SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 045-2021-SMV/10
Summary: Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C. is sanctioned with a fine of 8 UIT, equivalent to S/ 32,400.00 (Thirty-two thousand four hundred and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred three (03) serious infractions: one (01) classified in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10; and two (02) classified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, insofar as it did not keep or maintain updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files; for not having substantiated the information and documentation supporting the customer due diligence procedures; and for not having substantiated the required update for customers to whom the intensified customer due diligence procedure applies; respectively.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2021002691 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2021002691, and Report No. 834-2021-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as the defenses submitted by Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C.; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Securities Market Superintendency (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. FACTS
- Through Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Entity Supervision (hereinafter, IGSE) communicated to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (hereinafter, IGCP) the results of the evaluation of indications of possible infractions by Sura SAF.
- Through Official Letter No. 419-2021-SMV/10.3, notified on February 1, 2021 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), the IGCP initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against Sura SAF for having found indications of infraction of the Mutual Funds Investment in Securities and their Management Companies Regulation approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 068-2010-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments (hereinafter, Regulation), the Accounting Standards for Mutual Funds Investment in Securities approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 628-1997-EF/94.1 (hereinafter, Accounting Standards) and the Standards for the Prevention of Money Laundering and/or Terrorist Financing, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments (hereinafter, PLAFT Standards), in force at the time of the events;
- By letter received on February 2, 2021, Sura SAF requested Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2; therefore, through Official Letter No. 444-2021-SMV/10.3 of February 2, 2021, it was informed of the form of access to said report;
- By letter received on February 15, 2021, Sura SAF requested the extension of the deadline for the submission of its defenses, which was granted by Official Letter No. 645-2021-SMV/10.3, notified on February 15, 2021;
- The charges formulated against Sura SAF, the latter's defenses and their evaluation have been analyzed in Report No. 834-2021-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, IGCP Report), which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 248, subparagraph 2, of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO LPAG), through Official Letter No. 3070-2021-SMV/10, the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made available to Sura SAF for its review;
II. ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED
- In this administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not Sura SAF incurred an infraction of the provisions of Articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation, the first paragraph of the Accounting Standards and the comment of account "10 Cash and Banks" of the Chart of Accounts for Mutual Funds Investment in Securities, in the preparation of financial statements, reconciliation of bank statement balances and accounting balances as of June 30, 2018;
- Whether or not Sura SAF incurred an infraction of the provisions of Article 7, numerals 7.2, 7.4 and 7.5, literal c) of the PLAFT Standards, for not substantiating the information and documentation supporting the Customer Due Diligence (DDCC) procedures and for not substantiating the required update for customers to whom the intensified DDCC procedure applies, with respect to a group of customers observed in the SMV inspection carried out on Sura SAF from August 10 to September 14, 2018;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on Sura SAF;
III. ANALYSIS
- First Charge: Bank Reconciliation
Of the Regulations
- Articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation establish:
"Article 021.- FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.-
The financial information of mutual funds shall be prepared, under the responsibility of the management company, in accordance with the norms established by CONASEV. Said information shall refer to the following:
a) Statement of Financial Position: Shows the assets, liabilities and net equity of the mutual fund;
b) Income Statement: Comprises the income, costs and expenses originated by the operations of the mutual fund;
c) Detail of the Investment Portfolio: Shows the composition of the mutual fund's investments at a given date, indicating the valuation of each component of the portfolio.
Article 022.- BOOKS AND RECORDS.-
It is the responsibility of the management company to keep and maintain up to date the accounting of the mutual funds it manages, as well as the following books and records:
a) In relation to each of the mutual funds it manages:
1) Journal, in which the operations carried out are detailed;
2) Ledger, in which each of the accounts that make up the Assets, Liabilities, Equity, Income and Expenses of each mutual fund are presented;
(…)"
- On the other hand, the first paragraph of the Accounting Standards for Mutual Funds Investment in Securities approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 628-1997-EF/94.1 (hereinafter, Accounting Standards), state the following:
"The accounting standards comprise the Chart of Accounts for Mutual Funds Investment in Securities and Financial Information, establishing accounts or procedures related to their activities, being of mandatory observance by the Management Companies (…)."
- In this regard, in the comments of account "10 Cash and Banks" of the Chart of Accounts for Mutual Funds Investment in Securities, it is established:
"Checking accounts centralize all deposits from subscriptions, sales or interbank transfers; as well as expenditures for the purchase of investments and amortization of obligations by the Fund.
The balances of bank accounts must be subject to daily reconciliation with the account statements sent by the banks. Any differences must be investigated and regularized.
(…)".
Of the events that occurred
- According to the information obtained in the inspection carried out on Sura SAF from August 10 to September 14, 2018, the SMV inspection team reviewed the bank reconciliations prepared by Sura SAF and the account statements of the three (03) checking accounts (hereinafter, the Accounts) that the mutual fund Sura Corto Plazo Soles FMIV (hereinafter, Short Term Fund) maintains at Banco Scotiabank[1] as of June 30, 2018. Likewise, the balances of the Trial Balance were reviewed and validated and confirmation letters were sent to the banking entity, as of June 30, 2018;
- In this regard, it has been determined that the balances of the statements of the Accounts issued by Banco Scotiabank present differences with the bank balances of the bank reconciliation prepared by Sura SAF. Likewise, differences have been found with the balances of the Trial Balance as of June 30, 2018. The details of the differences are shown in the following table:
TABLE No. 1
Bank Reconciliations: Short Term Fund
| | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Accounting Code | Account No. | Bank Balance (Company) (Z) | Bank Balance (account statement - EECC) (A) | Telebanking operations not included in EECC (B) | Credits in Banks not included in Books (C) | Debits in Books not included in Banks (D) | Credits in Books not included in Banks (E) | Balance in Books F =(A-B-C+D-E) US$ | Balance in Books F =(A-B-C+D-E) S/ | Trial Balance (G) |
| 104101 | 6629687 | S/118,476 | S/4,059,902 | -S/4,038,785 | -S/20,000 | S/0 | -S/117,359 | S/0 | -S/116,241 | S/1,117 |
| 104121 | 6629695 | S/89,453 | S/59,932 | S/0 | S/0 | S/4,038,785 | -S/69,932 | S/0 | S/4,028,785 | S/4,058,306 |
| 104221 | 3341951 | S/134 | S/1,437 | S/0 | S/0 | S/1,319 | S/0 | S/2,756 | S/9,022 | S/4,754 |
- As can be observed, there are operations carried out through the "Telebanking" system, as well as debits and credits in books, that are not included in the bank statements of the Accounts; credits in banks that have not been included in the accounting books, and debits in books that do not appear in the bank's account statements, and therefore differences are presented in the balances of the statements of the Accounts and the balances in books;
- The described situation evidences deficiencies in the controls applied in the processing of the bank reconciliations of the Short Term Fund and in the processing of the information incorporated in the accounting, and therefore, in the balances of the aforementioned accounts;
- In this sense, it is evidenced that Sura SAF in the preparation of the financial statements, reconciliation of the balances of the bank account statements and the accounting balances, would have breached the provisions of Articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation and the provisions of the comment of account "10 Cash and Banks" of the Chart of Accounts for Mutual Funds Investment in Securities;
Of the defenses submitted
- Regarding the imputed charge, Sura SAF states the following:
It is intended to sanction Sura SAF for an involuntary and isolated error when making the monthly reconciliation
- It indicates that to analyze the conduct of Sura SAF, it is necessary to specify that the bank reconciliation is made up of two (2) distinct but complementary processes: daily reconciliation and monthly reconciliation;
- Sura SAF explains that daily reconciliation is carried out by the areas in charge of each of the accounts and specifies that the collection accounts are in charge of the Operations Area, while the investment accounts are under the responsibility of the Custody Area;
- It adds that once the balances are reconciled, they are entered into the treasury system (investment system), where a control is carried out in the system that confirms the closing of these cash accounts on a daily basis. It indicates that it should be noted that there is a restriction in the treasury system that is activated when the cash accounts have not yet been reconciled:
- On the other hand, Sura SAF indicates, the monthly reconciliation is carried out by the Accounting Area, where the balances recorded in the treasury system at month-end are validated with the bank account statement. This control is carried out in a working paper (Excel);
- Sura SAF adds that, having said the above, in the present case an involuntary error occurred in the form of presentation of the information and not in the execution of the records. Said error occurred when the monthly reconciliation was carried out, insofar as an account statement corresponding to another period was erroneously considered, which resulted in adjustments being shown in the working paper that had no relation whatsoever to the balances of the month;
- It also points out that it should be noted that the bank reconciliation process is carried out manually, and therefore, it is not possible to rule out eventual human errors in its execution. It adds that said incident - which remains within the reasonable margin provided for this type of manual activity - corresponds to an isolated event that has no antecedents for Sura SAF and that has not occurred again;
- It emphasizes that this is so much the case that it is an unusual and totally isolated event that its external auditors have not recorded observations to the Financial Statements for the 2017-2020 period, as can be seen in the extracts it attaches (external auditors' opinions);
- Sura SAF concludes that it is demonstrated that the error incurred in the monthly reconciliation constitutes an involuntary and unusual event for Sura SAF, which generated the differences found during the inspection that were subsequently imputed as an infraction;
- For this reason, it adds, the instructing authority cannot (nor should) generalize conducts or establish conclusions on a totally isolated and unprecedented event;
Sura SAF has acted with due diligence by promptly correcting the error in the monthly reconciliation: there is evidence that daily operations are correctly recorded in the books
1. Sura SAF points out that its diligent conduct in the face of this involuntary incident should be evaluated, given that they quickly corrected the involuntary error described above;
2. It reiterates that there are control mechanisms that allow a reasonable degree of reliability of its operations. By virtue of said mechanisms and after validating the aforementioned bank reconciliations with the corresponding account statements, it is evidenced that the books correctly record the daily operations. Sura SAF presents the following tables:
1. Sura SAF maintains that after redoing the reconciliations with the correct account statement, it has been verified that the balances in books show the correct balances. In this sense, Sura SAF attaches the following tables for the Scotiabank - Recaudo Soles account:
1. Likewise, Sura SAF attaches the following tables for the Scotiabank - Inversión Soles account:
1. Finally, Sura SAF also attaches the following tables for the Scotiabank – Inversión Dólares account:
1. Sura SAF points out that the differences in each monthly reconciliation do not affect the system movements (books), since these are recorded by other areas, with daily control of these movements. Likewise, the daily reconciliations were not affected by the aforementioned involuntary error, given that the daily control allows safeguarding the operations of its clients;
2. They also reiterate that the imputation of the Letter of Charges is based on the presentation of the balances within the framework of an internal control and that they have no effect whatsoever on the operations of its clients. Likewise, each of the differences mentioned by the Letter of Charges has been remedied to date;
3. It adds that, being so, an isolated event such as the aforementioned involuntary error cannot constitute a parameter to measure the diligence of Sura SAF in keeping both the accounting of the mutual funds and the books and records up to date;
4. Sura SAF indicates that due diligence implies adopting reasonable precautions that are consistent with the probability of human error. It reiterates that, in the present case, Sura SAF has a double bank reconciliation process, which can guarantee the reliability of its accounting information. An isolated and unusual error does not rule out the due diligence of Sura SAF and the lack of antecedents confirms it;
The PAS must be archived as the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation has been configured
- It points out that, to date (and since before the start of the PAS), Sura SAF maintains the record of daily operations correctly and updated, without any inconsistency having occurred that affects its clients or generates a situation of regulatory non-compliance;
- Sura SAF indicates that voluntary remediation as an exemption from liability must be evaluated based on the provisions of Article 257 of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO LPAG) and Article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation in force at the date, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation);
- Sura SAF adds that voluntary remediation prior to the notification of charges on the possible commission of infractions constitutes an exemption from liability, with which it is not necessary, nor pertinent, to initiate a sanctioning procedure;
- Sura SAF indicates that according to Article 257 of the TUO LPAG, if prior to the notification of charges that initiates a sanctioning procedure, the administered entity voluntarily remedies the possible infraction conduct, the authority is obliged to archive said procedure as an exemption from liability has been configured in favor of the administered entity;
- It adds that, on the other hand, Article 27 of the New Sanctions Regulation has similar regulation and establishes that "voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subparagraph 3) of Article 253 of the LPAG and provided that no communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent" constitutes an exemption from liability;
- Sura SAF specifies that the applicable regulations essentially establish three (3) requirements: i) that the remediation be voluntary, ii) that it be carried out prior to the notification of the imputation of charges, and iii) that no communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent;
- Well, it points out that in the present case the involuntary error when making the monthly reconciliation was corrected promptly. With this, the requirements established by the cited regulations are met for an exemption from liability to be configured;
- Sura SAF highlights that said rule privileges the reparation of any damage produced over the punitive intention and the sanctioning activity of the authority[2];
- Consequently, in the hypothetical case that it is considered that Sura SAF breached the applicable regulations, it requests that the alleged infraction conduct be deemed remedied, insofar as it was corrected long before the start of the PAS. With such support, it adds, the present PAS must be archived in this regard;
No regulatory non-compliance has occurred: Sura SAF did maintain and maintains updated the books, records and files of its clients.
