Rule · SMV · 18 Sep 2020
Valuation entities bidding to determine the minimum price in public purchase offers by exclusion and public acquisition offers must not have links to the offeror or holders of 5% or more of the securities, nor prior two-year relationships creating conflicts. They must set the minimum price within thirty (30) days of appointment, submit technical and economic proposals jointly in encrypted PDF of up to 10 megabytes via MVNet or SMV Virtual, and file the valuation report with working papers through those systems.
Lima, 18 September 2020
File No. 2020028623 and Joint Reports No. 778-2020-SMV/06/11/12 and No. 914-2020-SMV/06/11/12 of 14 August and 14 September 2020, respectively, issued by the Legal Advisory Office, the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision and the Deputy Superintendency of Research and Development; as well as the draft resolution approving the model of “Bases for the non-face-to-face selection process of the valuation entity responsible for determining the minimum price to be taken into account in the processes of public tender offers for exclusion and public acquisition offers”, and amending the Regulation of Public Acquisition Offers and Acquisition of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, (hereinafter, the Project);
That, in accordance with the provisions of article 1 of the Consolidated Text of the Organic Law of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, Organic Law of the SMV), the SMV has the purpose of ensuring the protection of investors, the efficiency and transparency of the markets under its supervision, the correct formation of prices and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purposes, through regulation, supervision and promotion;
That, literal b) of article 5 of the Organic Law of the SMV establishes as an attribution of the Board of Directors of the SMV the approval of the regulations of the securities market, as well as those to which natural and legal persons subject to the supervision of the SMV must adhere;
That, by Supreme Decree No. 008-2020-SA, published on 11 March 2020, the Health Emergency was declared at the national level for a period of ninety (90) calendar days, and measures were dictated for prevention and control to avoid the spread of COVID-19; said period having been extended by Supreme Decrees No. 020-2020-SA and No. 027-2020-SA, until 7 December 2020;
That, with Supreme Decree No. 044-2020-PCM, published on 15 March 2020 (hereinafter, DS 044-2020), specified by Supreme Decrees No. 045 and No. 046-2020-PCM, the National State of Emergency was declared for a period of fifteen (15) calendar days, due to the serious circumstances affecting the life of the Nation as a consequence of the COVID-19 outbreak; said period having been extended by Supreme Decrees No. 051-2020-PCM, No. 064-2020-PCM, No. 075-2020-PCM, No. 083-2020-PCM, No. 094-2020-PCM, No. 116-2020-PCM, No. 135-2020-PCM and by No. 146-2020-PCM until 30 September 2020;
That, Supreme Decree No. 116-2020-PCM, in addition to extending the National State of Emergency, established measures that citizens must observe in the new social coexistence, indicating in article 10 that Public Sector Entities must prioritize remote work in everything possible, implementing or enabling the virtualization of procedures, services or others, and in numeral 10.2 of the cited article, specifies that public entities may establish mechanisms for scheduling appointments for public attention through digital means to optimize their scheduling;
That, by article 1 of Ministerial Resolution No. 103-2020-PCM, the “Guidelines for attention to citizens and the operation of entities of the Executive Branch, during the validity of the declaration of health emergency produced by Covid-19, within the framework of Supreme Decree No. 008-2020-SA” were approved, establishing that entities of the Executive Branch must prioritize the following aspects: (a) Apply remote work in all activities and actions where possible; (b) Virtualize and enable the digitalization of procedures, services or others, as well as non-face-to-face mechanisms where possible for the entity; (c) Establish the maximum capacity of premises and areas to establish the necessary health and conditioning measures; (d) Prepare and approve the “Plan for surveillance, prevention and control of COVID-19 at work” in accordance with the Guidelines for the surveillance of the health of workers at risk of exposure to COVID-19, approved by the Ministry of Health through Ministerial Resolution No. 239-2020-MINSA;
That, the SMV, through Superintendent Resolution No. 046-2020-SMV/02, ordered the attention of the vast majority of its administrative procedures through the Peruvian Securities Market System (MVNet) and SMV Virtual, which allow the exchange of information through electronic platforms between natural and legal persons with the SMV, systems regulated in the Regulation of the MVNet and SMV Virtual System, approved by SMV Resolution No. 010-2013-SMV/01, establishing in its article 1 the following:
“Article 1.- Provision of procedures and services under the responsibility of the SMV The Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) shall process and/or provide, through remote work and through the existing virtual channels of attention, such as MVNet and the Securities Market Portal, all administrative procedures and services under its competence, including orientation ones, that have been initiated before and during the validity of the health emergency ordered by Supreme Decree No. 008-2020-SA published on 11 March 2020.
Therefore, procedures or services that require physical attention at the SMV facilities shall not be processed and/or provided, except for document processing services and access to administrative sanctioning files in process; and procedures or services that require the transfer or mobilization of the personnel of this Superintendency outside the place where they usually perform their duties.
In the case of operating authorization procedures in which the corresponding inspection visit had been carried out prior to the mandatory social immobilization (quarantine), said procedures shall continue to be processed until their conclusion."
That, on the other hand, articles 37 and 38 of the Securities Market Law establish the grounds for exclusion of a security from the Public Registry of the Securities Market and provide that in order to proceed with the exclusion of the security, it is mandatory that a public purchase offer be previously made in accordance with the provisions of article 69 of the same legal text;
That, article 69 of the Securities Market Law and subsection b of article 36 of the Regulation on Public Offers of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, provide that the minimum price to be taken into account in a public purchase offer shall be the one determined by a valuation entity, in the absence of an existing weighted average quotation of the last quarter of the security;
That, article 49 of the Regulation on Public Offers of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion provides that the valuation entity shall be selected by a Committee made up of three officials of CONASEV, now SMV, and the representative of the issuer who shall attend with voice but without vote, in accordance with the terms and conditions approved for that purpose by the General Manager of CONASEV;
That, likewise, subsection a of article 6 of the Regulation on Public Offers of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion provides that in indirect, involuntary acquisitions resulting from a public sale offer, the consideration to be offered in the public acquisition offer shall in no case be less than that established in Title IV of the aforementioned regulation;
That, by Management Resolution No. 025-2006-EF/94.45 the model terms and conditions for the selection process of the entity responsible for determining the minimum price in the processes of public offers of acquisition and public purchase offers (hereinafter, the "Bases") were approved;
That, considering the provisions of article 10 of Supreme Decree No. 116-2020-PCM and article 1 of Superintendency Resolution No. 046-2020-SMV/02, and taking into account that the SMV as of July 2, 2020 has put into operation an electronic platform that allows the non-face-to-face participation of administered persons in certain administrative procedures, it is considered necessary to establish provisions that allow selection processes of valuation entities to be carried out in a non-face-to-face manner in the processes of public offers of acquisition and public purchase offers by exclusion;
That, for said purpose, it is considered necessary to approve special terms and conditions that determine the conditions, requirements and documents that must be submitted to the SMV using the MVNET or SMV Virtual System;
That, in this sense, the model terms and conditions for the non-face-to-face selection process of the entity responsible for determining the minimum price in the processes of public offers of acquisition and public purchase offers by exclusion, will allow said selection process to be carried out in a non-face-to-face manner under conditions very similar to selection processes with face-to-face participation, safeguarding the equality of rights and opportunities of the bidders participating therein and complying with the provisions issued by the government to preserve health and life and to avoid the risk of contagion and the spread of COVID-19;
That, the Information Technology Office of the SMV shall be responsible for providing support and technical assistance in the event of technical difficulties with the use of the electronic platform through which the non-face-to-face selection process of the valuation entity will be developed;
That, given the current situation, it is considered that the selection procedure of valuation entities under the aforementioned conditions must have a temporary validity, it being considered that this should be until June 30, 2021, and later, depending on the evolution of the health crisis caused by COVID-19 and its effects, the need to extend its application beyond said date or to provide for its permanent character shall be determined;
That, additionally, it is required to make some modifications and additions to the Regulation on Public Offers of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, in order to optimize the valuation process to be carried out by the entity responsible for determining the minimum price in the processes of public offers of acquisition and public purchase offers by exclusion;
That, the Project was disseminated in citizen consultation on the SMV's Securities Market Portal for a period of ten (10) calendar days, in accordance with the provisions of SMV Resolution No. 008-2020-SMV/01, published on August 24, 2020 in the Official Gazette El Peruano, having received comments and suggestions that have allowed enriching the proposal; and,
In accordance with the provisions of subsection a) of article 1 and subsection b) of article 5 of the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, approved by Decree Law No. 26126 and its amendments, the First Final Complementary Provision of Ministerial Resolution No. 103-2020-PCM; as well as what was agreed in the Board session of September 17, 2020;
Article 1.- To approve the model of "Bases for the non-face-to-face selection process of the valuation entity responsible for determining the minimum price to be taken into account in the processes of public purchase offers by exclusion and public offers of acquisition", the same that shall be applicable from the entry into force of this resolution and shall have the following wording:
BASES FOR THE NON-PRESENTIAL SELECTION PROCESS OF THE VALUATION ENTITY RESPONSIBLE FOR DETERMINING THE MINIMUM PRICE TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT BY [THE OFFEROR] IN THE [PUBLIC OFFER OF PURCHASE BY EXCLUSION / PUBLIC OFFER OF ACQUISITION] ON [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] BY [THE ISSUER]
To select a legal entity that has the experience and meets the requirements established in these Bases to determine the minimum price to be taken into account in the [PUBLIC OFFER OF PURCHASE BY EXCLUSION / PUBLIC OFFER OF ACQUISITION] (hereinafter, [OPC / OPA]) on [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] by [THE ISSUER] (hereinafter, SECURITIES), in compliance with the provisions of Title IV of the Regulation of Public Offer of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, its amending rules (hereinafter, Regulation) and SMV Resolution No. XXX-2(02)0-SMV/0X.
