Enforcement · SMV · 23 Nov 2016
Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa is sanctioned with revocation of its operating authorization for fifteen infractions: six very serious (misallocating client funds, net equity below minimum capital, liquidity and solvency indicator below the minimum, retaining persons with legal impediments, facilitating false information to clients, and non-compliant credit operations), one serious (failure to deliver account statements), and four minor (failure to obtain client orders and three failures to timely communicate relevant facts).
Lima, 23 November 2016
Summary: Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa is sanctioned with the revocation of its operating authorization for having incurred fifteen (15) infractions:
Six (06) very serious:
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations for allocating funds received as a result of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.11 of the Sanctions Regulations for having a net equity lower than the minimum capital established.
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.12 of the Sanctions Regulations for having a liquidity and solvency indicator lower than the minimum established by the regulations.
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the Sanctions Regulations for directly maintaining persons who have a legal impediment or who do not comply with the requirements established by the regulations and for allowing them to carry out activities of the intermediation agent.
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulations for allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inaccurate information to the detriment of its clients.
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex I, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations for carrying out credit operations that do not comply with the provisions of the regulations.
One (01) serious:
One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulations for not delivering account statements to its clients.
Four (04) minor: - One (01) infraction contemplated in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations for not obtaining orders from its clients.
Three (03) infractions contemplated in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations for not timely communicating its relevant facts.
Administered party
:
Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa.
Subject
:
Administrative sanctioning procedure.
File No.:
2016035717.
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
Administrative files No. 2016035717 and No. 2016035729, Reports No. 877-2016-SMV/10.3 and No. 915-2016-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance and the defenses presented by Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa; and,
1. Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Commission for the Supervision of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
2. By means of writings sent to this Superintendency on 03 June and 04 July 2016, Mrs. María Teófila Alvarez Mayorca (hereinafter, Mrs. ALVAREZ) filed a complaint against GPI SAB, among others, because said stock brokerage company would have carried out unauthorized operations allocating the money delivered to purposes other than those entrusted; as well as it would not have delivered information to her that proves the operations instructed by her;
3. According to the provisions of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, LPAG) and the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, SANCTIONS REGULATIONS), in the preliminary investigation stage, a series of actions were carried out, among which are informing Mrs. ALVAREZ of the competencies of the SMV and the National Institute for the Defense of Competition and the Protection of Intellectual Property (INDECOPI); requesting information and documentation from the complainant and from GPI SAB; all of this, in order to clarify and know in detail the reported facts and determine the existence or not of indications of infraction according to the regulations, which has been developed in detail in Report No. 877-2016-SMV/10.3;
4. In addition to the aforementioned case, it should be noted that within the supervision and control activities assigned to the SMV, it was ordered to carry out two (02) inspection visits to GPI SAB, in order to verify compliance with the regulations applicable to the development of its functions related to securities intermediation. The first inspection was carried out between 08 and 23 September 2015 and the second inspection was carried out between 30 March and 13 April 2016;
5. By means of Reports No. 480-2016-SMV/10.2 and No. 780-2016-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Entity Supervision (hereinafter, IGSE), communicated to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (hereinafter, IGCP), the results of the evaluation of the indications of infractions by GPI SAB;
6. Likewise, by means of Memorandum No. 261-2016-SMV/10.2, No. 2508-2016-SMV/10.2 and No. 3069-2016-SMV/10.2, the IGSE communicated to the IGCP, the results of the evaluation of the indications of infraction with respect to the presentation of eventual information, as well as compliance with other obligations established in the regulations by GPI SAB;
7. It should be noted that the results of the two inspections carried out as well as that obtained from the review of compliance regarding the timeliness of the presentation of eventual information as well as other obligations established in the regulations by GPI SAB, have been evaluated in detail by the IGCP in Report No. 915-2016-SMV/10.3;
8. It should be noted that by means of Deputy Superintendent Resolution No. 047-2016-SMV/10, the accumulation of the administrative proceedings followed against GPI SAB through administrative files No. 2016035717 and No. 2016035729 was ordered, the same that will be evaluated under file No. 2016035717;
9. In that sense, the two cases outlined referred to by the files mentioned in the preceding recital will be developed in this resolution in two (02) chapters, indicating in each of them the detail of the development of the administrative sanctioning proceedings initiated against GPI SAB according to each case;
10. As indicated in the Facts section of this resolution, the SMV has carried out various supervision and control actions regarding the actions of GPI SAB in the securities market, in accordance with file No. 2016035729;
11. It should be noted that as a result of the foregoing recital and under the provisions of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Official Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, OFFICIAL LETTERS OF CHARGES), the IGCP initiated an administrative sanctioning proceeding against GPI SAB, imputing charges for having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV) and the Regulation of Intermediation Agents approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, RAI), in aspects related to having a liquidity and solvency indicator below the minimum level established in the regulations; the use of client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted; for having a net worth lower than that established in the regulations; for directly maintaining persons who have a legal impediment or without observing that they meet the requirements established in the regulations; for granting credits without observing the provisions of the regulations; and, for the failure to timely communicate relevant facts;
12. By writings submitted on 27 September, 04 and 05 October 2016, GPI SAB presented its defenses to Official Letter No. 5485-2016-SMV/10.3. It should be noted that, with respect to Official Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI SAB has not presented the corresponding defenses, despite having been validly notified with the referred official letter;
13. By Resolution of the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance No. 008-2016-SMV/10.3, it was resolved to accumulate files No. 2016035729 and No. 2016040289, having verified that there are common elements between them, so they are connected, which will form part of file No. 2016035729;
14. The charges formulated against GPI SAB and the defenses presented by the latter have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 915-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, REPORT), which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
15. In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, item 2, of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 6833-2016-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 915-2016-SMV/10.3 was made available to GPI SAB for its review;
16. In this administrative proceeding, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
a) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, by having a liquidity and solvency indicator below the minimum level required by the regulations;
b) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, by using client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
c) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in the infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.11 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, by having a net worth lower than the required capital, as it did not comply with covering the company's equity deficit as provided in the regulations;
d) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, for directly maintaining persons who have a legal impediment or without observing that they meet the requirements established in the regulations;
e) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infringement of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, by granting credits without observing the provisions of the regulations;
f) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infringement of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.14 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, by not timely communicating its relevant facts;
g) Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on GPI SAB for the matters indicated in the preceding items;
17. Article 172 of the LMV provides that stock brokerage firms must comply with the liquidity and solvency margins established by the SMV;
"Article 172.- Liquidity and Indebtedness Margins "Intermediation agents must comply with the indebtedness margins and other minimum liquidity and patrimonial solvency conditions that CONASEV indicates in relation to the type of operations, the term, the amount or the nature of the instruments traded and the class of intermediaries."
18. In that sense, Article 116, numeral 116.3 of the RAI provides the following:
Article 116.- Margins and conditions of liquidity and patrimonial solvency In accordance with the provisions of the Law, the margins and conditions of liquidity and patrimonial solvency are the prudential levels and limits that Agents must comply with regarding the following concepts: (…) 116.3 Liquidity and Solvency Indicator. (…).";
19. Within that context, articles 118 and 124 of the RAI establish that the agent company must maintain at all times a liquidity and solvency indicator equal to or greater than 1 and in the event of non-compliance, this must be reversed within three (03) days of the occurrence of said non-compliance;
"Article 118.- Reversal period.- The Agent's non-compliance with the aforementioned prudential levels and limits must necessarily be reversed within three (03) days of its occurrence, (...)".
"Article 124°.- Prudential Level.- The Agent must have at all times a liquidity and solvency indicator equal to or greater than 1";
20. On the other hand, in relation to the destination of the funds that the principals deliver to the agent company, article 195, literal a) of the LMV, establishes that intermediation agents are prohibited from allocating the funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
"Article 195.- Prohibitions Agent companies are subject to the following prohibitions, without prejudice to those contemplated in Article 177 and the others that emanate from this law: a) Allocating the funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted; (...)";
21. Likewise, article 48 of the RAI establishes that the securities, financial instruments or funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a different purpose unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in articles 194° and 207° of the LMV;
"Article 48.- Basic Rules.- The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in articles 194° and 207° of the Law. (...)";
22. Regarding the net equity of the agent company, article 189 of the LMV establishes, among others, that the net equity of agent companies cannot be less than the minimum capital and that the equity deficit incurred will be covered within thirty (30) days following its verification by the SMV;
"Article 189.- Minimum capital (...). Likewise, the net equity of agent companies cannot be less than the minimum capital. The equity deficit incurred will be covered within thirty (30) days following its verification by CONASEV";
23. For its part, articles 118, second paragraph, 120 and 122 of the RAI establish the following:
"Article 118.- Reversal period.- (...) In merit of the provisions of the Law, the net equity deficit of an Agent must be remedied within a maximum period of thirty (30) days. In this case, the verification by the SMV referred to in the Law shall be the sole communication of equity deficit that the Agent must make or any control action of the SMV".
Article 120.-. Calculation.- In the absence of information that accredits compliance with the margins and conditions of liquidity and equity solvency by an Agent, the respective body of CONASEV, on the basis of the information presented or corresponding to said Agent, may perform the respective calculations that allow it to obtain an approximation regarding the situation of said margins and conditions, when it considers it necessary as a result of its own supervisory activities
"Article 122.- Net Equity.- The Agent must maintain at all times a net equity that is equal to or greater than the amount of minimum capital established, in accordance with the provisions of the Law.
(...)";
24. Additionally, it should be noted that article 96 of the RAI establishes that:
"Article 96.- Rejection The Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV may reject the financial statements of an Agent, when any of the situations detailed below is verified: 96.1. Non-compliance with the rules governing their preparation. 96.2. Lack or non-existence of the source documentation, evidence or records that must support the financial statements presented. The rejection of the financial statements of an Agent means that they are not reliable, and in this case, the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV may issue the corresponding corrective measures. In situations where CONASEV determines the need to have information on the financial and economic situation of an Agent, for supervision and control purposes, it may make supported adjustments and estimates, on the basis of the information available to it.";
25. On the other hand, it should be noted that paragraph 58 of IAS 39 Financial Instruments – Recognition and Measurement (hereinafter, IAS 39)1 establishes:
"An entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or group of financial assets2 is impaired";
26. Likewise, paragraph 59 of IAS 39 states:
"A financial asset or a group of financial assets is impaired if, and only if, there is objective evidence of impairment as a result of one or more events that occurred after the initial recognition of the asset (a "loss event") and that loss event or events has an impact on the estimated future cash flows of the financial asset or group of financial assets that can be estimated reliably. (...). Objective evidence that an asset or a group of assets is impaired includes observable information that requires the attention of the holder of the asset on the following events that cause the loss:
a) significant financial difficulties of the issuer or the obligor;
b) breaches of contractual clauses, such as non-payment or delays in the payment of interest or principal;
c) the lender, for economic or legal reasons related to the borrower's financial difficulties, grants concessions or advantages that it would not have granted under other circumstances,
d) the borrower is likely to enter bankruptcy or another form of financial reorganization.
(…)”
27. Regarding the simultaneous exercise of the duties of director and representative of the stock brokerage company, article 8, numeral 5 of the RAI states:
[1] Applicable at the time of the commission of the facts.
[2] In which the Accounts Receivable are included.
“Article 8.- Conditions of organizers, shareholders and directors As applicable, the following rules must be observed: (…) 8.5 The same person may not simultaneously hold the positions or duties of Director and Representative of the Agent.”;
28. With regard to the granting of credits, article 194, literal m) of the LMV provides that stock brokerage companies are authorized to grant credits to their clients solely for the purpose that such clients acquire securities or financial instruments;
“Article 194.- Operations (…) m) Grant credits, with their own resources, solely for the purpose of facilitating the acquisition of securities by their principals, whether or not listed on the stock exchange and with the guarantee of such securities; (…)”;
29. Likewise, article 51 of the RAI establishes: “Article 51.- Contract.- The Agent may grant credits to its clients solely so that they can acquire securities or financial instruments through it. For this purpose, the Agent must enter into a loan agreement with its client, in which all the conditions of the credit shall be established”;
30. Finally, regarding the obligation to timely present relevant facts, article 98° of the RAI establishes that stock brokerage companies must inform the SMV of their relevant facts on the business day following the adoption of the agreement, the occurrence of the fact or the taking of knowledge thereof;
“Article 98.- Communication.- The Agents must inform CONASEV of their relevant facts within the business day following the adoption of the agreement or decision, the occurrence of the fact or act or having taken knowledge thereof, as applicable, in accordance with the means and forms established by CONASEV. The General Manager is responsible for timely communicating the Agent's relevant facts. The situations detailed in Annex 9, which occur in relation to a given Agent or its economic group, constitute relevant facts that the Agent must communicate to CONASEV, with sufficient detail and documentation; without prejudice that, by their nature, other situations not listed in said Annex also have such qualification and must be reported to CONASEV;
31. Likewise, Annex 9, numeral 12, of the RAI indicates as a relevant fact:
“Annex 9 (…) 12. Appointment and changes of directors, managers, Internal Control Officer, representatives, officers and legal representatives or attorneys-in-fact, and must present the list of names and positions of the removed or outgoing officers and of the officers appointed in their replacement, as well as the dates of cessation and commencement of duties, respectively.”;
32. Through Official Letter No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 (FIRST OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES) and Official Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3 (SECOND OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES), the following charges were imputed to GPI SAB:
a) For having a liquidity and solvency indicator below the minimum level required by the regulations, failing to comply with the provisions of article 172 of the LMV and article 124 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a very serious nature: “Not having a liquidity and solvency indicator equal to or higher than the minimum level, in accordance with the provisions of the regulations.”
b) For allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, contravening, as well as the provisions of article 195, literal a), as well as article 48 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as a very serious infraction: “Allocating funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.”
c) For having a net equity lower than the required capital, failing to comply with the provisions of article 189 of the LMV, as well as article 118, second paragraph and article 122 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.11 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a very serious nature: “Not having a net equity equal to or higher than the amount of the minimum capital, in accordance with the provisions of the regulations.”
d) For allowing persons who have a legal impediment or without observing that they comply with the requirements established in the regulations to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent, failing to comply with the provisions of article 8, numeral 8.5 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a very serious nature: “Maintaining directly or indirectly persons who have any legal or regulatory impediment, not observing that they comply with the requirements established in the current regulations, or allowing or facilitating them to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent.”
e) For granting credits without complying with the purpose established in the regulations, contravening the provisions of article 194, literal m) of the LMV and article 51 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex I, numeral 1.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, which establishes as a very serious infringement: “Perform functions, operations, activities, acts or contracts, not authorized or that do not comply with the requirements established in the regulations or that have not been registered in the Registry, when applicable.”
f) For not timely communicating relevant facts, breaching the provisions of article 98 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, which establishes as a minor infringement: “Not communicating relevant facts, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations”;
33. By Official Letter No. 3102-2016-SMV/10.2 of 24 May 2016, the IGSE, as a consequence of the analysis carried out on the information and documentation provided by GPI SAB during the inspection, communicated to the brokerage firm, among other observations, that the Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (hereinafter, ILS) as of 31 December 2015 was submitted to the SMV with calculation errors, among others, because the credits granted in favor of GPI Asset Management SAC (GPI ASSET), Mrs. Antonia Bellido Tagle Fernández Concha (Mrs. BELLIDO) and Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar (Mr. ARIZMENDI) did not have the respective guarantees, in accordance with the provisions of the RAI. Therefore, it was observed that upon recalculating, the ILS as of 31 December 2015 was less than 1, that is, the brokerage firm would be breaching the requirement of article 124 of the RAI, which states that the ILS must at all times be equal to or greater than 1;
Table No. 1
Recalculation of liquidity and solvency indicator as of 31 December 2015
| LIQUIDITY AND SOLVENCY INDICATOR | GPI SAB | SMV Recalculation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Net Equity | 959,816.00 | -3,856,580.00 | |
| B. Risk-Weighted Holding of Non-Debt Securities (TPR VNRD) | 68,436.87 | 68,436.87 | |
| C. Risk-Weighted Holding of Debt Securities (TPR VRD) | 0.00 | 0.00 | |
| D. Total Risk-Weighted Holding | 68,436.87 | 68,436.87 | |
| E. Net Amount of Short Positions and Breaches (INPDI) | 70,986.00 | 70,986.00 | |
| F. Equity Coverage Requirement (D + E) | 139,422.87 | 139,422.87 | |
| G. Excess or Deficit of Net Equity (A - F) | 820,393.13 | 820,393.13 | |
| H. Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (A / F) | 6.884 | -4.701 | |
| Source: Own elaboration |
34. By written submission presented on 31 May 2016, GPI SAB in response to Official Letter No. 3102-2016-SMV/10.2, regarding the observation on the guarantees of the “Accounts receivable from related parties”, stated that they met with their external auditors in order to evaluate all necessary measures to correct said situation and that allow either the computation of said guarantees or their replacement;
35. On 01 August 2016 GPI SAB informed the SMV that as of 31 July 2016 it had an ILS of 15.0213 ;
36. On 07 September 2016, by means of Official Letter No. 5101-2016-SMV/10.2, the IGSE, among other things, observed to the agent company that it was verified that the prudential limit relating to the ILS as of 31 July 2016, based on the determination of net equity, did not comply with what was required by the RAI, for which reason it required GPI SAB to remedy the ILS deficit within a period of three (03) days from receipt of said letter. Likewise, it was required to recognize in the financial statements, the liability and/or disclosure of the ongoing judicial proceedings, as applicable, in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards, of the debt that it would maintain with Ms. ALVAREZ;
[3] File No. 2016029390.
37. By means of a document submitted to the SMV on 12 September 2016, the agent company responded to Official Letter No. 5101-2016-SMV/10.2, and stated that it was carrying out the relevant actions for the purpose of restoring the ILS prudential limit. In that sense, it had not complied with remedying the deficit within a period of three (03) days from the receipt of said letter,
38. By Superintendent Resolution No. 126-2016-SMV/02, the operating authorization of GPI SAB was suspended, among other things, for not remedying the deficit of the ILS indicator as established in articles 118 and 124 of the RAI;
39. Additionally, according to the SECOND CHARGE LETTER, GPI SAB reported to the SMV that as of 31 July 2016 it had an ILS of 15.021, that is, within the levels required by the regulations; however, the calculation of said indicator by GPI SAB would have been prepared with some inaccurate data, which are analyzed in detail below:
40. For the purpose of determining the net equity of the stock exchange agent company as of a given date, article 125, numeral 125.2.3, of the RAI establishes that, from the sum obtained from net equity and the subordinated debt issued by the agent, the following must be deducted: "Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors, provided that they do not have guarantees that are 100% and of immediate realization";
41. In this regard, from the review of the Basic Financial Statements of GPI SAB as of 31 July 2016, submitted to the SMV, specifically the Statement of Financial Position as of said date, it was observed that the amount of "Accounts receivable from related parties" amounted to S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles), which is composed of credits granted to its related parties GPI ASSET, Ms. BELLIDO and Mr. ARIZMENDI4, credits which do not have guarantees of immediate realization5;
42. As established in the RAI, as long as the obligations constituting accounts receivable from related entities disclosed in the financial statements are not backed by the respective guarantees, these must be deducted for the calculation of net equity. However, it was verified that the amounts corresponding to the loans made by GPI SAB to its related parties were not included as part of the deductible items for the calculation of net equity, a component which then serves to perform the calculation of the ILS, as established in the regulations;
43. It should be noted that GPI SAB submitted as guarantees of immediate realization in favor of the loans to its related parties6, the following documents:
[4] According to the Notes to the Financial Statements as of 31 December 2015.
[5] This situation can be perceived from the audited financial information of GPI SAB as of 31 December 2015, where it was verified that in the same line item, there was an amount of S/ 9 486 971.00 (nine million four hundred eighty-six thousand nine hundred seventy-one and 00/100 Soles), which includes the credits, without guarantee, granted to its related parties GPI ASSET and Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI.
[6] In response to Memorandum No. 002-2016.INSPECCIÓN GPI.
a) For the loan to GPI ASSET: a share certificate of PPX Mining Corp. (formerly, Peruvian Precious Metals Corp) (TICKER PPX), a management and success fee contract for the private fund Costamar Pacífico and a business plan of GPI ASSET.
b) For the loan to Ms. BELLIDO: Expectant rights to profits and dividends regarding the ownership of the shares of GPI SAB, as owner of more than 90% of the same.
c) For the loan to Mr. ARIZMENDI: a share certificate of PPX, unexercised warrants of PPX and the title of concession of the metallic mine "Crema";
44. However, the documents submitted by GPI SAB in no case qualify as guarantees of immediate realization with respect to the credits with its related parties, given that the documents submitted in themselves are not concrete securities that the debtors – GPI ASSET and Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI – grant in favor of their creditor, since there is no evidence of a legal document constituting them as a real or personal guarantee;
45. Therefore, the accounts receivable from related parties reported in the Basic Financial Statements of GPI SAB as of 31 July 2016, which reaches the amount of S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles)7 must be considered in its entirety, as a deductible item, for the purposes of calculating the net equity of the agent company as of said date, in application of article 125, numeral 125.2.3 of the RAI. Which, as has been indicated, was not considered by GPI SAB in accordance with the ILS information submitted as of 31 July 2016;
46. For the purpose of determining the balances of client funds in intermediation accounts with respect to client credit balances (Control Annex 5) as of that date, in accordance with the information reported by GPI SAB as of 31 July 2016, as well as the documents held in the SMV's files8, the results shown in Annex 1 of Report N° 915-20106-SMV/10.3 were obtained, which are summarized in the following table;
Table N° 2 Control Annex 5: Indicator of client fund custody accounts as of 31.07.2016
| BALANCES FROM CLIENT OPERATIONS | |
|---|---|
| In Soles | S/ |
| Total Client Credit Balances (A) | 4,561,174.00 |
| Client Funds in Intermediation Accounts (B) | 1,995,396.00 |
| Difference (Surplus/Deficit) (B-A) | -2,565,778.00 |
47. The line item "Total Client Credit Balances (A)" takes into consideration the amount of S/ 1 939 218 (One million nine hundred thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen and 00/100 Soles)9 in view of the complaint filed
[7] A situation that can be seen from the Audited Financial Statements of GPI SAB as of 31 December 2015.
[8] Case Files N° 2016012090 and N° 2016022341.
[9] In accordance with the complaint filed, Ms. ALVAREZ made various deposits and withdrawals to GPI SAB to make investments. In this regard, she presents a letter dated 15 July 2015, signed by the General Manager of GPI SAB, through which he acknowledges that Ms. Alvarez maintains an investment account with her company in
the SMV by Ms. ALVAREZ against GPI SAB and its representatives, in which it is stated, according to the complainant, that the agency firm would have carried out operations other than those authorized with the money she delivered to the agency firm10. It should be noted that this situation has not been clarified by GPI SAB to date;
48. On the other hand, according to what was stated by GPI SAB, the agency firm would have used funds from clients other than Ms. ALVAREZ to cover margin requirements for repurchase operations of other clients in an amount of S/. 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles)11. Taking into account the provisions of Article 195, paragraph a) of the LMV12, it should be mentioned that to date, the agency firm has not provided evidence of the authorizations of the aforementioned clients to use their funds for said purpose;
49. In this manner, in accordance with the result shown in Table 2 of this resolution, the agency firm as of 31 July 2016 at least had a deficit in the client fund custody accounts, in the amount of S/ 2 565 778 (Two million five hundred sixty-five thousand seven hundred seventy-eight and 00/100 Soles), that is, it was verified that the accounting balances of client funds were considerably lower than the total credit balances of clients on that date;
50. Therefore, considering the complaint filed by Ms. ALVAREZ against GPI SAB and the fact that said agency firm has not provided evidence of the authorizations of the clients that support the use of their funds to cover margin requirements for repurchase operations of other clients in repurchase agreements13, GPI SAB must deduct said funds from the calculation of net worth.
abroad valued at USD 645 000,00 (six hundred forty-five thousand and 00/100 United States dollars). However, the amount included for the delivery of funds by Mrs. Álvarez to GPI SAB under the heading “Total Credit Balances of Clients (A)”, as of 19 September 2016, is USD 571 030,00 (five hundred seventy-one thousand thirty and 00/100 United States dollars). In this regard, the SMV has considered the movements of the funds owned by Mrs. Alvarez, (deposits and withdrawals) to which access has been possible during the investigation carried out. This amount has been expressed in soles at an exchange rate of S/ 3,396 as of 16 September 2016. These figures have been considered for the purposes of calculating prudential indicators of Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores Sociedad Agente de Bolsa PI SAB, without prejudice to the administrative procedures arising from the complaint filed by Mrs. Alvarez.
[10] This situation, to date, has not been clarified by GPI SAB, despite the SMV's request through Official Letter No. 5101-2016-SMV/10.2.
[11] Result obtained from the comparison of the balances of client funds in intermediation accounts with respect to the credit balances of clients, without considering the amount corresponding to Mrs. ALVAREZ.
[12] Article 195, literal a) of the LMV states that stock brokerage companies are prohibited from using the funds or securities they receive from their clients for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
[13] In this regard, through Official Letter No. 2651-2016-SMV/10.2 of 04 May 2016, GPI SAB was requested to provide: “Detail and supporting documentation of the differences obtained from the reconciliation of credit balances of clients versus the funds in operational bank accounts, according to the following summary (the complete calculation is attached in the email sent on 21.04.2016)”. In response, on 05 May 2016, GPI SAB replied the following: “(…) as a consequence of fixed income operations (repurchase agreements) on the side of our reported clients, a difference has been generated between the balance existing in banks and the balances of our creditor clients; the main cause has been the volatility of the securities market in the period of dates December 2015, January and February 2016; to this are added the margin calls of the repurchase operations that forced us to replenish before CAVALI, given that in this compliance we are a binding and joint party in the repurchase operations, with the commitment of payment of our clients in the short term or by entering guarantees in their portfolio”. From the foregoing, it is reasonably deduced that it did not have authorizations from the clients and took the funds without their authorization.
