Rule · HKMA · 23 Jun 2006
Each AI must tell the HKMA which of the four recognized ECAIs it plans to use, nominate ECAIs for the external ratings-based portfolios (sovereigns, banks, securities firms, corporates), notify the HKMA, apply those ratings consistently, and treat exposures lacking a nominated ECAI rating as unrated; AIs must not use ratings outside HKMA recognition. ECAIs must meet recognition criteria, including a methodology established at least one year (preferably three) and 12 months back-testing.
Our Ref.:
Circulars
23 Jun 2006
Basel II - External Credit Assessment Institutions' Ratings and Mapping of Ratings to Risk-Weights S4/10C B1/15C 23 June 2006 The Chief Executive All authorized institutions Dear Sir/Madam, Basel II - External Credit Assessment Institutions' Ratings and Mapping of Ratings to Risk-Weights I am pleased to inform you that, following consultation with the industry and the external credit assessment institutions ("ECAIs") which are currently recognized by the Monetary Authority ("MA") for banking supervisory purposes, the HKMA has now finalized its policy paper on Recognition of ECAIs for Basel II purposes. The policy paper is attached at Annex 1. In addition, based on the eligibility criteria and the mapping approach set out in the policy paper, the HKMA has completed its assessments on Fitch Ratings, Moody's Investors Service, Standard & Poor's Ratings Services, and Rating and Investment Information, Inc. ("R&I") and now proposes that their assessments for non-securitization exposures be recognized for the Standardized Approach to calculation of credit risk under the revised capital framework. A list of these ECAIs and the mapping of their risk assessments to the credit quality grades / risk-weights for exposures to sovereigns, banks and securities firms, and corporates is now attached at Annex 2, which will be included in the Capital Rules to be made by the MA. Unsolicited ratings issued by these ECAIs will receive the same treatment as solicited ratings under the Capital Rules. We are still in the process of reviewing the assessment methodologies of the recognized ECAIs for securitization transactions and considering the mapping of the relevant credit assessments of the ECAIs. We will publish a separate list of the recognized ECAIs and the mapping of their credit assessments for the Securitization Framework to be prescribed in the Capital Rules at a later stage. Authorized institutions ("AIs") that intend to adopt the Standardized Approach may start to nominate ECAIs and inform the HKMA of their nominations. What this means in practice is that each AI needs to tell us which of the four ECAIs we have recognized they plan to use
Encl. plus any others that they would propose to use which we have not yet assessed for recognition so that we can initiate the recognition process. Where an AI proposes to use the assessments of an ECAI that is not currently recognized by the HKMA, the HKMA will approach the ECAI inviting an application for recognition. Whether the assessment of the ECAI's eligibility can be completed before the implementation of the Capital Rules will depend on whether the HKMA has been provided sufficient lead time to undertake the recognition process and to obtain the necessary information from the ECAI. While the policy paper on Recognition of ECAIs has been mainly developed for implementation of Basel II, it will also be relevant for the recognition of ECAIs for other purposes by the HKMA, i.e. the minimum acceptable ratings of recognized ECAIs for the lender of last resort arrangement, the market risk capital adequacy framework, the liquidity ratio requirement under the Banking Ordinance and the profits tax concession scheme under
section 14A(4)(b) of the Inland Revenue Ordinance. All the ECAIs listed in Annex 2 have
already been recognized for these other purposes by the HKMA. However, based on our updated assessment of the quality of R&I's ratings, the minimum acceptable rating of R&I has been changed from BBB+ to BBB-. The revised list of recognized ECAIs and the respective minimum acceptable ratings, with immediate effect, is attached at Annex 3. A gazette notice and a press release, as attached at Annexes 4 and 5, have also been released today to announce the list of recognized ECAIs and the respective minimum acceptable ratings for the purposes of the profits tax concession scheme under section 14A(4)(b) of the Inland Revenue Ordinance. The policy paper and the list of recognized ECAIs and the mapping of their ratings for various purposes mentioned above may be subject to future changes if considered appropriate. Yours faithfully, Simon Topping Executive Director (Banking Policy) ECAIs (Annex 1) (Word file, 135KB) ECAIs (Annex 2) (PDF file, 19KB) ECAIs (Annex 3) (Word file, 37KB) ECAIs (Annex 4) (PDF file, 175KB) ECAIs (Annex 5) (Word file, 29KB) Last revision date : 01 August 2011
Annex 1
Recognition of External Credit Assessment Institutions
Introduction
Basel II permits banks a choice between the Standardized Approach and the Internal Ratings-Based Approaches for calculating their capital requirements for credit risk. The Standardized Approach requires banks to use credit assessments provided by external credit assessment institutions (ECAIs) recognized as eligible for capital purposes by national supervisors to determine the risk-weights on their credit exposures, including exposures related to securitization.
