SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 008-2019-SMV/10
Summary: Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of 10 UIT, equivalent to S/ 38,000.00 (Thirty-eight thousand and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred a minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, for failing to obtain orders from its client.
Likewise, it is declared that it has not been proven that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. incurred one (1) very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1, and one (1) serious infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, item 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, and consequently, the administrative sanctioning procedure is concluded in these respects.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2018023434 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2018023434 and Report No. 741-2018-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; and, the arguments and oral report submitted by Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.;
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- By document presented to the SMV on June 22, 2016, Mr. Humberto Bernardo Catep Fadel (hereinafter, Mr. Catep) files a complaint against Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. (hereinafter, Kallpa SAB) and against Mr. Ricky Marlon García Palza (hereinafter, Mr. García), former representative of said brokerage firm, because said intermediary allegedly carried out a series of purchase and sale transactions of securities in his name without his authorization;
- In this regard, as part of the preliminary inquiry stage, by Official Letter No. 3811-2016-SMV/10.3 notified on June 28, 2016, Kallpa SAB was given notice of the complaint filed by Mr. Catep and was requested to provide additional information and documentation in order to clarify the facts, granting a period of ten (10) business days counted from the notification thereof, which request was submitted on July 27, 2016, after the extension requested by said brokerage firm;
- By Official Letter No. 3964-2016-SMV/10.3 of July 6, 2016, Mr. Catep was informed of the competences assigned by law to the SMV and to the National Institute for the Defense of Competition and the Protection of Intellectual Property – INDECOPI;
- Likewise, by Official Letter No. 5074-2016-SMV/10.3 of September 6, 2016, Mr. Catep was requested to make comments regarding the information and documentation submitted by Kallpa SAB. Since Mr. Catep did not comment within the granted period, the request was reiterated by Official Letter No. 5515-2016-SMV/10.3 of September 20, 2016. Thus, by document received on September 27, 2016, Mr. Catep responded to the request made by the SMV;
- By Official Letter No. 6207-2017-SMV/10.3 of October 6, 2016, Kallpa SAB was requested to submit the originals of the orders whose signature Mr. Catep questions; the intermediary responded to said request on October 11, 2016;
- By Official Letter No. 6453-2016-SMV/10.3 of October 20, 2016, Kallpa SAB was requested to provide information and documentation regarding the denounced facts; which was attended by the intermediary by letter of October 25, 2016;
- By letter of September 5, 2017, Mr. Catep submitted a copy of two recordings referring to telephone conversations held with Mr. García, former representative of Kallpa SAB and who was in charge of his account; and by letter dated May 17, 2018, Mr. Catep submitted a document summarizing the denounced facts;
- As a result of the foregoing and under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law (hereinafter, TUO LPAG), by Official Letter No. 3187-2018-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), notified on June 12, 2018, the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against Kallpa SAB regarding the facts described by Mr. Catep as well as as a result of the information and documentation contained in this administrative file;
- By the Letter of Charges, charges were imputed to Kallpa SAB because it allegedly contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV), the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Regulation) and the Regulation of Intermediation Agents approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, current Regulation)[1], in force at the time of the events, in aspects related to the destination of client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted; failing to obtain orders from its clients; and, for denying the delivery of documentation requested by the SMV during the investigations;
- By document submitted on June 19, 2018, Kallpa SAB presented its corresponding defenses;
- In order to determine the authenticity or not of a group of signatures appearing in photocopies of alleged purchase and sale orders and account statements attributed to Mr. Catep, the SMV carried out a contracting process for a graphotechnical expert, who issued his expert report which was submitted on July 2, 2018. In this regard, by Official Letter No. 3461-2018-SMV/10.3 of July 3, 2018, Kallpa SAB was requested to provide its comments regarding the same, which were submitted on July 9, 2018;
- The charges formulated against Kallpa SAB, the latter's defenses and their evaluation have been analyzed in Report No. 741-2018-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 246, item 2, of the TUO LPAG, by Official Letter No. 3879-2018-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 741-2018-SMV/10.3 was made available to Kallpa SAB for its review;
- Likewise, on August 6, 2018, Kallpa SAB made use of its right to speak and presented its arguments regarding the imputations formulated as charges;
- By documents submitted on August 6, 7, 9 and 10, 2018, Kallpa SAB presented additional written arguments regarding Report No. 741-2018-SMV/10.3;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative sanctioning procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether Kallpa SAB incurred or not an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), by destining client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- Whether Kallpa SAB incurred or not an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, by failing to obtain orders;
- Whether Kallpa SAB incurred or not an infraction of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 2, item 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, by failing to deliver documentation requested by the SMV during the investigation;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on Kallpa SAB;
III. Analysis
3.1 Destining client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
A. Applicable Regulations
- Article 195, literal a) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, hereinafter LMV, prohibits stock brokerage firms from destining funds or securities received from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
- Likewise, Article 48 of the Regulation establishes:
"Article 48.- Basic Rules
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a purpose other than that, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in Articles 194 and 207 of the Law.
(…)."[2];
B. Of the Complaint
- By document presented to the SMV on June 22, 2016, and subsequent documents, Mr. Catep denounces Kallpa SAB and Mr. García indicating that from April 15 to December 31, 2014, shares of his property were sold without his consent (except for the purchase of SUE-RIO), thus breaching Article 195, numeral a) of the LMV and incurring an infraction for having carried out operations without the backing of the respective order;
- Likewise, in his complaint, Mr. Catep disowns the signature attributed to him that appears in the order listings for the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and account statements for August and September 2014 that were delivered to him by Kallpa SAB and Mr. García;
- In this sense, the complainant requests that a restitution measure be issued in his favor for the shares and funds he held in Kallpa SAB between April 15 and December 31, 2014. Mr. Catep states that taking into account the sales and purchases made by Kallpa SAB and Mr. García, the net book value of loss amounts to US$ 254,000.00 (Two hundred fifty-four thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars);
- In support of his complaint, Mr. Catep states that on August 13, 2013, he deposited in the bank account of Kallpa SAB the amount of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) and then on December 10 of that year deposited in said brokerage firm US$ 50,000.00 (Fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the purchase of shares according to his instructions;
- Likewise, Mr. Catep states that on April 8, 2014, he transferred the following securities to Kallpa SAB;
Table No. 1: Securities transferred to Kallpa SAB
| Type: Common shares issued by | Value | Quantity |
|---|
| Alturas Minerals Corp | ALT | 440,028[3] |
| Candente Copper Corp | DNT | 31,976 |
| Empresa Siderúrgica del Perú S.A.A. | SIDERC1 | 59,848 |
| Cía. Minera San Ignacio de Morococha S.A.A. | MOROCOI1 | 16,971 |
| Empresa Agroindustrial Pomalca S.A.A. | POMALCC1 | 81,934 |
| Empresa Agroindustrial Pucalá S.A.A. | PUCALAC1 | 56,983 |
| Southern Copper Corporation | SCCO | 2,619 |
| Sulliden Gold Corp. Ltd. | SUE | 29,725 |
| Type: ADR issued by | Value | Quantity |
| Minas Buenaventura S.A.A. | BVN | 1,869 |
- The complainant adds that he became aware of the situation of his portfolio when requesting his account statement corresponding to the month of February 2015, in which he observed an unjustified decrease of said portfolio by the amount of US$ 166,963.00 (One hundred sixty-six thousand nine hundred sixty-three and 00/100 United States Dollars), including the shares bought and sold without authorization by Kallpa SAB and Mr. García;
- Mr. Catep states that between July and August 2014, 2,619 SCCO were sold without his authorization; from August to December 2014, 1,869 BVN; in June 2014, 59,848 SIDERC1; in August 2014, 20,479 SUE-RIO[4];
- Likewise, Mr. Catep states that the purchase and sale of shares without his consent that left losses refers to the securities: ISNS[5], NUGT[6], FREE[7], LAKE[8], UGAZ[9], JUNG[10], FMCC[11], FNMA[12], MPLE[13], TV[14], LGC[15], NETE[16], PML[17] and YAHOO[18];
- Mr. Catep indicates that since May 2015 he has been exchanging letters with Kallpa SAB in order to obtain a solution regarding the patrimonial damage, however, this has not had the expected result;
- On the other hand, by letter received on September 5, 2017, Mr. Catep emphasizes the lack of the original document of the list of orders that support or sustain them. Likewise, he states that he expected the graphotechnical examination of the signatures as a normal course of the process, however, since such document does not exist, he attaches two recordings of conversations held with Mr. García, the first, of August 17, 2015, with Mr. Juan Carlos Catep Fadel, brother of Mr. Catep; and the second, of August 20, 2015, with Mr. Catep; As well as a copy of an email of May 8, 2015 that Mr. García would have sent him;
- Finally, Mr. Catep indicates that he expects the evidence that Mr. García forged the signatures and made operations without his consent to be clarified or conclusive, as will be heard in the recordings where the phrases will be found: "the fact that I have, the fact that a document has been signed has not been with the aspect of surprising" "that he has not wanted to defraud";
C. Of the Imputed Charges
Of the Facts
The funds and securities
- According to the documentation in the file, as of April 14, 2014, Mr. Catep had in Kallpa SAB funds totaling US$ 104,275.33 (One hundred four thousand two hundred seventy-five and 33/100 United States Dollars), which has been recognized by both parties, and which come from intermediation activities carried out by this stock brokerage firm on behalf of said principal with his authorization;
- Likewise, as of April 15, 2014, Mr. Catep owned shares that were in custody[19] in the matrix account that Kallpa SAB maintains in the Accounting Registry of CAVALI S.A. ICLV, hereinafter, CAVALI, which are detailed in Table No. 2:
Table No. 2: Securities of Mr. Catep as of 04/15/2014
| |
|---|
| Value | Quantity |
| ALT | 440,058 |
| DNT | 31,976 |
| MIRL | 185,551 |
| SIDERC1 | 59,848 |
| MOROCOI1 | 16,971 |
| POMALCC1 | 81,934 |
| PUCALAC1 | 56,983 |
| BVN | 1,869 |
| SCCO | 2,619 |
| SUE | 29,725 |
The destination of the resources
- According to what Mr. Catep stated in his complaint and as a result of preliminary inquiries, funds and securities owned by Mr. Catep would have been used by Kallpa SAB, represented by Mr. García, to carry out purchase and sale operations on the Lima Stock Exchange, hereinafter, BVL, and in the foreign market[20], on behalf of Mr. Catep, without the authorization of this principal;
- Within this framework, Kallpa SAB bought in the name of Mr. Catep RIO and FMCC shares in the foreign market between April 23 and May 16, 2014, using all the funds that Mr. Catep had as of April 21, 2014, that is, US$ 104,275.33 (One hundred four thousand two hundred seventy-five and 33/100 United States Dollars)[21];
- Such operations were supported by Kallpa SAB before this Superintendency with alleged orders attributed to Mr. Catep that would have been instructed to said stock brokerage firm by any of the following modalities: "written", "telephone", "telephone with subsequent written confirmation" and "internet", according to the copy of the client registration form of Mr. Catep dated June 14, 2013 signed by him and by representatives of Kallpa SAB, which has been submitted by both parties;
- However, in the preliminary inquiry stage, Kallpa SAB has not submitted the respective original orders instructed by Mr. Catep such as: original letters signed by said principal; telephone recording of the order; or the order entered via internet;
- Instead of such orders or the original instructions of Mr. Catep that must be collected prior to the execution of the operation, Kallpa SAB has submitted a copy of listings indicating the order number, date, instruction modality, order type, quantity, value, price, currency, market to which the order is directed, etc., which according to Kallpa SAB constitute the orders that would have been confirmed by the client with the signature of these listings, which hereinafter we will call Order Listings;
- However, Mr. Catep in his complaint states that he has not formulated any purchase or sale order (except for the purchase of SUE-RIO), nor signed any document related to the purchase or sale operations of securities during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and that the Order Listings presented by Kallpa contain forged signatures;
- Likewise, by document dated September 23, 2016, Mr. Catep states that he categorically denies, as a sworn statement, that the signatures noted in the documentation submitted by Kallpa SAB correspond to his signature and even less, that they have been made by his person or that they come from his handwriting;
- Likewise, it should be noted that Kallpa SAB has stated that the Order Listings constitute exact reproductions of the originals that they received scanned from Mr. García and that they do not have such originals, since said former representative did not deliver them;
- In view of this, by Official Letter No. 6454-2017-SMV/10.3 of October 20, 2016, Mr. García was requested to submit the original documents of the orders that Mr. Catep would have instructed between April 15 and December 31, 2014, with Mr. García stating that such documents are in the possession of the complainant;
- On the other hand, part of the securities holding owned by Mr. Catep, that is, the 59,848 SIDERC1 shares, 2,619 SCCO shares and 1,869 BVN shares, indicated in Table No. 2, would also have been destined to a purpose other than keeping them in custody in the matrix account of said brokerage firm in CAVALI; that is, Kallpa SAB sold, on behalf of Mr. Catep, these securities on the BVL and in the foreign market between June 23 and December 11, 2014, which would have been supported with alleged orders attributed by Kallpa SAB to Mr. Catep, which this principal has denied, as explained above;
Regarding SUE shares
- Mr. Catep in his complaint indicates that Kallpa SAB would have sold without his authorization 20,479 SUE-RIO shares. In this regard, as observed in Table No. 2, Mr. Catep owned as of April 15, 2014, 29,725 SUE shares. As stated in his complaint, Mr. Catep acknowledges the purchase of 15,384 SUE shares made on July 21, 2014, as detailed in Table No. 2. It should be noted that this purchase order of 15,384 SUE is part of the Order Listings that the client has denied, however, this purchase is not considered as unauthorized, according to what the complainant stated;
- As observed in Table No. 2, of these 29,725 SUE shares, 6,100 shares were sold on July 8, 2014, leaving a balance of 23,625 shares, which added to the 15,384 SUE shares purchased on July 21, 2014, give a balance of 39,009 shares. After a corporate event[22], for the holding of these 39,009 SUE shares, 20,479 RIO shares were received. Therefore, since this balance is what Mr. Catep indicates as sold without his consent, the principal is also acknowledging the sale of 6,100 SUE shares made on July 8, 2014, in addition to the purchase of 15,384 SUE made on July 21, 2014, despite the fact that in his complaint, Mr. Catep denied that he had ordered these transactions with SUE shares;
Table No. 3: Operations with SUE - RIO
| | | | |
|---|
| DATE | OPERATION | VALUE | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
| 04/15/2014 | | SUE | | 29,725 |
| 07/08/2014 | SALE | SUE | 6,100 | 23,625 |
| 07/21/2014 | PURCHASE | SUE | 15,384 | 39,009 |
| 08/13/2014 | EXCHANGE (1 SUE X 0.525 RIO) | SUE - RIO | | 20,479 |
| 08/21/2014 | SALE | RIO | 10,000 | 10,479 |
| 08/22/2014 | SALE | RIO | 10,479 | 0 |
- Consequently, the 20,479 RIO shares would have been destined to purposes other than those entrusted to Kallpa SAB, in this case the custody of these securities in the matrix account of the latter in CAVALI. That is, Kallpa SAB sold these securities on the BVL between August 21 and 22, 2014, which would have been supported with alleged orders attributed by Kallpa to Mr. Catep, which this principal has denied, as explained above;
Regarding UGAZ and JNUG shares
- Likewise, according to the information and documentation submitted by Kallpa SAB in the preliminary inquiry stage, Mr. Catep ordered by telephone the sale of 1,200 UGAZ shares and 500 JNUG shares, instructions that were executed by Kallpa SAB in operations carried out on March 3, 2015, so that by having ordered the sale of these securities, Mr. Catep would have acknowledged that he had that balance of securities. It should be noted that although these purchase and sale orders of UGAZ and JNUG are part of the Order Listings that the client has denied, the operations with these securities are not considered as unauthorized;
Table No. 4: Operations with UGAZ and JNUG securities
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| UGAZ | | | |
| 12/02/2014 | PURCHASE | 3,500 | 3,500 |
| 12/02/2014 | SALE | 2,000 | 1,500 |
| 12/04/2014 | PURCHASE | 5,000 | 6,500 |
| 12/04/2014 | SALE | 3,000 | 3,500 |
| 12/05/2014 | SALE | 2,300 | 1,200 |
| 12/11/2014 | PURCHASE | 2,000 | 3,200 |
| 12/11/2014 | SALE | 2,000 | 1,200 |
| 03/03/2015 | SALE | 1,200 | 0 |
| JNUG | | | |
| 11/12/2014 | PURCHASE | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| 11/12/2014 | SALE | 10,000 | 0 |
| 12/09/2014 | PURCHASE | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| 12/09/2014 | SALE | 5,000 | 5,000 |
| 12/23/2014 | REVERSE SPLIT 1:10 | | 500 |
| 03/03/2015 | SALE | 500 | 0 |
Summary of authorized operations
- Therefore, taking into account the operations that Mr. Catep acknowledges having instructed to Kallpa SAB but that had been classified as unauthorized by him in his initial complaint, the movement of his funds in dollars is summarized, which, as of December 11, 2014, should amount to US$ 57,547.40 (Fifty-seven thousand five hundred forty-seven and 40/100 United States Dollars); and, as a consequence of these operations that he acknowledges, the balances of his securities as of December 11, 2014 should be those indicated in Table No. 5:
Table No. 5: Securities that Mr. Catep should have had as of 12/11/2014
| Security | Quantity |
|---|
| ALT | 440,058 |
| DNT | 31,976 |
| MIRL | 185,551 |
| SIDERC1 | 59,848 |
| MOROCOI1 | 16,971 |
| POMALCC1 | 81,934 |
| PUCALAC1 | 56,983 |
| BVN | 1,869 |
| SCCO | 2,619 |
| SUE-RIO | 20,479 |
| SMC | 3,900[23] |
| UGAZ | 1,200 |
| JNUG | 500 |
Operations with other securities
- However, according to the charge imputed, the funds from the sale operations of securities owned by Mr. Catep as of April 15, 2014, which would not have been authorized by this client, and the funds from the sales of securities purchased without authorization from the principal with the balance of his funds as of April 21, 2014, would have been used for purchase and/or purchase and sale operations of other securities in the name of Mr. Catep, in the period from May 23 to December 11, 2014. These operations would also have been supported by alleged orders attributed by Kallpa SAB to Mr. Catep, which this principal has denied, as explained above;
- As a consequence of these operations that would not have been authorized by Mr. Catep through securities purchase and sale orders, the balance of his funds as of December 11, 2014 amounts to US$ 5,993.87 (Five thousand nine hundred ninety-three and 87/100 United States Dollars);
- It should be noted that the balances of funds in Soles, resulting from operations that would not have been authorized by Mr. Catep, would have been converted into Dollars to settle operations in this currency or Dollars would have been converted into Soles to settle operations, all in the name of Mr. Catep, in this latter currency. These foreign currency purchase and sale operations were also not authorized by Mr. Catep;
- Likewise, as a consequence of these operations that would not have been authorized by Mr. Catep through securities purchase and sale orders, the balance of his securities as of December 11, 2014 is as follows:
Table No. 6: Securities that Mr. Catep had as of 12/11/2014
| Security | Quantity |
|---|
| ALT | 440,058 |
| DNT | 31,976 |
| MIRL | 185,551 |
| MOROCOI1 | 16,971 |
| POMALCC1 | 81,934 |
| PUCALAC1 | 56,983 |
| FMCC | 500 |
| FNMA | 8,000 |
| LGC | 32,903 |
| UGAZ | 1,200 |
| MPLE | 120,960 |
| JNUG | 500 |
| SMC | 3,900 |
| TV | 46,066 |
Summary of operations that would not have been authorized
- Therefore, according to the imputation of charges, as a consequence of these operations that would not have been authorized by Mr. Catep through purchase and sale orders of securities registered in his name, the balance of his funds as of December 11, 2014 is lower by US$ 51,553.53 (Fifty-one thousand five hundred fifty-three and 53/100 United States Dollars), that is, a balance of only US$ 5,993.87 (Five thousand nine hundred ninety-three and 87/100 United States Dollars) remained, as indicated in Table No. 6;
Table No. 7: Funds of Mr. Catep
| |
|---|
| CONCEPT | AMOUNT (IN US$) |
| BALANCE OF FUNDS WITH AUTHORIZED OPERATIONS | 57,547.40 |
| BALANCE OF FUNDS WITH AUTHORIZED AND UNAUTHORIZED OPERATIONS | 5,993.87 |
| DIFFERENCE | 51,553.53 |
- Likewise, as a consequence of these operations that would not have been authorized by Mr. Catep through purchase and sale orders of securities registered in his name, Mr. Catep no longer holds 59,848 SIDERC1 shares, 2,619 SCCO shares, 1,869 BVN shares and 20,479 SUE-RIO shares and holds other shares that he would not have authorized to purchase: 500 FMCC, 8,000 FNMA, 32,903 LGC, 120,960 MPLE and 46,066 TV;
- In conclusion, the total amount in funds that would have been used by Kallpa SAB for purposes other than those entrusted by Mr. Catep amounts to the sum of US$ 51,553.53 (Fifty-one thousand five hundred fifty-three and 53/100 United States Dollars);
- Likewise, the securities that would have been used by Kallpa SAB for purposes other than those entrusted by Mr. Catep are 59,848 SIDERC1 shares, 2,619 SCCO shares, 1,869 BVN shares and 20,479 SUE-RIO shares;
- In relation to the above, according to the imputation of charges, Kallpa SAB would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since the funds and securities it held in custody owned by Mr. Catep as of April 21, 2014, have been used for securities purchase and sale operations that would not have been authorized by the principal, to the extent that the copies of the Order Lists have been disowned by the client and Kallpa SAB has not accredited the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds, such as the original orders instructed by Mr. Catep, which should have been obtained before carrying out the operations detailed in this official letter;
- Likewise, Kallpa SAB would have infringed the provisions of article 195, numeral a), of the LMV, by using the funds and securities owned by Mr. Catep for operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
D. On the graphotechnical expertise
- In order to expressly determine whether the signatures of Mr. Catep appearing in the Order List and in the account statements in his name for August and September 2014 issued by Kallpa SAB correspond or not to the handwriting of the aforementioned principal; based on the documentation detailed below, the SMV carried out a contracting process for a graphotechnical expert;
- Photocopies of thirteen (13) pages of lists of securities purchase and sale orders.
