Enforcement · SMV · 26 Apr 2012
Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is declared to have intervened in transactions that breached public takeover bid (OPA) rules. The resolution finds that Scotia Bolsa knew the acquisitions by Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Erasmo Wong, Jaime Heredia and Abaco were being carried out in violation of the OPA regime and should have abstained from participating, given the relationships among the acquirers and its role in receiving, recording, proposing and executing orders for 99,723,238 ANDAHUC1 shares (48.16%). The proceeding also evaluates whether a sanction is warranted and addresses Scotia Bolsa's defenses.
Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of the SMV No. 114-2012-SMV/11
|Lima, April 26, 2012 |
Summary: It is declared that Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has intervened in transactions carried out in transgression of the regulations
| Subject | : | Sanctioning procedure initiated against Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., for intervening in |
|---|---|---|
| transactions carried out in transgression of the regulations on Public Takeover Bids | ||
| File No. | : | 2011006470 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2011006470, Report No. 547-2011-EF/94.06.3 dated September 15, 2011 issued by the former Directorate of Issuers, and Memorandum No. 513-2012-SMV/11.2 dated March 9, 2012, issued by the General Office of Conduct Compliance;
CONSIDERING:
I. BACKGROUND
By Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 168-2009-EF/94.01.3 dated July 23, 2009, it was declared that Río Pativilca S.A. (Río Pativilca), Inversiones Dagomar S.A. (Dagomar), Mr. Erasmo Jesús Rolando Wong Lu Vega (Mr. Erasmo Wong), Mr. Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo (Mr. Jaime Heredia), Abaco Corporación S.A.C. (Abaco) and Mr. Antonio Palacios Tejada (Mr. Antonio Palacios) obtained a significant stake in Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A. (Andahuasi) without previously carrying out a Public Takeover Bid (OPA), having committed a very serious infraction, for which they were sanctioned with the respective fines;
By CONASEV Resolution No. 063-2009-EF/94.01.1 dated September 9, 2009, the Board of the then CONASEV, now the Superintendency of Securities Market – SMV, resolved to declare unfounded the appeals filed by Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia and Mr. Antonio Palacios and partially founded the appeal filed by Abaco, reducing the fine imposed on the latter;
In observance of the Principle of Due Process, contemplated both in Article IV, paragraph 1, subparagraph 1.2, of the Preliminary Title —general principle— and in paragraph 2 of Article 230 —special principle applicable to sanctioning power— of the General Administrative Procedure Law (LPAG), through Official Letter No. 970-2012-SMV/11 dated March 14, 2012, the administrative file to which this Resolution refers was made available to Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. (Scotia Bolsa) for its review;
II. ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED
a) Whether Scotia Bolsa was aware that the transactions carried out by Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia and Abaco were being carried out in violation of the OPA regulations and should have abstained from intervening in said transactions.
b) Whether or not a sanction should be imposed on Scotia Bolsa;
III. ANALYSIS
A. APPLICABLE LEGAL FRAMEWORK
The obligation to carry out an OPA is contemplated in Article 68 of the Securities Market Law, approved by Legislative Decree No. 861 (LMV), and in Articles 4, 6 and 8 of the Regulation on Public Takeover Bids and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10 (Regulation). These rules establish the obligation to carry out an OPA for the person or group of persons who acquires for consideration, directly or indirectly, in a single act or in no more than four successive acts, within a period of three years, a significant stake equal to or greater than 25% of the capital stock in a company that has at least one class of shares with voting rights registered on the stock exchange;
In relation to the concept of significant stake, numeral 16 of Article 1 of the Regulation establishes that any direct or indirect ownership of shares with voting rights representing a percentage equal to or greater than twenty-five percent of the capital stock of a company that has at least one class of shares with voting rights representing its capital stock registered on a stock exchange is considered as such;
Likewise, subparagraph a) of Article 56 of the Regulation states that the execution of an OPA generates the obligation of brokerage agents who become aware of a transaction that is carried out or has been carried out in violation of the provisions of the Regulation, to abstain from intervening in it and from registering the corresponding transfers, a circumstance that must be immediately communicated to the Superintendency of Securities Market - SMV;
B. THE CHARGE FORMULATED
C. FACTS SUPPORTING THE IMPUTED CHARGE
According to the sanctioning procedure mentioned in the BACKGROUND, Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia, Abaco and Mr. Antonio Palacios jointly obtained 99,723,238 (ninety-nine million seven hundred twenty-three thousand two hundred thirty-eight) ANDAHUC1 shares, representing 48.16% of the capital of Andahuasi, having violated the OPA rules;
Scotia Bolsa, having intervened as a brokerage agent in the transactions carried out by Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia and Abaco (Acquirers) was aware that these were being carried out in violation of the OPA regulations, based on the knowledge of the following facts:
i) Relationships among the Acquirers
a. Mr. Erasmo Wong is chairman of the Board of Directors of Barroco S.A., a company incorporated in Panama, which holds 82.04% of the common shares issued by Río Pativilca.