- Sura SAF points out that, as it has demonstrated above, once the validation of the bank reconciliation with the respective account statements corresponding to June 2018 was carried out, it was verified that the records in books correctly consider the records of daily operations;
- Sura SAF specifies that, to date, there are no balance differences that evidence the existence of any "deficiency in the controls applied in the processing of bank reconciliations", as suggested by the Letter of Charges. There is no such deficiency insofar as the control carried out by the different areas allowed the error to be corrected promptly;
- Likewise, Sura SAF refers that said error in the presentation of information when using an incorrect account statement does not imply that the books, records and files of its clients are outdated. This assumption implies an undue conclusion from an isolated event;
- Sura SAF indicates that it should be noted that, on the occasion of the involuntary error when presenting the information to the SMV, no claim was presented by its clients. This is because the operations of the participants have not been affected, insofar as the recognition of their subscriptions and redemptions are controlled in the daily reconciliations;
- It adds that this only confirms that Sura SAF is diligent and has mechanisms to quickly correct human errors that, involuntarily, may occur when bank reconciliations are carried out;
- It indicates that, in this sense, the conduct of Sura SAF does not precisely fit the imputed infraction of "not keeping or not maintaining updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files". That is, said infraction has not been configured in the present case;
- It mentions that as a consequence of the provisions in the previous numerals, the Principle of Typicality that governs the exercise of the sanctioning power of the Public Administration is not met. It indicates that, according to said principle, provided in numeral 4, Article 248 of the TUO LPAG, only conducts administratively sanctionable are infractions expressly provided in norms with the rank of law through their classification as such, without admitting extensive interpretation or analogy;
- Sura SAF adds that the essential content of this principle lies in the precise definition of the conducts susceptible to sanction, that is, in a detailed and complete description of the infraction conduct. The above provides the administered entity with the necessary legal certainty to decide what conducts it can carry out and what would be the specific consequences of their realization, thus making possible a reasoned exercise of its right to freedom. On this matter, GARCÍA DE ENTERRÍA Y FERNÁNDEZ states the following:
"Typicality is, then, the legal description of a specific conduct to which an administrative sanction will be connected. The specificity of the conduct to be classified comes from a double requirement: from the general principle of freedom, on which the entire Rule of Law is organized, which imposes that sanctionable conducts be an exception to that freedom and, therefore, exactly delimited, without any indeterminacy; and, secondly, to the correlative requirement of legal certainty, which would not be met if the description of what is sanctionable did not allow a sufficient degree of certainty for citizens to predict the consequences of their acts (lex certa)".
- Sura SAF points out that for the sanctioning power to be exercised, the infraction type must be described with absolute clarity in the rule and the conduct of the administered party must precisely fit that type. This is an indispensable requirement that the administrative authority must consider;
- It adds that, however, in the present case it is not possible for Sura SAF to breach the obligations to keep and maintain up to date the accounting of the mutual funds, books and records, to the extent that it has demonstrated that the daily reconciliation process allowed correcting the error incurred when performing the monthly reconciliation. There is, therefore, no state of non-updating or incorrect balances in its records and books;
- Therefore, Sura SAF concludes, this fact implies an open contravention of the provisions of the Principle of Typicity, set forth in numeral 4, article 248 of the TUO LPAG, according to which only those conducts that are precisely and indubitably provided for in rules with the rank of law and that fit the conduct of the administered party are punishable. It states that this does not occur in the present case;
- Sura SAF points out that, by virtue of the foregoing, Sura SAF's conduct does not exactly fit the infraction type imputed in the Statement of Charges, which determines that in the present case an administrative infraction has not been configured, in attention to the Principle of Typicity that governs the sanctioning power of administrative authorities;
Analysis of the defenses
- Previously, we must recall that the inspection included the evaluation of the activities and controls carried out by Sura SAF for the period from 1 to 30 June 2018, as well as the evaluation of the main accounting balances presented in the financial statements of the Short-Term Fund as of 30 June 2018;
Regarding the claim that Sura SAF is being sanctioned for an involuntary and isolated error when performing the monthly reconciliation
- In principle, it must be noted that Sura SAF acknowledges that it made an error in the preparation of its monthly bank reconciliations regarding the Short-Term Fund;
- Regarding the claim that there was an involuntary error in the form of presentation of the information and not in the execution of the records or that erroneously considering a bank statement from another period resulted in adjustments being shown in the working paper that bear no relation to the balances of the month, we must indicate that the balances of the Accounts of the Short-Term Fund, including the balances of the Bank-Current Accounts, must be correctly analyzed and supported by the supporting documentation as part of the accounting process and the determination of its financial statements;
- In that sense, bank reconciliations document the analysis that supports the balance of the Bank-Current Accounts, and in their preparation the corresponding bank statements are used as input;
- It should be added additionally that the bank reconciliation procedure is specified in the comments of Account 10 Cash and Banks, of the Chart of Accounts for Mutual Funds Investing in Securities that is part of the Accounting Standards applicable to Mutual Funds Investing in Securities;
- However, the accounting balances of the Accounts were not supported by their respective bank reconciliations presented to the inspection team, due to the erroneous balances considered as balances according to the banks and the composition of their reconciling items;
- In that sense, when the inspection team considered the correct balances in banks and the information found on the reconciling items, differences were observed between the final balance that would result according to the books and the one recorded in the Trial Balance at that date, a situation that was reflected in the Statement of Charges. Likewise, reconciling items not recorded in banks are observed; as well as not recorded in books;
- The situation described in the preceding paragraphs demonstrates that Articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation were not complied with because the financial information of the Short-Term Fund was not prepared in accordance with the standards established by the SMV, in accordance with the account "10 Cash and Banks" of the Chart of Accounts of Mutual Funds Investing in Securities, which provides that bank account balances must be subject to daily reconciliation with the bank statements sent by the banks. Any differences must be investigated and regularized;
- Indeed, it is appropriate to note that bank reconciliation is a control procedure that allows identifying differences between bank balances and accounting balances at the same date in order to investigate these differences and regularize or correct the accounting balances;
- In the present case, the error in having considered the bank statements of another period when reconciling the accounting balances as of 30 June 2018 as well as the errors in the composition of the reconciling items, evidences deficiencies in the processing of bank reconciliations and an inadequate analysis in the processing of the information incorporated into the accounting for the determination of the balances of the aforementioned accounting accounts, all evidenced at the date the inspection was carried out;
- This demonstrates that Sura SAF did not comply with article 22 of the Regulation to the extent that the inspection team determined a book balance (bank-current accounts) that differed from the balances recorded in the accounting of the management company according to its trial balance;
- On the other hand, Sura SAF has stated that its bank reconciliation is made up of two (2) different processes that complement each other; a daily reconciliation carried out by its operational areas (operations and custody) and a monthly reconciliation carried out by the accounting area. Likewise, it has a treasury system in which, once the balances in the daily reconciliation are reconciled, they are entered and that there is a restriction in the treasury system that is activated when the cash boxes have not yet been reconciled. Additionally, it states that the accounting area validates the balances recorded in the treasury system at month-end with the bank statement (it states that this control is carried out in an Excel working paper);
- However, although Sura SAF maintains that it carried out a double control, by independent areas and with the support of the treasury system, the errors in the processing of its bank reconciliations were presented, as indicated above;
- Regarding Sura SAF's statement that the aforementioned error is an isolated or unusual fact, it must be indicated that this, if applicable, does not change the observation detected by the inspection team, referring to the fact that the bank reconciliations as of 30 June 2018 did not support the accounting balances in banks of the Accounts at the same date and that the bank reconciliation procedure presented deficiencies;
- As mentioned, the inspection reviewed the financial information of the Short-Term Fund as of 30 June 2018, which served as the basis for the formulation subject to charge, however, we must specify that the imputation made has not indicated that the aforementioned error was a recurring fact, so this does not modify the situation observed;
- Additionally, regarding the fact that the external financial auditors have presented an unqualified opinion in their report on the financial statements of the Short-Term Fund as of 31 December 2018 and 31 December 2017, it must be indicated that the opinion of the external auditors is on the reasonableness of the financial statements at the indicated dates, which does not imply that there are no errors in the bank reconciliation procedure and in the analysis of the Bank Current Accounts as of 30 June 2018. Therefore, this does not demonstrate that it is an isolated or unusual fact;
Regarding the claim that Sura SAF has acted with due diligence by promptly correcting the error in the monthly reconciliation and that there is evidence that daily operations are correctly recorded in the books
- Sura SAF also states that the SMV must evaluate its diligent conduct, since it quickly corrected the involuntary error described above, which has been remedied as of the date of notification of the Statement of Charges;
- Sura SAF adds that there are control mechanisms that allow a reasonable degree of reliability in its operations and that by virtue of said mechanisms and after validating the aforementioned bank reconciliations with the corresponding bank statements, it is evident that the books correctly record the daily operations; and that after redoing the reconciliations with the correct bank statement, they have verified that the book balances show the correct balances;
- In relation to this, Sura SAF states that the differences in each monthly reconciliation do not affect the movements of the system (books), since these are recorded by other areas with a daily control of these movements and that the daily reconciliations were not affected by the aforementioned involuntary error, since the daily control allows safeguarding the operations of its clients and that due diligence also implies adopting reasonable precautions that are consistent with the probability of human error, for which it reiterates that its double control guarantees the reliability of its accounting information;
- On this matter, it must be indicated that Sura SAF has acknowledged that the bank reconciliations initially presented to the inspection team were redone with the correct bank statement;
- Indeed, although article 21 of the Regulation states that financial information must be prepared by the management companies in accordance with the Accounting Standards, and that, according to the comment of account "10 Cash and Banks" of the Chart of Accounts of Mutual Funds Investing in Securities, which states that bank account balances must be reconciled with the bank statements sent by the banks, Sura SAF changed its analysis of the "bank-current accounts" by modifying its bank reconciliations after what was observed by the inspection when the aforementioned comment of account 10 Cash and Banks says that any difference found must be investigated and regularized;
- That is, in the bank reconciliations modified by Sura SAF and presented in its defenses, it is observed that, -although the accounting balances of the Bank-Current Accounts according to its Trial Balance at that date (as of 30 June 2018) have not varied-, the processing of the information and the analysis of the movements were changed, by correcting the balance according to Banks and changing the composition of the reconciling items with respect to the original reconciliations.
