 2.607 | BVL |
| 4 | 06/10/2013 | Purchase | RIO | Rio Alto Mining Limited | 2,000 | 2.51 | BVL |
| 5 | 06/11/2013 | Purchase | RIO | Rio Alto Mining Limited | 3,000 | 2.36 | BVL |
| 6 | 06/13/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (ETF) | 1,000 | 9.44 | NYSE |
| 7 | 06/18/2013 | Purchase | TZA | Direccion Small Cap Bear 3x Shares (ETF) | 1,000 | 29.92 | NYSE |
| 8 | 06/18/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (ETF) | 1,000 | 9.06 | NYSE |
| 9 | 06/19/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (ETF) | 1,000 | 8.25 | NYSE |
| 10 | 06/20/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (ETF) | 2,000 | 6.67 | NYSE |
| 11 | 07/05/2013 | Purchase | TZA | Direxion Daily Small Cap Bear 3X (ETF) | 1,000 | 29.25 | NYSE |
| 12 | 07/10/2013 | Purchase | TZA | Direxion Daily Small Cap Bear 3X (ETF) | 1,000 | 27.75 | NYSE |
- Through writings sent on January 23, March 11 and June 10, 2014, BTG Pactual SAB presents documentation required by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as additional information that, in the opinion of the brokerage agent, would support the aforementioned orders;
- As indicated in the Client Registration Form of Mr. Eskenazi dated October 20, 2010 (hereinafter, Client Registration Form), sent by BTG Pactual SAB, the modality for receiving orders agreed by Mr. Eskenazi with BTG Pactual SAB for the transmission of instructions on behalf of the client is by telephone or through web applications;
- Likewise, within the information sent, BTG Pactual SAB presents eight (08) audio recordings of telephone calls containing instructions from Mr. Eskenazi for carrying out purchase and sale operations in his name. However, with respect to the operations indicated by Mr. Eskenazi in his writing of February 10, 2014, as unauthorized, only one (01) instruction, which supports the carrying out of one (01) of said operations, is contained in one of the aforementioned recordings;
- Indeed, Recording No. 8215691 of June 18, 2013 contains the instruction to purchase 1,000 NUGT shares at the limit price of US$ 9.14 given by Mr. Eskenazi, which supports the carrying out of the following operation, according to Policy No. 17203 presented by BTG Pactual SAB:
Table No. 02
| | | | | |
|---|
| Date | Type | Security | Quantity | Price (US$) | Market |
| 06/18/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | 1,000 | 9.06 | NYSE |
- In that sense, only one (01) of the purchase operations indicated by Mr. Eskenazi in his writing of February 10, 2014 has the respective order, obtained according to the modality established in the Client Registration Form;
- In that sense, as a result of the evaluation carried out, as well as under the protection of the provisions of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, Lpag), through Official Letter No. 3434-2014-SMV/10.3 an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against BTG Pactual SAB for having observed indications of the commission of an infraction of Article 175 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV) and Articles 30, numeral 30.2 and 75, numeral 75.5 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amending norms (hereinafter, Rai), by not complying with obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to reliable subsequent verification, in the operations in which they intervene and in accordance with what was agreed in their respective Client Registration Form;
- The aforementioned non-compliance is classified in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), according to which it constitutes a minor infraction "Not obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene";
- On August 7, 2014, BTG Pactual SAB presented its respective defenses;
- The charges formulated, as well as the defenses presented by BTG Pactual SAB have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 408-2015-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, item 1, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, item 2, of the Lpag, through Official Letter No. 1960-2015-SMV/10 the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made available to BTG Pactual SAB for its review;
- Issues to be determined
- In this administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether BTG Pactual SAB incurred or not in an infraction by not complying with obtaining the purchase orders whose existence or veracity can be verified by reliable subsequent verification mechanisms, corresponding to the eleven (11) purchase operations questioned by Mr. Eskenazi (hereinafter, operations), in accordance with the provisions of Article 175 of the LMV and Articles 30, numeral 30.2 and 75, numeral 75.5 of the Rai.
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on BTG Pactual SAB;
- Analysis
- Applicable regulations
- Article 175 of the LMV establishes that brokerage agents are obliged to obtain from their principals written or telephone orders provided that the latter are recorded, without prejudice to other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that the SMV may establish through general provisions;
- In that context, Article 30, numeral 30.2 of the Rai establishes that for the purposes of orders given for the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, it must be observed that orders on behalf of a client may be instructed to the brokerage agent, among others, through the following means: written, fax with subsequent confirmation, telephone, email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation, in accordance with what was agreed in their respective client registration form;
- Likewise, Article 75, numeral 75.5, penultimate paragraph of the Rai, referring to the indication of the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the intermediary and its client, so that instructions on behalf of the client are transmitted, provides that the enabling by the stock brokerage firm of any of the modalities of receiving orders obliges them to implement the corresponding mechanism, which allows subsequent verification by reliable means, of the conditions under which the orders were given[1];
- The non-observance of the obligations described above is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes a minor infraction: "Not obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene";
3.2 Of the charge formulated
- Through Official Letter No. 3434-2014-SMV/10.3, charges were formulated against BTG Pactual SAB for not complying with obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the operations in which they intervene; this to the extent that despite the provisions of the referred norms and that in the Client Registration Form, the modality of receiving orders agreed between Mr. Eskenazi and Btg Pactual Sab was telephone or through web applications; the intermediary did not comply with sending the audio recordings of the orders corresponding to the execution of the purchase operations detailed below, questioned by Mr. Eskenazi in his writing of February 10, 2014;
Table No. 03
| | | | | | |
|---|
| No. | Date | Type | Security | Quantity | Price (US$) | Market |
| 1 | 06/07/2013 | Purchase | TZA | 1,000 | 31.389 | NYSE |
| 2 | 06/07/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | 1,000 | 10.54 | NYSE |
| 3 | 06/07/2013 | Purchase | RIO | 3,000 | 2.607 | BVL |
| 4 | 06/10/2013 | Purchase | RIO | 2,000 | 2.51 | BVL |
| 5 | 06/11/2013 | Purchase | RIO | 3,000 | 2.36 | BVL |
| 6 | 06/13/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | 1,000 | 9.44 | NYSE |
| 7 | 06/18/2013 | Purchase | TZA | 1,000 | 29.92 | NYSE |
| 8 | 06/19/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | 1,000 | 8.25 | NYSE |
| 9 | 06/20/2013 | Purchase | NUGT | 2,000 | 6.67 | NYSE |
| 10 | 07/05/2013 | Purchase | TZA | 1,000 | 29.25 | NYSE |
| 11 | 07/10/2013 | Purchase | TZA | 1,000 | 27.75 | NYSE |
- Consequently, it was noted that BTG Pactual SAB would not have complied with obtaining the respective orders susceptible to subsequent verification by reliable means and in accordance with the specific conditions established in the Rai, from said principal, with respect to the referred operations and therefore would be incurring in an infraction classified as minor as established in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction: "Not obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene";
3.3 Of the defenses presented
-
- Mr. Eskenazi was aware of each operation.
a.1 The policies delivered by email
- According to BTG Pactual SAB, the twelve (12) operations questioned by Mr. Eskenazi were carried out with his full knowledge; that is, BTG Pactual SAB states that it complied with sending Mr. Eskenazi, via email, the policies corresponding to said operations on the same day they were made, that is, within the term established by Article 79 of the Rai, as recorded, according to the stock brokerage firm, in the copies of each email sent from the Confirmations Mailbox of BTG Pactual SAB that they attach as evidence;
a.2 The emails informing about the status of the portfolio
- Additionally, they state that as recorded in the email they attach, dated July 15, 2013, Mr. Ricardo Ángeles Sánchez, Representative of BTG Pactual SAB (hereinafter, Mr. Ángeles) summarized to Mr. Eskenazi the positions he held in his portfolio;
- Additionally, they state that as recorded in the email they attach, dated July 15, 2013, Mr. Ángeles sent Mr. Eskenazi the following summary of the positions he held in his portfolio:
- Detail of all purchases of RIO shares made, including the purchase of 2,000 securities at a price of US$ 2.51 each, made on June 10, 2013 and the purchase of 3,000 RIO shares at a price of US$ 2.36 each, made on June 11, 2013.
