Superintendency Resolution SMV
No. 021-2019-SMV/10
Summary: The administrative sanctioning proceeding initiated against Grupo Privado de Inversiones S.A. former Stock Brokerage Firm is archived.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. former Stock Brokerage Firm. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning proceeding |
| File No. | : | 2018035237 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2018035237 and Report No. 1382-2018-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- By document submitted to the SMV on August 31, 2017, Mr. Benjamín Alvarez Benavides (hereinafter, the Client) filed a complaint against Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. former Stock Brokerage Firm (hereinafter, GPI), stating that it had failed to return the capital invested in said company amounting to US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars);
- Likewise, by Official Letter No. 5510-2017-SMV/10.3, notified on September 5, 2017, the Client was informed that considering that the deadline for complaints against GPI to be covered by the Guarantee Fund expired on July 25, 2017, and given the date of submission of his complaint (August 31, 2017), it is not legally possible to execute said fund in his favor for the return of the invested capital subject of the complaint, since the latter was submitted extemporaneously. Likewise, in order to clarify the facts denounced and determine whether or not to initiate an administrative sanctioning proceeding against GPI, the Client was requested to provide additional information and documentation regarding the statements in his complaint. In this regard, the Client responded by documents submitted on September 18 and October 30, 2017;
- On the other hand, by Official Letter No. 5509-2017-MV/10.3, notified on April 24, 2018, GPI was given notice of the complaint filed by the Client and was requested to provide additional information and documentation in order to clarify the facts, granting a period of three (3) business days counted from the notification thereof. To date, GPI has not complied with the request;
- By Official Letter No. 1995-2018-MV/10.3, notified on April 24, 2018, the Client is reminded of the content of Official Letter No. 5510-2017-SMV/10.3. Mr. Alvarez submits an additional document on November 5, 2018, reiterating his request that his complaint be included within the coverage of the Guarantee Fund;
- As a result of the foregoing and under the provisions of Law No. 27444 - General Administrative Procedure Law (hereinafter, LPAG), by Official Letter No. 4916-2018-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), notified on September 7, 2018, the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance initiated an administrative sanctioning proceeding against GPI regarding the facts described by the Client as well as as a result of the information and documentation contained in this administrative file;
- By the Letter of Charges, GPI was charged with having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV), the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Regulation) in force at the time of the facts, in aspects related to using client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, using global accounts without observing the required conditions, and not obtaining orders from its clients;
- It should be noted that as of the date of this resolution, GPI has not submitted its respective defenses to any of the charges imputed in this administrative sanctioning proceeding;
- It is appropriate to mention that by SMV Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02 of January 25, 2017, it was resolved to declare unfounded the appeal filed by GPI against Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm;
- The charges formulated against GPI and their evaluation have been the subject of evaluation in Report No. 1382-2018-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, paragraph 2, of the LPAG, by Official Letter No. 6535-2018-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 1382-2018-SMV/10.3 was made available to GPI for its review;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative sanctioning proceeding, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not GPI incurred an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 hereinafter Sanctions Regulation, for using client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- Whether or not GPI incurred an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, for using global accounts without observing the required conditions;
- Whether or not GPI incurred an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not obtaining orders from its clients;
- Whether or not it is appropriate to impose a sanction on GPI;
III. Analysis
3.1 Using client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
Regarding the regulations
- Literal a) of Article 195 of the LMV prohibits stock brokerage firms from using the funds or securities they receive from their principals for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted:
- Likewise, Article 48 of the Regulation establishes that the securities, financial instruments or funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a different purpose unless the corresponding express authorization is available;
"Article 48.- Basic Rules.-
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available.
(…)"
- It should be noted that Article 48 of the Regulation was amended by SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01, in force as of February 1, 2013, and establishes the following:
"Article 48.- Basic Rules
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in Articles 194 and 207 of the Law.
(…)”[1].
