Rule · HKMA · 8 Sep 1988
Authorised institutions incorporated in Hong Kong must meet a minimum capital adequacy ratio of 8% by end-1992 (interim 7.25% by end-1990), with Tier 1 core capital at least 4% and Tier 2 supplementary capital no more than 100% of Tier 1; subordinated term debt is capped at 50% of Tier 1, general provisions/general loan loss reserves at 1.25 percentage points (exceptionally up to 2.0), and goodwill and investments in unconsolidated banking and financial subsidiaries are deducted. Institutions must begin planning to collect and collate data for the new ratio and complete a new return; the existing 5% minimum under the Banking Ordinance continues meanwhile.
Guideline No. 4.1.1
Our Ref. : CB / BANK / 120 8 September 1988 To : The Chief Executive, Authorised Institutions incorporated in Hong Kong. Dear Sir, Capital Adequacy I circulated last December a copy of the Basle Committee’s proposals for a new, world-wide, capital adequacy ratio. The Committee, in the light of comments and consultation, revised their initial paper, publishing a final version in July. A copy is attached. Many institutions commented, through their associations, on the December paper.. A draft version of a Hong Kong variation of the proposals was subsequently discussed with the Associations of Banks and of DTCs. It was generally agreed that Hong Kong should move from the present capital adequacy ratio to one based on the Basle format. The enclosed paper sets out such a format for Hong Kong. I have written to the two Associations seeking their views on it, by 28 September. I would particularly draw attention to the section concerning implementation, on pages 18 to 19. I would be grateful if you would begin planning to collect and collate the data needed to calculate the new ratio. Yours faithfully,
(A.W. Nicolle)
Commissioner of Banking
Encl c.c. Other authorised institutions
Local representative offices
Committee on Banking Regulations and
Supervisory Practices July 1988
INTERNATIONAL CONVERGENCE OF CAPITAL
MEASUREMENT AND CAPITAL STANDARDS
Introduction
This report presents the outcome of the Committee’s 1
work over several years to secure international convergence of supervisory regulations governing the capital adequacy of international banks. Following the publication of the Committee’s proposals in December 1987, a consultative process was set in train in all G-10 countries and the proposals were also circulated to supervisory authorities worldwide. As a result of those consultations some changes were made to the original proposals. The present paper is now a statement of the Committee agreed by all its members. It sets out the details of the agreed framework for measuring capital adequacy and the minimum standard to be achieved which the national supervisory authorities represented on the Committee intend to implement in their respective countries. The framework and this standard have been endorsed by the Group of Ten central-bank Governors.
With a view to implementation as soon as possible, it is intended
that national authorities should now prepare papers setting out their views on the timetable and the manner in which this accord will be implemented in their respective countries. This document is being circulated to supervisory authorities world with a view to encouraging the adoption of this framework in countries outside the G-10 in respect of banks conducting significant international business. _______________________________________________________________ 1 The Basle Committee on Banking Regulations and Supervisory Practices comprises representatives of the central banks and supervisory authorities of the Group of Ten countries (Belgium, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom, United States) and Luxembourg. The Committee meets at the Bank for International Settlements, Basle, Switerzland.
Two fundamental objectives lie at the heart of the Committee’s
work on regulatory convergence. These are, firstly, that the new framework should serve to strengthen the soundness and stability of the international banking system; and secondly that the framework should be fair and have a high degree of consistency in its application to banks in different countries with a view to diminishing an existing source of competitive inequality among international banks. The Committee notes that, in responding to the invitation to comment on its original proposals, banks have welcomed the general shape and rationale of the framework and have expressed support for the view that it should be applied as uniformly as possible at the national level.
Throughout the recent consultations, close contact has been
maintained between the Committee in Basle and the authorities of the European Community in Brussels who are pursuing a parallel initiative to develop a common solvency ratio to be applied to credit institutions in the Community. The aim has been to ensure the maximum degree of consistency between the framework agreed in Basle and the framework to be applied in the Community. It is the Committee’s hope and expectation that this consistency can be achieved although it should be noted that regulations in the European Community are designed to apply to credit institution generally, whereas the Committee’s framework is directed more specifically with banks undertaking international business in mind.
In developing the framework described in this document the
Committee has sought to arrive at a set of principles which are conceptually sound and at the same time pay due regard to particular features of the present supervisory and accounting systems in individual member countries. It believes that this objective has been achieved. The framework provides for a transitional period so that the existing circumstances in different countries can be reflected in flexible arrangements that allow time for adjustment.
In certain very limited respects (notably as regards some of the
risk weightings) the framework allows for a degree of national discretion in the way in which it is applied. The impact of such discrepancies on the overall ratios is likely to be negligible and it is not considered that they will compromise the basic objectives. Nevertheless, the Committee intends to monitor and review the application of the framework in the period ahead with a view to achieving even greater consistency.
It should be stressed that the agreed framework is designed to
establish minimum levels of capital for internationally active banks. National authorities will be free to adopt arrangements that set higher levels.
It should also be emphasised that capital adequacy as measured
by the present framework, though important, is one of a number of factors to be taken into account when assessing the strength of banks. The framework in this document is mainly directed towards assessing capital in relation to credit risk (the risk of counterparty failure) but other risks, notably interest rate risk and the investment risk on securities, need to be taken into account by
supervisors in assessing overall capital adequacy. The Committee is examining possible approaches in relation to these risks. Furthermore, and more generally, capital ratios, judged in isolation, may provide a misleading guide to relative strength. Much also depends on the quality of a bank’s assets and, importantly, the level of provisions a bank may be holding outside its capital against assets of doubtful value. Recognising the close relationship between capital and provisions, the Committee will continue to monitor provisioning policies by banks in member countries and will seek to promote convergence of policies in this field as in other regulatory matters. In assessing progress by banks in member countries towards meeting the agreed capital standards, the Committee will therefore take careful account of any differences in existing policies and procedures for setting the level of provisions among countries’ banks and in the form in which such provisions are constituted.
9. The Committee is aware that differences between countries in
the fiscal treatment and accounting presentation for tax purposes of certain classes of provisions for losses and of capital reserves derived from retained earnings may to some extent distort the comparability of the real or apparent capital position of international banks. Convergence in tax regimes, though desirable, lies outside the competence of the Committee and tax considerations are not addressed in this paper. However, the Committee wishes to keep these tax and accounting matters under review to the extent that they affect the comparability of the capital adequacy of different countries’ banking systems.
10. This agreement is intended to be applied to banks on a
consolidated basis, including subsidiaries undertaking banking and financial business. At the same time, the Committee recognises that ownership structures and the position of banks within financial conglomerate groups are undergoing significant changes. The Committee will be concerned to ensure that ownership structures should not be such as to weaken the capital position of the bank or expose it to risks stemming from other parts of the group. The Committee will continue to keep these developments under review in the light of the particular regulations in member countries, in order to ensure that the integrity of the capital of banks is maintained. In the case of several of the subjects for further work mentioned above, notably investment risk and the consolidated supervision of financial groups, the European Community has undertaken or is undertaking work with similar objectives and close liaison will be maintained.
11. This document is divided into four sections. The first two
describe the framework: Section I the constituents of capital and Section II the risk weighting system. Section III deals with the target standard ratio; and
Section IV with transitional and implementing arrangements.
I. THE CONSTITUENTS OF CAPITAL
(a) Core capital (basic equity)
12. The Committee considers that the key element of capital on
which the main emphasis should be placed is equity capital 2 and disclosed reserves. This key element of capital is the only element common to all countries’ banking systems; it is wholly visible in the published accounts and is the basis on which most market judgments of capital adequacy are made; and it has a crucial bearing on profit margins and a bank’s ability to compete. This emphasis on equity capital and disclosed reserves reflects the importance the Committee attaches to securing a progressive enhancement in the quality, as well as the level, of the total capital resources maintained by major banks. 3 _______________________________________________________________ 2 Issued and full paid ordinary shares/common stock and non-cumulative perpetual preferred stock (but excluding cumulative preferred stock). 3 One member country, however, maintains the view that an international definition of capital should be confined to core capital elements and indicated that it would continue to press for the definition to be reconsidered by the Committee in the years ahead.
13. Notwithstanding this emphasis, the member countries of the
Committee also consider that there are a number of other important and legitimate constituents of a bank’s capital base which may be included within the system of measurement (subject to certain conditions set out in sub-section (b) below).
