SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 080-2017-SMV/10
Summary: Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of three (03) UIT, equivalent to S/. 11,400.00 (Eleven thousand four hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred one (01) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex VII, item 1, numeral 1.15, of the Sanctions Regulation, because the Internal Control Officer did not perform his duties as provided in the Mutual Funds Regulation, by not reporting to the body on which he depends the results of his supervision work and by not performing his duties on an exclusive basis.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2016044605 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
HAVING SEEN:
The administrative file No. 2016044605 and Report No. 817-2017-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; and the arguments presented by Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora S.A. (hereinafter, Scotia Fondos);
WHEREAS:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- Within the supervision and control activities assigned to the SMV, through Official Letter No. 1473-2015-SMV/10.2, an inspection visit to Scotia Fondos was ordered, in order to verify compliance with the regulations applicable to the development of its functions. Said inspection was carried out from April 14, 2015 to May 6, 2015 (hereinafter, 2015 Inspection);
- With Report No. 008-2016-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities (hereinafter, Igse) communicated to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (hereinafter, Igcp) the results of the evaluation of the indications of non-compliance with the Mutual Funds Investment Regulation and their Management Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 068-2010-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments, in force at the time of the commission of the facts (hereinafter, Mutual Funds Regulation), by Scotia Fondos;
- With Official Letter No. 7110-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against Scotia Fondos, imputing charges for having contravened the provisions established in the Mutual Funds Regulation;
- By document received on December 14, 2016, Scotia Fondos presented its arguments;
- The charges formulated, as well as the arguments presented by Scotia Fondos, have been evaluated in Report No. 817-2017-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the consideration of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, item 1, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title, as well as in Article 246, item 2 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS (hereinafter, Tuo de la Lpag), through Official Letter No. 5130-2017-SMV/10, the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made available to Scotia Fondos for its review;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative sanctioning procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not Scotia Fondos incurred an infraction of the provisions of Annex VII, item 1, numeral 1.15 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), by not complying its Internal Control Officer (hereinafter, Fci) with the functions or provisions in accordance with the established in Article 5, second, fourth and sixth paragraphs of the Mutual Funds Regulation;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on Scotia Fondos for the aforementioned;
III. Analysis
Of the Internal Control Officer
-
- Of the Applicable Regulations
- Article 5, second, fourth and sixth paragraphs, of the Mutual Funds Regulation, in force at the time of the commission of the facts, establishes the functions and obligations that the Fci of a management company must comply with, as well as the nature of the position[1], which is detailed below:
"Article 5.- Internal Control
(….)
The internal control officer must be designated by the board of directors of the management company and in its absence by the general shareholders' meeting and shall depend on the body that designated him. In no case may the internal control officer depend on the general manager.
(….)
The internal control officer must perform his duties on an exclusive basis, with independence and neutrality with respect to any other activity that could generate a conflict of interest in the management company. Within this framework, the internal control officer may not be the general manager, managers, members of the investment committee, or the accountant of the management company and must not be subject to the prohibitions established in Article 25, item d), of the Regulation.
(…)
The internal control officer must report to the body on which he depends, through a bimonthly report, the results of his supervision work, detailing the activities carried out and the events observed. It is the responsibility of the internal control officer to correctly file these reports and the respective supporting documents or information that complements them. (…)";
- By material fact of March 24, 2014, Scotia Fondos communicated that the Board of Directors of the management company, meeting on March 21 of that year, designated Mrs. Paola Katherine Gonzales Gonzales (hereinafter, Mrs. Gonzales) as Fci of Scotia Fondos, assuming functions from March 24 of that year;
- From the review of the Minutes of the Board of Directors Meetings of May 13, July 31, September 30, November 28, 2014 and January 30, 2015, it was observed that it was the General Manager Mr. Gonzalo Javier Presa Carbajal (hereinafter, Mr. Presa) who was responsible for presenting to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos the Bimonthly Reports (hereinafter, Reports) of the Fci of the company. By way of example, the content of the Minutes of the Board Meeting of May 13, 2014 is described[2]:
"BIMONTHLY REPORT OF THE INTERNAL CONTROL OFFICER
Mr. Gonzales-Taboada gave the floor to the General Manager of the company, Mr. Gonzalo Presa Carbajal, who presented to the Board the Bimonthly Internal Control Report No. 02-2014-CI corresponding to the period from March 1 to April 30, 2014, prepared by the Internal Control Officer, which had been previously distributed to the directors by electronic means, regarding which he explained its most relevant aspects.
