Consultation · HKMA · 30 Sep 2021
The draft amendments repeal the existing standardized, ASA, basic indicator and STO operational risk approaches and related definitions, Schedules 4 and 15, and Division 6 of Part 2. They replace Part 9 of the Banking (Capital) Rules with a new framework requiring authorized institutions to calculate the operational risk risk-weighted amount as the capital charge multiplied by 12.5, with the charge equal to the Business Indicator Component multiplied by the Internal Loss Multiplier. New definitions and Business Indicator calculation methods are prescribed, including transitional treatment for institutions in operation for less than three years.
Proposed amendments to Banking (Capital) Rules (“BCR”) for implementing Basel III revised operational risk capital framework Item 1. Repeal the following existing definitions in section 2(1) of the BCR Existing definitions to be repealed Remarks (including references) (1) alternative standardized approach This definition is no longer required because the concerned approach will be repealed under the revised operational risk capital framework (“revised framework”). (2) ASA approach This definition is no longer required because the concerned approach will be repealed under the revised framework. (3) basic indicator approach This definition is no longer required because the concerned approach will be repealed under the revised framework”. (4) BIA approach This definition is no longer required because the concerned approach will be repealed under the revised framework. (5) gross income This term is the proxy for operational risk under the existing operational risk capital framework. It will be replaced by other proxies under the revised framework. (6) last 3 years Please see remarks for the new definition “last n years” in item 7(15) below. (7) standardized business line This term becomes obsolete under the revised framework.
Annex 1
Existing definitions to be repealed Remarks (including references) (8) standardized (operational risk) approach This definition is no longer required because the concerned approach will be repealed under the revised framework. (9) STO approach This definition is no longer required because the concerned approach will be repealed under the revised framework. Item 2. Amend the following existing definition in section 2(1) of the BCR Existing definition – amendment to be made Remarks (including references) (1) internal model – remove the reference to “operational risk”. This is an amendment to clarify that internal model is not relevant to the methodology for the calculation of operational risk capital charge under the revised framework. Item 3. Repeal the following existing provisions in Part 2 of the BCR Existing provisions to be repealed Remarks (including references) (1) Division 6 This Division is no longer required with the repeal of the existing three approaches under the revised framework. (2) Subsections (3) and (4) of section 32 These subsections are no longer required with the repeal of the existing three approaches under the revised framework.
Item 4. Amend the following existing provisions in Part 2 of the BCR Existing provisions – amendments to be made Remarks (including references) (1) Title and subsections (1) and (2) of section 33A – remove reference to “25(2)(a)”.
Section 25 is part of the existing Division 6 of the BCR to
be repealed as mentioned in item 3(1).
(2) Subsection (1) of section 34 – remove reference to “25(2)”. Section 25 is part of the existing Division 6 of the BCR to be repealed as mentioned in item 3(1). Item 5. Repeal the following existing Schedules of the BCR Existing schedules to be repealed Remarks (including references) (1) Schedule 4 This Schedule is no longer required with the repeal of the existing STO approach and ASA approach under the revised framework. (2) Schedule 15 The revised framework no longer contains the existing two approaches (i.e. STO approach and ASA approach) to which this Schedule is relevant. Item 6. Substitute the contents of Part 9 of the BCR with the provisions to be incorporated in accordance with items 7 to 13 below Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) Repeal the entire Part 9 of the BCR. The contents of Part 9 of the BCR are to be repealed and replaced with new provisions set out in items 7 to 13 below.
Item 7. Add the following definitions to a Division in Part 9 of the BCR for the interpretation of Part 9 (1) Basel Framework means the consolidated version of the Basel Committee’s global standards for the regulation and supervision of banks published by the Basel Committee in December 2019 and as amended or supplemented from time to time. References to chapters OPE10 and OPE25 of the Basel Framework in this document refer to the version of these chapters to be effective as of 1 January 2023. They are accessible through clicking the “View future version” link for each of these chapters on the “OPE – Calculation of RWA for operational risk” webpage of the Basel Framework (https://www.bis.org/basel_framework/standard/OPE.htm). (2) BI means the Business Indicator, which is determined in accordance with items 9 and 10. This definition is intended to signpost the term to the relevant items in this document for its determination for ease of reference. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.1
(3) BIC means the Business Indicator Component, which is determined in accordance with item 11. This definition is intended to signpost the term to the relevant item in this document for its determination for ease of reference. (4) dividend income, in relation to an authorized institution (“AI”)’s calculation of the ILDC, means dividend income from equity investments in entities and collective investment schemes as specified by the Monetary Authority (“MA”) based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
The term “collective investment scheme” is defined under
section 2(1) of the BCR.
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in supervisory guidance such as in the form of a code of practice, or supervisory policy manual, etc. (“SG”), having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (5) FC means the Financial Component of the BI, which is determined in accordance with items 9 and 10. This definition is intended to signpost the term to the relevant items in this document for its determination for ease of reference. (6) fee and commission expenses, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the SC, means expenses paid for receiving advice and services as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (7) fee and commission income, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the SC, means income received from advice and services as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework.
