SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 016-2017-SMV/10
Summary: The Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of six (06) UIT amounting to S/ 22,800.00 (Twenty-Two Thousand Eight Hundred and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) for having committed one (01) serious infraction classified in Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, item 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, for including securities in List 4 of the Referential Securities Table, without observing the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanction proceeding |
| File No. | : | 2014032690 |
| | |
The Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative File No. 2014032690, Report No. 766-2015-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, the defenses and arguments presented by the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.; and,
CONSIDERING:
- In accordance with Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the Comisión Nacional Supervisora de Empresas y Valores (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- The Extended Repo Operation is a type of operation established based on the provisions of SMV Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01, published on 24 July 2013, which modified Article 34 of the Operations Regulation in the Stock Exchange Trading Floor of the Bolsa de Valores de Lima, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 021-99-EF/94.10 and its amendments, hereinafter the Operations Regulation;
- In this regard, SMV Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01 states in its recitals that with respect to the modification of Article 34 of the Operations Regulation, the purpose is to establish a new modality of repo operations, called "Extended Repo Operations", which aims to allow brokerage firms to participate on behalf of accredited investors acting as reporting principals in repo operations with securities other than those comprising Lists 1, 2, and 3 of the Referential Securities Table;
- Consequently, the modification approved by the aforementioned resolution incorporated into said Article 34, Stock Exchange Repo Operation of Securities, regulatory aspects related to extended repo operations. It also modified the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, by virtue of which the conditions to be met by securities that may be subject to Extended Repo Operations were determined, with the purpose of establishing a methodology to determine the securities that could be subject to such operations;
- Therefore, as a result of SMV's supervision and control activities, the Bolsa de Valores de Lima, hereinafter Bvl, on 8 April 2014 submitted document GC-088/14 indicating therein that according to the Methodology of the Referential Securities Table, List 4 is composed of securities that are not part of Lists 1, 2, and 3 of said Table and that present, at minimum, a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%. Additionally, it indicated that "the Board of Directors of the BVL ordered the inclusion in said List 4 of shares BVLAC1, BVLBC1, and CAVALIC1, in the event they were not part of Lists 1, 2, or 3" (sic);
- By Office No. 4224-2015-SMV/10.3, charges were imputed to Bvl for failing to comply with the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, by including in List 4 of the Referential Securities Table securities that did not meet the requirement of maintaining a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%, thereby incurring the infraction classified as serious referred to in Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, item 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, hereinafter the Sanctions Regulation: "Failure to comply with its internal regulations or complementary provisions";
- By document No. GE-097/14, submitted on 1 October 2014, Bvl presented its defenses to Office No. 4224-2014-SMV/10.3;
- The charges formulated against Bvl and the defenses presented by the latter have been evaluated in Report No. 766-2015-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to this Deputy Superintendency for consideration;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, item 2, of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law and its amendments, hereinafter LPAG, by Office No. 3887-2015-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 766-2015-SMV/10.3 was made available to Bvl for review;
- On 12 October 2015, the representative of Bvl presented its oral report on the facts subject to this administrative sanction proceeding, and on 26 October 2015 it submitted written arguments;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative proceeding, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not Bvl incurred an infraction of the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation, by including the securities BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 in List 4 of the Referential Securities Table published on 9 August 2013, 1 October 2013, and 2 January 2014, and the security BVLAC1 in said list published on 1 October 2013 and 2 January 2014, securities that did not meet the requirement of maintaining a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%, thus failing to comply with the requirement of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, thereby incurring the infraction classified as serious as established in the Sanctions Regulation in its Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, item 2.1: "Failure to comply with its internal regulations or complementary provisions";
- Whether or not it is appropriate to impose a sanction on Bvl for the reasons indicated in the preceding item;
III. Analysis
3.1 Applicable Regulations
- Article 34, Stock Exchange Repo Operation of Securities, of the Operations Regulation provides that "(...) Repo operations in which the reporting company acts on behalf of an accredited investor may be subject to particular conditions regarding the securities subject to the operations. Operations subject to such special conditions shall be called extended repo operations (...)";
- The first paragraph of Article 27 of the Operations Regulation states that the Board of Directors of Bvl shall establish the methodology to be used for determining the securities with which repo operations may be carried out;
- Likewise, in accordance with Article 5 of CONASEV Resolution No. 021-99-EF/94.10, which approved the Operations Regulation, the Complementary Provisions referred to in the first paragraph of Article 27 of the Operations Regulation require prior authorization from the SMV for their application;
- Therefore, by SMV Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01 published on 24 July 2013, the Complementary Provisions to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation were modified, establishing that "(...) Extended repo operations may be carried out with shares or securities representing rights over shares that make up List 4 of the Referential Securities Table. This list is used solely for carrying out this type of operations and is composed of securities that are not part of Lists 1, 2, and 3 of the Referential Securities Table and that present at minimum a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%. (...)";
3.2 Charges
- By Office No. 4224-2015-SMV/10.3, a charge was imputed to Bvl for including the securities BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 in List 4 of the Referential Securities Table published on 9 August 2013, 1 October 2013, and 2 January 2014, as well as the security BVLAC1 in said list published on 1 October 2013 and 2 January 2014; securities that did not meet the requirement of maintaining a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%, as shown in Table No. 01, thus failing to comply with the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, thereby incurring the infraction classified as serious as established in Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, item 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulation: "Failure to comply with its internal regulations or complementary provisions";
Table No. 01
Trading Frequency Calculations
| | | | | |
|---|
| TVR published: On | Period | Number of Sessions | BVLAC1 | BVLBC1 | CAVALIC1 |
| 09/08/2013 | From 03/12/2012 to 31/05/2013 | 125 | 26.4% | 10.4% | 1.6% |
| 01/10/2013 | From 01/03/2013 to 29/08/2013 | 126 | 21.4% | 6.3% | 3.2% |
| 02/01/2014 | From 03/06/2013 to 29/11/2013 | 126 | 24.6% | 4.0% | 3.2% |
3.3 Defenses of the Administered and Their Evaluation
3.3.1. Methodology for determining securities for repo operations
- In this regard, Bvl states that according to the charging document, the methodology for determining the securities with which repo operations may be carried out is established by the Board of Directors of Bvl; however, it clarifies that the Board of Directors of Bvl does not determine the exclusion or inclusion of particular securities in the various lists recognized in the stock market;
- Likewise, Bvl specifies that due to a material error it informed the SMV that "The Board of BVL ordered the inclusion of shares BVLAC1, BVLBC1, and CAVALIC1 (...)" when what should have been indicated is that it was the Market Director who determined the inclusion of said securities in List 4. It adds that this is demonstrated by the methodology itself that has been published on Bvl's website since 1999 and that it attaches in its defenses. It also specifies that this methodology establishes that the Market Director may determine the modifications, inclusions, and withdrawals (of securities in Lists 1, 2, 3, and 4) that it considers convenient;
- Additionally, Bvl mentions that the aforementioned methodology, which includes List 4, has not been modified since board session No. 940/2013 of 25 February 2013, so it is applicable to the present case by virtue of Articles 27 and 34 of the Operations Regulation, also citing the Complementary Provision to Article 27 modified by SMV Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01 of 15 July 2013;
- In this sense, Bvl maintains that its Board of Directors approved the methodology to select the securities that make up the Referential Securities Table, within which the power is granted for the Market Director to determine the modifications, inclusions, and withdrawals thereof that it deems pertinent, in accordance with numeral 1.10 of the methodology.
