SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 050-2016-SMV/10
Summary: Seminario & Cía Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of three (03) UIT equivalent to S/ 11,100.00 (Eleven thousand one hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred one (01) serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.13; and one (01) minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Seminario & Cía Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2016032410 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2016032410, Report No. 899-2016-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, and the defenses presented by Seminario & Cía Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- By Report No. 1089-2015-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Entity Supervision (hereinafter, Igse) communicated to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (hereinafter, Igcp) the results of the evaluation of indications of possible infractions by Seminario SAB determined from an inspection visit; and by Memorandum No. 261-2016-SMV/10.2, the Igse communicated to the Igcp the results of the evaluation of indications of non-compliance with the timely presentation of eventual information by Seminario SAB;
- As a result of the above and under the provisions of the Law of General Administrative Procedure, Law No. 27444 and its amendatory norms (hereinafter, LPAG), by Official Letter No. 4615-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against Seminario SAB, imputing charges for having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law (LMV) and the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (Regulation) in aspects related to the granting of credits to clients and untimely communication of relevant facts;
- By document presented on September 8, 2016, Seminario SAB presented its defenses to Letter No. 4615-2016-SMV/10.3;
- The charges formulated against Seminario SAB and the defenses presented by the latter have been evaluated in Report No. 899-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Report), which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, item 2, of Law No. 27444, Law of General Administrative Procedure and its amendments (hereinafter, LPAG), by Official Letter No. 6778-2016-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 899-2016-SMV/10.3 was made available to Seminario SAB for its review;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether Seminario SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter Sanctions Regulation), for granting credits to its clients without the subscription of the respective loan contract; in accordance with Article 194, item m) of the Securities Market Law (LMV), and Article 51 of the Regulation.
- Whether Seminario SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation by not having presented the relevant fact of January 7, 2015 referring to the cessation of functions of Mr. Alberto Saavedra Urday (hereinafter, Mr. Saavedra) as representative of the intermediation agent, subject of charges, within the term established in Article 98 of the regulation, in force at the date of the event.
- Whether it corresponds or not to impose a sanction on Seminario SAB;
III. Analysis
3.1 On the Granting of Credits to Clients without the Subscription of the Loan Contract
- Article 194, item m) of the LMV establishes that stock brokerage firms are empowered to grant credits, with their own resources, solely for the purpose of facilitating the acquisition of securities by their clients, whether or not listed on the stock exchange and with the guarantee of such securities;
- In this sense, Article 51 of the Regulation establishes that in the case of granting credits to its clients, an intermediary must sign a loan contract with them. In said contract, all the conditions of the credit must be established;
Client Hare Bay Ltd. (hereinafter, Hare Bay)
- According to the Letter of Charges, based on the information contained in the document called "Movement of current account in US$ from 01/01/2013 to 11/03/2014" it was observed that Hare Bay since January 8, 2013 was overdrawn, that is, it presented a negative balance of US$ 49,074.50. Likewise, as could be seen from the information contained in said document, the negative balances in the foreign currency current account (US$) continued as a consequence of the execution of securities purchase operations, as well as for the commitments assumed by the various modalities of derivative contracts made in said period in the foreign market, despite the sale operations carried out that were not enough to cover the amounts of the purchase operations;
- In this sense, the company Hare Bay, according to its dollar account statement, would have maintained debts for significant amounts from January 8, 2013 to February 17, 2014, since on February 18, 2014 a payment was made by transfer for an amount of US$ 171,380.00, with which the balance of said client amounted to US$ 8.63; that is, in said period Hare Bay was overdrawn for amounts that ranged between US$ 33,336.46 and US$ 998,068.95;
Client Mrs. Silvia Inés de Avilés Canaval (Mrs. Avilés)
- In the document called "Movement of current account in US$ from 01/01/2013 to 11/03/2014" it was observed that Mrs. Avilés as of December 31, 2012 already maintained a negative balance amounting to US$ 52,238.64, and that as a consequence of the execution of securities purchase operations on the Lima Stock Exchange and purchase of securities in the foreign market, said negative balances continued in the foreign currency current accounts (US$);
- In this sense, in the dollar current account statement of Mrs. Aviles, two (02) periods with debit balance were observed, from January to February 2013 and from September 2013 to February 2014, for variable amounts ranging between US$ 1,508.30 and US$ 121,308.67;