(8) first year, in relation to the last n years, means the last calendar quarter of the period and the 3 immediately preceding calendar quarters. The terms “first year”, “second year”, “third year”, and “year” are defined based on the existing definitions of these terms under section 323 of the BCR. (9) high quality operational loss data means data on operational loss that meet the standards prescribed by the MA in relation to the identification, collection, treatment validation, review, scope and content, etc. of loss data based on the “minimum standards for the use of loss data under the standardized approach” set out in chapter OPE25 of the Basel Framework. Supervisory guidance:
The standards for high quality operational loss data will be provided in SG based on relevant criteria set out in chapter OPE25 of the Basel Framework (i.e. OPE25.14 to 25.34). (10) ILDC means the Interest, Leases and Dividend Component of the BI, which is determined in accordance with items 9 and 10. This definition is intended to signpost the term to the relevant items in this document for its determination for ease of reference. (11) ILM, in relation to an AI’s calculation of its capital charge for operational risk, means the Internal Loss Multiplier as determined in accordance with items 12 and 13. This definition is intended to signpost the term to the relevant items in this document for its determination for ease of reference. (12) interest earning assets, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the ILDC, means interest bearing assets and leased assets as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework.
(13) interest expenses, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the ILDC, means ordinary interest expenses and the expenses and losses related to leased assets as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (14) interest income, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the ILDC, means ordinary interest income and the income and profits related to leased assets as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (15) last n years means the last n years ending on a calendar quarter end date, where n can be any of the following: 3, 5, 10 or any integral number between 5 and 10. References to “last 3 years” in the existing definitions are replaced by “the last n years” to cater not only for the calculation of BI (which is based on data of the last 3 years) but also the calculation of ILM (which can be based on data of the last 5 years, 10 years or any number of years between the last 5 and the last 10 years). (16) LC means the Loss Component, which is determined in accordance with items 12 and 13. This definition is intended to signpost the term to the relevant items in this document for its determination for ease of reference.
(17) net interest income, in relation to an AI, means interest income after deducting its interest expenses. This term is based on the definition of the same term under existing section 323 of the BCR. (18) Net P&L on banking book, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the FC, means the “gains minus losses” arising from assets and liabilities booked in the banking book as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
(The term “banking book” is defined under section 2(1) of the BCR.) Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (19) Net P&L on trading book, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the FC, means the “gains minus losses” arising from assets and liabilities booked in the trading book as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
(The term “trading book” is defined under section 2(1) of the BCR.) Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework.
(20) operational loss event means any event as specified by the MA based on
Table 2 in chapter OPE25 of the Basel Framework, the classification of an
operational loss into which forms part of the requirements that the operational loss data of an AI must meet in order for the data to be considered as high quality operational loss data. Supervisory guidance:
Guidance based on Table 2 in chapter OPE25 of the Basel Framework will be set out in SG. (21) other operating expenses, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the SC, means expenses and losses from ordinary operations not included in other components of the BI as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (22) other operating income, in relation to an AI’s calculation of the SC, means income from ordinary operations not included in other components of the BI, as specified by the MA based on chapter OPE10 of the Basel Framework. Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.2 (Table 1)
Supervisory guidance:
Further explanation of this definition will be provided in SG having regard to the description of the term set out in OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework. (23) second year, in relation to the last n years, means the year immediately preceding the first year. The terms “first year”, “second year”, “third year”, and “year” are defined based on the existing definitions of these terms under section 323 of the BCR. (24) SC means the Services Component of the BI, which is determined in This definition is intended to signpost the term to the
accordance with items 9 and 10. relevant items in this document for its determination for ease of reference. (25) third year, in relation to the last n years, means the year immediately preceding the second year. The terms “first year”, “second year”, “third year”, and “year” are defined based on the existing definitions of these terms under section 323 of the BCR. (26) year means a period of 4 consecutive calendar quarters. This term is defined based on the existing definition of this term under section 323 of the BCR. The HKMA proposes to follow the approach of the current BCR to regard a “year” as a (moving) period of 4 consecutive calendar quarters rather than the financial year of the institution. This approach applies to the calculation of all the Business Indicator components and the Loss Component. Item 8. Add a Division in Part 9 of the BCR to set out an overall framework that an AI is required to follow for the calculation of the risk-weighted amount of its exposure to operational risk Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) To provide that an AI must calculate the risk-weighted amount of its exposure to operational risk by multiplying the capital charge for operational risk by 12.5. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.2
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (2) To provide that, subject to item 8(3), an AI must calculate its capital charge for operational risk by multiplying its Business Indicator Component (BIC) by its Internal Loss Multiplier (ILM). Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.2
(3) To provide that where an AI has been in operation for less than 18 months on any calendar quarter end date subsequent to the date on which this
section comes into operation, the institution must obtain the prior consent
of the MA on the use of either the method prescribed in this Part, or an alternative method, for calculating its capital charge for operational risk. This item is a modification of section 340 of the BCR to cater for the revised framework. Similar to the current practice under such section, we will not specify a particular alternative method. (The term “calendar quarter end date” is defined under
section 2(1) of the BCR.)