51. In this sense, taking into account the information indicated above, as well as the financial information of GPI SAB as of 31 July 2016, the recalculation of the ILS reported by GPI SAB was carried out, determining as a result of the procedure performed an ILS corresponding to the agent company below the limit established in article 124 of the RAI, that is, less than one (01), according to the following detail:
Table No. 03
Recalculation of the Liquidity and Solvency Indicator as of 31 July 2016 (In soles) LIQUIDITY AND SOLVENCY INDICATOR GPI VALORES SAB RECALCULATION SMV A. Net Equity 1,323,647.00 -2,479,820.88 B. Risk-Weighted Holding of non-Debt-Representative securities (TPR VNRD) 68,436.87 68,436.87
C. Risk-Weighted Holding of Debt-Representative securities
(TPR VRD) 0.00 0.00
D. Total Risk-Weighted Holding 68,436.87 68,436.87 E. Net Amount of Uncovered Positions and Defaults (INPDI) 19,683.00 19,683.00 F. Equity Coverage Requirement (D + E) 88,119.87 88,119.87 G. Excess or Deficit of Net Equity (A - F) 1,235,527.13 -2,567,940.75 H. Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (A / F) 15.021 -28.141
52. It should be noted that the recalculation of the ILS is carried out taking as reference the adjusted net equity14, that is, deducting the amount of: (i) S/ 8 124 372,00 (eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles) corresponding to the total of the account “Accounts receivable from Related Entities” reported by GPI SAB in its financial information as of 31 July 2016; and (ii) S/ 2 565 778,00 (Two million five hundred sixty-five thousand seven hundred seventy-eight and 00/100 soles) for the deficit of funds in its intermediation accounts15;
53. Likewise, it should be indicated that GPI SAB did not comply with remedying the deficit in its liquidity and solvency indicator within the term established in article 118 of the RAI;
54. Consequently, it is concluded that GPI SAB would have maintained an ILS below the level required in the RAI, according to the information used for the recalculation as of 31 July 2016;
55. In this regard, according to the foregoing, GPI SAB would have breached the provisions of article 172 of the LMV, as well as article 124 of the RAI and consequently would be subject to an infraction classified as very serious as provided in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
56. In this regard, as can be seen in the file, the SECOND OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, with which the charge under
[14] The detail of the calculation of the net equity is shown in Annex 2.
[15] When reconciling the custody of client funds in intermediation accounts on the dates December 31, 2015, January 29, 2016 and February 29, 2016, the following differences were obtained in the intermediation accounts: S/ -391 658.00 -(three hundred ninety-one thousand six hundred fifty-eight and 00/100 soles); S/ -584 172 –(five hundred eighty-four thousand one hundred seventy-two and 00/100 soles) and S/ 836 881.00 (eight hundred thirty-six thousand eight hundred eighty-one and 00/100 soles) respectively.
of evaluation, was validly notified via MVNET to GPI SAB; however, GPI SAB did not submit the respective defenses;
57. In this regard, it is appropriate to carry out the respective evaluation, as indicated in the detail of the charge formulated, GPI SAB reported that as of July 31, 2016 it had an ILS with a value of 15.021, stating in that regard that its ILS was within the limits required by the RAI;
58. However, the SMV observed to GPI SAB that said calculation contained inaccurate data, since the amounts corresponding to the credits granted to its related parties did not have the respective guarantees, in accordance with the provisions of the RAI. Likewise, it was determined that as of July 31, 2016, GPI SAB maintained a deficit in the intermediation accounts (client custody accounts); which implied a modification in the calculation of the net equity and therefore in the corresponding ILS16;
59. With regard to the credits granted to related parties without guarantees17, it should be noted that in the Statement of Financial Position of the Basic Financial Statements of GPI SAB as of July 31, 2016, it was observed that the amount of “Accounts receivable from related parties” amounted to S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles), is composed of the credits granted to its related parties GPI ASSET, Mrs. BELLIDO and Mr. ARIZMENDI18;
60. With respect to which, when the agent company was required to accredit the respective guarantees of immediate realization, for the accounts receivable from related parties19, as established by the RAI, GPI SAB presented certain documents that in no way qualify as guarantees of immediate realization with respect to said credits; since they do not constitute concrete securities that said debtors grant in favor of their creditor, the stock brokerage agent company, while, as has been noted, there is no evidence of a legal document that could constitute a real or personal guarantee;
61. Therefore, considering that said credits are not backed by the respective guarantees of immediate realization20, the amount of S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred
[16] “Article 123.- Definition.- The liquidity and solvency indicator is a ratio that results from dividing the net equity of the Agent by the result of the sum of its risk-weighted holdings plus its uncovered positions, all at a given day”.
[17] In order to determine the net equity of the stock brokerage agent company at a given date, article 125, numeral 125.2.3, of the REGULATION establishes that, from the sum obtained from the net equity and the subordinated debt issued by the agent, the “Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors, provided they do not have 100% guarantees and of immediate realization” must be deducted.
[18] For the loan to GPI ASSET: a share certificate of PPX Mining Corp. (formerly, Peruvian Precious Metals Corp) (TICKER PPX), a management and success fee contract of the private fund Costamar Pacífico and a business plan of GPI ASSET. For the loan to MRS. BELLIDO: Expectant rights for profits and dividends regarding the ownership of the shares of GPI SAB, as owner of more than 90% of the same and for the loan to MR. ARIZMENDI: a share certificate of PPX, warrants to be executed of PPX and concession title of the metallic mining company “Crema”. .
[19] In accordance with the Notes to the Financial Statements as of December 31, 2015.
[20] Said situation can be perceived from the audited financial information of GPI SAB as of December 31, 2015, where it was verified that in the same item, there was an amount ascending to S/ 9 486 971.00 (nine million four hundred eighty-six thousand nine hundred seventy-one and 00/100 Soles), which includes the credits, without guarantee, granted to its related parties GPI ASSET and Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI.
seventy-two and 00/100 Soles), referred to above, should have been considered in its entirety, by GPI SAB, as a deductible concept for the calculation of the net equity;
62. Likewise, regarding the deficit of funds in Intermediation Accounts, as mentioned in the detail of the charge formulated, according to the information reported by GPI SAB as of 31 July 2016, as well as the documents in the files of the SMV, the results obtained show the existence of a deficit in the balances for client operations, as shown in Table 2 of this resolution, in the amount of S/ 2 565 778. In the item called “Total Credit Balances of Clients (A)” an amount of S/ 1 939 218 (One million nine hundred thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen and 00/100 Soles) was considered in response to the complaint filed by Mrs. ALVAREZ against GPI SAB and its representatives, referring to the fact that the brokerage firm would have carried out operations different from those authorized with the money she gave it, a situation that has not been clarified by GPI SAB to date;
63. However, considering the existence of said deficit in the intermediation accounts and after evaluating the information provided by GPI SAB in this regard, the brokerage firm would have used funds from other clients, in order to cover guarantee margins for report operations of other clients reported in an amount of S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles)21 without, to date, the brokerage firm having complied with proving the authorizations of the aforementioned clients to use their funds for said purpose, considering the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV, despite the requirements made;
64. Thus, according to the result shown in Table 2, the brokerage firm as of 31 July 2016 maintained a deficit in the custody accounts of client funds, in an amount of S/ 2 565 778 (Two million five hundred sixty-five thousand seven hundred seventy-eight and 00/100 Soles), whereby it has been verified that the accounting balances of client funds were considerably lower than the total credit balances of clients on said date and for the referred amount;
65. In this sense, considering the amount for the complaint made by Mrs. ALVAREZ against GPI SAB, and that the brokerage firm has not complied with presenting documentation that supports the respective authorizations for the use of client funds for the purpose indicated by the stock brokerage firm, GPI SAB should have affected the results of the period, as of July 2016, and therefore deduct said amount from the calculation of net equity, a fact that was not carried out by the brokerage firm;
66. Therefore, the ILS corresponding to 31 July 2016 was recalculated, taking as reference the adjusted net equity, that is, deducting the amounts of the concepts referring to “Accounts Receivable from Related Entities” amounting to S/ 8 124 372 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles), as well as the amount amounting to S/ 2 565 778,00 (Two million five hundred sixty-five thousand seven hundred seventy-eight and 00/100 Soles) referring to the deficit of funds in its intermediation accounts;
[21] Result obtained from the comparison of the balances of client funds in intermediation accounts with respect to the credit balances of clients, without considering the amount corresponding to Mrs. ALVAREZ.
67. In that sense, the result was an ILS corresponding to the brokerage firm of -28.141 as of 31 July 2016, that is, less than one (01), whereby it has been determined that in said period GPI SAB maintained an ILS below the limit established in article 124 of the RAI. Which was not reversed by GPI SAB within a period of three (3) days in accordance with the provisions of article 118 of the RAI;
68. Therefore, taking into account that GPI SAB has not offered evidentiary elements or arguments that allow the imputed charge to be disproved, it has been proven that as of 31 July 2016, according to the recalculation carried out, GPI SAB maintained a Liquidity and Solvency Indicator below the level required in the RAI;
69. Consequently, considering what was stated in the evaluation carried out in relation to the charges made, it has been proven that according to the recalculation carried out, GPI SAB maintained a Liquidity and Solvency Indicator below the required level;
70. Similarly to the preceding events, for 2015 indicators, GPI SAB initially submitted prudential indicators that observed the limits established for them. In this sense, according to the information submitted by GPI SAB to the SMV, as of 31 July and 31 August 2015, the Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (hereinafter, ILS) of the stock brokerage firm, as one of the prudential limits that every intermediation agent must comply with in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, were the following:
Table No. 4
| LIQUIDITY AND SOLVENCY INDICATORS | 31/07/2015 | 31/08/2015 |
|---|---|---|
| A. NET EQUITY (NE) | 7,070,299.00 | 7,005,485.00 |
| B. SUBORDINATED DEBT (SD) | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| C. NET EQUITY + SUBORDINATED DEBT (A + B) | 7,070,299.00 | 7,005,485.00 |
| Other deductible concepts | 744,337.00 | 718,650.00 |
| c. Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors that do not have 100% guarantees | 3,712,363 | 3,705,619 |
| D. DEDUCTIBLE CONCEPTS (DC) | 4,456,700.00 | 4,424,269.00 |
| E. NET EQUITY = (C-D) | 2,613,599.00 | 2,581,216.00 |
| F. Weighted Total Risk Holding | 68,436.87 | 68,436.87 |
| G. Net Amount of Uncovered Positions and Defaults (INPDI) | 635,554.00 | 969,191.00 |
| H. Equity Coverage Requirement (F + G) | 703,990.87 | 1,037,627.87 |
| I. Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (E / H) | 3.713 | 2.488 |
71. Likewise, according to the information submitted by GPI SAB, the amounts recorded under the deductible items in order to calculate the aforementioned indicator (in order to obtain net equity), as of 31 July and 31 August 2015, in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, were as follows;
Table No. 5
INFORMATION ON THE DEDUCTIBLE ITEMS FOR THE CALCULATION OF NET EQUITY
| Deductible items* | 31/07/2015 (S/) | 31/08/2015 (S/) |
|---|---|---|
| Trade accounts receivable overdue by more than 10 days | 149,305 | 128,481 |
| Other accounts receivable overdue by more than 10 days | 110,702 | 111,121 |
| Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors that do not have collateral | 3,712,363 | 3,705,619 |
| 50% of the value of real estate, machinery and equipment free of liens | 137,942 | 134,194 |
| Net intangible assets | 221,361 | 219,526 |
| Prepaid expenses | 22,515 | 22,816 |
| Deferred charges and taxes | 102,512 | 102,512 |
| Total deductible items | 4,456,700 | 4,424,269 |
72. From the evaluation of the information required during the inspection, it was observed that there were significant differences between what GPI SAB reported to the SMV for the calculation of the ILS and what was reported in its Basic Financial Statements as of 31 July 2015, so by means of Memorandum No. 002-2015-INSP.GPI SAB of 15 September 2015, the stock brokerage firm was requested to provide the detailed composition of the "Accounts receivable from related entities" and "Other accounts receivable net" appearing in the Statement of Financial Position as of 31 July 2015, as well as the detail of the corresponding collateral;
73. Indeed, from the review of the "Notes to the Basic Financial Statements" corresponding to the closing as of 31 July 2015, in particular the detail of Note 7 "Other Accounts Receivable", it was observed that in the aforementioned period the item referring to "loans to shareholders" appearing as "Accounts receivable from Related Entities" in the Statement of Financial Position as of 31 July 2015 reached the amount of S/ 6 891 618,37 (Six million eight hundred ninety-one thousand six hundred eighteen and 37/100 Soles), observing the aforementioned differences, since the amounts reported by GPI SAB as part of the deductible items to obtain net equity and thus calculate the ILS did not correspond to what was disclosed in said financial statements;
74. By letter of 16 September 2015, GPI SAB, in response to the request made by the SMV officials, stated that the balances of the "accounts receivable from related entities" reported as of 31 July 2015 are composed of loans to shareholders in national currency for an amount of S/ 129 856,00 (One hundred twenty-nine thousand eight hundred fifty-six and 00/100 Soles) and of investment operations receivable or to be settled with the company GPI Asset Management SAC (hereinafter, GPI ASSET), minority shareholder of GPI SAB, for an amount of US$ 2 122 335,93 (Two million one hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred thirty-five and 93/100 United States Dollars) equivalent to S/ 6 761 762,27 (Six million seven hundred sixty-one thousand seven hundred sixty-two and 27/100 Soles);
75. Considering that in the letter of response to the request made, GPI SAB omitted to provide information regarding the request for the detail of the collateral, by means of Memorandum No. 003-2015-INSP.GPI SAB, the company was requested to detail, among others, the investment operations receivable or to be settled with GPI ASSET that generated the account receivable for US$ 2 122 335,93; as well as the collateral that would back the fulfillment of said obligations, considering that GPI SAB in the daily information submitted to the SMV for the calculation of indicators had been reporting a lower amount;
76. By letter of 23 September 2015, GPI SAB, in response to the request made by means of Memorandum No. 003-2015-INSP.GPI SAB, reported that: i) in the case of the funds managed by GPI ASSET, said funds come mainly from the capital increase made by Mrs. BELLIDO and from the own funds for the management of the brokerage firm's own position. Likewise, it stated that these are investment operations receivable or to be settled with GPI ASSET and that the latter granted a promissory note in November 2013 for US$ 1 000 000 (One million and 00/100 United States Dollars), which, as observed from the copy thereof, was signed by Mr. ARIZMENDI22;
77. According to what is stated in the FIRST OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, GPI SAB informed the SMV that its ILS as of 31 July and 31 August 2015 was 3.713 and 2.488, respectively, that is, they were within the levels required by the regulations, also reporting that the amount referred to the "Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors, provided that they do not have 100% collateral and immediate realization" as a deductible item in order to obtain net equity and after calculating the ILS in accordance with the provisions of articles 123 and 125 of the RAI, amounted to S/ 3 712 363,00 and S/ 3 705 619,00, respectively;
78. However, from the review of the Basic Financial Statements as of 30 June 2015 and 31 July 2015 submitted to the SMV, in particular in the detail of the Statement of Financial Position, it was observed that the amounts of the account referring to "Accounts Receivable from Related Entities" appearing as "Loans to Shareholders" in the Notes to said Financial Statements, Note 7 "Other Accounts Receivable", amounted to S/ 6 886 363,33 (Six million eight hundred eighty-six thousand three hundred sixty-three and 33/100 Soles) and S/ 6 891 618,37 (Six million eight hundred ninety-one thousand six hundred eighteen and 37/100 Soles), respectively;
79. In accordance with the provisions of article 125, numeral 2.3 of the RAI, in order to obtain the net equity of the brokerage firm and thus correctly calculate the ILS, the following must be deducted, among others, "Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors, provided they do not have 100% collateral and are immediately realizable";
80. In this regard, in accordance with the provisions of the RAI, as long as the obligations constituting the accounts receivable from related entities disclosed in the financial statements are backed by the respective collateral, in accordance with the provisions of the aforementioned article, they should not be deducted for the calculation of net equity, which could justify the differences in the amounts recorded for the calculation of the indicator and those disclosed in the corresponding financial statements;
81. As noted, GPI SAB reported that the Account receivable from Related Entities disclosed in the Basic Financial Statements as of 31 July 2015 was composed of loans made to shareholders, in the amounts of S/ 129 856,10 and S/ 6 761 762,27, the latter,
[22] Attached is the promissory note issued by GPI Asset Management SAC on 13 November 2013 for the indicated amount and signed by Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar in his capacity as General Manager of said company.
corresponding to the loan made to the company GPI ASSET and they also presented a copy of a promissory note issued by GPI ASSET as collateral23 for the obligation contracted with the brokerage firm. Likewise, with respect to the loan made to shareholders in the amount of S/ 129 856,10, despite the request made by SMV officials, they did not comply with reporting whether or not this obligation had the respective collateral;
82. With regard to the promissory note issued on 13 November 2013 by GPI ASSET, a shareholder of the brokerage firm, on 13 November 2013, for an amount of USD $ 1 000 000,00; it should be noted that the regulatory framework established in the Civil Code and in the Law on Security Interests, Law No. 28677, have not established the possibility of considering the issuance of said security as a real or personal guarantee24 of a patrimonial obligation;
83. In this sense, in accordance with the foregoing, the promissory note presented by GPI SAB as collateral for the obligation contracted by GPI ASSET in favor of the brokerage firm could not be considered as the collateral referred to in article 125 of the RAI;
84. Consequently, in accordance with the provisions of articles 11925 and 12026 of the RAI, the ILS reported by GPI SAB was recalculated based on the information submitted by the brokerage firm with the Basic Financial Statements corresponding to 2014 and 2015; as well as the Annual Audited Financial Statement for fiscal year 2013 and also considering the same information submitted by GPI SAB, such as the other deductible items, the
[23] It is presented by virtue of the request made by SMV officials.
[24] According to Jorge Avendaño, specific guarantees: "(…) are concrete securities that the debtor grants in favor of its creditor, so that the latter may enforce its credit against them, without being subject to the eventuality of its debtor's insolvency. These guarantees have mainly adopted the following forms: a) personal guarantees; and b) real guarantees." AVENDAÑO V., Jorge. "La Prenda". At http://revistas.pucp.edu.pe/index.php/derechopucp/article/viewFile/6515/6591 01.10.2015 03:44 pm "(…) a real guarantee consists of the express encumbrance of one or several assets for the fulfillment of an obligation. The encumbered asset, which is generally owned by the debtor, is thus marked or designated so that the creditor is paid with its value in the event of its debtor's non-compliance." AVENDAÑO V., Jorge. "La Prenda". At: http://revistas.pucp.edu.pe/index.php/derechopucp/article/viewFile/6515/6591 01.10.2015 03:44 pm. "(…) personal guarantees have the purpose of generating accessory obligations, in which a new debtor appears, the accessory debtor, upon the non-compliance of the principal debtor. In this sense, the accessory debtor will be the one who assumes the obligations of the principal through the conduct that the creditor will be able to require based on the rights that its status grants it, enforce the performance and see the payment satisfied." ÍSMODES TALAVERA, Javier. "De las garantías de los títulos valores. La fianza, el aval y la garantía real" in "Tratado de Derecho Mercantil" volume III, Lima, 2004, p. 206.
[25] Article 119 of the REGLAMENTO establishes that: "The Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV may reject the information submitted by an Agent regarding its margins and conditions of liquidity and patrimonial solvency, when any of the situations detailed below is verified: 119.1. Non-compliance with the provisions established for its determination and presentation. 119.2. Lack or non-existence of the documentation, records and other information that must support the information submitted by the Agent. The rejection of said information, regardless of the additional measures that may be applicable or initiated, implies that the Agent has not complied with the respective accreditation obligation."
[26] Likewise, article 120 of the REGLAMENTO states: "Article 120.-Calculation.- In the absence of information accrediting compliance with the margins and conditions of liquidity and patrimonial solvency by an Agent, the respective body of the SMV, based on the information presented or corresponding to said Agent, may perform the respective calculations that allow it to obtain an approximation regarding the situation of said margins and conditions, when it considers it necessary as a result of its own supervisory activities".
weighted risk holdings and uncovered positions, determining as a result of the procedure performed an ILS corresponding to the agent company below the limit established in the RAI for the entire recalculation period, which are recorded in Annex 2 of Report No. 915-2016-SMV/10.327 and which, by way of sample, are detailed, in the following table, the results for 31 July and 31 August 2015;
Cuadro N° 6
| RECALCULO DEL INDICADOR DE LIQUIDEZ Y SOLVENCIA | 31/07/2015 | 31/08/2015 |
|---|---|---|
| A. PATRIMONIO NETO | 7,070,299 | 7,005,485 |
| B. DEUDA SUBORDINADA (DS) | 0 | 0 |
| A. NET EQUITY + SUBORDINATED DEBT | 7,070,299 | 7,005,485 |
| Other deductible concepts | 744,337 | 718,650 |
| c. Accounts receivable from related companies, shareholders, managers and directors that do not have 100% guarantees | 6,886,363 | 6,891,618 |
| B. DEDUCTIBLE CONCEPTS (DC) | 7,635,955 | 7,610,268 |
| C. LIQUID EQUITY = (A-B) | -565,656 | -604,783 |
| D. Total Risk-Weighted Holdings | 68,437 | 68,437 |
| E. Net Amount of Uncovered Positions and Non-Compliances (INPDI) | 635,554 | 969,191 |
| F. Equity Coverage Requirement (D + E) | 703,991 | 1,037,628 |
| G. Equity Coverage Requirement (D) | 68,437 | 68,437 |
| H. Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (C / F) | -0.80 | -0.58 |
| I. Liquidity and Solvency Indicator (C / G) | -8.27 | -8.84 |
Note: For the calculation of the ILS, the basic financial statements as of 30 June and 31 July 2015 are considered.
85. That being so, in accordance with the provisions of article 118 of the RAI, the stock brokerage company's failure to comply with prudential levels and limits such as the ILS should have necessarily been reversed within three (03) days of its occurrence, which was not fulfilled in the present case;
86. In that regard, it was noted that GPI SAB would have maintained an ILS below the level required in the RAI, according to the information used for the recalculation of the preceding indicators; consequently, it has failed to comply with the provisions of article 172 of the LMV and article 124 of the RAI and therefore has incurred an infraction classified as very serious as provided in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, according to which the following constitutes an infraction: “Not having a liquidity and solvency indicator equal to or higher than the minimum level, in accordance with the provisions of the regulations”;
87. In this regard, GPI SAB states that, in accordance with Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 044-2016-SMV/10, a recalculation of the liquidity and solvency margin indicators is performed, in which a provision of S/ 8 124 372 is estimated for the item Accounts Receivable from Related Entities, where the net equity is adjusted by the amount of the provision;
88. On the other hand, they state that under the item “Accounts Receivable from Related Entities” there are amounts charged for disbursements to clients, which, according to GPI SAB, would correspond to client withdrawals, which were initially recorded in GPI SAB's accounts in accordance with the Chart of Accounts, Financial Information and Control Annexes
[27] The recalculation corresponds to a total of 22 dates corresponding to the month-end closing of the period between January 2014 and August 2015 (21 dates) plus the recalculated ILS as of 24 September 2015.
applicable to Stock Brokerage Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 305-1995-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, PREVIOUS MANUAL), which was replaced by the Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution 012-2011-SMV/01 (hereinafter, MANUAL). GPI SAB adds that, according to the MANUAL, the accounts of principals are shown in the Order Accounts and the accounts of the brokerage company are reported in the Balance Sheet Accounts (Statement of Financial Position);
89. However, GPI SAB argues that the funds of foreign principals were not correctly recorded in Order Accounts, in application of the MANUAL. In that regard, GPI SAB alleges that, based on that position, the flows of client withdrawals were assigned to the “Accounts Receivable from Related Entities”, which, according to the brokerage company, should not be subject to a provision for impairment but rather a restructuring of the accounts should be carried out where they should have been assigned in accordance with the MANUAL;
90. In this regard, with respect to the mention of Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 044-2016-SMV/10, by which the administrative intervention of GPI SAB is ordered, it should be noted that the amount of S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles) referred to in said resolution corresponds to the total of the “Accounts receivable from Related Entities” reported by GPI SAB in its financial information as of 31 July 2016, an amount that was considered for the recalculation of the ILS for that period. In this sense, its evaluation does not correspond in the present case, since in the present charge, financial information reported by the stock brokerage company in different periods has been considered, as indicated in the detail of the charge formulated;
91. On the other hand, according to the arguments of GPI SAB, in the Accounts Receivable from Related Entities, amounts paid to clients, foreign principals, would have been considered, which would have initially been recorded in GPI SAB's accounts, that is, in Trade Accounts Receivable, in accordance with the provisions of the PREVIOUS MANUAL; since, according to GPI SAB, the stock brokerage company did not modify the recording of said amounts to the “Order Accounts” in application of the MANUAL, but rather they would have been recorded in the Accounts Receivable from Related Entities;
92. In this regard, taking into account that the amounts mentioned by GPI SAB would refer to amounts corresponding to payments made to principals for withdrawals by them, said amounts could not have been considered as part of a specific account referring to an account receivable, as they are different concepts and in that sense, they could not form part of the Accounts Receivable from Related Entities28, even more so considering that GPI SAB has not presented documentation supporting what was argued in its defense (such as the list of said principals, the corresponding account statements in which the amounts disbursed to them can be identified, as well as the
[28] It should be noted that according to the review of the Individual Interim Financial Information - Balance Sheet as of 30 September 2012, the date of entry into force of the MANUAL, as well as as of 31 December 2012 of GPI SAB, it has been verified that GPI SAB reported that it did not record Accounts Receivable from Related Parties.
circumstances that may have generated a supposed account receivable from its clients, among others), that allows an evaluation in this regard;
93. Without prejudice to what was indicated in the previous recital, it should be mentioned that what was argued by GPI SAB is contradictory with what was stated during the inspection, since in the same, in response to the information requests29 made to the stock brokerage firm regarding the detail of the composition of the Accounts Receivable from Related Entities, as revealed in its Basic Financial Statements as of 31 July 2015, GPI SAB, as has been indicated, declared that the detail of the amounts revealed in said financial statements constituted loans granted to shareholders and investment operations receivable or to be settled to the company GPI ASSET, that is, loans granted to said company;
94. It should be added that the situation described above has been ratified by the external auditors, since, it should be noted, that in Note 6 of the Annual Audited Financial Statements as of 31 December 2015 of GPI SAB, it is observed that the Accounts Receivable from Related Parties includes accounts receivable from GPI ASSET, as well as from Mrs. BELLIDO and Mr. ARIZMENDI related to loans; likewise, it is worth mentioning that in paragraph 5 of the Audit Report of said Financial Statements, the external auditors indicated that as of 31 December 2015, GPI SAB maintains an outstanding balance receivable from its related company GPI ASSET and that the latter subscribed a payment commitment for the debt it maintains with GPI SAB;
95. Additionally, although according to the PREVIOUS MANUAL, the accounts receivable referring to client operations and those corresponding to the own account of the stock brokerage firm were shown on a consolidated basis in the Trade Accounts Receivable of the Statement of Financial Position, in accordance with what is also indicated in the referred manual, separate bank current accounts had to be kept for client operations, from those corresponding to own account and administrative operations of the stock brokerage firm30;
96. In this sense, at the level of detail of the accounting records31, it was possible to distinguish the accounts receivable originated by the operations of the firm from those corresponding to operations of the principals;
97. With regard to the request made by GPI SAB, that the Intervening Commission review the correct allocation of the balance sheet accounts and the order accounts, it should be specified that the correct application of the rule is an obligation of all supervised entities of the SMV, in that sense, the review of the correct allocation of the respective amounts in the corresponding accounts of the Financial Statements corresponds to be carried out by GPI SAB, in coordination with its external advisors, if applicable;
98. According to what has been previously exposed, GPI SAB has not disproved the imputed charge, therefore it has been proven that
[29] Information requests made through Memorandum No. 002-2015-INSP.GPI SA of 15 September 2015.