National supervisors are responsible for determining whether an ECAI meets the eligibility criteria listed in paragraph 91 of the paper “International Convergence of Capital Measurement and Capital Standards” issued by the Basel Committee in November 2005 (Basel II), so that banks incorporated in their jurisdictions can use the ECAI’s risk assessments for the calculation of capital requirement under Basel II.
This paper sets out the HKMA’s proposed approach to the recognition of eligible ECAIs, and is structured as follows:
the interpretation and application of the criteria for assessing whether an ECAI is eligible – Section II;
the approach to mapping the ECAI assessments to risk-weights under the Standardized Approach and Securitization Framework – Section III;
the application process and the information required to support an application – Section IV; and
the guidelines applicable to Authorization Institutions (AIs) with respect to nomination of ECAIs – Section V.
II. Recognition criteria
The key purpose of the recognition criteria is to identify ECAIs that produce credit assessments of sufficiently high quality, consistency and robustness to be used by banks for regulatory capital purposes.
For this purpose, the HKMA will take into account the following six criteria (set out in Basel II as shown in the boxes below) in determining the eligibility of an ECAI:
6.1 Objectivity
| The methodology for assigning credit assessments must be rigorous, systematic, and subject to some form of validation |
|---|
| based on historical experience. Moreover, assessments must be subject to ongoing review and responsive to changes in |
| financial condition. Before being recognized by supervisors, an assessment methodology for each market segment, including |
| rigorous backtesting, must have been established for at least one year and preferably three years. |
6.1.1 The objectivity of an ECAI’s methodology can be assessed on the following parameters:
(a) The ECAI must document and use rigorous, systematic assessment methodologies to ensure issuing of credible and reliable ratings.
(b) The assessment methodologies must incorporate factors relevant in determining an entity’s creditworthiness and have been established for each market segment (e.g. sovereigns, corporates and structured products) in respect of which the ECAI intends to seek recognition. Before being recognized by the HKMA, the core assessment methodology for each market segment must have been established for at least one year and preferably three years.
(c) The assessment methodologies of the ECAI should be based on both qualitative and quantitative approaches.
(d) The ECAI must have arrangements and follow procedures to ensure that its established assessment methodologies are applied accurately and consistently in making all credit assessments. For example, the ECAI is expected to have in place a rating committee to decide on the rating and an internal audit function (or a function that plays similar role and carries out similar tasks) which assesses the compliance of the ECAI with its internal policies.
(e) The ECAI must have and follow procedures established to ensure that its rating assessments are reviewed on an ongoing basis and updated in a timely manner, particularly on the occurrence of material events, including significant sector or issue-specific events.
(f) The ECAI should have a mechanism to review its methodologies and procedures to adapt them to changing environment.
(g) The ECAI should demonstrate that its rating methodologies are subject to robust, quantitative back-testing, using at least 12 months back-data. For this purpose, the ECAI should calculate and publish default studies, rating accuracy tests or transition matrices, based on its definition of default. Procedures should be in place to ensure that systematic rating errors reflected by back-testing and/or on-going review will be incorporated into the rating methodologies.
6.2 Independence
| An ECAI should be independent and should not be subject to political or economic pressures that may influence the rating. |
|---|
| The assessment process should be as free as possible from any constraints that could arise in situations where the |
| composition of the board of directors or the shareholder structure of the assessment institution may be seen as creating a |
| conflict of interest. |
6.2.1 The independence of an ECAI shall be assessed on the basis of the following factors:
(a) Ownership - the ownership of the ECAI and the composition of its Board of Directors should not be such that could jeopardize the objectivity of the rating process.
(b) Organizational structure - the ECAI should structure its businesses to ensure that its ratings have been thoroughly analysed, reviewed, and approved by independent and relevant persons within the institution’s organizational structure. An ECAI may do this by demonstrating:
that all rating decisions are made by a rating committee composed of adequately qualified and experienced individuals in accordance with the ECAI’s established criteria and methodology;
the presence of an internal audit or supervisory function or functions to carry out independent review on the rating methodologies, procedures and practices; and
the existence of firewalls separating ratings services and analysts from affiliated businesses, if any.
(c) Corporate governance - the ECAI has in place high standards of corporate governance that safeguard independence of its risk assessment and promote integrity. This can be demonstrated by:
the adoption and adherence to a code of conduct in line with market standards and internationally recognized principles (e.g. the IOSCO Code of Conduct Fundamentals for Credit Rating Agencies), and the public disclosure of such code; and
the existence of a mechanism in the ECAI to prevent, manage and eliminate conflicts of interest, including adequate safeguards to ensure that the ECAI’s rating assessments are independent from its major clients and issuers and that its staff and their relationships with the rated entities are regularly monitored.