Regarding the Charges Formulated
- By document submitted to the SMV on August 31, 2017, the Client filed a complaint against GPI, stating that he made deposits to GPI totaling US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars), for investments in shares of Peruvian companies listed on the Lima Stock Exchange (BVL); however, he indicates that when the staff of the stock brokerage firm had him sign the policies, he realized that the purchases had been made in the name of GPI, in a BUS ACCOUNT;
- Likewise, he states that by agreement between GPI and the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC (hereinafter, Interactive Brokers) they had created an access account with user No. U817716, for which Mr. Jorge Samanez (hereinafter, Mr. Samanez), an employee of GPI, gave him the access password. He adds that he has repeatedly requested Interactive Brokers to return his funds that GPI transferred to that intermediary for US$ 19,247.20 (Nineteen thousand two hundred forty-seven and 20/100 United States Dollars) and only US$ 958.10 (Nine hundred fifty-eight and 10/100 United States Dollars) have been returned to him by transfer to his Scotiabank account in 2013 and, furthermore, the shares that supposedly are in that account were also lost, consequently he states that GPI is directly responsible and should assume everything;
- The Client adds that GPI cannot have allowed, much less recommended, buying high-risk shares of a bank that had already failed such as Washington Mutual Inc. For all this, he states, GPI is directly responsible for his money and must return it, since they made him lose everything, and he also requests the execution of the Guarantee Fund for the amount of US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars);
- On the other hand, in response to Official Letter No. 5510-2017-SMV/10.3 of this General Intendancy, the Client states that he does not have a copy of instructions given by email; he indicates that he went to GPI's offices to inquire about the investment and the staff of the Operations area indicated that everything was fine, that they gave him the account statements and portfolio structures. He indicates that based on that high-confidence report, he directly gave them verbal order to buy more shares of the same value, in this case they were shares of Washington Mutual Inc. and the same staff of the Operations area had him sign the orders in the same office, who provided him with copies of said orders, which he attaches;
- Likewise, the Client states that he attaches additional documents that Mr. Samanez had him sign at GPI's office, they were several Interactive Brokers forms, to create a direct account at Interactive Brokers in the name of the Client, so that this principal directly conducts operations in that brokerage firm;
- Finally, the principal indicates that he has not received any type of payment from GPI, neither as a return of his investment, nor as a dividend, nor for the sale of shares, nor for any concept, absolutely nothing of retribution of his investments, which can be corroborated in the account statements he submits. He indicates that the only thing he received was from Interactive Brokers, who after several efforts sent him US$ 958.10 (Nine hundred fifty-eight and 10/100 United States Dollars) in 2013 to his Scotiabank account. He attaches to his complaint, among others;
- Simple copy of current account statements as of December 31, 2011, December 31, 2013 and August 10, 2016;
- Simple copy of bank receipts for cash deposits of the sums of US$ 320.00, (Three hundred twenty and 00/100 United States Dollars) of November 8, 2010; US$ 1,520.00, (One thousand five hundred twenty and 00/100 United States Dollars) of November 8, 2010; US$ 4,127.80 (Four thousand one hundred twenty-seven and 00/100 United States Dollars) of November 12, 2010 to current account No. 3361639 of Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. in the name of GPI;
- Simple copy of Document with Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. logo "Consulta Saldo Disponible CC/AH Movimientos el Histórico" of account No. 2554381 in the name of the Client in currency 1[2], in which it appears with date February 9, 2010 "Transfer" "Agencia Alfonso Ugarte" for the charge of 35,000;
- Simple copies of: policy No. 0071 for the purchase of 8,530 WAMKQ.PK securities of February 12, 2010; policy No. 00079 for the purchase of 63,400 WAMUQ.PK of February 25, 2010; policy No. 01008 for the purchase of 35,000 WAMUQ.PK securities of November 8, 2010; policy No. 00001053 for the purchase of 11,700 WAMKQ.PK securities of November 11, 2010; policy No. 0068 for the purchase of 77,000 WAMUQ.PK securities of February 11, 2010; policy No. 0078 for the sale of 77,000 WAMUQ.PK securities of February 24, 2010;
- Simple copy of transaction orders of February 11, 12, 24 and 25, 2010 signed by the Client, regarding purchase and sale of 77,000 WAMUQ.PK shares, purchase of 8,530 WAMKQ.PK shares and purchase of 63,400 WAMUQ.PK shares;
- Simple copy of the portfolio structure with the GPI logo as of January 5, 2012;
- Simple copies of account statements of account U817716 obtained from the Interactive Brokers website on January 4, 2010 and May 24, 2011;
- Copy of documents obtained from the Interactive Brokers website of October 20, 2009 regarding the registration of account U817716, delivery of user and password and transfer order of 30,000 WAMUQ.PK shares from the Client's account at CAVALI S.A. ICLV (hereinafter, CAVALI) to account U817716 at Interactive Brokers; and,
- Emails from the Client addressed to Mr. Samanez and to Interactive Brokers;
- Regarding the deposits, which the Client states in his complaint to have made in a current account that GPI maintained at Scotiabank Perú S.A.A., for the total amount of US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars), we must note that the aforementioned client has accredited with the copy of the respective bank receipts the following deposits for the sum of US$ 5,967.80 (Five thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars):
| Date | Deposit Amount US$ | Evidentiary documents (copies) |
|---|
| 08.11.2010 | 1,520.00 | Bank receipt from Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. of 08.11.2010, for the cash deposit made in Current Account No. 3361639 in the name of GPI, which is the intermediation account that this former stock brokerage firm maintained at said bank (hereinafter, Intermediation Account) |
| 08.11.2010 | 320.00 | Bank receipt from Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. of 08.11.2010 for the cash deposit made to the Intermediation Account |
| 12.11.2010 | 4,127.80 | Bank receipt from Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. of 12.11.2010 for the cash deposit made to the Intermediation Account |
| Total | 5,967.80 | |
| | |
- On the other hand, for the transfer of US$ 35,000.00 (Thirty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), which the Client states to have made to GPI, he has attached a copy of the "Reporte Consulta Saldo Disponible CC/AH Movimientos del Histórico" of current account No. 2554381, in the name of ALVAREZ BENAVIDES, BENJAMIN, where it is visualized, with date February 9, 2010, in the Concept column, a TRANSFER, made at the Agencia Alfonso Ugarte Branch, and a Charge of 35,000.00 which would be United States Dollars. Likewise, in the simple copy of the current account statement in United States Dollars of the Client with the GPI logo as of August 10, 2016, which the principal attaches to his complaint, the deposit of this amount is recorded on February 9, 2010;
- In this sense, the Client, by submitting the simple copies of the documents included in the preceding table, has accredited that he deposited to the Intermediation Account the sum of US$ 5,967.80 (Five thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars) as of November 8, 2010. Likewise, the Client attaches documents indicating that he would have deposited US$ 35,000.00 additional to GPI on February 9, 2010 for investments in the securities market, so the total amount that he would have delivered to GPI to be used for investments in the securities market amounts to US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars);
- On the other hand, the Client has stated that he has not received any type of payment, neither in cash nor by check from GPI, nor as a return of his investment, nor as a dividend, nor for the sale of shares, nor for any concept, absolutely nothing of retribution of his investments from GPI, and that it can be corroborated in the account statements he attaches to his complaint;
Regarding the destination of the resources
- Before evaluating the investments on behalf of the Client, it is worth mentioning that in the inspection carried out at GPI's warehouse on February 17 and 20, 2017 (hereinafter, Inspection) a client registration form was collected, signed by the Client and by Mr. Maximiliano García, representative of GPI, on January 12, 2010, and in which he is identified with RUT code of the CAVALI Accounting Registry No. 177917 and with client code CLIO1480. Likewise, on the same date, he also signed the Purchase-Sale Contract of Securities Abroad – PN;
- It should be noted that in the client registration form, it is observed that "growth" was selected as investment objective and in the annex of said form it is appreciated within the heading "Services requested by the Client", the following: (i) Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL, (ii) Repo operations, (iii) Over-the-counter operations and (iv) foreign exchange operations;
- As stated, the Client in his complaint states having deposited to GPI the total amount of US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars) since February 9, 2010.