[30] PREVIOUS MANUAL: Comments to the Account "10 Cash and Banks": "Current accounts must be opened for intermediation operations, differentiated from those corresponding to own account and administrative operations of the company".
[31] "(…) shall be supported by the auxiliary registry of current accounts of principals, duly individualized (…)".
according to the recalculation carried out, GPI SAB maintained a Liquidity and Solvency Indicator below the required level, failing in said periods, the provisions of article 172 of the LMV and article 124 of the RAI;
99. Consequently, GPI SAB has incurred an infraction classified as very serious as provided in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
100. According to what was reported by GPI SAB as of 31 July 2016, from the documents in the archives of the SMV32, and according to the detail on the Balances for Client Operations shown in Table No. 2, it was observed that, according to the information presented by GPI SAB at that time, the deficit of funds in the intermediation accounts as of 31 July 2016 was S/ 2 565 778,00;
101. In this regard, as indicated in the detail of the charge referring to the Liquidity and Solvency Indicator of this resolution, said amount includes the balance payable to Mrs. ALVAREZ in the amount of S/ 1 939 218,00 (One million nine hundred thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen and 00/100 Soles), which is subject to evaluation in a charge different from the present one, so with regard to the amount of S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles)33, according to what was indicated by GPI SAB, according to the responses to the information requests made, the agent company would have used said funds, corresponding to various principals of the agent company, for the purpose of covering guarantee margins for report operations of other reported principals, without having the respective authorization; since despite the request made to the agent company regarding the same, in accordance with the provisions of article 48 of the RAI, it did not comply with proving the existence of such authorizations;
102. Likewise, up to the date of issuance of the SECOND OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, the agent company did not prove the authorizations of principals to use their funds in order to cover guarantee margins of report operations of other principals;
103. Consequently, according to the foregoing, by not having proven the respective authorizations of its principals to dispose of their funds, it is concluded that GPI SAB allocated them to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, so it would have breached the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the RAI; and therefore it would be incurring in an infraction of a very serious nature established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
[32] Files No. 2016012090 and No. 2016022341
[33] Result obtained after deducting the balance payable to Mrs. ALVAREZ.
104. In this regard, as previously indicated in this resolution, the SECOND OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, with which the charge subject to evaluation is imputed, was validly notified via MVNet to GPI SAB; however, it must be indicated that GPI SAB, as of the date of issuance of this report, has not submitted the respective discharges;
105. Without prejudice to the foregoing, it is appropriate to carry out the respective evaluation. Indeed, as indicated in the detail of the charge formulated, according to the information provided by GPI SAB at the time, it was determined that as of July 31, 2016, GPI SAB maintained a deficit of funds in the intermediation accounts in the amount of S/ 2 565 778. This amount includes the balance payable to Mrs. ALVAREZ in the amount of S/ 1 939 218,00 (One million nine hundred thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen and 00/100 Soles), which is subject to evaluation in a charge imputation different from the present one;
106. Thus, with regard to the amount of S/ 626 560 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles), according to what was indicated by GPI SAB in response to the information requests made, the agent company used said funds, corresponding to various principals of the agent company, for the purpose of covering guarantee margins for report operations of other reported principals. This use of funds was made without having the respective authorization; since despite having been required to present such authorizations in accordance with the provisions of article 48 of the RAI, it did not comply with proving to date the existence of the same;
107. Therefore, as of July 31, 2016, according to what was indicated by GPI SAB, it used funds of principals to cover, among others, replenishment of guarantee margins for report operations of reported principals without having the authorization of principals covering the total amount used;
108. In that sense, according to the information provided by GPI SAB at the time and taking into account that said stock brokerage company has not offered evidence or arguments that allow disproving the imputed charge, it has been proven that the agent company used, without having the respective authorization, funds of principals that were under its custody, in the amount of S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles) as of July 31, 2016. This in accordance with the information obtained on the deficit of the intermediation accounts managed by GPI SAB;
109. Consequently, considering the evaluation carried out on the charges and the information presented as discharge, it has been proven that GPI SAB has used funds from the intermediation accounts of its clients without having the respective authorization. Therefore, the stock brokerage company has breached the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the RAI; and therefore has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance SMV Superintendency of the Securities Market DECADE OF PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES IN PERU - YEAR OF THE CONSOLIDATION OF THE SEA OF GRAU Page 26 of 94 110. By Circular No. 020-2016-SMV/10.2 of January 5, 2016 34, GPI SAB was informed that for the 2016 fiscal year, the minimum capital and net equity of a stock brokerage company is S/. 1 912 043 (One million nine hundred twelve thousand forty-three and 00/100 Soles), in accordance with the provisions of article 189 and First Final Provision of the LMV; 111. By Memorandum No. 001 and 002 - 2016.INSPECCION GPI dated 30 March and 07 April 2016, GPI SAB was requested, with respect to the "Accounts Receivable from related parties", which according to the audited financial information of GPI SAB as of 31 December 2015 comprised various transactions totaling S/ 9 486 971 (Nine million four hundred eighty-six thousand nine hundred seventy-one 00/100 soles), to provide for each of said accounts, the contracts and payment commitments, details of collections made and the support for the valuation carried out in order to determine possible provisions for doubtful collection of each transaction; 112. In Annex 1 of the Inspection Completion Record of GPI SAB dated 13 April 2016, it was recorded, among others, that the information requested by Memorandum No. 001-2016-INSPECCION GPI regarding the item "Accounts receivable from related parties" as of 31 December 2015 was pending delivery by GPI SAB; 113. By Official Letter No. 3102-2016-SMV/10.2, the IGSE informed the agent company, among others, that due to the impairment of the account receivable it maintains with its related party GPI ASSET for an amount of S/ 7 229 020 (Seven million two hundred twenty-nine thousand twenty and 00/100 Soles) generated by aspects described in the aforementioned official letter, the need arises to make the corresponding provision; which would bring about an adjustment in the financial statements of GPI SAB that would originate an equity deficit, according to the following recalculation made without considering the implicit tax effects in this type of adjustment: Table No. 7 Equity level as of 31.12.2015 NET EQUITY AS OF 31.12.15 GPI SAB Recalculation SMV A. Capital 6,191,465.00 6,191,465.00 B. Legal Reserve 743,293.00 743,293.00 C. Accumulated results -993,395.00 -993,395.00 D. Adjustment for doubtful collection provision 0.00 -7,229,020.00 E. Total Equity (A+B+C+D+E) = F 5,941,363.00 -1,287,657.00 G. Updated minimum equity Excess or Deficit 1,912,043.00 1,912,043.00 4,029,320.00 -3,199,700.00 114. In that sense, it was communicated that GPI SAB would present an equity deficit of at least S/ 3 199 700, thereby failing to comply with the provisions of article 122 of the RAI, by having a net equity lower than the minimum capital required by the LMV; 115. On 07 September 2016, by Official Letter No. 5101-2016-SMV/10.2, the IGSE required the agent company, among others, i) To make the adjustment for
the impairment of the account receivable from GPI ASSET, considering that the agent company had not complied with presenting the required source documentation supporting the balance of said account receivable nor the support for the valuation (estimate of impairment considering the age of the debt, non-compliance of 34 File No. 2016000029.
payment, credit record, financial situation of the debtor, among other considerations), ii) present the special audit report, as well as iii) the recognition in the financial statements, of the liability and/or disclosure of the ongoing judicial processes, as applicable, in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards, of the debt it would maintain with Mrs. ALVAREZ;
116. According to the FIRST OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, based on the information obtained in the inspection, it was determined that GPI SAB would maintain an equity deficit, in accordance with the following:
117. Despite the information requests made to GPI SAB regarding the analysis of the possible impairment of the account receivable that the agent company maintains with GPI ASSET and the lack of presentation of source documentation regarding the accounts receivable from Mrs. BELLIDO and Mr. ARIZMENDI35, the agent company did not comply with proving the collectability situation and existence of these accounts with the source documentation that originated them;
118. In this regard, the Independent Auditors' Report of 26 February 201636 on the financial statements of GPI SAB corresponding to fiscal year 2015, presents a qualified opinion, regarding the account receivable that GPI SAB maintains with its related party GPI ASSET, due to the uncertainty of collection by GPI SAB of the balance of the account receivable from its related party, the company GPI ASSET, for an amount up to S/ 7 229 020 (Seven million two hundred twenty-nine thousand twenty and 00/100 Soles)37;
119. In that sense, according to said report, the audit firm states, as a basis for its qualified opinion, that there are volatile variables (referring to the share price of the company PPX Mining Corp) that generate uncertainty in the flow presented regarding the return of the cash disbursed to GPI ASSET. Likewise, it indicates that from the date of the first disbursement in January 2013 until the date of issuance of the Report (26 February 2016) GPI ASSET amortized to GPI SAB an amount equivalent to 4% of the total loan granted;
120. Additionally, regarding the provision for impairment of the balance of the account receivable from related parties, the following must be considered:
a) The Independent Auditors' Report of 28 January 2016 of the consolidated financial statements as of 30 September 2015 of PPX Mining
[35] Information requested by Requirement Memoranda No. 001 and 002-2016.INSPECCIÓN GPI dated 30 March and 07 April 2016, the Inspection Completion Record of 13 April 2016 and Official Letter No. 5101-2016- SMV/10.2.
[36] Submitted on 01 March 2016 (File No. .2016008743)
[37] According to what is mentioned in the aforementioned report, said companies signed a payment commitment, including a payment schedule, whose installments will be paid bimonthly until cancellation. Likewise, the agent company attached as supporting documentation to the contract a projection of future cash flows of GPI ASSET's operations for the next 5 years, to support that there would be a return of the cash owed.
Corp., contains an emphasis paragraph indicating that there is uncertainty about the company's ability to continue as a going concern.
Likewise, said indication was made considering the recurring operating losses it has been incurring and the company's negative working capital38. In that sense, as stated, the company will need to increase its capital and obtain additional funds in order to continue as a going concern, concluding that the financial situation of PPX Mining Corp., as of 30 September 2015, is uncertain in the future since it would depend on market conditions and the results obtained from its exploration activity.
b) A significant part of the credit granted by GPI SAB to GPI ASSET would have been used for the acquisition of shares of the company PPX Mining Corp. in the name of third parties, as part of the wealth management service offered by GPI ASSET. This management would be reflected in accounting in subaccount 16890102 of the financial statements of GPI ASSET as of 31 December 2015, called “Gestión de Inversiones $” whose balance as of 31 December 2015 amounts to S/ 5 282 400,00 (Five million two hundred eighty-two thousand four hundred and 00/100 Soles).
According to the historical price information of the PPX security during 2014 and 2015, it is observed that the share has experienced strong volatility with a downward trend. Thus, at the close of 2015 the share was trading at USD 0,02, while its highest price during the 2014-2015 period was during the month of October 2014, reaching a price of USD 0,18. Additionally, as of 16 September 2016, the PPX security traded at USD 0,09.
c) With respect to the financial situation of GPI ASSET, it should be noted that the financial statements as at 31 December 2015 report that its net equity amounts to S/ 26 146,00. As for its assets, it has "Trade receivables" for S/ 1 045 540 corresponding to services to be collected whose payment receipts have an age greater than six (06) months and up to two (02) years. Likewise, it maintains the account "Other receivables" for S/ 7 313 169, of which S/ 5 282 400 would correspond to the acquisition of PPX shares through the "Investment Management"39 service and finally presents the account "Other financial assets" for S/ 548 251 of which 81% correspond to shares of GPI SAB and the remaining 19% correspond to investment shares of the company Conductores Eléctricos Peruanos S.A. which is in the process of liquidation;
121. Therefore, given the collection difficulties of the aforementioned receivables from GPI ASSET, since said company would not have an adequate equity level, nor sufficiently liquid assets to
[38] As at 30 September, the company has negative working capital amounting to CAD 3 889 676, according to note 1 to the audited consolidated financial statements.
[39] The nature of these operations and the name or corporate name of the debtors and the underlying financial assets - among other accounting information of GPI AM required by means of Oficio N° 2651-2016-SMV/10.2 - have not been reported. The name of this service is taken from the financial information of GPI AM. Additionally, it should be noted that GPI AM and GPI SAB have participated in the private placements of PPX Mining Corp. shares. For example, according to the material fact submitted by PPX on 16 July 2015 (Expediente N° 2015028489), which states that "As a commission for bringing the investor to the private placement, the Company issued a total of 3.384.940 common shares in favor of Abraham Gleiser Ludmir, Tomas Silva, GPI Valores SAB and GPI Asset Management S.A., all independent brokers and without any link to the share subscribers, representing 8% of the shares sold to the investor".
address the debt incurred with GPI SAB, it is appropriate for the total amount of S/ 7 229 020 (Seven million two hundred twenty-nine thousand twenty and 00/100 soles) to be deducted from the equity of the agent company, taking into account what is stated in paragraphs 58 and 59 of IAS 39, as well as what is stated in Article 96 of the RAI;
122. Likewise, the receivable from Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI for an amount of S/ 835 352,00 (Eight hundred thirty-five thousand three hundred fifty-two and 00/100 Soles) must also be deducted from the equity of the agent company, considering that GPI SAB did not submit the source documentation proving the existence of these loans, taking into account what is stated in Article 96 of the RAI;
123. In conclusion, the receivable from related parties corresponding to the financial statements of GPI SAB which as at 31 July 2016 has an amount of S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles), must be fully provisioned against the accumulated results account;
124. Considering the foregoing, the net equity of GPI SAB as at 31 July 2016 must be adjusted in accordance with the following detail:
Table N° 8
Equity Level as at 31 July 2016
(In soles)
| NET EQUITY AS AT 31.07.2016 | GPI VALORES SAB | SMV RECALCULATION |
|---|---|---|
| A. Capital | 6,191,465.00 | 6,191,465.00 |
| B. Legal reserve | 743,293.00 | 743,293.00 |
| C. Accumulated results | 1,519,331.00 | 1,519,331.00 |
| D. Adjustment for impairment provision of assets40 | 0.00 | -8,124,372.00 |
| E. Adjustment for deficit of funds in intermediation accounts | 0.00 | -626,560.00 |
| F. Adjustment for balance payable to Mr. Alvarez resulting from the complaint | 0.00 | -1,939,217.88 |
| G. Total (A+B+C+D+E+F) | 8,454,089.00 | -2,236,060.88 |
| H. Updated minimum equity | 1,912,043.00 | 1,912,043.00 |
| I. Excess or Deficit of Equity (E-F) | 6,542,046.00 | -4,148,103.88 |
125. It must be specified that the adjustment made takes into consideration, in addition to the provision for the impairment of the receivable from GPI ASSET and from Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI, the amount corresponding to the deficit of funds in intermediation accounts as at 31 July 2016; as well as the balance payable to Ms. ALVAREZ, considering the complaint filed against GPI SAB and its representatives41;
126. In this sense, according to the SECOND CHARGES NOTICE, it was verified that as at 31 July 2016 GPI SAB presented an equity deficit of S/ 4 148 103,88 (Four million one hundred forty-eight thousand one hundred three
[40] Includes the provision for the impairment of the receivable from its related party, the company GPI ASSET, for an amount of S/ 7 229 020. As well as, the receivable from Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI for an amount of S/ 835 352,00 because the source documentation of the existence of the credits was not submitted.
[41] Regarding the balance payable to Ms. ALVAREZ, it must be noted that according to the investigations carried out in response to the complaint filed, it has been proven that as at 10 July 2015 Ms. ALVAREZ had a balance of funds in her favor for US$ 645 000,00 in the intermediation account of GPI SAB, which, deducted by the concept of additional amounts delivered by GPI SAB to the principal until January 2016 for US$ 73 970,00, yields a net amount not delivered to Ms. ALVAREZ of US$ 571 030,00 (S/1,939,217.88).;
and 88/100 Soles). As of the date of issuance of this resolution, the agent company has not complied with rectifying it;
127. Consequently, GPI SAB has failed to remedy its capital deficit within thirty (30) business days counted from the notification of Office N° 3102-2016-SMV/10.2 dated 24 May 2016, in accordance with the provisions of Article 189 of the LMV and the second paragraph of Article 118 of the RAI;
128. Therefore, GPI SAB would have breached Article 189 of the LMV, Article 96 and the second paragraph of Article 118 and Article 122 of the RAI, as well as paragraphs 58 and 59 of IAS 39. In this regard, GPI SAB is subject to the infringement classified as very serious pursuant to Annex X, item 1, subsection 1.11 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, according to which the infringement consists of “Not having a net worth equal to or greater than the amount of the minimum capital, in accordance with what the regulations establish”;
129. In this regard, as previously indicated in this resolution, the SECOND CHARGE NOTICE, by which the charge under evaluation was imputed, was validly notified to GPI SAB via MVNet; however, it must be noted that GPI SAB did not submit the respective defenses;
130. Without prejudice to the foregoing, the respective evaluation must be carried out. In this regard, according to the charge made, GPI SAB did not make the impairment provision adjustment for the accounts receivable from GPI ASSET as of 31 December 2015 in the amount of S/ 7 229 020 (Seven million two hundred twenty-nine thousand twenty and 00/100 Soles), required by Office N° 3102-2016-SMV/10.2, which entails an adjustment in the financial statements of GPI SAB as of 31 December 2015 and which gives rise to a capital deficit of at least S/ 3 199 700 as of that date;
131. Likewise, according to the Financial Statements as of 31 July 2016 of GPI SAB, the Account Receivable from Related Entities amounts to S/ 8 124 372,00 (Eight million one hundred twenty-four thousand three hundred seventy-two and 00/100 Soles), corresponding to the accounts receivable from GPI ASSET and the accounts receivable from Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI. In this sense, according to the analysis in the detail of the charge formulated, the net worth of GPI SAB must be adjusted as of 31 July 2016, considering said amount, for the impairment provision of the entire account receivable from GPI ASSET, as well as the adjustment for the accounts receivable from Messrs. BELLIDO and ARIZMENDI;
132. Additionally, the adjustment of the amount corresponding to the deficit of funds in the intermediation accounts and the balance payable to Ms. ALVAREZ must also be made, considering the complaint filed against GPI SAB and its representatives;
133. It should be reiterated that GPI SAB has not submitted defenses and documentation that refute the adjustments to the net worth made by the SMV as of 31 July 201. Therefore, it is evident that as of that date GPI SAB presents a capital deficit of S/ 4 148 103,88 (Four million one hundred forty-eight thousand one hundred three and 88/100 Soles);
134. Consequently, according to the foregoing and taking into account that GPI SAB has not offered evidentiary elements or arguments that allow disproving the imputed charge, it has been established that the brokerage firm, by maintaining a deficit in its net equity as of 31 July 2016, has breached article 189 of the LMV, article 96 and the second paragraph of article 118 and article 122 of the RAI, as well as paragraphs 58 and 59 of IAS 39. Therefore, GPI SAB has incurred in an infraction classified as very serious as provided in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.11 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
135. From the supervision actions carried out by the IGSE, it was verified that until 17 August 2016, Mr. Héctor Martín Uccelli Romero (hereinafter, MR. UCELLI) simultaneously exercised the positions and/or functions of Director and Representative of the stock brokerage firm;
136. In that sense, the simultaneous exercise by the same person of the positions or functions of Director and Representative of the Agent violates the requirement set forth in article 8, numeral 5 of the RAI, and therefore would be subject to an infraction classified as very serious according to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, according to which it constitutes an infraction “To maintain directly or indirectly persons who have any legal or regulatory impediment, not to ensure that they comply with the requirements established in current regulations, or to allow or facilitate them to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent”;
137. In this regard, GPI SAB states that the provisions of article 230, numeral 4 of the LPAG regarding the principle of typicity42 must be taken into account; in that sense, it points out that only norms with the rank of law can establish sanctions, and regulations shall only serve to specify or graduate conducts. Therefore, GPI SAB alleges that in the present case article 8.5 of the RAI was used, which, according to the stock brokerage firm, does not have the rank of law and is not based on any of the provisions of the LMV;
138. GPI SAB adds that said conduct is not referred to in any norm with the rank of law and therefore cannot be subject to a sanction. To this must be added, in its opinion, the unreasonableness of the provision;
[42] “Article 230.- Principle of administrative sanctioning power. The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles: (…) 4.- Typicity.- Only infractions expressly provided for in norms with the rank of law, through their typification as such, constitute administratively sanctionable conducts, without admitting extensive interpretation or analogy. Regulatory provisions for development may specify or graduate those aimed at identifying conducts or determining sanctions, without constituting new sanctionable conducts in addition to those legally provided for, except in cases where the law allows typification by regulatory means”.
139. On the other hand, GPI SAB states that the prohibition referred to in article 8, numeral 8.5, only entered into force on 01 February 2013 and MR. UCELLI had the status of Director and Representative prior to the indicated date, so his appointment as such was made before the entry into force of the aforementioned norm;
140. Likewise, GPI SAB alleges that the status of Director and Representative of MR. UCELLI was known to the SMV, since it authorized him as representative of the agent company; however, the agent company points out that despite being fully known to the SMV, it has only now decided to bring it to light, more than three (03) years later;
141. The stock brokerage firm adds that on 25 September 2015 they sent a letter stating that MR. UCELLI had obtained a final passing result at the Universidad Tecnológica del Perú, which, according to GPI SAB, would evidence the good faith of the agent company, since, as indicated by GPI SAB, they have always promptly communicated compliance with the evaluation requirements of their representatives. In that sense, it states that this is clear evidence that the agent company did not attempt to hide that MR. UCELLI held both the position of Director and Representative;
142. The agent company reiterates that the SMV was fully aware of the positions held by MR. UCELLI, even before the aforementioned communication; despite this, according to what was indicated by GPI SAB, the SMV did not point out that a sanctionable infraction was being incurred. Therefore, the agent company states, it is not reasonable that three (03) years later a sanction is intended to be imputed;
143. Finally, it points out that MR. UCELLI no longer holds the position of Director of GPI SAB since 19 August 2016, with which, according to the agent company, said situation was regularized before the notification of the official letter of charges;
144. With regard to the arguments expressed by GPI SAB referring to the fact that article 8.5 of the RAI, on which the imputed charge is based, does not have the rank of law and therefore could not be subject to sanction in accordance with the provisions of article 230, numeral 4 of the LPAG, it must be noted that according to the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of the SMV, Legislative Decree No. 26126, article 1, literal a)43 (hereinafter, ORGANIC LAW OF THE SMV) it is a function of the SMV to issue the legal norms that regulate, among others, matters of the securities market. Likewise, article 7 of the LMV44 establishes that the SMV exercises the
[43] Article 1.- Definition, purpose and functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) (…) The functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) are the following: (…) a) To issue the legal norms that regulate matters of the securities market, product market and collective funds system. (…)”
[44] “Article 7.- Control and Supervision The Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) is the public institution in charge of the supervision and control of compliance with this law. The named institution is empowered to, adhering to the norms of common law and the general principles of law, administratively interpret the scope of the legal provisions related to the matters addressed in this law. It is also empowered to issue the corresponding regulations.”
supervision of compliance with the referred law and that it is empowered to, among other aspects, issue the corresponding regulations;
145. In that regulatory context, the SMV has the power and the obligation to issue the corresponding rules or provisions in order to regulate the securities market, as well as to exercise supervision of compliance with the rules established in the LMV and those it issues on the basis of its powers, by all participants in the securities market, which includes, in accordance with the provisions of article 145 of the LMV, brokerage agents and therefore to comply with supervising that these comply with their obligations in accordance with the established regulations;
146. Likewise, it should be noted that in accordance with article 168 of the LMV46, brokerage agents must obtain authorization for organization and operation from the SMV; in that sense, as provided in the aforementioned article, they are subject to the control and supervision of the SMV and therefore subject to compliance with the provisions of the rules issued by the SMV on the basis of the powers granted by the ORGANIC LAW OF THE SMV and the LMV;
147. Consequently, considering the foregoing, the obligation contained in article 8, numeral 8.5 of the RAI has been established by the SMV on the basis of its regulatory powers established in accordance with the law, and in that sense it constitutes an applicable rule of mandatory compliance by all brokerage agents, as is the case of GPI SAB;
148. Now then, continuing with the analysis, it should be noted that, as GPI SAB rightly mentions, in accordance with the Principle of Typicality, established in article 230, numeral 4 of the LPAG, “Only conducts expressly provided for in rules with the rank of law through their typification as such constitute administratively punishable infractions, without admitting extensive or analogical interpretation (…)”; consequently, in application of said principle, the sanctioning power of the public administration must be exercised within the provisions established by law for that purpose;
149. Taking that into account, it should be noted that the SMV, in accordance with the provisions of article 34247 of the LMV and article 5 of the ORGANIC LAW OF THE SMV48, has full powers to typify the conducts
[45] Article 1.- Purpose and Scope of the Law The purpose of this law is to promote the orderly development and transparency of the securities market, as well as adequate protection for investors. Public offerings of securities and their issuers (…), brokerage agents (…)” are included in this law.
[46] “Article 168.- Authorization of Organization and Operation To serve as a brokerage agent, authorization of organization and operation issued by CONASEV is required, which, through general provisions, shall determine the requirements for each class of brokerage agent. Brokerage agents are subject to the control and supervision of CONASEV.”
[47] “Article 342.- Persons subject to sanction Persons included in the scope of application of this Law who incur infractions of its provisions and of the general provisions issued by the SMV are subject to sanction by the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV). The power to determine the existence of administrative infractions with respect to all natural and legal persons under its jurisdiction prescribes after four years.”