- Likewise, according to the document "Movement of current account S/. from 01/01/2013 to 11/03/2014" it was observed, regarding operations in national currency, that as in its dollar current account as of December 31, 2012, Mrs. Avilés already had a negative balance with an amount of S/ 207,174.28 during the periods from January 18 to February 21, 2013 and from May 6 to December 27, 2013 the negative balances continued for amounts that ranged between S/ 8,690.44 up to S/ 206,087.28, even though sale operations were carried out;
- It should be noted that, according to the Letter of Charges, the negative balances of the current account statements of Hare Bay and Mrs. Avilés would have exceeded the settlement terms of the purchase operations carried out;
- In this regard, according to Article 194, item m) of the LMV and Article 51 of the Regulation, in force at the date of the events, the stock brokerage firm is empowered to grant credits, solely for the purpose of facilitating the acquisition of financial instruments by its clients, for which it must have a loan contract with said clients in accordance with the conditions established in the Regulation;
- In this sense, according to the Letter of Charges, Seminario SAB carried out purchase operations in the local market and in the foreign market on behalf of the clients Hare Bay and Mrs. Avilés even when they maintained negative balances in their current account statements at the time of the execution of said operations, and also the referred negative balances would have exceeded the settlement terms of said operations; therefore, said situation evidences that Seminario SAB would have been carrying out credit operations to its clients for the purpose of acquiring securities and making various modalities of derivative contracts; which was observed to Seminario SAB according to the Inspection Completion Act, without it having complied with answering it;
- Consequently, according to the above, according to the Letter of Charges, Seminario Sab would have granted credits to the mentioned clients without having the corresponding loan contract, contravening the provisions of Article 51 of the Regulation, thus incurring in an infraction classified as serious provided in Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation according to which it constitutes an infraction: "Carrying out special operations without having the respective authorization from the SMV or without observing any of the conditions or formalities required for it";
-
- Defenses of the Administered
On the Client Policy of Seminario SAB
- Seminario SAB states that the company Hare Bay and Mrs. Avilés are clients of the brokerage firm, so the contractual relationship is governed by the provisions of the Client File and the Client Policy;
- Likewise, it points out that according to the provisions of numeral 8, literal i) of the Client File, the client declares to know and accept that Seminario SAB may liquidate the client's securities positions, without prior notice and at its discretion, when the client maintains for any reason debit balances with Seminario SAB or liquidate repurchase operations when the client fails to deliver the guarantees or replacements required by CAVALI S.A. ICLV or the Regulation following the procedure established in the Client Policy;
- On the other hand, Seminario SAB states that in the corresponding section called "On the Settlement and Coverage of Operations" of the Client Policy of Seminario SAB, it is clearly stated that if the client fails to fully cancel its cash operations or at the maturity of forward operations or deliver the securities within the terms established for each modality or deliver the guarantees and replacements required by Seminario SAB or the clearing and settlement institution; as applicable, Seminario SAB reserves the right to liquidate without prior notice, the client's positions up to the amount of the non-compliance or balance owed to Seminario SAB, when it deems it appropriate. Additionally, the brokerage firm states that Seminario SAB reserves the right to liquidate without prior notice, the client's securities position when the client maintains for any reason debit balances with Seminario SAB;
- In this sense, Seminario SAB states that the brokerage firm is duly authorized by the clients to liquidate their positions in the cases of non-compliance with the delivery of funds or securities in the framework of its operations, as are the cases, according to it, of Hare Bay and Mrs. Avilés;
On the Applicable Regime
- On the other hand, Seminario SAB indicates that according to Article 176 of the LMV, intermediation agents are obliged to execute on behalf of their clients the orders they receive from them, for the negotiation of securities;
- However, according to what is argued by Seminario SAB, in the case of cash operations they may subordinate the fulfillment of the order, provided that the client has prior knowledge of it, to the client proving ownership of the securities or delivering them or the funds, as applicable, if they had ordered to sell or buy respectively;
- Consequently, Seminario SAB indicates that without prejudice to the obligation to verify the existence of resources and financial instruments or securities, intermediation agents are empowered to carry out operations without receiving the respective funds or securities, provided they have verified that they exist by the means they consider adequate and prudent; and that the provisions of the Regulation referring to uncovered positions (i.e. limits and registration) are complied with;
- Likewise, Seminario SAB states that Articles 87 and 136 of the Regulation establish the obligations regarding the registration of uncovered positions and the limits they must have, all of which, according to the brokerage firm, they have complied with. In this sense, they indicate that, regarding registration, they have sent the report called "Form A-5: Detail of Uncovered Positions and Non-Compliances" (hereinafter, the "Form A-5"), which according to the Technical Specifications Manual[1], as indicated by Seminario SAB, includes, among others, the following information;
Type Uncovered: CNL = Cash purchase operations without receipt of funds.
