Enforcement · SMV · 9 Sep 2009
CONASEV's Board dismissed appeals by Río Pativilca S.A., Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Erasmo Jesús Rolando Wong Lu Vega, Antonio Palacios Tejada and Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo against Tribunal Resolution No. 168-2009-EF/94.01.3, which found they acquired significant participation in Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A. without a prior public tender offer. Abaco Corporación S.A.C.'s appeal was partially upheld, reducing its fine from 250 to 220 UIT (S/ 781,000.00). The fines on the other parties (220 UIT for the companies, 200 UIT for the individuals) stand, and the obligation to sell via public offer within two months remains.
Lima, September 9, 2009
SEEN:
File No. 200917558, Memorandum No. 2194-2009-EF/94.04.1 dated August 24, 2009 from the Legal Advisory Office, and having heard the oral report of the attorney for Río Pativilca S.A., Inversiones Dagomar S.A., as well as Messrs. Erasmo Jesús Wong Lu Vega, Antonio Palacios Tejada and Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo.
WHEREAS:
I) Of the challenged resolution.-
That, by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal No. 168-2009-EF/94.01.3, dated July 23, 2009, hereinafter the Resolution, it was resolved:
To declare inadmissible the submissions of acquiescence made by Río Pativilca S.A., hereinafter Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Mr. Erasmo Jesús Rolando Wong Lu Vega, hereinafter Mr. Wong, Abaco Corporación S.A.C., hereinafter Abaco, Messrs. Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo, hereinafter Mr. Heredia, and Antonio Palacios Tejada, hereinafter Mr. Palacios;
To declare that Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Mr. Wong, Abaco and Messrs. Heredia and Palacios have acquired significant participation in Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A., hereinafter Andahuasi, without previously making a Public Tender Offer, hereinafter PTO, having thus incurred the infraction provided in Annex IV, numeral 1, 1.1, of the Sanctions Regulations in the Securities Market, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms;
To sanction Río Pativilca and Inversiones Dagomar S.A. with a fine, each of them, of two hundred twenty (220) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, equivalent to S/. 781,000.00 (Seven Hundred Eighty-One Thousand and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) and Messrs. Wong, Heredia and Palacios with a fine, each of them, of two hundred (200) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, equivalent to S/. 710,000.00 (Seven Hundred Ten Thousand and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), as well as Abaco with a fine of two hundred fifty (250) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, equivalent to S/. 887,500.00 (Eight Hundred Eighty-Seven Thousand Five Hundred and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), in observance of the limit set by article 352 of the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-JUS, hereinafter the SML;
To declare inadmissible the request made by Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A. and Messrs. Wong and Palacios to carry out a PTO in exchange for the obligation to make a public offer of sale that falls on Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Mr. Wong, Abaco and Messrs. Heredia and Palacios;
However, the right is reserved for the persons mentioned in the preceding paragraph, as well as for Abaco and Mr. Heredia, to request to avail themselves of the exception provided in article 72, subsection a), fourth paragraph of the SML, to carry out a PTO for 100% of the shares issued by Andahuasi;
To order, under the provisions of article 72, subsection a), first paragraph of the SML, that Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Mr. Wong, Abaco and Messrs. Heredia and Palacios are obligated to sell through public offer the shares of their property issued by Andahuasi, within a period no greater than two (02) months from notification of the Resolution;
The precautionary measures ordered by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 157-2009-EF/94.01.3 shall remain in force until Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Abaco and Messrs. Wong, Heredia and Palacios have strictly complied with the public offer of sale ordered by article 10 of the Resolution or, in the case of availing themselves of the exception provided in article 72, subsection a), fourth paragraph of the SML, until they have complied with making the respective PTO;
II) Of the appeals.-
That, on August 11, 2009, Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., and Messrs. Wong and Palacios filed an appeal against the Resolution, requesting: (i) That article 9 of the Resolution be left without effect and, consequently, that the substitution of the Public Offer of Sale, hereinafter POS, by the PTO of 100% of the shares issued by Andahuasi be ordered and (ii) That the fines imposed by the Resolution be reduced. They base their appeal on the following arguments:
They indicate that if all persons are sanctioned individually and not as a group as attributed in the charge sheet and in the respective infraction type, a certain fact would be sanctioned, which seeks to protect legally protected assets such as market transparency and adequate investor protection, making an interpretation beyond the purpose pursued by the PTO regulations, by attempting to sanction individually members of the economic group that together would have infringed the regulations and the principle of legality would not be complied with, therefore, they state that it corresponds to sanction the economic group that acquired significant participation and not each of its members;
They add that a violation of the principle of non bis in idem would also occur, which prohibits authorities from applying sanctions to the same subject for the same fact;
Finally, they request that the circumstances surrounding the acquisitions of Andahuasi shares be assessed (improper retention of shares by Investa SAB, acquisition of shares from another group of businessmen that put at risk the investment they had made, takeover of premises, installation of a board of directors without complying with the corresponding formalities, non-payment to workers among others) and, likewise, they indicate that their legal advisors requested the suspension of the trading of shares of Empresa Agraria Andahuasi without this occurring;