- Regarding the reconciliation procedure, even though the daily reconciliation and the monthly reconciliation correspond to procedures carried out by different areas, according to what was indicated by the management company itself, both procedures complement each other, since the accounting area, for the monthly reconciliation, validates the information entered into the treasury system, which is previously reconciled by the operational areas daily;
- Additionally, it must be indicated that the monthly bank reconciliation is the reconciliation at the last day of the month, the date on which the cut-off is made for the preparation of the financial statements, so having carried out daily reconciliations, it would collect what was previously recorded and analyzed. It should be emphasized, as indicated above, that despite the established controls indicated by Sura SAF, errors were presented in the processing of its bank reconciliations;
- That is, Sura SAF's bank reconciliation procedure should have detected the inconsistencies in the processing of bank movements, identified them, investigated them and regularized them, as indicated in the comment of account "10 Cash and Banks";
- Regarding what was indicated by Sura SAF, which states that due to its diligent conduct it quickly corrected the involuntary error or that as of the date of its defenses the differences indicated in the Statement of Charges are remedied, it must be specified that the observation regarding the bank reconciliations detected by the inspection was previously communicated to Sura SAF through Official Letter No. 6657-2018-SMV/10.2 dated 3 December 2018, which evidences that this was not a voluntary act of said management company;
- Indeed, in its response to the aforementioned official letter, Sura SAF informed as an action plan, the generation of a bank reconciliation procedure which it attached, indicating as implementation date 28 December 2018. However, it did not attach its explanations or support regarding the differences observed nor its modified bank reconciliations, which it has only included in its defenses to the Statement of Charges;
- On the other hand, Sura SAF has also indicated that this involuntary error being an isolated fact cannot constitute a parameter to measure its diligence in keeping the accounting of mutual funds such as books and records up to date;
- As regards this, as indicated above, bank reconciliations document the analysis that supports the balance of the Bank-Current Accounts, when there are differences between the accounting balances and the bank statements, which must be carried out as part of the accounting process that supports the balance of said account and whose objective is to investigate these differences and regularize or correct the accounting balances;
- In the present case, as explained, the financial information referring to the Bank - Current Accounts (of the Statement of Financial Position) was not prepared in accordance with the standards established by the SMV, which establishes in its Accounting Standards and in its chart of accounts that to determine the balance of this account bank reconciliations must be performed (article 21 of the Regulation and Accounting Standards);
- It must be indicated that although the bank reconciliations as of 30 June 2018 were prepared by Sura SAF and presented to the inspection team and these coincided with the balance of the Bank - Current Accounts, according to Sura SAF's Trial Balance at that date, however, they contained errors in the balance recorded according to Banks and in their reconciling items, so they did not support the accounting balance at the date of the inspection. In this regard, as already indicated, the inspection team determined a book balance that differed from the balances recorded in the accounting of the management company, evidencing the non-observance of articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation and the comment of account "10 Cash and Banks";
- It should be added that, on the occasion of its defenses, Sura SAF presented its modified bank reconciliations, which coincided with the same book balances. However, it is observed that with respect to the bank reconciliations originally delivered to the inspection team, in addition to correcting the balance in banks, new reconciling items were included and others were removed, which demonstrates that the first bank reconciliations were in error and were not updated to date, which confirms the imputed infraction;
- Without prejudice to the fact that the imputed infraction has been accredited, it is appropriate to note that regarding the modified bank reconciliations presented in its defenses and taking into account that Sura SAF has corrected the balance in banks, we must indicate that said management company maintains reconciling items for which it is understood that there are operations to be recorded in books (charges and/or credits). Likewise, in the modified bank reconciliation the accounting record that would correspond to be made cannot be recognized, because Sura Saf has not identified in its modified reconciliations which reconciling items are pending accounting record; and furthermore the amounts recorded are consolidated, that is, they do not detail each type of operation. Likewise, the image of the bank statements presented in its defenses are not complete;
- It must be taken into account that, according to the Accounting Standards, bank reconciliations are a procedure established in the chart of accounts of mutual funds as part of account 10 Cash and Banks (which includes account 104 Banks - Current Accounts), so they constitute part of the accounting information and records that support the balances of this account, in that sense, since Sura SAF has not presented bank reconciliations of the Accounts that support the book balance as of 30 June 2018 at the date of the inspection, as required by the Comment to account 10 Cash and Banks that has been imputed to Sura SAF, its non-compliance has been accredited, regardless of the fact that the management company states that its book balance would not have varied as of the date of its defenses;
Regarding the claim that the PAS must be archived as the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation has been configured
- Sura SAF indicates that voluntary remediation as an exemption from liability must be evaluated based on the provisions of article 257 of the TUO LPAG and article 27 of the New Sanctions Regulation, since the involuntary error when performing the monthly reconciliation was promptly corrected, thereby meeting the requirements established by the cited rules for an exemption from liability to be configured;
- It adds that, in the hypothetical case that the SMV considers that Sura SAF breached the applicable regulations, it requests that the infraction conduct be deemed remedied, to the extent that it was corrected long before the start of this sanctioning procedure and that with this support, it be archived in this regard;
- On this matter, it must be indicated that the application of said exemption for voluntary remediation is not appropriate to the extent that, as indicated, Sura SAF has not accredited with the corresponding documentation having remedied such non-compliance at the date the inspection was carried out or the date Official Letter No. 6657-2018-SMV/10.2 was notified;
- In this regard, it must be indicated that literal f) of article 27 of the New Sanctions Regulation requires that for the configuration of the exemption for voluntary remediation, no communication demanding compliance with the obligation must have been sent;
- In the present case, through Official Letter No. 6657-2018-SMV/10.2 dated 3 December 2018, Sura SAF was informed of the observations detected in the inspection, among others, the one corresponding to not keeping its books and records (the bank reconciliation)[3] in accordance with the Regulation;
- It should also be recalled that Sura SAF's response regarding its explanations for the differences observed and its modified bank reconciliations were only presented in the defenses to the Statement of Charges, so it has not accredited, as it indicates, that its bank reconciliations were corrected promptly and voluntarily;
- From the foregoing, in the present case the exemption for voluntary remediation does not apply;
Regarding the claim that there has been no regulatory non-compliance: Sura SAF did maintain and maintains updated the books, records and files of its clients
- Sura SAF has stated that the error in submitting information by using an incorrect account statement does not imply that its clients' books, records and files are outdated and that this assumption implies an improper conclusion from an isolated fact.
- Sura SAF indicates that it must be borne in mind that, on the occasion of the involuntary error in submitting the information to the SMV, no claim was filed by its clients. This is because the operations of the participants have not been affected, to the extent that the recognition of their subscriptions and redemptions are controlled in daily reconciliations;
- Sura SAF points out that in that sense, its conduct does not precisely fit the imputed infraction of "not keeping or not maintaining updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files." That is, it maintains that said infraction has not been configured in the present case;
- It also states that based on the foregoing, the principle of typicity that governs the exercise of the sanctioning power of the public administration is not met and that according to said principle, provided in numeral 4, article 248 of the TUO LPAG, only conducts administratively sanctionable are infractions expressly provided in norms with the rank of law through their typification as such, without admitting extensive interpretation or analogy;
- It adds that in order for the sanctioning power to be exercised, the infraction type must be described with absolute clarity in the norm and the conduct of the administered must fit precisely into said type and that this is an indispensable requirement that the administrative authority must consider;
- Sura SAF maintains that, however, in the present case it is not possible for it to breach the obligations to keep and maintain up to date the accounting of the mutual funds, books and records, to the extent that they have demonstrated that the daily reconciliation process allowed correcting the error incurred when making the monthly reconciliation and that there is no state of outdatedness or incorrect balances in our records and books;
- In this regard, it must be indicated that such argument is only supported by its statement, since Sura SAF has not demonstrated that its daily reconciliation process allowed correcting the error, since the inconsistency in said process was present at the time of the inspection, as evidenced in the Letter of Charges;
- With regard to the fact that the error in submitting information by using an incorrect account statement does not imply that its clients' books, records and files are outdated, it must be indicated that said situation has not been the object of observation, since what has been imputed is that its bank reconciliations, as of June 30, 2018, did not support the accounting balance of the banks-current accounts, information that is different from that generated by its clients;
- Regarding what Sura SAF states that the operations of the participants have not been affected and that no claims were filed by its clients, it must be indicated that although this has not been detected or observed, it is convenient to specify that~~,~~ current accounts centralize all deposits from subscriptions, sales or interbank transfers; as well as disbursements for the purchase of investments and amortization of obligations contracted by the fund, which is recorded in the bank reconciliations made by the management company;
- As to the fact that the conduct object of charges does not precisely fit the imputed infraction of "not keeping or not maintaining updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files," it must be noted that the arguments given by Sura SAF in its defenses have been duly evaluated and disproved, ratifying the regulatory breach object of charges, so the non-observance of the principle of typicity is not evidenced;
- Indeed, as explained above, it has been demonstrated in this administrative procedure that Sura SAF has not kept the corresponding books and records in accordance with the Accounting Standards and articles 20 and 21 of the Regulation, because the bank reconciliations of the Accounts as of June 30, 2018 that were prepared by Sura SAF and presented to the inspection team contained errors in the balance recorded according to Banks and in their reconciling items, so they do not support the balance of the Banks Current Accounts account of the Statement of Financial Position, regardless of whether its balance in books has not varied as of the date of its defenses, which constitutes the infraction typified in the Letter of Charges;
- For the foregoing, Sura SAF has not disproved the imputed charge, so it has incurred an infraction classified as serious typified in Annex I, numeral 2, item 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation[4], approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF-94.10 and its amendments, in force at the time the events occurred (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), in force at the time the events occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Not keeping or not maintaining updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files."
- Second charge: Breaches of customer due diligence (hereinafter, CDD)
- Failure to prove the information and documentation supporting the CDD procedures
Of the regulations
- Numeral 7.2 of article 7 of the Plaft Rules, in force at the date of the events, establishes:
"Article 7.- Customer Due Diligence by the Obligated Subject
(…)
7.2 Obligated subjects must develop policies and procedures aimed at obtaining adequate knowledge of the identity of their clients, including the processing of forms to be completed by them. For these purposes, clients must be requested to present public or private documents, in accordance with the Law and the Regulation, in order to obtain the information indicated below, verify the information provided even before starting the business relationship and keep it updated. (…)
In this sense, at least the following must be recorded and verified by reliable means, as applicable:
In the case of natural persons:
(…)
f) Particular signs and legal capacity.
(…)
i) Work center and position held, as well as time of service, if applicable.
(…)
In the case of Legal Persons or Structures:
(…)
d) Identification of directors and shareholders, partners or associates, who directly or indirectly have more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation of the legal person, considering the information required for natural persons, as applicable, identifying those who are PEP.
(…)
h) Legal persons that according to the regulations on linkage and economic group qualify as linked to the client.