The Board took note and after a brief exchange of opinions unanimously approved the Bimonthly Internal Control Report for the aforementioned period, presented by Mr. Presa";
- As additional information, in Memoranda No. 18-SFSAF and 01-SFSAF, of November 27, 2014 and January 28, 2015, respectively, it is evident that it was Mr. Presa who sent - attached to the indicated documents - the Bimonthly Reports of the Fifth and Sixth Bimester of 2014, prepared by the Fci of Scotia Fondos;
- Additionally, the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos, meeting on April 25, 2014, granted administrative powers to the Fci, Mrs. Gonzales, according to the following:
"a) issue on behalf of the companies invoices, cancellations, receipts and settlements, as well as receive and collect any sum owed to the company, as well as pay in all forms; b) require payment from the company's debtors; c) designate legal, financial or technical advisors, set their attributions, responsibilities, remunerations and arrange their separation; and, e) organize the administrative, accounting, financial, procurement and other regime"
- It should be noted that the indicated powers were registered in Electronic File No. 11026563, Title No. 00026499, of the Registry of Legal Persons of Lima of the National Superintendency of Public Registries – SUNARP, these powers were in force until May 22, 2015, the date on which Mrs. Gonzales resigned from the position of Fci of Scotia Fondos;
- On the other hand, the letter of December 26, 2014 responding to Requirement No. 220-S-2014000504 of December 16, 2014 formulated by Mrs. María Silvia Rodríguez, participant of the Fund called "Scotia Fondos Premium $ FMIV" (hereinafter, the Fund), was signed by Mrs. Marisol Trucios Loayza, Head of the Operations Department of Scotia Fondos, and the Fci of Scotia Fondos, Mrs. Gonzales;
- In the Board meeting of May 22, 2015, the resignation of Mrs. Gonzales from the position of Fci of Scotia Fondos was accepted. Likewise, the powers granted to Mrs. Gonzales were revoked as of the indicated date, which are registered in Entry C00032 of Electronic File No. 11026563 of the Registry of Legal Persons of Lima;
- By Official Letter No. 2343-2015-SMV/10.2 of May 28, 2015, the Igse sent the observations determined in the inspection to Scotia Fondos; therefore, by Letter of July 8, 2015, it responded to them;
- Of the charge formulated
- According to the Letter of Charges, charges were imputed for the following:
- Presentation of the Bimonthly Reports prepared by the FCI to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos
- According to the facts indicated, it was observed that the Reports prepared by the FCI, a position held by Mrs. Gonzales, were presented to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos by Mr. Presa, General Manager of Scotia Fondos, as can be seen in the Minutes of the Board Meetings of May 31, July 31, September 30 and November 28, 2014 and January 30, 2015 (hereinafter, Minutes);
- Likewise, in Memoranda No. 18-SFSAF and 01-SFSAF, of November 27, 2014 and January 28, 2015, respectively, it is verified that it was Mr. Presa who sent the Reports corresponding to the fifth and sixth bimester of 2014;
- In this sense, Scotia Fondos, by allowing the General Manager of the management company, Mr. Presa, to present the Reports prepared by the Fci to the Board, would have contravened Article 5, second and sixth paragraphs of the Mutual Funds Regulation, which states that the Fci, being designated by the Board of Directors of the management company, depends on said body; and, therefore, must report to the body on which it depends, through a bimonthly report, the results of its supervision work, detailing the activities carried out and the events observed; however, in the present case it was Mr. Presa, General Manager of Scotia Fondos, who reported said reports to the Board;
- Administrative Powers granted by the Board to the FCI
- According to what was observed in the Minutes of the Board Meeting of Scotia Fondos of April 25, 2014, the Board granted different administrative powers to the Fci, Mrs. Gonzales, such as, for example, requiring payment from the company's debtors, issuing on behalf of the company invoices, cancellations, receipts, among other powers that were in force until May 22, 2015, the date on which Mrs. Gonzales resigned from the position of Fci of Scotia Fondos;
- By virtue of the above, it is observed that the administrative powers would not be in accordance with the internal control functions proper to an Fci and, therefore, the regulation would have been breached to the extent that the Fci cannot perform administrative tasks in addition to its internal control tasks, since the Fci's tasks are on an exclusive basis, and must be performed with independence and neutrality with respect to any activity that could generate a conflict of interest in the management company;
- In this sense, Scotia Fondos would have infringed the provisions of Article 5, fourth paragraph, of the Mutual Funds Regulation;
- Participation of the FCI in the Attention of claims presented to Scotia Fondos by the participants
- As set forth, by letter of December 26, 2014, Requirement No. 220-S-2014000504 of December 16, 2014 formulated by the participant of the Fund, Mrs. María Silvia Rodríguez, is resolved; said letter was signed by Mrs. Marisol Trucios Loayza, Head of the Operations Department of Scotia Fondos, and also by Mrs. Gonzales, Fci of Scotia Fondos;
- On the matter, the Fci, Mrs. Gonzales, by signing the document mentioned in the previous consideration, would have participated in activities that are part of the management of the mutual funds administered by Scotia Fondos, activities that could have conflicted with the Fci's own functions; such as the supervision - subsequently - of the consultations, claims and, in general, of the service provided to the participant by the management company, which adjust to the procedures, deadlines and other rules that - for this purpose - are established by the management company; function recognized in Article 6, item e), of the Mutual Funds Regulation[3], an activity that the Fci is understood to control;
- That is, by actively participating in the claims attention process, its control functions would be affected, which could not be on an exclusive basis, since this puts at risk the independence and neutrality in the exercise of its activities, with respect to any other activity that could generate a conflict of interest in the management company. In this sense, Scotia Fondos would have infringed Article 5, fourth paragraph, of the Mutual Funds Regulation, since it allowed the Fci not to dedicate itself exclusively to its functions, nor to perform them with independence and neutrality;
- Of the Arguments and their Evaluation
A) On the presentation of the bimonthly reports prepared by the FCI to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos
- On the matter, Scotia Fondos states that the Fci has not failed to comply with the exercise of the functions and provisions that apply to it as provided in the referred norm, since at no time has it depended on the General Manager, nor has it reported to him, the presentation of the Bimonthly Audit Reports of 2014 as indicated in the Letter of Charges;