Subsequently, Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., and Messrs. Wong, Heredia and Palacios presented a document with legalized signatures in which they specify the scope of their appeal, stating the following: "It is important to specify that we accept in all its extremes the facts imputed in the charge sheet sent by the Issuers Directorate. In this sense, we request that it be taken into account that our appeal is limited solely to the claim for reduction of fine, it being understood that the extreme of the appeal related to the facts subject to imputation is withdrawn";
In the aforementioned document, they add that the fine imposed is disproportionate with the circumstances related to the acquisitions of Andahuasi shares, since they are being sanctioned individually when what is reasonable is that the sanction falls on the economic group E.W. jointly and severally and, on the other hand, they state that the fines imposed individually exceed the maximum allowed by the Sanctions Regulations, which is harmful to the principles of legality and proportionality recognized by the General Administrative Procedure Law, hereinafter the GAPL;
That, by document of August 18, 2009, Abaco filed an appeal against the Resolution, with the same claims as Río Pativilca and the others state in their appeal. Its appeal is based on the following grounds:
1.- The position of the Administrative Tribunal of declaring inadmissible the request for substitution of the POS by the PTO for lacking competence to rule on it, contravenes the provisions of its Statute and the Regulations of Organization and Functions of CONASEV;
It indicates that it is more reasonable and beneficial for the market to declare the substitution of the obligation to carry out a POS by a PTO for 100% of the shares of Andahuasi, since this will generate greater value and allow a prompt solution to the investment, as well as to the corporate situation;
Without prejudice to the foregoing, it requests that the Board grant the exception regulated in article 72, subsection a) fourth paragraph of the SML, in order to substitute the obligation to carry out a POS by a PTO;
2.- It affirms that the fine imposed by the Administrative Tribunal does not keep coherence and proportion with the reality and circumstances around the acquisition of Andahuasi shares, since the acquisitions made jointly have not been considered, therefore, in its criteria, the economic group should be sanctioned and not ABACO;
That, by document of August 19, 2009, Mr. Heredia filed an appeal in the same terms as the previous appeals under comment;
That, it should be noted that the referred appeal recognizes the facts related to the acquisition of significant participation in Andahuasi without previously making a PTO that were sanctioned by the Administrative Tribunal, by stating textually the following: "In this regard, I must mention that I accept in all extremes the facts imputed in the charge sheet sent by the Issuers Directorate";
That, likewise, it maintains that the fine imposed by the Administrative Tribunal does not keep proportion with the circumstances around the acquisition of Andahuasi shares and requests that it be taken into account that it has no record of sanction;
III) Of the analysis of the appeals
That, the appeals filed by the appellants were presented within the term and in accordance with the requirements provided by articles 207 and 211 of the GAPL;
III.1) On the substitution of the POS by a PTO That, in relation to the argument that it corresponds to the Administrative Tribunal to rule on the substitution of the POS by a PTO, it must be noted that from the reading of article 72[1] of the SML it can be inferred that the granting of this exception only proceeds after CONASEV has reached the conviction that it is more beneficial for the interest of the market to carry out a PTO in substitution of a POS, and it must also be indicated that this offer of sale must necessarily be formulated by all those natural or legal persons that reach significant participation in a company that has securities registered on the stock exchange without having launched a prior PTO, therefore the requirement of a POS in the regulated assumption is that of a corrective measure that seeks to restore things to the state prior to the commission of the infraction;
That, being the Administrative Tribunal the competent body to determine that an infraction has been committed in the securities market and apply the corresponding sanction, it corresponds to it to rule on the consequences established by article 72 of the SML for these cases, and therefore it is the one that reasonably should be in a position to rule and grant the exception of substituting the POS by the PTO, after determining that it is more beneficial for the market; however, the foregoing does not harmonize with the text of the SML that establishes that any reference to an attribution of CONASEV must be understood in the sense that it corresponds to the Board to exercise it, nor with the text of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of CONASEV, which delimits competencies in CONASEV and reserves to the Board the ruling of all exceptions contained in the laws and regulations, one of them being the one collected in the cited article 72 of the SML;
That, in effect, article 6 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of CONASEV states that: "The functions of the Board are: (...) and) To rule regarding the exceptions contained in the norms";
That, likewise, the precedent cited by the appellants (CONASEV Resolution No. 087-2005-EF/94.10) is not applicable because it was issued prior to the new Regulations of Organization and Functions of CONASEV, which clearly reserves to the Board the ruling of the PTO request as it constitutes an exception to the obligation of sale;
That, given that in the analyzed case there is a request for exception pending in CONASEV to formulate a PTO in substitution of the sale, which will be resolved once the analysis of said request is concluded through this resolution, the board rules only regarding the arguments of the appeal,
III.2) On the sanctions imposed