The following may act as valuation entities: the companies recognized by the aforementioned Regulation: audit firms, banks, investment banks, brokerage agents or consulting firms, specialized in business valuation activities, whose experience allows them to assume the proposed process. Brokerage agents may not participate in the offers in which they have performed this valuation work.
Those who, by themselves or through their directors, managers or technical personnel in charge of the valuation, may not act as valuation entities:
a. Have a link with the parties obligated to make the respective offer or with the holders of securities whose joint holding is equal to or greater than five percent (5%) of the total securities subject to the offer.
b. Be shareholders, directors, managers or advisors of the offeror or of the other parties obligated to make the offer.
c. Have or have had in the last two (2) years any type of relationship with the company, whether commercial, professional, personal, family or of another nature, as the case may be, that has generated or may generate a conflict of interest in the performance of their work.
The valuation entity must determine the minimum price to be taken into account in the corresponding offer within thirty (30) days following the date of its appointment. This deadline may be extended, only once and for a maximum period of fifteen (15) days, at the discretion of the “Selection Committee for the Valuation Entity and Price Determination” (hereinafter, Committee), upon a reasoned request from the valuation entity.
If the Committee decides to grant the extension of the deadline to determine the minimum price, in accordance with article 47 of the Regulation, the Issuer must disclose it to the market as a material fact.
The criteria to be used in determining the minimum price to be taken into account for the offer must consider the situation existing at the time the event that generates the obligation to make it occurs.
Once this minimum price is determined, the winning valuation entity will determine whether it requires adjustment due to the passage of time and what factor should be used to make such adjustment.
[Likewise, in the case of a Public Offer of Acquisition (OPA), the selected valuation entity must determine the value of the consideration for the transactions that generated the obligation to carry out the OPA. The minimum price to be taken into account for carrying out the offer may in no case be less than said value.]
The call will be made through the publication of the Call Notice (Annex No. 1), the Selection Process Schedule (Annex No. 2) and the Bases Request Form (Annex No. 3) attached to these bases, through the dissemination media of the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A – BVL and the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV.
The bases of the selection process will be made available to interested parties who request them free of charge, within the period established in the schedule, and to this end they must send their request (Annex No. 3) with all the required information and signed by their authorized legal representative, to the email account [ ].
The valuation entities that are registered in the selection process may formulate queries on the bases, within the period indicated in the schedule of the selection process; for this purpose they must send their queries addressed to the Selection Committee to the email account [ ].
The answering of the queries will be made, within the period indicated in the schedule of the selection process, in a single document. This will form part of the bases and will be communicated to all participating valuation entities via the SMV website (https://www.smv.gob.pe), the website and the Daily Bulletin of the Lima Stock Exchange, without indicating the valuation entity that formulated the query.
The technical and economic proposal must be presented jointly and in digital PDF format, each having a maximum size of up to 10 megabytes. Such proposals may be presented through the MVNet System or the SMV Virtual, and must be sent only once, within the period indicated in the schedule of the selection process. Proposals submitted after this deadline or duplicated will be considered as not accepted. All proposals will be recorded in the corresponding file of the selection process.
The digital format used for each of the proposals will be PDF protected through encryption of the documentation using a different key that the evaluating entity must enter for each corresponding PDF file for both the technical proposal and the economic proposal, and which the Committee will not have until the proposal opening stage, in order to guarantee the confidentiality and transparency of the selection process of the evaluating entity.
Once submitted, proposals may not be deleted or modified; proposals submitted by the legal entity in the first submission of documentation will be considered valid.
Proposals are submitted in Spanish or, failing that, accompanied by a simple translation with the indication and signature of the person acting as translator duly identified; likewise, the proposal must be signed by the legal representative and be numbered, in color or legible grayscale PDF format. The evaluating entity is responsible for the accuracy and veracity of said documents.
Each evaluating entity must appoint a representative; if said representation does not correspond to the general manager or an official of similar rank, the bidder must accredit the representative by means of a simple letter, which must be included in the file generated at the time of submitting the proposals so that they may participate in the selection process.
i) The Committee will send to the participating evaluating entities, one day before the scheduled date for the opening of the technical proposal, through the MVNet system or the SMV Virtual, as applicable, the access credentials to the SMV electronic platform that will be used for the public act. The minimum technical specifications to access the electronic platform are included in Annex 12.
The access credential to the SMV electronic platform will also be sent to the Public Notary who will participate in the selection process, as it is a public act.
ii) The opening of the Technical Proposal will be carried out on the date indicated in the schedule of the selection process, with the participation of the members of the Committee, if applicable, the representative of the issuer/bidder, the representatives of the Evaluating Entities and the Public Notary, who will draw up a record of all proceedings, which upon completion of the process will be added to the file as a sign of conformity.
iii) The president of the Committee will declare the process initiated by reading the corporate name of each of the legal entities that submitted their proposals and indicating the time at which the proposals were submitted on the electronic platform.
iv) Next, each participant will be called in accordance with the order of submission, who will identify themselves by holding their DNI up to the screen. The identity will be verified against the documentation submitted in the file.
v) The participant's representative will state aloud the key generated for the digital technical proposal document.
vi) Each member of the Committee, the Public Notary and the representative of the issuer/bidder must access the technical proposal, verifying compliance with the requirements demanded by the Bases.
vii) If the Committee determines that any proposal does not comply with any formal requirement demanded by the bases, the proposal will be considered as not submitted.
viii) At the end of the public act, the Public Notary will proceed to draw up and sign the minutes of the session, which will be incorporated into the file.
In a reserved act, the Committee will proceed to evaluate and score the Technical Proposals of the participating evaluating entities in accordance with the criteria established in Annex 10. The scoring of the technical proposal will be informed to the participants at the beginning of the public act of opening of the economic proposal.
i) The Committee will send to the participating evaluating entities, one day before the scheduled date for the opening of the economic proposal, the access credentials to the SMV electronic platform for the public act. The minimum technical specifications to access the electronic platform are included in Annex 12.
The link to the SMV electronic platform will also be sent to the Public Notary who will participate in the selection process, as it is a public act.
ii) The opening of the economic Proposal will be carried out on the date indicated in the schedule of the selection process, with the participation of the members of the Committee, if applicable, the representative of the issuer/bidder, the representatives of the Evaluating Entities and the Public Notary, who will draw up a record of all proceedings, which upon completion of the process will be added to the file as a sign of conformity.
iii) The president of the Committee will declare the process initiated by reading the corporate name of each of the legal entities that scored above the minimum established in the criteria set forth in Annex 10.
iv) Next, each participant will be called in accordance with the order of submission of the previous day, who will identify themselves by holding their DNI up to the screen. The identity will be verified again against the documentation submitted in the file.
v) The participant's representative will state aloud the key generated for the economic proposal document, which will be different from that of the technical proposal.
vi) Each member of the Committee, the Public Notary and the representative of the issuer/offeror must enter the economic proposal, verifying compliance with the requirements demanded by the Bases.
vii) In the event that the Committee establishes that any proposal does not comply with any formal requirement demanded by the bases, the proposal shall be considered as not submitted.
viii) The Selection Committee shall evaluate and qualify the Economic Proposals submitted, in accordance with the criteria indicated in Annex 10, shall determine the total score reached by each of the bidding companies in their Technical and Economic Proposals, establishing the corresponding order of merit, which shall be read and the winning valuation entity shall be declared.
ix) At the end of the public act, the Public Notary shall proceed to draw up and sign the minutes of the session, which shall be incorporated into the file.
The Committee shall publish the result of the selection (selected valuation entity, address and amount of the economic proposal) on the SMV website (https://www.smv.gob.pe).