- They add that as indicated in their response letter to Official Letter No. 2343-2015-SMV, the Bimonthly Audit Reports of 2014 prepared by Mrs. Gonzales, in her capacity as Fci, were read before the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos by the General Manager, Mr. Presa, who acted as secretary of the meeting and had no involvement in their preparation or drafting, a situation that is also not questioned in the imputation of charges;
- In this sense, the management company reiterates that it was the same Fci, the person who sent in advance and from her email, to the email of Mr. Carlos Carrillo Arteaga (hereinafter, Mr. Carrillo), Manager of the General Secretariat of Banco Scotiabank Perú (hereinafter, Scotiabank), each of the Reports prepared by her, together with her corresponding memorandum of convocation for the respective Board Meeting, duly signed by the General Manager;
- In this regard, Scotia Fondos has signed with Scotiabank a "General Support, Administration and Custody of Securities Contract" (hereinafter, Contract), which regulates the processing and conservation of information related to the administration of Mutual Funds, the support of the accounting computer system service, as well as the outsourcing of various services permitted by the Mutual Funds Regulation, including the function of preparing the agenda for Board meetings and transferring the corresponding documents and reports;
- In order to prove the aforementioned, they reiterate that printed copies of the emails stored in the servers of Scotia Fondos were made available to the Igcp, by virtue of reliable evidence, through which the Fci sent to the Board, through the General Secretariat of Scotiabank, the Reports, according to the following detail:
| | |
|---|
| Email Date | Documents Attached to the Email | Board Date |
| 11/27/2014 | - Fifth Bimonthly Report. - Convocation Memorandum No. 18-SFSAF dated November 27, 2014. | 11/28/2014 |
| 01/27/2015 | - Sixth Bimonthly Report. - Convocation Memorandum No. 01-SFSAF dated January 27, 2015. | 01/30/2015 |
- Additionally, Scotia Fondos states that, by virtue of the principle of typification of sanctions governing administrative sanctioning procedures, and in order to avoid a "gaseous or empty" imputation, it must be previously determined what is meant by "report", in the context of the Mutual Funds Regulation. It adds that said determination must be made in the context of the fundamental principles governing the actions of the management company and its officers, such as the principle of "Honesty, Care and Diligence" in the performance of their activities, the principle of "Observance" of the norms regulating the exercise of their activities, as well as in their own internal documents, whether the functions established in the Organization and Functions Manual (hereinafter, Mof) and the internal procedures established in the Procedures Manual of Scotia Fondos (hereinafter, Mp), which do not establish a concrete definition of the word "report";
- On the other hand, Scotia Fondos indicates that the content of the Reports must be taken into consideration, which clearly state that: "in accordance with the provisions of Article 5 of the Mutual Funds and Management Companies Regulation, which establishes that the Internal Control Officer must report to the Board through a bimonthly report, the results of his supervision work, detailing the activities carried out and the events observed";
- Thus, Scotia Fondos indicates that it is necessary to understand the word "report" according to its purpose, and in accordance with the provisions of "Neutrality" and "Independence" established in Article 5 of the Mutual Funds Regulation, in such a way that, beyond a formality that the General Manager acts as Secretary of the Board and that, therefore, reads the documents reached through the General Secretariat and that require approval by the Directors, in substance, the Reports were prepared and reported in accordance with the regulations and procedures that governed the conduct of the Fci;
- Therefore, the management company considers that the delivery of information made by the Fci to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos through the General Secretariat complies with the obligation to "report" referred to in the Mutual Funds Regulation, even more so when the internal procedures contained in the Procedures Manual in force at that date did not establish alternative mechanisms to reach the documentation to the Board, other than through the General Secretariat of Scotiabank;
- By virtue of the above, the management company states that having demonstrated that it was the Fci who reported the Reports prepared by herself to the Board, through the General Secretariat of Scotiabank, it considers that the arguments that attempt to prove that the Convocation Memoranda to the Board Meeting were sent by the General Manager to the General Secretariat of Scotiabank and the subsequent reading (in the capacity of Secretary of Minutes but not as General Manager) of said Reports should be dismissed;
- In this regard, Scotia Fondos states that each of the Convocation Memoranda signed by the General Manager was made by virtue of the Bylaws of the Company, which date from 1988 constituted before Public Notary Oscar Medelius Rodríguez, which in its fortieth article state textually, that "The Board of Directors", to act as "Secretary of Minutes" of the Non-Presential Board Meeting, all this, in accordance with item 6 of Article 188 of the General Corporations Law, regulations that apply in a supplementary manner to the Securities Market Law, approved by Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, Lmv);
- Taking this into account, and in full exercise of its functions as Secretary of the Board Meeting, Scotia Fondos states that it makes sense that Mr. Presa read before the Board the Report reported by the Fci to the Board through the General Secretariat of Scotiabank, and in all cases stating literally "that it had been prepared by the Fci, and that it had been distributed by them by electronic means, exposing the most relevant aspects to the Directors", a situation that has not been mentioned or analyzed by the Igcp at the time of preparing the Official Letter of reference, but which is expressly stated in the minutes of the board meeting;
- In that context, the management company states that the reading of the Reports made by the General Manager corresponds to a mere function of the Secretary of Minutes of each of the Board Meetings. Likewise, they specify that the presentation of the Reports to the Board, made by the General Manager is a common practice in companies, whether issuers, investment fund management companies, mutual fund management companies, management companies or any other company participating in the securities market, regardless of who prepared them;
Evaluation
- On this matter, it must be noted that the obligations of the Fci established in article 5, second and sixth paragraphs of the Mutual Funds Regulation, provide that it must be appointed by the board of directors of the management company and, in its absence, by the general shareholders' meeting, and shall report to the body that appointed it. Likewise, it is specified that in no case may the internal control officer report to the general manager, and it is established as an obligation of this officer to report to the body on which it depends;