- Detail on the purchase of 4,000 NUGT shares: 1,000 of them at a price of US$ 9.06 each, acquired on June 18, 2013; another 1,000 at a price of US$ 8.25 each, acquired on June 19, 2013; and 2,000 at a price of US$ 6.25 each, acquired on June 20, 2013.
- Detail on the purchase of 2,000 TZA shares: 1,000 of them at a price of US$ 29.25 each, acquired on July 5, 2013 and the other 1,000 at a price of US$ 27.75, acquired on July 10, 2013.
- In that sense, the 5,000 RIO shares, the 4,000 NUGT shares and the 2,000 TZA shares in which Mr. Eskenazi's portfolio increased during the months of June and July 2013 are precisely the shares acquired through seven (07) of the orders that Mr. Eskenazi claims to be unaware of;
a.3 Mr. Eskenazi had access to information about his account statements
- BTG Pactual SAB argues that Mr. Eskenazi accessed on several occasions the account statements corresponding to the months of June and July 2013, which is precisely the period in which the operations that Mr. Eskenazi questions were carried out. They state that they obtained this information from the electronic services provider of BTG Pactual SAB (Andes Consulting), which allows them to prove, according to BTG Pactual SAB, that Mr. Eskenazi accessed his account statements through different IPs around the world;
- Likewise, they state that Mr. Eskenazi chose the option of consulting his account statements through the BTG Pactual SAB website, as recorded in the Client Registration Form. They highlight that this modality allowed Mr. Eskenazi to consult his account statements uninterruptedly twenty-four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week;
a.4 Mr. Eskenazi ordered the sale of shares he claims not to know he had
- According to BTG Pactual SAB, Mr. Eskenazi ordered the carrying out of the following operations:
- The sale operation of 1,000 NUGT shares made on June 10, 2013, (through which the only 1,000 NUGT shares that Mr. Eskenazi had at that date and that had been acquired on June 7, 2013 were sold, whose purchase he claims not to recognize).
- The purchase operation and the sale operation of 1,000 NUGT shares made on the same day, that is, June 13, 2013. (Before the purchase made, that same day, Mr. Eskenazi did not have any NUGT shares).
- The sale operation of 5,000 RIO shares made on July 15, 2013 (among which were the 2,000 RIO shares acquired on June 10, 2013 whose purchase has been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi).
- The sale operation of 6,000 RIO shares made on August 12, 2013 (through which the 3,000 RIO shares that were acquired on June 11, 2013 and whose purchase has been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi were sold).
- The sale operation of 2,000 NUGT shares made on July 19, 2013 (among which were the 1,000 NUGT shares acquired on June 18, 2013, whose purchase has been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi).
- In all cases, the securities sold by Mr. Eskenazi are precisely the securities acquired during the months of June and July 2013 through the purchase orders that he now claims to be unaware of, as stated by BTG Pactual SAB;
a.5 In his (recorded) communications Mr. Eskenazi refers to securities he claims not to know he had.
- According to BTG Pactual SAB, in the conversations held between Mr. Ángeles and Mr. Eskenazi, as recorded in recordings No. 8223886 and 8228443 dated July 8 and 18, 2013, respectively, Mr. Eskenazi refers to his holding of TZA shares; however, in the complaint presented, Mr. Eskenazi denies having ordered the purchase of said shares;
- Likewise, they state that in the recording dated July 8, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi refers to the TZA shares he held at that date, however, prior to the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares made on July 5, 2013 (which Mr. Eskenazi now claims to be unaware of), Mr. Eskenazi did not have any TZA securities;
- Additionally, they allege that in the recording dated July 18, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi refers to the 2,000 TZA shares he held at that date, being the case that said holding originates from the operation made on July 5, 2013 referred to in the previous recital and the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares made on July 10, 2013;
- On the other hand, they state, in relation to the eleven (11) operations detailed above, that it was Mr. Eskenazi himself who proposed to BTG Pactual SAB on different occasions to document those orders by alternative means while he was out of the country. An example of this, according to BTG Pactual SAB, is the communication via email of June 12, 2013, held by Mr. Eskenazi and Mr. Ángeles. In the copy of this email, which they attach to their defense writing, mention is made of the following:
"From: Jonathan Eskenazi <jeskenazi@hotmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, June 12, 2013 12:54 AM
To: Angeles, Ricardo
Subject: Call me urgently
bro I'm going to the airport in 5 hours...I'm going to see the beginning of the market
if nugt goes up we exit
rios I think it can bounce to 280 it would be good
sue tell me what's happening? should we exit?