(d) Financial resources - the ECAI must be financially viable so that it can operate free from economic and political pressures exerted by its owners/shareholders or rated entities. In meeting this requirement, an ECAI needs to demonstrate that its financial viability does not depend upon a few clients.
6.3 International access / Transparency
| The individual assessments should be available to both domestic and foreign institutions with legitimate interests and at |
|---|
| equivalent terms. In addition, the general methodology used by the ECAI should be publicly available. |
6.3.1 An ECAI’s individual credit assessments must be accessible to any bank or credit institution that intends to use the credit assessments of the respective ECAI to calculate its regulatory capital requirements under Basel II.
6.3.2 Every bank or credit institution as referred to under 6.3.1 must be provided access to the credit assessments at equivalent terms, without undue discrimination in the terms and prices offered to domestic versus non-domestic banks or credit institutions.
6.3.3 For each rating, the ECAI should disclose whether the rating issued is solicited or unsolicited. Unsolicited ratings will receive the same treatment as solicited ratings if an ECAI can demonstrate that:
a) it has stated policies and procedures regarding unsolicited ratings which demonstrate that the methodologies used for unsolicited assessment will not be less stringent than those for solicited assessment and that the ECAI does not differentiate between unsolicited and solicited ratings in its credit judgements; and
b) it clearly identifies those ratings that are unsolicited.
In considering whether to accept an ECAI’s unsolicited ratings, the HKMA may request the ECAI concerned to provide statistical evidence of changes in ratings which were assigned on an unsolicited basis or of changes in status of ratings from an unsolicited basis to a solicited basis and explanation on such changes so as to demonstrate that it has not used unsolicited ratings to put pressure on entities to obtain solicited ratings. When the HKMA is aware of an ECAI using unsolicited ratings to put pressure on entities to obtain solicited ratings, it will consider whether to continue recognizing the ECAI for capital adequacy purposes.
6.3.4 The principles of the methodology employed by an ECAI for the formulation of its credit assessments should be publicly available.
6.4 Disclosure
| An ECAI should disclose the following information: its assessment methodologies, including the definition of default, the |
|---|
| time horizon, and the meaning of each rating; the actual default rates experienced in each assessment category; and the |
| transitions of the assessment, e.g. the likelihood of AA ratings becoming A over time. |
6.4.1 To enable users to decide about the appropriateness of risk assessments, ECAI should make public the following information:
a) assessment methodologies, including timely disclosure of any material changes in the methodologies;
b) meaning of each rating;
c) definition of default, the time horizon within which a default is considered and, where appropriate, a measure of loss given a default;
d) actual default rates experienced in each rating category;
e) transition matrices (i.e. rating transitions of assessed entities over time, e.g. the likelihood of AA ratings become A over time);
f) whether rating was solicited or unsolicited (and definition of unsolicited rating); and
g) code of conduct.
6.5 Resources
| An ECAI should have sufficient resources to carry out high quality credit assessments. These resources should allow for |
|---|
| substantial on going contact with senior and operational levels within the entities assessed in order to add value to the |
| credit assessments. Such assessments should be based on methodologies combining qualitative and quantitative approaches. |
6.5.1 An ECAI should have sufficient financial and human resources to carry out high quality credit assessments. The ECAI must demonstrate that:
a) it is financially sound and has the capability to invest in the necessary technological infrastructure to ensure speedy acquisition and processing of data/information and timely release of reliable and credible ratings;
b) it has established recruitment and training policies to ensure that its professional analytical staff possess the necessary experience and skills to carry out risk assessments thoroughly and competently;
(c) the size of its professional analytical staff is sufficient to allow the use of established procedures to ensure credible, reliable and consistent assessments and on-going contact with the rated entities as a routine component of the surveillance process; and
(d) it has the expertise in assessing securitization, if recognition of its credit assessment of securitizations is sought.
6.6 Credibility
| To some extent, credibility is derived from the criteria above. In addition, the reliance on an ECAI’s external credit |
|---|
| assessments by independent parties (investors, insurers, trading partners) is evidence of the credibility of the assessments |
| of an ECAI. The credibility of an ECAI is also underpinned by the existence of internal procedures to prevent the misuse of |
| confidential information. In order to be eligible for recognition, an ECAI does not have to assess firms in more than one |
| country. |
6.6.1 Credibility can be assessed according to factors such as the following:
a) the extent to which the ECAI meets criteria 6.1 to 6.5;
b) the market share of the ECAI, particularly in the market in which the ECAI is operating and where recognition is sought;
c) the degree of acceptance by predominant users in the market (i.e. issuers, investors, bankers, insurers, securities traders and other financial services regulators (e.g. securities regulators or regulators from other countries));
d) statistical data that demonstrates market reliance on the credit rating agency’s ratings (e.g. market movements in response to ratings changes);
e) existence of internal procedures to prevent the misuse or unauthorised disclosure of confidential information;
f) the adequacy of financial resources of the ECAI; and
(g) whether there is any pricing difference on the basis of rating results.