14. The Committee has therefore concluded that capital, for supervisory
purposes, should be defined in two tiers in a way which will have the effect of requiring at least 50 per cent. of a bank’s capital base to consist of a core element comprised of equity capital and published reserves from post-tax retained earning ( tier 1). The other elements of capital (supplementary capital) will be admitted into tier 2 up to an amount equal to that of the core capital. These supplementary capital elements and the particular conditions attaching to their inclusion in the capital base are set out below and in more detail in Annex
1. Each of these elements may be included or not included by national
authorities at their discretion in the light of their national accounting and supervisory regulations. (b) Supplementary capital (i) Undisclosed reserves
15. Unpublished or hidden reserves may be constituted in various
ways according to differing legal and accounting regimes in member countries. Under this heading are included only reserves which, though unpublished, have been passed through the profit and loss account and which are accepted by the bank’s supervisory authorities. They may be inherently of the same intrinsic quality as published retained earnings, but, in the context of an internationally agreed minimum standard, their lack of transparency, together with the fact that many countries do not recognise undisclosed reserves, either as an accepted accounting concept or as a legitimate element of capital, argue for excluding them from the core equity capital element. (ii) Revaluation reserves
16. Some countries, under their national regulatory or accounting
arrangements, allow certain assets to be revalued to reflect their current value, or something closer to their current value than historic cost, and the resultant revaluations can arise in two ways:
(a) from a formal revaluation, carried through to the balance sheets of banks’ own premises; or (b) from a notional addition to capital of hidden values which arise from the practice of holding securities in the balance sheet valued at historic cost. Such reserves may be included within supplementary capital provided that the assets are considered by the supervisory authority to be
prudently valued, fully reflecting the possibility of price fluctuations and forced sale.
17. Alternative (b) is relevant to those banks whose balance sheets
traditionally include very substantial amounts of equities held in their portfolio at historic cost but which can be, and on occasions are, realised at current prices and used to offset losses. The Committee considers these “latent” revaluation reserves can be included among supplementary elements of capital since they can be used to absorb losses on a going -concern basis, provided they are subject to a substantial discount in order to reflect concerns both about markets volatility and about the tax charge which would arise were such gains to be realised. A discount of 55 per cent. on the difference between the historic cost book value and market value is agreed to be appropriate in the light of these considerations. The Committee considered, but rejected, the proposition that latent reserves arising in respect of the undervaluation of banks’ premises should also be included within the definition of supplementary capital. (iii) General provisions/general loan loss reserves
18. General provisions or general loan-loss reserves are created
against the possibility of future losses. Where they are not ascribed to particular assets and do not reflect a reduction in the valuation of particular assets, these reserves qualify for inclusion in capital and it has been agreed that they should be counted within tier 2. Where, however, provisions have been created against identified losses or in respect of a demonstrable deterioration in the value of particular assets, they are not freely available to meet unidentified losses which may subsequently arise elsewhere in the portfolio and do not possess an essential characteristic of capital. Such specific or earmarked provisions should therefore not be included in the capital base.
19. The Committee accepts, however, that, in practice, it is not always
possible to distinguish clearly between general provisions (or general loan loss reserves) which are genuinely freely available and those provisions which in reality are earmarked against assets already identified as impaired. This partly reflects the present diversity of accounting, supervisory, and importantly, fiscal policies in respect of provisioning and in respect of national definitions of capital. This means, inevitably, that initially there will be a degree of inconsistency in the characteristics of general provisions or general loan-loss reserves included by different member countries within the framework.
20. In the light of these uncertainties, the Committee intends during the
transitional period (see paragraphs 45 to 50 below) to clarify the distinction made in member countries between those elements which should conceptually be regarded as part of capital and those which should not qualify. The Committee will aim to develop before the end of 1990 firm proposals applicable to all member countries, so as to ensure consistency in the definition of general provisions and general loan-loss reserves eligible for inclusion in the capital base by the time the interim and final minimum target standards fall to be observed.
normal practice will be to consolidate subsidiaries for the purpose of assessing the capital adequacy of banking groups. Where this is not done, deduction is essential to prevent the multiple use of the same capital resources in different parts of the group. The deduction for such investments will be made against the total capital base. The assets representing the investments in subsidiary companies whose capital had been deducted from that of the parent would not be included in total assets for the purposes of computing the ratio.
25. The Committee carefully considered the possibility of requiring
deduction of banks’ holdings of capital issued by other banks or deposit-taking institutions, whether in the form of equity or other capital instruments. Several G-10 supervisory authorities currently require such a deduction to be made in order to discourage the banking system as a whole from creating crossholdings of capital, rather than drawing capital from outside investors. The Committee is very conscious that such double-gearing (or “double-leveraging”) can have systemic dangers for the banking system by making it more vulnerable to the rapid transmission of problems from one institution to another and some members consider these dangers justify a policy of full deduction of such holdings.
26. Despite these concerns, however, the Committee as a whole is
not presently in favour of a general policy of deducting all holdings of other banks’ capital, on the grounds that to do so could impede certain significant and desirable changes taking place in the structure of domestic banking systems.
27. The Committee has nonetheless agreed that:
(a) individual supervisory authorities should be free at their discretion to apply a policy of deduction, either for all holdings of other banks’ capital , or for holdings which exceed material limits in relation to the holding bank’s capital or the issuing bank’s capital, or on a case-by-case basis; (b) where no deduction is applied, banks’ holding of other banks’ capital instruments will bear a weight of 100 per cent; (c) in applying these policies, member countries consider that reciprocal cross-holdings of bank capital designed artificially to inflate the capital position of the banks concerned should not be permitted; (d) the Committee will closely monitor the degree of doublegearing in the international banking system and does not preclude the possibility of introducing constraints at a later date. For this purpose, supervisory authorities intend to ensure that adequate statistics are made available to enable them and the
Committee to monitor the development of banks’ holdings of other banks’ equity and debt instruments which rank as capital under the present agreement.
II. THE RISK WEIGHTS
28. The Committee considers that a weighted risk ratio in which
capital is related to different categories of asset or off-balance sheet exposure, weighted according to broad categories of relative riskiness, is the preferred method for assessing the capital adequacy of banks. This is not to say that other methods of capital measurement are not also useful, but they are considered by the Committee to be supplementary to the risk weight approach. The Committee believes that a risk ratio has the following advantages over the simpler gearing ratio approach:
(i) it provides a fairer basis for making international comparisons between banking systems whose structures may differs; (ii) it allow off-balance-sheet exposures to be incorporated more easily into the measure; (iii) it does not deter banks from holding liquid or other assets which carry low risk.
29. The framework of weights has been kept as simple as possible
and only five weights are used - 0, 10, 20, 50 and 100 per cent. There are inevitably some broad-brush judgments in deciding which weight should apply to different types of asset and the weightings should not be regarded as a substitute for commercial judgment for purpose of market pricing of the different instruments.
30. The weighting structure is set out in detail in Annexes 2 and 3.
There are six aspects of the structure to which attention is particularly drawn. (i) Categories of risk captured in the framework
31. There are many different kinds of risks against which banks’
managements need to guard. For most banks the major risk is credit risk, that is to say the risk of counterparty failure, but there are many other kinds of risk - for example, investment risk, interest rate risk, exchange rate risk, concentration risk. The central focus of this framework is credit risk and, as a further aspect of credit risk, country transfer risk. In addition, individual supervisory authorities have discretion to build in certain other types of risk. Some countries, for example, will wish to retain a weighting for open foreign exchange positions or for some aspects of investment risk. No standardisation has been attempted in the treatment of these other kinds of risk in the framework at the present stage.
seven G-10 countries which are members of the Community compared with the manner in which it was applied by the non-Community countries.
35. In the light of these arguments, the Committee has concluded
that a defined group of countries should be adopted as the basis for applying differential weighting coefficients, and that this group should be full members of the OECD or countries which have concluded special lending arrangements with the IMF associated with the Fund’s General Arrangements to Borrow. This group of countries is referred to as the OECD in the reset of the report.
36. This decision has the following consequences for the weighting
structure. Claims on central governments within the OECD will attract a zero weight (or a low weight if the national supervisory authority elects to incorporate interest rate risk); and claims on OECD non-central government public-sector entities will attract a low weight [see (iii) below]. Claims on central governments and central banks outside the OECD will also attract a zero weight (or a low weight if the national supervisory elects to incorporate investment risk), provided such claims are denominated in the national currency and funded by liabilities in the same currency. This reflects the absence of risks relating to the availability and transfer of foreign exchange on such claims.