b. Likewise, Mr. Erasmo Wong is Chairman of the Board of Directors and General Manager of Río Pativilca, a company holding 96.051% of the common shares of Agro Industrial Paramonga S.A.A.
c. Additionally, Mr. Erasmo Wong and his brothers Mr. Eduardo Javier Pedro Wong Lu Vega, Mr. Efraín Roberto Teodoro Wong Lu Vega and Mr. Eric Augusto Wong Lu Vega are regular directors of Río Pativilca and Agro Industrial Paramonga S.A.A. It should be noted that in the latter, Mr. Erasmo Wong holds the position of Chairman of the Board of Directors.
d. Dagomar, a company incorporated in Panama, has as joint attorneys-in-fact Mr. Luis Fernando Palomino Miranda and Mr. Antonio Palacios.
e. Mr. Antonio Palacios is alternate director and judicial attorney-in-fact of Río Pativilca, as well as alternate director of Agro Industrial Paramonga S.A.A., both companies indirectly controlled by Mr. Erasmo Wong.
f. Likewise, Mr. Antonio Palacios and Mr. Luis Fernando Palomino Miranda have acted as attorneys-in-fact of Corporación E. Wong S.A.C. until July 2008, a period in which Mr. Erasmo Wong and his other brothers also acted as attorneys-in-fact of said company. Additionally, Mr. Antonio Palacios is attorney-in-fact of Corporación E.W. S.A.C., a company where Mr. Erasmo Wong and his other brothers are also attorneys-in-fact.
g. Mr. Jaime Heredia and Mr. Efraín Roberto Teodoro Wong Lu Vega are partners of the company W & H Internacional Sociedad Comercial de Responsabilidad Limitada, with the former holding the position of General Manager in said company.
ii) Participation of Scotia in the purchase transactions carried out by the Acquirers in a continued and joint manner
Scotia Bolsa as a brokerage agent with respect to the orders detailed below participated in the entire process from the receipt of orders, their registration, the formulation of the respective purchase proposals and their execution:
Orders of Río Pativilca
Purchase orders for a total of 49,806,939 ANDAHUC1 shares dated May 7, 8, 11 and 14, 2009. Said orders were settled through policies issued by Scotia Bolsa dated May 7, 8, 11 and 14, 2009.
Orders of Dagomar
Purchase orders for a total of 6,769,065 ANDAHUC1 shares dated May 18, 19 and 20, 2009. Said orders were settled through policies dated May 18, 19 and 20, 2009 issued by Scotia Bolsa.
The acquisitions of Dagomar are unusual, because said client does not register additional operations to those mentioned in recent years.
Order of Mr. Erasmo Wong
Purchase order for 2,977,200 ANDAHUC1 shares dated May 20, 2009. Said order was settled through a policy dated May 20, 2009.
The acquisition made by Mr. Erasmo Wong is unusual, due to the few stock market transactions made in recent years and for reduced amounts. Said acquisition occurred as a consequence of a change of client originally informed to CAVALI S.A. ICLV (CAVALI), by virtue of which the original purchasing client Dagomar was replaced by Mr. Erasmo Wong.
Order of Mr. Jaime Heredia
Purchase order for 3,714,780 ANDAHUC1 shares dated May 21, 2009. Said order was settled through a policy dated May 21, 2009.
The acquisition made by Mr. Jaime Heredia is unusual, due to the few stock market transactions made in recent years and for reduced amounts. Said acquisition occurred as a consequence of a change of client originally informed to CAVALI S.A. ICLV (CAVALI), by virtue of which the original purchasing client Dagomar was replaced by Mr. Jaime Heredia.
Orders of Abaco
Purchase orders for a total of 36,725,261 ANDAHUC1 shares dated May 22, 25, 26, 28 and June 3, 4, 5, 8 and 9, 2009. Said orders were settled through policies issued on May 22, 25, 26, 28 and June 3, 4, 5, 8 and 9, 2009.
On May 28, 2009, Scotia Bolsa carried out two (02) crossed transactions for a total of 1,011,000 ANDAHUC1 shares between Dagomar, as seller, and Abaco, as buyer. According to what was reported by Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios, representative of Scotia Bolsa, these transactions were instructed by Mr. Augusto Chiong, alternate director of Agro Industrial Paramonga S.A.A.
The acquisitions of Abaco are unusual, because said client does not register additional operations to those mentioned in recent years.
iii) Statement of the Representative of Scotia Bolsa
Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios, representative of Scotia Bolsa, has declared before SMV officials on June 10, 2009, as recorded in the Inspection Record of Scotia Bolsa of the same date, the following: (i) that he carried out the crossed transactions for a total of 1,011,000 ANDAHUC1 shares between Dagomar and Abaco; (ii) that Mr. Augusto Chiong is the spokesperson and/or representative of the Wong economic group, to which the companies Dagomar and Abaco belong, and (iii) that Mr. Jaime Heredia is part of the Wong economic group.
iv) Communication of Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Antonio Palacios, Dagomar and Río Pativilca
Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Antonio Palacios, Dagomar and Río Pativilca, through a document presented to the SMV on June 19, 2009, have stated the following:
“(…) both Mr. Jaime Heredia Landeo and Abaco Corporación S.A.C. contacted us to ask about this investment and to indicate that they were also interested in acquiring shares of Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi because they had the impression that with the presence of the Wong group in said company the value of said shares would increase.
Since they were free to make said acquisitions and since ultimately the presence of said persons in Empresa Agraria Andahuasi turned out to be more friendly than that of the other group, we agreed that they also acquire shares and even recommended they speak with Mr. Augusto Chiong, who was a person (sic) who had followed up on the shares and our acquisitions.”;
IV. DEFENSES PRESENTED
a. It states that the statement made by Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios does not correspond to the facts nor to the real and true statement that this officer gave. The statement was unilaterally drafted by officials of the then CONASEV and has not been accepted by the declarant, since the inspection record does not bear the signature of the officer.
It adds that the record does not comply with the requirements of Article 156 of the LPAG, which states that the record must be read and signed by the declarants; consequently, the record supporting the statement, besides being inaccurate, is null.
b. It states that the communication sent on June 19, 2009 to the then CONASEV not only occurred after all the transactions carried out by the Acquirers through Scotia Bolsa, but was not presented by them as a Material Event and was not forwarded by the then CONASEV to Scotia Bolsa. Consequently, Scotia Bolsa had no obligation and not even the possibility of knowing the content of the communication and therefore knowing or deducing that the acquisition transactions had been previously concerted.
c. It acknowledges the receipt, execution and allocation of each of the orders referred to in numerals 2.2.1, 2.2.2, 2.2.3, 2.2.4 and 2.2.5 of the charge letter and that although they were carried out successively, in no case did they correspond to a concertation and/or connection with Scotia Bolsa in order to avoid the formulation of an OPA nor to the knowledge of a structuring operation of successive or continuous acquisitions by the Acquirers.
It adds that the fact that the Acquirers expressly acknowledge the concertation produced and even have submitted to the charges imputed by the then CONASEV in no way implies that Scotia Bolsa has participated in said concertation or has had knowledge of it.
Likewise, it indicates that the concertation has been restricted to the sphere of the Acquirers and in no case can it be extended, based on the profound and extensive investigation carried out by the then CONASEV, from which basically indications were obtained, to Scotia Bolsa, who in its capacity as stock market intermediary and in accordance with the regulations that govern it has received, executed and allocated each of the orders given by the Acquirers, assuming that each of them acted for individual interests, without a relationship of connection that united them beyond that which was evident.
Scotia Bolsa states regarding the transactions carried out, the following:
Purchase orders of Río Pativilca
Río Pativilca carried out five (05) transactions for the acquisition of 49,806,949 shares of Andahuasi, representing 21.90% of the registered capital stock of Andahuasi. The transactions carried out by Río Pativilca in themselves do not configure the obligation to formulate an OPA.
Purchase orders of Dagomar
Dagomar carried out four (04) transactions for the acquisition of 6,769,065 shares of Andahuasi, representing 2.98% of the registered capital stock of Andahuasi and in no case constitutes the obligation to formulate an OPA.
As of the date the transactions were ordered and executed, Dagomar was not declared as a company part of the Wong Group in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV), so Scotia Bolsa could not presume that this client was related, formed part of the economic group or maintained concertation with the Wong Group.
Purchase order of Erasmo Wong
Mr. Erasmo Wong carried out one transaction for the acquisition of 2,977,000 shares of Andahuasi, representing 1.31% of the registered capital stock of Andahuasi.
Although as of the date the purchase order was given, Mr. Erasmo Wong held the position of Chairman of the Board of Directors of Río Pativilca and therefore Scotia Bolsa could know the status of direct related party with Río Pativilca, in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation on Indirect Ownership, Relatedness and Economic Groups, even when it could be the case established in Article 68 of the LMV to carry out an OPA, this was not necessarily such because even with the evident relatedness, this does not reflect the intention to acquire a significant stake in a concerted manner, but could respond to personal interests.
Furthermore, the sum of the acquisitions made by Río Pativilca (21.90%) and Mr. Erasmo Wong (1.31%) amounts to 23.21% of the registered capital stock of Andahuasi, which would not oblige them to carry out an OPA.
Purchase orders of Jaime Heredia
Mr. Jaime Heredia carried out one transaction for the acquisition of 3,714,780 Andahuasi shares, representing 1.63% of the registered capital stock of Andahuasi, which in no case constitutes the obligation to formulate an OPA.