6.6.2 An ECAI does not need to assess institutions in more than one country to be eligible for recognition.
Concerning the use an eligible ECAI’s credit assessments of securitizations in the standardized and IRB approaches of the Securitization Framework, the credit assessments must be publicly available and included in the ECAI’s transition matrix in order to be eligible for risk-weighting purposes. Further, the assessment must take into account and reflect the entire amount of credit risk exposure the AI has with regard to all payments owed to it. For example, if the AI is owed both principal and interest, the credit assessment must fully take into account and reflect the credit risk associated with timely payment of both principle and interest.
Credit assessments of exposures in the form of a collective investment scheme (as defined under the Capital Rules) by an eligible ECAI is eligible for risk weighting purposes, provided that the assessments must fulfil the following criteria:
a) the assessments must depend primarily on the credit quality of the assets held by the scheme; and
b) the assessments must be for fixed-income collective investment schemes (e.g. money market funds and bond funds) only. This means that equity funds should be treated in accordance with the equity treatment of the Capital Rules.
Mapping process
The HKMA will assign an eligible ECAI’s rating categories to the risk-weights available under the Standardized Approach and Securitization Framework, i.e. deciding which rating categories correspond to which risk-weights.
In doing so, the HKMA will consider a variety of qualitative and quantitative factors to differentiate between the relative degrees of risk expressed by each rating category. Quantitative parameters may help to promote a more consistent mapping of rating categories into the available risk-weights under the Standardized Approach.
Quantitative factors
As recommended by the Basel Committee, the HKMA will evaluate the cumulative default rate (CDR) associated with all issues assigned the same risk rating by an ECAI to help determine the appropriate risk-weights to which the ECAI’s rating categories should be mapped.
The HKMA will evaluate two separate measures of CDRs associated with each Credit Quality Grade (represented by the numerals of 1 to 5 or 6, with 1 being the best) contained in the Standardized Approach, using in both cases the CDR measured over a three-year period (i.e. three-year CDR), that is, the sum of all defaults that have occurred in a given three-year period for all rated items belonging to the same rating category. The two measures are:
a) for evaluation of the long-run default experience over time, the ten-year average of the three-year CDR[1]; and
(b) for evaluation of the most recent record of default experience, the most recent three-year CDR.
Both of the measures under paragraphs 13(a) and (b) provided by the particular ECAI will be compared to the aggregate default experience of other ECAIs internationally.
The long-run default experience of the ECAI will be compared with the reference values of CDRs (i.e. the “long-run reference three-year CDRs” as set out in Table 2 of Annex 2 of Basel II), based on the Basel Committee’s observations of the default experience reported by major rating agencies internationally.
Recognizing that the ten-year average of an eligible ECAI’s particular rating category would not be expected to match exactly the long-run reference three-year CDRs, Basel II has provided national supervisors with two benchmarks for CDRs to assist them in interpreting whether a CDR falls within an acceptable range for a rating category to qualify for a particular risk-weight, namely a “monitoring” level benchmark and a “trigger” level benchmark.
The HKMA proposes to adopt the two benchmarks for CDR developed by the Basel Committee, (i.e. Table 3 of Annex 2 in Basel II) in its mapping process. Specifically, the HKMA will compare the two most recent three-year CDR provided by the ECAI to the “benchmarks” for CDRs and determine the mapping based on the guidance under paragraphs 18 and 19 below.
Exceeding the “monitoring” level CDR benchmark implies that a rating agency’s current default experience for a particular rating category is markedly higher than international default experience. Although such assessments would generally still be considered eligible for the associated risk-weights, the HKMA will consult the relevant ECAI to understand why the default experience appears to be significantly worse. If it is determined that the higher default experience is attributable to weaker standards in assessing credit risk, a higher Credit Quality Grade (e.g. move from Credit Quality Grade 2 to Credit Quality Grade 3) may be assigned to the ECAI’s rating category.
Exceeding the “trigger” level benchmark implies that an ECAI’s default experience is considerably above the international historical default experience for a particular risk category. Thus there is a presumption that the ECAI’s standards for assessing credit risk are either too weak or are not applied appropriately. If the observed three-year CDR exceeds the trigger level in two consecutive years, the HKMA will move the rating category into a higher Credit Quality Grade, unless we are satisfied that the higher observed CDR is not attributable to weaker assessment standards.