37. As regards the treatment of interbank claims, in order to
preserve the efficiency and liquidity of the international interbank market there will be no differentiation between short-term claims on banks incorporated within or outside the OECD . However, the Committee draws a distinction between, on the one hand, short-term placement with other banks which is an accepted method of managing liquidity in the interbank market and carries a perception of low risk and , on the other, longer-term cross-border loans to banks which are often associated with particular transactions and carry greater transfer and/or credit risks. A 20 per cent. weight will therefore be applied to claims on all banks. wherever incorporated, with a residual maturity of up to and including one year; longer-term claims on OECD incorporated banks will be weighted at 20 per cent; and longer-term claims on banks incorporated outside the OECD will be weighted at 100 per cent. (iii) Claims on non-central-government, public-sector entities (PSEs)
38. The Committee concluded that it was not possible to settle on a
single common weight that can be applied to all claims on domestic publicsector entities below the level of central government (e.g. states, local authorities, etc.), in view of the special character and varying creditworthiness of these entitles in different member countries. The Committee therefore opted to allow discretion to each national supervisory authority to determine the appropriate weighting factors for the PSEs within that country. In order to preserve a degree of convergence in the application of such discretion, the Committee agreed that the weights ascribed in this way should be 0, 10, 20, or 50 per cent, for domestic PSEs but that PSEs in foreign countries within in the OECD should attracts a standard 20 per cent. weight. These arrangements will be subject to review by the Committee in pursuit of further convergence
towards common weights and consistent definitions in member countries and in light of decisions to be taken within the European Community on the specification of a common solvency ratio for credit institutions. Commercial companies owned by the public sector competitive inequality vis-à-vis similar private-sector commercial enterprises. (iv) Collateral and guarantees
39. The framework recognises the importance of collateral in
reducing credit risk, but only to a limited extent. In view of the varying practices among banks in different countries for taking and different experiences of the stability of physical or financial collateral values, it has been found possible to develop a basis for recognising collateral generally in the weighting system. The more limited recognition of collateral will apply only to loans secured against cash or against- securities issued by OECD central governments and specified multilateral development banks. These will attract the weight given to the collateral (i.e. a zero or a low weight). Loans partially collateral (i.e. a zero or a low weight). Loans partially collateralised by these assets will also attract the equivalent low weights on that part of the loan which is fully collateralised.
40. As regards loans or other exposures guaranteed by third parties,
the Committee has agreed that loans guaranteed by OECD central governments, OECD public-sector entities, or OECD incorporated banks will attract the weight allocated to a direct claim on the guarantor (e.g. 20 per cent. in the case of banks). Loans guarantor (e.g. 20 per cent. in the case of banks). Loans guaranteed by non-OECD incorporated banks will also be recognised by the application of a 20 per cent. weight but only where the underlying transaction has a residual maturity not exceeding one year. The Committee intends to monitor the application of this latter arrangement to ensure that it does not give rise to inappropriate weighting of commercial loans. In the case of loans covered by partial guarantees, only that part of the loan which is covered by the guarantee will attact the reduced weight. The contingent liability assumed by banks in respect of guarantees will attract a credit conversion factor of 100 per cent. (see sub-section (vi) below). (v) Loans secured on residential property
41. Loans fully secured by mortgage on occupied residential
property have a very low record of loss in most countries. The framework will recognise this by assigning a 50 per cent. weight to loans fully secured by mortgage on residential property which is rented or is (or is intended to be) occupied by the borrower. In applying the 50 per cent. weight, the supervisory authorities will satisfy themselves, according to their national arrangements for the provision of housing finance, that this concessionary weight is applied restrictively for residential purposes and in accordance with strict prudential criteria. This may mean for example, that in some member countries the 50 per cent. weight will only apply to first mortgages, creating a first charge on the
property; and that in other member countries it will only be applied where strict, legally-based, valuation rules ensure a substantial margin of additional security over the amount of the loan. The 50 per cent. weight will specifically not be applied to loans to companies engaged in speculative residential building or property development. Other collateral will not be regarded as justifying the reduction of the weightings that would otherwise apply. 4 _______________________________________________________________ 4 One member country feels strongly that the lower weight should also apply to other loans secured by mortgages on domestic property, provided that the amount of the loan does not exceed 60 per cent. of the value of the property as calculated according to strict legal valuation criteria.
(vi) Off-balance-sheet engagements
42. The Committee believes that it is of great importance that all
off-balance-sheet activity should be caught within the capital adequacy framework. At the same time, it is recognised that there is only limited experience in assessing the risks in some of the activities; also that for some countries, a complex analytical approach and detailed and frequent reporting system cannot easily be justified when the amounts of such business, particularly in the newer, more innovative instruments, are only small. The approach that has been agreed, which is on the same lines as that described in the Committee’s report on the supervisory treatment of off-balance-sheet exposures issued to banks in March 1986, is comprehensive in that all categories of off-balance-sheet engagements , including recent innovations, will be converted to credit risk equivalents by multiplying the nominal principal amounts by a credit conversion factor, the resulting amounts then being weighted according to the nature of the counterparty. The different instruments and techniques are divided into five broad categories (within which member countries will have some limited discretion to allocate particular instruments according to their individual characteristics in national markets):
(a) those which substitute for loans (e.g. general guarantees of indebtedness, bank acceptance guarantees and standby letters of credit serving as financial guarantees for loans and securities) - these will carry a 100 per cent. credit risk conversion factor; (b) certain transaction related contingencies (e.g. performance bonds, bid bonds, warranties and standby letters of credit related to particular transactions) - a 50 per cent. credit risk conversion factor; (c) short-term, self-liquidating trade-related contingent liabilities arising from the movement of goods (e.g. documentary credits collateralised by the underlying shipments) - a 20 per cent. credit risk conversion factor; (d) commitments with an original maturity 5 exceeding one year (the longer maturity serving broadly as a proxy for higher risk facilities) and all NIFs and RUFs - a 50 per cent. credit risk conversion factor. Shorter-term commitments or commitments which can be unconditionally cancelled at any time, it is agreed, generally carry only low risk and a nil weight for these is considered to justified on de minimis grounds; (e) interest and exchange rate related items (e.g. swaps, options, futures) - the credit risk equivalent amount for these contracts will be calculated in one of two ways (see below and Annex 3). _______________________________________________________________
5 In order to facilities data collection, during the transitional period up to end-1992, but not beyond, national supervisory authorities will have discretion to apply residual maturity as a basis for measuring commitments.
Special treatment is needed for the items in (e) above because
banks are not exposed to credit risk for the full face value of their contracts, but only to the cost of replacing the cash flow if a counterparty defaults. Most members of the Committee accept that the correct method of assessing the credit risk on these items is to calculate the current replacement cost by marking to market and to add a factor to represent potential exposure during the remaining life of the contract. Some member countries, however, are concerned about the consistency of this method in relation to the rest of the system which only makes broad distinctions between relative risks for onbalance-sheet items, particularly for banks where these off-balance-sheet items currently constitute only a very small part of the total risks. They would prefer to apply an alternative approach consisting of conversion factors based on the nominal principal sum underlying each contract according to its type and maturity. The Committee has concluded that members will be allowed to choose either of the two methods. The details of the two alternative methods are set out in Annex 3.
III. A TARGET STANDARD RATIO
In the light of consultations and preliminary testing of the
framework, the Committee is agreed that a minimum standard should be set now which international banks generally will be expected to achieve by the end of the transitional period. It is also agreed that this standard should be set at a level that is consistent with the objective of securing over time soundly-based and consistent capital ratios for all international banks. Accordingly, the Committee confirms that the target standard ratio of capital to weighted risk assets should be set at 8 per cent. (of which the core capital element will be at least 4 per cent.). This is expressed as a common minimum standard which international banks in member countries will be expected to observe by the end of 1992, thus allowing a transitional period of some four-and-a-half years for any necessary adjustment by banks who need time to build up to those levels. The Committee fully recognises that the transition from existing, sometimes long -established, definitions of capital and methods of measurement towards a new internationally agreed standard will not necessarily be achieved easily or quickly. The full period to end-1992 is available to ensure progressive steps towards adjustment and banks whose ratios are presently below the 8 per cent. standard will not be required to take immediate or precipitate action.
IV. TRANSITIONAL AND IMPLEMENTING ARRANGEMENTS
(i) Transition
Certain transitional arrangements have been agreed upon to
ensure that there are sustained efforts during the transitional period to build up individual banks’ ratios towards the ultimate target standard; and to facilitate smooth adjustment and phasing in of the new arrangements within a wide variety of existing supervisory systems.