Item 9. Add a Division in Part 9 of the BCR to set out the methodology that an AI is required to follow for the calculation of its BIC Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) To provide that an AI must, after each calendar quarter end date - (a) calculate its Business Indicator (BI) as the sum of the following 3 components, each as determined respectively under items 9(2), (3) and (4):
(i) Interest, Leases and Dividend Component (ILDC); (ii) Services Component (SC); and (iii) Financial Component (FC), and (b) for the determination of ILDC, SC and FC, include the data of any acquired business and merged activities over the period prior to the Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.3, 25.4, 25.7 and 25.34
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) acquisition/merger that is relevant to the calculation; and (c) convert its BI to its BIC in accordance with item 11. (2) To provide that an AI must determine the ILDC as the sum of- (a) the lower of- (i) the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net interest income for the last 3 years; and (ii) 2.25% times the arithmetic mean of the interest earning assets for the last 3 years; and (b) the arithmetic mean of the dividend income for the last 3 years. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.5
Supervisory guidance:
As mentioned under item 7(14), (13), (12) and (4), we intend to replicate OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework in SG to provide guidance for the following items:
“interest income” (component for calculating “net interest income”; “interest expenses” (component for calculating “net interest income”; “interest earning assets”; and “dividend income”. (3) To provide that an AI must determine the SC as the sum of- (a) the higher of- (i) the arithmetic mean of the other operating income for the last 3 years and Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.5
Supervisory guidance:
As mentioned under item 7(22), (21), (7) and (6), we intend to replicate OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework in
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (ii) the arithmetic mean of the other operating expenses for the last 3 years, and (b) the higher of- (i) the arithmetic mean of the fee and commission income for the last 3 years; and (ii) the arithmetic mean of the fee and commission expenses for the last 3 years. SG to provide guidance for the following items:
“other operating income”;
“other operating expenses”;
“fee and commission income”; and
“fee and commission expenses”.
(4) To provide that an AI must determine the FC as the sum of- (a) the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net P&L on trading book for the last 3 years; and (b) the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net P&L on banking book for the last 3 years. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.5
Supervisory guidance:
As mentioned under item 7(19) and (18), we intend to replicate OPE10.2 (Table 1) of the Basel Framework in SG to provide guidance for the following items:
“net P&L on trading book”; and
“net P&L on banking book”.
(5) To provide that an AI must determine the arithmetic mean of the income referred to in item 9(2)(b) and each of the income or expenses referred to in item 9(3) for the last 3 years by:
(a) aggregating the income or expenses for the last 3 years; and (b) dividing the aggregate figure arrived at in (a) by 3. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.5
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (6) To provide that an AI must determine the arithmetic mean of the interest earning assets referred to in item 9(2)(a)(ii) for the last 3 years by:
(a) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the first year; (b) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the second year; (c) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the third year; and (d) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (a), (b) and (c) by 3. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.5
(7) To provide that an AI must determine the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net interest income referred to in item 9(2)(a)(i) and each of the net P&L referred to in item 9(4) for the last 3 years by:
(a) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution in the first year; (b) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution in the second year; (c) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution in the third year; and (d) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (a), (b) and (c) by 3. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.5 footnote 1
(8) To provide that where, on any calendar quarter end date subsequent to the date on which this section comes into operation, an AI has been in operation for 18 months or more but less than 3 years, the institution shall treat any Items 9(8) and (9) are modifications of the transitional arrangements specified under section 341 of the BCR to
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) partial year of operation of 6 months or more as a full year, and any partial year of operation of less than 6 months as zero, for the purpose of calculating any arithmetic mean referred to in items 9(5), (6) and (7) for the last 3 years. cater for the more granular parameters in the revised framework. (9) To provide that, without prejudice to item 9(8), on any calendar quarter end date subsequent to the date on which this section comes into operation – (a) Where an AI has been in operation for 2 years and 6 months or more but less than 3 years, the AI must – (i) determine the arithmetic mean of the income referred to in item 9(2)(b) and each of the income or expenses referred to in item 9(3) for the last 3 years by:
(A) aggregating the income or expenses for the first year and the second year; (B) annualising the income or expenses for the partial year; and (C) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A) and (B) by 3. (ii) determine the arithmetic mean of the interest earning assets referred to in item 9(2)(a)(ii) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the first year; Items 9(8) and (9) are modifications of the transitional arrangements specified under section 341 of the BCR to cater for the more granular parameters in the revised framework.