For recently established ECAIs and those that have compiled only a short record of default data, the HKMA may ask the ECAI for its two most recent CDRs and a projection of the ten-year average of the three-year CDR, i.e. the value that the ECAI believes to be the long-term default rate associated with all items assigned the same credit assessment. the HKMA will review this assessment on the basis of the availability of data and the methodology used by the ECAI in question, comparing it with those used to calculate the benchmarks. Based on the consideration of such qualitative factors (e.g. those set out in paragraph 23), the HKMA may then adjust the mapping of the ECAI accordingly.
The HKMA may also compare the default rates of an ECAI seeking for recognition with other major ECAIs to see if there is a general trend of higher default rates during a particular period and take this factor into account in the mapping process. This kind of comparison is particularly relevant for ECAIs that concentrate in rating regional entities and during the time of a regional economic downturn as the average default rates may be higher than the benchmarks developed by the Basel Committee.
Qualitative factors
The measures of CDRs as mentioned above will form the central basis of the mapping process. They are the key to ensure consistency between the credit assessments of different ECAIs and to differentiate the relative degree of risk expressed by each credit rating in the mapping process. However, the mapping process should also take into account qualitative factors which influence the comparability of the credit assessment’s CDRs with the benchmark CDRs. This is because what rating agencies are measuring varies from one another and different ECAIs employ different methodologies.
Hence, the quantitative assessment may need to be adjusted due to differences in qualitative factors associated with the ECAI in question and the international entities upon which the Basel Committee constructed its benchmarks, such as the following:
a) definition of default and the variables used to weight default events. An ECAI may use a more or less stringent definition as compared to the international benchmark, which may lead to discrepancies of CDRs. Similarly, the choice of variables used to weight default events may have an impact on the results;
b) treatment of debt issuers whose ratings are withdrawn over time because all their rated debt has matured or they have been acquired by another company or for any other reason (censored obligors), in the default rate calculation. The inclusion of censored obligors in the default rate calculation during the observation period will likely produce downwardly biased default rate estimates;
c) meaning of each credit assessment i.e. the substance of the opinion represented by a particular rating category. An ECAI’s assessments may measure the “probability of default” for the instrument rated or the “expected loss” in the event of the issuer default. The difference in the basis of assessment may result in apparent performance discrepancies between ECAIs that use one form of rating measure as opposed to the other;
d) pool of issuers covered (which may be static or periodically adjusted);
e) range of rating categories assigned by the ECAI;
f) dynamic properties and characteristics of the rating system or methodology (e.g. a “point-in-time” rating system or a “through the cycle” system); and
g) geographical coverage, i.e. the use of regional or global data.
Application process
Applicant
An application for ECAI recognition may be initiated by the HKMA, AIs intending to use an ECAI’s ratings under the Standardized Approach, or ECAIs themselves, as appropriate.
Where an AI intends to use the ratings of an ECAI, it should disclose to the HKMA its intention. The HKMA will then invite the relevant ECAI to apply for recognition.
In considering an application, the HKMA would first wish to establish whether the applicant concerned has already been recognized by other supervisors and consider if it could rely on the recognition of such supervisor (see paragraph 31 below for details on the indirect recognition approach to be adopted by the HKMA).
When an application is initiated by an ECAI, it should demonstrate that at least one AI intends to use its ratings for prudential risk-weighting purposes. This requirement is meant to ensure that only applications of ECAIs whose ratings would genuinely be used for prudential risk-weighting purposes will be considered.
Irrespective of which party is to initiate an application for recognition, any application should be supported by all relevant information deemed necessary for the purpose of recognition. The Annex sets out the information that ECAIs will be required to submit for recognition, which is indicative and non-exhaustive. The application should also be supported by evidence that the credit assessments will be used for risk-weighting purposes under the revised capital adequacy framework.
Group-level application for recognition
Indirect recognition
Segmented recognition
Basel II allows for assessments of ECAIs to be recognized on a limited basis, e.g. by type of claims or by jurisdiction. It appears that ECAIs generally categorize rated institutions into the following three broad asset classes or market segments: structured finance (including securitization), public finance (including sovereign and municipalities) and commercial entities (including banks, investment firms and insurance companies).
An ECAI only needs to make a single submission covering its application for recognition in various different market segments. However, it will need to provide separate information when rating methodologies, procedures, or information differ by market segments and/or by products.
An ECAI should specify the purpose of the recognition, i.e. for use of credit assessment to determine the risk-weight of an institution’s credit exposure under the Standardized Approach for credit risk and/or for the risk-weight of securitization exposures under the Standardized Approach and Internal Ratings-Based Approaches.
On-going recognition
a) to verify that ECAIs have procedures in place to ensure that their credit assessments remain appropriate over different time periods and market conditions, including that:
their ratings are reviewed at least annually, and revised in response to changes in financial conditions; and
their ratings are subject to back-testing on an annual basis.
(b) to require ECAIs to inform the HKMA promptly of any material changes in the methodology they use for assigning ratings, including changes that alter a significant number of ratings or potentially prompt the need for a change in mapping, as well as any significant changes in other recognition criteria (e.g. change of ownership or internal structure and major deterioration in financial positions).
(c) to review the continuing eligibility of an ECAI if it comes to the HKMA’s attention that there is a marked deterioration in the performance and/or market acceptance of the agency.
(d) the HKMA shall withdraw the recognition of any eligible ECAI that ceases to comply with the recognition criteria, having regard to the impact of such a decision on AIs and the relevant considerations and decisions of other regulatory authorities that have also recognized the ECAI concerned for the purposes of their capital adequacy regimes. Before a decision of derecognition is made, the HKMA will first notify the ECAI concerned in writing of its intention to withdraw the recognition as well as which of the eligibility criteria in respect of which the HKMA is considering non-compliance by the ECAI. The ECAI concerned will be allowed to make written representations to the HKMA within a reasonable period of time after being notified. Where representations are made by the ECAI, the HKMA will take them into account in deciding whether to derecognize the ECAI.
III. Guidelines applicable to authorized institutions with respect to the nomination of external credit assessment institutions
a) nominate one or more ECAI(s) (the “nominated ECAI(s)”) that their assigned ratings will be used by the AI for deriving risk-weights for exposures in each of the external ratings-based portfolios, provided that the nominated ECAI(s) can provide a reasonable coverage on the AI’s exposures within the portfolios in terms of the types of counterparties and different geographical regions covered by the ECAI(s), having regard to other ECAIs that have already been recognized by the HKMA;
b) notify the HKMA on its nominated ECAI(s) and the application of the ratings of such ECAI(s) on each of the AI’s external ratings-based portfolios;
c) use the ratings of the nominated ECAI(s) within each of the external ratings-based portfolios consistently, and seek the consent of the HKMA on any subsequent changes to such ECAI(s) and the application of its/their ratings; and
d) treat a relevant exposure or the person to whom the AI has a relevant exposure as “unrated” for risk-weighting purposes if that exposure or that person does not have a rating assigned to it by any ECAI chosen by the AI.
The above requirements are to ensure that an AI applies the ratings of its nominated ECAIs consistently and avoid any possible cherry-picking of ratings provided by different ECAIs.
In determining its nominated ECAIs, an AI should pay special attention to the criterion of “reasonable coverage”. Where an AI has significant exposures within the external ratings-based portfolios to a particular type of counterparties or a particular country that are not rated by the AI’s nominated ECAIs but by other ECAI(s) recognized by the HKMA, the AI should include such ECAI as a nominated ECAI to comply with the “reasonable coverage” requirement. For example, if an AI has significant exposures to issuers in a particular country and such issuers are only rated by a domestic ECAI which is recognized by the HKMA, the AI should include such ECAI as one of its nominated ECAIs and use the ratings assigned by the ECAI to determine the risk-weights for its exposures to issuers in that country.
The HKMA may give recognition to a particular ECAI for its ratings with respect to a particular market segment or geographical region only. In such case, AIs should not apply the ECAI’s ratings that do not fall within the HKMA’s recognition in risk-weighting their exposures.
Hong Kong Monetary Authority
June 2006
Annex
List of information required for recognizing ECAI
Objectivity
how this methodology is determined, implemented, reviewed and changed;
a description of the process in place to ensure the consistent application of the assessment methodologies across all credit assessments, in particular the role of rating committees and guidelines governing them, the extent of input from rated entities, the access to non-public information etc; and
quantitative inputs (e.g. key variables, data sources, assumptions and quantitative techniques used, extent of input from rated entities) and qualitative inputs (e.g. regarding the strategy, business plans of the rated entities).
If the ECAI employs different methodologies for different market segments, and/or products (particularly for structured products), separate explanation should be provided for each market segment in respect of which the ECAI intends to seek recognition from the supervisor.
Details on back-testing including:
a description of the methodology used by an ECAI to verify the accuracy of its ratings systems;
the latest back-testing results and conclusions; and
a description of the process in place to ensure that systematic errors in ratings highlighted by back-testing will be addressed by changes in rating methodologies.