[48] “Article 5. Powers of the Board of Directors of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) The powers of the Board of Directors of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) are the following: (…)
corresponding infractions, as well as to impose the respective sanctions on persons included in the scope of application of the LMV, such as brokerage agents, who incur infractions of the provisions established not only in the LMV, but also for infractions of the general provisions issued by the SMV on the basis of its regulatory powers, such as the provisions established in the RAI and, as in the present case, for non-compliance with the provisions of article 8, numeral 8.5 of the RAI;
150. In this way, the non-compliance with said obligation, issued by the SMV on the basis of its regulatory power, by brokerage agents constitutes validly sanctionable conduct typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION. Therefore, the action of the SMV in relation to this charge as well as to the entire sanctioning procedure does not violate the provisions of the principle of typicality contemplated in article 230, numeral 4 of the LPAG;
151. With regard to the arguments presented by GPI SAB regarding the fact that the SMV was aware of MR. UCELLI's status as Director and Representative of GPI SAB, it should be noted that by means of Directoral Resolution of Secondary Markets No. 005-2009-EF/94.06.1 of 30 January 2009, the SMV authorized MR. UCELLI as representative of GPI SAB, after having verified compliance with the requirements established in the RAI; at the date of said authorization, article 8, numeral 8.5 of the aforementioned RAI established that “The same person may not jointly and simultaneously hold the positions or functions of Director, General Manager and Representative of the Agent”;
152. Therefore, considering that as of 30 January 2009 MR. UCCELLI held the positions of Director and Representative of the agent company, this did not represent a breach of the provisions of the aforementioned rule, in force at that date. Consequently, the authorization granted to MR. UCELLI as representative of GPI SAB was carried out in accordance with the provisions of the RAI;
153. However, subsequently, through SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01, published on 24 September 2012, among other provisions, article 8, numeral 8.5 of the RAI was amended, according to the following text: “The same person may not simultaneously hold the positions or functions of Director and Representative of the Agent”;
154. Said regulatory provision, in accordance with the provisions of article 11 of SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01, entered into force on 01 February 2013. Therefore, as of that date, MR. UCELLI was prevented from simultaneously holding the positions of Director and Representative of GPI SAB;
155. Now then, continuing with the evaluation of the arguments presented, although it is not verified that GPI SAB carried out actions to conceal MR. UCELLI's status as Director of the brokerage firm, it should be noted that, as can be seen from the provisions of article 109 of the Political Constitution of Peru of 199349, all norms enter into force
[d] “d) Criminalize the infractions of those who participate in the securities market, product market, collective fund systems and other matters under its competence, observing the provisions of articles 343, 349, 350 and 351 of Legislative Decree 861, Securities Market Law. (…)”.
[49] “Article 109.- Validity and obligatory nature of the Law
obligatorily from the day following publication unless the same norm has provided for postponing or deferring its validity in whole or in part;
156. This situation occurred in the present case, so as of 01 February 2013 all intermediation agents were obliged to comply with the provisions of article 8, numeral 8.5 of the RAI, and in accordance with the provisions of article 103 of the Political Constitution of Peru, to observe compliance with existing situations. This obligation cannot be ignored by any intermediation agent and its compliance is not conditioned on a requirement from the SMV in that regard, since all intermediation agents are aware of the norm, as well as its obligatory nature;
157. Finally, as GPI SAB states, the brokerage firm informed the SMV that as of 18 August 2016 MR. UCELLI resigned from the position, and therefore ceased to have the status of Director of GPI SAB as of that date, which will be considered when evaluating the sanction to be imposed;
158. Consequently, in accordance with the foregoing, GPI SAB has not disproved the imputed charge, and therefore has committed an infraction because MR. UCELLI held the positions of Director and Representative of the brokerage firm at the same time, until 17 August 2016, thereby failing to comply with the requirement set forth in article 8, numeral 5 of the RAI, and therefore has incurred an infraction classified as very serious according to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS;
159. As of 31 December 2015, GPI ASSET maintained an account payable to GPI SAB in the amount of S/ 7 229 020 (Seven million two hundred twenty-nine thousand twenty and 00/100 Soles);
160. From the information obtained through emails of 15 and 22 April 2016 in response to the information requests made to GPI SAB50 regarding the financial statements of GPI ASSET51 and the detail of the “Other accounts receivable” item as of 31 December 2015 of said financial statements, it was observed that only the “Other accounts receivable, net” item, which represents approximately 81% of total assets52, included an item related to investments for an amount close to the loan amount, corresponding to subaccount 16890102 “Investment Management” for S/ 5 282 400.00,
[50] Information requests made through Memorandum No. 002-2016. GPI INSPECTION and email sent to GPI SAB on 21 April 2016.
[51] Corresponding to the periods ended 31.12.2014 and 31.12.15 of GPI ASSET.
[52] According to the financial statements of GPI ASSET as of 31 December 2015, its total assets at that date are S/. 9 039,160.
[*] The law is obligatory from the day following its publication in the official gazette, unless otherwise provided by the same law that postpones its validity in whole or in part.” “Article 103.- Special laws, non-retroactivity, repeal and abuse of rights Special laws may be issued because the nature of things so requires, but not by reason of differences between persons. The law, from its entry into force, applies to the consequences of existing legal relations and situations and has no retroactive force or effects; except in both cases, (…)”.
therefore the difference, in the amount of S/ 1 946 620 (One million nine hundred forty-six thousand six hundred twenty and 00/100 Soles) would have had another destination, different from that required by the regulations. The detail of the composition of the aforementioned accounting item of GPI ASSET is as follows:
Table No. 9
Other Accounts Receivable, net as of 31.12.2015 (*)
| SUBACCOUNT | DETAIL | In soles |
|---|---|---|
| 14220001 | Acc. Soc. Loan S. | 59,884.60 |
| 14220101 | Acc. Soc. LOAN $. | 54,323.52 |
| 16120101 | Loan without guarantee 3rd party $. | 286,348.27 |
| 16240001 | Tax Claim S. | 14,438.00 |
| 16800101 | Misc. A/R $. | 9,048.24 |
| 16890101 | Other Misc. A/R $. | 1,567,680.00 |
| 16890102 | Investment Management $. | 5,282,400.00 |
| 40171030 | 3rd category income tax payable | 4,783.00 |
| 40186001 | Net Asset Temporary Tax | 23,733.00 |
| 40115001 | I.G.V. Debit Tax | -2,148.30 |
| 40171031 | Income tax 3rd installment payment | 12,679.00 |
| TOTAL | 7,313,169.00 |
(*) Financial Statements of GPI ASSET
161. By Official Letter No. 2651-2016-SMV/10.2 of 04 May 2016, the IGSE requested the agent company, with respect to the financial information as of 31 December 2015 of GPI ASSET, to deliver the detail of certain accounting accounts included in the item "Other accounts receivable, net" for an amount of S/ 7 313 169, aforementioned. Likewise, it was requested to present the detail of the item Other accounts payable for S/ 8 635 17653. It should be noted that the nature of these operations and the name or corporate name of the debtors and the underlying financial assets – among other accounting information of GPI ASSET, required through the aforementioned official letter, were not reported by the stock brokerage firm;
162. By Official Letter No. 3102-2016-SMV/10.2, it was observed to GPI SAB that the credit granted to GPI ASSET would not comply with the provisions of article 194 of the LMV and article 51 of the RAI, regarding which, GPI SAB, by letter submitted on 31 May 2016, stated that "As we understand from what the external auditors expressed, said credit does comply with the provisions of the LMV, but needs to be detailed in such a way that it adjusts to what is indicated in art. 194 of the LMV". However, the agent company did not send additional information in this regard;
[53] The text of the request is as follows: "4. Regarding the financial information as of 31 December 2015 of GPI ASSET, provide the detail of the following accounting accounts included in the item Other accounts receivable, net, amounting to S/ 7 313 169, indicating name or corporate name of the debtors, number and date of source documents, and the analysis of the collectability of said accounts receivable: -14220001 Acc. Soc. Loans S/ for 59 884 - 14220101 Acc. Soc. Loan $ for S/ 54 323 - 16120101 Unsecured loans 3rd party for S/ 286 348. - 16890102 Investment management for S/ 5 282 420, indicating the nature of these operations and the name or corporate name of the debtors and the underlying financial assets, if applicable. Likewise, provide the detail of the item Other accounts payable amounting to S/ 8 635 176."
163. According to what is indicated in the SECOND OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, it was observed that the credit granted by GPI SAB to GPI ASSET for an amount of S/ 7 229 020 (Seven million two hundred twenty-nine thousand twenty and 00/100 Soles) as of 31 December 2015, would not have been entirely destined to the acquisition of securities, since, as verified in the financial statements of GPI ASSET as of 31 December 2015, only the item "Other accounts receivable, net", includes an item related to investments, corresponding to the subaccount called "Investment Management" for the amount of S/ 5 282 400,00 (Five million two hundred eighty-two thousand four hundred and 00/100 Soles), as shown in Table No. 9 of this resolution, referring to "Other Accounts Receivable, Net";
164. In that sense, the rest of the loan, that is, the amount amounting to S/ 1 946 620 (One million nine hundred forty-six six hundred twenty and 00/100 Soles), would have been destined to a purpose different from the acquisition of securities, established in the LMV and in the RAI. It should be noted that GPI SAB has not complied with explaining the detail of the use by GPI ASSET of said part of the loan;
165. Consequently, according to the above, as long as GPI SAB did not prove that the entirety of the loan granted to GPI ASSET has been destined to the acquisition of securities, it would have breached the provisions of article 194, literal m) of the LMV and article 51 of the RAI, for which it would be incurred in the infraction of a very serious nature established in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, according to which it constitutes an infraction "To perform functions, operations, activities, acts or contracts, not authorized or that do not comply with the requirements established in the regulations or that have not been registered in the Registry, when applicable";
166. On the matter, the charge formulated to GPI SAB, for, among others, the granting of credits to its clients without this complying with the purpose established by the regulations., was validly notified via MVNET. However, GPI SAB did not present the corresponding discharges;
167. Notwithstanding this, it corresponds to carry out the respective evaluation. In this sense, according to the charge made, from the documentation presented by the stock brokerage firm, it was identified that from the credit granted by GPI SAB to GPI ASSET for an amount of S/ 7 229 020, only the amount corresponding to S/ 5 282 400 would be related to investments made by GPI ASSET according to the information shown in the financial statements of GPI ASSET as of 31 December 2015;
168. GPI SAB has not been able to sustain or prove that the difference of the credit granted, that is, the amount of S/ 1 946 620 was destined by GPI ASSET, for the acquisition of securities or financial instruments, in accordance with the provisions of article 194, literal m) of the LMV; notwithstanding that this was observed by the SMV to GPI SAB through Official Letter No. 3102-2016-EF/10.2 of 24 May 2016;
169. Additionally, by letter submitted on 31 May 2016, GPI SAB stated that the credit granted to GPI ASSET complied with the provisions of the LMV and the RAI and that in days following said letter it would send to the SMV the details for its corresponding verification. However, up to the date of issuance of this resolution, GPI SAB has not presented information in this regard;
170. Consequently, taking into account the foregoing and that GPI SAB has not offered evidentiary elements or arguments that allow the charge imputed to be rebutted, it has been determined that said stock brokerage firm has incurred an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS;
171. According to the supervision actions, it was determined that GPI SAB failed to communicate within the period established by the regulations the relevant facts referring to:
a) The cessation of duties of Mr. Tomás Enrique Silva Berengel (hereinafter, Mr. SILVA) as representative of the brokerage agent, which occurred on 03 December 2015. This information should have been communicated as a relevant fact on 04 December 2015; however, said communication was made on 07 December 2015.
b) The cessation of duties of Mrs. María Alicia Marrou Salazar (hereinafter, Mrs. MARROU) as representative of the brokerage agent, which occurred on 15 December 2015. This information should have been communicated as a relevant fact on 16 December 2015; however, said communication was made on 17 December 2015;
172. Consequently, in accordance with the foregoing, the stock brokerage firm did not communicate the aforementioned relevant facts within the period established in article 98 of the RAI, and therefore it would be incurring in an infraction classified as minor according to the provisions of Annex X numeral 3.14 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, according to which it constitutes an infraction “Not communicating the relevant facts, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations”;
173. In this regard, GPI SAB argues that an alleged infraction is imputed for not having timely communicated the relevant facts referring to the cessations of duties of Mr. SILVA and Mrs. MARROU, as representatives of the agent company. Likewise, it states that, in accordance with what is indicated in the letter of charges, the purpose of the norm was fully complied with since in both cases, according to what was indicated by the agent company, the communication was made on the next business day. In that sense, GPI SAB alleges that it is not reasonable to seek to open a sanctioning procedure for only one day of delay, since that, according to the stock brokerage firm, transgresses the principle of reasonableness54, enshrined in article IV, numeral 1.4 of the Preliminary Title of the LPAG;
[54] Article 1.4 of the LPAG:
174. Likewise, GPI SAB states that as can be seen from the cited norm, the qualification of infractions must strictly attend to what is necessary to satisfy its purpose, and in this case the information was provided, according to the agent company, only one business day later;
175. Additionally, the stock brokerage firm points out that taking into account that it is only about the cessation of duties of a representative, they are not facing any situation of gravity or that could generate any harm;
176. According to what was argued by GPI SAB in its defenses, it must be noted that the agent company acknowledges that it communicated the relevant facts referring to the cessation of duties of Mr. SILVA and Mrs. MARROU, as representatives of the agent company, one (01) business day after the expiration of the period established in article 98 of the RAI. In this regard, it should be noted that in the case of Mr. SILVA the relevant fact should have been communicated on 04 December 2015, however it was presented only on 07 December 2015, that is, with three (03) calendar days of delay;
177. On the other hand, regarding the argument referring to the fact that attending to the principle of reasonableness established in article 1.4 of the Preliminary Title of the LPAG, it is not reasonable to initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure for the present case, it must be noted that as mentioned above, in accordance with article 342 of the LMV, persons included in the scope of application of the LMV, such as brokerage agents, are subjects liable to sanction by the SMV, insofar as they incur infractions to the provisions established in the LMV, as well as to the provisions of a general nature issued by the SMV, such as the one established in article 98 of the RAI, to the extent that the untimely presentation of relevant facts, in addition to constituting the breach of an obligation, limits the capacity of supervision and control of brokerage agents by the SMV. Likewise, investor protection is affected since the information about who are the authorized representatives to act precisely on behalf of the intermediaries is disseminated to the market through the SMV Portal;
178. In this sense, according to the foregoing, the qualification as an infraction of the facts evaluated in the present charge is in accordance with what is required by the principle of reasonableness and therefore strictly attends to the breach in which GPI SAB has incurred;
179. Likewise, it should be stated that the sanction that must be applied must be imposed in a manner proportional to the act committed, in accordance with the provisions of the LMV and the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS for infractions of a minor nature as corresponds in the present case and considering within the respective evaluation the sanction criteria also established in the LMV, as well as in article 230 of the LPAG;
[*] “Principle of reasonableness.- The decisions of the administrative authority, when they create obligations, classify infractions, impose sanctions, or establish restrictions on the administered, must adapt within the limits of the attributed power and maintaining due proportion between the means to be employed and the public purposes that must be protected, so that they respond to what is strictly necessary for the satisfaction of their mandate”.
180. With regard to what was indicated by GPI SAB, that as it deals with the cessation of functions of a representative, they are not facing a situation of gravity or that could generate harm, it must be indicated that said aspects mentioned will be subject to evaluation at the time of determining the corresponding sanction for the infractions subject to evaluation;
181. Consequently, GPI SAB has not disproved the charges made;
182. According to the supervision actions, it was determined that GPI SAB did not comply with communicating within the term established by the regulations the relevant fact referring to the cessation of functions of Mr. Gianfranco Aguirre Barreda (hereinafter, Mr. AGUIRRE) as representative of the brokerage agent, which occurred on 29 April 2016. This information should have been communicated as a relevant fact on 02 May 2016; however, said communication was made on 03 May 2016;
183. Consequently, according to the above, the stock brokerage company did not communicate the aforementioned relevant fact within the term established in article 98 of the RAI, and therefore it would be incurring in an infraction classified as minor according to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, according to which it constitutes an infraction “Not communicating the relevant facts, or not doing so within the term established by the regulations”;
184. In this regard, the charge formulated against GPI SAB, for, among others, the untimely communication of relevant facts, was validly notified via MVNET on 26 October 2016. However, GPI SAB did not present the corresponding defenses;
185. Notwithstanding this, the respective evaluation must be carried out. In this sense, according to the charge made, it was verified that GPI SAB did not timely communicate the relevant fact subject to charges, since the maximum term for the communication of said relevant fact was 02 May 2016; however, it was communicated one (01) day after its expiration, that is, on 03 May 2016;
186. Therefore, taking into account that GPI SAB has not offered evidentiary elements or arguments that allow disproving the imputed charge, it has been established that GPI SAB has presented the relevant fact extemporaneously;
187. Consequently, considering what was stated in the evaluation carried out with regard to the charges made with the FIRST OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES and SECOND OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, it has been established that the relevant facts of 03 and 15 December 2015, as well as of 29 April 2016 were not timely communicated, in that sense it has been determined that the stock brokerage company has breached the provisions of article 98 of the RAI and therefore has incurred in three (03) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
188. According to what is indicated in the Facts section of this resolution, once the complaint formulated by Mrs. ALVAREZ against GPI SAB was presented, a series of actions were carried out in order to clarify the denounced facts, in accordance with file No. 2016035717;
189. As a result of the aforementioned and under the protection of the provisions of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 5485-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES), the IGCP initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against GPI SAB, imputing charges for having contravened the provisions of the LMV and RAI, in aspects linked to the destination of client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted; intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements established in the regulations; allowing third parties outside the intermediary to carry out activities related to those of the agent company; providing its clients with inaccurate information; not preparing its financial information in accordance with the regulations; using global accounts without observing the required conditions; not delivering account statements; not collecting orders from its clients; and, not delivering policies for the operations carried out;
190. With the brief presented on 04 October 2016, GPI SAB presented the defenses to Official Letter No. 5485-2016-SMV/10.3;
191. The charges formulated against GPI SAB and the defenses expressed by the latter have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 877-2016-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendence;
192. In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in article 230, subsection 2, of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 6656-2016-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 877-2016-SMV/10.3 was made available to GPI SAB for its review;
193. In this extreme of the present administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendence of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
a) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, by destining client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
b) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, for intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations;
c) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, for directly or indirectly maintaining persons who have any legal or regulatory impediment, for failing to observe that they comply with the requirements established in the current regulations, or for allowing or facilitating them to carry out activities related to those of the brokerage agent;
d) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, for providing its clients with false and inaccurate information, or for allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inaccurate information to the detriment of its clients;
e) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, for using global accounts without observing the required conditions;
f) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.4 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, for not preparing, in accordance with the rules that regulate its preparation, the information to which they are obligated by the regulations or by requirement of CONASEV;
g) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, for not complying with sending to its clients the information to which it is obligated (account statements), or for not doing so in the form and opportunity required by the regulations;
h) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, by not collecting orders;
i) Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, by not delivering policies;
j) Whether or not it is appropriate to impose a sanction on GPI SAB for the matters indicated in the preceding subsections;
194. Article 195, numeral a), of the LMV, applicable at the date the events occurred, establishes that brokerage agents are prohibited from using the funds or securities they receive from their principals for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
"Article 195.- Prohibitions Brokerage firms are subject to the following prohibitions, without prejudice to those contemplated in article 177 and the others arising from this law: a) Using the funds or securities they receive from their principals for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted. (...)";
195. Likewise, article 48 of the RAI establishes that the securities, financial instruments or funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than that, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in articles 194 and 207 of the LMV;
"Article 48.- Basic Rules The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose refers to any of the operations defined in articles 194 and 207 of the Law. (...)";
196. Similarly, article 77, numeral 77.3 of the RAI states that in the case of unwritten orders it is presumed that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client;
"Article 77.- Information on orders (...) 77.3 In the case of unwritten orders, it is presumed, unless proven otherwise, that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client";
197. Regarding the intervention of a brokerage firm in the brokerage of securities and financial instruments, article 37, numeral 37.4.1 of the RAI states that;
"Article 37.- Requirements.- In order for the Agent to intervene in the brokerage of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions: (...) 37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is on its own behalf, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements: 37.4.1. Sign a contract with each of the clients who wish it to intermediate this type of operations for them, in accordance with the provisions of article 40 of these Regulations. (...)";
198. Regarding allowing persons who have a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the brokerage agent, articles 198 and 200 of the LMV provide the following:
"Article 198.- Definition.- The representative of a brokerage firm is one who, duly authorized, acts on its behalf in acts related to the exercise of its functions. CONASEV shall determine the requirements that those acting as representatives of a brokerage firm must meet. Article 200.- Joint and Several Liability.- Brokerage firms are jointly and severally liable with their operators and other representatives for all their improper acts, as well as for their omissions, when a detriment to the principals derives therefrom.";
199. For its part, article 2, numeral 2.22, and articles 23 and 25 numeral 25.1 of the RAI state:
2.22. Representative: Natural person duly authorized as such, who on behalf of the Agent is the only one empowered to carry out one or more of the operations indicated in subsections a), b), c), d), e), f), g), h), i), k), p), q), s) and t), of article 194 of the Law in the case of brokerage firms, or subsections a), b), c), d), e), f) and i), of article 207 of the Law, in the case of intermediary firms.
Article 23.- Authorization.- The Agent, in order to initiate and carry out the operations authorized by its operating authorization, as well as the permitted special operations, must have authorized Representatives.
For a natural person to exercise the function of Representative of an Agent, they must obtain authorization from CONASEV and register in the Registry.
25.1. The Agent is responsible for ensuring that its Representatives have the respective authorization.
(…)”
200. Regarding providing its clients with inaccurate information, Article 195, literal h) of the LMV prohibits stock brokerage firms from misleading about the liquidity of a security:
“Article 195.- Prohibitions.- Brokerage firms are subject to the following prohibitions, without prejudice to those contemplated in Article 177 and others arising from this law:
h) Misleading about the liquidity of a security. (…)”
201. Regarding the use of global accounts, as established in Article 37, numeral 37.4.2 of the RAI, with respect to the intervention of a brokerage firm in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments, it is established that it is a requirement:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions: (…)
37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is in its own name, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements: (…)
37.4.2. Have control records of global accounts as established in this Regulation. (…)”
202. Likewise, Article 90 of the RAI establishes regarding global accounts;
“Article 90.- Content.- The Agent, for each Global Account in its name, referred to in numeral 37.4.2 of Article 37 of this Regulation, must implement control records that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts. Likewise, the aforementioned records must allow the immediate generation of the following information:
90.1. Movements of securities and financial instruments in the global account.
90.2. Movements of funds related to the global account.
90.3. Balances of financial instruments and funds consolidated and at the level of the Agent's clients.
90.4. Consolidated record of financial instruments and funds related to global accounts.
These records must contain information updated on the day and be supported by the confirmations and account statements received from the foreign intermediary that executes the operations corresponding to each account, and if applicable, in the information provided by the entity responsible for the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, according to the operability of each account. Likewise, they must be consistent with the policies that the Agent must issue for this type of operations”;
203. Regarding the preparation of its financial information in accordance with the regulations, Article 91 of the RAI states:
ʺArticle 91°.- Registry.- The Agent must timely record in its accounting books all transactions or economic, financial, or any other events in which it participates, that affect it or may affect it, or for which it is necessary to keep control thereof.
Such records must be duly supported by source documentation or pertinent evidence, and strictly adhere to the provisions of the IFRS.ʺ
204. On the other hand, Control Annex 3, Order Accounts per Client Account, numeral A, literal 3 of section 2.2. Control Annexes of Chapter 2 “Provisions related to order accounts for intermediation and control annexes” of the “Manual of Financial Information of Intermediation Agents”, approved by SMV Resolution No. 012-2011-SMV/01, states the following:
“Control Annex 3: Order Accounts per Client Account A. Securities and financial instruments of clients or third parties under control (1+2+3) 3. In global accounts in the name of the intermediary: The securities and financial instruments of the AI's clients, which are in a global account in a foreign entity, in the name of the AI, as established in the RAI, shall be presented. (…)”
205. Regarding client account statements, the RAI in its Articles 82 and 83 establishes the following;
“Article 82.- Client Account Statement.- The client account statement is a report that shows in detail the movements made during a determined period and the balances of securities, financial instruments, and funds in the name of a client.
Each client must have an account statement, which must contain at least the following information for each transaction made:
82.1. Transaction date.
82.2. Type of transaction: Purchase, sale, collection, payment, transfer, or any other.
82.3. Description corresponding to the type of transaction: The description must be clear and sufficient to identify the nature of the transaction, especially in the case of transfers or others different from purchases, sales, collections, or payments.
82.4. Identification of the corresponding document: policy, receipt, or other.
82.5. In the case of purchase and sale operations of securities or financial instruments, for each of these:
82.5.1. Denomination of the security or financial instrument.
82.5.2. The quantity purchased and/or sold.
82.5.3. Unit price.
82.6. Currency of the transaction.
82.7. Amount of the transaction.
82.8. Monetary balance at the end of each date.
In addition, the client account statement must present separately and clearly the balance of all securities and instruments owned by the client, under the control or responsibility of the Agent, specifying their availability status or any other.
In the event that a client has more than one identification code for carrying out their operations, the Agent must implement an account statement in which all the aforementioned codes are consolidated.
In the case of financial instruments managed in global accounts in the name of the Agent, the name of the Depository or Custody Institution of said instruments must be specified.
available to its clients, account statements of their movements and balances of securities, financial instruments and funds, by the means agreed with them, as recorded in each client's registration form.
Within thirty (30) calendar days following the close of each month, the Agent must prove that it has sent or made available account statements of movements to its clients who have carried out any transaction during that period, except when said movements are solely placements. The Agent must keep a faithful copy of the account statements that were made available to its clients on magnetic media.
For clients who have not carried out any transaction within any of the quarters of each year, and provided they maintain balances of securities, financial instruments or funds, the Agent must prove, when applicable, that it sent or made available their account statement within thirty (30) calendar days following the close of the quarter.
In no case may the Agent exempt itself from the obligation established in this article, to provide information to its clients regarding their transactions, securities and financial instruments”;
206. Regarding the obligation to collect orders from its clients, article 175 of the LMV provides the following regarding orders:
by means of which their principals express their decisions regarding the negotiation of securities or financial instruments and other services they may provide.
Through orders, principals grant a mandate to their brokerage agent to carry out the operations set forth in articles 194 and 207, as well as for the receipt of benefits, subscription of shares or any other activity related to securities or financial instruments, with prior authorization from Conasev in accordance with items t) and i) of said articles, respectively.
Orders empower brokerage agents to exercise the mandate they contain. In the case of subscription of shares, receipt of benefits or other similar matters, brokerage agents are authorized by their principal's mandate to act on their behalf without the need for any additional requirement or condition, except those determined by the principal themselves.