write by whats app"
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, BTG Pactual SAB recognizes that the fact that the client was out of the country did not excuse them from having to obtain his orders in accordance with what was agreed in the Client Registration Form, as stated in Article 30, numeral 2 of the Rai. In that line, they state that they have adjusted their order reception policy (Trading Desk Policy) and instructed their representatives not to make the same mistake again;
- Additionally, they state that in the event that it is decided to impose an administrative sanction on them, it must be considered that Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in Article 348 of the LMV and Article 230, numeral 3, of the Lpag, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the possible offender to the clarification of the facts that occurred;
- In that sense, BTG Pactual SAB develops each of the sanction criteria applicable to sanctioning procedures;
3.4 Evaluation of the defenses presented
-
In accordance with the aforementioned regulations, for brokerage agents to carry out certain operations on behalf of their clients, they are obligated to obtain written orders from them, except for those orders whose existence or veracity can be verified by reliable subsequent verification mechanisms, and this will depend on the modality expressly agreed upon in the client registration form for the receipt of such orders; this in accordance with the provisions of Article 175 of the LMV and Article 30, numeral 2 of the RAI;
-
In the client registration form signed by Mr. Eskenazi, it was established that the modalities for receiving orders agreed between Btg Pactual Sab and Mr. Eskenazi for transmitting instructions on behalf of the client were specifically two: i) Telephone and ii) Applications implemented from the intermediary's website;
-
In this regard, it must be specified that according to Article 175 of the LMV, orders may be telephone orders as long as they are recorded from the moment they are received and in accordance with the provisions of Article 77A of the RAI; for an intermediary to receive orders from a client by telephone means, it must implement a call recording system that allows registering the orders;
-
Regarding web applications as a means of transmitting orders, it should be noted that with respect to the latter, in the information submitted by BTG Pactual SAB no reference is made to the aforementioned applications as a means for its clients to communicate their orders via the Internet;
-
On the other hand, Article 75, penultimate paragraph of the Rai, provides that the authorization by the stock brokerage firm of any of the modalities for receiving orders, indicated in the referred article, obligates them to implement the corresponding mechanism that allows subsequent verification by reliable means of the conditions under which the orders were given;
-
Since in this administrative sanctioning procedure the charge was imputed for not obtaining orders from Mr. Eskenazi for the execution of operations that the client states he did not authorize, and considering that the means agreed in the Client Form for transmitting orders from Mr. Eskenazi to the intermediary were Telephone and Web Applications; BTG Pactual SAB had to rebut the imputed charge by means of subsequent verification by reliable means. However, the stock brokerage firm did not send the audio recordings of the orders corresponding to the execution of the purchase operations detailed in Table No. 03 of this resolution or means linked to any web application;
-
Consequently, based on the foregoing, it is concluded that BTG Pactual SAB did not comply with obtaining the respective orders susceptible to subsequent verification by reliable means and in accordance with the specific conditions established in the Rai, from said client, with respect to the referred operations;
-
Notwithstanding the foregoing, BTG Pactual SAB argues that the execution of these eleven (11) operations was known to Mr. Eskenazi and that it was Mr. Eskenazi himself who proposed on different occasions to document the orders supporting the operations by alternative means while he was out of the country;
-
According to what was alleged by BTG Pactual SAB, the alternative means referred to would be email and WhatsApp Messenger[2], (hereinafter, WhatsApp), and they present, according to BTG Pactual SAB, by way of example, a copy of the email sent by Mr. Eskenazi on June 12, 2013, from his personal email[3], to Mr. Ángeles, through which they maintain a communication in which Mr. Eskenazi indicates that he will be traveling and in that sense gives instructions for the execution of certain operations with the securities of which he is the holder and asks him to write via WhatsApp;
-
Additionally, as noted, BTG Pactual SAB, in order to demonstrate that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the purchase operations carried out, alleges that since they complied with sending him the policies corresponding to said operations, as well as informing him about the portfolio status via email and since Mr. Eskenazi had permanent access to information about his account statements, Mr. Eskenazi cannot ignore the execution of said operations;
-
Likewise, they argue that Mr. Eskenazi ordered certain sale operations of securities acquired in the aforementioned purchase operations, which appear in the policies sent to Mr. Eskenazi and in certain recorded communications, in which Mr. Eskenazi refers to some of the securities regarding which he stated he was not the holder;
-
In this sense, considering the arguments presented by BTG Pactual SAB and the information submitted, it is necessary to evaluate each of the eleven (11) purchase operations, with respect to which BTG Pactual SAB has not complied with presenting the corresponding orders susceptible to subsequent verification by reliable means;
- Purchase operation carried out on 07/06/2013: Purchase of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 10.54
-
BTG Pactual SAB states that before the purchase operation of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 10.54 carried out on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi on 07/06/2013, Mr. Eskenazi did not hold any NUGT securities;
-
Thus, according to BTG Pactual SAB, the sale operation of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 10.86 carried out on 10/06/2013 corresponds to the sale of those 1,000 NUGT shares acquired on 07/06/2013, whose purchase Mr. Eskenazi claims not to recognize;
-
In this regard, according to what was stated by BTG Pactual SAB, this sale operation was ordered by Mr. Eskenazi (jeskenazi@hotmail.com[4]) via an email dated June 10, 2013[5] sent to Mr. Ángeles ([6]ricardo.angeles@celfin.com10), whose text is as follows:
“I don't have internet call me
Nugt is sold today take out what you can”
-
According to the operations contained in the Client's Current Account Statement for the period from February 3, 2013 to February 6, 2014, submitted by Mr. Eskenazi himself[7], which shows a final balance as of February 6, 204 – US$ 30,065.55, as well as the one submitted by BTG Pactual SAB as of December 9, 2013[8] (hereinafter, Account Statement), submitted during the preliminary inquiry stage, which presents movements for the period from April 26, 2013 to December 9, 2013, showing the same operations and final balance as the account statement submitted by Mr. Eskenazi, it is observed that Mr. Eskenazi did not hold NUGT shares before the date of the purchase operation of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 10.54, carried out on June 7, 2013, since with respect to the shares he acquired prior to that date, it is verified in the same Account Statement that sale operations were carried out;
-
Also, as observed in the Account Statement, the operation following June 7, 2013, carried out with this security, is the sale operation carried out on June 10, 2013, which is not part of the operations questioned by Mr. Eskenazi, according to the content of his complaint writings;
-
Likewise, in the Custody Movement from January 1, 2008 to February 24, 2014 regarding NUGT shares, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB with the defense brief, the purchase and sale operations carried out with this security on June 7, 2013 and June 10, 2013, respectively, are verified;
-
As can be seen from the aforementioned documentation, as well as from the sequence of operations with said security, it can be concluded that the sale operation carried out on June 10, 2013 corresponds to the shares acquired in the purchase operation of June 7, 2013, since no subsequent purchase operation is observed between that date and June 10, 2013;
-
Therefore, the sale operation instructed by Mr. Eskenazi on June 10, 2013 of 1,000 NUGT shares, regarding which he has not questioned having given the respective order, cannot correspond to the sale of shares other than the 1,000 NUGT shares acquired on June 7, 2013, and in that sense Mr. Eskenazi cannot allege ignorance of said purchase operation, since he could not have disposed of shares of which he was not the holder, from which it follows that the referred client was aware of the acquisition of said shares;
-
However, although from the information presented by BTG Pactual SAB it follows that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the purchase operation of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 10.54 carried out on June 7, 2013 in his name, BTG Pactual SAB, in accordance with the provisions of the LMV, the Rai and what was agreed in the Client Registration Form, should have obtained the order by telephone and made the corresponding recording;
- Purchase operation carried out on 07/06/2013: Purchase of 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 31.389
-
Regarding this purchase operation, although BTG Pactual SAB has not expressly argued in its defense brief regarding Mr. Eskenazi's knowledge of said purchase operation, from the evaluation of the other arguments alleged, the documentation submitted during the preliminary inquiry stage and those submitted with its defense, it has been possible to determine that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the referred purchase operation;
-
Indeed, according to the Account Statement, it is observed that Mr. Eskenazi did not hold TZA shares before the date of the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 31.389, carried out on June 7, 2013, since with respect to the shares he acquired prior to that date, it is verified in the same Account Statement that sale operations were carried out;
-
As also observed in the Account Statement, the operation following June 7, 2013, carried out with this security, is the sale operation carried out on June 11, 2013, which is not part of the operations questioned by Mr. Eskenazi, as indicated in his complaint writings;
-
Likewise, in the Custody Movement from January 1, 2010 to August 7, 2014 regarding TZA shares, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB with the defense brief, the purchase and sale operations carried out with this security on June 7, 2013 and June 11, 2013, respectively, are verified;
-
As can be seen from the aforementioned documentation, as well as from the operations carried out with said security, it is validly inferred that the sale operation carried out on June 11, 2013 corresponds to the shares acquired in the purchase operation of June 7, 2013, since no purchase operation is observed after that date and before the sale operation of June 11, 2013;
-
Therefore, the sale operation instructed by Mr. Eskenazi on June 11, 2013 of 1,000 TZA shares, regarding which he has not questioned having given the respective order, cannot correspond to the sale of shares other than the 1,000 TZA shares acquired on June 7, 2013, and in that sense Mr. Eskenazi cannot allege ignorance of said purchase operation, since he could not have disposed of shares of which he was not the holder, from which it is concluded that the referred client was aware of the acquisition of said shares;
-
However, although from the analysis carried out it can be concluded that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares carried out on June 7, 2013, BTG Pactual SAB had the obligation to act in accordance with the provisions of the LMV, the Rai, as well as with what was agreed in the Client Registration Form, that is, to obtain Mr. Eskenazi's order by telephone and make the corresponding recording;
- Purchase operations of RIO shares carried out on 07/06/2013 (Purchase of 3,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.607); on 10/06/2013, (Purchase of 2,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.51) and on 11/06/2013 (Purchase of 3,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.36)
-
Regarding the purchase operation of June 7, 2013, it should be noted that BTG Pactual SAB has not presented arguments in its defense brief in this regard;
-
However, it should be specified, as in the previous cases, that according to what could be verified from the information contained in the Account Statement and in information whose source is CAVALI ICLV S.A., before the purchase operation of 3,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.607 carried out on June 7, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi had not acquired RIO securities;
-
Likewise, after said purchase operation, the purchase operations of 2,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.51 on June 10, 2013 and 3,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.36 on June 11, 2013 are observed, totaling 8,000 RIO shares. Regarding these last two (02) operations, BTG Pactual SAB states that these shares were subject to sale operations on July 15, 2013 and August 12, 2013, respectively;
-
Subsequent to the three (03) purchase operations of RIO shares mentioned above, on June 27, 2013, another purchase operation of 3,000 RIO shares at US$ 1.71 was carried out on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi, which has not been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi;
-
After that date, according to the information contained in the Account Statement, no other purchase operations of RIO shares on behalf of this client are verified. In this sense, as of June 27, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi held 11,000 RIO shares;
-
According to what was alleged by BTG Pactual SAB, it carried out on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi two (02) sale operations of RIO shares, on July 15, 2013 in which 5,000 shares were sold at US$ 2.00 and on August 12, 2013 in which 6,000 shares were sold at US$ 2.60, and according to BTG Pactual SAB, this included the 3,000 RIO shares acquired on June 11, 2013; sale operations that have not been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi;
-
It should be added that regarding the three (3) purchase operations of RIO shares referred to above, via email dated July 15, 2013, Mr. Ángeles (ricardo.angeles@celfin.com) sends Mr. Eskenazi (jeskenazi@hotmail.com) information on the shareholdings as of that date, among which were the RIO shares, recommending the sale of 5,000 RIO shares, whose text is as follows:
“BRO note that we are dropping……it's urgent…jump even if flat….
According to EECC
(….)
RIO 11K @ 2.38=USD 22K
Sell 5K @ 2.00
3K @ 1.71
3k @ 2.36
2k @ 2.51
3k @ 2.60
(….)”.
- After sending this email, on the same date, July 15, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi carried out a sale operation of 5,000 RIO shares, which is recorded in Recording No. 8227190, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, whose transcription is as follows:
Mr. Ángeles: “I just sent you the email with the detail of your prices….
(…) sell 5,000 RIO (…) you are not going to lose US$1,000 you are going to lose… how much... US$ 200 (…)”
(….)
Mr. Eskenazi: “(…) sell 3k at 2.00 right now and we wait for 2 (…)”
(…)
Mr. Ángeles: “(…) that's why I tell you 3000 you bought at 1.71 another price you bought 2000 at 2.36 which is the lowest (…)
(…)
Mr. Eskenazi: “(…) ok then that's what you want to be happy? sell 5000 RIO… sell 5000 RIO now (…)”
Mr. Ángeles: “(…) I have to take your order (…)”
(…)
Mr. Eskenazi*: “(…)* ok sell 5 (…)”
Mr. Ángeles: “I sell you 5,000 RIO at US$ 2.00”
-
As detailed in the transcription of the recording, Mr. Eskenazi ordered the sale of 5,000 RIO shares, which according to the review of the Account Statement would be part of the 11,000 RIO shares he had acquired up to June 27, 2013;
-
Likewise, on August 12, 2013, BTG Pactual SAB on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi carried out the sale operation of 6,000 RIO shares at US$ 2.60, regarding which the sale order of 3,000 shares is recorded in Recording No. 8237856, whose transcription is as follows:
Mr. Ángeles: “taking advantage that this mini rally in gold favors you with RIO and Sulliden….let's reduce half the position and the other half we'll wait one more week (…)”.
Mr. Eskenazi “ok, how much do you want to sell?
Mr. Ángeles “half now (…)”
Mr. Eskenazi: “how much...of RIO?”
Mr. Ángeles: “yes, half of RIO you have 6,000…we go out with 3 only at 2.55 (…)”
Mr. Eskenazi: “ok”
-
According to the conversation recorded in the recording, Mr. Ángeles tells Mr. Eskenazi that he has 6,000 RIO shares and recommends selling 3,000 shares (half of the RIO shares he held in his account). Then, Mr. Eskenazi agrees to sell the 3,000 RIO shares, thereby also accepting that as of that date he had 6,000 RIO shares, which added to the 5,000 shares he ordered to sell on July 15, 2013 results in the amount of 11,000 shares, which necessarily include the 8,000 shares acquired in the purchase operations of June 7, 10 and 11, 2013, operations that are not recognized by Mr. Eskenazi, according to the complaint writings;
-
In this sense, according to the analysis carried out, Mr. Eskenazi cannot ignore said purchase operations, since he could not have disposed of shares of which he was not the holder, that is, he could not have ordered the sale of said shares carried out on July 15, 2013 and August 12, 2013, as evidenced by BTG Pactual SAB with the recordings transcribed above. Consequently, it is concluded that the referred client was aware that said shares were part of his securities portfolio;
-
As in the operations previously evaluated, it should be noted that although it has been concluded that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the purchase operations of RIO shares carried out on June 7, 10 and 11, 2013, BTG Pactual SAB should have obtained Mr. Eskenazi's orders by telephone and made the corresponding recordings, in accordance with the Client Registration Form, thus complying with the LMV and the Rai;
- Purchase operation carried out on 13/06/2013: Purchase of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 9.44
-
BTG Pactual SAB states that before the purchase operation of 1,000 NUGT shares carried out on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi on June 13, 2013, this client did not have NUGT shares in his securities portfolio. Likewise, it states that on the same date Mr. Eskenazi ordered the sale of those 1,000 NUGT shares, whose purchase he claims not to recognize;
-
In this regard, as verified in the Account Statement, before the purchase operation of June 13, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi no longer held NUGT shares, since those acquired in previous purchase operations had already been sold;
-
In this sense, the sale operation of 1,000 NUGT shares carried out on June 13, 2013, could not correspond to shares other than those acquired in the purchase operation of the same date. Furthermore, it should be noted that according to the information in the Account Statement, the only operations carried out on that date were the purchase and sale operations of the NUGT shares;
-
On the other hand, it should be added that via email dated June 13, 2013[9], submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, Mr. Eskenazi communicated to Mr. Ángeles the following:
“please apply intraday to today's purchase and sale”.
-
Considering that on June 13, 2013 BTG Pactual SAB only carried out the purchase and sale operations of 1,000 NUGT shares on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi, it can validly be concluded that Mr. Eskenazi, when requesting that “intraday” be applied to his purchase and sale of “today” (June 13, 2013), was referring to the purchase and sale of 1,000 NUGT shares on June 13, 2013 and therefore that Mr. Eskenazi ordered the purchase of said shares;
-
Notwithstanding this, BTG Pactual SAB should have obtained Mr. Eskenazi's purchase order for 1,000 NUGT shares by telephone and made the corresponding recording, as agreed in the Client Registration Form;
- Operation of Purchase carried out on 18/06/2013: Purchase of 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 29.92
-
Regarding this purchase operation, BTG Pactual SAB has not presented arguments in its defense brief;
-
However, as in the previous cases, according to the information in the Account Statement, before the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares on June 18, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi did not hold TZA shares in his securities portfolio, since those acquired on June 7, 2013 were sold on June 11, 2013;
-
Likewise, according to the Account Statement, the next operation with this security, carried out on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi, corresponds to the sale operation of 1,000 TZA shares carried out on June 19, 2013, in this sense, it is evident that said operation corresponds to the sale of the 1,000 TZA shares acquired on June 18, 2013;
-
Consequently, if Mr. Eskenazi agreed with the sale operation of the 1,000 TZA shares acquired on June 18, 2013, since he has not presented any questioning regarding said operation, then he was aware that said shares were part of his securities portfolio;
-
In this regard, it should be noted that on June 19, 2013, Messrs. Eskenazi and Ángeles held a conversation, which is recorded in Recording No. 8216485, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, whose transcription, of the relevant part, is as follows:
Mr. Eskenazi: “hey listen, what I want to do is sell and then buy today itself (…) 30.50 we go out and then at 30 or 29.90 I buy again…so that it's intraday (…)”
Mr. Ángeles: “(…) if you buy today and go out today it's intraday but yesterday's policy is already issued and the policy is sent to the Superintendency (…)”
Mr. Eskenazi: “(…) yesterday's is normal…what I want to do today is sell and then buy…that is, it's a reverse intraday…right now it already went up I can sell at 30.50 30.45…I want to wait to buy…if I don't buy it's no longer intraday you understand..if I don't buy it's fine you charge normal…yesterday's is normal you understand if I sell you charge 30% but if I sell and then buy before the end of the day charge me intraday for both (…)”.
Mr. Ángeles: “ok (…) don't worry…so you see I support you”
Mr. Eskenazi "(…) the thing is that in NUGT I am indeed leveraged, I'm screwed there….that's why I want to get out of TZA to be fine (…) how much is it at?"
Mr. Ángeles: "I want to get out at 30.60…it's already at 30.41…it's going to go to 31 ah (…)"
Mr. Eskenazi: "do you have a sale?"
Mr. Ángeles: "yes, 31..come on set it at 30.90 then (…)"
Mr. Eskenazi: "ah..30.60 no?"
Mr. Ángeles: "I think the market can fall a little more ah…or do you want to secure now?"
Mr. Eskenazi "no, you handle it, you handle it…I'll write to you on WhatsApp if anything"
- In the conversation transcribed above, Mr. Eskenazi proposes to Mr. Ángeles an operations strategy regarding the TZA security (due to price levels) in which the client states "I want to get out of TZA"; regarding this security, Mr. Ángeles tells him that the "policy has already been issued" to which Mr. Eskenazi responds "yesterday's, normal; later he mentions "yesterday's, normal" referring to the purchase of TZA, because he orders to sell this security and then perhaps buy this security again at the end of the day. Since this conversation is from June 19, 2013, when both persons refer to "yesterday" it is validly inferred that they are referring to June 18, 2013, the date on which BTG Pactual SAB bought 1,000 TZA shares on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi;
- From the analysis carried out, it can be concluded that Mr. Eskenazi knew of the execution of the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 29.92, however, as in the previous cases and in accordance with the Client Registration Form, BTG Pactual SAB should have obtained Mr. Eskenazi's order by telephone and made the corresponding recording;
- Likewise, it should be added that in this recording it is registered that Messrs. Eskenazi and Ángeles converse regarding selling these securities because the price of the security had risen to US$ 30.41 and could rise further, then Mr. Eskenazi tells the representative "you handle it (…) I'll write to you on WhatsApp if anything". According to the movement of operations, on June 19, 2013 BTG Pactual SAB sold 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 30.40 on behalf of Mr. Eskenazi, an operation that would have been handled by the representative or would have been specifically ordered by WhatsApp as inferred from the conversation;
- Purchase operations carried out on 06/19/2013 (Purchase of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 8.25) and on 06/20/2013 (Purchase of 2,000 NUGT shares at US$ 6.67)
- In this regard, it should be mentioned that before the execution of the purchase operations of June 19, 2013 and June 20, 2013 for a total of 3,000 NUGT shares, on June 18, 2013[10] a purchase operation of 1,000 NUGT shares was carried out, which added to the NUGT shares acquired in the aforementioned purchase operations, totaled 4,000 NUGT shares;
- Subsequently, as observed in the Account Statement, on June 26, 2013 Mr. Eskenazi ordered the purchase of 2,000 NUGT shares at US$ 4.65, bringing his securities portfolio to a total of 6,000 NUGT shares. It should be noted that this purchase operation has not been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi;
- Likewise, according to the Account Statement, these 6,000 shares were sold by Mr. Eskenazi on June 28, 2013 (2,000 shares), July 16, 2013 (2,000 shares) and July 19, 2013 (2,000 shares), sale operations whose orders have not been the subject of the complaint filed by Mr. Eskenazi;
- In recording No. 8226506 of July 12, 2013, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, Mr. Eskenazi stated:
Mr. Eskenazi: "brother I need you to help me because I'm really full (…) I'm going to give you the sale prices I want NUGT I want to exit 2k at 6.30 or around you know maybe 6.25...you handle them then (…)".
- As noted, on June 28, 2013 Mr. Eskenazi had already sold 2,000 NUGT shares, so in his securities portfolio there remained 4,000 NUGT shares;
- In the conversation of July 12, 2013 transcribed above, Mr. Eskenazi tells Mr. Ángeles to sell 2,000 NUGT shares, thus acknowledging that he still had a position in NUGT securities. It should be noted that in this conversation, Mr. Eskenazi tells Mr. Ángeles the sale price at which he wants to offer to the market, that is, around US$ 6.30, and tells him "you handle them", from which it follows that Mr. Eskenazi tells Mr. Ángeles to seek the best sale price;
- Subsequently, on July 16, 2013, as verified in the Account Statement and in the Custody Movement from January 1, 2008 to February 24, 2014 corresponding to NUGT shares, the sale operation of 2,000 NUGT shares is carried out at the price of US$ 6.49, higher than the sale price indicated by Mr. Eskenazi two (02) business days earlier (07/12/2013);
- Regarding the sale operation carried out on 07/19/2013, BTG Pactual SAB submits recording No. 8229452 of 07/19/2013, in which Mr. Eskenazi mentions:
Mr. Ángeles: "(…) I already coordinated with Kike I need your ok to sell 2,000 NUGT at market just that (…)"
Mr. Eskenazi: "it's fine, but don't confirm everything to me (…)"
Mr. Ángeles: "no no, it's fine, I coordinate with him and it's just a minute (….) I need your ok and that's it"
(…)
Mr. Eskenazi: "don't worry when Kike says it just do it and call me and I'll tell you ok (…)"
Mr. Ángeles: "no, I can't do it without the ok".
Mr. Eskenazi: "ok then"
- It should be noted that before July 19, 2013, Mr. Eskenazi held 2,000 NUGT shares in his securities portfolio, since 2,000 NUGT shares had already been sold in the sale operation carried out on July 16, 2013. In the conversation recorded in the aforementioned recording, Mr. Ángeles requests confirmation to sell 2,000 NUGT shares at market price. Mr. Eskenazi agrees to sell and thus his telephone sale order is obtained;
- Consequently, the conversations recorded in the aforementioned recordings prove that Mr. Eskenazi acknowledges ownership of at least 4,000 NUGT shares;
- Likewise, by email of July 15, 2013, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB with the response brief, Mr. Ángeles (ricardo.angeles@celfin.com) informs Mr. Eskenazi (jeskenazi@hotmail.com) of the detail of his shareholding as of July 15, 2013 with the respective quantities and prices, among which are the NUGT shares, which correspond to the purchase operations carried out on June 18, 19 and 20, 2013, the text of which is as follows:
"BRO look we're dropping……it's urgent…jump out even if flat….
According to Account Statement
NUGT 4K @ 6.66=USD 22K
at least sell 1K or 2K NUGT @ 6.00
The last trade you earned USD 2k
Your purchases are:
1K @ 9.06
1k @ 8.25
2k @ 6.67
(….)"
- It should be mentioned, additionally, that the 1,000 NUGT shares acquired at $9.06 correspond to the purchase operation of June 18, 2013, whose order despite having been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi, has been proven by BTG Pactual SAB with recording No. 8215691, in which the order obtained by telephone is recorded;
- After sending this email, on the same date, that is, July 15, 2013, Messrs. Eskenazi and Ángeles hold a conversation, which is recorded in Recording No. 8227190, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, in which reference is made to the following:
Mr. Ángeles: "I just sent you the little email with the detail of your prices (…)".
(…)
Mr. Ángeles*: "I'm not telling you to sell all these papers (…) at least sell something, that is flat or can exit to tell my manager that he has sold RIO, TV[11], has sold NUGT (…)".*
- From the foregoing, the email to which Mr. Ángeles refers would be the one sent to Mr. Eskenazi on the same date, whose text has been indicated in the previous recital, since in this conversation reference is also made to the recommendation to sell the shares detailed in said email. Likewise, during the conversation Mr. Eskenazi does not disagree with the information sent by Mr. Ángeles;
- In that sense, although the orders for the NUGT share purchase operations carried out on June 19, 2013 and June 20, 2013 have been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi, according to the information submitted by BTG Pactual SAB and the analysis carried out, it follows that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of said purchase operations. Furthermore, it must be taken into consideration that, according to the Account Statement, the NUGT share sale operations carried out on June 28, 2013, July 16, 2013 and July 19, 2013, operations that were not questioned by Mr. Eskenazi, could not correspond to the sale of shares other than those acquired in the purchase operations not acknowledged by Mr. Eskenazi, according to the analysis carried out above;
- As mentioned above, although it is concluded that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the execution of the purchase operations of 1,000 NUGT shares at US$ 8.25 and 2,000 NUGT shares at US$ 6.67, carried out on June 19, 2013 and June 20, 2013, respectively, BTG Pactual SAB should have obtained Mr. Eskenazi's purchase orders by telephone making the corresponding recordings, in accordance with applicable regulations;
- Purchase operations carried out on 07/05/2013 (1,000 TZA shares at US$ 29.25) and on 07/10/2013 (1,000 TZA shares at US$ 27.75):
- Regarding the purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares carried out on July 5, 2013, it should be noted at the outset that it has been verified in the Account Statement and in the Custody Movement from January 1, 2008 to February 24, 2014 corresponding to TZA shares, that before said purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares, Mr. Eskenazi did not hold any TZA security, since he had already carried out sale operations of previously acquired shares;
- On the other hand, in Recording No. 8223886 of July 8, 2013, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB by brief presented on March 11, 2014[12], which records the conversation held between Mr. Eskenazi and Mr. Ángeles, reference is made to the following:
Mr. Eskenazi: "(…) I have the TZA (…) in TZA I would like to wait for 29.80 something like that (…)".
- As observed from the above text, Mr. Eskenazi states that he has TZA shares and that he will wait for a price of US$ 29.80 to sell. In that sense, the shares to which he refers necessarily correspond to those acquired in the purchase operation of July 5, 2013 at a price of $ 29.25, taking into account that, before that date Mr. Eskenazi did not have TZA shares;
- Likewise, the purchase operation subsequent to the one carried out on 07/05/2013, as observed in the Account Statement, corresponds to the one carried out on 07/10/2013, in which 1,000 TZA shares are acquired, bringing Mr. Eskenazi's account to 2,000 TZA shares as of that date;
- In that sense, in Recording No. 8228443 of July 18, 2013, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, by brief of March 11, 2014, which records the conversation between Messrs. Eskenazi and Ángeles, reference is made to the following:
Mr. Eskenazi: "(…) how many TZA do I have? 2,000?"
Mr. Ángeles: "yes"
Mr. Eskenazi: "because on the internet it says 1,000 (…)"
Mr. Ángeles: "I'm going to send you an email with the info with average purchase price (…)".
- As can be seen, in said conversation Mr. Eskenazi refers to the 2,000 TZA shares he holds as of that date, whose holding is confirmed by Mr. Ángeles, which refer according to what is indicated in the previous recitals, to those acquired in the purchase operations carried out on July 5, 2013 (1,000 shares) and July 10, 2013 (1,000 shares). It should be noted that, in the Account Statement, as well as in the Custody Movement corresponding to the TZA security, it is verified that on July 12, 2013 a purchase operation of 800 TZA shares was carried out, however, it is also observed that these were sold on the same day. Therefore, as of July 18, 2013, he no longer held said shares. It should be noted that said purchase and sale operations have not been questioned by Mr. Eskenazi;
- Likewise, it should be noted that by email of July 15, 2013, attached to his response brief, Mr. Ángeles (ricardo.angeles@celfin.com) sends Mr. Eskenazi (jeskenazi@hotmail.com) information on the detail of his shareholding as of that date with the respective quantities and prices, among which are the TZA shares, the text of which is as follows:
"BRO look we're dropping……it's urgent…jump out even if flat….
According to Account Statement
(….)
TZA 2K @ 27.72= 54K
Sell 1K
1K @ 27.75
1K @ 29.25
(…)"
- After sending this email, on the same date July 15, 2013, Messrs. Eskenazi and Ángeles hold a conversation, recorded in recording No. 8227190, whose pertinent part as indicated is the following:
Mr. Ángeles: "I just sent you the little email with the detail of your prices (…)"
1. It should be noted that during the conversation, Mr. Eskenazi does not disagree with the information sent by Mr. Ángeles.
