Resolution of the Deputy Superintendence of Prudential Supervision SMV
No. 043-2017-SMV/10
Summary: Mrs. Antonia Luzmila Mariana Bellido Tagle Fernández Concha is sanctioned with a five (05) year disqualification, for having incurred one (01) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, for diverting the funds received as a consequence of her intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, in her capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of Grupo Privado de Inversiones-Valores S.A., former stock brokerage company, from February 21, 2013 onward.
| | |
|---|
| Administered party | : | Mrs. Antonia Luzmila Mariana Bellido Tagle Fernández Concha. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2017001169 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2017001169, and Report No. 235-2017-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendence of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
I. Facts
- Taking into account the complaints filed by the clients of Grupo Privado de Inversiones Valores S.A., former Stock Brokerage Company[1] (hereinafter, GPI), against said company for having diverted the funds delivered to GPI to purposes other than those entrusted, this Superintendence of the Securities Market has evaluated the denounced facts and found indications of infraction on the part of Mrs. Antonia Luzmila Mariana Bellido Tagle Fernandez Concha (hereinafter, Mrs. Bellido Tagle);
- As a result of the foregoing and under the provisions of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, LPAG), through Official Letter No. 220-2017-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges) notified on January 13, 2017, the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (IGCP) initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding the facts described by GPI's clients who have filed various complaints against said company for having diverted the funds delivered to GPI to purposes other than those entrusted;
- Through the Letter of Charges, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, imputing charges for having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV) and the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the time of the events (hereinafter, Regulation), in aspects related to the destination of client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- It should be noted that despite being validly notified, in addition to having herself become aware of the Letter of Charges according to the MVNet log, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has not submitted the respective defense;
- The charges formulated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and their evaluation have been the subject of evaluation in Report No. 235-2017-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendence;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, item 2, of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 1743-2017-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 235-2017-SMV/10.3 was made available to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle for her review;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendence of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not Mrs. Bellido-Tagle incurred an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter Sanctions Regulation), by diverting client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on Mrs. Bellido-Tagle for the aforementioned;
III. Analysis
Diverting client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
- Article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, applicable at the time of the events, establishes that intermediation agents are prohibited from diverting the funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted:
“Article 195.- Prohibitions
Stock brokerage companies are subject to the following prohibitions, without prejudice to those contemplated in Article 177 and others emanating from this law:
- Diverting the funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
(…)”;
- Likewise, Article 48 of the Regulation establishes that the securities, financial instruments or funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than that unless the corresponding express authorization is available:
“Article 48.- Basic Rules
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available.
(…)”;
- It should be noted that the first paragraph of Article 48 of the Regulation was amended by SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01 in force as of February 1, 2013, which establishes the following:
“Article 48.- Basic Rules
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose is related to any of the operations defined in Articles 194 and 207 of the Law.
(…)”[2];
- Likewise, it is appropriate to mention the applicable regulations of the General Corporations Law, which given Mrs. Bellido-Tagle's status as General Manager and Chairman of the Board of GPI from February 21, 2013 onward and Mr. Luis Felipe Arizmendi Echecopar (hereinafter Mr. Arizmendi) as General Manager and Chairman of the Board of GPI, according to the period corresponding to each case (without prejudice to his subsequent participation as de facto representative of Mr. Arizmendi), and Mr. Héctor Martín Uccelli Romero (hereinafter, Mr. Uccelli) in his capacity as director, Institutional Clients Manager and representative of GPI, are applicable to them, in particular Articles 152, 177 and 190 which state:
“Article 152.- Administrators
The administration of the company is in charge of the board of directors and one or more managers, except as provided in Article 247.
Article 177.- Responsibility
Directors are liable, unlimitedly and jointly, to the company, shareholders and third parties for damages caused by agreements or acts contrary to law, the bylaws or those carried out with fraud, abuse of powers or gross negligence
(…)
Article 190.- Responsibility
The manager is liable to the company, shareholders and third parties for damages caused by non-compliance with his obligations, fraud, abuse of powers and gross negligence.
(…)”
- On the charge formulated
- In relation to the complaints filed by GPI's clients against said former stock brokerage firm, of which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has been chair of the board and general manager since February 21, 2013 and of which she is also the majority shareholder; in addition to the responsibility of the latter regarding the deficit of GPI's client funds in the intermediation accounts; according to the facts detailed below, it is established that, additionally, with the consent of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi continued to exercise functions related to the positions of general manager and chair of the board of GPI after February 21, 2013 (when legally it no longer corresponded to him), in addition to continuing to act as a de facto representative;
- As is known to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Uccelli, the following persons, among others, have denounced GPI for the non-return of the funds entrusted to said former stock brokerage firm and, as stated by most of them, they placed their trust in GPI and consequently in Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as General Manager and Chair of the Board and also in her spouse Mr. Arizmendi:
- Mrs. María Teófila Álvarez Mayorca,
- Mrs. Rosa Mayo Frid de Schwartzman,
- Mrs. María del Rosario Silva Ruete de Gastañaga,
- Mr. Julio César Cáceres Rodríguez and his wife Mrs. Ana María Alvis Correa de Cáceres,
- Mrs. Silvia Mariela Eugenia Roca Perales,
- Mrs. Ana María Serapia Colmenares Adrianzen,
- Mr. Roberto Lorelli,
- Mr. Pedro Rodolfo Félix Urday Berenguel and his wife Mrs. Carmen Beatriz Natividad Zegarra de Urday,
- Mrs. Marcela Quijano Herrera,
- Mrs. Cecilia María Camino Rodríguez Larraín de Holguín,
- Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, and
- It should be noted that, for the purposes of this evaluation, the complaint filed by Mr. Fernando Garrido Jefferson is not considered, since from the evaluation of the documents in the file it was evidenced after the Letter of Charges that there were other infractions different from that of using funds for purposes other than those entrusted;
- According to the following recitals, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as General Manager and Chair of the Board of GPI since February 21, 2013[3], and Mr. Arizmendi, in his capacity as General Manager and Chair of the Board of GPI until February 20, 2013[4], as well as, after that date, in his capacity as de facto representative of GPI; and Mr. Uccelli in his capacity as director, Institutional Clients Manager and representative of GPI, would have disposed of the funds delivered by the GPI clients mentioned in the preceding recitals, and would have used them for purposes other than those entrusted, not having proven to date directly or indirectly or through GPI, the execution of operations in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations and even less having followed the investment instructions given by said clients;
- Regarding GPI Asset Managment S.A.C. (hereinafter, GPIAM), according to the information obtained from the Registry of Legal Persons of SUNARP, it appears that Mr. Arizmendi (founding majority partner of GPIAM) was general manager and chair of the board of said company from March 15, 2013 until April 12, 2017, while Mrs. Bellido-Tagle held the general management of such company until March 14, 2013, while Mr. Uccelli was registered as founding shareholder and is a director of GPIAM until April 12, 2017;
- Likewise, it should be mentioned that GPI and GPIAM signed on February 27, 2014 the so-called "Quantitative Support and Financial Advisory Services Agreement"[5], which originated from a services agreement dated February 18, 2013 between the parties and which was made due to the express interest of the shareholders, staff and clients of GPI in having the permanent support of Mr. Arizmendi[6] in various areas of the stock brokerage firm's activities[7]. According to this agreement, GPIAM offered GPI, among others, advisory in the design, implementation and execution of the investment portfolios that GPI offered to its clients, whatever their modality;
- It should be noted that this financial advisory services agreement provided by GPIAM (through Mr. Arizmendi) to GPI, added to the fact that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and GPIAM are the two (02) main shareholders of GPI and jointly hold 99.9% of GPI's share capital since February 2, 2012, that Mr. Arizmendi is Chair and General Manager of GPIAM and that Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle are spouses, is what generates Mr. Arizmendi's active participation in the management of GPI's client funds, as a de facto representative with decision-making capacity, which was fully known and consented to by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, being GPI's principal executive and having the principal role in the administrative decisions of this stock brokerage firm as Chair of the Board and General Manager since February 21, 2013, in addition to being the spouse of Mr. Arizmendi;
- Likewise, it should be noted that Mr. Arizmendi had an active participation assuming the role of direct manager of the Clients' investments with the full knowledge and consent of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, his spouse, as is the case of Mrs. María Teófila Alvarez Mayorca, Mrs. María del Rosario Silva Ruete de Gastañaga, Mrs. Cecilia María Camino Rodríguez Larraín de Holguín, Mrs. Rosa Mayo Frid de Schwartzman, Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, Mr. Roberto Lorelli, among others, whom he even informed about the investment strategies that would have been carried out with the funds or the supposed operations carried out in their name; and notwithstanding that during the time they were served by Mr. Arizmendi, he had already ceased to be general manager and chair of the board of GPI;
- It is also important to mention that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle had an active participation in the management of funds of GPI's clients or in the supposed execution of operations in the name of the latter, since jointly with her spouse, Mr. Arizmendi (who was recognized as if he were chair of the board, general manager and owner of GPI, even though he had ceased to be registered as such, both by the clients themselves and by GPI staff) and with Mr. Uccelli, in practice they decided the management of the portfolios of the company's clients, allowing Mrs. Bellido-Tagle for Mr. Arizmendi to relate directly with them and send them communications, being a de facto representative within GPI. Likewise, Mr. Arizmendi exercised such control power over the general manager and chair of the board registered with SUNARP, that is, his own wife, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, who together with GPIAM (in which Mr. Arizmendi is general manager and chair of the board) are the two main shareholders of GPI and jointly hold 99.9% of GPI's share capital;
- On the defenses and their evaluation
- As of the date of this resolution, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has not complied with presenting her defenses to the charge subject to analysis in this section, notwithstanding that she was validly notified in accordance with the regulations, having been granted a period to comply with such requirement;
- Regarding the charge formulated and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle's participation in the imputed infraction, it should be noted that although as of February 20, 2013 said person assumed the positions of General Manager and Chair of the Board of GPI, thereby becoming the highest direction and administrative authority of the former SAB, this did not in any way represent GPI's separation from Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as highest executive authority of the company, so that, and with the full consent of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and without the latter objecting to Mr. Arizmendi's actions or ordering the appropriate administrative measures so that Mr. Arizmendi would not participate with her in the company, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle allowed Mr. Arizmendi to continue exercising and issuing directives to the company's staff, as demonstrated in the emails he sent to Mrs. Alvarez regarding the management of funds and investments of said client, among others;
- All of this, added to the fact that in most of the aforementioned complaints the complainants themselves have stated that Mr. Arizmendi, spouse of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, was the one who managed their investments together with his spouse, based on the former's trust in GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and her spouse, even when Mr. Arizmendi was formally no longer part of GPI, he continued meeting or sending them emails or signing documents regarding the management of funds by said former brokerage firm, a situation or action that was not objected to by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, on the contrary, she supported her spouse in all activity that involved assuming responsibilities or obligations in the name of GPI;
- Likewise, it is important to highlight that the activities, coordination, information handled, among others, derived from the commercial relationship with GPI's clients, evidence, under the assent and participation of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, that Mr. Arizmendi exercised the position of de facto representative, through which he not only dealt directly with GPI's complaining clients but also provided them with proprietary information that is only handled by representatives, and, in some cases, only by the senior management of the former brokerage firm, among whom is Mrs. Bellido-Tagle;
- It should be remembered that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as chair of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to September 2016, like Mr. Arizmendi, had an active participation in the facts denounced and described in this resolution, since Mrs. Bellido-Tagle as the highest authority of GPI, not only allowed Mr. Arizmendi to assume the role of direct manager of the management of funds or investments of GPI's clients, but also, jointly with him, informed her clients about the investment strategies that would have been carried out with the funds or the supposed operations carried out in their name. Mrs. Bellido-Tagle even consented to Mr. Arizmendi giving directives to officials of the former stock brokerage firm in order to attend to the information requests of such clients regarding their investments, notwithstanding that during the time they were served by Mr. Arizmendi, he had already ceased to be general manager and chair of the board of GPI since those positions were held by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle;
- Without prejudice to this, the Letter of Charges formulated describes the facts in which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager and chair of the board of GPI, has the obligation to adequately safeguard the funds of the company's clients; and, regarding Mr. Arizmendi's participation as de facto representative of GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has direct responsibility for allowing said person's participation in the acquisition of clients and in the management of investments and funds that they deposited in GPI, all in accordance with the context of actions that have been proven in the following complaints filed against GPI that prove a mechanism aimed at using funds for purposes other than those entrusted;
- Likewise, it should be specified that Mr. Uccelli (Director, Institutional Clients Manager and representative of GPI, an official under the direct supervision and responsibility of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, given her capacity as chair of the board and general manager of GPI), had an active participation assuming the role of direct manager of the management of the clients' investments with the money they deposited in GPI, as is the case of Mrs. Ana María Colmenares Adrianzen; additionally participating in a mechanism aimed at irregularly disposing of GPI's clients' money jointly with Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in the cases of the complaints of Messrs. Ana María Colmenares Adrianzen, Julio César Cáceres Rodriguez, Maria del Rosario Silva Ruete de Gastañaga, Marcela Quijano Herrera, Cecilia María Camino Rodríguez Larraín de Holguín, Roberto Lorelli, and Pedro Félix Urday Berenguel, among others; who in the case of several clients (Messrs. Ana María Colmenares Adrianzen, Cecilia María Camino Rodríguez Larraín de Holguín, María del Rosario Silva Ruete de Gastañaga, Julio César Cáceres Rodríguez, Roberto Lorelli, and Pedro Félix Urday Berenguel) has been Mr. Uccelli the person who signed, as representative of GPI, the corresponding client registration forms or has signed receipts, in his capacity as Director of GPI, for the delivery of funds in GPI's accounts transferred by the clients Messrs. Julio César Cáceres Rodríguez, María del Rosario Silva Ruete de Gastañaga and Marcela Quijano Herrera;
- In this sense, as can be seen and as long as it has not been disproven by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle or Mr. Arizmendi, or Mr. Uccelli, or the former brokerage firm itself, as of the date of this resolution it has not been proven, with the corresponding documentation, the supposed investments made (orders, policies, account statements, contracts, global account records, etc.) or, at least, authorizations from the respective clients, to use their funds for purposes other than those entrusted, considering the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV, Article 48 of the Regulation, in force at the date of the events, notwithstanding the requirements made; therefore GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle as general manager and chair of the board of GPI since February 21, 2013, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as general manager and chair of the board of GPI until February 20, 2013 as well as, after that date, in his capacity as de facto representative of GPI and Mr. Uccelli, would have used the funds of the intermediation accounts without having the authorization of their clients for at least a total amount of S/ 8,147,597.51[8], according to the cited complaints;
- Likewise, it is important to mention that Article 198 of the LMV establishes that the representative of a brokerage firm is one who, duly authorized, acts in its name in acts related to the exercise of its functions;
- On the other hand, it is appropriate to cite some additional evidentiary elements that prove that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Uccelli have participated jointly in a mechanism through which they sought to use the funds delivered by their clients for purposes other than those entrusted, for which they signed a series of documents, among other actions, that they delivered to their clients in which they stated the execution of various operations and gave explanations of the supposed destination of the funds that GPI would have made;
- Regarding Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, the following documents, among others, are recorded:
- All communications addressed to the SMV signed by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in response to requests for information and documentation regarding the complaints filed by Mrs. María Alvarez Mayorca, Mrs. Rosa Mayo de Schwartzman, Mrs. María Silva Ruete and Cecilia Camino Rodríguez Larrain de Holguín. It should be noted that in these letters Mrs. Bellido-Tagle stated, in the name of GPI, having carried out operations abroad in the name of such clients or, in some cases, having indicated that, despite the latter, she does not have the records or documentation supporting such operations;
- Letters signed by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle dated July 6 and 15, 2015 indicating "to whom it may concern" in which she states that Mrs. Alvarez has an investment account in GPI valued at US$ 775,000.00 and US$ 645,000.00 abroad, respectively;
- Mutual loan agreement dated November 10, 2015 signed by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle with Mrs. Alvarez for US$ 650,000.00, a legal figure in which the SAB lends to the client, however, in this contract the client lends to the SAB and said funds have not been returned to Mrs. Alvarez;
- Email dated March 7, 2016 in which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle responds to Mrs. Alvarez indicating that she has provided all the information she has and that she has not failed the commitments assumed by GPI;
- Email dated April 19, 2016 in which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle responds to Mrs. Alvarez that, on behalf of Mr. Arizmendi, she proposes forms of payment for her debts;
- Email dated September 15, 2016 in which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, responding to a payment request made by Mrs. Silvia Roca Perales, states "indeed the payment dates vary but it is common in this type of investments we will communicate with you shortly";
- Regarding Mr. Arizmendi, the following documents, among others, are recorded:
- Letter with the GPI logo dated June 9, 2016 signed by Mr. Arizmendi, addressed to Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, through which he states that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46, which according to him has been mainly destined to investments abroad.
- Letter dated November 4, 2016 signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI, addressed to Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, through which he states that the original value of the portfolio is US$ 441,787.46 and that it has yields pending regularization for a total of US$ 11,250.00.
- Letter dated March 11, 2016 from Mr. Arizmendi, unsigned, addressed to Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, through which he states that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46 and the Principal Balance (as of the date) is US$ 432,747.46. This letter was attached by Mr. Arizmendi via email addressed to the aforementioned client on March 15, 2016, in which it is observed that he indicates as an attachment the document named "Reporte Maggie Batievsky al 11 de marzo de 2016.docx".
- Letter dated April 4, 2016 from Mr. Arizmendi, unsigned, addressed to Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, through which he states that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46 and the principal balance (as of the date) is US$ 448,747.60. This letter was attached by Mr. Arizmendi via email addressed to the aforementioned client on that same date, in which it is observed that he indicates as an attachment the document named "Reporte Maggie Batievsky al 04 de abril de 2016.docx".
- Letter dated November 17, 2016 signed by Mr. Arizmendi addressed to Mr. Francisco Rivadeneira Cockburn in which he informs the aforementioned client of the funds delivered and the investments made in his name.
- Email from Mr. Arizmendi to Mrs. María Alvarez Mayorca dated September 30, 2013, 16:29 hours: "I send you the transaction statement. The shares are already in your CAVALI account (custody) a hug, Luis Felipe and Antonia."
- Email from Mr. Arizmendi to Mrs. María Alvarez Mayorca dated September 30, 2013, 16:31 hours, with a copy to the general manager of GPI (Mrs. Bellido-Tagle): "As I mentioned in the previous email, I send you your position in CAVALI a hug";
- Regarding Mr. Uccelli, the following documents, among others, are recorded:
- Client Registration Forms signed by Mr. Uccelli where it is indicated that the GPI representative in charge of the client is Mr. Uccelli. We refer to the client registration forms of Messrs. Julio César Cáceres Rodriguez; Ana María Colmenares Adrianzen; Cecilia María Camino Rodriguez Larraín de Holguín; Silvia Roca Perales; Roberto Lorelli; Pedro Urday Berenguel; and, María Silva Ruete de Gastañaga.
- Letter dated May 9, 2016 signed by Mr. Uccelli in which he details the investments that would have been made with the funds of Mrs. Ana María Colmenares Adrianzen and her husband Mr. Arturo Lecca Arrieta.
- Letter dated August 18, 2016 signed by Mr. Uccelli in which he details more information about the investments that would have been made with the funds of Mrs. Ana María Colmenares Adrianzen and her husband Mr. Arturo Lecca Arrieta.
- Receipts for the receipt of funds signed by Mr. Uccelli, in his capacity as director of GPI, dated June 19, 2015 in relation to the US$ 50,000.00 delivered by the clients Messrs. Julio César Cáceres Rodriguez and Ana María Alvis Correa.
- Receipts for the receipt of funds signed by Mr. Uccelli regarding the bank transfers to GPI's intermediation accounts made by Messrs. Marcela Quijano Herrera and María Silva Ruete;
- Letter dated August 26, 2015, in which Mr. Uccelli, on behalf of GPI, signs a letter of presentation before the American embassy in which he states that Mrs. Silvia Roca Perales has an investment account with custody at Pershing;
- What is stated in the preceding recitals also proves the concerted action on the part of GPI's main authorities, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager and chair of the board of GPI, as well as Mr. Arizmendi also in his capacity as general manager and chair of the board of GPI and additionally later in his capacity as de facto representative and Mr. Uccelli in his capacity as director, institutional clients manager and representative of GPI, having participated in the facts described above, since they in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, participated in concert in a mechanism aimed at irregularly disposing of GPI's clients' money through irregular acts that led to generating the deficit incurred in GPI's intermediation accounts and to using the funds of its clients, delivered to GPI, for purposes other than those entrusted, which allows concluding that they have used the funds of the brokerage firm's clients for operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thereby failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
On the deficit of the intermediation accounts
- On the other hand, regarding the supervisory actions adopted by the SMV, a capital deficit arising from the intermediation accounts was evidenced, different from the shortfall of funds that has been the subject of the complaints presented and detailed in this resolution;
- Indeed, as indicated in numeral 5 of this resolution, it has been evidenced that GPI, through its principal representatives, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as chair of the board and general manager since 21 February 2013; Mr. Arizmendi, in his capacity as chair of the board and general manager until 20 February 2013 and in his capacity as de facto representative from 21 February of that year onward, and Mr. Uccelli, in his capacity as director, institutional clients manager and representative; incurred, as of 31 July 2016, a deficit in the management of the intermediation accounts of the former SAB for a total of S/ 626,560.00, which to date neither said company nor its directors have disproven, since on the contrary GPI has maintained in its defenses[9] that such deficit situation would be remedied with the presentation of authorizations from its clients in which they authorize GPI to dispose of their funds, however this has not been accredited to date;
- Such deficit situation was one of the infractions that gave rise to the sanction of revocation of GPI's operating authorization ordered by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10 of 23 November 2016, which was subject to challenge by GPI and resolved by Superintendent Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02 of 25 January 2017, which confirmed the revocation sanction;
- It should be noted that as of 21 November 2016, an increase of S/ 1,100,978.03 (One million one hundred thousand nine hundred seventy-eight and 03/100 Soles) is shown with respect to the shortfall of funds reported as of 31 July 2016, which was S/ 626,560.00, which, as of 21 November 2016, makes a total of S/ 1,727,538.03; this because in the balances of the operating bank accounts the reconciliation items were not considered because they were not supported by GPI; in particular the bank charges not recorded in the books;
- However, by Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 029-2017-SMV/10 it was determined that this shortfall of funds increased by S/ 319,328.46 as of 1 February 2017 and that the total amount of this shortfall, amounting to S/ 945,888.46, was evidenced in the transfer record of the assets custodied by GPI to Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. and which was signed, among others, by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle;
- It should also be noted that the aforementioned deficit incurred has not been explained by said former brokerage firm, nor by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, nor have they complied with presenting the corresponding authorizations from their clients for the use of their funds, which demonstrates that the funds of the clients' intermediation accounts were used without the respective authorization;
- What is stated in the preceding recitals accredits a systematic mechanism of concerted action on the part of GPI's principal directors, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Uccelli, to dispose of GPI's clients' funds and manage them differently from those ordered by them, without requiring the corresponding authorization and informing them of the execution of operations that they supposedly carried out in their name, which has not been proven to date, which reaffirms the commission of the infraction referring to the prohibition of disposal of funds and securities for purposes other than those entrusted by its clients;
- This systematic mechanism of concerted action of Mr. Arizmendi, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and others is observed in the following cases;
- Of the complaints imputed to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle
- Of the complaint of Mrs. Alvarez
The Complaint
- In the complaint presented, Mrs. María Teófila Alvarez Mayorca, hereinafter Mrs. Alvarez, stated that during the month of January 2015 she made interbank transfers and cash deposits to the dollar intermediation account opened by GPI at Banco Financiero del Perú, hereinafter, operating account, for a total of US$ 950,000.00. The client indicates that of this amount, GPI returned US$ 305,000.00 in cash, leaving a balance of US$ 645,000.00. She also stated that the amount she delivered to GPI was never credited to the account in the name of Mrs. Alvarez at the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC, through which she was to invest in a liquid and conservative portfolio based on ETFs;
- Mrs. Alvarez also states that GPI has not given her any proof of the destination of her investments, so they would not have been invested in ETFs;
- She adds that the returns of funds for a total of US$ 305,000.00 were made due to the collection pressure she had been exerting, but were not generated by an instruction to sell securities or liquidate positions on her part, since she never instructed orders in that sense;
- Additionally, Mrs. Alvarez stated that by letter of 28 April 2015, Mr. Arizmendi, who signs as President and General Manager of GPIAM, addressed to Mr. Jesús Alcalá Mateo (who is Mrs. Alvarez's lawyer) hereinafter Mr. Alcalá, regarding Mrs. Alvarez's investments, states that they received the US$ 950,000.00 in GPI's account to be invested with a conservative profile and obtain income, preferably quarterly, and that the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI and GPIAM, in similar amounts;
- Mrs. Alvarez stated that through said writing, it is recognized that there is a verbal instruction to invest the US$ 950,000.00 with a conservative profile. She also indicates that she never instructed GPI to divide the responsibility for the investments with GPIAM, since at all times she dealt and related with GPI because it was evident that Mr. Arizmendi acted in coordination with Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager and chair of the board of GPI, who was copied on most of the emails that Mr. Arizmendi addressed to the client;
- Furthermore, Mrs. Alvarez indicates that Mr. Arizmendi sent her a writing dated 15 July 2015 signed by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, who signed as general manager of GPI, addressed "to whom it may concern", in which it is stated that Mrs. Alvarez has an investment account abroad valued at US$ 645,000.00 and whose custody is at Interactive Brokers LLC;
- Regarding this writing, Mrs. Alvarez states that she never authorized a transfer to Interactive Brokers LLC;
- Finally, Mrs. Alvarez indicates that through the so-called "Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Guarantee" dated 10 November 2015 signed between her and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI, the origin of the obligation is recognized in an initial transfer of US$ 950,000.00; returns of US$ 305,000.00 are recorded; and the existence of a balance in favor of the client of US$ 645,000.00 is recognized;
- In this regard, Mrs. Alvarez specifies that this contract was signed under this format because her intention was simply that the money she had delivered be returned and that, by the month of July 2015, it had been required in its entirety;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- For her part, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, through documentation sent on 15 September 2016, accredited that the funds delivered by Mrs. Alvarez entered the operating account. She also stated that the funds were transferred to Interactive Brokers LLC, although she did not accredit this transfer of funds;
- Regarding the destination of said funds, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, through a writing presented on 26 July and 15 September 2016, states that from the conversations with Mrs. Alvarez it clearly flowed that she had a horizon of three (03) years and that her main purpose was to generate income of 12% per year. Therefore, since there are currently no fixed-income instruments, such as sovereign or corporate bonds, that can provide said yield, a modality of investments that with moderate risk could provide said profitability was the use of selling "put" options based on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange;
- GPI also added that in the so-called "Mutual Money Loan Agreement with Repurchase Pact", which was entered into on 10 November 2015, the position of Mrs. Alvarez's puts was expressed, a position that she supposedly maintained as of 10 November 2015 as follows;
- Sale of 110 put option contracts of GDXJ with expiration in February 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 30.
- Sale of 125 put option contracts of GDX with expiration in March 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 25.
- Cash for approximately US$ 2,500;
- Likewise, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, stated that Mrs. Alvarez received returns on her funds in the sum of US$ 305,000.00;
Of the charge formulated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
- Mrs. Alvarez and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, confirmed the amount of US$ 950,000.00 delivered by Mrs. Alvarez in GPI's operating account as well as the subsequent returns of US$ 305,000.00, leaving a pending balance to be returned of US$ 645,000.00. Likewise, both parties also agree that the money delivered was for the purpose of making investments with financial instruments in the foreign market;
- The foregoing concurs with the amounts mentioned in the "Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Pact" signed on 10 November 2015, in which it is described that GPI received US$ 950,000.00 from Mrs. Alvarez, that it returned to the client US$ 305,000.00 and that the pending balance to be returned to her amounts to the sum of US$ 645,000.00;
- It should also be added that GPI indicates that through the aforementioned mutual loan agreement, it is stated that the pending balance to be returned to Mrs. Alvarez amounts to the sum of US$ 645,000.00 and that said amount is invested in put options, which are in the name of Mrs. Alvarez, with which the position of Mrs. Alvarez's puts is expressed, a position that GPI stated is maintained to date (that is, it mentions it in this way both in its letters of 26 July and 15 September 2016), according to the detail transcribed in the contract in question, as follows:
- Sale of 110 put option contracts of GDXJ with expiration in February 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 30.
- Sale of 125 put option contracts of GDX with expiration in March 2016 and at the exercise price of US$ 25.
- Cash for approximately US$ 2,500;
- On the other hand, it has been accredited that the coordination between Mrs. Alvarez and GPI regarding the execution of the acts whose object was to carry out the investments of the aforementioned client were carried out between the company's general manager, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, and with the direct participation of Mr. Arizmendi;
- Indeed, it is accredited that Mr. Arizmendi sent an email on 24 April 2015 to Mr. Alcalá, with a copy to Mrs. Teresa Orlandini Alvarez Calderón, GPI Representative, hereinafter Mrs. Orlandini, through which he indicates that they have made a combination of strategies that they manage both at GPI and at GPIAM; furthermore, Mr. Arizmendi indicates that the idea is that it yields above 9% per year, within a term of two (02) or three (03) years;
- Likewise, Mr. Arizmendi sent another email on 28 April 2015 to Mr. Alcalá, with a copy to Mrs. Orlandini, through which he indicates that as they make better "rollovers" they will have better prospects for the investments. Finally, by letter of 28 April 2015, Mr. Arizmendi, who signs as President and General Manager of GPIAM, addressed to Mr. Alcalá, regarding Mrs. Alvarez's investments, states that they received the US$ 950,000.00 in GPI's account to be invested with a conservative profile and obtain income, preferably quarterly, and that the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI and GPIAM, in similar amounts;
- As can be seen, from the moment of the investment of the amount of US$ 950,000.00, Mr. Arizmendi had an active participation assuming the role of direct manager of the client's investments, informing about the investment strategies that they would have carried out with the funds, between GPI and GPIAM;
- This full knowledge of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle of the management of Mrs. Alvarez's funds, in addition to her capacity as General Manager of GPI and spouse of Mr. Arizmendi, is directly reflected in the letters she signed on 06 and 15 July 2015 indicating "to whom it may concern" that Mrs. Alvarez has an investment account valued at US$ 775,000.00 and US$ 645,000.00 abroad, respectively;
- Likewise, after GPI returned US$ 305,000.00 to Mrs. Alvarez and she requested the return of the remaining US$ 645,000.00, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle actively participates in the first months of 2016, manifesting full knowledge of the management of the client's funds;
- Indeed, by email of 07 March 2016, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle tells Mrs. Alvarez, in response to a request for her funds, that she will return her funds with the money that Sura Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. will pay her or with a loan they are arranging, whichever comes first. Likewise, by email of 19 April 2016, she tells her that on behalf of Mr. Arizmendi, she sends her a payment proposal for the outstanding balance, which ratifies Mr. Arizmendi's principal role in the management of the client's funds with Mrs. Bellido-Tagle's participation;
- Furthermore, it should be added that for the client the management of her funds was directly related to Mr. Arizmendi, therefore by email of 01 July 2015 she directly requests Mr. Arizmendi, with a copy to Mrs. Orlandini, the return of US$ 350,000.00 of her funds. In response to this request, Mr. Arizmendi again actively participates in the management and handling of the funds, telling Mrs. Alvarez that it is impossible to comply with her request for funds because they have invested in options and need at least 60 days to divest without losses;
- Therefore, the commercial relationship, that is, Mrs. Alvarez's engagement of GPI, with Mr. Arizmendi's active participation in the management of the funds and with Mrs. Bellido-Tagle's participation, to carry out operations abroad, had a substantially different conduct as to the objective of the client's investment, since Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, maintained that she invested Mrs. Alvarez's funds in taking short positions in put options on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange with an investment horizon of three (03) years, when the initial instruction of the aforementioned client was to invest with a conservative profile (which has been stated and recognized in writing by Mr. Arizmendi by letter of 28 April 2015);
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, on this last point, it should be noted that GPI has not sent to date a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions that accredit Mrs. Alvarez's will to allocate her funds to investments with an investment horizon of three (03) years, as GPI states and, specifically, to take short positions in put options, which were the operations that GPI has intermediated, as stated by GPI;
- With regard to the operations intermediated by GPI in the foreign market on behalf of Mrs. Alvarez, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of Mrs. Alvarez or in the name of GPI, provided in the latter case by Interactive Brokers LLC or by other entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments;
- Likewise, GPI has not provided copies of the policies of the operations carried out and copies of the client's account statements with the information of the operations carried out in the foreign market;
- All these documents would accredit the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with GPI's intermediation, with the funds delivered by Mrs. Alvarez, however, and as mentioned, this has not been accredited by GPI;
- It should be noted that neither GPI nor Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has accredited that the funds owned by the client or the securities and financial instruments in which these funds have been invested, or a combination of both, are custodied by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened at a foreign entity in the name of GPI, accrediting that the funds or securities and financial instruments are indisputable property of Mrs. Alvarez. Likewise, they have not accredited that these funds, securities and financial instruments are in the name of the aforementioned client at a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evidenced that GPI was required to provide the minimum documentation accrediting that it complied with the instructions given by its client, that is, to verify that the funds delivered were used according to the investment decision given by Mrs. Alvarez;
- To date, GPI has not accredited with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the destination of the pending balance to be returned to Mrs. Alvarez amounting to the sum of US$ 645,000.00, in whose management Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, have actively participated. That is, whether she allocated them to taking short positions in put options on ETFs listed on the New York Stock Exchange or whether she allocated them to another purpose, in neither case has she accredited the destination of the money delivered by the complainant, so it is concluded that she allocated it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- It should be noted that according to article 77 of the Regulation, it is the brokerage firm that must prove the conditions under which the order was given, since if not, it is presumed that it was given under the conditions indicated by the client;
- With regard to the foregoing, it is clear that GPI, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since it received the funds delivered by Mrs. Alvarez for custody and investment instructions given by said client, and has also not accredited the corresponding express authorizations from Mrs. Alvarez for the use of these funds;
- In this sense, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would have infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the Lmv, and article 48 of the Regulation, by allocating the funds owned by Mrs. Alvarez to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
Of the defenses presented in this complaint
- GPI stated in the defenses it presented at the time[10] that the problem that occurred with Mrs. Alvarez lies in the fact that the brokerage firm did not explain in detail, in writing and at the appropriate time, the type of investment it was making. It indicates that what happened between June 2015 and January 2016 caused a temporary loss of the value of the investment which in turn caused Mrs. Alvarez to seek to disavow the investments, arguing that they had been made in a manner different from that requested;
- GPI adds that indeed during 2015 and the first months of 2016, the losses in said securities were massive and there were investors who realized the losses, among which is the brokerage firm itself, however, so far in 2016, ETFs such as GDX, GDXJ and BVN have had high returns;
- On the other hand, GPI indicates that the funds were not allocated for purposes other than those indicated by Mrs. Alvarez, but rather there was no clear agreement between the parties regarding their application, even though in the past and in Mrs. Alvarez's Pershing LLC account, GPI had carried out similar operations, given the good temporary results of the same;
- Likewise, GPI states that the "Mutual Loan Agreement with Repurchase Pact" signed on 10 November 2015 by the client and GPI (hereinafter Mutual Loan Agreement) was not the most suitable and beyond Mrs. Alvarez's recent questioning, such contract revealed the client's full knowledge that by her engagement GPI had invested US$ 642,500.00 in Puts and/or in ETF on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), in the case of their execution, so it cannot be ignored that Mrs. Alvarez was at that time aware of the destination of her investments, although now she denies it. Even less can the SMV accept this statement when the documentation accompanying the complainant herself accredits the contrary;
- Likewise, GPI adds that the Mutual Loan Agreement is suitable proof of the destination of Mrs. Alvarez's investments made by GPI, so the presumption indicated in numeral 77.3 of article 77 of the Regulation, in force at the date of the events, cannot be applied, there being already an agreement as to the investments existing as of 10 November 2015, which expressed the prior liquidation of investments, with return to the investor, as she has recognized, of the US$ 305,000.00;
- Therefore, according to GPI, the factual assumption invoked in the imputation that GPI did not accredit its client's instructions is not given. GPI adds that Mrs. Alvarez recognized at the time that her funds were invested in Puts, so it is not possible to apply the presumption of article 77 of the Regulation;
- Finally, GPI refers that today, the investor states that this is due to "collection pressure", reveals on the contrary the improper manner in which the investor alludes to the realization of her investments: "collections". This also demonstrates how the investor seeks to illegitimately avoid the risks inherent in the market and seeks to transfer them to the intermediary;
Evaluation of the defenses
- Regarding the fact that the stock brokerage firm did not explain in detail, in writing and in a timely manner, the type of investment that Mrs. Alvarez was making, it must be noted that GPI has not presented evidence proving that GPI provided information to Mrs. Alvarez regarding her investments;
- Indeed, such evidence refers, in principle, to having the authorizations instructed by this client for certain investments to be made. Likewise, in addition to not having these authorizations, GPI has also not proven with the account statements issued by foreign intermediaries or by foreign entities responsible for the registration and custody of securities or financial instruments, policies and account statements of the client issued by GPI, the destination of the investments of Mrs. Alvarez's funds;
- Regarding the fact that there was no destination other than that indicated by Mrs. Alvarez, but rather that there was clearly no agreement between the parties regarding their application, it should be noted that only GPI's argument is available regarding the fact that it would have invested the balance of US$ 645,000.00 in the sale of Put options; however, these investments have also not been proven;
- Regarding the fact that the Mutual Loan Agreement revealed Mrs. Alvarez's full knowledge of the investments made by GPI for US$ 642,500.00 in Puts and/or ETFs in the case of the execution of such options, it must be noted that what is indicated in said contract regarding the destination of the funds delivered by Mrs. Alvarez, that is, the effective realization of the aforementioned investments, has not been proven by GPI;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that since March 2015, Mrs. Alvarez's lawyer, Mr. Jesús Alcalá, requested Mr. Arizmendi to prove the investments made by GPI on behalf of Mrs. Alvarez. However, GPI has not proven that it issued a documented response regarding the destination of such funds;
- This request for information by Mr. Jesús Alcalá regarding the investments by GPI of Mrs. Alvarez's funds was explained by Mr. Arizmendi through a letter dated April 28, 2015, in which he indicates, among other things, that US$ 950,000.00 was received in GPI's accounts to be invested with a conservative profile and obtain income, preferably quarterly, and that the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI and Gpi Asset;
- Regarding this letter, it should be noted that although Mr. Arizmendi signs it as president and general manager of Gpi Asset, it should be highlighted that it proves the will of GPI and its actions as representative of the brokerage firm by citing phrases such as: "we received in the accounts of GPI Valores SAB the amount of US$ 950,000.00"..."the responsibility for the investments has been divided between GPI Valores SAB and GPI Asset Management SAC in similar amounts.";
- Regarding what Mr. Arizmendi said in the aforementioned letter, that the investment of Mrs. Alvarez's funds had been destined to positions in options to earn premiums, this client since July 2015 expressed her disagreement with this investment strategy although she was willing to find a solution;
- Indeed, through an email dated July 1, 2015, Mrs. Alvarez requested Mr. Arizmendi to deliver funds for US$ 350,000.00 (in May GPI had returned US$ 175,000.00 of the US$ 950,000.00), receiving as a response from the latter, through an email dated July 3 of that year at 11:03 hours: "I wish we could do it in those times, but it will be impossible, due to the way we have invested through options. As I told you, we need at least 60 days to divest without losses. I apologize a thousand times for this. (...) what I will do is change the investment strategy (...) but I have to make the whole strategy change and that requires time (...)";
- It should be noted that in this email Mr. Arizmendi acknowledges that he invested Mrs. Alvarez's funds following an investment strategy different from that instructed by the client, so he indicates that he will change the strategy;
- In view of this, subsequently, through an email dated July 3, 2015 at 11:51 hours, Mrs. Alvarez tells Mr. Arizmendi: "As we stated, there was a misunderstanding on your part in the mandate we gave; we understood that it was the same modality in which we had been working. But as you know, this is already so and the issue is to find a solution (...)";
- Regarding this email, it should be noted that as proven, in the account statements issued by the servicing broker dealer Bolton Capital Inc., the operations executed by the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC from August 2013 to December 2014, with GPI's intervention, were mainly purchases and sales of ETFs; that is, with a conservative profile;
- It should be added that through a letter received by GPI on November 4, 2015, Mrs. Alvarez requested said brokerage firm to return the US$ 645,000.00, stating in it: "I know there was a misunderstanding which was not on my part because our instructions were different (...)";
- As noted, Mrs. Alvarez has been claiming from GPI about the destination of her funds since at least March 2015, in addition to reiterating that the investments with her funds were made with an investment profile different from that indicated by the aforementioned client;
- Therefore, given that the modality of instruction of orders of Mrs. Alvarez according to the Client Registration Form signed on September 29, 2014 is email with digital signature and written confirmation, and taking into account the presumption contained in Article 77, numeral 77.3 of the Regulations[11] in force at the time of the events, it is evident that GPI did not comply with the instructions given by Mrs. Alvarez for the destination of her funds, in addition to the fact that said stock brokerage firm has not proven the effective realization of the alleged investments;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that the Mutual Loan Agreement does not by itself prove the client's ownership of the funds and/or securities and financial instruments indicated therein;
- Indeed, these documents by themselves would not prove the position of funds and/or securities and financial instruments owned by Mrs. Alvarez, because, in the case of intermediation in the foreign market, it is also required to prove the position of funds and/or securities and financial instruments of the client with account statements in the name of Mrs. Alvarez or in the name of GPI provided by entities responsible for the execution of operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities responsible for the registration or custody of securities or financial instruments, in which, with the necessary reconciliations, the ownership of funds or financial instruments of Mrs. Alvarez is indisputably demonstrated;
- It should be noted that analogously, in the case where the funds are deposited in the Operating Account and the securities and financial instruments are held in custody in the parent account of the stock brokerage firm in the CAVALI Accounting Registry, the client's fund position would not be proven by the mere mention in an account statement in the client's name issued by GPI that said client has a certain amount of money deposited in this intermediary, but this description must be supported by the money that is actually deposited in a financial entity in the name of GPI, money that can be verified with the fund reconciliations per client that allow indisputably determining that the client has funds held in custody by GPI. Likewise, for the case of positions of securities and financial instruments, this is verified through the authorized local clearing and settlement institution, which is CAVALI;
- In this sense, it is not acceptable that the Mutual Loan Agreement by itself proves the investments that GPI would have made with the funds entrusted by this client;
- Regarding the fact that with the signing of the Mutual Loan Agreement Mrs. Alvarez was aware of the destination of her investments, it should be noted that as indicated, GPI has not proven that the aforementioned investments were effectively made in the name or on behalf of Mrs. Alvarez;
- In relation to the fact that GPI considers that the presumption contemplated in numeral 77.3 of Article 77 of the Regulations[12], in force at the time of the events, is not applicable, given the existence of the Mutual Loan Agreement that proves the destination of Mrs. Alvarez's investments as of November 10, 2015, as well as the return to the investor of US$ 305,000.00 and that Mrs. Alvarez acknowledged at the time that her funds were invested in Puts, it must be mentioned that the existence of orders to invest the money in options has not been proven, and it has also not been proven that this investment in options (not ordered by the client) was effectively made;
- Likewise, it should be indicated that, as mentioned above, the Mutual Loan Agreement does not constitute suitable evidence of the destination of the investments ordered by Mrs. Alvarez;
- Accordingly, it is concluded that GPI both in the preliminary inquiries and in its defenses only states, but does not prove, that it invested with Mrs. Alvarez's authorization the balance of US$ 645,000.00 in the sale of Puts on ETFs;
- Likewise, it is valid to maintain that in the present case the factual assumption invoked in the charge imputation is met, that GPI did not prove the instructions of its client to invest in taking positions in sale of Puts, so according to numeral 77.3 of Article 77 of the Regulations, in force at the time of the events, it is presumed that Mrs. Alvarez's instructions for the use of her funds consisted of the following;
- Invest her funds in a liquid and conservative portfolio based on ETFs.
- That the investment would be executed by the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC using the account that Mrs. Alvarez has opened in her name in this foreign intermediary since August 2013;
- Consequently, GPI has not proven the investments made with the US$ 645,000.00 that Mrs. Alvarez had as of July 10, 2015, after the last withdrawal of funds, and the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments of Mrs. Alvarez as of the date of its defenses (October 4, 2016). It should be noted that it is only proven that GPI has delivered to Mrs. Alvarez US$ 73,970.00 for returns on investments made on behalf of this investor;
- Therefore, by having destined Mrs. Alvarez's funds differently from what was authorized by the client, GPI breached the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulations;
- Accordingly, by not having presented any evidence proving that it observed literal a) of Article 195 of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulations, GPI has not lifted the charge formulated, so it is concluded that it has incurred an infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations; as resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals proves, in addition to the concerted action of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[13], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[14], among others[15], having participated in the events described above as part of a mechanism they used with several clients, since in practice as maximum administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal management of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, so it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referring to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus breaching the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulations;
- Regarding the complaint of Mrs. Mayo
The Complaint
- In the complaint of October 25, 2016 presented before the SMV, Mrs. Rosa Mayo Frid de Schwartzman, hereinafter, Mrs. Mayo, stated that GPI has invested her funds without her authorization in high-risk options when her profile is conservative, and that she has not signed any portfolio management contract or any document authorizing them to trade in the foreign market;
- Likewise, she has requested GPI to indemnify her for what she will lose and what she has lost due to these high-risk investments;
- Mrs. Mayo also indicates that she has requested from GPI on repeated occasions information and documentation regarding her investments without receiving any response;
- Mrs. Mayo also adds that when she asked for her client registration form, she was surprised that, to her client registration form, GPI's representative, Mrs. Alicia Marrou, had inserted a page, which Mrs. Mayo has not signed, in which it said that she understood finance very well and that she was high-risk, when she knows little about finance and her profile is conservative;
- Through a letter dated November 2, 2016, Mrs. Mayo states that she has only dealt with GPI and never with the foreign intermediaries Pershing, Interactive Brokers or others;
- That on November 30, 2011, she transferred to GPI a package of shares of her property (shares issued by Credicorp Ltda., Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A., Scotiabank del Perú S.A.A., Ferreycorp, Minsur S.A., Refineria La Pampilla S.A.A., Compañía Minera Volcan S.A.A., Sociedad Minera Cerro Verde S.A.A. and Souther Copper Corporation), which prove that such investments are conservative and that she has never taken high-risk investments;
- Finally, she refers that for weeks she has been demanding from GPI, without response from it, information about the options that said brokerage firm has invested in her name that expire in January 2017, that if she does nothing about it all the money invested in them will be lost and she is already losing 70% of her investments;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, through a letter sent on November 4, 2016, has stated that she has not provided Mrs. Mayo with portfolio management services and that Mrs. Alicia Marrou Salazar (Marrou) was a representative of said client until 2015. She attaches to her letter a copy of the following documentation:
- "Know Your Client Investment Profile" form dated July 12, 2011 with which Mrs. Mayo was evaluated, it being necessary to indicate that such form was only signed by Mrs. Alicia Marrou, GPI's representative.
- Report issued by INFOCORP regarding Mrs. Mayo.
- Purchase and sale contract of securities abroad dated July 12, 2011.
- Account statements from August 16, 2011 to May 4, 2013 issued by GPI in the name of Mrs. Mayo.
- Account statements for November and December 2011 and for July, August, September, October, November and December 2012 issued by GPI in the name of Mrs. Mayo.
- Account statements from January to December 2013 issued by GPI in the name of Mrs. Mayo.
- Account statements from January to December 2014 issued by GPI in the name of Mrs. Mayo.
- Account statements from January to September and from November 2015 to February 16, 2016 issued by GPI in the name of Mrs. Mayo.
- Account statements from February to September 2016 issued by GPI in the name of Mrs. Mayo;
- Likewise, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI has stated that the aforementioned account statements have been sent to Mrs. Mayo via email by her representative, Mrs. Alicia Marrou Salazar; however, she has not proven her statement. She also refers that the foreign intermediary does not issue individual account statements;
- Similarly, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI has indicated that she attaches the signed orders and policies issued since 2011, and the reports of the SIVXXI and GAM programs with the detail of all operations; however, she has not complied with attaching any of the referred documents;
- Finally, the brokerage firm specifies that Mrs. Mayo's representative was Mrs. Alicia Marrou Salazar until 2015;
Regarding the Charge Formulated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
- According to what Mrs. Mayo stated in her complaint and documentation attached to it, her disagreement is appreciated for the investment made by GPI in her name in derivative operations such as options that are high-risk without her authorization and that she also considers were made outside her conservative profile;
- According to the account statements of Mrs. Mayo that GPI has sent in response to Official Letter No. 6590-2016-SMV/10.3, this stock brokerage firm maintains that it has carried out operations with options at least from January 2013 to April 2013 with an investment of US$ 126,000.00 and has maintained that investment amount in options until September 2016 with maturity in January 2017, so it is evident that it has carried out additional operations with options until 2016, including renewals of the maturities of the options through the "rollover" modality, as shown in Table No. 1.
Table No. 1
Movement of the investment in options in the name of Mrs. Mayo (US$)
| DATE | CAPITAL | BALANCE | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation | Value | Maturity | No. Contracts | Strike Price | Amount | Premium | | | |
| 01/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 158,789.46 | Sale PUT | NUGT | March 2013 | 84 | 15 | 126,000.00 | 1,092.00 |
| 02/04/2013 | 126,000.00 | - | Sale PUT | NUGT | June 2013 | 84 | 15 | 126,000.00 | 1,092.00 |
| 02/28/2013 | 126,000.00 | 158,789.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 03/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 159,881.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 04/09/2013 | 126,000.00 | - | SALE CALL | - | May 2013 | 84 | 7 | 58,800.00 | 1,260.00 |
| 04/30/2013 | 126,000.00 | 159,881.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 05/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,141.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 06/30/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,141.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 07/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 08/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 09/30/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 10/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 11/30/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 12/31/2013 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 01/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 02/28/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 03/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 04/30/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 05/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 06/30/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 07/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 08/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 09/30/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 10/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 11/30/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 12/31/2014 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 01/31/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 02/28/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 03/31/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 04/30/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 05/31/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 06/30/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 07/31/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 08/31/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 09/30/2015 | 126,000.00 | 161,146.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 11/30/2015 | 126,000.00 | 126,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 02/16/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 02/29/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 03/31/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 04/30/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 05/31/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 06/30/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 07/31/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 08/31/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
| 09/30/2016 | 126,000.00 | 63,185.22 | - | - | January 2017 | - | - | - | - |
- In this regard, by means of Official Letter No. 6590-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI was requested to provide its comments regarding what was stated by Mrs. Mayo; however, neither Mrs. Bellido-Tagle nor the former stock brokerage firm complied with providing the corresponding explanations regarding the questioned investment or regarding what was indicated in the respective complaint;
- Likewise, there is an email dated February 19, 2016 at 3:19 p.m. addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, by which Mrs. Mayo requests the transfer of all her securities, reports, and funds to Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. She also states that Mr. Uccelli informed her that there are options registered in her name, that they are risky when her profile is conservative, that she does not recognize that type of operation, and that she will come the following Monday at 11:00 a.m. for the corresponding explanations;
- Similarly, there is another email dated October 20, 2016 at 3:13 p.m. addressed to Mrs. Orlandini and Mr. Arizmendi, by which Mrs. Mayo states that she has reviewed all her statements going back and that at least since February 2016 options appear for a value of US$ 63,185.22 and an exposure of US$ 126,000.00 maturing in January 2017, so she urgently needs to know what that is, what it is invested in, and what the situation is;
- There is also another email dated October 24, 2016 at 10:53 a.m. addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, Mr. Ucelli, and Mrs. Orlandini, by which Mrs. Mayo states that for two weeks she has been asking for the status of her investments and her discomfort due to the lack of information regarding her investments, that she has requested appointments with Mr. Arizmendi on several occasions, however, of the last three he has not shown up and she has only been attended by Mrs. Orlandini who has not provided the information she needs; that her risk profile has always been moderate, however, they have invested her money in high-risk investments, among others;
- Likewise, there is an email dated October 25, 2016 at 10:56 a.m. addressed to Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Orlandini, by which Mrs. Mayo reiterates her discomfort at the lack of response from the brokerage firm and the evasions given regarding the destination of the funds delivered to the firm, indicating even that Mr. Arizmendi on that date was going to send to her email the information on the analysis and information of her portfolio; that she had requested from the latter the return of her money and that they keep the investments that were made without her authorization and without her knowledge that they were high risk;
- There is also an email dated November 2, 2016 at 3:11 p.m. addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, Mr. Uccelli, Mrs. Orlandini, among others, by which Mrs. Mayo states that she was at GPI's offices so that they would provide her with the papers and explanations of the investment made by the firm on her behalf and that Mrs. Orlandini informed her that without her authorization they liquidated her options that matured in January 2017 and that the money they obtained would not be given to her because the SAB had lost those funds obtained from the sale; that she has been going to the intermediary's offices every day without being given any explanation;
- There is another email dated November 3, 2016 at 4:20 p.m. from Mrs. Orlandini addressed to Mrs. Mayo with a copy to Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Uccelli, among others, in which she informs her that she commits with Mr. Arizmendi to deliver the requested report of the options operations on November 4 at the meeting scheduled for 12:30 at GPI's offices;
- There is also another email dated November 4, 2016 at 12:18 p.m. from Mrs. Orlandini addressed to Mrs. Mayo in which she communicates that they have not given her the information and that Mr. Arizmendi is not in the office, apologizing once again and that she tries to do everything within her reach;
- The foregoing reflects that Mr. Arizmendi had an active participation as de facto representative assuming the role of direct manager of Mrs. Mayo's investments, to whom he even reported on the investment strategies that would have been carried out with the funds or the supposed operations carried out in her name; and although during the time she was attended by Mr. Arizmendi, he had already ceased to be general manager and chairman of the board of GPI, which also implies that this was permitted by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and she consented to such participation without any questioning;
- On the other hand, by means of the aforementioned Official Letter No. 6590-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI was requested, among others, to provide a copy of the orders and policies supporting the options operations; however, said brokerage firm has not complied with providing such documents. It should be noted that according to Mrs. Mayo's client registration form, the orders given have the modality of being telephone orders with written confirmation;
- On this last point, it should be noted that GPI has not sent to date a copy of writings, emails, or other forms of transmission of instructions that prove Mrs. Mayo's willingness to allocate her funds to investments in options;
- With regard to these operations intermediated by GPI in the foreign market on behalf of Mrs. Mayo, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in this last case by entities responsible for the execution of the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities responsible for the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, related to the options operations;
- These documents would prove the investments that have been made in the foreign market with options, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by Mrs. Mayo; however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI;
- It should be noted that neither GPI, nor Mr. Arizmendi, nor Mrs. Bellido-Tagle have proven that the funds owned by Mrs. Mayo or the financial derivatives or securities resulting from the execution of the options, in which these funds have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI, proving that the funds or financial derivatives or securities resulting from the execution of the options are indisputable property of Mrs. Mayo. Likewise, they have not proven that these funds and financial derivatives are in the name of the aforementioned client in a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was requested to provide the minimum documentation proving that it complied with the instructions given by its client, that is, to verify that the funds delivered were used according to the investment decision given by Mrs. Mayo;
- To date, neither Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, nor GPI, nor Mr. Arizmendi have proven, on the basis of the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments in options from January 2013 to date (maturing in January 2017) for the amount of US$ 126,000.00, or that they have allocated them to another destination; in no case have they proven the destination of the money delivered by Mrs. Mayo, so it is concluded that they have allocated it to operations or purposes other than those for which it was entrusted to them;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the document presented by GPI in which it is stated that Mrs. Mayo accepts investing in options and that she has an aggressive investment profile is not signed by her, as she has stated in her complaint;
- In relation to the foregoing, it is clear that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, the brokerage firm itself, and Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative, would not have complied with the provisions of Article 48 of the Regulation, since they received the funds delivered by Mrs. Mayo for custody and the investment instructions given by said client, and without proving the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- In this sense, GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, and Mr. Arizmendi would have infringed the provisions of Article 195, numeral a) of the LMV, and Article 48 of the Regulation, by allocating the funds owned by Mrs. Mayo to operations, purposes, or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- On the other hand, GPI states that it supposedly carried out operations with Options, as detailed below;
Table No. 2
Supposed options operations in the name of the client (in US$) and balance of investments as indicated by GPI, which have not been proven with the required documentation
| | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| DATE | CAPITAL | BALANCE | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
| Operation | Value | Maturity | No. Contracts | Strike Price | Amount | Premium | | | |
| 01/31/2013 | 126,000 | 158,789.46 | Sale PUT | NUGT | Mar-13 | 84 | 15 | 126,000 | 1,092 |
| 02/04/2013 | 126,000 | - | Sale PUT | NUGT | Jun-13 | 84 | 15 | 126,000 | 1,092 |
| 02/28/2013 | 126,000 | 158,789.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 03/31/2013 | 126,000 | 159,881.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 04/09/2013 | 126,000 | - | Sale CALL | - | May-13 | 84 | 7 | 58,800 | 1,260 |
| 04/30/2013 | 126,000 | 159,881.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 09/30/2016 | 126,000 | 63,185.22 | - | - | Jan-17 | - | - | - | - |
- Regarding these options operations, in the preliminary inquiry stage, GPI presented to the SMV on November 4, 2016 the document called "Know Your Client (KYC) Investment Profile" dated July 12, 2011, by which the client was evaluated[16] and in which it was stated that she accepts investing in options and that she has an aggressive investment profile; however, such document is not signed by her and was only signed by Mrs. Marrou, GPI's representative at that time, who signed the Client Registration Form of the client;
- Likewise, it should be noted that in the Annex to the client registration form of the client signed on July 12, 2011 by the Client and Mrs. Marrou, the following is stated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Operations with futures, options and derivatives", "Advisory in capital markets (international)" and "Other operations authorized by the Securities Market Law";
- It should be noted that what was stated by the Client and by GPI regarding the investments that GPI claims to have made, in relation to the Client's risk profile, is not evaluated, considering that, despite the requirements made by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that proves the carrying out of the operations indicated in Table No. 2 and others that it would have carried out that explain that the Client's portfolio amounts to US$ 63,185.22 as of September 30, 2016, that is, the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the Client's funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the records of global account controls, the policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds that the Client entrusted to them for custody and investment instructions given by her and that, according to both parties, amount to US$ 126,000.00 at least since January 2013;
- The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 126,000.00 is proven by the documents that GPI has presented as "Account Statement" of the Client, as well as by a letter from Mrs. Alicia Marrou Salazar dated October 6, 2015[17], by which, at the time of her resignation from GPI, she gives account of the available funds of various clients, among them, those of the Client, which, according to Mrs. Marrou, were managed by Mr. Arizmendi and Mr. Uccelli in an account in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C at the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC. The detail is shown in Table No. 3:
Table No. 3
Proof of funds delivered by the client
| Date / Month | Amount Deposit/ Withdrawal of Funds | Concept | GPI Deposit / Charge Account | Supporting documents |
|---|
| Jan-13 | 126,000.00 | Capital (Amount in exposure) | Not indicated | "Account Statement" reports as of 01/31/2013 and 02/28/2013, in the name of the Client, attached by GPI in its writing dated 11/04/2016, which states an invested amount of US$ 126,000.00 in options, as well as "Account Statements" reports from February to September 2016, in the name of the Client, which states an investment amount (exposure) of US$ 126,000.00 in options. |
| Letter from Mrs. Alicia Marrou Salazar dated 10/06/2015 addressed to GPI Asset Management S.A.C., attention Mr. Arizmendi, indicating that the clients' money at that date (among them the Client) were deposited in a Global Account No. xxxxx30 at Interactive Brokers in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C., so due to her resignation as Representative of GPI, she leaves record of the available cash balances reported to clients at that date. | | | | |
- The aforementioned letter from Mrs. Marrou shows a first destination of the funds, from GPI's accounts to GPI Asset Management S.A.C, which was not authorized by the client, since GPI has not presented documentation in this regard and rather has indicated, through "Account Statements", that GPI managed the Client's funds;
- Likewise, GPI states that it carried out operations (according to its statement it would be understood that said firm would have carried them out), and even in the event that they had been carried out in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C, through Interactive Brokers LLC, these have not been proven by said former brokerage firm before this Superintendency, so this reflects that such operations were never carried out, which allows us to validly maintain that in reality such funds were disposed of for purposes not authorized by the Client, such as the transfer of those funds to an account in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C;
- In this sense, according to Article 48 of the Regulation, the funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, unless there is express authorization from the client and said purpose refers to any of the operations indicated in Article 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not proven the carrying out of the operations with the required documentation, this allows us to validly maintain that the funds delivered by the Client were disposed of for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for investments according to the Client's prior instructions;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not disprove this charge, and consequently, it has been proven that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation; as resolved by Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 002-2017-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals proves, in addition to the concerted action of part of GPI's main authorities, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[18], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[19], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism that they used with several clients, since in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal management of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, so it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referred to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mrs. Silva Ruete
The Complaint
- In the complaint of November 2, 2016 presented to the SMV, Mrs. María del Rosario Silva Ruete de Gastañaga, hereinafter, Mrs. Silva, states that on November 15, 2013, together with her husband, Mr. Mario Anibal Gastañaga Coll Cárdenas, hereinafter, Mr. Mario Gastañaga, they invested US$ 100,000.00 and as proof of the operation GPI gave them a receipt in the name of her and Mr. Gastañaga, showing the payment of a "return" of 10% per year and, she adds, that there was no contract or guarantee document of the operation carried out, much less the nature and destination of the investment, which for GPI the receipt was sufficient;
- Likewise, Mrs. Silva states that on February 27, 2014 she invested US$ 200,000.00 and GPI gave her a receipt issued in the name of her and her son, Mr. Aníbal Ricardo Gastañaga Silva, hereinafter, Mr. Ricardo Gastaña;
- Regarding the aforementioned investments of Mrs. Silva, one jointly with Mr. Mario Gastañaga and another with Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga, Mrs. Silva states that on October 17, 2016 conciliation hearings were held in which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle attended, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, requesting the payment of US$ 300,000.00 plus returns until the total cancellation of the debt[20], in which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle stated "that there are pending obligations but that the obligation cannot be paid because it is suspended by the Superintendency" [21];
- Mrs. Silva adds that, in this way, the conciliation failed due to lack of agreement, thus demonstrating that GPI has no intention of complying with its obligations;
- Finally, Mrs. Silva states that GPI has made the following payments for the concept of 10% "Return": a) For the investment of US$ 100,000.00 they paid 10 quarters for a total of US$ 25,000.00 (US$ 2,500.00 per quarter); and, b) For the investment of US$ 200,000.00 they paid 9 quarters for a total of US$ 45,000.00 (US$ 5,000.00 per quarter);
- By writing presented on November 15, 2016, in response to Official Letter No. 6700-2016-SMV/10.3, Mrs. Silva states that she has not signed any document with foreign intermediaries and that she did not give any order or instruction. Likewise, she attaches documents proving the transfers and deposits made to GPI's accounts;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- By letter sent on November 8, 2016, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, states that she has not provided Mrs. Silva, Mr. Mario Gastañaga, and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga, hereinafter, the Clients, with the portfolio management service;
- Likewise, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, indicates that the investment modality was for a term of thirty-six (36) months and that it sought the generation of premiums based on the sale of options abroad, in order to generate a flow of income. GPI adds that it operated on its own account and paid the agreed profitability. Similarly, GPI refers to the following;
- The Clients' funds come from the cancellations of deposit certificates in municipal and/or rural savings banks, as well as deposits received in GPI's account at Banco Financiero. It attaches a copy of the corresponding vouchers and account statements.
- It does not have the detail of the operations carried out in the name of the Clients.
- It does not have copies of the account statements received from abroad regarding the operations carried out in the name of the Clients.
- It does not have a record of orders instructed by the Clients.
- Given the type of operation, no policies were issued, since it operated in GPI's own position.
- No account statements were issued for the Clients. The documentation received consists fundamentally of copies of the checks received for the payments of profitability within the agreed terms.
- It does not have a copy of the records of global account controls that have been used specifically for the Clients.
- It attaches the Client Registration Form corresponding to the Clients;
On the charge formulated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds delivered in November 2013
- Before describing the details of the investments, it should be noted that Ms. Silva in her complaint of November 2, 2016 considered that she and her family were part of a special group in Mr. Arizmendi's circle, who were convinced to invest in GPI by a close family friend who worked at GPI and who told them that the investments were very good and that interest in foreign currency could reach or exceed 10% annually and that at that time a very close group of Mr. Arizmendi's circle was being formed and they considered this gentleman as the owner of GPI;
- In this regard, it should be noted that what Ms. Silva stated is related to the fact that, although Mr. Arizmendi ceased to be Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI since February 21, 2013, he subsequently maintained an active participation in the management of client funds, as also demonstrated in the case of Ms. Alvarez, due to his relationship as spouse of the main shareholder of the brokerage firm that holds 88.11% of the share capital, that is, Ms. Bellido-Tagle, and also due to his position as general manager of GPIAM, a company that is the second main shareholder of GPI with 11.88% of the share capital and that since February 18, 2013 had signed a contract to provide financial advisory services to GPI, so that Mr. Arizmendi permanently supports the brokerage firm, as stated in said contract;
- According to what Ms. Silva stated in her complaint and documentation attached to it, on November 15, 2013 Mr. Mario Gastañaga made two (02) interbank transfers to the Operating Account, for the amounts of US$ 25,000.00 and US$ 38,116.43, and indicates that the amount of US$ 36,883.57 from the Caja Rural de Cañete Promotora de Finanzas (Pro Finanzas) went directly to GPI, with which the investment totals US$ 100,000.00;
- Likewise, both Ms. Silva and GPI attach a receipt dated November 15, 2013 issued by said brokerage firm and signed by Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, Director and Representative of GPI, hereinafter Mr. Uccelli, in which it is stated that they have received from Ms. Silva and Mr. Mario Gastañaga the sum of US$ 100,000.00 to be invested under the following conditions: Yield: 10% annually, Term: 36 months, Accrual: Quarterly;
- In this regard, GPI states that the Clients' funds come from the cancellations of deposit certificates in municipal and/or rural savings banks, as well as deposits received in GPI's account at Banco Financiero;
- Therefore, it is proven with the documents presented by Ms. Silva that US$ 63,116.43 were credited to the Operating Account and that GPI states that the funds come from cancellations of deposit certificates from municipal and/or rural savings banks, which is related to what Ms. Silva stated regarding the amount of US$ 36,883.57 (balance to complete the US$ 100,000.00) coming from Pro Finanzas and going directly to GPI, so it is concluded that the entirety of US$ 100,000.00 was credited to the Operating Account;
Funds delivered in February 2014
- Ms. Silva states that the US$ 200,000.00 delivered to GPI on February 27, 2014 come from the Caja Rural de Cañete (Pro Finanzas) that went directly to GPI (no document attached), from two (02) interbank transfers, one from an account in the name of Ms. Silva and another from a joint account in the name of Ms. Silva and Mr. Mario Gastañaga (attaches bank statements proving withdrawals of funds from these accounts on February 25 and 26, 2014), to GPI's account, as well as a cash deposit to complete the indicated amount (no document attached);
- Likewise, both Ms. Silva and GPI attach a receipt dated February 27, 2014 issued by GPI and signed by Mr. Ucelli in which it is stated that they have received from Ms. Silva and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga the sum of US$ 200,000.00 to be invested under the following conditions: Yield: 10% annually, Term: 36 months, Accrual: Quarterly;
- On the other hand, according to account statements issued by Banco Financiero regarding the Operating Account for the month of February 2014, attached by GPI in its brief of November 8, 2016, it is proven that between February 24 and 28, 2014 transfers and deposits were made to the Operating Account for the total sum of US$ 200,000.00;
- Likewise, GPI states that the Clients' funds come from the cancellations of deposit certificates in municipal and/or rural savings banks, as well as deposits received in GPI's account at Banco Financiero;
- Therefore, GPI states and proves that the US$ 200,000.00 were credited by the Clients to the Operating Account;
On the destination of the resources
- Regarding the total investment of US$ 300,000.00, Ms. Silva states that no order or instruction was given;
- On the other hand, GPI states that with the Clients' money of US$ 300,000.00 it has operated on its own account abroad by selling options to obtain premiums and generate a flow of income,
- However, Ms. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, has stated that she does not have the record of orders given by the Clients, nor the policies of the operations carried out on own account, nor account statements in the name of the Clients, nor the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations on behalf of GPI. Therefore, said brokerage firm has not complied with providing such documents required by Oficio N° 6699-2016-SMV/10.3;
- It should be noted that according to the client registration form in the name of Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Ms. Silva, dated November 17, 2010, updated on February 22, 2013 for the inclusion of Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga, the order modality is: "Other modality subject to verification and confirmation";
- On the latter, it should be noted that GPI has not sent to date a copy of briefs, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, which prove the Clients' willingness to allocate their funds to investments in options which were carried out on GPI's own account;
- Regarding these option sale operations that would have been carried out in the foreign market on GPI's own account with the Clients' funds, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in this last case by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments;
- All these documents would prove the investments that would have been made in the foreign market with options, with the intervention of GPI and on own account of this brokerage firm, with the funds delivered by the Clients, however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI;
- It should be noted that GPI has also not proven that the funds owned by the Clients or the financial derivatives or the securities resulting from the execution of the options, in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI proving that the funds or financial derivatives or the securities resulting from the execution of the options are indisputable property of the Clients. Likewise, GPI has also not proven that these funds, financial derivatives or other financial instruments or securities are in the name of the Clients in a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required to provide the minimum documentation proving that it complied with the instructions given by the Clients, that is, proving that they had ordered that their funds be invested in the foreign market, in the sale of options;
- Likewise, through notarial letters delivered to GPI on September 26, 2016, attention to Ms. Bellido-Tagle, both Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Ms. Silva request that they comply with the payment of US$ 100,000.00 plus interest and US$ 200,000.00 plus interest, respectively;
- GPI did not prove with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding recitals, the investments in sale of options from November 2013 to February 26, 2014 with the amount of US$ 100,000.00 and then with the total accumulated amount of US$ 300,000.00 from February 27, 2014 to September 2016, or that it has destined them to another purpose; in none of the cases has it proven the destination of the money delivered by the Clients, so it is concluded that it would have destined it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- Likewise, it should be noted that in the Client Registration Form it is stated that the services requested by the Clients are only: "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Report Operations", "Capital market advisory (Peru)" and "Capital market advisory (international)". It is not stated that the Clients chose to indicate that GPI could carry out on their behalf "Operations with futures, options and derivatives";
- In the present case Ms. Silva states that the Clients credited US$ 300,000.00 to the Operating Account and although she states that no order or instruction was given, she also indicates that she invested her funds through GPI, so it was necessary that there be at least one order to make this investment according to the regulatory framework of brokerage agents, because the Clients have not been provided with portfolio management services; therefore, the Clients did not instruct that their funds be invested in the foreign market, even more so considering that the funds entered the Operating Account used by GPI for operations in the local market; nor did the Clients instruct that their funds be invested in the sale of options;
- In relation to the above, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and Ms. Bellido-Tagle would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since they received the funds delivered by the Clients for their custody and investment instructions given by said principals, and they have also not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi and Ms. Bellido-Tagle would have infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds owned by the Clients to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that in receipts issued by GPI, this former brokerage firm states having made supposed investments with the principals' funds, as presented below;
Table No. 1
Supposed Investment in the name of Mrs. Silva and Mr. Mario Gastañaga according to receipt issued by GPI, which has not been proven with the required documentation (in US$)
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | CREDIT | EXPECTED YIELD | INVESTMENT TERM |
| 11/15/2013 | 100,000.00 | 10% annually | 36 MONTHS |
Table No. 2
Supposed Investment in the name of Mrs. Silva and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga according to receipt issued by GPI, which has not been proven with the required documentation (in US$)
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | CREDIT | EXPECTED YIELD | INVESTMENT TERM |
| 02/27/2014 | 200,000.00 | 10% annually | 36 MONTHS |
- Regarding these investments shown in Tables No. 01 and 02, in the preliminary inquiry stage GPI has stated that the investment modality was for a term of thirty-six (36) months and sought the generation of premiums based on the sale of options abroad, in order to generate a flow of income;
- Likewise, according to documentation sent by GPI in the preliminary inquiry stage, it is observed that in the client registration form dated November 17, 2010 with client code No. CLIO1082, Mr. Mario Gastañaga appears as Holder and Ms. Silva as Holder 2. It should be mentioned that in the Client Registration Form dated February 22, 2013 with code CLIO1082, Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga appears as Holder 3 (handwritten numbering) (only his name appears and only he signs the mentioned form);
- Additionally, it should be noted that both forms were signed by the mentioned principals, in each case, as well as by Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, representative of GPI, it being noteworthy that in the form of November 17, 2010 the following is stated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Report operations", "Capital market advisory (Peru)", and "Capital market advisory (international)" and that in the Client Registration Form dated February 22, 2013, in addition to the mentioned items, the item "Off-exchange operations" is added; It should be noted that in an inspection of GPI's files[22], carried out on January 11, 2017, copies of the mentioned Client Registration Forms were also collected;
- Likewise, Ms. Silva states in her complaint that GPI told them that the investments they made were very good and that yields in foreign currency could reach or exceed 10% annually, which encouraged them to invest; furthermore, they state and prove that GPI has paid them US$ 25,000.00 (Twenty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the investment of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) and US$ 45,000.00 (Forty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the investment of US$ 200,000.00 (Two hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars);
- It should be noted that what GPI states regarding the investments that GPI claims to have made is not evaluated, considering that, despite the requirements formulated by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that proves the execution of the option sale operations, which explain the yields paid to the principals of US$ 25,000.00 (Twenty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the investment of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) and US$ 45,000.00 (Forty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the investment of US$ 200,000.00 (Two hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars); that is, the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the principals' funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the control records of global accounts, the policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds that Ms. Silva and Mr. Mario Gastañaga, as well as Ms. Silva and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga entrusted to them for custody and investment instructions given by them and that, according to both parties, amount to US$ 100,000.00, delivered in November 2013 and US$ 200,000.00, delivered in February 2014, respectively, as shown in Tables No. 1 and 2 of this resolution;
- The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) in one case and US$ 200,000.00 (Two hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) in the other, is proven by the documents (copies) presented by Ms. Silva and GPI: i) Interbank transfer vouchers destined to GPI's intermediation account, ii) Report issued by GPI stating the liquidation of term deposit certificate in the name of the principals, iii) Term deposit certificates, iv) Account statements of GPI's intermediation accounts proving the credit of the amount of the term deposit liquidation and other cash credits made by the principals, v) Letter signed by the principals requesting the financial entity that upon maturity of their term deposit the resulting amount be transferred to GPI's intermediation account[23], vi) Receipt signed by GPI regarding the funds received from the principals and vii) GPI letter presented to this Superintendency on November 8, 2016. The detail is shown in Tables No. 03 and 04;
Table No. 3
Proof of funds delivered by Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. María Silva Ruete to GPI (in US$)
| Date | Credit Amount | Credit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 11/14/2013 | 25,000.00 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | One (01) interbank transfer voucher from an account of Mr. Mario Gastañaga at BBVA Banco Continental and bank statement of Mr. Mario Gastañaga indicating the interbank transfer number and amount, destined to GPI's dollar intermediation account. |
| 11/15/2013 | 38,113.00 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | One (01) interbank transfer voucher from a joint account of Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. María Silva Ruete at Banco de Crédito del Perú, destined to GPI's dollar intermediation account. |
| 11/08/2013 | 36,887.00 | No. 317885693 at Banco Financiero | CD No. 4657 at CRAC Profinanzas S.A., in the name of Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. María Silva Ruete, dated 11/13/2012, for the amount of S/ 95,586.52 at a term of 360 days, at an interest rate of 8.25% and maturing on 11/08/2013. |
| Letter dated 11/08/2013 signed by Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. Silva, by which they request that, upon maturity of CD No. 4657, the amount resulting from the operation be transferred to GPI's soles intermediation account. The amount of US$ 36,887.00, which is missing to complete the US$ 100,000.00 delivered, results from dividing the amount of CD No. 4657 including interest (S/ 103,472.41) by the exchange rate of S/2.805/US$, which is related to the exchange rate of that date, according to the BVL Bulletin. | | | |
| Total Capital | 100,000.00 | - | Receipt issued by GPI dated November 15, 2013 signed by Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, as director of GPI, in which he states that they have received US$ 100,000.00 from Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. María Silva Ruete. |
| - | GPI letter dated 11/07/2016 by which it states that the funds come from the cancellations of term deposits in municipal and/or rural savings banks, as well as deposits received in GPI's account at Banco Financiero. | | |
Table No. 4
Proof of funds delivered by Mrs. Maria Silva Ruete and Mr. Anibal Gastañaga to GPI (in US$)
| | | |
|---|
| Date | Credit Amount | Credit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
| 02/25/2014 | 76,230.31 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | CD No. 1222 at CRAC Profinanzas S.A., in the name of Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. María Silva Ruete, dated 02/27/2013, for the amount of S/ 199,000.00 at a term of 360 days, at an interest rate of 7.95% and maturing on 02/22/2014. |
| Document presented by GPI stating the liquidation of CD No. 1222 for the amount of S/ 214,817.00, which at the exchange rate of S/ 2.818/US$ amounts to US$ 76,230.31. | | | |
| Bank account statements of GPI in Soles and Dollars, presented by GPI, proving the credits in Soles and then the exchange to Dollars. | | | |
| 02/26/2014 | 35,726.92 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | GPI current account statement in Dollars, presented by GPI, proving the credits made in the intermediation account. |
| 02/27/2014 | 9,920.32 | | |
| 02/27/2014 | 78,118.65 | | |
| 02/28/2014 | 3.80 | | |
| Total Capital | 200,000.00 | - | Receipt issued by GPI dated February 27, 2014, signed by Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, as director of GPI, in which he states that they have received US$ 200,000.00 from Mrs. María Silva Ruete and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga Silva. |
- Likewise, it should be noted that it is accredited that GPI has delivered to Mr. Mario Gastañaga and Mrs. Silva, between March 2014 and June 2016, US$ 25,000.00 (Twenty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the investment of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) and, to Mrs. Silva and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga, between June 2014 and June 2016, US$ 45,000.00 (Forty-five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for the investment of US$ 200,000.00 (Two hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), for the concept of returns on the investments that it states it has made, accredited in payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of Mr. Mario Gastañaga, in the case of the investment of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) and in the name of Mrs. Silva, in the case of the investment of US$ 200,000.00 (Two hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), with the corresponding acknowledgment of receipt, according to documentation sent by GPI and Mrs. Silva;
- As previously indicated, GPI states that it has carried out operations, however these have not been accredited by said former agent company before this Superintendency, therefore, this reflects that such operations were never carried out, which validly allows us to maintain that in reality such funds were disposed of for purposes not authorized by Mrs. Silva and Mr. Mario Gastañaga as well as by Mrs. Silva and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga;
- In this sense, in accordance with Article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, unless expressly authorized by the client and that such purpose refers to any of the operations indicated in Article 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not accredited the carrying out of the operations with the required documentation, it validly allows us to maintain that the funds delivered by Mrs. Silva and Mr. Mario Gastañaga, as well as by Mrs. Silva and Mr. Aníbal Gastañaga were disposed of for purposes other than those entrusted;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not disprove the present charge, and consequently, it was accredited that GPI incurred in one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; in accordance with what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2017-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is indicated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[24], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[25], among others, having participated in the facts described above, as part of a systematic mechanism that they used with several clients, since in practice as maximum administrative authorities of said agent company, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal handling of the funds of the clients of the former agent company, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, therefore it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referring to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mr. Cáceres
The Complaint
- In the complaint of November 4, 2016 presented before the SMV, Mr. Julio César Cáceres Rodríguez and his wife Mrs. Ana María Alvis Correa de Cáceres, hereinafter, the Clients[26] state that GPI has allocated US$ 130,000.00 that were delivered by them, to purposes other than the instructions they indicated to said agent company;
- In this regard, the Clients indicate that between 2011 and 2015 they delivered to GPI US$ 130,000.00 for the purpose of investing in derivatives and fixed income, in their name;
- However, the Clients add, that GPI did not deliver any policy or document to them that accredits the investment of the money delivered in financial instruments in their name, nor did it deliver account statements informing them of the returns on their investments, they only delivered internal reports of the payments of the returns offered, during the period from 2011 to 2015;
- Additionally, the Clients state, given the repeated non-payments of returns in 2016 by GPI and the lack of response from this stock brokerage agent company to their payment requests, the Clients sent on October 14, 2016 to said company a notarized letter, in order to have information on the destination of their funds;
- Likewise, they indicate that CAVALI S.A. ICLV, hereinafter Cavali, has informed them that there are no securities registered in the name of Mr. Cáceres Rodríguez in the Accounting Registry that institution administers;
- By writing presented on November 22, 2016, in response to Official Letter No. 6774-2016-SMV/10.3, the Clients state that they do not have any written proof that accredits the orders and instructions given to GPI for the use of the US$ 130,000.00 and that they have not signed any document with foreign intermediaries;
- Likewise, the Clients indicate that the only documents they received from GPI, where the destination of the funds delivered is reported, are those presented in their complaint writing of November 4, 2016:
- Document issued by GPI showing that the sum of US$ 60,000.00 was invested in PUT FAS January strike 28.33.
- Document issued by GPI in which it is indicated that the sum of US$ 80,000.00 was apparently invested in fixed income, since it is indicated that at maturity there will be a return of 1.8750%.
- Receipt issued by GPI in which it is indicated that the sum of US$ 50,000.00 was invested in fixed income, since it is indicated that the return will be quarterly at 36 months;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI by letter sent on November 16, 2016, stated that she has not provided the Clients with portfolio management service, that the investments were managed in an account in the name of GPI abroad, with knowledge of the Clients. She indicates that the investment modality was to generate a flow of income, which are investments abroad of a third party, not recorded as liabilities of GPI since they were not. Likewise, she stated the following;
- She does not have the detail of the operations carried out in the name of the Clients.
- She does not have copies of the account statements received from abroad regarding the operations carried out in the name of the Clients.
- She does not have a record of orders instructed by the Clients, with the exception of capital withdrawals requested regarding the investments or requests for payment of returns and the checks delivered to GPI.
- Given the type of operation, policies were not issued, since it operated in GPI's foreign account.
- Regarding the issuance and delivery of account statements to the Clients, she states that the documentation received by the Clients consists fundamentally of copies of the checks and deposit vouchers received for the payments of the requested return and capital withdrawals.
- She does not have a copy of the control records of global accounts that have been used specifically for the Clients.
- She attaches the Client Registration Form corresponding to the Clients;
On the charge formulated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds delivered by the Clients
- In accordance with what was stated by the Clients in their complaint and documentation attached to it, on January 5, 2011 they made two (02) interbank transfers to GPI's dollar intermediation account in the Operating Account, for the total amount of US$ 60,000.00;
- Likewise, on December 17, 2013 the Clients made one (01) interbank transfer to the Operating Account for the amount of US$ 20,000.00;
- Finally, on June 17, 2015 they made a deposit by manager's check to the Operating Account for the sum of US$ 50,000.00;
- Therefore, it is accredited with documents presented by the Clients that they credited a total amount of US$ 130,000.00 to the Operating Account between January 5, 2011 and June 17, 2015;
- In this regard, GPI and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI have not questioned the documents (copy of vouchers and manager's check) that accredit the credits of funds made by the Clients to the Operating Account;
On the destination of the resources
- Regarding the funds delivered of US$ 130,000.00, the Clients state that the purpose of this delivery of funds was that they be destined to investments in their name in derivatives and fixed income,
- In relation to the indicated, according to documentation sent by the Clients, GPI issued a report as of January 6, 2011 in which it is indicated that the amount of US$ 60,000.00 credited by the Clients (client code CLI01709) on January 5, 2011 was invested in their name, through the global account in Interactive Brokers LLC ("Interactive Brokers Bus Account"*), in sale of PUTs having an open position in 21 PUT contracts on FAS (ETF) at the exercise price of US$ 28.33 with maturity on January 21, 2011, with a total premium of US$ 1,260.00. According to the report, this would mean a return of 2.1% regarding the investment of US$ 60,000.00 at maturity. It should be noted that this occurs if the Clients at the maturity of the PUTs obtain the premium if the buyers of the PUTs do not exercise their put option;
- Likewise, GPI issued a report as of September 20, 2014 in which it is indicated that with the amount of US$ 60,000.00 credited on January 5, 2011 and the amount of US$ 20,000.00 credited on December 17, 2013, the Clients had an open position with a maturity on September 20, 2014 with a total premium of US$ 1,500.00. According to the report, this would mean a return of 1.8750% regarding the total accumulated investment at that date of US$ 80,000.00. It should be noted that the report does not detail the type of security or instrument, the price and quantity, however, since the report mentions the terms "open position", "premium" and "maturity", it would be an investment in options, which can be CALL or PUT;
- Finally, GPI issued a receipt dated June 19, 2015 signed by Mr. Ucelli in which it indicates that he has received from the Clients the amount of US$ 50,000.00 to be invested under the following conditions: Expected return: 10% annual; Term: 36 months; Accrual: Quarterly; Payment schedule: quarterly from September 30, 2015 to June 30, 2018. In this regard, the Clients state that this receipt indicates that the amount of US$ 50,000.00 was invested in fixed income, since it is indicated that the return will be quarterly at 36 months;
- Regarding the delivery of funds from the Clients and the investments that would have been made, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI only states that the investments were made abroad and were managed in an account in the name of the agent company abroad, not specifying the type of security or financial instrument in which they have invested;
- Likewise, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of GPI before the request made in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 6738-2016-SMV/10.3, states that she does not have the record of the orders given by the Clients, nor with the policies of the operations carried out, nor with account statements in the name of the Clients, nor with the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations abroad in the name of GPI. It should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the stock brokerage agent company and the Clients, must adhere to the provisions of the Regulation. According to the client registration form in the name of the Clients, dated September 15, 2014, the order modalities are: "Written" and "Other means authorized by SMV"*;
- On the latter, it should be noted that GPI did not send a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, that accredit the will of the Clients to destine their funds to investments in their name in this type of derivative financial instruments or other financial instruments or securities, made in 2011 through GPI's global account in Interactive Brokers LLC, according to a report issued by GPI, and later "in account in the name of GPI abroad", according to what was stated by GPI,
- In relation to the investments made with the Clients' funds, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of the agent company, provided in this last case by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments. These documents would accredit the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by the Clients, however, and as mentioned, this has not been accredited by GPI;
- It should be noted that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, GPI nor Mr. Arizmendi have also not accredited that the funds owned by the Clients or the financial derivatives or the securities product of execution of these or other financial instruments or securities, in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI accrediting that the funds or financial derivatives or the securities product of the execution of these, or other financial instruments or securities, are indisputable property of the Clients. Likewise, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, GPI nor Mr. Arizmendi, have also not accredited that these funds and/or financial instruments are in the name of the Clients in a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required the minimum documentation that accredits that it complied with the instructions given by the Clients and that accredits the investments made in their name with their funds;
- Likewise, the Clients by notarized letter delivered to GPI on October 14, 2016, attention to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, request a detailed report on which bonds and shares the US$ 130,000.00 that they credited to GPI are invested in;
- It should be noted that GPI did not accredit with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, including the request of the Clients, the investments from January 5, 2011 to December 16, 2013 with the amount of US$ 60,000.00 credited by the Clients, then with the accumulated amount of US$ 80,000.00 from December 17, 2013 to June 16, 2015 and, finally, with the accumulated amount of US$ 130,000.00 from June 17, 2015 to September 2016, made according to the instructions of the Clients or that it has destined them to another destination; in none of the cases has it accredited the destination of the money delivered by the Clients, therefore it is concluded that it would have destined it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- In relation to the exposed, it is clear that GPI, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would not have complied with the provisions of Article 48 of the Regulation since they received the funds delivered by the Clients for their custody and investment indications given by said principals, and has also not accredited the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would have infringed the provisions of Article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by destining the funds owned by the Clients to operations, purposes or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- On the other hand, it should be indicated that in reports issued by GPI, this stock brokerage agent company states that it has supposedly carried out operations or invested with the Clients' funds, as indicated below:
Table No. 1
Supposed operations in the name of the clients and settlement value according to report issued by gpi, which have not been accredited with the required documentation
| DATE | CREDITS | SETTLEMENT VALUE | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation | Value | Maturity | No. Contracts | Exercise Price | Amount / Exposure | Premium | | | |
| 01/05/2011 | 60,000.00 | - | | | | | | | |
| - | - | - | Sale PUT | FAS | Jan-21-11 | 21 | 28.33 | 60,000 | 1,260 |
| 12/17/2013 | 20,000.00 | - | | | | | | | |
| - | - | - | - | - | Sep-20-14 | - | - | 80,000 | 1,500 |
| 07/31/2016 | - | 43,014.00 | | | | | | | |
Table No. 2
Supposed Investment in the name of the clients according to receipt issued by gpi, which has not been accredited with the required documentation
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | CREDIT | EXPECTED RETURN | INVESTMENT TERM |
| 06/17/2015 | 50,000.00 | 10% annual | 36 MONTHS |
- Regarding the two (02) operations with options shown in Table No. 1 and the investment with an expected return of 10% annual in dollars at a term of 36 months shown in Table No. 2, in the preliminary inquiry stage, GPI has presented before the SMV on November 16, 2016 the Client Registration Form of the Clients signed on September 15, 2014 by the Clients and Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, representative of GPI, it is indicated as "Services Requested by the Client" the following: "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Report operations", "Advisory in capital markets (Peru)", and "Advisory in capital markets (international)";
- It should be noted that in the inspection carried out on January 11, 2017 to the files of GPI[27], another Client Registration Form signed on October 4, 2010 by the Clients and Mr. Héctor Ucelli was observed, where the same services contracted by the Clients are indicated in accordance with the form of September 15, 2014;
- Likewise, the Clients state that they delivered the funds for the purpose that GPI destine them to investments in derivatives and fixed income and as demonstrated in the receipt issued by GPI on June 19, 2015, the amount of US$ 50,000.00 was destined for fixed income investment, with an expected return of 10% annual, at a term of 36 months. On the other hand, GPI in the preliminary inquiry stage has stated that the investment modality was to generate income flows, that GPI operated in its own account abroad and tried to generate the agreed return;
- It should be noted that what was stated by GPI regarding the investments that it states it has made in the name of the clients is not evaluated, considering that, despite the requests made by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that accredits the carrying out of the operations indicated in Table No. 1 with the US$ 80,000.00 credited by the Clients and others that it would have made that explain the returns paid to the principals from 2011 to 2016 and that the settlement value of the investment amounts to US$ 43,014.00 as of July 31, 2016, as well as the investment with the US$ 50,000.00; that is, the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the Clients' funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the control records of global accounts, the policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not accredited the use of the funds that the Clients entrusted to it for custody and investment indications given by them and that, according to both parties, amount to US$ 130,000.00, delivered between January 2011 and June 2015;
- The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 130,000.00 is accredited by the documents that the Clients have presented such as a copy of the vouchers of interbank transfers, bank deposit and a receipt that certifies a deposit made in the bank account of GPI. The detail is shown in Table No. 3:
Table No. 3
Accreditation of funds delivered by clients to gpi (in US$)
| Date / Month | Credit Amount | Credit Account | Evidentiary documents (copies) |
|---|
| 01/05/2011 | 50,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero | One (01) interbank transfer voucher from an account of Mrs. Ana María Alvis Correa de Cáceres at Banco Interbank to the intermediation account of GPI. |
| 10,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero. | One (01) interbank transfer voucher from an account of Mrs. Ana María Alvis Correa de Cáceres at Banco Interbank to the intermediation account of GPI. A report issued and signed by GPI of January 6, 2011 in which it states, in addition to the operations made with derivatives in the name of the Clients, that on January 5, 2011 a credit of US$ 60,000.00 (US$ 50,000.00 plus US$ 10,000.00) was received | |
| 12/17/2013 | 20,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero | One (01) interbank transfer voucher from an account of Mrs. Ana María Alvis Correa de Cáceres at Banco Interbank to the intermediation account of GPI. A report issued and signed by GPI of September 20, 2014 in which it states, in addition to the exposure of the Clients' portfolio, that on January 5, 2011 and December 17, 2013, it received US$ 60,000.00 and US$ 20,000.00, respectively, which sums a total of US$ 80,000.00. |
| 06/17/2015 | 50,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero | One (01) deposit voucher of one (01) manager's check, issued by BBVA Continental in the name of GPI, in the intermediation account of GPI. |
| Receipt of June 19, 2015 issued by GPI signed by Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, in his capacity as director of GPI, in which he states that they have received US$ 50,000.00 in account CLIO1709 (registered in the name of the Clients in the Client Registration Form). | | | |
| Total Capital | 130,000.00 | | |
- Likewise, it should be noted that it is accredited that GPI has delivered from January 2011 to August 2016 to the Clients US$ 97,150.00 (Ninety-seven thousand one hundred fifty 00/100 United States Dollars) for returns on the investments it states it has made, accredited in payment receipts or payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of the Clients and signed by one of them, according to documentation submitted by GPI and the Clients;
- As previously indicated, GPI states it has carried out operations (according to its assertion, it would be understood that said company had carried them out), however these have not been accredited by said former agent company before this Superintendency, therefore, this reflects that such operations never occurred, which validly allows sustaining that in reality such funds were disposed of for purposes not authorized by the Clients;
- In this sense, in accordance with Article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent may not be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, unless expressly authorized by the client and provided that said purpose refers to any of the operations indicated in Article 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not accredited the execution of the operations with the required documentation, it validly allows us to sustain that the funds delivered by the Clients were disposed of for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for investments in accordance with the Client's prior instructions;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not rebut this charge, and consequently, it was accredited that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; and in accordance with what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 004-2017-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[28], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[29], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism they used with several clients, since in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said agent company, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal management of the funds of the clients of the former agent company, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, therefore it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referring to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- Regarding the complaint of Mrs. Roca
The Complaint
- Through writings presented to the SMV on November 28 and December 7, 2016, Mrs. Silvia Mariela Eugenia Roca Perales, hereinafter Mrs. Roca, states that in October 2011 she delivered to GPI a total of US$ 150,000.00: US$ 100,000.00 of her property and US$ 50,000.00 of property of her daughter, Mrs. María Luisa Gonzalez Roca, hereinafter Mrs. Gonzalez, for investments and attaches documents accrediting the delivery of this amount;
- In this regard, she attaches copies of client registration forms, one in the name of Mrs. Roca and another in the name of Mrs. Roca and Mrs. Gonzalez;
- On the other hand, she indicates that at the time of the delivery of the funds GPI told her that the money could not be disposed of in the short term, but required a reasonable time (minimum 3 years) to be able to withdraw it. She attaches a copy of the vouchers accrediting the payment of returns for the funds delivered;
- Likewise, she states that on June 23, 2014 she received an email from GPI with documents in English to open an account with the foreign intermediary Pershing LLC of the United States of America, hereinafter Pershing, through the servicing broker dealer[30] Bolton Global Capital, Inc., she indicates that these documents were sent completed and she was asked to sign them, for which they entered account number 39K-361259;
- In relation to the foregoing, she attaches a copy of a letter in English dated May 13, 2015 from Bolton Global Capital, Inc, addressed to Mrs. Roca, through which they inform her that as of May 7, 2015 GPI is not affiliated with Bolton Global Capital Inc., therefore GPI must very soon transfer the client's account to a new entity;
- She also attaches a copy of a letter signed by Mr. Ucelli on behalf of GPI dated August 26, 2015 addressed to the Embassy of the United States of America, through which they state that Mrs. Roca has been a client of GPI since January 2011 and maintains an investment account with custody of Pershing;
- Additionally, Mrs. Roca attaches a copy of a document issued and signed by GPI without date in which it is stated that the amount of US$ 100,000.00 delivered on October 7 and 14, 2011 (US$ 50,000.00 on each date), is invested in the name of Mrs. Roca (with client code CLI02225) in the global account that GPI has opened at Interactive Brokers LLC, hereinafter Interactive Brokers, and the portfolio consists of the sale of 100 put option contracts (Put) on FAS (ETF) at the exercise price of US$ 10 per ETF, with a total premium of US$ 3,000.00;
- Mrs. Roca also attaches a copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated September 20, 2014 in which it is stated that the amount of US$ 150,000.00 delivered on October 7, 14 and 21, 2011 (US$ 50,000.00 on each date), is invested in the name of Mrs. Roca and Mrs. Gonzalez (both with client code CLIO2225[31]) with a total premium of US$ 1,827 with maturity on September 20, 2014;
- Finally, Mrs. Roca states that she did not know what her money was invested in, that GPI gave her a list of the amounts they delivered from the returns of her funds (she attaches a copy of documents), but not of the funds she had delivered. She indicates that she has repeatedly requested information (she attaches a copy of emails) about her investment and that to date GPI has not sent her the requested information;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- It should be noted that through Official Letter No. 7093-2016-SMV/10.3 of November 29, 2016, the complaint filed by Mrs. Roca was transferred to GPI, as well as information and documentation was requested regarding the commercial relationship of the brokerage firm with Mrs. Roca and about the operations carried out in the name of this client, granting a period of three business days to present the information, which expired on December 5, 2016;
- Through a writing presented on December 7, 2016, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle on behalf of GPI requested this General Intendancy to extend the period granted through Official Letter No. 7093-2016-SMV/103, which was granted through Official Letter No. 7259-2016-SMV/10.3 sent to GPI on December 9, 2016, granting a period until December 9, 2016, it being necessary to indicate that to date, GPI has not sent the requested information;
Regarding the charge formulated against Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- According to documents presented by Mrs. Roca, she would have delivered US$ 50,000.00 to GPI on each of the following dates: October 7, 2011, October 14, 2011, and October 21, 2011; thus accrediting that together with her daughter, Mrs. Maria Luisa Gonzales Roca (Mrs. Gonzales), she initially invested in GPI US$ 100,000.00 (first two deposits), and then, jointly with her daughter, Mrs. Gonzalez, an additional US$ 50,000.00 (third deposit) and that the payments were made in GPI's intermediation accounts;
- Likewise, it should be noted that in the report issued and signed by GPI, which shows the first payments of US$ 50,000.00 each, dated October 7 and 14, 2011, the agent company states that the investments on behalf of Mrs. Roca would have been made through the global account in the name of GPI at Interactive Brokers. On the other hand, in the report issued and signed by GPI dated September 20, 2014, which shows the three (03) payments of US$ 50,000.00 each, dated October 7, 14 and 21, 2011, GPI does not indicate the global account through which the investments of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez would have been made;
- Regarding the foreign intermediaries that would have intervened in the operations on behalf of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez (joint account), Mrs. Roca has stated that she signed documents to open an investment account in her name at Pershing. Likewise, GPI has stated in a letter sent on August 26, 2015 to the Embassy of the United States of America that Mrs. Roca has an investment account with custody of Pershing;
- Finally, it should be noted that Mrs. Roca has not accredited that GPI has returned capital to her, she only accredits that GPI has paid her returns;
- Therefore, the total amount paid by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez to GPI for investment amounts to US$ 150,000.00;
Regarding the destination of the resources
- Regarding the funds delivered of US$ 150,000.00, Mrs. Roca has not mentioned or specified the orders that she, or later she and Mrs. Gonzalez, gave to GPI for the investment of their funds, nor does she attach documentation in this regard;
- Regarding the investments that supposedly would have been made with the funds of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez, it should be indicated that, according to documentation submitted by Mrs. Roca, in the same reports issued and signed by GPI in which this agent company recognizes the payments of money for the total amount of US$ 150,000.00, it states the operations that would have been carried out on behalf, first of Mrs. Roca and, then, of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez, with the same client code CLI02225, which are detailed in Table No. 01:
Table No. 1
Supposed Investments in the name of the clients (in US$)
| | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation Date | Operation Type | Value / Instrument | Quantity | Price | Premium | Investment Amount |
| ND | Sale of Options | PUTS on FAS (ETF), maturity 11/19/2011, strike US$ 10 | 100 contracts | 0.30 | 3,000.00 | 100,000.00 |
| ND | ND | Maturity 09/20/2014 | ND | ND | 1,827.00 | 150,000.00 |
ND: Not determined.
- What is indicated in the preceding table reflects, according to a report issued and signed by GPI, that this brokerage firm would have supposedly carried out at least two operations, one sale of Puts on FAS (ETF) with maturity in November 2011 for a total of US$ 100,000.00 and another operation for US$ 150,000.00 with maturity on September 20, 2014, which due to the indicated characteristics of "maturity" and "premium" would also have been an investment in options, although there is no information on the underlying value, quantity and exercise price;
- In this regard, GPI and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle have not responded to the request made in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 7093-2016-SMV/10.3, regarding whether it has the record of the orders given by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez, the policies of the operations carried out, the account statements in the name of these clients, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations abroad in the name of GPI or in the name of Mrs. Roca;
- On the other hand, there is an email from Mrs. Roca dated November 26, 2014 at 5:54 pm addressed to Mrs. Orlandini through which she requests the immediate withdrawal of her investments in order to obtain the invested funds, which is answered by the latter through an email of the same day at 06:14 pm in which she indicates that since the next day is a holiday, she will enter the request the following Monday and that there will be time if corrections are needed;
- It should be noted that Mrs. Roca has presented a copy of an email from March 14, 2016 at 9:31 am in which she requests Mrs. Orlandini information about her investments and requests an appointment in order to have more information. This request is also answered by email on March 15 of that year at 12:06 pm in which Mrs. Orlandini indicates that the next day the matter will be regularized and that her best advice is to wait and that in such cases it is best to act with a cool head;
- It should be noted that through an email of March 28, 2016 at 3:45 pm addressed to Mrs. Orlandini, Mrs. Roca requested a meeting regarding her investments and their future, a response that was sent by the former through an email of March 29, 2016 at 09:31 am in which she indicates that she should give her more time to have things clearer and to inform her properly and that she herself is waiting for certain management results;
- Through an email of April 22, 2016 at 8:17 am addressed to Mrs. Orlandini, Mrs. Roca requests information about her funds in order to make decisions and that she requires advice. The former responds on April 27, 2016 at 12:01 pm that she copies her response to Mrs. Lourdes Cárdenas so that she schedules a meeting with the Head of GPI to be able to answer Mrs. Roca's questions;
- There is also an email of August 8, 2016 at 4:54 pm addressed to Mrs. Orlandini in which Mrs. Roca requires her account statement, documents accrediting the ownership of the custody account, explanations on the risks and payment mechanisms of investment, among others. In response to such request, Mrs. Orlandini responds through an email of August 8, 2016 at 5:36 pm indicating that she will request the required information;
- There is an email from Mrs. Roca dated September 15, 2016 at 11:26 am addressed to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in which she states that she has an investment with GPI and asks when she will receive the check corresponding to September 2016 (referring to the payment of the agreed interest). Said email was answered by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle on the same day at 12:00 hours in which she states "indeed the payment dates vary but it is common in this type of investments we will communicate with you shortly". It should be noted that, through the same means, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle transfers Mrs. Roca's query to Mrs. Orlandini, who also by email of the same day at 12:53 pm indicates to Mrs. Roca "As we have explained we depend on market prices that allow the release of funds last month the check came out on August 18. These are variable income investments and these are complicated times. As soon as they release we will be communicating to deliver the check";
- Likewise, there is an email from Mr. Arizmendi dated November 7, 2016 at 05:25 pm addressed to Mrs. Roca and copied to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Ucelli and Mrs. Orlandini, in which he apologizes for the delay in the response and that he has asked Mr. Orlandini and Mr. Ucelli to prepare the information for immediate remission and that, as soon as he has it, he will call her by telephone;
- Mrs. Roca attaches another email from Mr. Arizmendi dated November 14, 2016 at 11:36 hours addressed to Mr. Sergio León (advisor of Mrs. Roca) in which he states that, in response to the request for the sending of the respective account statement in favor of the aforementioned client, Mr. Arizmendi orders that Mrs. Orlandini and Mr. Ucelli send the requested information on that date. It should be added that Mr. León's request was made on November 11, 2016 at 11:44 am and was addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Ucelli and Mrs. Orlandini and copied to Mrs. Roca;
- There is an email of November 25, 2016 at 10:13 am in which Mrs. Orlandini sends Mrs. Roca, by indication of the Management, the document called "Account Report". It should be noted that said email is copied to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle;
- Likewise, there is a letter of August 26, 2015 signed by Mr. Ucelli and addressed to the embassy of the United States of America in which they present Mrs. Roca as a client of GPI and state that said client has an investment account with custody at Pershing / Bank of New York No. 39K-361259;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the brokerage firm and Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez, according to the client registration form in their name, dated October 3, 2011, the modality of orders is: "Other modality subject to verification and confirmation";
- On the latter, it should be noted that GPI has not sent to date a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, accrediting the will of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez to allocate their funds to investments in derivative financial instruments indicated in Table No. 03 and other operations with securities and financial instruments that would have been carried out since October 2011 through GPI's global account at Interactive Brokers, according to a report issued by GPI, and since June 2014 that would have been carried out through Pershing using the account in the name of Mrs. Roca at this foreign intermediary;
- In relation to the investments supposedly made with the funds of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of the agent company, provided in the latter case by entities in charge of the execution of the alleged operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments. These documents would accredit the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by said clients;
- It should be noted that GPI has also not accredited that the funds owned by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez or the derivative financial instruments in which the funds would have been invested, indicated in Table No. 03, or the securities resulting from the execution of the latter, or other securities and financial instruments, in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are custodied by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in an entity abroad in the name of GPI accrediting that the funds, securities and financial instruments are indisputable property of Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez. Likewise, it has not accredited that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of Mrs. Roca and/or Gonzalez in an entity abroad;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required the minimum documentation accrediting that it complied with the instructions given by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez and accrediting the investments made in their name with their funds;
- To date, GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi, have not accredited with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments since October 2011 with the amount of US$ 150,000.00 paid by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez, which supposedly would have been made according to the instructions of these clients or that it has destined them to another purpose; in none of the cases has it accredited the destination of the money delivered by these clients, therefore it is concluded that it would have destined it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- In relation to the foregoing, it is clear that GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi in their capacity as de facto representative, would not have complied with the provisions of Article 48 of the Regulation since it received the funds delivered by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez for their custody and investment instructions given by said clients, and has also not accredited the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi would have infringed the provisions of Article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds owned by Mrs. Roca and Gonzalez to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
Regarding the discharges and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its discharges to the charge under analysis;
- Before evaluating the destination of the funds that GPI would have made, it should be specified that the two (02) Client Registration Forms were signed on October 3, 2011, one in the name of Mrs. Roca and another in the name of the Clients[32], identified with client code CLIO2225, and signed in both cases by Mr. Uccelli, Representative and Director of GPI at that time, and as stated by Mrs. Roca in the preliminary inquiry stage, the three (03) payments were on October 7, 14 and 21, 2011, that is, after the signing of both forms;
- It should be noted that in the inspection carried out on January 11, 2017 to GPI's files (hereinafter, Inspection), a third Client Registration Form was observed in the name of the Clients signed on September 23, 2014;
- Likewise, Mrs. Roca states that, guided by Mrs. Orlandini, she initially paid US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand 00/100 United States Dollars) to GPI and later US$ 50,000.00 (Fifty thousand 00/100 United States Dollars) belonging to her daughter Mrs. Maria Luisa Gonzales Roca, who, not having the minimum income amount of US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand 00/100 United States Dollars), would have chosen to pay said amount in the name of Mrs. Roca;
- Likewise, the reports issued by GPI of October 28, 2015 and October 12, 2016 in which the returns or interest paid as "withdrawals" are detailed, presented by Mrs. Roca in the preliminary inquiry stage, are only in the name of the aforementioned client; however some of the payment vouchers issued by GPI dated June, July and August 2013 are issued proportionally in the name of each of the Clients, while the vouchers issued from September 2013 to August 2016 are issued jointly in the name of the Clients;
- Once the clarification is made, it should be indicated that, in reports issued by GPI, this former brokerage firm would have supposedly carried out operations or invested with the Clients' funds with client code CLIO2225, as indicated below:
Table No. 2
Supposed Operations in the name of the clients according to the report issued by gpi, which have not been substantiated with the required documentation
| | | | | | | | |
|---|
| DATE / PERIOD | CREDITS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
| Operation | Value | Maturity | No. Contracts | Strike Price | Amount / Exposure | Premium | | |
| 07/10/2011 | 50,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 14/10/2011 | 50,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| Oct 2011 | - | Sale PUT | FAS | 19-Nov-11 | - | 10 | 100,000 | 3,000 |
| 21/10/2011 | 50,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 2014 | - | Open Position | - | 20-Sep-14 | - | - | 150,000 | 1,218 |
| Total Capital | 150,000.00 | | | | | | | |
- Regarding the two (02) operations with options and financial instruments shown in Table No. 2 at the preliminary inquiry stage, according to the documentation submitted by Mrs. Roca, in the two (02) Client Registration Forms signed on October 3, 2011, the following is stated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Advisory in capital markets (Peru)", and "Advisory in capital markets (international)"; likewise, the investment objective is stated as "preservation", "growth" and "income/revenues";
- It should be noted that as previously stated in the Inspection, a third Client Registration Form in the name of the Clients signed on September 23, 2014 by them and also by Mr. Uccelli was observed, in which, in addition to the services contracted by the Clients according to the form of October 3, 2011, the services of "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL" and "Report operations" are indicated; likewise, the same investment objective is maintained;
- Likewise, Mrs. Roca states that she spoke directly with Mrs. Orlandini, who informed her of a safe long-term savings with no risk, only that the money could not be disposed of in the short term but required a reasonable time (minimum 3 years), to later be able to withdraw it;
- It should be noted that what was stated by GPI is not evaluated, according to reports issued by this former stock brokerage firm submitted by Mrs. Roca, regarding the investments that it would have made in the name of the Clients. This considering that, despite the requirements made by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that accredits the execution of the operations indicated in Table No. 2, with the funds credited by the Clients in October 2011 and others that it would have made since October 2011 that would explain the yields paid to the principals from October 2011 to 2016 amounting to US$ 136,682.00 (One hundred thirty-six thousand six hundred eighty-two and 00/100 United States Dollars) and that the liquidation value of the investment would amount to US$ 80,277.50 (Eighty thousand two hundred seventy-seven and 50/100 United States Dollars) as of October 28, 2015, that is, with the account statements of the foreign intermediary that executed the operations with the Clients' funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled jointly with the global account control records, policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not accredited the use of the funds that the Clients entrusted to it for custody and investment instructions given by them and that, according to both parties, amount to US$ 150,000.00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), delivered in October 2011;
- It should be noted that the delivery of these funds in the sum of US$ 150,000.00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) is accredited by the documents submitted by Mrs. Roca and some gathered in the Inspection such as copies of the interbank transfer vouchers to GPI's intermediation account, copies of letters signed by persons authorizing the liquidation of their term deposit certificates and the transfer of funds to GPI, copy of the interbank transfer proof to GPI's intermediation account of the funds from the liquidation of the term deposits (also gathered in the Inspection), copies of emails from GPI confirming receipt of the funds and reports issued by GPI indicating the dates and amounts of the credits received from the Clients. The detail is shown in Table No. 3;
Table No. 3
Accreditation of funds delivered by the clients to gpi (in US$)
| Date | Credit Amount | Credit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 07/10/2011 | 50,000.00 | 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Email from Mrs. Roca addressed to Mrs. Paola Carranza of Los Portales S.A. dated October 3, 2011, by which she requests the transfer of US$ 50,000.00 to GPI's dollar intermediation account. |
| Email from Mrs. Roca addressed to Mrs. Orlandini dated October 6, 2011, by which she informs her that she has already sent the letter for the deposit to GPI and that it will be effective on October 7, 2011 for US$ 50,000.00 ordered by Los Portales S.A. | | | |
| Email from procesos@grupobbva dated October 6, 2011 addressed to Mrs. Roca indicating that they have processed an interbank transfer for the amount of US$ 50,000.00 from the remitter Los Portales S.A. to be credited to GPI's dollar intermediation account. | | | |
| Email from Mrs. Orlandini addressed to Mrs. Roca dated October 7, 2011, by which, in response to an email from the latter, she confirms receipt of the amount transferred to GPI's dollar intermediation account. | | | |
| Report signed by GPI without date. | | | |
| Report signed by GPI dated September 20, 2014. | | | |
| Document issued, signed and sealed by GPI dated October 4, 2011 gathered in the inspection in which it is indicated that Mrs. ROCA began her relationship with GPI by investing US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) | | | |
| 14/10/2011 | 50,000.00 | 317885693 at Banco Financiero | Two (02) letters dated October 3, 2011, one signed by Mrs. Arantxa Talía González Roca and another by Mrs. Micaela Cayetana González Roca, addressed to CRAC Chavín, by which they request the total cancellation of their fixed-term deposits and that they be transferred to GPI's soles intermediation account. |
| Email from Mrs. Roca addressed to Mrs. Orlandini dated October 6, 2011, by which she informs her that she has already ordered the deposits to GPI and that they will be effective on October 10, 2011 for S/ 168,000.00 ordered by CRAC Chavín. | | | |
| Email from Mrs. Paquita Liliana Noriega Ríos of CRAC Chavín dated October 12, 2011, addressed to Mrs. Roca, by which she indicates that she is sending her the transfer proof of the cancellations of her family's fixed-term deposits, according to her request. | | | |
| (DOCUMENT GATHERED IN THE INSPECTION). Transfer proof from CRAC Chavín's account at Banco de Crédito del Perú to GPI's soles intermediation account, for the amount of S/ 167,890.08 with the indication of beneficiary "Roca Perales Silvia Mariela Eugenia". | | | |
| Report signed by GPI without date. | | | |
| Report signed by GPI dated September 20, 2014. | | | |
| Document issued, signed and sealed by GPI dated October 4, 2011 gathered in the inspection in which it is indicated that Mrs. ROCA began her relationship with GPI by investing US$ 100,000.00 (One hundred thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) | | | |
| 21/10/2011 | 50,000.00 | 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Two (02) interbank transfer vouchers made on October 20, 2011, one for US$ 24,001.79 and another for US$ 26,001.88, ordered by Tecnología Forestal Plantar SAC to GPI's dollar intermediation account. |
| Email from Mr. Gonzalo Herrera, General Manager of Tecnología Forestal Plantar SAC, dated October 21, 2011, addressed to Mrs. Orlandini, by which he indicates that he attaches the vouchers for the two (02) deposits that total US$ 50,000.00. | | | |
| Email from Mrs. Orlandini, addressed to Mr. Gonzalo Herrera with a copy to Mrs. Roca, dated October 24, 2011, by which she confirms receipt of the funds. | | | |
| Report signed by GPI dated September 20, 2014. | | | |
| Total Capital | 150,000.00 | - | - |
| | | |
- As can be seen from the above table, part of the credits are supported by documents issued and signed by GPI, which are closely related to various reports submitted by other complainants before this Superintendency, because they have a similar format and structure: Internal client identification code, credits made by the client; information on portfolios, exposure and trading, similar signature and distinctive seal of GPI. Likewise, in some cases the sheet has a GPI letterhead and in others it does not, among other similar characteristics;
- Additionally, it is taken into account that reports with the same characteristics – both in format and design and with similar elements mentioned in the previous paragraph – have been submitted, in various cases, by GPI itself to this Superintendency;
- Likewise, through Official Letter No. 7093-2016-SMV/10.3, the aforementioned documentation was transferred to GPI and through Official Letter No. 7549-2016-SMV/10.3 charges were imputed to it, granting it in both cases a period to know its position on the matter; however, having elapsed in excess the periods granted to the aforementioned former brokerage firm, it has not complied with said requirements to date
- On the other hand, it should be noted that it is accredited that GPI has delivered from October 2011 to August 2016 to the Clients US$ 136,682.00 (One hundred thirty-six thousand six hundred eighty-two and 00/100 United States Dollars) for yields of the investments that it states it has made, accredited in a report signed by GPI dated October 28, 2015 (which indicates the payments made from October 2011 to October 2015), unsigned report dated October 12, 2016 (which incorporates the yields paid in November and December 2015 and in 2016), and payment receipts or payment vouchers since 2012 issued by GPI proportionally in the name of Mrs. Roca, Mrs. Maria Luisa Gonzales Roca or in the name of both principals, according to documentation submitted by Mrs. Roca;
- In that sense, according to Article 48 of the Regulation, the funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, except with express authorization from the client and that said purpose refers to any of the operations indicated in Articles 194 of the LMV;
- Consequently, since GPI has not accredited the execution of the operations with the required documentation, it validly allows us to maintain that the funds delivered by the Clients were disposed of for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for investments in accordance with the prior instructions of the aforementioned principals;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not disprove the present charge, and consequently, it was accredited that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; and according to what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 010-2017-SMV/10
- In that sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[33], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[34], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism that they used with several clients, since in practice as maximum administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal handling of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, so it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referred to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mrs. Colmenares
The Complaint
- Through writings submitted to the SMV on December 2, 6, 13, 19 and 26, 2016 and attached documents, Mrs. Ana María Serapia Colmenares Adrianzen, hereinafter, Mrs. Colmenares, states that in May 2012, together with her spouse, Mr. Carlos Teobaldo Lecca Arrieta, hereinafter, Mr. Lecca, they delivered to GPI US$ 100,000.00 for investments, both signing the respective Client Registration Form on May 11, 2012,
- Subsequently, in November 2012, they delivered an additional US$ 40,000.00 for investments. She attaches documents that accredit the delivery of these amounts;
- Mrs. Colmenares also states that from the beginning of the commercial relationship they were attended by Mr. Ucelli, who provided them with information about GPI and with whom they signed the corresponding client registration form;
- Likewise, she states that the Client Registration Form is the only document signed and provided for their relationship with GPI, that this intermediary never consulted them and much less did they give verbal or written instructions to GPI about the operations, only the instruction of capital preservation, which is indicated in the aforementioned form, and obtaining income;
- Mrs. Colmenares indicates that later, upon Mr. Lecca transferring his funds to her, a new Client Registration Form was signed on October 2, 2014 in which only she appears as holder. The principal states that in this form the conditions for capital preservation and obtaining income were reiterated and at that time GPI only indicated that the profitability could vary according to the behavior of the stock market, but that the capital was assured;
- Regarding the aforementioned, Mrs. Colmenares states that this is the fundamental aspect of her complaint filed against GPI before the Consumer Protection Commission of INDECOPI, regarding which she attaches a copy of the resolution admitting the complaint issued by said institution[35];
- This resolution additionally states that Mrs. Colmenares denounced before said body that in September 2015, GPI indicated that her capital was placed in operations "ProShares Short VIX – Term Futures-SVXY", and that this implied carrying out high-risk transactions, which was not authorized or instructed by her, and also contradicted what was agreed, so she requested the return of her money;
- Mrs. Colmenares adds that in April 2016, GPI informed her that as a consequence of the operations with "ProShares Short VIX – Term Futures-SVXY" her capital was reduced to US$ 78,000.00, so there was a decrease in her monthly income. Finally, she indicates that in May 2016 Mrs. Colmenares again requested GPI to return the entirety of her invested capital;
- Regarding her complaint, Mrs. Colmenares attaches copies of writings she sent to GPI dated May 2 and 18, 2016, as well as the notarial letter sent by the Bullard Falla Escurra Law Firm, in the name of Mrs. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, to GPI on June 8, 2016[36], and copies of the writings that this intermediary sent to Mrs. Colmenares dated May 9 and August 18, 2016[37];
- Regarding the letter of May 2, 2016, which is addressed to GPI and attention to Mr. Uccelli, Mrs. Colmenares states, among others, that said brokerage firm did not comply with the indications given by them, in the sense of investing with the objective of "preserving" having invested in high-risk financial instruments. It should be noted that through a letter of May 9, 2016, Mr. Uccelli, on behalf of GPI, responds to what was requested by Mrs. Colmenares, in which he states, among others, that said brokerage firm has invested in financial instruments according to what was explained and accepted by the clients, among which are derivatives;
- Regarding the letter of May 18, 2016, Mrs. Colmenares expresses her disagreement with what was stated by Mr. Ucelli in his response of May 9, 2016 and requests the return of the total principal;
- It should be highlighted that in the notarial letter sent to GPI on June 8, 2016, it is stated that the high-risk placements made by GPI regarding the capital of Mrs. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca were not informed, instructed or consented by them. It adds that at no time were they informed about the high risks of these operations, nor was their express authorization requested to carry them out. It also indicates that GPI has carried out high-risk operations discretionally, deviating from the instructions given by the principals to only carry out low-risk operations or oriented to preserve capital;
- Likewise, it should be noted that Mrs. Colmenares attaches a summary table dated April 22, 2016 on the capital placed, yield payments, capital value at that date and estimated value at maturity (January 2017) of the placement of the initial capital of US$ 140,000.00. She indicates that this table was given to her by GPI for the purpose of asking for an explanation of the reason for the reduction and repeated postponement of monthly yields;
- Finally, she attaches copies of receipts and payment vouchers received from GPI for yields in the name of Mrs. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca and some only in the name of the latter, until September 2014; and from October 2014 to April 2016 only in the name of Mrs. Colmenares;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- It should be noted that through Official Letter No. 7263-2016-SMV/10.3 of December 9, 2016, the complaint filed by Mrs. Colmenares was transferred to GPI, as well as information and documentation was requested regarding the commercial relationship of the stock brokerage firm with Mrs. Colmenares and on the operations carried out in the name of this client, granting it a period of three business days to present the information, which expired on December 15, 2016, it being necessary to indicate that to date neither GPI nor Mrs. Bellido-Tagle have sent the requested information;
On the charge formulated to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- According to documents submitted by Mrs. Colmenares, she and Mr. Lecca delivered to GPI the following amounts for investments:
- On May 11, 2012: US$ 100,000.00. She attaches as support;
- Copy of two (02) interbank transfer requests to Banco de Crédito del Perú from Mr. Lecca dated May 11, 2012 so that, charged to his account, two (02) transfers are made for US$ 50,000.00 each in favor of GPI in the Dollar Current Account at Banco Financiero del Perú No. 000-317885723 hereinafter Intermediation Account, as well as a copy of the respective transfer vouchers.
- Copy of document signed by GPI dated July 22, 2013 stating that on May 11, 2012 US$ 100,000.00 was received as capital from Mrs. Colmenares (client code CLIO2328).
- Copy of document signed by GPI dated April 22, 2016 stating that on May 11, 2012 US$ 100,000.00 was received as capital from Mrs. Colmenares (client code CLIO2389).
- On November 5, 2012: US$ 40,000.00. She attaches as support;
- Copy of Check No. 09721509 from Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. dated November 5, 2012 for the amount of US$ 40,000.00 in the name of GPI and copy of the deposit voucher of this cashier's check in the Intermediation Account.
- Copy of document signed by GPI dated July 22, 2013 stating that on November 5, 2012 US$ 40,000.00 was received as capital from Mrs. Colmenares (client code CLIO2328).
- Copy of document signed by GPI dated April 22, 2016 stating that on November 5, 2012 US$ 40,000.00 was received as capital from Mrs. Colmenares (client code CLIO2389);
- Therefore, Mrs. Colmenares has accredited that she delivered to GPI, together with Mr. Lecca, a total amount of US$ 140,000.00 as capital for investments;
- It should be highlighted that both Mrs. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca as well as GPI coincide in stating that the former delivered to the latter US$ 140,000.00 for investments;
- Finally, it should be noted that Mrs. Colmenares has not accredited that GPI has returned capital to her, she only accredits that GPI has paid her yields;
On the destination of the resources
- Regarding the funds delivered in the amount of US$ 140,000.00, Ms. Colmenares has not mentioned or specified the orders that she or Mr. Lecca gave to GPI for the investment of their funds, nor does she attach any documentation in that regard. She only states that the investment objective was capital preservation and obtaining income, as indicated in the Client Registration Form dated May 11, 2012, signed by her and Mr. Lecca, and in the Client Registration Form dated October 2, 2014, signed only by her;
- Regarding the investments that would have been made with Ms. Colmenares's funds, it should be noted that, according to documentation submitted by Ms. Colmenares, through a letter dated May 9, 2016 signed by Mr. Uccelli addressed to Ms. Colmenares, he states the following:
- The assets used throughout the duration of the investment have varied, according to the market situation on each occasion and each date, and may be instruments linked to general market indices such as the Standard & Poor's, sector indices such as the Financial Select Sector SPDR, product indices such as the Market Vectors Gold Miners, or other types of assets linked to indices, volatility, or market returns.
- The terms used vary from one month, or sometimes even less, to three or six months, and on the last occasion they were forced by the market to do so for a longer term. Both the asset and the term always depend on what, according to market behavior, the strategy can offer.
- By August 2015, the asset used in the operations was SVXY (ProShares Short VIX Short-Term Futures). The purchase obligations had a maturity of September 2015 at a price of US$ 80.00. On August 19, 2015, SVXY closed at a price of US$ 91.84, so the purchase obligation was within a risk range normally used in the operations they carry out. After bad news about the Chinese economy on that date, the markets plummeted, causing sharp falls; SVXY closed three days later at US$ 57.14 and after three more days closed at US$ 42.88. With this market situation and a purchase obligation in September at US$ 80.00, they were forced to postpone the operation to January 2017, in the same asset and at a price of US$ 85 (which is where the current obligation is), in order to try to protect the value and not be forced to buy at US$ 80 an asset whose price was US$ 42.00, which would have generated an immediate loss.
- Considering what was stated by Mr. Uccelli and information from some internet pages about financial assets[38], GPI supposedly would have made the following investments with Ms. Colmenares's funds:
- Sale of put option contracts (Put) on SVXY (ETF) with maturity in September 2015, at an exercise price of US$ 80. It is not stated in which month and year the operation was carried out.
Therefore, Mr. Uccelli states that the purchase obligation of the asset (which is generated for the investor who sells a Put of the asset) had a maturity in September 2015 at the price of US$ 80.00 and, since, from the end of August 2015, the price of the asset (SVXY) was at levels of US$ 42, had the Puts been exercised, it would have caused a loss for the investor selling the Puts, in this case Ms. Colmenares, by having to buy SVXY at US$ 80 when it was at US$ 42 in the market.
- Rollover of Puts on SVXY, which means repurchasing the sold Puts and selling Puts with a new maturity date and exercise price. It would have had to be carried out between August and September 2015;
- With this operation, the maturity of the put option contracts is postponed from September 2015 to January 2017 and the exercise price is modified from US$ 80 to US$ 85, thus avoiding being forced to buy assets at US$ 80 in September 2015 when their price was US$ 42;
- Notwithstanding that, following what was stated by Mr. Uccelli, we could consider that the previous operations that GPI would have carried out with the funds of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca since May 2012 would be options on certain types of ETFs[39], at least the last two operations carried out, including the rollover with maturity in January 2017, refer to options on ETFs, in this case SVXY (ETF);
- Therefore, it is appreciated that the commercial relationship, that is, the mandate of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, from May 2012 to October 1, 2014, and of Ms. Colmenares, from October 2, 2014, to GPI, to make investments, had a substantially different conduct regarding the investment objective of the clients, since GPI has acknowledged that in August 2015 Ms. Colmenares's funds were invested in short put option positions on ETFs and that it made a new investment in options with maturity in January 2017, which are investments that involve assuming high risks, when the initial instruction of Ms. Colmenares was to invest with the objective of capital preservation and obtaining income;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, on this last point, it should be noted that neither GPI nor Ms. Bellido-Tagle have responded to the request made in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 7263-2016-SMV/10.3, regarding whether it has the record of the orders given by Ms. Colmenares and/or Mr. Lecca, the policies of the operations carried out, the account statements in the name of these clients, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations abroad in the name of GPI or in the name of these principals;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that through a letter of August 18, 2016, that Mr. Ucelli addressed to Ms. Colmenares in response to the questions raised by the latter, the first of the named states that in the meeting that Mr. Arizmendi held with the lawyers of the aforementioned client (Estudio Bullard, Falla, Ezcurra), he explained that the market situation had harmed the value of the investment. This demonstrates the participation of both Mr. Ucelli and Mr. Arizmendi in handling Ms. Colmenares's case;
- It should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the client registration form in the name of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, dated May 11, 2012, is: "Other modality subject to verification and confirmation", and according to the client registration form in the name of Ms. Colmenares, dated October 2, 2014, it is "Other means authorized by the SMV";
- On this last point, it should be noted that neither GPI, nor Ms. Bellido-Tagle, nor Mr. Arizmendi have sent to date a copy of writings, emails, or other forms of transmission of instructions, that prove the willingness of Ms. Colmenares to allocate her funds to investments in derivative financial instruments in August or September 2015 until January 2017, or that prove the willingness of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca to allocate their funds to other operations with securities and financial instruments, including derivatives, that would have been carried out since May 2012;
- With regard to the investments made with the funds delivered by Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, which since October 2, 2014 became solely the property of Ms. Colmenares, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in this last case by foreign entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments. These documents would prove the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by said clients; however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI;
- It should be noted that GPI has also not proven that the funds owned by Ms. Colmenares or the derivative financial instruments (options) in which such funds supposedly would have been invested, or the securities resulting from the eventual execution of the latter, or other securities and financial instruments, in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI, proving that the funds, securities, and financial instruments are indisputably the property of Ms. Colmenares. Likewise, it has not proven that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of Ms. Colmenares in a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required to provide the minimum documentation proving that it complied with the instructions given by Ms. Colmenares and/or Mr. Lecca until October 2014, and by Ms. Colmenares from October 2014 to 2016, and proving the investments made in their name with their funds;
- To date, GPI has not proven with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments made since May 2012 with the amount of US$ 100,000.00 and since November 2012 with the total amount of US$ 140,000.00 in accordance with the instructions of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca for capital preservation and obtaining income, as indicated in the Client Registration Form of May 11, 2012; that is, whether the funds were allocated to investments in options on ETFs or whether they were allocated to another purpose, in neither case has it proven the destination of the money delivered by these clients, so it is concluded that it would have been allocated to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- It should be noted that in the present case, Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca paid US$ 140,000.00 to the Intermediation Account and, as they state, the only instruction was that indicated in the Client Registration Form signed by them on May 11, 2012 as investment objective, that is, capital preservation and obtaining income, an instruction that was maintained in the Client Registration Form signed only by Ms. Colmenares on October 2, 2014;
- With regard to the foregoing, GPI, Ms. Bellido-Tagle, and Mr. Arizmendi, in their capacity as de facto representative, would not have complied with the provisions of Article 48 of the Regulation, since it received the funds delivered by Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca for their custody and investment instructions given by said clients, and has also not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Ms. Bellido-Tagle, and Mr. Arizmendi would have infringed the provisions of Article 195, numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds initially owned by Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, and later only by Ms. Colmenares, to operations, purposes, or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted,
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- On the other hand, according to a letter from Mr. Uccelli dated May 9, 2016, this former stock brokerage firm states that it supposedly carried out operations with options as indicated below:
Table No. 1
Supposed operations in the name of the clients according to a report issued by GPI, which have not been proven with the required documentation
| | | | | | | | | |
|---|
| DATE / PERIOD | DEPOSITS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | | |
| Operation | Value | Maturity | No. Contracts | Exercise Price | Amount / Exposure | Premium | | | |
| 05/11/2012 | 100,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 11/05/2012 | 40,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 2015 | - | Sale PUT | SVXY | Sep 2015 | - | 80 | - | - | |
| Aug - Sep 2015 | - | Repurchase PUT (Rollover) | SVXY | - | - | - | - | - | |
| Aug - Sep 2015 | - | Sale PUT (Rollover) | SVXY | Jan-17 | - | 85 | - | - | |
| Total Capital | 140,000.00 | | | | | | | | |
- Regarding these supposed operations with options (sale of Puts) shown in Table No. 1, in the preliminary inquiry stage, Ms. Colmenares has presented to the SMV the Client Registration Forms of Mr. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca signed, the first in the name of both on May 11, 2012, and the second signed only by Ms. Colmenares on October 2, 2014, it being noted that both forms were signed by Mr. Uccelli, in which the following is indicated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Repo operations", "Advisory in capital markets (Peru)", and "Advisory in capital markets (international)"; likewise, in these forms the investment objective is indicated as "preservation" and "income/earnings";
- It should be noted that in the inspection carried out on January 11, 2017, of GPI's files[40], the two aforementioned client registration forms signed on May 11, 2012 and October 2, 2014 were observed;
- Likewise, Ms. Colmenares states that in the second form the conditions for capital preservation and obtaining income were reiterated and at that time GPI only told them that the profitability could vary according to the behavior of the stock market, but that the capital was assured. Furthermore, in the notarized letter sent to GPI on June 8, 2016, by the lawyers of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, it is stated that the high-risk placements made by GPI with respect to the capital of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca were not informed, instructed, or consented to by them. It adds that at no time were they informed about the high risks of these operations, nor was their express authorization requested to carry them out. It also indicates that GPI has carried out high-risk operations discretionally, deviating from the instructions given by the principals to only carry out low-risk operations or operations aimed at preserving capital;
- It should be noted that what was stated by GPI, according to a letter from Mr. Uccelli dated May 9, 2016, regarding the investments that it states it made in the name of Ms. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca from May 11, 2012 to October 1, 2014, and in the name of Ms. Colmenares from October 2, 2014, is not evaluated, considering that despite the requests made by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that proves the carrying out of the operations indicated in Table No. 1 and others that it would have carried out that could explain the yields paid to the principals from June 2012 to April 2016, that is, the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the funds of Mr. Colmenares and Mr. Lecca, and that later became the property solely of Ms. Colmenares, of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the control records of global accounts, the policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds that the Clients delivered to said company in May and November 2012 for a total of US$ 140,000.00 and that since October 2, 2014 belong entirely to Ms. Colmenares and that have been entrusted for custody and investment instructions given by her and that, according to both parties, amount to US$ 140,000.00, delivered in May and November 2012;
- The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 140,000.00 is proven by the documents presented by the Client, such as a copy of the bank vouchers for the deposit of a cashier's check and interbank transfer, interbank transfer request forms, a copy of a check with the date, signature, and GPI reception logo, and a copy of reports signed by GPI. The detail is shown in Table No. 2;
Table No. 2
Proof of funds delivered by clients to GPI (in US$)
| Date | Deposit | Deposit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 05/11/2012 | 50,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero | One (01) interbank transfer request form signed by Mr. Lecca and one (01) interbank transfer voucher from an account of Mr. Lecca at Banco de Crédito del Perú to the intermediation account of GPI. |
| 50,000.00 | One (01) interbank transfer request form and one (01) interbank transfer voucher from an account of Mr. Lecca at Banco de Crédito del Perú to the intermediation account of GPI. | | |
| 11/05/2012 | 40,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero | One (01) cashier's check, issued by BBVA Banco Continental in the name of GPI and (01) deposit voucher of this cashier's check in the intermediation account of GPI. |
| Total Capital | 140,000.00 | - | Document signed by GPI on July 22, 2013, stating that US$ 140,000.00 was received as capital from the Clients (code CLIO2328). |
| Document signed by GPI on April 22, 2016, stating that US$ 140,000.00 was received as capital from Colmenares (code CLIO2389). | | | |
- Likewise, it should be noted that it is proven that GPI has delivered from June 2012 to September 2014 to the Clients and from October 2014 to April 2016 to Ms. Colmenares the total sum of US$ 78,862.00 for yields from the investments that it states it has made, proven as indicated, regarding the periods, in the writing of December 19, 2016, of Ms. Colmenares, in reports signed by GPI on July 22, 2013 and April 22, 2016, and receipts or vouchers of payment issued by GPI in the name of the Clients or in the name of Ms. Colmenares, according to the period indicated above, some of these with acknowledgment of receipt by the principals, according to documentation submitted by the Client in her complaint;
- As stated above, according to the letter of Mr. Uccelli dated May 9, 2016, GPI states that it carried out operations; however, these have not been proven by said former brokerage firm before this Superintendency, which allows validly maintaining that in reality such funds were used for unauthorized purposes, first by the Clients and then by Ms. Colmenares;
- In this sense, according to Article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, unless expressly authorized by the client and that said purpose is related to any of the operations indicated in Article 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not proven the carrying out of the operations with the required documentation, it can be validly maintained that the funds delivered by the Clients in May and November 2012 for a total of US$ 140,000.00 and that since October 2, 2014 belong entirely to Ms. Colmenares[41], were used for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for investments according to the prior instructions, first of the Clients and, from October 2, 2014, of Ms. Colmenares;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not rebut this charge, and consequently, it was proven that GPI incurred one (1) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; and in accordance with what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 009-2017-SMV/10.3;
- In this sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals proves, in addition to the concerted action of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Ms. Bellido-Tagle[42], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[43], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism that they used with several clients, since in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal management of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm; however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, so it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction related to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mr. Lorelli
The Complaint
- Through a writing presented to the SMV on December 9, 2016, Mr. Roberto Lorelli (hereinafter, Mr. Lorelli) submits a copy of the notarized letter that he sent to GPI on December 7, 2016, attention to Mr. Arizmendi and Ms. Bellido-Tagle, by which he requests the liquidation and return of the invested capital for a total of US$ 105,000.00. In this writing, Mr. Lorelli states that, in October 2016, Mr. Arizmendi made a commitment to him to return his money;
- Then, through a writing presented on December 16, 2016, Mr. Lorelli attaches copies of documents issued and signed by GPI, in which this stock brokerage firm acknowledges the receipt of funds from this principal from November 2012 to August 2013 for an amount greater than that indicated by Mr. Lorelli in his first writing, as well as a copy of a deposit voucher to an account in the name of GPI from November 2012 and a copy of the Client Registration Form of Mr. Lorelli dated April 19, 2010;
- Additionally, it should be noted that in the copies of the documents issued and signed by GPI indicated in the preceding paragraph, referring to the situation of the investment portfolio made in the name of Mr. Lorelli (with client code CLI01528), positions of investments in sale of put options (Puts) are indicated;
Arguments of GPI in the preliminary inquiries
- It should be noted that through Official Letter No. 7281-2016-SMV/10.3 of December 12, 2016, the complaint presented by Mr. Lorelli was transferred to GPI, and information and documentation were requested regarding the commercial relationship of the brokerage firm with Mr. Lorelli and the operations carried out in the name of this client, granting a period of three business days to present the information, which expired on December 15, 2016, it being noted that to date, GPI has not sent the requested information;
On the charge formulated against Ms. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- Mr. Lorelli delivered to GPI the amounts detailed below for investment purposes;
- On November 5, 2012: US$ 51,000.00 and November 12, 2012: US$ 31,765.87 and US$ 22,323.45. Attached as support;
- Copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated November 12, 2012, referring to the portfolio situation of the investments made in the name of Mr. Lorelli (client code CLIO1528), which states that on November 5, 2012 a (01) deposit of US$ 51,000.00 was received from this client and on November 12, 2012 two (02) deposits were received, one for US$ 31,765.87 and another for US$ 22,323.45.
- Copy of the voucher for the cash deposit in the amount of US$ 51,000.00 made on November 9, 2012 to the Current Account in Dollars at Banco Financiero del Perú No. 000-317885723 in the name of GPI, which was GPI's dollar intermediation account at that date.
- Copy of a document issued and signed by GPI stating that on November 12, 2012, before the maturity of the deposit term, two (02) certificates of deposit in the name of Mr. Lorelli at Caja Rural de Ahorro y Crédito Profinanzas with deposit dates July 1 and 31, 2012 at a term of approximately one year[44] were liquidated, one for the amount of US$ 31,765.87 and another for the amount of US$ 22,323.45.
It should be noted that the amounts and date of these certificate of deposit liquidations that GPI acknowledges in one report coincide with the amounts and date of the deposits that this brokerage firm acknowledges in another report having received on November 12, 2012 from Mr. Lorelli;
- On April 15, 2013: US$ 15,000.00. Attached as support is a copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated April 28, 2013, referring to the portfolio situation of the investments made in the name of Mr. Lorelli (client code CLIO1528), which states that on April 15, 2013 a (01) deposit of US$ 15,000.00 was received from this client;
- On August 8, 2013: US$ 99,915.00. Attached as support is a copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated August 14, 2013 called "Account Movements" of Mr. Lorelli (client code CLIO1528).
- Therefore, Mr. Lorelli has proven that he invested in GPI a total amount of US$ 220,004.32 from November 12, 2012 to August 8, 2013 and these amounts have been acknowledged by GPI, according to documents issued and signed by this brokerage firm;
On the destination of the resources
- With regard to the funds delivered for US$ 220,004.32, Mr. Lorelli has not mentioned or specified the orders he instructed to GPI for the investment of his funds, nor does he attach documentation in this regard;
- Regarding the investments that would have been made with Mr. Lorelli's funds, it should be noted that, according to documentation submitted by Mr. Lorelli, in the report issued and signed by GPI dated April 28, 2013 in which this brokerage firm acknowledges the cash deposits up to April 15, 2013 for US$ 120,089.32, it indicates the operation that would have been carried out on behalf of Mr. Lorelli, with client code CLI01528, which refers to a sale of Put options on NUGT (ETF) expiring on May 18, 2013 with an investment (exposure) of US$ 105,000.00 and a total premium of US$ 1,575.00;
- What is indicated in the previous recital reflects, according to a report issued and signed by GPI, that this brokerage firm would have carried out at least one operation on behalf of Mr. Lorelli, a sale of Puts on NUGT (ETF) expiring in May 2013 for a total of US$ 105,000.00;
- In this regard, GPI and Ms. Bellido-Tagle have not responded to the request made in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 7281-2016-SMV/10.3, regarding whether it has the record of the orders given by Mr. Lorelli, the policies of the operations carried out, the account statements in the name of this client, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations abroad in the name of GPI or in the name of Mr. Lorelli. It should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the brokerage firm and Mr. Lorelli, according to the Client Registration Form dated April 19, 2010, is: "Other modality subject to verification and confirmation";
- On the latter, it should be noted that GPI and Ms. Bellido-Tagle have not submitted to date a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, which prove Mr. Lorelli's willingness to allocate his funds to investments in derivative financial instruments such as the sale of Puts on NUGT (ETF) and other operations with securities and financial instruments that would have been carried out since November 2012;
- With regard to the investments made with Mr. Lorelli's funds, GPI has not submitted to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in the latter case by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments. These documents would prove the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by said client, however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI;
- GPI has also not proven that the funds owned by Mr. Lorelli or the derivative financial instruments in which the funds would have been invested (sale of Puts) or the securities resulting from the execution of the latter, or other securities and financial instruments in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI proving that the funds, securities and financial instruments are indisputable property of Mr. Lorelli. Likewise, it has not proven that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of Mr. Lorelli in a foreign entity;
- Likewise, in the present case and like the previous ones, the active participation of Mr. Arizmendi in the management of the funds or the management of the investments that would have been made in the name of Mr. Lorelli is evident, however, and despite the information requests by this Superintendency that prove the destination of the funds or the operations carried out, this has not been proven to date;
- To date, GPI has not proven with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments in the name of Mr. Lorelli from November 2012 to April 14, 2013 with the amount of US$ 105,089.32; then, with the amount of US$ 120,089.32 from April 15 to August 7, 2013; and, finally, with the amount of US$ 220,004.32 from August 8, 2013 to 2016, made according to the instructions of this client or that it has destined to another destination; in none of the cases has it proven the destination of the money delivered by this client, so it is concluded that it would have destined it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- In relation to the above, it is clear that GPI, Ms. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi in their capacity as de facto representative, would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since it received the funds delivered by Mr. Lorelli for their custody and investment instructions given by said client, and has also not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Ms. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi would have infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds owned by Mr. Lorelli to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- On the other hand, GPI states that it supposedly carried out at least one operation or invested with the Client's funds[45], as indicated below:
Table No. 1
Supposed operations with options in the name of the client and balance of investments according to report issued by gpi, which have not been proven with the required documentation (in US$)
| DATE | DEPOSITS | BALANCE OF INVESTMENTS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation | Value | Expiration | No. Contracts | Exercise Price | Amount / Exposure | Premium | | | |
| 11/12/2012 | 105,089.32 | 105,089.32 | | | | | | | |
| - | - | - | Sale PUT | NUGT | 18-May-13 | - | - | 105,000 | 1,575 |
| 04/28/2013 | 120,089.3 | 121,664.32 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
- Regarding this supposed operation with options (sale of Puts) that, according to a report issued by GPI, it has carried out, it should be noted that in the Annex of the Client Registration Form of the client signed on April 19, 2010, presented by the Client, the following is stated as "Services requested by the Client": "Purchase/sale of securities on the BVL, repurchase operations, capital market advisory (Peru) and capital market advisory (International)";
- It should be noted that said operation is not evaluated, considering that, despite the requests made by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the documentation that supports the carrying out of the sale of Puts operation indicated in Table No. 01 and the balance of investments (including the profit from the premium for the sale of the Put option) as of April 28, 2013 and others that it would have carried out since it received the first deposit of funds from the Client, in November 2012, that is, the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the Client's funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the records of global account controls, the policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds that the Client entrusted to them for custody and investment instructions given by him and that, according to what was stated by the Client and that has not been questioned by GPI in the preliminary inquiry stage nor after the notification of the Charge Letter, amounts to at least US$ 105,000.00 (One hundred five thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) at least from November 2012 to 2016;
- The delivery of these funds by the Client is proven by the documentation presented by the Client in the preliminary inquiry stage, referring to a (01) voucher of cash deposit of a part of those funds and to documents issued and signed by GPI that account for the total funds delivered by the Client. Likewise, the Client also presents documentation referring to reports issued by GPI that account for payments that GPI has made in favor of the client for yields. The detail is shown in Table No. 2:
Table No. 2
Proof of funds delivered by client to gpi (in US$)
| Date | Deposit Amount | Deposit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 11/09/2012 | 51,000.00 | No. 317885723 | One (01) cash deposit voucher for US$ 51,000.00 dated 11/09/2012 in GPI's intermediation account. |
| - | Document issued and signed by GPI dated 11/12/2012 regarding the Client's portfolio. | | |
| 11/12/2012 | 31,765.87 | - | Document issued and signed by GPI stating that two (02) certificates of deposit (CDs) No. 3128 dated 07/01/2012 and No. 3137 dated 07/31/2012 in the name of the Client at CRAH Profinanzas S.A. were liquidated before maturity. These CDs are attached. |
| 22,323.45 | | Document issued and signed by GPI dated 11/12/2012 regarding the Client's portfolio. | |
| 04/15/2013 | 15,000.00 | - | Document issued and signed by GPI dated 04/28/2013 regarding the Client's portfolio. |
| 08/08/2013 | 99,915.00 | - | Document called "Account Movements" of the Client issued and signed by GPI dated 08/14/2013. |
| Total | 220,004.32 | - | - |
- As can be seen from the previous table, the deposits, except for the US$ 51,000.00 for which a cash deposit voucher is counted as support, are supported only by documents issued and signed by GPI, which are closely related to various reports presented by other complainants before this Superintendency, because they have a similar format and structure: Internal client identification code, deposits made by the client; information on portfolios, exposure and trading, similar signature and distinctive seal of GPI. Likewise, in some cases the sheet has a GPI letterhead and in others it does not, among other similar characteristics;
- Additionally, it is taken into account that reports with the same characteristics – both in format and design and with similar elements mentioned in the previous paragraph – have been presented, in various cases[46], by GPI itself to this Superintendency;
- Likewise, through Official Letter No. 7281-2016-SMV/10.3 the aforementioned documentation was transferred to GPI and through Official Letter No. 085-2017-SMV/10.3 charges were imputed to it, granting in both cases a period to know its position on the matter; however, having elapsed in excess the periods granted to the aforementioned former brokerage firm, it has not complied with said requirements to date;
- Likewise, it should be noted that from the document called "Account Movements" of the Client dated 08/14/2013 issued by GPI and presented by the client in its complaint, a total amount for yields of the investments made on behalf of the client amounting to US$ 9,658.00 (Nine thousand six hundred fifty-eight and 00/100 United States Dollars) is identified;
- As previously indicated, in a report issued and signed by GPI, it states that it has carried out at least one operation (according to the report, said firm states that it would have carried them out); however, this has not been proven by GPI with the documentation required in the preliminary inquiry stage and in the Charge Letter, therefore, this reflects that such operation with options and other operations with securities and financial instruments, which would explain the yields paid by GPI to the Client, never took place, which allows us to validly maintain that in reality the funds delivered by the Client were used for purposes not authorized by him;
- In this sense, according to article 48 of the Regulation, the funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, unless expressly authorized by the client and that said purpose refers to any of the operations indicated in articles 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not proven the carrying out of the operations with the required documentation, it allows us to validly maintain that the funds delivered by the Client were used for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for investments according to the Client's prior instructions;
- Consequently, it was concluded that GPI did not disprove the present charge, and therefore, it was proven that GPI incurred in one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation; and according to what was resolved by SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 005-2017-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is indicated in the preceding recitals proves, in addition to the concerted action of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Ms. Bellido-Tagle[47], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[48], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism that they used with several clients, since in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal management of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, so it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referred to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mr. and Mrs. Urday
The Complaint
- Through a document presented to the SMV on December 23, 2016, Mr. Pedro Rodolfo Félix Urday Berenguel and Mrs. Carmen Beatriz Natividad Zegarra de Urday, hereinafter Mr. and Mrs. Urday, denounce GPI for negligence in the management of their funds;
- Mr. and Mrs. Urday state that they have been clients of GPI since 2007 and that since May 2011 they transferred their funds, which were in time deposits in savings and credit unions, to a new investment alternative that, according to GPI executives, was very safe and convenient for them and required a minimum entry amount of US$ 100,000.00, so convinced of this they chose to invest US$ 40,000.00 in May 2011, US$ 64,670.11 in June 2011, from a cancellation of a time deposit certificate in CRAC Profinanzas (for S/ 180,382.59), US$ 40,743.69 in August 2011, from a cancellation of a time deposit certificate in CMAC Paita (for S/ 112,241.44) and, finally, US$ 45,080.50 in September 2013. In sum, the invested amount amounts to US$ 190,494.90;
- Mr. and Mrs. Urday add that at all times they assumed that the investment alternative they accessed followed the principle of capital preservation, which characterized their investments from the beginning of the relationship with GPI. However, since August 2015 they did not receive periodic income or received a lower income and in October 2015 they received a document from GPI in which they were given to understand that their funds had been reduced by half, since they showed a liquidation value close to half the value of their initial contributions. They attach a copy of the document;
- Mr. and Mrs. Urday state that on February 4, 2016 they had a meeting with Mr. Arizmendi at GPI's offices and he assured them that the losses suffered by their funds would be reversed in the following months, that he made an analysis of the global economic situation and told them about the benefits of the investment strategy applied;
- Mr. and Mrs. Urday add that at the end of 2016, after the suspension of GPI's negotiations by the SMV, in a meeting with Mr. Arizmendi, he explained that the investment of their funds had been made following a strategy through which GPI grouped the funds of several clients in an "omnibus" account that this brokerage firm opened in an investment bank abroad in the name of GPI, and from which they invested "short" in an index called "Short Term XIV", while selling Put options on the same index. Finally, the money from the premiums obtained from the sale of Puts was used to pay income to GPI's clients;
- Mr. and Mrs. Urday also state that the investment strategy used by GPI with their funds corresponds more to a Hedge Fund strategy, due to the high risk involved and the sophistication of the strategy used. These types of investments are usually used and offered to expert investors, who also tend to seek non-traditional alternatives to profit from their funds and are also willing to assume high risks. They state that in their case, GPI did not take into account their level of knowledge of the securities market, their risk profile or their investment objective when allocating their funds to its "Short Term VIX" short and Put sale strategy;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- It should be noted that through Official Letter No. 7519-2016-SMV/10.3 dated December 27, 2016, the complaint presented by Mr. and Mrs. Urday was transferred to GPI, as well as information and documentation was requested regarding the commercial relationship of the brokerage firm with these clients and on the operations carried out in the name of these clients, granting a period of three business days to present the information, which expired on January 2, 2017, it being necessary to indicate that to date, GPI has not sent the requested information;
On the charge formulated to Ms. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- According to documents presented by Mr. and Mrs. Urday, they delivered to GPI US$ 190,494.9 for investments and attach as support:
- Copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated September 25, 2013, which states dates and amounts of deposits made by Mr. and Mrs. Urday between May 16, 2011 and September 25, 2013 for US$ 190,494.9.
- Copy of the deposit voucher to GPI's dollar intermediation account dated May 14, 2011 for the amount of US$ 40,200.00 and copy of the deposit voucher to GPI's dollar intermediation account dated September 25, 2013 for US$ 45,080.50;
- Therefore, Mr. and Mrs. Urday have proven that they delivered to GPI a total amount of US$ 190,494.9 and have stated that they invested in a new investment alternative in this brokerage firm since May 2011 and these amounts have been acknowledged by GPI, according to documents issued and signed by GPI;
On the destination of the resources
-
Regarding the funds delivered in the amount of US$ 190,494.9, Messrs. Urday have not mentioned or specified the orders they instructed to GPI for the investment of their funds, nor do they attach any documentation in that regard. They only state that they invested in a new investment modality since May 2011, convinced by GPI executives, and that at all times they took for granted that the investment alternative they were accessing followed the principle of capital preservation, which characterized their investments since the beginning of the relationship with GPI in 2007;
-
With regard to the investments that would have been made with the funds of Messrs. Urday, it should be noted that, according to documentation submitted by the principals, in the copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated January 14, 2012, regarding the clients' portfolio, it indicates the execution of a sale transaction of Call options on FAS (ETF) for an amount of US$40,600.00 and the obtaining of a premium of US$ 812.00, and another transaction of sale of Put options on EDC (ETF) for an amount of US$ 106,400.00 and the obtaining of a premium of US$ 1,800.00, which would have been made in the global account that GPI had at the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC. Likewise, there is a copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated September 20, 2014, which indicates premiums obtained from open positions that expired on September 20, 2014, for US$ 924.00 and US$ 1,191.00, which would also be options transactions;
-
In addition, it should be noted that there is a copy of a document issued and signed by GPI dated September 25, 2013, which indicates a portfolio investment value of the principals in the amount of US$ 190,494.90;
-
Finally, as mentioned in the complaint of Messrs. Urday, Mr. Arizmendi told them that GPI would have invested in the sale of options on SVXY (ETF) and short strategies with respect to this ETF;
-
These transactions that would have been carried out with the funds of Messrs. Urday would explain why in reports signed by GPI it is stated that the liquidation value of the investment of US$ 105,414.40 from June and August 2011 amounts as of October 28, 2015 to US$ 56,380.90, and that the investment of US$ 85,080.50 from May 2011 and September 2013 amounts as of October 28, 2011 to US$ 45,505.30. It should be noted that Messrs. Urday indicate that they told GPI that the deposits totaling US$ 85,080.50 should be managed separately from the other two deposits, because the returns on this investment would be in favor of Mr. Urday's brother. However, GPI has not proven the transactions it would have carried out with the entirety of Messrs. Urday's funds, for US$ 190,494.90, nor the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments as of the date;
-
The foregoing reflects, according to documents issued and signed by GPI, that this stock brokerage firm would have carried out at least two (02) options transactions on behalf of Messrs. Urday, at least two (02) others that would also be options (since premiums are obtained and there is an expiration term), and other transactions that, according to the clients, Mr. Arizmendi has mentioned as "short" strategies and sale of Put options on SVXY (ETF);
-
Likewise, it is observed that Mr. Arizmendi has a direct participation in the management of the clients' funds, informing them regarding the type of investments made, the benefits of the investment strategy followed by GPI, and the modality for investing abroad using an "omnibus" account in the name of GPI at a foreign intermediary, which groups several principals. As previously indicated, this participation of Mr. Arizmendi is related to the fact that, after leaving the position of Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI in February 2013, on behalf of GPIAM he participated in financial advisory to GPI since February 2013, in addition to being the spouse of the main shareholder, Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle;
-
On this matter, the direction of Mr. Arizmendi in the management of Messrs. Urday's funds as well as the transactions carried out in their name should be highlighted, from the beginning of the commercial relationship with said clients, that is, August 2010, which is supported by the documents indicating that both Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle jointly participated in the management of the funds of the clients who have denounced GPI, regardless of whether or not they held the position of general manager or chairman of the board;
-
Indeed, as Messrs. Urday have indicated in the letter dated December 23, 2013, addressed to this Superintendency, on February 4, 2015, they were summoned by Mr. Arizmendi to a meeting in which he assured them that the loss suffered on their funds would be reversed in the following months, in addition to explaining the benefits of the investment strategy applied. Likewise, the gentlemen state that on a later occasion, they met with Mr. Arizmendi, in which he explained that they could not avoid significant losses in the management of the investment of said principals, acknowledging that the investment strategy was managed very disorderly by his executives and that this was due to a lack of supervision on his part;
-
The foregoing reflects the active participation of Mr. Arizmendi in the management of Messrs. Urday's funds, which has not been denied by GPI or by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, who had access to such statement, which appears in the aforementioned complaint brief and was forwarded to said company through Official Letter No. 7519-2016-SMV/10.3;
-
On the other hand, GPI has not responded to the request made in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 7519-2016-SMV/10.3, regarding whether it has the record of the orders given by Messrs. Urday, the policies of the transactions carried out, the account statements in the name of this client, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations abroad in the name of GPI or in the name of Messrs. Urday. It should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the stock brokerage firm and Messrs. Urday, according to the Client Registration Form dated August 23, 2010, is: "Other modality subject to verification and confirmation";
-
On the latter, it should be noted that GPI has not submitted to date a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions that prove the willingness of Messrs. Urday to allocate their funds to investments in derivative financial instruments such as sales of Puts on SVXY (ETF) and other transactions with securities and financial instruments that would have been carried out since May 2011;
-
With regard to the investments made with the funds of Messrs. Urday, GPI has not submitted to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in the latter case by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments. These documents would prove the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by said client; however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI or by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle;
-
It should be noted that GPI has also not proven that the funds owned by Messrs. Urday or the derivative financial instruments in which the funds would have been invested (sale of Puts and Calls) or the securities resulting from the execution of Puts, or other securities and financial instruments in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened at a foreign entity in the name of GPI, proving that the funds, securities and financial instruments are indisputably the property of Messrs. Urday. Likewise, it has not proven that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of Messrs. Urday at a foreign entity;
-
Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required to provide the minimum documentation proving that it complied with the instructions given by Messrs. Urday and proving the investments made in their name with their funds;
-
To date, neither GPI nor Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager of the company have proven with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments in the name of Messrs. Urday from May 2011 to September 2016, made in accordance with the instructions of this principal or that they have been allocated to another destination; in none of the cases has it proven the destination of the money delivered by these clients, so it is concluded that it would have been allocated to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
-
In relation to the foregoing, it is clear that GPI, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative, and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the RAI, since they received the funds delivered by Messrs. Urday for their custody and investment instructions given by said principal, and they have also not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
-
Likewise, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would have infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds owned by Messrs. Urday to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
-
GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
-
On the other hand, in reports issued by GPI, this former stock brokerage firm states that it supposedly carried out operations or invested with the Clients' funds[49], as indicated below;
Table No. 1
Supposed Operations in 2011 in the name of the clients according to a report issued by gpi, that have not been proven with the required documentation
| DATE | DEPOSITS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation | Value | Expiry | Quantity of Securities | Price | Investment/ Exposure Amount | Premium | | |
| 05/16/2011 | 40,000.00 | | | | | | | |
| 06/27/2011 | 64,670.71 | | | | | | | |
| 08/23/2011 | 40,743.69 | | | | | | | |
| May-Dec 2011 | - | 18 Sale operations | - | - | - | - | 12,210 | - |
| | Purchase (Initial Investment) | FAS | - | 280 | - | 40,600 | - |
| | Sale Calls | FAS | Jan-20-12 | 280 | 2.90 | - | 812 |
| | Sale Puts | EDC | Jan-20-12 | 800 | 2.25 | 106,400 | 1,800 |
| Total | 145,414.40 | | | | | | | |
Table No. 2
Supposed operations in 2013 and 2014 in the name of the clients according to a report issued by gpi, that have not been proven with the required documentation (investments i – amount in us$)
| | | | | | | | |
|---|
| DATE/ PERIOD | DEPOSITS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
| Operation | Value | Expiry | Quantity of Securities | Price | Investment/ Exposure Amount | Premium | | |
| 05/16/2011 | 40,000.00 | | | | | | | |
| 09/25/2013 | 45,080.50 | | | | | | | |
| Jul - Sep 2013 (*) | - | 1 Operation | - | - | - | - | 600 | - |
| | Trading | - | - | - | - | 85,080.5 | - |
| | | | Sep-20-14 | | | 85,080.5 | 924 |
| Total | 85,080.50 | | | | | | | |
| Liquidation value as of 10/28/2015 | 45,505.30 | | | | | | | |
| (*) It is not indicated with which funds this operation would have been carried out. | | | | | | | | |
Table No. 3
Supposed operations in 2013 and 2014 in the name of the clients according to a report issued by gpi, that have not been proven with the required documentation (investments ii – amount in us$)
| | | | | | | | |
|---|
| DATE | DEPOSITS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
| Operation | Value | Expiry | Quantity of Securities | Price | Investment/ Exposure Amount | Premium | | |
| 06/27/2011 | 64,670.71 | | | | | | | |
| 08/23/2011 | 40,743.69 | | | | | | | |
| Jul - Sep 2013 (*) | - | 1 Operation | - | - | - | - | 600 | - |
| | Trading | | | | | 105,414.4 | - |
| | | | Sep-20-14 | | | 105,414.4 | 1,191 |
| Total | 105,414.40 | | | | | | | |
| Liquidation value as of 10/28/2015 | 56,380.90 | | | | | | | |
| (*) It is not indicated with which funds this operation would have been carried out. | | | | | | | | |
-
It should be noted that the supposed operations that GPI states it has carried out are separated by periods considering that the Clients specify that they gave instructions to GPI so that two (02) contributions totaling US$ 85,080.50 (Eighty-five thousand eighty and 50/100 United States Dollars) (Investments I) be managed separately from two contributions totaling US$ 105,414.40 (One hundred five thousand four hundred fourteen and 40/100 United States Dollars) (Investments II);
-
The mentioned investments would have been managed separately since 2013, according to GPI reports of September 25, 2013, September 20, 2014 and October 28, 2015; however, in 2011 it cannot be determined whether the investments would have been made separately, because the amount of US$ 145,414.40 (One hundred forty-five thousand four hundred fourteen and 40/100 United States Dollars) invested in 2011 includes the two (2) contributions totaling US$ 105,414.40 (One hundred five thousand four hundred fourteen and 40/100 United States Dollars) (Investments II) plus the contribution of US$ 40,000.00 (Forty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), which is part of the US$ 85,080.50 (Eighty-five thousand eighty and 50/100 United States Dollars) (Investments I);
-
Regarding these options transactions (sale of Calls and Puts) and other operations that GPI states it has carried out in reports issued by this company, which are shown in Tables No. 1, 2 and 3, in the preliminary inquiry stage, the clients have presented in their complaint before the SMV on December 23, 2016, their respective client registration form signed on August 23, 2010 by the Clients (Holder and Holder 2), and Mr. Héctor Uccelli Romero, representative of GPI, in which the following is stated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Report operations", "Advisory in capital markets (Peru)", and "Advisory in capital markets (international)"; likewise, in this form the investment objective is stated as "preservation", "growth" and "income/revenues";
-
It should be noted that in the inspection carried out[50], another client registration form was observed, signed on September 10, 2014 by the Clients (Holder and Holder 2) and Mr. Tomás Silva Berenguel, Representative of GPI, where the same services contracted by the Clients and the same investment objective are indicated, in accordance with the form of August 23, 2010;
-
Likewise, the Clients state that they delivered the funds to GPI which were managed separately, being distributed: i) in Investments II US$ 85,080.50 (Eighty-five thousand eighty and 50/100 United States Dollars) and ii) in Investments I: US$ 105,414.40 (One hundred five thousand four hundred fourteen and 40/100 United States Dollars), for the purpose of investing in a new investment modality that the aforementioned principals assumed followed the principle of capital preservation that characterized their investments since the beginning of their relationship with GPI in 2007;
-
It should be noted that what GPI states regarding the investments it claims to have made in the name of the clients is not evaluated, considering that, despite the requests made by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that proves the execution of the operations indicated in Tables No. 1, 2 and 3 with the US$ 190,494.90 deposited by the Clients and others that it would have carried out that explain the returns or interest paid to the principals from 2011 to 2016, US$ 48,077.00 for the investments of Investments I and US$ 82,801.00 for the investments of Investments II, and that the liquidation value of the investment as of October 28, 2015 amounts in Investments I to US$ 45,505.30 and in Investments II, to US$ 56,380.90; this to the extent that GPI has not proven with the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the Clients' funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the control records of global accounts, the policies, orders, etc.;
-
Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds that the Clients entrusted to it for custody and investment instructions given by them and that, according to both parties, total US$ 190,494.90 (One hundred ninety thousand four hundred ninety-four and 90/100 United States Dollars), separated into two investment periods, US$ 85,080.5 (Eighty-five thousand eighty and 50/100 United States Dollars) (Investments I), delivered in May 2011 and September 2013, and US$ 105,414.40 (One hundred five thousand four hundred fourteen and 40/100 United States Dollars) (Investments II), delivered in June and August 2011;
-
The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 190,494.90 (One hundred ninety thousand four hundred ninety-four and 90/100 United States Dollars) is proven by the documents presented by the Clients and others that have been collected in the Inspection, such as a copy of documents issued and signed by GPI, two (02) vouchers and two (02) interbank transfer requests from the Clients to GPI's dollar brokerage account, a certificate of time deposit in a savings and credit union, documents indicating the liquidation of time deposit certificates and proof of interbank transfers from savings and credit unions to GPI's soles brokerage account. The detail is shown in Tables No. 4 and 5;
Table No. 4
Proof of funds delivered by the clients (investments i) (in us$)
| Date | Deposit Amount | Deposit Account | Evidentiary documents (copies) |
|---|
| 05/16/2011 | 40,000.00 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Bank Voucher and interbank transfer request from Mr. Pedro Urday's account to GPI's dollar brokerage account dated May 14, 2011. |
| Reports issued and signed by GPI dated January 14, 2012, September 25, 2013 and September 20, 2014. | | | |
| 09/25/2013 | 45,080.50 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Bank Voucher and interbank transfer request from Mr. Pedro Urday's account to GPI's dollar brokerage account dated September 25, 2013 |
| Report issued and signed by GPI dated September 25, 2013, September 20, 2014 and October 28, 2015. | | | |
| Total Capital | 85,080.50 | | |
Table No. 05
Proof of funds delivered by the clients (investments ii) (in us$)
| Date | Deposit Amount | Deposit Account | Evidentiary documents (copies) |
|---|
| 06/27/2011 | 64,670.71 | No. 317885693 at Banco Financiero | Certificate of deposit (CD) No. 10667 in the name of the Clients at CRAC Profinanzas for S/ 180,352.89 dated 04/16/2011, for a term of 1 year, presented by the Clients and collected in the Inspection. |
| Document presented by the Clients and collected in the Inspection, which indicates the liquidation of CD No. 10667 and the transfer of funds to GPI's soles brokerage account for S/ 179,457.73 and, after payment of commission, S/ 178,555.82, indicating that "it remains in options", which is equivalent to US$ 64,670.71 at the exchange rate of 2.761 of 06/22/2011. | | | |
| Proof of interbank transfer from the bank account of CRAH Profinanzas to GPI's soles brokerage account for S/. 179,457.73 with the handwritten indication "Cancelac Sr. Pedro Urday CLIO 1109 Profinanzas # 10667", collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| Reports issued and signed by GPI dated January 14, 2012, September 25, 2013, September 20, 2014 and October 28, 2015. | | | |
| 08/23/2011 | 40,743.69 | | Document presented by the Clients and collected in the Inspection, which indicates the liquidation of a time deposit certificate in the name of the Clients at CMAC Paita for S/ 112,241.44 dated 08/08/2010 with maturity on 08/11/2011, and the transfer of funds to GPI's soles brokerage account for S/ 111,954.46 and, after payment of commission, S/ 111,393.25, indicating that "it remains in options", which is equivalent to US$ 40,743.69 at the exchange rate of 2.734 of 08/19/2011. |
| Proof of interbank transfer from the bank account of CRAH Paita to GPI's soles brokerage account for S/. 111,954.46 with the reference "Cancelac de Cta URDAY BERENGEL", collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| Reports issued and signed by GPI dated January 14, 2012, September 25, 2013, September 20, 2014 and October 28, 2015. | | | |
| Total Capital | 105,414.40 | | |
- Likewise, it should be noted that it is accredited that GPI has delivered between 2011 and August 2016 to the Clients US$ 48,077.00 (Forty-eight thousand seventy-seven and 00/100 United States Dollars) for returns on investments of Investments I that it states it has made and US$ 82,801.00 (Eighty-two thousand eight hundred one and 00/100 United States Dollars) for returns on investments of Investments II that it states it has made, accredited in reports issued and signed by GPI and payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of the Clients and signed by one of them, according to documentation issued by GPI and presented by the Clients in their complaint;
- As previously indicated, according to the documentation issued by GPI, this former brokerage firm states it has carried out operations, however these have not been accredited before this Superintendency, which allows concluding that in reality such funds were used for purposes not authorized by the Clients;
- In this sense, according to Article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, except with express authorization from the client and that such purpose refers to one of the operations indicated in Article 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not accredited the execution of operations with the required documentation, it validly allows us to maintain that the funds delivered by the Clients for the sum of US$ 190,494.90 (One hundred ninety thousand four hundred ninety-four and 90/100 United States Dollars), separated into two investment periods, US$ 85,080.50 (Eighty-five thousand eighty and 50/100 United States Dollars) (Investments I), delivered in May 2011 and September 2013, and US$ 105,414.40 (One hundred five thousand four hundred fourteen and 40/100 United States Dollars) (Investments II), delivered in June and August 2011, were used for purposes other than those entrusted;
- Consequently, it was concluded that GPI did not rebut this charge, so it was accredited that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; and according to what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 008-2017-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[51], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[52], among others, having participated in the facts described above, as part of a systematic mechanism they used with several clients, since in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal handling of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, therefore it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referring to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mrs. Quijano
The Complaint
- By written submission presented to the SMV on January 11, 2017, Mrs. Marcela Quijano Herrera, hereinafter Mrs. Quijano, denounces GPI and requests the return of the invested capital of US$ 150,000.00 that was delivered to said company in May 2014;
- Mrs. Quijano states that she has been a client of GPI for 10 years and that there was always a very satisfactory relationship. She indicates that in May 2014 she delivered to GPI US$ 150,000.00 for investments (attaches receipt), that the contract was for three (03) years and a profitability of 10% per annum in dollars, payable in quarterly installments of US$ 3,750.00;
- The client adds that until May 2016 the returns were paid as agreed. From August 2016 the payment of returns was suspended due to reasons not completely clarified, which was to be explained in a meeting with Mr. Arizmendi, which never occurred;
- Mrs. Quijano states that GPI committed to sending her a letter explaining the problem and assumes also proposing a solution. She adds that from the week of December 19, 2016, any communication with them has been impossible, neither by telephone nor through email;
Arguments of GPI in the preliminary inquiries
- By Official Letter No. 171-2017-SMV/10.3 of January 11, 2017, the complaint presented by Mrs. Quijano was transferred to GPI, as well as information and documentation was requested regarding the commercial relationship of the brokerage firm with the referred client and on the operations carried out in her name, granting a period of three (3) business days to present the information. The referred period expired on January 16, 2017; however, GPI did not send the requested information;
On the charge formulated to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- According to the document presented by Mrs. Quijano, she delivered to GPI US$ 150,000.00 for investments and attaches as support a copy of a receipt signed by Mr. Ucelli, dated May 19, 2014, which states that US$ 150,000.00 has been received from Mrs. Quijano, by means of a Scotiabank manager's check, to be invested for a term of 36 months and indicating a return of 10% per annum in dollars and a schedule of quarterly return payments;
- Therefore, Mrs. Quijano has accredited that she invested in GPI an amount of US$ 150,000.00 for a term of 36 months and that she was offered a return of 10% per annum and this amount and conditions of the investment have been recognized by GPI, according to a document issued and signed by Mr. Uccelli, Director at that time of GPI and to date Representative of this brokerage firm;
On the destination of the resources
- With regard to the funds delivered of US$ 150,000.00, Mrs. Quijano has not mentioned or specified the orders she instructed to GPI for the investment of her funds, nor do they attach documentation in this regard. She only states and accredits that she invested for a term of 36 months and that she was offered a return of 10% per annum with interest accrued quarterly;
- Regarding the investments that would have been made with Mrs. Quijano's funds, there is no information or documentation in this regard;
- As for the investments that would have been made with Mrs. Quijano's capital, she states that in August 2016 Mr. Arizmendi was going to explain in a meeting the reasons for the suspension of interest payments, which indicates that he has a direct participation in the management of the client's funds. As previously indicated, this participation of Mr. Arizmendi since May 2014 and precisely in August 2016, as the client states, is related to the fact that, after leaving the position of Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI in February 2013, in the name of GPIAM, being Chairman and General Manager of this company, he participated in financial advisory to GPI since February 2013, in addition to being the spouse of the main shareholder, Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle; as in the case of other complainants, for the period of the complaint, and due to the fact that Mrs. Quijano mentions the participation of Mr. Arizmendi, it follows that both spouses jointly have participated in the management of the funds of all clients who have denounced GP;.
- In this regard, there is no record of the orders given by Mrs. Quijano, the policies of the operations carried out, the account statements in the name of this client, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing operations abroad in the name of GPI or in the name of Mrs. Quijano;
- On the latter, it should be noted that to date there is no copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, which accredit the will of Mrs. Quijano to allocate her funds to investments in securities and financial instruments, including derivatives, since May 2014, that have generated the returns paid to the client until May 2016, as the client indicates, at a rate of 10% per annum in dollars;
- With regard to the investments made with Mrs. Quijano's funds, there are no copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in this last case by entities in charge of executing operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of securities or financial instruments. These documents would accredit the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by said client;
- It should be noted that it is also not accredited that the funds owned by Mrs. Quijano or securities and financial instruments, including derivatives, in which the funds would have been invested to generate the returns paid to the client, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI accrediting that the funds, securities and financial instruments are indisputable property of Mrs. Quijano. Likewise, it is also not accredited that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of Mrs. Quijano in a foreign entity;
- To date, it is not accredited with all the documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments in the name of Mrs. Quijano from May 2014 to September 2016, made by GPI according to the instructions of this client or that it has destined them to another purpose; in none of the cases is the destination of the money delivered by this client accredited, therefore it is concluded that it would have been destined to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- With regard to the above, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would not have complied with the provisions of Article 48 of the RAI since they received the funds delivered by Mrs. Quijano for custody and investment instructions given by said client, and they have also not accredited the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle would have infringed the provisions of Article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds owned by Mrs. Quijano to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
On the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- On the other hand, according to the receipt issued by GPI, this former brokerage firm supposedly would have invested the Client's funds[53], as indicated below;
Table No. 1
Supposed Investment in the name of the client according to receipt issued by gpi, which has not been accredited with the required documentation (in US$)
| | | |
|---|
| DATE | DEPOSITS | EXPECTED RETURN | INVESTMENT TERM |
| | | |
| 05/19/2014 | 150,000.00 | 10% per annum | 36 months |
- Regarding the supposed investment of US$ 150,000.00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars), the Client only specifies that she sought to invest the money for a term of thirty-six (36) months, with a return of 10% per annum, according to the document issued by GPI on May 19, 2014;
- The quarterly returns amounted to US$ 3,500.00 (Three thousand five hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars) and, as the Client states, were paid by GPI until May 2016; that is, she was paid returns corresponding to eight (08) quarters, between August 2014 and May 2016[54];
- Likewise, the Client states that since August 2016 the returns have not been paid, so she requested GPI to return the total of her funds;
- It should be noted that what GPI states regarding the investments that it indicates, in the receipt of May 19, 2014, to have made in the name of the Client is not evaluated, considering that by Official Letter No. 171-2017-SMV/10.3, in the preliminary inquiry stage, GPI was required to inform the SMV of the record of orders given by the Client, the policies of the operations carried out and the account statements issued by GPI. However, to date, GPI has not sent any information that could clarify the facts subject of the complaint or could demonstrate whether intermediation operations were actually carried out in the local market with the Client's funds that explain the generation and payment of quarterly returns to this client between August 2014 and May 2016;
- Moreover, it should be indicated that there is also no supporting information that would prove that GPI has invested abroad, through a foreign intermediary, since copies of the account statements issued by foreign intermediaries in the name of the referred brokerage firm or in the name of the client have not been provided, provided by entities in charge of executing operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of securities or financial instruments;
- Therefore, it can validly be concluded that it has not been possible to accredit and/or support, with evidence, the existence of the operations, from May 2014 to September 2016, that explain the generation and payment of quarterly returns to this client between August 2014 and May 2016;
- The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 150,000**,**00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) is accredited by the documents (copies) that the Client has presented, in her writings of January 11 and 16, 2017, such as deposit voucher of manager's check, manager's check and receipt issued and signed by GPI. The detail is presented in Table No. 2:
Table No. 2
Accreditation of funds delivered by clients to gpi (in US$)
| Date / Month | Deposit Amount | Deposit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 05/19/2014 | 150,000.00 | No. 317885723 of Banco Financiero | Copy of deposit voucher of manager's check in the intermediation account of GPI dated May 19, 2014. |
| Copy of manager's check of Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. in favor of GPI dated May 19, 2014. | | | |
| Email of May 12, 2014, in which Mrs. Teresa Orlandini Alvarez Calderón (torlandini@gpivalores.com) informs the CLIENT (marcequijanoh@hotmail.com) about the bank accounts where she can transfer the funds. Thus, she is indicated that in Banco Financiero she can deposit in the current account in dollars No. 000-317885723. | | | |
| Document -receipt- of May 19, 2014, signed by the Director of GPI, Mr. UCCELLI, where it is textually expressed: "We have received from Mrs. Marcela Quijano Herrera, the amount of US$ 150,000.00 dollars (one hundred fifty thousand American dollars) in a manager's check of Scotia Bank (...)" | | | |
| Total Capital | 150,000.00 | | |
- Thus, it can validly be affirmed that the Client transferred to GPI an amount of US$ 150,000.00 (One hundred fifty thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for an investment that would have a return of 10% per annum;
- Likewise, it should be noted that what the client states regarding GPI having delivered from May 2014 to May 2016 to the Client a total of US$ 28,000.00 (twenty-eight thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars) for returns on the investments that it states it has made is accredited;
- As previously indicated, GPI expresses, through a receipt, to have carried out operations, however these have not been accredited by said former brokerage firm before this Superintendency with evidence that the funds have been invested in the purchase and/or sale of securities and financial instruments in the local or foreign market that allow a profit (return), and there is also evidence, due to the Client's claim, that these funds have not been returned, which validly allows maintaining that in reality such funds were used for purposes not authorized by the Client;
- In this sense, according to Article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, except with express authorization from the client and that such purpose refers to one of the operations indicated in Article 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not accredited the execution of operations with the required documentation, it validly allows us to maintain that the funds delivered by the Client were used for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for investments according to the prior instructions of the Client;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not rebut this charge, therefore, it was accredited that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; and according to what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 006-2017-SMV/10;
- In this sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[55], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[56], among others, having participated in the facts described above, as part of a systematic mechanism they used with several clients, since in practice as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal handling of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, therefore it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referring to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- On the complaint of Mrs. Camino
The Complaint
- In the complaint of November 7, 2016 presented before the SMV, Mrs. Cecilia María Camino Rodríguez Larraín de Holguín, hereinafter Mrs. Camino, attached a notarized letter sent to GPI with attention to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi on October 31, 2016, through which she requests the return of the capital invested by her and her husband not returned by this brokerage firm, which amounts to US$ 159,626.48. Mrs. Camino specifies that between May 22, 2009 and December 13, 2011 they delivered to GPI the total sum of US$ 174,626.48 and that between December 1, 2015 and August 19, 2016 they have made capital withdrawals for the amount of US$ 15,000.00, so they request the return of the difference of invested capital;
- By written submission presented on November 21, 2016, in response to Official Letter No. 6775-2016-SMV/10.3, Mrs. Camino does not attach vouchers or other proof of money deposits that she would have made to GPI's accounts, she only specifies that they were made by checks from Banco de Crédito del Perú;
- However, she attaches documents issued by GPI that would have been signed by Mr. Uccelli, in which the situation of the deposits and investments of Mrs. Camino and Mr. Jorge Holguín Reyes, hereinafter Mr. Holguin, identified with client code CLIO1157, hereinafter the Clients, is reported as of January 5, 2011, June 23, 2014, March 31, 2015, September 4, 2015, April 21, 2016 and August 19, 2016, through which the list of deposits made by the Clients to GPI from May 22, 2009 to December 13, 2011, for the total amount of US$ 174,626.48 is shown;
- It should be noted that the document as of January 5, 2011 indicates that the investments of the Clients[57] are made through the global account of GPI in the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney;
- Additionally, Mrs. Camino attaches a document issued on April 21, 2016 and that would have been signed by Mr. Uccelli on behalf of GPI in which it is stated that the amount of US$ 50,000.00 delivered by the Clients on December 13, 2011, as a consequence of a cancellation of a term deposit in Profinanzas, was credited to an account abroad;
- On the other hand, Mrs. Camino states that with the money that the Clients delivered, GPI invested in shares of companies listed on stock exchanges, some of them were issued in the name of the Clients and others, the majority, are part of GPI's portfolio and it is in relation to the latter that GPI paid them returns;
- Mrs. Camino adds that they have not had accounts abroad, nor had third-party intermediaries in their relationship with GPI, that their relationship has been direct with this brokerage firm;
- Finally, Mrs. Camino adds that the operation she ordered by telephone was the sale of FAS and that in the corresponding receipts "Capital" was recorded, although what should have been recorded was "gain from sale of shares", or another similar term. From the figure received for that concept by GPI, the sum of US$ 16,000.00 was deducted, for overdraft, so the net amount received was US$ 31,765.00. She states that this operation was carried out in June 2014;
Arguments of GPI in the preliminary inquiries
- Ms. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, by letter sent on November 16, 2016, stated that the brokerage firm has registered a much lower amount of capital and the Clients have received a much higher amount than their investment in yields; that it has not provided the Clients with portfolio management services, that the investments were managed in an account in the name of GPI abroad, with the Clients' knowledge. She indicates that the investment modality was to generate a flow of income, that these are investments abroad of a third party, not recorded as liabilities of GPI since they were not. Likewise, GPI states the following:
- It does not have the detail of the operations carried out in the name of the Clients.
- It does not have copies of the account statements received from abroad regarding the operations carried out in the name of the Clients.
- It does not have a record of orders instructed by the Clients, except for capital withdrawals requested regarding investments or requests for payment of yields.
- Given the type of operation, no policies were issued, since it operated in GPI's foreign account.
- Regarding the issuance and delivery of account statements to the Clients, it states that the documentation received by the Clients consists fundamentally of copies of checks and deposit vouchers received for payments of requested yield and capital withdrawals.
- It does not have a copy of the control records of global accounts that have been used specifically for the Clients.
- It attaches the Client Registration Form corresponding to the Clients;
Of the charge formulated against Ms. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- According to documents presented by Ms. Camino, GPI delivered to said client reports issued that would have been signed by Mr. Uccelli on behalf of said brokerage firm in which he acknowledges that the Clients delivered US$ 174,626.48 to GPI for investments, these being those of May 22, June 6 and December 12, 2009 for a total of US$ 124,626.48 and on December 13, 2011 the additional amount of US$ 50,000.00;
- In this sense, it is clear that Ms. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as General Manager, has acknowledged that GPI received funds from the Clients to be invested in securities and financial instruments for the benefit of its clients, which has been proven by herself through a letter of November 16, 2016 addressed to this Superintendency, that is, she ratified what was the destination of the funds entrusted to her by the Clients;
- However, although this Superintendency through Official Letter No. 6739-2016-SMV/10.3 required evidentiary proof of the destination of such funds, both Ms. Bellido-Tagle and GPI have not complied with such requirement;
- Likewise, it should be noted that there are reports in which GPI states that the investments on behalf of the Clients would have been made through the global account in the name of GPI at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney and that the Clients' deposit made on December 13, 2011 for US$ 50,000.00 would have been credited to a foreign account, without specifying whether it was at the same foreign intermediary or another;
- In this regard, Ms. Bellido-Tagle and GPI in their writing of November 16, 2016 have not questioned the receipt of these amounts from the Clients, for investments;
- Therefore, both Ms. Camino and Ms. Bellido-Tagle and GPI agree that the amount delivered by the Clients to this brokerage firm for investments amounts to US$ 174,626.48;
- Regarding the capital withdrawal made by the Clients, GPI has proven with copies of payment vouchers for "capital" or "capital withdrawal", signed by Ms. Camino or Mr. Holguin, and with copies of manager's checks in favor of Ms. Camino or Mr. Holguin,
- Thus, for the capital return of June 23, 2014: six (06) receipts and checks for a total of US$ 31,765.00, charged to GPI's dollar intermediation account at Banco Financiero del Perú (No. 317885723); however, regarding this amount, Ms. Camino attaches the same six (06) receipts and points out that GPI recorded "Capital" in these, although what should have been recorded was "gain from sale of shares" or another similar term;
- In this regard, it should be noted that from the reports issued and signed by GPI, presented by Ms. Camino, it is observed that the amount of US$ 31,765.00 corresponds to a gain from the sale of FAS (ETF) on behalf of the Clients that GPI would have made, because the sale amount was US$ 85,644.00, from which commissions and "margin" were deducted, and from the resulting balance, the amount of US$ 36,000.00 was credited to the Clients' investment account ("trading account") and the amount of US$ 31,765.00 was delivered to the Clients; therefore, this last amount delivered should not be considered as a capital withdrawal, but as a withdrawal of yields or gains from the sale of securities;
- On the other hand, additionally there are the capital returns detailed below;
- On May 20, June 24, September 15, October 19 and 28 and December 1, 2015, GPI has returned to the Clients a total of US$ 18,600.00 charged to GPI's dollar intermediation account at Banco Financiero del Perú (No. 317885723).
- On May 13 and August 18, 2016, GPI has returned to the Clients a total of US$ 10,000.00 charged to GPI's dollar intermediation account at Scotiabank Perú S.A.A. (No. 3361639);
- It should be noted that according to Ms. Camino in her complaint, GPI has only returned to the Clients the total sum of US$ 15,000.00: on December 1, 2015 (US$ 5,000.00), on May 13, 2016 (US$ 5,000.00) and on August 19, 2016 (US$ 5,000.00); however, there are other documents signed by them that prove they have received a greater amount;
- For its part, GPI states that it has returned to the Clients the total sum of US$ 73,315.00; however, taking into account the amounts that are proven with copies of documents for "capital" and "capital withdrawal signed by the Clients", and additionally considering that the amount of US$ 31,765.00 is a withdrawal for yield, the total sum delivered by GPI to the Clients amounts to US$ 28,600.00;
- Therefore, the difference between the total amount paid by the Clients to GPI for investment US$ 174,626.48 and the total amount for capital returned by this brokerage firm to them US$ 28,600.00, amounts to US$ 146,026.48;
- In this sense, it is clear that GPI and Ms. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as General Manager and Chairman of the Board of GPI, to date should have an asset of US$ 146,026.48 registered in the name of the Clients which should be fully credited in their favor, or failing that, demonstrate the destination of such funds according to the instructions given by them, which has not occurred to date;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to mention that through email of October 26, 2016 at 10:54 hours addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, Ms. Orlandini and Mr. Ucelli, Ms. Camino requires the first named various information regarding the funds delivered as well as the investments made, however, this has not had a response from the recipients of said emails or at least, Ms. Bellido-Tagle or Arizmendi, or GPI have not proven the respective response in file 2016045072, that is, Ms. Bellido-Tagle did not provide adequate information and documentation of the destination of funds delivered by the Clients, which is why it is concluded that Ms. Bellido-Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi and GPI would have destined the funds as a consequence of their intermediation activities for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
Of the destination of the resources
- Regarding the funds delivered of US$ 174,626.48, Ms. Camino has not mentioned or specified the orders that the Clients gave to GPI for the investment of their funds, nor does she attach documentation in this regard;.
- However, Ms. Camino states that they ordered by telephone the sale of FAS (ETF), an operation that would have been carried out by GPI in June 2014;
- Likewise, according to documentation sent by the Clients, in the same reports issued and signed by GPI in which this brokerage firm acknowledges the deposits of money for the total amount of US$ 174,626.48, it indicates the supposed purchase and sale operations of securities that would have been carried out and the balance of investments in options on behalf of the Clients (client code CLI01157), which are detailed in Table No. 01:
Table No. 1
Supposed investments in the name of the clients (in US$)
| Date Oper./Balance | Type Oper. | Value/Instrument | Quantity | Price | Amount |
|---|
| 04/10/2009 | Purchase | UWM | 1,000 | 30.30 | 30,300.00 |
| - | Purchase | SUE | 10,000 | 0.93 | 9,250.00 |
| 04/10/2009 | Purchase | FAS | 1,500 | 25.00 | 37,500.00 |
| - | Purchase | EDC | 1,000 | 41.00 | 41,000.00 |
| - | Sale | CALLS on EDC (ETF), exp. 01/21/2011, strike US$ 43.64 | 10 contracts | 1.20 | 1,200.00 |
| - | Purchase | EDC | 600 | 66.66 | 39,996.00 |
| 02/19/2013 | Sale | UWM | 1,000 | 54.81 | 54,810.00 |
| 06/05/2014 | Sale | FAS | 900 | 95.16 | 85,644.00 |
| 06/23/2014 | Balance | Options | - | - | 116,300.00 |
| 08/14/2014 | Purchase | SMC | 1,000 | 0.44 | 440.00 |
| 01/13/2015 | Sale | RIO | 5,250 | 2.76 | 14,490.00 |
| 03/31/2015 | Balance | Options | - | - | 116,300.00 |
| 09/04/2015 | Balance | Options | - | - | 116,300.00 |
| 04/21/2016 | Balance | Options | - | - | 116,300.00 |
| 08/19/2016 | Balance | Options | - | - | 116,300.00 |
- What is indicated in the preceding table would reflect, according to GPI, that the Clients, as of August 19, 2016, supposedly had a balance in options equivalent to US$ 116,300.00, however, there is no detail of such holding, that is, the number of contracts, their price, their expiration, etc.;
- Regarding the delivery of funds from the Clients and the investments that would have been made, some of which are indicated in reports issued and signed by GPI shown in Table No. 01, this brokerage firm only states that the investments were made abroad and were managed "in an account in the name of GPI abroad", without specifying the type of security or financial instrument in which they have invested;
- It should be noted that through notarized letter of October 31, 2016, Ms. Camino required GPI, attention to Mr. Arizmendi and Ms. Bellido-Tagle, the return of the invested capital, however, said letter has not had a response from Ms. Bellido-Tagle or Mr. Arizmendi to date. It should also be noted that the aforementioned client through letter of November 21, 2016 requested GPI, attention to Mr. Arizmendi and Ms. Bellido-Tagle the transfer of her client portfolio and that such request is a product of the refusal by the latter to not comply with the return of her funds;
- Likewise, GPI before the requirement made in the preliminary investigation stage through Official Letter No. 6739-2016-SMV/10.3, Ms. Bellido-Tagle has stated that she does not have the record of the orders given by the Clients, nor with the policies of the operations carried out, nor with account statements in the name of the Clients, nor with the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the operations abroad in the name of GPI. It should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the brokerage firm and the Clients, must adhere to the provisions of the Regulation. According to the client registration form in the name of the Clients, dated April 6, 2015, the order modalities are: "Written" and "*Other means authorized by SMV";
- On the latter, it should be noted that GPI has not sent to date a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, that prove the will of the Clients to allocate their funds to investments in the securities and derivative financial instruments indicated in Table No. 01 or other financial instruments or securities, made until January 2011 through GPI's global account at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, according to a report issued by GPI, and subsequently "in an account in the name of GPI abroad", as stated by GPI. Therefore, there is only the statement of Ms. Camino regarding the sale order of FAS (ETF), which would support the operation that GPI would have carried out in June 2014;
- In relation to the investments made with the Clients' funds, GPI has not sent to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in this last case by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments. These documents would prove the investments that have been made in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by the Clients, however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI;
- It should be noted that GPI has also not proven that the funds owned by the Clients or the securities and derivative financial instruments indicated in Table No. 01, or the securities resulting from the execution of the latter, or other securities and financial instruments, in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI proving that the funds, securities and financial instruments are indisputable property of the Clients;
- Likewise, it has not proven that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of the Clients in a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required to provide the minimum documentation that proves that it complied with the instructions given by the Clients and that proves the investments made in their name with their funds;
- To date, GPI nor Ms. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager, has not proven with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding paragraphs, the investments from May 2009 to December 12, 2011 with the amount of US$ 124,626.48 paid by the Clients, then with the total accumulated amount of US$ 174,626.48 from December 13, 2011 to September 2016, made according to the instructions of the Clients or that she has destined them to another destination; in none of the cases has she proven the destination of the money delivered by the Clients, so it is concluded that she would have destined it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- In relation to the above, it is clear that GPI, Ms. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager and chairman of the board of GPI from February 22, 2013 to date, and Mr. Arizmendi, in his capacity as general manager and chairman of the board of GPI from its constitution until February 21, 2013 and in his capacity as de facto representative, both would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since they received the funds delivered by the Clients for their custody and investment indications given by said clients, and have also not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Ms. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi would have infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, and article 48 of the Regulation, by allocating the funds owned by the Clients to operations, purposes or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
Of the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- It should be noted that in the inspection carried out on January 11, 2017 to GPI's files[58] (hereinafter, Inspection), two (02) additional Client Registration Forms signed by the Clients[59] were observed, identified with client code CLIO1157: Registration Form No. 1, of February 19, 2008 and Registration Form No. 2 of April 7, 2010, which are added to Registration Form No. 3 of September 23, 2014[60] and Registration Form No. 4 of April 6, 2015[61];
- It should be noted that in Client Registration Form No. 4, the Clients are identified with CLIO 2981, that is, with a different client code than the one used for the same Clients in the three (03) previous forms mentioned above. Additionally, it is important to note that the four (04) Client Registration Forms were signed by Mr. Hector Uccelli Romero, representative of GPI on those dates;
- The reports issued by GPI, presented by the Client and/or by GPI and/or collected in the Inspection, which indicate the deposits made by the Clients and/or capital withdrawals and/or yield payments, are in the name of the Clients or in the name of the client code that identifies them (CLIO1157)[62]; and, the vouchers or payment receipts for capital withdrawal or yields are some in the name of the Clients and others only in the name of Ms. Camino;
- Once these clarifications are made, it should be noted that in reports issued by GPI -presented by Ms. Camino, which have also been collected in the Inspection and in other reports found in this diligence; the former brokerage firm states it has supposedly carried out the following operations;
Table No. 2
Supposed operations in the name of the clients according to report issued by gpi, that have not been proven with the required documentation
| DATE / PERIOD | DEPOSITS / WITHDRAWALS | Operation | Value | Expiration / Strike Price | Quantity Securities | Price | Investment/Exposure Amount | Premium / Gain |
|---|
| 05/22/2009 | 49,876.50 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| - | - | Purchase | RBS | - | - | - | - | - |
| 06/06/2009 | 49,749.98 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 10/04/2009 | - | Purchase | UWM | - | 1,000 | 30.30 | 30,300.00 | - |
| 10/04/2009 | - | Purchase | FAS | - | 500 | 75.00 | 37,500.00 | - |
| 10/21/20009 | - | Trading | FAS | - | - | - | - | 4,000 |
| 11/25/2009 | - | Trading | FAS | - | - | - | - | 3,875 |
| 12/12/2009 | 25,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 12/22/2009 | | Trading | EDC | - | - | - | - | 3,600 |
| 05/22/2009 - 04/07/2010 | - | - | RIO (formerly SUE) | - | 10,000 | 0.925 | 9,250.00 | - |
| 01/27/2010 | - | Trading | UYG / FAS | | | | | 3,695 |
| 03/11/2010 | - | Trading | FAS | | | | | 4,000 |
| 04/16/2010 | - | Trading | FAS | | | | | 4,000 |
| 05/22/09-04/07/2010 | - | Purchase | UYG | - | 10,000 | 6.300 | 63,000.00 | - |
| 04/07/2010-11/09/2010 | - | Sale | UYG | - | 1,000 | 63.800 | 63,800.00 | - |
| 11/10/2010 - 01/04/2011 | - | Purchase | EDC | - | 1,000 | 41.00 | 41,000.00 | - |
| 11/09/2010 | - | Trading | UYG | | | | | 4,000 |
| 12/06/2010 | - | Trading | UYG | | | | | 4,000 |
| - | - | Sale Calls | EDC | 01/21/2011; US$ 43.64 | 1,000 | 1.20 | - | 1,200 |
| August 2011 | - | Sale Calls | EDC | - | - | - | - | 500 |
| Sep 2011 | - | Sale Calls | EDC | - | - | - | - | 1,500 |
| Jan-Dec 2011 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | - | 27,778 |
| 12/13/2011 | 50,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| Dec 2011 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | 1,323 |
| - | - | Sale Puts | EDC | 02/18/2012; US$ 135 | 700 | 2.25 | 94,500.00 | 1,575 |
| - | - | Sale Puts | FAS | 02/18/2012; US$ 75 | 700 | 2.5 | 52,500.00 | 1,750 |
| - | - | Sale Puts | FAS | 05/19/2012; US$ 81 | 600 | 2.1 | 50,000.00 | 1,260 |
| - | - | Sale Puts | EDC | 07/20/2012; US$ 135 | 700 | 7.2 | 94,500.00 | 5,040 |
| Jan -Dec 2012 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | - | 20,819 |
| 02/19/2013 | - | Sale | UWM | - | 1,000 | 54.81 | 54,810.00 | - |
| Jan - Dec 2013 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | - | 32,625 |
| 06/05/2014 | - | Sale | FAS | - | 900 | 95.16 | 85,644.00 | - |
| 06/23/2014 | -31,765.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 08/14/2014 | - | Exchange Bonus | SMC | - | 1,000 | 0.44 | - | - |
| Jan - Dec 2014 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | - | 19,636 |
| 01/13/2015 | - | Sale | RIO (formerly SUE) | - | 5,250 | 2.76 | 14,490.00 | - |
| 2015 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | - | 12,845 |
| 2015 | -18,600.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 2016 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | - | 5,885 |
| 2016 | -11,000.00 | - | - | - | - | - | - | 3,900 |
| Total Capital | 113,261.48 | | | | | | | |
| Liquidation Value as of 08/19/2016 | 40,738.55 | | | | | | | |
- Regarding the alleged transactions with financial instruments and options shown in the preceding table, during the preliminary inquiry stage, GPI submitted to the SMV, on November 16, 2016, Client Registration Form No. 4 of the Clients signed on April 6, 2015, which states as "Services Requested by the Client" the following: "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Repo transactions", "Capital markets advisory (Peru)", and "Capital markets advisory (international)"; likewise, the investment objective is stated as "preservation", "growth" and "income/revenue";
- On the other hand, Mrs. Camino, within the documents submitted on November 21, 2016, attached Client Registration Form No. 3 of the Clients signed on September 23, 2014, which indicates, in addition to the same services mentioned in the previous form, the service of "Over-the-counter transactions", as well as the same investment objective;
- For her part, in Client Registration Form No. 2 signed on April 7, 2010, the following is stated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Repo transactions", "Over-the-counter transactions" and "Capital markets advisory (Peru)", as well as the same investment objective.
- Finally, Client Registration Form No. 1 signed on February 19, 2008, does not contain the section "Services Requested by the Client" and the investment objective has the same characteristics as the previous forms: "preservation", "growth" and "income/revenue";
- Likewise, regarding the transactions that it claims to have carried out, GPI indicated, during the preliminary inquiry stage, that the investment modality was to generate a flow of income, that GPI operated on its own account abroad and tried to generate the agreed profitability; likewise, it states that the portfolio management service was not performed;
- For her part, Mrs. Camino states that the investments that GPI made with the money they delivered were made in shares of companies listed on stock exchanges;
- It should be noted that no assessment is made of what was stated by GPI and Mrs. Camino during the preliminary inquiry stage and in the reports issued by this former stock brokerage firm, regarding the investments it allegedly made in the foreign market on behalf of the Clients. This is because it is considered that, despite the requirements made by the SMV, to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that accredits the execution of the transactions indicated in Table No. 2, with the funds paid by the Clients and others that it allegedly made since May 2009 that would explain the yields paid to the principals and the liquidation value of the investments as of August 19, 2016 indicated in the referred table; that is, with the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the transactions with the Clients' funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the global account control records, policies, orders, among others;
- It should be noted that there is a statement from the principal by which she states textually: "(…) the transaction that I ordered by telephone was the sale of FAS Shares (…)." The execution of the aforementioned transaction is not accredited, because GPI has not demonstrated with documentation supporting this sale transaction; likewise, it has not accredited the execution of the purchase of these shares nor the other transactions indicated in Table No. 2;
- According to the foregoing, since there is no reliable information accrediting the use of the funds to carry out transactions in the domestic or foreign market, it can reasonably be stated that the execution of the sale transaction of FAS securities (ETF), supposedly carried out on June 5, 2014, has not been accredited by GPI;
- Thus, the payment vouchers and checks[63], dated June 23, 2014, accredit that the Clients received, for said transaction[64], the amount of US$ 31,765.00 (Thirty-one thousand seven hundred sixty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) as "capital", as can be seen from the copy of documents signed by Mrs. Camino[65], therefore, it can reasonably be concluded that the withdrawals made were for capital and not for yield;
- On the other hand, Mrs. Camino attaches a report dated June 23, 2014 in which GPI states that it allegedly carried out purchase and sale of instruments called FAS. Regarding this report, the aforementioned lady indicates that it can be seen that the US$ 31,765.00 (Thirty-one thousand seven hundred sixty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) were delivered to her as profitability. However, despite her observation, from the mentioned report it cannot be distinguished whether said amount was delivered as capital or as yields, since it only refers to "Withdrawal"; and, on the other hand, as previously stated, there are payment vouchers signed by Mrs. Camino as "capital";
- Consequently, the amount delivered by GPI, indicated in the previous paragraph, to the Clients, even though the complainant indicates that it corresponds to gains from the sale of FAS shares (ETF), should not be considered as gain (yield), to the extent that Mrs. Camino has signed the payment vouchers as "capital";
- In that sense, the Clients have not presented sufficient evidence to rebut the six (06) payment vouchers signed by Mrs. Camino, where it is visualized that she received the sum of US$ 31,765.00 (Thirty-one thousand seven hundred sixty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) as "Capital", so they must be deemed as capital returns to the Clients and not gains from the sale of the instruments called FAS;
- Now, according to the payment vouchers signed by one of the Clients[66], in the years 2015 and 2016, GPI has delivered to them US$ 18,600.00 (Eighteen thousand six hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars) and US$ 11,000.00 (Eleven thousand and 00/100 United States Dollars)[67], respectively, as capital withdrawal. Both amounts total US$ 29,600.00 (Twenty-nine thousand six hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars)[68];
- In that sense, to the US$ 29,600.00 (Twenty-nine thousand six hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars) must be added the amount for capital withdrawal of US$ 31,765.00 (thirty-one thousand seven hundred sixty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars); thus, a total amount of US$ 61,365.00 (sixty-one thousand three hundred sixty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) is obtained, which is accredited as the amount of capital returned by GPI to the Clients;
- Therefore, by subtracting the sum of US$ 61,365.00 (sixty-one thousand three hundred sixty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) from the payments made by the Clients for the sum of US$ 174,626.48 (one hundred seventy-four thousand six hundred twenty-six and 48/100 United States Dollars), the amount not returned to them is a total of US$ 113,261.48 (one hundred thirteen thousand two hundred sixty-one and 48/100 United States Dollars). It should be highlighted that GPI has not accredited the destination of these funds delivered by the Clients, in investments, transactions or other purposes, previously authorized by the principals;
- Therefore, the difference between the total amount paid by the Clients to GPI, and the total amount for capital returned, amounts to US$ 113,261.48 (One hundred thirteen thousand two hundred sixty-one and 48/100 American dollars), this being the amount owed to the principals; balance that, to date, has not been returned[69]. Thus, it can reasonably be stated that the referred monetary amount has been destined for other purposes, not authorized by the Clients;
- On the other hand, the delivery of funds for the sum of US$ 174,626.48 (One hundred seventy-four thousand six hundred twenty-six and 48/100 United States Dollars), as well as the capital returns, are accredited by the documents presented by Mrs. Camino, GPI and others collected in the Inspection, such as: interbank transfer voucher to the GPI intermediation account, bank account statement of the Clients, term deposit certificates, letters of request from the principals to the rural savings bank so that the amount of their deposits be transferred to the intermediation account and reports issued by GPI indicating the payments received from the Clients. The detail is shown in the following table;
Table No. 3
Accreditation of funds delivered by clients to GPI and returned by GPI to them (In US$)
| Date / Period | Amount of Payment / Withdrawal | Payment / Charge Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 05/22/2009 | 49,876.50 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Interbank transfer voucher from account No. 194-1131255-1-27 at Banco de Crédito del Perú (BCP) in the name of the Clients to the GPI soles intermediation account, collected in the Inspection. |
| Account statement, issued by BCP, of account No. 194-1131255-1-27 in the name of the Clients, corresponding to May 2009. An interbank transfer dated May 21, 2009 and a charge for US$ 50,001.30 can be seen (this would be the US$ 50,000.00 transferred to GPI plus the BCP commission). | | | |
| Reports issued by GPI dated April 7, 2010, October 4, 2010, November 9, 2010, January 4, 2011, February 14, 2012, April 26, 2012, March 12, 2013, February 3, 2014, June 3, 2014, June 23, 2014, March 31, 2015, September 4, 2015, February 12, 2016, April 21, 2016, June 14, 2016 and August 19, 2016, presented by Mrs. Camino and/or collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| 06/06/2009 | 49,749.98 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Term Deposit Certificate (CD) No. 007962 issued by CRAC Profinanzas on March 4, 2009 in the name of the Clients, with account No. 099-010-001-00051-6, for the amount of US$ 49,750.00 at a term of 370 days, collected in the Inspection. |
| Letter dated June 2, 2009 signed by Mrs. Camino, addressed to CRAC Profinanzas, by which the Clients request the early cancellation of CD No. 007962, account No. 099-010-001-00051-6, and that the amount resulting from the transaction be transferred to the GPI intermediation account, collected in the Inspection. It should be noted that the amount of US$ 49,750.00 of the CD is very similar to the amount that the Clients indicate they have paid to GPI. | | | |
| Reports issued by GPI dated April 7, 2010, October 4, 2010, November 9, 2010, January 4, 2011, February 14, 2012, April 26, 2012, March 12, 2013, February 3, 2014, June 3, 2014, June 23, 2014, March 31, 2015, September 4, 2015, February 12, 2016, April 21, 2016, June 14, 2016 and August 19, 2016, presented by Mrs. Camino and/or collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| 12/12/2009 | 25,000.00 | - | Reports issued by GPI dated April 7, 2010, October 4, 2010, November 9, 2010, January 4, 2011, February 14, 2012, April 26, 2012, March 12, 2013, February 3, 2014, June 3, 2014, June 23, 2014, March 31, 2015, September 4, 2015, February 12, 2016, April 21, 2016, June 14, 2016 and August 19, 2016, presented by Mrs. Camino and/or collected in the Inspection. |
| 12/13/2011 | 50,000.00 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Term Deposit Certificate (CD) No. 3133 issued by CRAC Profinanzas on December 14, 2010 in the name of the Clients, with account No. 099-010-000-00597-7, for the amount of S/ 154,120.00 at a term of 360 days, maturing on December 9, 2011. Document collected in the Inspection. |
| Letter dated December 7, 2011 signed by the Clients, addressed to CRAC Profinanzas, by which the Clients request that at the maturity of CD No. 3133, account No. 099-010-000-00597-7, the amount resulting from the transaction be transferred to the GPI intermediation account. Document collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| Report issued by GPI stating the cancellation of the December 2011 CD issued by CRAC Profinanzas for the amount of S/ 154,120 with reference December 10, 2011. It is indicated that of this amount, S/ 134,900.00 was used to purchase US$ 50,000.00 at the exchange rate of S/ 2.698 on December 13, 2011, amount that was credited to account CLIO1157 (Clients' account). This report was presented by Mrs. Camino and also collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| Reports issued by GPI dated February 14, 2012, April 26, 2012, March 12, 2013, February 3, 2014, June 3, 2014, June 23, 2014, March 31, 2015, September 4, 2015, February 12, 2016, April 21, 2016, June 14, 2016 and August 19, 2016, presented by Mrs. Camino and/or collected in the Inspection. | | | |
| 06/23/2014 | -31,765.00 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of the Clients, signed by Mrs. Camino, and manager's checks. |
| 2015 | -18,600.00 | No. 317885723 at Banco Financiero | Payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of the Clients, some signed by Mrs. Camino, others by Mr. Holguín, and manager's checks. |
| 2016 | -11,000.00 | No. 3361639 at Scotiabank Perú | Payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of the Clients, some signed by Mrs. Camino, others by Mr. Holguín, and manager's checks. |
| Total Capital not returned | 113,261.48 | | |
- Likewise, it should be noted that GPI has accredited that from July 2009 to August 2016 it delivered to the Clients US$ 219,772.24 (Two hundred nineteen thousand seven hundred seventy-two and 24/100 United States Dollars)[70] as yields from the investments it claims to have made, accredited in payment receipts or payment vouchers issued by GPI in the name of the Clients and signed by one of them, according to documentation sent by GPI;
- As indicated above, GPI stated that it carried out transactions, however these have not been accredited by said former brokerage firm before this Superintendency, therefore, this would reflect that it has not been possible to prove that such transactions were carried out, which allows validly sustaining that such funds were used for purposes not authorized by the Clients;
- In that sense, according to Article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, except with express authorization from the client and that such purpose is related to any of the transactions indicated in Articles 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not accredited the execution of the transactions with the required documentation, it allows us to validly sustain that the funds delivered by the Clients were used for purposes other than those entrusted;
- It was then concluded that GPI did not rebut this charge, and consequently, it was accredited that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, and in accordance with what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 011-2017-SMV/10;
- In that sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of the main authorities of GPI, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[71], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[72], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism that they used with several clients, since in practice as maximum administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal handling of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, however, they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, therefore it is concluded that they participated in the commission of the infraction related to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thus failing to comply with the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the LMV and Article 48 of the Regulation;
- Regarding the complaint of Mrs. Batievsky
The Complaint
- By writings submitted to the SMV on December 28 and 29, 2016, Mrs. Margoth Batievsky Fleischman, hereinafter Mrs. Batievsky, sends a copy of the letter she sent to GPI on December 28, 2016 by which she claims the return of her invested capital and the corresponding earned premiums;
- In the writing sent to GPI, Mrs. Batievsky states that she has been a client of this stock brokerage firm since 2010 and that she was introduced by Mrs. Alicia Marrou who worked at GPI until 2015, that from the beginning Mr. Arizmendi offered her a yield between 1% and 2% monthly based on investments in the stock market in Peru and abroad;
- Likewise, she states that she delivered to GPI a total capital of US$ 441,787.46 as stated in the letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi on June 9, 2016, as well as in the letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi for GPI on November 4, 2016; in this writing, he confirms that the values as of that date of her portfolio, which will be included in the liquidation process of the obligations and investments of GPI, amount to US$ 441,787.46, plus yields to be regularized for US$ 11,250.00 (August to October);
- Mrs. Batievsky adds that for several months she has not been provided detailed reports of her portfolio, nor does she have access via internet to the information of her portfolio, and that she even had to renew the contract with GPI;
- She also mentions that on June 9, 2016, Mr. Arizmendi, by a letter signed by him on behalf of GPI and on a sheet bearing the GPI letterhead, explained that her portfolio was based on indices related to gold and silver that they managed and knew very well, and that at the end of September 2016, Mr. Arizmendi explained that since GPI was intervened, it had no possibility of moving the money from that "omnibus" account of GPI at the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC, hereinafter Interactive Brokers, in which GPI had invested the money she delivered and that it could not regularize the yields obtained;
- Finally, Mrs. Batievsky states that in another document signed by Mr. Arizmendi on behalf of GPI on November 4, 2016, signing under his signature "for GPI" and on a sheet bearing the GPI letterhead, he informs her that the values of her portfolio are put sale contracts of SVXY and GDX expiring on November 18, 2016 and January 20, 2017;
GPI's arguments in the preliminary inquiries
- It should be noted that by Official Letter No. 7572-2016-SMV/10.3 of December 30, 2016, the complaint filed by Mrs. Batievsky was transferred to GPI, as well as information and documentation was requested regarding the commercial relationship of the stock brokerage firm with Mrs. Batievsky and on the transactions carried out on behalf of this client, granting a term of three business days to present the information, which expired on January 4, 2017, it being necessary to indicate that to date, GPI has not sent the requested information;
Regarding the charge formulated to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle regarding this complaint
The Funds
- According to documents presented by Mrs. Batievsky, she delivered to GPI a total of US$ 441,787.46 for investments and attaches as support:
- Copy of letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi with the GPI logo dated June 9, 2016 addressed to the principal, by which he informs her that the capital invested through GPI (Mr. Arizmendi mentions "our represented") is US$ 441,787.46, the same that has been destined mainly to investments abroad.
- Copy of letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI (Mr. Arizmendi signs "for GPI") dated November 4, 2016 addressed to the principal, by which he informs her that the original value of the portfolio is US$ 441,787.46;
- Therefore, Mrs. Batievsky has accredited that she invested in GPI a total amount of US$ 441,787.46 and has stated that she has been a client of this stock brokerage firm since 2010 and these amounts have been recognized by GPI, according to documents signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI;
Regarding the destination of the resources
- Regarding the funds delivered in the amount of US$ 441,787.46, Mrs. Batievsky has not mentioned or specified the orders she instructed GPI to carry out for the investment of her funds, nor has she attached documentation in that regard; she only states that she has been a GPI client since 2010, and that Mr. Arizmendi offered her a return of between 1% and 2% monthly based on investments in the stock exchange in Peru and abroad;
- As for the investments that would have been made with Mrs. Batievsky's funds, it should be noted that, according to documentation submitted by the client, in the letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI on June 9, 2016, on behalf of GPI and on a sheet bearing GPI letterhead, he states that according to the client's risk profile and the instruments used, said investments will be destined to generating returns from arbitrage, stock dividends and option premiums that seek to generate amounts similar to income, preferably monthly, and that have the least possible adverse impact on the principal, even though fluctuations of both the principal and the returns are possible to occur over time. In that sense, GPI would have invested Mrs. Batievsky's funds in shares and other securities, as well as in the sale of options;
- Likewise, in the letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI on November 4, 2016, on behalf of GPI, signed under his signature "for GPI" and on a sheet bearing GPI letterhead, he maintains that as of that date Mrs. Batievsky's investment portfolio is valued at US$ 443,631.34 and that he has carried out option sale transactions detailed below, which were pending settlement as of that date:
- SVXY Put sale contracts as of January 20, 2017 for US$ 293,750.46.
- GDX Put sale contracts as of January 20, 2017 for US$ 103,996.56.
- SVXY Put sale contracts as of November 18, 2016 for US$ 45,884.28;
- What is stated in the previous paragraph reflects, according to a letter signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI and as if he were an authorized representative of said company, that this brokerage firm would have carried out at least three (03) transactions on behalf of Mrs. Batievsky, two (02) Put sale transactions on SVXY (ETF) and one (01) Put sale transaction on GDX (ETF);
- Likewise, it is observed that Mr. Arizmendi has direct participation in the management of the client's funds, informing her regarding the type of investments he has made according to the client's risk profile, as well as the valuation of her investment portfolio and the latest ETF option sale transactions that were pending expiration as of November 2016;
- As previously stated, this participation by Mr. Arizmendi is related to the fact that, after leaving the position of Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI in February 2013, in the name of GPIAM he participated in financial advisory to GPI since February 2013, in addition to being the spouse of the main shareholder, Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle; the documents indicate that both jointly have participated in the management of the funds of the clients who have reported GPI;
- In this regard, GPI has not responded to the request made in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 7572-2016-SMV/10.3, regarding whether it has the record of orders given by Mrs. Batievsky, the policies of the transactions carried out, the account statements in the name of this client, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing operations abroad in the name of GPI or in the name of Mrs. Batievsky. It should be noted that the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the brokerage firm and Mrs. Batievsky, according to the undated Client Registration Form, is: "Email with digital signature and with written confirmation";
- On the latter, it should be noted that GPI has not submitted to date a copy of writings, emails or other forms of transmission of instructions, which prove Mrs. Batievsky's willingness to allocate her funds to investments in derivative financial instruments such as Put sales on SVXY (ETF) and GDX (ETF) and other transactions with securities and financial instruments that would have been carried out since 2010;
- With regard to the investments made with Mrs. Batievsky's funds, GPI has not submitted to date copies of the account statements in the name of the brokerage firm, provided in the latter case by entities in charge of executing the operations and, if applicable, by foreign entities in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or instruments in the foreign market, with the intervention of GPI, with the funds delivered by said client, however, and as mentioned, this has not been proven by GPI;
- It should be noted that GPI has also not proven that the funds owned by Mrs. Batievsky or the derivative financial instruments in which the funds would have been invested (Put sales) or the securities resulting from the execution of the latter, or other securities and financial instruments in which these funds would have been invested, or a combination of both, are held in custody by GPI in the local market or under its responsibility in an account opened in a foreign entity in the name of GPI, proving that the funds, securities and financial instruments are indisputable property of Mrs. Batievsky. Likewise, it has also not proven that these funds and/or securities and financial instruments are in the name of Mrs. Batievski in a foreign entity;
- Consequently, it is evident that GPI was required to provide the minimum documentation proving that it complied with the instructions given by Mrs. Batievski and proving the investments made in her name with her funds;
- Likewise, through a writing delivered to GPI on December 28, 2016, attention Mrs. Bellido-Tagle-Tagle, Mrs. Batievsky requests the return of her invested capital and the earned premiums corresponding;
- To date, GPI and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle have not proven with all the required documentation indicated in the preceding recitals, the investments in the name of Mrs. Batievski from 2010 to September 2016, which would have been made according to the instructions of this client or that they have been destined to another destination; in none of the cases has the destination of the money delivered by this client been proven, so it is concluded that it would have been destined to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- In relation to the above, it is clear that GPI, Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle-Tagle would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since they received the funds delivered by Mrs. Batievsky for their custody and investment indications given by said client, and they have also not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds;
- Likewise, GPI, Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle- would have infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds owned by Mrs. Batievsky to operations, purposes or objectives other than those for which they were entrusted;
Regarding the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI did not present its defenses to the charge under analysis;
- Likewise, it should be noted that through a letter dated October 6, 2015 addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, Mrs. Marrou presents her resignation to GPI and indicates a list of clients, among whom is Mrs. Batievsky, whose funds were hosted "in a Global Account No. xxxxx30 at Interactive Brokers in the name of GPI ASSET MANAGEMENT S.A under the administration of Mr. Héctor Ucelli and yours….(…)";
- On the other hand, it should be noted that in a report issued by GPI signed by Mrs. Marrou, in letters signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI presented by the Client[73] and in reports gathered in the Inspection, this brokerage firm states that it supposedly carried out operations or invested with the Client's funds, according to the detail set out below:
Table No. 1
Supposed operations in the name of the client according to report issued by gpi, which have not been proven with the required documentation (in US$)
| DATE / PERIOD | DEPOSITS | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation | Value | Expiry; Strike price | No. Contracts | Amount / Exposure | Premiums | | |
| 11/16/2010 -10/18/2012 | 441,787.46 | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 11/16/2010 -02/04/2013 | - | Options | - | - | - | - | 126,767.1 |
| 2011 | - | 31 Operac. | - | - | - | 186,262.50 | - |
| 01/23/2013 | - | PUT Sale | NUGT | March 2013; 14 | 170 | 238,000 | 3,740 |
| 02/01/2013 | - | PUT Sale | GDXJ | March 2013; 20 | 106 | 212,000 | 5,300 |
| Jul - Sep 2013 | - | 3 Sales | - | - | - | 4,230 | - |
| 2015-11/04/2016 | - | PUT Sale | SVXY | 20-Jan-17 | - | 293,750.46 | - |
| 2015-11/04/2016 | - | PUT Sale | GDX | 20-Jan-17 | - | 103,996.56 | - |
| 2015-11/04/2016 | - | PUT Sale | SVXY | 20-Jan-17 | - | 45,884.28 | - |
| Total Capital | 441,787.46 | | | | | | |
| Market Value of the Portfolio as of 11/04/2016 | 443,631.34 | | | | | | |
- Regarding these supposed options operations that generated premiums and other operations with financial instruments, as GPI has indicated, the Client Registration Form of the Client subscribed on November 11, 2010 by the Client and Mrs. Marrou, who signs as representative of GPI, has been gathered in the Inspection, in which the following is indicated as "Services Requested by the Client": "Purchase/Sale of securities on the BVL", "Repo operations", "Operations with futures, options and derivatives", "Advisory in capital markets (Peru)", and "Advisory in capital markets (international)"; the object of the investment is not indicated. Likewise, it should be noted that in the documentation presented by the Client there is a copy of a Client Registration Form, which does not have the second page (Annex Client Registration Form) in which the services requested by the client should be included;
- It should be noted that in the letter of June 9, 2016, Mr. Arizmendi, in the name of GPI, states that according to the client's risk profile and the instruments used, said investments will be destined to generating returns from arbitrage, stock dividends and option premiums that seek to generate amounts similar to income, preferably monthly, and that have the least possible adverse impact on the principal, even though fluctuations of both the principal and the returns are possible to occur over time;
- For her part, the Client in an email of January 8, 2016 addressed to Mr. Arizmendi, presented in her complaint, states, referring to a report of February 2013, that this type of document with the information on investments and expected profitability in options is what she needs and expects to be provided about her capital month by month. Likewise, she indicates that the profitability in times of high volatility was higher, and finally indicates that when they spoke initially Mr. Arizmendi offered her at least 1% monthly. Likewise, in the letter of December 26, 2016 addressed to GPI, the Client states, among others, that from the beginning Mr. Arizmendi offered her a return of between 1 and 2% monthly based on investments in the stock exchange in Peru and abroad;
- It should be noted that what GPI and the Client state regarding the investments that this former brokerage firm states it has made in the name of the Client is not evaluated, considering that, despite the requirements formulated by the SMV to date, GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding supporting documentation that proves the carrying out of operations with options and other financial instruments in the foreign market that explain the returns paid to the Client and the market value of the portfolio as of November 4, 2016, as indicated by GPI and detailed in Table No. 1; that is, the account statements of the foreign intermediary that carried out the operations with the Client's funds, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the records of global account control, the policies, orders, etc.;
- Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds that the Client entrusted to it for custody and investment indications given by her and that, according to the documentation presented by the Client and that gathered in the Inspection, amounts to US$ 441,787.46, delivered between November 16, 2010 and October 18, 2012[74], funds that have not been partially withdrawn by the Client, as concluded from the email of Mr. Arizmendi of April 4, 2016, addressed to the Client, through which he indicates that he attaches the corresponding report to the Client as of April 4, 2016;
- Indeed, Mr. Arizmendi states in his email: "I have taken the trouble to go line by line since November 16, 2010, including all income, withdrawals, returns, option write-offs, etc., and I get the numbers that I finally send you…". In that sense, according to the letter of April 4, 2016 from Mr. Arizmendi addressed to the Client[75]; it is indicated that after the deposits, "withdrawals made[76]" for US$ 118,767.10, "earned premiums" for US$ 126,767.10, and "additional premiums paid" for US$ 84,000.00 (approx. Years 2014 and 2016), the "Principal Balance (to date, reconciling with the corrected figure above)" is US$ 448,747.60,;
- The delivery of these funds for the sum of US$ 441,787.46 is proven by the documents presented by the Client and another gathered in the Inspection, such as a bank transfer voucher, a copy of a document called "Cover Sheet" dated November 11, 2010, a copy of the letters of March 11, April 4, June 9 and November 4, 2016 through which Mr. Arizmendi, in the name of GPI, states the amount of the initial capital contributed by the Client to GPI, as well as a copy of a document signed by Mrs. Marrou on the situation of the Client's portfolio as of February 4, 2013, a copy of the letter from Mrs. Marrou addressed to Mr. Arizmendi of October 6, 2015. The detail is shown in Table No. 2;
Table No. 2
Proof of funds delivered by the client to gpi (in US$)
| Date | Deposit Amount | Deposit Account | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 11/16/2010 | 100,000.00 | 3361639 at Scotiabank Perú | Bank transfer voucher to GPI's intermediation account, presented by the Client. |
| Document called "Cover Sheet" of 11/11/2010, signed by GPI representative, found in the Inspection, in which it is indicated that the Client will begin her relationship with GPI by investing US$ 100,000.00 in Interactive Brokers. It should be noted that the funds were deposited in a GPI intermediation account and the Client signed on 11/11/2010 a contract for intermediation in the foreign market where she authorizes GPI to administer the custody of her financial instruments in a global account in the name of GPI. | | | |
| Other documents indicating that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46, which are also indicated in this table as supporting documents of the balance of US$ 341,787.46 deposited from 04/01/2011 to 10/18/2012. | | | |
| 04/01/2011, 06/03/2011 and 10/18/2012 (*) | US$ 341,787.46 | - | Letter of 03/11/2016 from Mr. Arizmendi, unsigned, addressed to the Client, through which he indicates that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46 and the Principal Balance (to date) is US$ 432,747.46. This letter would have been attached by Mr. Arizmendi through an email he sent to the Client on 03/15/2016, in which the document called "Report Maggie Batievsky as of March 11, 2016.docx" is indicated as an attachment. |
| Letter of 04/04/2016 from Mr. Arizmendi, unsigned, addressed to the Client, through which he indicates that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46 and the Principal Balance (to date) is US$ 448,747.60. This letter would have been attached by Mr. Arizmendi through an email he sent to the Client on that same date, in which it is observed that he indicates as an attachment the document called "Report Maggie Batievsky as of April 4, 2016.docx". | | | |
| Letter with the GPI logo of 06/09/2016 signed by Mr. Arizmendi, addressed to the Client, through which he indicates that the initial invested capital is US$ 441,787.46, which has been destined mainly to investments abroad. | | | |
| Letter of 11/04/2016 signed by Mr. Arizmendi in the name of GPI, addressed to the Client, through which he indicates that the original value of the portfolio is US$ 441,787.46. | | | |
| Letter from Mrs. Marrou of 10/06/2015 addressed to GPI Asset Management S.A.C., attention Mr. Arizmendi, indicating that the clients' money (among them the Client) were hosted in a Global Account No. xxxxx30 at Interactive Brokers in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C., so that, due to her resignation as Representative of GPI, she leaves a record of the available cash balances reported to the clients as of that date. The amount in the name of the Client is US$ 317,329.56, that is, part of the total invested capital. | | | |
| Report called "Summary of Options" of 02/04/2013, signed by Mrs. Marrou, in which the amount of US$ 441,787.46 is indicated as contributed capital. | | | |
| Bank transfer voucher to GPI's intermediation account, presented by the Client. For S/ 190,000.00 plus commissions, the total charged amounts to S/ 190,002.70. The transfer was made from a Scotiabank savings account in the name of the Client to the current account in soles 000-317885693 at Banco Financiero in the name of GPI (intermediation account in soles) | | | |
| Email from the Client of 10/18/2012 addressed to Mrs. Marrou, in which she indicates that she has transferred S/ 190,000.00; in a previous email Mrs. Marrou indicates to the Client the current account in soles 000-317885693 at Banco Financiero in the name of GPI (intermediation account in soles); in a subsequent email Mrs. Marrou indicates to the Client: "as soon as we see it in the account I confirm". | | | |
| In addition to the email of 10/18/2012, the Client presented a report of Movements in her savings account at Scotiabank Perú from 01/01/2010 to 02/27/2013 in which a "Transfer" is observed on 10/18/2012 for S/ 190,002.70 (according to the Client this amount corresponds to the deposit she made to GPI on 10/18/2012). | | | |
| Regarding another deposit, the Client presented reports of Movements in her savings account at Scotiabank Perú from 01/01/2010 to 02/27/2013 in which a "Transfer between Accounts" is observed on 03/31/2011 for S/ 41,250.00 (according to the Client this amount corresponds to the deposit she made to GPI on 04/01/2011). For this case the Client additionally presented a bank voucher of transfer between accounts for an amount of S/ 41,250.00 from her soles savings account at Scotiabank to current account 6720307 of the same bank in the name of GPI (Intermediation account in soles of the former intermediary). | | | |
| Total Capital | 441,787.46 | | |
| (*) The dates of these deposits have been indicated by the Client. | | | |
1. Likewise, it should be noted that it is accredited that GPI has delivered to the Client the amount of US$ 202,767.10, corresponding in part to the concept of "withdrawals made" for a total of US$ 118,767.10[77] and in part to the concept of "additional premiums paid" for a total of US$ 84,000.00, as accredited in a copy of a letter from Mr. Arizmendi addressed to the Client dated 04 April 2016, submitted by the Client[78], for returns on investments that GPI states it has made;
2. It should be noted that the letter from Mrs. Marrou dated 06 October 2015 indicated in Table No. 2 shows a destination of the funds, from GPI's account to that of GPI Asset Management S.A.C, which was not authorized by the principal, since GPI has not presented documentation in this regard and rather has indicated, through letters signed by Mr. Arizmendi and a report signed by Mrs. Marrou, on behalf of GPI, that this former brokerage firm managed the Client's funds;
3. Likewise, GPI states that it carried out operations, and even assuming they had been carried out in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C, through Interactive Brokers LLC, these have not been accredited by said former brokerage firm before this Superintendency, which validly allows sustaining that in reality such funds were disposed of for purposes not authorized by the Client, such as the transfer of those funds to an account in the name of GPI Asset Management S.A.C;
4. In that sense, in accordance with article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent may not be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, except with express authorization from the Client and provided that said purpose refers to one of the operations indicated in article 194 of the LMV;
5. Therefore, since GPI has not accredited the carrying out of the operations with the required documentation, this validly allows us to sustain that the funds delivered by the Client in the sum of US$ 441,787.46 were disposed of for purposes other than those entrusted;
6. It was then concluded that GPI did not rebut this charge, and consequently, it was accredited that GPI incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation; and in accordance with what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 012-2017-SMV/10;
7. In that sense, what is stated in the preceding recitals accredits, in addition to the concerted action of part of GPI's main authorities, that is, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle[79], as well as Mr. Arizmendi[80], among others, having participated in the events described above, as part of a systematic mechanism they used with several clients, since in fact, as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, they knew of the deficit incurred or the illegal handling of the funds of the clients of the former brokerage firm, yet they allowed said infraction to continue to the detriment of such clients, for which it is concluded that they participated in the commission of such infraction referring to the destination of funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thereby failing to comply with the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the Regulation;
5. Use of client funds in custody for purposes other than those entrusted
Of the charge formulated against Mrs. Bellido regarding the use of funds in custody
- According to the supervision work carried out by the SMV, indications of infraction by GPI were found regarding the custody of client funds;
- These facts have been the subject of an administrative sanctioning procedure contained in file No. 2016035717, with respect to which Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10 was issued, sanctioning GPI with the revocation of its operating authorization, which has been the subject of an appeal that was resolved by Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02 of 25 January of this year;
- Likewise, through Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 029-2017-SMV/10, it was declared that GPI used the funds of the intermediation accounts without having the authorization of its clients for an amount complementary to the funds deficit determined through Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10, allocating said funds to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted. Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 029-2017-SMV/10 became final as no appeal was filed against it;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, the facts are described below in which Mr. Arizmendi, in his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until 23 February 2013 and after that date in his capacity as de facto representative; and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as general manager and chairwoman of the board of GPI from 24 February of that year onward; however, having the duty to adequately safeguard the funds of the clients of the brokerage firm, and in accordance with the facts of the complaints described in the preceding recitals, they would have managed them differently from what those clients ordered, which accredits a mechanism whose objective was to allocate the funds to purposes other than those entrusted.
Of the facts that occurred
- Through Memorandum No. 001-2016-INSP.GPI of 30 March 2016, GPI was requested, among others, to present the following information: i) Reconciliation between the cash balances of clients maintained in the intermediation accounts (domestic and foreign) and the credit balances of clients at the close of the months of December 2015 and January and February 2016;
- Likewise, GPI was requested, if negative differences were determined between the accounting balance of the Banks account in relation to the balances of the Credit Clients, to provide an explanation of the nature of said differences, as well as the respective documentary support and, ii) List of all clients that record credit and debit balances, at the close of the months of December 2015, January and February 2016, according to the respective client account statements, consistent with their accounting records;
- Likewise, with Official Letter No. 2651-2016-SMV/10.2 of 04 May 2016, GPI was requested to provide the detail and support of the differences obtained from the reconciliation of credit balances of principals versus the funds in operating bank accounts, for the periods corresponding to 31 December 2015, 31 January and 29 February 2016 and in accordance with the amounts indicated therein[81];
- Through Official Letter No. 3102-2016-SMV/10.2, the General Superintendency of Supervision of Entities, hereinafter IGSE, communicated to GPI, among others, about the deficit of funds in intermediation accounts with respect to credit balances; without GPI having informed to date about the authorizations that the principals would have granted it for the use of their funds, nor has it presented documentation accrediting the existence of such authorizations;
- Through Report No. 780-2016-SMV/10.2, the IGSE indicated, among others, that the deficit of funds in the intermediation accounts as of 31 July 2016 was S/ 626,560.00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles), in accordance with the information reported by GPI as of 31 July 2016 and the files held by the SMV;
- With Report No. 978-2016-SMV/10.2, the IGSE communicated the update of the calculation of the deficit of the intermediation accounts that was reported through Report No. 780-2016-SMV/10.2, as well as the results of the evaluation of the indications of possible infractions to the regulations by GPI, indicating that the deficit of funds of principals as of 21 November 2016 resulting from the difference between the bank balances of the intermediation accounts and the credit balances would amount to S/ 1,727,538.03. Consequently, the deficit of funds of principals would have increased by S/ 1,100,978.03 with respect to the deficit of funds reported as of 31 July 2016 of S/ 626,560.00;
- From the review of the information sent by GPI to the SMV, in response to the request made regarding the update of the report called "Liquidity Balances including CPC" as of 21 November 2016, which shows a detail of the total of its principals with the respective monetary balances, in soles and dollars at the indicated date, it was observed that the total amount of credit balances in national currency amounts to S/ 1,330,281.17 and foreign currency to US$ 512,411.97[82]; that is, the credit balance in national currency reached the amount of S/ 3,081,192.87 (Three million eighty-one thousand one hundred ninety-two and 00/87 Soles);
- Likewise, the balances of the operating bank current accounts in national currency and foreign currency as of 21 November 2016 show a total amount of S/ 1,107,658.72[83] and US$ 71,991.84[84], respectively, making a total in national currency of S/ 1,353,654.84 (One million three hundred fifty-three thousand six hundred fifty-four and 84/100 Soles);
- When calculating the balance of the custody accounts in client funds as of 21 November 2016 (in national and foreign currency), a deficit of funds of principals is found that results from the difference between the credit balance and the bank balances, which would amount to S/ 1,727,538.03 (One million seven hundred twenty-seven thousand five hundred thirty-eight and 03/100 Soles). The detail of the calculation is shown below:
| | |
|---|
| Accounts | As of 21/11/2016 | |
| S/ | US$ | |
| Client funds in Intermediation Accounts (operating) | 1,107,658.72 | 71,991.84 |
| Credit balances of clients | -1,330,281.17 | -512,411.97 |
| Surplus /Deficit | -222,622.45 | -440,420.13 |
| Exchange rate[85] | 1.00 | 3.4170 |
| Surplus /Deficit in Soles in S/ and US$ | -222,622.45 | -1,504,915.58 |
| Total deficit in national currency | -1,727,538.03 | |
Source: Report "Liquidity balances including CPC" as of 21 November 2016 and "Balances of Operating Accounts" in national currency and foreign currency, as of 21 November 2016.
- It should be recalled that the deficit of funds of principals as of 21 November 2016 shows an increase of S/ 1,100,978.03 (One million one hundred thousand nine hundred seventy-eight and 03/100 Soles) with respect to the deficit of funds reported as of 31 July 2016, which was S/ 626,560.00;
- In that sense, as can be seen, with the balances of the intermediation accounts it was not possible to cover the deficit of the credit balances of the clients. In this regard, as previously indicated, GPI stated that the funds of the intermediation accounts were used to cover guarantee margins of repo operations and, it should be additionally noted that, until January 2017, the brokerage firm has not complied with accrediting the authorizations of the respective principals to use their funds for said purpose, considering the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV, notwithstanding the requirements made; therefore GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative, would have used the funds of the intermediation accounts without having the authorization of its clients for a total amount updated as of 21 November 2016 of S/ 1,727,538.03;
- What is stated in the preceding recital accredits that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as general manager and chairwoman of the board of GPI, as well as Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative and related to Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and GPI, would have participated in the events described above, since both in practice, as the highest administrative authorities of said brokerage firm, knew of the deficit incurred, which allows concluding that they would have allocated the funds of the clients of the brokerage firm to operations and purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thereby failing to comply with the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the Regulation;
Of the defenses and their evaluation
Regarding the deficit as of 31 July 2016
- In this regard, as previously indicated in this resolution, GPI was notified of the charge referring to the deficit as of 31 July 2016 for the amount of S/ 626,560.00; however, despite having been validly notified via MVNet, GPI has not submitted the respective defenses as of the date of issuance of this resolution;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, the respective evaluation must be carried out. Indeed, as indicated in the detail of the charge formulated, according to the information provided by GPI at the time, it was determined that as of 31 July 2016 GPI maintained a deficit of funds in the intermediation accounts in the amount of S/ 2,565,778. This amount includes the balance payable to Mrs. Alvarez in the amount of S/ 1,939,218.00 (One million nine hundred thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen and 00/100 Soles), which has been the subject of evaluation in a charge imputation different from the present one in the administrative sanctioning procedure against GPI;
- Thus, with respect to the amount of S/ 626,560.00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles), according to what GPI stated in response to the information requests made, the brokerage firm supposedly would have used said funds, corresponding to various principals of the brokerage firm, for the purpose of covering guarantee margins for repo operations of other reported principals. GPI did not accredit that this use of funds was made with the respective authorization of its clients; since despite having been required to present such authorizations in accordance with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation, it has not complied with accrediting the existence thereof to date;
- Therefore, as of 31 July 2016, according to what GPI stated, it supposedly used funds of principals to cover, among others, replenishment of guarantee margins for repo operations of reported principals without having the authorization of principals covering the total amount used;
- In that sense, according to the information provided by GPI at the time and taking into account that said brokerage firm has not offered evidentiary elements or arguments that allow rebutting the imputed charge, it has been accredited that the brokerage firm used, without having the respective authorization, funds of principals that were under its custody, in the amount of S/ 626,560.00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles) as of 31 July 2016. This is in accordance with the information obtained on the deficit of the intermediation accounts administered by GPI;
Regarding the deficit after 31 July 2016[86]
- In this regard, GPI was notified of the charge referring to the complementary deficit incurred as of 21 November 2016 for the amount of S/ 1,100,978.03 (One million one hundred thousand nine hundred seventy-eight and 03/100 Soles); however, despite having been validly notified via MVNet, GPI did not submit the respective defenses;
- As previously indicated, as of 21 November 2016, there was an increase of S/ 1,100,978.03 (One million one hundred thousand nine hundred seventy-eight and 03/100 Soles) with respect to the deficit of funds reported as of 31 July 2016, which was S/ 626,560.00 (Six hundred twenty-six thousand five hundred sixty and 00/100 Soles);
- It should also be noted that the aforementioned deficit incurred has not been the subject of explanation by said former brokerage firm, nor has it complied with presenting the corresponding authorizations of its clients for the use of their funds, which demonstrates that the funds of the clients' intermediation accounts were used without having the respective authorization,
- It should be noted that the increase in the deficit in the intermediation account between 31 July 2016 and 21 November 2016 is mainly sustained by the fact that for the last indicated date, the reconciliation items were not considered in the balances of the operating bank accounts to the extent that they were not supported by GPI; in particular the bank charges not recorded in books;
- In this regard, in order to obtain the amount of the deficit of funds in intermediation accounts, through Requirement Memoranda No. 001 and 002 dated 21 and 23 September 2016, GPI was requested to present and explain in a detailed and documented manner Control Annex No. 5 as of 20 September 2016. It should be noted that the aforementioned Control Annex has as components the "Credit Balances of Clients" and "Client Funds in Intermediation Accounts", whose reconciliation as of 20 September 2016 showed a deficit of funds that was neither explained nor supported. Therefore, through Official Letters No. 6857 and 6974 dated 11 and 21 November 2016, GPI was again requested to update the aforementioned Control Annex No. 5 and explain the resulting deficit; however, despite the repeated requests made, GPI did not send the requested documentation;
- Because current information corresponding to bank reconciliations was not available, a review of said reconciliations as of 30 September 2016 was carried out, as it was the last period reported by GPI. As a consequence of such review, it was observed that the reconciling items constituted a material balance with respect to the amount recorded in the operating bank accounts MN 6720307 and ME 3361369 maintained at Banco Scotiabank;
- In order to review the reconciling items presented by GPI, a sample was taken from the detail of reconciling items corresponding to "Bank Discounts not recorded in Books" and GPI was requested to present the supporting documentation accrediting that said transactions were effectively carried out, as well as an explanation of the reasons why they were pending reconciliation. GPI has not responded to Official Letter No. 6974-2016-SMV/10.2;
- Subsequent to the aforementioned facts, and in compliance with the provisions of Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10, which was confirmed by Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/2 of 25 January 2017, it should be noted that on 01 February 2017, the assets of GPI were transferred to Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., hereinafter Kallpa SAB. The Transfer Record, hereinafter the Record, was signed by the representatives of GPI and Kallpa SAB; SMV officials participating for this purpose as observers;
- In this sense, as a result of the transfer and the evaluation carried out by the SMV, as recorded in the Record, and the information sent on 20 February 2017 by GPI, the credit balance, without including therein the claims of the intermediary itself, was S/ 563,525.98 and USD 301,040.70; balances that were reviewed and contrasted in accordance with the information gathered during the administrative intervention at GPI;
- On the other hand, on the transfer date, as recorded in the Record, GPI delivered to Kallpa SAB checks for amounts of S/ 422,334.31 and USD 25,312.06 from Scotiabank. On 20 February 2017, GPI delivered to the SMV a check for S/ 96,963.50 which GPI endorsed in favor of Kallpa SAB and made available to said intermediary through Official Letter No. 1186-2017-SMV/10.2. It should be noted that the amount of the indicated check was added to those delivered at the signing of the Record. Therefore, the total delivered in soles amounted to S/.519,297.81;
- Given the foregoing, the final difference between the credit balance and the money delivered to Kallpa SAB is detailed below;
| | |
|---|
| Accounts | As of 01/02/2017 | |
| S/ | US$ | |
| Checks delivered | 519,297.81 | 25,312.06 |
| Credit balances of clients | -563,525.98 | -301,040.72 |
| Surplus /Deficit | -44,228.17 | -275,728.66 |
| Exchange rate[87] | 1.00 | 3.2701 |
| Surplus /Deficit in Soles in S/ | -44,228.17 | -901,660.29 |
| Total deficit expressed in national currency | -945,888.46 | |
- Consequently, the deficit of funds of principals shows an increase, expressed in Soles, of S/ 319,328.46 (Three hundred nineteen thousand three hundred twenty-eight and 46/100 Soles) with respect to the deficit of funds reported as of 31 July 2016, which was S/ 626,560.00; it being necessary to specify that these balances do not include the amounts delivered to GPI or its representatives by other clients to carry out operations abroad and other transactions, which have been reported to the SMV and are being evaluated in other administrative procedures;
- Considering the foregoing, it can be concluded that GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi in his capacity as de facto representative, have used the funds of the intermediation accounts without having the authorization of its clients for a total amount updated as of 01 February 2017 of S/ 945,888.46;
- Consequently, from the evaluation carried out on the charges, it has been accredited that both GPI and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi have used the funds of their clients' intermediation accounts without having the respective authorization. Therefore, GPI, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and Mr. Arizmendi have failed to comply with the provisions of article 195, literal a) of the LMV and article 48 of the Regulation; and therefore have incurred a very serious infraction established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation*;*
IV. Evaluation of the Sanction
-
In accordance with Article 348 of the LMV and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with Article 230, numeral 3, of the LPAG and Article 236-A of the aforementioned normative body, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria set forth by the LMV, the Sanctions Regulation and the LPAG;
-
Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The harm caused and the repercussion on the market; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; e) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; f) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; and, g) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification;
-
In accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, sanctions that became final within the four (04) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction are considered as the offender's antecedents; it should be noted that, on a personal basis, in the case of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, it corresponds to state that she does not present infraction antecedents;
-
Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, in the present case, in relation to the funds of GPI's clients that were destined to purposes other than those authorized without the respective authorization, it must be taken into account that damage has been produced to their particular interests, mainly because it has affected the trust they had in GPI and in its main directors, that is, Mrs. Bellido Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi, and Mr. Uccelli, and therefore has affected their trust in the securities market, to the extent that to date the destination given to the resources that were delivered to them for the respective investments has not been accredited and they have been destined to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
-
Likewise, a protected legal interest has been affected, consisting of the protection of the investor, since Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has openly breached various obligations (in her capacity as chair of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 onward), of the intermediaries that operate in the securities market in accordance with the provisions of the LMV and the Regulation, which have the purpose of preventing the affectation of investors' interests and making the operations carried out transparent; which Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has not complied with, with respect to the resources entrusted to her by her clients, in her capacity as the highest administrative authority of an authorized intermediary;
-
Indeed, through the infraction of destining funds to different purposes, the trust that investors must have regarding the stock brokerage firms and their representatives who carry out operations in the securities market is affected, as well as exposing investors and the market to unnecessary risk situations;
-
It should be noted that the fiduciary role of the directors and representatives of the brokerage agents is fundamental in providing confidence to the investor regarding the management of their funds entrusted for investments in the securities market, and it is therefore not admissible, as Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has done, to maintain that operations have been executed, without accrediting them with the corresponding documents such as orders, policies and account statements of the foreign intermediary or the corresponding custody entity, if the operations were carried out abroad, even more so if the client has been requesting the status of the funds for several months and the ability to dispose of them;
-
As for the economic harm caused and the repercussion on the market, it should be indicated that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as the highest director of GPI (who is chair of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 onward), has not accredited the destination of the funds delivered by her clients, and these cannot dispose of the funds delivered or the result of the investments made, in accordance with their instructions, so the economic harm for such clients amounts to the balance of their capital not delivered by GPI, which is S/ 8,147,597.51 (with respect to the complaints against GPI) and S/ 945,888.46 (deficit in GPI's intermediation accounts, money owned by GPI's clients other than those that are the subject of complaint), which was destined to purposes other than those entrusted, plus the returns they could have obtained in the best investment alternative in the market according to the clients' investment profile if these funds had been returned at the time required by the investor;
-
Likewise, regarding the repercussion on the market, it should be noted that by having failed to observe the LMV and the Regulation and having disposed of the money delivered to the stock brokerage firm, directed in this case by Mr. Arizmendi, Mrs. Bellido Tagle and Mr. Uccelli, for purposes other than those ordered, the securities market has been exposed, altering the trust that investors should have in the intermediaries and their representatives who participate in the negotiation of operations;
-
Without prejudice to the foregoing, it is appropriate to note that both the absence of taking orders in accordance with the regulations, as well as the failure to deliver information to clients, in particular, the sending of account statements, and subsequently the delay in the return of the invested funds, generated uncertainty regarding the updated amount of their investments and their destination;
-
Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, in relation to this criterion, it should be noted that GPI had a commercial relationship with the clients mentioned in numeral 2 of section III of this resolution, some even since 2009 and 2010 and from later years (according to their client registration form) and would have supposedly carried out operations on their behalf in the local and foreign market, and from approximately those years onward receiving funds from such clients for S/ 8,147,597.51 (with respect to the complaints against GPI) and S/ 945,888.46 (deficit in GPI's intermediation accounts, money owned by GPI's clients other than those that are the subject of complaint), to be destined to investments, for which it is required in accordance with the regulations to collect the prior orders of these clients;
-
However, GPI, through a mechanism carried out by Mr. Arizmendi, jointly with the participation of Mrs. Bellido Tagle and Mr. Uccelli, not only did not collect the corresponding orders for the receipt of these funds, but also has not accredited their destination, with the documents that every stock brokerage firm must have and that its representatives must obligatorily observe, in addition to the orders, the policies, the account statements of the foreign intermediaries in charge of the execution of the operations or of the corresponding custody entities, some document of authorization from the client for the use of the funds, etc., with respect to several GPI clients who entrusted their money to this former stock brokerage firm;
-
Likewise, it was observed in the cases derived from the complaints presented by the clients mentioned in numeral 2 of section III of this resolution, that GPI has not accredited the receipt by such clients of the respective account statements in the name of the latter;
-
It should also be indicated that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, in her capacity as the highest administrative authority of GPI (as chair of the board and general manager of GPI since February 21, 2013), at the date of the events, knew the securities market regulations, so it is not admissible that she has not observed the various obligations contained in the LMV and the Regulation when funds are received from its clients, taking into account that the client deposits their trust in the stock brokerage firm and its representatives (as indicated by the aforementioned clients who chose GPI for the management of their investments given the trust placed in Mr. Arizmendi and Mrs. Bellido-Tagle and require knowing the destination of their investments and disposing of their funds or selling their holding of financial instruments, which may have been generated as a result of the intermediation activities, at the moment they require it;
-
In this sense, the action of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, as the highest administrative and directive authority of GPI, reflects an inappropriate and illegal mechanism to the detriment of its clients destined to dispose of the money that they entrusted to the former stock brokerage firm in which the three aforementioned persons served;
-
It should also be indicated that, in addition to the complaints considered in this administrative procedure, there are additionally others whose resolution and/or initiation of sanctioning procedure was carried out subsequent to the imputation of charges of this file; although they have not been included, the denounced facts are of a similar nature to those described above;
-
Regarding the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction in the present case, it should be indicated that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has not accredited the investments made through GPI with the S/ 8,147,597.51 (with respect to the complaints against GPI), that the clients mentioned in numeral 2 of section III of this resolution delivered to GPI between the years 2010 to 2015. It should be added that there is a monetary shortfall in GPI for S/ 945,888.46 (deficit in GPI's intermediation accounts, money owned by GPI's clients other than those that are the subject of complaint) that has also not been accredited by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, especially considering that it is she, as general manager, who must know the destination of said funds, a situation that to date has not been clarified;
-
In this sense, it is concluded that the illicit benefit obtained as a product of the infraction of destining funds to purposes other than those ordered is at least S/ 8,147,597.51 (with respect to the complaints indicated above against GPI and that have become final) plus the opportunity cost incurred since the clients delivered the funds to GPI under the administration of Mr. Arizmendi jointly with Mrs. Bellido Tagle and Mr. Uccelli. It should be added that there is a monetary shortfall in GPI for S/ 945,888.46 (deficit in GPI's intermediation accounts, money owned by GPI's clients other than those that are the subject of complaint)
-
In relation to the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it must be specified that in the present case Mrs. Bellido Tagle, jointly with Mr. Arizmendi, and Mr. Uccelli, through GPI, have developed a mechanism that had the purpose of disposing of the clients' money for purposes other than those indicated by the latter, since there is only the argument of GPI, issued by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle or by Mr. Arizmendi or by Mr. Uccelli, regarding the fact that the S/ 8,147,597.51 (with respect to the complaints against GPI indicated above) was invested in supposed operations in the foreign market with financial instruments, mainly derivatives; however, these investments have not been accredited and it has not been proven that GPI's clients instructed that their funds be invested in that manner. It should be added that there is a monetary shortfall in GPI for S/ 945,888.46 (deficit in GPI's intermediation accounts, money owned by GPI's clients other than those that are the subject of complaint);
-
In this sense, the intentionality is evidenced in the action in a concerted mechanism of Mrs. Bellido Tagle (in her capacity as chair of the board and general manager of GPI from December 21, 2013 onward) jointly with Mr. Arizmendi, and Mr. Uccelli in their capacity as director, institutional clients manager and representatives of GPI, which can be determined by having developed various acts that compromise the action of such natural persons;
-
Indeed, Mrs. Bellido Tagle, Mr. Arizmendi, and Mr. Uccelli signed various documentation, or sent emails, etc. in the name of GPI, affirming having carried out operations in the name of such clients, even explaining to them the volatility of the market and the future horizons for the recovery of their funds (in some cases); however, although Mrs. Bellido Tagle was required, in her capacity as general manager of GPI, she has not accredited such operations with the respective documentation; therefore, it is considered that it is not possible to admit that Mrs. Bellido Tagle, jointly with Mr. Arizmendi, and Mr. Uccelli, persons with experience in the securities market, can obviate compliance with essential norms of intermediation in the securities market and neglect the fiduciary responsibility that should have characterized them with respect to each of their clients;
-
The foregoing demonstrates the intentionality of Mrs. Bellido-Tagle in her capacity as the highest administrative authority of GPI (chair of the board and general manager from February 21, 2013 onward), to dispose of the funds of GPI's clients for purposes other than those entrusted within the framework of a concerted mechanism to appropriate the money of its clients;
-
In relation to the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infractions and the offender's contribution to their clarification, it should be indicated that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has not presented discharges of the infraction that is the subject of this sanctioning procedure;
-
Without prejudice to the foregoing, Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 must be taken into account, which modified, among others, Article 230, numeral 3, of the LPAG, and introduced as additional criteria of reasonableness: (i) the probability of detection of the infraction and (ii) recidivism for the commission of the infraction within the term of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final. Additionally, Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 modified, among others, Article 236-A of the LPAG, restructuring the exempting and mitigating assumptions of responsibility;
-
In this sense, it corresponds to evaluate the following criteria for grading the principle of reasonableness established in Article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG:
-
In relation to the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be indicated that in this file it has not been evidenced that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle informed the SMV in advance of the realization of the supposed operations in which she indicates that GPI intervened for the intermediation of the financial instruments that she indicates would have bought or sold in the name of the clients. Additionally, to date GPI, nor Mrs. Bellido-Tagle, have not accredited the supposed realization of operations that they indicate would have carried out;
-
Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the information that GPI provided to the regulator did not reasonably evidence elements that allow knowing of the infraction that is the subject of this administrative sanctioning procedure. The omission in the elaboration of information supporting GPI's relationship with the clients, such as orders or account statements, increases the difficulty of detecting these infractions;
-
It should be added, furthermore, that in the analyzed case it was possible to detect the infraction committed by Mrs. Bellido-Tagle based on the facts exposed by the clients in the complaints formulated against said former stock brokerage firm; and in the case of the deficit in intermediation accounts, as a result of the supervision and control activities of the SMV
-
With reference to recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within the term of one (01) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, it must be stated that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle does not present antecedents of sanction for infractions identical to the infraction for destination of funds different from those entrusted that is the subject of sanction in this administrative sanctioning procedure;
-
As for the exempting and mitigating assumptions of responsibility, in accordance with the provisions of Article 236-A of the LPAG, it is not observed that in the present case any of the assumptions that constitute exempting and mitigating conditions of responsibility has been configured;
-
From the foregoing, it is concluded that Mrs. Bellido-Tagle has incurred in the commission of one (01) infraction qualified as very serious of the Sanctions Regulation;
-
In accordance with the provisions of Article 20 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the commission of the facts, for the infraction referring to destining client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, typified as very serious, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle is liable to be sanctioned with a fine greater than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT, dismissal or disqualification for a maximum term of five (05) years in accordance with the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that Mrs. Antonia Luzmila Mariana Bellido-Tagle Fernández Concha has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by having contravened, in her capacity as chair of the board and general manager of Grupo Privado de Inversiones-Valores S.A. former stock brokerage firm from February 21, 2013 onward, the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments and Article 48 of the Regulation of Brokerage Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
Article 2.- Sanction Mrs. Antonia Luzmila Mariana Bellido-Tagle Fernández Concha with the sanction of disqualification for the period of five (5) years for the commission of the very serious infraction referred to in Article 1 of this resolution.
Article 3.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal resource presented before the same, within the term of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 4.- In the event that this resolution is not subject to challenge through a reconsideration or appeal resource within the term of fifteen (15) business days from notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on Advertising of Normative Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
Article 5.- Transcribe this resolution to Mrs. Antonia Luzmila Mariana Bellido-Tagle Fernández Concha, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
- Article 1 of Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02 of January 25, 2017 declared unfounded the appeal filed by GPI against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10, by which GPI's operating authorization was revoked, among other infractions. ↑
- It should be noted that said obligation is currently maintained in Article 83 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01, in force as of December 31, 2016. ↑
- It should be noted that from July 7, 2009 to February 20, 2013, Mrs. Bellido-Tagle held the position of alternate director and occupied the position of administration and finance manager from June 1, 2002 to February 20, 2013. As of February 21, 2013, she took the position of general manager and chairman of the board. ↑
- It should be noted that in August and September 2004, Mr. Arizmendi was appointed general manager and chairman of the board of GPI. ↑
- Submitted by GPI by letter dated February 27, 2014. ↑
- Who was Chairman of the Board and General Manager of GPI until February 21, 2013. ↑
- As indicated in the contract. ↑
- US$ 2,491,543.84. ↑
- Which are part of the administrative sanctioning procedure contained in file No. 2016035717. ↑
- According to Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 049-2016-SMV/10 of November 23, 2016. ↑
- In the case of unwritten orders, it is presumed that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client. ↑
- In the case of unwritten orders, it is presumed that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- In his capacity as director and representative of GPI. ↑
- It should be noted that in the recitals related to this complaint, the reference "Client" refers to Mrs. Mayo. ↑
- Gathered in the inspection carried out at GPI on January 11, 2017 (File No. 2017002716) ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- A conciliation hearing held between Mr. Mario Gastañaga and GPI for the payment of US$ 100,000.00 and another held between Mrs. Silva and GPI for the payment of US$ 200,000.00. ↑
- It should be noted that by Superintendency Resolution No. 126-2016-SMV/02 of September 19, 2016, it was resolved to suspend GPI's operating authorization; it being necessary to specify that said resolution, in its Article 4, states that the suspension measure ordered does not exempt GPI from complying with obligations contracted in the market prior to the suspension decreed, nor from complying with said obligations during the suspension period, to the extent pertinent. Likewise, Article 5 of said resolution states that the measure ordered does not exempt GPI's directors or managers from administrative liability incurred during the operation of said brokerage firm. ↑
- File No. 2017002716. ↑
- File No. 2017002716. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- Term used for the complaint of Messrs. Cáceres. ↑
- File No. 2017002716. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- It is a service broker that facilitates the opening and operation of brokerage and custody accounts at Pershing. ↑
- The account with client code CLIO225 became joint, that is, in the name of Mrs. Roca and Mrs. Gonzales. On this matter, since GPI did not submit its comments regarding the complaint filed, it is not possible to determine the reasons for such change. ↑
- The term "Clients" refers to Mrs. Roca and Mrs. Gonzalez. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- Resolution No. 1 dated November 4, 2016 issued by the Technical Secretariat of the Consumer Protection Commission of INDECOPI. ↑
- Attached to its brief submitted on December 19, 2016. ↑
- Attached to its brief submitted on December 19, 2016. ↑
- Proshares.com and finance.yahoo.com. ↑
- Linked to the behavior of general market indices such as the Standard & Poor's, sector indices such as the Financial Select Sector SPRD, product indices such as the Market Vector Gold Miners or other types of assets linked to indices, volatility or market returns. ↑
- File No. 2017002716. ↑
- According to what is indicated in the complaint and the Client Registration Form of October 2, 2014. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- Attaches a copy of the deposit certificates indicating deposit date, maturity and interest rate. ↑
- It should be noted that the term "Client" used in Resolution No. 005-2017 refers to Mr. Lorelli. ↑
- In the files detailed below, it was GPI itself that sent the documentation: File Nos. 2016041460; 2016041846; and, 2016042063. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- According to Resolution No. 008-2017, the term "Clients" refers to Messrs. Urday. ↑
- File No. 2017002716. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- According to Resolution No. 006-2017, the term "Client" refers to Mrs. Quijano. ↑
- Indicated in the receipt issued by GPI on May 19, 2014. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- The term "Clients" refers to Mrs. Camino and Mr. Holguin. ↑
- Information contained in File No. 2017002716. ↑
- According to Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 011-2017-SMV/10. The term "Clients" refers to Mrs. Camino and her husband, Mr. Jorge Holguín Reyes (Mr. HOLGUIN). ↑
- Submitted by the Client and gathered in the Inspection. ↑
- Submitted by the Client, by GPI and also gathered in the Inspection. ↑
- It should be noted that in certain reports the number identifying them is CLIO1147. ↑
- Delivered in the preliminary proceedings to the SMV. ↑
- Sale of instruments called FAS. ↑
- There are six (6) vouchers in the name of the Clients signed by Mrs. Camino; while in support of those vouchers there are six (6) checks, three (3) in the name of Mrs. Camino and three (3) in the name of Mr. Holguín. ↑
- The vouchers in the name of the Clients are signed, some by Mrs. Camino and others by Mr. Holguín. Likewise, in support of those vouchers there are checks in the name of Mrs. Camino and a deposit voucher to Mrs. Camino's account. ↑
- It should be noted that a payment voucher of July 27, 2016 for US$ 1,800.00 is for "Return + Capital (Order LFA)" an amount that, according to GPI's report, corresponds to US$ 1,000.00 of capital and US$ 800.00 for return. ↑
- It should be noted that the aforementioned vouchers were submitted by both Mrs. Camino and GPI; except for the case of four (04) vouchers and checks that were submitted only by GPI, and not by Mrs. Camino, where the withdrawal of US$ 9,100.00 (Nine thousand one hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars) is evidenced – during the years 2015 and 2016 – for capital. The receipts are signed by both Mrs. Camino and Mr. Holguín. That is why they are considered at the time of the evaluation of this case and are included as capital withdrawals within the amounts indicated above. The vouchers are from September 15, 2015, October 19, 2015, October 28, 2015 and July 27, 2016. ↑
- From the documentation in the file, it can be seen that Mrs. Camino, by notarial letter notified to GPI on November 2, 2016, requested the return of her funds, a situation that as of the date of preparation of this resolution neither GPI nor the Clients have indicated has been completed. ↑
- GPI states that the amount paid to the Clients for these concepts amounts to US$ 224,860.24; however, it only accredits US$ 219,772.24. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- According to Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 12-2017-SMV/10, the term "Client" refers to Mrs. Batievsky. ↑
- As indicated by the Client in a brief of February 27, 2017. ↑
- Likewise, in the report as of February 4, 2013, signed by Mrs. Marrou, it is observed that after the "withdrawals made" for US$ 118,379.00, the contributed capital is not reduced, since the withdrawal is made from the "earned premiums" for US$ 126,767.10. ↑
- Withdrawals made from earned premiums, not from the initial contributed capital. ↑
- It should be noted that the amount of "withdrawals made" for US$ 118,379.00, very similar to the amount of US$ 118,767.10 (the one seen in the Letter sent by Mr. Arizmendi on April 4 mentioned above), is also indicated in handwritten form in the report of February 4, 2013 signed by Mrs. Marrou. According to this report, the amount of "withdrawals made" is subtracted from the amount for "accumulated profitability in US$" or "earned premiums", which is the profitability generated up to February 4, 2013 by the operations that GPI states it would have carried out with the Client's funds. This is related to the fact that the "withdrawals made" have not been deducted from the initial invested capital, according to the aforementioned report (Mrs. Marrou indicates as total capital US$ 459,215.56, which includes the initial invested capital plus the "earned premiums" net of "withdrawals made" for the operations that GPI states it would have carried out). Likewise, in the letter of April 4, 2016, Mr. Arizmendi confirms to the Client that the initial invested capital of US$ 441,787.46 is maintained and that said capital plus the product of the "earned premiums" net of "withdrawals made" is what originates the principal balance at that date. ↑
- Taking into account that the Client has presented these documents, in addition to accrediting the amount of invested capital, she is acknowledging the amount of returns received from GPI. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI from February 21, 2013 to date. ↑
- In his capacity as chairman of the board and general manager of GPI until February 20, 2013 and as de facto representative from that date onward. ↑
- Said information was requested in greater detail by email of April 21, 2016. ↑
- Account MN 6720307. ↑
- Account ME 3361369 In national currency it is equivalent to S/ 1,750,911.70 ↑
- In national currency it is equivalent to S/ 245,996.12 ↑
- Average exchange rate published by the Central Reserve Bank of Peru as of November 21, 2016. ↑
- According to Report No. 019-2017-SMV/10.3 of January 6, 2017 (File No. 2016047427) and what was resolved by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 029-2017-SMV/10. ↑
- Exchange rate corresponding to February 1, 2017 (source: BCRP), date of transfer of funds from GPI to KALLPA SAB. ↑