Enforcement · SMV · 27 Jan 2020
The Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct Supervision fines Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret De Mola, General Manager of Andino Investment Holding S.A.A., 100 UIT for a very serious infraction under numeral 1.11, subsection 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation. The charge is improper use of privileged information through 18 purchases of the issuer's shares between 4 April 2017 and 18 March 2018 while a reserved material fact was in force. The resolution addresses his defenses, including lack of personal benefit, voluntary remediation, and retroactive application of the new Sanctions Regulation.
No. 010-2020-SMV/11
Lima, January 27, 2020
Summary: Sanction Mr. Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret De Mola, General Manager of Andino Investment Holding S.A.A., with a fine of 100 UIT, for having incurred a very serious infraction typified in numeral 1.11, subsection 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation
| Administered party | : | CARLOS RODOLFO JUAN VARGAS LORET DE MOLA |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2019003060 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2019003060 and Report No. 567-2019-SMV/11.2 (Report), issued by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendence of Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
"(...) the amount of S/ 18,354.97 corresponds to the profits obtained as a consequence of the sale of a total of 20,500 shares representing the share capital of AIH, which were acquired by me while a reserved fact approved by the Superintendence of the Securities Market by Official Letter No. 096-2017-SMV/02 was in force, and its corresponding extensions approved by Official Letters Nos. 177-2017-SMV/02, 243-2017-SMV/02 and 12-2018-SMV/02 according to the following detail:
Indeed, all the shares indicated in the preceding table, acquired for a total of S/ 36,596.51 were sold by me on May 2, 2018, through my stockbroker, (...) receiving a total net for said operation of S/ 54,951.48. The difference between the mentioned amounts results in a profit of precisely S/ 18,354.97, an amount that according to what was informed to you, I deposited voluntarily (...) on May 11, 2018." (Underlining is ours)
It should be noted that the reserved fact to which Mr. Vargas refers in his response will be detailed later and was in force from April 4, 2017 to March 18, 2018;
"(...) both the sale of the shares indicated in the Official Letter (acquired by me while a reserved fact was in force), carried out on May 2, 2018 through my stockbroker Credicorp Capital SAB, and the voluntary deposit of the profit obtained as a consequence of the mentioned sale in the bank account owned by AIH, had as their sole purpose to minimize the impact of the infraction involuntarily committed by me, in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Securities Market regulations". (Underlining is ours)
Likewise, Mr. Vargas stated that since his usual stockbroker was Credicorp SAB, he made an involuntary error in considering only the shares acquired through said brokerage firm. In addition, he added that the error arose because on those dates he changed his custodian, from Continental Bolsa SAB (hereinafter, Continental SAB) to Credicorp SAB, so he requested the record of share purchases only from the latter.
Having reviewed his stock market operations, he indicated that his purchase operations through Continental SAB were as follows:
As can be observed, the total shares acquired by Mr. Vargas during the period of validity of the reserved fact, through Continental SAB, amounted to 71,687 shares.
In his writing he also details that, as a consequence of the Issuer's capital increase of August 9, 2018[1], all shareholders of the Issuer received a benefit of 200% in free shares, which is why all the shares acquired through Continental SAB, amounting to 71,687 shares representing the Issuer's share capital, were increased by 200%, that is, from 71,687 they became 215,061 shares.
Furthermore, he indicated that in order to minimize the impact of the involuntarily committed infraction, he proceeded to carry out the total sale of his shares acquired through Continental SAB. Thus, on November 15, 2018, in a first sale, he sold 71,687 shares of the Issuer, receiving a total net of S/ 71,471.94. While the second sale was made on November 16, 2018 regarding 143,374 shares of the Issuer, receiving a total net of S/ 142,943.88.