(…)
j) Statement of Financial Position and Income Statement."
events occurred
- From the review of the CDD procedure of a sample of clients of Sura SAF, it was identified that in the forms used for CDD the information is incomplete and is also not found in the files of the respective clients, as explained below:
- Regarding natural persons, the following information is not available:
-
- Legal capacity: This information is not indicated, even in some cases the customer knowledge form does not have this field for its registration.
- Work center and position held*,* as well as time of service*,* if applicable: Not all the information is indicated, or in some cases part of it.
- The detail of the observations per client is shown in the following table:
TABLE No. 2
Information Registry of Natural Persons
| CODE | NAME OF THE PARTICIPANT | DATE OF REGISTRATION | WORK CENTER AND POSITION HELD, AS WELL AS TIME OF SERVICE, IF APPLICABLE | LEGAL CAPACITY |
|---|
| 43363580 | SERGIO MONAR | 31/03/2017 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 40789814 | ROBERTO GUZMAN | 05/05/2017 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 09935183 | CARLOS LOO KUNG | 12/07/2017 | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 07476045 | PAOLA FRY | 04/01/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 44725112 | JOSÉ VASQUEZ | 15/01/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 44725066 | JORGE ZUZUNAGA | 16/01/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 08275934 | SANDRA BARCLAY | 31/01/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION | YES INDICATES |
| 44726292 | SERAPIO TICONA | 01/03/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 44725037 | EUFRACIA CHATA | 02/03/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE |
| 42939905 | LUIS DUEÑAS | 10/04/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 07869119 | CARLOS BELLATIN | 17/04/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 23804316 | JORGE POLO Y LA BORDA | 19/04/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER, POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 29239647 | EVA MONROY | 02/05/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER, POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 44726717 | MARÍA RISCO | 03/05/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 44726484 | AQUILA ROJAS | 03/05/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER, POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 08811199 | MARÍA ACHA | 14/05/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 44726692 | EULOGIA MAYHUIRI | 22/05/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER AND POSITION | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
| 04431042 | WILFREDO ALBARRACIN | 24/07/2018 | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) |
(*) The form does not have the "legal capacity" field
- Regarding legal persons, the following information is not available:
- Identification of directors and shareholders, partners or associates, who directly or indirectly have more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation of the legal person, considering the information required for natural persons, as applicable, identifying those who are PEP*:* The information of directors is not recorded, even in the forms there is no field to record this information.
- Legal persons that according to the regulations on linkage and economic group qualify as linked to the client: This information is not recorded.
-
- Statement of Financial Position and Income Statement: In the clients' files it is not evidenced that Sura SAF has collected the financial statements of the clients.
- The detail of the observations per client is shown in the following table:
TABLE No. 3
Information Registry of Legal Persons
| CODE | NAME OF THE PARTICIPANT | DATE OF REGISTRATION | IDENTIFICATION OF DIRECTORS AND SHAREHOLDERS[5] | LEGAL PERSONS LINKED TO THE CLIENT | STATEMENTS OF FINANCIAL POSITION AND INCOME STATEMENT |
|---|
| 44725334 | HPSA CORP. | 22/06/2017 | DOES NOT INDICATE (Missing information of directors | DOES NOT INDICATE | NOT COLLECTED |
| 44671364 | INVERSIONES SI DON LUIS S.A. | 01/08/2017 | DOES NOT INDICATE (Missing information of directors) | DOES NOT INDICATE | NOT COLLECTED |
| 44726472 | DU CONDOR S.A. | 17/04/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE (Missing information of directors) | DOES NOT INDICATE | NOT COLLECTED |
| 44726348 | FERREYROS S.A. | 23/04/2018 | - | - | NOT COLLECTED |
- For the foregoing, Sura SAF was charged with having breached the provisions of numeral 7.2 of article 7 of the PLAFT Rules.
- Failure to prove the required update for clients to whom the intensified CDD procedure applies
Of the Regulations
- Article 7, numerals 7.4 and 7.5, of the Plaft Rules establish:
"Article 7.- Customer Due Diligence by the Obligated Subject"
(…)
7.4Obligated subjects, based on the information obtained through their policies and procedures for adequate knowledge of their clients and with a risk-based approach, must identify those cases in which it is warranted to intensify their due diligence procedures in customer knowledge, among which the following must be considered:
- Non-resident clients, national or foreign.
(…)
d) Trusts: In this case the obligated subject must identify the identity of the settlor, trustee and beneficiaries
e) Non-domiciled companies.
f) Politically exposed persons (PEP) or those who administer public resources. Obligated subjects must have appropriate risk management systems and must strengthen their customer knowledge procedures when one of their clients becomes a PEP or an official who administers public resources, as the case may be, after having started business relationships with the obligated subject.
(…)
In each client's file it must be indicated whether it is a client to whom the intensified due diligence procedure in customer knowledge corresponds to be applied.
7.5 Obligated subjects to strengthen their customer knowledge procedures must at least carry out the following additional measures, as applicable:
(…)
c) Carry out at least once (1) a year a review of the profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, of the client, as well as, if domiciled in Peru, carry out a visit to their home or offices, when deemed necessary, in case the review of the client's profile, background, documentation does not correspond with what was declared.
(…)"
Of the events occurred
- From the review of the documents supporting the CDD procedures carried out for the clients indicated in Table No. 4 to whom it is warranted to intensify the CDD procedures, in the inspection carried out by the SMV no documents were found indicating that Sura SAF has carried out, at least once (1) a year since their admission as clients or since the last update of their information, a review of the profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, of these clients;
TABLE No. 4
Annual Update Clients Intensified CDD
| No. | CLIENT | DATE OF ADMISSION OR UPDATE | CHARACTERISTIC OF THE CLIENT | ANNUAL UPDATE OF PROFILE, BACKGROUND, DOCUMENTATION, AMONG OTHER ASPECTS |
|---|
| 1 | COFIDE Fideicomiso Gobierno Regional San Martín | 13/11/2013 | Trust | No (As of Nov 2017) |
| 2 | Flores Tipismana, Rita Rosario | 15/10/2014 | PEP | No (As of Oct 2017) |
| 3 | Jiménez Trelle, Alfonso | 31/03/2014 | PEP | No (As of Mar 2018) |
| 4 | Ortiz Ríos, Rita María | 11/08/2011 | PEP | No (As of Aug 2018) |
| 5 | HPSA Corporación | 22/06/2017 | Non-domiciled company | No (As of Jun 2018) |
- Therefore, as set forth, Sura SAF was charged with having breached article 7, numeral 7.4 and numeral 7.5, literal c) of the Plaft Rules, because with respect to the clients mentioned in Table No. 4, an annual update of the profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, would not have been carried out;
Of the Defenses Presented
2.1. Failure to prove the information and documentation supporting the CDD procedures
- Regarding natural persons
The imputation of the Letter of Charges is incorrect and inconsistent
- Sura SAF states that Table No. 2 shows that there would be no information on the legal capacity of seventeen (17) clients, and in turn, states that in the case of nine (9) clients, information on the work center, position and time of service would not be indicated;
- However, Sura SAF states that upon reviewing Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2 and its annexes –which support the initiation of this PAS– no information is found on almost all the clients mentioned in Table No. 2. It specifies that there is no reference in the report and its annexes on fourteen (14) of the clients mentioned;
- That is, Sura SAF indicates, the Letter of Charges has not shown any evidence in this PAS -beyond a simple statement- that demonstrates the alleged lack of recorded information;
- In this regard, Sura SAF indicates that they evidence the inconsistency in the last column of the following table:
TABLE No. 5
| IDC | NAME OF THE PARTICIPANT | INDICATES WORK CENTER AND POSITION HELD, AS WELL AS TIME OF SERVICE, IF APPLICABLE | INDICATES LEGAL CAPAC. | SUPPORT OF SMV |
|---|
| 43363580 | SERGIO MONAR | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 40789814 | ROBERTO GUZMAN | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 09935183 | CARLOS LOO KUNG | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 07476045 | PAOLA FRY | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 44725112 | JOSÉ VASQUEZ | DOES NOT INDICATE TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 44725066 | JORGE ZUZUNAGA | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 08275934 | SANDRA BARCLAY | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION | YES INDICATES | - |
| 44726292 | SERAPIO TICONA | DOES NOT INDICATE TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 44725037 | EUFRACIA CHATA | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE | NONE |
| 42939905 | LUIS DUEÑAS | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | NONE |
| 07869119 | CARLOS BELLATIN | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | - |
| 23804316 | JORGE POLO Y LA BORDA | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER, POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | NONE |
| 29239647 | EVA MONROY | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER, POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | NONE |
| 44726717 | MARÍA RISCO | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | NONE |
| 44726484 | AQUILA ROJAS | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER, POSITION AND TIME OF SERVICE | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | NONE |
| 08811199 | MARÍA ACHA | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | - |
| 44726692 | EULOGIA MAYHUIRI | DOES NOT INDICATE WORK CENTER AND POSITION | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | NONE |
| 04431042 | WILFREDO ALBARRACIN | YES INDICATES | DOES NOT INDICATE (*) | - |
- Sura SAF indicates that this implies that the information that supposedly would support the imputation in this regard does not exist, and therefore, a PAS would be initiated based on mere statements without any support. In this sense, Sura SAF adds, an incorrect and inconsistent imputation is contrary to the legal system and generates the nullity of the PAS in this regard;
- Sura SAF adds that this serious error in the imputation made in the Letter of Charges is not only inaccurate, incorrect and inconsistent with the supporting report and its annexes, but also implies a series of contraventions of the legal system;
- In this regard, Sura SAF argues that one of the limits of the punitive power of the State is regulated in the Principle of Presumption of Lawfulness, provided in numeral 9, article 248 of the TUO LPAG, according to which "entities must presume that the administered have acted in accordance with their duties as long as they do not have evidence to the contrary.";
- In the present case, Sura SAF states that there is no evidence demonstrating that Sura SAF has failed to register the information on fourteen (14) of the clients mentioned in the imputation of charges. That is, the imputation of charges has been limited to making a mere statement that has not been verified in the PAS file;
- Along these lines, Sura SAF states that if the Letter of Charges did not have any evidentiary means demonstrating the alleged regulatory breach to which it refers, then it should have been presumed that Sura SAF was acting in accordance with the law, as indeed occurs;
- It considers that, instead of presuming the lawfulness of Sura SAF's conduct, and despite not having evidence to the contrary, with the Letter of Charges a sanctioning procedure has been improperly initiated against an administered who did not commit the imputed conduct. That is why the Principle of Presumption of Lawfulness that governs the exercise of the sanctioning power is violated;
- Likewise, it states that it is evident that an imputation has been made without correctly verifying the reasons that support its decision to initiate a sanctioning procedure, as required by the Principle of Material Truth enshrined in numeral 1.11, article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO LPAG;
- According to said principle, Sura SAF adds that the administrative authority must "fully verify the facts that serve as the basis for its decisions, for which it must adopt all necessary evidentiary measures." In this regard, it indicates that CASSAGNE specifies that administrative actions must be aimed at the identification and clarification of the real facts produced, regardless of how they have been alleged and proven by the administered;
- According to said author, Sura SAF states, the Principle of Material Truth postulates that the administrative authority is obliged to carry out all evidentiary diligences that tend to the investigation of the facts and then base the decision, disregarding the allegation and demonstration by the individual[6];
- Sura SAF adds that said principle has been violated in this PAS to the extent that the Letter of Charges does not reflect such verification referred to by material truth, but rather contains only a statement that has not been duly verified by the authority;
- On the other hand, Sura SAF indicates that the Letter of Charges has also not considered that, in the case of one of the clients mentioned in Table No. 2, it is not legally possible to sanction Sura SAF, since the applicable norm was repealed when this client was admitted;
- It refers to the case of Mr. Wilfredo Albarracín, regarding whom it is imputed not to have indicated the registration of "legal capacity" information. It indicates that Mr. Albarracín was admitted as a client on July 24, 2018, and for that date, literal f), numeral 7.2 of the Plaft Rules -which established the obligation to include the "legal capacity" field in the forms- had been repealed by article 1 of Superintendence Resolution No. 073-2018-SMV/02, published on May 31, 2018, whose text is as follows:
"f) Particular signs and identification of the representatives, considering the information required in the case of natural persons; as well as verifying the corresponding powers."