In accordance with the preceding paragraphs, brokerage agents are obligated to the following:
a) Collect orders from their principals in written or telephone form, provided that the latter are recorded, without prejudice to other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that Conasev may establish through general provisions.
b) Implement systems that allow the recording of orders when they are made by telephone so that they are registered from the moment they are received. For this purpose, they must have a recording system for orders received by telephone, as well as a registration and filing system for them in accordance with the general rules issued by Conasev.
Such recordings, as well as the aforementioned registry, must be kept for five years and made available to Conasev in the manner it establishes through a general rule.
From the moment the principal gives the order by telephone, it is understood that they have been previously informed of the registration conditions of orders given through this medium, as well as the acceptance of the corresponding recording.
c) Use only systems, as well as means of receiving and registering orders authorized by Conasev.
Likewise, brokerage agents must make available to their principals the policy that proves the operations carried out on their behalf”;
207. For its part, article 30, numeral 30.2 of the RAI states;
“Article 30.- Receipt, Registration and Transmission of Orders.- For the purpose of orders given for the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, the following must be observed:
(…)
30.2. Orders on behalf of a client may be instructed to the Agent through the following means: (i) written, (ii) fax with subsequent confirmation, (iii) telephone, (iv) through applications implemented from the Agent's website, (v) private electronic communication network with registered users, recognized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision; (vi) email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation; (vii) ADM in accordance with the provisions of the Direct Market Access Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 024-2012-SMV/01 or the norm that replaces it; (viii) intermediated routing in accordance with the provisions of the Integrated Market through Intermediated Routing Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 107-2010-EF/94.01.1, or, (ix) other means of communication authorized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, in accordance with what is agreed in its respective client registration form.
In all the above cases, the Agent is responsible for verifying the authenticity of the orders it receives through the additional means it considers.”;
208. In turn, numeral 37.5 of article 37 of the RAI states:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to be able to intervene in the brokerage of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…) 37.5. Each operation intermediated by the Agent must have the corresponding client order”;
209. Regarding the obligation to deliver policies, the RAI establishes the following:
“Article 79.- Policy.- For each operation it intermediates, the Agent must issue the respective policy and make it available to the corresponding client, within a period no greater than three (03) days following the execution of the operation.
The Agent is responsible for ensuring that the policies delivered to its clients bear the signature of a Representative or Manager.
Article 81.- Policies for Foreign Operations.- In the case of operations executed in foreign markets, the Agent must issue a policy for each client, corresponding to each order executed through a foreign broker.
In these policies, in addition to the information detailed in the preceding article, the Agent must disclose:
81.1. Regarding the stated price, it shall be indicated whether it is the price of the original operation obtained abroad, or whether it is an average price assigned by the Agent. In the latter case, the list of corresponding prices and quantities shall be detailed.
81.2. The commission of the foreign intermediary and of any other foreign entity, if applicable.
81.3. The net commission corresponding to the Agent”;
210. By means of Oficio N° 5485-2016-SMV/10.3, the following charges were imputed to GPI SAB:
a) For allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thereby contravening the provisions of article 195, literal a), as well as article 48 and article 77, numeral 77.3 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as a very serious infraction: “Allocating funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted”;
b) For intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations, failing to comply with the provisions of article 37, numeral 37.4.1 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.18 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a very serious nature: “Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations”;
c) For allowing persons who have a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent, failing to comply with the provisions of articles 198 and 200 of the LMV and article 2, numeral 2.22 and articles 23 and 25, numeral 25.1 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a very serious nature: “Maintaining
directly or indirectly persons who have any legal or regulatory impediment, failing to observe that they comply with the requirements established in the current regulations, or allowing or facilitating them to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent.”
d) For allowing its clients to be provided with inaccurate information, failing to comply with the provisions of article 195, literal h) of the LMV; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a very serious nature: “Providing its clients with false and inaccurate information, or allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inaccurate information to the detriment of its clients.”
e) For using global accounts without observing the required conditions, failing to comply with the provisions of article 37, numeral 37.4.2 and article 90 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have infringed Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature: “Using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations or for purposes other than the corresponding one”;
f) For not preparing its financial information in accordance with the regulations, failing to comply with the provisions of article 91 of the RAI and Control Annex 3, Order Accounts per Client Account, numeral A, literal 3 of section 2.2. Control Annexes of Chapter 2 “Provisions relating to order accounts for intermediation and control annexes” of the “Financial Information Manual for Intermediation Agents”; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.4 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature: “Not preparing in accordance with the rules that regulate its preparation, the information to which they are obligated by the regulations or by requirement of CONASEV”;
g) For not delivering account statements, failing to comply with the provisions of articles 82 and 83 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature: “Not complying with sending its clients the information to which it is obligated, or not doing so in the form and opportunity required by the regulations”;
h) For not collecting orders from its clients, failing to comply with the provisions of article 175 of the LMV and article 37, numeral 37.5 and article 30, numeral 30.2 of the RAI; in that sense, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which establishes as an infraction of a minor nature: “Not collecting orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene”;
i) For not delivering policies, breaching the provisions of article 175 of the LMV and articles 79 and 81 of the RAI; in that regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided for in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.6 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, which establishes as an infraction of a minor nature: “Not delivering policies to its clients for the operations carried out”;
211. In the complaint of 03 June 2016 submitted to the SMV, Mrs. ALVAREZ stated that during the month of January 2015 she made interbank transfers and cash deposits to the dollar intermediation account opened by GPI SAB at Banco Financiero del Perú (hereinafter, OPERATING ACCOUNT), for a total of US$ 950,000.00. The client indicates that of this amount, GPI SAB returned US$ 305,000.00 in cash to her, leaving a balance of US$ 645,000.00;
212. On 04 July 2016, Mrs. ALVAREZ supplemented her complaint stating that the US$ 950,000.00 she delivered to GPI SAB were never credited to the account in the name of Mrs. ALVAREZ at the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC, which she has had open since August 201355 and that, according to her instructions, that was the mechanism to be used to invest in a liquid and conservative portfolio based on ETFs. Likewise, she states that these funds were not credited to a bank, agent or broker, national or international either;
213. Mrs. ALVAREZ also states that GPI SAB has not given her any proof of the destination of her investments, so they would not have been invested in ETFs and that possibly not even positions in options were taken as GPI SAB states;
214. She adds that the returns of funds for a total of US$ 305,000.00 were made due to the collection pressure she had been exerting, but were not generated by an instruction to sell securities or liquidate positions on her part, since she never instructed orders in that sense;
215. Additionally, Mrs. ALVAREZ states that by letter of 28 April 2015, Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar (Mr. ARIZMENDI), who signs as President and General Manager of GPI ASSET, addressed to Mr. Jesús Alcalá Mateo (who is Mrs. ALVAREZ's lawyer), in relation to Mrs. ALVAREZ's investments, states that they received the US$ 950,000.00 in the GPI SAB account to be invested with a conservative profile and obtain income, preferably quarterly, and that the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI SAB and GPI ASSET, in similar amounts;
216. Mrs. ALVAREZ states that through said writing, it is acknowledged that there is a verbal instruction to invest the US$ 950,000.00 with a conservative profile. Likewise, she indicates that she never instructed GPI SAB to divide the responsibility for the investments with GPI ASSET, since at all times she dealt and related with GPI SAB because it was evident that Mr. ARIZMENDI acted in coordination with his spouse and general manager of GPI, Mrs. BELLIDO, who was copied on most of the emails that Mr. ARIZMENDI sent to the client;
217. Furthermore, Mrs. ALVAREZ indicates that Mr. ARIZMENDI sent her a writing dated 15 July 2015 signed by Mrs. BELLIDO, who signed as general manager of GPI SAB, addressed “to whom it may concern”, in which it is stated that Mrs. ALVAREZ has an investment account abroad valued at US$ 645,000.00 and whose custody is at Interactive Brokers LLC;
[55] Account No. 39K361176
218. Regarding this writing, Mrs. ALVAREZ states that she never authorized a transfer abroad to Interactive Brokers LLC. However, she indicates, GPI SAB must demonstrate that it has or had an account at Interactive Brokers LLC, with investments valued at US$ 645,000.00;
219. Finally, Mrs. ALVAREZ indicates that through the so-called “Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Guarantee” dated 10 November 2015 signed between her and GPI SAB, the origin of the obligation is acknowledged in an initial transfer of US$ 950,000.00; returns of US$ 305,000.00 are recorded; and the existence of a balance in favor of the client of US$ 645,000.00 is acknowledged;
220. In this regard, Mrs. ALVAREZ specifies that this contract was signed under this format because her intention was simply for the money she had delivered to be returned and that, as of July 2015, it had been requested in full;
221. For its part, GPI SAB through documentation submitted on 15 September 2016 has proven that the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ entered the OPERATING ACCOUNT. Likewise, it states that the funds were transferred to Interactive Brokers LLC, although it does not prove this transfer of funds;
222. Regarding the destination of said funds, GPI SAB, through a writing submitted on 26 July and 15 September 2016, states that from the conversations with Mrs. ALVAREZ it clearly emerged that she had a horizon of three (03) years and that her main purpose was to generate income of 12% per year. Therefore, since there are currently no fixed-income instruments, such as sovereign or corporate bonds that can provide such yield, a modality of investments that with moderate risk could provide such profitability was the use of selling “put” type options based on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange;
223. Likewise, GPI SAB adds that in the so-called “Money Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Agreement”, which was entered into on 10 November 2015, the position of Mrs. ALVAREZ's puts was expressed, a position that is maintained to date. According to GPI SAB, Mrs. ALVAREZ's investment position as of 10 November 2015 was as follows;
a) Sale of 110 put option contracts (puts) of GDXJ with expiration in February 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 30.
b) Sale of 125 put option contracts (puts) of GDX with expiration in March 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 25.
c) Cash for approximately US$ 2 500;
224. Likewise, GPI SAB points out that Mrs. ALVAREZ received returns on various dates and accredits the delivery of these funds as returns in the documentation attached to her briefs presented on 27 June 2016 and 15 September 2016;
225. According to what was stated by both Mrs. ALVAREZ and GPI SAB and with the documentation in the file, it should be highlighted that both coincide in stating that the former deposited in the OPERATING ACCOUNT of the latter US$ 950 000,00, a monetary transfer that the agent company itself has accredited documentary evidence in the file;
226. Likewise, it should be indicated that both parties also coincide that the money delivered was for the purpose of making investments with financial instruments in the foreign market;
227. Additionally, it should be noted that both parties coincide, and it is accredited with the documentation in the file, that GPI SAB delivered to Mrs. ALVAREZ the sum of US$ 305 000,00 as a refund of funds;
228. The aforementioned agrees with the amounts mentioned in the “Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Pact” signed on 10 November 2015, in which it is described that GPI SAB received US$ 950 000,00 from Mrs. ALVAREZ, that it returned to the client US$ 305 000,00 and that the balance pending return to her amounts to the sum of US$ 645 000,00;
229. It should also be added that GPI indicates that through the aforementioned mutual loan agreement, it is stated that the balance pending return to Mrs. ALVAREZ amounts to the sum of US$ 645 000,00 and that said amount would be invested in put options, which would be in the name of Mrs. ALVAREZ, according to the detail set forth below, however GPI SAB has not documentary accredited the effective realization of those investments::
a) Sale of 110 put option contracts (puts) of GDXJ with expiration in February 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 30.
b) Sale of 125 put option contracts (puts) of GDX with expiration in March 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 25.
c) Cash for approximately US$ 2 500;
230. On the other hand, it has been accredited in the file that the coordination between Mrs. ALVAREZ and GPI SAB regarding the realization of the acts that had as their object to carry out the investments of the referred client, was carried out between the general manager of the company, Mrs. BELLIDO –TAGLE and with the direct participation of Mr. ARIZMENDI;
231. Such commercial relationship, that is, the entrustment of Mrs. ALVAREZ to GPI SAB to carry out operations abroad, had a substantially different conduction as to the objective of the client's investment, since GPI SAB has stated that it would have invested Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds in taking short positions in put options on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange with an investment horizon of three (03) years, when the initial instruction of the aforementioned client was to invest with a conservative profile. This has been acknowledged in writing by Mr. ARIZMENDI through a letter dated 28 April 2015;
232. In relation to the operations intermediated by GPI SAB in the foreign market on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ, GPI SAB has not accredited the realization of the operations that it supposedly would have carried out in the name of Mrs. Alvarez through the remission of copies of the account statements in the name of Mrs. ALVAREZ or in the name of GPI SAB, provided in the latter case by Interactive Brokers LLC or by other entities in charge of the execution of the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments;
233. Likewise, GPI SAB has not provided copies of the policies or account statements of the client that accredit the realization of the alleged operations;
234. All these documents should accredit the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intermediation of GPI SAB, with the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ, however, and as mentioned, this has not been accredited by GPI SAB;
235. It should be indicated that GPI SAB has also not accredited that the funds owned by the client or the securities and financial instruments in which these funds have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI SAB in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI SAB, demonstrating that the funds or securities and financial instruments are indisputably owned by Mrs. ALVAREZ. Likewise, it has also not accredited that these funds, securities and financial instruments are in the name of the aforementioned client Mrs. ALVAREZ in a foreign entity;
236. Consequently, despite the fact that GPI SAB was required to provide the documentation accrediting that it complied with the instructions given by its client and the investments made, this company has not attended said requirement;
237. To date, GPI SAB has not accredited the destination of the balance pending return to Mrs. ALVAREZ that amounts to the sum of US$ 645 000,00. That is, whether it has destined them to take short positions in put options on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange or whether it has destined them to another purpose, in none of the cases has it accredited the destination of the money delivered by the complainant, for which it is concluded that it has destined it to operations or purposes different from those for which they were entrusted;
238. It should be noted that according to article 77 of the RAI, it is the agent company that must prove the conditions under which the order was given, since otherwise it is presumed that it was given under the conditions indicated by the client;
239. In relation to the foregoing, it is clear that GPI SAB would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the RAI since it received the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ for custody and investment in accordance with the instructions given by said principal, and has not proven the destination of those funds nor the authorizations related to said destination;
240. Therefore, GPI SAB would have infringed the provisions of article 195, numeral a), of the LMV, and article 48 of the RAI, by allocating the funds owned by Mrs. ALVAREZ to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
241. GPI SAB states in its defenses that the problem that occurred with Mrs. ALVAREZ lies in the fact that the brokerage firm did not explain in detail, in writing and at the appropriate time, the type of investment that was being made. It indicates that what happened between June 2015 and January 2016 caused a temporary loss of the investment's value which in turn caused Mrs. ALVAREZ to seek to disavow the investments, arguing that they had been made in a manner different from the one requested;
242. GPI SAB adds that indeed during 2015 and the first months of 2016, the losses in said securities were massive and there were investors who realized the losses, among which is the agent company itself; however, so far in 2016, ETFs such as GDX, GDXJ and BVN have had high returns;
243. GPI SAB adds that the funds were not allocated for purposes other than those indicated by Mrs. ALVAREZ, but rather there was no clear agreement between the parties regarding their application, even though in the past and in Mrs. ALVAREZ's Pershing LLC account, GPI SAB had carried out similar operations, given their good temporary results;
244. Likewise, GPI SAB points out that the “Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Agreement” signed on 10 November 2015 by the principal and GPI SAB (hereinafter MUTUAL LOAN AGREEMENT), was not the most suitable and beyond Mrs. ALVAREZ's recent questioning, such contract revealed the client's full knowledge that by her order GPI SAB had invested US$ 642 500,00 in Puts and/or in ETFs on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), in the case of their execution, so it cannot be ignored that Mrs. ALVAREZ was at that time aware of the destination of her investments, although now she denies it. Even less can the SMV accept this statement when the documentation submitted by the complainant herself proves the contrary;
245. Likewise, GPI SAB adds that the MUTUAL LOAN AGREEMENT is suitable evidence of the destination of Mrs. ALVAREZ's investments made by GPI SAB, so the presumption indicated in numeral 77.3 of article 77 of the RAI cannot be applied, there being already an agreement regarding the investments existing as of 10 November 2015, which expressed the prior liquidation of investments, with the return to the investor, as she has acknowledged, of US$ 305 000,00;
246. Therefore, according to GPI SAB, the factual assumption invoked in the imputation that GPI SAB did not prove its principal's instructions does not occur. GPI SAB adds that Mrs. ALVAREZ acknowledged at the time that her funds were invested in Puts, so it is not possible to apply the presumption of article 77 of the RAI;
247. Finally, GPI SAB states that today, the investor stating that this is due to “collection pressure”, reveals on the contrary the improper manner in which the investor refers to the realization of her investments: “collections”. This also shows how the investor seeks to illegitimately evade the risks inherent to the market and seeks to transfer them to the intermediary;
248. As to the fact that the brokerage firm did not explain in detail, in writing and at the appropriate time, the type of investment that Mrs. ALVAREZ was making, it must be indicated that GPI SAB has not presented evidentiary means proving that GPI SAB provided information to Mrs. ALVAREZ regarding her investments;
249. Indeed, such evidentiary means refer, in principle, to having the authorizations instructed by this principal for certain investments to be made. Likewise, in addition to not having these authorizations, GPI SAB has also not proven with the account statements issued by foreign intermediaries or by foreign entities in charge of the registration and custody of the securities or financial instruments, policies and account statements of the client issued by GPI SAB, the destination of the investments of Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds;
250. Regarding the fact that there was no destination other than the one indicated by Mrs. ALVAREZ, but rather that there was no clear agreement between the parties regarding their application, it should be noted that there is only GPI SAB's argument that it would have invested the balance of US$ 645 000,00 in the sale of Put options; however, these investments have also not been proven;
251. As to the fact that the MUTUAL LOAN AGREEMENT revealed Mrs. ALVAREZ's full knowledge regarding the investments made by GPI SAB for US$ 642 500,00 in Puts and/or in ETFs in the case of the execution of such options, it must be indicated that what is stated in said contract regarding the destination of the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ, that is, the effective realization of the aforementioned investments, has not been proven by GPI SAB;
252. On the other hand, it should be noted that since March 2015, Mrs. ALVAREZ's attorney, Mr. Jesús Alcalá, requested Mr. ARIZMENDI to prove the investments made by GPI SAB on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ. However, GPI SAB has not proven that it issued a documented response regarding the destination of such funds;
253. This request for information by Mr. Jesús Alcalá regarding the investments by GPI SAB of Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds was explained by Mr. ARIZMENDI through a letter dated 28 April 2015, in which he indicates, among other things, that US$ 950 000,00 was received in GPI SAB's accounts to be invested with a conservative profile and to obtain income, preferably quarterly, and that the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI SAB and GPI ASSET;
254. Regarding this letter, it should be noted that although Mr. ARIZMENDI signs it as president and general manager of GPI ASSET, it must be highlighted that it evidences the will of GPI SAB and its actions as representative of the agent company by citing phrases such as, for example: “we received in GPI Valores SAB's accounts the amount of US$ 950 000,00”…“the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI Valores SAB and GPI Asset Management SAC in similar amounts”. As for Mr. ARIZMENDI's action as representative of GPI SAB, it should be indicated that this will be proven in the charge referring to allowing third parties to carry out activities related to those of the SAB;
255. Regarding what Mr. ARIZMENDI said in the aforementioned letter, that the investment of Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds had been allocated to options positions to earn premiums, this client since July 2015 expressed her disagreement with this investment strategy although she was willing to find a solution;
256. Indeed, by email of 01 July 2015, Mrs. ALVAREZ requested Mr. ARIZMENDI to deliver funds for US$ 350 000,00 (in May GPI SAB had returned US$ 175 000,00 of the US$ 950 000,00 to her), receiving as a response from the latter, by email of 03 July of that year at 11:03 hours: “I wish we could do it in those times, but it is going to be impossible, due to the way we have invested through options. As I told you, we need at least 60 days to divest without losses. I apologize a thousand times for it. (…) what I am going to do is gradually change the investment strategy (…) but I have to make the entire strategy change and that requires time (…)”
257. It should be highlighted that in this email Mr. ARIZMENDI acknowledges that he invested Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds following an investment strategy different from that instructed by the client, for which he indicates that he will change the strategy;
258. In view of this, subsequently, by email of 03 July 2015 at 11:51 hours, Mrs. ALVAREZ states to Mr. ARIZMENDI: “As we stated to you, there was a misunderstanding on your part in the mandate we gave; we understood that it was the same modality in which we had been working. But as you know this is already so and the issue is to find a solution for it (…)”
259. Regarding this email, it should be noted that as is proven in the record, in the account statements issued by the servicing broker dealer Bolton Capital Inc., the operations executed by the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC from August 2013 to December 2014, with the intervention of GPI SAB, were mainly purchases and sales of ETFs; that is, with a conservative profile;
260. It should be added that by letter received by GPI SAB on 04 November 2015, Mrs. ALVAREZ requested said agent company to return the US$ 645 000,00, stating in it: “I know that there was a misunderstanding which was not on my part since our instructions were different (…)”
261. As has been noted, Mrs. ALVAREZ has been claiming from GPI SAB regarding the destination of her funds since at least March 2015, in addition to reiterating that the investments with her funds were made with an investment profile different from that indicated by the aforementioned client;
262. Therefore, given that the modality for instructing orders of Mrs. ALVAREZ according to the Client Registration Form signed on 29 September 2014 is email with digital signature and with written confirmation, and taking into account the presumption contained in article 77, numeral 77.3 of the RAI56, it is evident that GPI SAB did not comply with the instructions given by Mrs. ALVAREZ for the destination of her funds, in addition to the fact that said stock brokerage company has not proven the effective execution of the alleged investments;
[56] In the case of non-written orders, it is presumed that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client.
263. On the other hand, it should be noted that the MUTUAL AGREEMENT does not by itself prove the client's ownership of the funds and/or securities and financial instruments indicated;
264. Indeed, these documents by themselves would not prove the position of funds and/or securities and financial instruments owned by Mrs. ALVAREZ, because, in the case of intermediation in the foreign market, it is also required to prove the position of funds and/or securities and financial instruments of the principal with account statements in the name of Mrs. ALVAREZ or in the name of GPI SAB provided by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, in which, with the necessary reconciliations, the ownership of funds or financial instruments of Mrs. ALVAREZ is indisputably demonstrated;
265. It should be noted that analogously, in the case that the funds are deposited in the OPERATING ACCOUNT and the securities and financial instruments are held in custody in the master account of the brokerage firm in CAVALI's Accounting Registry, the client's fund position would not be credited merely by the mention in an account statement in the client's name issued by GPI SAB that said client has a certain amount of money deposited with this intermediary, but rather this description must be backed by the money that is actually deposited in a financial entity in the name of GPI SAB, money that can be verified with the fund reconciliations per client that allow undeniably determining that the client has funds held in custody by GPI SAB. Likewise, in the case of positions of securities and financial instruments, this is verified through the authorized local clearing and settlement institution, which is CAVALI;
266. In that sense, it is not acceptable that the MUTUAL AGREEMENT by itself proves the investments that GPI SAB would have made with the funds entrusted by this client;
267. Regarding the fact that with the signing of the MUTUAL AGREEMENT Mrs. ALVAREZ was aware of the destination of her investments, it should be noted that as has been indicated, GPI SAB has not proven that the aforementioned investments were effectively made in the name or on behalf of Mrs. Alvarez;
268. Regarding the fact that GPI SAB considers that the presumption contemplated in numeral 77.3 of article 77 of the RAI57 is not applicable, given the existence of the MUTUAL AGREEMENT that proves the destination of Mrs. ALVAREZ's investments as of 10 November 2015 as well as the return to the investor of US$ 305 000,00 and that Mrs. ALVAREZ acknowledged at the time that her funds were invested in Puts, it must be mentioned that the existence of orders to invest the money in options has not been proven and it has not even been proven that this investment in options (not ordered by the client) was effectively made;
[57] In the case of unwritten orders, it is presumed that these have been given under the conditions indicated by the client.
269. Likewise, it should be indicated that, as has been mentioned above, the MUTUAL AGREEMENT does not constitute suitable proof of the destination of the investments ordered by Mrs. ALVAREZ;
270. Accordingly, it is concluded that GPI SAB both in the preliminary inquiries and in its defenses only states, but does not prove, that it invested with Mrs. ALVAREZ's authorization the balance of US$ 645 000,00 in the sale of Puts on ETF;
271. Likewise, it is valid to maintain that in the present case the factual assumption invoked in the charge imputation is met, that GPI SAB did not prove its client's instructions to invest in taking short positions in Puts, so that according to numeral 77.3 of article 77 of the RAI it is presumed that Mrs. ALVAREZ's instructions for the use of her funds consisted of the following;
a) Invest her funds in a liquid and conservative portfolio based on ETF.
b) That the investment would be executed by the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC using the account that Mrs. ALVAREZ has open in her name at this foreign intermediary since August 2013;
272. Consequently, GPI SAB has not proven the investments made with the US$ 645 000,00 that Mrs. ALVAREZ had as of 10 July 2015, after the last withdrawal of funds, and the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments of Mrs. ALVAREZ as of the date of its defenses (04 October 2016). It should be noted that it is only proven in the record that GPI SAB has delivered to Mrs. ALVAREZ US$ 73 970,00 for concept of returns from the investments made on behalf of this investor;
273. Therefore, by having used Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds in a manner different from that authorized by the client, GPI SAB breached the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the RAI;
274. Accordingly, by not having presented any evidentiary means by which it proves having observed literal a) of article 195 of the LMV and article 48 of the RAI, GPI SAB has not rebutted the charge formulated, so it is concluded that it has incurred an infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
275. According to the information in the record, it is observed that GPI SAB would have intervened, under the modality called "In its own name"58, in the intermediation of operations in the foreign market through the purchase and sale of various securities and financial instruments;
[58] Understood as that in which the foreign intermediary understands that the Agent is the holder of the operations and of the financial instruments that are acquired. It should be specified that in these cases the Agent carries out operations abroad, under said modality, but on behalf of its clients.