The difference between the amounts corresponding to the profits that he would have obtained from the sale of the shares – through Continental SAB – acquired during the validity of the reserved fact (S/ 71,471.94 + S/ 142,943.88 = S/ 214,415.82) and the amount that he would have paid for the acquisition of the same (S/ 106,591.69) resulted in a profit amounting to S/ 107,824.13, an amount that he deposited to the Issuer on November 16, 2018, for which he attached the respective deposit voucher as proof;
Five (05) purchase operations of shares of the Issuer carried out by Mr. Vargas through Credicorp Capital SAB, according to Mr. Vargas himself:
Thirteen (13) purchase operations of shares of the Issuer carried out by Mr. Vargas through Continental SAB, according to Mr. Vargas himself:
Non-existence of personal benefit
He states that it is necessary to determine the components of the infraction imputed to him in order to verify if he has indeed committed it. In the specific case, the imputed infraction is contained in the referred subsection 1.10 of the Old Sanctions Regulation, which provides: "1.10 Making improper use and availing oneself, directly or indirectly, for one's own benefit or that of third parties, of privileged information that one possesses".
Regarding the infraction, it is necessary to consider that in order to configure it, it will be necessary that the following assumptions are met jointly: (a) possessing privileged information, (b) making improper use of privileged information, directly or indirectly, and (c) the benefit for oneself or a third party.
Regarding the first assumption, if he possessed privileged information, it should be noted that at the date on which the infraction is imputed to him, he held the position of General Manager and according to the list of persons who knew the information whose reservation was requested, he was aware of it.
Regarding the second element, it will be necessary to verify if he has made direct or indirect improper use of privileged information. In this regard, he states that the share purchases were made involuntarily during the period of validity of the Reserved Fact, since it was not his will to make said purchases because he has stockbrokers who are directly responsible for managing, advising and administering his investments. In this sense, he affirms that he did not use privileged information since the stockbrokers with whom he contracted and who manage his investments did not know of the Reserved Fact.
Finally, it must be determined if he obtained a direct benefit as a consequence of the involuntary purchase of shares during the validity of the Reserved Fact. On this assumption he states that as he has set forth in the writings presented previously, a personal benefit is not configured since when he became aware of the involuntary purchase, he proceeded with the total sale of the shares acquired within the term in which the reserved fact remained as such, and likewise he proceeded voluntarily with the return of the profit that he could have obtained for his own benefit, without this having been required by the IGSC.
Consequently, Mr. Vargas states that according to the considerations indicated above, a benefit in my favor has not been configured. There was no economic benefit since the profits in their entirety were returned to the Issuer, returning to the situation he had before May 5, 2017.
Exemption from responsibility and application of the new SMV Sanctions Regulation
In this regard, he states that although the acts imputed to him were carried out during the validity of the Old Sanctions Regulation, which does not provide as an exemption from responsibility the voluntary correction referred to above; however, according to the provisions of the second article of the New Sanctions Regulation, "infractions committed before the validity of this resolution shall be substantiated in accordance with the rules in force at the time they occurred, unless the provisions approved by this resolution are more favorable to him".
The principle of benign retroactivity is applicable in administrative sanctioning procedures, being recognized in numeral 5 of article 248 of the LPAG, which states that "the sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered party incurred the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable to him. The sanctioning provisions produce retroactive effect insofar as they favor the presumed infringer or the infringer, both in regard to the typification of the infraction and the sanction and its prescription periods, even with respect to sanctions in execution upon the entry into force of the new provision".
Mr. Vargas states that administrative sanctioning law provides for the possibility of applying a norm that contains more favorable provisions for the administered party, even when at the time of the facts another norm was the applicable one.
He states that such profits were voluntarily transferred to the Issuer before the return of the amount equivalent to S/ 5,165.00 was required of him. Subsequently, in accordance with what was indicated in his writing of November 16, 2018, on November 15 and 16, 2018, he voluntarily proceeded with the sale of 215,061 common shares of the Issuer that were acquired through Continental SAB, including the shares subject to a capital increase. On November 16, 2018, he voluntarily states that he proceeded with the return of S/ 107,824.13, an amount equivalent to the profit derived from the transactions.
He details that the sale of the Issuer's shares and the delivery of the profit to it referred to in his defenses was made voluntarily when he became aware that his former stockbroker, Continental SAB, had acquired shares of the Issuer during the validity of the Material Fact.
In this sense, the sale of the shares that he involuntarily acquired through his stockbrokers as well as the delivery of the corresponding profits were transferred to the Issuer, without this generating a personal benefit and voluntarily. It is important to emphasize that said actions were carried out without there having been a prior requirement from the IGSC.
