Enforcement · SMV · 24 Aug 2017
The Superintendent of the Securities Market resolves the appeal filed by Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar against Resolution No. 042-2017-SMV/10, which sanctioned him with a five-year disqualification for a very serious infraction under Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the SMV Sanctions Regulation for diverting client funds to purposes other than those authorized. The resolution confirms the sanction, finding that Arizmendi acted as de facto representative of Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. after leaving his formal positions, and that client funds were transferred to accounts of GPI Asset Management S.A.C. without authorization. The appeal is declared unfounded and the appealed resolution is upheld.
No. 078-2017-SMV/02
Lima, August 24, 2017
The Superintendent of the Securities Market
WHEREAS:
File No. 2017001169 and Memorandum No. 2955-2017-SMV/06 issued by the Legal Advisory Office;
CONSIDERING:
That, by Superintendency Resolution No. 042-2017-SMV/10 (hereinafter, the "Appealed Resolution"), Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar (hereinafter, "Arizmendi") was sanctioned with a five (5) year disqualification for having incurred in one (1) very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, the "Sanctions Regulation"), for allocating funds received as a consequence of his intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted to him, in his capacity as Chairman of the Board and General Manager of Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. former Stock Brokerage Firm (hereinafter, "GPI") and subsequently, as de facto representative of said company;
That, by document submitted on July 14, 2017, Mr. Arizmendi filed an appeal against the Appealed Resolution, requesting its revocation, in accordance with the factual and legal grounds supporting his appeal;
ON THE ARGUMENTS OF THE APPEAL BY MR. ARIZMENDI
That, Mr. Arizmendi states that, in accordance with article 230, literal 2 of the General Administrative Procedure Law – LPAG, Law No. 27444, entities must apply sanctions subject to due process. In this sense, he states that article 3 of the LPAG establishes as a validity requirement of the administrative act, the motivation, which implies that a concrete and direct relationship of the relevant proven facts of the specific case be developed, exposing the justification of why said facts comply or not with supporting the contested matter;
That, likewise, he indicates that article 230 of the LPAG recognizes as a principle of due process, the presumption of lawfulness, which obliges the Administration to carry out the necessary actions to verify the effective commission of the imputed charges, and in the absence of evidence, issue an acquittal ruling;
That, in accordance with the foregoing, Mr. Arizmendi states that the Appealed Resolution begins by referring to the complaints filed against GPI for allegedly having used the funds delivered by its clients for purposes other than those entrusted;
That, in this line, he adds that, in recital 2 of the Appealed Resolution, it is stated that the SMV has evaluated the denounced facts and has found indications of infraction on the part of Mr. Arizmendi, without taking into account that the administrative sanctioning procedure must prove that: (i) Mr. Arizmendi incurred in the infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, and (ii) whether it corresponds to impose a sanction on Mr. Arizmendi;
That, Mr. Arizmendi indicates that for the SMV the complaints filed by some clients of GPI against said company are sufficient proof to conclude that Mr. Arizmendi continued exercising functions related to the positions of General Manager and Chairman of the Board as a de facto representative with the "consent" of his spouse, Mrs. Antonia Bellido-Tagle Fernández-Concha (hereinafter, "Bellido-Tagle");
That, in this line, he adds that the SMV bases the sanction imposed against him on pure speculation, without providing any proof of what is affirmed nor exposing any fact or document that proves the charges for which he is sanctioned in the Appealed Resolution;
That, finally, Mr. Arizmendi states that the SMV has not carried out an adequate evidentiary activity in the present administrative sanctioning procedure. In this sense, he questions that the SMV has not verified whether the clients of GPI received any return on their investments and that it is concluded that there was an intention to allocate client funds for different purposes, when money has been paid to them (a fact that has not been verified by the SMV);
ANALYSIS OF THE APPEAL BY MR. ARIZMENDI
That, the appeal filed by Mr. Arizmendi complies with the requirements established in articles 122, 216, 218 and 219 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444[1], approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS (hereinafter, "TUO LPAG"), given that it was filed within the 15-day term of notification of the administrative act, indicates the act being appealed and is founded;