The transitional period will be from the date of this paper to the
end of 1992, by which latter date all banks undertaking significant cross-border business will be expected to meet the standard to be met by the end of 1990 (see paragraph 49 below).
Initially no formal standard or minimum level will be set. It is
the general view of the Committee, however, that every encouragement should be given to those banks whose capital levels are at the low end of the range to build up their capital as quickly as possible and the Committee expects there to be no erosion of existing capital standards in individual member countries’ banks. Thus, during the transitional period, all banks which need to improve capital levels up to the interim and final standards should not diminish even temporarily their current capital levels (subject to the fluctuations which can occur around the time new capital is raised ). A level of 5 per cent. attained by application of the framework and transitional arrangements is considered by some countries to be a reasonable yardatick for the lower capitalised banks to seek to attain in the short term. Individual member countries will, of course, be free to set, and announce, at the outset of the transitional period the level from which they would expect all their banks to move towards the interim and final target standard. In order to assess and compare progress during the initial period of adjustment to end-1990 in a manner which takes account both of existing supervisory systems and the new arrangements, the Committee and individual supervisory authorities will initially apply the basis of measurement set out in paragraph 48 below.
In measuring the capital position of banks at the start of the
transitional period, a proportion of the core capital elements, reducing to 10 per cent, by end - 1990. In addition, throughout the transitional period up to end - 1992, subject to more restrictive policies which individual authorities may wish to apply, term subordinated debt may be included without limit as a constraint of supplementary elements and the deduction from tier 1 capital elements in respect of goodwill may be waived.
At end-1990 there will be an interim minimum standard of 7.25
per cent. of which at least half should be core capital. However, between end - 1990 and end - 1992 up to 10 per cent. of the required core elements may be made up of supplementary elements. This means. in round figures, a minimum core capital element of 3.6 per cent., of which tier 1 elements should total at least 3.25 per cent., is to be achieved by the end of 1990. In addition, from end
than 50 per cent. of tier 1. In addition, general loan loss reserves or general provisions (having the characteristics described in paragraph 49) will be limited at end - 1992 to 1.25 percentage points, or exceptionally and temporarily up to
2.0 6
percentage points, within supplementary elements.
For ease of reference, the arrangements described in paragraphs 45 to 50 are summarised in a table at Annex 4. _______________________________________________________________ 6 These limits would only apply in the event that no agreement is reached on a consistent basis for including unencumbered provisions or reserves in capital (see paragraphs 20 and 21).
(ii) Implementation
51. The arrangements described in this document will be
implemented at national level at the earliest possible opportunity. Each country will decide the way in which the supervisory authorities will introduce and apply these recommendations in the light of their different legal structures and existing supervisory arrangements. In some countries, changes in the capital regime may be introduced, after consultation, relatively speedily without the need for legislation. Other countries may employ more lengthy procedures, and in some cases these may require legislation. In due course the member states of the European Community will also need to ensure that their own domestic regulations are compatible with the Community’s own legislative proposals in this field. None of these factors needs result in any inconsistency in the timing of implementation among member countries. For example, some countries may apply the framework in this report, formally or informally, in parallel with their existing system, certainly during the initial period of transition. In this way banks can be assisted to start the necessary process of adjustment in good time before substantive changes in national systems are formally introduced. July 1988
Annex 1
Definition of capital included in the capital base (To apply at end - 1992 - see Annex 4 for transitional arrangements) A. Capital elements Tier 1 (a) Paid-up share capital/common stock (b) Disclosed reserves Tier 2 (a) Undisclosed reserves (b) Asset revaluation reserves (c) General provisions/general loan loss reserve (d) Hybrid (debt/equity) capital instruments (e) Subordinated term debt The sum of Tier 1 and Tier 2 elements will be eligible for inclusion in the capital base, subject to the following limits. B. Limits and restrictions (i) The total of Tier 2 (supplementary) elements will be limited to a maximum of 100 per cent. of the total of Tier 1 elements; (ii) subordinated term debt will be limited to a maximum of 50 per cent. of Tier 1 elements; (iii) where general provisions/general loan loss reserve include amounts reflecting lower valuations of asset or latent but unidentified losses present in the balance sheet, the amount of such provisions or reserves will be limited to a maximum of 1.25 percentage points, or exceptionally and temporarily up to 2.0 percentage points, of risk assets; 1 _______________________________________________________________ 1 This limit would only apply in the event that no agreement is reached on a consistent basis for including unencumbered provisions or reserves in capital (see paragraphs 20 and 21).
(iv) asset revaluation reserves which take the form of latent gains on unrealised securities (see below) will be subject to a discount of 55 per cent.
C. Deductions from the capital base
Form Tier 1: Goodwill
From total capital: (i) Investment in unconsolidated banking and financial subsidiary companies N.B. The presumption is that the framework would be applied on a consolidated basis to banking groups. (ii) Investments in the capital of other banks and financial institutions (at the discretion of national authorities). D. Definition of capital elements (i) Tier 1: includes only permanent shareholders’ equity (issued and fully paid ordinary shares/common stock and perpetual non-cumulative preference shares ) and disclosed reserves (created or increased by appropriations of retained earnings or other surplus, e.g. share premiums, retained profit, 2 general reserves and legal reserves). In the case of consolidated accounts, this also includes minority interests in the equity of subsidiaries which are less than wholly owned. This basic definition of capital excludes revaluation reserves and cumulative preference shares. (ii) Tier 2: (a) undisclosed reserves are eligible for inclusion within supplementary elements provided these reserves are accepted by the supervisor. Such reserve consist of that part of the accumulated aftertax surplus of retained profits which banks in some countries may be permitted to maintain as an undisclosed reserve. A part from the fact that the reserve is not identified in the published balance sheet, it should have the same high quality and character as a disclosed capital reserve; as such, it should not be encumbered by any provision or other known liability but should be freely and immediately available to meet unforeseen future losses. This definition of undisclosed reserve excludes hidden values arising from holding of securities in the balance sheet at below current market prices (see below). _______________________________________________________________ 2 Including, at national discretion, allocations to or from reserve during the course of the year from current year’s retained profit.
(b) Revaluation reserves arise in two ways. Firstly, in some countries, banks (and other commercial companies ) are permitted to revalue fixed assets, normally their own premises, from time to time in line with the change in market values. In some of these countries the amount of such reevaluations is determined by law. Revaluations of this kind are reflected on the face of the balance sheet as a revaluation reserve. Secondly, hidden values or “latent” revaluation reserve may be present as a result of long-term holdings of equity securities valued in the balance sheet at the historic cost of acquisition. Both types of revaluation reserve may be included in Tier 2 provided that the assets are prudently valued, fully reflecting the possibility of price fluctuation and forced sale. In the case of “latent” revaluation reserves a discount of 55 per cent. will be applied to the difference between historic cost book value and market value and market value to reflect the potential volatility of this form of unrealised capital and the notion tax charge on it. (c) General provisions/general loan loss reserves: provisions or loan loss reserves held against future, presently unidentified losses are freely available to meet losses which subsequently materialise and therefore qualify for inclusion within supplementary elements. Provisions ascribed to impairment of particular assets or known liabilities should be excluded. Furthermore, where general provisions/general loan loss reserves include amounts reflecting lower valuations of assets or latent but unidentified losses already present in the balance sheet, the amount of such provisions or reserves eligible for inclusion will be limited to a maximum of 1.25 percentage points, or exceptionally and temporarily up to 2.0 percentage points. 3 _______________________________________________________________ 3 This limit would apply in the event that no agreement is reached on a consistent basis for including unencumbered provisions or reserves in capital (see paragraphs 20 and 21).
(d) Hybrid (debt/equity) capital instruments. This heading includes a range of instruments which combine characteristics of equity capital and of debt. Their precise specifications differ from country to country, but they should meet the following requirements:
Annex 2
Risk weights by category of on-balance-sheet asset 0% (a) Cash 1 (b) Claims on central governments and central banks denominated in national currency and funded in that currency (c) Other claims on OECD 2 central government 3 and central banks (d) Claims collateralised by cash or OECD centralgovernment securities 3 or guaranteed by OECD central government 4 0,10,20 or (a) Claims on domestic public-sector entities, excluding 50% (at central government, and loans guaranteed 4 by such national entities discretion) 20% (a) Claims on multilateral development banks (IBRD, IADB, AsDB, AfDB, EIB) 5 and claims guaranteed by, or collatealised by securities issued by such banks 4 (b) Claims on banks incorporated in the OECD and loans guaranteed 4 by OECD incorporated banks _______________________________________________________________ 1 Includes (at national discretion) gold bullion held in own vaults or on an allocated basis to the extent backed by bullion liabilities. 2 The OECD comprises countries which are full members of the OECD or which have concluded special lending arrangements with the IMF associated with the Fund’s General Arrangements to Borrow.