As of the date the acquisition transaction was executed and until today, Mr. Jaime Heredia is not related to the Wong Group, so Scotia Bolsa could not presume that this client had concerted these acquisitions jointly with the Wong Group.
Purchase orders of Abaco
Abaco carried out several transactions for the acquisition of 36,725,261 Andahuasi shares, representing 16.14% of the registered capital stock of Andahuasi, which in no case constitutes the obligation to formulate an OPA.
As of the date the acquisition transaction was executed and until today, Abaco is not related to the Wong Group, so Scotia Bolsa could not presume that this client had concerted these acquisitions jointly with the Wong Group.
d. It maintains that although it is true the purchase transactions were carried out continuously between May 6, 2009 and June 9, 2009, at prices that were successively increasing, it is not possible to conclude that these events denote concertation or knowledge of it, since in the period in which the transactions occurred, the interest of various investors in acquiring shares of companies that at the time were agrarian sugar companies was already known to the market, so it is not strange that successive acquisitions occurred by different investors, whose intervention caused prices to increase steadily.
It adds that the assumption made by the then CONASEV, that both the continued succession of acquisitions and the price increase are due to concertation, is not supportable, especially since the Acquirers themselves individually bid at prices that allowed the acquisition of shares ultimately set by the market and that if they had responded to an evident concertation they would have maintained the offer price for all transactions or at least maintained these prices for crossed transactions, which despite the demand for shares by the Acquirers could have reflected the concertation.
Likewise, it states that the charge letter considers that the acquisitions made by Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia, Dagomar and Abaco, by the fact of not being usual investors, explain in themselves the specific interest in acquiring control of Andahuasi, concluding that these indications point to confirming the concertation among the Acquirers.
In this regard, it considers that this argument is far from reality, because although the then CONASEV has concluded from these indications and after a broad and extensive investigation, that these would be linked to the concertation, viewed as isolated operations they only denote operations of unusual investors without this last fact by itself denoting the imputed concertation.
It adds that the then CONASEV has been able to determine this concertation not based on the indication of the unusual nature of the acquisitions but basically on the submission to the imputed concertation charges and the profound and profuse investigation carried out over several months.
e. It states that from an operational point of view neither the stock brokerage firm nor its representatives have several months or multiple statements that the then CONASEV had to conclude the concertation, but rather each of the orders made by the acquirers has been received and executed on the day, collected and transmitted immediately for execution.
It adds that the representative before taking each order does not consult the Public Registries or the RPMV, to see who the shareholders and directors are, nor does it have filters to detect possible connections between clients and economic group. Even the then CONASEV has not been able to prove the connection of all the Acquirers but only the concertation, basically by effect of their own statements (the submission), since it only had indications as it recognizes in the charge letter.
It concludes that although the representatives of Scotia Bolsa could notice the connection between Río Pativilca and Mr. Erasmo Wong and therefore evaluated whether both related clients exceeded the 25% threshold, which did not happen, in all the other transactions carried out by the Acquirers there was no way to identify these connections, if any, within the ordinary diligence that the representative must maintain, since it is beyond this diligence to verify legal documents prior to the execution of an order that, according to the rule must be transmitted immediately.
f. It maintains that it is necessary to consider that the holding of shares with suspended rights, which gives rise to the reduction of capital stock for OPA purposes, is not of knowledge and public scope, so Scotia Bolsa has not had how to know that the registered capital it used to calculate each of the transactions carried out by the Acquirers should not have been taken into account for purposes of determining the percentage and calculation of the significant stake.
