Consultation · HKMA · 26 Oct 2018
The Monetary Authority consults the Hong Kong Association of Banks on a draft Code of Practice giving guidance on rules 20(4)(b), 31, 37(1)(a) and 41 of the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules, with comments due by 30 November 2018 and planned implementation on 1 July 2019. The draft Code sets out how authorized institutions should assess a competent and reliable third party market data provider, calculate an employee's annual salary, treat holdings in a CIS with more than 80% of investments in land as interests in land, and determine economic dependence between counterparties, including 50% thresholds for receipts, expenditures, sales and funding.
Banking Policy Department
Our Ref: B4/1C
B2/1C
B9/130C
By email and by hand
26 October 2018
Ms Diana Cesar
Chairperson
The Hong Kong Association of Banks
Room 525, 5/F Prince Building
Central
Hong Kong
Dear Ms Cesar,
Consultation on draft Banking (Exposure Limits) Code I am writing to consult the Association on a set of draft Banking (Exposure Limits) Code (“the Code”) to be made under section 97M of the Banking Ordinance (“BO”). The Code is intended to provide technical guidance on the application of the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules (“BELR”) which was issued to the Association for statutory consultation on 5 October 2018. One important element of the Code is the guidance on how an authorized institution should determine whether two counterparties are economically dependent in practice for the purposes of Rule 41 of the BELR (in relation to the single counterparty / group of linked counterparties exposure limit). In the course of making the draft Code, we realise that certain provisions originally intended to be included in the Code should more appropriately be included in Rule 41 directly. As a result, we would propose changes to Rule 41, which have been reflected under paragraph 5(1) of the draft Code. This consultation of the draft Code is conducted pursuant to section 97M of the BO, which requires the Monetary Authority to formally consult a number of persons specified in that section (including the Association) before the Code is approved and issued. In preparing the draft Code, we have taken into consideration relevant comments received from the industry associations in response to our earlier non-statutory consultations of the proposals 1 .
1 Consultation on amendments to the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules in May 2018 (main provisions) and June 2018 (transitional provisions), and Consultation on new Exposure Limits framework (CP 16.01) in March 2016.
We will take into account the comments received in this consultation to enhance the draft Code, as appropriate. Our current plan is to implement the Code on the same date when the BELR are implemented, i.e. on 1 July 2019. I would be grateful if the Association’s comments on the draft Code could reach us by 30 November 2018. Online access to this letter, together with the enclosed draft Code and annex, is available through the HKMA’s Supervisory Communication Website (http://www.stet.inclnet.hk/PWS/CMS.nsf). I am writing in similar terms to the Members of the Banking Advisory Committee and the Deposit-taking Companies Advisory Committee, and The DTC Association. Yours sincerely, Daryl Ho Executive Director (Banking Policy) Encl cc: FSTB (Attn: Ms Eureka Cheung)
G.N. [number]
DRAFT
BANKING ORDINANCE (CHAPTER 155)
CODE OF PRACTICE
The Monetary Authority, having consulted the persons specified in section 97M(2) of the Banking Ordinance (Chapter 155) and approved and issued a code of practice pursuant to section 97M(1) of that Ordinance, hereby, as required pursuant to section 97M(3) of that Ordinance- (a) identify the following code (with English and Chinese versions) as being that code entitled:
(i) in English — 'Code of Practice for the Purposes of Providing Guidance in Respect of the Provisions of Rules 20(4)(b), 31, 37(1)(a) and 41 of the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules (Chapter 155[])'; and (ii) in Chinese — 「就《銀行業(風險承擔限度)規則》(第 155[]章)第 20(4)(b), 31, 37(1)(a) 及 41 條的條文提供指引的實 務守則」; (b) specify 1 July 2019 as the date on which the Monetary Authority’s approval of the code is to take effect; and (c) specify the following provisions of the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules (Chapter 155[]) as the relevant provisions for which the code is approved:
(i) Rule 20(4)(b);
(ii) Rule 31;
(iii) Rule 37(1)(a); and
(iv) Rule 41
Date Norman T. L. Chan Monetary Authority
DRAFT
Code of Practice for the Purposes of Providing Guidance in Respect of the Provisions of Rules 20(4)(b), 31, 37(1)(a) and 41 of the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules (Chapter 155[ ])
Table of Contents
I. Preliminary...........................................................................................4
Code of Practice for the Purposes of Providing Guidance in Respect of the Provisions of Rules 20(4)(b), 31, 37(1)(a) and 41 of the Banking (Exposure Limits) Rules (Chapter 155[]) (Approved and issued by the Monetary Authority pursuant to
section 97M(1) of the Banking Ordinance (Chapter 155))
I. Preliminary
subscribed information provided by a competent and reliable third party market data provider.” (2) In determining, for the purposes of rule 20(4)(b) of the BELR, whether a third party market data provider is competent and reliable, an AI should take into account the following in respect of the third party market data provider:
(a) market position and reputation;
(b) financial strength and service capability; (c) track records; (d) contingency service arrangements; (e) any other factors that the AI may consider appropriate.
3. Guidance on rule 31 of the BELR in respect of “a method to calculate
an employee’s annual salary that the Monetary Authority considers reasonable” (1) Rule 31 provides as follows:
“An authorized institution must, except with a consent given under rule 32, for each of its employees, at all times maintain an aggregate financial facility amount not exceeding the employee’s annual salary calculated by a method that the Monetary Authority considers reasonable.” (2) The Monetary Authority considers, for the purposes of rule 31 of the BELR, a method to calculate annual salary of an AI’s employee reasonable if the method reflects the sum of (i) the employee’s historical annual salary or annualised salary based on the employee’s latest fixed salary over a time interval (e.g. monthly); and (ii) any other fixed monetary payments and benefits payable to the employee such as fixed annual bonuses and housing allowances for the year concerned. Other variable payments and non-monetary benefits such as variable bonuses, performance based commissions and incentives, and medical insurance should be excluded from the calculation of the employee’s annual salary for the purposes of rule 31 of the BELR.
counterparty or an entity specified in paragraph (a), (b) or (c); (e) an entity that is controlled by an entity specified in paragraph (d); or (f) any other entity that— (i) controls; and (ii) is economically dependent on, an entity specified in paragraph (d). (3) For subrule (1), if the reference counterparty is a counterparty in relation to which the institution’s ASCE ratio does not exceed 5% or is an exempted sovereign entity, the institution, in determining its ASC exposure to the LC group (by reference to the reference counterparty), may treat any of the following entities as not being in the LC group— (a) an entity specified in subrule (2)(d) that is economically dependent on the reference counterparty; (b) an entity specified in subrule (2)(e) that is controlled by an entity specified in paragraph (a); (c) an entity specified in subrule (2)(f) that controls and is economically dependent on the entity specified in paragraph (a). (4) For subrule (1), if a counterparty of an authorized institution (counterparty A) is a linked counterparty of the reference counterparty by virtue of subrule (2)(a), (b) or (c) and the institution’s ASCE ratio in relation to the counterparty A does not exceed 5%, the institution, in determining its ASC exposure to the LC group (by reference to the reference counterparty), may treat any of the following entities as not being in the LC group— (a) an entity specified in subrule (2)(d) that is economically dependent on the counterparty A; (b) an entity specified in subrule (2)(e) that is controlled by an entity specified in paragraph (a); (c) an entity specified in subrule (2)(f) that controls and is economically dependent on the entity specified in paragraph (a).
(5) For subrule (1), if 2 or more counterparties of an authorized institution— (a) are controlled by, or economically dependent on, an exempted sovereign entity or The Financial Secretary Incorporated established under the Financial Secretary Incorporation Ordinance (Cap. 1015); and (b) are otherwise not in an LC group under subrule (1), regardless of whether the exempted sovereign entity or The Financial Secretary Incorporated is a counterparty of the institution, the counterparties are treated as not being in an LC group of the institution. (6) For this rule, an entity (subordinate entity) is treated as being controlled by another entity (parent entity) if— (a) the parent entity owns more than 50% of the voting rights in the subordinate entity; (b) the parent entity has control of a majority of the voting rights in the subordinate entity under an agreement with other shareholders (or similar holders of voting rights); (c) the parent entity has the right to appoint or remove a majority of the members of the subordinate entity’s board of directors (or a similar governing body); (d) a majority of the members of the subordinate entity’s board of directors (or a similar governing body) have been appointed solely as a result of the parent entity exercising its voting rights; or (e) the parent entity has the power, under a contract or otherwise, to exercise a controlling influence over the management or policies of the subordinate entity. (7) For this rule, an entity (Entity A) is economically dependent on another entity (Entity B) if they are connected in a way that if Entity B were to encounter financial problems (in particular funding or repayment difficulties), Entity A would also be likely to encounter financial problems (in particular funding or repayment difficulties).” (2) When an AI assesses, for the purposes of rules 41(2)(d), 41(2)(f)(ii), 41(3)(a) and 41(4)(a) of the BELR, whether a counterparty is
economically dependent on the reference counterparty, the AI may rely on information provided in good faith by either of the counterparties provided that such information is not in conflict with any information otherwise available to or in possession of the AI. (3) An AI should regard, for the purposes of rule 41(7) of the BELR, that if Entity B were to encounter financial problems (in particular funding or repayment difficulties), Entity A would also be likely to encounter financial problems (in particular funding or repayment difficulties) and hence Entity A is economically dependent on Entity B when any of the following applies:
(i) 50% or more of the gross receipts or gross expenditures (on an annual basis) of Entity A are derived from transactions with Entity B; (ii) Entity A has fully or partly guaranteed the exposure of Entity B, or is liable in respect of that exposure in any other manner (e.g. by the giving of an indemnity), and the exposure is so significant that Entity A is likely to default if a claim occurs; (iii) 50% or more of Entity A’s product/output or services is sold to Entity B, and Entity B cannot easily be replaced by other customers; (iv) the expected source of funds to repay the loans of both Entity A and Entity B is the same and neither Entity A nor Entity B has another independent source of income from which the loans may be fully repaid; (v) it is likely that the financial problems of Entity B would cause difficulties for Entity A in terms of full and timely repayment of liabilities; (vi) both Entity A and Entity B rely on the same source for 50% or more of their funding and neither Entity A nor Entity B has another independent source of funding. (4) To avoid doubt, when Entity A is economically dependent on Entity B, an AI should include Entity A in the LC group of Entity B. However, if Entity B is not economically dependent on Entity A, an AI should
not include Entity B in the LC group of Entity A unless Entity B meets other criteria for inclusion in the LC group of Entity A.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 4 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added