- Bvl points out in its arguments that, upon authorization from the SMV to establish the rules for extended repo operations, the Board of Directors of Bvl empowered the Market Director to determine at its discretion the variations in the shares that may correspond to the Referential Securities Table List No. 4. It also indicates that the methodology referred to in Article 27 of the Operations Regulation is established by the Board of BVL and is a single one. It also states that repo operations and the shares used for such purpose are public, instantly known by the authority, yet were not observed by the SMV;
- Bvl explains that according to the parameters approved by the methodology, the system generates a list of securities ordered according to the score obtained; the Market Director receives lists 1, 2, 3, and 4 and, using the faculties granted in the methodology, may modify, incorporate, or withdraw the securities it deems convenient according to its own market, stock exchange, and/or economic situation criteria;
Evaluation of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted that before the incorporation of the Extended Repo Operation, Article 27 of the Operations Regulation stated: "The Council shall establish the methodology to be used for determining the securities with which the operations provided for in this Title may be carried out, as well as those that may be delivered as margin collateral, in accordance with the provisions of the following article. The securities shall be chosen based on their liquidity, volatility, concentration, and dispersion of holdings, among other criteria. The selected securities shall be grouped into lists of securities according to their risk level. (...)";
- As can be seen, through the aforementioned article, the Council, now the Board of Directors of Bvl, was empowered to establish the methodology to be used to select the securities with which the operations provided for in Title III Other Operations of the Operations Regulation may be carried out, among which are Repo Operations. Said article establishes that securities shall be chosen based on their liquidity, volatility, concentration, and dispersion of holdings, among other criteria, and that the selected securities shall be grouped into lists according to their risk level. By virtue of this faculty, the methodology for the operations provided for in this Title, among which are Repo Operations, is regulated;
- Thus, with respect to Repo Operations with shares and securities representing rights over shares, the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation indicated only the following:
"Repo Market with shares and securities representing rights over shares.
The current methodology for Calculating the Referential Securities Table TVR shall remain in force until the date indicated by the Board of Directors, which shall be informed to the market at least 10 (ten) Stock Exchange Trading Days in advance.
Repo operations with securities subject to extraordinary situations may be renewed, provided that the maturity date of the new operation does not exceed the exchange date in cases of merger, spin-off, or IPO, or the settlement date of the offer, in cases of OPA or OPC";
- Consequently, in accordance with the aforementioned Complementary Provision, the methodology for Calculating the Referential Securities Table, which is used for the selection of securities with which Repo Operations with shares and securities representing rights over shares may be carried out, hereinafter the Methodology, has been published since 1999 on Bvl's website;
- According to the Methodology, the selected securities make up Lists 1, 2, and 3, and the selection is made quarterly based on the stock market movement recorded in the previous six months, considering the evolution of the indicators: i) trading frequency, ii) frequency of intermediaries, iii) number of operations; and, iv) traded volume for all securities traded in that analysis period (six months). The selection procedure consists of calculating a total score for each security by summing the partial scores obtained for each indicator, scores that are weighted, with trading frequency being the indicator with the greatest weight in the calculation of the total score; the securities with the highest score, which become those with the lowest risk for carrying out Repo Operations, make up List 1, and so on, according to the total score indicated in the Methodology, the securities of Lists 2 and 3 are completed;
- From the foregoing, it follows that the Methodology involves four (04) stock market indicators and procedures for calculating partial and total scores; likewise, in Lists 1, 2, and 3, it is observed that there is an established relationship between the risk level and the penalty or discount on the value of the collateral backing the Repo Operation: the higher the risk, the greater the discount or penalty on the value of the collateral backing the Repo Operation.;
- Subsequently, upon establishing the new modality of Repo Operations, called "Extended Repo Operations", as mentioned by SMV Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01 which approved the modification of Article 34 of the Operations Regulation, the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation was also modified, incorporating a specific methodology for the selection of securities with which only "Extended Repo Operations" may be carried out, hereinafter, List 4 Methodology (underlining ours);
"Repo Market with shares and securities representing rights over shares
The current methodology for Calculating the Referential Securities Table TVR shall remain in force until the date indicated by the Board of Directors, which shall be informed to the market at least 10 (ten) Stock Exchange Trading Days in advance.
Repo operations with securities subject to extraordinary situations may be renewed, provided that the maturity date of the new operation does not exceed the exchange date in cases of merger, spin-off, or IPO, or the settlement date of the offer, in cases of OPA or OPC.
Extended repo operations may be carried out with shares or securities representing rights over shares that make up List 4 of the Referential Securities Table. This list is used solely for carrying out this type of operations and is composed of securities that are not part of Lists 1, 2, and 3 of the Referential Securities Table and that present at minimum a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%.
The provisions of the preceding paragraph are not applicable to preferential subscription certificates or any other security representing rights over shares that by their nature have temporary validity."