- From the foregoing, it follows that according to the regulatory framework, the Fci must report the content of its reports, in this case, to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos; that is, a direct relationship is established in the communication that the FCI must make to the Board regarding its reports and the results of its supervision work; and the detail of the activities carried out and the events observed;
- In this sense, the word “report” cannot be understood as the possibility that the Reports were simply read by the General Manager of Scotia Fondos, or that they were sent by email to Mr. Carrillo, or that it is Mr. Presa who forwards the memoranda to Mr. Francisco Rivadeneira, who is the legal advisor of the General Secretariat, as can be seen in the Minutes; as well as the emails of November 27, 2014 and January 27, 2015; and Memoranda No. 18-SFSAF of November 27, 2014 and 01-SFSAF of January 27, 2015. Consequently, the term “report”, in the framework that the Fci must perform its activities with independence and neutrality, establishes that the Fci itself must present to the Board the content of the Reports and provide the necessary explanations of the results obtained, which does not occur in the present case;
- In this regard, it is necessary to highlight that the fact that Mr. Presa has been responsible for reading the Reports before the company's Board of Directors does not ensure that the results are transmitted appropriately, since it is his work (management of the company) over which the Fci also exercises supervision and prepares the respective report. This exposes the reason why it is not appropriate for the general manager to be responsible for presenting the Reports in Board sessions, since such conduct would call into question the independence of the Fci within the management company;
- As can be seen from the reading of the documents in the file, the Fci of Scotia Fondos, Mrs. Gonzales, did not comply with her obligation to report directly to the Board, because it can be seen that she did not transmit the content of her Reports – directly – to the Directors, but through a person who did not participate in the preparation of those documents, who does not know the work performed and who has a conflict of interest;
- In this regard, it is necessary to indicate that the rule does not intend for third parties to report to the company's Board; on the contrary, it seeks for the company's own Fci to report to the body that appointed it, since the nature of its functions lies in informing the results of the supervision of the activities carried out and the events observed in the company, typical of the General Manager's management. In this sense, it must be noted that by not reporting directly to the body that appointed it, the supervision and control function of the Fci is distorted, because this can generate a conflict of interests, in addition to demonstrating that the Fci would not be performing its functions as an independent firm but rather its reports are being mediated by an intermediary with a conflict of interest regarding their content;
- On this matter, it is necessary to complement the analysis, specifying that article 5, seventh paragraph, of the Mutual Funds Regulation states that the work of the Fci is governed, among others, by the International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing, as well as by the “Code of Ethics issued by The Institute of Internal Auditors”;
- The International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing establish in the title “Attribute Standards”, numeral “1100 – Independence and Objectivity” that the internal audit activity must be independent**[4]. Likewise, said standard in numeral “1110 – Organizational Independence”[5]** indicates that the chief audit executive must report to a level within the organization that allows the internal audit activity to fulfill its responsibilities;
- In addition to the foregoing, section “1110.A1”[6] of the aforementioned international standard provides that the internal audit activity must be free from interference in determining the scope of internal auditing, in performing its work and in communicating its results;
- From the foregoing regarding the obligation to communicate the results of the work performed by the Fci through the Reports, it is observed that the independence work referred to in the Mutual Funds Regulation and other applicable regulations has not been fulfilled at the time of reporting to the Board the results of its supervision work;
- With regard to the Contract, it must be noted that it cannot be inferred from it that there is any element linked to the imputed fact or to the function of preparing the agenda for Board sessions and forwarding the corresponding documents and reports;
- On the other hand, regarding the interpretation of the word “report”, it must be stated that article 5, sixth paragraph of the Mutual Funds Regulation does not leave room for an empty interpretation, since reporting involves transmitting or communicating or giving notice**[7]**, which is observed in the Fci's obligation to communicate – directly – to the Board the Reports, whether through emails, board sessions, among others; since the cited regulation states that in no case may the internal control officer report to the general manager, therefore, neither can it depend on him to report; on the contrary, as stated in the aforementioned rule, it must report to the body on which it depends, so that communication must be between the FCI and the Board of Scotia Fondos without intermediaries; otherwise, the objective of having an officer who assumes its responsibilities of supervision and evaluation of the functions, procedures and internal controls of the management company independently and neutrally would not be met;
- In addition to the foregoing, the management company itself acknowledges that said function was not fulfilled when it states the following:
“(….) Therefore, we consider that the delivery of information made by the Internal Control Officer to the Board of Scotia Fondos through the General Secretariat complies with the obligation to “report” referred to in the Mutual Funds Regulation, especially when the internal procedures contained in the Procedures Manual in force at that date did not establish alternative mechanisms to reach the documentation to the Board, other than through the General Secretariat of Scotiabank Peru”. (Emphasis added);
- As can be inferred from the preceding quote, the management company itself states that it did not have internal procedures allowing the Fci to inform – directly – the Board in Board Sessions. In this sense, and after reviewing the Mof attached to the defense brief, it can be observed that the Fci did not perform said function in accordance with article 5, second and sixth paragraphs of the Mutual Funds Regulation; nor was it allowed to report directly to the body on which it depended, in this case, the Board of Scotia Fondos, because its internal procedures were not in accordance with the applicable regulations;