- Photocopies of four (4) pages of account statements for August and September 2014.
- On this matter, the Graphotechnical Expert Report dated July 2, 2018 concludes that: "From the foregoing, it cannot be established whether each of the seventeen questioned signatures, attributed to Mr. Humberto Bernando Catep Fadel, contained in the photocopies of the seventeen (17) pages of a list of securities purchase and sale orders and account statements of Annex I, correspond or not to the handwriting of the holder due to the technical issues indicated above.";
On the comments of Kallpa SAB
- Through Official Letter No. 3461-2018-SMV/10.3, Kallpa SAB was requested to provide its respective comments regarding the aforementioned Graphotechnical Report, with Kallpa SAB stating, in writing submitted on July 9, 2018, that it regrets that due to a series of technical issues the expertise cannot be conclusive;
- Likewise, Kallpa SAB states that despite such impossibility on the part of the expert to scientifically verify the authenticity of Mr. Catep's signatures, it does not invalidate the usefulness of the order lists and account statements as evidence, which must be assessed together with the other evidence presented at the time, and therefore considers that the result of the expertise does not prevent the SMV from concluding that the operations were carried out by Kallpa SAB in compliance with Mr. Catep's orders;
- Kallpa SAB invokes article 175 of the TUO LPAG according to which "the facts invoked or that are conducive to deciding a procedure may be subject to all necessary means of proof, except those prohibited by express provision"; that is, the intermediary considers that there is freedom of proof in the administrative procedure, so an expertise is not the only way to satisfactorily prove that there was consent on the part of the client, since there are other means of proof that demonstrate that Mr. Catep gave his consent;
- As additional evidence to be considered, Kallpa SAB cites the list of accesses to the Kallpa Web by Mr. Catep; telephone conversations held between Mr. Catep and Kallpa SAB officials where he acknowledges the purchase and sale of securities that he later disowns; and the identification of a series of actions by Mr. Catep in relation to operations subsequent to the questioned period and that can be interpreted as an acknowledgment of the previous operations;
- Likewise, Kallpa SAB indicates that in application of the principle of material truth contemplated in article IV of the TUO LPAG, the SMV must assess all the evidence provided by Kallpa SAB, since the mere fact that the expertise cannot be carried out due to technical issues cannot lead to the conclusion that Kallpa SAB acted without Mr. Catep's consent, as this would violate the principle of material truth in light of the evidence in the file;
Analysis
- Regarding the fact that the SMV must consider the Order List and the account statements subject to graphotechnical expertise as evidentiary elements to accredit as valid the operations questioned by Mr. Catep, it must be indicated that this is not admissible because the originals of such documents have not been presented, in addition to the fact that, taking into account what is indicated by the graphotechnical expertise, there are technical elements that prevent determining whether the signatures appearing in such documents correspond or not to Mr. Catep's handwriting;
- Likewise, it is important to highlight the importance of the evidentiary means cited in the preceding recital given that its objective is to serve as a basis to confirm Mr. Catep's will regarding the operations recorded in the Order List that he disowns in his complaint and therefore, determining in order to corroborate the veracity of the reported facts;
- Finally, regarding the fact that the other evidentiary means indicated by Kallpa SAB must be taken into consideration, it must be indicated that since the graphotechnical expertise has not been able to determine the falsity or not of the signatures appearing in the Order List, it corresponds then to analyze each of the other evidentiary means, indications, facts and other information and documentation appearing in the file in order to determine the existence or not of infractions to the regulations governing the Securities Market;
E. Determination of the destination of funds and securities
- Before proceeding to evaluate the defenses presented by Kallpa SAB, it is necessary to specify, based on the evidentiary means, indications, facts and other information and documentation appearing in the file, what is the exact amount of funds and securities used for purposes other than those entrusted; considering for this, in addition to the analysis contained in Report No. 741-2018-SMV/10.3 of the instructing body, the additional written arguments presented after the issuance of said report by Kallpa SAB during August 2018, information that analyzed together with the information initially presented in its defenses by the intermediary, has been used as a source of evaluation to make the referred precision;
- In his complaint before the SMV of June 22, 2016, Mr. Catep disowns all operations carried out between April 15 and December 31, 2014, with the exception of the purchase operation of SUE shares on July 21, 2014;
- However, through an email of March 1, 2015 at 07:52 pm addressed to Mr. Jorge Washington Rodríguez López, hereinafter Mr. Rodríguez, representative of Kallpa SAB, Mr. Catep stated the following:
"(…) I am dismayed by the stock movements carried out by Mr. García, he did what (sic) he wanted, all for commissions, from September to date, from the total portfolio of 320,000 dollars to more or less 150,000 dollars, a difference of 170 thousand dollars in less than 5 months I did not authorize sales or purchases, I trusted (sic) this gentleman too much, unfortunately I lost my Kallpa password. Well (sic) I don't know how we are going to work with you, to recover the money (…) the tremendous difference doesn't add up (sic) for me, so I beg you to instruct accounting to do an accounting audit of the stock purchase and sale movements, because I even suspect there are transfers of money to other clients of Mr. García, he had a lot of freedom to commit crimes and also buy and sell to favor other client friends of his. Mr. García proposes the following, sell the shares in this manner.
ALT 440,000 shares at 0.32
DNT 31,976 shares at 0.70
FMCC 5,000 shares at 6.00
(…)
Jorge study well each of the shares and comment on each one and whether these prices are or not outside reality, and see how we are going to work with you, please help me recover the patrimony of my whole family.
Jorge tell Mr. Alberto to withhold the commissions of Mr. García and the other one from Arequipa who goes halves with Mr. García, until some capital is recovered, please do not forget to communicate to him (…)". (underlining added)
- Complementarily to the email sent on March 1, 2015 by Mr. Catep to Mr. Rodríguez, in the conversation held between Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep, initiated on March 2, 2015 at 13:42:57 hours[24], they refer to the email sent by Mr. Catep the previous day, March 1, 2015, as shown below in the transcription of part of said conversation;
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: (…) Hello sir how are you I am Jorge Rodriguez how are you.
Mr. Catep: Ah Jorge how are you.
Mr. Rodríguez: Likewise sir, … fine fine, I just saw your email and you tell me about the problem you have and well let me comment point by point on the first email you sent me. You have previously been operating with Mr. Ricky, right?
Mr. Catep: Yes!
Mr. Rodríguez: And… from what you tell me he had total freedom to manage… eh.
Mr. Catep: That is the problem as I keep traveling…. I have practically disengaged from the whole problem.
- As observed in the transcription, Mr. Rodríguez indicates to Mr. Catep that, according to the latter's account, Mr. García had total freedom to manage the operations, to which Mr. Catep states that the problem was that he was traveling; however, he does not disown what is referred to in the text of his email of March 1, 2015;
- Likewise, in another part of the conversation Mr. Catep mentions the number of months he has been harmed by Mr. García and that this has caused losses in his securities portfolio, a period that although not precise must be indicated is not more than 4 months, that is, the principal does not mention that he has been harmed for 8 or 9 months, as is the period from April 15 to December 11, 2014, which he states in his complaint before the SMV, but rather mentions between 1 and 4 months, which is related to his statement in the email of the previous day, March 1, 2015, regarding that Mr. García has done what he wanted "from September to date". From September 1 to December 11, 2014 there is a period of 3 months and 11 days. The transcription is as follows:
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes yes it walks with gold but it is junior that is as I tell you it is the same as UGAZ those shares only serve to hold them for a time a time is a week no more not so long otherwise what is happening what has happened will happen.
Mr. Catep: yes pe (…), unfortunately this gentleman has screwed me in one month I have lost 160 thousand… in four months….three months….
- Likewise, it should be noted that this email evidences the following:
- Mr. Catep's acknowledgment of the carrying out of operations with his consent from April 15 to August 31, 2014. Thus, the questioned period of unauthorized operations would be limited from September 1 to December 11, 2014.
- The contradiction incurred by Mr. Catep is evidenced by stating in his complaint that he disowns the operations since April 15, 2014, when in the cited email of March 1, 2015 he states that he disowns them since September 2014.
- He asks about the way of working to recover the money or losses incurred, as inferred from September 2014. Although in the email he claims that Mr. García would have operated without his consent, Mr. Catep is ready to assume the current position of his investments and recover the losses, which is contradictory behavior of an investor whose funds and securities have been used for purposes other than those entrusted.
- He highlights that he has spoken with Mr. García about the losses incurred and that he has proposed a plan to recover such losses, requesting Mr. Rodríguez's opinion on the quantity and price to sell the securities that make up his portfolio proposed by Mr. García, to which Mr. Catep agrees and does not state that he did not authorize the operations that led to the new securities portfolio, with the new securities that were purchased in the period in which he supposedly did not authorize operations, but rather accepts receiving the recommendations of the new representative;
- These contradictions of Mr. Catep regarding the period in which he supposedly would not have authorized the carrying out of operations, as well as regarding whether Mr. García's action was contrary to his authorization or whether the principal gave authorization to the representative to carry out operations at the representative's discretion while the client was traveling and the acceptance to restructure the securities portfolio instead of requesting the immediate replacement of funds and securities, is added to the fact that his acts and statements after his email of March 1, 2015 do not reaffirm his position regarding that he would not have authorized the carrying out of operations either since April 15 or since September 2014 and therefore should claim the immediate replacement of his funds and securities disposed without his authorization, but rather he continues carrying out operations with the new balance of funds and securities reached as of December 31, 2014, after the operations supposedly not authorized by him and also shows knowledge of the operations with securities supposedly negotiated without his authorization and knowledge, as will be explained below;
- Regarding the valuation of Mr. Catep's securities portfolio from April to December 2014, sent by Kallpa SAB, Table No. 8 shows the respective valuation amounts at the close of each month. It should be noted that the valuation of Mr. Catep's portfolio in the analyzed period reached its highest amount in July 2014, fell slightly in August 2014 and fell drastically in September and October 2014;
Table No. 8: Valuation of Mr. Catep's portfolio
| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Month | Amount (US$) | Variation % with respect to the previous month | | | | --- | | | | | | | |
| 30-Apr-14 | 207,053.88 | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 31-May-14 | 286,351.00 | 38.30 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 30-Jun-14 | 311,845.75 | 8.90 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 31-Jul-14 | 321,995.95 | 3.25 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 31-Aug-14 | 313,199.05 | -2.73 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 30-Sep-14 | 226,298.35 | -27.75 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 31-Oct-14 | 160,857.73 | -28.92 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 30-Nov-14 | 163,840.10 | 1.85 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 11-Dec-14 | 155,659.84 | -4.99 | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 31-Dec-14 | 133,068.04 | -18.78 | | | | | | | | | | | |
Source: Account statements of Mr. Catep issued by Kallpa SAB.
- As observed in the text of the email, Mr. Catep disowns operations since September 2014, the period from which his portfolio precisely begins to depreciate. Likewise, the principal acknowledges that he had a securities portfolio valued at US$ 320,000.00 (Three hundred twenty thousand United States Dollars) and that it has decreased to more or less US$ 150,000.00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) in less than 5 months;
- It should be noted that since the valuation of Mr. Catep's investment portfolio reached approximately US$ 320,000.00 (Three hundred twenty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), which is the maximum level reached by the valuation of said portfolio, occurred at the close of July 2014, until the last operation carried out by Kallpa SAB on behalf of Mr. Catep with the intervention of Mr. García, that is, December 11, 2014[25], there is a period of 4 months and 11 days, close to the 5 months indicated by Mr. Catep in his email of March 1, 2015, which elapsed since the valuation of his portfolio decreased from approximately US$ 320,000.00 (Three hundred twenty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars);
- Likewise, as of December 11, 2014, the valuation of Mr. Catep's securities portfolio amounts to US$ 155,659.84 (One hundred fifty-five thousand six hundred fifty-nine and 84/100 United States Dollars), which would be the "more or less 150,000 dollars" that Mr. Catep states in his email of March 1, 2015;
- Therefore, it is evidenced in the email of March 1, 2015 that Mr. Catep acknowledges that at least until the close of August 2014 he has carried out operations and that since September 2014 ("from September to date") he would not have authorized the operations executed by Kallpa SAB, which is also consistent with the acknowledgment he makes of the valuation of his securities portfolio that reached approximately 320 thousand dollars in July 2014 and that decreased drastically in less than 5 months until December 11, 2014 to an amount of "more or less 150,000 dollars";
- Likewise, other facts are mentioned below that indicate that Mr. Catep explicitly or implicitly acknowledges operations carried out until August 31, 2014 and that complement what is stated in his email of March 1, 2015, in which he implicitly acknowledges operations until August 31, 2014, and that contradicts his complaint before the SMV in which he disowns operations carried out from April 15 to December 11, 2014, with the exception of one (01) purchase operation of SUE shares carried out on July 21, 2014;
He expressly acknowledges purchases of SIDERC1 shares
- Below is transcribed part of the conversation initiated on March 24, 2015 at 12:23:48 hours between Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep:
(…)
Mr. Catep: Hey Jorge, look, I'm reviewing right now but I don't have the Sider sales policies.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, okay, the Sider policies are fine... but look at the email I sent you, there's an email that says Sider, in that one everything comes out and all the operations are detailed, look there.
Mr. Catep: No, no, I don't have the latest Sider ones, the sale ones.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, look at the email I sent you please, it's there.
Mr. Catep: But I'm reviewing here, Jorge isn't here! I need those because I have a hearing.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay sir... sir, have you seen the document I sent you about Sider?
Mr. Catep: Yes, I've seen it.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay, have you seen you sold 68,102?
Mr. Catep: Jorge, listen, I had 59,900 Sider shares... I have the sale here already.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay.
Mr. Catep: I bought again, sixty...
Mr. Rodríguez: You bought 35,402 and 32,700.
(…)
- As observed in the transcriptions, Mr. Catep indicates that he had 59,900[26] SIDERC1; in his complaint before the SMV he has disavowed the sale of these securities made on June 23, 2014 and other subsequent operations with these securities; however, in the cited conversation, referring to the SIDERC1 shares, he mentions "I bought again", with which the client expressly acknowledges that he bought these SIDERC1 securities again, which occurred on August 5 and 6, 2014, that is, within the period he claims not to have made operations[27], according to his complaint before the SMV;
He implicitly acknowledges operations with SUE shares
- Mr. Catep only acknowledges in his complaint the purchase of 15,384 SUE shares made on July 21, 2014 and indicates that Kallpa SAB would have sold without his authorization 20,479 SUE-RIO shares;
- In this regard, Mr. Catep held as of April 14, 2014, 29,725 SUE shares. Then, 6,100 shares were sold on July 8, 2014, leaving a balance of 23,625 shares, which added to the 15,384 SUE shares purchased on July 21, 2014, give a balance of 39,009 shares. After a corporate event[28], for holding these 39,009 SUE shares the client received 20,479 RIO shares;
- Therefore, because this balance of 20,479 SUE shares is the one that Mr. Catep points out as sold without his consent in the complaint before the SMV, the client by acknowledging this balance as his own is also implicitly acknowledging the sale of 6,100 SUE shares made on July 8, 2014, that is, within the period he claims not to have made operations[29], according to his complaint before the SMV;
- It is important to highlight the contradictions incurred by Mr. Catep in the facts reported before the SMV since he has denied having ordered the execution of operations during the questioned period with the exception of one (01) operation with SUE shares of July 21, 2014; however, and as analyzed above, facts have been found indicating that he made other operations in the questioned period, at least until August 31, 2014;
- Therefore, taking into account that in the email of March 1, 2015 Mr. Catep implicitly accepts having authorized the operations carried out by Kallpa SAB on his behalf until August 31, 2014, the proof of said email becomes fundamental to determine the controverted period regarding the reported facts, so the period between September 1 and December 11, 2014 is considered "controverted", for which the evidence and circumstantial evidence supporting the will or not of the cited client for the execution of operations in the period determined as "controverted" will be analyzed;
Use of the new balance of funds and securities
- Taking into account the operations carried out by Kallpa SAB on behalf of Mr. Catep between April 15 and December 31, 2014, the balance of funds available in favor of the client was US$ 6,385.87. Likewise, the shares that made up the client's investment portfolio as of December 31, 2014 are indicated in Table No. 6, among which are the UGAZ and JNUG shares, which were purchased in December 2014, that is, during the period in which Mr. Catep supposedly did not authorize operations, according to his complaint from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and according to the email of March 1, 2015 sent by him to Mr. García from September to December 2014;
- With knowledge of that portfolio of shares reached with supposedly unauthorized operations by Mr. Catep, this client in March 2015, following Mr. Rodriguez's recommendations that they were bad investments, ordered the representative to sell the UGAZ and JNUG shares that were in his share portfolio, as recorded in the recording of the orders instructed by telephone on March 3, 2015, which is in the file. Transcription of part of the conversation is indicated below:
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: Well sir, let me inform you JNUG is falling 4% down, it's at 26.79.