-
This means that in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, Methodology List 4 was expressly established to select the securities that would be subject to negotiation in Extended Repo Operations, which consists of calculating a single stock market indicator for the securities: Quotation frequency, unlike the Methodology which, for the selection of securities, considers the evolution of four (04) stock market indicators and has a procedure to calculate a total score per security, as explained above;
-
As can be seen in the text incorporated into the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, unlike the provisions of the Methodology, no reference is made to the power of the Director of Markets to modify, include or exclude securities, the only parameter involved in Methodology List 4 being quotation frequency, which, at the proposal of the BVL[1], was approved by the SMV, so that it is equal to or greater than 25%. Consequently, if it had been considered to grant prerogatives to the Director of Markets to exclude securities that have a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%, or to include securities that have a quotation frequency lower than 25%, such power would necessarily have had to be approved by the SMV, in accordance with Article 5 of CONASEV Resolution No. 021-99-EF/94.10, which, as mentioned, was not regulated in the aforementioned Methodology List 4;
-
Regarding the statement by the BVL that the methodology referred to in Article 27 of the Operations Regulation is a single one, it should be noted that this is not correct, since as explained in recital 29 of this resolution, for extended repo operations the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation was amended, establishing a specific methodology for this type of operations. Likewise, it should be noted that with SMV Resolution No. 008-2015-SMV/01, in force since May 4, 2015, the SMV approves a new amendment to the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, including therein, only as of said amendment, expressly what is indicated in the Methodology and Methodology List 4 as "Methodology for calculating the Reference Securities Table" (hereinafter, New Methodology);
-
Therefore, until May 3, 2015, in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, only mention was made that the Methodology would be informed to the market 10 (ten) Stock Exchange Sessions in advance. The Methodology was published and detailed on the BVL website and was not part of the complementary provision to Article 27;
-
On the other hand, Methodology List 4 was expressly indicated and detailed in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation itself, and only as of May 4, 2015, upon approval by the SMV, what is indicated in the Methodology and Methodology List 4 was integrated into the New Methodology, which is expressly regulated in the aforementioned Complementary Provision;
-
In the New Methodology, for shares, a distinction is made between: i) Repo Market with shares and securities representing rights over shares, which may be carried out with shares and securities representing rights over shares that make up lists 1, 2 and 3 of the Reference Securities Table –TVR; and ii) Extended repo market with shares and securities representing rights over shares, which may be carried out with shares or securities representing rights over shares that make up List 4 of the Reference Securities Table. Likewise, a section is included on the methodology for calculating the reference securities table, which includes the previously mentioned Methodology and Methodology List 4; and it specifies that the results are delivered to the Director of Markets, so that he may determine withdrawals. In this last aspect, it should be noted that this new methodology allows the Director of Markets to withdraw certain securities from a List, but does not authorize him to incorporate securities into any list if they have not been included as a result of the application of the methodology;
-
Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be noted that there are differences in the procedures indicated in the Methodology with respect to Methodology List 4, which would explain why the Methodology granted the Director of Markets the power to modify, withdraw or add new securities to the lists that are not the result of the calculation itself;
-
Thus, it can be seen that in the Methodology the following cases could arise for the Director of Markets to use the prerogatives provided in the provisions then in force:
-
A first case can be observed in the case of securities that have an acceptable quotation frequency, which is the indicator with the greatest weight in the calculation, that are excluded from one list and become part of another list of greater risk or do not form part of any list, because the incidence of the other indicators in the calculation of the total score results in their not reaching the score required to form part of any list, another of greater risk, or none;
-
In this scenario, the Director of Markets could have decided to add a security that does not form part of any list to List 3, or to modify Lists 1, 2 and 3 by moving a security from a higher-risk list to a lower-risk one;
-
Consequently, in this scenario what is observed is that the quotation frequency indicator of a security could be attenuated in the calculation process by the other indicators, so the Director of Markets, according to certain criteria, could make the corresponding modifications, withdrawals or inclusions;
-
That is, for example, if a security had a quotation frequency of 30% but due to the score obtained according to the Methodology it did not reach the level to form part of Lists 1, 2 or 3, at the discretion of the Director of Markets, according to the Methodology, he could include it in List 3. It should be noted that this possibility has been eliminated in the New Methodology;
-
A second case can be observed in the case of securities that, regardless of their low or high quotation frequency, have formed part of Lists 1, 2 or 3, as a result of the calculations of the Methodology, a security could be withdrawn from a list by the Director of Markets due to different criteria, such as being a share of the Venture Capital Segment or loss of quotation of the security;
-
On the other hand, it should be noted that the case of Methodology List 4 is different and was expressly detailed in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation itself: several indicators do not intervene in its calculation, no total score per security is calculated and the selected securities do not have a penalty percentage to be valued as principal of extended repo operations; it only consists of the calculation of a single indicator: quotation frequency, which must be equal to or greater than 25%, in accordance with what was approved by the SMV, at the proposal of the BVL. It should be reiterated that compliance with this single requirement was not subject to the discretion of the Director of Markets, that is, he could not discretionally add to this list 4 a security that did not meet the 25% quotation frequency;
-
In this regard, it is observed that in the case of securities BVLAC1, BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1, the quotation frequency in the evaluation period for the selection of securities of List 4, prior to the publication of the Reference Securities Table, was at all times less than 25%, even, in some periods, less than 5%, as shown in Table No. 2:
Table No. 01
Quotation Frequency Calculations
| | | | | | |
|---|
| TVR Published As Of | Period | Subsequent Calculation Period (1) | Number of Subsequent Sessions | BVLAC1 | BVLBC1 | CAVALIC1 |
| 09/08/2013 | From 03/12/2012 to 31/05/2013 | Jun -08/08/2013 | 48 | NC (2) | 4.2% | 6.3% |
| 01/10/2013 | From 01/03/2013 to 29/08/2013 | Sep 2013 | 21 | 23.8% | 14.3% | 4.8% |
| 02/01/2014 | From 03/06/2013 to 29/11/2013 | Dec 2013 | 21 | 4.8% | 0.0% | 4.8% |
- The calculation period is the one after the analysis period and before the publication of the TVR. Atypical operations are excluded
- Not Calculated: The security did form part of List 4
- Additionally, it should be noted that the security CAVALIC1 as of October 1, 2013 and the security BVLBC1 as of January 2, 2014, dates on which List 4 of the Reference Securities Table was published, had even lost quotation, which is a criterion that the BVL used to withdraw securities from a list, so it in no way contributed to compliance with the requirement of trading frequency greater than 25%;
- For the foregoing, it is additionally concluded that in the supposed and denied case that the Director of Markets had the power to add the securities BVLAC1, BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 to the Reference Securities Table, there is no technical support for the Director of Markets to have included said securities in List 4 that had a quotation frequency of less than 25%, even less than 5%;
- Likewise, as mentioned, since May 4, 2015, the prerogative that the Director of Markets has to modify the securities making up the lists that result from the application of the New Methodology, which includes extended repo operations and was approved by the SMV, is limited only to withdrawals of securities, so it is clear that the Director of Markets currently has no power to add securities to any of the lists of the Reference Securities Table;
- In this sense, the text of numeral 1.10 of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 008-2015-SMV/01, is transcribed below: 1.10 The results are delivered to the Director of Markets, so that he may determine withdrawals, in accordance with the following criteria:
- Volatility (annualized standard deviation depending on each security);
- Securities traded at less than S/.0.05 or $0.05;
- No financial information;
- Announcement of financial non-compliance;
- Companies of the Venture Capital segment subject to evaluation." (our emphasis);
- As can be seen, this new provision would reinforce what is stated in recital 46 of this resolution regarding the fact that there is no technical support for the Director of Markets to have prerogatives to add securities that have a quotation frequency of less than 25%, even less than 5%, because these have a greater risk of devaluation due to liquidity risk, which increases the risk of non-compliance inherent in this type of operations;