- Likewise, it is necessary to indicate that the function of “reporting” cannot be interpreted as the possibility that the General Manager, acting as Secretary of the Board Session, transmits or reports the Reports, because this could involve a conflict of interests, since, as we know, such reports contain the results of the evaluation of the supervision of the company's activities, one of the controlled activities being those performed by the General Manager of Scotia Fondos himself;
- It is necessary to indicate that regardless of whether the General Manager acts as Secretary in Board Sessions, article 5, sixth paragraph of the Mutual Funds Regulation is imperative when it states that it is the Fci who reports to the body on which it depends. In this sense, even though the company's Bylaws state that the General Manager is the secretary in Board sessions, the Fci is also obliged to attend such meetings, since the nature of its position is to report how the company has performed within a period;
- In view of the foregoing, it is concluded that the company has not rebutted the imputed charge;
B) On the Administrative Powers granted to the FCI and its participation in the handling of a claim
- Regarding the administrative powers granted by board session of April 25, 2014 to the Fci, registered on February 2, 2015 in the Public Registries of Lima, Scotia Fondos states that the granting of said administrative powers was carried out as part of compliance with a corporate governance policy of the financial conglomerate that requires officers and managers of Scotia Fondos to have joint and standardized administrative powers, and that although the Fci was invested with the powers granted, it did not use them, nor exercise any of the powers granted, nor any administrative function other than internal control during its tenure at the company;
- Likewise, they indicate that the withdrawal of powers made by the Board of Scotia Fondos in a non-face-to-face session held on May 22, 2015, where the powers granted to the Fci were revoked, was carried out within the framework of a recommendation by the SMV officers in charge of the inspection carried out by the Igse, and not due to an alleged conflict of interest, and all this with the sole purpose of not inducing confusion to the supervisor;
- Notwithstanding all of the foregoing, Scotia Fondos states that it is not possible to consider the granting of powers as a breach “per se” of the fourth paragraph of article 5 of the Mutual Funds Regulation, since said paragraph was amended by SMV Resolution No. 010-2015-EF/94.01, of June 7, 2015, the date on which the powers had already been granted to the Fci, and where at no time did the Mutual Funds Regulation establish that exclusive dedication expressly implied that the Fci could not perform another function whose nature differs from the activities of supervision and evaluation of the functions, procedures and internal controls in the management company or in the economic group;
- On the other hand, and regarding the participation of the Fci in a certain process of resolution and handling of complaints and claims dated December 26, 2014, that is, seven (07) months after the granting of its powers, Scotia Fondos reiterates that the Fci's signature on the document sent to the participant was made as part of the control procedure implemented in the Internal Control System Manual of Scotia Fondos and in accordance with the functions and obligations established for the Fci in the Mp duly reviewed and sent to the Smv on different occasions, in order to verify and validate that the process of resolution and handling of complaints and claims is carried out within the established deadlines and in accordance with current regulations, by the operations unit of Scotia Fondos, whose responsible officer was Mrs. Marisol Fiorella Trucios Loayza, as Wealth Management Operations Manager, who signed all communications on behalf of the management company;
- In this sense, Scotia Fondos states that the Fci's signature attested to the control performed on each of the claims, so it should not be considered as a participation or representation within the process of resolution and handling of complaints and claims of the participants; on the contrary, it shows the diligence and responsibility with which the Fci fulfilled its functions, since it was fully informed of a claim through which Mrs. María Rodríguez Hernández was requesting information on the regularization of two specific redemption operations, which were duly addressed when resolving the information request;
- Finally, and notwithstanding all of the foregoing, the management company specifies that the Fci only had the possibility of exercising the administrative powers granted by the Board from the moment of their registration in the Public Registries of Lima, on February 2, 2015, until the date of their revocation by Board Session of May 22, 2015;
Evaluation:
- In this regard, it must be noted that article 5, fourth paragraph of the Mutual Funds Regulation, in force at the time of the commission of the facts[8], contains an imperative obligation; this means that the Fci must perform its work on an exclusive dedication basis, with independence and neutrality with respect to any other activity that could generate a conflict of interest in the management company;
- From the foregoing, it follows that on the date on which the administrative powers were granted to Mrs. Gonzales (Board Session of April 25, 2014 and registration with SUNARP on February 2, 2015), the obligation regarding the Fci's actions being on an exclusive dedication basis with respect to any other activity that could generate a conflict of interest in the management company was already in force;
- In this sense, it must be noted that although there was a corporate governance policy of the financial conglomerate, such internal provisions cannot be contrary to the applicable regulations, so the observation made during the 2015 Inspection should not have been understood as a recommendation, but as an indication for not being in accordance with article 5 of the Mutual Funds Regulation, which follows from Official Letter No. 2343-2015-SMV/10.2, which states that the observations made as a result of the inspection are made without prejudice to the evaluation that the instructing body of the sanctioning procedure may make regarding such observations;
- As to the fact that it is not possible to consider the granting of powers as a breach “per se” of the fourth paragraph of article 5 of the Mutual Funds Regulation, since said paragraph was amended by SMV Resolution No. 010-2015-EF/94.01, of June 7, 2015; it should be noted that the imputed charge is based on the rule in force at the time of the commission of the facts, which expressly contained the obligation to carry out activities on an exclusive dedication basis, which implied that it be carried out with independence and neutrality with respect to any other activity that could generate a conflict of interest in the management company. Likewise, according to the dictionary of the Royal Spanish Academy, the adjective “exclusive” in its second meaning refers to “Only, sole, excluding any other.”; that is, given the aforementioned definition, when the rule states that the FCI must perform its work on an exclusive dedication basis, it implies by definition that it cannot perform other work or must perform them solely, excluding any other;