Finally, the SMV shall inform the results of the selection to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A. for its dissemination, on the following business day, in the Daily Bulletin of the Lima Stock Exchange.
a) Presentation letter (Annex No. 4).
b) Sworn Declaration that the valuation entity, its directors, managers, advisors or technical personnel in charge of determining the minimum price of the securities that will be the object of the [OPC / OPA] are not in any of the impediments indicated in the REGULATION (Annex No. 5).
c) Experience of the Valuation Entity
i. Sworn Declaration of the list of services similar or related to the applicant of this selection process carried out by the valuation entity with a seniority no greater than three (3) years (Annex No. 6).
ii. Sworn Declaration of the information on the personnel proposed by the company for the conduct of the valuation process (Annex No. 7).
d) Letter of commitment of each of the members that form part of the personnel proposed by the company for the conduct of the valuation process. (Annex No. 8).
In the event that any member of the personnel proposed by the Valuation Entity is replaced, the Valuation Entity must send to the SMV in a timely manner the letter of commitment of the new member.
e) Analysis of the sector, company and context of the operation
i. Analysis of the sector to which the company to be valued belongs.
ii. Analysis of the company to be valued, carried out based on the available public information [and/or the information provided by the issuer].
iii. Analysis of the context of the operation for which the valuation is required (description that demonstrates the valuation entity's knowledge of the relevant facts related to the carrying out of the [OPC / OPA]).
f) Work Plan
i. Organization of the work team (organizational chart, list of the members of the work team, detail of the assignment of responsibilities).
ii. Description of the methodology to be used. The valuation entity must carry out its work in accordance with internationally accepted valuation practices and considering, at least, the following duly justified criteria:
1) Book value of the company;
2) Liquidation value of the company;
3) Value of the company as a going concern;
4) Weighted average price of the securities during the semester immediately prior to the date of occurrence of the cause that generates the obligation to carry out the offer; and,
5) If any OPA has been formulated within the twelve months prior to the date of occurrence of the cause that generates the obligation to carry out the offer, the consideration offered at such opportunity.
Additionally, the valuation entity may support the impossibility of applying any of the mentioned criteria and propose a criterion that, in its judgment, is more appropriate for the specific case.
iii. Schedule of activities.
a) Economic Proposal duly signed by the legal representative of the valuation entity, which must specify the following concepts:
1) Cost of the valuation service
2) Cost of asset appraisals
3) Cost of legal advice
4) Others, if applicable
b) The remuneration shall be for the account of [those responsible for the exclusion of the securities / those obligated to formulate the subsequent OPA] (Annex No. 9).
The evaluation of the proposals shall be carried out by the Committee which shall be composed of the representative of the issuer who shall attend with voice but without vote and by three officials of the SMV: The Deputy Superintendent of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, who shall preside over the Committee, the Deputy Superintendent of the Deputy Superintendency of Research and Development and the Deputy Superintendent of the Legal Advisory Office.
Each of the members of the Committee may designate their respective representative.
If in the first call there are fewer than two (2) valuation entities or if the Committee considers that none or only one of them qualifies in accordance with the minimum conditions established to act as a valuation entity in the selection process; or that no bidder reaches the minimum score required in the technical proposal; or that no bidder reaches the minimum score required to carry out the valuation assignment, the selection process shall be declared void.
On the second and third call, the process shall be declared void if no valuation entity has submitted a proposal, or if, having submitted one or more valuation entities, the members of the Committee consider that none of them qualifies in accordance with the minimum conditions established to act as a valuation entity in the selection process; or that no bidder reaches the minimum score required in the technical proposal; or that no bidder reaches the minimum score required to carry out the valuation engagement, the selection process shall be declared void
In the event that after three (3) calls a valuation entity cannot be appointed, the price for carrying out the offer shall be the average of the fifteen stock exchange quotations prior to the occurrence of the event that generates the obligation to make the offer, or of the beginning of the acts that give rise to the obligation to make the offer, if these were successive and continuous, updated by the variation of the selective index of the respective stock exchange. For the determination of said value, transactions carried out by the issuer and its respective related parties must be excluded.
For the purposes of the corresponding evaluation, the evaluation criteria mentioned in Annex No. 10 shall be applied.
As a result of the evaluation, the total score achieved by each of the valuation entities shall be determined, and the one obtaining the highest score shall be selected as the winner. This result shall be communicated to the SMV and to the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. for its dissemination.
Challenges related to the election of the winning valuation entity or any other related to the selection process may be submitted to the COMMITTEE within the business day following the communication of the award of the good pro, after payment of a fee equivalent to four percent (4%) of the Tax Unit (UIT), attaching the documentation and information supporting it. The Committee shall resolve the challenge within a period no greater than two (2) business days, and said resolution shall not be subject to challenge.
The winning valuation entity must observe the provisions that the SMV may have issued regarding the operation for which the valuation is required.
The winning valuation entity shall submit to the SMV, through the MVNet System or the SMV Virtual, a report that shall include all the information referring to the basis and the determination of the assumptions used for the application of each methodology. Likewise, it must attach as annexes a copy of the working papers with the calculations supporting the results obtained, the studies, projects, appraisals and other relevant reports used in the evaluation of the company.
The valuation report is public in nature and must have the minimum content detailed below:
The valuation reports submitted to the SMV and disseminated to the securities market must contain, among others, the points detailed below. In the event that, in the opinion of the valuation entity, one or some of the points are not applicable, it must set out in detail the grounds for this in the corresponding section. Likewise, the valuation entity may include criteria and additional information it considers necessary for the development of the function assumed.
I. Cover Page of the Report
1.1. The text: <<Valuation report of [Identification of the Issuer]>>
1.2. The text: <<Public offer [indicate the type or types of offer that gave rise to the preparation of the valuation report]>>.
1.3. The text: <<Prepared by: Identification of the [VALUATION ENTITY]>>
1.4. Date of preparation and signing of the valuation report.
II. Declaration of Responsibility
“The signatories declare that they have carried out an investigation and analysis that leads them to consider that this valuation report of the [securities] issued by [Issuer] has been prepared in accordance with the technical proposal submitted in the call for the selection of the valuation entity and observing the requirements detailed in Annex V of the Regulation on Public Offer of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10 and amendments, based on public information, as well as all information provided by the issuer.
Likewise, this valuation report contains professional criteria and opinions, and has been prepared with the sole purpose of determining the minimum price to be considered in the framework of compliance with the obligation to make a Public Offer of [Acquisition / Purchase of Securities by Exclusion] of the [securities] issued by [Issuer].
The opinions and estimates expressed constitute the valuation of [VALUATION ENTITY] as of the cut-off date that gave rise to the obligation for [Issuer] to make the respective public offer, as well as subsequent events that could affect the price of the [securities] issued by [Issuer].
This valuation report does not constitute a recommendation to buy, sell or hold the security; the valuation carried out is independent and has not been influenced by other activities of the [VALUATION ENTITY].
This valuation report is published on the Securities Market Portal (https://www.smv.gob.pe) where additional information on the related public offer can also be consulted. The information used in this report comprises the Financial Statements [specify whether audited annual FS, unaudited quarterly FS] corresponding to [Issuer].
[VALUATION ENTITY] informs the market that the information has been obtained primarily from [Issuer] and [specify if other sources exist], and therefore no audit or verification procedures have been applied to it. [VALUATION ENTITY] cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness and assumes no responsibility for any error or omission in it.
However, [VALUATION ENTITY] and the officers signing it are responsible for damages that may arise from the issuance of a valuation report with errors that lead to the modification of the minimum price to be considered in the aforementioned public offering, inadequate technical support, or insufficiency in its content, within the scope of their competence, in accordance with the liability established by the Civil Code or administrative liability that may arise.”
Name and Signature of each member of the work team Date of preparation and signing of the report of valuation
3.1 Identification of the [ISSUER] and of the public offering that gave rise to the preparation of the valuation report.
3.2 Purpose of the valuation report: Indicate that the minimum price to be considered in the framework of the public offering for acquisition or purchase of securities by exclusion, as applicable, is being determined.
3.3 Values or amounts obtained by the different valuation methodologies: Present a summary table showing the different values obtained by applying the methodologies in the valuation report (Table in section XI).
3.4 Minimum price selected at the discretion of the valuation entity based on the different methodologies (section XI).
IV. Background of the transaction: Summary of the context that gave rise to the obligation to determine a valuation process.
5.1 Business Lines: List and describe the main types of products and/or services provided by the issuer, indicate the average amounts or percentages corresponding to the revenues of each business line, and other revenue levels deemed important.
5.2 Shareholders and Board of Directors: Indicate the main shareholders with more than four percent (4%) ownership, the country of origin of each, and the members of the board of directors.
5.3 Organizational chart of the [ISSUER].
5.4 Dividend policy.
5.5 Diagram of the Issuer's Economic Group, if any.
VI. Macro-Environmental Analysis: Describe how changes in the scenarios of each of the macro-environmental elements, as applicable, could affect the production and sales levels of goods and/or services provided by the [ISSUER]. Include the analysis of the economic sector and contingencies, in accordance with the following:
6.1 Analysis of the economic sector(s) of the product(s) and/or services provided by the issuer and the markets they target nationally and internationally.
