Enforcement · SMV · 31 Jan 2018
The Superintendent of the Securities Market declared MAGOT Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C.'s appeal unfounded and upheld the fine imposed by Resolution No. 055-2016-SMV/10 for failing to notify clients at least eight days in advance of a new tariff, as required by Article 22.5 of the former Brokerage Agents Regulation. The resolution also rejected the argument that the withdrawal of the complainants terminated the sanctioning procedure, ordered the administrative remedies exhausted, and directed notification to the parties and publication on the SMV website.
Superintendent Resolution
No. 012-2018-SMV/02
Lima, January 31, 2018
The Superintendent of the Securities Market
WHEREAS:
File No. 2015045046 and Report No. 1339-2017-SMV/06 issued by the Legal Advisory Office;
CONSIDERING:
That, by Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 055-2016-SMV/10 of December 30, 2016 (hereinafter, the Resolution), it was declared that MAGOT Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. (hereinafter, Magot) incurred an infraction of a serious nature classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10[1] of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2011-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), for having contravened numeral 22.5[2] of Article 22 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events (hereinafter, Former RAI), for not communicating to its clients, prior to its application and with an advance notice of no less than eight (8) days, the implementation of a new tariff;
That, by document submitted on January 20, 2017, Magot filed an appeal against the Resolution;
Arguments of Magot's appeal
That, in the Resolution, the application of erroneous legal criteria is observed, since although the sanctionable assumption (contained in numeral 22.5 of Article 22 of the Former RAI) supposes that Magot must make known to the client all information that said client ignores, the new operation costs replicated in the tariff schedule were public knowledge since October 2013, due to the publication of the respective norms and the commented dissemination of such legal provisions in specialized journalistic media of usual consultation among stock market investors;
That, the purpose of the allegedly infringed norm, that is, that the client, if deemed pertinent, may terminate the contractual relationship and request the transfer of their securities, has not been affected or impeded;
That, Mr. and Mrs. Enid Sabina Alatrista Macedo and Antero Edgardo Rojas Tejada (hereinafter, the complainants) submitted a withdrawal, for which the present sanctioning procedure should be concluded;
That, clients who did not make any claim or complaint against Magot have been included in the sanctioning procedure, thus failing to comply with the provisions of subsection 4[3] of Article 75 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, in force at the time of the events;
Analysis of Magot's appeal
That, regarding the fact that the new operation costs were public knowledge since October 2013 due to the publication of the norm and dissemination in journalistic media, it should be noted that the tariff for "Maintenance of matrix account" was approved, along with others, by Superintendent Resolution No. 119-2013-SMV/02, published on October 1, 2013. However, as correctly stated in the Resolution, the CAVALI tariff schedule is applicable between said securities clearing and settlement institution and the brokerage firms, and not between the latter and their clients, which was reflected in the fact that other brokerage firms, unlike Magot, chose not to pass on the cost of said tariff to their clients, not charging any payment for the service of maintaining securities in matrix account;
That, if said brokerage firm chose to pass on the commission to its clients, it should, in observance of numeral 22.5 of Article 22 of the Former RAI (in force at the time of the events), communicate in advance about it;
That, on the other hand, it should be noted that the publication of the resolution approving CAVALI's tariffs and the dissemination carried out in journalistic media about it do not in any way exempt Magot from complying with the provisions of numeral 22.5 of Article 22 of the Former RAI. The appellant's position that it would be exempt from communicating to its clients would imply making distinctions where the norm does not make them;
That, knowledge on the part of clients does not cover the purpose of the norm, which is to know that whoever is going to charge for said service communicates it in advance. Knowing the resolution that approved the tariff on the part of the client did not imply knowing whether their brokerage firm was going to charge or not for the service, as has been seen, in fact, that some brokerage firms charge and others do not;
That, regarding the fact that the purpose of the allegedly infringed norm, that is, that the client may terminate the contractual relationship and request the transfer of their securities, has not been affected or impeded, it should be noted that the possibility that said norm recognizes to clients could hardly have been applied in the present case because Magot at no time communicated to them that it was going to make said charge, which necessarily had to occur for the client to choose to exercise any of the rights recognized by the norm, that is, the termination of the contract and the transfer of their securities. In that sense, if Magot had communicated to its clients, they could have evaluated the convenience of keeping their securities with said brokerage firm or transferring them to another that would not charge them for the service of maintaining securities in matrix account;
That, regarding the fact that the sanctioning procedure should be concluded as a consequence of the withdrawal submitted by the complainants, it should be considered that, in accordance with Article 1 of the SMV Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126, one of the functions of the SMV is "To supervise compliance with the legislation of the securities market, product market and collective funds systems by natural and legal persons participating in said markets." In that sense, said supervision faculty is also recognized by Articles 1[4] and 3[5] of the SMV Regulations of Organization and Functions (hereinafter, the ROF);