276. Indeed, through communication presented on 15 September 2016, GPI SAB states that the amount of US$ 950 000,00 was paid by Mrs. ALVAREZ into the OPERATING ACCOUNT, that is, both parties acknowledge that these funds were transferred and deposited in the OPERATING ACCOUNT of GPI SAB;
277. Likewise, through communications sent on 26 July and 15 September 2016, GPI SAB has indicated that the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ were used to carry out operations in the foreign market, so upon having transferred the funds of this client to the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC, in which the agent company has had a global account open for carrying out operations in the foreign market on its own behalf and on behalf of its clients since 05 October 200959;
278. It should be noted that such statement is also supported by the letter of 15 July 2015 signed by Mrs. BELLIDO and which was delivered to Mrs. ALVAREZ as a letter of introduction as a financial reference before the Embassy of the United States of America;
279. In that sense, with respect to Mrs. ALVAREZ, GPI SAB would not have signed with her the contract for carrying out operations in the foreign market, given the interest of the aforementioned client that said agent company intermediate this type of operations, also taking into account that a copy of such contract was requested from GPI SAB through Oficio N° 3372-2016-SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016 and Oficio N° 5050-2016-SMV/10.3 of 06 September 2016, and has not been accredited to date;
280. Accordingly, since GPI SAB maintains that it has intervened in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments “On its own behalf” in the foreign market through the modality of global accounts in the name of GPI SAB, this agent company should have signed with Mrs. ALVAREZ the respective contract as established in numeral 37.4.1 of subsection 37.4 of article 37 of the RAI, in which the minimum content referred to in article 40 of said regulation should have been detailed, such as the purpose of the contract, the client's declaration of knowing the implications of such operations, the responsibility of the agent company, among others;
281. It should be noted that GPI SAB states that the investment in the foreign market was made following the same criteria that Mrs. ALVAREZ put in her declaration before Pershing LLC, since only in that way can one have a range of instruments that allows a broader and more varied management in the intention of achieving returns based on premiums with options. Unfortunately, adverse events can occur unexpectedly and this contributes to negative results, eventually temporary, but which become permanent when the losses are realized;
282. In this regard, it should be highlighted that GPI SAB states that the investment in the foreign market would have been made following the same criteria that Mrs. ALVAREZ signed in her declaration before Pershing LLC, without
[59] According to communication sent by GPI SAB to this Superintendency on 07 October 2009.
however it must be indicated that GPI SAB has not accredited with any evidentiary means that the funds paid by Mrs. ALVAREZ to the CUENTA OPERATIVA were transferred to a foreign intermediary and that such operations were carried out as stated in its defenses; that is, it is not accredited that GPI SAB carried out operations with the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ, whether it was with the modality of “on its own behalf” (global account) in Interactive Brokers LLC or another foreign intermediary or “on behalf of the client” in the account that Mrs. ALVAREZ had open in Pershing LLC or another foreign intermediary;
283. Accordingly, charges were imputed to GPI SAB considering that said agent company affirmed that it had carried out various operations in the foreign market with the money delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ through the global account it has in Interactive Brokers LLC and therefore it should previously have the contract signed with the client. However, upon not having presented through its defenses any evidentiary means of the transfer of the funds from the CUENTA OPERATIVA to an account in a foreign intermediary, nor of the operations supposedly carried out, with which the configuration of the infraction evaluated in Chapter Second, literal A of this resolution was accredited; it has not been accredited that GPI SAB has intervened in the modality on its own behalf, in which previously the signing of a contract with the client is required, therefore it is concluded that it has not been possible to accredit that it has incurred an infraction qualified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18, of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
284. According to the information and documentation that appears in the file, it has been evidenced that GPI SAB would have allowed an unauthorized person to carry out activities proper to a representative of an agent company;
285. According to the documentation detailed in the various emails that Mr. ARIZMENDI sent to Mrs. ALVAREZ, it is observed that the first of the named, without having the corresponding authorization, on behalf of GPI SAB, would have carried out activities proper to a representative;
286. Indeed, through email to Mrs. ALVAREZ of 25 September 2013, Mr. ARIZMENDI forwarded her a report that would be the account statement that would have been issued by the international broker Pershing, in which he explains the detail of her investments. In this way, Mr. ARIZMENDI exercised the function of providing advice on securities and stock market operations (literal b) of article 194 of the LMV). It should be remembered that in 2013 Mrs. ALVAREZ began her commercial relationship with GPI SAB entrusting her funds to it in order to carry out operations abroad;
287. Likewise, by email of 30 September 2013 at 11:53 hours, Mr. ARIZMENDI took the order from Mrs. ALVAREZ and transmitted it so that the over-the-counter purchase transaction of securities be executed, as is the case of the shares of PPX Mining Corp., hereinafter, PPX. (function contemplated in literal a) of article 194 of the LMV);
288. Similarly, by email of 30 September 2013 at 14:34 hours, Mr. ARIZMENDI offered Mrs. ALVAREZ the services of GPI SAB for the acquisition of financial instruments (function contemplated in literal a) of article 194 of the LMV);
289. In the same way, according to the email of 30 September 2013 at 16:29 hours, Mr. ARIZMENDI informed a client of GPI SAB, in this case, Mrs. ALVAREZ, of the effective conclusion of a purchase transaction of the PPX shares and even that such shares were already in the name of said principal in CAVALI, information that, in addition to being protected by identity confidentiality, can only be provided by the brokerage firm (function contemplated in literals a) and b) of article 194 of the LMV);
290. In the same sense, Mr. ARIZMENDI received directly or indirectly information protected by identity confidentiality (article 45 of the LMV) which was sent to him by officials of GPI SAB (email of 30 September 2013 at 3:01 pm); or even gave instructions to the personnel of the brokerage firm, assuming functions of a director of the company (email of 30 September 2013 at 12:57 hours); or even participated in the preparation of the proposals for the settlement of disputes that GPI SAB had with Mrs. ALVAREZ (email of 19 April 2016 at 17:28 hours);
291. It should be noted that Mr. ARIZMENDI's email (farizmendi@gpivalores.com) has the same domain used by the officials of GPI SAB (@gpivalores.com), that is, he sends and receives emails as part of the team of workers of said brokerage firm;
292. It is appropriate to mention that all communications were made when Mr. ARIZMENDI had ceased to be part of GPI SAB, of which he was Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI SAB until 21 February 2013;
293. Finally, it should be noted that although in the section called “Signature” of such emails the full name of Mr. ARIZMENDI appears as President and General Manager of GPI ASSET, this does not invalidate the attributions improperly assumed by said person as representative of GPI SAB;
294. Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of articles 198 and 200 of the LMV and article 2, numeral 2.22, and articles 23 and 25 numeral 25.1 of the RAI, GPI SAB should not have allowed Mr. ARIZMENDI to assume attributions proper to a representative of a brokerage firm, thus GPI breaching the aforementioned regulations;
295. GPI SAB states that the factual assumptions on which the charges formulated are based are contradictory, given that it is intended to attribute responsibility for both infractions to the brokerage firm with respect to the actions of Mr. ARIZMENDI, who has no functional link with GPI SAB, which reflects the lack of causality (identification of the alleged offender and the imputation);
296. GPI SAB states that, under the assumptions of the imputation “Allowing persons who have a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the brokerage agent”, the company would have “tolerated” (but not executed) the acts that Mr. ARIZMENDI would have directly carried out and even facilitated information, however, such facts would not have been committed by the company but rather the offending conduct would have been carried out by the aforementioned Mr. ARIZMENDI;
297. However, GPI SAB states that under the imputation “Providing inaccurate information” it would be the company itself that would have provided inaccurate information when the one who provided advice to Mrs. ALVAREZ was Mr. ARIZMENDI;
298. GPI SAB states that Mr. ARIZMENDI has not acted as a representative of the company in any of the extremes indicated in the LMV, since it considers that there is no evidence that he has executed orders in the securities market nor that he has had access to any of the trading, execution, operation or custody systems of the SAB, since the management of Mrs. ALVAREZ's securities was carried out by authorized personnel of the SAB;
299. Likewise, regarding the email that Mr. ARIZMENDI sent to Mrs. ALVAREZ on 25 September 2013, GPI SAB states that since the former ceased to belong to the directive and managerial team of the SAB, he has provided his advice to some clients of the company, as is the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, in his capacity as an economist and that advice in the securities market is not restricted solely to brokerage agents and/or their representatives, and any person qualified for such practice may legally exercise it;
300. GPI SAB states that although Mr. ARIZMENDI had direct and personal dealings with Mrs. ALVAREZ, it has not been substantiated how this reflects conduct prohibited by the regulations;
301. Regarding the email that Mr. ARIZMENDI sent to Mrs. ALVAREZ on 30 September 2013 at 11:53 hours, GPI SAB states that the fact that the former transmitted a message to the SAB's operators (referring to the over-the-counter transaction for the purchase of PPX shares in the amount of US$ 250,000.00) does not make him an operator of the securities market, since there is no evidence that he executed the operations or had access to the SAB's trading, execution, operation or custody systems;
302. Regarding the email that Mr. ARIZMENDI sent to Mrs. ALVAREZ on 30 September 2013 at 14:34 hours, GPI SAB states that Mr. ARIZMENDI is linked to GPI SAB in his capacity as spouse of the shareholder and general manager of the company, which does not prevent him from conducting business for the benefit of the SAB;
303. Likewise, GPI SAB points out that promoting a company's services is not a function reserved for the company's representatives, whether or not they have interests in the intermediary, which, in its opinion, is consistent with the principle of legality set forth in literal a) of numeral 20 of article 2 of the Political Constitution of Peru, which states that no one is obliged to do what the law does not command, nor prevented from doing what it does not prohibit, and therefore Mr. ARIZMENDI did not incur, by doing so, in conduct supposedly "reserved" for stock brokerage firms;
304. With regard to the email of 30 September 2013 at 16:29 hours, in which GPI SAB is questioned that Mr. ARIZMENDI had information protected by the duty of confidentiality, said brokerage firm states that Mr. ARIZMENDI received from Mrs. ALVAREZ information that she voluntarily and directly entrusted to him, and therefore considers that the SAB did not share with Mr. ARIZMENDI information that he did not have before or that was not his own, as evidenced by the prior emails and pointed out by Mrs. ALVAREZ herself;
305. Likewise, GPI SAB states that Mr. ARIZMENDI is not prohibited from seeking to resolve the SAB's disputes with Mrs. ALVAREZ, since, given his good relationship with the aforementioned client, he was the most suitable person to seek to do so, and that the charges imputed have not indicated what the supposed prohibition is;
306. On the other hand, GPI SAB states that the use of a SAB email does not constitute an infraction, since many companies may provide email accounts to their partners, clients, workers or former workers, without this in any way implying a relationship of dependency or representation;
307. With regard to the alleged contradiction between the factual assumptions on which the charges filed for "Allowing persons with a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent" and "providing inaccurate information" are based, it should be noted that these are two distinct infractions, since although it is true that Mr. ARIZMENDI participated in both, the facts proven in the record and the typology used in the charges, in accordance with the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, show that they are responsibilities of the brokerage firm itself and not of the natural persons who participated in such facts;
308. Indeed, in the first charge, GPI SAB did not at any time prevent Mr. ARIZMENDI from having access to information and documentation and from carrying out activities proper and exclusive to a representative and director of a brokerage firm, while in the second charge, the firm was observed for its general manager having allowed Mr. ARIZMENDI to provide a client with information that was not accurate;
309. It should also be noted that GPI SAB has not presented evidence proving the lack of the principle of causality in the two aforementioned infractions; on the contrary, it has given arguments aimed at directing them to the natural person who participated in them, that is, Mr. ARIZMENDI, when in reality they are obligations proper and exclusive to the brokerage firm;
310. Likewise, it is appropriate to mention that in its brief submitted on 27 September 2016, GPI SAB, arguing the aforementioned alleged contradiction between the two aforementioned charges, requested that the OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES be reformulated on these two points, a request that was duly answered by Official Letter No. 5673-2016-SMV/10.3, in which it was indicated that this would be evaluated comprehensively at the time of evaluating the defenses submitted;
311. On the other hand, with regard to the defenses formulated by GPI for the present charge: "Allowing persons with a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the intermediation agent" and "providing inaccurate information", it should be noted that with respect to the questioning of the content of the emails of 30 September 2013, it is worth highlighting, in addition to what has been said in the present charge, that they evidence phrases, statements, explanations, and facts typical of a representative of a stock brokerage firm but not those formulated by a financial advisor, since this differs, among other things, by the sufficiency of information (much of it protected by identity confidentiality or by being exclusively managed by a stock brokerage firm);
312. Indeed, Mr. ARIZMENDI in the emails addressed to Mrs. ALVAREZ, with a copy to the general manager of GPI SAB, indicated or provided information that could only come from a representative who, in addition to managing the information, made decisions as a senior director of the company;
"I sent you your position in account at Pershing", "they are the costs of commissions both from Pershing and from us in the operations we have carried out for you. Normally, the commissions we charge between ourselves and Pershing range between 0.50% and 0.825% of the amount traded", "In other words, we only charge you the times it is necessary to carry out transactions… We do not charge you anything else on the side of GPI Valores SAB" (email to Mrs. ALVAREZ of 25 September 2013, 20:07 hours);
313. In this email, Mr. ARIZMENDI, on behalf of GPI SAB, sends the client information that generally contains an account statement issued by a foreign intermediary, in this case Pershing, regarding the movements of funds, securities and financial instruments abroad in the client's name60 and informs her of the commissions charged by the brokerage firm;
314. It should be noted that in this case it is observed that Mr. ARIZMENDI sends the client information that comes from a counterparty of GPI SAB (in this case the foreign intermediary Pershing), advising her regarding its content; it is not that the client sent said information to Mr. ARIZMENDI requesting his advice like any economist who provides advice in the securities market as GPI SAB maintains. Without prejudice to the aforementioned, GPI SAB has not proven that it has authorization for Mrs. ALVAREZ's information, such as account statements and policies, to be sent directly to an external advisor;
315. Moreover, in said email another email of 25 September 2013 at 05:54 pm is attached, in which Mr. Jose Luis Carranza, representative of GPI SAB, sends Mr. ARIZMENDI the position of Mrs. ALVAREZ as of 25 September 2013; that is, an employee of GPI SAB reports and transmits to Mr. ARIZMENDI certain information as if he were a representative of the brokerage firm and additionally it is information protected by the duty of confidentiality, therefore, it is not legally sustainable to affirm that such information can feasibly be transmitted directly by the brokerage firm
[60] Mrs. ALVAREZ has an account open in her name with this intermediary since August 2013.
brokerage firm to a commercial advisor of Mrs. ALVAREZ outside the brokerage firm, as GPI SAB states in its defenses;
"I send you the draft of the contract that we use (…). In any case, Tere and Lucero can help you with any relatively urgent doubt" (email to Mrs. ALVAREZ of 26 September 2013, 12:57 hours with copy to Mrs. Lucero Málaga – Controller of GPI SAB, Teresa Orlandini- Customer Service, Representative of GPI SAB);
316. In this email Mr. ARIZMENDI has the staff of GPI SAB and makes them available to a client of the firm, in this case, Mrs. ALVAREZ. Through this email Mr. ARIZMENDI not only assumes the functions of a director, but also, in the circumstances of the prior negotiations for carrying out a purchase operation of PPX shares, acting as a representative he tells the client that she can also seek guidance from the staff of the brokerage firm;
"I send you the corrected contract in a few more minutes, along with the promissory note, which serves as additional guarantee (…) As for the shares they will be those of Peruvian Precious Metals (PPX) (…) the amount of shares that we are going to transfer today in the over-the-counter operation is the following: (…) Amount in money of the operation: USD 250,000.00 (…) in number of shares: USD 1,923,077 (…) Additional guarantee: Promissory note of GPI Valores SAB (…) These are the terms that I am going to add to the contract and on which the promissory note will be made. I am passing the operation today." (Email to Mrs. ALVAREZ of 30 September 2013, 11:53 hours);
317. Here Mr. ARIZMENDI not only speaks on behalf of the general manager of GPI SAB, but also conducts negotiations regarding the investment of Mrs. ALVAREZ's funds and states that he will pass the over-the-counter operation; that is, he has clearly taken the investment order of the client's funds, an activity exclusive to a representative of the brokerage firm;
318. Regarding what GPI SAB indicated about there being no evidence that Mr. ARIZMENDI has executed the operation or had access to the trading, execution, operation or custody systems of the SAB, it should be noted that for the over-the-counter operation with securities that trade on the Lima Stock Exchange, as is the case of PPX, it is not required to enter a trading or execution system; it is enough for one representative to take the purchase order and another representative or the same one to take the sale order and both are transmitted to the staff of the brokerage firm in charge of registering these transfers in CAVALI, for their settlement;
319. In this particular case, it is evidenced from the aforementioned emails that Mr. ARIZMENDI acted as representative of Mrs. ALVAREZ who transmitted her order to the staff of the brokerage firm in charge of the settlement of the over-the-counter operation of 30 September 2013.
"I pass you the extract of the transaction. The shares are already in your CAVALI account (custody) a hug, Luis Felipe and Antonia." (Email to Mrs. ALVAREZ of 30 September 2013, 16:29 hours);
"As I commented to you in the previous email, I send you your position in CAVALI a hug" (email to Mrs. ALVAREZ of 30 September 2013, 16:31, with copy to the general manager of GPI SAB);
320. Here Mr. ARIZMENDI, on behalf of GPI SAB (since no other reasonably valid interpretation would fit) and with the approval of the general manager of the firm, confirms to the client her holdings registered in CAVALI;
321. It should also be noted that as part of the email subject to comments, another email is attached (30 September 2013 2:45 pm) in which Mr. Luis Enrique Arteaga Ruiz, Operations Manager of GPI SAB61, sends Mr. ARIZMENDI the details of the over-the-counter transaction, that is, after the over-the-counter transaction was carried out, in an internal process in which it is understood that there is not the remotest possibility that a third party outside GPI SAB would participate (understood as someone who is not an employee or director), information regarding said transaction was transferred to a person who is not a representative and has no formal link with the brokerage firm and, on the other hand, also cannot have access to information protected by the duty of confidentiality;
322. Regarding what was indicated by GPI SAB that Mr. ARIZMENDI received from Ms. ALVAREZ information that she voluntarily and directly entrusted to him, and therefore it considers that GPI SAB did not share with Mr. ARIZMENDI information that he did not have before or that was external to him, as evidenced by the prior emails pointed out by Ms. ALVAREZ herself; it should be noted that Ms. ALVAREZ shared information with Mr. ARIZMENDI regarding her interest in investing her money on 30 September 2013, but not because he was an advisor outside the brokerage firm, but because she instructed him to invest her funds and Mr. ARIZMENDI took her purchase order, in accordance with what was indicated above. In this sense, Mr. Luis Enrique Arteaga Ruiz transmits the information about the settlement of Ms. ALVAREZ's purchase transaction to Mr. ARIZMENDI, not in his capacity as the client's external commercial advisor, but in his capacity as the representative in charge of this particular transaction;
323. Notwithstanding the foregoing, it should be noted that GPI SAB has not proven that Ms. ALVAREZ voluntarily and directly entrusted to him information about her investment to be made on 30 September 2013, such as value, quantity, prices, among other conditions, with any evidentiary means, since from the emails supporting this imputation no such disclosure by the client to Mr. ARIZMENDI is derived; on the contrary, it is evidenced that it was the latter who informed her of the type of share that would be purchased, that such securities would be acquired over-the-counter, the quantity and final amount of the transaction to be carried out, from which it follows that he was the person in charge of this transaction, among others, (all of this with the full knowledge of the general manager of GPI SAB, who, moreover, did not object in any way to Mr. ARIZMENDI's actions), in addition to the fact that Mr. ARIZMENDI learned of Ms. ALVAREZ's position in CAVALI, not from her but from a manager of GPI SAB, Mr. Luis Enrique Arteaga Ruiz, according to an email of 30 September 2013 at 02:45 pm; therefore, from Ms. ALVAREZ's behavior with respect to Mr. ARIZMENDI, it can be seen that it was logically a relationship between a duly authorized representative of the brokerage firm and its client;
“We are sending you both the mutual loan agreement and the promissory note of GPI Valores SAB (…) when you can stop by GPI Valores SAB, you sign the originals and take an original and the promissory note. We are going to process the transaction in a few more minutes and send you the position of
[61] Who, by means of an email of 30 September 2013 at 3:01 pm, sent an email to the general manager of GPI SAB, with a copy to Mr. ARIZMENDI, in which he states: “Dear Antonia, I am sending the details of the over-the-counter transaction”.
CAVALI, where the transactions will already appear in your account” (email to Ms. ALVAREZ of 30 September 2013, 14:34 hours);
324. Through this email, Mr. ARIZMENDI offers Ms. ALVAREZ the services of GPI SAB for the acquisition of financial instruments (function contemplated in subsection a) of article 194 of the LMV);
325. As to the fact that Mr. ARIZMENDI is not prevented from conducting business for the benefit of the company in his capacity as spouse of the shareholder and general manager of the company and that this is not an activity restricted only to representatives of the brokerage firm, it should be noted that such an interpretation lacks legal basis, since it has already been demonstrated in the preceding recitals that the activities carried out by Mr. ARIZMENDI are proper to a duly authorized representative;
326. Additionally, it should be noted that the role of representative of a corporation, such as GPI SAB, falls on whoever has been appointed as such and in accordance with the formalities described in the General Corporations Law, Law No. 26887 (hereinafter, LGS)62, and even their actions are binding before the company for the purpose of determining its liability to third parties63;
327. For its part, it should be specified that in accordance with the provisions of article 198 of the LMV, a representative is one who, duly authorized, acts in the name of the brokerage firm. In the present case, Mr. ARIZMENDI acted in the name of GPI SAB, and not only that, he used the company's personnel to serve a client of the SAB, received from personnel of the brokerage firm information that should not be accessible to someone who is not the proper representative and is also information protected by the duty of confidentiality, and forwarded it to the client. In that sense, maintaining that a third party, not a representative of the company, can carry out acts such as those described, and that this is not prevented by the regulations, is contrary to the regulation of the securities market, and also, by the LGS itself;
328. Likewise, it must be specified that promoting the services of the SAB is a completely different figure from the activities carried out by Mr. ARIZMENDI that have been observed in this charge, differences that stand out given the scope and competencies that exist between a promoter (a figure that GPI SAB presents as the one incurred) and a representative of an agent company;
“Dear María, On behalf of LF who went out to an urgent meeting, I sent the proposal, just as we offered to do today (…)” (email from the general manager of GPI SAB to Mrs. ALVAREZ dated 19 April 2016, 17:28 hours
[62] Article 14.- Appointments, powers and registrations The appointment of administrators, liquidators or any representative of the company as well as the granting of powers by the latter takes effect from its express acceptance or from the moment the aforementioned persons perform the function or exercise such powers. These acts or any revocation, resignation, modification or substitution of the persons mentioned in the preceding paragraph or of their powers, must be registered leaving record of the name and identity document of the appointee or of the representative, as the case may be. (…)
[63] In the case of the representation of the company it is advisable to recall the provisions of article 12 of the LGS: Article 12.- Scope of representation The company is obligated towards those with whom it has contracted and towards third parties in good faith for the acts of its representatives celebrated within the limits of the powers conferred upon them even if such acts commit the company to businesses or operations not included within its corporate purpose. (…)
and that it was sent with a copy to Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Germán Florez García-Rada, lawyer of the agent company) Our highlighting;
329. It should be noted that in this email the general manager of GPI SAB sends to Mrs. ALVAREZ the proposal for payment of her credits (for the debt amounting to US$ 645 000,00) against the agent company which was previously coordinated with Mr. ARIZMENDI whom she cites in the email as “LF”;
330. As to the fact that Mr. ARIZMENDI is also not prohibited from seeking to resolve the SAB's disputes with Mrs. ALVAREZ since, given his good relationship with the aforementioned client, he was the most suitable person to seek to do so and that the charges imputed have not indicated what the supposed prohibition is, it should be noted that according to what was previously indicated, it is evident that Mr. ARIZMENDI did not act as an external commercial advisor unrelated to the stock brokerage agent company but as a representative of the same, so these efforts on behalf of Mr. ARIZMENDI transmitted by the General Manager of the stock brokerage agent company (as payment proposals for her credits, that is, great decision-making capacity by the agent company) form part of the actions carried out by Mr. ARIZMENDI as a representative without having the corresponding authorization;
331. Finally, as to the fact that Mr. ARIZMENDI's email with the GPI SAB domain does not constitute an infraction of the regulations, it should be indicated that what was observed is that the stock brokerage agent company allowed that through an email owned by the agent company, Mr. ARIZMENDI carry out actions proper to a representative, and even handle information and documentation that exclusively only a person with such capacity could do through said emails, which was directly known to the general manager of the agent company who was copied on the emails; and which ratifies his action as an unauthorized representative according to the regulations;
332. For the foregoing, GPI SAB has not disproved the charge formulated so it has been proven that it incurred in the infraction classified as very serious, typified by Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.7 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
333. In her complaint presented on 03 June 2016, Mrs. ALVAREZ indicates that GPI SAB has misled about the liquidity of the value of the company PPX of which it acted as sponsor, regarding which GPI SAB has not issued any comment in response to Official Letter No. 3372-2016-SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016, through which the aforementioned complaint was forwarded to it;
334. In the documents attached to the brief of amplification of the complaint presented on 04 July 2016, it is proven that through email dated 30 September 2013 at 11:53 hours from Mr. ARIZMENDI to Mrs. ALVAREZ, with copy to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, general manager of GPI SAB, the following was mentioned:
Luis Felipe Arizmendi farizmendi@gpivalores.com To. María Teófila Alvarez Mayorca malvarezmayorca@gmail.com CC: Antonia Bellido Tagle abellido@gpivalores.com
“Dear María (…) As for the shares, they will be those of Peruvian Precious Metals (PPX) (…). It is within the eligible securities of the BVL, although it is not as liquid as the first board securities such as Credicorp (BAP) or Southern Copper Corporation (SCCO) could be (…). (….)”;
335. According to the information published in the Daily Bulletin of the Lima Stock Exchange (BVL) on 27 September 2013, the business day prior to the date of the aforementioned email from Mr. ARIZMENDI, the trading frequency, which is the indicator to measure the liquidity of a security in the Stock Exchange Session of the BVL, of the BAP and SCCO securities, amounted to 100 and 75%, respectively, which meant that they were high-liquidity securities. On the other hand, the trading frequency of PPX was 5%, that is, it was a security of very low or almost nil liquidity;
336. Therefore, by pointing out to Mrs. ALVAREZ, with a copy to Mrs. BELLIDO, that the PPX securities, which were to be acquired by the client on 30 September 2013, were not as liquid as the BAP and SCCO securities could be, Mr. ARIZMENDI was indicating that the PPX securities were also liquid, but do not reach the high liquidity levels of the BAP and SCCO securities;
337. As indicated by the same Daily Bulletin of the BVL, the trading frequency is calculated by taking the number of Trading Sessions in which a security has established a quotation among the last 20 Stock Exchange Trading Sessions in the case of equity-representative securities such as PPX. Therefore, the trading frequency of 5% indicates that PPX only established a quotation in one (01) session in the last 20 Stock Exchange Trading Sessions as of 27 September 2013, which made it a security that had very little or almost no liquidity;
338. Therefore, although the message was sent by Mr. ARIZMENDI, said message was copied to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, general manager of GPI SAB who also knew of its content, so she should not have allowed Mr. ARIZMENDI to provide inaccurate information to Mrs. ALVAREZ regarding the liquidity situation of the PPX security by saying that they were not as liquid as high-liquidity shares (BAP and SCCO), and presenting them as an investment alternative with favorable future prospects, but rather should have directly informed Mrs. ALVAREZ that the PPX securities had very little or almost no liquidity, which would have allowed the client to have accurate information about the liquidity situation of the security, before making the decision to invest in these securities;
339. Likewise, GPI SAB would have provided inaccurate information because it did not communicate to Mrs. ALVAREZ all the information they had regarding the PPX shares, such as that it was a junior company, that is, it did not emphasize the characteristics of this type of company nor the risks acquired when buying these securities, so GPI SAB should have provided Mrs. ALVAREZ with accurate information about the PPX securities so that the client could make an informed investment decision;
340. Even, GPI SAB did not previously inform her that the counterparty in the purchase of 1 923 077 PPX shares that Mrs. ALVAREZ was going to execute was GPI SAB itself;
341. On the other hand, GPI SAB provided inaccurate information to Mrs. ALVAREZ given that with the signing of the mutual loan agreement of 30 September 2013, the delivery of a promissory note and the purchase of PPX shares as part of the conditions of this contract, incongruent information was provided to Mrs. ALVAREZ;
342. In this regard, it should be noted that the mutual loan agreement regulated in the regulations governing the securities market is that which consists of the granting of credits to its clients by the stock brokerage firms, the latter assuming such credits with their own resources (article 194 subsection m) of the LMV);
343. In the present case, the aforementioned article 194 subsection m) and articles 51, 52 and 53 of the RAI were cited in said contract, when in reality, the tenor of said contract indicated that it was not a loan from the brokerage firm to Mrs. ALVAREZ but rather the reverse, that is, that the latter lent money to GPI SAB;
344. Likewise, in the aforementioned mutual loan agreement, Mrs. ALVAREZ was told that the purchase of the 1 923 077 PPX shares would only be temporary, that is, for the term of the aforementioned mutual loan agreement and that the temporary ownership over said securities is a guarantee of the money delivered as a monetary loan in favor of GPI SAB;
345. Likewise, in said contract, it was stated that there was also a promissory note for US$ 265,000 in favor of Mrs. ALVAREZ as additional guarantee for the payment of principal and interest for the term of 180 days, interest that was also paid by GPI SAB to Mrs. ALVAREZ as if it were actually a loan and not an investment made by this client; when it is fully proven in the file that the money entered the operating account of GPI for the execution of operations in the securities market, issuing the respective orders and policies;
346. All of this would reflect GPI SAB's action of providing inaccurate information to Mrs. ALVAREZ regarding the investment of her money;
347. GPI SAB states that this charge and the charge referred to as “allowing third parties outside the company to carry out activities proper to the SAB” flow from conducts attributed contradictorily to a natural person and a legal person in which the first named has no connection with the second, so the principle of causality between the offender and the imputation would not be met and therefore the principle of due process established in the LPAG would not be complied with.