Mr. Catep: Damn, you should have just sold it.
Mr. Rodríguez: But sir, I'm telling you yesterday and you tell me you don't want to... what can I do.
Mr. Catep: Yeah but in the morning I already decided to sell it
(….)
Mr. Catep: In the morning I had already decided to sell, it's just that the thing is to grab a little bit there and sell it.
(….)
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay sir, let's sell both papers at once and because those papers are going to keep falling as I told you, they're going to keep falling.
Mr. Catep: Okay then, I give you the decision.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay okay but I still like to inform you what we're going to do with your papers, okay? So you know, you know well, okay?.
Mr. Catep: Okay.
Mr. Rodríguez: ok.
Mr. Catep: How much is UGAZ?
Mr. Rodríguez: UGAZ is at 2.63, at that price I just sold right now, UGAZ went up a little.
Mr. Catep: Did you sell?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes, I sold
Mr. Catep: See, in the morning it was just to decide, I told you.
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: (…) JNUG is a leveraged one, it's a juniors mining market, for that reason I'm telling you let's sell since yesterday (…)
Mr. Catep: That's why in the morning I had already decided... just sell it!
Mr. Rodríguez: That's why sir, I'm going to sell it right now, okay?
500 are already sold at 26.75.
Mr. Catep: Okay then.
- The sell orders for these shares were executed in operations carried out on March 3, 2015, as observed in Table No. 9;
Table No. 9: Operations and movement of funds of Mr. Catep in March 2015
| OP. DATE | SETTLE. DATE | OPER. TYPE | SECURITY | QTY. | PRICE | DEBIT / CREDIT | BALANCE |
|---|
| 12/31/14 | | | | | | | 6,385.87 |
| 01/31/15 | | | | | | | 6,385.87 |
| 03/02/15 | | | | | | | 6,385.87 |
| 03/03/15 | 03/06/15 | SALE | UGAZ | 1,200 | 2.6300 | 3,119.80 | 9,505.67 |
| 03/03/15 | 03/06/15 | SALE | JNUG | 500 | 26.7501 | 13,267.46 | 22,773.13 |
| 03/09/15 | 03/12/15 | PURCHASE | BVN | 1,047 | 10.1799 | -10,750.58 | 12,022.55 |
| 03/23/15 | 03/26/15 | SALE | BVN | 1,047 | 10.9900 | 11,407.81 | 23,430.36 |
| 03/30/15 | 04/02/15 | PURCHASE | BVN | 2,343 | 9.9000 | -23,397.04 | 33.32 |
| 04/10/15 | 04/15/15 | SALE | BVN | 2,343 | 10.8000 | 25,086.88 | 25,120.20 |
- Therefore, after the execution of operations carried out between April 15 and December 31, 2014, Mr. Catep gave conformity to the available balance of UGAZ and JNUG securities as of December 31, 2014 reached as a result of operations supposedly not authorized by him and, as we will see next, used the proceeds of these sales to make new investments in securities, which is not a behavior consistent with what was stated in his email of March 1, 2015 regarding that he did not authorize operations since September 2014, so he should not agree with the balance of his securities as of December 31, 2014, specifically UGAZ and JNUG;
- Subsequently, on March 9, 2015 Mr. Catep orders the purchase of BVN securities for more than US$ 10,000.00, necessarily using the money from the sales of UGAZ or JNUG securities, which he states he did not authorize to purchase in 2014, considering that he knew that his new balance of funds as of December 31, 2014 amounted only to US$ 6,385.87, as well as he was aware of his new balance of securities with UGAZ and JNUG. Then, on March 23, 2015 he orders the sale of these BVN securities. These purchase and sale orders were instructed by telephone[30] and were executed in operations carried out on March 9 and 23, 2015, as observed in Table No. 9;
- After the operations carried out from March 3 to 23, 2015, the balance of funds in favor of Mr. Catep that as of March 2, 2015 amounted to US$ 6,385.87[31] increased to US$ 23,430.36 as of March 26, 2015, date of settlement of the operation of March 23, 2015;
- In this context, on March 30, 2015 at 8:27:17[32] hours the mentioned gentlemen begin a conversation, part of which is transcribed below:
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, gold is falling a little right now, the market opens in a few minutes... if Buenaventura reaches 10 round we buy something, last time we bought at 10.30 more or less, now I tell you let's buy at least... we have 23,000 let's buy 10,000 dollars or 15,000 dollars if it reaches 10, I don't know, what do you think?
Mr. Catep: At what price has it opened?
Mr. Rodríguez: The market hasn't opened yet but that's why I tell you if it opens, I mean... I can't be watching the paper second by second but I do believe that if it reaches that level we have to start participating.
Mr. Catep: Wait wait, what time is it, it's 8:30, right? Can you call me in 15 minutes?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay sir, it's just that this is immediate, last time it bounced just the same and in a second the change was in 5 minutes.
Mr. Catep: In 5 minutes.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay, I'll call you in 5, okay sir
- Then, as agreed, Mr. Rodríguez makes another telephone call to Mr. Catep which begins on March 30, 2015 at 08:35:23 hours[33], part of which is transcribed below:
Mr. Rodríguez: Mr. Catep, it's Jorge, do we buy something sir?.
Mr. Catep: Okay look, I've checked... they told me to buy at 9.90 everything.
Mr. Rodríguez: Everything? okay, I'm going to place an order for everything at 9.90 to see if it goes through.
Mr. Catep: Okay and another thing I wanted to ask you.
Mr. Rodríguez: Tell me.
Mr. Catep: Find out about RIO, because there's going to be... there's been a merger of RIO, right? Does that RIO disappear or has it bought another company and they're going to make another company, how is it?.
Mr. Rodríguez: I'll explain what has happened, first I'm placing the order 2,343 at 9.9 all the money there is, the 23,400 hopefully we buy (…).
(Our highlight)
- As observed in the transcriptions of part of the conversations held by Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep on March 30, 2015, Mr. Rodriguez in the first call mentions to Mr. Catep that there are US$ 23,000.00[34] of available money in the client's current account at Kallpa SAB and he does not disavow this amount, which is not consistent with what was stated in his email of March 1, 2015 regarding that he did not authorize Mr. García to carry out operations since September 2014 and therefore should not agree with the new balance of funds as of December 31, 2014. Then, in the second call Mr. Catep orders to buy at the price of US$ 9.90 "everything". Given this, Mr. Rodríguez tells him that he is placing the order for 2,343 securities at US$ 9.90, all the money there is, the US$ 23,400[35]; as observed, again Mr. Rodríguez mentions to him the amount of money available in the client's current account at the brokerage firm and Mr. Catep does not disavow this and his purchase order for BVN securities was entered that way;
- The order was executed on March 30, 2015, with the purchase operation of 2,343 BVN at the price of US$ 9.90, settling the operation with a total amount of US$ 23,397.04, as observed in Table No. 9.
- Consequently, at the time of giving the purchase order for BVN securities on March 30, 2015, Mr. Catep accepted that the available balance of funds in his client current account was US$ 23,430.36, an amount that included the available balance of funds as of December 31, 2014 after all operations carried out between April 15 and December 31, 2014 and after the operations carried out between March 3 and 23, 2015;
- Therefore, after the execution of operations carried out between April 15 and December 31, 2014, Mr. Catep gave conformity to the available balance of his client current account reached as a result of the credits and debits of funds from the settlement of those operations carried out, supposedly not authorized by him and, likewise, used that available balance to make new investments in securities, which is not a behavior consistent with what was stated in his email of March 1, 2015 regarding that he did not authorize operations since September 2014 so he should not agree with the balance of his funds as of December 31, 2014;
- The balance of the client's funds after the last operation that he acknowledges in his complaint amounts to US$ 104,275.33 (One hundred four thousand two hundred seventy-five and 33/100 United States Dollars); from this amount is deducted the amount of US$ 20,171.69 (Twenty thousand one hundred seventy-one and 69/100 United States Dollars) for the purchase of 15,384 SUE shares of July 21, 2014, which the client acknowledges in his complaint, leaving an amount of US$ 84,103.64 (Eighty-four thousand one hundred three and 64/100 United States Dollars);
- Said amount, plus the balance of some securities of the client as of April 14, 2014, were used in successive purchase and sale operations of securities, both in soles and dollars, indicated in Annexes 1 and 2 of this resolution, and reached the amount of US$ 5,993.87 as of December 11, 2014, which as a result of the delivery of dividends corresponding to the JNUG security for US$ 392.00, the balance as of December 31, 2014 amounted to US$ 6,385.87 (Six thousand three hundred eighty-five and 87/100 United States Dollars) in the client's current account, plus the holding of shares detailed in Table No. 6 of this resolution;
- This amount of US$ 6,385.87 (Six thousand three hundred eighty-five and 87/100 United States Dollars) increased to US$ 23,430.36 (Twenty-three thousand four hundred thirty and 36/100 United States Dollars) in March 2015, as a result of the operations authorized by Mr. Catep, so by accepting on March 30, 2015 that this amount be used for the purchase of BVN securities, according to what was explained above, the client gave conformity to that balance of US$ 6,385.87 (Six thousand three hundred eighty-five and 87/100 United States Dollars) and therefore to all operations carried out between April 15 and December 31, 2014, which in the complaint he has disavowed;
Knowledge of operations with some securities
- However, the facts described in this evaluation indicate that Mr. Catep on March 30, 2015 gave conformity to the balance of his funds as of December 31, 2014 amounting to US$ 6,385.87 (Six thousand three hundred eighty-five and 87/100 United States Dollars) and to his holding of securities as of December 31, 2014 that includes the UGAZ and JNUG securities, by using these funds and securities in new operations, below are described other facts that also indicate that Mr. Catep in March 2015 gave conformity to some operations carried out during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, in addition to those of UGAZ and JNUG already mentioned, which appear in his current account statement and which in his complaint he has disavowed;
- Indeed, in the conversation held between Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep, initiated on March 2, 2015 at 13:42:57 hours[36], aspects of the operations carried out between April 15 and December 31, 2014 are discussed, as observed below in the transcription of part of said conversation:
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: (…) I would like if possible to talk right now extensively to see what recommendations I can give you based on the papers you have.
(…)
Mr. Catep: Yes! yes! tell me.
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: (…) For those UGAZ papers, it's a paper that only serves for trading, it doesn't serve to hold long term so you have 1,200 shares and right now the ticket is worth 2 dollars and that ticket over time will go to zero.
Mr. Catep: Damn...
Mr. Rodríguez: That's why that ticket is not to have it there in the portfolio, trevali yes, trevali yes is a paper yes I think it's a paper that should be held there, no problem.
Mr. Catep: Of course trevali yes... more or less I knew something about trevali but UGAZ... What is UGAZ?
Mr. Rodríguez: UGAZ is a leveraged gas ticket, I mean those tickets only serve for people to buy and sell during a day, two days, a week but not to hold long term, it doesn't serve for that.
Mr. Catep: Wow!... Unfortunately, this gentleman, damn, I don't know but you guys were buying for a while, I saw you were buying UGAZ UGAZ UGAZ.
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes but it's for the day only, I mean not to keep the paper! Mmm I mean it doesn't serve to keep the paper to be honest with you
Mr. Catep: How much is it right now?
Mr. Rodríguez: It's at 2 dollars 70 (2.70)
Mr. Catep: At what price did you buy, do you know more or less-- can you see there?.
Mr. Rodríguez: I see here that the last ticket you bought was at 8 almost 9.
Mr. Catep: Asuu machu
(…)
And how many shares do we have there please?.
Mr. Rodríguez: That's why 1,200, you have 1,200.
Mr. Catep: Mmm I mean like 10,000 dollars.
Mr. Rodríguez: Mmm no now they're worth 2 dollars 60 (2.60) only, 1,200 by 2.60 isn't much, it gives 3,100 dollars, isn't much.
Mr. Catep: Okay then, what else, let's see what else has closed more or less.
Mr. Rodríguez: Mmm Maple... mmm I don't know how you have so many Maple... Maple already went bankrupt.
Mr. Catep: Maple no?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes it went bankrupt yes.
Mr. Catep: And now?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Zero.
Mr. Catep: What?!.
Mr. Rodríguez: It's zero.
Mr. Catep: Zero?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Zero... the company has gone bankrupt.
Mr. Catep: And it doesn't have uh... haven't they liquidated it?... it doesn't have something... it doesn't trade anymore... right?.
Mr. Rodríguez: No it doesn't trade anymore.
Mr. Catep: And now it's a loss?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes the company... I mean not even selling all the assets it has will be able to pay the debt it has with the banks.
Mr. Catep: Daaamn.
(….)
Mr. Rodríguez: Then Minera IRL is in a complicated situation but I think nothing serious, I mean yes it's serious but I don't think it will go bankrupt, I think we just have to wait there and even more if possible we should buy more because the company is well punished, something similar happens with Luna Gold.
Mr. Catep: Okay...
Mr. Rodríguez: With Luna Gold too, then JNUG is another similar to gas, I would also say sell it right away.
Mr. Catep: Which which?
Mr. Rodríguez: JNUG is from junior miners but it's also leveraged, it's not a formal company.
Mr. Catep: Junior miners... which one is it?
Mr. Rodríguez: JNUG.
Mr. Catep: Ah JNUG.
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes.
Mr. Catep: Is it Peruvian or foreign?.
Mr. Rodriguez: Foreign too.
Mr. Catep: Okay okay.
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes to be honest with you, of the papers you have I would sell to make cash, I sell UGAZ, I sell the SMC you have 3,900, I sell JNUG and that would be it and make cash and see how we reconfigure everything because those papers really I don't see them turning around, I don't see them doing anything interesting.
Mr. Catep: But if we sell I won't even have 5 thousand dollars I think.
Mr. Rodríguez: Mmm no... I think yes! in JNUG you have there like 14 more or less, then in UGAZ it will be 3,000, we would have 17 more or less and then well the SMC which are like 500 dollars more... 17 thousand dollars more or less... I mean yes something can be done.
Mr. Catep: Okay okay and how much do we have in that J one you tell me?
Mr. Rodríguez: In JNUG we have like 14 thousand dollars.
Mr. Catep: Okay and how much was invested?
Mr. Rodríguez: You have 500 bought at 36 and the share right now is at 28 but if we don't take them out that yes can go to 20 and 15 like that...
Mr. Catep: Don't you think it will rebound? Does that walk with gold or outside gold?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes yes it walks with gold but it's junior, I mean it's like I tell you it's the same as UGAZ, those shares only serve to hold them for a while, a while is a week no more, not so long otherwise what is happening will happen, what has happened.
Mr. Catep: yes pe (…), unfortunately this gentleman has screwed me, in a month I've lost 160 thousand... in four months... three months...
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes... unfortunately he has made a decision, some really radical decisions, they seem very strong to me.
Mr. Catep: Tamare... What would we do right now?
Mr. Rodríguez: We have to sell and with the money we make start restructuring the portfolio little by little.
Mr. Catep: Mmm what would we buy, say... you would handle it now?!
Mr. Rodríguez: In dollars I would call you to make a purchase, one thing I would like to buy not only today but maybe tomorrow or the following days Petrobras, Brazilian oil company, which is a huge company that is coming out right now at 6 dollars
Mr. Catep: That one is also bad.
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: Oil is in a bad way but that's why it's the moment when you have to buy when things are bad.
Mr. Catep: But precisely that gentleman said it's bad let's buy! and boom
Mr. Rodríguez: But look at the papers you've bought, they're not companies, they're artificial creations, that's the difference!
Mr. Catep: Mmm.
Mr. Rodríguez: If you had, I don't know, bought in a mining company I would have said okay.
Mr. Catep: Okay okay what else... what other paper is there?
Mr. Rodríguez: I mean right now since Petrobras has fallen it seems to me it's at an attractive price, another paper that I would like if it falls I buy... is Buenaventura
Mr. Catep: Ahh I had Buenaventura and this one has sold it...!!
Mr. Rodríguez: no but we don't have it anymore.
Mr. Catep: He screwed me... Buenaventura of course... imagine that we bought Buenaventura at 55.
Mr. Rodríguez: yes of course... asu machu.
Mr. Catep: mmm?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes of course it's right now at 11 and something.
Mr. Catep: But I think that can rebound.
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes yes I mean we're going to buy Buenaventura again anyway! ....... if not look let's do the following we can make the sale and not buy anything and we'll see little by little calmly because there's no rush in seeing how we restructure little by little.
Mr. Catep: Of course, but I think the problem is what do I do!
Mr. Rodríguez: But we already do that, we sell the 3 securities we mentioned, which are SMC, UGAZ, and JNUG, and we leave the money there and we see little by little, and every day I call him and tell him, sir, look, this has happened, do you like it?... yes... ok... I don't like it... we see another option, it's the best because, I mean, here at least I can't desperately say buy or not, we go little by little, there's really no hurry.
Mr. Catep: Tell me, in the 3, how much have we invested?
Mr. Rodríguez: ehhhh... let's see, 10 and... about 28 more or less.
Mr. Catep: 28... so about 28 more or less.
Mr. Rodríguez: yes
(…)
- Then, Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep start a conversation on March 3, 2015, at 10:08:49 hours[37] and the first informs the second of the prices of the securities that make up the client's portfolio, as shown below in the transcription of part of said conversation:
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: Well, here we are going to see how the market is today with the securities we talked about yesterday, let's see first UGAZ ehhh it's the same as yesterday 2.60 it hasn't gone up, it's stable, and JNUG is rising slightly, it's at 28.40.
Mr. Catep: Okay...
Mr. Rodríguez: There isn't much variation to speak of, right?... today is a very calm day... then Trevali keeps recovering, it's already at 94 cents.
Mr. Catep: okay..
Mr. Rodríguez: Then MIRL keeps rising, little by little, 6 and a half.
Mr. Catep: okay..
Mr. Rodríguez: Ehh Luna Gold also went up a little... Freddie Fannie stable.
Mr. Catep: okay..
Mr. Rodríguez: yes, not much news there.
Mr. Catep: Okay, well, keep going... more or less... and if it goes up a little more, sell it, because today the 2 you tell me, UGAZ and..
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay.
Mr. Catep: Or what do you think? Shall we wait?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Look, let's do the following, if it seems good to you, we wait... I'll call you after midday to inform you how they're doing, to see if there's any news, does that seem okay?.
Mr. Catep: Okay, that's fine.