- In this commercial relationship that the Client maintained with GPI, it is observed in the documents presented by the principal that, furthermore, on October 20, 2009 the principal was accepted by Interactive Brokers to have an account in his name under GPI's administration, which has been confirmed by Interactive Brokers by email of February 14, 2017 addressed to this Superintendency in which it states that account No. U817716 in the name of the Client is open since October 20, 2009[3] under base account No. I785166 in the name of GPI. Likewise, in said email it is indicated that on November 13, 2009 funds or securities were deposited in said account[4] for custody by Interactive Brokers;
- Regarding this deposit of funds or securities, it should be noted that the Client attaches in his complaint a document in Interactive Brokers format by which this principal on October 20, 2009 requests this foreign intermediary that 30,000 common shares issued by Washington Mutual Inc. (hereinafter, WAMUQ.PK shares)[5] be transferred from his RUT account 177917 at CAVALI to his account U817716 at Interactive Brokers through The Depositary Trust Company (DTC). According to CAVALI records, it is accredited that 30,000 WAMUQ shares that were held in custody in the matrix account of Cartisa Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. in the name of the Client were sent on November 13, 2009 abroad through DTC;
- Then, regarding the movements of this account No. U817716, there is the information sent by the complainant referring to account statements obtained from the Interactive Brokers website on January 4, 2010 and May 24, 2011 in which it appears that the Client maintained 77,268 WAMUQ.PK shares, as well as cash in custody of Interactive Brokers. Likewise, according to the account statements of base account No. I785166 in which GPI administered account No. U817716 of the Client and other GPI principals, for the period 2010 to 2016 sent by Interactive Brokers to this Superintendency, it is recorded that on August 20, 2012 these 72,268 WAMUQ.PK shares were withdrawn from account U817716 due to the delisting of the security, and that on July 25, 2013 the Client withdrew[6] from this account the amount of US$ 950.28 (Nine hundred fifty and 28/100 United States Dollars); this withdrawal has also been indicated by the Client in his complaint[7];
- However, in his complaint the Client states that part of the amount of US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars) that he delivered to GPI would have been transferred to his account U817716 at Interactive Brokers under GPI's administration, it should be noted that, according to the policy information that GPI sent daily to this Superintendency and the information of the copies of the policies issued by GPI sent by the Client in his complaint, reconciled with the information of the account statements of two global accounts (hereinafter Accounts 1 and 2) that GPI maintained at Interactive Brokers, it is accredited that GPI used almost the entirety of the amount US$ 40,967.80 (Forty thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars) for the purchase of WAMUQ.PK shares, which were sold and repurchased, and of other securities issued by Washington Mutual Inc. with ISIN code US9393228302 (hereinafter, WAMKQ.PK shares), operations that were executed in the aforementioned global accounts in the name of GPI and on behalf of the Client, as detailed in Tables No. 1 and 2;
TABLE No. 1
OPERATIONS ON BEHALF OF THE CLIENT MADE IN THE GLOBAL ACCOUNT THAT GPI MAINTAINED AT INTERACTIVE BROKERS
| Oper. Date | Settle. Date | Oper. Type | Security | Price | Quantity | Charge / Deposit (US$) | Balance (US$) |
|---|
| 9/2/10 | 9/2/10 | DEPOSIT | | | | 35,000.00 | 35,000.00 |
| 11/2/10 | 11/2/10 | PURCHASE | WAMUQ.PK | 0.19000 | 77,000 | -15,117.26 | 19,882.74 |
| 12/2/10 | 12/2/10 | PURCHASE | WAMKQ.PK | 2.31000 | 8,530 | -19,886.23 | -3.49 |
| 24/2/10 | 24/2/10 | SALE | WAMUQ.PK | 0.25300 | 77,000 | 19,247.20 | 19,243.71 |
| 25/2/10 | 2/3/10 | PURCHASE | WAMUQ.PK | 0.29980 | 63,400 | -19,235.38 | 8.33 |
| Total Deposits | | | | | | 35,000.00 | |
TABLE No. 2
OPERATIONS ON BEHALF OF THE CLIENT MADE IN THE GLOBAL ACCOUNT THAT GPI MAINTAINED AT INTERACTIVE BROKERS
| Oper. Date | Settlement Date | Oper. Type | Value | Price | Quantity | Debit / Credit (US$) | Balance (US$) |
|---|
| 7/11/10 | 7/11/10 | | | | | | 8.33 |
| 8/11/10 | 8/11/10 | CREDIT | | | | 1,840.00 | 1,848.33 |
| 8/11/10 | 11/11/10 | PURCHASE | WAMUQ.PK | 0.04780000 | 35,000 | -1,706.93 | 141.40 |
| 12/11/10 | 12/11/10 | CREDIT | | | | 4,127.80 | 4,269.20 |
| 11/11/10 | 16/11/10 | PURCHASE | WAMKQ.PK | 0.36000000 | 11,700 | -4,267.08 | 2.12 |
| Total Credits | | | | | | 5,967.80 | |
- As shown in Table No. 1, the US$ 35,000.00 (Thirty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) that the client claims to have paid to GPI on February 9, 2010, was used to purchase 77,000 WAMUQ.PK shares and 8,530 WAMKQ.PK shares; then the 77,000 WAMUQ.PK shares were sold on February 24, 2010, and with the proceeds of these sales, on February 25, 2010, 63,400 WAMUQ.PK shares were purchased, leaving a balance of US$ 8.33 (Eight and 33/100 United States Dollars) since March 2, 2010;