That, in relation to the duty of motivation of administrative acts, it must be noted that the Appealed Resolution is indeed duly motivated, since it extensively develops the various complaints of GPI clients, the content of emails and letters issued by Mr. Arizmendi himself, the statements of Mrs. Alicia Marrou Salazar (hereinafter "Marrou"), the circumstances related to Mr. Arizmendi's actions in representation of GPI, among others, which allow clearly concluding that Mr. Arizmendi, jointly with other GPI officials, developed a mechanism aimed at disposing of GPI clients' money for purposes other than those indicated by the latter;
That, regarding Mr. Arizmendi's participation in the mechanism indicated in the previous paragraph, it must be taken into account that Mr. Arizmendi was the highest executive officer of GPI in his capacity as General Manager and Chairman of the Board of the same from August 2004 until February 20, 2013, period during which an important part of the deposits of the complaining GPI clients were made and/or money and securities of these were in custody of GPI, such as:
That, regarding the amounts detailed above, as well as other additional amounts indicated in the Appealed Resolution, GPI has not presented documentation accrediting the destination given to the money received, alleging only that it would have been destined to operations with derivatives in the foreign market, despite the various requirements made by the SMV;
That, subsequently, Mr. Arizmendi, despite ceasing to be formally the General Manager and Chairman of the Board of GPI, continued actively related to said company, serving as de facto representative of the same, as concluded from the following evidentiary elements developed in the Appealed Resolution:
That, additionally, in the case of Mrs. Batievsky's complaint, she presents two letters signed by Mr. Arizmendi in representation of GPI and on sheets with the letterhead of said company, dated June 9, 2016 and November 4, 2016, respectively, in which the amount she delivered to GPI to make investments is acknowledged. In the last of said letters, Mr. Arizmendi details that Mrs. Batievsky's investment portfolio is valued at US$ 443,631.34 and that he has carried out various option sale operations, which are pending liquidation;
That, therefore, it is clearly appreciated that after leaving the positions of Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI, Mr. Arizmendi continued linked to the management and administration of GPI clients' assets, informing them about the evaluation and destination that would have been given to their investments and serving therefore in practice as a representative of said former stock brokerage firm, despite the fact that he had not been authorized to perform said function by the SMV;
That, on the other hand, Mrs. Marrou, former representative of GPI, at the time of her resignation, reports in a letter of October 6, 2015 addressed to GPIAM, attention to Mr. Arizmendi[2], that the funds of various GPI clients, among which is Mrs. Rosa Mayo Frid (Section 5.2 of the Appealed Resolution), were managed by Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Uccelli in an account in the name of GPIAM at the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC. It should be noted that GPI has not presented to date the documentation accrediting Mrs. Mayo's authorization to allocate to GPIAM the funds she entrusted to said former stock brokerage firm;
That, in relation to this point, it must be highlighted that the behavior of the highest authorities of GPI consisting of deriving and managing the amounts entrusted to said former stock brokerage firm in accounts in the name of GPIAM does not constitute an isolated fact, since said action, in addition to that indicated in the previous paragraph, is also appreciated in the case of Mrs. Álvarez, whose investments, as stated by Mr. Arizmendi himself in his letter of April 28, 2015 cited above, were destined in part to accounts in the name of GPIAM, despite the fact that this was not authorized by Mrs. Álvarez. It should be noted that the foregoing also occurred in the case of Mrs. Batievsky's investments, as detailed on pages 111 to 113 of the Appealed Resolution;
That, it must be highlighted that Mr. Arizmendi held the positions of General Manager and Chairman of the Board of GPIAM at the time of the events described in the previous paragraph[3], so said action accredits a management clearly contrary to the regulations on the administration of the patrimonies managed by GPI and GPIAM, taking into account that part of the money entrusted by clients to GPI was transferred and managed in accounts in the name of GPIAM, where the main executive officer was Mr. Arizmendi himself;
That, on the other hand, it must be taken into account that Mr. Arizmendi is the spouse of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI, a company in which Mr. Arizmendi was in turn Chairman of the Board and General Manager until February 20, 2013, date from which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle occupies the position in his place;