(…)
- Therefore, taking into account that in the email of March 1, 2015, Mr. Catep implicitly acknowledges having authorized the operations carried out by Kallpa SAB on his behalf until August 31, 2014, as well as the conversation held on March 2, 2015, among other facts that will be shown later, a contradictory behavior of Mr. Catep is evidenced with respect to what was stated in his complaint before this Superintendency;
- The aforementioned in the preceding recital is also supported by the fact that in his complaint, Mr. Catep himself acknowledged that in February 2015 he became aware of the situation of his securities and funds portfolio, that is, by March 1, 2015, Mr. Catep should have known when the alleged unauthorized purchase and sale of securities by him occurred;
- Next, the securities operations that Mr. Catep has acknowledged are evaluated:
UGAZ AND JNUG
- As observed in the transcriptions, Mr. Catep shows conformity regarding his holding of UGAZ and JNUG shares, even asking Mr. Rodríguez how much he invested in these shares, at what prices he invested, and how much balance he has; likewise, he asks questions regarding what type of securities they are and the possibilities regarding the recovery of the JNUG price;
- As observed in Table No. 10, Mr. Catep did not have a balance of UGAZ and JNUG as of April 14, 2014, and the first operations with these securities were carried out during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and as of December 31, 2014, and even until March 2, 2015, he still had a balance of these shares;
- Consequently, with that knowledge of his holding of UGAZ and JNUG shares as of December 31, 2014, and March 2, 2015, as observed in the transcriptions, Mr. Catep ordered on March 3, 2015, by telephone, the sale of 1,200 UGAZ shares and 500 JNUG shares, instructions that were executed by Kallpa SAB in operations carried out on March 3, 2015, which shows that Mr. Catep acknowledges that he had this balance of securities and therefore orders their sale; thus, he acknowledges the purchase and sale operations of UGAZ shares, carried out from December 2 to 5, 2014, and the purchase and sale operations of JNUG shares, carried out on December 9, 2014, which in his complaint he has disavowed. The detail is shown in Table No. 8;
Table No. 10: Operations with UGAZ and JNUG
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| UGAZ | | | |
| 04/15/2014 | | | 0 |
| 12/02/2014 | PURCHASE | 3,500 | 3,500 |
| 12/02/2014 | SALE | 2,000 | 1,500 |
| 12/04/2014 | PURCHASE | 5,000 | 6,500 |
| 12/04/2014 | SALE | 3,000 | 3,500 |
| 12/05/2014 | SALE | 2,300 | 1,200 |
| 12/11/2014 | PURCHASE | 2,000 | 3,200 |
| 12/11/2014 | SALE | 2,000 | 1,200 |
| 03/03/2015 | SALE | 1,200 | 0 |
| JNUG | | | |
| 04/15/2014 | | | 0 |
| 11/12/2014 | PURCHASE | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| 11/12/2014 | SALE | 10,000 | 0 |
| 12/09/2014 | PURCHASE | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| 12/09/2014 | SALE | 5,000 | 5,000 |
| 12/23/2014 | REVERSE SPLIT 1:10 | | 500 |
| 03/03/2015 | SALE | 500 | 0 |
- It should be noted that by selling all his holdings in UGAZ and JNUG securities on March 3, 2015, Mr. Catep acknowledges operations carried out with such securities and therefore contradicts what was stated in his complaint by disavowing all operations with these securities carried out between April and December 2014;
FMCC and FNMA
- As observed in Table No. 11, Mr. Catep did not have a balance of FMCC and FNMA as of April 14, 2014, and carried out purchase and sale operations during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and as of December 31, 2014, he still had a balance of these shares;
Table No. 11: Operations with FMCC and FNM
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| FMCC | | | |
| 12/31/2013 | | | 18,921 |
| 4/14/14 | | | 0 |
| 5/13/14 | PURCHASE | 15,000 | 15,000 |
| 5/15/14 | PURCHASE | 1,000 | 16,000 |
| 5/16/14 | PURCHASE | 2,700 | 18,700 |
| 5/23/14 | SALE | 2,200 | 16,500 |
| 6/13/14 | PURCHASE | 1,100 | 17,600 |
| 6/23/14 | PURCHASE | 2,000 | 19,600 |
| 7/16/14 | SALE | 600 | 19,000 |
| 7/17/14 | SALE | 200 | 18,800 |
| 7/18/14 | SALE | 1,200 | 17,600 |
| 7/21/14 | SALE | 600 | 17,000 |
| 9/3/14 | PURCHASE | 5,000 | 22,000 |
| 10/23/14 | SALE | 5,000 | 17,000 |
| 10/28/14 | SALE | 2,000 | 15,000 |
| 12/3/14 | SALE | 5,000 | 10,000 |
| 12/11/14 | SALE | 5,000 | 5,000 |
| FNMA | | | |
| 12/31/2013 | | | 10,130 |
| 4/14/14 | | | 0 |
| 6/18/14 | PURCHASE | 500 | 500 |
| 6/23/14 | PURCHASE | 3,000 | 3,500 |
| 6/24/14 | PURCHASE | 700 | 4,200 |
| 7/16/14 | SALE | 1,400 | 2,800 |
| 7/17/14 | SALE | 800 | 2,000 |
| 7/18/14 | SALE | 800 | 1,200 |
| 7/21/14 | PURCHASE | 1,000 | 2,200 |
| 7/21/14 | SALE | 800 | 1,400 |
| 10/23/14 | SALE | 1,400 | - |
| 11/21/14 | PURCHASE | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| 12/3/14 | SALE | 2,000 | 8,000 |
| 12/31/14 | | | 8,000 |
| 03/21/15 | | | 8,000 |
- By email of March 22, 2015, addressed to Mr. Rodríguez, Mr. Catep requests other policy documents for operations with FMCC and FNMA in order to "square the balances"; however, he mentions the number of the policies he has received, which correspond to all the purchase and sale operations of FMCC and FNMA indicated in Table No. 11, and requests that it be reviewed so that it squares, and also states that in his portfolio he has 5,000 FMCC shares and 8,000 FNMA shares, that is, he acknowledges the balances he has as of December 31, 2014, and even until March 21, 2015;
- Therefore, on March 22, 2015, Mr. Catep acknowledges all the purchase and sale operations carried out with FMCC and FNMA, despite this, he does not acknowledge them in his subsequent complaint;
- Likewise, in the conversation initiated between Mr. Rodríguez and Mr. Catep on March 24, 2015, at 11:41:36 hours[38], they refer to the balances of FMCC and FNMA shares and operations with these securities, as observed in the transcription of part of the conversation:
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: "Look sir, I am now looking at the close of 2013, December 2013, and I see in your folder that you have 18,921 Freddie and 10,130 Fannie"
Mr. Catep: "Okay, from that, in April, March, or June, everything was sold and repurchased again and it went to zero."
Mr. Rodríguez: "Ehh but are you sure of that data?"
Mr. Catep: "Yes, yes, I sold everything"
Mr. Rodríguez: "It's just that"
Mr. Catep: "It was repurchased again, all that has to be squared"
(…)
Highlight added
- In the transcription, it is observed that Mr. Catep acknowledges that between March, April, or June 2014, all his balance of FMCC and FNMA securities was sold, and as observed in Table No. 11, indeed the balance of these securities as of December 31, 2013, was sold and went to zero in both securities as of April 14, 2014. However, Mr. Catep also acknowledges that those shares were repurchased again, thereby acknowledging the purchase operations of said securities carried out after the balance went to zero, after April 14, 2014, that is, the period he disavows having authorized operations;
- Finally, Mr. Catep in the conversation also states that after repurchasing again, it went to zero, which coincides with the operations carried out with FNMA until October 23, 2014, when it went to zero again, as observed in Table No. 11. Regarding these securities, it went to zero as of April 14, 2014, repurchased again, and then sold, going to zero again on October 23, 2014. However, subsequently, a purchase and a sale operation were carried out, leaving a balance of 8,000 FNMA as of December 31, 2014;
- Therefore, in addition to acknowledging by email all the operations carried out with FMCC and FNMA in the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, by requesting the policies for all operations, Mr. Catep also acknowledges in a conversation held with Mr. Rodríguez that he repurchased both securities again in the mentioned period, so he at least acknowledges the purchase operations of those securities carried out in this period, detailed in Table No. 11. Likewise, Mr. Catep acknowledges that he sold what was repurchased and that it went to zero again, which occurred regarding the FNMA security in October 2014 as observed in Table No. 11;
- In conclusion, although in the conversations Mr. Catep states that he does not precisely remember all the operations carried out with FMCC and FNMA, which is also manifested in the email of March 22, 2015, by which he requests Mr. Rodríguez to "square the balances," it is evident that Mr. Catep acknowledges operations that were carried out with said securities in the period that in his complaint he disavows having carried out operations, which also constitutes a contradiction with respect to what was later stated in his complaint;
TV and LGC
- As observed in the transcriptions, on March 2, 2015, Mr. Catep shows conformity regarding his holding of TV[39] and LGC[40] shares that Mr. Rodríguez informs him of, even the next day Mr. Rodríguez informs him of the price behavior of these securities;
- As observed in Table No. 12, Mr. Catep did not have a balance of TV and LGC as of April 14, 2014, and the first operations with these securities were carried out during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and as of December 31, 2014, and even until March 2, 2015, he still had a balance of these shares;
Table No. 12: Operations with TV and LGC
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
| TV | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 08/22/2014 | PURCHASE | 36,315 | 36,315 |
| 08/27/2014 | SALE | 36,315 | 0 |
| 08/29/2014 | PURCHASE | 30,066 | 30,066 |
| 09/18/2014 | PURCHASE | 16,000 | 46,066 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 46,066 |
| 03/02/2015 | | | 46,066 |
| LGC | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 07/09/2014 | PURCHASE | 29,824 | 29,824 |
| 07/11/2014 | SALE | 29,824 | 0 |
| 08/14/2014 | PURCHASE | 12,903 | 12,903 |
| 08/22/2014 | PURCHASE | 20,000 | 32,903 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 32,903 |
| 03/02/2015 | | | 32,903 |
- This conformity of Mr. Catep with the holding of TV and LGC shares evidences that he acknowledges at least the purchase and sale operations of TV shares of August 29 and September 18, 2014, respectively; as well as, at least, the purchase operations of LGC shares, carried out on August 14 and 22, 2014; which he has disavowed in his complaint. The detail is shown in Table No. 12. Likewise, Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep hold a conversation that starts on March 24, 2015, at 12:23:48 hours[41], part of which is transcribed below:
(…)
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay then, you're missing the sale of Sider, right?
Mr. Catep: Okay, I'm missing that one and Luna Gold too, I think I'm missing 8,500...
Mr. Rodríguez: Luna Gold too, I've sent you the file, let's see right now and you tell me what you're missing for Luna Gold.
Mr. Catep: 8,900, please check that.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sale... you bought 29,824 in July 2014 and sold 2 days later.
Mr. Catep: Wait, wait... July... okay, July 14 purchase... okay
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes, and you sold them 2 days later.
Mr. Catep: Where is the sale then?
Mr. Rodríguez: Well, that sale you don't have in the policy, he tells me.
Mr. Catep: No, I don't have it.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay, I'm putting it here to take it out (…) okay
Mr. Catep: okay...
Mr. Rodríguez: What else are you missing?
Mr. Catep: I've figured out that 8,900 in sales are missing here
Mr. Rodríguez: From which security?
Mr. Catep: From Luna Gold, of course.
Mr. Rodríguez: No sir, Luna Gold, it's only that sale, you haven't sold more because you bought 12,903... 12,903 and then bought 20,000 more, those are 32,903... let's see how much you have in your portfolio... and you have that amount in your portfolio, there are no more operations, you've only made one sale, you haven't made more sales of Luna Gold.
Mr. Catep: Okay, purchase, purchase, but I don't have a single sale here, not a single sale.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay sir, that's why I tell you that for that sale we're going to get the policy, don't worry (…)
(…)
- As observed in the transcription, Mr. Catep acknowledges the operations carried out with LGC that Mr. Rodríguez points out to him, and only states that he is missing the policy for the sale operation of these shares;
- Therefore, it is evidenced that on March 24, 2015, Mr. Catep acknowledged all the operations carried out with LGC from July 9 to August 22, 2014, since someone who does not acknowledge operations with a certain security does not ask about the purchases or sales made, or the balance of his holding, much less request the policies for the operations carried out;
- On the other hand, regarding TV shares, by email of March 17, 2015, addressed to Mr. Rodríguez, Mr. Catep requests the sale policy for 35,206 TV shares. It should be noted that although the quantity is not exact[42], Mr. Catep is acknowledging that there were sale operations of TV in the period he disavows operations in his complaint, and therefore he is also acknowledging the purchase of these securities, because as of April 14, 2014, he did not have a holding of these securities. That is, Mr. Catep acknowledges the purchase and sale operation of TV shares of August 22 and 27, 2014;
- Therefore, it is evidenced that between March 17 and 24, 2015, Mr. Catep acknowledged all the operations carried out with TV from August 22 to September 18, 2014, which constitutes a new contradiction in his version contained in such complaint;
MPLE
- As observed in the transcriptions, on March 2, 2015, Mr. Catep shows conformity regarding his holding of MPLE[43] shares that Mr. Rodríguez informs him of, even Mr. Rodríguez informs him that the issuer has gone bankrupt and the client states he knows they were liquidating it, and upon Mr. Rodríguez's explanation that the shares are worth zero due to the high debt that exceeds the value of its assets, the client only shows his dismay at this information, but does not state that he did not authorize the investment in these securities;
Mr. Catep: Okay, what else, let's see what else has closed more or less.
Mr. Rodríguez: Mmm Maple... mmm I don't know how you have so many Maple... Maple has already gone bankrupt, no.
Mr. Catep: Maple no?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes, it went bankrupt, yes.
Mr. Catep: And now?
Mr. Rodríguez: Zero.
Mr. Catep: What?!
Mr. Rodríguez: It's zero.
Mr. Catep: Zero?
Mr. Rodríguez: Zero... the company has gone bankrupt.
Mr. Catep: And it doesn't have eh... haven't they liquidated it?... it doesn't have something... it no longer trades... right?
Mr. Rodríguez: No, it no longer trades.
Mr. Catep: And now it's lost?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes, the company... I mean, even selling all the assets it has, it won't be able to pay the debt it has with the banks.
Mr. Catep: Wow.
(….)
- As observed in Table No. 13, Mr. Catep did not have a balance of MPLE as of April 14, 2014, and the first operations with these securities were carried out during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, and as of December 31, 2014, and even until March 2, 2015, he still had a balance of these shares;
Table No. 13: Operations with MPLE
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 07/30/2014 | PURCHASE | 75,940 | 75,940 |
| 08/06/2014 | SALE | 75,940 | 0 |
| 08/29/2014 | PURCHASE | 303,150 | 303,150 |
| 09/03/2014 | SALE | 303,150 | 0 |
| 09/09/2014 | PURCHASE | 120,960 | 120,960 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 120,960 |
| 03/02/2015 | | | 120,960 |
- This conformity of Mr. Catep with the holding of MPLE shares evidences that he acknowledges at least the purchase operation of September 9, 2014, which he disavows in his complaint. The detail is shown in Table No. 13;
- The other operations with MPLE shares were purchases and sales, leaving the balance at zero, before the purchase operation of September 9, 2014;
- Likewise, by his email of March 1, 2015, Mr. Catep has implicitly acknowledged having authorized operations until August 31, 2014, so he acknowledges having authorized the operations with MPLE shares carried out between July 30 and August 29, 2014;
- Additionally, considering that in the conversation of March 2, 2015, with Mr. Rodríguez, Mr. Catep acknowledges the holding of MPLE at that date, this holding does not include the purchase of 303,150 shares of August 29, 2014, so Mr. Catep is implicitly acknowledging the sale operation of 303,150 shares carried out on September 3, 2014;
- In that sense, a new contradiction of Mr. Catep is noted by acknowledging the holding of MPLE securities on March 1, 2015, against what was said in his complaint;
BVN
- Regarding BVN, in the transcriptions it is observed that Mr. Rodríguez recommends Mr. Catep to buy BVN[44] and the client states that he had these securities and indicates that that gentleman - referring to Mr. García - has sold them; however, he does not state that Mr. García sold them without his authorization, but only shows his annoyance at the sale of those securities, as if it were a bad decision; in response, Mr. Rodríguez tells him that they will repurchase these securities anyway, which indeed happens in March 2015;
Table No. 14: Operations with BVN
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
| BVN | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 1,869 |
| 08/21/2014 | SALE | 1,069 | 800 |
| 11/07/2014 | PURCHASE | 3,000 | 3,800 |
| 11/07/2014 | SALE | 500 | 3,300 |
| 11/14/2014 | SALE | 2,000 | 1,300 |
| 11/20/2014 | PURCHASE | 2,400 | 3,700 |
| 11/21/2014 | SALE | 2,900 | 800 |
| 12/11/2014 | SALE | 800 | 0 |
- As observed in Table No. 14, Mr. Catep had 1,869 BVN as of April 14, 2014, and carried out purchase and sale operations of these securities between August 21 and December 11, 2014, going to zero as of December 31, 2014, and even until March 2, 2015, he did not have these securities;
- This conformity of Mr. Catep with the zero balance of BVN securities evidences that he acknowledges at least the sale operations of August 21 and December 11, 2014, through which he sold all his holding as of April 14, 2014. The detail is shown in Table No. 4;
- The other operations carried out between November 7 and November 21, 2014, were purchases and sales of the BVN security, which have not been acknowledged by Mr. Catep in his complaint; however, it should be noted that these were netted among themselves, so they did not increase the balance of 1,869 BVN that the client had as of April 14, 2014;
SIDERC1
- As observed in Table No. 15, Mr. Catep had 59,848 SIDERC1[45] as of April 14, 2014, which were fully sold, 68,102 of these shares were purchased again, and they were fully sold again, all these operations carried out during the period between April 15 and December 31, 2014;
Table No. 15: Operations with SIDERC1
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
| BVN | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 59,848 |
| 06/23/2014 | SALE | 59,848 | 0 |
| 08/05/2014 | PURCHASE | 35,402 | 35,402 |
| 08/06/2014 | PURCHASE | 32,700 | 68,102 |
| 10/28/2014 | SALE | 68,102 | 0 |
- In the conversation initiated on March 24, 2015, at 12:23:48 hours, Messrs. Rodríguez and Catep refer to SIDERC1 shares; transcription of part of the mentioned conversation is indicated below:
(…)
Mr. Catep: Okay Jorge, look, I'm reviewing right now, but I don't have the sale policies for Sider.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, okay, the Sider policies are fine... but look at the email I've sent you, there's an email that says Sider, in that one everything comes out and all the operations are detailed, look there.
Mr. Catep: No, no, I don't have the latest Sider ones, the sale ones.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, look at the email I've sent you, please, it's there.
Mr. Catep: But I'm reviewing here, Jorge, it's not there! I need those because I have a hearing.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay sir... sir, have you seen the document I've sent you about Sider.
Mr. Catep: Yes, I've seen it.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay, have you seen you've sold 68,102.
Mr. Catep: Jorge, listen, I had 59,900 Sider shares... okay, here I have the sale, it's already there.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay.
Mr. Catep: I bought again, sixty... has been bought...
Mr. Rodríguez: You bought 35,402 and 32,700.
Mr. Catep: Okay, so it was bought again and sold, but the sale hasn't reached me.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay, but it's in the file there.
Mr. Catep: No, no, it's fine, but I want the policies, friend.
Mr. Rodríguez: Okay, so you're missing the sale of Sider, okay?