Uncovered amount: The amount of the policy minus the balances in account or holdings that can cover the operation.
- In this sense, Seminario SAB states that by way of example, on May 15, June 14, July 15 and August 29, 2013, they sent to the SMV the Form A-5 (which they offer as evidence) that include Hare Bay's operations as uncovered and under the code CLN. However, as stated by Seminario SAB, it has not been the case of Mrs. Avilés, since, after the internal valuation of her holdings, as stated by the brokerage firm, they verified that they had a positive result and, therefore, did not qualify as uncovered;
- Thus, Seminario SAB concludes that it has complied with its obligations to timely inform about the operations and amounts that were uncovered at the time;
On Money Loans
- On the other hand, Seminario SAB argues that, considering what is described in the previous point, neither the LMV nor the Regulation have established for an intermediation agent the obligation to enter into a loan contract when there is an uncovered position;
- Likewise, it refers that Article 88.2 of the Regulation simply indicates that an operation ceases to be uncovered if it becomes a money loan, for which the provisions of the Regulation itself must be complied with. However, this does not imply, according to what is alleged by Seminario SAB, that while its indicators remain in compliance, they are obliged to enter into such loan contracts;
- So, according to what is stated by Seminario SAB, the existence of negative balances in the current account statements of its clients Hare Bay and Mrs. Avilés, which would evidence, as indicated in the Letter of Charges, says Seminario SAB, credit operations in favor of said clients at the date of execution of operations and their settlement; the only thing that evidences, according to Seminario SAB, is the existence of uncovered positions or non-compliance by said clients that were duly reported to its institution in accordance with the requirements of the applicable regulations;
- In this sense, Seminario SAB argues that, except for what is indicated in the Letter of Charges, the SMV has not offered evidence that—in accordance with the Civil Code—proves the existence of a credit granted by the brokerage firm to the aforementioned clients. Likewise, they indicate that there is no such evidence, because said credit has not been granted. Seminario SAB states that, if considered, they offer their testimonial and the testimonial of the referred clients, confirming that they have not been granted a credit and therefore, there is no loan contract;
- On the other hand, Seminario SAB, points out that the consequences and implications that the statement about the existence of a credit or money loan with the referred clients may have for the brokerage firm should be evaluated. In this sense, it alleges that if such an agreement existed, they could not demand the fulfillment of obligations from their clients at the time of the settlement of their operations but within the thirty (30) day term established in the Civil Code for cases in which a return has not been agreed. Additionally, it states, they could not use the holdings of their clients, as indicated in the Client Policy nor follow the execution processes established in the regulations, but only after the thirty (30) day term referred to above has expired. Likewise, it refers that the statement about the existence of a credit derived only from the existence of negative balances is not consistent with the regulations that its own institution has issued;
- Consequently, Seminario SAB alleges that from the existence of negative balances in the current account statements of its clients, the existence of a credit or a loan contract that does not comply with the regulations cannot be inferred. Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of Article 235, numeral 5 of the Law of General Administrative Procedure, Law No. 27444 (LPAG), it states that the existence of this alleged infraction cannot be considered proven; therefore, they request to declare the non-existence of an infraction in the present case;
On the amounts indicated in the Letter