6.1.1 Description or analysis of variables affecting the economic sector(s) of the product and/or services provided by the [ISSUER] in which it carries out its economic activities nationally.
6.1.2 Description or analysis of variables affecting the economic sector(s) of the product and/or services provided by the [ISSUER] internationally, if applicable.
6.2 Contingencies: Identify the company's relevant contingencies that may affect its revenues.
6.3 Other macro-environmental elements that have had an impact on the company's development or that are considered relevant.
VII. Micro-Environmental Analysis: Describe how changes in the scenarios of each of the micro-environmental elements, as applicable, could affect the production and sales levels of goods and/or services provided by the [ISSUER], including the following:
7.1 Distribution and commercialization: Description of the main distribution and commercialization channels of the goods and/or services provided.
7.2 Description of the main competitors.
7.3 Other micro-environmental elements considered relevant.
8.1 Porter Analysis: Indicate the factors that determine the competitive strategy of the [ISSUER].
8.2 Description of the [ISSUER] with respect to the industry.
9.1. Basis: Indicate the Financial Statements used.
9.2. Financial Analysis: Include the analysis of the main accounts and the comparison with the sector.
9.2.1. Table of main financial ratios: Develop liquidity, management, leverage, and profitability ratios, according to the period determined by the valuation entity.
9.2.2. Horizontal analysis of the Financial Statements according to the period determined by the valuation entity.
9.2.3. Vertical analysis of the Financial Statements according to the period determined by the valuation entity.
The valuation entity must carry out its work considering, at least, the following duly substantiated criteria and methodologies:
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them.
Formula:
݈݊݅ܽ݅݉ݎݐܽ ݎܸ݈ܽ ൌ ܾ݈ܽ݁ݐ݊ܿ ݎܸ݈ܽ
ݏݒ݅ݏܲܽ ݈ܽݐܶ െ ݏݒ݅ݐܿܣ ݈ܽݐܶ ൌ
݈݊݅ܽ݅݉ݎݐܽ ݎ݈ܽݒ
ሺ ൌ ݊óܽܿܿ݅ ݎ ܾ݈ܽ݁ݐ݊ܿ ݎܸ݈ܽ
ሻ ݏ݊݁ܽܿܿ݅ ݀݁ ܰ°
In the case of a valuation to determine the minimum price to be considered when the issuer has shares different from those that make up its share capital, the valuation entity shall disclose the variables and factors used to determine the book value of the different types or classes of shares, and the corresponding grounds.
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them, as well as the grounds for the appraisals used and/or amounts used in each of the liquidation values of the accounts. Include the corporate name of the appraisal company, liquidation factor for each account, as applicable, among other concepts used in determining the liquidation value of assets and liabilities (support the estimates, include appraisal documents and, if applicable, liquidation factor calculation tables; as Annexes).
Formula:
Liquidation value ൌ ܸܣܮܶ െ ܸܮܲܶ െ ܣܦܥ
Unit liquidation value ൌ Liquidation value Number of shares
Where:
ܸܣܮܶ = Liquidation value of Total Assets ܸܮܲܶ = Liquidation value of Total Liabilities ܣܦܥ = Costs incurred in the dismantling of the activity (personnel compensation expenses, legal expenses and other contingencies)
In the event that the appraisal entity considers other factors in the above formulas, it must disclose the grounds for using them, as well as the grounds for the elements or criteria that make up said factors.
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them, as well as the grounds for the calculations made with the securities price database.
The calculation of the price resulting from the quotation or weighted average price of the security for the semester immediately preceding the date of occurrence of the cause that generates the obligation to carry out the offer.
For the purposes of calculating the price, the transactions carried out during said period must be ordered, considering the traded volume from lowest to highest, grouping them into four (4) tranches with an equal number of transactions per tranche, excluding from the calculations the first and fourth tranches, which contain the transactions with the lowest and highest volume, respectively.
The criterion of the semester quotation or weighted average price shall apply only if during said period the total number of shares traded represents more than five (5) percent of the total securities in circulation and registers a trading frequency greater than 60%.
In the above calculation, transactions carried out by the issuer, as well as those carried out by the persons responsible for the exclusion and their related parties, must be excluded.
10.3. If any OPA has been formulated within the twelve (12) months prior to the date on which the obligation to formulate an offer was generated: Consideration or price applied in said OPA.
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them, as well as the support for the calculations made, observing the following:
10.4.1. Assumptions used in determining the free cash flows of the issuer and/or the shareholder, as applicable, if one or both of these two (2) cash flow models are selected, the reasons for using the flow must be justified:
10.4.1.1. Assumptions used in the projections of variables related to the quantity of goods produced and/or services offered.
10.4.1.2. Assumptions used in the projections of variables related to the prices of goods produced and/or services offered.
10.4.1.3. If applicable, other assumptions used in the projections of variables related to sales and/or revenues from goods produced and/or services offered.
10.4.1.4. If applicable, other assumptions used in the projections of variables related to demand by type of customers and/or products.
10.4.1.5. Assumptions used in the projections of production and/or service costs.
10.4.1.6. Assumptions used in the projections of administrative and selling expenses or other types of expenses.
10.4.1.7. Assumptions used in the projections of financial income and financial expenses.
10.4.1.8. Assumptions used in the projections of taxes.
10.4.1.9. Assumptions used in the projections of investments (accounting and tax depreciation, amortization, capex, working capital, projects, among others and as applicable)
10.4.1.10. Assumptions used in the number of years projected.
10.4.1.11. Other assumptions used in the projections of other accounts used in determining cash flows.
10.4.2. Table of amounts of the projections of the cash flows of the issuer and/or the shareholder (include the projections, and attach the worksheets and cash flows as an annex)
Formula:
Free cash flow ൌ EBIAT Depreciation Amortization െ CAPEX െ ∆WK
Where:
EBIAT (Earning Before Interest After Taxes) = EBIT – Taxes.
EBIT (Earning Before Interest Taxes) = EBITDA – Depreciation – Amortization.
EBITDA (Earning Before taxes Interest and Depreciation) = Gross profit (loss) – Selling expenses – Administrative expenses. Gross profit (loss) = Revenue from ordinary activities (Sales) – Cost of sales. CAPEX = Investment in Fixed Assets. ∆WK = Variation in working capital. The items or accounting accounts used must be described.
In the event that the appraisal entity considers other factors in the above formula, it must disclose the grounds for using them, as well as the grounds for the elements or criteria that make up said factors.
10.4.3. Assumptions used in determining the cost of shareholder capital:
The following formula must be applied, and each variable used must be disclosed and justified (type, term, period, source, others).
Formula:
CoK = Rf + β(Rm - Rf) + Rp + Rc
Where:
ܴ = Risk-free rate
ܴ = Market return
β = Beta statistic
PRM= Market risk premium = ܴ െ ܴ
ܴ = Country risk
ܴ = Exchange rate risk
βୟ୮ୟ୪ୟ୬ୡୟୢ୭ ൌ βୢୣୱୟ୮ୟ୪ୟ୬ୡୟୢ୭ ሾሺ1 ሺ1െTሻ ாሿ
T = Effective tax rate
D = Market value of debt or detail the accounting accounts used.
E = Market value of the company's equity or detail the accounting accounts used.
If the valuation entity considers other factors in the above formulas, it must disclose the grounds for using them, as well as the grounds for the elements or criteria that make up said factors. Likewise, if different values are determined, it must be disclosed in a table according to each of the
variables used in the market and specify the value chosen by the valuation entity.
10.4.4. Assumptions used in the calculation of the weighted average cost of capital (WACC): The accounts used and the tax rate used, among others, must be justified.
Formula:
WACC =
C
D+C CoK +
D
D+C Kd(1-T)
Where:
WACC
= weighted average cost of capital
CoK
= Opportunity cost of capital
Kd = Cost of debt
T = Effective tax rate
D = Debt. Detail the amounts of liabilities used.
C = Capital. Detail the amounts used.
10.4.5. Assumptions used in determining the different debt financing rates of the issuer (Kd).
10.4.6. Assumptions used to determine the long-term growth rate (g = long-term growth rate).
10.4.7. Valuation using each of the discount rate and growth rate values determined in the previous stages. Indicate the values obtained according to the combinations of discount rates and growth rates in the matrix.
Formula:
VE = FCD +
VT
(1+r)^t
VT =
FCL_T(1+g)
(r-g)
FCD = Σ FCL
(1+r)^t t i=1
Where:
VE = Enterprise value of the Issuer
FCD = Discounted cash flow of the company
VT = Terminal value r = WACC
ݐ = projection horizon FCL்= Free cash flow for period t ݃ = long-term growth rate of the Issuer.