Mr. Catep: Okay, I'm missing that one and Luna Gold too, I think 8,500 (…)
(…)
(Highlight added)
- As observed in the transcription, Mr. Catep recognizes the sale operation of his holding of 59,848 SIDERC1 shares, then recognizes that he bought those shares again and they were sold; in response, Mr. Rodríguez points out the quantities purchased of 35,402 and 32,700, and Mr. Catep reiterates that he bought and sold them and states that he does not have the policy for that sale operation. Likewise, through an email dated March 17, 2015, addressed to Mr. Rodríguez, Mr. Catep requests the sale policy for 68,102 SIDERC1 shares;
- Therefore, it is evident that on March 17 and 24, 2015, Mr. Catep recognized the operations carried out with SIDERC1 from June 23 to October 28, 2014, detailed in Table No. 15, which he was unaware of in his complaint, thus incurring a new contradiction regarding what was stated previously;
SUE and RIO
- In his complaint, Mr. Catep only recognizes the purchase of 15,384 SUE shares made on July 21, 2014, and indicates that Kallpa SAB allegedly sold 20,479 SUE-RIO shares without his authorization;
- Regarding this, as observed in Table No. 16, Mr. Catep held 29,725 SUE shares as of April 14, 2014. Then, 6,100 shares were sold on July 8, 2014, leaving a balance of 23,625 shares, which, when added to the 15,384 SUE shares purchased on July 21, 2014, results in a balance of 39,009 shares. Following a corporate event, due to the holding of these 39,009 SUE shares, the client received 20,479 RIO shares. Therefore, since this balance is what Mr. Catep indicates was sold without his consent, the client is also recognizing the sale of 6,100 SUE shares made on July 8, 2014, in addition to the purchase of 15,384 SUE shares made on July 21, 2014;
Table No. 16: Operations with SUE - RIO
| DATE | OPERATION | VALUE | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| RIO | | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | | 0 |
| 04/23/2014 | PURCHASE | RIO | 9,700 | 9,700 |
| 06/19/2014 | SALE | RIO | 5,000 | 4,700 |
| 06/20/2014 | SALE | RIO | 4,700 | 0 |
| SUE | | | | |
| 04/15/2014 | | SUE | | 29,725 |
| 07/08/2014 | SALE | SUE | 6,100 | 23,625 |
| 07/21/2014 | PURCHASE | SUE | 15,384 | 39,009 |
| 08/13/2014 | EXCHANGE (1 SUE X 0.525 RIO) | SUE - RIO | | 20,479 |
| 08/21/2014 | SALE | RIO | 10,000 | 10,479 |
| 08/22/2014 | SALE | RIO | 10,479 | 0 |
- Therefore, Mr. Catep implicitly recognizes having ordered the operation by stating that his sold balance without his authorization amounts to 20,479 SUE shares, a balance that necessarily includes the sale operation of 6,100 SUE shares;
- Additionally, regarding RIO shares, distinct from SUE before the union of RIO with SUE and the SUE shares that later converted to RIO, in the conversation initiated between Mr. Rodríguez and Mr. Catep on March 24, 2015, at 11:41:36 hours, Mr. Catep refers to these two (02) values. Below is the transcription of part of the mentioned conversation:
(
…)
Mr. Catep: The RIO ones are also missing.
Mr. Rodríguez: We sent them too, sir, meaning they have been sent.
Mr. Catep: It's not that there aren't any, they haven't sent me the receipt.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, in the document, the receipt was there, it should have reached you, check the document.
Mr. Catep: There is no receipt there.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, the document, meaning the same Ms. Elizabeth Cueva when she filled it out, put a receipt there.
Mr. Catep: There is none, they must have sent the list of all that have been sent with a receipt… for example, here I have 20 thousand RIO missing, I don't know how many sale shares, and those are not charged, look from last year, please check everything you sent me.
(….)
Mr. Catep: (…) Now this one from Sulliden SUE, that one too… it says here… it says purchase, purchase, but there is no sale.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, Sulliden disappeared, it has converted to RIO.
Mr. Catep: That's why, but I had SUE here… it says 10,000 2,900 (…)
Mr. Rodríguez: The rest might have converted to RIO, remember that it converted to RIO.
Mr. Catep: They passed them to RIO then?
Mr. Rodríguez: Yes, sir.
Mr. Catep: Have the shares been passed to me?
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, Sulliden disappeared to become RIO shares, that was several months ago.
Mr. Catep: Darn, clarify that for me, put it in writing, speed it up for me, please help me with that.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sir, I am helping you, I am calling to give you a solution, but you must listen a little and understand that in the case of Sulliden, the shares automatically converted to RIO, there will be no sale operation.
Mr. Catep: But what I see here… I had SUE, I don't know how many shares… but it says here that 15,984 shares were bought again.
Mr. Rodríguez: From Sulliden?
Mr. Catep: Of course, and the other says 6,100 only… of course, I had others, surely they converted to RIO as you say, but these bought in July?
Mr. Rodriguez: In July of 2014.
Mr. Catep: Of course.
(….)
- As observed in Table No. 16, Mr. Catep implicitly recognizes having ordered the operation by stating that his sold balance without his authorization amounts to 20,479 SUE shares, a balance that necessarily includes the sale operation of 6,100 SUE shares;
- Additionally, regarding RIO shares, distinct from SUE before the union of RIO with SUE and the SUE shares that later converted to RIO, in the conversation initiated between Mr. Rodríguez and Mr. Catep on March 24, 2015, at 11:41:36 hours, Mr. Catep refers to these two (02) values. Below is the transcription of part of the mentioned conversation:
(….)
Mr. Catep: Las de la RIO también faltan.
Mr. Rodríguez: También los enviamos señor o sea también lo han enviado
Mr. Catep: No es que no hay pues no me han mandado cargo.
Mr. Rodríguez: Señor en el documento estaba ahí el cargo ahí le debe haber llegado revise el documento.
Mr. Catep: No hay ni un cargo ahí.
Mr. Rodríguez: Señor el documento o sea la misma sra. Elizabeth Cueva cuando lo ha llenado ha puesto un cargo ahí.
Mr. Catep: No hay pues han debido mandar la relación de todas las que han mandado un cargo…por ejemplo acá tengo RIO faltan 20 mil no se cuantas acciones de venta y esas no se cargan mira del año pasado a ver revisa por favor todo lo que te mandado.
(….)
Mr. Catep: (…) Ahora de esta de Sulliden SUE esa tampoco… dice acá… dice compra compra pero no hay la venta.
Mr. Rodríguez: Señor Sulliden desapareció se ha convertido en RIO.
Mr. Catep: Por eso pues ya pero yo ahí tenía SUE…acá dice 10 000 2 900 (…) y dice venta 6 100 y el resto?
Mr. Rodríguez: El resto puede ser que se haya convertido en RIO acuérdese que se convirtió en RIO.
Mr. Catep: Me las pasaron a RIO entonces?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Sí, señor.
Mr. Catep: ¿Las acciones me las han pasado?.
Mr. Rodríguez: Señor, Sulliden desapareció para ser acciones de RIO eso fue hace varios meses.
Mr. Catep: Pucha no se aclárame eso pues me lo pones agilíceme eso por favor ayúdame en eso.
Mr. Rodríguez: señor yo lo estoy ayudando yo lo estoy llamando para darle solución pero o sea…debe escuchar un poco y entender que en el caso de Sulliden las acciones se convirtieron automáticamente en RIO, no va a haber operación de venta.
Mr. Catep: Pero lo que yo veo acá…yo tenía SUE no se cuántas acciones…pero dice acá que se ha comprado nuevamente 15 984 acciones.
Mr. Rodríguez: de Sulliden?
Mr. Catep: Claro y la otra dice 6 100 nada más…claro yo tenía otras seguramente han pasado a RIO como dices pero ¿estas que se han comprado en julio?.
Sr. Rodriguez: en julio del 2014
Sr. Catep: claro
(….)
- As observed in Table No. 16, Mr. Catep did not hold RIO shares as of April 14, 2014, and held 29,725 SUE shares on that date. However, in the conversation he recognizes sale operations of RIO shares exceeding 20,000 from 2014;
- Regarding SUE shares, he expresses ignorance about the conversion of these shares to RIO; furthermore, he states that he held prior SUE shares, which he held as of April 14, 2014; he also recognizes the sale operation of 6,100 SUE shares, as explained previously, which took place on July 8, 2014; and finally, he asks Mr. Rodríguez what happened to the other shares, and this representative indicates that they must have converted to RIO shares;
- Consequently, it is evident that Mr. Catep recognizes he had an initial balance of SUE shares, recognizes the sale of 6,100 SUE shares, and that he also bought SUE shares in July 2014[48]; on the other hand, he recognizes that there was a sale of over 20,000 RIO shares; however, it should be noted that he did not have that amount of RIO shares that he could sell, only purchase operations of 9,700 RIO shares on April 23, 2014, and the sale of all these shares in June 2014;
- Therefore, taking into account Mr. Catep's manifest ignorance of the conversion of SUE shares into RIO, as observed in the transcriptions, the RIO shares that Mr. Catep recognizes as sold and which, according to what he indicates in the conversation, are more than 20,000 are the SUE shares converted to 20,479 RIO shares on August 13, 2014, and which were sold in their entirety as RIO in August 2014, as detailed in Table No. 16;
- Likewise, another evidence of the recognition of operations with SUE shares is that through an email dated March 17, 2015, addressed to Mr. Rodríguez, Mr. Catep requests the policy for the sale of 9,284 SUE shares. It should be noted that this amount is the result of the purchase of 15,384 SUE shares that he recognizes in his complaint minus the sale of 6,100 shares that he does not recognize in his complaint; however, Mr. Catep in this email does not consider that he held a prior holding of SUE shares and that subsequently these converted to RIO and were sold as RIO, as explained previously.
- In conclusion, on March 17 and 24, 2015, Mr. Catep recognizes the sale of 6,100 SUE shares from July 8, 2014; furthermore, on March 24, 2015, he recognizes the sale of 20,479 SUE shares (converted to RIO) from August 21 and 22, 2014, which he was unaware of in his complaint.
ISNS
- As observed in Table No. 17, Mr. Catep did not hold ISNS shares as of April 14, 2014, and during the period between April 15 and December 31, 2014, purchase and sale operations of these shares were observed carried out on behalf of this client, leaving the balance at zero;
TABLE No. 17: OPERATIONS WITH ISNS
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| RIO | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 09/03/2014 | PURCHASE | 12,000 | 12,000 |
| 09/03/2014 | SALE | 12,000 | 0 |
| 09/04/2014 | PURCHASE | 9,000 | 9,000 |
| 09/04/2014 | PURCHASE | 1,500 | 10,500 |
| 09/08/2014 | SALE | 1,500 | 9,000 |
| 09/09/2014 | PURCHASE | 2,000 | 11,000 |
| 09/09/2014 | SALE | 1,500 | 9,500 |
| 09/10/2014 | PURCHASE | 700 | 10,200 |
| 09/18/2014 | SALE | 5,000 | 5,200 |
| 10/22/2014 | SALE | 5,200 | 0 |
- Through an email dated March 17, 2015, addressed to Mr. Rodríguez, Mr. Catep requests the sale policies for 13,200 ISNS shares, and through an email dated March 18, 2017, he reiterates that they send said policies;
- As observed in Table No. 17, Mr. Catep sold 13,200 ISNS shares between September 8 and October 22, 2014, so with the request for the policies of these sales, the client is recognizing the realization of these sale operations, and therefore also recognizes the purchases for this amount, because as of April 14, 2014, he did not have a balance of these values. Consequently, on March 17 and 18, 2015, Mr. Catep recognizes at least the purchase and sale operations of ISNS carried out between September 4 and October 22, 2014, which he was unaware of in his complaint;
- The other two (2) operations carried out on September 3, 2014, were the purchase and sale of the ISNS value which Mr. Catep has not recognized in his complaint; however, it should be specified that these netted each other, so they did not increase the balance of zero (0) that the client had as of April 14, 2014.
FREE, SCCO, CVERDEC1, PML, YHOO
Table No. 18: Operations with other values
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| FREE | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 05/23/2014 | PURCHASE | 6,600 | 6,600 |
| 06/13/2014 | SALE | 6,600 | 0 |
| 08/29/2014 | PURCHASE | 30,066 | 30,066 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 0 |
| 03/01/2015 | | | 0 |
| SCCO | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 2,619 |
| 07/08/2014 | SALE | 800 | 1,819 |
| 07/15/2014 | PURCHASE | 34 | 1,853 |
| 07/16/2014 | PURCHASE | 200 | 2,053 |
| 07/16/2014 | SALE | 200 | 1,853 |
| 07/17/2014 | PURCHASE | 500 | 2,353 |
| 07/18/2014 | PURCHASE | 300 | 2,653 |
| 07/18/2014 | PURCHASE | 200 | 2,853 |
| 07/18/2014 | SALE | 200 | 2,653 |
| 07/23/2014 | SALE | 834 | 1,819 |
| 08/21/2014 | PURCHASE | 420 | 2,239 |
| 08/22/2014 | SALE | 2,239 | 0 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 0 |
| 03/01/2015 | | | 0 |
| CVERDEC1 | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 07/23/2014 | PURCHASE | 983 | 983 |
| 07/31/2014 | SALE | 55 | 928 |
| 08/18/2014 | SALE | 928 | 0 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 0 |
| 03/01/2015 | | | 0 |
| PML | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 08/19/2014 | PURCHASE | 29,050 | 29,050 |
| 08/22/2014 | SALE | 29,050 | 0 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 0 |
| 03/01/2015 | | | 0 |
| YHOO | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | |
| 08/22/2014 | PURCHASE | 1,700 | 1,700 |
| 09/02/2014 | SALE | 1,700 | 0 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 0 |
| 03/02/2015 | | | 0 |
- As observed in Table No. 18, Mr. Catep did not hold FREE, CVERDEC1, PML, and YHOO shares and held 2,619 SCCO shares as of April 14, 2014, and during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, operations with these shares were observed, which he denied in his complaint;
- However, as previously stated, through an email dated March 1, 2015, Mr. Catep implicitly recognized that he authorized operations up to August 31, 2014, and was unaware of operations carried out on his behalf from September to December 2014. Consequently, Mr. Catep implicitly recognizes the operations carried out with FREE, SCCO, CVERDEC1, PML, and YHOO shares between July 8 and August 22, 2014;
- Additionally, regarding the sale operation of 1,700 YHOO shares on September 2, 2014, it should be noted that Mr. Catep did not indicate in his complaint the holding of these values because he was unaware of all operations carried out after April 14, 2014. However, since it was evidenced that in March 2015 he recognized various operations carried out after April 14, 2014, and implicitly all operations carried out up to August 31, 2014, it is concluded that if in his email of March 1, 2015, he recognizes that he authorized the purchase of 1,700 YHOO shares on August 22, 2014, and in his complaint he does not recognize the holding of these values, Mr. Catep is implicitly also recognizing that he authorized the sale of 1,700 YHOO shares, which occurred on September 2, 2014; this is in addition to the previous analysis carried out regarding the operations that took place during the first quarter of 2015 with the net balance result of the operations as of December 31, 2014;
ATACOBC1[49] and RELAPAC1[50]
Table No. 19: Operations with ATACOBC1 and RELAPAC1
| DATE | OPERATION | QUANTITY | BALANCE |
|---|
| RELAPAC1 | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 06/24/2014 | PURCHASE | 71,850 | 71,850 |
| 07/23/2014 | SALE | 71,800 | 50 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 50 |
| 03/01/2015 | | | 50 |
| ATACOBC1 | | | |
| 04/14/2014 | | | 0 |
| 07/30/2014 | PURCHASE | 86,790 | 86,790 |
| 08/01/2014 | SALE | 86,790 | 0 |
| 12/31/2014 | | | 0 |
| 03/01/2015 | | | 0 |
- Finally, as observed in Table No. 19, Mr. Catep did not hold ATACOBC1 and RELAPAC1 shares and during the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014, operations with these shares were observed, which he denied in his complaint;
- However, as previously stated, through an email dated March 1, 2015, Mr. Catep implicitly recognized that he authorized operations up to August 31, 2014, and was unaware of operations carried out on his behalf from September to December 2014. Consequently, Mr. Catep implicitly recognizes the operations carried out with ATACOBC1 and RELAPAC1 shares between June 24 and August 1, 2014;
- Therefore, although it could not be demonstrated that the copies of the Order Lists contain the authentic signature of Mr. Catep and Kallpa SAB stated that it does not have the original records of the orders or the originals of the Order Lists to verify the authenticity of the signature, according to what is evaluated in this resolution, it is evident that Mr. Catep, after the execution of operations, between March 1 and 24, 2015, recognized the operations carried out from April 15 to December 11, 2014, which he denied in his complaint to the SMV;
- As a consequence of these operations recognized by Mr. Catep, the balance of his funds as of December 31, 2014, amounts to the amount of US$ 6,385.87 (Six thousand three hundred eighty-five and 87/100 United States Dollars);
- It should be noted that the fund balances in Soles, resulting from operations authorized by Mr. Catep, were converted into Dollars to liquidate operations in this currency or Dollars were converted into Soles to liquidate operations in this latter currency;
- Likewise, as a consequence of these operations recognized by Mr. Catep, the balance of his securities as of December 31, 2014, was the following:
TABLE No. 20
| Security | Quantity |
|---|
| ALT | 440,058 |
| DNT | 31,976 |
| MIRL | 185,551 |
| MOROCOI1 | 16,971 |
| POMALCC1 | 81,934 |
| PUCALAC1 | 56,983 |
| RELAPAC1 | 50 |
| FMCC | 5,000 |
| FNMA | 8,000 |
| LGC | 32,903 |
| UGAZ | 1,200 |
| MPLE | 120,960 |
| JNUG | 500 |
| SMC | 3,900 |
| TV | 46,066 |
- It should be specified that the client recognizes the operations that led to him holding 5,000 FMCC, 8,000 FNMA, 32,903 LGC, 1,200 UGAZ, 120,960 MPLE, 500 JNUG, 3,900 SMC, 46,066 TV, and 50 RELAPAC1 as of December 31, 2014, which he denies in his complaint to the SMV. Likewise, it should be noted that through telephone instructions, whose records are in the file, on March 3, 2015, Mr. Catep authorized the sale of 1,200 UGAZ and 500 JNUG, so he no longer possesses these securities as of this date.