3. Some member countries intend to apply weights to securities issued by OECD central
governments to take account of investment risk. These weights would, for example, be 10 per cent. for all securities or 10 per cent. for those maturing in up to one year and 20 per cent. for those maturing in over one year.
4. Commercial loans partially guaranteed by these bodies will attract equivalent low
weights on that part of the loan which is fully covered. Similarly, loans partially collateralised by cash or securities issued by OECD central governments and multilateral development banks will attract low weights on that part of the loan which is fully covered.
5. Claims on other multilateral development banks in which G-10 countries are
shareholding members may, at national discretion, also attract a 20 per cent. weight.
(c) Claims on banks incorporated in countries outside the OECD with a residual maturity of up to one year and loans with a residual maturity of up to one year guaranteed by banks incorporated in countries outside the OECD (d) Claims on non-domestic OECD public-sector entities excluding central government, and loans guaranteed4 by such entities (e) Cash items in process of collection 50% (a) Loans fully secured by mortgage on residential property that is or will be occupied by the borrower or that is rented 100% (a) Claims on the private sector (b) Claims on banks incorporated outside the OECD with a residual maturity of over one year (c) Claims on central governments outside the OECD (unless denominated in national currency - and funded in that currency -see above) (d) Claims on commercial companies owned by the public sector (e) Premises, plant and equipment and other fixed assets (f) Real estate and other investments (including nonconsolidated investment participations in other companies ) (g) Capital instruments issued by other banks (unless deducted from capital) (h) All other assets
Annex 3
Credit conversion factors for off-balance-sheet items The framework takes account of the credit risk on off-balancesheet exposures by applying credit conversion factors to the different types of off-balance-sheet instrument or transaction. With the exception of foreign exchange and interest rate related contingencies, the credit conversion factors are set out in the table below. They are derived from the estimated size and likely occurrence of the credit exposure, as well as the relative degree of credit risk as identified in the Committee’s paper “The management of banks’ offbalance-sheet exposures: a supervisory perspective” issued in March 1986. The credit conversion factors would be multiplied by the weights applicable to the category of the counterparty for an on-balance-sheet transaction (see Annex 2). Instruments Credit conversion factors
and credit lines) with an original 2 maturity of up to one year, or which can be unconditionally cancelled at any time 0%
8. Similar commitments with an original 2
maturity of up to one year, or which can be unconditionally cancelled at any time 0% (N.B. Member countries will have some limited discretion to allocate particular instruments into item 1 to 8 above according to the characteristics of the instrument in the national market.) _______________________________________________________________ 1 These items are to be weighted according to the type of asset and not according to the type of counterparty with whom the transaction has been entered into. Reverse repos (i.e. purchase and resale agreements - where the bank is the receiver of the asset) are to be treated as collateralised loans, reflecting the economic reality of the transactions. The risk is therefore to be measured as an exposure on the counterparty. Where the asset temporarily acquired is a security which attracts a preferential risk weighting, this would be recognised as collateral and the risk weighting would be reduced accordingly.
2. But see footnote 5 in the main text.
Foreign exchange and interest rate related contingencies The treatment of foreign exchange and interest rate related items needs special attention because banks are not exposed to credit risk for the full face value of their contracts, but only to the potential cost of replacing the cash flow (on contracts showing positive value) if the counterparty defaults. The credit equivalent amounts will depend inter alia on the maturity of the contract and on the volatility of the rates underlying that type of instrument. Despite the wider range of different instruments in the market, the theoretical basis for assessing the credit risk on all of them has been the same. It has consisted of an analysis of the behaviour of matched pairs of swaps under different volatility assumptions. Since exchange rate contracts involve an exchange of principal on maturity, as well as being generally more volatile, higher conversion factors are proposed for those instruments which features exchange rate risk. Interest rate contracts 3 are defined to include single-currency interest rate swaps, basis swaps, forward rate agreements, interest rate futures, interest rate options purchased and similar instruments. Exchange rate contracts 3 include cross-currency interest rate swaps, forward foreign exchange contracts, currency futures, currency options purchased and similar instruments. Exchange rate contracts with an original maturity of 14 calendar days or less are excluded. _______________________________________________________________ 3 Instrument traded on exchange may be excluded where they are subject to daily margining requirements. Options purchased over the counter are included with the same conversion factors as other instruments, but this decision might be reviewed in the light of future experience.
A majority of G-10 supervisory authorities are of the view that the best way to assess the credit risk on these items is to ask banks to calculate the current replacement cost by marking contracts to market, thus capturing the current exposure without any need for estimation, and then adding a factor (the “add-on”) to reflect the potential future exposure over the remaining life of the contract. It has been agreed that, in order to calculate the credit equivalent amount of its off-balance-sheet interest rate and foreign exchange rate instruments under this current exposure method, a bank would sum:
In order to arrive at the credit equivalent amount using this original exposure method, a bank would simply apply one of the following two sets of conversion factors to the notional principal amounts of each instrument according to the nature of the instrument and its maturity:
Maturity 5
Interest Rate Exchange Rate
Contracts Contracts
Less than one year 0.5% 2.0%
One year and less 1.0% 50% than two years (i.e. 2%+3%) For each additional 1.0% 3.0 year _______________________________________________________________ 5 For interest rate contracts, there is national discretion as to whether the conversion factors are to be based on original or residual maturity. For exchange rate contracts, the conversion factors are to be calculated according to the original maturity of the instrument.
It is emphasised that the above conversion factors, as well as the “addons” for the current exposure method, should be regarded as provisional and may be subject to amendment as a result of changes in the volatility of exchange rates and interest rates. Careful consideration has been given to the arguments put forward for recognising netting, i.e. for weighting the net rather than the gross claims arising out of swaps and similar contracts with the same counterparties. The criterion on which a decision has been based is the status of a netting contract under national bankruptcy regulations. If a liquidator of a failed counterparty has (or may have ) the right to unbundle the netted contracts, demanding performance on those contracts favourable to his client and defaulting on unfavorable contracts, there is no reduction in counterparty risk. Accordingly, it has been agreed that:
7 Close-out as defined in this context refers to a bilateral contact which provides that, if one of the counterparties is wound up, the outstanding obligations between the two are accelerated and netted to determine the counterparty’s net exposure. 8 The other principal form of netting, payments netting, which is designed to reduce the counterparty risk arising out of daily settlements, will not be recognised in the capital framework since the counterparty’s gross obligations are not in any way affected.
Once the bank has calculated the credit equivalent amounts, whether according to the current or the original exposure method, they are to be weighted according to the category of counterparty in the same way as in the main framework, including concessionary weighting in respect of exposures backed by eligible guarantees and collateral. In addition, since most counterparties in these markets, particularly for long-term contracts, tend to be first -class names, it has been agreed that a 50 per cent, weight will be applied in respect of counterparties which would otherwise attract a 100 per cent. weight. 9 However, the Committee will keep a close eye on the credit quality of participants in these markets and reserves the right to raise the weights if average credit quality deteriorates or if loss experience increases. _______________________________________________________________ 9 Some member countries reserve the right to apply the full 100 per cent. weight.
Annex 4
Transitional arrangements
Initial End-1990 End-1992
COMMISSIONER OF BANKING September 1988
HONG KONG
International convergence of banks’ capital measurement and capital standards :
A new Hong Kong ratio
Consultative paper
Introduction
Last December the Basle Committee on Banking Regulations and Supervisory Practices (1) published proposals to standardize the measurement of banks’ capital, and to set minimum levels of capital adequacy. There were two objectives, of helping to strengthen the stability of the international banking system and of removing a source of competitive inequality for banks arising from differences in supervisory arrangements among countries. _______________________________________________________________ (1) The Committee comprises representatives of the central banks ad supervisory authorities of the Group of Ten countries (Belgium, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Netherlands, Sweden, UK, US, Switzerland) and Luxembourg.
other factors as well : interest rate exposure, quality of earnings, concentration of loan portfolio, management competence, etc.