It adds that Scotia Bolsa has made the calculation of these transactions based on the information of capital stock of Andahuasi, which is registered in the Public Registries and in the RPMV;
V. EVALUATION OF THE DEFENSES
Regarding the first argument (literal a) referring to the questioning of the validity of the Inspection Report of Scotia Bolsa dated June 10, 2009, which contains the statement of Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios, representative of Scotia Bolsa, first, it is pertinent to note that Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios, then representative of Scotia Bolsa, participated in the purchases of ANDAHUC1 shares of Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Abaco and Mr. Jaime Heredia. Likewise, Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios carried out the cross operations of May 28, 2009 between Dagomar and Abaco, ordered by Mr. Augusto Chiong;
In said statement, made on June 10, 2009, Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios stated that Mr. Augusto Chiong was presented as spokesperson and/or representative of the Wong economic group by the companies Dagomar and Abaco and that he generally intervened as the orderer of purchases of said companies. Additionally, Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios indicated that Mr. Jaime Heredia was part of the Wong economic group;
It should be noted that although the aforementioned Mr. Díaz did not sign the Inspection Report of Scotia Bolsa dated June 10, 2009, it does contain the statements in question, and both the SMV officials and the then Internal Control Officer of Scotia Bolsa, Mr. Alejandro José Roberto Bazo Bertrán, signed it, recording what was expressed by Mr. Díaz, so it cannot be argued that said statement is inaccurate or null, much less that it was drafted unilaterally by the officials of the then CONASEV;
It is important to note that according to Article 56 of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, the Internal Control Officer, together with the Board of Directors and the General Manager, is responsible for the internal control system of the intermediation agent[1], and among other activities, said officer is responsible for verifying matters related to the execution of operations, so his conformity expressly stated and ratified through his signature on the aforementioned report, which includes the statement of Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios, evidences the veracity of what is recorded therein and its legal validity;
Regarding the second argument (literal b) referring to the fact that Scotia Bolsa had no obligation and not even the possibility of knowing the content of the communication of Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Antonio Palacios, Dagomar and Río Pativilca, presented to the SMV on June 19, 2009, it should be noted that although the statement of charges refers to said communication, it does not constitute the basis of the imputation of charges against Scotia Bolsa, but rather it is the sum of elements, which appreciated as a whole, prove the commission of the infraction to the provisions of subsection a) of Article 56 of the Regulation;
Likewise, it should be taken into account that in this aspect of the imputation of charges, the fact that Scotia Bolsa had the obligation or possibility of knowing about the aforementioned statement subsequently made by the Acquirers is not attributed as a determining element of the commission of the imputed infraction, but rather the reference to those statements is intended to show that Mr. Jaime Heredia and Abaco contacted Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Antonio Palacios, Dagomar and Río Pativilca for the acquisition of ANDAHUC1 shares. In that sense, this reference is an additional element that confirms the existing relationships between the mentioned persons, who, on the respective dates, were clients of Scotia Bolsa, except for Mr. Palacios;
Regarding the third argument (literal c) referring to the fact that the operations carried out in no case correspond to a collusion and/or link with Scotia Bolsa nor to the knowledge of a structuring of acquisitions by the Acquirers, it should be noted that the charge imputed to Scotia Bolsa is the commission of the infraction to the provisions of subsection a) of Article 56 of the Regulation, which establishes that intermediation agents who become aware of an operation that is carried out or has been carried out in violation of the OPA rules must refrain from intervening in it and from registering the corresponding transfers, immediately communicating the fact to the SMV;
In that sense, the purpose of this proceeding is to determine whether there are sufficient elements to appreciate that Scotia Bolsa knew of the joint action of Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia and Abaco to acquire significant participation in Andahuasi, and it is not the objective of this proceeding to determine whether or not there was collusion and/or link on the part of the Acquirers with Scotia Bolsa;
In that order of ideas, in relation to the purchase orders and operations of the Acquirers and the knowledge that these were carried out in violation of the OPA regulations, the following should be noted:
i) All purchase operations of the Acquirers were carried out through Scotia Bolsa.
The Acquirers, who were unusual investors in the securities market, bought through Scotia Bolsa in a very short period important volumes of ANDAHUC1 shares, a situation that was known by Scotia Bolsa.
ii) Scotia Bolsa registered purchase orders continuously, making it possible to appreciate that the purchase operations subject to charge of one principal began when those of another principal ceased, as follows:
| Acquirer | Start of purchases | End of purchases |
|---|---|---|
| Río Pativilca S.A. | 05/07/2009 | 05/14/2009 |
| Inversiones Dagomar S.A. | 05/18/2009 | 05/20/2009 |
| Erasmo Wong Lu | 05/20/2009 | 05/20/2009 |
| Jaime Raúl Heredia Landeo | 05/21/2009 | 05/21/2009 |
| Abaco Corporación S.A.C. | 05/22/2009 | 06/09/2009 |
iii) The operations were carried out at successively higher prices from May 7, 2009 to May 25, 2009.
The purchase price of the Acquirers increased steadily from S/. 0.72 Nuevos Soles per share on May 7, 2009 to S/. 1.57 Nuevos Soles per share on May 25, 2009, a situation that, as previously mentioned, was notorious in the market, which, added to the important volumes of shares being acquired in that short period of time, allowed an intermediary such as Scotia Bolsa to know that particular situation, in order to refrain from continuing to carry out the purchase operations.
iv) On May 7, 2009, Río Pativilca began purchases of ANDAHUC1 shares, managing to acquire by May 14, 2009 a quantity of 49,806,939 ANDAHUC1 shares in four (04) trading days.