- On the other hand, regarding his security holdings as of April 14, 2014, according to what is evaluated in this resolution, it is evident that in March 2015 Mr. Catep recognizes having sold the balance of 2,619 SCCO, 1,869 BVN, 20,479 SUE, and 59,848 SIDERC1 that he held as of April 14, 2014;
Additional indications that prove Mr. Catep's consent to the operations in the controversial period
- In addition to what has been stated, evidentiary indications are appreciated that reasonably show that there was a will to buy or sell the securities by Mr. Catep during the controversial period or that said client had knowledge of the operations carried out in his name, which must be evaluated jointly with the facts and evidence presented previously in order to determine the existence or not of the infraction referred to the use of funds for purposes other than those entrusted;
Access to the KALLPA WEB
- Regarding this, as has been proven in the present procedure, the Kallpa Web report is in the file, in which it is seen that from April 14 to August 22, 2014, Mr. Catep had an active and constant review of the information provided by said web such as "list portfolio structure", "list current account", "List operation details", "Show Form /APP/ Portfolio", "Show Policy", among others;
- Likewise, according to said report, it is seen that Mr. Catep continued accessing the Kallpa Web from August 22, 2014, to April 24, 2015, meaning he maintained a constant review of the information that Kallpa SAB provided him regarding the status of his investments;
- It should be noted that in the telephone conversation on March 2, 2015, between Mr. Rodríguez and Mr. Catep, the latter stated that he had lost his access key to the Kallpa Web, which is contradictory given that according to the aforementioned record, it is known that Mr. Catep did access said web, even on March 2, 2015, at 14:35:42 hours;
- Another fact that reflects Mr. Catep's contradiction regarding his statement of not having accessed the Kallpa Web when, according to the cited record, he did, is having stated, in the telephone conversation with Mr. Alberto Alejandro Arispe Bazan (hereinafter, Mr. Arispe) on May 8, 2015, in which said client stated: "(…) they haven't given me that key, I haven't had that key (…)";
- What is stated in the preceding consideration allows us to conclude that Mr. Catep used his personal username and password to access the Kallpa Web to know the detail of his operations and therefore, the status of his portfolio;
Mr. Catep maintained constant communication with Mr. García;
- On the other hand, telephone communications between Mr. Catep and the representatives of Kallpa SAB are in the file, in which it is seen that said client stated that he maintained constant communication with Mr. García (then representative of Kallpa SAB) regarding his portfolio;
- In fact, in the conversation on May 8, 2015, Mr. Catep stated to Mr. Arispe regarding Mr. García: "(…) well, I told you that I called him, I called him every day "how is this" and there it is "stable stable" we are going to wait for the pique and with that it was, and that's how we have been, nothing more (…)";
- In this sense, a client who claims to converse permanently with his representative about the status of his investments denotes his constant attention to his portfolio, a fact that is consistent with his permanent access to the Kallpa Web to, among other things, review his operations and know the use of his funds;
Mr. Catep requested policies for the operations he denied authorizing
- The file also contains the request made by Mr. Catep to Mr. Rodríguez through an email dated March 11, 2015, at 10:43 pm, in which he requests the sending of the original policies for the operations carried out between January 2014 and March 2015 (which includes precisely the period in which the operations he denied authorizing took place) for the preparation of his income tax declaration;
- Such request for information to Kallpa SAB is contradictory because for someone who denies the execution of operations in his name, it is not reasonable that he could include them in his tax declaration before the tax regulator, a situation that also constitutes an indication that would prove the acceptance of the existence of the said operations;
Mr. CATEP has recognized part of the operations he denied in his complaint
- In his complaint, Mr. Catep denies the operations from April 15, 2014, but according to the email of March 1, 2015, that he sent to Mr. Rodríguez, he indirectly recognizes the execution of operations with his consent from April 15 to August 31, 2014, so the questioned period of unauthorized operations would be limited from September 1 to December 11, 2014.
- Such a situation evidences a new contradiction on the part of Mr. Catep to state in his complaint that he denies the operations from April 15, 2014, when in the cited email of March 1, 2015, he states that he denies them from September 2014.
Mr. Catep asked Mr. Rodríguez for his advice to reverse the losses
- According to the cited email of March 1, 2015, addressed to Mr. Rodríguez, it is seen that Mr. Catep asked the first, upon becoming aware of the considerable drop in the value of his investments, for his advice to determine the way to work to recover the money or losses incurred.
- Regarding this, it should be indicated that although Mr. Catep claims that Mr. García carried out operations without his consent, Mr. Catep is willing to assume the current position of his investments and recover the losses, which is a contradictory behavior for an investor to whom his funds and securities have been allocated for purposes other than those entrusted.
Mr. Catep denounces all operations with the exception of one
- As previously indicated, Mr. Catep has denied in his complaint having authorized the execution of operations in his name from 15 April to 31 December 2014, with the exception of the SUE security;
- In the case of the SUE security, it has been demonstrated in this proceeding that Mr. Catep authorized the purchase and sale operations of said securities, with the last sale operation of these securities occurring on 22 August 2014, because the aforementioned client has indirectly acknowledged having authorized, in accordance with the cited email of 1 March 2015 that Mr. Catep sent to Mr. Rodriguez;
- Regarding Mr. Catep's statement that he only acknowledges the purchase of these SUE securities made on 21 July 2014, this creates a contradiction with respect to the investment decisions made by Mr. CATEP within the period in question, since it is unreasonable to maintain that he was unaware of the existence of other operations carried out in his name and only regarding the movement of the SUE security, taking into account that it has also been established that Mr. Catep has indirectly acknowledged part of the operations denied in his complaint; in addition to the income recorded on the Kallpa Web;
- On the other hand, the file contains telephone conversations between Mr. Rodriguez and Mr. Catep in which this client mentions to the representative of Kallpa SAB the execution of operations that he consented to and the existence or not of the balance as of the date of such securities (among them FMCC, FNMA, LGC, JNUG); however, it is observed that the reference to operations with said securities is within the period that the client denies having authorized;
- Therefore, although it has not been possible to demonstrate that the copies of the Order Listings contain the authentic signature of Mr. Catep and Kallpa SAB has stated that it does not have the original records of the orders or the originals of the Order Listings to verify the authenticity of the signature, in light of the indications that would reflect that Mr. Catep had knowledge of the operations carried out in his name that he denies in his complaint, added to the fact that there is evidence supporting that said client has indirectly acknowledged that he authorized the execution of operations until August 2014, which is contradictory to the fact that before this Superintendency he denied having carried out operations from 15 April to 11 December 2014, it is not possible to conclude that the infraction in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, referring to the destination of funds for purposes other than those entrusted, has been configured, so it is appropriate to archive this charge;
3.2 Failure to obtain orders from its clients
Of the Regulations
- Article 175 of the LMV provides regarding orders the following:
“Article 175. Orders.- Orders are instructions given to brokerage agents, through which their clients express their decisions regarding the negotiation of securities or financial instruments and other services they may provide.
Through orders, clients grant a mandate to their brokerage agent to carry out the operations set forth in articles 194 and 207, as well as for the receipt of benefits, subscription of shares or any other activity related to securities or financial instruments, with prior authorization from Conasev in accordance with items t) and i) of said articles, respectively.
Orders empower brokerage agents to exercise the mandate they contain. In the case of subscription of shares, receipt of benefits or other similar matters, brokerage agents are authorized by their client's mandate to act on their behalf without the requirement of any additional requirement or condition, except those determined by the client themselves.
In accordance with the preceding paragraphs, brokerage agents are obligated to the following:
- Obtain written or telephone orders from their clients, provided that the latter are recorded, without prejudice to other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that Conasev may establish through general provisions.
- Implement systems that allow the recording of orders when made by telephone so that they are recorded from the moment they are received. For this purpose, they must have a system for recording orders received by telephone, as well as a system for registering and archiving them in accordance with the general rules issued by Conasev.
Such recordings, as well as the aforementioned registry, must be kept for five years and made available to Conasev in the manner it establishes through a general rule.
From the moment the client gives the order by telephone, it is understood that they have been previously informed of the conditions for recording orders given through this medium, as well as the acceptance of the corresponding recording.
- Use only systems, as well as means of receiving and registering orders authorized by Conasev.
Likewise, brokerage agents must make available to their clients the policy that evidences the operations carried out on their behalf.”
- For its part, article 30, numeral 30.2 of the Regulation amended by Resolution SMV No. 040-2012-SMV/01, in force as of 1 February 2013, establishes the following:
“Article 30.- Receipt, Registration and Transmission of Orders.- For the purpose of orders given for the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, the following must be observed:
(…)
30.2. Orders on behalf of a client may be instructed to the Agent through the following means: (i) written, (ii) fax with subsequent confirmation, (iii) telephone, (iv) through applications implemented from the Agent's website, (v) private electronic communication network with registered users, recognized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision; (vi) email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation; (vii) ADM in accordance with the provisions of the Direct Market Access Regulation, approved by Resolution SMV No. 024-2012-SMV/01 or the rule that replaces it; (viii) intermediated routing in accordance with the provisions of the Integrated Market through Intermediated Routing Regulation, approved by Resolution CONASEV No. 107-2010-EF/94.01.1, or, (ix) other means of communication authorized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, in accordance with what is agreed in its respective client registration form.
In all the above cases, the Agent is responsible for verifying the authenticity of the orders it receives through the additional means it considers.”[51]
- In turn, article 37, numeral 37.5 of the Regulation states:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.5. Each operation intermediated by the Agent must have the corresponding client order.”[52]
- For its part, article 69 of the Regulation states:
“(…)
The Agent must keep the documents, books and records that make up its information system for a minimum period of ten (10) years, counted from the generation of the corresponding information, except in the case of the recording registry referred to in article 175 of the Law, which must be kept for five (5) years)
(…)”
- In relation to the above, article 78 of the Regulation states that the Order Registry is the only means that evidences the conditions under which it was given by the client and must contain, among others, the client's signature, except in the modalities of receiving orders in which it is not necessary, in accordance with the provisions of the client registration form, in which case the Agent must have the respective verification means;
Of the charge formulated
- As indicated in the previous charge, the funds and securities owned by Mr. Catep were used by Kallpa SAB to carry out purchase and sale operations of financial instruments on the BVL and in the foreign market, on behalf of the aforementioned client, without the authorization of the latter;
- Likewise, as stated, Kallpa SAB has carried out a series of operations in the name of Mr. Catep from 15 April to 31 December 2014;
- Accordingly, for the aforementioned operations, Kallpa SAB should have obtained, for each of them, the corresponding purchase and sale orders instructed by Mr. Catep, and for each order received a record must have been generated containing the minimum information required by article 78 of the Regulation, in force at the date of the events[53];
- Likewise, such orders should have been instructed in accordance with the modalities established in the Client Registration Form in the name of Mr. Catep dated 14 June 2013, that is: “Written”, “Telephone”, “Telephone with subsequent written confirmation” and “Internet”;
- It should be noted that the process of obtaining orders from a client by a stock brokerage firm must be prior to the execution of the operations, which must be evidenced by the presentation of the corresponding order registry, so if the order instruction modality is “written”, the order registry must correspond to a letter, form of the stock brokerage firm or other means signed by the client prior to the execution of the operation and indicating the name of the Representative of the stock brokerage firm who took and processed the order, among other minimum information required by article 78 of the Regulation;
- Likewise, regarding the order instruction modalities with subsequent written confirmation, it should be noted that through Official Letter No. 6207-2016-SMV/10.3 notified on 6 October 2016, Kallpa SAB was requested to provide the original documents of the copies of the listings presented as Annexes 53 and 54 to its brief of 27 July 2016, which would confirm the orders that Mr. Catep would have instructed between 15 April and 31 December 2014, with said brokerage firm responding, through a brief presented on 11 October 2016, that it does not have such documents; it should even be noted that to date the aforementioned brokerage firm has not complied with such request;
- Thus, taking into account the above, in accordance with the provisions of article 175 of the LMV and article 37, numeral 37.5 of the Regulation, Kallpa SAB had the obligation to obtain the orders regarding the operations carried out from 15 April to 31 December 2014, in accordance with the modalities agreed with the client in the client registration form, and using systems, as well as reception means authorized by the SMV; however, such orders would not have been obtained by Kallpa SAB, taking into account that these have not been evidenced by the aforementioned stock brokerage firm with the order registries according to the instruction modality of each of these, it was imputed that it would have breached in this way the securities market regulations;
Of the defenses
- In its defense brief presented on 19 June 2018, Kallpa SAB reiterates all the arguments set forth in its first defense brief dated 8 August 2017;
- In this sense, the defenses presented by Kallpa SAB are cited below as well as their corresponding analysis:
- Kallpa SAB states that the Order Listing signed by Mr. Catep does not constitute the purchase order; however, it considers that this does not prevent them from demonstrating that such orders were given by the aforementioned client, obtained and executed by the SAB;
- Kallpa SAB states that the subsequent confirmation made by Mr. Catep through the signing of the Order Listing demonstrates that the orders existed, that is, they were obtained as required by the regulations and in response to them the SAB executed the operations as it corresponds to do in compliance with its contract with Mr. Catep, so, in its opinion, the factual assumption of this infraction is not configured, since Kallpa SAB did obtain the orders from the aforementioned client, although it did not keep the originals;
Evaluation of the Defense
- On this matter, it should be noted that the order constitutes the instruction given by the client to the intermediary for the execution of a certain operation; this instruction is prior to the execution of the operation and must be obtained before the latter and in accordance with the modality indicated in the client's registration form;
- If the order instruction modality was “written”, the stock brokerage firm must present the written order signed by the client; if it is “telephone”, it must present the audio of the telephone conversation showing the client's instruction; and if it is “telephone with subsequent written confirmation”, it will be sufficient for the stock brokerage firm to present the written order or listing that confirms the order or orders given previously;
- In the present case, Kallpa SAB, as it has stated, obtained the orders that generated the execution of the operations questioned by Mr. Catep, and presented the Order Listing; however, given Mr. Catep's questioning that the signatures appearing on this listing are not his, the stock brokerage firm is obligated to reliably demonstrate that it did obtain the orders from Mr. Catep and that, in this case, the subsequent confirmation was made by the client with the signing of the Order Listing, for which it is necessary to present the originals of said listings to verify that the signature corresponds to the client;
- However, both in the preliminary inquiry stage and in the present administrative sanctioning proceeding, Kallpa SAB has not presented the corresponding originals of the Order Listing, or other evidence proving that the client instructed orders with another modality, such as an audio, a written document, etc., despite the requests made by this Superintendency;
Defense
- Kallpa SAB states that the obligation of the stock brokerage firm in accordance with article 175, literal a) of the LMV is to obtain orders, as it claims occurred in this case; however, it considers that such article does not stipulate that the former is absolute or that there is an unalterable duty of conservation of the same (without there being periods of time in which the stock brokerage firm ceases to have material possession of these documents), especially when the client himself is the one who requests and demands their delivery (as has happened in the present case), as has been noted in the testimony of Mr. García when Mr. Arispe asks him who is the person who keeps the aforementioned documents;
- Therefore, Kallpa SAB considers that the infraction cannot be imputed to it since Mr. García complied with obtaining the orders from Mr. Catep, so article 257, numeral 1, literal b)[54] of the TUO LPAG is applicable, because Kallpa SAB has acted in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense, corresponding to the exoneration of the aforementioned infraction type since the conduct of Kallpa SAB, at all times, has been to act under the instructions of the investor himself;
Evaluation of the Defense
- As to the claim that Kallpa SAB obtained the orders and in compliance with a legal duty delivered the originals of the orders subject to charge to Mr. Catep, and therefore should be exonerated from the imputed infraction, it should be noted that the obligation to obtain the respective orders constitutes an unavoidable obligation of the intermediary that does not admit any interpretation such as that claimed by Kallpa SAB in its defenses and that upon the sole request of the regulator it must comply with delivering them, especially considering that their evidence will allow determining the existence or not of a very serious infraction such as the destination of funds or securities for purposes other than those entrusted;
- Likewise, it should be noted that Kallpa SAB had no legal obligation to deliver to Mr. Catep the originals of the orders, since it is the brokerage firm that should have kept them; furthermore, Kallpa has not evidenced having delivered them to Mr. Catep, and it is only a statement of the brokerage firm;
- In the present case, through Official Letter No. 6207-2016-SMV/10.3, Kallpa SAB was requested to present the respective orders supporting the operations questioned by Mr. Catep, with the SAB stating through a letter of 6 October 2016 “(…) despite the repeated requests made to Mr. Ricky García, to date the originals of the documents that were attached in the aforementioned annexes have not been sent, which is why we do not have them.” (underlining added);
Defenses presented on 19 June 2018
- In said brief, Kallpa SAB states that although it does not have the original orders signed by Mr. Catep, this does not prevent it from being possible to demonstrate and conclude that such orders were indeed given by Mr. Catep, obtained and executed by Kallpa SAB;
- Kallpa SAB states that it does have copies of the Order Listing signed by Mr. Catep through which the instruction of all the operations that he now questions is acknowledged. The confirmation made by Mr. Catep through the signing of the Order Listing demonstrates that the orders existed, that is, they were obtained as required by the regulations, and in response to them Kallpa SAB carried out the operations as it corresponds to do in compliance with its contract with Mr. Catep and the applicable regulations;
- Therefore, Kallpa SAB considers that the factual assumption of this infraction is not configured, since it did obtain the orders from Mr. Catep, although it did not keep the originals;
- The obligation of the stock brokerage firm in accordance with literal a) of article 175 of the LMV is to obtain orders, as Kallpa SAB indeed obtained them; however, the aforementioned article does not establish an unalterable duty of conservation of the same, that is, it does not prevent the documents from being delivered to the client temporarily if the client requests it, as has happened in the case of Mr. Catep;
- In support of this, Kallpa SAB refers to the emails from Mr. García to Mr. Arispe, in which Mr. García states that Mr. Catep did not deny not having the orders but rather conditioned their delivery on the granting of a guarantee in compensation for the decline in his portfolio;
- In this sense, Kallpa SAB states that Mr. García did obtain the orders from Mr. Catep, so literal b) of numeral 1 of article 257 of the TUOLPAG is applicable, because it acted in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense, so the exoneration of the aforementioned infraction type corresponds since the conduct of Kallpa SAB was, at all times, to act under the instructions of the investor himself;
Analysis of the defense
- Regarding the defenses presented, it should be noted that each of them has been previously evaluated in the analysis of the defenses presented by Kallpa SAB on the matter as described above in this resolution, so we refer to them;
- Notwithstanding the above, it should be emphasized that in the present infraction it is not discussed whether the firm can or cannot evidence the existence of an operation instructed by a client, but rather the non-compliance observed refers to having the support of the instruction given before the execution of the operation, that is, obtaining the respective order under the formality established by the regulations and, for the present case, that indicated in the client registration form of Mr. Catep;
Allegations presented by Kallpa SAB
- In its allegations, Kallpa SAB has reiterated its defense arguments presented within this administrative sanctioning proceeding; however, it adds that the respective imputation of charges violates the principle of lawfulness and material truth since it seeks to reverse the burden of proof to Kallpa SAB;
- In this regard, it should be recalled that the substantive obligation to obtain orders from its clients belongs to the stock brokerage firm itself, since it is the one that maintains a commercial relationship with the client and not the regulator as Kallpa SAB seeks to maintain; therefore, it is materially impossible to assume that it is the regulator who must prove compliance with an obligation that emanates legally and exclusively from the administered party, in this case Kallpa SAB;
- The request for the presentation of the orders subject to questioning constitutes only the verification of compliance with a legal mandate, a fact that, when not complied with, indisputably reveals the non-observance of the latter, so the alleged violation of the principles of lawfulness and material truth is not appreciated;
- It should be noted that Kallpa SAB acknowledged that it does not have the orders corresponding to the operations subject to charge, in this case the originals of the Order Listing, an obligation that corresponds only to the intermediary, so since the orders of 9 and 11 December 2014 have not been evidenced, it has been established that Kallpa SAB incurred the infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation;
3.3 Denying the delivery of information requested by the SMV
Of the Regulations
- Articles 69 and 71 of the Regulation, in force at the date of the events, provide the following:
Article 69.- Maintenance and conservation
(…)
The Agent must keep the documents, books and records that make up its information system for a minimum period of ten (10) years, counted from the generation of the corresponding information, except in the case of the recording registry referred to in article 175 of the Law, which must be kept for five (5) years.
(…)
Article 71.- Supervision Actions
The Agent must provide to the officials of the various bodies of the SMV the documentation, books, records, recordings or other information that make up its information system during inspections and other supervision and control actions.
Consequently, the Agent is prohibited from taking any action that could hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of the SMV.
