Enforcement · SMV · 31 Mar 2023
Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is sanctioned with a reprimand for three serious infractions under Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation. The firm failed to provide the SMV with information on prudential limits or margins, specifically the Equity Risk indicator, in structured files dated 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, contrary to articles 109 and Annex L of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents.
PERÚ Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas
SMV
Superintendency of the Market de Valores
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of unity, peace and development"
Lima, 31 de marzo de 2023
Summary: Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is sanctioned with a reprimand, for having incurred three (3) serious infractions: typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not providing the SMV with information on prudential limits or margins in accordance with the provisions of the regulations.
Administrado
:
Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A Asunto :
Administrative sanctioning procedure
Expediente N° :
2022027351
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
Administrative file No. 2022027351, and Report No. 1520-2022-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as the discharges and arguments presented by Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.;
1. Pursuant to article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
2. As a result of the supervision activities, indications of possible infractions were determined on the part of Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A (hereinafter, KALLPA SAB), inasmuch as it would have failed to comply with the provisions of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, RAI);
3. Under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, approved by D.S. No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO DE LA LPAG), by means of Official Letter No. 3482- 2022-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES), notified on 01 July 2022, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against KALLPA SAB regarding the facts evidenced in the investigation carried out;
4. By brief of 12 July 2022, KALLPA SAB presented the requested discharges;
5. The charges formulated against KALLPA SAB and the discharges of the latter have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 1520-2022- SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
6. In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in article 230, subsection 2, of the TUO LPAG, by means of Official Letter No. 5728-2022-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 1520-2022-SMV/10.3 was made available to KALLPA SAB for its review;
7. On 15 December 2022, the stock brokerage company presented its oral report;
8. On 16 December 2022, KALLPA SAB submitted additional written arguments;
9. In this administrative proceeding, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it is appropriate to determine the following:
a. Whether KALLPA SAB incurred or not an infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, in force as of 19 December 2018 (hereinafter, SANCTIONS REGULATION), by not having complied with observing article 109 and Annex L, subparagraphs a), b) and c) of the RAI, by not having provided information on the Equity Risk indicator in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in the structured file dated 15 February 2019;
b. Whether KALLPA SAB incurred or not an infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, for not having complied with observing the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subparagraph a) of the RAI, by not having provided information on the Equity Risk indicator in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in the structured file dated 26 March 2019;
c. Whether KALLPA SAB incurred or not an infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, for not having complied with observing the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subparagraph c) of the RAI, by not having provided information on the Equity Risk indicator in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in the structured file dated 24 May 2019;
d. Whether or not a sanction should be imposed on KALLPA SAB;
10. Articles 99, 106 and 109 of the RAI establish the following:
“Article 99.- Prudential limits The Agent must comply with and maintain adequate control of the following prudential limits or margins:
(…)
c) Solvency Indicators:
1. Equity Risk Indicator.
(…)”;
“Article 102.- Rejection The SMV shall reject the information submitted by an Agent regarding its prudential limits, when any of the situations detailed below is verified:
a) Non-compliance with the provisions established for its determination and submission; or,
b) Lack or non-existence of the documentation, records and other information that supports the information submitted by the Agent.
The rejection of said information, regardless of the additional measures that may be appropriate, implies that the Agent has not complied with the obligations indicated in this title, and therefore the provisions of article 101 apply.”
“Article 106.- Equity risk indicator The equity risk indicator results from dividing the risk exposure of the own portfolio in accordance with article 109 by the Agent's liquid equity
(…)”;
"Article 109.- Exposure to the risk of the own portfolio The exposure to the risk of the Agent's own portfolio is the sum of all holdings of Financial Instruments owned by the Agent weighted by the factor corresponding to each of them.
The Agent must calculate its exposure to the risk of the own portfolio at the end of each day, in accordance with the factors and procedures established in Annex L";
11. In relation to this, Annex L, subsection a) of the RAI establishes the following:
"ANNEX L: DETERMINATION OF THE LEVEL OF EXPOSURE TO THE RISK OF THE OWN PORTFOLIO
a) Own portfolio
For the calculation, Financial Instruments that meet the following conditions are considered as own holdings:
1. Those that are registered in its name, have no lien or encumbrance whatsoever and are freely available for sale by the Agent, except those whose purpose is the settlement of the second transaction of a securities loan. This exception does not apply for the purposes of the provisions of subsection b) of article 111 when the term for said settlement is greater than three (3) days;
2. Financial Instruments that have been acquired for own account and are pending settlement. Those appearing in the name of clients in the Agent's global accounts are excluded;
3. Those received in securities lending when the Agent acts as borrower, in the part pending repurchase to comply with the settlement of the second transaction of a securities loan; 4. Those delivered in securities lending when the Agent acts as lender; and,
5. Financial Instruments delivered as collateral, whether in transactions where the agent acts as reportado or as borrower, or other type of encumbrance.
(...)";
Financial Instruments sold pending settlement are not considered in this calculation. Additionally, the derivative instruments in which the Agent operates for its own account are considered, as well as the position in a currency other than its functional currency.
(...)";
12. In relation to the valuation criteria of financial instruments, Annex L, subsection b) of the RAI establishes the following:
"ANNEX L: DETERMINATION OF THE LEVEL OF EXPOSURE TO THE RISK OF THE OWN PORTFOLIO
(...)
b) Valuation criteria
Securities issued by entities of the Peruvian State must be valued at fair value, or at the price provided by Price Provider Companies when they remain in the own portfolio for more than three (3) days.
The valuation of other Financial Instruments must be carried out at fair value or at the price provided by Price Provider Companies, as applicable.
(...)";
13. Regarding the obligation to value with price provider companies the financial instruments in which brokerage agents invest for their own account, article 2 of Supreme Decree No. 033-2016-EF, by which "They determine entities obligated to value their investments by price provider companies", establishes the following:
"Article 2. Entities obligated to value their investments by price provider companies
(...)
1) The entities that are obligated to value at prices or rates provided by price provider companies, the securities, financial instruments or other investments authorized by the SMV, in which they invest for their own account, are the following:
a) Stock Exchanges;
b) Securities Clearing and Settlement Institutions;
c) Entities responsible for the Conduction of Centralized Negotiation Mechanisms;
d) Stock Brokerage Firms;
e) Securities Intermediary Firms;
(...)";
14. Along the same lines, article 5A of the Regulation of Price Provider Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 101-2009-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments, establishes the following:
"Article 5A. FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS OR OPERATIONS THAT MUST BE VALUED AT PRICES PROVIDED BY A PRICE PROVIDER COMPANY
Entities must value at prices provided by a Price Provider Company the following financial instruments or operations:
a) Securities issued by State entities, negotiated in Peru or abroad;
b) Debt-representative instruments, placed by public or private offering, negotiated in Peru or abroad;
c) Derivative instruments; and,
d) Others determined by the Superintendent of the Securities Market.;
(...)" (underlining added);
15. Regarding the weighting factors, Annex L, subsection c), of the RAI, states the following:
"(...)
2. Debt-representative instruments
To calculate the level of exposure of the Agent's own portfolio, the following will be applied to its valuation:
For Financial Instruments representing debt whose holding by the Agent with respect to an individual issuer or a group of related issuers is equal to or greater than the limit of 10% of the Agent's net book equity, a factor of 1.00 will be applied to the excess of said limit. This weighting will be applied during the days that the excess over the limit remains.
In the other cases, the following factors must be considered:
Classifications of Long-Term Debt Instruments, of the International Market
(...)
Classifications of Long-Term Debt Instruments, of the Local Market
(...)
To the factors determined in accordance with the provisions of this numeral, except for cases of concentration or in which the factor by classification is 1.00, the factor corresponding to the term for the maturity of the Financial Instrument is applied, as indicated in the following table:
Factors according to term for maturity
(...)" (underlining added);
16. By means of Official Letter No. 983-2019-SMV/10.21, notified on 22 February 2019, KALLPA SAB was requested to submit the documentary support for the structured file "Exposure to the risk of the own portfolio" (hereinafter, ECP) corresponding to 15 February 2019, as well as to explain the reasons why the TV shares issued by Trevali Mining Corporation were not included in the structured file ECP; therefore, in response to the aforementioned official letter, KALLPA SAB regarding the TV shares, indicated the following:
"(...) At the time of generating the indicators process, there was this inconsistency in our information system, which is why the correct quantity of the TV Security was not processed, so we will proceed to rectify and resend the indicators for the day 15.02.2019 (...)"
17. In this regard, KALLPA SAB was charged with not having reported the TV shares as part of the structured file ECP of 15 February 2019, which on that date were part of its own portfolio according to the information recorded in CAVALI S.A. ICLV. Therefore, KALLPA SAB would have infringed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection a) of the RAI, as it would not have provided information on the Equity Risk Indicator (hereinafter, IRP) in accordance with the regulations, since this results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106 of the RAI;
18. From the review of the information submitted by KALLPA SAB, inconsistencies were detected in the "Price" field of the structured file ECP, corresponding to 15 February 2019, regarding the debt instrument (hereinafter, IRD) identified with ticker "LUSUR3BC1A" issued by the company Luz del Sur, in which a price equal to zero (0) was recorded;
19. According to the information2 submitted by the price provider company named Valuadora y Proveedora de Precios del Perú S.A., used by KALLPA SAB for the valuation of its instruments, the price for the instrument "LUSUR3BC1A" was 106.192%;
20. For this reason, by means of Official Letter No. 983-2019-SMV/10.2, KALLPA SAB was requested to provide support for the price of said instrument. In response to the aforementioned Official Letter, KALLPA SAB stated the following:
"(...) At the time of generating the indicators process, there was this inconsistency in our information system, which is why the correct price of the security LUSUR3BC1A was not processed, so we will proceed to rectify and resend the indicators for the day 15.02.2019"
21. Based on the foregoing, KALLPA SAB was charged with having infringed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection b) of the RAI, given
[1] File No. 2019006959.
[2] Price Vector File (VP_15022019.xml) contained in file 2019006664.
that inconsistencies have been detected regarding the price of the instrument with ticker "LUSUR3BC1A" in the structured file ECP corresponding to 15 February 2019, as it would not have provided information on the IRP in accordance with the regulations, since this results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106 of the RAI;
22. Considering that, according to Annex L, subsection c), numeral 2 of the RAI, the determination of the weighting factor for debt instruments is calculated by multiplying the risk classification factor (hereinafter, FCR) by the maturity term factor (hereinafter, FPV), except for cases of concentration or in which the risk classification factor is 1. In such cases, the weighting factor will be equal to the FCR. It should be noted that to calculate the FCR and the FPV, the provisions of Annex L, subsection c) of the RAI are used;
23. According to the provisions of Official Letter No. 983-2019-SMV/10.2, as of 15 February 2019 and according to the information used from the Bloomberg Terminal, the factors determined do not match the factors used by KALLPA SAB, as detailed below;
24. In the first group of financial instruments reviewed for the date 15 February 2019, considering that the FCR with equivalences BBB+ or higher corresponds to a factor of one (1), the weighting factors will also be one (1). Therefore, it is detailed in the following table that KALLPA SAB would have reported the following:
Recalculation of the weighting factors as of 15/02/2019
| Weighting factor | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information date | Registered Flag | IF Code | Risk classification | Risk classification factor | According to KALLPA | According to SMV |
| 15/02/2019 | Not Registered | HUNT OIL 28 | BBB- | 1.00 | 0.063 | 1.00 |
| 15/02/2019 | Not Registered | SMIPET 22 | BB | 1.00 | 0.063 | 1.00 |
| 15/02/2019 | Not Registered | PFAVHC 20 | B- | 1.00 | 0.25 | 1.00 |
| 15/02/2019 | Registered | BNCOM0BS22 | BBB | 1.00 | 0.40 | 1.00 |
| 15/02/2019 | Not Registered | COZCAR 22 | B+ | 1.00 | 0.40 | 1.00 |
| 15/02/2019 | Not Registered | CREDVA 22 | B+ | 1.00 | 0.40 | 1.00 |
| 15/02/2019 | Not Registered | SWY 4 ¾ | B+ | 1.00 | 0.4 | 1.00 |
25. In the second group of financial instruments reviewed as of 15 February 2019, differences were found in the FCR and FPV. The FCR of the instrument with mnemonic “LUSUR3BC1A” corresponds to a factor of 0.2, since its classification is AAA within the long-term debt instrument classifications of the local market; however, KALLPA SAB assigned it a value of 0.1;
26. On the other hand, the FPV for the instruments with mnemonics “T 2 7/8 11/30/23” and “EDP4BC9A” is 0.4, since the maturity terms are between 3 and 5 years; however, KALLPA SAB assigned values of 0.6 and 0.25, respectively. Because the differences occur in the FCR and FPV, the weighting factors are also affected, as detailed in the following table;
Recalculation of the FCR and FPV as of 15/02/2019
Risk classification factor
Term factor for maturity
Weighting factor
Information date
Flag
Registered IF Code According to
KALLPA
According to
SMV
According to
KALLPA
According to
SMV
According to
KALLPA
According to
SMV
15/02/2019 Registered LUSUR3BC1A 0.100 0.200 0.600 0.600 0.063 0.120 15/02/2019 Not Registered T 2 7/8 11/30/23 0.100 0.100 0.600 0.400 0.063 0.040 15/02/2019 Registered EDP4BC9A 0.200 0.200 0.250 0.400 0.800 0.080
27. Based on the foregoing, KALLPA SAB was charged with having infringed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection c) of the RAI, since inconsistencies have been detected regarding the weighting factors of the financial instruments held in its own portfolio, and therefore it would not have provided information on the IRP in accordance with the regulations, since this results from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the agent, as indicated in article 106 of the RAI;
28. KALLPA SAB states that, in accordance with the provisions of articles 99 and 100 of the RAI, on 15 February 2019, it reported to the SMV the corresponding prudential limit indicators, as detailed below:
| Indicators presented on 15 February 2019 | Prudential limit | Original Report | Excess Level in | limit Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Share Capital | >=1,999,633 | 4,493,637 | 2,494,004 | Compliant |
| 2. Net equity | >=1,999,633 | 12,718,592 | 10,718,959 | Compliant |
| 3. Equity risk | <=1 | 0.065 | 0.935 | Compliant |
| 4. Indebtedness | <=10 | 0.071 | 9.929 | Compliant |
| 5. Agent liquidity | >=1 | 9.666 | 8.666 | Compliant |
| 6. Intermediation liquidity | <=1 | 0.119 | 0.881 | Compliant |
| 7. Exposure of forward transactions | <=10 | 0.480 | 9.520 | Compliant |
| 8. Exposure to foreign transactions | <=20 | 5.490 | 14.510 | Compliant |
29. Therefore, KALLPA SAB mentions in the previous table that all the reported indicators fully comply with the prudential limits required by the regulations; that is, they were under the Compliant condition;
30. KALLPA SAB points out that for the preparation of the aforementioned indicators, an agent must evaluate no fewer than 30 variables that serve as "input" for their determination. Likewise, for the particular case, only for the calculation of the ECP, which is in question and serves as the basis for the Equity Risk and Intermediation Liquidity indicators, it is required to estimate no fewer than 20 variables;
31. KALLPA SAB adds that, as can be observed, the Equity Risk Indicator (with a value of 0.065) and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator (with a value of 0.119) are approximately 90% below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1). These values are well below the limits established by the SMV regarding solvency and liquidity indicators on the reported date. Likewise, it is observed that the other six prudential limit indicators are well below the limits established by the SMV on 15 February 2019;
32. It mentions that, a few days after 15 February 2019, and as described in the OFICIO DE CARGOS, observations were made to KALLPA SAB regarding the calculation of some indicators. In these observations, the SMV pointed out that KALLPA SAB showed inconsistencies in the calculation of its indicators. These inconsistencies were:
a) That KALLPA SAB did not report the holding of 4,300 TV shares, which had a total market value of S/. 3,867.
b) That KALLPA SAB reported the price of the LUSUR3BCIA bond as 0.00%, when in reality it was 106.19% of nominal value. The total market value was S/. 53,096.
c) That KALLPA SAB did not correctly assign the weighting factors of ten financial instruments held in its own portfolio.
33. KALLPA SAB points out that it immediately made the corresponding modifications, generating a revised report of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators as of 15 February 2019, which are shown below;
Indicators presented on 15
February 2019
Prudential limit
Original Revised Report Variation in the excess of the limit Level Level revised Excess in limit Result
34. In this regard, KALLPA SAB mentions that all the reported indicators continued to comply in excess with the prudential limits required by the regulations; that is, they continued under the Compliant condition;
35. Therefore, as KALLPA SAB points out, the observations made by the SMV only modified two (2) of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators (both shaded in the previous table), which corresponded to the Equity Risk Indicator, with a revised value of 0.105 (previously 0.065) and the Liquidity for Intermediation Indicator, with a revised value of 0.124 (previously 0.119);
36. It adds that the values after the review of the Equity Risk Indicator and Liquidity for Intermediation Indicator remained well below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1). When the first ratio rises from 0.065 to 0.105, the excess "buffer" of the ratio falls from 0.935 to 0.895, that is, by -3.94%. Likewise, when the second ratio rises from 0.119 to 0.124, the excess "buffer" of the ratio falls from 0.881 to 0.876, that is, -0.55%. Although there was a very slight increase in the indicators, these new results are in practice immaterial and do not affect in any way the stock brokerage firm, nor the clients, nor "risk management", nor the market, nor any other participant;
37. KALLPA SAB concludes that the modifications in the two indicators generated by the observations made by the SMV had a negligible and immaterial impact on their values, confirming that KALLPA SAB complied with the levels required by the SMV, regarding the solvency and liquidity indicators as of 15 February 2019;
38. KALLPA SAB has not made any statement regarding the facts subject to the charge, so they have not been disproved;
39. The intermediary has limited itself to stating that, in accordance with the provisions of articles 99 and 100 of the RAI, all the indicators reported as of 15 February 2019, even with the adjustments made in accordance with what was observed, complied in excess with the prudential limits required by the regulations, since the Equity Risk Indicator and the Liquidity for intermediation Indicator were below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1);
40. In relation to the foregoing, it should be noted that the charge imputed refers to the fact that in the calculation of the equity risk indicator as of 15 February 2019, KALLPA SAB did not observe the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subparagraphs a), b) and c) of the RAI, so the intermediary did not provide the SMV with information on the aforementioned indicator in accordance with the regulations, since it results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, so by means of Official Letter No. 1562-2019-SMV/10.2, KALLPA SAB was requested to immediately correct what was observed;
41. It should be noted that the breach of the limit of the Equity Risk Indicator and the Liquidity for intermediation Indicator was not the subject of imputation, which is a more serious infraction since, according to the SANCTIONS REGULATION, it qualifies as a very serious infraction3; therefore, what the stock brokerage firm states regarding the impact that what was observed had on compliance with the prudential levels does not disprove the imputed charge;
42. By means of Official Letter No. 1562-2019-SMV/10.2, notified on 26 March 2019, KALLPA SAB was requested to explain the reasons why the participation quotas of the investment funds called Kallpa Inmobiliario 1 and Kallpa Inmobiliario 2 (according to note No. 9 to the audited Financial Statements as of 31 December 2018) were not included in the ECP file. In response to the aforementioned official letter, KALLPA SAB stated that the participation quotas of
[3] SANCTIONS REGULATION, Annex X: "1.6 Failure to maintain prudential limits or margins at the levels established by the regulations on the matter"
the aforementioned funds would be included in the calculation of the aforementioned limits under the weighting factor 0.5, as provided in Annex L, subparagraph c) of the RAI;
43. In this regard, KALLPA SAB was charged with not having reported in the structured ECP file of 26 March 20194, the participation certificates of the investment funds with ticker symbols KALLPAINMB1 and KALLPAINMB2:
44. Therefore, KALLPA SAB would have transgressed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subparagraph a) of the RAI, since it would have omitted information regarding the financial instruments held for own account; therefore, it would not have provided the information on the equity risk indicator, in accordance with the regulations, since it results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106 of the RAI;
45. KALLPA SAB points out that on 26 March 2019 it reported to the SMV the corresponding prudential limit indicators prepared in accordance with the requirements of the RAI, as detailed below:
| Indicators submitted on 26 March 2019 | Prudential limit | Original Report | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Level | Excess over limit | Result | ||
| 1. Share Capital | >=1,999,633 | 4,493,637 | 2,494,004 | Compliant |
| 2. Net equity | >=1,999,633 | 11,141,505 | 9,141,872 | Compliant |
| 3. Equity risk | <=1 | 0.063 | 0.937 | Compliant |
| 4. Indebtedness | <=10 | 0.198 | 9.802 | Compliant |
| 5. Agent liquidity | >=1 | 4.572 | 3.572 | Compliant |
| 6. Intermediation liquidity | <=1 | 0.095 | 0.905 | Compliant |
| 7. Exposure of forward transactions | <=10 | 0.569 | 9.431 | Compliant |
| 8. Exposure to transactions abroad | <=20 | 6.164 | 13.836 | Compliant |
46. Therefore, KALLPA SAB states that, on that date, all the reported indicators complied in excess with the prudential limits required by the regulations; that is, they were under the Compliant condition;
47. In this regard, the Equity Risk Indicator (with a value of 0.063) and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator (with a value of 0.095) were approximately 90% below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1). In this sense, KALLPA SAB states that these values indicated low risk in solvency and liquidity levels on the reported date. Likewise, it indicates that adequate risk management is observed in the other six prudential limit indicators reported by KALLPA SAB on 26 March 2019;
48. It adds that, after sending the prudential limit indicators on 26 March 2019, the IGSE made observations regarding the calculation of some of them, which, as detailed in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS, corresponded to the fact that the participation quotas of the investment funds called Kallpa Inmobiliario 1 and Kallpa Inmobiliario 2 held by Kallpa SAB were not entered into the Own Portfolio Exposure file
[4] File No. 2019011935.
(ECP):
49. KALLPA SAB states that, after evaluating the observations received, the corresponding modifications were made, generating a revised report of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators as of 26 March 2019, which are detailed below:
| Indicators submitted on 26 March 2019 | Prudential limit | Original Previous level | Revised Report Level | Excess over limit | Result | Variation in excess of the limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Share Capital | >=1,999,633 | 4,493,637 | 4,493,637 | 2,494,004 | Compliant | 0.00% |
| 2. Net equity | >=1,999,633 | 11,141,505 | 11,141,505 | 9,141,872 | Compliant | 0.00% |
| 3. Equity risk | <=1 | 0.063 | 0.090 | 0.910 | Compliant | -2.74% |
| 4. Indebtedness | <=10 | 0.198 | 0.198 | 9.802 | Compliant | 0.00% |
| 5. Agent liquidity | >=1 | 4.572 | 4.572 | 3.572 | Compliant | 0.00% |
| 6. Intermediation liquidity | <=1 | 0.095 | 0.093 | 0.907 | Compliant | 0.23% |
| 7. Exposure of forward transactions | <=10 | 0.569 | 0.569 | 9.431 | Compliant | 0.00% |
| 8. Exposure to foreign transactions | <=20 | 6.164 | 6.164 | 13.836 | Compliant | 0.00% |
50. In accordance with the aforementioned table, KALLPA SAB states that all the reported indicators continued to comply in excess with the prudential limits required by the regulations; that is, they continued under the Compliant condition;
51. Therefore, the observations made by the IGSE, as mentioned by KALLPA SAB, only modified two (2) of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators, which corresponded to the Equity Risk Indicator, with a revised value of 0.090 (previously 0.063) and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator, with a value of 0.093 (previously 0.095);
52. In this regard, the new values of the Equity Risk Indicator and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator remained well below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1). When the first ratio rose from 0.063 to 0.090, the excess "buffer" of the ratio fell from 0.937 to 0.910, i.e., by -2.74%. On the other hand, the correction of the second ratio allowed it to go from 0.095 to 0.090, therefore the excess "buffer" of the ratio increased from 0.905 to 0.907, i.e., +0.23%. As can be seen, the modification of the first indicator affected it negatively; however, the adjustment of the second indicator positively affected the limit recalculated with respect to the previous one, benefiting KALLPA SAB;
53. Kallpa SAB concludes that on this date it is again verified that the modifications in the two indicators, generated by the observations, had a negligible and non-material impact on their value, confirming that the solvency and liquidity levels required by the SMV were largely met on 26 March 2019;
54. At the outset, it should be noted that KALLPA SAB has not submitted defenses regarding the imputed charge; the stock brokerage firm has only stated that its prudential limits complied at all times with the levels required by the regulations;
55. In relation to the foregoing, it should be noted that the imputed charge is linked to the fact that KALLPA SAB breached the provisions of article 109° and Annex L, subparagraph a) of the RAI, by not having provided information on the Equity Risk Indicator in accordance with the regulations, in the structured file ECP of 26 March 2019. Thus, it is clear that the breach of the limits of the Equity Risk Indicator and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator was not the subject of the imputation, but rather the failure to comply with the provisions of the RAI at the time of calculating the IRP;
56. It should be specified that this charge does not concern the effects of the prudential indicators on the brokerage firm itself, but rather the inconsistencies detected in the information submitted and detailed in Oficio N° 1562-2019-SMV/10.2, by not having provided information regarding the Equity Risk Indicator in accordance with the regulations, since this results from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the agent;
57. In the third group of financial instruments reviewed by the IGSE for 24 May 20195, differences were detected in the weighting factors. In the case of the financial instrument with mnemonic "PORTA2PC3D", it maintains a credit rating equivalent to "CP-2", so the FCR amounts to 0.5. Likewise, the maturity date of said instrument is 10 May 2020, corresponding to an FPV of 0.1, so the weighting factor that corresponded was 0.5; however, KALLPA SAB assigned it a value of 0.02;
58. On the other hand, in the case of the IF with mnemonic "SUAMSA 27", according to the IGSE, it maintains a credit rating within the range "AA+" to "BBB-"; therefore, the risk classification factor amounts to 0.2. Likewise, the maturity date of said instrument is 11 April 2027, corresponding to a factor of 0.6. In summary, the weighting factor would be 0.12; however, KALLPA SAB assigned it a value of 0.80;
59. In this regard, the IGSE made the aforementioned observations through Oficios N° 1562-2016-SMV/10.2 and N° 2884-2019-SMV/10.2. Therefore, in response to said official letters, KALLPA SAB stated that they proceeded to correct the weighting factors considered for the preparation of the ECP file;
60. Accordingly, KALLPA SAB was charged with having breached the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subparagraph c) of the RAI, since inconsistencies have been detected regarding the weighting factors of the financial instruments held in own portfolio, and therefore it would not have provided information on the IRP in accordance with the regulations,
[5] File N° 2019021537.
since this results from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the agent, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI;
61. KALLPA SAB states that on 24 May 2019, it reported to the SMV the corresponding prudential limit indicators prepared in accordance with the requirements of the RAI, as detailed below:
| Indicators submitted on 24 May 2019 | Prudential limit | Original Report | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Level | Excess over limit | Result | ||
| 1. Share Capital | >=1,999,633 | 4,493,637 | 2,494,004 | Compliant |
| 2. Net equity | >=1,999,633 | 11,431,944 | 9,432,311 | Compliant |
| 3. Equity risk | <=1 | 0.124 | 0.876 | Compliant |
| 4. Indebtedness | <=10 | 0.042 | 9.958 | Compliant |
| 5. Agent liquidity | >=1 | 27.637 | 26.637 | Compliant |
| 6. Intermediation liquidity | <=1 | 0.142 | 0.858 | Compliant |
| 7. Exposure of forward transactions | <=10 | 0.513 | 9.487 | Compliant |
| 8. Exposure to foreign operations | <=20 | 5.631 | 14.369 | Compliant |
62. Regarding the previous table, KALLPA SAB mentions that as of that date, it is observed that all the reported indicators fully exceeded the prudential limits required by the regulations; that is, they were under the Compliant condition;
63. It indicates that in particular, the Equity Risk Indicator (with a value of 0.124) and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator (with a value of 0.142), were 85% below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1). This means that the values maintained a low risk in the solvency and liquidity levels of KALLPA SAB on the reported date; and, that an adequate risk management is also observed in the other six prudential limit indicators reported on 24 May 2019;
64. It mentions that, after the submission of the prudential limit indicators on 24 May 2019, the IGSE made observations regarding the calculation of some of them, which, as detailed in the OFICIO DE CARGOS, corresponded to the fact that the weighting factor by risk classification of the PORTA2PC3D and SUAMSA 27 bonds was not entered correctly:
65. Therefore, after the evaluation of the observations received, KALLPA SAB made the corresponding modifications, generating a revised report of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators as of 24 May 2019, which are shown below:
66. According to the previous table, KALLPA SAB states that all the reported indicators continued to fully comply with the prudential limits required by the regulations; that is, they continued under the Compliant condition; and, that the observations made by the IGSE only modified two (2) of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators, which corresponded to the Equity Risk Indicator, with a revised value of 0.119 (previously 0.124) and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator, with a value of 0.141 (previously 0.142);
67. In this regard, KALLPA SAB mentions that the new values of the Equity Risk Indicator and Intermediation Liquidity Indicator remained well below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1). By reducing the ratio from 0.124 to 0.119, the excess "buffer" of the ratio increases from 0.876 to 0.881, that is, it improves by +0.54%. On the other hand, the correction of the second ratio allowed it to decrease from 0.142 to 0.141, therefore the excess "buffer" of the ratio increases from 0.858 to 0.859, that is, +0.07%. As can be seen, the modification of both indicators positively affected the prudential limit recalculated with respect to the previous ones;
68. KALLPA SAB reiterates that it is again verified that the modifications in the two indicators, generated by the observations, had a little significant and non-material impact on their value, also verifying that the revised values placed KALLPA SAB in a better risk position in relation to the one previously reported;
69. In this regard, KALLPA SAB, by way of conclusion, regarding the structured files of 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, mentions the following:
a) Although it is true that there were differences between the information originally sent by KALLPA SAB and the information obtained after the adjustments, those differences are totally immaterial. They are immaterial from an accounting, regulatory, administrative, risk, among others, point of view.
b) The circumstances that generated the inaccuracy in the calculation of some variables necessary for the determination of some prudential limit indicators of KALLPA SAB, were not the result of negligence or manipulation of the information by the SAB, nor were they done to "improve"/"window-dress" its
indicators, because as can be clearly seen, the difference is immaterial and in some cases does not benefit KALLPA SAB since it imposed a greater penalty during the original calculation of its weighted holdings. The prudential limit indicators of KALLPA SAB are well below the limits established by the SMV, both before and after the adjustments.
c) As demonstrated in the previous points, the review of the Equity Risk Indicator and Intermediation Liquidity Indicator showed little significant variations in the ratios of KALLPA SAB, which does not imply a directionality in the preparation of the reports that seeks to show a better result in the indicators reported to the SMV. There is no bad intention, nor fraud, nor the objective of influencing in any way the regulator or the market.
d) There are more than 30 variables that are calculated to determine the indicators, and each variable depends on other data. There are approximately more than 100 data and figures that must be taken into account to calculate and report the indicators daily. Internal problems and inaccuracies will always occur, because "the perfect is the enemy of the good";
70. Similarly to the preceding infractions, in the present case KALLPA SAB has not presented arguments that disprove the imputed charge, focusing its defenses on pointing out that its prudential indicators complied at all times with the levels required by the regulations:
71. In relation to the foregoing, KALLPA SAB points out that, in accordance with the provisions of the RAI, all the indicators reported on 24 May 2019 exceeded the prudential limits required by the regulations, since the Equity Risk Indicator and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator were 85% below the required prudential limit (less than or equal to 1) and the modification of both indicators positively affected the prudential limit compared to the previous ones, so it is verified that the modifications had a negligible and non-material impact on their value;
72. In this regard, it should be noted that the charge imputed is linked to the fact that KALLPA SAB breached the provisions of Article 109 and Annex L, subparagraph c) of the RAI, by not having provided information on the Equity Risk Indicator, in accordance with the regulations, in the structured ECP file of 24 May 2019. Thus, it is clear that the breach of the limits of the Equity Risk Indicator and the Intermediation Liquidity Indicator was not the subject of the imputation, but rather the failure to comply with the RAI at the time of calculating the IRP;
73. Therefore, regarding the fact that after the modifications of two (2) of the eight (8) prudential limit indicators, as a result of the observations of IGSE, referring to the "equity risk" indicator and the "intermediation liquidity" indicator, they had a negligible and non-material impact on their value, confirming that the solvency and liquidity levels required by the SMV were met on 24 May 2019; it should be reiterated that the foregoing is not essential to rebut the imputed charge, whose classification has been objective by virtue of the observations of Official Letter No. 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, and subsequent correction dated 3 June 2019, by which KALLPA SAB stated that it proceeded to correct the weighting factors considered for the preparation of the ECP file dated 24 May 2019;
74. It should be reiterated that this charge does not concern the effects of the prudential indicators on the brokerage firm itself, but rather the inconsistencies detected in the information submitted, by not having provided information regarding the Equity Risk Indicator, since this results from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the broker, which led to the rejection of the information by the IGSE, with respect to the structured ECP file of 24 May 2019;
75. In its written arguments, KALLPA SAB points out that the IGSE official letters refer to inconsistencies in data or "inputs" and that none of said official letters explicitly states that the procedures executed by KALLPA SAB for the preparation of the indicators did not correspond to what is established by the RAI. Likewise, the intermediary specifies that a distinction must be made between the data or inputs used and the procedures executed for the calculation of the indicators, and therefore considers that since said procedures were not observed by the IGSE, it follows that KALLPA SAB complied at all times with the calculation of the indicators and prudential limits in accordance with the regulations in force;
76. In this regard, it should be noted that the data referred to by KALLPA SAB are those that were submitted by the intermediary and from which the calculation of the ECP and IRP is made, it being necessary to state that the month-end prudential indicators disseminated to the market through the SMV Portal (www.smv.gob.pe), that is, as has been set forth, the objective fact is that KALLPA SAB provided the SMV with information on prudential indicators that were not in accordance with the regulations, which is what has been imputed;
77. In this sense, it should be specified that in this sanctioning procedure no aspects related to the effectiveness of the information system of the stock brokerage firm have been evaluated or imputed, so if from the facts subject to charges it had been determined that KALLPA SAB did not have the infrastructure and technological capacity enabling it to have information systems from which data are generated for an adequate and timely administration of the information oriented to its activities that constitute its corporate purpose; there would have been a more serious situation6 than that imputed in this sanctioning procedure;
78. KALLPA SAB points out that in the months of February, March and May 2019, the IGSE, by means of official letters, requested information on some points considered in the preparation of the prudential indicators on the dates subject to charges, and therefore the Operations, Accounting and Internal Control areas of KALLPA SAB responded to these official letters and implemented what said intendancy recommended. Subsequent to the foregoing, the stock brokerage firm specifies that there were no comments from the SMV, and therefore it understood that the changes were accepted and validated;
[6] Sanctions Regulation, Annex X, numeral 1.5: "Not having the physical infrastructure, human resources, and technological capacity enabling it to comply with its intermediation activities, in accordance with the provisions of the regulations."
79. It adds that, subsequently, between the months of September and October 2019, the IGSE conducted an on-site audit of KALLPA SAB, which focused on the process of preparing indicators. As a result of the audit, the SMV made a series of recommendations which were implemented by KALLPA SAB with the guidance of the SMV evaluation team;
80. The intermediary maintains that, finally, in November 2019, it informed the SMV in writing that it had implemented all the recommendations received. Since then, KALLPA SAB points out that it has not received any official letter from the SMV observing the process of preparing prudential limits;
81. Therefore, KALLPA SAB points out that, until the imputation of charges, the SMV did not send an official letter rejecting the information that KALLPA SAB submits daily regarding its prudential limits. Thus, it considers that the SMV never rejected the information submitted on 15 February 2019, nor that submitted on 26 March 2019, nor that submitted on 24 May 2019. Since it did not reject it, KALLPA SAB assumed that it did comply with submitting these indicators in substance and in a timely manner. Now, through this administrative sanctioning procedure, it is intended to reject the information submitted on 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, since it states that KALLPA SAB has not provided the information on prudential limits or margins in accordance with the regulations. Therefore, KALLPA SAB indicates that it finds a contradiction in this;
82. Therefore, in this context, KALLPA SAB argues that the SMV has not followed the process established by Article 102 of the RAI to carry out the evaluation and analysis of the determination (or calculation) of the prudential limits that agents are obliged to submit daily to the SMV and that they define in their Legal Grounds. Therefore, in KALLPA SAB's view, there is an inconsistency in stating that information has not been provided in accordance with the regulations 36 months ago, when the information has indeed been submitted, since under the denied assumption that it had not been submitted, the SMV should have intervened at that time;
83. Likewise, KALLPA SAB mentions that, taking into account the provisions of Chapter I of Title VI of the RAI, if the IGSE had considered that the information on prudential limits submitted by KALLPA SAB, in the reports corresponding to 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, was incorrect, in application of Article 102 of the RAI, the SMV would have rejected them so that KALLPA SAB proceeds to reverse the situation noted by the supervisor within the period indicated in the norm itself;
84. However, it points out that the IGSE not only did not reject the reports submitted, but also coordinated with KALLPA SAB so that the Agent's internal processes be adjusted to improve the calculation of the aforementioned indicators. It indicates that this occurred in the first half of 2019. KALLPA SAB highlights that to date, more than three years later, the SMV has not rejected the information submitted by KALLPA SAB regarding its prudential limits or margins in application of Article 102 RAI;
85. KALLPA SAB points out that, since 01 February 2018, when the submission of prudential limits under the new RAI entered into force, until today, in application of the aforementioned article, the SMV has reliably verified that KALLPA SAB: (a) Has not failed to comply with the provisions established for the determination and submission of prudential limits; and, (b) the lack or non-existence of the documentation, records and other information supporting the information submitted by KALLPA SAB has not been proven;
86. Likewise, in its arguments, the intermediary points out that for the SMV to approve a rejection, the following would have to happen;
a) That the prudential indicators submitted by an agent have not been prepared correctly intentionally and for the purpose of fictitiously complying with the limits established by the RAI.
b) That the rejected prudential indicators were determined by fabricating the form of their calculation or by fabricating or concealing the required information.
c) That after the declared rejection, the agent must detail the reasons why erroneous indicators were submitted and, within a maximum period of 3 days, submit indicators correctly calculated and that comply with the limits required by the RAI.
d) That if the previous point is not complied with, the agent will automatically be prevented from carrying out the intermediation process.
87. Additionally, in its arguments KALLPA SAB points out that Article 102 of the RAI does not expressly state the process and the SMV body responsible for executing the rejection of the information on prudential indicators sent by intermediaries;
88. Likewise, it indicates that the Single Text of Administrative Procedures of the SMV (TUPA) does not contemplate the process through which an agent can appeal the sanction of rejection of its prudential indicators, considering the existence of the right of defense protected by the Political Constitution of Peru;
89. On the other hand, the stock brokerage firm states that according to the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV (ROF), the only SMV body with powers to sanction intermediaries is the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision (SASP); and that the Manual of Organization and Functions (MOF) of the SASP also does not expressly state the body thereof responsible for declaring the rejection of the prudential indicators submitted by the Agents;
90. Based on the foregoing, in its arguments. KALLPA SAB states that neither Offices No. 983, 1562 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2 of the IGSE, in which it is indicated that inconsistencies would have been found in the preparation of its indicators, nor the STATEMENT OF CHARGES, where it is affirmed that KALLPA SAB "would have incurred in three (3) infractions classified as serious for not providing the SMV with information on the prudential limits or margins in accordance with the provisions of the regulations", expressly stated that the SMV had rejected its prudential indicators subject to charge, in application of article 102 of the RAI; therefore it reiterates that in the aforementioned offices of the SMV the word "rejection" was not mentioned in any paragraph, nor was any mention made of article 102 of the RAI;
91. Therefore KALLPA SAB indicates, there is a formal error in the imputation of charges and in the report of the instructing body, since the SMV never rejected the indicators and therefore cannot now state that it did, otherwise its defense would have been different, so it considers that there has been a failure in due process;
92. Likewise, KALLPA SAB mentions, that the STATEMENT OF CHARGES does not indicate within the argumentation of sanction, that the IGSE had expressly rejected the prudential indicators subject to charge in application of article 102 of the RAI. Thus, the intermediary refers that the STATEMENT OF CHARGES indicated that the IGSE had found information inconsistencies regarding financial instruments in own holding, without indicating anywhere in the document the application of article 102 of the RAI;
93. In this sense, the stock brokerage company indicates that the lack of foundation of sanction related to the application of article 102 of the RAI in the STATEMENT OF CHARGES, generated that its written discharge presented on 12 July 2022 does not include the defense arguments applicable for the rejection of the information on prudential indicators subject to charges, for this reason, it argues that the instructing body did not grant KALLPA SAB the right of defense established in article 139°, paragraph 4 of the Political Constitution of Peru
94. Based on the aforementioned, KALLPA SAB indicates that in the present sanctioning procedure the due process has been affected by including a cause of sanction that was not incorporated as such in the STATEMENT OF CHARGES, by stating that the IGSE had sanctioned it with the rejection of its prudential indicators subject to charge, insofar as according to the intermediary, the serious implications generated in the agents by the fact that the SMV rejects the information on its prudential limits, the rejection process of article 102 has similar effects as a sanction imposed by the SMV on the SAB. In this sense, it reiterates that the IGSE never rejected its prudential indicators, what the IGSE stated was that there were inconsistencies, but did not reject them;
95. With regard to what was mentioned by KALLPA SAB that the IGSE never rejected the information presented on 15 February 2019, nor that presented on 26 March 2019, nor that presented on 24 May 2019; it must be indicated that this lacks support, because the IGSE sent Offices No. 983-2019-SMV/10.2, No. 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and No. 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, notified 22 February, 26 March and 31 May 2019, in which it observed and rejected the information presented in the structured files ECP of dates 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, respectively, granting a rectification period in accordance with the provisions of articles 101 and 102 of the RAI. It should be noted that, according to the second paragraph of article 102 of the RAI, the rejection of said information is independent of the additional measures that may be appropriate;
96. Additionally, it should be highlighted that it is contradictory that KALLPA SAB with its discharges states that it is intended to reject the information presented on 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, when the same administered party has presented the rectification for each rejection of the information made by the IGSE, on dates 27 February, 29 March and 3 June 2019, respectively;
97. As regards what was stated by KALLPA SAB that the procedure established in article 102° of the RAI would not have been followed, as has been indicated above, KALLPA SAB has not accredited said allegation, on the contrary it has been indicated in the preceding recitals that the same supervised party has been duly notified with the rejection offices made by the IGSE and that they have been rectified by the same KALLPA SAB;
98. On the particular, it must be reiterated what was stated in the preceding recitals, in the sense that it has been verified that through Offices No. 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2 the information presented in the structured files ECP of dates 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, respectively, was rejected. Likewise in the aforementioned offices it has been verified that the situation detected was recorded in accordance with the first paragraph of article 102° of the RAI and a period was granted to send the communication in accordance with the provisions of the first paragraph of article 101° of the RAI;
99. It should be noted that the referred offices were not only limited to indicating the inconsistencies detected, as KALLPA SAB intends to allege, but in addition to that it was requested to correct the information sent. In this regard, it should be noted that according to the Royal Spanish Academy, the word "corregir" in its first meaning has the meaning "to amend what is erroneous" and the word "desestimar" in its second meaning has the meaning "to discard"; in this sense, the information initially submitted by KALLPA SAB, having presented inconsistencies, was discarded or rejected, for which it was required to resubmit the information amending what was observed; had it been considered that the information initially submitted had not been rejected, the correction thereof would not have been required;
100. Regarding what was indicated by KALLPA SAB, that the SMV has reliably verified that: (a) It has not failed to comply with the provisions established for the determination and submission of prudential limits; and, (b) the lack or existence of the documentation, records and other information supporting the information submitted by KALLPA SAB has not been proven; the following should be noted:
a) Regarding Oficio N° 983-2019-SMV/10.2, it was required to submit the documentary support of the information detailed in Annex N° 01 of the aforementioned oficio, corresponding to the ECP file of 15 February.
b) Regarding Oficio N° 1562-2019-SMV/10.2, it was required to correct the weighting factor of the financial instruments of the ECP file, as well as to explain the reasons why the participation quotas of the investment funds established by the contracts: "Kallpa Inmobiliario" 1 and "Kallpa Inmobiliario 2" were not included in the ECP file as of 31 December 2018 and as of 26 March 2019, as well as to submit the policies, procedures and internal controls referring to prudential limits and margins.
c) Regarding Oficio N° 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, it was required to correct the weighting factor including, if applicable, the risk classification factor and the maturity term factor, of the financial instruments in Table N° 01 of the aforementioned oficio, corresponding to the ECP file of 24 May 2019.
101. Therefore, it has been verified that in said oficios the situation detected was detailed in accordance with article 102° of the RAI and a term was granted in accordance with the provisions of the first paragraph of article 101° of the RAI; in this sense, what was alleged by KALLPA SAB regarding the fact that the SMV would not have rejected the information submitted regarding its prudential limits or margins in application of article 102° of the RAI is refuted;
102. As for what was indicated by Kallpa SAB regarding the fact that the rejection implies intentionality or fabricating its calculation, such aspects are considered as part of the evaluation of the sanction to be imposed, which will be considered in the respective section;
103. With regard to the supervision of prudential indicators, it should be noted that their regulation is provided for by the RAI, and compliance therewith is mandatory for intermediaries. In this sense, article 38, numeral 13 of the ROF and the MOF in its numeral 9, literal b) of the position of Intendente of the IGSE, has provided that the IGSE is the body of the SMV responsible for conducting and carrying out the supervision and monitoring of the entities under its competence, among them the stock brokerage firms; therefore, in the event that the information of the indicators submitted by the intermediaries does not comply with the provisions of the RAI, it corresponds to the IGSE to observe and reject them, as observed in the present case when the IGSE issued Oficios N° 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2;
104. As for the fact that the TUPA of the SMV does not contemplate the process through which an agent may appeal the rejection of its indicators, it should be noted that appeals are regulated by the TUO DE LA LPAG, and not by the TUPA. In this sense, in the event that KALLPA SAB had not agreed with the correction mandates of its indicators subject to charges provided by Oficios N° 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, it could have exercised its right to file an appeal against them, as established by articles 218, 220 and 221 of the TUO DE LA LPAG; however, the stock brokerage firm did not file any appeal, and on the contrary proceeded to reject the information initially submitted and submit a new one remedying what was observed. In this sense, it should be noted that the stock brokerage firm, as established by the TUO DE LA LPAG, had available the right to file in due course appeals against the referred oficios; however, by its own decision, it did not exercise said right, for which reason what was indicated regarding the impairment of its right to defense is refuted;
105. On the other hand, KALLPA SAB states that the rejection of the prudential indicators is similar to a sanction, and since said ground for sanction was not included in the OFICIO DE CARGOS, due process and its right to defense have been affected, that the IGSE only pointed out inconsistencies, that it never rejected its indicators, and that for that reason in its discharges of 12 July 2022 it did not include defense arguments applicable to the rejection;
106. In this regard, it must be reiterated that this sanctioning procedure originates from the specific and objective fact that KALLPA SAB, by not including securities representing participation as part of its ECP and by not calculating and considering the weighting factors to which its own holding of securities is exposed in accordance with the requirements of the regulations, failed to comply with the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subparagraphs a), b) and c) of the RAI as previously indicated, the aforementioned being the cause for sanction, and therefore the OFICIO DE CARGOS imputed that the intermediary would have committed as a serious infraction the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES: “No proporcionar a la SMV la información sobre los límites o márgenes prudenciales de acuerdo con lo que establece la normativa.”, in this sense, it must be reiterated that in this procedure what is imputed is not related to the compliance or non-compliance with the prudential levels by the intermediary or to another cause, but to the aforementioned;
107. Likewise, it must be reiterated that Oficios N° 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2 not only communicated inconsistencies in the information submitted by KALLPA SAB regarding its ECP, but also requested that it be corrected; therefore, the intermediary proceeded to rectify it;
108. Additionally, it must be indicated that the OFICIO DE CARGOS was notified on 01 July 2022, detailing the objective and specific facts that led to the imputation of charges, so KALLPA SAB submitted its defenses on 12 July 2022. Likewise, through Oficio N° 5728-2022-SMV/10, notified on 10 November 2022, this Superintendencia Adjunta communicated to the intermediary that it had received Informe Nº 1520-2022-SMV/10.3 from the instructing body, and as a result, KALLPA SAB requested to be granted the right to speak, so it presented its oral report on 15 December 2022 and on 16 December 2022, it submitted additional written arguments, that is, in this administrative sanctioning procedure the provisions of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES regarding the sanctioning procedure have been strictly respected, and KALLPA SAB has been able to exercise its right of defense without any impairment;
109. Regarding what was stated by KALLPA SAB that in its defenses of 12 July 2022 its right of defense was affected because it did not include applicable arguments for the dismissal, it should be noted that this does not conform to the reality of the facts insofar as the stock brokerage company, as a result of the facts on which the OFICIO DE CARGOS was based, included as a preliminary matter and legal grounds, defenses regarding the dismissal of the prudential indicators and application of article 102 of the RAI, which were evaluated previously;
110. On the other hand, it must be indicated that what was stated by KALLPA SAB regarding that the IGSE had sanctioned it with the dismissal of its indicators, it should be clarified that this is not correct, it is an interpretation of the intermediary itself. In accordance with the foregoing, according to the ROF, the IGSE supervises and monitors the stock brokerage companies, without prejudice that as a result of such activities, indications of infraction are detected, so in compliance with article 38, numeral 237 of the ROF, the IGSE refers such indications to the instructing body for its evaluation. Likewise, in accordance with article 41, numeral 6 of the ROF, it is the Intendencia General de Cumplimiento Prudencial (IGCP) that proposes to the Superintendencia Adjunta de Supervisión Prudencial the application of sanctions, which is evaluated by the latter, so it is this Superintendencia Adjunta that, on the basis of the provisions of article 32, numerals 16 and 17 of the ROF, is constituted as the sanctioning body; therefore, neither the IGSE nor the IGCP impose sanctions on the administered; the present sanctioning procedure being limited to the facts subject to charges;
111. It mentions that it has not been established and/or identified what is the evidence that would allow concluding that KALLPA SAB breached Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES because it did not provide the SMV with the
[7] “23. Assess the indications of possible breaches of the regulations detected within its area of competence and forward, for its consideration, the respective reports to the General Superintendency of Prudential Compliance."
information on the prudential limits or margins in accordance with the provisions of the regulations. Therefore, in the opinion of KALLPA SAB, it has indeed sent the information in accordance with the regulations every day since October 2008. In this sense, it considers that the SMV would have to prove that this has not been the case, when it is evident that it has been so;
112. It points out that indeed, throughout this administrative sanctioning procedure it is stated that a series of inconsistencies related to the calculation of the item Exposure to the risk of the own portfolio ("ECP") have been detected, corresponding to 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, so KALLPA SAB would have incurred on three (3) occasions in infractions classified as serious, thus failing to observe the provisions of the RAI;
113. In the opinion of KALLPA SAB, these immaterial inconsistencies do not imply, nor mean that it has not provided the SMV with the information in accordance with the regulations. Since it has indeed delivered information to the SMV complying with the regulations; however, it points out that such information had minor inconsistencies. Thus, the intermediary points out that the basis used in this proceeding to conclude that KALLPA SAB did not provide the SMV with information on the prudential limits or margins in accordance with the regulations is solely the inconsistency in the calculation of the ECP item, despite the fact that all the prudential limits reported were within those required by the RAI itself. Therefore, according to KALLPA SAB, that does not imply "not providing information in accordance with the regulations";
114. In this regard, it should be noted that the breaches on three (3) occasions of Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS are considered three (3) independent infractions, whose imputation was objective based on the breaches described in the STATEMENT OF CHARGES, which are supported by Official Letters No. 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, in which the information submitted by KALLPA SAB in the structured ECP files dated 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, respectively, was rejected. Likewise, it has been verified that in said official letters the situation detected was detailed in accordance with the first paragraph of article 102 of the RAI and KALLPA SAB complied with the correction in accordance with the provisions of article 101 of the RAI, without prejudice to the additional actions that had to be carried out;
115. Additionally, KALLPA SAB has not submitted defenses or arguments that have disproved the facts subject to the charge; the intermediary has limited itself to stating that the information in question had minor inconsistencies in the calculation of the ECP item, that all the prudential limits reported were within those required by the RAI itself, and that this did not imply "not providing information in accordance with the regulations".
116. In this regard, it should be reiterated that the imputations in the STATEMENT OF CHARGES concern the non-observance of article 109 of the RAI and of Annex L, subsections a), b) and c), since information on the Equity Risk Indicator would not have been provided in accordance with the provisions of the regulations. Therefore, given their nature, these breaches are independent of the effects they could have had on compliance with the margins required by the RAI, without prejudice to this being considered in the assessment of the sanction to be imposed;
117. Indeed, the regulations referred to above objectively and clearly state which values must be included as part of the intermediaries' own portfolio and how the risk exposure of said portfolio is determined; however, KALLPA SAB, despite the provisions of the regulations, the information it sent to the SMV as part of its ECP did not include as part of its own portfolio securities such as TV, KALLPAINMB1 and KALLPAINMB2. Likewise, the security LUSUR3BC1A was valued considering a price that did not correspond to it, and its risk exposure was based on a weighting factor not in accordance with its FCR. Similarly, the risk exposure of securities such as HUNT OIL 28, BNCOM0BS22, SWY 4 ¾, T 2 7/8 11/30/23, PORTA2PC3D, SUAMSA 27, among others, was based on weighting factors that did not correspond to those required in accordance with the regulations; situations that affect the calculation of the prudential limits, and that in turn potentially undermine the confidence of the regulator, as well as that of the market, regarding what the effective risks to which the intermediary is exposed are;
118. KALLPA SAB mentions that it is recognized that in administrative sanctioning law the standard of the presumption of lawfulness, in accordance with the provisions of subsection 9 of article 246 of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444 – General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO DE LA LPAG), requires that "entities must presume that the administered parties have acted in accordance with their duties as long as they do not have evidence to the contrary";
119. It adds that, in accordance with this principle of presumption of innocence, of correctness or of lawfulness, "the authorities must presume that the administered parties have acted in accordance with their duties as long as they do not have evidence to the contrary and it is so declared by a final administrative resolution (…). The presumption will only yield if the entity can gather sufficient evidence on the facts and their authorship, be certain that all the constituent elements of the foreseen type have occurred, and have sufficient logical reasoning that articulates all these elements forming conviction";
120. It adds that this presumption means a state of provisional certainty by which the accused acquires the following attributes to be respected throughout the proceeding, which will be analyzed by verifying their observance in this sanctioning proceeding:
(i) Not to be sanctioned except by virtue of evidence that generates conviction about the responsibility of the administered party and provided that it has been obtained legitimately. An administered party cannot be sanctioned on the basis of an inference or a suspicion, however reasonable or logical the mental approach followed by the authority may be.
121. In this regard, KALLPA SAB adds that, as Fernando de Trazegnies states, it is essential to begin by understanding that evidence constitutes the cornerstone of all legal reasoning. In that sense, its relevance stands out because of the link it establishes between law and reality; in such a way that a Law that is applied without correlation with it would be totally incoherent and unjust'. Evidence prevents the norm from being an arbitrariness, and constitutes both a right and a duty. It is essential to establish a legal consequence, and even more so one that implies a sanction, that there be full conviction that a situation is what it is and not what the opposing party seeks to make it appear;
122. In addition to the foregoing, KALLPA SAB points out that the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights states that in order to resolve against an administered party in an administrative sanctioning procedure, the administration must have evidence demonstrating that the accused committed the infraction attributed to it. It adds, likewise, that "the level of proof of the accusation is that it be proven beyond all reasonable doubt";
123. KALLPA SAB mentions that the aforementioned analysis, taking into consideration the provisions of the referred subsection 9 of article 246 of the TUO DE LA LPAG, as well as Article II of the Preliminary Title of the New Criminal Procedure Code approved by Legislative Decree No. 957, concludes that, in other words, an administered party can only be convicted if the accusation is the only possible hypothesis that explains the proven facts of the case. It adds that "if there is another theory that can explain the proven facts of the case, then the accused cannot be convicted". Therefore, in line with what was indicated by the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights, if there is (reasonable) doubt that the accused committed the imputed facts, then the authority must acquit him;
124. As KALLPA SAB points out, this is the standard set for sanctioning procedures, which due to their punitive nature resemble criminal proceedings. This standard establishes the level of proof that must be met to sanction a private individual in an administrative sanctioning procedure. "The Public Administration must not only be responsible for presenting evidence of the accusation, but must also be responsible for demonstrating that it is the only one that explains the proven facts of the case";
125. Consequently, KALLPA SAB concludes that if the Public Administration (i) does not have evidence proving the commission of the infraction, and/or (ii) cannot demonstrate that the accusation is the only explanation for the proven facts of the case, the accused must be acquitted;
126. On this matter, it should be noted that this administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against KALLPA SAB in light of the facts set forth as charges, in which the indications of infractions to the regulations governing the securities market were detailed, based on the various requirements made through official letters by virtue of the supervisory powers of the SMV, which were remedied by KALLPA SAB without prejudice to the additional measures that had to be taken;
127. In this regard, the argument of KALLPA SAB related to an alleged violation of the principle of presumption of lawfulness is not admissible, since KALLPA SAB itself has been duly notified with Official Letters No. 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, in which the inconsistencies detected in the ECP files dated 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019 were detailed; therefore, compliance with the procedure for rejecting the information submitted by KALLPA SAB in the aforementioned structured files is accredited;
128. Likewise, as previously indicated, KALLPA SAB has accepted the inconsistencies imputed as charges, alleging that they are minor and that they did not negatively or significantly affect the result of the margins;
129. It is also appropriate to add that what was indicated by the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights and in the various doctrine pointed out by KALLPA SAB has not been contravened, because the level of proof of this administrative procedure is based on objective evidence that has determined that in the structured files dated 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, the stock brokerage firm incurred inconsistencies in its determination and communication to this Superintendency, which is why it was required on three occasions to send the documentary support of financial instruments and include securities that were part of its own portfolio, as well as to make corrections of prices and weighting factors in the aforementioned structured files, insofar as what was initially submitted did not comply with the provisions of the regulations;
130. In that sense and given the evidence indicated, it is concluded that it has not been proven that in this procedure the principle of lawfulness contemplated in subsection 9 of article 248 of the TUO DE LA LPAG has been violated;
131. KALLPA SAB mentions the Principle of Material Truth, regulated in numeral 1.11 of Article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO DE LA LPAG, which, according to KALLPA SAB, is a principle of utmost importance since it seeks to guarantee that the Administrative Authority verifies the facts in order not to affect the defense and protection of both the public interest and the rights of the parties, fundamental rights recognized in the Political Constitution of Peru
(ii) That it not be imposed the burden of proving its own innocence, since the evidentiary activity corresponds to the Public Administration. Thus, on the one hand, it ratifies that in sanctioning matters the burden of proof falls on the Public Administration, so it is up to the authorities to identify, bring to the file and act on sufficient evidence to support rejecting the presumption, with the administered party even being released from acting on any evidence that could incriminate it.
132. In this regard, KALLPA SAB points out that the Constitutional Court has established that "any sanction, whether criminal or administrative, must be based on a minimum of incriminating evidentiary activity, that is, the burden of proof corresponds to the accuser; the latter must prove the fact for which they accuse a certain person, proscribing sanctions based on presumptions of guilt";
133. For this purpose, KALLPA SAB mentions that in the IGSE's indicia report, in order to rebut the alleged impairment of the Principle of Lawfulness, it sustains on pages 6, 7, 9 and 10 thereof, that the evidence proving that KALLPA SAB did incur the imputed infraction is the following:
a) (…) "in response to Official Letter No. 1562-2019-SMV/10.2, KALLPA SAB stated that the participation quotas with mnemonic KALLPAINMB1 and KALLPAINMB2 will be included in the calculation of the aforementioned limits under the weighting factor of 0.5, as established in subsection c) of Annex L of the RAI.
In light of the foregoing in the previous paragraphs, it follows that KALLPA SAB would have omitted on two (2) occasions information regarding the IF held in its own portfolio, breaching the provisions of subsection a) of ANNEX L."
b) (...) "In response to said official letter, KALLPA SAB stated that at the time of generating its indicators there was said inconsistency in its system, for which reason it did not process the correct price and therefore they will proceed to rectify and resend the indicators dated 15/02/2019.
In light of the foregoing in the previous paragraphs, it follows that KALLPA SAB would have sent inaccurate information regarding the prices of the instruments held in its own portfolio, breaching the provisions of subsection b) of ANNEX L."
c) (…) "In response to said official letters, KALLPA SAB stated that they proceeded to correct the weighting factors considered for the preparation of the ECP file".
In light of the foregoing in the previous paragraphs, it follows that KALLPA SAB would have sent inaccurate information regarding the weighting factors of the IF held in its own portfolio, breaching the provisions of subsection c) of ANNEX L."
d) (…) "In accordance with the facts set forth and the cited regulations, the existence of indicia regarding the possible commission of infractions of the securities market regulations by Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has been detected."
134. Likewise, KALLPA SAB points out that the STATEMENT OF CHARGES sustains on pages 6, 7, 9, 11 and 12 thereof that the evidence proving that KALLPA SAB did incur the imputed infraction is the following:
a) (...) "KALLPA SAB would not have reported in the structured file ECP of 15/02/2019 (See Table No. 1) the shares named Trevali Mining Corporation, with ISIN code No. CA89531J1093, which form part of its own portfolio according to the information registered in CAVALI SA. ICLV (See Table No. 2). Therefore, KALLPA SAB would have transgressed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection a) of the RAI, for which reason it would not have provided information on the Equity Risk Indicator (hereinafter, IRP) in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since the latter results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI."
b) (…) "KALLPA SAB would have transgressed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection b) of the RAI, given that inconsistencies have been detected regarding the price of the instrument with mnemonic "LUSUR3BCIA" of the structured file ECP corresponding to the date 15/02/2019, for which reason it would not have provided information on the IRP in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since the latter results from dividing the EP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI."
c) (...) "KALLPA SAB would have transgressed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection c) of the RAI, given that inconsistencies have been detected regarding the weighting factors of the financial instruments held in its own portfolio, for which reason it would not have provided information on the IRP in accordance with what
is established by the regulations, since the latter results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI."
d) (….) "KALLPA SAB would have transgressed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection a) of the RAI, given that it would have omitted information regarding the financial instruments held in its own portfolio; for which reason it would not have provided the information on the equity risk indicator, in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since the latter results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI."
e) (...) "KALLPA SAB would have transgressed the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection c) of the RAI, given that inconsistencies have been detected regarding the weighting factors of the financial instruments held in its own portfolio, for which reason it would not have provided information on the IRP in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since the latter results from dividing the ECP by the agent's net equity, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI."
f) (….) "For the breaches linked to the structured files ECP corresponding to 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, indicated in numerals 1.2.1, 1.2.2. and 1.2.3 of this official letter, Kallpa SAB would have incurred three (3) infractions classified as serious in numeral 2, subsection 2.17, of Annex X of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as an infraction: "Failure to provide the SMV with information on prudential limits or margins in accordance with what is established by the regulations";
135. Therefore, KALLPA SAB points out that from the extracted texts, the following can be observed:
a) It is not recognized that, in accordance with the requirements established in the RAI, KALLPA SAB is obligated to submit daily a total of eight (8) indicators that represent the prudential limits or margins of the Agent. It is not stated that for the preparation of the aforementioned indicators, an Agent must evaluate no fewer than 30 variables that serve as "input" for their determination. Likewise, in the particular case of KALLPA SAB, it is not recognized that only for the calculation of the item Exposure to the risk of the own portfolio ("ECP"), called into question in the IGSE REPORT, it is required to estimate no fewer than 20 variables.
Due to the complexity of determining the prudential limits, it may be feasible that operational risks are generated at the time of their calculation, which does not mean that KALLPA SAB acted intentionally to manipulate the information submitted to the SMV with the ultimate purpose that the prudential limits fraudulently comply with the caps established in the RAI.
b) It is not identified what the evidence or evidentiary elements are under which it can be established with absolute certainty or at least with reasonable doubt that KALLPA SAB did not provide the SMV with the information on the prudential limits or margins in accordance with what the regulations establish.