That, in order to determine whether the sanction imposed by the challenged resolution conforms to law, it is necessary to analyze the infraction type that gave rise to the initiation of the sanctioning procedure and that bases the sanction;
That, the Sanctions Regulations establish in Annex IV, numeral 1, 1.1 that the following are very serious infractions of natural or legal persons that acquire or increase significant participation, of directors, managers and shareholders of the target company, other investors, responsible for the exclusion of a security from the Registry, stock brokerage firms, Stock Exchange, ICLV, and other natural or legal persons that are related to the obligation or execution of a PTO or POC: "Not carrying out the PTO in the cases that correspond or acquiring or increasing significant participation without observing the regulations.";
That, this infraction is verified when there is a transgression of article 68 of the SML, which establishes the obligation to carry out a PTO to the person or group of persons that intend to acquire for consideration, directly or indirectly in a single act or successive acts within a period of three years, significant participation or equal to or greater than 25% of the share capital in a company that has at least one class of shares with voting rights registered on the stock exchange; acquisition that in turn can be made individually or jointly, in the latter case through the concert of wills to acquire significant participation;
That, in the analyzed case, the infraction has occurred through the joint acquisition of shares (through the concert of wills), which, moreover, has been recognized by the appellants;
That, from the review of the information in file No. 2009017558 and taking into account what was stated in the documents presented on August 18 and 19, 2009, by Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Messrs. Wong and Palacios (in which the facts imputed in the charge sheet are accepted as true), as well as the document of Abaco presented before the Administrative Tribunal, it is concluded that, in effect, the infraction contemplated in Annex IV, numeral 1, 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations has been recognized;
That, in accordance with current regulations (article 20 of the Sanctions Regulations) for the commission of very serious infractions a fine greater than 50 UIT and up to 300 UIT may be imposed;
That, according to article 348 of the SML and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulations, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the offender's record, the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, the harm caused or its restitution and its impact on the market, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender to its clarification;
That, in accordance with the new text of article 230 of the GAPL, as amended by Legislative Decree No. 1029 published on June 24, 2008, it was provided that authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction;
That, likewise, the referred norm establishes that for the purposes of grading the sanction the following criteria must be observed: a) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal asset; b) The economic harm caused; c) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; e) The illegally obtained benefit; and f) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender";
That, regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest or protected legal asset, it is agreed with what was stated by the Administrative Tribunal, in the sense that the infraction committed violated the principles of transparency in the securities market and did not allow real and potential investors, as well as shareholders who sold or stopped selling their securities, to adopt their investment decisions with sufficient information;
That, concerning the harm caused, as well as regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it is considered that Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Abaco and Messrs. Wong, Heredia and Palacios, although they are not repeat offenders in the market regarding this type of conduct, it flows from the file that they continued carrying out operations in violation of the PTO regulations, as indicated in their defenses, in order not to be harmed by the presence of a competing economic group, a fact that ceased with the notification of the charges;
That, likewise, it must be noted that it is agreed with the Resolution that Río Pativilca, Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Abaco, and Messrs. Wong, Heredia and Palacios do not have a record of sanctions for infractions that are within the supervision scope of CONASEV;
That, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it must be taken into account not only that the appellants acted with knowledge of their acts, but also that, as a consequence of the struggles for the takeover of control of Andahuasi, corporate conflicts were caused in the company, generating a situation of lack of control;
That, regarding the harm caused to investors, it is agreed with what was expressed in recitals 141 and 150 of the Resolution, regarding that the amount they failed to pay to those who sold them the ANDAHUAC1 shares amounts to S/. 10,452,117.92;
That, regarding the impact on the market, it is agreed with the Resolution, in that the operations carried out by the appellants together with those carried out by the competing group in the takeover of control of Andahuasi allowed the prices of Andahuasi shares to reach a level that doubled the price they had at the beginning of April of this same year;
That, likewise, it must be mentioned that the appellants have voluntarily recognized the commission of the infraction before the Administrative Tribunal, through the submissions of acquiescence presented before said instance, having, moreover, several of them ratified their position of recognition of the infraction committed, by filing the appeal or through subsequent documents;
That, regarding what was requested by the appellants to assess the special circumstances around the acquisitions of Andahuasi shares, such as the retention by Investa of the transfer of a package of shares, the takeover of the premises of Andahuasi, the installation of a board of directors without complying with the formalities, it must be specified that although they could evidence the circumstances in which the infraction occurred, in no case can they be qualified as exemptions from responsibility;