That, without prejudice to the supervision faculties recognized to this Superintendency, it should be specified that the fact that the complainants have withdrawn does not exempt Magot from responsibility for the breach of its obligations as an entity supervised by the SMV. In that sense, it should be noted that although withdrawal is a figure recognized by the LPAG, this norm also establishes limitations to the scope of said figure. Thus, numeral 189.7 of Article 189 of the LPAG in force at the time of the events established that "The authority may continue the procedure ex officio if from the analysis of the facts it considers that third-party interests could be affected or the action raised by the initiation of the procedure entails general interest";
That, regarding the above, it is appropriate to keep in mind what was stated by Morón Urbina[6], who indicates that "It is transcendental for its proceeding that the particular interest manifested by the administered is not incompatible with some public interest that makes necessary the continuation of the procedure until the final determination of the material truth; since if the latter were present, the duty of the official to resolve the case will always subsist, and the request for withdrawal is not admissible.";
That, thus, in the present sanctioning procedure it has been possible to corroborate that by not complying with the provisions of numeral 22.5 of Article 22 of the Former RAI, Magot has violated the public interest and affected the principle of transparency, according to which it is intended, among others, to provide the greatest possible information to investors for adequate decision-making, so it would not be appropriate to archive the sanctioning procedure due to the withdrawal;
That, finally, regarding the fact that by including in the sanctioning procedure clients who did not make any claim or complaint against Magot, the provisions of subsection 4[7] of Article 75 of the LPAG in force at the time of the events would be breached, it should be remembered that the invoked article intends that in the processing of administrative procedures entities do not exceed by requesting additional information to that required in the norms, but in no way can it be inferred from said norm that it prevents the SMV from verifying compliance with the obligations of its supervised entities or requiring information from their clients;
That, therefore, accepting the thesis invoked by Magot would imply limiting the supervision function of the SMV, which comprises, without being understood in a limiting manner, attributions such as making information requests, cross-checking the information received, among others. In that sense, having exercised a faculty recognized by law, this Superintendency has not violated in any way the provisions of the LPAG subsection invoked by Magot; and,
In accordance with the provisions of subsection 26 of Article 12 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare unfounded the appeal filed by MAGOT Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. against Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 055-2016-SMV/10.
Article 2.- Consider the administrative route exhausted.
Article 3.- Transcribe this resolution to MAGOT Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C., to Mr. and Mrs. Enid Sabina Alatrista Macedo and Antero Edgardo Rojas Tejada, and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Article 4.- Order the publication of this resolution on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (www.smv.gob.pe).
Register, communicate and publish.
José Manuel Peschiera Rebagliati
Superintendent of the Securities Market
"2.10 Failure to send to its clients the information to which it is obligated, or not doing so in the form and opportunity required by the regulations."
"Article 22.- TARIFF SCHEDULE OF SERVICES
(...)
22.5. The modification of tariffs unilaterally by the Agent must comply with the following rules:
22.5.1. Be expressly established in the clients' registration forms.
22.5.2. Modifications must be communicated to clients, prior to their application when they signify an increase with respect to what has been accepted by them, with an advance notice of no less than eight (08) days, unless it is a tariff agreed as variable or modifications that signify more favorable conditions for clients, in which case they will apply immediately.
22.5.3. The prior communication must expressly state that the client may terminate the contractual relationship, in accordance with the conditions established in the client's registration form. In this case, the client must not assume any cost for the transfer of their securities or financial instruments, unless specifically agreed otherwise or the cost is originated by a third party.
22.5.4. Expressly establish in the clients' registration forms, the conditions and communication mechanisms for the Agent to comply with its obligation of prior communication of tariff modification.
(...)" ↑
"Article 75.- Duties of authorities in procedures
The duties of authorities regarding the administrative procedure and its participants are the following:
(...)
4. Abstain from requiring from the administered the compliance with requirements, the performance of procedures, the provision of information or the making of payments, not legally provided for.
(...)" ↑
"ARTICLE 1.- The Superintendency of the Securities Market is a specialized technical body attached to the Ministry of Economy and Finance, whose purpose is to ensure the protection of investors, the efficiency and transparency of the markets under its supervision, the correct formation of prices and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purposes, through regulation, supervision and promotion. It has legal personality of internal public law and enjoys functional, administrative, economic, technical and budgetary autonomy, with the Superintendent of the Securities Market being responsible for the budget pliego.
(...)"
"ARTICLE 3.- The functions of the SMV are the following:
(...)
2. Supervise compliance with the legislation of the securities market, the product market and the collective funds system, by natural and legal persons participating in said markets.
(...)"
↑
Comments to the General Administrative Procedure Law. – Gaceta Jurídica S.A. – Ninth Edition, page 546. ↑
"Article 75.- Duties of authorities in procedures
The duties of authorities regarding the administrative procedure and its participants are the following:
(...)
4. Abstain from requiring from the administered the compliance with requirements, the performance of procedures, the provision of information or the making of payments, not legally provided for.
(...)"
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“provisions of subsection 4 of Article 75 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, in force at the time of the events”
“SMV Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126, one of the functions of the SMV is "To supervise compliance with the legislation of the securities market”
“Regulations of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added