Guidance · HKMA · 20 Jul 1998
All financial institutions must independently assess Year 2000 preparations, prioritise mission-critical systems, and complete contingency plans largely by 31 March 1999, after the 31 December 1998 deadline for other programme aspects. They must inventory hardware and software, establish budgets, test links with third parties, and independently verify vendor compliance rather than rely on supplier statements. Institutions must involve counsel, review contracts and insurance, and provide customer-contact staff with current information.
Gita!ifiiti
20Jul 1998
Guidance on the Independent Assessment of Year 2000 Preparations 20 July 1998 Guidance on the Independent Assessment of Year 2000 Preparations The Basle Committee on Banking Supervision has recently issued a guidance note on the independent assessment of banks' Year 2000 preparations. The guidance note has also been adopted by the Joint Year 2000 Council as an international standard for securities firms and insurance companies supervisors as well. This guidance note provides a structure and specific questions that regulators, auditors and others could ask in conducting an independent assessment of financial institutions' readiness for the Year 2000. It is also a good reference for the management of financial institutions in their internal evaluations of Year 2000 preparations. I enclose herewith a copy of the guidance note and the associated press statement for your reference. As mentioned in my letter of 3 April 1998, all Als with work still in progress should be subject to some form of independent assessment of the Year 2000 compliance process. Where Als claim to be already Year 2000 compliant, the HKMA will require documentary evidence to support this and may require independent assessment. The HKMA's approach in conducting independent assessment will be largely in line with the recommendations of the guidance note. The guidance note makes it clear (page 11) that the need to develop contingency plans to assure business continuity is an integral part of the Year 2000 programme. Als should already be well advanced on certain elements of their contingency plans, and should be further developing these plans during the testing phase as the likelihood of particular events occurring is better understood. Because the full awareness of the potential problems that need to be catered for may only become apparent through external testing, it is recognised that it may not be possible for institutions to have finalised and tested their contingency plans by 31 December 1998, which is the deadline for the other aspects of Als' Year 2000 programmes. They should however aim to have largely completed their work on contingency plans by 31 March 1999, though it may be necessary to update and test their plans after that date to take account of changing circumstances. Should you have any questions on this subject, please contact Mr. Edmond Lau, Head of Banking Development Division at 2878 8110 or Mr. Brian Lee, Senior Manager of the
~ -
Banking Development Division at 2878 1651.
Supervisory Guidance on the Independent Assessment of Financial Institution Year 2000 Preparations J O I N T Y E A R 2 0 C O U N C I L Basle Committee on Banking Supervision Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems International Association of Insurance Supervisors International Organization of Securities Commissions Bank for International Settlements July 1998
1
The guidance focuses on problems that similarly apply to all financial institutions. It does not deal with the specific problems of the different financial sectors. For instance, the insurance companies have to be aware of and to obviate the high risk of large insurance and reinsurance claims arising as a result of Year 2000.
2
“Mission critical” systems are those that a financial institution needs to have operational in order to conduct its most basic functions (for example, determining customer balances). Each institution needs to determine which systems are mission critical and establish priorities for deployment of scarce resources. 3 For the local operations of foreign organisations, it may be appropriate to substitute oral explanations of plans rather than requiring translations of such plans.
4 -
by the cooperation, responsiveness and capability of the institution’s management and the amount of time remaining prior to the millennium change.
5 -
I. Developing a Strategic Approach
The importance of timely preparations for the millennium change requires establishing the Year 2000 project as a strategic objective of the financial institution with a high degree of involvement by senior management. There should be an assignment of clear lines of responsibility and accountability. A Year 2000 team should be established to oversee the programme on an institution-wide basis. The strategic objective should be clearly communicated to all staff. In addition, the institution’s board of directors and senior management should be involved in assessing the resource implications of the Year 2000 and kept informed through regular reports on the status of Year 2000 preparations. Examiners/auditors should ask:
4
Examples of completion targets are provided in several of the documents issued by national authorities contained in the bibliography at the end of this document. Targets will often vary by the size and complexity of the Year 2000 issue as well as from country to country.