c) On the contrary, the commission of the infractions is based on the IGSE indicia report, for example, on the basis that inconsistencies have been detected regarding the weighting factors of the financial instruments held in KALLPA SAB's own holding; that is, reversing the burden of proof toward KALLPA SAB. As can be seen, through the IGSE indicia report, despite the fact that Kallpa SAB has correctly reported the eight (8) prudential limits required of the Agent on a daily basis, it is intended to sanction Kallpa
SAB for not being able to demonstrate that it did not commit the infraction, this infraction being that of "not providing the SMV with the information on the prudential limits or margins in accordance with what the regulations establish";
136. In this regard, KALLPA SAB states that in the present sanctioning procedure the obligations incumbent upon every Administrative Authority have been disregarded, namely (i) not to seek to sanction an administered party except through evidence that generates conviction regarding its administrative responsibility, and (ii) not to impose on the administered party the burden of proving its own innocence and, if this is not proven, to seek to sanction it for that reason;
137. Therefore, KALLPA SAB concludes that if the analysis developed in the IGSE indicia report were upheld for the purpose of seeking to sanction KALLPA SAB, an evident violation of the Principle of Lawfulness or Presumption of Innocence, as well as the Principle of Material Truth, would occur;
138. Regarding what was stated by KALLPA SAB, that it is not recognized in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS that, in accordance with the requirements established in the RAI, only for the calculation of the ECP item, it is required to estimate no fewer than 20 variables and that it may be feasible that operational risks are generated at the time of their calculation; it must be stated that this is not admissible, since the OFFICIO DE CARGOS has complied with detailing the facts imputed as charges, the substantive obligations violated described in the RAI, the administrative classification in which the inconsistencies incurred are subsumed and the sanction that could be imposed for said infractions, among others;
139. Furthermore, in relation to the preceding recital, KALLPA SAB is a company supervised by the SMV, with authorization to operate granted by Resolution CONASEV No. 049-2008-EF/94.01.1, dated 14 August 2008, and is aware of the regulations regarding the prudential limits or margins established in the RAI to which it is subject in its capacity as an intermediation agent, and of the "inputs" that it must observe for the determination of the indicators whose non-compliance (whether caused by operational risks or others) KALLPA SAB knows is sanctionable by the SMV as it is classified in numeral 2, subsection 2.17, of Annex X of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
140. Without prejudice to the foregoing, the RAI has established the possibility that the SMV may disregard the information submitted by an intermediation agent, when certain situations are verified, without prejudice to the additional measures that may be appropriate. Therefore, in the present case, having followed the established procedure and based on the facts subject to charges, this Deputy Superintendency considers that the principle of material truth has not been violated in this regard;
141. On the other hand, regarding what was mentioned by KALLPA SAB referring to the fact that in the present administrative sanctioning procedure it has not been identified what the evidence or evidentiary elements are under which it can be established with absolute certainty or at least with reasonable doubt that KALLPA SAB did not provide the SMV with the information on the prudential limits or margins; in this regard, what was stated in the analyses of the preceding discharges is reiterated, that the present imputation of charges is based on the facts imputed subject to charges, in which it has been detailed that on three occasions inconsistencies have been detected in the structured files dated 15 February,
26 March and 24 May 2019, for which, by virtue of article 102 of the RAI, the information was disregarded and rectification was requested in accordance with the provisions of article 101, proof of which has been the various official letters issued by the SMV, as well as the corresponding rectifications by KALLPA SAB;
142. Finally, it is not verified that in Oficios N° 983-2019-SMV/10.2, 1562-2019-SMV/10.2 and 2884-2019-SMV/10.2, nor in this administrative sanctioning procedure, the burden of proof has been violated, since it is reiterated that the procedure for rejecting the information submitted by KALLPA SAB has been followed in accordance with the procedure established in articles 101° and 102° of the RAI. Therefore, what was alleged by KALLPA SAB regarding the violation of the principle of material truth is refuted;
143. KALLPA SAB points out that, in sanctioning matters, the Principle of Typicity provided in numeral 4 of article 246 of the TUO DE LA LPAG must be taken into account, which establishes that only infractions expressly provided in norms of legal rank, through their typification as such, constitute administratively sanctionable conduct, without admitting extensive interpretation or analogy;
144. KALLPA SAB mentions that the Constitutional Court, when ruling on this principle, has concluded that it not only implies that the competent administrative authority may only sanction the conduct (action or omission) of an administered party if it is expressly typified as a punishable infraction in the law or norm with legal rank that is applicable, but also that the administrative authority cannot include in the content of the infraction conduct that is not expressly provided therein, through extensive interpretation or analogy;
145. In that understanding, KALLPA SAB indicates that it must be recognized that on 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, it did send to the SMV the corresponding eight (8) indicators of prudential limits of the Agent, all of them prepared in accordance with what is required in the RAI, despite the fact that the OFICIO DE CARGOS states that there were non-compliances linked only to the calculation of the item Exposure to the risk of the own portfolio (ECP) on the aforementioned dates;
146. Kallpa SAB concludes, indicating that the fact that it had some internal problems that affected the information sent, without this having any negative implication for the regulator, nor constituting the infraction provided in subsection 2.17 of numeral 2 of Annex X of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, of not sending the information in accordance with the regulations. Therefore, if a sanction were applied, the Principle of Typicity would be violated;
147. Previously, it must be recalled that, as evaluated, the following violations of the regulations have been detected:
a) Regarding the first charge: The provisions of article 109° and Annex L, subsections a), b) and c) of the RAI were violated, to the extent that information on the IRP was not provided in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since it results
from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the agent, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI. (underlining added).
b) Regarding the second charge: The provisions of article 109° and Annex L, subsection a) of the RAI were violated, since information regarding the financial instruments held in own possession was omitted; therefore, information on the IRP was not provided, in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since it results from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the agent, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI.
c) Regarding the third charge: The provisions of article 109° and Annex L, subsection c) of the RAI were violated, since inconsistencies are observed regarding the weighting factors of the financial instruments held in own possession, therefore information on the IRP was not provided in accordance with what is established by the regulations, since it results from dividing the ECP by the net equity of the agent, as indicated in article 106° of the RAI.
148. Therefore, what was alleged by KALLPA SAB that on 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, it sent to the SMV the corresponding eight (8) indicators of prudential limits, prepared in accordance with what is required in the RAI, and that the fact that it had some internal problems that affected the information sent does not constitute the infraction provided in subsection 2.17, numeral 2 of Annex X of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, is not admissible, since the infraction type is “not providing the SMV with information on the prudential limits or margins in accordance with what is established by the regulations” (underlining added), so the fact of having submitted the prudential indicators, violating the provisions of article 109° and Annex L subsections a), b) and c) of the RAI, does not result in an extensive interpretation or analogy of the infraction type indicated in the OFICIO DE CARGOS; on the contrary, in the aforementioned OFICIO DE CARGOS it has not been indicated that KALLPA SAB has not submitted the indicators, but rather that they have been submitted with inconsistencies that contravene what is established in the regulations, specifically in the RAI; or, in other words, it has not provided the SMV with the information under analysis, in accordance with what is established by the regulations;
149. Finally, in accordance with what has been developed in the preceding recitals, what was alleged by KALLPA SAB regarding the alleged violation of the principle of typicity established in subsection 4 of article 248° of the TUO DE LA LPAG is refuted;
150. KALLPA SAB mentions that, in relation to the reports of the prudential limits questioned, it must be proven whether the actions of KALLPA SAB produced what is known in sanctioning law as "organizational failure", that is, actions that lead to error on the part of the administered party, when there is no planning or prior knowledge thereof. The aforementioned actions were not carried out to the detriment and to harm the public administration;
151. In view of this, KALLPA SAB states that it is important to point out that the statements made in the STATEMENT OF CHARGES, such as «it would have been transgressed», "present inconsistencies" or "the related non-compliances" are excessive because, first, they were not carried out to hide information from the supervisor, and, second, it must be considered that any operational process may present errors, defined as operational risks which, if correctly managed, do not affect the company's operations, as is the case at KALLPA
SAB. Therefore, the intermediary states that what must be determined in the present case is the organization's failure with respect to the specific protected legal interests. In this way, it will be obligatory to determine the "true nature" of the damage caused if it is considered to exist;
152. In this regard, it should be noted that in the present case, KALLPA SAB has been charged after it was detected that the ECP was not calculated in accordance with the regulations on 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, so the information was disregarded, in accordance with the SMV's supervisory powers, so KALLPA SAB was duly notified and even remedied the requirements, which has led to the provisions of subsection 2.17, numeral 2 of Annex X of the REGULATIONS ON SANCTIONS having been infringed on three (3) occasions;
153. Regarding KALLPA SAB's statement that it did not intend to hide information from the SMV and that the inconsistencies derive from errors due to operational risks, it should be noted that this will be taken into account in the evaluation of the sanction to be imposed;
154. KALLPA SAB argues that the potential sanction proposed by the instructing body is not consistent with the Principle of Reasonableness that must necessarily be observed by the Administrative Authority when sanctioning an administered party;
155. In this regard, it states that numeral 3 of article 246 of the TUO DE LA LPAG enshrines the principle of reasonableness, which is also expressly recognized in the last paragraph of article 200 of the Constitution, according to which any exercise of public power cannot be carried out in an arbitrary, disproportionate or excessive manner;
156. KALLPA SAB mentions that the principle of reasonableness seeks to "rationalize" the sanctioning activity of the Administration, preventing the administrative authority from exceeding its repressive action, guiding it within a criterion of weighing, moderation and balance;
157. On the other hand, KALLPA SAB states that, following Majar, in the sanctioning field, the principle of reasonableness constitutes the limit to the exercise of the sanctioning power, a tool that is also used both to select the specific sanction to apply among those available in the legal system, and to proceed with its graduation;
158. Likewise, KALLPA SAB states that according to doctrine, the principle of reasonableness has a dual dimension:
a) Every decision imposing a burden by an administrative entity must be adopted within the limits of the powers attributed, that is, such decisions imposing a burden must not distort the purpose of the functions granted; and,
b) Every decision imposing a burden must maintain a proper proportion between the means to be employed (the content of said decision) and the public purpose sought to be protected by such decision;
159. This second dimension, KALLPA SAB states, aspires for the decision imposing a burden to be "proportional" and for the "least burdensome" possible measure to be applied to the administered party, in accordance with the provisions of article 64 paragraph 10 of the TUO DE LA LPAG;
160. Therefore, KALLPA SAB states, the application of the principle of reasonableness seeks to avoid the imposition of sanctions that generate an "excess of punishment", such as measures with a "confiscatory" effect;
161. KALLPA SAB states, indicating that it is evident that the potential sanction (a minimum fine of 25 UITS) is disproportionate since it not only widely exceeds the alleged legal benefit obtained, but also does not take into consideration the fact that the alleged "inconsistencies" are totally immaterial and have no relevance whatsoever;
162. For all the foregoing, KALLPA SAB concludes that the potential sanction is disproportionate and violates the Principle of Reasonableness;
163. Regarding what was stated by KALLPA SAB, based on various doctrine mentioned, that the potential sanction is disproportionate since it not only widely exceeds the alleged legal benefit obtained, but also does not take into consideration the fact that the alleged "inconsistencies" are totally immaterial and have no relevance; it must be stated that the application of the principle of reasonableness established in paragraph 3 of article 248 of the TUO DE LA LPAG will be taken into account at the time of determining the corresponding sanction;
164. In conclusion, in accordance with the points previously analyzed, KALLPA SAB has not disproved the charges imputed, and therefore has incurred in three (03) infractions classified as serious typified in numeral 2, paragraph 2.17, of Annex X of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, which establishes as an infraction: "Failure to provide the SMV with information on prudential limits or margins in accordance with the provisions of the regulations"
165. In accordance with article 348 of the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree 861 and its amendments, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF (hereinafter, LMV) and article 258 of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES; in accordance with article
[8] “Article 25.- SANCTION CRITERIA The administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the following criteria: a) Prior record, for final sanctions imposed by the SMV within the period of four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned. The commission of the same infraction in the year prior to the infraction to be sanctioned is not considered a prior record. b) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction, the final sanction imposed by the SMV within the period of one (1) year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned is taken into account. c) Circumstances of the commission of the infraction. d) Economic damage caused and its impact on the market. e) Illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction. f) Probability of detection of the infraction. g) Severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest. h) Existence or not of intent in the conduct of the offender. When, from the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria, it is noted that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the facts imputed, by exception and through a reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided may be imposed”.
248°, numeral 3, of the TUO OF THE LPAG9 , article 25710 of the aforementioned normative body and articles 26° and 27° of the SANCTION REGULATIONS; the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria set forth by the LMV, the SANCTION REGULATIONS and the TUO OF THE LPAG;
166. Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Prior record of the offender; b) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The economic damage caused and the impact on the market; d) Recidivism11; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; g) The existence or not of intent in the conduct of the offender; and, h) The probability of detection of the infraction;
167. In this sense, in order to reconcile the criteria established in the LAW with those indicated in the SANCTION REGULATIONS, and the TUO LPAG; and that these criteria are adequately considered so that their assessment observes the principle of reasonableness and that the sanction to be imposed is appropriate to them, the following criteria have been analyzed;
168. With regard to the prior sanction record, it must be noted that according to article 25°, literal a) of the SANCTION REGULATIONS, final sanctions imposed by the SMV within the period of four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned constitute prior records, and the commission of the same infraction in the year prior to the infraction to be sanctioned is not considered a prior record;
[9] “Article 248.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles: (…) 3. Reasonableness.- Authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, observing the following criteria indicated for their graduation: a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; b) The probability of detection of the infraction; c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; d) The economic damage caused; e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within the period of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final. f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and g) The existence or not of intent in the conduct of the offender”.
[10] “Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions 1.- The following constitute conditions exempting liability for infractions: a) Fortuitous event or duly proven force majeure. b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense. c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the ability to understand the infraction. d) The mandatory order of a competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions. e) The error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision. f) The voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 253. 2.- The following constitute conditions mitigating liability for infractions: a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender expressly and in writing acknowledges their responsibility. In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount. b) Others established by special norm”.
[11] The sanction criteria referring to Recidivism and the Probability of detection of the infraction were introduced by article 2° of Legislative Decree No. 1272 which modified, among others, article 230°, numeral 3 of the LPAG.
169. In this sense, from the review carried out in said period it has been verified that KALLPA SAB presents the following prior records:
| Resolution No. | Resolved | Finality Prior Record | (*) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 043-2015- SMV/1012 | KALLPA SAB is sanctioned with a reprimand for having incurred an infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.4, of the Sanctions Regulations, for having allowed inaccurate information to be provided to the market and for having incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.4 of the Sanctions Regulations for not recognizing in memorandum accounts the balances of the portfolios of clients to whom portfolio management services are provided, as provided in article 91 of the Regulations for Intermediation Agents and other accounting standards. | 25/01/2016 | a; b; and, c |
| 2 | Deputy Superintendent of SMV Resolution No. 001-2016- SMV/1013 | KALLPA SAB is sanctioned with a reprimand for having incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulations for having submitted periodic information outside the deadline established in the Regulations for Intermediation Agents, approved by Resolución CONASEV N° 045-2006- EF/94.10, referring to the basic financial statements and control annexes corresponding to the close of January 2013. | 26/06/2016 | a; b; and, c |
| 3 | Deputy Superintendent of SMV Resolution No. 090-2017- SMV/1014 | KALLPA SAB is sanctioned with four (04) reprimands, for having incurred four (04) minor infractions classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, for not having timely communicated four (04) material events related to changes in related parties and in the compliance officer. | 13/10/2017 | a; b; and, c |
| 4 | Deputy Superintendent of SMV Resolution No. 008-2019- SMV/1015 | KALLPA SAB is sanctioned with a fine of 10 UIT, equivalent to S/ 38 000,00 (Thirty-eight thousand and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, for not obtaining orders from its client. Likewise, it is declared that it has not been proven that KALLPA SAB incurred one (1) very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1, and one (1) serious infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulations, and, consequently, the administrative sanctioning procedure is concluded in these respects. | 03/04/2019 | c |
[*] Literals Section II of this Resolution.
170. Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, it must be noted that in the present case it has not been possible to prove that KALLPA SAB's actions caused damage to the public interest or had an impact on the market;
171. Notwithstanding the foregoing, it should be noted that the requirements related to prudential limits aim at the orderly and sustained development of the securities market through the presence of intermediation agents that have sufficient equity and financial backing, enabling them to face the risks inherent in their activity and avoid harm to their clients, in particular, and to the market, in general; therefore, not providing the SMV with information on any prudential limit, in the manner established by the regulations, affects its
[12] Notified on 31 December 2015
[13] Notified on 04 January 2016
[14] Notified on 21 September 2017
[15] Notified on 12 March 2019
supervision and control tasks, which limits the achievement of objectives related to investor protection; as well as the stability of the securities market;
172. On the other hand, it should be noted that prudential limits are disseminated to the market at the close of each month through the SMV Portal (www.smv.gob.pe), so if an intermediary's information system is not effective in generating information and said system does not generate consistent information in accordance with the requirements of the regulations, there would be a potential impact on the public interest to the extent that complete and truthful information would not be transmitted to the market;
173. As for the economic harm caused and the impact on the market, it should be noted that in the present case, it has not been evidenced that the infractions incurred by KALLPA SAB produced a concrete quantifiable harm in the market, that is, it has not been determined that one or more investors were concretely affected or caused economic harm, so it has also not been evidenced that there was an impact on the market;
174. With reference to recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, account is taken of that final sanction imposed by the SMV within the period of one (1) year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned. Within this framework, this criterion is not met;
175. With regard to the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be mentioned that the infractions detected against KALLPA SAB arose in response to the supervision work by the SMV regarding its prudential limits, which gave rise to the request for the respective documentary support, the corresponding correction, and subsequent remediation by the agent company;
176. In this regard, it should be noted that the infractions were committed as a result of KALLPA SAB's internal process for the calculation of the ECP for 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019 and submission to the SMV in structured files, resulting in inconsistencies and omissions in the information contained in said files, which affected the calculation of the IRP; the materiality of what was observed in said calculation should be considered;
177. In its defense, KALLPA SAB states that the calculation of the ECP requires estimating no fewer than 20 variables and that, given the complexity of determining prudential limits, it may be feasible that operational risks are generated at the time of their calculation;
178. In this regard, it should be mentioned that KALLPA SAB, as a company supervised by the SMV, is aware of the rules that regulate the securities market and, in that sense, is aware of the regulations regarding the prudential limits established in the RAI, to which it is subject in its capacity as a brokerage agent. However, KALLPA SAB infringed the provisions of article 109° of the RAI by calculating in three (3) structured files, dated 15 February, 26 March and 24 May 2019, its exposure to own-portfolio risk, contravening the provisions of Annex L of the RAI;
179. It should be noted that the securities market is a highly specialized, complex market, in which for an intermediary to be able to participate in it, it must be authorized by the regulator, and therefore brokerage firms must have technological and physical infrastructure, as well as duly trained personnel, that enable the intermediary to comply with basic prudential requirements whose fundamental objective is the protection of the investor and the integrity of the market; otherwise, it would entail affecting those legal interests that are intrinsically necessary for the proper functioning and development of the securities market;
180. In this sense, strict compliance with the regulatory framework contributes to the fulfillment of those objectives, and therefore interpretations by an administrator regarding compliance or non-compliance with the regulations based on what the same person considers minor or immaterial would lead to subjective interpretations of the application of the rule according to each administered party, affecting the aforementioned legal interests; this is without prejudice to the fact that, in the event of the commission of an infraction as a result of an operational risk, the imposition of the sanction considers principles such as reasonableness and proportionality;
181. As regards the reference to operational risk, this is a risk intrinsic to the management of a business or activity, for which intermediaries must adopt measures that allow it to be mitigated, and therefore the occurrence or potential occurrence of losses caused by inadequate processes, staff errors, technological failures or external events does not imply that a brokerage firm is not obliged to comply with the provisions of the regulatory framework that governs it. In this sense, a body of rules has been issued regarding the treatment of risks by intermediaries, among them the Operational Risk Management Regulation16;
182. As regards the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infractions, it should be noted that it has not been established that KALLPA SAB obtained a benefit directly related to the infractions under analysis in this administrative proceeding;
183. As regards the existence or not of intent in the conduct of the infringer, it should be indicated that it has not been evidenced that KALLPA SAB acted with intent in the commission of the infractions;
184. As regards the probability of detection of the infractions, it should be indicated that in the present case, the infractions incurred by KALLPA SAB were evidenced as a result of the supervision and control activities carried out by the SMV regarding compliance with prudential limits or margins, in accordance with the provisions of the applicable regulations, and therefore the probability of detection was high;
185. With regard to the acknowledgment of responsibility of the infringer (article 257°, numeral 2, subparagraph a) of the TUO DE LA LPAG), its contribution to the clarification of the infraction, and the correction made after its requirement or the initiation of the administrative sanctioning proceeding, established in article 26°17, subparagraphs a), b) and c), respectively, of the SANCTIONS REGULATION,
[16] Approved by Superintendency Resolution No. 00027-2016-SMV/01.
[17] Article 26.- MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES OF LIABILITY FOR INFRACTIONS The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for infractions: a) Acknowledgment of responsibility by the infringer expressly and in writing, once the administrative sanctioning proceeding has been initiated. When the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced, taking into account the following:
it should be indicated that KALLPA SAB, in accordance with what was stated in its defenses, has not acknowledged its responsibility in the commission of the imputed infraction; however, it has contributed to the clarification of the infraction. It should be noted that the intermediary corrected the observed matter after having received the respective requirements from the SMV;
186. Consequently, in application of article 26 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, this should be considered as a mitigating circumstance of liability;
187. In accordance with what is determined in article 257°, numeral 1 of the TUO DE LA LPAG and article 27° of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, it is not observed that in the present case any of the assumptions that constitute exempting conditions of liability has been configured;
188. For the foregoing reasons, KALLPA SAB has incurred three (3) infractions classified as serious in accordance with numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17, of Annex X of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, which establishes as an infraction: “Failure to provide the SMV with information on prudential limits or margins in accordance with the provisions of the regulations”;
189. In accordance with article 34° of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, serious infractions are punishable with a fine of no less than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) Tax Units or with suspension of the authorization to operate for up to twenty (20) days
Finally, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO OF THE LPAG, which states that sanctions must be proportional to the non-compliances classified as infractions, and, considering that it has not been evidenced that the infraction committed has had an impact on the market nor accredited damages, or that the brokerage firm has obtained any illicit benefit from the commission of these infractions, that no intentionality was evidenced in its conduct, that said intermediary is not a repeat offender with respect to the referred infraction, that it has contributed to the clarification of the infractions and that it remedied them at the request of the IGSE, the circumstances of the commission of the infractions and that the probability of detection of the same was high, this Deputy Superintendency considers that it is possible to impose on KALLPA SAB a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided for serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of the second paragraph of article 25 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
1. If the acknowledgment of the infraction is presented within the term granted for the presentation of defenses, the reduction amount shall be fifty percent (50%).
(…) The acknowledgment of responsibility regarding an infraction must be made precisely, concisely, clearly, expressly and unconditionally, and must not contain ambiguous or contradictory expressions; otherwise, it shall not be understood as an acknowledgment. If defenses are presented, despite having made an acknowledgment of responsibility, it shall be understood as a non-acknowledgment, and the authority shall proceed to evaluate the defenses.
b) Contribution of the offender to the clarification of the infraction.
c) The remediation carried out after its request or at the beginning of the administrative sanctioning procedure.
Article 1.- Declare that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 and its amending norms, by failing to comply with the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsections a), b) and c) of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments, for not having provided information on the Equity Risk indicator in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in the structured file dated 15 February 2019.
Article 2.- Declare that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 and its amending norms, by failing to comply with the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection a) of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments, for not having provided information on the Equity Risk indicator in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in the structured file dated 26 March 2019.
Article 3.- Declare that Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 and its amending norms, by failing to comply with the provisions of article 109 and Annex L, subsection c) of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments, for not having provided information on the Equity Risk indicator in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in the structured file dated 24 May 2019.
Article 4.- Sanction Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. with a reprimand for the commission of the infractions referred to in articles 1 to 3 above.
Article 5.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 6.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by means of a reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
Article 7.- Transcribe this resolution to Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Signed by: GUTIERREZ OCHOA Omar Darío Reason:
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.”
“Deputy Superintendent of SMV Resolution No. 008-2019-SMV/10... Notified on 12 March 2019”
“Deputy Superintendent of SMV Resolution No. 090-2017-SMV/10... Notified on 21 September 2017”
“Operational Risk Management Regulation... Approved by Superintendency Resolution No. 00027-2016-SMV/01.”
“Deputy Superintendent of SMV Resolution No. 001-2016-SMV/10... Notified on 04 January 2016”
“Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, in force as of 19 December 2018”
“Policy on dissemination... approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added