- Consequently, it is concluded that in the case of Extended Repo Operations, the conditions approved by the SMV that must be met by the securities participating in this type of operations and the methodology for the selection of these securities were established in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation and no power was granted to the Director of Markets, nor to the Board of Directors of the BVL, to modify such conditions or to allow the entry of securities that do not comply with the requirements indicated therein; this is without prejudice to the fact that there is also no technical reasonableness for the entry of the securities in question into List 4 of the Reference Securities Table, as additionally explained;
- Finally, regarding the BVL's claim that repo operations and the shares used for such purpose are public, instantly known by the authority, however were not observed by the SMV, it should be noted that there was indeed supervision by the SMV regarding the methodology for calculating quotation frequency used to determine the shares that make up List 4 of the Reference Securities Table, as can be seen from Official Letter No. 1439-2014-SMV/11.1 of March 21, 2014, by which the BVL was requested to provide details and clarifications regarding the aforementioned methodology, which was answered by the BVL on April 7, 2014; which ultimately led to the initiation of this sanctioning procedure;
Defense
3.3.2 By the Director of Markets
- In this regard, the BVL states that List 4 of the Reference Securities Table contains shares from different sectors that can be used to carry out extended repo operations, by reporting companies acting on behalf of an accredited investor. The requirements for certain shares to be included in List 4 are that they are not included in Lists 1, 2, and 3 of the Reference Securities Table and that they have at least a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%;
- The BVL adds that Reference Securities Tables 1, 2, 3 and 4 are not definitive, since the methodology currently in force allows the Director of Markets, under his sole criteria and responsibility, to incorporate, withdraw or modify securities from said tables, disregarding one or some of the parameters previously established by the Board of Directors;
- The BVL specifies that the Director of Markets has full discretion to resolve matters related to operations carried out on the exchange, as follows from Article 119 of the Market Law, hereinafter LMV, and Articles 5 and 14 of the Director of Markets Regulation. 2.3.2.4. Therefore, the BVL indicates that according to the cited rules, in the case of securities BVLAC1, BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1, these were incorporated into Reference Securities Table 4 by express decision of the Director of Markets, so that they may be used as principal in repo operations and also that the reporting investor is an accredited investor;
- The BVL states that the Board of Directors approves a methodology, not the Reference Securities Table, since as mentioned the table is generated automatically, according to the established parameters. Therefore, it is valid to maintain that the Director of Markets can modify, incorporate or withdraw securities from that table with criteria different from those previously established;
Evaluation of the defense
- On this matter, it should be noted that what the BVL states is not accurate regarding the fact that in the case of Extended Repo Operations, the Director of Markets is empowered to, under his sole criteria and responsibility, incorporate, withdraw or modify securities from List 4 of the Reference Securities Table, since as indicated in previous recitals, the methodology for determining the securities that will be used in said operations is clearly established in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, which states that these operations can only be carried out with securities that make up List 4 of the Reference Securities Table, which is made up of securities that are not in Lists 1, 2 and 3 and that have at least a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%;
- In this sense, there is no need to rule on what the BVL states about the powers of the Director of Markets, since as demonstrated in previous paragraphs, in the case analyzed the aforementioned official does not have the power to incorporate, withdraw or modify securities from List 4 of the Reference Securities Table and his action in this particular case had to conform to the provisions of the complementary provisions of Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, which are approved by the SMV;
- Likewise, it should be clarified that with respect to the other repo operations with securities in Tables 1, 2 and 3, but not in Table 4, until May 3, 2015, the applicable methodology did grant the Director of Markets the power to determine modifications, additions and withdrawals that he considers convenient. Additionally, it should be noted that according to the New Methodology, in force as of May 4, 2015, the Director of Markets only has the power to make withdrawals of securities from the tables; this based on the results delivered to him by application of the New Methodology;
Defense
- On the other hand, the BVL mentions that although it is true that 4 operations were carried out with the shares BVLAC1 and BVLBC1, at the date of presentation of the defenses there were no operations pending maturity whose principal for repo operations was made up of said shares, since they were settled on each of the maturity dates and in all cases the final settlement of the operations was complied with, there being no operations in force at the date, nor any claim, so it can be stated that there has been no effect on the market;
- The BVL also states that regarding the repo operations carried out with CAVALIC1 shares, 5 of the 11 operations carried out are currently pending maturity, with no non-compliance recorded in the replenishment of guarantee margins;
Evaluation of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted that the fact that the extended repo operations carried out with the securities BVLAC1, BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 have not recorded any non-compliance in the replenishment of guarantee margins and that to date the final settlement of these operations has been complied with, does not lift the charge observed for not having complied with the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation by including in List 4 of the Reference Securities Table securities that did not comply with maintaining a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the aspects mentioned such as the effect on the market will be subject to evaluation at the time of determining the sanction;
Defense
- The BVL indicates that the inclusion of securities in the Reference Securities Table List 4 has been approved by the SMV and included within the BVL's methodology, so it has not breached the Complementary Provisions of the Operations Regulation, since what happened was that the Director of Markets made use of the powers granted in the Methodology approved by the BVL Board of Directors to incorporate, modify or withdraw securities from the Reference Securities Table, when market criteria so consider it necessary, which is consistent with the framework established in the LMV, which establishes that the decisions it adopts are unappealable; the BVL highlights that the aforementioned power approved by the BVL Board of Directors was always present and remains in force to date;
Evaluation of the defense
- With regard to this argument, it should be noted that although the SMV approved the amendment to the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, through Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01, which established as the methodology for selecting securities in the case of extended repo operations, that such operations may be carried out with shares or securities representing rights over shares that make up List 4 of the Reference Securities Table, which is made up of securities that are not part of Lists 1, 2, and 3 of the Reference Securities Table and that have at least a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%, it must be taken into account that both Resolution No. 016-2013-SMV/01 itself and Joint Report No. 667-2013-SMV/10 of July 8, 2013, which supports said resolution, at no time analyze or refer to a supposed power of the Director of Markets to incorporate, modify or withdraw securities from List 4 of the Reference Securities Table, as the BVL claims;
- For the foregoing, what the BVL states is not accurate in the sense that the Director of Markets had powers to incorporate, modify or withdraw securities from List 4 of the Reference Securities Table for the carrying out of extended repo operations;
- Likewise, it should be clarified that the methodology applicable for the selection of securities to be used in extended repo operations (securities not included in Lists 1, 2 and 3 and minimum trading frequency of 25%) is detailed in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation approved by Resolution 016-2013-SMV/01 and furthermore, the aforementioned resolution did not empower the BVL Board of Directors to introduce modifications to said methodology for this type of operations. Therefore, the BVL's statement that the power of the Director of Markets to incorporate, modify or withdraw securities from List 4 of the Reference Securities Table for the carrying out of extended repo operations was always present and remained in force at the date of presentation of the defenses is incorrect;
Defense
- Finally, the BVL mentions, in its arguments, as examples of variations executed by the Director of Markets on shares contained in List No. 4 of the Reference Securities Table, the following: i) In the fourth quarter of 2013, a junior category company was excluded from List No. 4 for not having a current quotation; ii) In the first quarter of 2014, BACKUS I 1 was moved, promoting it from List 4 to List 3 and iii) In the third quarter of 2014, EXSA I 1 was excluded for not having a current quotation;