On the application of the principle of proportionality
Mr. Vargas argues that if a sanction is imposed, he requests that Article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation be applied to him; and in that sense, applying the principle of proportionality, a sanction lower than the legal minimum established for the infraction charged, that is, less than 50 UIT, be imposed.
In this regard, he argues that Article 246(3) of the LPAG is applicable to him, which regulates the principle of reasonableness and proportionality of the administrative sanctioning power, and that this principle has been incorporated in Article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, considering the following: (a) He has not been sanctioned by the SMV within the four (4) years prior to the date, (b) He has not committed an infraction for improper use of privileged information in the past, (c) He maintains commercial relations with Credicorp SAB and maintained commercial relations with Continental SAB for portfolio management, so when he became aware of the share purchase transactions of the Issuer during the validity of the Reserved Fact, he proceeded with the transfer of the shares and returned all profits derived from them, returning to the situation immediately prior to the entry into force of the Reserved Fact, (d) The transfer of the Issuer's shares was made before detection by the SMV, and before the SMV required him to sell the shares and/or return profits, (e) There has been no harm to the public interest, and (f) There has been no intentionality or benefit for himself or third parties in his conduct, since when he became aware of the acquisition of the Issuer's shares during the validity of the Reserved Fact, he proceeded with the sale of the same and the delivery of the profits to the Issuer.
Finally, he concludes by stating that the principle of proportionality is applicable to him, a guarantee of every administered party in the framework of administrative sanctioning procedures; and as a consequence, the imposition of a sanction below the legal range provided in the Sanctions Regulation.
4.1 Applicable Regulations
4.2 Preliminary aspects prior to the evaluation of defenses
In order to make an evaluation of whether the information held by Mr. Vargas was privileged information and from that fact, analyze whether he has incurred in any of the prohibitions contemplated in the LMV, first, it is necessary to determine if the information has such nature.
Article 34 of the LMV states that the issuer may assign to a fact or negotiation in progress the character of reserved, when its premature disclosure could cause harm to the issuer, provided that the respective agreement is adopted by no less than three quarters of the members of the Board of Directors of the company in question or of the organ exercising its functions.
It should be noted that the reserved information indicated in Article 34 of the LMV is included within privileged information, in accordance with Article 40 of the LMV, as follows:
“Article 40.- Definition
For the purposes of this law, privileged information is understood as any information referring to an issuer, its businesses or one or several securities issued or guaranteed by them, not disclosed to the market; and whose public knowledge, by its nature, is capable of influencing the liquidity, price or quotation of the issued securities. It also includes the reserved information referred to in Article 34 of this Law and that which is held regarding the acquisition or disposal operations to be carried out by an institutional investor in the securities market, as well as that referring to public acquisition offers.” (Underlining and emphasis are ours)
In the case under analysis, it should be indicated that on April 4, 2017, the Board of Directors of the Issuer held a non-presential session in which, among others, Mr. Wolf Dieter Krefft Berthold, as Chairman of the Board, and Mr. Vargas as secretary, participated.
The Chairman of the Board began the session stating that, according to the recommendation of the General Management in charge of Mr. Vargas, it was convenient for the interests of the company to evaluate different strategic investment and/or management alternatives for its Maritime Services and Logistics Services division.
Likewise, he referred that his Management had contracted the services of an investment bank in order for them to act as advisors to the company and carry out the pertinent analysis (which could imply a market sounding contacting potential investors) and, if applicable, carry out the execution of the new strategy subsequently approved by the company, which could include, among others, the acquisition and/or sale of asset(s), strategic associations, debt reprofiling, mergers and/or acquisitions, among other alternatives.
In this sense, as the first agreement of said session, it was established:
“RESOLVED, to approve the evaluation of investment and/or management alternatives for the business units of Maritime Services and Logistics Services of the Company, which could imply a market sounding contacting potential investors, directly or through the investment bank.”
Furthermore, in said session, the Chairman of the Board indicated that, as a consequence of the approval of the aforementioned agreement, it was necessary to qualify said fact as reserved and therefore, present to the Superintendent of the Securities Market the corresponding communication, including the required documentation indicated in the Regulation of Material Facts and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Regulation of Material Facts).