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (B) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the second year; (C) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets outstanding at the end of each full calendar quarter within the partial year; and (D) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A), (B) and (C) by 3. (iii) determine the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net interest income referred to in item 9(2)(a)(i) and each of the net P&L referred to in item 9(4) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution in the first year; (B) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&Lrecognized by the institution in the second year; (C) annualising the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution of the partial year; and (D) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A), (B) and (C) by 3. (b) Where an AI has been in operation for 2 years or more but less than 2 years and 6 months, the AI must –
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (i) determine the arithmetic mean of the income referred to in item 9(2)(b) and each of the income or expenses referred to in item 9(3) for the last 3 years by:
(A) aggregating the income or expenses for the first year and the second year; and (B) dividing the aggregate figure arrived at in (A) by 2. (ii) determine the arithmetic mean of the interest earning assets referred to in item 9(2)(a)(ii) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the first year; (B) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the second year; and (C) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A) and (B) by 2. (iii) determine the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net interest income referred to in item 9(2)(a)(i) and each of the net P&L referred to in sub-item 9(4) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution in the first year;
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (B) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&Lrecognized by the institution in the second year; and (C) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A) and (B) by 2. (c) Where an AI has been in operation for 18 months or more but less than 2 years, the AI must – (i) determine the arithmetic mean of the income referred to in item 9(2)(b) and each of the income or expenses referred to in item 9(3) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the income or expenses for the first year; (B) annualising the income or expenses for the partial year; and (C) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A) and (B) by 2. (ii) determine the arithmetic mean of the interest earning assets referred to in item 9(2)(a)(ii) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets as at the 4 calendar quarter end dates of the first year; (B) determining the arithmetic mean of the institution’s interest earning assets outstanding at the end of each full calendar quarter within the partial year; and
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (C) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A) and (B) by 2. (iii) determine the arithmetic mean of the absolute value of the net interest income referred to in item 9(2)(a)(i) and each of the net P&L referred to in item 9(4) for the last 3 years by:
(A) determining the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution in the first year; (B) annualising the absolute value of the net interest income or the net P&L recognized by the institution of the partial year; and (C) dividing the sum of the figures arrived at in (A) and (B) by 2. Item 10. Add a Division in Part 9 of the BCR to set out the required exclusions from the BI Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) To provide that an AI must not take into account any of the following items in the calculation of the BI:
(a) income and expenses from insurance or reinsurance businesses; (b) premiums paid and reimbursements/payments received from insurance or reinsurance policies purchased; (c) administrative expenses, including staff expenses, outsourcing fees Basel Framework reference:
OPE10.3
Note: For item 10(1)(f), reference to “interest expenses” (instead of to “financial and operating lease expenses” under OPE 10.3(6)) is intentional. “Financial and operating lease expenses” is not intended to be a defined term in the
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) paid for the supply of non-financial services (e.g. logistical, IT, human resources), and other administrative expenses (e.g. utilities, telephone, travel, office supplies, postage); (d) recovery of administrative expenses including recovery of payments on behalf of customers (e.g. taxes debited to customers); (e) expenses of premises and fixed assets (except when these expenses result from operational loss events); (f) depreciation/amortisation of tangible and intangible assets (except depreciation arising from operating lease assets should be included in interest expenses); (g) provisions/reversal of provisions (e.g. on pensions, commitments and guarantees given) except for provisions arising from operational loss events; (h) expenses due to share capital repayable on demand; (i) impairment/reversal of impairment (e.g. on financial assets, nonfinancial assets, investments in subsidiaries, joint ventures and associates); (j) changes in goodwill recognized in P&L accounts; and (k) corporate income tax (tax based on profits including current tax and deferred tax). BCR, and is subsumed under the defined term “interest expenses”. (2) To provide that the MA may approve an AI to exclude data related to its divested businesses and activities from the calculation of the BI, if the Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.33
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) institution demonstrates to the satisfaction of the MA that the divested businesses and activities are no longer relevant to its risk profile. [Note: such exclusions must be disclosed in accordance with the Pillar 3 requirements.] Item 11. Add a Division in Part 9 of the BCR to set out the methodology that an AI is required to follow for converting the BI into the BIC Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) To provide that an AI must determine its BIC by - (a) separating its BI into 3 portions as shown in the following Table; (b) multiplying each portion with the corresponding marginal coefficient as shown in the Table; and (c) aggregating the 3 products arrived at for the 3 portions. Portion of BI (HK$’ billion) Marginal coefficient 10 or less 12% Over 10 and up to 300 15% Over 300 18% Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.7 (an example is given in Footnote 2 that follows OPE25.7). € is converted into HK$ at an exchange rate of €1 = HK$10.