Evaluation of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted that without prejudice to what is stated in preceding recitals that in the case analyzed the Director of Markets did not have the power to incorporate, modify or withdraw securities from List 4 of the Reference Securities Table for the carrying out of extended repo operations, it should be mentioned that the examples presented by the BVL do not refer to the incorporation of securities into List 4, as was the case of the shares issued by CAVALI and the BVL, since they only refer to withdrawals of securities from List 4 due to loss of quotation or transfer to List 3;
Defense
- Finally, the BVL states that in the opinion of the Director of Markets and the market itself, the status of issuers of CAVALI and the BVL is unique from a positive point of view, since both companies have a high level of internal and external controls and also indicates that extended repo operations are aimed exclusively at accredited investors, who had sufficient knowledge to evaluate the risk of their operations;
Evaluation of the defense
- On this matter, it should be noted that it is not the purpose of this proceeding to evaluate the economic and administrative situation of CAVALI and the BVL, nor the characteristics of the investors who carry out extended repurchase operations, but rather to determine whether the BVL incurred in the charges imputed to it;
Defense
The alleged infraction violates the principle of legality and typicality
- The BVL states that the infraction imputed to it does not comply with the principle of legality[2], and neither does it clearly, certainly and unequivocally describe the conduct that is prohibited. It mentions that, in order to give content to the alleged infraction, recourse has been made to the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, which constitutes a violation of the principle of legality because the LMV and the Organic Law of the SMV have established that it corresponds to the Sanctions Regulation to expressly provide for the infracting conduct;
- The BVL indicates that if a sanction were to be applied in the case analyzed, the principle of typicality would be violated, since it is intended to impose a sanction based on a provision of the Sanctions Regulation lacking its own material content, a resolution that refers to another regulation[3]. It adds that it is not compatible with the principle of typicality, that technique of Administrative Sanctioning Law, according to which any contravention of the mandates established by a certain norm is generically classified as an infraction; a situation that could also open a wide margin of arbitrariness and discretion in favor of the sanctioning body, which could sanction any conduct that involves a breach of internal regulations or complementary provisions, regardless of its significance;
- The BVL states that "Not complying with its internal regulations or complementary provisions" does not have real content, since it is based on vague and indeterminate premises to attribute the commission of an infraction to a certain conduct, it does not delimit, nor establish what is to be understood by said infraction type, nor does it indicate to which internal regulations or complementary provisions the norm refers, so pretending to sanction it for the aforementioned infraction type is the most open and inaccurate form used to classify an infraction and impose sanctions in open violation of the norms and principles that regulate the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure;
- The BVL adds that, in the opinion of the Constitutional Court, open and inaccurate statements such as the one described are not susceptible of being considered as an infraction under the principle of typicality, because they lack real and objective content;
- The BVL also cites the judgment issued by the Constitutional Court No. 01873-2009-PA/TC[4] stating in its arguments that it is a judgment of mandatory observance since the Constitutional Court is the body responsible for interpreting constitutional norms and that according to articles VI and VII of the Constitutional Procedural Code both the set of resolutions that form constitutional jurisprudence and binding precedents are of mandatory observance according to judgment No. 03741-2004-AA/TC[5] issued by the aforementioned Court;
- For the foregoing, the BVL states that it has not incurred in a sanctionable infraction because the inclusion of certain securities in List 4 has been made by virtue of the powers of the LMV, the Regulation of the Director of the Exchange and the methodology itself to determine the securities that make up the different Reference Value Tables, granted to the Director of the Exchange;
Evaluation of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted that in administrative matters, the description of infracting conduct must allow the administered to know the obligations they must comply with and the consequences derived from their non-compliance. In this sense, this knowledge can be given through the substantive norm and the corresponding sanctioning norm, which has occurred in the present case;
- Indeed, through the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, the conditions that the securities that would be subject to extended repurchase operations had to have were established, which were not complied with by the BVL when it included in List 4 of the Reference Values Table published on August 9, 2013, October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014 the securities BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1, and the security BVLAC1 in the list published on October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014, that is, the complementary provision clearly and expressly develops the obligation that had to be complied with for the realization of the referred extended repurchase operations, also fixing the corresponding infraction type in Annex VIII, literal A) numeral 2, item 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, from whose reading its referral to complementary provisions, such as the one referred to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, is clearly deduced;
- Likewise, regarding the infracting conduct, Moron Urbina[6] specifies that "(...) the use of indeterminate legal concepts in the definition of the sanctionable conduct would not be contrary to the principle, in itself, as long as the concretion of such concepts is reasonably feasible by virtue of being referred to logical, technical or experience criteria, which allow foreseeing, with sufficient certainty, the nature and essential characteristics of the conducts constituting the typified infraction";
- The unity of solution that underlies the indeterminate legal concept makes its use in sanctioning norms, in principle, admissible, since when there is a single solution, the application of the norm does not entail a margin of discretion for the official in the definition of the sanctionable conduct";
- In this sense, it can validly be maintained that the principle of typicality admits a certain degree of indeterminacy to the extent that there are previously established guidelines in the legal system, such as norms (Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation), that provide clear and sufficient information about the behavior intended to be sanctioned, allowing to foresee with sufficient certainty the nature and characteristics of an infracting conduct, not leaving the administration a margin of discretion, since the elaboration of these criteria only allows a single solution and not several possible solutions;
- Thus the Constitutional Court has ruled in File No. 2050-2002-AA/TTC[7], stating that the principle of legality is satisfied when the provision of infractions and sanctions in the law is complied with and that the principle of typicality from an administrative point of view can be complemented through the respective regulations, that is, it admits regulatory "elaboration" in order to eliminate the risk of legal insecurity;
- On the other hand, it should be mentioned that according to doctrine, the legislator selects the most intolerable and most harmful unlawful behaviors for the most important legal goods. Thus, we have that for Muñoz Conde[8], "From the wide range of unlawful behaviors that occur in reality, the legislator selects, in accordance with the principle of minimum intervention, those most intolerable and most harmful to the most important legal goods and threatens them with a penalty, describing them in the factual assumption of a criminal norm, thus also fulfilling the requirements of the principle of legality or legalized intervention.";
- Likewise, it should be noted that doctrine states that it is very difficult to describe all infraction types, as the BVL pretends to maintain in the present case;
- On this matter, Muñoz Conde[9] states "This does not mean that the legislator has to describe with all exactitude and even its most intimate details the behaviors that it considers should be punished as a crime. That would suppose an exasperation of the principle of legality that, taken to its ultimate consequences, would lead to an overwhelming casuistry that, in any case, would always leave some factual assumption outside the legal description.";
- On the other hand, regarding judgment 01873-2009 issued by the Constitutional Court, cited by the BVL in its defenses, it should be noted that article VI[10] of the Constitutional Procedural Code only regulates the diffuse control of judges and establishes that the interpretation of constitutional precepts and principles is in charge of the Constitutional Court and likewise according to article VII[11] of the Constitutional Procedural Code, the judgments of the Constitutional Court that have so expressed it constitute binding precedent, in this sense, it should be mentioned that in the case analyzed, the judgment under comment does not qualify as binding precedent, since it has not been indicated as such [12];.