1. Additionally, Seminario SAB states that the negative balances mentioned in the Letter of Charges are correct for collection purposes, but they do not show the balances at the close of each day. According to them, they charge purchases on T+2 and credit sales on T+3. Therefore, to determine the real balance at the close of each day, Seminario SAB indicates that the balances must be adjusted by charging purchases on T+3, especially when the client uses the day trade strategy. Thus, it states that if such adjustment is made, it can be seen that the amounts do not reach those mentioned in the Letter of Charges and that the negative balances are lower than those shown in the referred letter;
-
- Analysis of the defense
2. Regarding what Seminario SAB states in the sense that the conduct described in the imputed charge regarding the granting of credits to its clients Hare Bay and Avilés without the signing of the respective mutual loan agreement is circumscribed within what is defined as an uncovered position, its power being to convert such situation into a money mutual loan, it must be indicated that the Uncovered Position is regulated in article 87 of the Regulation, which specifies, among others, that an operation is uncovered when the obligation to comply with settlement or coverage thereof is borne by the brokerage agent, to the extent that the purchase or sale operation has been executed without the latter having received the funds or securities and financial instruments necessary to comply with the settlement of the operation;
3. According to the charges formulated, Seminario SAB was observed that, in accordance with the information in the documents called “Movement of Current Account in US$ from 01/01/2013 to 11/03/2014” and “Movement of Current Account in US$ and S/ from 01/01/2014 to 11/03/2014”, corresponding to the movements of the operations carried out in said period by Hare Bay and Mrs. Avilés, respectively, the aforementioned clients were in an overdrawn situation;
4. That is, it was observed that said clients had debtor balances for significant amounts in the period from 08/01/2013 to 18/02/2014[2] in the case of Hare Bay. Likewise, in the case of Mrs. Aviles from 12/31/2012 to 02/20/2013, as well as from 09/09/2013 to 02/20/2014 in her dollar current account and from 12/31/2012 to 02/21/2013 and from 09/19/2013 to 12/27/2013 in her soles current account, and within which the brokerage company carried out purchase operations on behalf of said clients even though they did not have the necessary funds to settle the respective purchase operations; for which reason, it was considered that said brokerage company, using the attribution contained in literal m) of article 194 of the LMV, granted credits, with its own resources, to the mentioned clients;
5. Seminario SAB has stated in its defenses that the operations carried out on behalf of its clients Hare Bay and Avilés, which involved financing for continuous periods, were as uncovered positions according to article 87 of the RAI. In this regard, it must be indicated that article 88 of the RAI states that an Uncovered Position must be maintained until its situation changes, among others, because they become money mutual loans or the uncovered position is settled, recognizing the effects of such settlement;
6. In this regard, it should be noted that notwithstanding the provisions of article 195, subsection f), of the LMV, which prohibits brokerage firms from executing operations without verifying the existence of the resources and securities to which they refer, situations are observed in which they intermediate operations of clients that entail payment risk because they are basically purchase operations, whose non-compliance entails for the intermediaries the obligation to cancel said operations with their own resources, thus originating a credit in their favor. This situation can occur in the case of resources that were in transit and that had been subject to the verification to which the intermediary is obliged. In these cases, after verifying the existence of the resources in transit, the intermediary carries out the operation based on the agent's trust in certain clients and that the latter keeps under its power the securities purchased with its resources or others that guarantee compliance by the client. In this situation, it is also a fact that the agent and its client have agreed on a potential credit from the very moment the former admitted the execution of a purchase operation, without the respective delivery of cash by the latter.
7. For practical purposes and because in almost all cases the agent carries out the mentioned operations under the assumption that they will be honored by the client before they are required, it is admissible that the mentioned agreement does not immediately materialize in a money mutual loan contract, but rather after the credit has effectively been granted, which occurs when the agent assumes payment for the operations ordered by the client. This is unless the agent liquidates the client's position, if it is not possible to comply with the formalities established for the mutual loan; situations that are provided for in articles 176 and 194 of the LMV and that should occur immediately, if the agent acts with rationality and the required diligence of the case;
8. However, when the non-compliances that become uncovered positions of a certain client have been repeated and the agent has continued executing operations or when it does not liquidate in the shortest term the positions of the defaulting client to its own detriment, despite being empowered by article 176 of the LMV to do so; the agent's willingness to grant a credit to its client is evidenced. Therefore, it is not a matter of forced credits or temporary non-compliances but of agreed financing or mutual loans;
9. In the present case, according to the current account movements, it is observed that in the case of client Hare Bay, Seminario SAB financed it continuously for a period exceeding one year, and in the case of client Avilés, the credit granted was extended for more than four (04) months (See graphs); therefore, as mentioned, there is no situation of temporary non-compliances, but of agreed financing;
10. Likewise, it must be indicated that in the described situation, when an intermediary provides its own resources to settle its clients' operations, said non-compliances cease to constitute uncovered positions, and as stated in article 88, numeral 88.3 of the Regulation, the effects of such settlement must be recognized. That is, if more than ten (10) days pass without the intermediary receiving the funds from its clients, the commercial accounts receivable must be recognized as a deductible concept for the calculation of net equity; and in the event that the non-compliance originated by the repeated and continuous financing of the agent to its client is prolonged over time; and if the provisions of article 176 of the LMV have not been applied; the respective money mutual loan contract must be signed. The opposite case would imply a situation in which the intermediary would be exposed to a situation in which, if the reimbursement of the granted credit is not made, there would be an impact on the liquidity and solvency of the agent and therefore on its ability to meet its obligations to the market;
1. The obligation established in the Regulation regarding the signing of a money mutual loan contract when the intermediary grants a credit to its clients seeks to avoid the situation described above. Indeed, for this purpose, the intermediary must require guarantees that back the granted credit, establishing the power of the brokerage firm to execute the guarantees if the client does not comply with the contract conditions or replenishment of guarantees, as stated in articles 51, 52 and 53 of the Regulation. Thus, prior to the execution of operations by the client with the money granted by the intermediary, it is established that they have the necessary backing in such a way as to mitigate the impact of non-compliances on the liquidity and solvency of the agent and thereby protect the integrity of the market; a situation that does not occur when the brokerage firm grants credits without prior guarantee requirements and is subject to the client having the necessary funds to comply with the payment of its debts;
2. Regarding what is stated about article 176 of the LMV, it must be indicated that the referred article establishes that if after the operation is carried out, the client does not comply with delivering the securities or funds, as the case may be for sale or purchase operations respectively, the brokerage firm may dispose of any amount of money that said client has in accounts of the brokerage firm exclusively for the settlement of such operations, provided that said funds are not destined for operations that have already been executed and are pending settlement. It also indicates that in the case of purchase operations in which the respective funds have not been delivered, the brokerage firm may sell the securities resulting from said operation.
3. In this sense, the mentioned article limits the disposal of available resources of a client by an intermediary to cover the settlement of operations and not to cover in general any concept of debtor balances, considering in particular the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation, which states that the assets delivered by clients to intermediaries for custody cannot be used for different purposes, unless they have the corresponding express authorization and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in articles 194 and 207 of the LMV;
4. Likewise, the application of the provisions of article 176 of the LMV implies that an uncovered position changes its situation, as established in article 88, numeral 88.3 of the Regulation; this with the aim of avoiding situations that are prolonged over time and that affect the solvency and liquidity of the intermediaries;
5. Regarding the means of evidence, it must be indicated that the imputed charge is based on the information derived from the current account movements of Messrs. Hare Bay and Avilés, obtained as part of the inspection carried out on Seminario SAB; which, as mentioned, in said documents a continuous and reiterative financing by the intermediary to the mentioned clients is observed;
6. Regarding what Seminario SAB states that if there were a money mutual loan it would imply that compliance with its clients' obligations could not be demanded at the time of settlement of its operations but within the thirty (30) day term established in the Civil Code for cases in which a return has not been agreed; and that it could not use its clients' holdings, as indicated in the Client Policy, nor follow the execution processes established in the regulations, but only after the thirty (30) day term referred to above has expired; it should be indicated, as mentioned, that in the event an operation is executed without the intermediary having previously received the funds from its clients, which would constitute a granting of credit without a return having been initially agreed; the intermediary is empowered by article 176 of the LMV to dispose of any amount of money that said clients had in accounts of the intermediary exclusively for the settlement of such operations and in the case of purchase operations, the agent is empowered to sell the securities resulting from said operation; therefore, it is not necessary to apply the term established in the Civil Code by application of a special norm; without prejudice to the foregoing, that in the event that an intermediary recurrently and continuously finances a particular client, it entails for the reasons set forth the obligation to sign a mutual loan contract;
7. Regarding that for the determination of the real balance the balances of the current account movements must be adjusted considering that purchases are charged on T+2 and sales are credited on T+3; it must be noted that the imputed charge is based on what was observed regarding the continuous financing of Seminario SAB to its clients Hare Bay and Avilés, and not on the amount of the credit granted;
8. Therefore, Seminario SAB granted credits to its clients without having the corresponding mutual loan contract, in which the contract conditions are established as well as the constitution of guarantees covering the amount of the credit, contravening the provisions of article 51 of the RAI, thereby having infringed Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature: “Carrying out special operations without having the respective authorization from the SMV or without observing any of the conditions or formalities required for it”
- Regarding the communication of relevant facts
3.2.1 Applicable Regulations
- Article 97 of the regulation establishes that situations, acts, facts, decisions, agreements or contingencies that affect or may affect the agent or its economic group are considered relevant facts of the agent. Likewise, information of the agent or its economic group, which by its nature must be reported to the SMV for supervision and control purposes, has the qualification of a relevant fact, unless it is a matter of importance of a company of its economic group, whose reporting obligation corresponds to it;
- In this sense, article 98 of the regulation establishes that agents must inform the SMV of their relevant facts within the following business day of the occurrence of the fact or act or of having become aware of it, as appropriate, in accordance with the means and forms established by the SMV. It also states that the General Manager is responsible for timely communicating the agent's relevant facts;
- For its part, numeral 12 of Annex 9 of the Regulation indicates as a relevant fact:
“12. Appointment and changes of directors, managers, Internal Control Officer, representatives, officers and legal representatives or attorneys, and must present the list of names and positions of the removed or outgoing officers and of the officers appointed in their replacement, as well as the dates of cessation and start of duties, respectively.”;
3.2.2 Regarding the formulated charge
- According to the Letter of Charges, it was determined that Seminario SAB did not comply with communicating within the term established by the regulations the relevant fact referring to the cessation of duties of Mr. Saavedra as representative of the brokerage agent, which occurred on January 7, 2015, since said communication was made on January 14, 2015**[3]**;
- Consequently, according to the foregoing, the brokerage firm did not communicate the mentioned relevant fact within the term established in article 98 of the Regulation**,** for which it would be incurring an infraction classified as minor according to the provisions of Annex X numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction “Not communicating relevant facts, or not doing so within the term established by the regulations”;
3.2.3 Regarding the defenses of the administered party
- In this regard, Seminario SAB argues that said non-compliance was mainly due to a misunderstanding on the part of the person in charge of sending the referred information. In this sense, according to what was indicated by Seminario SAB, this was because although Mr. Saavedra presented his resignation letter on January 7, 2015, it was only in the week of January 14 that internal coordination was carried out for his settlement and documentary delivery that was in his possession, since on January 8 and 9 he was on medical rest, as stated, according to what was alleged by Seminario SAB, in the medical certificate they attach as evidence;
3.2.4 Analysis of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted in relation to what was argued by Seminario SAB in its defenses, that the brokerage firm has not precisely stated on what date other than January 7, 2015 Mr. Saavedra would have ceased, as indicated by the brokerage firm, in the position of representative of the brokerage agent, since it only limits itself to stating that on the referred date the resignation letter would have been presented and it is in the week of January 14, 2015 that the respective coordination for the settlement would have been carried out;
- Likewise, in relation to the medical certificate signed by Dr. Daniel E. Florian Ortiz, presented by Seminario SAB as support for its defense argument, it should be mentioned that although it can be observed in it the indication of a physical rest for January 8 and 9, 2015, said document does not prove a different date of cessation of Mr. Saavedra as representative of the brokerage agent, even more so when the brokerage firm itself with the communication of the relevant fact declared that the cessation of Mr. Saavedra occurred on January 7, 2015;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be mentioned, as has been stated, that article 98 of the Regulation establishes that brokerage agents must inform the SMV of their relevant facts within the following business day of the agreement or decision being taken, of the occurrence of the fact or act or of having become aware of it, as appropriate, in accordance with the means and forms established by the SMV. Likewise, the mentioned article establishes that the situations detailed in Annex 9 of the Regulation, such as the one indicated in its numeral 12, mentioned above, constitute relevant facts that the brokerage agent must comply with communicating to the SMV, with sufficient detail and documentation;