Item 12. Add a Division in Part 9 of the BCR to set out the methodology that an AI is required to follow for the determination of its ILM Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) To provide that for the purpose of determining the ILM, an AI must be classified into one of the following 3 categories based on the size of its BI:
BI (HK$’ billion) Category
10 or less Bucket 1 AI
Over 10 and up to 300 Bucket 2 AI
Over 300 Bucket 3 AI
Basel Framework reference:
The categorisation is in line with the classification of banks as described in OPE25.11 and 25.18. (2) To provide that subject to item 12(11), any Bucket 1 AI must take its ILM as 1. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.11
(3) To provide that subject to item 12(7), any Bucket 2 or Bucket 3 AI that meets the requirement set out in item 12(4) must determine its ILM based on the below formula (Formula A):
Formula A
ILM = ln [exp(1) -1 + (LC/BIC) 0.8] where LC is the AI’s Loss Component which is calculated by multiplying the arithmetic mean of its operational risk losses incurred over the following period by 15:
Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.8 and 25.12
OPE25.15 (which requires “all years of good-quality data available beyond 5 years must be included”). We do not intend to require the annualising of operational loss in a partial year since operational loss does not occur regularly or on an ongoing basis, hence annualisation is not a good way to proxy annual operative loss.
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (i) if the institution has maintained high quality operational loss data for the last 10 years or more, the period is the last 10 years; and (ii) if the institution has maintained high quality operational loss data for the last 5 years or more but less than the last 10 years, the period is such number of years. Supervisory guidance:
See remarks for “high quality operational loss data” under item 7(9). Guidance will be provided in SG to explain this term. (4) To provide that if an AI is to calculate its ILM by Formula A set out under item 12(3) according to the provisions in this Division, it must have maintained high quality operational loss data for at least the last 5 years. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.10 (without exercising the MA’s discretion to allow an AI to calculate its ILM using less than 5 years of high quality operational loss data). Supervisory guidance:
See remarks for “high quality operational loss data” and “operational loss event” under items 7(9) and (20) respectively. Guidance will be provided in SG to explain these terms. (5) To provide that in calculating the “operational risk losses” in a year for the purpose of determining its ILM based on Formula A, an AI must take the sum of the gross loss amounts of any operational loss events recognized by the institution in the year minus the recovery amounts of any operational loss events received by the institution in the same year. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.25 (which provides that banks should use losses net of recoveries in the loss dataset) and OPE25.29 (which provides that losses should be allocated to the corresponding years of the loss dataset in line with their accounting treatment). Supervisory guidance:
Guidance on the computation of the gross loss amount will be provided in SG based on OPE25.24 to 25.27 of the Basel
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) Framework. (6) To provide that:
(a) An AI must calculate “the arithmetic mean of the operational risk losses” for a period of the last 10 years, or any number of years between 5 and 10 years, as the case requires, by (i) calculating the amounts of operational risk losses for the first year and every year preceding the first year in the period; (ii) aggregating the amounts of operational risk losses for all the years in the period; and (iii) dividing the result in (ii) by the number of years in the period; and (b) Where, on any calendar quarter end date subsequent to the date on which this section comes into operation, the number of years is between 5 and 10 years, an AI must treat any partial year of more than 6 months as a full year and any partial year of less than 6 months as zero. BCR reference:
The OPE chapters of the Basel Framework do not specify the treatment of a partial year. Our intended treatment follows the spirit of section 341(2)(a)(ii) of the BCR, which takes into account the data in a partial year of 6 months or more in the calculation. However, we do not intend to require the annualising of operational loss in a partial year since operational loss does not occur regularly or on an ongoing basis, hence annualisation is not a good way to proxy annual operational loss. (7) To provide that subject to items 12(8), (9) and (10), any Bucket 2 or Bucket 3 AI which does not meet the requirement set out in item 12(4) must take its ILM as 1.25. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.10 (see remarks for item 12(4)).
Requiring such AIs to take ILM as 1.25 is a local treatment to reflect the MA’s intention to penalise AIs which fail to meet the relevant data or event classification requirements.
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (8) To provide that any AI, on first becoming a Bucket 2 or Bucket 3 AI, may initially take its ILM as 1 for a transitional period of no longer than 9 months or any other period as agreed by the MA, and must determine its ILM based on Formula A after such period. This is a local treatment to provide some leniency taking into account industry comments received during the consultation. (9) To provide that, unless otherwise approved by the MA, any newly established Bucket 2 or Bucket 3 AI that has been in operation for less than 5 years must take its ILM as 1. This is a local treatment to provide some leniency to those newly established AIs falling within this scenario, which is expected to be a rare occurrence in practice. The “unless otherwise approved by the MA” wording is intended to be a flexibility, where necessary, to tailor the ILM value (e.g. in case a value higher than 1 is considered appropriate to hasten an AI’s compliance with the date requirements) to cater for circumstances peculiar to each case. (10) To provide that:
(a) for any Bucket 2 or Bucket 3 AI that is required to calculate its capital adequacy ratio on both a solo basis and a consolidated basis under section 3C of the BCR, if it only meets the requirement set out in item 12(4) on a solo basis but not on a consolidated basis, it must take the following as its ILM on a consolidated basis:
(i) 1.25 if its ILM determined on a solo basis based on Formula A is less than or equal to 1; or (ii) the higher of 1.25 or its ILM determined on a solo basis based on Formula A, if the latter is higher than 1; and This is a local treatment that is consistent with OPE25.13 of the Basel Framework. When an AI can meet the data quality standards only on a solo basis but not a consolidated basis, we propose that its ILM on a consolidated basis should be the higher of 1.25 or the value of the solo ILM. Making the ILM larger than 1 should provide an incentive for AIs to meet the data quality standards on a consolidated basis. 1.25 is determined by expert judgement, to which the industry did not object during consultation of the policy proposal.
Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (b) in this item 12(10), a reference to calculating the capital adequacy ratio on a solo basis means calculating the ratio on a soloconsolidated basis for any AI that has been granted the MA’s approval to do so under section 28(2)(a) of the BCR. (11) To provide that any Bucket 1 AI may calculate its ILM based on Formula A if:
(a) it meets the following conditions:
(i) it is a subsidiary of a larger banking group; and (ii) it has notified the MA that the following conditions are met at least 3 months prior to wishing to calculate its ILM by Formula A:
it meets the requirement set out in item 12(4); its parent company calculates ILM on a consolidated basis under the capital rules applicable to such company; and its operational loss data are either included in the calculation of its parent company’s ILM or would be included in such calculation were it not for justifiable considerations such as the materiality of the institution in relation to its banking group, or (b) it has obtained the MA’s prior consent to do so. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.11 (item 12(11)(a) is a local requirement to address industry comments received during the consultation). OPE25.11 provides a discretion for supervisors to allow Bucket 1 banks to calculate their own ILMs. Item 12(11)(b) caters for the situation where the MA decides to exercise this discretion more generally at a later stage when relevant loss data reported by Bucket 1 AIs evidence that they can meet the standards for high quality operational loss data as specified by the MA in accordance/alignment with OPE25 (please also see proposed definition for “high quality operational loss data” in item 7(9) above).
Item 13. Add a Division in Part 9 of the BCR to set out the required exclusions from the LC Matters to be provided Remarks (including references) (1) To provide that for the purpose of calculating its LC, an AI must exclude the losses arising from an operational loss event under any of the following situations:
(a) the cumulative losses after deduction of recoveries arising from the event over the period referred to in item 12(3) is less than a threshold prescribed by the MA in accordance with OPE25.18 of the Basel Framework; (b) the losses have been accounted for in the risk-weighted amount for credit risk; or (c) the MA has approved the institution to exclude the losses arising from the event from the calculation. Basel Framework reference:
OPE25.18, 25.20, 25.30 and 25.32
Supervisory guidance: The threshold under item 13(1)(a) will be set out in SG at €20,000 (i.e. HK$200,000) based on OPE25.18. We do not presently intend to exercise the discretion in OPE25.18 to increase the threshold to €100,000 (i.e. HK$1,000,000), but including a threshold in SG will provide us with the flexibility to adjust it quickly in the future if necessary. (2) To provide that the MA will grant the approval in item 13(1)(c) if he considers it prudent to exclude such losses having regard to the risk profile of the institution. Guidance on the conditions that an AI needs to satisfy for the MA to grant the approval will be set out in SG. The conditions are based on Basel Framework OPE25.30 and 25.32, viz., where (i) the loss event is no longer relevant to the AI’s risk profile, (ii) the loss amount is significant enough to justify for the exclusion and (iii) the loss has been included in the AI’s operational losses (for LC calculation) for at least 3 years. The MA may also consider approving exclusion under other scenarios on a case by case basis.
Supervisory guidance to supplement BCR amendments for implementing Basel III revised operational risk capital framework 1
Table A - BI Components (re OPE10.2 Table 1 of Basel Framework)
Income statement or balance sheet items Description Typical sub-items Reference in proposed BCR amendments (i) Interest, leases and dividend component (ILDC) 1 Interest income Interest income from all financial assets and other interest income (including interest income from finance and operating leases and profits from leased assets) Interest income from loans and advances, assets available for sale, assets held to maturity, trading assets, finance leases and operating leases Interest income from hedge accounting derivatives Other interest income Profits from leased assets Item 7(14) 2 Interest expenses Interest expenses from all financial liabilities and other interest expenses (including interest expenses from finance and operating leases, depreciation and impairment of operating lease assets, and losses from leased assets) Interest expenses from deposits, debt securities issued, finance leases and operating leases Interest expenses from hedge accounting derivatives Other interest expenses Losses from leased assets Depreciation and impairment of operating lease assets Item 7(13)
1 This supervisory guidance may take the form of a Code of Practice (“CoP”) or a supervisory policy manual module, etc., to be issued by the Monetary Authority (“MA”). A CoP is one to be issued by the MA under section 97M of the Banking Ordinance.