It should be noted that on a single day, May 14, 2009, Scotia Bolsa intermediated a cross operation between Industrial Andahuasi SAC (Industrial) and Río Pativilca, through which the latter acquired 49,422,573 ANDAHUC1 shares.
v) On May 18, 2009, Dagomar continued with the purchase of shares, managing to acquire by May 20, 2009 a quantity of 6,769,065 ANDAHUC1 shares in three (03) trading days.
vi) On May 20, 2009, Dagomar, after the purchases made as indicated in the preceding paragraph, issued another purchase order to Scotia Bolsa for 2,977,200 ANDAHUC1 shares; however, due to a change of principal, the purchase operation ended up appearing in favor of Mr. Erasmo Wong, who indeed acquired precisely 2,977,200 ANDAHUC1 shares. The change of principal made by Scotia Bolsa, added to the facts referring to the significant quantity of shares of this acquisition, the previous purchases of Dagomar and the short term in which all these purchase operations were carried out, evidence the existence of a relationship between Dagomar and Mr. Erasmo Wong, which was known by Scotia Bolsa.
vii) On May 21, 2009, Mr. Jaime Heredia acquired a quantity of 3,714,780 ANDAHUC1 shares, an acquisition that occurred as a consequence of the change of the original buyer principal Dagomar to Mr. Jaime Heredia. The change of principal made by Scotia Bolsa, added to the facts referring to the significant quantity of shares of this acquisition, the previous purchases of Dagomar and the short term in which all these purchase operations were carried out, evidence the existence of a relationship between Dagomar and Mr. Jaime Heredia, which was known by Scotia Bolsa.
viii) Subsequently, between May 22, 2009 and June 9, 2009, Abaco acquired a total of 36,725,261 ANDAHUC1 shares in nine (09) trading days.
It should be noted that on May 28, 2009, Mr. Junior Daniel Díaz Dios, representative of Scotia Bolsa, received an order from Mr. Augusto Chiong to carry out two cross operations between Dagomar and Abaco for a total of 1,011,000 ANDAHUC1 shares (one for 495,500 and another for 515,500 ANDAHUC1 shares). These cross operations, under the order of the same person, carried out by Scotia Bolsa, evidence the existing relationship between Dagomar and Abaco, which was known by Scotia Bolsa.
The facts previously indicated, together with those indicated in recital 10 of this Resolution, prove that Scotia Bolsa knew that the mentioned operations were carried out in violation of the OPA regulations, so that argument put forward by Scotia Bolsa in the sense that the various acquirers participated for individual interests is left without support;
According to the foregoing, the argument of Scotia Bolsa lacks support, in the sense that (i) the individual operations of Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia and Abaco, as well as (ii) the sum of the acquisitions made by Río Pativilca and Mr. Erasmo Wong did not configure the obligation to formulate an OPA;
Likewise, Scotia Bolsa's argument that it was unaware that the Acquirers were part of an economic group lacks foundation because according to the Regulation, for the infraction imputed to Scotia Bolsa to be configured, it is enough that significant participation is acquired —without observing the applicable regulations— through an intermediary, and it is not admissible that said intermediary —in this case Scotia Bolsa— attempts to argue that in order to refrain it was necessary to know that such persons had to form an economic group;
Regarding the fourth argument (literal d) referring to the fact that the acquisition operations were continuous and unusual, it is appropriate to note, first, that Scotia Bolsa has acknowledged that the purchase operations were carried out continuously at prices that were successively increasing and that the interest of various investors in acquiring shares of Andahuasi and other companies in the agricultural sector was known to the market;
Additionally, it should be considered that an alleged collusion does not imply —as Scotia Bolsa states— that the price of ANDAHUC1 shares would necessarily have remained, because —as can be seen in the events that occurred— in the present case the prices increased as a consequence of the interest in acquiring the aforementioned shares, a situation that was known to Scotia Bolsa;
On the other hand, regarding what was indicated by Scotia Bolsa, in the sense that the statement of charges wrongly presumes that the unusual acquisitions —of Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia, Dagomar and Abaco— explain in themselves the interest in acquiring control of Andahuasi, it should be noted that such appreciation by Scotia Bolsa is biased, since the unusual nature of said acquisitions is not the only element of the imputation of charges, but rather it is the sum of elements, which appreciated as a whole, prove the commission of the infraction to the provisions of subsection a) of Article 56 of the Regulation;
Regarding the fifth argument (literal e), referring to the operability of a stock brokerage firm and the impossibility of verifying legal documents prior to the execution of an order, it should be noted that Scotia Bolsa, as an intermediation agent, has specialized knowledge of the functioning and operability of the securities market, as well as of its duties, obligations and prohibitions, so according to what is set forth in recital 10, it should have refrained from intervening in the operations of the Acquirers;
It should be noted that Scotia Bolsa's argument, in the sense that (i) the individual operations of Río Pativilca, Dagomar, Mr. Erasmo Wong, Mr. Jaime Heredia and Abaco, as well as (ii) the sum of the acquisitions made by Río Pativilca and Mr. Erasmo Wong did not configure the obligation to formulate an OPA, reveals that Scotia Bolsa evaluated the operations of the Acquirers to avoid carrying out purchase operations that exceeded the thresholds of the OPA rules, and knew of the special characteristics of the purchase operations of the Acquirers —successive operations of significant amounts of related persons— and the situation in which said purchase operations were being carried out;
In relation to the sixth argument (literal f) of Scotia Bolsa, in the sense that it had no way of knowing the number of shares with suspended voting rights and that it rather calculated the operations based on the information on the share capital of Andahuasi that appeared in the Public Registries and in the RPMV, it is important to highlight that this statement of Scotia Bolsa itself denotes that said intermediary did carry out a review of the amount of share capital of Andahuasi, of the thresholds of the OPA rules and of the quantities of shares involved in the purchase operations of the Acquirers, so it was aware of the implications, and despite this, it did not refrain from intermediating said operations;
Without prejudice to the latter and regarding said argument, it should be noted that the fact that Industrial was one of the main shareholders of Andahuasi and that in turn Andahuasi owned 78.76% of the share capital of Industrial constituted public information, among other facts, because that information was disclosed on the Securities Market Portal in the information on the main shareholders of securities issuers, economic groups and financial information, in the latter case specifically in the audited financial information of Andahuasi as of December 31, 2008;
In addition, it should be considered that Industrial was a client of Scotia Bolsa, in accordance with its respective Client Registration Form, so Scotia Bolsa knew the identity of the persons authorized to carry out operations on behalf of Industrial, the validity of their powers, and in general, the documentation that allowed it to process the sale operation of 49,422,573 ANDAHUC1 shares. In that framework, it has been determined that Scotia Bolsa had a copy of the Book called Minutes of the General Shareholders' Meeting No. 3, belonging to Industrial, in which the participation of Andahuasi in the General Shareholders' Meeting of April 24, 2009 representing 78.75648573% of the share capital of Industrial is recorded;
For all the foregoing, Scotia Bolsa did know that Industrial was a shareholder of Andahuasi and that Andahuasi was the majority shareholder of Industrial, so the shares of Industrial in Andahuasi had suspended voting rights, in accordance with Article 105 of the General Corporations Law and should not be taken into account for the calculation of the percentage that generates the obligation to launch an OPA;
Finally, in relation to this argument, it should be taken into account that even in the case that the computation of the operations of the Acquirers had been carried out based on the information on the share capital of Andahuasi that appears in the Public Registries and in the RPMV —as revealed by Scotia Bolsa— the Acquirers would likewise have obtained significant participation in Andahuasi in violation of the OPA rules;
VI. EVALUATION OF THE SANCTION
The facts described in this resolution constitute a serious infraction, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 2.1 of Annex IV of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 (Sanctions Regulation), which states that it is a serious infraction: “Register or intervene in operations that are carried out or have been carried out in violation of the regulations.” Likewise, Article 21 of the same norm establishes that this infraction is punishable by a fine of more than 25 and up to 50 Tax Units or suspension of the operating authorization of the brokerage firms for up to twenty (20) days;
Article 348 of the LMV and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the infraction, provide that the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the offender's antecedents, the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, the harm caused or its restitution and its repercussion on the market, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender to its clarification;
Additionally, Article 230.3 of the LPAG states that in applying the principle of reasonableness in the exercise of the administrative sanctioning power, the authorities must ensure that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction, and a proportional sanction must be applied, graduated according to the following criteria: i) the seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal right; ii) the economic harm caused; iii) the repetition or continuity of the commission of the infraction; iv) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction; v) the illegally obtained benefit; and, vi) the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender;
The aforementioned criteria have been incorporated in the amendment of Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, recently made by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01, in force as of April 17, 2012;
Likewise, it should be noted that SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 amended Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, referring to the criterion of “Offender's Antecedents,” so according to numeral 5 of Article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered party incurred the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable, it corresponds to determine whether the new text of Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation is more favorable for Scotia Bolsa;
According to the corresponding evaluation, the new text of Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation is not more favorable for Scotia Bolsa, so the provisions of the previous Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation are applicable to it regarding the criterion “Offender's Antecedents”;
According to the indicated, in relation to the infraction antecedents, Scotia Bolsa has antecedents having been sanctioned by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 096-2008-EF/94.01.3 of April 4, 2008, with a fine of 25.1 UIT;
Regarding the seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal right, which includes the repercussion on the market, in the present case it is proven that the action of Scotia Bolsa has indeed generated harm to the public interest, since the action of the brokerage firm generated a pernicious effect because it allowed the Acquirers to obtain significant participation in Andahuasi without formulating an OPA. Regarding the protected legal right, it is considered necessary to specify that the prohibition referred to in subsection a) of Article 56 of the Regulation has the purpose of preventing the clients of brokerage firms from infringing the OPA rules, thereby preserving equal treatment among the shareholders of the company;