Matrix of share values
Matrix of the different values obtained according to the different capital discount rates (cok) and growth rates.
r₁ r₂ r₃ ... rₙ g₁ Va(g₁,r₁) Va(g₁,r₂) Va(g₁,r₃) … Va(g₁,rₙ) g₂ Va(g₂,r₁) Va(g₂,r₂) Va(g₂,r₃) … Va(g₂,rₙ) g₃ Va(g₃,r₁) Va(g₃,r₂) Va(g₃,r₃) … Va(g₃,rₙ) ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ gₖ Va(gₖ,r₁) Va(gₖ,r₂) Va(gₖ,r₃) ⋮ Va(gₖ,rₙ)
Where:
Va: Current value of the share rᵢ: Discount rate, where i ∈ [1, 2…n] gⱼ: Long-term growth rate, where j ∈ [1, 2…k]
Present the range of values obtained in the valuation for each of the “cok” calculated and possible “g”.
Formula:
EV/Sales = (Market Capitalization + Net Debt) / Sales Sales EV/EBITDA = (Market Capitalization + Net Debt) / EBITDA EBITDA P/B = Price per share Book value per share
Other multiples applicable to the sector.
Where:
Book value per share ൌ
Total Assets - Total Liabilities
No. of shares outstanding
Return on equity (ROE) =
Net Income
Net Equity
Price െ Earnings or Price to earnings ሺP/Eሻ ൌ Price per share Earnings per share
10.6. Value of the consideration or price applied in the transactions that generated the obligation to make the offer, if such information is available according to the specific case.
10.7. Determination of the minimum price, support and justification thereof.
10.8. Update of the price over time: include appropriate adjustment factors, rates of return or reference instruments used and the sources.
XI. Results of the application of the methodologies Present the results obtained in the different methodologies applied and add a table with the different amounts or resulting values. Select the price through the criterion that, in the judgment of the valuation entity, is most appropriate for the case, include the basis for the selection. Likewise, calculate the price due to the passage of time by multiplying it with an adjustment factor, include the support for the adjustment factor used.
XII. Sensitivity Analysis of critical variables: Determine whether the sensitivity analysis should be carried out, and the respective analysis of each variable must be justified.
XIII. Other information that, in the judgment of the valuation entity, it considers important to disclose.
XIV. Conclusions and recommendations.
XV. Information Sources: List of the information sources used with a summary reference to the content and date of each one of them.
XVI. Annexes (working papers, projected financial statements, projected cash flow, historical price quotes, among others considered relevant).»
Once the report is completed, it must be delivered to the SMV, through the MVNet System or the SMV Virtual. The SMV will forward to the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A., through the MVNet System, the report delivered by the valuation entity. The SMV and the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. will disseminate the report immediately through the website of the Portal del Mercado de Valores, the Bolsa News system, and any other means they deem pertinent.
Annex No. 11 attaches the list of fixed assets and the relation of information available to [THE ISSUER].
The issuer's failure to deliver the aforementioned information or any other information does not exempt the winning valuation entity from carrying out the valuation. In such case, it must be done with the available public information. The winning valuation entity must record this situation in its report.
[THE PARTY OBLIGATED TO PAY or BIDDER] will be responsible for the payment of the fees to the winning valuation entity. The payment modality will be 50% of the total fees at the time of signing the valuation contract and the remaining 50% at the time of [the carrying out of the corresponding offer/ the conclusion of the procedure that gave rise to the valuation]. The signing of the contract between the winning valuation entity and the issuer/ bidder must be communicated by the issuer within 7 calendar days after the completion of the selection process of the valuation entity.
SELECTION OF THE ENTITY RESPONSIBLE FOR DETERMINING THE MINIMUM PRICE TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT BY [THE BIDDER IN THE [PUBLIC OFFER OF PURCHASE FOR EXCLUSION / PUBLIC OFFER OF ACQUISITION] ON [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] BY [THE ISSUER] THROUGH THE USE OF ELECTRONIC MEANS
Select a legal entity that has the experience, technical personnel and necessary infrastructure to determine the minimum price to be taken into account in the [PUBLIC OFFER OF PURCHASE FOR EXCLUSION / PUBLIC OFFER OF ACQUISITION] on [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] by [THE ISSUER] in compliance with the provisions of the Reglamento de Oferta Pública de Adquisición y de Compra de Valores por Exclusión approved by Resolución CONASEV N° 009-2006-EF/94.10, its amending norms and Resolución SMV N XXXX-2020- SMV/0X.
Audit firms, banks, investment banks, brokerage agents or consulting companies, specialized in business valuation activities, whose experience allows them to assume the proposed process, may act as valuation entities. Brokerage agents may not participate in the offers in which they have performed this valuation work.
Those who by themselves or through their directors, managers or technical personnel in charge of the valuation may not act as valuation entities:
a. Have a link with the parties obligated to make the respective offer or with the holders of securities whose joint holding is equal to or greater than five percent (5%) of the total securities subject to the offer.
b. Be shareholders, directors, managers or advisors of the bidder or of the other parties obligated to make the offer.
c. Have or have had in the last two (2) years any type of relationship with the company, whether commercial, professional, personal, family or of another nature, as the case may be, that has generated or may generate a conflict of interest in the performance of its work.
The terms of the selection process will be sent to interested parties who request them, in accordance with the format of Annex No. 3, to the email [ ] between the days [ ] and [ ] from 09:00 to 12:00 hours.
Queries will be made until [ ] hours on the day [ ] and must be sent to the email [ ] of the SMV.
The resolution of the queries will be published in a single document on [ ] on the SMV website (https://www.smv.gob.pe), on the website and in the Daily Bulletin of the Lima Stock Exchange and other means that the Committee deems pertinent, without indicating the valuation entity that submitted the query.
The digitized and encrypted technical and economic proposals must be submitted on [ ], from [ ] to [ ] hours, through the MVNet System or the SMV Virtual, to the file previously communicated to the participants. Once submitted, the proposals may not be modified.
The opening of the Technical Proposals will be held on [ ] at [ ] hours, through the use of the SMV electronic platform, with the access credentials previously notified to the participants.
The opening of the Economic Proposals will be held on [ ] at [ ] hours, through the use of the SMV electronic platform, with the access link previously notified to the participants.
The minimum technical specifications to access the electronic platform are included in Annex 12.
The result of the selection process will be announced on [ ] at [ ] hours on the SMV website.
Likewise, said result will be published on the following business day in the Daily Bulletin of the Lima Stock Exchange.
The determination of the minimum price to be taken into account in the [PUBLIC TENDER OFFER / PUBLIC ACQUISITION OFFER] on [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] by [THE ISSUER] must be made within thirty (30) days following the date of its appointment. This deadline may be extended, only once and for a maximum period of (15) additional days, at the discretion of the Selection Committee upon a reasoned request from the valuation entity.
This deadline will not be extended when the basis of the request is the non-delivery of information by the issuer to the winning valuation entity or the issuer's objection to any point of the valuation report.
[DATE]
ACTIVITY DATE TIME PLACE
Lima,
Gentlemen
Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV Av. Santa Cruz 315 Miraflores.-
Ref.: Selection Process for
Valuation Entity
By means of this application, I [FULL NAMES AND SURNAMES OF THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE], identified with [IDENTITY DOCUMENT AND NUMBER], domiciled at [INDICATE ADDRESS], in the position of [INDICATE POSITION] on behalf of [NAME OF PARTICIPATING LEGAL ENTITY], request that the terms and conditions of the selection process for the entity responsible for determining the minimum price to be taken into account by [THE BIDDER] in the [PUBLIC TENDER OFFER FOR EXCLUSION / PUBLIC TENDER OFFER FOR ACQUISITION] on [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] by [THE ISSUER] be sent to us, declaring under oath that the following information is true:
| Name, Denomination or Corporate Name: | |
|---|---|
| Legal Domicile: | |
| RUC: | Telephone number(s): |
| Authorized person: | |
| Email address: |
[STATE CITY AND DATE]
--------------------------------------------------------------------- NAME AND SIGNATURE OF LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE Identity Document Number
Lima,
Gentlemen
Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV Av. Santa Cruz 315 Miraflores.-
Ref.: Selection Process for
Valuation Entity
Dear Sirs:
In accordance with the terms of the Terms and Conditions of the process for the selection of the valuation entity responsible for determining the minimum price to be taken into account in the [PUBLIC TENDER OFFER FOR EXCLUSION / PUBLIC TENDER OFFER FOR ACQUISITION] on [THE SECURITIES ISSUED] by [THE ISSUER], the firm I represent requests to be considered as a bidder in the called selection process. In this regard, my represented company is pleased to submit for your consideration, through the channels established in Superintendency Resolution No. xxxx-2020-SMV/02, the attached documentation that proves it has the technical capacity and suitable infrastructure to participate in the aforementioned process.