Tier 1 or core capital consisting of permanent shareholders’ equity (fully paid up ordinary shares and irredeemable noncumulative preference shares) and disclosed reserves (e.g. share premiums, general reserves and retained earnings); and Tier 2 or supplementary capital consisting of undisclosed reserves, general provisions/general loan loss reserves, asset revaluation reserves, hybrid capital instruments, subordinated term debt and term preference shares. On the asset side, all assets together with off-balance sheet items are included.
8. The aim is for minimum capital adequacy ratios to be not less than
8% by end-1992, with an intermediate target of 7.25% by end-1990; in either case, Tier 2 (supplementary) capital is not to exceed 100% of Tier 1 (core) capital.
9. Key changes to Hong Kong’s present ratio which are proposed
include -
Capital : to be divided into two tiers, Tier 2 being no more than 100% of Tier 1 For inclusion in Tier 1 . Irredeemable non-cumulative preference shares For inclusion inn Tier 2 (generally with limitations) . Asset revaluation reserves . Undisclosed reserves . General provisions . Hybrid capital, including subordinated debt, with a minimum tern of at least five years. Deductions from capital . Investment in other banks’ capital, and in unconsolidated related companies.
Risk assets
10/20% weight
. Claims on central governments and central banks of Hong Kong and industrialised countries 20% weight . Other claims on Hong Kong and OECD countries public sector entities . Claims on authorized institutions, on other banks incorporated in industrialised countries and on other overseas banks with a residual maturity of under one year . Claims on multilateral lending organizations 50% weight . First mortgages on owner occupied property In addition . Off-balance sheet risk to be weighted according to assessed credit equivalence . Collateralised (including guaranteed) assets generally to be weighted according to the credit risk of collateral if less than that of the primary obligor . Import and export bills to be weighted according to the obligor Capital base Irredeemable non-cumulative preference shares
10. The present Hong Kong ratio includes preference shares within
capital, but without definition. The Basle framework requires preference shares to meet certain criteria for inclusion in Tier 1 or Tier 2 capital. Irredeemable non-cumulative preference shares are eligible as Tier 1 capital because their dividends can be passed without becoming a charge on future profit. We
consider it correct to apply a qualifying test to preference capital, and propose to follow Basle. (Other forms of preference share are considered later.) Asset revaluation reserves
11. The Basle framework allows “revaluation reserves” to be included
within supplementary capital at the discretion of national supervisory authorities. There are two categories of reserves : from revaluation of an institution’s own premises and other fixed assets; and from latent surpluses from holdings of securities valued at historic cost. The former is particularly important for institutions with large branch networks. Reserves can either be “on balance sheet” (though possibly undisclosed, i.e. “hidden”), or “latent”, this is, not entered into the accounts.
12. We propose to count, as supplementary capital, reserves arising
from the revaluation of an institution’s own premises, and latent surpluses from long-term holdings of equity securities. Assets must be prudently valued, fully reflecting the possibility of price fluctuation and forced sale.
13. Revaluation of premises should be carried out by professional
valuers, on a basis satisfactory to both the Commissioner and the external auditors. To allow a margin in view of the inherent uncertainty in such valuations, only 70% of the appreciation on valuation will be included in the capital base.
14. Past revaluation surpluses may either be held as undisclosed, or
disclosed, reserves (1); some may have been capitalized. All existing fixed asset revaluation reserves will count as supplementary capital (2) . _______________________________________________________________ (1) According to accepted accounting standards, they should go to the disclosed capital reserve account, and not to undisclosed reserves. (2) Institutions can of course capitalise part or all such reserves, in which case they would then count as core capital.
“Latent” surpluses arising from long-term holdings of equity
securities valued at historic cost, will be recognized if the securities re listed on the Unified Exchange in Hong Kong or on any other stock exchange as specified in the Securities (Recognition of Stock Markets) (Consolidation) Notice under the Securities Ordinance (a list of these is at Annex G) . The surplus will be subject to a 55% discount to reflect the risk of forced sale, and any tax charge which might arise on disposal. Undisclosed or inner reserves
The Basle framework treats reserves, which are freely available, but
undisclosed, as supplementary capital, because of their lack of transparency.
Arguments were presented during our consultations that there were
peculiar reasons for banks in Hong Kong to maintain undisclosed reserves, that they were of the same quality as published retained earnings, that they were know to the supervisory authority, and that therefore they should count as core capital.
Whether reserves are disclosed or not does not affect their quality
as capital. In commenting to Basle, we suggested, therefore, that undisclosed reserves should be treated as core capital. This comment was not accepted and indeed the Basle framework is a compromise between often conflicting interests of many countries.
Despite our general sympathy with the banks’ contention, we do not
consider that Hong Kong is so different as to warrant departing from the standard at this point. There is also a practical problem : the Basle framework limits Tiers capital to no more than 100% of Tier 1 capital. Were undisclosed reserves (less asset revaluation reserves) moved to Tier 1 capital, a new ratio of Tier 2 to Tier 1 capital would be needed. This would take Hong Kong further away from the principle of convergence.
We conclude, therefore, that undisclosed reserves should be
included in supplementary capital.
General provisions
The Basle agreement permits general provisions which are freely
available to absorb future losses to quality as Tier 2 capital. Where such provisions reflect lower valuations for assets or latent but unidentified losses present in the balance sheet, these latter amounts would be limited to 1.25% of risk assets.
At present general provisions are not included in the Hong Kong
capital base. But we see no reason not to follow the Basle framework. In doing so, we recognize that it is in practice difficult to distinguish between the two portions of general provisions referred to in the preceding paragraph : the portion that is freely available to absorb future losses, and that which, in reality, may reflect present or imminent losses, perhaps in amounts as yet unquantified, on existing problem or troubled loans. Balancing these different considerations, we propose to allow general provisions, whether or not earmarked against latent risk, to be included in supplementary capital up to 1.25% of risk assets. This represents a concession compared with Hong Kong’s present ratio. Provisions against loans to troubled debtor countries would not qualify. Hybrid (debt/equity) capital instruments
These instruments, such as irredeemable cumulative preference
stock, perpetual subordinated debt, combine characteristics of equity capital and of debt. To be eligible as capital, they must meet the following requirements :
(a) be unsecured, fully paid up obligations, subordinated to depositors and general creditors; (b) not redeemable, repayable or cancelable, at the initiative of the holder or without the prior consent of the Commissioner of Banking; (c) available to participate in losses without the institution being obliged to cease trading (unlike conventional subordinated debt) (1); _______________________________________________________________ (1) To satisfy this requirement, the instrument must convert to ordinary shares or irredeemable preference share in the event that the sum of the retained earnings and capital reserve accounts of the institution shows a negative balance.
(d) normally subject to Hong Kong or English law; (e) no restrictive convenants which might trigger repayment or prevent further loan capital being raised. (f) any variation in the terms and conditions of the issue will require the prior consent of the Commissioner of Banking. (g) although the capital instrument may carry an obligation to pay interest that cannot permanently be reduced or waived (unlike dividends on ordinary share), it must allow service obligations to be deferred (as with cumulative preference shares) where the profitability of the institution would not support payment.
24. We consider that these instruments should be counted as Tier 2
capital. The existing capital adequacy requirement under the Banking Ordinance already admits perpetual subordinated debt (up to 50% of total capital). Subordinated term debt and term preference shares
25. Unsecured subordinated debt capital with a fixed term to maturity is
not now counted as capital in Hong Kong. As it is not normally available to participate in the losses of a bank which continues trading, the Basle Committee limits it, and redeemable preference shares, to a maximum of 50% of Tier 1 capital. It is intended to adopt this limit and to require an original maturity of at least five years. Other requirements include those for perpetual instruments set out above (except that condition (b) refers to early repayment etc.). In addition the value of the capital would be discounted by reducing its nominal value by one-fifth each year during the five years preceding maturity. Investments in certain unconsolidated subsidiaries
26. The Basle Committee envisaged that supervision would usually be
applied to banking groups consolidated; where not the framework requires deduction from the capital base of investments in unconsolidated subsidiaries engaged in banking and financial activities. In Hong Kong, banking and finance subsidiaries are normally consolidated but out rules provide for the deduction of capital-like investment in any (unconsolidated) subsidiary, holding company, or connected company (1) as also, effectively, investments in any associated
company. The reason for such deductions is that the capital invested in these entities should be viewed as primarily supporting the risks inherent in their activities and not generally available to support risks in the banking company. _______________________________________________________________ (1) “Connected” as defined under paragraph 3 (ii) of the Third Schedule to the Banking Ordinance.
of 0.2 (i.e. 20%); negotiable claims over one year, but less than ten years, 0.5 (50%); and others 1.0 (100%).
33. The Basle Committee found it difficult to settle on the treatment of
these risks. With respect to country risk, the option canvassed in their first proposal was to give a preferential weight only to claims on the home country’s public sector and to banks generally (except that for overseas banks, under one year claims only). They also included a low weight for other government claims, but only where these were in local currency, and funded in that currency. Investment risk was ignored (other than to suggest, at national discretion, low, rather than zero, weights for government debt, graduated according to maturity).
34. Our initial proposals, on which we consulted the Associations, were
to enlarge the Basle Committee’s zero/low weight group. For central government risk, we suggested the G7 countries (i.e. UK, US, Japan, Germany, France, Canada and Italy, plus Hong Kong) but not to claims on other G7 public sector. For banks, we proposed preferential weights be extended to all authorized institutions, regardless of place of incorporation.
35. The Basle Committee finally modified their framework to extend
low credit weights to the public sector and banks of all industrialised countries. To define this they used a proxy, which is admitted to be arbitrary - full members of OECD plus those lending to the IMF’s General Arrangement to Borrow - at present only Saudi Arabia (collectively referred to in this paper as “OECD”). Weights for investment risk, to which the Committee are to give further thought, remain for national authorities’ discretion. It is clear however that some countries are to draw a distinction between differing government debt maturities.
36. In the light of the Basle Committee’s comments, our present ratio,
and our first proposals, we now conclude that the Hong Kong ratio should be formulated thus (with present weights shown in Brackets) - Central governments and central banks . Hong Kong, and OECD - Direct obligations under one year 10% (20%), one year and over 20% (50/100%).
. Other countries - denominated and funded in local currency 20%; other 1000% (20/50/100%). Other public sector entities . Public sector utilities and non-commercial entities in Hong Kong, (e.g. KCRC, Housing Authority) and similar entities in OECD countries - 20% (100%); . Local governments in OECD countries - 20% (100%) . All others 100% (100%) . Banks (1) and multilateral organizations . Institutions authorized in Hong Kong, banks incorporated in OECD, and IMF, IBRD, ADB AND other regional development banks - 20% (20/50/100%) . Other banks - under one year 20%, other 100% (20/50/100%). _______________________________________________________________ (1) A question is whether claims on branches of the same institution located in different countries should be weighted differently because of different country transfer risks. While this a legitimate question, dealing with it in this capital framework would likely be complicated. It is moreover not clear that it would be appropriate. There will therefore be no differentiation between different branches of the same institution for the purpose of risk weighting.
. claims secured on securities issued by, or guaranteed by multilateral organizations - 20% . claims guaranteed by Hong Kong authorized institutions and other OECD banks, or secured on their obligations - 20% Mortgages
41. The Basle Committee first suggested that a preferential weight, of
50%, should be given for loans to owner-occupiers, secured by first mortgages. They noted the low loss record for such lending. During our consultations we were urged to follow suit in Hong Kong.
42. The Committee’s final report notes that in some countries the stock
of owner-occupied housing is low. To maintain a balance between countries, the Committee agreed therefore to extend the 50% concession to loans for rented residential property, secured by mortgage. Loans for speculative residential building, and property development will not be favoured.
43. The evidence given us earlier this year supports the banks’
contention that losses in Hong Kong on first mortgage lending to owneroccupiers are low. We therefore agree that the 50% weight should be adopted. We intend to specify minimum criteria for such loans to rank for the concession. We do not propose to include rented residential property within the 50% weight. It is noted that banks in Hong Kong have substantial portfolio of mortgage loans to owner-occupiers. Import and Export bills
44. The current Hong Kong ratio weights such bills, if maturing within
six months, at 50%. This recognises the importance of foreign trade to Hong Kong. The Basle framework however makes no provision. Bills will therefore be weighted according to the counterparty of the claim, e.g. an import bill at 100% if the claim was on a commercial customer, and an export bill, carrying a bank guarantee, at 20% generally.
45. Given concessions elsewhere, and the objective of not departing
from the framework except in circumstances wholly peculiar to Hong Kong, it is intended to drop these 50% weights. The Basle approach is more logical, and
may not overall result in institutions having a noticeably higher capital requirement. Off-balance sheet items
46. The Basle framework captures all off-balance sheet items. Risk
weights for these items are determined analytically in a two-step process. First, the notional principal, or face value, amount of the item is multiplied by one of 4 credit conversion factors (1) to arrive at a approximate balance sheet “credit equivalent amount”. Then the credit equivalent amount is assigned, like any balance sheet asset, to the appropriate risk category according to the counterparty. The different categories of off-balance sheet items and their credit conversion factors are summarized in Annex C. _______________________________________________________________ (1) The 4 credit conversion factors are 0%, 20%, 50% and 100%. Items with 0% conversion, for example, include unused commitments with an original maturity of one year or less; those with 100% conversion include financial guarantees. standby letters credit, and other direct credit substitutes.
contracts with the same counterparties. The Committee finally agreed that banks may net contracts subject to novation, but not those subject to close-out clauses, since it appears that counterparty risk is genuinely reduced by the substitution of a novated contract which legally extinguishes the previous obligation.
53. We will wish to consider this aspect further, and in the light of
practice in Hong Kong and elsewhere before determining the position. Target ratio and transitional arrangements
54. The Basle target is for minimum ratios to be 8% by the end of 1992,
with an interim target of 7.25% by the end of 1990. We propose that these minimal, in general, be adopted in Hong Kong, for all authorized institutions incorporated in Hong Kong. In principle, there would be two transitional periods: from now to end 1990, and from 1991 to end 1992. The detailed transitional arrangements, which relate to the capital base, are described in
Annex E. It is however necessary to retain some flexibility at this stage over the
transition. Until data are collected from institutions, showing the effect of the new risk weights, it will not be clear how great will be the transitional adjustment, and therefore whether the Basle minimal can be introduced earlier.
55. It should be noted that the proposed ratios constitute only a
minimum standard. Because the ratio does not take explicit account of all factors affecting an institution’s risk profile many authorized institutions are likely to be required to operate above the minimum ratio. Consolidation
56. In applying the Basle framework to a locally incorporated institution
with local and overseas branches and subsidiaries, our intention is to weight their overseas held assets with those held in Hong Kong in accordance with certain general principles :
(a) Overseas branches : Branch assets would be weighted according to Hong Kong rules. (b) Local subsidiaries : They would be consolidated if they are in banking or in business with risks similar to banking (leasing, credit card, hire purchase, etc.).
(c) Overseas subsidiary banks, in countries following the Basle framework : Because these institutions are capitalised locally, it would be more appropriate to view the risks associated with their assets from their point of view rather than that of the parent. Their risk asset weightings should therefore be calculated using the rules of the banking supervisors of those countries (and not those of Hong Kong), as they would be required to do anyway. The resulting figures can then be consolidated with those of the parent. (d) Other overseas subsidiaries : They will need to be consolidated with the parent if they are in banking or business with risks similar to banking. We propose that they follow the Hong Kong rules on risk weightings, but we will be open to discussion with the institution concerned on whether modifications against the circumstances of the host country of the subsidiary is needed.
57. Consolidated supervision of financial groups is a difficult area
which, among other things, will be closely examined by the Basle Committee. The European Community has undertaken, or is undertaking work in this direction with which the Committee maintains close liaison. We intend to discuss this part further with some of the authorized institutions concerned before making firm proposals. Implementation
58. The present capital adequacy requirement under the Banking
Ordinance came into effect on 1 September 1988. However, we consider that our proposals under the Basle framework, once finalized, should be implemented as soon as practicable thereafter.
59. Implementation of the Basle framework requires :
(a) changing the statutory minimum capital adequacy ratio of 5% in
section 98(1) of the Banking Ordinance, and the maximum of 8%
for banks and 10% for deposit-taking companies, in section 101(1)
and complete replacement of the Third Schedule (for both of which the Financial Secretary has authority); and (b) changing the return s submitted to the Commissioner’s Office; (c) it may also require amendments to various other sections in the Ordinance for consistency. On the part of authorized institutions, it would require some changes in record keeping. Institutions are therefore asked to start preparations for making the necessary changes.