348. Likewise, GPI SAB adds that the present imputation would have been made directly by Mr. ARIZMENDI, so it is not possible that at the same time such situation is attributed to the brokerage firm.
349. As support for this, it states that the misleading about the liquidity of a security was done by Mr. ARIZMENDI and not by GPI SAB; and that the charge imputed by stating that not all the information was given to Mrs. ALVAREZ about the PPX security does not question the misleading about the liquidity of the security but the delivery of all the information available on certain securities, since brokerage firms are empowered to advise their clients and are not obliged to satisfy the supposed standard that the present charge establishes, especially considering that Mrs. ALVAREZ declared in her Client Registration form that she had high knowledge of the securities market, in addition to having her own advisors, including Mr. ARIZMENDI;
350. Likewise, GPI SAB states that it is not appropriate to issue any comment regarding the advice and recommendations given by Mr. ARIZMENDI, in reference to the email he sent to Mrs. ALVAREZ on 30 September 2013 at 11:53 hours, regarding the purchase of PPX shares. In that sense, since the charge has indicated that such information was provided by Mr. ARIZMENDI, the charge cannot be imputed to GPI SAB in application of the principle of causality.
351. Regarding the mutual loan contract of 30 September 2013, GPI SAB acknowledges that the contractual model of the mutual loan was not adequate; however, the execution of the contract and granting a promissory note as guarantee has nothing to do with the alleged breached norm (article 195, literal h) of the LMV), given that it refers to an alleged act of deception regarding the liquidity of a security listed on the stock exchange, so the attributed conduct does not withstand the test of typicity. It adds that there is no evidence that GPI SAB advised Mrs. ALVAREZ in the purchase of the PPX securities, nor whether they were liquid or not, and that therefore it assumes no responsibility.
352. Regarding the alleged non-observance of the principle of causality between the offender and the formulated imputation, it must be ratified that GPI SAB has not presented evidentiary means that prove the lack of observance of the principle of causality in the present infraction; on the contrary, it has given arguments with the objective that it be directed to the natural person who participated in them, that is, Mr. ARIZMENDI, when in reality it concerns the observance of obligations that are own and exclusive to the agent company;
353. Indeed, regarding the fact of the information provided by Mr. ARIZMENDI to Mrs. ALVAREZ, according to email of 30 September 2013 at 11:53 hours, the formulated charge questions the actions of GPI SAB, through its General Manager who did not observe the quality of the information provided, nor even requested its precision; on the contrary, he validated this information by not having taken any action on the matter; thus providing Mrs. Alvarez with inaccurate information or allowing or facilitating third parties to provide her with inaccurate information;
354. It should be remembered that it is the obligation of the agent company to provide its clients with all the information that allows them to know whether or not they are dealing with a liquid security before making an investment decision, and not to allow subjective assessments or inaccurate information about certain securities to be provided to its clients, as Mr. ARIZMENDI did;
355. It should be added that GPI SAB's defenses on the matter are incongruent with those referred to in the charge regarding “allowing persons who have a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the brokerage agent,” since in the latter GPI SAB states that the spouse of the general manager and shareholder of the company can procure business for the benefit of the SAB and that as advisor to Mrs. ALVAREZ he could send various documentation and information to said client; however, now it states that all the information provided by Mr. ARIZMENDI and its implications must be attributed only to said person and not to GPI SAB;
356. Likewise, it should be indicated that the formulated charge is not based only on the fact of the information that Mr. ARIZMENDI provided to Mrs. ALVAREZ, with the knowledge of the general manager of GPI SAB, but also on the facts referred to the information that the SAB had about the PPX shares; that it did not inform who was going to be the counterparty, in the purchase of 1 923 077 PPX shares, by Mrs. ALVAREZ; and, regarding what was stated in the mutual loan contract of 30 September 2013. On this point it must be mentioned that according to article 173 of the LMV, the relationship between intermediaries and their principals is governed by the rules of commercial commission, and article 261 of the Code of Commerce establishes that no commission agent shall buy for himself or for another what he has been ordered to sell, nor sell what he has been entrusted to buy, without the principal's license;
357. As for the execution and guarantees of the money mutual loan contract with repurchase agreement of 30 September 2013, it has nothing to do with misleading about the liquidity of a security; that there is no evidence that GPI SAB advised Mrs. ALVAREZ in the purchase of the PPX securities, nor whether they were liquid or not; it should be indicated that it has been proven in the file, according to the email dated 30 September 2013 at 11:53 hours from Mr. ARIZMENDI to Mrs. ALVAREZ (with copy to the general manager of GPI SAB), that the purchase of such securities was an operation that was coordinated and offered from its beginnings by Mr. ARIZMENDI with full knowledge of the general manager of GPI SAB, so it cannot be argued that the SAB did not participate in Mrs. ALVAREZ's decision to purchase said shares;
358. It should be added that, with this argument, GPI SAB would indirectly seek to disavow its participation in the beginnings of the transaction for the purchase of PPX shares, which was in full knowledge and coordination by the general manager of the company, who at no time questioned its transaction or later disavowed the execution of the mutual loan contract of 30 September 2013, since it is so much so that such purchase was planned, that the operation was carried out under the same conditions that were informed to Mrs. ALVAREZ, and that was reflected in the cited contract;
359. Likewise, it must be recalled that what is described in the facts supporting the charge filed relating to the mutual loan agreement is precisely related to completing the purchase of the PPX securities (which had very little or almost no liquidity, which were securities issued by a junior company, and that investment in these types of securities involved greater risk due to the nature of the issuing company's activity); that is, GPI SAB, with the consent and validation of its general manager, allowed Mrs. ALVAREZ to be provided with inaccurate information about the liquidity of the PPX security with the aim that she purchase them (and GPI SAB was also the counterparty to the transaction in its capacity as seller) and thus guarantee a mutual loan agreement in which the main beneficiary was the SAB itself;
360. Additionally, it must be noted that in the email of 30 September indicated in the statement of charges, in which inaccurate information is provided to Mrs. ALVAREZ about the liquidity of the PPX securities, Mrs. ALVAREZ is informed that an over-the-counter transaction will be carried out and that as a result thereof, the terms of the mutual loan agreement regarding the amount, principal, additional guarantee and amount of the promissory note will be reported;
361. On the other hand, as to the claim that GPI SAB was not obligated to meet the alleged information standard contained in this charge, it must be noted that although Mrs. ALVAREZ stated that she had extensive knowledge of the securities market, it is evident, from the information contained in the file, including the emails sent by Mr. ARIZMENDI, that the liquidity of the PPX securities reported to the client was not accurate, which was not corrected by the general manager of GPI SAB, much less expanded in order to provide other elements of judgment for making an adequate investment decision;
362. For the foregoing reasons, the commission of the infraction charged to GPI SAB has been established, given the inaccurate information about the liquidity of the PPX securities provided by Mr. ARIZMENDI to Mrs. ALVAREZ with full knowledge of the general manager of GPI SAB, which had the objective of benefiting the brokerage firm, in accordance with the fact that in the purchase-sale transaction of such securities, the selling counterparty was GPI SAB and that such securities were incorporated into the so-called mutual loan agreement of 30 September 2013; it should be added that it has also been established that the content of the latter did not observe the rules established by the regulations governing the securities market (which has even been acknowledged by GPI SAB in its defense submissions), all with the objective of providing inaccurate information to Mrs. ALVAREZ regarding the investment of her money;
363. Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the principle of causality has been established in this charge with the evidence shown, which constitutes compliance with the principle of due process contemplated in the LPAG, and therefore it is concluded that GPI SAB incurred an infraction classified as very serious, typified by Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
364. According to the information in the file, it has been evidenced that Mrs. ALVAREZ in the month of January 2015 deposited funds in the amount of US$ 950 000,000 into the OPERATING ACCOUNT, which has also been confirmed by GPI SAB, taking into account in addition that both parties also agree that the money delivered was for the purpose of making investments with financial instruments in the foreign market;
365. Such funds, according to GPI SAB, would have been transferred to the global account that said brokerage firm has open at Interactive Brokers LLC., in accordance with the letter of 15 July 2015 signed by Mrs. BELLIDO and which was delivered to Mrs. ALVAREZ as a letter of introduction as a financial reference before the Embassy of the United States of North America;
366. Likewise, according to what was stated by GPI SAB through its communications sent to this Superintendency on 26 July and 15 September 2016, said brokerage firm would have intervened on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ in the intermediation of operations in the foreign market through the sale of “put” type options based on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), which can be stated were carried out through the global account that GPI SAB has open at Interactive Brokers LLC;
367. In support of such assertion, by communication sent on 26 July 2016, GPI SAB stated that Ms. ALVAREZ would have had the following investments and funds;
a) Sale of 110 put options contracts of GDXJ expiring in February 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 30.
b) Sale of 125 put options contracts of GDX expiring in March 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 25.
c) Cash for approximately US$ 2 500;
368. Likewise, by communication sent on 15 September 2016, GPI SAB attached a table showing that as of 30 June 2016, Ms. ALVAREZ would have had the following investments and funds;
a) Sale of 110 put options contracts of GDXJ at the exercise price of US$ 30. It does not indicate the expiration date of these contracts.
b) Sale of 125 put options contracts of GDX and at the exercise price of US$ 25. It does not indicate the expiration date of these contracts.
c) Cash for US$ 2 502.50;
369. As has been noted in this resolution, these alleged investments have not been proven by GPI SAB;
370. As observed, the investments in put option contracts had February (in the case of the GDXJ puts) and March 2016 (in the case of the GDX puts) as expiration; however, as of 30 June 2016 they had another expiration not specified by GPI SAB, which is explained, according to what that brokerage firm indicated in its writings, by the extension of the options' expiration through "rollover", a modality that, as GPI SAB explains in its writings, this brokerage firm uses when the option contracts, due to a sharp and unexpected drop in the market, are within the adverse execution zone (understood as loss of principal);
371. Therefore, according to what GPI SAB reported, that brokerage firm on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ would have intervened in the foreign market to invest the funds of this client in the sale of put option contracts, whose expirations were extended, at least once, through the "rollover" modality, extensions that are also operations with the option contracts;
372. However, GPI SAB would not have observed the provisions of numeral 37.4.2 of article 37 of the RAI, which expressly requires that for these operations, the brokerage agent must have the global account records, which in accordance with article 90 of the aforementioned regulation, must indicate the movements of securities and financial instruments, of funds, balances of financial instruments and funds, among others;
373. Indeed, it has been demonstrated that with respect to the global account supposedly opened at Interactive Brokers LLC, GPI SAB would not have the control records of this global account from January 2015 to date, which would allow identifying the movements and balances of financial instruments and funds of Mrs. ALVAREZ, also taking into account that this was requested from GPI SAB through Oficio N° 3372-2016-SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016 and Oficio N° 050-2016-SMV/10.3 of 06 September 2016, and has not been accredited to date;
374. In this regard, it should be noted that GPI SAB has not formulated any defense on the matter, regarding the failure to observe the provisions of numeral 37.4.2 of article 37 of the RAI, which expressly requires that for the operations that GPI SAB claims to have carried out, the brokerage agent must have the global account records, which in accordance with article 90 of the aforementioned regulation, must indicate the movements of securities and financial instruments, of funds, balances of financial instruments and funds, among others;
375. On this matter, it should be noted that to date, GPI SAB has not accredited with any evidentiary means the existence of operations abroad that it claims to have carried out on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ;
376. Likewise, it should be noted that although GPI SAB has repeatedly affirmed having carried out such operations, this Superintendency has requested, both in the preliminary inquiry stage and in the present administrative sanctioning procedure, the documents supporting its statement; however, to date, this has not been accredited in the file;
377. Similarly, it should be noted that GPI SAB has not accredited with any evidentiary means that the funds paid by Mrs. ALVAREZ to the OPERATING ACCOUNT were transferred to a foreign intermediary and that such supposed operations were carried out as stated in its defenses, thereby configuring the infraction evaluated in Chapter Second, literal A of this resolution; that is, it is not accredited that GPI SAB carried out operations with the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ, whether in the modality of own name (global account) at Interactive Brokers LLC or another foreign intermediary or "in the client's name" in the account that Mrs. ALVAREZ had opened at Pershing LLC or another foreign intermediary;
378. Accordingly, charges were imputed to GPI SAB considering that said brokerage firm affirmed that it had carried out various operations in the foreign market with the money delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ through the global account it has at Interactive Brokers LLC and therefore, it should have the control records of global accounts. However, by not having presented through its defenses any evidentiary means of the transfer of funds from the OPERATING ACCOUNT to an account at a foreign intermediary, nor of the operations carried out, thereby accrediting the configuration of the infraction evaluated in Chapter Second, literal A of this resolution, it cannot be accredited that GPI SAB has intervened in the own-name modality, in which having the control records of global accounts is required, so it is concluded that it has not been possible to accredit that it has incurred an infraction qualified as serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19, of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
379. In her complaint filed on 03 June 2016, Mrs. ALVAREZ indicated that the outstanding patrimonial obligations to her person were not recorded accounting-wise in the financial statements of GPI SAB;
380. In this regard, through Oficio N° 3372-2016- SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016, the aforementioned complaint was forwarded to GPI SAB so that it present the respective defenses, however, to date GPI SAB has not formulated any comment on the matter;
381. As has been accredited in the present proceeding, according to what was stated by both Ms. ALVAREZ and GPI SAB and with the documentation in the file, both parties agree in stating that the former deposited in the latter's OPERATING ACCOUNT US$ 950,000.00, a bank transfer that the agent company itself has accredited documentary evidence in the file;
382. Likewise, according to what was stated by GPI SAB, these funds were transferred to the global account that the company has at Interactive Brokers LLC, so that operations are carried out in the foreign market on behalf of Ms. ALVAREZ;
383. However, GPI SAB has not accredited having control records of global accounts, according to what is stated in the RAI, regarding the operations carried out on behalf of Ms. ALVAREZ through the global account at Interactive Brokers LLC, which are specifically taking positions as sellers of Put options;
384. In that sense, it has also not been accredited that GPI SAB has recorded this information in the financial information it presents to this Superintendency corresponding to the months of January 2015 to July 2016, that is, it would not have recorded the US$ 950,000.00 and, subsequently to the fund returns, the US$ 645,000.00 in the corresponding accounting entries of the agent company;
385. Indeed, according to the aforementioned regulations, GPI SAB should have presented in Control Annex 3 of the financial information for the months of January 2015 to July 2016, the valuation of Ms. ALVAREZ's positions as seller of Put options, according to the operations that have been carried out through the global account that GPI SAB has at Interactive Brokers LLC;
386. GPI SAB acknowledges that the financial information was not adequate and states that given the relative complexity of some instruments such as options, the correct financial presentation of such securities is difficult in local-type systems;
387. On the other hand, it should be noted that GPI SAB has not accredited with any evidentiary means that the funds paid by Ms. ALVAREZ to the OPERATING ACCOUNT were transferred to a foreign intermediary and that such operations were carried out as stated in its discharges; that is, it is not accredited that GPI SAB carried out operations with the funds delivered by Ms. ALVAREZ, whether it was with the modality of "in its own name" (global account) at Interactive Brokers LLC or another foreign intermediary or "in the client's name" in the account that Ms. ALVAREZ had open at Pershing LLC or another foreign intermediary;
388. Accordingly, it should be highlighted that charges were imputed to GPI SAB considering that said agent company affirmed that it had carried out various operations in the foreign market with the money delivered by Ms. ALVAREZ through the global account it has at Interactive Brokers LLC and therefore, in attention to said operations, it should have presented in the "Control Annex 3: Order Accounts for Client Accounts", the valuation of Ms. ALVAREZ's positions as seller of Put options;
389. In that sense, according to the operations that GPI SAB stated it had carried out through the aforementioned global account, by not having presented through its discharges any evidentiary means of the transfer of funds from the OPERATING ACCOUNT to an account in a foreign intermediary, nor of the supposed operations carried out, with which the infraction evaluated in Chapter Two, literal A of the present resolution was configured, it has not been accredited that GPI SAB has intervened in the own-name modality, which originates the obligation to present in the financial information of the stock brokerage agent company the valuation of the financial instruments acquired through a global account, so it is concluded that it has not been possible to accredit that it has incurred in an infraction qualified as serious, as established in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.4, of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
390. As the preceding regulations have indicated, the client's account statement constitutes a means that will show the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments in the name of a client, as well as reflect detailed information to know if the order given by the latter was fulfilled in its entirety, that is, if it was bought or sold on the indicated date, at what price, quantity, conditions, among others; and, in the case of operations abroad, the last paragraph of article 82 of the RAI provides that the name of the depository or custody institution of the financial instruments must be indicated;
391. It should also be added that article 83 of the RAI provides the periodicity in which such account statements must be communicated to clients and that in no case can the agent company exempt itself from the obligation to provide information to its clients regarding their operations, securities or financial instruments;
392. It should be remembered that according to what was stated by both Ms. ALVAREZ and GPI SAB and with the documentation in the file, both parties agree in stating that the former deposited in the latter's OPERATING ACCOUNT US$ 950,000.00, a bank transfer that the agent company itself has accredited documentary evidence in the file;
393. According to the information provided by GPI SAB, said agent company on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ would have intermediated operations in the foreign market to invest the funds paid in January 2015 by this principal, specifying that it would have carried out operations of put option contracts on ETFs, whose expirations were extended through the modality of "rollover" operations, and also states that the principal also has a balance of funds in her favor;
394. Therefore, from January 2015 to date, GPI should have sent Mrs. ALVAREZ the respective Account Statements in which they are informed regarding the operations eventually carried out in the foreign market, the balance of securities, financial instruments and available funds as well as all information, in accordance with the cited regulations, that allows them to make adequate investment decisions;
395. Upon verification of the documentation in the file, it is observed that GPI SAB has not proven that it has sent via email to Mrs. ALVAREZ the respective account statements from January 2015 to date, according to the modality of access to the account statement agreed in the Client Registration Form of Mrs. ALVAREZ signed on 29 September 2014, that show the information indicated by the regulations regarding operations carried out in the foreign market;
396. It should also be noted that the lack of account statements in the name of Mrs. ALVAREZ was brought to the attention of GPI SAB through Official Letter No. 3372-2016-SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016 and Official Letter No. 5050-2016-SMV/10.3 of 06 September 2016, requiring in them the presentation and proof of receipt of such account statements, however, GPI SAB has not proven that it sent them from January 2015 to date, in which the information regarding the eventual operations in the foreign market is shown, it being proven that Mrs. ALVAREZ, according to her complaint, only has account statements that show the operations carried out in the local market with common shares issued by PPX;
397. GPI SAB states that similarly to the previous charge, since it is related, the local systems used by GPI SAB are not the most adequate for the preparation of account statements required by the regulations. It adds that the information given to Mrs. ALVAREZ may have suffered from a lack of greater detail and explanation;
398. According to what has been indicated, GPI SAB acknowledges that from January 2015 to date, it has not sent Mrs. ALVAREZ the respective Account Statements in which they are informed regarding the operations carried out in the foreign market, the balance of securities, financial instruments and available funds as well as all information, in accordance with the cited regulations, that allows them to make adequate investment decisions;
399. In that sense, it is concluded that GPI SAB incurred an infraction classified as serious, typified by Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
400. According to what was indicated by GPI SAB through its communications sent to this Superintendency on 26 July and 15 September 2016, with the funds delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ in January 2015, which were transferred to the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC, GPI SAB would have intermediated operations on behalf of this principal in the foreign market through the sale of put options based on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE);
401. GPI SAB has not specified nor proven to date the detail of the operations carried out since January 2015 with the US$ 950 000,00 delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ. However, according to what was indicated above, with such funds GPI SAB intermediated operations in the foreign market on behalf of this principal, having specified that it would have carried out, at least on one occasion until 10 November 2015, operations of sale of put option contracts on the ETFs GDXJ and GDX and, at least on one occasion, extensions of the expirations of these put option contracts (rollovers);
402. Therefore, for the execution of these operations that GPI SAB specifies and others that it would have intermediated on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ from January 2015 to date, said agent company should have obtained orders given by Mrs. ALVAREZ, the same ones that should have been instructed by email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation, which was the means agreed in the Client Registration Form of Mrs. ALVAREZ signed on 29 September 2014;
403. It should be noted that through Official Letter No. 3372-2016-SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016 and Official Letter No. 5050-2016-SMV/10.3 of 06 September 2016, GPI SAB was requested to present a copy of the records of the orders, in this case copies of the emails digitally signed or of the subsequent written confirmations, that support the operations carried out in the name of Mrs. ALVAREZ from 2015 to date, however, GPI SAB has not sent such documents to date, limiting itself to stating that the conversations were private and by mutual agreement when they were agreed between Mrs. ALVAREZ and GPI SAB; which is not in accordance with the modality of orders established by the principal in her client registration form;
404. Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of article 175 of the LMV and article 37.5 of the RAI, GPI SAB had the obligation to have the orders that authorize it to intermediate operations on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ. Such orders would not have been obtained by GPI SAB, thus breaching the regulations of the securities market;
405. Regarding the taking of orders, GPI SAB points out that it acknowledges that there was a confusion, since the conversation between Mrs. ALVAREZ and Mrs. Teresa Orlandini, head of customer services at GPI SAB, should have been duly documented in an order execution agreement based on the requested strategy;
406. GPI SAB points out that verbally the instructions were understood as "investing for a three-year horizon in instruments that generate income around 1% monthly", with which it was decided to invest in that manner, basically in the sale of puts on the NYSE market, so that sufficient premiums would be obtained to generate the desired profitability;
407. GPI SAB adds that it did not document said instruction and does not have it recorded either, since it was a conversation with the Customer Service area, which always had a correct relationship with Mrs. ALVAREZ. Then, in the period between June 2015 and February 2016, there was an unexpected and strong fall in the prices of mining companies and in the specific case, that of the ETFs GDX and GDXJ, which fell between 40 and 50% in the period, which forced the "rollover" of the positions to avoid an execution adverse to the client's interests;
408. It adds that although initially GPI SAB omitted to request from Mrs. ALVAREZ the signing of any document regarding the execution of her investments, that was remedied with the signing of the mutual loan contract, entered into with Mrs. ALVAREZ on 10 November 2015, in which by mutual agreement the destination of Mrs. ALVAREZ's investments was expressed, evidencing her investment instruction;
409. Finally, it points out that there was no bad faith at all, but there was carelessness in the collection of orders that today has brought the judicialization of this case due to the existing dispute between the parties;
410. Regarding the replies presented, it should be noted that GPI SAB acknowledges that at the time of the delivery of funds by Mrs. ALVAREZ in January 2015 it did not document the client's initial instruction nor does it have the corresponding recording that supports the orders of said principal regarding investing in the sale of options;
411. Likewise, regarding the "rollover" operations carried out subsequently to avoid the adverse execution of the execution of the positions, GPI SAB also acknowledges that it omitted to request from Mrs. ALVAREZ the signing of any document regarding the execution of her investments;
412. It should be noted that the process of collecting orders from a principal by a stock brokerage firm must be prior to the execution of the operations, which must be accredited with the presentation of the corresponding order record according to the modality of instruction of the order agreed with Mrs. ALVAREZ in the Client Registration Form, in this case by email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation;
413. In this sense, having GPI SAB received from Mrs. ALVAREZ the amount of US$ 950 000,00 for the realization of operations, , GPI SAB should have had the respective orders for the investment of said funds whether for the realization of operations that said agent company alleges, any other that it would have intermediated on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ from January 2015 to September 2016, or even in the case that it has not carried out any operation with the funds, for which said agent company should have collected orders given by Mrs. ALVAREZ, the same ones that should have been instructed by email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation, which was the means agreed in the Client Registration Form of Mrs. ALVAREZ signed on 29 September 2014;
414. In the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, this Superintendency required GPI SAB to accredit the corresponding orders , however, said agent company has not accredited in its replies with any evidentiary means the referred orders;
415. Regarding the judicialization of the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ's debt against GPI SAB, it is convenient to specify that in the present administrative sanctioning procedure said stock brokerage firm has been observed for the lack of observance of the regulations governing the securities market, an administrative matter whose competence is not related to the legal assets discussed at the judicial level, which in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ against GPI SAB would be the breach of obligations derived from the signing of a promissory note in favor of said principal;
416. With regard to the fact that with the signing of the mutual contract by Mrs. ALVAREZ the obligation to collect orders subject to charges would have been remedied, it should be indicated that in principle such contract does not constitute, in any way, the formality required by the RAI for the taking of orders by the agent company; also taking into account that the orders to carry out the operations on behalf of the referred client should have been taken as of January 2015 and not until November of that year, the occasion of the signing of said contract;
417. Therefore, according to the provisions of article 175 of the LMV and article 37.5 of the RAI, GPI SAB had the obligation to have the orders authorizing it to intervene in the intermediation of operations on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ. Said orders were not collected by GPI SAB incurring in this way in an infraction qualified as minor, typified by Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
418. In view of the points set forth in the preceding paragraphs of this official letter, in the preliminary investigation initiated in response to the complaint filed by Mrs. ALVAREZ, through Official Letter No. 3372-2016-SMV/10.3 of 07 June 2016 and Official Letter No. 5050-2016-SMV/10.3 of 06 September 2016, information was requested from GPI SAB regarding the transactions intermediated abroad from January 2015 to date on behalf of this client, requesting, among others, a copy of the policies corresponding to said transactions as well as the acknowledgments of receipt by Mrs. ALVAREZ, information that has not been sent to date;
419. Indeed, GPI SAB has stated that it carried out the following transactions on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ, for which it must have the corresponding policies; however, these have not been evidenced to date:
a) Sale of 110 put option contracts of GDXJ with expiration in February 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 30. Subsequently, the expiration of these options was renewed through "rollover" transactions.