On the Charges
- According to the facts set out in the preceding charges and as part of the preliminary inquiries conducted by this Superintendency, by Official Letter No. 6207-2016-SMV/10.3 of 6 October 2016, Kallpa SAB was required to present the originals of the orders relating to the attached copies detailed in annexes 53 and 54 to its brief of 27 July 2016, in order to carry out the respective expert examination of the signatures appearing on such documents, taking into account that Mr. Catep has denied that the signatures noted on the orders he allegedly instructed between 15 April and 31 December 2014 are his; and considering that, in accordance with the regulations cited above, it has the obligation to keep the orders for the transactions carried out by its clients;
- It should be noted that the aforementioned requirement to present the original orders relating to those instructed by Mr. Catep that are the subject of the investigation was reiterated by Official Letter No. 6453-2016-SMV/10.3 of 20 October 2016, granting Kallpa SAB a period of three days for such compliance; however, to date this has not been complied with;
- In this regard, Article 66, paragraph 66.2 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, establishes that in investigative procedures, administered persons are obliged to provide the information and documents they knew of and that are reasonably appropriate to the objectives of the proceeding in order to reach the material truth;
- For its part, Article 71 of the Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, provides that the brokerage agent must provide the officials of this Superintendency with the information, documentation and facilities they require during supervision and control actions. It also establishes that the agent is prohibited from taking any action that could hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of this Superintendency;
- Consequently, despite the reiterated requirements, and taking into account that it is the obligation of brokerage firms to deliver information to the supervisor during investigations, documentation that is also within the period established by Article 69 of the Regulation for its preservation, Kallpa SAB would have incurred an infraction of the regulations cited above;
On the Defenses
- In its defense brief submitted on 19 June 2018, Kallpa SAB reiterates all the arguments set out in its first defense brief dated 8 August 2017;
- Accordingly, the defenses submitted by Kallpa SAB are cited below, together with their corresponding analysis:
- Kallpa SAB states that for this infraction to be configured, it must have in its possession the documents requested, that is, it must act intentionally with the purpose of delaying the SMV's investigations; however, the real reason for not delivering the original documents signed by Mr. Catep is Kallpa SAB's inability to locate the originals because they are in the possession of the aforementioned client;
- Therefore, Kallpa SAB reaffirms that at no time was it its intention to hide information to delay the investigations, but rather that due to an internal failure the original documentation required is not in its possession;
- Kallpa SAB states that it has been diligent in responding to all information requests within the periods established by the SMV, and has sent through its briefs all the original documents and copies containing Mr. Catep's signature that are in its possession, and therefore considers that there is an exemption from the obligation contained in Article 71 of the Regulation, so the charge imputed should be left without effect;
- Finally, it should be noted that in its defenses submitted on 19 June 2018, Kallpa SAB reiterates the same arguments set out in its defense brief dated 8 August 2017, concluding that since it does not have the information required, it is not possible for this infraction to be configured, and therefore it should be resolved that it did not incur an infraction;
Evaluation of the defenses
- As regards the claim that Kallpa SAB could not deliver the originals of the orders at issue because they are in the possession of Mr. Catep, it should be noted that said intermediary has not presented any evidentiary means supporting such assertion, since stating that such orders were delivered to such client by its former representative, Mr. García (which has not been accredited, since the representative's statement does not constitute a decisive evidentiary means), does not relieve said intermediary of complying with having the respective orders to which it is obliged by the LMV and the Regulation;
- Notwithstanding this, it should be noted that the failure to collect orders from its clients has been evaluated in the present case, since it has not demonstrated that it has the orders that authorized Mr. Catep's transactions challenged in this proceeding and, in that sense, the existence of said infraction by Kallpa SAB has been determined; therefore, charges were imputed considering that, since it is the obligation of the brokerage firm to have such orders, Kallpa SAB could present them at the time of its defenses, which in relation to the infraction that is the subject of this analysis could entail that Kallpa SAB would have delayed the delivery of information to the regulator; however, having determined the infraction of not collecting the respective orders, it is appropriate to proceed with the archiving of this charge;
V. Evaluation of the Sanction
- In accordance with Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, in concordance with Article 248, paragraph 3[55] and Article 257 of the TUO LPAG, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria set forth in Article 7 of Decree Law No. 21907, as amended by Law No. 27659[56], the Sanctions Regulation and the TUO LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or the protected legal interest; c) The harm caused and the repercussion on the market; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; e) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; f) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; and g) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification;
- In accordance with Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, the offender's antecedents are considered to be the sanctions that became final within the four (4) years prior to the time of the commission of the infraction;
- In this regard, as to the infraction relating to not collecting orders from its client, specifically for the transactions of 9 and 11 December 2014, in application of the aforementioned Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, it should be noted that Kallpa SAB, with respect to said period, presents the following infraction antecedents:
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 004-2012-SMV/10 of 27 June 2012, Kallpa SAB was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred the serious infraction classified in Annex X, paragraph 2, subparagraph 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulation, for "Not having manuals, procedures, policies or internal control systems, in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations; or not complying with their provisions or not supervising their compliance." It should be noted that said resolution became consented and final since Kallpa SAB did not challenge the aforementioned sanction.
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 028-2014-SMV/10 of 13 November 2014, Kallpa SAB was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred two minor infractions classified in Annex I, paragraph 3, subparagraph 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, for "Not providing in a timely manner, or doing so incompletely, or without observing the technical specifications approved by the SMV or without communicating the approval by the corresponding corporate body, to the SMV, (...), the individual or consolidated audited financial information, the individual or consolidated interim financial statements, management report, additional audit report, material events, annual reports";
- It should be noted that these sanctions became consented since they were not subject to any challenge;
- Accordingly, it is concluded that Kallpa SAB does have a record of a final sanction imposed within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned;
- Regarding the seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or the protected legal interest, it should be noted that Kallpa SAB's conduct has affected the protected legal interest consisting of investor protection, since said SAB has breached its obligation to collect the orders subject to observation in accordance with the provisions of the LMV and the Regulation, which are intended to prevent harm to investors' interests; through compliance with the requirements established to carry out transactions on their behalf with the money or securities they have delivered to the brokerage firm, which includes complying with the modality or modalities agreed with the client to collect the orders supporting the execution of transactions, this could create insecurity and distrust among investors and other market participants
- As regards the economic harm caused and the repercussion on the market, it should be noted that no effect on this matter has been evidenced;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that according to the information in the file, Kallpa SAB had a commercial relationship with Mr. Catep since 14 June 2013, having received said SAB between 13 August and 10 December 2013 the total amount of US$ 150,000.00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the execution of transactions on behalf of the aforementioned client;
- Likewise, it should be noted that Mr. Catep also transferred his investment securities portfolio from Inversión y Desarrollo SAB to Kallpa SAB's master account on 8 April 2014;
- Thus, Mr. García, as Kallpa SAB's representative in the city of Arequipa, was in charge of carrying out the instructions given by Mr. Catep; however, it has been demonstrated in this resolution that for the transactions of 9 and 11 December 2014, Kallpa SAB did not collect the corresponding orders from Mr. Catep;
- It should be added that Mr. Catep is a client residing in the city of Arequipa, where Kallpa SAB had until December 2014 a commercial office in which Mr. García worked as representative; however, Kallpa SAB did not collect Mr. Catep's orders, since said intermediary has not accredited having the documentation that reliably proves that these orders were collected;
- With regard to the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it should be noted that in the present case no evidence of intentionality incurred by Kallpa SAB has been found;
- With regard to the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification, it should be noted that Kallpa SAB has not acknowledged the commission of the infraction relating to collecting orders from its client, in this case, from Mr. Catep; however, it has contributed to the clarification of the facts reported by said client;
- On the other hand, Article 236-A of Law No. 27444, the General Administrative Procedure Law, in force at the time the facts occurred, establishes that the following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for the commission of the administrative infraction:
- The voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subparagraph 3) of Article 235 of Law No. 27444.
- Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- In this regard, it should be noted that Kallpa SAB has not presented the original of the orders allegedly signed by Mr. Catep for the transactions of 9 and 11 December 2014;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the infraction relating to not collecting Mr. Catep's orders that are the subject of the charges has not been generated by an error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that said Article 236-A was amended by Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272, which incorporates and restructures the grounds for exemption and mitigation of liability[57]. It should be noted that said legal provision has been incorporated in Article 257, literal f) of the TUO LPAG, in force at the date;
- Accordingly, it is appropriate to evaluate the following criteria for graduation of the principle of reasonableness established in Article 248, paragraph 3 of the TUO LPAG:
- In relation to the probability of detection of the infraction, it is appropriate to note that the information provided by Kallpa SAB to the regulator did not reasonably evidence elements allowing knowledge of the infraction that is the subject of this administrative sanctioning proceeding.
It should be added, moreover, that in the case analyzed it was possible to detect the infraction committed by Kallpa SAB based on the facts set out by Mr. Catep in the complaint filed against said former brokerage firm;
- With reference to recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within the period of one (1) year from the time the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, it must be stated that, taking into account the period to be considered for purposes of determining recidivism, this has not occurred;
- As regards the grounds for exemption and mitigation of liability, in accordance with the provisions of Article 257 of the TUO LPAG, it is not observed that in the present case any of the grounds constituting conditions for exemption and mitigation of liability has been configured;
- From the foregoing, it is concluded that Kallpa SAB has incurred the commission of one (1) infraction classified as minor under the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, and therefore, in accordance with the provisions of Article 30 of the Sanctions Regulation, for the commission of minor infractions the offender is imposed a sanction of warning or a fine of not less than one (1) UIT nor more than twenty-five (25) UIT;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, paragraph 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- To declare that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex X, paragraph 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, in force at the time the facts occurred, by having contravened the provisions of Article 175 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, and Article 37 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the time the facts occurred, with respect to its obligation to collect the orders issued by Mr. Humberto Bernardo Catep Fadel on 9 and 11 December 2014.
Article 2.- To declare that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has not incurred a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, paragraph 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
Article 3.- To declare that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has not incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex I, paragraph 2, subparagraph 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
Article 4.- To sanction Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. with a fine of 10 UIT, equivalent to S/ 38,000.00 (Thirty-eight thousand and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infraction referred to in Article 1 of this resolution.
Article 5.- In accordance with Article 31 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, the offender on whom the sanction of a fine has been imposed for the commission of very serious, serious or minor infractions may request from the Administration Office a reduction of the amount to be paid, provided it accredits prior and joint compliance with the requirements set forth in said article.
Article 6.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 7.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by means of a reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of paragraph 1, Article 7 of the Policy on Publicity of Regulatory Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by Superintendency Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
Article 8.- To transcribe this resolution to Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
| ANNEX 1 (IN DOLLARS) | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| OPERATIONS CARRIED OUT BY KALLPA ON BEHALF OF MR. CATEP AND FUND MOVEMENTS | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | |
| OP. DATE | SETTLE. DATE | OPERATION TYPE | VALUE | QTY. | PRICE | POLICY | DEBIT | CREDIT | BALANCE |
| 01/04/14 | BALANCE | | | | | | | 925.59 |
| 08/04/14 | 11/04/14 | SALE | FNMA | 2,500 | 4.0640 | 201-002629 | | 10,045.07 | 10,970.66 |
| 11/04/14 | 16/04/14 | SALE | FMCC | 13,500 | 3.9259 | 201-002733 | | 52,395.94 | 63,366.60 |
| 11/04/14 | 16/04/14 | SALE | FNMA | 2,000 | 3.9500 | 201-002735 | | 7,810.08 | 71,176.68 |
| 14/04/14 | 21/04/14 | SALE | FMCC | 8,500 | 3.9388 | 201-002766 | | 33,098.65 | 104,275.33 |
| 23/04/14 | 28/04/14 | PURCHASE | RIO | 9,700 | 2.0222 | 201-002893 | 19,885.59 | | 84,389.74 |
| 12/05/14 | DIVIDEND | BVN | | | 001-0006929 | | 19.71 | 84,409.45 |
| 13/05/14 | 16/05/14 | PURCHASE | FMCC | 15,000 | 4.5100 | 201-003609 | 68,398.71 | | 16,010.74 |
| 15/05/14 | 20/05/14 | PURCHASE | FMCC | 1,000 | 4.5100 | 201-003685 | 4,559.92 | | 11,450.82 |
| 16/05/14 | 21/05/14 | PURCHASE | FMCC | 2,700 | 4.2037 | 201-003726 | 11,477.45 | 0.00 | -26.63 |
| 23/05/14 | 28/05/14 | PURCHASE | FREE | 6,600 | 1.1888 | 201-003870 | 7,981.44 | 0.00 | -8,008.07 |
| 23/05/14 | 28/05/14 | SALE | FMCC | 2,200 | 4.3323 | 201-003895 | | 9,424.65 | 1,416.58 |
| 10/06/14 | DIVIDEND | SCCO | | | 001-0007544 | | 261.90 | 1,678.48 |
| 13/06/14 | 18/06/14 | PURCHASE | FMCC | 1,100 | 4.2209 | 201-004407 | 4,695.10 | 0.00 | -3,016.62 |
| 13/06/14 | 18/06/14 | SALE | FREE | 6,600 | 0.8677 | 201-004416 | | 5,610.32 | 2,593.70 |
| 18/06/14 | 23/06/14 | PURCHASE | FNMA | 500 | 4.1000 | 201-004519 | 2,073.15 | | 520.55 |
| 19/06/14 | 24/06/14 | SALE | RIO | 5,000 | 2.3000 | 201-004565 | | 11,327.87 | 11,848.42 |
| 20/06/14 | 25/06/14 | SALE | RIO | 4,700 | 2.2800 | 201-004605 | | 10,586.81 | 22,435.23 |
| 23/06/14 | 26/06/14 | PURCHASE | FMCC | 2,000 | 3.8800 | 201-004622 | 7,848.68 | 0.00 | 14,586.55 |
| 23/06/14 | 26/06/14 | PURCHASE | FNMA | 3,000 | 3.9000 | 201-004623 | 11,833.55 | 0.00 | 2,753.00 |
| 24/06/14 | 27/06/14 | PURCHASE | FNMA | 700 | 3.8100 | 201-004648 | 2,697.60 | 0.00 | 55.40 |
| 01/07/14 | 01/07/14 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM001-008210 | 42.38 | 0.00 | 13.02 |
| 08/07/14 | 11/07/14 | SALE | SUE | 6,100 | 1.2800 | 101-009265 | | 7,740.66 | 7,753.68 |
| 08/07/14 | 11/07/14 | SALE | SCCO | 800 | 33.7000 | 101-009275 | | 26,727.49 | 34,481.17 |
| 09/07/14 | 14/07/14 | PURCHASE | LGC | 29,824 | 1.1400 | 101-009329 | 34,292.59 | 0.00 | 188.58 |
| 11/07/14 | 16/07/14 | SALE | LGC | 29,824 | 1.2000 | 101-009516 | | 35,480.13 | 35,668.71 |
| 15/07/14 | 18/07/14 | PURCHASE | SCCO | 34 | 32.6000 | 101-009636 | 1,140.55 | | 34,528.16 |
| 16/07/14 | 21/07/14 | PURCHASE | SCCO | 200 | 33.1900 | 201-005106 | 6,644.57 | | 27,883.59 |
| 16/07/14 | 21/07/14 | SALE | FMCC | 600 | 4.1167 | 201-005117 | | 2,442.13 | 30,325.72 |
| 16/07/14 | 21/07/14 | SALE | FNMA | 1,400 | 4.2586 | 201-005118 | | 5,895.21 | 36,220.93 |
| 16/07/14 | 21/07/14 | SALE | SCCO | 200 | 33.0300 | 201-005120 | | 6,599.44 | 42,820.37 |
| 16/07/14 | 16/07/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006063 | 89.47 | | 42,730.90 |