- Likewise, it should be noted that the precepts contained in judgment 01873-2009 regarding that according to the principle of typicality, generic legal types must be proscribed because these alone are insufficient to sanction[13], also indicates that a sanction can only be imposed if the prohibited conduct and its consequence are legally provided[14] and finally maintains that according to the referred principle the sanctionable conducts must be duly delimited, and clauses whose content is not express and knowable, which is filled or concretized through arguments used for that purpose, sometimes subsequent to the act intended to be sanctioned, must not be allowed[15], are in the same line as the aspects developed by the cited authors, in which the sanction is always linked to the existence of a previously provided sanctionable conduct that does not allow a margin of discretion to the administrative authority;
- For the foregoing, in order to comply with the principle of legality and the principle of typicality, it is sufficient that from the norm, which contains the general description of the factual assumption, it is reasonably possible to extract the infracting conduct;
- In the present case, the infraction type established in Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, item 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulation is validly complemented with the norms contained in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, which contains provisions that regulate the conditions that the securities subject to extended repurchase operations must comply with;
- Consequently, in the present case it is indeed feasible to know what the sanctionable conduct is, in effect, as indicated above in accordance with the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, extended repurchase operations can only be carried out with securities that comply with certain conditions such as not being part of Lists 1, 2 and 3 of the Reference Values Table and having a trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%; therefore, if said norms are not complied with, the referred obligation is breached, consequently the breach of said provision with the mentioned conditions (obligation) is subject to a sanction previously determined in the Sanctions Regulation, insofar as it is classified as a serious infraction of the stock exchanges not complying with its complementary provisions; that is, for the present proceeding, not complying with the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation;
- For the foregoing, in the manner mentioned, the discretion of the administration is limited since the determination of the infraction and the corresponding sanction are previously established in the norms, therefore the BVL's argument regarding the existence of an alleged margin of arbitrariness and discretion on the part of the sanctioning body lacks foundation;
- Thus specified the scope of the norms under analysis, they present a sufficient degree of determination to delimit the scope of non-compliance and its consequence and in this way to communicate to the obligated subjects its scope, so the principle of typicality would not be violated and therefore neither the principle of legality;
- For the foregoing, it is concluded that the BVL has not disproved the grounds of the charge imputed in the charge document;
IV. Evaluation of the Sanction
- From the foregoing, it has been determined that the BVL included in List 4 of the Reference Values Table securities that did not comply with maintaining a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%[16], thus failing to comply with the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Operations Regulation, therefore it incurred in the infraction classified as serious as established in Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, item 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the date of the commission of the infraction: "Not complying with its internal regulations or complementary provisions", which is sanctionable with a fine greater than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT or suspension of the operating authorization, according to article 21 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- According to article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of article 230[17] of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the contribution of the infractor to its clarification and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A[18] of the LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Antecedents of the infractor; b) Circumstances of the commission of the infraction; c) The harm caused and its repercussion in the market; d) Voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction; e) Contribution of the infractor to its clarification; f) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good; g) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; h) The illegally obtained benefit; i) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the infractor; j) Voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges; k) Error induced by the administration by an act or administrative provision, confusing or illegal;
- Regarding the antecedents of the infractor, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation in force modified by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012/SMV.10.1, the sanctions imposed and that have become final during the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction regarding any infraction type;
- From the review carried out, it has been verified that the BVL does not register sanctions during the mentioned period;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that the BVL, in its capacity as administrator of a centralized trading mechanism, knows the obligations contained in the stock market regulations and specifically what is regulated in the Operations Regulation and in the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of said regulation. In its operations, the BVL has failed to comply with certain obligations that have been evaluated above, which were detected as part of the supervision and control activities of the SMV;
- It should be noted that in its defenses the BVL has not explained the technical reasons that determined that the Director of Markets introduced securities to List 4 without them complying with the requirements of trading frequency equal to or greater than 25%;
- Additionally, it should be indicated that the BVL in its defenses has not indicated the basis for which the Director of Markets chose only the securities BVLBC1, CAVALIC1 and BVLAC1 to include them in List 4;
- Regarding the economic harm and the repercussion in the market, it should be noted that it has not been possible to evidence that the infraction incurred by the BVL has caused concrete economic harm to the participants or has caused repercussion in the market;
- It should be specified, furthermore, that by incorporating in List 4 securities that did not comply with having a quotation frequency equal to or greater than 25%, the BVL allowed market participants to carry out Extended Repurchase Operations with CAVALIC1 shares, in the period in which the Reference Values Table published on August 9, 2013 was in force; with CAVALIC1 and BVLAC1 shares, in the period in which the Reference Values Table published on October 1, 2013 and the Reference Values Table published on January 2, 2014 were in force;
- On the other hand, as observed in Table No. 03, in the periods of validity of the indicated Reference Values Tables, six (06) operations were carried out with CAVALIC1 and two (02) operations with BVLAC1. These eight (08) operations involved a total negotiated amount greater than 2 million Nuevos Soles and more than half a million Dollars with the participation of various reporting principals. In the period of the extended repurchase operations with CAVALIC1 and BVLAC1 shares (from 90 to 360 days) the operations were exposed to greater risks of non-compliance with replenishment of guarantee margins and non-compliance with final settlement due to the greater risk of depreciation of the securities that guarantee these repurchase operations due to the liquidity risks of the security. It should be specified that the largest number of operations were carried out with CAVALIC1, the most illiquid share of the three involved, a security that in all the calculation periods of the Reference Values Table presented a quotation frequency of less than 5%, having even lost quotation at the time of publication of the Reference Values Table, as mentioned above;
Table No. 03
Extended Repurchase Operations
| | | | | | | | |
|---|
| TVR Published As Of | Period | Security | No. of Ops. | Number of Shares | Cash Amount (S/.) | Cash Amount (US$) | No. of Reporting Parties | No. of Reported Parties |