- Then, as shown in Table No. 2, with the balance of US$ 8.33 (Eight and 33/100 United States Dollars) plus the Client's credits of US$ 5,967.80 (Five thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars), GPI made on behalf of this client the purchase of 35,000 WAMUQ.PK shares on November 8, 2010, and the purchase of 11,700 WAMKQ.PK shares on November 11, 2010, leaving a balance of US$ 2.12 (Two and 12/100 United States Dollars) since November 16, 2010;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the WAMUQ.PK and WAMKQ.PK shares purchased by GPI on behalf of the Client in the global account were transferred to the second global account, and these shares, together with the WAMUQ.PK and WAMKQ.PK shares purchased in the second global account, were withdrawn from this global account in August 2012 due to the delisting of both shares. As for the fund balance of US$ 2.12 (Two and 12/100 United States Dollars), GPI has reported this balance in favor of the Client in the Brokerage Account, according to the Transfer Deed signed on February 1, 2017, between GPI and Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.[8] (hereinafter, Kallpa SAB);
- Regarding the operations detailed in Tables No. 1 and 2, GPI has not complied with sending the necessary information required in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 5509-2017-SMV/10.3, including the record of orders that would have been given by the Client, the policies of the operations carried out on his behalf, the global account control records identifying the operations that would have been carried out on his behalf in the foreign market through a global account, and balances of funds, securities and financial instruments of the Client in these accounts, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations, as well as the Client's account statements issued by GPI;
- Although GPI has not sent the aforementioned information to date, the Client has stated in his complaint that he ordered GPI to purchase shares of Washington Mutual Inc. at the offices of this former brokerage firm and also attaches a copy of the written orders that, he indicates, he was made to sign at said offices, which are those that instruct the execution of the purchase and sale operations of 77,000 WAMUQ.PK shares of February 11 and 24, 2010, as well as the purchase of 8,530 WAMKQ.PK shares of February 12, 2010, and the purchase of 63,400 WAMUQ.PK shares of February 25, 2010, detailed in Table No. 1. Likewise, the Client has sent the policies issued by GPI regarding these operations, as well as the Client's account statement up to August 10, 2016, where these operations are recorded, and the account statements of the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations have been sent to this Superintendency by the foreign intermediary itself;
- However, neither party has sent the record of the orders given by the Client through the means agreed in the client registration form of January 12, 2010, that is, "telephone with written confirmation", or other documentation proving that this client also authorized the purchase operations of 35,000 WAMUQ.PK shares of November 8, 2010, and the purchase of 11,700 WAMKQ.PK shares of November 11, 2010, detailed in Table No. 2, with respect to which this client has sent a copy of the policies of these operations, as well as the Client's account statement up to August 10, 2016, where these operations are recorded, and the account statements of the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations have been sent to this Superintendency by the foreign intermediary itself;
- Consequently, as has been evidenced, GPI was required to provide the minimum necessary documentation proving that it complied with the instructions given by the Client, and that proves the investments made on behalf of said client with his funds;
- However, to date, GPI has not proven that the purchase operations of WAMUQ.PK and WAMKQ.PK shares of November 8 and 11, 2010, respectively, have been authorized by the Client, so it is possible to conclude that GPI would have used the funds that the Client held in custody as of November 7, 2010, plus the funds paid by this client on November 8 and 12, 2010, minus the funds of US$ 2.12 (Two and 12/100 United States Dollars) that it has reported in favor of the client, that is, US$ 5,974.01 (Five thousand nine hundred seventy-four and 01/100 United States Dollars), for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- In relation to the above, GPI was charged with not having complied with the provisions of Article 48 of the Regulation, since they received the funds delivered by the Client for custody and investment instructions given by said client, and they have not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI was charged with having infringed the provisions of Article 195, paragraph a) of the LMV, by using the Client's funds for operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI, as of the date of this resolution, has not complied with presenting its defenses to the charge under analysis in this section, even though it was duly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- Regarding the charge imputed, it should be noted that neither party has indicated the existence of a portfolio management contract signed between the Client and GPI, and in the Inspection, such contract was not obtained;