- In this context, on January 14, 2015, Seminario SAB communicated that Mr. Saavedra ceased in the position of Representative of the Brokerage Agent on January 7, 2015. Information that implies the modification of the data recorded in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (Rpmv) in relation to the related persons of the brokerage firm and that is freely accessible to the public, in accordance with the provisions of article 16 of the LMV;
- In this sense, it is necessary to point out that according to the provisions of article 13 of the LMV, legal entities registered in the Rpmv, as brokerage firms are, are obliged to present the information that the LMV and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of said information;
- Likewise, it is necessary to point out that according to article 16 of the Regulation, in accordance with article 16-A[4] of the LMV, brokerage agents, the representatives and directors of the agent, as well as other persons who directly or indirectly relate to the agent, in the exercise of their activities must act with responsibility, care and diligence in relation to their duties with their clients and the market;
- In this sense, according to the provisions of the aforementioned regulations, it is the obligation of brokerage agents to send the information they are obliged to present, such as that which constitutes relevant facts, ensuring that the information they present is truthful and timely so that after its communication it does not result inaccurate;
- Thus, if a rectification or clarification of the information sent is necessary, it must be carried out in a timely manner. For this, the MVNet System allows brokerage firms and all supervised companies to carry out such actions;
- Therefore, if Seminario SAB recorded an erroneous date when communicating the relevant fact referring to the cessation of duties of Mr. Saavedra as representative of the brokerage agent, the brokerage firm should have corrected said information in attention to its duty of diligence, as well as in attention to the responsibility of presenting its information truthfully;
- Consequently, the date recorded in the relevant fact referring to the cessation of duties of Mr. Saavedra as representative of the brokerage agent is the one declared by Seminario SAB and communicated to the SMV as true, that is, January 7, 2015;
- On the other hand, in relation to the application of the Sanction Criteria developed by the administering company in its defense brief, it must be indicated that said aspects will be subject to evaluation at the time of determining the corresponding sanction;
- Consequently, according to the foregoing, Seminario SAB failed to comply with the provisions of article 98 of the Regulation.
IV. Evaluation of the Sanction
- From the foregoing, it has been determined that Seminario SAB incurred two (02) infractions, one classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which the following constitutes a serious infraction: "Carrying out special operations without having the respective authorization from the SMV or without observing any of the conditions or formalities required for such purpose"; and another classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as a minor infraction: "Failure to communicate relevant facts, or failure to do so within the period established by the regulations"; In accordance with Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulations, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in Article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of Article 230[5] of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the offender's contribution to its clarification, and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in Article 236-A[6] of the LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's background; b) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, which includes the impact on the market; c) The economic harm caused; d) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegally obtained benefit; g) The existence or absence of intent in the offender's conduct; h) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification; i) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to the notification of the corresponding charges; and j) The error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- Regarding the offender's background, in accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the current Sanctions Regulations, sanctions imposed by the SMV that have become final within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction constitute background. In this regard, from the review carried out in said period, it has been verified that Seminario SAB for the charge imputed regarding the Relevant Fact records the following final sanctions:
- By Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 263-2011-EF/94.01.3 of November 28, 2011, Seminario SAB was sanctioned with a fine of 40 UIT for having incurred serious infractions classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1, as well as in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations. However, by Superintendent Resolution No. 086-2012-SMV/02 of July 16, 2012, the appeal filed by Seminario SAB against said resolution was declared partially founded and it was resolved to reduce the fine imposed on Seminario SAB for the commission of the infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations to 25.1 UIT.
- By Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of SMV No. 14-2013-SMV/10 of December 19, 2013, Seminario SAB was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred one (01) minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations. By Superintendent Resolution No. 140-2014-SMV/02 of December 10, 2014, the appeal filed against said resolution was declared unfounded.