We declare that we have taken knowledge of all the terms and conditions contained in the Terms and Conditions of this Call, of the rules established in the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF, of the Regulation of Public Tender Offer and Acquisition of Securities by Exclusion, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, Superintendency Resolution No. xxxx-2020-SMV/02 and other applicable rules issued by the SMV in use of its attributions; to which we submit in their entirety in order to comply with the assumed obligations.
Likewise, we expressly declare to have taken knowledge about [THE ISSUER], in accordance with the existing documentation [in the Public Registry of the Securities Market and/or the one provided in the present selection process].
Additionally, we declare that before the present call [No / Yes] we have established conversations with the representatives of [THE ISSUER] and in case of granting us the award we will only receive as remuneration the amount established in the Economic Proposal presented in Annex No. 9 attached.
I hereby, in my capacity as legal representative of [corporate name of the valorization entity], declare that neither the company nor its representatives, nor the persons who will be directly in charge of the valorization process, are prevented from carrying out the work that is the subject of the call.
The information and documentation we submit are authentic and, in the event that any inaccuracy is verified, the Selection Committee has the right to disqualify our participation.
The documents are duly numbered as established in the Bases.
Sincerely,
--------------------------------------------------------------------- NAME AND SIGNATURE OF LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE Identity Document Number RUC Number of the valorization entity
Lima,
Messrs.
Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores – SMV
Av. Santa Cruz 315
Miraflores.-
To your attention:
For the purposes of contracting the legal entity that will be in charge of determining the minimum price to be taken into account in the [PUBLIC TENDER FOR EXCLUSION / PUBLIC ACQUISITION OFFER] [OPC /OPA] regarding [THE SECURITIES] issued by [THE ISSUER], we declare, under oath, the following:
a. Our company or its directors, managers or technical personnel in charge of the valorization have no connection with those obligated to make the respective offer or with the holders of securities whose joint holding is equal to or greater than five percent (5%) of the total securities that are the subject of the offer.
b. Our company and neither its directors, managers or technical personnel in charge of the valorization are shareholders, directors, managers or advisors of the bidder or of the other parties obligated to make the offer.
c. Our company has not had nor has it had in the last two (2) years any type of relationship with the company, whether commercial, professional, personal, family or of another nature, as the case may be, that has generated or may generate a conflict of interest in the performance of its duties.
Sincerely,
--------------------------------------------------------------------- NAME AND SIGNATURE OF LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE Identity Document Number
No.
Descriptio n of the service
Contracting
Entity1
Representative
Representative e
Telephone Participation in the
Contract
(Sole or
Association, indicating percentage of participation) Amount of the Contract2 (U.S. Dollars or Peruvian Soles) Dates Observations (Completed or Not completed - Reasons) Start Date End Date 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
--------------------------------------------------------------------- NAME AND SIGNATURE OF LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE Identity Document Number
Note: In the event that the services were rendered in an associated form, the percentage of participation must be stated.
[1] If the name of the contractor cannot be included due to confidentiality agreements, it will not be taken into account for evaluation purposes.
[2] In the event that, due to confidentiality agreements, the exact information cannot be provided, ranges may be included. The lower limit of each range may not be less than 75 % of the upper limit.
[STATE CITY AND DATE]
Messrs.
Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV Av. Santa Cruz 315 Miraflores.-
To your attention:
By means of this sworn statement, I, [FULL NAME OF THE COMPANY'S REPRESENTATIVE], identified by [IDENTITY DOCUMENT AND NUMBER], residing at [ADDRESS], representing [CORPORATE NAME OF THE VALORIZING ENTITY], declare under oath that the information on the proposed key personnel is as follows:
1. Position: (Coordinator / Assistant) Full name: Identity document: Nationality:
2. University Degree: Registration Number in the Professional Association:
3. Postgraduate Degree:
4. Specialization Courses:
5. Teaching experience: Subjects:
6. Current position in the valorizing entity: Years of activity in the valorizing entity:
7. Number of years of professional experience: (total, in valorization and in the securities market)
8. Professional positions (institution or company, position, period of employment) - ………………………………………………………………………… - …………………………………………………………………………
9. Experience in the conduct of services similar to or related to the one requested, participation, duration, others.
| No. | Description of the service | Dates | Remarks (Completed or Not completed - Causes) |
|---|
| Contracting Entity3 | Contract Amount4 (U.S. Dollars or Nuevos Soles) | Execution | Term | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| 3 | ||||
| 4 | ||||
| 5 | ||||
| 6 | ||||
| 7 | ||||
| 8 | ||||
| 9 | ||||
| 10 |
Yours faithfully,
………………………………………
NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE
[STATE CITY AND DATE]
Messrs.
Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV Av. Santa Cruz 315 Miraflores.-
To your attention:
I, [STATE FULL NAME], identified by [IDENTITY DOCUMENT AND NUMBER], residing at [STATE THE ADDRESS], declare under oath:
Whereas, I undertake to provide my services in the position of [INSERT THE POSITION TO BE HELD] to carry out the management of the valuation process [INSERT THE NAME OF THE CALL] in the event that the company [INSERT THE NAME OF THE VALUED ENTITY] is awarded the award.
I also declare my willingness to carry out the activities that comprise the
[3] If the name of the contractor cannot be included due to confidentiality agreements, it will not be taken into account for evaluation purposes.
[4] In the event that, due to confidentiality agreements, the exact information cannot be provided, ranges may be included. The lower limit of each range may not be less than 75 % of the upper limit.
performance of the aforementioned position, during the execution period of the valuation process.
Sincerely,
………..........................................................
Signature, First and Last Name of the personnel
| Concept | Amount |
|---|---|
| Fee for the determination of the minimum price to be taken into account in the [PUBLIC PURCHASE OFFER / PUBLIC ACQUISITION OFFER] on [THE VALUES] issued by [THE ISSUER] | _______ and 00/100 Soles ( S/ ___,00). |
The amounts include Value Added Tax.
--------------------------------------------------------------------- NAME AND SIGNATURE OF LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE Identity Document Number
To qualify the valuation entity, the following Evaluation Criteria shall be considered exclusively:
| FACTORS | MAXIMUM SCORE | RATING |
|---|
I. Technical Proposal 80 points
Note: The maximum total score is one hundred (100) points and will be allocated according to compliance with each qualification factor.
It will be necessary for the valuation entity to reach a minimum score of fifty (50) points in the evaluation of the factors of the Technical Proposal, in order to subsequently carry out the evaluation of the Economic Proposal. If the aforementioned score is not reached, the valuation entity will be excluded from the selection process.
Finally, the valuation entity that obtains the highest score after adding the scores obtained in the Technical Proposal and in the Economic Proposal will be the one in charge of determining the minimum price to be offered in the [OPC / OPA]. The minimum score necessary to carry out this assignment is sixty (60) points. If there is a tie in total scores, the valuation entity that has received the highest qualification in the Technical Proposal must be selected.
List of the company's fixed assets specifying in each case whether the asset requires an appraisal or if it has one, indicating, if applicable, the date of the appraisal report and the name of the appraiser.
[List of] documents, reports and, in general, all information that may be required by the winning valuation entity, in order to carry out the valuation to determine the minimum price to be paid in the [OPC / OPA].
[THE ISSUER DID NOT COMPLY WITH SUBMITTING THE INFORMATION REQUESTED THROUGH OFFICIAL LETTER No. ::::: WITHIN THE INDICATED PERIOD]
Article 2.- Suspend the application of the model of “Bases for the selection process of the entity responsible for determining the minimum price to be taken into account in the public offering of purchase and public offering of acquisition processes”, approved by Managerial Resolution No. 025-2006-EF/94.45, as long as this resolution is in force.
Article 3.- Modify the second paragraph of article 44, subsection c) of article 46, article 47 and the second paragraph of article 55 of the Regulation of Public Offering of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, in accordance with the following text:
“Article 44.- MINIMUM PRICE TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT FOR THE OFFERS
(…)
In these cases, the corresponding offer must be made by the obligated party within a period of six (6) months from when the obligation to make the offer is generated or five days from the issuance of the report referred to in article 51, whichever occurs first. Any request for extension of the term must be duly justified by the obligated party.
Article 46.- IMPEDIMENTS
Those who by themselves or through their directors, managers or technical personnel in charge of the valuation may not act as valuation entities:
(…)
c) Have or have had in the last two (2) years any type of relationship with the company, whether commercial, professional, personal, family or of another nature, as the case may be, that has generated or may generate a conflict of interest in the performance of their work.
Article 47.- TERM TO DETERMINE THE PRICE BY THE VALUATION ENTITY
The valuation entity must determine the minimum price for the realization of the corresponding offer within thirty (30) days following the date of its designation. This term may be extended only once and up to an additional period of fifteen (15) days, at the discretion of the Committee referred to in article 49, upon a justified request from the valuation entity.
In the event that the Committee decides to grant the extension to the term to determine the minimum price, said decision will be communicated to the valuation entity and to the Issuer. The latter must disclose it to the market as a material fact. The General Superintendency of Conduct Supervision or the body that acts in its place, will inform the respective stock exchange about the granting of said extension, so that it may disseminate it in its daily bulletin.