| 17/07/14 | 22/07/14 | PURCHASE | SCCO | 500 | 32.6000 | 101-009772 | 16,440.58 | | 26,290.32 |
| 17/07/14 | 22/07/14 | SALE | FNMA | 800 | 4.5550 | 201-005168 | | 3,606.50 | 29,896.82 |
| 17/07/14 | 22/07/14 | SALE | FMCC | 200 | 4.4200 | 201-005167 | | 849.50 | 30,746.32 |
| 18/07/14 | 23/07/14 | PURCHASE | SCCO | 300 | 32.4000 | 101-009889 | 9,803.83 | | 20,942.49 |
| 18/07/14 | 23/07/14 | PURCHASE | SCCO | 200 | 32.4200 | 201-005188 | 6,490.53 | | 14,451.96 |
| 18/07/14 | 23/07/14 | SALE | FMCC | 1,200 | 4.3300 | 201-005196 | | 5,137.47 | 19,589.43 |
| 18/07/14 | 23/07/14 | SALE | FNMA | 800 | 4.3700 | 201-005197 | | 3,464.57 | 23,054.00 |
| 18/07/14 | 23/07/14 | SALE | SCCO | 200 | 32.4900 | 201-005201 | | 6,491.47 | 29,545.47 |
| 21/07/14 | 24/07/14 | PURCHASE | SUE | 15,384 | 1.3000 | 101-009971 | 20,171.69 | | 9,373.78 |
| 21/07/14 | 24/07/14 | PURCHASE | FNMA | 1,000 | 4.2500 | 201-005216 | 4,292.60 | | 5,081.18 |
| 21/07/14 | 24/07/14 | SALE | FMCC | 600 | 4.1867 | 201-005235 | | 2,483.77 | 7,564.95 |
| 21/07/14 | 24/07/14 | SALE | FNMA | 800 | 4.2200 | 201-005236 | | 3,338.10 | 10,903.05 |
| 23/07/14 | 30/07/14 | SALE | SCCO | 834 | 32.9299 | 101-010241 | | 27,226.73 | 38,129.78 |
| 23/07/14 | 30/07/14 | PURCHASE | CVERDEC1 | 983 | 25.4000 | 101-010193 | 25,183.55 | | 12,946.23 |
| 30/07/14 | 04/08/14 | PURCHASE | MPLE | 75,940 | 0.15300 | 101-010578 | 11,719.03 | | 1,227.20 |
| 31/07/14 | 05/08/14 | SALE | CVERDEC1 | 55 | 25.60000 | 101-010747 | | 1,375.73 | 2,602.93 |
| 05/08/14 | 05/08/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006415 | 0.55 | | 2,602.38 |
| 06/08/14 | 11/08/14 | SALE | MPLE | 75,940 | 0.16200 | 101-011042 | | 12,196.19 | 14,798.57 |
| 11/08/14 | 11/08/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006490 | 37.97 | | 14,760.60 |
| 14/08/14 | 19/08/14 | PURCHASE | LGC | 12,903 | 0.93000 | 101-011586 | 12,103.33 | | 2,657.27 |
| 18/08/14 | 21/08/14 | SALE | CVERDEC1 | 928 | 25.20000 | 101-011762 | | 23,183.90 | 25,841.17 |
| 19/08/14 | 22/08/14 | PURCHASE | PML | 29,050 | 0.39900 | 101-011846 | 11,690.91 | | 14,150.26 |
| 21/08/14 | 26/08/14 | PURCHASE | SCCO | 420 | 31.00000 | 101-011952 | 13,132.29 | | 1,017.97 |
| 21/08/14 | 26/08/14 | SALE | RIO | 10,000 | 2.70000 | 101-011957 | | 26,767.13 | 27,785.10 |
| 21/08/14 | 26/08/14 | SALE | BVN | 1,069 | 13.20000 | 101-011962 | | 13,989.11 | 41,774.21 |
| 22/08/14 | 27/08/14 | PURCHASE | LGC | 20,000 | 0.81925 | 101-012029 | 16,526.32 | | 25,247.89 |
| 22/08/14 | 27/08/14 | PURCHASE | TV | 36,315 | 1.19845 | 101-012038 | 43,897.08 | | -18,649.19 |
| 22/08/14 | 27/08/14 | PURCHASE | YHOO | 1,700 | 37.99765 | 201-006160 | 65,184.67 | | -83,833.86 |
| 22/08/14 | 27/08/14 | SALE | PML | 29,050 | 0.42500 | 101-012042 | | 12,239.76 | -71,594.10 |
| 22/08/14 | 27/08/14 | SALE | RIO | 10,479 | 2.72000 | 101-012048 | | 28,257.06 | -43,337.04 |
| 22/08/14 | 27/08/14 | SALE | SCCO | 2,239 | 32.00000 | 101-012054 | | 71,030.08 | 27,693.04 |
| 27/08/14 | 27/08/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006729 | 225.00 | | 27,468.04 |
| 27/08/14 | 27/08/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006743 | 43.58 | | 27,424.46 |
| 28/08/14 | 28/08/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006747 | 246.26 | | 27,178.20 |
| 28/08/14 | DIVIDEND | SCCO | | | 001-0006929 | | 218.28 | 27,396.48 |
| 27/08/14 | 01/09/14 | SALE | TV | 36,315 | 1.26000 | 101-012263 | | 45,362.26 | 72,758.74 |
| 29/08/14 | 03/09/14 | PURCHASE | MPLE | 303,150 | 0.11000 | 101-012401 | 33,634.09 | | 39,124.65 |
| 29/08/14 | 03/09/14 | PURCHASE | TV | 30,066 | 1.22000 | 101-012399 | 36,996.88 | | 2,127.77 |
| 01/09/14 | 01/09/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0007183 | 108.95 | | 2,018.82 |
| 02/09/14 | 05/09/14 | SALE | YHOO | 1,700 | 39.25824 | 201-006493 | | 66,170.73 | 68,189.55 |
| 03/09/14 | 08/09/14 | PURCHASE | DGAZ | 10,000 | 4.45000 | 201-006502 | 44,972.82 | | 23,216.73 |
| 03/09/14 | 08/09/14 | PURCHASE | FMCC | 5,000 | 3.76000 | 201-006511 | 19,007.51 | | 4,209.22 |
| 03/09/14 | 08/09/14 | PURCHASE | ISNS | 12,000 | 8.67500 | 201-006518 | 105,141.29 | | -100,932.07 |
| 03/09/14 | 08/09/14 | SALE | MPLE | 303,150 | 0.11700 | 101-012708 | | 35,162.65 | -65,769.42 |
| 03/09/14 | 08/09/14 | SALE | ISNS | 12,000 | 9.10146 | 201-006551 | | 108,130.93 | 42,361.51 |
| 04/09/14 | 09/09/14 | PURCHASE | ISNS | 9,000 | 7.44444 | 201-006576 | 67,635.53 | | -25,274.02 |
| 04/09/14 | 09/09/14 | SALE | DGAZ | 10,000 | 4.61000 | 201-006593 | | 45,624.65 | 20,350.63 |
| 08/09/14 | 08/09/14 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0006887 | 151.58 | | 20,199.05 |
| 08/09/14 | 11/09/14 | PURCHASE | ISNS | 1,500 | 6.30000 | 201-006681 | 9,537.49 | | 10,661.56 |
| 08/09/14 | 11/09/14 | SALE | ISNS | 1,500 | 7.37400 | 201-006708 | | 10,954.63 | 21,616.19 |
| 09/09/14 | 12/09/14 | PURCHASE | ISNS | 2,000 | 6.28000 | 201-006739 | 12,680.78 | | 8,935.41 |
| 09/09/14 | 12/09/14 | PURCHASE | MPLE | 120,960 | 0.12200 | 101-012985 | 14,884.39 | | -5,948.98 |
| 09/09/14 | 12/09/14 | SALE | ISNS | 1,500 | 6.85000 | 201-006772 | | 10,169.06 | 4,220.08 |
| 10/09/14 | 15/09/14 | PURCHASE | ISNS | 700 | 5.75000 | 201-006797 | 4,062.87 | | 157.21 |
| 12/09/14 | 17/09/14 | PURCHASE | NETE | 100 | 4.70000 | 201-006912 | 471.81 | | -314.60 |
| 12/09/14 | 17/09/14 | SALE | NETE | 100 | 5.00000 | 201-006958 | | 498.12 | 183.52 |
| 18/09/14 | 23/09/14 | PURCHASE | TV | 16,000 | 1.16000 | 101-013399 | 18,720.08 | | -18,536.56 |
| 18/09/14 | 23/09/14 | SALE | ISNS | 5,000 | 4.02400 | 201-007163 | | 19,927.55 | 1,390.99 |
| 21/10/14 | 24/10/14 | PURCHASE | NUGT | 2,000 | 21.87500 | 201-008250 | 44,131.38 | | -42,740.39 |
| 22/10/14 | 27/10/14 | SALE | ISNS | 5,200 | 2.95000 | 201-008337 | | 15,161.29 | -27,579.10 |
| 23/10/14 | 28/10/14 | SALE | FMCC | 5,000 | 2.20000 | 201-008402 | | 10,859.14 | -16,719.96 |
| 23/10/14 | 28/10/14 | SALE | FNMA | 1,400 | 2.28000 | 201-008403 | | 3,151.64 | -13,568.32 |
| 24/10/14 | 29/10/14 | PURCHASE | LAKE | 2,000 | 14.71250 | 201-008436 | 29,583.89 | | -43,152.21 |
| 24/10/14 | 29/10/14 | SALE | LAKE | 2,000 | 13.21010 | 201-008465 | | 26,306.67 | -16,845.54 |
| 24/10/14 | 24/10/14 | CREDIT | | | | CM002-009426 | | 899.52 | -15,946.02 |
| 28/10/14 | 31/10/14 | SALE | NUGT | 500 | 18.90000 | 201-008584 | | 9,383.66 | -6,562.36 |
| 28/10/14 | 31/10/14 | SALE | FMCC | 2,000 | 2.25000 | 201-008589 | | 4,450.79 | -2,111.57 |
| 31/10/14 | 31/10/14 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM002-9454 | | 2,111.57 | 0.00 |
| 04/11/14 | 07/11/14 | PURCHASE | NUGT | 3,000 | 11.45000 | 201-008883 | 34,643.47 | | -34,643.47 |
| 07/11/14 | 07/11/14 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM002-009496 | | 5,021.61 | -29,621.86 |
| 07/11/14 | 12/11/14 | PURCHASE | BVN | 3,000 | 9.55000 | 201-009045 | 28,882.84 | | -58,504.70 |
| 07/11/14 | 12/11/14 | SALE | BVN | 500 | 9.80010 | 201-009068 | | 4,860.36 | -53,644.34 |
| 07/11/14 | 12/11/14 | SALE | NUGT | 3,000 | 12.11667 | 201-009077 | | 35,998.30 | -17,646.04 |
| 12/11/14 | 17/11/14 | PURCHASE | RIO | 531 | 2.29000 | 201-009219 | 1,228.47 | | -18,874.51 |
| 12/11/14 | 17/11/14 | PURCHASE | JNUG | 10,000 | 3.72500 | 201-009237 | 37,679.67 | | -56,554.18 |
| 12/11/14 | 17/11/14 | SALE | JNUG | 10,000 | 3.87500 | 201-009266 | | 38,307.06 | -18,247.12 |
| 14/11/14 | 19/11/14 | SALE | RIO | 531 | 2.23000 | 201-009367 | | 1,169.73 | -17,077.39 |
| 14/11/14 | 19/11/14 | SALE | BVN | 2,000 | 9.07500 | 201-009373 | | 17,990.78 | 913.39 |
| 20/11/14 | 25/11/14 | PURCHASE | BVN | 2,400 | 9.38999 | 201-009557 | 22,732.82 | | -21,819.43 |
| 20/11/14 | 25/11/14 | PURCHASE | NUGT | 1,500 | 14.90000 | 201-009567 | 22,562.80 | | -44,382.23 |
| 20/11/14 | 25/11/14 | SALE | NUGT | 3,000 | 15.37500 | 201-009599 | | 45,700.46 | 1,318.23 |
| 21/11/14 | 26/11/14 | PURCHASE | NUGT | 1,500 | 15.20000 | 201-009621 | 23,003.33 | | -21,685.10 |
| 21/11/14 | 26/11/14 | PURCHASE | FNMA | 10,000 | 2.50000 | 201-009628 | 25,291.75 | | -46,976.85 |
| 21/11/14 | 26/11/14 | SALE | BVN | 2,900 | 9.90209 | 201-009645 | | 28,432.91 | -18,543.94 |
| 21/11/14 | 26/11/14 | SALE | NUGT | 1,500 | 15.75000 | 201-009655 | | 23,414.85 | 4,870.91 |
| 02/12/14 | 05/12/14 | PURCHASE | UGAZ | 3,500 | 10.93571 | 201-009937 | 38,535.83 | | -33,664.92 |
| 02/12/14 | 05/12/14 | SALE | UGAZ | 2,000 | 10.54000 | 201-009967 | | 20,997.81 | -12,667.11 |
| 03/12/14 | 09/12/14 | SALE | FMCC | 5,000 | 2.32000 | 201-0010030 | | 11,481.56 | -1,185.55 |
| 03/12/14 | 09/12/14 | SALE | FNMA | 2,000 | 2.38000 | 201-010031 | | 4,711.92 | 3,526.37 |
| 04/12/14 | 10/12/14 | PURCHASE | UGAZ | 5,000 | 9.24400 | 201-010047 | 46,379.08 | | -42,852.71 |
| 04/12/14 | 10/12/14 | SALE | UGAZ | 3,000 | 8.72000 | 201-010068 | | 26,068.26 | -16,784.45 |
| 05/12/14 | 11/12/14 | SALE | UGAZ | 2,300 | 9.43913 | 201-010113 | | 21,558.91 | 4,774.46 |
| 05/12/14 | 05/12/14 | DIVIDEND | BVN | | | 001-0009016 | | 55.14 | 4,829.60 |
| 09/12/14 | 09/12/14 | DIVIDEND | BVN | | | 001-0009080 | | 17.64 | 4,847.24 |
| 09/12/14 | 12/12/14 | PURCHASE | JNUG | 10,000 | 3.61500 | 201-010150 | 36,463.29 | | -31,616.05 |
| 09/12/14 | 12/12/14 | SALE | JNUG | 5,000 | 3.65010 | 201-010188 | | 18,092.82 | -13,523.23 |
| 11/12/14 | 16/12/14 | PURCHASE | UGAZ | 2,000 | 8.44000 | 201-010251 | 17,019.51 | | -30,542.74 |
| 11/12/14 | 16/12/14 | SALE | BVN | 800 | 10.10000 | 101-016582 | | 8,010.32 | -22,532.42 |
| 11/12/14 | 16/12/14 | SALE | UGAZ | 2,000 | 8.60010 | 201-010282 | | 17,058.42 | -5,474.00 |
| 11/12/14 | 16/12/14 | SALE | FMCC | 5,000 | 2.32000 | 201-010298 | | 11,467.87 | 5,993.87 |
| ANNEX 2 (IN SOLES) | | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| OPERATIONS CARRIED OUT BY KALLPA ON BEHALF OF MR. CATEP | | | | | | | | | |
| AND FUND MOVEMENTS | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | |
| OP. DATE | SETTLE. DATE | OPERATION TYPE | VALUE | QTY. | PRICE | POLICY | DEBIT | CREDIT | BALANCE |
| 01/06/2014 | | | | | | | | 0.00 |
| 23/06/2014 | 26/06/2014 | SALE | SIDERC1 | 0.4100 | 59,848 | 101-005808 | | 24,326.06 | 24,326.06 |
| 24/06/2014 | 27/06/2014 | PURCHASE | RELAPAC1 | 0.3340 | 71,850 | 101-008599 | 24,204.88 | | 121.18 |
| 26/06/2014 | 26/06/2014 | WITHHOLDING | | | | RET01-0005788 | 239.39 | | -118.21 |
| 01/07/2014 | 01/07/2014 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM002-00008210 | | 118.21 | 0.00 |
| 23/07/2014 | 30/07/2014 | SALE | RELAPAC1 | 0.3300 | 71,800 | 101-010160 | | 23,489.66 | 23,489.66 |
| 30/07/2014 | 04/08/2014 | PURCHASE | ATACOBC1 | 0.2620 | 86,790 | 101-010537 | 22,935.09 | 0.00 | 554.57 |
| 01/08/2014 | 06/08/2014 | SALE | ATACOBC1 | 0.2780 | 86,790 | 101-010801 | | 23,919.53 | 24,474.10 |
| 05/08/2014 | 08/08/2014 | PURCHASE | SIDERC1 | 0.3600 | 35,402 | 101-010901 | 12,854.63 | 0.00 | 11,619.47 |
| 06/08/2014 | 11/08/2014 | PURCHASE | SIDERC1 | 0.3500 | 32,700 | 101-010991 | 11,550.70 | 0.00 | 68.77 |
| 06/08/2014 | 06/08/2014 | WITHHOLDING | | 1.2000 | 29,824 | RET01-0006429 | 86.79 | | -18.02 |
| 21/08/2014 | 21/08/2014 | REFUND OF WITHHOLDING JULY 2014 | | | | IC001-0010579 | | 248.91 | 230.89 |
| 22/09/2014 | 22/09/2014 | REFUND OF GK FUNDS - AUGUST 2014 | | | | IC001-0010850 | | 1,652.71 | 1,883.60 |
| 22/10/2014 | 22/10/2014 | REFUND OF GK FUNDS - SEPTEMBER 2014 | | | | IC001-0011324 | | 741.19 | 2,624.79 |
| 24/10/2014 | 24/10/2014 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM001-009426 | 2,624.79 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| 28/10/2014 | 31/10/2014 | SALE | SIDERC1 | 0.3100 | 68,102 | 101-014962 | | 20,929.54 | 20,929.54 |
| 31/10/2014 | 31/10/2014 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM001-009454 | 6,191.12 | 0.00 | 14,738.42 |
| 07/11/2014 | 07/11/2014 | CURRENCY EXCHANGE | | | | CM001-009496 | 14,738.42 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
-
In force as of December 31, 2016. ↑
-
It should be noted that said obligation is currently maintained in article 83 of the current Regulation. ↑
-
The transferred amount is 440,058. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Rio Alto Mining Ltd. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Image Sensing Systems, Inc. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Direxion Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (ETF). ↑
-
Common shares issued by FreeSeas Inc. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Lakeland Industries, Inc. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Velocity Shares 3X Long Natural (ETF). ↑
-
Common shares issued by Direxion Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3X Shares (ETF). ↑
-
Common shares issued by the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac). ↑
-
Common shares issued by the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae). ↑
-
Common shares issued by Maple Energy Plc. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Trevali Mining Corporation. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Luna Gold Corp. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Net Element Inc. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Panoro Minerals Ltd. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Yahoo!. ↑
-
Some of these shares passed to Kallpa SAB as a result of the transfer ordered by Mr. Catep on April 8, 2014, as stated by the complainant in his complaint and the information held by CAVALI, and others were acquired by Mr. Catep up to April 14, 2014. ↑
-
Using a global account in the name of Kallpa SAB. ↑
-
Which is the entirety of Mr. Catep's funds according to the account statement of said client for the month of April 2014 submitted by Kallpa SAB. ↑
-
In May 2014, Rio Alto Mining Ltd. and Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. reached an agreement under which Rio Alto Mining Ltd. acquired all outstanding shares issued by Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. (SUE) in exchange for 0.525 of a common share issued by Rio Alto Mining Ltd. (RIO). This transaction was settled at CAVALI on August 13, 2014. ↑
-
As a consequence of the agreement between Rio Alto Mining Ltd. and Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. ↑
-
The recording is in the file. ↑
-
Although Mr. Catep in his email of March 1, 2015 states that he is dismayed by the movements made by Mr. García "to date", it should be noted that no operations were carried out on behalf of Mr. Catep between December 12, 2014 and March 1, 2015. ↑
-
The exact amount he had as of April 14, 2014 was 59,848 shares. ↑
-
With the exception of one (01) purchase operation of SUE shares on July 21, 2014. ↑
-
In May 2014, Rio Alto Mining Ltd. and Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. reached an agreement under which Rio Alto Mining Ltd. acquired all outstanding shares issued by Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. (SUE) in exchange for 0.525 of a common share issued by Rio Alto Mining Ltd. (RIO). This transaction was settled at CAVALI on August 13, 2014. ↑
-
With the exception of one (01) purchase operation of SUE shares on July 21, 2014. ↑
-
The recordings are in the file. ↑
-
Amount equal to the fund balance as of December 31, 2014, given that in January and February 2015 there were no credits or debits of funds in Mr. Catep's dollar current account and the soles account was at zero as of December 31, 2014, and in January and February 2015 only account maintenance charges were added. ↑
-
The recording of this conversation is in the file. ↑
-
The recording of this conversation is in the file. ↑
-
The exact amount was US$ 23,430.36. ↑
-
The exact amount was US$ 23,430.36 ↑
-
The recording is in the file. ↑
-
The recording is in the file. ↑
-
The recording is in the file. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Trevali Mining Corporation. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Luna Gold Corp. ↑
-
The recording is in the file. ↑
-
The sale was of 36,315 shares. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Maple Energy PLC. ↑
-
ADRs issued by Compañía de Minas Buenaventura S.A.A. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Empresa Siderúrgica del Perú S.A.A. - SIDERPERÚ ↑
-
Mr. Catep mentions the approximate amount of 59,900. ↑
-
In May 2014, Rio Alto Mining Ltd. and Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. reached an agreement under which Rio Alto Mining Ltd. acquired all outstanding shares issued by Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. (SUE) in exchange for 0.525 of a common share issued by Rio Alto Mining Ltd. (RIO). This transaction was settled at CAVALI on August 13, 2014. ↑
-
This is the only operation in the period from April 15 to December 31, 2014 that he acknowledges in his complaint. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Compañía Minera Atacocha S.A.A. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Refinería La Pampilla S.A.A. ↑
-
The cited provisions are currently regulated in article 49 of the current Regulation. ↑
-
It should be noted that the requirements that the agent must meet for the intermediation of financial instruments traded abroad are currently regulated in article 63 of the current Regulation. ↑
-
Obligation set forth in article 51 of the Current Regulation. ↑
-
Article 255.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following constitute conditions exempting from liability for infractions:
(…)
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense. ↑
-
Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
3. Reasonableness.- The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct does not prove more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed rules or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, observing the following criteria indicated for their graduation:
a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction;
b) The probability of detection of the infraction;
c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right;
d) The economic harm caused;
e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the date the resolution sanctioning the first infraction became final.
f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and
g) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct. ↑
-
Through Law No. 27659, article 7 of Decree Law No. 21907 was amended, providing that collective fund management companies that contravene the provisions of said decree or the regulatory rules issued by the SMV shall be sanctioned taking into consideration the offender's background, the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, the harm caused and its impact on the market. ↑
-
"Article 255.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following constitute conditions exempting from liability for infractions:
a) Duly proven fortuitous event or force majeure.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the ability to understand the infraction.
d) The binding order of a competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) Error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) Voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 235.
2.- The following constitute conditions mitigating liability for infractions:
a) If, after an administrative sanctioning proceeding has been initiated, the offender expressly and in writing acknowledges responsibility. In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount no less than half of its amount.
b) Others established by special rule.” ↑