- It should also be noted that the amendment of article 5 of the Regulation by SMV Resolution No. 010-2015-EF/94.01 maintains the same exclusivity obligation indicated above, the amendment consisting of the incorporation of the fact that the FCI position may now be held by an officer who performs internal control functions in other companies of the economic group;
- Given the foregoing, it must be considered that in the present case, it is indeed observed that the Fci, Mrs. Gonzales, performed actions or had administrative powers that by themselves placed the Fci in a situation of conflict of interest in the activities that corresponded to it as Fci in Scotia Fondos established in article 6 of the Mutual Funds Regulation. In this sense, the mere fact of granting such powers affected its independence and neutrality, as well as its obligation to perform its work on an exclusive dedication basis; since the powers in question entailed being immersed in a risk of conflicts of interest in relation to the activities to be performed by the Fci.[9] Therefore, such powers should not have been conferred due to the nature of the position;
- On the other hand, and regarding the handling of Request No. 220-2014000504 of December 16, 2014, made by the fund participant, Mrs. María Silvia Rodríguez, it is observed that the claim was answered by both the Head of Operations, Mrs. Marisol Trucios Loayza, and by the Fci, Mrs. Gonzales, by Letter of December 26, 2014[10]. The participant states that when trying to make a redemption and not finding any current mutual fund product, she indicates that she has not made any total redemption to date and wishes to know who authorized such redemptions and who requested them and likewise for her money to be returned;
- In this sense, in the response letter, the participant is informed in detail about the redemptions made, stating: Type of fund, certificate number, redemption date, branch, payment date, form of payment and who collected the redemption, stating that a copy of the redemption request and payment voucher at the counter was attached. Consequently, from the situation described, it follows that the FCI's participation was not limited to verifying a process intended to be carried out within the established deadlines, as Scotia Fondos states, but rather it participated in the management of the solution of a claim;
- Regarding the foregoing, it should be mentioned that from the review of the letter of July 8, 2015, by which response is given to Official Letter No. 2343-2015-SMV/10.2 regarding observations determined in the 2015 Inspection, the management company itself indicates that the officer signed the Letter of December 26, 2014, by which Mrs. Silva's claim is resolved, before it was sent to the participant. In this sense, and as stated, no initialed approval is observed in the response document to the claim, but rather a signature, so there is no evidence of compliance with the exclusivity function established in article 5, fourth paragraph, of the Mutual Funds Regulation;
- In addition to the foregoing, and as a complement to this analysis, in the Fci's participation in the handling of the aforementioned participant's complaint, it can be stated that such participation generates a conflict of interest, considering that said action is contrary to the provisions of article 6, literal e) of the Mutual Funds Regulation[11], according to which, among others, it is the function of the Fci to supervise that consultations, claims and, in general, the service provided to the participant by the management company, directly or through promoters, comply with the procedures, deadlines and other rules that for this purpose must be set forth in the simplified prospectus and participation regulation of the mutual fund. In this sense, it can be observed that if the Fci participates in the handling of consultations and claims, it loses objectivity when subsequently supervising this activity;
- By virtue of the foregoing, it must be stated that Scotia Fondos has not rebutted the charges subject to this analysis;
c) On the legal defenses
- Regarding the legal arguments, Scotia Fondos indicated that, in accordance with the provisions of article 348 of the Lmv, and numeral 3) of article 230 of the Administrative Procedure Law[12], the following must be considered;
- As to the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right: Scotia Fondos indicates that in the present case the general principles of conduct governing the internal control system have not been affected, that this would only have been possible if the General Manager had prepared, modified, distorted or misrepresented the information presented in the 2014 Bimonthly Internal Control Reports, which has not occurred, nor is it the subject of the imputation of charges. Furthermore, it must be considered that the quality of the bimonthly information submitted has not been questioned;
- Likewise, Scotia Fondos states that in the present case it is not evident that a quantifiable economic harm with market repercussion has been caused; it has no record of similar cases, only has breaches of submission of periodic and occasional information; it has not been sanctioned for infractions or conduct analogous or equal to the one imputed; it has complied with regularizing in due course the observations made under the inspection procedure required by the Igse, so the file should be archived; it is not possible to affirm that the infractions incurred have generated any type of illegal benefit; and it is not possible to evidence that it acted with intent or malice in the commission of the alleged infractions;
- On the other hand, Scotia Fondos states that the following should be considered as mitigating factors, if an infraction is deemed to have been committed: the fact that since 2015 it has contributed to the clarification of the imputed charges and that it has voluntarily and at the first opportunity remedied the alleged errors in the performance of certain control procedures, such as the registration of the revocation of the Fci's powers, as well as inviting the Fci to the board sessions held regarding the 2015 Bimonthly Reports; therefore, if a sanction is determined, it must be proportional to the material harm caused;
Evaluation:
- The criteria and mitigating factors for imposing sanctions developed by Scotia Fondos will be taken into consideration at the time of the evaluation of the sanction;
IV. Evaluation of the sanction
- In accordance with Article 348 of the LMV and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with Article 246, numeral 3 of the TUO of the LPAG and Article 255 of the aforementioned normative body, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria set forth in the LMV, the Sanctions Regulation and the TUO of the LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The harm caused and the repercussion on the market; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; e) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; f) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct; and, g) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification;