Article 55.- Sale of shares of indirect acquisition.-
(...)
In such cases, the acquirer or the one who increases significant participation must carry out the subsequent OPA or the sale of the securities within a period of six months counted from its indirect acquisition, or within the five days following the issuance of the valuation report, whichever occurs first. (...).”
Article 4.- Incorporate a third paragraph to article 44 and subsection f) to article 50 of the Regulation of Public Offering of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, in accordance with the following text:
(…)
The party obligated to formulate the offer must apply the corresponding due diligence procedures for the formulation and execution of the offer. In the case of the OPA, the request for the selection of the valuation entity must be submitted within a period of ten (10) days from the determination of its obligation. In the case of the OPC, the request for the selection of the valuation entity must be submitted within a period of ten (10) days following the issuance of the SMV Resolution that orders the exclusion.
The valuation entity must carry out its work in accordance with internationally accepted valuation practices and considering, at least, the following duly justified criteria:
(…)
f) Value by multiples and comparable transactions.
(…)”
Article 5.- Amend Annex V of the Regulation on Public Tender Offers for Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, in accordance with the following text:
The valuation reports that are submitted to the SMV and disseminated to the securities market must contain, among others, the points detailed below. In the event that, in the opinion of the valuation entity, one or some of the points are not applicable, it must set out in detail the grounds for this in the corresponding section. Likewise, the valuation entity may include additional criteria and information that it considers necessary for the development of the function assumed.
I. Cover Page of the Report
1.1. The text: <<Valuation report of [Identification of the Issuer]>>
1.2. The text: <<Public offer [indicate the type or types of offer that gave rise to the preparation of the valuation report]>>.
1.3. The text: <<Prepared by: Identification of the [Valuation Entity]>>
1.4. Date of preparation and signing of the valuation report.
“The signatories declare that they have carried out an investigation and analysis that leads them to consider that this valuation report of the [securities] issued by [Issuer] has been prepared in accordance with the technical proposal presented in the call for the selection of the valuation entity and observing the requirements detailed in Annex V of the Regulation on Public Tender Offers for Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10 and amendments, based on public information, as well as all information provided by the issuer.
Likewise, this valuation report contains professional criteria and opinions, and has been prepared for the sole purpose of determining the minimum price to be considered in the framework of compliance with the obligation to formulate a Public Offer of [Acquisition / Purchase of Securities by Exclusion] of the [securities] issued by [Issuer].
The opinions and estimates expressed constitute the valuation of [VALUATION ENTITY] as of the cut-off date that gave rise to the obligation for [Issuer] to formulate the respective public offer, as well as subsequent events that could affect the price of the [securities] issued by [Issuer].
This valuation report does not constitute a recommendation to buy, sell or hold the security; the valuation carried out is independent and has not been influenced by other activities of the [VALUATION ENTITY].
This valuation report is published on the Securities Market Portal (https://www.smv.gob.pe) where additional information on the related public offer can also be consulted. The information used in this report includes the Financial Statements [specify whether audited annual FS, unaudited quarterly FS] corresponding to [Issuer].
[VALUATION ENTITY] informs the market that the information has been obtained mainly from [Issuer] and [specify if other sources exist], and therefore no audit or verification procedures have been applied to it. [VALUATION ENTITY] cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness and assumes no responsibility for any error or omission in it.
However, [VALUATION ENTITY] and the officers who sign it are responsible for the damages that could be generated by the issuance of a valuation report with errors that lead to the modification of the minimum price to be considered in the aforementioned public offer, inadequate technical support or insufficiency in its content, within the scope of its competence, in accordance with the responsibility established by the Civil Code or administrative responsibility that could be generated.”
Name and Signature of each member of the work team Date of preparation and signing of the report of valuation
3.1. Identification of the [ISSUER] and of the public offer that gave rise to the preparation of the valuation report.
3.2. Purpose of the valuation report: Indicate that the minimum price to be considered in the framework of the public tender offer for acquisition or purchase of securities by exclusion, as applicable, is being determined.
3.3. Values or amounts obtained by the different valuation methodologies: Present a summary table setting out the different values obtained by applying the methodologies in the valuation report (Table in numeral XI).
3.4 Minimum price selected in the opinion of the valuation entity based on the different methodologies (numeral XI).
5.1. Business Lines: List and describe the main types of products and/or services provided by the issuer, indicate the average amounts or percentages corresponding to the revenues of each business line, other revenue levels considered important.
5.2. Shareholders and Board of Directors: Indicate the main shareholders with more than four percent (4%) participation, the country of origin of each and the members of the board of directors.
5.3. Organizational chart of the [ISSUER].
5.4. Dividend policy.
5.5. Diagram of the Economic Group of the Issuer, if any.
VI. Macro Environmental Analysis: Describe how changes in the scenarios of each of the macro environmental elements, as applicable, could affect the production and sales levels of goods and/or services provided by the [ISSUER]. Include the analysis of the economic sector and contingencies, in accordance with the following:
6.1. Analysis of the economic sector(s) of the product(s) and/or services provided by the issuer and the markets to which they are directed at national and international level.
6.1.1 Description or analysis of variables that affect the economic sector(s) of the product and/or services provided by the [ISSUER] in which it carries out its economic activities at national level.
6.1.2. Description or analysis of variables that affect the economic sector(s) of the product and/or services provided by the [ISSUER] at international level, if applicable.
6.2. Contingencies: Identify the relevant contingencies of the company that may affect its revenues.
6.3. Other macro environmental elements that have had an impact on the development of the company or that it considers relevant.
VII. Micro Environmental Analysis: Describe how changes in the scenarios of each of the micro environmental elements, as applicable, could affect the production and sales levels of goods and/or services provided by the [ISSUER], among them, the following:
7.1. Distribution and commercialization: Description of the main distribution and commercialization channels of the goods and/or services provided.
7.2. Description of the main competitors.
7.3. Other micro environmental elements that it considers relevant.
8.1. Porter's Analysis: Indicate the factors that determine the competitive strategy of the [ISSUER].
8.2. Description of the [ISSUER] with respect to the industry.
9.1. Basis: Indicate the Financial Statements used.
9.2. Analysis of the Finances: Include the analysis of the main accounts and the comparison with the sector.
9.2.1 Table of main financial ratios: Develop the liquidity, management, leverage and profitability ratios, according to the period determined by the valuation entity.
9.2.2 Horizontal analysis of the Financial Statements in accordance with the period determined by the valuation entity.
9.2.3 Vertical analysis of the Financial Statements in accordance with the period determined by the valuation entity.
The valuation entity must carry out its work considering, at least, the following duly substantiated criteria and methodologies:
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them. Formula:
Book value = Equity value = Total Assets – Total Liabilities equity value Book value per share = ( No. of shares)
In the event that it is a valuation to determine the minimum price to be considered when the issuer has shares different from those that make up its share capital, the valuation entity shall disclose the variables and factors used to determine the book value of the different types or classes of shares, and the corresponding grounds.
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them, as well as the grounds for the appraisals used and/or amounts used in each of the liquidation values of the accounts. Include the corporate name of the appraisal company, liquidation factor of each account, as applicable, among other concepts used in determining the liquidation value of assets and liabilities (support the estimates, include appraisal documents and, if applicable, calculation tables of the liquidation factor; as Annexes).
Formula:
Liquidation value ൌ ܸܣܮܶ െ ܸܮܲܶ െ ܣܦܥ
Unit liquidation value ൌ Liquidation value
Number of shares
Where:
ܸܣܮܶ = Liquidation value of Total Assets
ܸܮܲܶ = Liquidation value of Total Liabilities
ܣܦܥ
= Costs incurred in the dismantling of the activity (personnel compensation expenses, legal expenses and other contingencies)
In the event that the valuation entity considers other factors in the above formulas, it must disclose the grounds for using them, as well as the grounds for the elements or criteria that make up said factors.
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them, as well as the grounds for the calculations made with the securities price database.
The calculation of the price resulting from the quotation or weighted average price of the security of the semester immediately prior to the date of occurrence of the cause that generates the obligation to carry out the offer. For the purposes of calculating the price, the transactions carried out during said period must be ordered, considering the traded volume from lowest to highest, grouping them into four (4) tranches with an equal number of transactions per tranche, excluding from the calculations, the first and fourth tranches, which are those containing the lowest and highest volume transactions, respectively.
The criterion of the semester weighted average quotation or price shall apply only if during said period the total number of shares traded represents more than five (5) percent of the total outstanding securities and registers a trading frequency greater than 60%. In the previous calculation, transactions carried out by the issuer, as well as those carried out by the persons responsible for the exclusion and the related parties of both, must be excluded.
10.3. If any OPA has been formulated within the twelve (12) months prior to the date on which the obligation to formulate an offer was generated: Consideration or price applied in said OPA.
Describe the steps to follow and the results of each of them, as well as the support for the calculations made, observing the following:
10.4.1 Assumptions used in determining the free cash flows of the issuer and/or the shareholder, as one or both of these two (2) cash flow models are selected, and the reasons for using the flow must be justified:
10.4.1.1 Assumptions used in the projections of variables related to the quantity of goods produced and/or services offered.
10.4.1.2 Assumptions used in the projections of variables related to the prices of goods produced and/or services offered.
10.4.1.3 If applicable, other assumptions used in the projections of variables related to sales and/or revenues from goods produced and/or services offered.
10.4.1.4 If applicable, other assumptions used in the projections of variables related to demand by type of customers and/or products.
10.4.1.5 Assumptions used in the projections of production and/or service costs.
10.4.1.6 Assumptions used in the projections of administrative and selling expenses or other types of expenses.
10.4.1.7 Assumptions used in the projections of financial income and financial expenses.
10.4.1.8 Assumptions used in the projections of taxes.
10.4.1.9 Assumptions used in the projections of investments (accounting and tax depreciation, amortization, capex, working capital, projects, among others and as applicable)
10.4.1.10 Assumptions used in the number of projected years.
10.4.1.11 Other assumptions used in the projections of other accounts used in determining cash flows.
Formula:
Free cash flow ൌ EBIAT Depreciation Amortization െ CAPEX െ ∆WK
Where:
EBIAT (Earning Before Interest After Taxes) = EBIT – Taxes.
EBIT (Earning Before Interest Taxes) = EBITDA – Depreciation – Amortization.
EBITDA (Earning Before taxes Interest and Depreciation) = Gross profit (loss) – Selling expenses – Administrative expenses.
Gross profit (loss) = Revenue from ordinary activities (Sales) – Cost of sales.
CAPEX = Investment in Fixed Assets.
∆WK = Variation of working capital. The items or accounting accounts used must be described.
In the event that the valuation entity considers other factors in the previous formula, it must disclose the grounds for using them, as well as the grounds for the elements or criteria that compose said factors.
The following formula must be applied, and each variable used must be disclosed and justified (type, term, period, source, others).
Formula:
CoK ൌ ܴ β൫ܴ െܴ൯ ܴ ܴ
Where:
ܴ = Risk-free rate
ܴ = Market return
β = Beta statistic
PRM= Market risk premium = ܴ െ ܴ
ܴ = Country risk
ܴ = Exchange rate risk
βୟ୮ୟ୪ୟ୬ୡୟୢ୭ = βୢୣୱୟ୮ୟ୪ୟ୬ୡୟୢ୭ ሾሺ1 + ሺ1െTሻ ாሿ
T = Effective tax rate
D = Market value of debt or detail the accounting accounts used.
E = Market value of the company's equity or detail the accounting accounts used.
In the event that the valuation entity considers other factors in the previous formulas, it must disclose the grounds for using them, as well as the grounds for the elements or criteria that compose said factors. Likewise, if different values are determined, they must be disclosed in a table according to each of the variables used in the market and specify the value chosen by the valuation entity.
10.4.4 Assumptions used in the calculation of the weighted average cost of capital (WACC): The accounts used and the tax rate used, among others, must be justified.
Formula:
ܹܥܥܣ ൌ
ܥ
ܭܥ ܥܦ
ܦ
ܦܥ ܭௗሺ1 െ ܶሻ
Where:
ܹܥܥܣ
= weighted average cost of capital
ܭܥ
= Opportunity cost of capital
ܭௗ = Cost of debt
ܶ = Effective tax rate
ܦ = Debt. Detail the amounts of liabilities used.
ܥ = Capital. Detail the amounts used.
10.4.5 Assumptions used in determining the different issuer debt financing rates (ܭௗ).
10.4.6 Assumptions used to determine the long-term growth rate ( ݃ = long-term growth rate).
10.4.7 Valuation using each of the discount rate and growth rate values determined in the previous stages. Indicate the values obtained according to the combinations of discount rates and growth rates in the matrix.
Formula:
VE ൌ FCD
VT
ሺ1 ݎሻ௧
VT ൌ
FCL்ሺ1 ݃ሻ
ሺݎ െ ݃ሻ
FCD ൌ FCL
ሺ1 ݎሻ௧
௧
ୀଵ
Where:
VE = Enterprise value of the Issuer
FCD = Discounted cash flow of the company
VT = Terminal value r = WACC
ݐ = projection horizon
FCLt= Free cash flow of period t
݃ = long-term growth rate of the Issuer.
Matrix of the different values obtained according to the different cost of equity (cok) and growth rates.
r1 r2 r3 ... rn g1 Va(g1,r1) Va(g1,r2) Va(g1,r3) … Va(g1,rn) g2 Va(g2,r1) Va(g2,r2) Va(g2,r3) … Va(g2,rn) g3 Va(g3,r1) Va(g3,r2) Va(g3,r3) … Va(g3,rn) ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ ⋮ ⋱ ⋮ gk Va(gk,r1) Va(gk,r2) Va(gk,r3) ⋮ Va(gk,rn)
Where:
Va: Current value of the share ri: Discount rate, where i ∈ [1, 2…n] gj: Long-term growth rate, where j ∈ [1, 2…k]
Present the range of values obtained in the valuation for each of the calculated “cok” and possible “g”.
Formula:
EV/Sales = Market Capitalization + Net Debt / Sales Sales EV/EBITDA = Market Capitalization + Net Debt / EBITDA EBITDA P/B = Price per share Book value per share
Other multiples applicable to the sector.
Where:
Book Value per share ൌ
Total Assets – Total Liabilities
No. of shares outstanding
Return on equity (ROE) =
Net Income
Net Equity
Price – Earnings or Price to earnings (P/E) = Price per share Earnings per share
10.6. Value of the consideration or price applied in the transactions that generated the obligation to make the offer, if such information is available according to the specific case.
10.7. Determination of the minimum price, support and justification thereof.
10.8. Update of the price over time: include appropriate adjustment factors, rates of return or reference instruments used and the sources.
XI. Results of the application of the methodologies Present the results obtained in the different methodologies applied and add a table with the different amounts or resulting values. Select the price through the criterion that, in the judgment of the valuation entity, is most appropriate for the case, include the basis for the selection. Likewise, calculate the price due to the passage of time by multiplying it by an adjustment factor, include the support for the adjustment factor used.
XII. Sensitivity Analysis of critical variables: Determine whether the sensitivity analysis should be carried out, and the respective analysis of each variable must be substantiated.
XIII. Other information that, in the judgment of the valuation entity, it considers important to disclose.
XIV: Conclusions and recommendations.
XV. Information Sources: List of the information sources used with a summary reference to the content and date of each one of them.
XVI. Annexes (working papers, projected financial statements, projected cash flow, price history, among others considered relevant)."
Article 6.- Order the publication of this resolution in the Official Gazette El Peruano and on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (https://www.smv.gob.pe).
Article 7.- This resolution shall enter into force on the day following its publication and shall remain in force until 30 June 2021, except for the provisions of articles 3, 4 and 5, which have indefinite validity.
SOLE.- Selection Processes of Valuation Entity in progress Considering the declaration of the Health Emergency State and the National Emergency State, within whose framework measures for prevention and control have been issued to avoid the spread of COVID-19, those Selection Processes of Valuation Entity to determine the minimum price to be taken into account in a Public Offer of Purchase by Exclusion or in a Public Offer of Acquisition, which are in progress at the entry into force of this resolution, shall be redirected through the reformulation of the bases and the launch of a new call.
For this purpose, the General Superintendence of Conduct Supervision, within a maximum period of five (5) business days, counted from the day following the publication of this resolution in the Official Gazette El Peruano, must disseminate on the Securities Market Portal the reformulated Bases of the Selection Processes of Valuation Entity and the respective schedules, which must observe the provisions contained in this resolution.
Register, communicate and publish.
Signed by: PESCHIERA REBAGLIATI Jose
Reason:
Date: 12/03/2020 16:24:10
José Manuel Peschiera Rebagliati
Superintendent of the Securities Market
Signed by: VARGAS PIÑA Julio Cesar FAU 20131016396 Reason:
Signed by: PEREDA GALVEZ Roberto Enriq
Reason:
Signed by: RIVERO ZEVALLOS Carlos Fabian FAU 2013 Reason:
Signed by: GIL VASQUEZ Liliana FAU 20131016396 hard Reason:
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“amending the Regulation of Public Acquisition Offers and Acquisition of Securities by Exclusion, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10”
“Consolidated Text of the Organic Law of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Decree Law No. 26126”
“approved by SMV Resolution No. 009-2020-SMV/01 (hereinafter, the «Non-in-person Bases»)”
“by SMV Resolution No. 009-2020-SMV/01 the model of Terms for the non-face-to-face selection process... was approved”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added