60. The following will be the implementation arrangements :
(a) following consultations, institutions will be asked to complete a new return, giving the information necessary to compile the revised ratio. A parallel run period for the existing and the new reporting arrangement will be expected to start from the end of 1988. (b) during the first quarter of 1989, after the parallel data have been compared with the present capital adequacy ratio, a timetable will be prepared for replacing the Third Schedule with the Basle framework and the dates by which it is to be observed. Meanwhile the minimum capital adequacy ratio will remain at 5% (or as agreed with individual institutions) under the Banking Ordinance; (c) other necessary legislative amendments will then be introduced; The industry and members of the Banking and Deposit-taking Companies Advisory Committees will be consulted at various stages of the implementation plan. Office of the Commissioner of Banking September 1988
Annex A
Definition of Capital Base
(A) Tier 1 (Core) Capital
(a) Ordinary paid up share capital X
(b) Irredeemable non-cumulative reference shares X (c) Share premium X (d) General reserve X (e) Retained earnings X (f) Minority interests (when X on consolidated basis) X Deduct : Goodwill (1) ( X ) Total Tier 1 Capital X (B) Tier 2 (Supplementary) Capital (a) Undisclosed reserves X (b) General provisions/ general loan loss reserves (2) X (c) revaluation of own premises (3) X (d) latent reserves of equity X securities (4) _______________________________________________________________ (1) To the extent that it is carried in the balance sheet (2) Excluding provisions against loans to troubled debtor countries, and limited to 1.25% of risk assets. (3) Limited to 70% of valued appreciation.
(4) Subject to a discount of 55% on the difference between book value and market value.
(e) Hybrid (debt/equity) capital instruments (i) perpetual X subordinated debt (ii) irredeemable cumulative X X preference shares (f) Term debt etc (1) (limited to 50% of Tier 1) (i) subordinated term X debt (ii) term preference X X shares Total Tier 2 capital (limited to 100% of Tier 1) X
Total capital base before deduction X
Deductions :
(a) Shareholding in subsidiary and X holding company (b) Loans to, shares and debentures issued by, and guarantees of liabilities of, connected companies, where in the opinion of the Commissioner, the institution has made the loans, is holding the shares or debentures or as the case may be, has given the guarantees, other than in the ordinary course of business. X (c) Equity investment in any company, not being a subsidiary, in which the institution holds the beneficial ownership, directly or indirectly, of not less than 20% of the share capital X
(d) Investments in the capital of other banks and financial institutions (where applicable) X Total deduction ( X )
Total capital base after deduction X
======
_______________________________________________________________ (1) Discounted by a fifth at the commencement of each of the last five years before maturity.
Annex B
Principal Risk Weights by category of
On-Balance Sheet assets
Risk
Weight Nature of item
0% (a) Hong Kong Government certificates of indebtedness held for note issue (b) Currency notes and coins (c) Loans and other assets fully collateralised by cash deposits of equivalent value with the institution (d) Gold bullion held in own values or on an allocated basis to the extent backed by bullion liabilities 10% (a) Claims on central governments of Tier 1 countries and their central banks maturing in 1 year or under (b) Loans or other assets guaranteed by central governments of Tier 1 countries or loans fully collateralised by securities of such governments maturing in 1 year or under _______________________________________________________________ Note : Tier 1 countries comprise Hong Kong, OECD countries and countries which have concluded special lending arrangements with the IMF associated with the Fund’s General Arrangements to Borrow (see Annex F).
Risk
Weight Nature of item
20% (a) Claims on central governments of Tier 1 countries and their central banks maturing over 1 year (b) Loans or other assets guaranteed by central governments of Tier 1 countries or loans collateralised by securities of such governments maturing over 1 year (c) Local currency claims on central governments of tier 2 countries and their central banks funded by that currency (d) Claims on local governments of OECD countries (e) Claims authorised institutions in Hong Kong and loans or other assets guaranteed by such institutions (f) Claims on other banks incorporated in the OECD countries and loans or other assets guaranteed by such banks (g) Claims on other foreign banks (2) and loans or other assets guaranteed by such banks maturing in 1 year or under (h) Claims on or loans guaranteed by public sector utility and non-commercial entities (3) of Tier 1 countries, excluding the central governments of such countries. _______________________________________________________________ (2) Foreign banks are banks not authorized in Hong Kong and not incorporated in the OECD countries. (3) In Hong Kong, public sector entities include MTRC, Housing Authority, Hong Kong Building and Loan Agency Ltd., KCRC etc.
Risk
Weight Nature of item
20% (i) Claims on IBRD, IMF, ADB and other regional development banks and claims guaranteed by, or collateralised by securities issued by such banks (j) Cash items in process of collection 50% (a) Loans fully secured by first mortgage on borroweroccupied residential property (b) Foreign exchange and interest rate contracts not weighted in 0% - 20% (4) 100% (a) Claims on the private sector (b) Claims on central governments of Tier 2 countries (5) (unless denominated in and funded by local currency) (c) Claims on foreign banks maturing over 1 year (d) Capital instruments issued by authorized institutions or other banks (unless deducted from capital) (e) Claims o commercial companies owned by the public sector (f) Premises, plant and equipment and other fixed assets 100 % (g) Real estate and other investments (including nonconsolidated participations in other companies unless deducted from capital) (h) All other assets not elsewhere specified _______________________________________________________________ (4) As most counterparties of these contracts tend to have high credit quality, it has been proposed that a 50% weight will be applied in respect of counterparties which would otherwise attract a 100% (5) Tier 2 countries comprise all countries other than Tier 1 countries.
Annex C
Off-balance sheet items
Credit conversion factors for off-balance sheet items Off-balance sheet fall in the following categories. Their risk weights are to be calculated by multiplying the credit conversion factors by the weights applicable to the counterparty for an on-balance sheet transaction. Credit Items Conversion
standby facilities and credit lines) with an original maturity exceeding one year
8. Similar commitments with an original 0%
maturity of up to one year, or which can be unconditionally canceled at any time
9. Foreign exchange and interest rate See Annex D
related items
Annex D
Foreign exchange and interest rate contracts Interest rate contracts include single-currency interest rate swaps, basis swaps, forward rate agreements, interest rate futures, interest rate options purchased and similar instruments. Exchange ate contracts include cross-currency interest rate swaps, forward foreign exchange contracts, currency futures, currency options purchased and similar instruments. (Exchange rate contracts with an original maturity of 14 calendar days or less are excluded). Exemptions from capital weighting will be permitted, where (a) the instruments are traded on exchanges and are subject to daily margining requirements; or (b) the replacement costs of the instrument are fully collateralised by cash or tier 1 government securities, in which case they may be given the weight of the underlying security. Current exposure method In order to calculate the “credit equivalent amount” of off-balance-sheet interest rate and foreign exchange rate instruments, an institution would sum :
In order to arrive at the credit equivalent amount using this original exposure method, an institution would apply one of two sets of conversion factors to the notional principal amounts of each instrument according to the nature of the instrument and its original maturity. Interest Exchange Original rate rate maturity contracts contracts Less than one year 0.5 % 2.0 % One year and less than 1.0 % 5.0 % two years (i.e. 2% + 3%) For each additional 1.0 % 3.0 % year
Annex E
Transitional arrangements on capital base Initial End-1990 End-1992
Annex F
The following countries belong to the Organization For Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and comprise those countries which have concluded special lending arrangements with the IMF associated with the Fund’s General Agreements to Borrow :
Australia Luxembourg
Austria Netherlands
Belgium New Zealand
Canada Norway
Denmark Portugal
West Germany Saudi Arabia
Finland Spain
France Sweden
Greece Switzerland
Iceland Turkey
Irish Republic U.K.
Italy U.S.A.
Japan
Annex G
Recognized Stock Exchange
Auckland Stock Exchange
American Stock Exchange
Amsterdam Stock Exchange
Brussels Stock Exchange
Copenhagen Stock Exchange
Frankfurt Stock Exchange
Korea Stock Exchange
Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange
Luxembourg Stock Exchange
Manila Stock Exchange
Member Exchanges of Australian Associated Stock Exchange Milan Stock Exchange Montreal Stock Exchange National Association of Securities Dealers (USA) New York Stock Exchange Osaka Stock Exchange Oslo Stock Exchange Paris Bourse Securities Exchange of Thailand Singapore Stock Exchange Stockholm Stock Exchange The International Stock Exchange of the United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland Limited Toronto Stock Exchange Tokyo Stock Exchange Wellington Stock Exchange Zurich Stock Exchange
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 4 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added