That, on the other hand, regarding what was stated by the appellants in the sense that they requested the suspension of the trading of Andahuasi shares, without this occurring, it must be indicated that CONASEV ex officio evaluated such possibility having reached the conclusion that there were not enough elements to justify said decision, notwithstanding this, other measures were adopted, such as the issuance of a precautionary measure, through which the registration of a registry block was ordered in the Accounting Registry of Cavali of 20,394,185 shares issued by Andahuasi;
That, in relation to the argument expressed by the appellants in the sense that it corresponds to sanction the economic group that acquired significant participation and not each of its members, it must be noted that in the normative framework to sanction natural or legal persons that infringe provisions related to the securities market, joint and several responsibility has not been regulated for the case of companies that make up an economic group, so it is not possible in the analyzed case to sanction an economic group as if it were a single offender as the appellants intend;
That, on the other hand, regarding the argument that a violation of the principle of non bis in idem has occurred, it must be indicated that for this to occur, the triple identity is necessarily required, concerning the subject, fact and basis, and that having previously sanctioned a subject, they are judged and sanctioned again for the same facts and under the same basis to the same subject, which has not occurred in the present case;
That, finally regarding the extreme of the documents by which they specify that their appeals, "(...) is limited solely to the claim for reduction of fine, it being understood that the other extremes are withdrawn", it must be indicated that from them the sense of their appeal has been clarified, it not being necessary therefore to rule on the other grounds set forth in the appeal in which the conditions that must be present for a violation of the PTO norms to occur are expressed;
That, due to the consequences indicated above, it is concluded that the amount of the sanction imposed on the appellants is adequate, and a reduction thereof is not appropriate;
That, without prejudice to this, it is observed that the Administrative Tribunal has omitted to apply a similar sanction to the legal persons involved in the infraction, a circumstance that must be corrected, having had in view, before resolving the analyzed case, the documents of recognition of infraction of the appellants, therefore it corresponds to reduce by 30 UIT the sanction imposed on Abaco in order that it keeps similarity with the one applied to Río Pativilca and Inversiones Dagomar S.A.;
Being in accordance with the provisions of subsection t) of article 11 of the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of CONASEV, approved by Legislative Decree No. 26126 and its amendments, as well as to what was agreed by the Board of CONASEV meeting in its session of August 31, 2009;
IT IS RESOLVED:
Article 1.- To declare unfounded the appeals filed by Río Pativilca S.A., Inversiones Dagomar S.A. and by Messrs. Erasmo Jesús Rolando Wong Lu Vega, Antonio Palacios Tejada and Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo, against the Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 168-2009-EF/94.01.3.
Article 2.- To declare partially founded the appeal filed by Abaco Corporación S.A.C. against the Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 168-2009-EF/94.01.3, reducing the fine imposed to 220 UIT, in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, equivalent to S/. 781,000.00.
Article 3.- To consider the administrative route exhausted.
Article 4.- Transcribe this resolution to Río Pativilca S.A., Inversiones Dagomar S.A., Abaco Corporación S.A.C., to Messrs. Erasmo Jesús Rolando Wong Lu Vega, Antonio Palacios Tejada and Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo, to Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A., to the Lima Stock Exchange, as well as to CAVALI S.A. ICLV.
Article 5.- Order the dissemination of this resolution on the CONASEV Portal.
Register, communicate and file
[pic]
Nahil Liliana Hirsh Carrillo
President
[1] Legislative Decree No. 861, Securities Market Law and its amendments
"Article 72 Non-compliance.- In the event of non-compliance with the preceding rules, the following rules shall apply:
a) Whoever acquires or increases their significant holding without observing the respective procedure shall be suspended in the exercise of the political rights inherent to the acquired shares, obliged to sell them through a public offering within a period no greater than two (2) months. While the suspension of the indicated securities lasts, they shall not be counted for the quorum.
Without prejudice to the foregoing, CONASEV may exceptionally additionally determine the suspension of the rights inherent to the shares it held prior to the acquisition or increase of significant holding, as well as determine that said prior holding is not counted for quorum purposes.
In the event of obtaining a capital gain as a product of the sale of the acquired shares, it must be delivered to the shareholders who transferred such securities to it. Any agreement adopted by exercising the representation of the acquired shares without regard to the obligation to carry out a public offering of acquisition shall be null, as well as any act of disposition carried out with such securities.
CONASEV may determine the cases of exception to the obligation of sale by public offering established in the first paragraph of this subsection, provided that this is more beneficial to the interest of the market and the obligated party carries out a public offering of 100% of the share capital. (...)"
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-JUS, hereinafter the SML;”
“By CONASEV Resolution No. 063-2009-EF/94.01.1 dated September 9, 2009, the Board of the then CONASEV, now the Superintendency of Securities Market – SMV, resolved to declare unfounded the appeals”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added