That, likewise, GPIAM, of which Mr. Arizmendi was its main executive officer, was, together with Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, the main shareholder of GPI (both together holding 99.9% of the share capital of GPI). Additionally, GPIAM had a contract signed with GPI to provide financial advisory, through Mr. Arizmendi, to the latter;
That, the facts described in the previous paragraphs accredit that even after leaving the positions of Chairman of the Board and General Manager in GPI, Mr. Arizmendi maintained a direct participation and interest in the development of GPI's operations, which would explain his acting as de facto representative of GPI, as has been accredited above and the incorrect use of the resources managed by GPI and GPIAM, which would have as a consequence that part of the resources of GPI clients entrusted to said company be destined to accounts in the name of GPIAM;
That, it is clearly appreciated that the investment scheme developed in all the complaints filed against GPI has similar characteristics, which consists of inducing clients to make investments tending to obtain income and preserve capital under a conservative profile that would supposedly end up being invested in operations with high-risk options, inducement that is evidenced since Mr. Arizmendi was the main executive officer of GPI. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in none of the denounced cases, GPI has been able to present documentation that reliably accredits the realization of said operations, including the money that was received when Mr. Arizmendi was Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI;
That, not only has the money entrusted by clients been used for purposes other than those authorized by them, but also, to date GPI has not complied with returning the full amount of the money that was entrusted to it by its clients who now denounce said fact, as detailed in Section 5 of the Appealed Resolution;
That, GPI has stated that said money would have supposedly been invested in options abroad; however, it does not accredit with reliable documentation said assertion, nor does it comply with restoring the money to its clients as a product of the supposed investments. GPI has only accredited, in some cases, the return of part of the capital entrusted by its clients and the delivery of returns to them, but in no case has it complied with restoring the full amount that was entrusted to it or accrediting in what said amounts would have been invested;
That, it must be taken into account that Mr. Arizmendi has several years of experience dedicated to carrying out operations in the securities market, so it is not possible to admit that he can obviate compliance with basic rules of intermediation in the securities market, such as collecting orders from his clients, presenting the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary that accredit the realization of the operations abroad that are stated to have been carried out[4], allocating part of the money entrusted by clients to a company in which he was Chairman of the Board and General Manager (GPIAM), without having the corresponding authorizations;
That, the realization of the aforementioned acts clearly demonstrates the non-compliance by Mr. Arizmendi of his fiduciary duties towards his clients, in his capacity as General Manager of GPI. It should be noted that the irregular behavior was maintained over time, while Mr. Arizmendi acted as a de facto representative of said company and as main executive officer of GPIAM;
That, from the foregoing, the participation of Mr. Arizmendi in the scheme that is developed and explained in detail in the Appealed Resolution is accredited, tending to allocate the money entrusted by his clients to purposes other than those authorized by them, which includes amounts delivered by clients to GPI since 2011, date on which Mr. Arizmendi was the main executive officer of said former stock brokerage firm;
That, therefore, it is not true, as Mr. Arizmendi states, that the Appealed Resolution concludes solely on the basis of the complaints of GPI clients, that he would have served as de facto representative of GPI as of February 21, 2013, since the foregoing is also accredited by the various emails and letters in the file, in which Mr. Arizmendi reports the investments made by GPI clients and their destination (as in the cases described above of Mrs. Álvarez and Mrs. Batievsky), information that can only be handled by the Representatives of a stock brokerage firm;
That, to the foregoing must be added the fact that part of the money delivered by Mrs. Álvarez and Mrs. Batievsky to GPI was destined to accounts in the name of GPIAM, in which Mr. Arizmendi was the main executive officer;
That, in this sense, the Appealed Resolution has not determined the responsibility of Mr. Arizmendi on mere speculations without foundations, but rather various documentation, complaints and facts have been evaluated that conclusively accredit the responsibility of Mr. Arizmendi, as has been developed above;