5
In order to achieve Year 2000 readiness within existing time constraints, financial institutions may find it necessary to use approaches that are less than optimal from a longer-run business operation perspective. In such instances, post-century date change plans will address replacing temporary fixes with more permanent ones.
6
“Change management” is the process whereby a new version of an application is put into production under appropriate controls.
7
See FFIEC: “Guidance Concerning Testing for Year 2000 Readiness” (April 10, 1998) 8 Examples of critical test dates include: September 9, 1999, December 31, 1999, etc. See FFIEC Interagency Statement “Guidance Concerning Testing for Year 2000 Readiness” for a full list of critical test dates.
9
See FFIEC: “Guidance Concerning Testing for Year 2000 Readiness” (April 10, 1998)
10 See FFIEC: “Guidance Concerning Contingency Planning in Connection with Year 2000 Readiness” (May 13, 1998)
14 -
VIII. Miscellaneous Issues
1. Legal issues
Legal issues may arise from the lack of specificity in contract terms dealing with Year 2000 issues. Consequently, financial institutions should involve their in-house and/or outside counsel in the preparation, review and implementation of the institution’s Year 2000 action plan. Contracts, indemnification provisions, and officer and director insurance policies should be reviewed and amended, as appropriate. Current and future purchases of hardware/software technology should require certification that it is Year 2000 compliant. If contract changes or modifications are refused, then the institution should consider replacing the service or product. The following list provides general information regarding legal issues and is not intended to provide legal advice regarding specific transactions or matters. Examiners/auditors should ask:
1. Is senior management diligently overseeing the Year 2000 conversion process in order
to avoid potential liability for failure to comply with legal responsibilities to the financial institution? What Directors’ and Officers’ insurance coverage exists?
2. Has the financial institution consulted legal consel as to the appropriate and proper
documentation regarding its Year 2000 efforts? How will internal documentation being generated now affect the institution’s potential future litigation position? What steps is the institution taking to avoid, as well as prepare for, litigation that arises from the Year 2000?
3. Has the financial institution reviewed insurance policies to ascertain if they cover
business losses and liability as a result of the Year 2000?
4. Has the financial institution reviewed the licence agreements and long-term
maintenance agreements relating to all third-party licensed software? Has this review been done in conjunction with a legal audit in order to preserve the institution’s legal rights against software vendors?
5. What are the financial institution’s rights and duties as a systems user relative to
maintenance contractors and software suppliers?
6. What are the financial institution’s rights and duties as a systems provider? Has the
institution provided appropriate documentation to other entities for which they provide services? Is the financial institution taking the necessary steps to avoid litigation arising from computer services they provide?
15 -
7. Has the financial institution revised its contracts or included in new contracts
provisions ensuring Year 2000 compliance with external service providers, software developers and suppliers?
8. Does the financial institutions understand the regulatory consequences of remediation
failures in key areas of business operations?
2. Merger/acquisition issues
The extent of Year 2000 conversion efforts will bear directly on corporate merger and acquisition strategies since they will compete for project managers and technical resources. Merger and acquisition strategies should therefore include an assessment of the Year 2000 issue, to the extent possible. This should not only include an analysis of the state of readiness of the organisation to be acquired but also what counterparty problems will, in effect, be “inherited” from that organisation. Examiners/auditors should ask:
1. Has the financial institution taken Year 2000 into account when considering mergers,
acquisitions, or business expansions?
2. Has the financial institution included in such considerations dealings with new
customers and counterparties?
3. What due diligence and other measures is the financial institution taking in merger and
acquisition transactions to protect against inheriting Year 2000 problems and compounding those of the financial institution?
3. Issues related to remote locations
Remote or overseas operations need to devote attention to Year 2000 issues. In particular, management information systems for businesses that run interactively with or independently from the head office must be included in the financial institution’s system inventory and plans. Examiners/auditors should ask:
1. How is the financial institution ensuring the Year 2000 readiness of operations
conducted at remote locations, both domestically and overseas?
16 -
2. What kind of reporting is required from these locations by the head office?
3. How is the head office supporting these remote locations and providing information
that is needed by host country supervisors?