- That is, Sura SAF points out, it is intended to sanction it for the alleged breach of an obligation that has already been left without effect and that is not currently in force. It specifies that the Plaft Rules ceased to consider "legal capacity" as an element to be declared in the forms because, using various tools and procedures, the identification and legal capacity of clients can be effectively guaranteed;
- On this matter, Sura SAF adds, the provisions of the Principle of Benign Retroactivity apply, set forth in numeral 5, article 248 of the TUO LPAG, according to which "the sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered party incurred the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable to it";
- It states that according to said principle, in the present case the obligation to register "legal capacity" has been left without effect and is not in force for the legal system. That being so, the current regulations are more favorable to Sura SAF, and therefore, they must be applied. This evidently has the consequence that it cannot and should not be sanctioned in application of the Principle of Benign Retroactivity;
- Sura SAF indicates that the situation described above occurs for all the clients mentioned in Table No. 2 of the Charge Letter. However, as they have previously indicated, fourteen (14) of them must be excluded from the PAS, and for that reason, they are only mentioning Mr. Albarracín, who is not part of said group;
- Based on the foregoing, it states that in the hypothetical case that the PAS is not archived, it requests that the mentioned cases be removed from the PAS, since no regulatory breach has been proven regarding them;
Sura SAF has acted with due diligence in the registration of information that supports the DDCC procedures
- Sura SAF indicates that, according to the Plaft Rules, for registration the data related to the identification of the persons participating in the contractual relationship are required, and the identity, representation (if applicable), nationality, address, profession or occupation, corporate purpose and other minimum data linked to natural and/or legal persons, as applicable, must be registered;
- Sura SAF adds that, regarding verification, the Plaft Rules mention that it will be carried out through documents, such as the DNI or other official and private documents; regarding the identity of clients, no additional requirement should be made. That is, the rule is limited solely to stating that said corroboration may be carried out through independent and reliable data, such as, for example, a search through the RENIEC web portal (for natural persons) and the review of the Registry Entry or the Certificate of Incorporation (for legal persons);
- To obtain the required minimum data, Sura SAF uses reasonable and appropriate tools in order to comply with its obligations, and at the same time, to facilitate the access of participants to the market. For this, documents that it considers pertinent for the review procedure are used, each of which is evaluated as a whole to corroborate the data provided by natural or legal persons, while avoiding requirements that are unreasonable for the client;
- Sura SAF reiterates that all the data required by the Plaft Rules are recorded in the mutual fund administration contract and in the sworn statement. Said documents request names and surnames, occupation, address, among other data. Likewise, not all the fields recorded – such as the workplace – are necessary for the client's profiling, since they are not weighable within the risk level assessment;
- Likewise, it states that Sura SAF has documents such as the aforementioned mutual fund administration contract and the sworn statement, which record the information required by the Plaft Rules; that is, the "legal capacity" field was always part of its formats;
- Similarly, as part of its DDCC procedures and in compliance with applicable regulations, before starting the contractual relationship, Sura SAF validates the identity and legal capacity of persons. For this, a copy of the DNI is requested to be sent and then verified in the "Online Queries" program offered by RENIEC, which provides information on all citizens;
- It adds that, as can be seen, Sura SAF has a strict client knowledge policy. This situation disproves the existence of a situation of non-compliance or deficiencies in the process of capturing and registering information;
- It states that all of the above is complemented by Sura SAF's obligation to carry out DDCC procedures adequately, in detail and corporately, by cross-checking and corroborating information with the related company AFP Integra (annex attached). It specifies that as part of an economic group, and having a Corporate Compliance Officer, they have the power to exchange information, as established in article 3.5 of the Plaft Rules[7];
- It indicates that said circumstance allows the registered information to be cross-checked, providing reliability and security to all data collected on its clients.
- In summary, Sura SAF indicates, the procedures and provisions applicable to it make the information registration obligations comply, reducing any eventual non-compliance to an isolated fact that does not imply negligent conduct nor generates any harm to its users or the market in general;
Sura SAF's conduct must be evaluated under a parameter of reasonableness
- Sura SAF states that by virtue of what has been accredited in the preceding recitals, the lack of proven evidence and the fact that information has only been received on the alleged non-compliance in the registration of information of only three (3) clients, said circumstances must be evaluated and the PAS must be archived by virtue of the Principle of Reasonableness;
- Sura SAF adds that said principle is set forth in numeral 1.4, article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO LPAG and establishes that "the decisions of the administrative authority, when they create obligations, classify infractions, impose sanctions or establish restrictions on administered parties, must adapt within the limits of the attributed power and maintaining due proportion between the means to be employed and the public purposes to be protected, so that they respond to what is strictly necessary for the satisfaction of their mandate";
- Sura SAF states that along the same lines, the Constitutional Court has indicated in the Judgment in Case No. 00017-2011-PI/TC that the imposition of sanctions is the last ratio:
"(...) nor is it about the mere existence of a legal asset to be protected generating per se the need to resort to criminal sanction to protect it. This, not only because criminal sanction is the last ratio, which has as a constitutional correlate determining that it is only possible to resort to the restriction of rights (personal freedom) when it is not possible to achieve the same ends through less restrictive measures (…)".
- Sura SAF indicates that in the present case, it is intended to sanction Sura SAF for an alleged non-compliance referring to only three (3) cases out of an extremely larger universe of clients. It specifies that the alleged non-compliance represented 0.03% and 0.027% of the totality of participants that Sura SAF managed in the years 2017 and 2018, respectively;
- However, it adds, in the opinion of the instructing body it would not be sufficient that Sura SAF has maintained diligent conduct; it indicates that it would be intended to require that no error or omission be presented in the registration of said information, without any margin of error. However, perfection cannot be demanded when making said registration;
- Sura SAF states that, far from a scenario of non-compliance, Sura SAF has indeed carried out various reasonable actions that only demonstrate its diligence: it has carried out its own verifications, following the provisions of the Plaft Rules;
- In this scenario, Sura SAF states, since it has not been accredited in the PAS that Sura SAF breached its duty of diligence, they request that the PAS in this regard be archived;
- Regarding legal persons
On the identification of directors and shareholders, partners or associates
- Sura SAF states that it complied at all times with the correct registration of information on DDCC. It indicates that in the sworn statement signed by its clients (attached in an annex to its defenses), it was always requested to indicate whether or not they had the information subject to observation and that said documentary evidence supports the request made by Sura SAF to its clients;
- Sura SAF adds that likewise, as part of the verification procedure established by the Plaft Rules, the information provided by legal persons was corroborated (and is corroborated), both through official and private documents, carrying out a detailed review of the Registry Entry or the Certificate of Incorporation of the company, and the respective RUC Record;
- It indicates that all the documents listed in the preceding recital allow knowing and validating the directors and shareholders, as well as their participation percentage in force at the time of contracting;
On legal persons that qualify as related to the client
- Sura SAF states that through sworn statements it did request the pertinent information from its clients, requesting that they mention if they had any relationship with other legal persons or economic groups. It states that it attaches the format used at that time, to register client information, which contains the specific information that they supposedly had not registered;
- Sura SAF adds that in the context of identification procedures, it complied with implementing the form that allows obtaining information on the client's identity. Likewise, it reiterates that, as part of its verification procedures, they request additional documents in order to corroborate the information provided. It indicates that a clear example of this is the RUC record, which informs whether there are legal persons related to the company subject to evaluation;
- Sura SAF adds that, lastly, if the client does not fill in certain fields, the Compliance Officer weighs the client's risk level, which it categorizes as "Special" for subsequent monitoring. This reduces any risk associated with the failure to provide information and allows any omission affecting regulatory compliance to be remedied;
On the Statement of Financial Position and Income Statement
- In this regard, Sura SAF states that it also requests in the sworn statement information on "profits of the last fiscal year" and "average monthly income", in order to know the financial position and income statement of clients, for which it attaches the corresponding forms;
- Sura SAF adds that, as part of its procedures, it also reviews reliable pages that provide public information on shareholders, directors and financial statements of legal persons, such as the SMV pages, the Lima Stock Exchange, among others;
- Sura SAF states that for the case of the client Ferreyros S.A., the information on the financial statements could be found and validated through the mentioned pages. Likewise, it attaches the financial statements of the company Ferreycorp S.A.A. as of December 31, 2017;
- Sura SAF adds that on December 28, 2018 it communicated to the SMV the modification of the Internal Operating Procedures Manual, indicating that, if the information referring to profits of the last fiscal year and average monthly income of clients is not found satisfactory, the information from public sources would be reviewed, as a first option. Failing that, copies of the financial statements would be requested through the designated commercial and/or commercial areas;
- Sura SAF also states that it verifies the "Equifax" platform, which not only provides information on the credit level of clients, but also on the financial behavior of each client;
- In summary, it states that Sura SAF has not breached any obligation and should not be sanctioned, not only because its conduct is adequate to current regulations, but also for carrying out complementary and diligent actions that eliminate risks, and in turn, protect the correct development of the market and users;
2.2. Failure to accredit the required updating for clients to whom the intensified DDCC procedure applies
The PAS must be archived by application of the Principle of Benign Retroactivity
- Sura SAF states that in the present case a case of voluntary correction has been configured which, as has been set forth in the previous sections, exempts it from administrative responsibility and from any eventual sanction;
- Sura SAF indicates that on December 28, 2018 it communicated to the SMV as an action plan, the modification of the Operating Procedures Manual, indicating that an annual reevaluation of clients would be carried out in the Compliance Tracker, as well as an annual update of information in coordination with the operations area, in order to guarantee the obligation established in the Plaft Rules. Sura SAF attaches in an annex to its defenses the corresponding part of the Operating Procedures Manual;
- It adds that, accordingly, Sura SAF currently complies with the obligation to update data and review the background of its clients. For this, the following are carried out: i) address verifications of natural persons (if necessary), ii) reviews of clients in the aforementioned "Compliance Tracker" program, software that – although the rule does not require it – greatly facilitates the compliance work; and, iii) data update forms are also sent in order to keep the information complete and documented;
- Thus, Sura SAF adds, after the SMV carried out the inspection and before having received the Charge Letter that initiated the present PAS, Sura SAF – by its own and spontaneous will – carried out the corresponding correction of the alleged non-compliance;
- That being so, the requirements are met for a case of exemption from responsibility due to voluntary correction to be configured, the same ones that are established both in the TUO LPAG and in the New Sanctions Regulation and that were already cited in previous sections;
- It adds that the applicable regulations require that the correction be voluntary; that it be carried out prior to the notification of the imputation of charges, and that no communication has been sent demanding compliance with the obligation;
- Therefore, Sura SAF concludes, in the hypothetical case that it is considered that it breached the applicable regulations, it requests that the alleged infracting conduct be deemed corrected, to the extent that it was corrected long before the start of the present PAS. With such support, the present PAS must be archived in relation to this aspect;
Additional issue
- Sura SAF specifies that, without prejudice to what is indicated in the previous sections, it has verified that, in the list of clients sent on this imputation, Mrs. Rita María Ortiz Ríos was included. However, it specifies that Mrs. Ortiz is not a client of Sura SAF, according to the company's client registry. It attaches in an annex the proof that said lady is not its client;
- Likewise, it states that they have not found a record of her in RENIEC either, so there is an additional ground for the imputation in said aspect to be left without effect, in compliance with the principles previously mentioned;
Analysis of the defenses
Failure to Accredit the information and documentation that supports the DDCC procedures
- Regarding natural persons
- With regard to Sura SAF's statement that in Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2 and its annexes – which support the initiation of the present PAS – there is no reference whatsoever to fourteen (14) of the clients mentioned in Table No. 2, it should be noted that such statement is incorrect since Sura SAF has not taken into account everything explained in the Charge Letter and what is stated and supported in Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2 and its annexes;
- Indeed, the Charge Letter states that the observations to the registration of client information originate "from the review of the DDCC procedure of a sample of clients of Sura SAF".