2. Subsequently, although the Account Statement records a purchase operation of 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 25.87 carried out on July 16, 2013, these shares were sold in the sale operation carried out on the same day. It should be noted that the orders given in said operations have not been objected to by Mr. Eskenazi;
3. From the foregoing it follows that the detail of said shares, sent by email of July 15, 2013, would be those acquired in the purchase operations of 1,000 TZA shares at US$ 29.25 carried out on July 5, 2013 and 1,000 TZA shares acquired at US$ 27.75 carried out on July 10, 2013, because the 800 TZA shares purchased on July 12, 2013 and the 1,000 TZA shares acquired on July 16, 2013, were sold on the same day by order of Mr. Eskenazi, as observed in the Account Statement and according to the recording registered on July 12, 2013[13];
4. Therefore, although from the analysis carried out above, it is concluded that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the execution of the TZA share purchase operations carried out on July 5, 2013 and July 10, 2013, which formed part of his investment portfolio, BTG Pactual SAB should have complied with its obligation to obtain the orders issued by Mr. Eskenazi by telephone making the corresponding recordings, in accordance with what was agreed in the Client Registration Form and the provisions of the Rai and the LMV;
5. Given the foregoing, it is concluded that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the execution of the purchase operations that in his complaint he indicated he had not authorized; likewise, it was established that as a consequence of said operations, the TZA, NUGT and RIO securities formed part of his portfolio; in such a way that on the basis of the same he ordered sale operations; the same that are supported by telephone instructions that were recorded or by orders transmitted by email or by operations that were not questioned by Mr. Eskenazi; which in graphic terms we can summarize as follows;
1. On the other hand, regarding the other aspects alleged by BTG Pactual SAB, which in the opinion of the brokerage firm would demonstrate that Mr. Eskenazi was aware of the operations carried out on behalf of this client, that is, that the corresponding policies were delivered to him by email and that he also had permanent access to his account statements, the following should be noted:
The policies were delivered by email
- BTG Pactual SAB states that it complied with sending Mr. Eskenazi, via email, the policies corresponding to the twelve (12) operations questioned by Mr. Eskenazi on the same day on which they were carried out, that is, within the period established by article 79 of the Rai, as recorded in the copies of nine (09) emails sent from the Confirmations Mailbox of BTG Pactual SAB, according to what was indicated by the brokerage firm, which they attach as evidence;
- As can be seen from the copies of each of the aforementioned emails, they indicate that the digitized policies corresponding to the twelve (12) purchase operations that Mr. Eskenazi does not acknowledge are attached to the email; likewise, it should be indicated that said emails are dated the same day the operations were carried out; this from the email address confirmaciones@celfin.com to Mr. Eskenazi's email address jeskena@hotmail.com, as observed in the following detail:
Table No. 04
| | | | | | |
|---|
| No. | Operation Date | Email Date | Security | Quantity | Price (US$) | Policy No. |
| 1 | 06/07/2013 | 06/07/13 | TZA | 1,000 | 31.389 | 17150 |
| 2 | 06/07/2013 | 06/07/13 | NUGT | 1,000 | 10.54 | 17169 |
| 3 | 06/07/2013 | 06/07/13 | RIO | 3,000 | 2.607 | 45868 |
| 4 | 06/10/2013 | 06/10/13 | RIO | 2,000 | 2.51 | 46922 |
| 5 | 06/11/2013 | 06/11/13 | RIO | 3,000 | 2.36 | 46948 |
| 6 | 06/13/2013 | 06/13/13 | NUGT | 1,000 | 9.44 | 17191 |
| 7 | 06/18/2013 | 06/18/13 | TZA | 1,000 | 29.92 | 17202 |
| 8 | 06/18/2013 | 06/18/13 | NUGT | 1,000 | 9.06 | 17203 |
| 9 | 06/19/2013 | 06/19/13 | NUGT | 1,000 | 8.25 | 17210 |
| 10 | 06/20/2013 | 06/20/13 | NUGT | 2,000 | 6.67 | 17221 |
| 11 | 07/05/2013 | 07/05/13 | TZA | 1,000 | 29.25 | 17306 |
| 12 | 07/10/2013 | 07/10/13 | TZA | 1,000 | 27.75 | 17332 |
- Likewise, BTG Pactual SAB presented a copy of some emails sent by Mr. Eskenazi to address Mr. Ángeles, in the period from June to July 2013[14], from the account jeskena@hotmail.com, which is the email address that appears in the Client Registration Form signed by Mr. Eskenazi, so it is valid to presume that he had access to the emails mentioned in the previous recital and therefore to said policies, so if he disagreed he could go to the brokerage firm to question each of said policies;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, it should be noted that the sending of policies is an obligation subsequent to the execution of the operations, so it does not exempt the brokerage firm from obtaining the orders that support the operations by the means agreed with its client;
Mr. Eskenazi had permanent access to information about his account statements
- BTG Pactual SAB argues that, as recorded in the Client Registration Form, Mr. Eskenazi chose the option of consulting his account statements through the BTG Pactual SAB website, a modality that allowed him to access the account statements uninterruptedly;
- In that sense, they indicate that according to the information provided by their electronic service provider, Mr. Eskenazi accessed on several occasions the account statements corresponding to the months of June and July 2013, the period in which the operations that Mr. Eskenazi questions were carried out;
- Regarding this argument, indeed according to the Client Registration Form signed by Mr. Eskenazi, the modality of access to the account statements chosen by the client is through the BTG Pactual SAB website, so Mr. Eskenazi could access each of them in order to verify the investments made;
- It should be noted that from an extract of the communication held by Mr. Eskenazi with Mr. Ángeles recorded in Recording No. 8228443 of July 18, 2013, it follows that indeed Mr. Eskenazi consulted the website of the brokerage firm, when the account statement for the month of June 2013 was already available, as detailed in the following text:
Eskenazi: "(…) how many TZA do I have? 2000?
Ángeles: "yes"
Eskenazi: "on the internet it says 1000 hey, that web is wrong"
Ángeles: "I'm going to send you an email with the info with average purchase price (…)"
- Although Mr. Eskenazi may have had access to his account statements through the website of the stock brokerage firm, as he indeed did with respect to the account statement corresponding to the month of June 2013, the information he was able to access through the review of said account statements was subsequent information about his operations, that is, subsequent to the receipt of the orders and their execution. However, it should be noted that knowledge of these operations through the account statement allowed the client to make timely claims upon observing that operations would have been carried out without his consent, which has not been demonstrated in the information submitted by Mr. Eskenazi;
- On the other hand, according to what was indicated in the defenses of BTG Pactual SAB and the information submitted in the preliminary inquiry stage, Mr. Eskenazi would have ordered the purchase of these shares through other means such as email and the WhatsApp application, and in some cases would have instructed Mr. Ángeles so that he would be in charge of the opportunity to purchase the securities depending on market conditions;
- In this regard, it should be specified that BTG Pactual SAB has not presented the emails, as well as the messages in the WhatsApp application, to which reference is made in the preceding paragraph, and in which the instruction made by Mr. Eskenazi regarding the questioned purchase operations is effectively indicated; however, it should be noted, as mentioned previously, that in Recording No. 8216485 of 19 June 2013, reference is made to the use of the WhatsApp application as a means to instruct orders;
- Notwithstanding this, it should be indicated that the email and the WhatsApp application mentioned and which, in the opinion of the stock brokerage firm, would constitute other means by which Mr. Eskenazi would have instructed the purchase of the securities indicated in this case, in order to be considered orders that support the stock brokerage firm's actions in the purchase of the securities, must comply with the requirements established in the regulations[15], in order to constitute reliable subsequent verification means of the purchase or sale orders of certain securities;
- Additionally, it should be mentioned that even if in this case the purchase orders had been instructed through said means and these had complied with the regulatory requirements, which has not been proven in this proceeding, this would not invalidate the charges imputed to BTG Pactual SAB, since the brokerage firm should have collected the orders in accordance with the modality agreed in the Client Registration Form, that is, by telephone, before carrying out the operations;
- Consequently, according to what was set forth in the preceding recitals, BTG Pactual SAB has not disproved the imputed charge, and therefore has committed an infraction by not collecting Mr. Eskenazi's orders corresponding to the eleven (11) purchase operations detailed above, of the twelve (12) operations questioned in Mr. Eskenazi's complaint, through reliable subsequent verification means, that is, in accordance with what was agreed in the Client Registration Form. Therefore, BTG Pactual SAB has incurred an infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Evaluation of the sanction
- From the foregoing, it has been determined that BTG Pactual SAB incurred one (01) infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, which describes as a minor infraction: "Failure to collect orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene";