Independence
country of incorporation and year of establishment;
an overview of the group structure of the ECAI showing the holding company and subsidiaries, if any;
a list of shareholders who hold more than a 10% of interest or voting rights and the composition of board of directors; and
a copy of organization structure.
summary of arrangements for separating rating and non-rating parts of the organization;
disclosure of any ratings that have been issued for any shareholders and description of policies and procedures that have been implemented to ensure fair and objective ratings are produced in such cases;
self-certification of internal audit function (or a function that plays similar role and carries out similar tasks) to ensure that internal policies are followed – including details of remit, independence, resources and power; and
self-certification of adherence to a Code of Conduct similar to that proposed by IOSCO and explanation of non-adherence, if any.
International access/Transparency/Disclosure
Evidence that the ECAI has disclosed sufficient information to the public (including rating methodology, individual risk assessment, types of credit assessment, i.e. solicited or unsolicited).
Evidence that modifications to methodologies and ratings are made known to the public as soon as possible.
Evidence of efforts to ease public access, such as creating helpdesks, providing free publications and giving public presentations.
Evidence that credit assessments are accessible at equivalent terms to all parties, both domestic and non-domestic, with legitimate interest in them.
Evidence that the credit assessments of securitization exposures are published in an accessible form to the public and included in the transition matrices if the recognition of its credit assessments of securitization positions is sought.
Resources
evidence that the ECAI’s income does not depend on a few major clients (N.B. the ECAI is not required to disclose the names of the clients for confidentiality reasons.);
financial statements for the last three years; and
letter of support from the parent entity (if applicable).
self-certification that key staff possess requisite skills level to carry out risk assessment thoroughly and competently; and
a brief description of the recruitment and training policy to demonstrate that staff with appropriate skills are being recruited and their skills are maintained or improved over time through an adequate training programme.
Credibility
the estimated market shares of the ECAI (breakdown by segment of geographic location, if possible);
statistical evidence which demonstrates market reliance on the ratings;
authorities that have recognized its rating including their names and purposes; and
list of countries where the ECAI is active.
Self-certification that there is no structural pricing difference on the rating results.
Evidence of internal procedures or safeguards to prevent the misuse of information by staff.
Mapping
the definition of default;
a description of the methodology to calculate the CDRs including:
i) two most recent three-year CDRs for each credit assessment category;
ii) ten-year average of the three-year CDR;
iii) selection of pool (static versus dynamic/adjusted); and
iv) aggregation of defaults (weighting mechanism);
the statistical significance of the default rates;
the meaning of the credit assessment categories, the range of credit assessments that the ECAI assigns and the target probability of default for each individual credit assessment category, if any;
the internal mapping of its short term assessments to long term assessments
transition matrices;
geographic coverage; and
dynamic characteristics of the rating methodology (point-in-time or through the cycle).
[1] In 2002, for example, a supervisor would calculate the average of the three-year CDRs for issuers assigned to each rating grade (“the cohort”) for each of the ten years 1990-1999.
Annex 2
TABLE A
EXPOSURES TO SOVEREIGNS
Credit quality grade
(sovereigns)
Riskweight
Standard &
Poor’s
Ratings
Services
Moody’s
Investors
Service
Fitch
Ratings
Rating and
Investment
Information,
Inc.
1 0% AAA
AA+
AA
AAAaa
Aa1
Aa2
Aa3
AAA
AA+
AA
AAAAA
AA+
AA
AA2 20% A+
A
AA1
A2
A3
A+
A
AA+
A
A3 50% BBB+
BBB
BBBBaa1
Baa2
Baa3
BBB+
BBB
BBBBBB+
BBB
BBB4 100% BB+
BB
BBBa1
Ba2
Ba3
BB+
BB
BBBB+
BB
BB5 100% B+
B
BB1
B2
B3
B+
B
BB+
B
B6 150% CCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
D
Caa1
Caa2
Caa3
Ca
C
CCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
D
CCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
TABLE B
EXPOSURES TO BANKS AND SECURITIES FIRMS
Credit quality grade
(banks and securities firms)
Riskweight
Riskweight for short-term exposures
Standard &
Poor’s
Ratings
Services
Moody’s
Investors
Service
Fitch
Ratings
Rating and
Investment
Information,
Inc.
1 20% 20% AAA
AA+
AA
AAAaa
Aa1
Aa2
Aa3
AAA
AA+
AA
AAAAA
AA+
AA
AA2 50% 20% A+
A
AA1
A2
A3
A+
A
AA+
A
A3 50% 20% BBB+
BBB
BBBBaa1
Baa2
Baa3
BBB+
BBB
BBBBBB+
BBB
BBB4 100% 50% BB+
BB
BBB+
B
BBa1
Ba2
Ba3
B1
B2
B3
BB+
BB
BBB+
B
BBB+
BB
BBB+
B
B5 150% 150% CCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
D
Caa1
Caa2
Caa3
Ca
C
CCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
D
CCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
TABLE C
EXPOSURES TO CORPORATES
Credit quality grade
(corporates)
Riskweight
Standard &
Poor’s Ratings
Services
Moody’s
Investors
Service
Fitch
Ratings
Rating and
Investment
Information,
Inc.