Thus, all members of the Board of Directors of the Issuer unanimously decided:
“RESOLVED to qualify the agreement described in numeral 1 of this session (Evaluation of new strategic alternatives), as “Reserved Fact” under the norms of the Peruvian securities market and request the Superintendency of the Securities Market and the Lima Stock Exchange that agenda item 1 be qualified as a “Reserved Fact” or analogous.” (Underlining is ours)
Through Official Letters No. 94 and 96-2017-SMV/02 of April 7 and 10, 2017, respectively, in accordance with Article 34 of the LMV and numeral 15.3 of Article 15 of the Regulation of Material Facts, the Issuer was notified of the conformity to the requirements presented by the Issuer to assign to the mentioned information the reserved character during the agreed term. It should be noted that within the list of persons that the Issuer informed know of the reserved information, Mr. Vargas expressly appears.
Through writing of July 13, 2017, the Issuer indicated that the Board in a non-presential session held the same day and with the favorable vote of all its members, approved that the reserved character of the information be maintained until November 30, 2017.
Through Official Letter No. 177-2017-SMV/02 of July 18, 2017, the Superintendent of the Securities Market gave conformity to the requirements presented by the Issuer to assign to the mentioned information the reserved character during the agreed term, specifying that said reserve would be maintained in accordance with the provisions of Article 16[4] of the Regulation of Material Facts.
Through writing of October 13, 2017, the Issuer indicated that in the board session of the same day, with the favorable vote of all its members, the agreement to extend the reserve term by one hundred twenty (120) additional calendar days was approved.
Through Official Letter No. 243-2017-SMV/02 of October 16, 2017, the Superintendent of the Securities Market gave conformity to the requirements presented by the Issuer to assign to the mentioned information the reserved character during the agreed term, which was until January 15, 2018, and specified that said reserve would cease at the time when the assumptions referred to in Article 16 of the Regulation of Material Facts take place.
Through writing of January 11, 2018, the Issuer indicated that in the board session of the same day, with the favorable vote of all its members, the agreement to extend the reserve term by one hundred twenty (120) additional calendar days was approved.
Through Official Letter No. 12-2018-SMV/02 of January 16, 2018, the Superintendent of the Securities Market gave conformity to the requirements presented by the Issuer to assign to the mentioned information the reserved character during the agreed term, which was until May 16, 2018, and specified that said reserve would cease at the time when the assumptions referred to in Article 16 of the Regulation of Material Facts take place.
On March 18, 2018, the Issuer publicly disclosed as a material fact that it signed a “Stock Purchase Agreement” with DP World Perú, through which it was agreed: (i) the transfer of the shares owned by the Company in the subsidiary Cosmos Agencia Marítima S.A.C., and indirectly the transfer of its shares in Tritón Transports S.A., Neptunia S.A. and Terminales Portuarios Euroandinos S.A.; and (ii) the transfer of the property called Centro Logístico Gambetta registered in Electronic Entry No. 70060596 of the Registry of Properties of Callao.
Likewise, the Issuer also informed that through the “Stock Purchase Agreement”, Inversiones Santa Orietta S.A.C., committed to transfer the shares of its ownership in Cosmos Agencia Marítima S.A.C. and the property called Sucursal Paita registered in Electronic Entry No. 11137286 of the Registry of Properties of Piura. Furthermore, that the agreed purchase value would have amounted to US$ 315.7 million.
From the above, it can be affirmed that the agreement reached by the Issuer and to which the qualification of reserved information was granted, and therefore, of privileged information, was maintained with said character from April 4, 2017 until March 18, 2018, the day on which the Issuer communicated it as a material fact to the market.
Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of Article 40 of the LMV, it has been objectively demonstrated that from April 4, 2017 to March 18, 2018, Mr. Vargas had knowledge of privileged information, so he was prohibited from carrying out the three (3) conducts indicated in Article 43 of the LMV. It should be noted that the prohibited conducts of Article 43 of the LMV must be read together with Article 6 of the Regulation against Market Abuse, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2012-SMV/01[5] (hereinafter, Regulation against Market Abuse).
Having evidenced the existence of privileged information, a second step in the analysis regarding the identification of any non-compliance referred to in Article 43 of the LMV, is to verify if the agent to whom any of the improper conducts is attributed, had access to the privileged information analyzed above.
In this sense, it is necessary to refer to the presumption of access indicated in Article 41 of the LMV[6], when it refers that unless proven otherwise, it is presumed that the directors and managers of the issuer possess privileged information. That is, according to the presumption, Mr. Vargas, having the position of General Manager of the Issuer, is included in the legal presumption that he had access to the information qualified as privileged.
Although the above is sufficient to consider the second requirement under analysis fulfilled, in the particular case, there is additional information that is evidence corroborating that Mr. Vargas had access to the privileged information.
In accordance with numeral 13.2 of Article 13 of the Regulation of Material Facts[7], the reserved information must be communicated to the Superintendent of the Securities Market within the day following the adoption of the Board agreement that assigns the reserved character to the fact or negotiation in progress, including among others, the complete list of persons who know the information subject of the reserve agreement, whether or not they work for the Issuer.
In order to comply with this last requirement, the Issuer sent to the Superintendent of the Securities Market the list of persons who had knowledge and access to the information subject of the fact, in which Mr. Vargas expressly appears.
As can be observed, from the presumption indicated in Article 41 of the LMV explained above, from his acting as Secretary in the board session of April 4, 2017, as well as from having been included in the list of persons who had knowledge of the fact qualified as reserved in his capacity as General Manager, the access that Mr. Vargas had to the information qualified as reserved in the board session of April 4, 2017, is demonstrated; and, therefore, to privileged information.
Once the existence of privileged information has been verified, as well as the access that Mr. Vargas had to it, the third step in the analysis in order to identify any non-compliance related to privileged information mentioned in Article 43 of the LMV, leads to evaluating whether the agent who had access to privileged information carried out any of the following acts:
Revealed or confided the information to other persons;
Recommended the carrying out of operations with securities regarding which he had privileged information; and,
Made improper use or availed himself, directly or indirectly, for his own benefit or that of third parties, of the privileged information;
As indicated in the Charge Letter, the infraction that Mr. Vargas would have committed is typified in literal c) of Article 43 of the LMV, for having made use of privileged information when carrying out purchases of shares of the Issuer, during the period in which a material fact of the Issuer was qualified as reserved information.
These share purchase operations of the Issuer, carried out through the brokerage firms Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB, would show that Mr. Vargas made said purchases making improper use of privileged information for his own benefit, since he carried them out with knowledge of a reserved fact during the period in which it was maintained as such.
The own benefit that he would have or may have obtained from his purchase and sale operations of the Issuer's shares is quantifiable and will be detailed later when one of the defenses given by Mr. Vargas is evaluated.
Of the information qualified as privileged
Regarding the first assumption, Mr. Vargas admits that, since he held the position of General Manager and according to the list of persons who knew the information whose reserve was requested and was sent to the SMV, he was aware of it.
Taking into account the statement made by Mr. Vargas himself that in his capacity as General Manager he acted as secretary of the Board session of April 4, 2017 of the Issuer[8], as well as having been included in the list of persons who had knowledge of the fact qualified as reserved, prepared by the Issuer, it is corroborated that Mr. Vargas had reserved information, which as indicated above, qualifies as privileged information, in accordance with Article 40 of the LMV.
Of the access to privileged information
Regarding the second assumption, Mr. Vargas indicates that it will be necessary to verify whether, directly or indirectly, he made improper use of privileged information. In this regard, he states that the purchases of shares were made involuntarily during the period in which the reserved fact was in force, since, as he states, it was not his will to make them, given that he has brokerage firms that are directly responsible for managing, advising and administering his investments.
Therefore, Mr. Vargas concludes that he did not use privileged information since his brokerage firms with which he contracted and which managed his investments were not aware of the reserved fact.
In this regard and in order to corroborate what Mr. Vargas said in relation to this second assumption, the IGSC, at the request of the IGCC, sent Official Letter No. 1307-2019-SMV/11.1 dated March 13, 2019 to Credicorp SAB through which it requested, among others, a copy of Mr. Vargas's client registration form or intermediation contract, as well as to specify the original means by which the orders made by Mr. Vargas regarding his operations with the Issuer's security (AIHC1) from April 1, 2017 to March 21, 2018 were received.