- With respect to the criteria to be taken into account for imposing the sanction, we must point out that article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of article 230 of the Lpag, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the offender's contribution to its clarification and the extenuating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A of the Lpag;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's background; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The economic harm caused and the repercussion on the market; d) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegally obtained benefit; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; h) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification; i) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to the notification of the corresponding charges; and j) The error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- With regard to the offender's background, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the current Sanctions Regulation, amended by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV.10.1, final sanctions imposed within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction constitute background;
- In this regard, from the review carried out, it has been verified that BTG Pactual SAB does not register final sanctions within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction. In that sense, BTG Pactual SAB does not register a sanction background;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it has not been possible to prove that BTG Pactual SAB's actions in the commission of the infraction analyzed in this sanctioning proceeding have caused damage to the public interest or have had a repercussion on the market. However, it should be taken into account the affectation to a protected legal interest, consisting of investor protection, since by not having complied with the provisions of the LMV and the Rai, which aim to prevent the affectation of investors' interests through compliance with the requirements established to carry out operations on their behalf with the money or securities they have delivered to the stock brokerage firm, which includes complying with the modality or modalities agreed with the client to collect the orders that support the carrying out of operations, this could create insecurity and distrust in investors and other market participants;
- It should be indicated that orders are instructions to intermediation agents, through which their principals express their decisions regarding trading and other services they may provide; orders empower intermediation agents to exercise the mandate they contain; in this sense, in order to protect the investor, it is essential that intermediaries, within the intermediation process, receive and execute orders faithfully observing the will expressed by their clients through the Client Form; otherwise, as previously indicated, insecurity and distrust are created; and in turn, market efficiency is affected, and therefore the legal interest referred to as its integrity;
- With regard to the economic harm caused, it has not been evidenced that the infraction incurred by BTG Pactual SAB has caused concrete economic harm to market participants;
- Regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction subject of this resolution, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 7 of article 230 of the Lpag, it is not observed that in this case the assumptions that could constitute a repetition and/or continuity of the infraction subject of this administrative sanctioning proceeding are present;
- As for the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be mentioned that BTG Pactual SAB, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, knows the rules that regulate the securities market, the specific regulation for intermediation agents, as well as their mandatory compliance, in relation to the case evaluated in this administrative sanctioning proceeding, that is, the obligation to comply with collecting the orders given by its clients in accordance with what was agreed in the Client Registration Form, as established by the Rai;
- In this sense, although the stock brokerage firm recognizes the obligation to comply with the provisions of the Rai, regarding the support of the orders given by its clients, BTG Pactual SAB carried out successively, between 7 June and 10 July 2013, the eleven (11) questioned purchase operations on which the imputation of charges was based, without complying with what was agreed with its client. So, if Mr. Eskenazi, according to what was indicated by BTG Pactual SAB, preferred to communicate his orders through means other than telephone because he was out of the country, the stock brokerage firm should not have executed said orders while there was no modification in the modality established in the Client Registration Form and the requirements established in the RAI to admit said modalities were complied with, if applicable;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, it has not been proven in this proceeding that BTG Pactual SAB obtained any benefit by incurring the imputed infraction;
- With regard to the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it should be specified that no intentionality has been evidenced in the conduct incurred by BTG Pactual SAB;
- As for the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offenders to its clarification, BTG Pactual SAB has acknowledged the commission of the infraction, evaluated in this administrative sanctioning proceeding. In that sense, it voluntarily declares not to have collected the orders for the carrying out of the questioned purchase operations in accordance with the provisions of what was agreed in the Client Registration Form. Likewise, in this administrative sanctioning proceeding, it should be considered that although the imputed charge has not been disproved, the operations that Mr. Eskenazi indicated he had not authorized were indeed known to him; which in turn allowed him to adopt investment decisions; which were either not questioned by Mr. Eskenazi or are supported by telephone recordings;
- On the other hand, BTG Pactual SAB acknowledges that the fact that the client was out of the country did not excuse them from having to collect his orders in accordance with what was agreed in the corresponding Client Registration Form, as indicated in article 30, numeral 30.2 of the Rai. In this line, they state that they have adjusted their order reception policy (Trading Desk Policy) and instructed their representatives not to make the same mistake again;
- Additionally, with regard to the evaluation of the extenuating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A of the Lpag, it is necessary to point out that BTG Pactual SAB has not proven voluntary correction of the acts or omissions constituting the infraction evaluated in this administrative sanctioning proceeding. Likewise, in this case it has not been evidenced that the infracting conduct by BTG Pactual SAB was generated by an error induced by the administration through a confusing and illegal administrative act or provision;
- Consequently, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, and in application of the principle of reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of article 230 of the Lpag, which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, it corresponds to impose on BTG Pactual SAB a sanction applicable to minor infractions in accordance with article 22 of the Sanctions Regulation, corresponding to the application of a fine considering the UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
- Declare that BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by failing to collect the orders of its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the operations in which they intervene in accordance with what is set forth in the recital part of this resolution, in accordance with the provisions of article 175 of the Securities Market Law, as well as article 30, numeral 30.2 and article 75, numeral 75.5 of the Intermediation Agents Regulation.
- Sanction BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa with a fine of one (01) UIT, amounting to S/ 3,700.00 (Three Thousand Seven Hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infraction mentioned in the preceding article.
- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the event that this resolution is not challenged through a reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01, as well as by the provisions of article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation.
- Transcribe this resolution to BTG Pactual Perú S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutierrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
In accordance with article 77, numeral 77.1 of the Rai, applicable to the commission of the facts, orders must be given under specific conditions of quantity, price, execution term and others, depending on the market and type of security or instrument. ↑
-
Application used on phones that allows sending and receiving messages. ↑
-
Email registered in the Client Registration Form. ↑
-
Email address registered in Mr. Eskenazi's Client Registration Form. ↑
-
A copy of the email was submitted by written document presented on 11 March 2014, in the preliminary inquiry stage. ↑
-
As of July 2013, Celfin Capital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. changed its corporate name to the current BTG Pactual SAB. ↑
-
Submitted by written document presented on 10/02/2014 ↑
-
Presented on 10/06/2014. ↑
-
A printed copy of said email was submitted by BTG Pactual SAB by written document submitted on 10 June 2014, in the preliminary inquiry stage. ↑
-
Although with respect to said purchase operation, Mr. Eskenazi indicated he had not given the respective order, as indicated, BTG Pactual SAB demonstrated that Mr. Eskenazi gave the order for the carrying out of said operation, with Recording No. 8215691. ↑
-
Trevali Mining Corporation. ↑
-
Submitted in the preliminary inquiry stage. ↑
-
In Recording No. 8225506 of 12 July 2013, submitted by BTG Pactual SAB, the following is recorded:
Mr. Eskenazi: "(…) you have bought 800 (…) you don't listen to me (….)"
Mr. Ángeles: "(…) that's why give me a specific price (…)"
Mr. Eskenazi "that's fine (…) how many have you bought? 800? (…) those you sell yes or yes, but those you sell them, you handle them (…) if you see it at 29 and something just sell them (…) or 27 and something I don't know (…) those you handle them (…)".
As can be seen, in this conversation Mr. Eskenazi indicates that he has bought 800 TZA shares and tells Mr. Ángeles to sell these shares, that he "handle" them; considering the movement of operations and the price levels indicated, it is evident that Mr. Eskenazi is referring to the TZA securities.
In this sense, it is verified that on 12 July 2013, the purchase and sale operations on the same day (intraday) for 800 TZA shares are recorded. ↑
-
Period in which the operations questioned by Mr. Eskenazi were carried out. ↑
-
Considering the provisions of article 75, numeral 5 of the Rai. [↑](#footnote-ref-15]