b) Sale of 125 put option contracts of GDX with expiration in March 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 25;
420. Subsequently, the expiration of these options would have been renewed through "rollover" transactions. In that sense, and taking into account the aforementioned regulations, GPI SAB would have failed to deliver policies to Mrs. ALVAREZ for the transactions carried out abroad on behalf of this client from January 2015 to date, such as the aforementioned ones, and therefore would have incurred an infraction;
421. GPI SAB states that it has not incurred the imputed infraction given that the execution of all the buy and sell orders of shares that were made in the Pershing LLC account of Mrs. ALVAREZ was carried out directly in her account, with the tickets loaded by Pershing and by the exchanges or markets where they were executed clearly appearing, so that, in that case, the issuance of policies is not applicable;
422. GPI SAB adds that in the case of options transactions or other instruments abroad, the local systems, whether of the SAB or of CAVALI, do not have the applications that allow an issuance of policies similar to the one that the SAB always carries out when it comes to transactions carried out on the Lima Stock Exchange or through the omnibus accounts of foreign intermediaries. It is a deficiency in the policy reporting system and, specifically, of the type of instrument used in this particular portfolio;
423. In the present case, this Superintendency requested from GPI SAB the evidence of the corresponding policies for the transactions that it supposedly would have carried out on behalf of Mrs. ALVAREZ as well as the acknowledgment of receipt by the latter; however, said brokerage firm has not evidenced the respective policies to date;
424. In particular, the presentation of the policies supporting the acquisition of options was requested as detailed in the facts supporting the present charge; however, GPI SAB has not evidenced or supported with the respective evidentiary means the existence of such transactions that would give rise to the issuance of policies;
425. Likewise, as has been stated, although GPI SAB has repeatedly affirmed having carried out such transactions, this Superintendency has requested, both in the preliminary inquiry stage and in the present administrative sanctioning procedure, the documents supporting its statement; however, to date, this has not been evidenced in the record;
426. Accordingly, charges were imputed to GPI considering that said brokerage firm affirmed that it had carried out various transactions in the foreign market with the money delivered by Mrs. ALVAREZ and therefore should have the policies corresponding to said transactions. However, since it did not present through its defenses any evidentiary means of the transfer of funds from the OPERATING ACCOUNT to an account with a foreign intermediary, nor of the supposed transactions carried out, with which the configuration of the infraction evaluated in Chapter Two, literal A of the present resolution was evidenced; it has not been evidenced that GPI SAB could have the respective policies, so it is concluded that it has not been possible to evidence that it incurred an infraction classified as minor, as established in Annex X, numeral 3, item 3.6, of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
427. In accordance with article 6 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of article 23064 of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the contribution of the offender to its clarification and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A65 of the LPAG;
428. Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Background of the offender; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, which includes the repercussion on the market; c) The economic harm caused; d) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegally obtained benefit; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender; h) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender to its clarification; i) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to the notification of the corresponding charges; and j) The error induced by the administration by a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
429. In that regard, taking into account that the date on which the Letter of Charges regarding this case was notified to GPI SAB was 30 May 2016, it should be noted that GPI SAB has the following infraction records:
a) By means of Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10 of 20 June 2014, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a fine of four (04) UIT for having incurred two (02) infractions of a very serious nature and three (03) infractions of a serious nature.
[64] "Article 230.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power. (...) 3. Reasonableness.- The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed rules or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria, which are indicated in order of priority for their gradation: a) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right; b) The economic harm caused; c) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; e) The illegally obtained benefit, and; f) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct. (...)"
[65] "Article 236 - A.- Mitigating factors of liability for infractions The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for the commission of the administrative infraction: 1.- Voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 235. 2.- Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision."
b) By means of Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 023-2014-SMV/10 of 07 November 2014, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a fine of 3.2 UIT for having incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature.
c) By means of Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 034-2015-SMV/10 of 22 December 2015, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature;
430. It should be noted that the sanctions imposed in the aforementioned resolutions became final insofar as GPI SAB did not challenge such decisions. Likewise, it should be noted that by means of Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10, it was resolved to sanction GPI SAB, among others, for having incurred a serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS for not having control records of global accounts; this being the same type of infraction as one of the charges imputed in the present sanctioning procedure;
431. On the other hand, it should be taken into account that article 17 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS has been amended through SMV Resolution No. 006-2012/SMV.10.1, in force as of 17 April 2012, which provides that sanctions imposed by the SMV and that have become final within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction are considered records;
432. Regarding the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, the infractions related to providing false information to its clients and allowing persons who have a legal impediment to carry out activities related to those of the SAB, which were committed in September 2013, it should be noted that GPI SAB has no infraction records;
433. Likewise, in the framework of the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, the infraction related to the destination of funds for different purposes was committed as of January 2015, so it should be noted that GPI SAB has the infraction records according to Deputy Superintendent Resolutions SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10 and No. 023-2014-SMV/10 cited above;
434. Similarly, still referring to the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, regarding the infractions related to not preparing its financial information in accordance with the regulations and not delivering the account statements, which were committed from February to December 2015, GPI SAB has the two aforementioned records;
435. It should be noted that regarding the two infractions mentioned in the preceding recital that were committed from January to July 2016, GPI SAB has three records: the two aforementioned resolutions and Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 034-2015-SMV/10 of 22 December 2015, by means of which GPI SAB was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature. It should be noted that this sanction became final insofar as it was not subject to any challenge;
436. On the other hand, in relation to the infractions incurred by GPI SAB, subject of charges with Letter No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it should be noted that it has been verified that GPI SAB has sanction records, insofar as it registers the following final sanctions within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infractions subject of charges, insofar as they were not subject to any challenge:
a) By means of Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 016-2014- SMV/10 of 20 June 2014, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a fine of four (04) UIT for having incurred two (02) infractions of a very serious nature and three (03) infractions of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numerals 1, subsections 1.18 and 1.19 and numeral 2 subsections 2.16 and 2.19 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS.
b) With Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 023-2014-SMV/10 of 07 November 2014, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a fine of 3.2 UIT for having incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS.
c) By means of Superintendencia Adjunta SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/10 of 22 December 2015, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a reprimand for having incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS;
437. It should be noted that, with respect to the infraction related to the untimely communication of the material event that occurred on 15 December 2015, GPI SAB has as prior sanction records Superintendencia Adjunta SMV Resolution No. 016-2014-SMV/10 and Superintendencia Adjunta SMV Resolution No. 023-2014-SMV/10, detailed above;
438. Regarding the seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, in the case of the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, as well as in the case of the infractions that are the subject of charges with Official Letter No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Official Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI SAB's conduct in the commission of the infractions analyzed in the administrative sanctioning proceedings derived from said complaints has indeed caused harm to the public interest. It should be specified that in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, GPI SAB states that it carried out a series of transactions abroad; however, it has not proven by any means (documentary or other evidence) that it actually carried them out, failing to comply for that purpose with the regulations governing the securities market. In this way, GPI SAB's conduct affects the trust that investors have when they entrust their funds and securities to brokerage firms for the purpose of carrying out transactions in the securities market. The improper use of funds entrusted for custody and the failure to comply with the minimum prudential parameters required by the regulations affect investor trust and the integrity of the securities market;
439. Additionally, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, it must also be taken into account that harm has been caused to her particular interests, mainly because it has affected the trust that Mrs. ALVAREZ had in GPI SAB and therefore has affected her trust in the securities market, since she entrusted resources for the ordered investments and to date has no evidence whatsoever of the destination of her resources, which have been used for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
440. Likewise, regarding the fact that certain funds of clients were used for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted without the respective authorization, which is the subject of charges with Official Letter No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Official Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it must be taken into account that, with respect to the clients who entrusted funds to GPI SAB, harm has been caused to their particular interests, mainly because it has affected the trust they had in GPI SAB and therefore has affected their trust in the securities market, insofar as the resources that were delivered to it for the respective investments have been used for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
441. In this regard, it should be indicated that in the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, as well as in the case of the infractions that are the subject of charges with Official Letter No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Official Letter No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, a protected legal interest has been affected, consisting of investor protection, since GPI SAB has openly breached various obligations of intermediaries operating in the securities market in accordance with the provisions of the LMV and the RAI, which are intended to prevent harm to investors' interests and to make the transactions carried out transparent; and, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, GPI SAB has not complied with returning the resources that said client entrusted to it, as well as the same situation with respect to the resources entrusted by other clients, in respect of which a deficit in the intermediation accounts has been detected as a result of the inspections carried out;
442. Indeed, by having committed the infractions related to using funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, failing to comply with the minimum levels of the liquidity and solvency indicator and net equity of the brokerage firm, failing to observe the regulations regarding the granting of credits, and providing information to its client that is clear and precise; as well as the timely communication of material events; it inevitably calls into question the security and reliability that investors must have with respect to the brokerage firms that carry out transactions in the securities market, as well as exposing investors and the market to unnecessary risk situations. Likewise, it should be added, with regard to the untimely presentation of material events, that this limits the supervisory and control capacity of the intermediation agents, and in this proceeding it involves breaches of up to three (03) calendar days of delay;
443. Additionally, in relation to the breaches of the minimum levels of the liquidity and solvency and equity indicator of the brokerage firm, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it must be noted that every stock brokerage firm, in the exercise of its intermediation operations in the securities market, must maintain minimum conditions of equity, liquidity and solvency in accordance with the provisions of the regulations, in order to ensure that they have sufficient liquid resources with which they can assume eventual losses in the face of possible adversities that arise in the market, taking into account the risks to which they are exposed considering the activities they carry out and in this way they can comply with their obligations in the development of their activities minimizing the effects of such risks in relation to the operations they carry out with their clients; without compromising the resources of these, therefore, as GPI SAB has breached the minimum levels of the liquidity and solvency and equity indicator established in the RAI, in addition to having affected the legal interest consisting of investor protection, the integrity of the market has also been affected;
444. It should also be added that in relation to the infraction incurred by GPI SAB regarding the granting of credit without it complying with the purpose established in the regulations subject of charges through Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, as well as with respect to the exercise of director and representative, that such breaches put the integrity of the market at risk by not having observed the provisions established in the LMV and in the RAI, creating distrust among investors;
445. As for the economic damage caused, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, it should be noted that not having accredited the destination of the funds delivered to GPI SAB, an economic damage has been caused to Mrs. Alvarez for the amounts delivered by her to GPI SAB for the realization of operations abroad with a conservative profile;
446. In this regard, since GPI SAB has not accredited the movement of the investments made and the current status of the funds and investment portfolio of Mrs. ALVAREZ, considering the outstanding balance to be returned to Mrs. ALVAREZ amounting to the sum of US$ 645 000,00, and since GPI SAB has not presented any document or other indication that accredits what was affirmed in this case, it is not feasible to determine the destination given by GPI SAB to the funds of Mrs. ALVAREZ;
447. Since GPI SAB has not accredited by any means the effective realization of investments with the funds of Mrs. ALVAREZ, it must be noted that the economic damage for the client amounts to the balance of her capital not delivered by GPI SAB, which is US$ 645 000,00, which was destined for purposes other than those entrusted, plus the results that would have been obtained with these funds if they had been invested in accordance with the instructions of Mrs. ALVAREZ since the client delivered the funds to GPI SAB or the yields that would have been obtained in the best investment alternative in the market according to the investment profile of Mrs. ALVAREZ, if these funds had been returned at the opportunity required by the investor;
448. It should be noted that it is only accredited that GPI SAB delivered to Mrs. ALVAREZ between 12 May 2015 and 29 January 2016 an amount of US$ 73 970,00 for the concept of yields from the investments made since January 2015. It should be noted that these amounts were qualified as yields by the same stock brokerage firm;
449. Notwithstanding the foregoing, it is appropriate to note that the failure to deliver information to Mrs. ALVAREZ, in particular, in the sending of account statements, generated uncertainty regarding the updated amount of her resources in custody, which, probably, would have allowed them to make adequate investment decisions;
450. As for the funds of clients that were destined for purposes other than those authorized without the respective authorization, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it must be noted that as of 31 July 2016 and in accordance with the information presented by GPI SAB at the time, a deficit of funds in the intermediation accounts was determined at least for an amount of S/ 2 565 778, which includes the balance payable to Mrs. ALVAREZ for an amount of S/ 1 939 218,00 (One million nine hundred thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen and 00/100 Soles). In that sense, in relation to the amount of S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles)66, the destination of those funds or their use for purposes authorized by the clients holding those resources has not been accredited;
451. In this regard, since GPI SAB has not accredited the authorizations of the clients for the use of their funds that were in the operating account managed by the stock brokerage firm, it was determined that the use of the same was made without authorization of said clients, therefore it must be noted that the economic damage in relation to them amounts to the balance of the deficit of the intermediation account of the agent company determined as of 31 July 2016 and in accordance with the information presented by GPI SAB at the time, is at least amounting to S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles), since it was destined for purposes other than those for which it was entrusted;
452. Regarding the other infractions, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it must be noted that it has not been possible to evidence that the infractions incurred by GPI SAB have caused a concrete economic damage to the market participants;
453. Regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it must be noted that in the case of the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, as well as in relation to the infractions, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it is not observed that this assumption has been configured;
454. Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, according to the information in the file, GPI SAB received the funds for a total of US$ 950 000,00 delivered by the aforementioned client with the latter's instruction to carry out operations in the foreign market, under a conservative and liquid profile based on ETFs. However, GPI SAB has not proven the effective realization of any investment with those funds;
455. Likewise, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, it was observed that GPI SAB allowed a person outside the company, in this case, Mr. ARIZMENDI, to carry out a series of acts on behalf of the SAB, typical of the representatives or directors of GPI SAB, including having information protected by the duty of confidentiality, especially considering that Mr. ARIZMENDI's actions were endorsed by the intermediary's own general manager;
456. Not only did GPI SAB allow a third party, Mr. ARIZMENDI, to carry out activities related to those of the brokerage agent, but it also allowed, through its general manager, Mr. ARIZMENDI to provide inaccurate information to a client, Mrs. ALVAREZ, regarding the lack of liquidity of the securities to be acquired (PPX shares) in whose respective purchase-sale operation, GPI SAB even participated as counterparty, aspects that were not made transparent to Mrs. ALVAREZ, among others;
457. Without prejudice to the particular circumstances due to the type of client and operations, in the case of the complaint by Mrs. ALVAREZ, it should be noted that GPI SAB, in its capacity as brokerage agent, knows the regulations of the securities market, and in that sense it is its duty to comply with its
[66] Result obtained after deducting the balance payable to Mrs. ALVAREZ.
provisions. However, it has been determined, according to the evaluation carried out in this sanctioning procedure, the breach of various provisions of the LMV and the RAI;
458. Likewise, it should be added, in relation to the infraction referred to the destination of funds, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016- SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, that while said funds were in the intermediation accounts of GPI SAB, it received the referred funds for the realization of operations in the securities market, in accordance with the provisions of the LMV. However, GPI SAB allocated such funds to a different purpose and without having the respective authorizations;
459. Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, it should be noted that GPI SAB has not proven the investments made with the US$ 645 000,00 that Mrs. ALVAREZ had as of July 10, 2015, after the last withdrawal of funds, and the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments of Mrs. ALVAREZ at the date of her defenses (October 4, 2016). It is only proven in the file that GPI SAB has delivered to Mrs. ALVAREZ US$ 73 970,00 for concept of yields of the supposed investments made on behalf of this investor, therefore it is concluded that the illegally obtained benefit as a result of the infraction of destination of resources to purposes other than those ordered, is at least greater than US$ 645 000,00 which is part of the US$ 950 000,00 that GPI SAB received on January 19, 2015, taking into account the yields that would have been obtained with these funds if they had been invested according to the instructions of Mrs. ALVAREZ since the client delivered the funds to GPI SAB or the yields that would have been obtained in the best investment alternative in the market according to the investment profile of Mrs. ALVAREZ, if these funds had been returned at the opportunity required by the investor;
460. Likewise, it should be noted that while GPI SAB has not proven the authorizations of the clients for the use of their funds for the purposes indicated by the stock brokerage company, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, and also, while it has not proven that the deficit of the intermediation account as of July 31, 2016 has been corrected and according to the information presented by GPI SAB at the time, it is concluded that the illegally obtained benefit as a result of the infraction of destination of resources to purposes other than those entrusted, amounts to at least S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles);
461. Regarding the other infractions, subject of charges with Oficio N° 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Oficio N° 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it has not been proven in this procedure that GPI SAB has obtained any specific economic benefit by incurring the imputed infractions;
462. In relation to the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ it must be specified that GPI SAB, as it has indicated, has received the funds delivered by Mrs. Alvarez and has not proven the effective realization of investments with said funds, even though it is in the best position to carry out that proof. Additionally, it did not deliver account statements; therefore, it is considered that it is not possible to admit that an intermediary such as GPI SAB with several years operating in the market can ignore compliance with essential rules of intermediation in the securities market and neglect the fiduciary responsibility it should maintain with respect to each of its clients;
463. Additionally, it should be highlighted that in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, as well as in the evaluated case, subject of charges with Office No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Office No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI SAB has used money from Mrs. ALVAREZ and other clients for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, so according to the analysis carried out, her conduct denotes intentionality; likewise, it has not been proven that Mrs. ALVAREZ instructed that her funds be invested in taking positions in Put options, so various acts have been developed that compromise the actions of GPI SAB who through its defenses has not been able to prove in any way the destination given to the funds that were delivered to it by Mrs. ALVAREZ;
464. Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infractions and the contribution of the offender to their clarification, it should be indicated that, in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, it should be indicated that GPI SAB has not acknowledged the commission of the infractions subject of this sanctioning procedure - except those referred to delivering account statements in the manner required by the regulations and obtaining the corresponding orders-; additionally it has not contributed to the clarification of the infractions, since it has only limited itself to presenting its defenses partially, indicating, as the main argument, the fact that Mrs. ALVAREZ, through the MUTUAL CONTRACT, would have acknowledged the supposed investments made by GPI on her behalf; not having demonstrated the destination that it indicates it gave to the money delivered by the client;
465. Regarding the infractions subject of charges with Office No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Office No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it should be noted that in relation to the charges imputed with Office No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 GPI SAB has not acknowledged the commission of any of the infractions subject of this sanctioning procedure, except the one referred to the untimely presentation of the relevant fact; likewise it should be noted that in relation to the charges imputed with Office No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI SAB has not presented the respective defenses, in that sense it has not contributed to their clarification;
466. Likewise, regarding the voluntary rectification by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges, it should be indicated that in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, GPI SAB has not proven the voluntary rectification of the acts or omissions constituting the infractions evaluated in this administrative sanctioning procedure prior to the notification of the imputation of charges nor to the date of this resolution; except in the case corresponding to the infraction referred to the exercise of the functions of director and representative of the brokerage agent, as indicated in the respective analysis;
467. Likewise, it should be indicated that in the case of Mrs. ALVAREZ, as well as in the case of the infractions subject of charges with Office No. 5478-2016-SMV/10.3 and Office No. 6589-2016-SMV/10.3, it has not been evidenced that the infraction conducts by GPI SAB have been generated by an error induced by the administration by a confusing and illegal administrative act or provision;
468. From the foregoing, it is concluded that GPI SAB has incurred in the commission of eleven (11) infractions: six (06) qualified as very serious, one (01) serious and four (04) minor of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS;
469. Considering the analysis carried out regarding the sanction criteria, and taking into account the provisions of article 15 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in the analyzed case it corresponds to impose on GPI SAB the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
Article 1°.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, having contravened the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, and article 48, first paragraph of the Brokerage Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the date of the events, for allocating the funds received as a consequence of its brokerage activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted..
Article 2°.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.11 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, having contravened the provisions of article 189 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments; and by articles 118 and 122 of the Brokerage Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments; and, by IAS 39, paragraphs 58 and 59, in force at the date of the events, for having a net equity lower than the minimum capital established.
Article 3.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of article 172 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments; and by article 124 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the date of the events, for having a liquidity and solvency indicator below the minimum established by the regulations.
Article 4.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of article 2, numeral 2.22, article 8, numeral 5 and articles 23 and 25 numeral 25.1 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the date of the events, for directly maintaining persons who have a legal impediment or who do not comply with the requirements established by the regulations and for allowing them to carry out activities of the intermediation agent.
Article 5.-Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones-Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of article 195, literal h) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, for allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inaccurate information to the detriment of its clients.
Article 6.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a very serious infraction classified in Annex I, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of article 195, literal m) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, and article 51 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the date of the events, for carrying out credit operations that do not comply with the provisions of the regulations.
Article 7.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones-Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of articles 82 and 83 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not delivering account statements to its clients.
Article 8.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones-Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of article 175 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments; and articles 30, numeral 30.2 and 37, numeral 37.5 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not collecting orders from its clients.
Article 9.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred three (03) minor infractions classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, by having contravened the provisions of article 98 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the date of the events, for not timely communicating its relevant facts.
Article 10.- Archive the charges imputed to Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa regarding the infractions classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.18; numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19; numeral 3, subparagraphs 3.5 and 3.6; and Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms.
Article 11.- Sanction Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa with the revocation of its operating authorization for the commission of the very serious infractions referred to in articles 1 to 6 of this resolution.
The revocation of the operating authorization does not exempt Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa from compliance with the obligations contracted in the securities market prior to the decreed revocation, nor its directors or managers from the administrative responsibility they may have incurred during the operation of the referred stock brokerage firm.
Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa must deliver to the Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores on the day following the notification of this resolution and under its responsibility, by means of an inventory, the deposited securities, as well as the money and/or checks pending delivery owned by its clients. The Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores shall designate a stock brokerage firm to be responsible for the custody of the same, as well as of the securities represented by book entries that have not been transferred.
Within the same period as the preceding paragraph, Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa must deliver to the Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores, under its responsibility and by means of an inventory, all its transaction books and records related to securities market intermediation.
Article 12°.- The guarantee referred to in article 136 of the Securities Market Law must be maintained by Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa until six (6) months after the revocation of its operating authorization or until the judicial actions that, within said period or before it, may have been filed against Grupo Privado de Inversiones – Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa by the beneficiaries of said guarantee are resolved by a final judgment with the force of res judicata.
Article 13°.- Order that within a period of three (03) business days Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa comply with returning the US$ 645 000,00 that Mrs. María Teófila Alvarez Mayorca delivered to said stock brokerage firm on 19 January 2015, in accordance with what is set forth in this resolution.
Article 14°.- Order that within a period of three (03) business days Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa comply with returning the S/ 626 560,00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles) for the concept of deficit of funds owned by clients in the intermediation accounts. This amount must be delivered to the SMV so that in turn it may be delivered to the stock brokerage firm that is designated to be responsible for the custody of funds and securities in accordance with the provisions of the third paragraph of article 11 of this resolution.
Within the framework of the provisions of article 26, second paragraph of the Guarantee Fund Regulations, the return ordered by this article must be made under warning that the guarantee fund will be executed to comply with the entirety of this obligation. In this last case, the amount to be replenished by the guarantee fund shall be delivered to the designated stock brokerage firm to be responsible for the custody of funds and securities in accordance with the provisions of the third paragraph of article 11 of this resolution
Article 15°.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative remedy, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Superintendencia Adjunta de Supervisión Prudencial by filing a motion for reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 16°.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by means of a motion for reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7° of the Policy on Publicity of Regulatory Projects, General Rules and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by Resolución CONASEV Nº 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 10° A of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by Resolución CONASEV N° 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending rules.
Article 17°.- Transcribe this resolution to Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa, to the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Signed by: GUTIERREZ OCHOA Omar Darío
Reason:
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“According to the provisions of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amending norms...”
“...contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments...”
“...Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.”
“...approved by Resolución CONASEV Nº 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 10° A of the Sanctions Regulations...”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization...”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“appeal presented by GPI against Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization...”
“Resolution of Deputy Superintendency No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10. It should be noted that said resolution was subject to an appeal”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10”
“Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SVM/10, which resolved to cancel the authorization of operation”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10. It should be noted that said resolution was subject to an appeal by GPI”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Resolution of the Deputy Superintendence No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the authorization of operation...”
“Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“appeal filed by GPI against Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“against the Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization...”
“Deputy Superintendent Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the authorization of operation”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the authorization of operation of said former stock brokerage firm”
“deficit of funds that has been the subject of the complaints presented... sanctioned by revocation of GPI's operating authorization ordered by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10”
“one of the infractions that gave rise to the sanction of revocation of GPI's operating authorization ordered by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10 of 23 November 2016”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm”
“Operating authorization revoked by SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10.”
“Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to revoke the operating authorization”
“Deputy Superintendence Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization”
“Authorization to operate was revoked by Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added