- In this regard, Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2 states that "in order to evaluate the implementation of client due diligence procedures by Fondos SURA (…) the list of clients as of June 30, 18 was obtained (…). Thus, based on a sample of the files of forty-three (43) participants, the DDCC procedures carried out by Fondos Sura (…) were evaluated".
- That is, the observations to the registration of information of the eighteen (18) natural person clients mentioned in Table No. 2 come from the review carried out by the SMV inspection team of the documentation provided by the administration company itself regarding the sample of forty-three (43) clients, selected by the inspection team. From this sample of forty-three (43) clients, the inspection team found observations to the registration of information of eighteen (18) clients, mentioned in Table No. 2;
- Regarding the review carried out on the registration of information of the sample of forty-three (43) clients, it should be noted that not all clients regarding whom observations were found are mentioned in Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2, but only some examples of clients regarding whom Sura SAF would have failed to register certain type of information such as "legal capacity" or "workplace";
- On the latter, it should be specified that the complete list of the sample of forty (43) clients and the respective observations corresponding to each of them is in a working document (Excel), prepared by the SMV inspection team, and which is in the file of the present administrative sanctioning procedure to which Sura SAF has access from the date of notification of the Charge Letter, in exercise of its right of defense;
- Therefore, what Sura SAF states regarding the information that supposedly would support the imputation in this aspect not existing is incorrect, and that a PAS is being initiated based on mere statements without any support;
- In this regard, it has been demonstrated that what is stated in the Charge Letter, in particular the questioned observations, do have the corresponding evidentiary support which is in a working paper (Excel), a document called "Client Due Diligence Sample", prepared by the inspection team designated by this Superintendency and accredited before the administration company to request documentation from Sura SAF in order to review it within the framework of the supervision actions that this Superintendency periodically develops;
- It should be highlighted that for the preparation of the Excel "Client Due Diligence Sample", the information and documentation provided by Sura SAF itself in response to the request made through Memorandum No. 01-2018 of August 8, 2018 was taken into account; and through emails addressed to Fondos Sura personnel, the SMV inspection team formulated it, that is, said working paper was prepared with the very information that the administration company has and provided;
- It should be noted that according to article 166[8] of the TUO LPAG, conducting inspections and collecting documents constitute means of proof, which has occurred in the present case and the administration company itself has provided the respective documentation to the SMV inspection team in order to verify regulatory compliance, and as a consequence, Report No. 1253-2020-SMV/10.2 has been prepared, of which the aforementioned document called "Client Due Diligence Sample" is part;
- In this sense, since the existence of evidentiary means that evidence the infraction incurred is accredited in the present administrative sanctioning procedure, no non-compliance with the principle of presumption of lawfulness alleged by Sura SAF is observed, which ratifies the observance of all guarantees attached to the principles of the administrative procedure contained in Article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO LPAG, among them, that of material truth, since in the present case the infraction committed by Sura SAF has been demonstrated with the evidence described in the Charge Letter;
- On the other hand, regarding the application of the Principle of Benign Retroactivity, set forth in numeral 5, article 248 of the TUO LPAG, which Sura SAF mentions in its defenses, it should be noted that, in effect, literal f), numeral 7.2 of the Plaft Rules – which established the obligation to include the "legal capacity" field in the forms – was repealed by article 1 of Superintendency Resolution No. 073-2018-SMV/02, therefore, the current regulations are more favorable to Sura SAF and, consequently, the archiving of the charge in the aspect of the observations referring to the non-registration of "legal capacity" in the forms of the seventeen (17) clients mentioned in Table No. 2, among which Mr. Albarracín is included, corresponds;
- Consequently, according to what has been mentioned, the observations to the registration of information of natural person clients are limited to the following nine (9) clients:
TABLE No. 6
| No. | IDC | NAME OF THE PARTICIPANT | REGISTRATION DATE | INDICATES WORKPLACE AND POSITION HELD, AS WELL AS LENGTH OF SERVICE, IF APPLICABLE |
|---|
| 1 | 09935183 | CARLOS LOO KUNG | 12/07/2017 | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION AND LENGTH OF SERVICE |
| 2 | 44725112 | JOSÉ VASQUEZ | 15/01/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE LENGTH OF SERVICE |
| 3 | 08275934 | SANDRA BARCLAY | 31/01/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION |
| 4 | 44726292 | SERAPIO TICONA | 01/03/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE LENGTH OF SERVICE |
| 5 | 42939905 | LUIS DUEÑAS | 10/04/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE POSITION |
| 6 | 23804316 | JORGE POLO Y LA BORDA | 19/04/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORKPLACE, POSITION AND LENGTH OF SERVICE |
| 7 | 29239647 | EVA MONROY | 02/05/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORKPLACE, POSITION AND LENGTH OF SERVICE |
| 8 | 44726484 | AQUILA ROJAS | 03/05/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORKPLACE, POSITION AND LENGTH OF SERVICE |
| 9 | 44726692 | EULOGIA MAYHUIRI | 22/05/2018 | DOES NOT INDICATE WORKPLACE AND POSITION |
- In this regard, Sura SAF, starting from not taking into account the existence of the inspection team's working document (Excel), points out that it is intended to sanction it for an alleged breach referring to only three (3) cases out of an extremely larger universe of clients. It specifies that the alleged breach represented 0.03% and 0.027% of all participants managed by Sura SAF in 2017 and 2018, respectively;
- However, this statement is also inaccurate because even in the denied assumption that the imputation refers only to three (3) clients, it originates from the review of the documentation of a sample of thirty-one (31) natural person clients out of a total of forty-three (43) of the total sample selected (which includes both natural and legal persons) by the inspection team, so the breach percentage must be calculated in relation to the number of clients in the reviewed sample of natural persons and not to the totality of Sura SAF's clients in a given period. In this case, the breach percentage would be approximately 10% of the sample of natural persons;
- Nevertheless, it should be highlighted that the imputed observations are limited to nine (9) clients of the sample of thirty-one (31) natural person clients, so the breach percentage represents almost one third (29%). Consequently, these omissions in the recording of client information in the DDCC procedure cannot be minimized as Sura SAF attempts in its defenses;
- It should be noted that the aforementioned observations indicated in the working document (Excel) called "Client Due Diligence Sample" and in the Letter of Charges have not been disproved by Sura SAF in its defenses with the copy of the mutual fund management contracts or other documents used for the DDCC of each of the nine (9) mentioned clients, where it can be observed that the information such as "time of service", "work center" or "position held" has been recorded;
- Regarding the DDCC procedures alleged by Sura SAF in order to disprove the existence of a breach of the regulations, it should be indicated that what it describes does not invalidate the imputed charge because, as stated, in its defenses, it has not presented evidence that lifts the observation formulated by the Letter of Charges based on the inspectors' documentation;
- Finally, regarding the principle of reasonableness alleged by Sura SAF, it should be indicated that this will be taken into account at the time of determining the corresponding sanction;
- Regarding legal persons
On the identification of directors and shareholders, partners or associates
- In its defenses, Sura SAF attaches the sworn declaration forms regarding the clients HSPA Corp., Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A. and DU Cóndor S.A.; in these formats the following question is observed: do your directors and shareholders, partners or associates have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation in the company?, and as answer options, "Yes" and "No". The answer in the case of HSPA Corp. and DU Cóndor S.A. is "No" and in the case of Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A. no answer is observed;
- In this regard, it should be noted that subsection d) of numeral 7.2 of article 7 of the Plaft Rules, in force at the date of the events, obliges the entity to record the "identification of directors and shareholders, partners or associates, who have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation of the legal person, considering the information required for natural persons, as applicable, identifying those who are PEP."