- Regarding the charge for granting credits without signing a contract; it records as background the sanction indicated in literal a) of the preceding recital and additionally the sanction imposed by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 148-2010-EF/94.01.3 for having incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.9 of the Sanctions Regulations. By CONASEV Resolution No. 061-2011-EF/94.01.1 of July 22, 2011, the appeal filed against said resolution was declared unfounded;
- Regarding the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it should be noted that in the present case it has not been possible to prove that the actions of Seminario SAB in the commission of the infraction analyzed in this sanctioning procedure have caused damage to the public interest or have had an impact on the market; however, the legal interest related to the protection of investors has been affected insofar as the untimely presentation of relevant facts limits the capacity of supervision and control of intermediation agents by the SMV. Likewise, insofar as the information on representatives is disseminated to the market through the SMV Portal, the investment decision-making process is affected by not timely providing information on the situation of the employment relationship between a person who performs the functions of representative and an intermediation agent;
- Likewise, since Seminario SAB granted credits to its clients without having signed the respective mutual loan agreement and therefore without the requirement of the conditions established for such purpose; the integrity of the market has been affected because the intermediary carried out special operations without having the required guarantees;
- As for the economic harm caused, it should be mentioned that it has not been possible to evidence that the infraction incurred by Seminario SAB has caused concrete economic harm to market participants;
- Regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that in the analyzed case it is not observed that this assumption has been configured;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that Seminario SAB, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, is aware of the rules that oblige it to present relevant facts to the SMV within the established periods and to sign mutual loan agreements. However, Seminario SAB did not timely present the relevant fact, subject of this sanctioning procedure; nor did it sign the respective contract despite maintaining debtor balances with clients for extended periods;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, it has not been proven in this procedure that Seminario SAB obtained any benefit by incurring the imputed infraction;
- Regarding the existence or absence of intent in the offender's conduct, it should be specified that no intent has been evidenced in the conduct of Seminario SAB regarding the infraction under analysis;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification, it should be noted that Seminario SAB has acknowledged only the commission of the infraction related to the relevant fact, stating that said non-compliance was due to an error by the person responsible for sending said information;
- Likewise, regarding the evaluation of the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in Article 236-A of the LPAG, it should be noted that Seminario SAB has not voluntarily corrected the acts or omissions constituting the infraction contained in the Charge Letter;
- Likewise, it should be noted that in the present case it has not been evidenced that the infringing conduct by Seminario SAB was generated by an error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- Although in accordance with the provisions of Article 15 of the Sanctions Regulations, in the analyzed case the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction should be imposed on Seminario SAB, however, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, and in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of Article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, and taking into account that no harm caused or illegally obtained benefit has been evidenced, as well as the provisions of the third paragraph of Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulations, it is appropriate to impose on Seminario SAB a sanction applicable to minor infractions, as provided in Article 22 of the Sanctions Regulations;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that Seminario & Cía. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, regarding the observance of the provisions of Article 51 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments; for granting credits to its clients without signing the respective mutual loan agreement.
Article 2.- Declare that Seminario & Cía. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not having timely presented the relevant fact of January 7, 2015 regarding the cessation of functions of the representative of the intermediation agent.
Article 3.- Sanction Seminario & Cía. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A with a fine of three (03) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infractions, equivalent to S/ 11,100.00 (Eleven thousand one hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions mentioned in Articles 1 and 2.
Article 4.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative remedy, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a motion for reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 5.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by motion for reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on Advertising of Regulatory Projects, General Rules and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
Article 6.- Transcribe this resolution to Seminario & Cía. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
Manual of Technical Specifications for the submission to the SMV of Information of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 026-2012-SMV/01. ↑
-
According to the referred document, a transfer made on February 18, 2014 for the amount of US$ 171,380.00 is observed, with which the balance of the mentioned client amounted to US$ 8.63. ↑
-
File No. 2015001252. ↑
-
Persons registered in the Rpmv who act in the securities market, whether receiving or executing investment orders or advising or managing investments in securities on behalf of third parties or estates, must behave with diligence and transparency in the interest of their clients and in defense of the integrity of the market. ↑
-
"Article 230.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power.
(…)
3. Reasonableness.- The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria that are indicated in order of priority for their graduation:
a) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest;
b) The economic harm caused;
c) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction;
d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction;
e) The illegally obtained benefit, and;
f) The existence or absence of intent in the offender's conduct.
(…)" ↑
-
"Article 236 - A.- Mitigating circumstances of responsibility for infractions
The following constitute mitigating conditions of responsibility for the commission of the administrative infraction:
1.- The voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 235.
2.- Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision." ↑