- As for the investments made on behalf of the Client, as stated in the Charge Letter, it is proven that the Client ordered the purchase and sale of 77,000 WAMUQ.PK shares (February 11 and 24, 2010) and the purchase of 8,350 WAMKQ.PK shares (February 12, 2010) and 63,400 WAMUQ.PK shares (February 25, 2010), operations that were executed in global account 1 in the name of GPI at Interactive Brokers, leaving a cash balance of US$ 8.33 (Eight and 33/100 United States Dollars) plus the purchased shares. To prove these operations, the policy data that GPI sent daily to SMV through MVnet regarding operations carried out in the foreign market on behalf of its clients was used, and the date, value, quantity and price of the operations have been verified with the operations recorded in the name of GPI in global account 1;
- With the cash balance of US$ 8.33 (Eight and 33/100 United States Dollars) plus the amount of US$ 5,967.80 (Five thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars), GPI made on behalf of this client the purchase of 35,000 WAMUQ.PK shares on November 8, 2010, and the purchase of 11,700 WAMKQ.PK shares on November 11, 2010, leaving a balance of US$ 2.12 (Two and 12/100 United States Dollars) since November 16, 2010. To prove these operations, the policy data that GPI sent daily to SMV through MVnet regarding operations carried out in the foreign market on behalf of its clients was used, and the date, value, quantity and price of the operations have been verified with the operations recorded in the name of GPI in global account 2;
- Therefore, GPI must have the respective authorization from the Client for the execution of the operations of November 8 and 11, 2010, as well as the records of the orders instructed by this client or other documentation proving the respective authorization, documentation that has not been presented by GPI in the preliminary inquiries and in this administrative sanctioning procedure, and, likewise, in the Inspection, such documentation was not obtained;
- Consequently, since to date, GPI has not proven that the purchase operations of WAMUQ.PK and WAMKQ.PK shares of November 8 and 11, 2010, respectively, have been authorized by the Client, it is concluded that GPI used the funds in the amount of US$ 8.33 (Eight and 33/100 United States Dollars) that the Client held in custody as of November 7, 2010, plus the funds paid by this client on November 8 and 12, 2010, for US$ 5,967.80 (Five thousand nine hundred sixty-seven and 80/100 United States Dollars), minus the funds of US$ 2.12 (Two and 12/100 United States Dollars) that it has reported in favor of the client, that is, US$ 5,974.01 (Five thousand nine hundred seventy-four and 01/100 United States Dollars), as detailed in Table No. 3, for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thereby failing to comply with paragraph a) of Article 195 of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
TABLE No. 3
MOVEMENT OF FUNDS (IN US$)
| | |
|---|
| 07/11/2010 | Balance in account | 8.33 |
| 08-12/11/2010 | Credits | 5,967.80 |
| Total | 5,976.13 |
| Less | | |
| 16/11/2010 | Balance in account | -2.12 |
| | |
| Balance used without Client authorization | 5,974.01 |
- On the other hand, the fund balance of US$ 2.12 (Two and 12/100 United States Dollars) that remained since November 16, 2010, was reported by GPI as a balance in favor of the Client held in the Brokerage Account, according to the Transfer Deed signed on February 1, 2017, between GPI and Kallpa SAB;
- Because the funds held in the brokerage accounts that GPI maintained at Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. were less than the credit balances in favor of the clients, Kallpa SAB made a proration of the funds among all former clients of GPI who became clients of Kallpa SAB, assigning the Client the amount of US$ 0.18 (18/100 United States Dollars), which remained in custody of Kallpa SAB;
- It should be noted that since the resources of GPI transferred to Kallpa SAB were insufficient to fully cover the credit balances of the former clients of GPI, through Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 029-2017-SMV/10, issued by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision on May 19, 2017 (hereinafter, the Resolution), which became final, the execution of the Guarantee Fund has been ordered in favor of the affected clients indicated in the annex of the Resolution, for the respective amounts of their affectation indicated in the mentioned annex;
- Regarding the Client, the Resolution orders the execution of the Guarantee Fund in favor of this client for the amount of US$ 1.94 (One and 94/100 United States Dollars).
- Notwithstanding GPI's non-compliance, mention should be made of the provisions of Article 342 of the LMV, in force at the date of the events[9], which established that the power of CONASEV[10] to determine the existence of infractions prescribes after three years and that later said norm was modified extending the prescription period to four years;
- Likewise, Article 233, numeral 233.3 of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law and its amendments (hereinafter, LPAG) states that the authority declares prescription ex officio and concludes the procedure when it notices that the term to determine the existence of infractions has been met;
- In that sense, it has been verified that from November 8 and 11, 2010, dates on which the purchases of WAMUQ.PK and WAMKQ.PK shares were made, operations not authorized by the Client, until August 31, 2017, date on which he filed his complaint, in the first case 06 years, 09 months and 23 days elapsed and in the second case 06 years, 09 months, 20 days elapsed, thus exceeding the term[11] of three years established by Article 342 of the LMV, for this Superintendency to determine the existence of infractions to the securities market regulations. It should be noted that the denounced facts were prescribed at the date of the filing of the complaint (August 31, 2017);
- Therefore, having verified the passage of the prescription period, and in application of Article 233, numeral 233.3 of the LPAG, the complaint filed by the Client in this section is archived, insofar as the power of the SMV to determine the existence of infractions by GPI has prescribed;
- Without prejudice to the aforementioned, and regardless of the fact that the infraction regarding the use of funds for different purposes has prescribed, it should be noted that the 63,400 WAMUQ.PK shares and 8,530 WAMKQ.PK shares, purchased by GPI on behalf of the Client with his authorization in global account 1, were transferred to global account 2, and these shares, together with the 35,000 WAMUQ.PK shares and 11,700 WAMKQ.PK shares, purchased by GPI in global account 2 without the Client's authorization, that is, a total of 98,400 WAMUQ.PK shares and 20,230 WAMKQ.PK shares, were withdrawn from this last global account on August 20, 2012, due to the delisting of these shares, without any consideration, leaving the balances of these shares at zero. The detail is shown in Table No. 4;
TABLE No. 4
MOVEMENT OF SECURITIES IN THE GLOBAL ACCOUNTS
| Date | Oper. | Global Account 1 | | Global Account 2 | |
|---|
| WAMUQ | WAMKQ | WAMUQ | WAMKQ | | |
| 12/2/10 | Purchase | | 8,530 | | |
| 25/2/10 | Purchase | 63,400 | | | |
| 25/2/10 | Transfer | | -8,530 | | 8,530 |
| 25/2/10 | Transfer | -63,400 | | 63,400 | |
| 8/11/10 | Purchase | | | 35,000 | |
| 11/11/10 | Purchase | | | | 11,700 |
| | 0 | 0 | 98,400 | 20,230 |
| 20/8/12 | Withdrawal | | | -98,400 | -20,230 |
| 20/8/12 | Balance | | | 0 | 0 |
- Finally, regarding the Client's request for the return of the amount invested in GPI under the scope of the Guarantee Fund Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 013-2011-SMV/01 and its amendments, it should be mentioned that according to the provisions of Article 29 of the Guarantee Fund Regulation, the Guarantee Fund will back the complaints filed against brokerage firms with authorization of operation revoked by final resolution of the SMV within six (6) months after said revocation, that is, for the present case, until July 25, 2017; therefore, in this case under analysis, the application of the Guarantee Fund does not apply, because the Client filed the complaint on August 31, 2017, that is, extemporaneously, and it should also be taken into account that the infraction for the use of funds for different purposes was prescribed at the date of the filing of the complaint;
3.2 Use of global accounts without observing the required conditions
On the Regulations
- As established in Article 37, numeral 37.4.2 of the Regulation, regarding the intervention of a brokerage firm in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments in the foreign market, it is a requirement:
"Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is in its own name, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements:
(…)
37.4.2. Have global account control records as established in this Regulation.
(…)"[12]
- On the other hand, Article 90 of the Regulation establishes regarding global accounts:
"Article 90.- Content.- The Agent, for each Global Account in its name, referred to in numeral 37.4.2 of Article 37 of this Regulation, must implement control records that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts. Likewise, the aforementioned records must allow the immediate generation of the following information:
90.1. Movements of securities and financial instruments in the global account.
90.2. Movements of funds related to the global account.
90.3. Balances of financial instruments and funds consolidated and at the level of the Agent's clients.
90.4. Consolidated record of financial instruments and funds related to global accounts.
These records must contain information updated on the day and be supported by the confirmations and account statements received from the foreign intermediary that executes the operations corresponding to each account, and, if applicable, in the information provided by the entity in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, according to the operability of each account. Likewise, they must be consistent with the policies that the Agent must issue for this type of operations."[13]
On the Charges formulated
- According to the documentation in the file, it is appreciated that it is proven that GPI has carried out on behalf of the Client operations in the foreign market from February to November 2010, using a global account that this former brokerage firm maintained at Interactive Brokers, the same ones that are detailed in Tables No. 1 and 2;
- In this regard, according to the cited regulations, when the brokerage firm operates through a global account[14], it is the obligation of the firm to have global account control records where the movements of funds and financial instruments are recorded and that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts;
- In that sense, GPI has not proven, to date, to have the global account control records[15] until December 31, 2016, required by the regulations, even though this was requested from the former brokerage firm through Official Letter No. 5509-2017-SMV/10.3;
- Consequently, GPI was charged with not having observed the provisions of Article 37, paragraph 37.4, numeral 37.4.2 of the regulation, which expressly requires that for these operations, the brokerage agent must have the global account control records, which in accordance with Article 90 of the cited regulation, must indicate the movements of securities and financial instruments, of funds, balances of financial instruments and funds, among others;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI, as of the date of this resolution, has not complied with presenting its defenses to the charge under analysis in this section, even though it was duly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- Notwithstanding the above, mention should be made of the provisions of Article 342 of the LMV, which establishes the prescription period for the power of CONASEV[16] to determine the existence of infractions;
- Likewise, Article 250, numeral 250.3 of the TUO LPAG states that the authority declares prescription ex officio and concludes the procedure when it notices that the term to determine the existence of infractions has been met;
- In that sense, it has been verified that until August 20, 2012, the date on which the 98,400 WAMUQ.PK shares and 20,230 WAMKQ.PK shares, owned by the Client, which were held in global account No. U826019 in the name of GPI at Interactive Brokers, were withdrawn due to the delisting of these shares, leaving the balance at zero, this former intermediary had the obligation to have the respective global account control record. Regarding the balance of funds in favor of the Client, it has been verified that GPI held it in the Brokerage Account;
- From August 20, 2012, to August 31, 2017, the date on which he filed his complaint, 05 years and 11 days elapsed, thus exceeding the term[17] of three years established by Article 342 of the LMV, for this Superintendency to determine the existence of infractions to the securities market regulations;
- Therefore, having verified the passage of the prescription period, and in application of Article 250, numeral 250.3 of the TUO LPAG, this administrative sanctioning procedure is archived in this section, insofar as the power of the SMV to determine the existence of infractions by GPI has prescribed;
- Failure to collect orders from its clients
On the Regulations
- Article 175 of the LMV, in force until June 25, 2011, provides regarding orders the following:
"Article 175. Written Orders.- Brokerage agents are obliged to collect written orders from their clients, except for other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that CONASEV establishes through general provisions. Likewise, they must deliver a policy that proves the operations carried out on their behalf.
- It should be noted that said Article 175 was modified by Law No. 29720, which entered into force as of June 26, 2011, which states:
"Article 175. Orders.- Orders are instructions given to brokerage agents, through which their clients express their decisions regarding the negotiation of securities or financial instruments and other services they may provide.
Through orders, principals grant a mandate to their brokerage agent to carry out the transactions set forth in articles 194 and 207, as well as for the receipt of benefits, subscription of shares or any other activity relating to securities or financial instruments, with prior authorization from Conasev in accordance with items t) and i) of said articles, respectively.
Orders empower brokerage agents to exercise the mandate they contain. In the case of the subscription of shares, receipt of benefits or other similar matters, brokerage agents are authorized by their principal's mandate to act on the principal's behalf without any additional requirement or condition being necessary, except those determined by the principal himself.
In accordance with the preceding paragraphs, brokerage agents are obligated to do the following:
- Obtain orders from their principals in written or telephone form, provided that the latter are recorded, without prejudice to other modalities susceptible of subsequent verification that Conasev may establish through general provisions.
- Implement systems that allow the recording of orders when they are made by telephone so that they are registered from the moment they are received. For this purpose, they must have a system for recording orders received by telephone, as well as a system for registering and filing them in accordance with the general rules issued by Conasev.
Such recordings, as well as the aforementioned register, must be kept for five years and made available to Conasev in the manner it establishes by general rule.
From the moment the principal gives the order by telephone, it is understood that the principal has been previously informed of the conditions for registering orders given through this medium, as well as of the acceptance of the corresponding recording.
- Use only systems, as well as means of receiving and registering orders, authorized by Conasev.
Likewise, brokerage agents must make available to their principals the policy that evidences the transactions carried out on their behalf."
- For its part, article 30, numeral 30.2 of the Regulation, in force until January 31, 2013, states:
"Article 30.- Receipt, Registration and Transmission of Orders.- For the purposes of orders given for the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, the following must be observed:
30.2 The Agent must keep appropriate control of each of the orders it receives and, where applicable, of their modifications and corrections. This control includes, among others, the adequate and timely registration of orders in the Order Registration and Allocation System."
- It should be noted that said numeral 30.2 has been amended by SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01, which is in force as of February 1, 2013, and establishes the following:
"Article 30.- Receipt, Registration and Transmission of Orders.- For the purposes of orders given for the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, the following must be observed:
(...)
30.2. Orders on behalf of a client may be instructed to the Agent through the following means: (i) written, (ii) fax with subsequent confirmation, (iii) telephone, (iv) through applications implemented from the Agent's web page, (v) private electronic communication network with registered users, recognized by the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision; (vi) electronic mail with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation; (vii) ADM in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation of Direct Access to the Market, approved by SMV Resolution No. 024-2012-SMV/01 or the rule that replaces it; (viii) intermediated routing in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation of the Integrated Market through Intermediated Routing, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 107-2010-EF/94.01.1, or, (ix) other means of communication authorized by the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision, in accordance with what is agreed in its respective client registration form.
In all the foregoing cases, the Agent is responsible for verifying the authenticity of the orders it receives through the additional means it considers."[18]
- In turn, article 37, numeral 37.5 of the Regulation states:
"Article 37.- Requirements.- In order for the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(...)
37.5. Each transaction intermediated by the Agent must have the corresponding client order."[19]
Regarding the Charges Formulated
- As indicated in this resolution, it is established that GPI carried out transactions in the foreign market on behalf of the Client from February to November 2010, the detail of which is shown in Tables No. 1 and 2. However, according to documentation submitted by the Client in its complaint and in accordance with what is set forth in this resolution, it is only established that the principal instructed the orders for the transactions detailed in Table No. 1 of this resolution;
- For its part, with respect to the transactions detailed in Table No. 2, GPI has not established to date that it has the order records required by the regulations, which should have been obtained by said former stock brokerage firm, in accordance with the provisions of the regulations; however, although this was requested from the former brokerage firm through Official Letter No. 5509-2017-SMV/10.3, it has not been established to date;
- It should be noted that with respect to the orders that GPI should have obtained from the Client, it is observed that in the client registration form of January 12, 2010, the Client selected as the order reception modality the option "telephone with written confirmation".
- Therefore, taking into account the foregoing, in accordance with the provisions of article 175 of the LMV and article 37, numeral 37.5 of the Regulation, GPI had the obligation to obtain the principal's orders for the transactions of November 8 and 11, 2010, detailed in Table No. 2. However, said orders would not have been obtained by GPI, taking into account that they have not been established by the former stock brokerage firm, for which reason it was charged that it would have thus breached the securities market regulations;
Regarding the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI, as of the date of this resolution, has not complied with submitting its defenses to the charge subject to analysis in this part, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, mention should be made of the provisions of article 342 of the LMV, in force at the time the facts occurred[20], which established that CONASEV's[21] power to determine the existence of infractions prescribes after three years;
- Likewise, article 250, numeral 250.3 of the TUO LPAG states that the authority declares prescription ex officio and considers the procedure concluded when it notices that the period to determine the existence of infractions has been met;
- In that sense, it has been verified that from November 8 and 11, 2010, the dates on which the purchases of 35,000 WAMUQ. PK shares and 11,700 WAMKQ.PK shares were made, respectively, transactions not authorized by the Client, that is, GPI did not previously obtain the respective orders from the principal, until August 31, 2017, the date on which it submitted its complaint, in the first case 06 years, 09 months and 23 days elapsed and in the second case 06 years, 09 months and 20 days, thus exceeding the period established by article 342 of the LMV, for this Superintendency to be able to determine the existence of infractions of the securities market regulations;
- Therefore, having verified the passage of the prescription period, and in application of article 250, numeral 250.3 of the TUO LPAG, this administrative sanctioning procedure is archived in this part, insofar as the SMV's power to determine the existence of infractions by GPI has prescribed;
- Finally, it should be indicated that the resolution of this administrative sanctioning procedure is based on the evaluation of the information contained in the respective file whose source is the documentation provided by the Client and that gathered in the Inspection; insofar as GPI has not made any statement in this regard, neither in the preliminary inquiry stage nor in the defense submission stage; it being necessary to consider in said context the role played by the SMV as the entity that supervises the securities market and whose objective is that the purpose established in its Organic Law and in the Securities Market Law be fulfilled, which is to promote the orderly development and the transparency and integrity of the securities market; as well as the adequate protection of the investor, among others;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that the power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market to determine the existence of an infraction has prescribed with respect to the obligation of Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. former Stock Brokerage Firm to apply Mr. Benjamín Alvarez Benavides's funds to the purposes indicated by him; to obtain the respective orders from Mr. Benjamín Alvarez Benavides and to use global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations for the transactions subject to analysis in this resolution.
Article 2.- Order the archiving of the sanctioning procedure initiated against GPI with respect to the infractions mentioned in article 1 of this resolution, and consequently, consider said administrative procedure concluded in that part.
Article 3.- Transcribe this resolution to Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. former Stock Brokerage Firm, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision
- It should be noted that said obligation is currently maintained in article 83 of the Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, current Regulation). ↑
- The document does not indicate whether it is in Soles or Dollars, although some movements are observed with the indication "dollar" so it would be in Dollars. ↑
- The term "application" is indicated. ↑
- The term "funded" is indicated. ↑
- With ISIN code US9393221034. ↑
- The description in the account statement is "disbursement initiated bv Benjamin Alvarez". ↑
- The amount indicated is US$ 950.10 (Nine hundred fifty and 00/100 United States Dollars) and the difference would be due to transfer commissions. ↑
- Stock brokerage firm designated by this Superintendency to custody the credit balances, securities and financial instruments of principals that GPI held in custody, in accordance with Official Letter No. 560-2017-SMV/10.2 of January 26, 2017. ↑
- It should be noted that article 342 of the LMV was amended by Law No. 29782, which was in force as of July 29, 2011. ↑
- Today SMV. ↑
- Period that was in force until 07/28/2011. ↑
- It should be noted that the obligation to have control mechanisms for global accounts is maintained in item e) of article 63 of the current Regulation. ↑
- It should be noted that the obligation is maintained in article 93 of the current Regulation. ↑
- That is, an account opened in the name of the intermediary at a foreign broker, in order to carry out transactions abroad and with funds of its clients. ↑
- Said global account control register would identify the transactions carried out with securities and financial instruments in the foreign market on behalf of the Client, and would include the positions in options, as well as the corresponding fund balances of the same. ↑
- Today SMV. ↑
- Period that was in force until 07/28/2011. ↑
- The cited provisions are currently regulated in article 49 of the current Regulation. ↑
- It should be noted that the requirements that the agent must comply with for the intermediation of financial instruments traded abroad are currently regulated in article 63 of the current Regulation. ↑
- It should be noted that article 342 of the LMV was amended by Law No. 29782, which was in force as of July 29, 2011. ↑
- Today SMV. ↑