Annex 2
Income statement or balance sheet items Description Typical sub-items Reference in proposed BCR amendments 3 Interest earning assets Total gross outstanding loans, advances, interest bearing securities (including government bonds and zero coupon bonds) and leased assets, including those in nonaccrual status Item 7(12) 4 Dividend income Dividend income from investments in stocks and collective investment schemes not consolidated in the AI’s financial statements, including dividend income from nonconsolidated subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures Item 7(4) (ii) Services component (SC) 5 Fee and commission income Income received from providing advice and services (including income received by the AI for providing outsourcing services) Fee and commission income from:
Securities (issuance, origination, reception, transmission, execution of orders on behalf of customers) Clearing and settlement Asset management Custody Fiduciary transaction Payment services Structured finance Servicing of securitizations Loan commitments and guarantees given Foreign transactions (e.g. foreign exchange, remittance) Item 7(7) 6 Fee and commission expenses Expenses paid for receiving advice and services (including outsourcing fees paid Fees and commission expenses from:
Clearing and settlement
Item 7(6)
Income statement or balance sheet items Description Typical sub-items Reference in proposed BCR amendments by the AI for the supply of financial services, but not outsourcing fees paid for the supply of non-financial services such as those on logistics, IT, human resource) Custody Servicing of securitizations Loan commitments and guarantees received Foreign transactions (e.g. foreign exchange, remittance) 7 Other operating income Income from ordinary banking operations not included in but of a similar nature to any of the other items (under the column of “Income statement or balance sheet items”) in this table, excluding income from operating leases Rental income from investment properties Gains from non-current assets and disposal groups classified as held for sale not qualifying as discontinued operations (measured in accordance with IFRS 5.37 or HKFRS 5) Item 7(22) 8 Other operating expenses Expenses and losses from ordinary banking operations not included in but of a similar nature to any of the other items (under the column of “Income statement or balance sheet items”) in this table, and from operational loss events, excluding expenses from operating leases Losses from non-current assets and disposal groups classified as held for sale not qualifying as discontinued operations (measured in accordance with IFRS 5.37 or HKFRS 5) Losses incurred as a consequence of operational loss events (e.g. fines, penalties, settlements, replacement cost of damaged assets), which have not been provisioned/reserved for in previous years Expenses related to establishing Item 7(21)
Income statement or balance sheet items Description Typical sub-items Reference in proposed BCR amendments provisions/reserves for operational loss events (iii) Financial component (FC) 9 Net P&L on trading book Gains minus losses on trading assets and trading liabilities (e.g. derivatives, debt securities, equity securities, loans and advances, short positions, other assets and liabilities) Gains minus losses from hedge accounting Gains minus losses from exchange differences Item 7(19) 10 Net P&L on banking book Gains minus losses on financial assets and liabilities measured at fair value through the profit and loss account Realised gains minus losses on financial assets and liabilities not measured at fair value through the profit and loss accounts (e.g. loans and advances, assets available for sale, assets held to maturity, financial liabilities measured at amortised cost) Gains minus losses from hedge accounting Gains minus losses from exchange differences Item 7(18)
Table B - Standards for high quality operational loss data (re item 7(9) of proposed BCR amendments)
Item Particulars Basel Framework reference 1 An AI must have documented policies, procedures and processes to manage operational loss data for capital calculation purposes covering:
(i) end-to-end system design for identification, collection, aggregation and treatment of the data; (ii) storage, retention, archiving and as applicable deletion of the data; and (iii) back-up of the data, and such policies, procedures and processes must be subject to:
validation before the loss data can be used for the calculation of capital charge for operational risk under Part 9 of the BCR; and regular independent reviews by internal or external auditors or other capable parties. OPE25.16 2 An AI must classify and document the criteria for classifying an operational loss event into one of the event-type categories specified in Table C in accordance with the description, categories and activity examples described in the Table. OPE25.17 3 An AI must capture operational loss data from- all material activities and exposures; all appropriate systems and subsystems and all geographic locations. OPE25.18 4 An AI must maintain operational loss data for an operational loss event if the cumulative operational losses arising from the event after deduction of recoveries over the calculation period as applicable to the AI is more than or equal to HK$200,000. OPE25.18. € is converted into HK$ at an exchange rate of €1 = HK$10.