On March 15, 2019, through communication CCSAB-0037-2019, Credicorp SAB in response to the previous official letter, attached a copy of the client registration form, also accompanying the respective documentary support and indicating that Mr. Vargas's purchase orders were received through the web channel via@inversiones, a system that allows its clients to carry out financial operation instructions by electronic means, according to the terms established in its Client Policy.
In this sense, Credicorp SAB attached the purchase orders entered in the via@inversiones system with dates 10/04/2017, 10/18/2017, 10/24/2017, 11/15/2017, 02/05/2018 and 02/13/2018, in which Mr. Vargas's name appears for operations with the Issuer's security (AIHC1).
On the other hand, from the review of the client registration form sent by Credicorp SAB, it can be stated that the modalities for presenting orders authorized by Mr. Vargas are written and telephone. Likewise, in the client registration form there are no persons authorized to carry out operations on behalf of Mr. Vargas, no registered attorney-in-fact appears.
Furthermore, it is necessary to emphasize that in numeral 8 of the Declarations section of Credicorp Capital Bolsa of the client registration form sent by Credicorp SAB, it is explicitly stated that: "8. Credicorp Capital Bolsa informs that it does NOT offer portfolio management services." (Emphasis and underlining is ours), which shows that what Mr. Vargas stated is not accurate.
Below, the pertinent part of the client registration form provided by Credicorp SAB:
Since the operations were not only carried out through Credicorp SAB, but there was also the participation of Continental SAB, the IGCC considered it necessary to make the same request to said brokerage firm in order to verify what Mr. Vargas said.
In this sense, through Official Letter No. 1308-2019-SMV/11.1 dated March 13, 2019, the IGSC sent a request in the same terms as that issued to Credicorp SAB, but this time to Continental SAB.
In response to said request, on March 14, 2019, Continental SAB attached the required information, indicating that there were thirteen (13) orders made by Mr. Vargas to purchase shares of the Issuer, of which twelve (12) were received through the internet and only one was received by telephone, not indicating that it was made by any attorney-in-fact or person in charge of his investments.
In this regard, from the analysis of the documents received by Continental SAB, it can be stated that from the review of the front of the securities intermediation services contract between Mr. Vargas and Continental SAB, it has been verified that the modalities of communication of orders authorized by Mr. Vargas were by written means, agent web application and by telephone.
Likewise, it has also been verified that the object of said contract only refers to the securities intermediation service and no mention is made of any additional service, such as discretionary portfolio management[9], which would be the only modality by which Mr. Vargas would have involuntarily carried out the transactions with the Issuer's securities (AIHC1), as he has indicated in his defenses.
In this sense, it is necessary to take into account the object of the Securities Intermediation Services Contract signed between Continental SAB and Mr. Vargas, which is transcribed below:
As can be seen, Continental SAB states that it only provides stock market intermediation services in the purchase and sale of securities on the BVL and foreign exchanges, as well as securities custody service. Nowhere in it is there any mention of any portfolio management service, as an additional service contracted by Mr. Vargas.
Likewise, it should be noted that the General Superintendency of Conduct Compliance has listened to the recording of the telephone order that Mr. Vargas made on June 20, 2017, in which he identifies himself with his name and national identity document in order to purchase 5,090 shares of the Issuer.
Having said the above, it is evident that what Mr. Vargas indicated regarding the fact that he would have involuntarily made the purchases of shares of the Issuer (AIHC1) during the period in which the reserved fact was in force, both through Continental SAB and through Credicorp SAB, does not correspond to reality, so said arguments do not contribute to Mr. Vargas's defense, nor do they disprove the charge imputed to him.
Of the benefit that was obtained or could have been obtained
Regarding the last assumption indicated by Mr. Vargas himself referring to the direct benefit as a consequence of the involuntary purchase of shares (which, it has been evidenced, were not made in such a way) that he would have made during the validity of the reserved fact, he indicates that a benefit for himself is not configured since when he became aware of the involuntary purchases, he proceeded with the total sale of the shares acquired within the term in which the reserved fact remained as such – voluntarily returning – the profit that he had obtained for his own benefit. Consequently, Mr. Vargas states that no benefit has been configured in his favor and therefore, it would not fall within the imputed infraction type.