| 08/09/2013 | From 08/09/2013 to 09/30/2013 | CAVALIC1 | 1 | 49,004 | 333,227.20 | | 6 | 1 |
| 10/01/2013 | From 10/01/2013 to 12/31/2013 | CAVALIC1 | 4 | 286,840 | 790,829.46 | 494,070.66 | 6 | 2 |
| BVLAC1 | 1 | 55,663 | 570,350.92 | | 1 | 1 | | |
| 01/02/2014 | From 01/02/2014 to 03/31/2014 | BVLAC1 | 1 | 64,592 | 576,483.60 | | 1 | 1 |
| CAVALIC1 | 1 | 2,550 | | 7,583.54 | 1 | 1 | | |
| | TOTAL | 8 | | 2,270,891.18 | 501,654.20 | 15 | 6 |
| | CAVALIC1 | 6 | 338,394 | | | | |
| | BVLAC1 | 2 | 120,255 | | | | |
- Likewise, regarding what was stated by the BVL in its defenses (considerations 59 and 60 of this resolution), it should be indicated that it has been verified that the eight (08) extended repurchase operations carried out in the period in which the Reference Values Tables published on August 9 and October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014 were in force, have been settled within the established term and no non-compliance with replenishment of guarantee margins was observed;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, it should be considered that in the decision-making process by an investor, the legal good referred to transparency must be observed; this to the extent that said process must be based on truthful, sufficient and complete information, so that in a context of uncertainty of probable events that may affect the value of their assets and therefore not achieve their investment objectives, they can manage and mitigate the risks associated with their investment decisions. In this sense, by incorporating the BVL the shares BVLAC1, BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 in List 4 of the Reference Values Table, it induced investors to assume that said securities had a quotation frequency greater than 25%, since normatively, that was one of the conditions to be included in said list, which limited investors from having at their disposal information that would have allowed them to completely identify the market, liquidity and credit risks associated with extended repurchase operations; therefore it is concluded that the legal good of transparency has been affected;
- Likewise, although only accredited investors could participate in extended repurchase operations, the eventual non-compliance with the settlement of these operations, and especially considering that they were securities with a trading frequency of less than 25%, could lead to assumptions of forced execution of the extended repurchase operations and even to the suspension of the reported brokerage firm until compliance with the settlement of said operations. This in turn could have generated an impact on the other investors and clients of such reported brokerage firms regarding the custody of their securities as well as for the timely execution and settlement of their operations;
- On the other hand, it should be indicated that, notwithstanding the provisions of the previous considerations, in the present case it has not been possible to prove that the action of the BVL has caused concrete harm to the public interest;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the infractors to its clarification, it should be indicated that the BVL in its defenses has not acknowledged the commission of the imputed infraction nor has it contributed to its clarification;
- Regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it should be specified that in the present case analyzed, it is not observed that this assumption has been configured;
- Concerning the illegally obtained benefit, it should be specified that based on the information in Table No. 03 and that which appears in the records of the SMV, the BVL has obtained benefits by incurring in the imputed infraction by having recorded income from commissions for the extended repurchase operations; as well as the proportional part of its participation of the BVL in the capital of CAVALI in relation to the commissions charged by the latter, for the referred operations, as detailed in the following table;
| | |
|---|
| S/ | US$ |
| CAVALI Commission | 140.28 | 1,160.24 |
| BVL Participation in CAVALI Capital: 40% (1) | 56.11 | 464.10 |
| BVL Commission (2) | 105.21 | 870.22 |
| Total benefit from commissions (1+2) | 161.32 | 1,334.32 |
- Regarding the existence or non-existence of intent in the offender's conduct, it must be stated that no intent has been verified in the conduct of Bvl;
- Additionally, regarding the evaluation of the mitigating circumstances of liability established in Article 236-A of the LPAG[19], it should be noted that in the present case, prior to the imputation of the charge to Bvl, the securities BVLBC1 and BVLBC1 no longer appeared in List 4 of the Reference Values Table, published on July 1, 2014, meaning they could not be subject to extended repurchase operations; however, the security CAVALIC1 continued to appear in said list. After the imputation of the charge to Bvl, in List 4 of the Reference Values Table published on October 1, 2014, the security CAVALIC1 was removed from this list, so no voluntary remediation of the infraction would have occurred before the imputation of the charge. Likewise, it should be noted that it has not been evidenced that the imputed infractions were generated by error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272[20] must be taken into account, which modified, among others, Article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG, and introduced as additional criteria of reasonableness: (i) the probability of detection of the infraction and (ii) recidivism for the commission of the infraction within a period of one (1) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction. Additionally, Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 modified, among others, Article 236-A[21] of the LPAG, restructuring the exempting and mitigating circumstances of liability;
- In this sense, it is appropriate to evaluate the following criteria for grading the principle of reasonableness established in Article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG:
- Regarding the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that in the analyzed case it was possible to detect the infractions committed by Bvl, insofar as they were identified as a result of the supervision and control actions of the General Superintendency of Entity Supervision.
- With reference to recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction, it should be indicated that Bvl does not present sanctions identical to the one that is the subject of analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure.
- Regarding the exempting and mitigating circumstances of liability, in accordance with the modification of Article 236-A of the LPAG, it is not observed that in the present case any of the circumstances constituting exempting and mitigating conditions of liability have been configured;
- For the foregoing, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, specifically the fact that Bvl has no record of sanctions, that it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed by Bvl have caused economic harm to market participants or to the market, and in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of Article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, as well as the provisions of the third paragraph of Article 6[22], it is appropriate to impose on Bvl a sanction applicable to minor infractions in accordance with Article 22 of the Sanctions Regulations;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
IT IS RESOLVED:
Article 1.- To declare that Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A. has incurred in a serious infraction typified in Annex VIII, literal A), numeral 2, subparagraph 2.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having included the securities BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 in List 4 of the Reference Values Table, published on August 9, 2013, October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014, and the security BVLAC1 in the referred list published on October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014, thus failing to comply with the provisions of the Complementary Provision to Article 27 of the Regulations on Operations in the Stock Exchange of the Lima Stock Exchange, the latter approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 027-99-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
Article 2.- To sanction Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A. with a fine of six (06) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, equivalent to S/ 22,800.00 (Twenty-Two Thousand Eight Hundred and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) for the commission of the infraction referred to in Article 1 of this resolution.