- In accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, sanctions that became final within the four (04) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction are considered as the offender's antecedents, it being necessary to indicate that only the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision Resolution No. 004-2015-SMV/10 of February 12, 2015, is recorded as a sanction antecedent, by which Scotia Fondos was sanctioned with a fine of 33.9755 UIT for having incurred in fourteen (14) minor infractions for having submitted periodic and occasional information outside the deadline established in the applicable norms, typified in Annex 1, item 3., numeral 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- It should be noted that the resolution cited in the preceding recital became final insofar as by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2016-SMV/10 the reconsideration appeal filed by the administered party was declared unfounded;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it should be indicated that the fact that the Fci did not directly report to the Board of Directors of Scotia Fondos its reports covering a period of 10 months and that it did not perform its functions with exclusive dedication by having been granted powers other than its functions for a period of 13 months, affects the trust that investors may have in the management companies in the diligent development of their functions; likewise, as a result of said situation, the minimum caution that management companies must comply with in order not to harm, with their actions, not only the interests of their participants, but also those of the company itself, is neglected;
- The Internal Control Officer, as responsible for the supervision and evaluation of the functions, procedures and internal controls of the management company, must seek that they provide reasonable assurance to achieve the company's objectives regarding the effectiveness and efficiency of its operations, reliability and sufficiency of the information generated and compliance with applicable norms; therefore, it constitutes a first line of control whose observance contributes to management companies being able to comply with their obligations, which in turn contributes to market integrity, transparency and investor protection; therefore, since Scotia Fondos had an Fci that did not dedicate itself exclusively to the performance of its functions and did not report to the body on which it depended, it has affected the aforementioned principles;
- On the other hand, it should be indicated that the Fci has among its functions to evaluate compliance with all provisions governing the management company, to communicate to the SMV any relevant fact that may be harmful to the participant and is detected in the exercise of its functions, to verify that the prices or rates of transactions carried out on behalf of the mutual fund have been made at market prices, and to supervise that inquiries, claims and, in general, the service provided to the participant by the management company, directly or through promoters, conform to the procedures, deadlines and other rules that for this purpose must be set forth in the simplified prospectus and participation regulations of the mutual fund; that is, activities whose results are closely linked to the management of the general management; therefore, since it is the General Manager and not the Fci who reports to the Board of Directors, there is a situation of conflict of interest, with the risk that the aforementioned body is not informed with the depth and detail of the corresponding party; that is, the Fci;
- As for the harm caused and the repercussion on the market, it should be indicated that it has not been evidenced that the actions of Scotia Fondos have caused concrete harm to market participants or have had a repercussion on the market;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, in relation to the infraction subject of the sanctioning procedure, Scotia Fondos, in its capacity as management company at the date of the events, knows the securities market regulations and, therefore, the observance of the obligations contained in the Mutual Fund Regulation regarding the obligations that the internal control officer must comply with, which it did not observe;
- On the other hand, regarding the benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, it has not been accredited in this administrative sanctioning procedure that Scotia Fondos obtained any benefit by incurring the imputed infraction;
- In relation to the existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct, it should be noted that no intent has been evidenced in the conduct of Scotia Fondos;
- As for the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification, it should be indicated that Scotia Fondos has not acknowledged the imputed charges. However, it did contribute to the clarification of the imputed charges;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, the additional reasonableness criteria of Article 246 of the TUO of the LPAG must be taken into account (introduced by Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272[13] which modified, among others, Article 230, numeral 3, of the LPAG): (i) the probability of detection of the infraction and (ii) recidivism for the commission of the infraction within a period of one (1) year from the date the resolution sanctioning the first infraction became final. Additionally, the exempting and mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in Article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG must be analyzed (modification introduced by Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 which modified the assumptions of Article 236-A[14] of the LPAG);
- In this sense, it is appropriate to evaluate the following graduation criteria of the principle of reasonableness established in Article 246, numeral 3 of the TUO of the LPAG:
- In relation to the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that in the case analyzed it was possible to detect the facts imputed to Scotia Fondos, insofar as it was detected as a result of the inspection carried out on the management company with the objective of verifying compliance with the applicable regulations regarding the development of its functions;
- With reference to recidivism of the infraction for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (01) year from the date the resolution sanctioning the first infraction became final, it should be indicated that Scotia Fondos does not present sanctions identical to the one that is the subject of analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure;
- As for the exempting and mitigating circumstances of responsibility, in accordance with the provisions of Article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, it is not observed that in the present case any of the assumptions constituting exempting and mitigating conditions of responsibility have been configured;
- From the foregoing, it is concluded that Scotia Fondos has incurred an infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex VII, item 1., numeral 1.15 of the Sanctions Regulation.