1 20% AAA
AA+
AA
AAAaa
Aa1
Aa2
Aa3
AAA
AA+
AA
AAAAA
AA+
AA
AA2 50% A+
A
AA1
A2
A3
A+
A
AA+
A
A3 100% BBB+
BBB
BBBBaa1
Baa2
Baa3
BBB+
BBB
BBBBBB+
BBB
BBB4 100% BB+
BB
BBBa1
Ba2
Ba3
BB+
BB
BBBB+
BB
BB5 150% B+
B
BCCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
D
B1
B2
B3
Caa1
Caa2
Caa3
Ca
C
B+
B
BCCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
D
B+
B
BCCC+
CCC
CCCCC
C
TABLE D
SHORT-TERM EXPOSURES ( BANKS, SECURITIES FIRMS AND CORPORATES) Short-term credit quality grade (banks, securities firms and corporates) Riskweight Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services Moody’s Investors Service Fitch Ratings Rating and Investment Information, Inc. 1 20% A-1+ A-1 P-1 F1+ F1 a-1+ a-1 2 50% A-2
P-2 F2 a-2
3 100% A-3 P-3 F3 a-3
4 150% B
B-1
B-2
B-3
C
D
Not
Prime
B
C
D b c
Annex 3
List of recognized ECAIs and the respective minimum acceptable ratings
| Recognized ECAIs | Minimum Rating Required | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liquidity Regime[1] | Market Risk Capital | Lender of Last | Profits Tax | ||
| Adequacy[2] | Resort[3] | Concession | |||
| Scheme[4] | |||||
| Long-term | Short-term | ||||
| Fitch Ratings | A- | F1 | BBB- | BBB- | BBB- |
| Moody’s Investors Service | A3 | P-1 | Baa3 | Baa3 | Baa3 |
| Rating and Investment Information, | A- | a-1 | BBB- | BBB- | BBB- |
| Inc. | |||||
| Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services | A- | A-1 | BBB- | BBB- | BBB- |
The MA reserves the right to make adjustments to the list of rating agencies and minimum credit ratings recognized by the MA.
[1] Refers to HKMA’s guideline on Liquidity Risk Management issued on 20 August 2004 [2] Refers to HKMA's guideline on Maintenance of Adequate Capital Against Market Risk issued on 8 March 2002 [3] Refers to HKMA’s policy statement on the Lender of Last Resort issued on 30 June 1999 [4] Refers to section 14A(4)(b) of the Inland Revenue Ordinance
Annex 4
G.N. 3804
INLAND REVENUE ORDINANCE (Chapter 112)
It is hereby notified that the minimum acceptable credit rating of Rating and Investment Infomation, Inc., a rating agency which has been recognized by the Monetary Authority for the purpose of section 14A(4)(b) of the Inland Revenue Ordinance, is revised from BBB+ to BBB. The Monetary Authority reserves the right to make adjustments to the above minimum credit rating requirement from time to time. 23 June 2006 William A. RYBACK for Monetary Authority
Press Release
Credit rating agencies recognized by the Monetary Authority under the profits tax concession scheme
The Hong Kong Monetary Authority announced today (23 June) that the minimum rating required for Rating and Investment Information, Inc. (“R&I”), a recognized credit rating agency for the purpose of the profits tax concession scheme under section 14A(4)(b) of the Inland Revenue Ordinance, has been revised from BBB+ to BBB- with immediate effect. The decision is made as a result of an updated assessment of the quality of R&I’s ratings, based on the international benchmarks of assessment of credit rating agencies’ ratings provided by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision under its Basel II framework.
Under the profits tax concession scheme, which came into effect on 24 May 1996, interest income and trading profits derived from eligible debt securities are entitled to a concessionary tax rate equal to 50% of the prevailing profits tax rate. To be eligible, a debt issue should, among other criteria, possess a minimum credit rating from a rating agency recognized by the Monetary Authority (MA).
Subsequent to the revision of the minimum rating requirement of R&I, the four existing credit rating agencies that have been recognized by the MA for the purpose of the profits tax concession scheme since May 1996 and their minimum rating requirements are:
| Recognized credit rating agency | Minimum rating required |
|---|---|
| Fitch Ratings | BBB- |
| Moody’s Investors Service | Baa3 |
| Rating and Investment Information, Inc. | BBB- |
| Standard and Poor’s Ratings Services | BBB- |
The MA reserves the right to make adjustments to the list of rating agencies and minimum credit ratings recognized by the MA.
Hong Kong Monetary Authority
23 June 2006
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 5 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added