Article 3.- In accordance with Article 18 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, the offender on whom the fine sanction has been imposed for the commission of very serious, serious or minor infractions may request from the Administration Office a reduction of the amount to be paid, provided they accredit prior and joint compliance with the requirements indicated in the referred article.
Article 4.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal recourse before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 5.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by reconsideration or appeal recourse within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on Publicity of Normative Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms.
Article 6.- To transcribe this resolution to Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
According to the agreement of the Board of Directors Session of February 27, 2013. ↑
-
Which provides for the existence of a prior law that allows predicting with sufficient degree of certainty those conducts that may be sanctioned and the consequences of their non-compliance are known in terms of liability and eventual sanction. ↑
-
Notwithstanding that the Organic Law of SMV has expressly provided that the Sanctions Regulations would contemplate all those conducts that are typified as infractions and in that relation the conduct imputed is not described, therefore it does not constitute an infraction. ↑
-
- (…) b. principle of typicity, by virtue of which, the legal description of a specific conduct appears connected to an administrative sanction. This requirement derives from two specific legal principles; that of freedom and that of legal security. According to the first, conducts must be exactly delimited, without indeterminacies, while in relation to the second, citizens must be in conditions to predict, in a sufficient and adequate manner, the consequences of their acts, so general or indeterminate clauses of infraction that allow an action left to the "arbitrium" of the administration are not allowed, but rather it must be prudent and reasoned.
According to this principle, generic legal types must be proscribed and although the Administration sometimes conducts itself on the basis of deontological standards of conduct, these are insufficient, by themselves, to sanction, because although they can be interpreted as indeterminate legal concepts, the sanction must be based on concrete and detailed analysis of the facts (…)" ↑
-
Judgment No. 03741-2004-AA/TC
"7.1 The distinction between jurisprudence and precedent
42. The incorporation of binding constitutional precedent, in the terms specified by the Constitutional Procedural Code, generates on the other hand, the need to distinguish it from the jurisprudence emitted by this Court. The judgments of the Constitutional Court, given that they constitute the interpretation of the Constitution of the highest jurisdictional court of the country, are established as a source of law and bind all powers of the State. Likewise, as established by Article VI of the Constitutional Procedural Code and the First General Provision of the Organic Law of the Constitutional Court No. 28301, judges and courts interpret and apply laws and regulations in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution and the interpretation that the Constitutional Court makes of them through its jurisprudence in all types of processes. Jurisprudence constitutes, therefore, the doctrine developed by the Court in the different areas of law, as a consequence of its work in each case it resolves.
43. On the other hand, in order to confer greater predictability to constitutional justice, the legislator of the Constitutional Procedural Code has also introduced the technique of precedent, in Article VII of the preliminary title, by establishing that "The judgments of the Constitutional Court that acquire the authority of res judicata constitute binding precedent when the Judgment so expresses it, specifying the extent of its normative effect (...)". Thus, although both jurisprudence and constitutional precedent have in common the characteristic of their binding effect, in the sense that no authority, official or individual can resist its mandatory compliance, the Court, through constitutional precedent exercises a general normative power, extracting a norm from a concrete case." ↑
-
MORÓN URBINA, Juan Carlos. Comments on the Law of the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure, Ninth edition, page 711. ↑
-
"The principle of legality in sanctioning matters prevents attributing the commission of a fault if it is not previously determined in the law, and also prohibits applying a sanction if it is not also determined by law (…).
The principle of legality should not be identified with the principle of typicity. The first, guaranteed by ordinal "d" of subsection 24) of Article 2 of the Constitution, is satisfied when compliance with the provision of infractions and sanctions in the law is met. The second, however, constitutes the precise definition of the conduct that the law considers as a fault. Such precision of what is considered anti-juridical from an administrative point of view (…) is not subject to an absolute reserve of law, but can be complemented through the respective regulations (…)". ↑
-
MUÑOZ CONDE, Francisco. General Theory of Crime, Second Edition, page 31. ↑
-
MUÑOZ CONDE, Francisco. General Theory of Crime, Second Edition, pages 31 and 32. ↑
-
"Article VI.- Diffuse control and constitutional interpretation
When there is incompatibility between a constitutional norm and another of inferior hierarchy, the Judge must prefer the first, provided that it is relevant to resolve the controversy and it is not possible to obtain an interpretation in accordance with the Constitution.
Judges cannot fail to apply a norm whose constitutionality has been confirmed in an unconstitutionality process or in a popular action process.
Judges interpret and apply laws or any norm with the rank of law and regulations according to the constitutional precepts and principles, in accordance with the interpretation of them that results from the resolutions issued by the Constitutional Court. ↑
-
"Article VII.- Precedent
The judgments of the Constitutional Court that acquire the authority of res judicata constitute binding precedent when the judgment so expresses it, specifying the extent of its normative effect. When the Constitutional Court resolves departing from the precedent, it must express the factual and legal grounds supporting the judgment and the reasons why it departs from the precedent." ↑
-
Constitutional grievance recourse filed by Mr. Vicente Rodolfo Walde Jáuregui against the resolution of the Sixth Civil Chamber of the Superior Court of Justice of Lima that declared inadmissible the demand against the National Council of the Magistracy for violation of constitutional rights by having issued Administrative Resolutions No. 066-2006-PCM and 249-3007-CNM that sanctioned him with dismissal from the position of Titular Vocal of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Republic. ↑
-
Numeral 12 subsection b) of judgment No. 01873-2009. ↑
-
Numeral 12 subsection c) of judgment No. 01873-2009. ↑
-
Numeral 40 of judgment No. 01873-2009. ↑
-
The securities BVLBC1 and CAVALIC1 in List 4 of the TVR published on August 9, 2013, October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014, and the security BVLAC1 in the list published on October 1, 2013 and January 2, 2014. ↑
-
"Article 230.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power.
(…)
3. Reasonableness.- Authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria that are indicated in order of precedence for their grading:
a) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good;
b) The economic harm caused;
c) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction;
d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction;
e) The illegally obtained benefit, and;
f) The existence or non-existence of intent in the offender's conduct.
(…)" ↑
-
"Article 236 - A.- Mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for the commission of the administrative infraction:
1.- The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 235.
2.- Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision." ↑
-
Article 236 - A.- Mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for the commission of the administrative infraction:
1.- The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 235.
2.- Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision." ↑
-
Published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on December 21, 2016, ↑
-
"Article 236-A
1.- The following constitute exempting conditions of liability for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction.
d) The mandatory order of competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) Error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 235.
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for infractions:
a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges their responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount.
b) Others established by special norm." ↑
-
"Article 6.- Criteria and mitigating circumstances to consider for the imposition of sanctions
(…)
When the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria and mitigating circumstances allows concluding that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, by exception and through a reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided may be imposed.
(…)". ↑