- However, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed in the preceding recitals, considering that from the facts analyzed it has not been evidenced that the infraction committed by Scotia Fondos has caused economic harm to market participants, nor to the market, that it does not record sanction antecedents; this General Intendancy considers that it would be possible to impose on Scotia Fondos a sanction corresponding to the lower classification than that provided in accordance with the provisions of Article 6, third paragraph of the Sanctions Regulation, for which reason it is proposed to impose a fine applicable to minor infractions, in accordance with Article 22 of the Sanctions Regulation; and,
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments.
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. has incurred an infraction of a very serious nature, typified in Annex VII, item 1, numeral 1.15 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, because its Internal Control Officer did not perform its functions in the manner provided in Article 5, second, fourth and sixth paragraphs of the Regulation of Mutual Funds of Investment in Securities and their Management Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 068-2010-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments, in force at the time of the commission of the facts, by not reporting to the body on which it depends the results of its supervision work and by not performing its functions with exclusive dedication.
- Sanction Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. with a fine of three (03) UIT equivalent to S/. 11,400.00 (Eleven thousand four hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infraction referred to in Article 1 of this resolution.
- In accordance with Article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, the offender on whom the sanction of a fine has been imposed for the commission of very serious, serious or minor infractions may request from the Administration Office a reduction of the amount to be paid, provided that it accredits prior and joint compliance with the requirements indicated in the referred article.
- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it becomes final, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the event that this resolution is not subject to challenge by reconsideration or appeal within the period of fifteen (15) business days from notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on Advertising of Normative Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10 A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
- Transcribe this resolution to Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
It is necessary to specify that the modification of Article 5 established by SMV Resolution No. 008-2013-SMV/01.1 in force at the time of the commission of the facts applies to this case. It should be noted that by Superintendency Resolution No. 010-2015 the referred Article 5 was modified, which entered into force as of June 8, 2015. ↑
-
Likewise, in the board of directors meeting minutes of July 31, September 30 and November 28, 2014 and January 30, 2015, the same paragraphs are included in the reports of the internal control officer No. 03-2014-CI, 04-2014-CI, 05-2014-CI and 06-2014-CI. ↑
-
Mutual Fund and Management Company Regulation
"Article 6.-
For the performance of its functions, the internal control officer must prepare an annual work program, which must be approved by the body on which it depends. This program must consider the activities that allow it to meet at least the following objectives:
(….)
e) Supervise that inquiries, claims and, in general, the service provided to the participant by the management company, directly or through promoters, conform to the procedures, deadlines and other rules that for this purpose must be set forth in the simplified prospectus and participation regulations of the mutual fund." ↑
-
International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing
"Tax Standards
(….)
1100 – Independence and Objectivity
The internal audit activity must be independent, and internal auditors must be objective in performing their work. (…)" (underlining is ours). ↑
-
International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing
"Tax Standards
(….)
1110-Organizational Independence
The chief executive officer must report to a hierarchical level within the organization that allows the internal audit activity to fulfill its responsibilities." ↑
-
International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing
"Tax Standards
(….)
1110.A1 – The internal audit activity must be free from interference in determining the scope of internal auditing, in performing its work and in communicating the results." ↑
-
According to the Royal Spanish Academy – RAE, the word "report" for the context analyzed means: "Transmit, communicate, give news." In: http://dle.rae.es/?id=W3GBnj7 ↑
-
This is the modification to Article 5 made by SMV Resolution No. 008-2013-SMV/01.1. ↑
-
In this regard, the Code of Ethics issued by The Institute of Internal Auditors includes "Objectivity" as a rule of conduct, which involves, among others, the following:
(…)
2.1 Internal auditors shall not participate in any activity or relationship that may impair or appear to impair their impartial evaluation. This participation includes those activities or relationships that may be in conflict with the interests of the organization.
2.2 They shall not accept anything that may impair or appear to impair their professional judgment.
(…)" . ↑
-
Documents collected in the 2015 Inspection. ↑
-
Article 6.- Functions
(….)
e) Supervise that inquiries, claims and, in general, the service provided to the participant by the management company, directly or through promoters, conform to the procedures, deadlines and other rules that for this purpose must be set forth in the simplified prospectus and participation regulations of the mutual fund.
(…)". ↑
-
It should be noted that Scotia Fondos has made its arguments under the analysis without considering the modifications to the General Administrative Procedure Law established by Legislative Decree No. 1272. ↑
-
Published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on December 21, 2016. ↑
-
"Article 236-A
1.- The following constitute exempting conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction.
d) The mandatory order of a competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) The error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) The voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in numeral 3) of Article 235
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount.
b) Others established by special norm." ↑