4. Disclosure and customer awareness
As the millennium draws closer, it is important for a financial institution to communicate with its customers and counterparties regarding the institution’s state of preparedness. This could include a statement in the annual shareholders’ report as well as additional printed material that can be made readily available to customers upon request. In addition, all line personnel with regular direct contact with customers should be provided with current information so that they may accurately answer questions posed by customers. 11 Examiners/auditors should ask:
1. Has an information officer and other personnel been assigned the specific duty of
preparing information for customers on the financial institution’s Year 2000 efforts? Are these personnel available to answer the questions of individual customers related to Year 2000 issues?
2. What efforts is the financial institution making to communicate periodically to its
customers on its Year 2000 conversion programme?
3. Are line personnel adequately informed about the status of the financial institution’s
Year 2000 efforts in order to answer questions posed by customers? Do they know to whom more detailed or complicated questions should be referred?
11 See FFIEC: “Guidance on Year 2000 Customer Awareness Programs” (May 13, 1998)
17 -
IX. Supervisory Assessment and Follow Up
A critical step that should be taken by supervisors following an independent review of a financial institution’s Year 2000 action plan is an overall assessment of the institution’s level of preparedness. This includes a determination of whether the institution is doing all it can to ensure that it is ready and whether any serious disruptions to the institution’s ongoing activities are likely to take place. This step involves summarising the strengths and weaknesses of the institution’s Year 2000 plan and determining how well the plan is being implemented. The supervisors should discuss their conclusions with the senior management and board of directors of the financial institution. They should make recommendations on any additional actions necessary to ensure the institution’s Year 2000 readiness. Supervisors should be prepared to apply proactive supervisory pressure on those institutions that appear to be falling behind in their conversion efforts. Once supervisors identify an institution that is going to have significant problems, the supervisors need to work closely with the institution to remedy the situation, to the extent possible, and to develop contingency plans to deal with the consequences of not being Year 2000 compliant. The appropriate supervisory response will vary depending on the level of severity of the deficiency. For those financial institutions that supervisors determine are in unsatisfactory condition because of their lack of Year 2000 preparations, formal enforcement actions should be considered.
18 -
Bibliography
The following documents have been developed by supervisory agencies in various countries. They are considered good resource materials for supervisors and others making an independent assessment of the state of readiness of individual financial institutions. Canada:
Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions Year 2000 Project (September 25, 1997) Italy:
Banca d’Italia
Website address: www.bancaditalia.it
Survey of the compliance of Italian banks’ information systems with euro and Year 2000 requirements (February 1998) Germany:
Deutsche Bundesbank
Website address: www.bundesbank.de
Japan:
Bank of Japan
Website address: www.boj.or.jp
Bank of Japan Checklist for the Year 2000 Problem (August 19, 1997) Announcement letter of the interlocking tests of major payment systems in Japan for BOJNET participants (April 27, 1998) Ministry of Finance Checklist for the Year 2000 Problem used by the Ministry of Finance’s Inspection (December 22, 1997) Netherlands:
Circular: Year 2000 problem (September 26, 1997) Questionnaire Year 2000 (October 24, 1997) Sweden:
19 -
Finans-Inspektionen
The Financial Sector, Information Systems and Year 2000 (March 31, 1998) United Kingdom:
Bank of England
Financial Sector Preparations for the Year 2000 (February 1998) United States:
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System The Federal Reserve’s Year 2000 Supervision Program (SR 97-79) (November 12, 1997) Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) Website address: www.fdic.gov Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC) Website address: www.ffiec.gov Guidance on Year 2000 Customer Awareness Programs (May 13, 1998) Guidance Concerning Contingency Planning in Connection with Year 2000 Readiness (May 13, 1998) Guidance Concerning Testing for Year 2000 Readiness (April 10, 1998) Guidance Concerning the Year 2000 Impact on Customers (March 17, 1998) Guidance Concerning Institution Due Diligence in Connection with Service Provider and Software Vendor Year 2000 Readiness (March 17, 1998) Safety and Soundness Guidelines Concerning the Year 2000 Business Risk (December 17, 1997) Year 2000 Project Management Awareness (May 5, 1997) Year 2000 Examiner Questionnaire (May 16, 1997) Year 2000 Exam Procedures (May 16, 1997) The Effect of Year 2000 on Computer Systems (June 1996) Federal Reserve Bank of New York Website address: www.ny.frb.org/bankinfo/y2k
20 -
Y2K, Second District Highlights (May 20, 1998) Addressing Year 2000 Issues in Foreign Banking Organisations (December 10, 1997) Year 2000 Alert (April 4, 1997) Office of the Comptroller of the Currency Website address: www.occ.treas.gov Year 2000 and System Integration Considerations in Corporate Application Decisions (AL 98-1/January 20, 1998) Year 2000 Letter to Bankers (May 28, 1998) Disclosures Involving Year 2000 Issues in Securities Filings with OCC (AL 98-02, SEC Staff Legal Bulletin) Securities and Exchanges Commission Web site address: www.sec.gov/news/home2000.htm Year 2000 Readiness Reports To Be Made by Transfer Agents. (Comments due 30 days after publication in the Federal Register.) March 5, 1998. [Rel. No. 34-39726; File No. S7-8-98] Reports To Be Made by Certain Brokers and Dealers. (Comments due 30 days after publication in the Federal Register.) March 5, 1998. [Rel. No. 34-39724; File No. S7-7-98] Division of Market Regulation Year 2000 ("Y2K") Work Program
Basle Committee on Banking Supervision
SUPERVISORY GUIDANCE ON THE INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTION YEAR 2000 PREPARATIONS Following publication of "The Year 2000: A Challenge for Financial Institutions and Bank Supervisors" (September 1997) and its conduct of a survey on the level of preparedness in the G10 and selected non-G-10 countries, the Basle Committee on Banking Supervision decided to take additional steps to promote Year 2000 preparedness globally. One of these has been to prepare a supervisory guidance note on the independent assessment of banks' Year 2000 preparations. Another has been the establishment, following the Year 2000 Roundtable that took place at the BIS in April 1998, of a Joint Year 2000 Council in collaboration with the Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems, the International Association of Insurance Supervisors, and the International Organization of Securities Commissions. At a recent meeting in Rome, the Joint Year 2000 Council reviewed the work being conducted in its parent Committees. As a result, it decided to adopt the Basle Committee Supervisory Guidance and to make it an international standard for securities firms and insurance companies supervisors as well. The document is attached. It is hoped that this guidance will move supervisors from a level of general awareness of the problem to a specific, concrete-programme of action for overseeing Year 2000 readiness, both on an individual institution basis and on a system-wide basis. The document provides a structure for conducting an independent assessment of financial institution readiness related to the Year 2000. The Basle Committee believes that the guidance contained in this document can be beneficial to examiners, auditors and others. The Committee also believes that supervisors should consider conducting prudential interviews with senior management of banks and other financial institutions on this critical topic and that this guidance could form the
foundation of such discussion. In addition, supervisors should consider sharing this guidance with their financial institutions in order to help them in their own internal evaluations of action plans. With regard to the specific issue of Year 2000, no supervisor has the ability to make certain that problems will not occur due to the millennium change. Each financial institutions bears responsibility for its own systems. However, supervisors should be able to assess whether the steps being taken by financial institutions to achieve Year 2000 readiness appear to be reasonable and prudent. Supervisors need to follow up quickly with those institutions that are viewed to be inadequately addressing the Year 2000 problem. As outlined in the Basle Committee's September 1997 paper, the wide range of year 2000-related risks necessitates that management implement a targeted, multifaceted action plans to protect both the organisation and its shareholders. Addressing the Year 2000 issue consists of several important elements. These elements fall into seven broad categories: (1) developing a strategic approach; (2) creating organisational awareness; (3) assessing actions and developing detailed plans; (4) renovating systems, applications and equipment; (5) validating the renovation through testing; (6) implementing tested, compliant system; and (7) contingency planning. The guidance note is organised under these seven headings. It also contains a final
section on miscellaneous issues as well as a list of resource
documents issued by supervisory authorities in various countries.
These documents are referenced, as appropriate, in footnotes.
The Basle Committee continues to pay close attention to this issue and will be ready to report on the status of its work at the International Conference of Bank Supervisors in October 1998.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 5 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added