- That is, said article on the one hand obliges the entity to identify the directors of the legal person, if applicable, and on the other hand, the shareholders, partners or associates, who have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation of the legal person;
- It should be specified that the cited subsection d) does not refer to the obligation to identify directors who have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation of the legal person, but only that it be stated who the directors are, since the objective is for the entity to identify the persons who are members of the board of directors in charge of the administration of a company, in addition to one or more managers. That is why, in complement to this requirement, the entity is obliged to identify the "administrators"[9];
- Therefore, requiring that the obligated subject only identify directors who have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation of the legal person, implies limiting the due knowledge of the legal person client, given that not all directors necessarily have a representative participation in the share capital, such as independent directors or directors of publicly traded corporations;
- Therefore, taking into account the aforementioned, it is concluded that the sworn declaration format that the clients filled out is wrong in the part of the question: do your directors and shareholders, partners or associates have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation in the company? Therefore, the correct wording is that the format asks about the shareholders, partners or associates who have directly or indirectly more than 5% of the share capital, contribution or participation in the company and, on the other hand, that it asks whether the legal person has directors and, if applicable, have the field enabled for the registration of directors;
- Consequently, given what has been explained and taking into account the provisions of subsection d) of numeral 7.2 of article 7 of the PLAFT Rules, Sura SAF has not disproved the charge in the extreme referring to the fact that the information of directors is not recorded, even in the forms there is no field to record this information, in relation to the clients HSPA Corp., Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A. and DU Cóndor S.A.;
On the legal persons linked to the client
- In this regard, it should be noted that in the Letter of Charges Sura SAF was imputed that in the forms used for the DDCC the information of the legal persons that according to the regulations on linkage and economic group qualify as linked to the client was not recorded, that is, it was not indicated;
- On the matter, Sura SAF argues that it did request the pertinent information from the clients, through the sworn declarations, and attaches the forms of said declarations of the clients HSPA Corp., Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A. and DU Cóndor S.A., duly signed by the legal representatives of these legal persons; in these formats, the following requirement is observed: Indicate the legal persons related or linked to the company and the corresponding field to fill in the information. In the three (3) forms it is observed that the corresponding fields are empty, that is, no information was filled in;
- Taking into account the aforementioned, it is not possible for this Deputy Superintendence to evidence whether the three (3) legal person clients did not fill in the information because they have no linked legal persons or because it was an omission in the recording of information;
- There is only Sura SAF's statement in its defenses regarding that it has proven that it requested the information and that it also has procedures for verifying the recorded information, such as the one in the SUNAT, and for subsequent monitoring of clients who have left certain fields of the forms empty, which is feasible to verify in subsequent supervision work;
- Likewise, it should be noted that a search of public information has been carried out on the SUNAT website (https://e-consultaruc.sunat.gob.pe) of the companies domiciled Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A. and DU Cóndor S.A. and there is no record of information of legal persons linked to these companies, and neither are these companies registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market as supervised entities or members of an economic group of which a supervised entity is part;
- Therefore, taking into account the aforementioned, the filing of the imputed charge in this extreme corresponds;
On the Statement of Financial Position and Income Statement
- It should be noted that in the Letter of Charges Sura SAF was imputed that in the files of the observed clients it is not evidenced that Sura SAF has collected the financial statements of the clients;
- On the matter, Sura SAF argues that in the sworn declaration it requests information on "profits of the last fiscal year" and "average monthly income", in order to know the financial position and income statement of the clients. As stated above, Sura SAF attached to its defenses the forms corresponding to the clients HSPA Corp., Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A. and DU Cóndor S.A.;
- However, in the three (3) forms no information has been filled in on "profits of the last fiscal year" and "average monthly income". Notwithstanding this, it should be specified that the "profits of the last fiscal year" and the "average monthly income" do not show all the information presented by the Statement of Financial Position and the Income Statement, and the regulations require that these two (2) financial statements be available for the due knowledge of the legal person client;
- On the other hand, regarding the company Ferreyros S.A., Sura SAF argues that the financial statements of this company could be found and validated on the pages of the SMV, the Lima Stock Exchange, among others, and attaches the financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of the company Ferreycorp S.A.A. However, as can be verified in the content of these financial statements, which it attaches, and in the websites of the SMV and the Lima Stock Exchange, which it indicates, the company Ferreycorp S.A.A. is a legal person different from the company Ferreyros S.A.; the first is a holding and the second is one of the subsidiaries of this holding. Therefore, having the financial statements of Ferreycorp S.A.A. does not remedy the fact that it has not collected the financial statements of Ferreyros S.A.;
- Likewise, regarding the modification of the Internal Operating Procedures Manual, communicated on December 28, 2018 to the SMV, to establish that, through the designated commercial areas, a copy of the financial statements be requested from clients, it should be noted that this fact is subsequent to the events and, notwithstanding this, does not remedy the omission of not collecting financial statements from clients, especially since it has not accredited that said commercial areas and others have formulated the request for the observed information;
- Finally, it should be noted that the review of the information of private credit bureaus such as "Equifax", which Sura SAF mentions in its defenses, also does not remedy the omission of not collecting financial statements from clients, because credit bureaus show a credit level and financial behavior of persons, but not the amount of assets, liabilities, income, expenses, profits, equity, among others, of a legal person, which are shown in the financial statements;
- Consequently, Sura SAF has not disproved the imputation referring to the fact that in the clients' files it is not evidenced that it has collected the financial statements of the clients HSPA Corp., Inversiones Sí Don Luis S.A., DU Cóndor S.A. and Ferreyros S.A.;
- For the above, it is evidenced that Sura SAF has breached the provisions of numeral 7.2 of article 7 of the PLAFT Rules;
Failure to accredit the required updating for clients to whom the intensified DDCC procedure applies
- It should be noted that in the Letter of Charges Sura SAF was imputed that it would not have carried out an annual update of the profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, regarding five (5) clients, mentioned in Table No. 4. This table specifies that the annual update of clients numbered 1 to 5 is not observed as of November 2017, October 2017, March 2018, August 2018 and June 2018, respectively;
- On the matter, Sura SAF argues that regarding the imputed charge a case of voluntary remediation is configured because on December 28, 2018 it communicated to the SMV as an action plan the modification of the Operating Procedures Manual, which now indicates that "all clients with high risk level will undergo an annual verification that will include updating the Compliance Tracker search, the certificate will be saved in the client's file (documentum)." Therefore, Sura SAF would comply to date with the obligation to update the data and review the background of its clients and that the remediation was by its own and spontaneous will, before the notification of the Letter of Charges;
- Regarding what Sura SAF argues, it should be noted that the imputed charge does not refer precisely to the fact that the management company is not carrying out the annual update as of the date of imputation of the charges (February 2021) or that its internal procedures do not contemplate that it must carry out an annual update in the cases that correspond, as indicated by the Plaft Rules, in such a way that the alleged voluntary remediation can be evaluated;
- It should be specified that the imputed charge refers to the fact that Sura SAF did not carry out the annual update of the profile, background and documentation as of November 2017 for the client COFIDE Fideicomiso Gobierno Regional San Martín; as of October 2017 for the client Rita Rosario Flores Tipismana; as of March 2018 for the client Alfonso Jiménez Trelle; as of August 2018 for the client Rosa[10] María Ortiz Ríos; and as of June 2018 for the client HPSA Corporation. It should be noted that in the defenses, Sura SAF has not presented documentation regarding the update as of 2017 and 2018 of the profile, background and documentation of the mentioned clients, in the periods corresponding to each of them, which ratifies the infraction incurred;
- It should be specified that according to the annex to the defenses presented, the update of the Operating Procedures Manual of Sura SAF was carried out in March 2019[11], so, taking into account the annual updates of the profile, background and documentation would be being carried out since that month, these are subsequent to the months of October and November 2017 and March, June and August 2018, which are the imputed periods. Consequently, and notwithstanding that the observation does not refer to the fact that the referred Manual includes the obligations contained in the PLAFT rules, such subsequent actions do not relieve said management company from compliance with the observed regulations, since it has not accredited that those have contributed to remedying the imputed infraction regarding the observed periods, that is, the 2017 and 2018 fiscal years;
- Notwithstanding the above, it should be highlighted that the facts that are the subject of the charge, among others, were observed (before March 2019) by the IGSE through Letter No. 6657-2018-SMV/10.2 of December 3, 2018 addressed to Sura SAF, indicating that "the application of reinforced procedures is not evidenced, such as the minimum review (at least once a year) of the client's profile, background, documentation, among other aspects, as specified by the LAFT Rule." In response, Sura SAF replied by letter of December 28, 2018, referred to in the defenses;
- Regarding this, it should be indicated that subsection f) of article 27 of the New Sanctions Regulation requires that for the configuration of the exemption for voluntary remediation, no communication demanding compliance with the obligation must have been sent. Therefore, even though the observation does not refer to the fact that the referred Manual includes the obligations contained in the PLAFT rules; the modification of the Operating Procedures Manual, by which Sura SAF would be complying to date with the obligation to update the data and review the background of its clients, was not an action by its own and spontaneous will, as it states in its defenses and is also not applicable to the analysis;
- For the above, it is demonstrated that there was no alleged voluntary remediation alleged by Sura SAF regarding the imputed facts, nor that it occurred before the notification of charges, in the terms stated by Sura SAF, since the SMV observed the alleged breach since December 3, 2018;
- In conclusion, Sura SAF has also not disproved the charge in this extreme and consequently it is evidenced that Sura SAF has breached article 7, numeral 7.4 and numeral 7.5, subsection c) of the Plaft Rules;
IV. EVALUATION OF THE SANCTION
- The administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the provisions established in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, whose Single Ordered Text was approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF (hereinafter, LMV), the Sanctions Regulation, the New Sanctions Regulation and the TUO LPAG;
- In accordance with the regulations, the determination of the sanction will be made in accordance with article 348 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, whose Single Ordered Text was approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF (hereinafter, LMV), article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation and article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO LPAG[12];
- Within this framework, the evaluation of this sanction must consider: a) Background of the offender; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right; c) The damage caused and the repercussion on the market; d) Recidivism[13]; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender; h) The probability of detection of the infraction; and, i) The acknowledgment of responsibility of the offender and its contribution to the clarification of the infraction;
- In relation to the background of the offender, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation and article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, the sanctions imposed by the SMV that became final within the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction constitute background;
- Regarding the infraction referring to not keeping, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books and records occurred on June 30, 2018, Sura SAF has the following infraction backgrounds:
- Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 048-2014-SMV/10 of December 31, 2014, through which Sura SAF is sanctioned with a fine of 12.015 UIT for having incurred ten (10) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation for having submitted periodic and timely information outside the established deadline.
It should be indicated that said sanction has become final in the administrative instance since it was not subject to challenge.
- Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 027-2016-SMV/10 of July 8, 2016, through which Sura SAF is sanctioned with six (06) warnings and a fine of 24.54 UIT, for having incurred nineteen infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation for having submitted periodic and timely information outside the established deadline.
It should be indicated that said sanction was subject to reconsideration by Sura SAF which was resolved by Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 70-2017-SMV/10 declaring said reconsideration unfounded.
- Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 018-2017-SMV/10 of March 28, 2017, through which Sura SAF is sanctioned with three warnings and a fine of 5.884 UIT for having incurred six (06) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation for having submitted periodic and timely information outside the established deadline.
It should be indicated that said sanction was subject to reconsideration by Sura SAF which was resolved by Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 061-2017-SMV/10 declaring said reconsideration inadmissible.
- Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 111-2017-SMV/10 of November 11, 2017, through which Sura SAF is sanctioned with a fine of one (01) UIT for having incurred one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation for not having complied with the provisions of the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing, regarding the submission within the established deadline of the Annual Independent Compliance Report.