Item Particulars Basel Framework reference 5 The operational loss data for an operational loss event referred to in item (4) must include the information as set out in Table D. OPE25.19 6 An AI must have processes to independently review the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the operational loss data. OPE25.22 7 An AI must maintain records of payments received for recovery of operational losses. If requested by the MA, the AI must produce the records to the MA for inspection. OPE25.25 8 An AI must build its loss data set based on the “date of accounting” (see item 1 “reference dates” in Table D). OPE25.28 9 Losses and related recoveries caused by a common operational loss event or by related operational loss events over time but posted to the accounts over several years should be allocated to the corresponding years in line with their accounting treatment. OPE25.29 10 The scope of losses used to calculate the operational risk capital requirements must include acquired businesses and merged entities over the period prior to the acquisition/merger that is relevant to the calculation. OPE25.34
Table C – Classification of operational loss events (re OPE25.17 Table 2 of Basel Framework / item 7(20) of proposed BCR amendments)
An AI should regard as an operational loss event any event that falls within any of the event-type categories based on the classification guidance tabulated as follows:
Event-type category Description Categories Activity examples Internal fraud Losses due to acts of a type intended to defraud, misappropriate property or circumvent regulations, the law or company policy, excluding diversity/ discrimination events, which involves at least one internal party Unauthorised activity Transactions not reported (intentional) Transaction type unauthorised (with monetary loss) Mismarking of position (intentional) Theft and fraud Fraud / credit fraud / worthless deposits Theft / extortion / embezzlement / robbery Misappropriation of assets Malicious destruction of assets Forgery Check kiting Smuggling Account takeover / impersonation etc Tax non-compliance / evasion (wilful) Bribes / kickbacks Insider trading (not on firm’s account) External fraud Losses due to acts of a type intended to defraud, misappropriate property or circumvent the law, by a third party Theft and fraud Theft / robbery Forgery Check kiting Systems security Hacking damage Theft of information (with monetary loss) Employment practices and workplace safety Losses arising from acts inconsistent with employment, health or safety laws or agreements, from payment of personal injury Employee relations Compensation, benefit, termination issues Organised labour activity Safe environment General liability (slip and fall etc) Employee health and safety rules events
Event-type category Description Categories Activity examples claims, or from diversity / discrimination events Workers compensation Diversity and discrimination All discrimination types Clients, products and business practices Losses arising from an unintentional or negligent failure to meet a professional obligation to specific clients (including fiduciary and suitability requirements), or from the nature or design of a product. Suitability, disclosure and fiduciary Fiduciary breaches / guideline violations Suitability / disclosure issues (know-your-customer etc) Retail customer disclosure violations Breach of privacy Aggressive sales Account churning Misuse of confidential information Lender liability Improper business or market practices Antitrust Improper trade / market practices Market manipulation Insider trading (on firm’s account) Unlicensed activity Money laundering Product flaws Product defects (unauthorised etc) Model errors Selection, sponsorship and exposure Failure to investigate client per guidelines Exceeding client exposure limits Advisory activities Disputes over performance of advisory activities
Event-type category Description Categories Activity examples Damage to physical assets Losses arising from loss or damage to physical assets from natural disaster or other events Disasters and other events Natural disaster losses Human losses from external sources (terrorism, vandalism) Business disruption and system failures Losses arising from disruption of business or system failures Systems Hardware Software Telecommunications Utility outage / disruptions Execution, delivery and process management Losses from failed transaction processing or process management, from relations with trade counterparties and vendors Transaction capture, execution and maintenance Miscommunication Data entry, maintenance or loading error Missed deadline or responsibility Model / system misoperation Accounting error / entity attribution error Other task misperformance Delivery failure Collateral management failure Reference data maintenance Monitoring and reporting Failed mandatory reporting obligation Inaccurate external report (loss incurred) Customer intake and documentation Client permissions / disclaimers missing Legal documents missing / incomplete Customer / client account management Unapproved access given to accounts Incorrect client records (loss incurred) Negligent loss or damage of client assets Trade counterparties Non-client counterparty misperformance Miscellaneous non-client counterparty disputes Vendors and suppliers Outsourcing Vendor disputes
Table D – Information required to be maintained for an operational loss event
Information Narratives Basel Framework reference
Information Narratives Basel Framework reference financial accounting periods (“timing losses”). Any material timing loss (i.e. that exceeds HK$200,000) should be included in the loss data set when it is due to the event that spans more than one financial accounting period and gives rise to legal risk. but must exclude:
(a) costs of general maintenance contracts on property, plant or equipment; (b) internal or external expenditures to enhance the business after the operational risk losses: upgrades, improvements, risk assessment initiatives and enhancements; and (c) insurance premiums.
4. Operational
risk loss
Operational risk loss is the gross loss amount net of recoveries. OPE25.24
5. Recoveries of
gross loss amount
A recovery in relation to an operational loss event means, subsequent to a loss being recognized, the occurrence of funds or inflows of economic benefits received from a third party. Recoveries should be divided into non-insurance recoveries and insurance recoveries. Only payment received (as opposed to receivables) can be counted as recoveries. Tax effects, which refer to the benefit of deferred tax liability or reductions in corporate income tax liability due to operational losses, should also be excluded. OPE25.24, 25.25 and
25.19 (FN4)
Table E – Exclusion of loss data from LC calculation
Reference in proposed BCR amendments
Particulars Basel Framework reference
Item 13(1)(a) The threshold for excluding the losses from an operational loss event from the calculation of the LC is HK$200,000, consistent with item (4) of Table B. OPE25.18 Item 13(2) The MA will consider it prudent to exclude the losses arising from an event from the calculation of the LC if the following conditions are met:
(a) the institution proves to the satisfaction of the MA that the event is no longer relevant to the institution’s risk profile; (b) the cumulative losses after deduction of recoveries arising from the event over the calculation period exceeds 5% of the arithmetic mean of annual operational risk losses over the same period; and (c) the losses arising from the event have been included in the calculation of the annual operational risk losses for a period of at least 3 years. (This does not apply to an event occurred in businesses or activities divested by the institution.) OPE25.30 and 25.32
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 5 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated