Guidance · CBI · 12 Jul 2024 · EES viðmiðunarreglur, Viðmiðunarreglur ESMA35-43-3565, Dreifibréf
Financial undertakings, management companies of securities funds and managers of specialised funds authorised under Act no. 115/2021 must ensure they neither remunerate employees nor assess performance in ways conflicting with the duty to act in clients' best interests, and bonus schemes must not incentivise recommending certain financial instruments when others better suit retail investors. Bonuses must be in appropriate proportion to fixed remuneration and never exceed 25% of fixed remuneration; granting bonuses to employees in risk management, internal audit or compliance, and paying bonuses to board members, are entirely prohibited. They must familiarise themselves with the ESMA guidelines and take them into account in their operations as applicable.
11 July 2024
Ref.: 2310114
Circular no. 23/2024
To: Financial undertakings, management companies of securities funds and managers of specialised funds that are authorised to carry out tasks falling under the Act on Markets for Financial Instruments no. 115/2021.
Association of Companies in Financial Services
Subject: ESMA Guidelines on certain aspects of the remuneration requirements in markets for financial instruments (MiFID II).
The Central Bank of Iceland has adopted guidelines1 on certain aspects of remuneration requirements on the basis of Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II2) which is implemented in the Act on Markets for Financial Instruments no. 115/2021 (hereinafter “mffl”). The guidelines are issued by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA). The guidelines are addressed to supervisory authorities, financial undertakings that carry out tasks according to the 4th paragraph of Article 20 of Act no. 161/2002, management companies of securities funds that are authorised to carry out tasks according to the 3rd paragraph of Article 5 of Act no. 116/2021 and managers of specialised funds that are authorised to carry out tasks according to the 3rd paragraph of Article 9 of Act no. 45/2020. In this circular, reference will be made to a company as a collective term for those parties to which the guidelines apply. The purpose of the guidelines is to promote consistent interpretation and supervisory actions regarding rules on remuneration policy, conflicts of interest and business practices in connection with the remuneration of the companies.
The guidelines concern remuneration policy (fixed remuneration and variable remuneration, i.e. bonuses) and remuneration practices, conflicts of interest and business practices in connection with remuneration. The remuneration policy of investment firms is discussed in the 10th paragraph of Article 24. MiFID II, which was implemented by Article 37 of mffl and Article 27 of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565. Corporate governance with regard to remuneration policy is also discussed in the 3rd paragraph of Article 9. MiFID II, but that provision was implemented into Icelandic law by the 4th paragraph of Article 10 of mffl. Conflicts of interest are discussed in the 3rd paragraph of Article 16 and Article 23. MiFID II and Article 34 of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565. Those provisions were implemented into Icelandic law by the 2nd paragraph of Article 21 and Article 32 of mffl. Business practices in connection with remuneration are then discussed in the 1st paragraph and the 10th paragraph of Article 24. MiFID II, but those provisions were implemented into Icelandic law by the 1st paragraph of Article 33 and Article 37 of mffl.
According to the 1st paragraph of Article 37 of mffl, an investment firm that provides investment services to clients shall ensure that it neither remunerates its employees nor assesses their performance in a way that conflicts with its obligation to act in the best interests of its clients. It is further provided in the same paragraph that bonus schemes shall not create incentives for employees to recommend certain financial instruments when others would better suit the needs of a retail investor. According to the 2nd paragraph, bonus schemes and severance agreements shall otherwise be governed by Article 57 a and Article 57 b (currently Article 57 b and Article 57 d)3 of Act no. 161/2002 on Financial Undertakings. It then states in the 3rd paragraph of Article 37.
[1] Guidelines on certain aspects of the MIFID II remuneration requirements; ESMA35-43-3565
[2] Directive 2014/65/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 May 2014 on markets in financial instruments (MiFID II)
[3] See further in Article 81 of the amending Act no. 38/2022
mffl that further rules on bonus schemes and severance agreements are laid down in the aforementioned Regulation (EU) 2017/565.
The guidelines are divided into three parts, along with two appendices. In the first part, requirements for the structure of remuneration policy and their implementation are further elaborated, inter alia with regard to variable remuneration. There is also a fairly detailed discussion of how a company aligns its interests and those of the relevant party, cf. the definition in the 1st point of Article 2 of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, with the interests of its clients. In the second part, requirements regarding corporate governance in connection with remuneration are further elaborated. There, inter alia, it is discussed how remuneration policies are to be kept track of by the company's managers and on the review of remuneration policy and the recording of data that arise in the preparation of remuneration policy and are otherwise connected to it, and that companies should establish a communication channel to be followed when incidents occur that may involve breaches of rules on remuneration. In the third part, requirements on how to handle risks that may arise from remuneration policy and its implementation are further elaborated. There is a somewhat detailed discussion of how a company should establish a system intended to assess compliance with its remuneration policy and whether it is likely to achieve the objectives underlying the policy. In Appendix I to the guidelines, examples are set out of conflicts of interest that may arise in connection with remuneration policies that can be difficult to manage. In Appendix II to the guidelines, there is a comparison table for these guidelines and older guidelines on comparable subject matter (Guidelines on remuneration policies and practices; ESMA/2013/606).
As stated above, remuneration policy and remuneration are discussed in mffl, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, in addition to provisions of Act no. 161/2002 on Financial Undertakings concerning bonuses and severance agreements. The domestic legal environment thus contains stricter conditions for the payment of bonuses than generally applies in the EU. For example, it is provided in the 5th point of the 1st paragraph of Article 57 b of Act no. 161/2002 that bonuses are in an appropriate proportion to fixed remuneration and never exceed 25% of fixed remuneration, cf. also the 2nd paragraph of Article 37 of mffl. In addition, there are several items in the guidelines that do not apply domestically due to restrictions in the Act on Financial Undertakings, cf. the following:
In items 34-36, remuneration, including variable remuneration, of employees in control units is addressed. According to the 5th paragraph of Article 57 b of Act no. 161/2002, cf. the 2nd paragraph of Article 37 of mffl, it is entirely prohibited to grant bonuses to employees working in risk management, internal audit or compliance.
The remuneration of board members and executives, including variable remuneration, is discussed in item 37 of the guidelines, and bonuses to board members are used as an example in item 40 thereof. According to the fifth paragraph of Article 57 b of Act No. 161/2002, cf. the second paragraph of Article 37 of the mffl., it is prohibited to pay bonuses to board members.
Despite the foregoing, i.e. stricter authorizations for the payment of bonuses under the mffl., the guidelines apply to all other aspects concerning remuneration policies and the payment of bonuses in general.
According to the third paragraph of Article 16. of the ESA regulations, which were implemented by Act No. 24/2017 on the European Financial Market Supervisory System, competent authorities and the relevant supervised entities shall seek all means to comply with the guidelines of the supervisory authorities and general recommendations. The purpose of the guidelines is to establish coordinated, efficient and effective supervisory practices within the European financial system, as well as to ensure common, uniform and consistent application of legislation within the EEA.
The Financial Supervisory Authority of the Central Bank of Iceland directs financial undertakings, management companies of securities funds and managers of specialized funds that have authorization to perform tasks falling under the Act on Markets for Financial Instruments No. 115/2021, to familiarize themselves with the aforementioned ESMA guidelines and take them into account in their operations as applicable. The Financial Supervisory Authority will rely on the guidelines in its supervisory practices and in assessing whether the requirements under the provisions discussed above are met.
This circular will be published on the Central Bank's website along with a link to the English version of the guidelines.
Yours faithfully,
CENTRAL BANK OF ICELAND
Gísli Óttarsson
Managing Director
Prudential Supervision
Kristín Logadóttir
Head of Department
Prudential Supervision
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“The Central Bank of Iceland has adopted guidelines1 on certain aspects of remuneration requirements on the basis of Directive 2014-65/EU (MiFID II2) which is implemented in the Act on Markets for Financial Instruments no. 115/2021 (hereina…”
“The Central Bank of Iceland has adopted guidelines1 on certain aspects of remuneration requirements on the basis of Directive 2014-65/EU (MiFID II2) which is implemented in the Act on Markets for Financial Instruments no. 115/2021 (hereina…”
More like this from CBI
CBI published 7 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Central Bank of Iceland — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added