It should be indicated that said sanction was subject to appeal by Sura SAF which was resolved by Superintendent Resolution No. 098-2018-SMV/02 declaring said appeal unfounded;
- Regarding the infraction referring to failure to carry out the client due diligence process in accordance with the regulations on prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing that occurred between June 2017 and August 2018, Sura SAF has the same infraction background indicated above;
- Regarding the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, in this case it has not been possible to prove that Sura SAF's conduct in committing the infractions in this sanctioning procedure has caused damage to the public interest;
- However, in relation to the infraction referring to failure to keep the books and records in the manner required by the regulations, it must be taken into account that the checking accounts centralize all deposits from subscriptions, sales or interbank transfers, as well as expenditures for the purchase of investments and amortization of obligations contracted by the fund, so the bank reconciliation procedure established as part of the accounting rules allows identifying differences between bank balances and accounting balances at the same date in order to investigate these differences and regularize or correct the balances in a timely manner;
- In this sense, an adequate reconciliation between the banking information and the records and books of the management company contributes to the transparency and consistency that all information provided not only to the fund's participants but also to the market must follow;
- Regarding the infraction referring to failure to apply the CDD procedure to the observed clients of the management company, it must be indicated that within the framework of the rules for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, the principle of knowledge of the client allows management companies to collect information from their clients, which in turn allows comparing the characteristics of their clients' transactions with those of their economic activity, continuously monitoring the clients' operations, and having elements of judgment that allow analyzing unusual transactions of those clients and determining the existence of suspicious operations;
- Given the above, it must be indicated that the process of proper client identification is a key component within the regulatory framework of the securities market, which allows the achievement of its objectives such as the protection of investors, ensuring that markets are fair, efficient and transparent; as well as the prevention of illegal use of the securities market, which helps prevent the occurrence of fraud and market abuse practices; as well as money laundering and terrorist financing. In this sense, effective client identification and procedures for that purpose are necessary for market transparency, investor protection and to maintain market integrity;
- Regarding the harm caused and the impact on the market, it should be noted that it has not been possible to evidence that the infractions incurred by Sura SAF in this sanctioning procedure have caused any concrete economic harm to market participants or have had an impact on the market;
- In relation to recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the date the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, it must be indicated that Sura SAF does not present sanctions, within the aforementioned period, for the commission of the same infractions subject to analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infractions, it must be indicated that Sura SAF, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, knows the rules that regulate the securities market and in that sense, is aware of the obligations contained in the PLAFT Rules, the Regulation and the Accounting Rules;
- In the Inspection carried out, the activities and controls carried out by Sura SAF for the period from June 1 to 30, 2018 were evaluated, as well as the evaluation of the main accounting balances presented in the financial statements of the Short Term Fund as of June 30, 2018, identifying that the bank reconciliations as of June 30, 2018 did not support the accounting balances in banks of the Accounts at the same date and that the bank reconciliation procedure presented deficiencies. In this regard, the bank reconciliations presented to the inspection team contained errors in their balances according to banks and in their reconciling items;
- Sura SAF has stated that this was due to an involuntary error when the monthly bank reconciliation was carried out by its accounting area by erroneously considering a bank statement corresponding to another period and that this did not affect its accounting balances. However, it is observed that in its modified bank reconciliations, presented in its defenses, in addition to correcting balances according to banks, they modify reconciling items, with respect to the original reconciliations;
- On the other hand, in the client knowledge procedure that Sura SAF continuously carries out, knowing the obligations contained in the PLAFT Rules, it was determined that with respect to the observed clients, it did not evidence the information and documentation that supports the CDD procedures nor the required updating for clients to whom the intensified CDD procedure applies, in order to acquire sufficient and updated knowledge of these clients and final beneficiaries, and thus manage the ML/TF risks to which it is exposed in its business relationships;
- In this administrative sanctioning procedure, it has not been proven that Sura SAF has obtained any illicit benefit as a result of having incurred the infractions subject to analysis;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it must be noted that no intentionality has been verified, in this administrative sanctioning procedure, in Sura SAF's conduct regarding the imputed infractions analyzed;
- Regarding the probability of detection of the infractions, it must be indicated that the facts constituting the infractions committed by Sura SAF, which are analyzed, were evidenced as a result of the supervision and control actions carried out by the SMV regarding the regulations governing the activities of fund management companies. The infractions were detected in an inspection carried out at Sura SAF's offices, and as a consequence of the review and analysis of the information and documentation provided by the management company only in this diligence. Therefore, the probability of detection of these infractions was low;
- Regarding the acknowledgment of responsibility by the offender and its contribution to the clarification of the infractions, it has not acknowledged the commission of the infractions subject to this sanctioning procedure, limiting itself only to the presentation of its defenses;
- In relation to the mitigating circumstances of responsibility, it must be indicated that it is not observed that any of the assumptions that constitute mitigating conditions of responsibility have been configured in this procedure;
- Regarding the exempting conditions of responsibility and in relation to what was alleged by Sura SAF regarding voluntary correction, it must be noted that according to article 255, numeral 1, literal f) of the TUO LPAG, the following constitutes an exemption from responsibility for the infraction committed: "The voluntary correction[14] of the act or omission constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges (…)";
- In this sense, from the normative text it is noted that for voluntary correction to apply as an exemption from responsibility, two (02) actions must concur before the notification of charges: i) the cessation of the infringing conduct voluntarily[15], that is, the adaptation of the conduct to the norm; and, ii) repair, remedy a defect or compensate a damage caused, derived from the improper action (correction of the effects derived from that infringing conduct). Therefore, if a conduct cannot be reversed or repaired or it is not possible to compensate the damage produced by the commission of the infraction, it will not be eligible for correction;
- In this context, it is pertinent to specify that the RAE defines voluntary as "an act that is born of the will, and not by force or necessity external to it, "not obligation or duty". Likewise, regarding the voluntariness of an action, the RAE defines that it is by "mere whim and without any other reason for what is resolved". From this, it can be deduced that a certain action or performance is voluntary when it is not subject to obligations or duties;
- Along these lines, Morón Urbina indicates that one of the requirements that configures said exempting condition requires that "(…) the correction of the infringing conduct occurs voluntarily or spontaneously, that is, it must be carried out without coming from a mandate of the authority. That is, it would not be voluntary if there were already a requirement or coercive measure of the authority or another similar document through which the administered is requested to correct the act or omission that can be classified as an infraction"[16]*;
- In that order of ideas, the correction of the infringing conduct must be the product of the free initiative of the administered, that is, it adapts its behavior to the legal system without any requirement or request by the administration or any coercive measure; and therefore it will cease to be voluntary when there are requirements made by the administrative authority or the application of any coercive measure, since from the moment such requirement exists, the correction of the conduct will cease to be by the administered's own initiative, that is, it will cease to be voluntary;
- On this matter, Sura SAF has stated in its defenses that for the two imputed infractions, the assumption of exemption from responsibility should be applied because it corrected the two imputed infractions before the notification of the Office of Charges, in application of article 257 of the TUO LPAG and article 27, literal f) of the New Sanctions Regulation.
- As explained above in the evaluation of the defenses presented, the facts subject to imputation were previously brought to the attention of Sura SAF by this Superintendency through Office No. 6657-2018-SMV/10.2 dated December 3, 2018, that is, before the start of this administrative sanctioning procedure and as a consequence of what was found in the inspection carried out by the SMV. In this sense, through the referred office, the management company was required to communicate, within a period no greater than twenty (20) business days counted from the notification thereof, the actions to be adopted or action plan established that lead to correcting the incidents determined during the inspection.
- In this sense, and taking into account that article 27, literal f) of the New Sanctions Regulation provides that voluntary correction constitutes an exemption provided that no communication has been sent requiring compliance with the obligation, and that the voluntariness of correcting the imputed facts has not been proven, the request made by Sura SAF is not admissible insofar as it was detected in the inspection and required by the cited Office No. 6657-2018-SMV/10.2;
- Therefore, Sura SAF has incurred an infraction classified as serious typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Failure to keep or maintain updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files";
- Likewise, Sura SAF has incurred two (02) infractions classified as serious typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Failure to carry out the client due diligence process, in accordance with the regulations on prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, in the cases that according to the provisions of said regulation its application corresponds";
- In accordance with article 21 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the date the facts occurred, said infractions are punishable with a fine greater than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) Tax Units (UIT) or with suspension of the authorization to operate for up to twenty (20) days;
- It should be noted that the New Sanctions Regulation states that said infractions are punishable with a fine not less than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) UIT or with suspension of the authorization to operate for up to twenty (20) days. It must be indicated that said norm will be the applicable one to this case as it is more favorable;
- Finally, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO LPAG, which states that sanctions must be proportional to the non-compliances classified as infractions, and, considering that it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed have caused damage to the public interest, nor that they have had an impact on the market, or that the management company has obtained any illicit benefit from their commission, that no intentionality was evidenced in its conduct and that the management company is not a recidivist regarding the referred infraction, this General Intendancy considers that it is possible to impose on Sura SAF a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided for serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of the third paragraph of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation.
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments.
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C. has incurred one (1) infraction of a serious nature, typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF-94.10, for having failed to comply with articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation of Mutual Funds of Investment in Securities and their Management Companies approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 068-2010-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments, the first paragraph of the Accounting Rules for Mutual Funds of Investment in Securities approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 628-1997-EF/94.1 and the comment of account "10 Cash and Banks" of the Chart of Accounts for Mutual Funds of Investment in Securities, by failing to keep or maintain updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files.
- Declare that Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C. has incurred one (1) infraction of a serious nature, typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF-94.10, in force at the time the facts occurred, for having failed to comply with article 7, numeral 7.2 of the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and/or Terrorist Financing, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments, by failing to evidence the information and documentation that supports the due diligence procedures of client knowledge.
- Declare that Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C. has incurred one (1) infraction of a serious nature, typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF-94.10, in force at the time the facts occurred, for having failed to comply with article 7, numerals 7.4 and 7.5, literal c) of the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and/or Terrorist Financing, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments, by failing to evidence the required updating for clients to whom the intensified due diligence procedure of client knowledge applies.
- Sanction Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C. with 8 UIT equivalent to S/ 32,400.00 (Thirty-two thousand four hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of articles 1, 2 and 3 of this resolution.
- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal, presented before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the event that this resolution is not challenged through a reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes consented, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- Transcribe this resolution to Fondos Sura Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.C.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
The accounts are: Collection No. 6629687 and Investment No. 6629695 and No. 3341951. ↑
-
HUAPAYA, Ramón, SANCHEZ, Lucio and ALEJOS, Oscar. "The exemption from responsibility for voluntary correction in the General Administrative Procedure Law of Peru. In: "Administrative Law as an instrument at the service of the citizen". Lima: Palestra Editorial ↑
-
(…)
From the review of bank reconciliations as of June 30, 2018 of the SURA Short Term Soles FMIV fund, deficiencies are noted in the data used in the bank reconciliation, because the balances of the bank accounts of Scotiabank do not match the balances shown according to the respective bank statements of said accounts, at the same date. Likewise, from the review of the reconciling items between the balances according to banks and those recorded in the accounting books for said fund, the following differences are noted:
The described would evidence deficiencies in the controls applied in the processing of bank reconciliations of the funds under management of Fondos Sura, and in the processing of accounting information related to said items. ↑
-
It should be noted that this type of infraction has been included in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.6 of the New Sanctions Regulation ↑
-
The DCCC form does not have the field to record the information of directors and shareholders. Regarding shareholders, in the forms of these clients it is recorded as a declaration that they do not have more than 5% of the company's share capital. Furthermore, it was noted that the directors and shareholders are not PEPs. ↑
-
CASSAGNE, Juan Carlos. "Administrative procedure and process". First edition. Buenos Aires: Abeledo Perrot, 2005. p.75. ↑
-
"3.5 When the obligated subject is part of an economic group, it must include policies and procedures at the group level in matters of prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, including policies and procedures for the exchange of information within the group, as well as for the adequate protection, confidentiality and use of said information". ↑
-
Article 177.- Means of proof
The facts invoked or that are conducive to deciding a procedure may be subject to all necessary means of proof, except those prohibited by express provision. In particular, in the administrative procedure it is appropriate:
-
Gather background and documents.
-
Request reports and opinions of any type.
-
Grant hearing to the administered, interrogate witnesses and experts, or obtain from them written statements.
-
Consult documents and minutes.
-
Carry out ocular inspections. ↑
-
Literal g) of numeral 7.2 of article 7 of the Plaft Rules. ↑
-
Due to a typographical error, "Rita" was written instead of "Rosa" in the imputed charge, and it should be indicated that, in attention to the documents and files delivered by Sura SAF to the SMV inspection team, the management company knew which client the imputed observation referred to, for which reason, and with the clarification made, it is not admissible to maintain that it does not know the client subject to comment. ↑
-
In the letter of December 28, 2018, which is in this file, Sura SAF indicated as the commitment date for the modification of the Manual of Operating Procedures March 31, 2019. ↑
-
"Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
3. Reasonableness.- The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, observing the following criteria that are indicated for the purposes of their graduation:
a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction;
b) The probability of detection of the infraction;
c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest;
d) The economic harm caused;
e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the date the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final.
f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and
g) The existence or non-existence of intent in the conduct of the offender". ↑
13. The sanctioning criteria referring to Recidivism and the Probability of detection of the infraction were introduced by Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272, which amended, among others, Article 230; numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
14. According to the Royal Spanish Academy (RAE), subsanar means "To excuse or pardon a mistake or offense"; "To repair or remedy a defect" or "To compensate for a damage". ↑
15. According to the Dictionary of the Royal Spanish Academy, the term voluntario or voluntaria has as one of its meanings "That which is done by spontaneous will and not by obligation or duty". ↑
16. Morón, Juan Carlos (2017). Commentaries on the General Administrative Procedure Law. Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444. Volume II. Twelfth Edition. Gaceta Jurídica: Lima. P. 513. ↑