With reference to the economic harm caused, it is appropriate to note that the action of Scotia Bolsa has allowed the Acquirers to generate economic harm to the shareholders of Andahuasi, harm that has been determined in the Resolutions mentioned in the BACKGROUND of this Resolution. Accordingly, the main affected have been the investors, since the action of Scotia Bolsa consists of having allowed, facilitated and/or carried out operations that infringed the OPA regulations. Had Scotia Bolsa timely communicated about the objective of the Acquirers and not carried out these operations that infringed norms, the economic harm caused would have been avoided;
In relation to the repetition and/or continuity of the infraction, in the present case no elements or facts have been found that allow sustaining that this sanction criterion has been configured;
Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that the infraction took place at a time when Andahuasi was subject to continuous conflicts in its corporate governance. The main shareholders of the company immediately prior to the commission of the infraction were Industrial 30.69% and Ducktown Holdings S.A. with 10.35%. At that time the shareholding of the company was dispersed (approximately 44% of shares were in the hands of Andahuasi's own workers);
Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, as indicated in what refers to the economic harm, it cannot be sustained that Scotia Bolsa has obtained an illegal benefit from the infraction determined and that is the subject of this proceeding. However, it facilitated the Acquirers to obtain significant participation in the shares of Andahuasi to the detriment of the other shareholders;
With reference to the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, from the facts exposed it has been proven that Scotia Bolsa acted knowingly that the Acquirers were buying shares of Andahuasi to have a significant participation in said company;
Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender to its clarification, Scotia Bolsa has not acknowledged the commission of the infraction; on the contrary, it has tried to sustain, insufficiently, that it did not facilitate the Acquirers to carry out operations without formulating an OPA;
Without prejudice to the foregoing and concluded above, in the analysis of the evaluation of the sanction it is necessary to highlight the aspects detailed below —in addition to the facts described above— which are important because they evidence, by the nature of their function, the fact that Scotia Bolsa should have refrained from intervening in the referred operations of the Acquirers and thereby avoid transgressing the OPA rules:
a. Scotia Bolsa, like every brokerage agent, has a thorough knowledge of securities market regulations, and also, like every intermediary, has professional and specialized knowledge of the functioning and operation of the securities market.b. Scotia Bolsa, as an authorized intermediary and supervised entity, has full knowledge of the duties, obligations, and prohibitions that apply to it, and that it must observe as an intermediary, especially those duties, obligations, and prohibitions directly related to the execution of operations, as this is its main activity.c. Scotia Bolsa, like every intermediary—as established in the regulations—knows, applies, and must comply with the procedures that allow it to know each of its clients, regarding identity and other aspects, which by its very nature is even a basic and necessary requirement for the normal functioning of its activities.d. In accordance with the facts set forth above, Scotia Bolsa has not shown conduct appropriate to that of a brokerage agent with respect to its clients, in the exercise of its intermediation function in the process of purchasing ANDAHUC1 shares by the Acquirers;In accordance with the provisions of numeral 13 of article 43 of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree N° 216-2011-EF.RESOLVES:Article 1.- Declare that Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has intervened in operations carried out in violation of regulations, having incurred the serious infraction provided for in numeral 2.1 of Annex IV of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution N° 055-2011-EF/94.10, which establishes that intervening in operations that are carried out or have been carried out in violation of regulations constitutes a serious infraction.Article 2.- Sanction Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. with a fine equivalent to fifty (50) Tax Units in force at the time of the infraction, equivalent to S/. 177,500.00 (One Hundred Seventy-Seven Thousand Five Hundred and 00/100 New Soles) for the commission of the infraction referred to in Article 1 of this Resolution.Article 3.- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative process, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision by filing a motion for reconsideration or an appeal, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.Article 4.- In the event that this Resolution is not challenged by a motion for reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of its notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of Securities Market (www.smv.gob.pe), in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 3 of the Rules related to the publication and dissemination of resolutions issued by the decision-making bodies of the Superintendency of Securities Market, approved by CONASEV
Resolution N° 073-2004-EF/94.10.Article 5.- Transcribe this resolution to Scotia Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A., and to CAVALI S.A. ICLV.Register and communicate,Roberto Enrique Pereda GálvezDeputy SuperintendentDeputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision[1] A system whose objective is to provide reasonable assurance for the effectiveness and efficiency of its operations, the reliability and sufficiency of the information generated by its information system; and, compliance with applicable laws and regulations.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 3 of the Rules related to the publication and dissemination of resolutions issued by the decision-making bodies of the Superintendency of Securities Market, approved by CONASEV Resolu…”
“In accordance with the provisions of numeral 13 of article 43 of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree N° 216-2011-EF.”
“By CONASEV Resolution No. 063-2009-EF/94.01.1 dated September 9, 2009, the Board of the then CONASEV, now the Superintendency of Securities Market – SMV, resolved to declare unfounded the appeals”
“Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of SMV No. 114-2012-SMV/11 of April 26, 2012”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added