That, likewise, it must be noted that, contrary to what Mr. Arizmendi alleges, the Appealed Resolution has indeed verified and taken into account that GPI delivered money to its clients that would have been product of returns on their investments and that even in some cases corresponded to the return of part of the invested capital. In this sense, to cite some examples, this is recognized in recitals 114, 167, 300, 464 and 572 of the Appealed Resolution referring to the cases of Mrs. Álvarez, Silva Ruete, Roca, Quijano, Batievsky, respectively;
That, notwithstanding the foregoing, contrary to what Mr. Arizmendi maintains, the fact that GPI has accredited the delivery of returns to its clients or the return of part of the capital invested by them, in no way accredits that the authorized destination would have been given to their investments, since the latter must be accredited by means of the orders signed by the clients, the policies and the account statements sent by the foreign intermediary as a product of the realization of the operations, the certificates accrediting the custody of the securities acquired in favor of the clients, among others, documentation that to date has not been presented by GPI;
Whereas, it is important to take into account that obtaining returns or returning part of the capital invested by clients does not negate the obligation of a stock brokerage firm to faithfully comply with the instructions given by its clients, in accordance with their risk profile, since if such returns are obtained as a result of carrying out operations not authorized by the clients or that involve assuming a greater risk than tolerable by them, in the same manner the regulations related to fiduciary duties in favor of clients would be infringed, since clients are exposed to risks not authorized or tolerated by them; and,
In accordance with the provisions of Article 2 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Securities Market, and subsection 26 of Article 12 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare unfounded the appeal filed by Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 042-2017-SMV/10.
Article 2.- Consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Article 3.- Transcribe this resolution to Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A., and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Article 4.- Order the dissemination of this resolution on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV.
Register, communicate, and publish.
Lilian Rocca Carbajal
Superintendent of the Securities Market
Article 122.- Requirements of written submissions
Every written submission presented before any entity must contain the following:
Article 216.- Administrative appeals
(...)
216.2 The term for filing appeals is fifteen (15) peremptory days, and they must be resolved within thirty (30) days.
Article 218.- Appeal
The appeal shall be filed when the challenge is based on a different interpretation of the evidence produced or when it involves pure questions of law, and must be addressed to the same authority that issued the challenged act so that it may forward the proceedings to the hierarchical superior.
The written appeal must state the act being appealed and comply with the other requirements set forth in Article 122 of this Law. ↑
This communication was obtained by the SMV in the inspection carried out on GPI on January 17, 2017. ↑
In recital 17 of the Appealed Resolution, it is stated that, according to information obtained from the Registry of Legal Persons of SUNARP, Mr. Arizmendi (majority founding partner of GPIAM) was general manager and chairman of the board of said company from March 15, 2013, until April 12, 2017, while Mrs. Bellido-Tagle held the general management of such company until March 14, 2013. ↑
According to subsection 39.3 of the former Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and in force at the time of the events, to sign a contract with a foreign intermediary that will execute instructions in the foreign market, it is necessary that the latter assume the commitment to send the local intermediation agent monthly account statements on its balances and movements of funds and financial instruments:
“Article 39.- CONDITIONS OF THE INTERMEDIARY
The Agent must sign contracts or equivalent documents with foreign intermediaries that will execute its instructions in foreign markets, provided they comply with the following conditions:
(...)
39.3. They have the obligation to provide monthly account statements, with information on their balances and movements of funds and financial instruments.” ↑
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“...article 230, literal 2 of the General Administrative Procedure Law – LPAG, Law No. 27444, entities must apply sanctions subject to due process.”
“...subsection 26 of Article 12 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added