Before beginning the analysis of the argument presented by Mr. Vargas, who states that the benefit resulting from the transactions carried out with the Issuer's shares constitutes an indispensable requirement for the commission of the charge imputed in literal c) of article 43 of the LMV to be configured, it is necessary to reiterate that what is provided by the norm is the prohibition for persons who possess privileged information to make improper use, for their own benefit or that of third parties, of said information.
In this sense, it does not follow that the norm requires that there has been a benefit in favor of the person who carried out the transactions making improper use of privileged information, but rather that the improper use of privileged information be made seeking to obtain or with a view to obtaining a benefit for themselves or for third parties, which is logical, since a person who uses privileged information will seek to benefit themselves or benefit third parties in the short, medium or long term.
The aforementioned is in accordance with article 6 of the Regulation against Market Abuse, whose text says:
"Article 6.- Prohibitions
6.1. Within the framework established in article 43 of the Securities Market Law, in addition to natural persons, institutional investors that manage third-party resources that are to be destined for investment in publicly offered securities, issuers, price providers, valuation entities, risk rating companies, intermediation agents and other legal persons that possess privileged information are prohibited from making use of privileged information.
The prohibition of use provided in article 43, subsection c) of the Securities Market Law is incurred when operations are carried out with securities regarding which one has privileged information.
6.2. The sanctions established by virtue of the provisions of article 43 of the Securities Market Law are applicable, regardless of whether the person who has revealed, recommended or made use of privileged information has obtained a gain or avoided a loss. Likewise, said sanctions apply to all natural or legal persons who have revealed, recommended or made use of privileged information obtained through any means, whether because it has been voluntarily or involuntarily transmitted to them or because they had obtained it lawfully or through illicit, improper or fraudulent means." (Underlining and emphasis are ours)
From the foregoing, it is concluded that the existence or obtaining of a benefit is not a necessary element for the infraction to be configured, in accordance with the established regulatory framework. Thus, the benefit may or may not exist, without affecting the determination of whether or not the prohibition provided in subsection c) of article 43 of the LMV was incurred.
As expressly stated in the second paragraph of numeral 6.1 of article 6 of the Regulation against Market Abuse, the prohibition of use provided in article 43, subsection c) of the LMV is incurred when operations are carried out with securities regarding which one has privileged information.
On the other hand, since Mr. Vargas repeatedly refers to the return of short-term profits that he may have made, it is appropriate to note that the purpose of this sanctioning procedure is to determine whether the infraction related to the improper use of privileged information, for one's own benefit or that of third parties, occurred, in accordance with subsection c) of article 43 of the LMV, so it is not appropriate to analyze the non-compliance with norms that regulate the return of short-term profits, which constitutes a different obligation and matter.
In this way, it can be concluded that for the purposes of determining the infraction corresponding to the prohibited conduct established in subsection c) of article 43 of the LMV, it is not relevant that Mr. Vargas has proceeded to return to the Issuer the profits obtained in the terms of article 44 of the LMV[10] which regulates the return of short-term profits. However, said return will be taken into account when analyzing the mitigating circumstances of the case.
The reason for this request, which Mr. Vargas makes as a defense, finds as its main reason that the previous Sanctions Regulation did not recognize voluntary remediation as an exemption from responsibility, while article 27 of the current Sanctions Regulation provides that voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges and provided that no communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent, constitutes a condition exempting from responsibility for infractions.
In relation to this defense, Mr. Vargas adds that the principle of benign retroactivity is applicable in administrative sanctioning procedures, in accordance with numeral 5 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG[12].
In the case under analysis, Mr. Vargas reiterates that on May 2, 2018 he proceeded with the sale of the shares acquired through Credicorp SAB within the period from October 5, 2017 to February 13, 2018. Likewise, he refers that he transferred the profits to the Issuer's account on May 11, 2018, which amounted to S/ 18,354.97. Mr. Vargas indicates that these profits were voluntarily transferred to the Issuer before the return of the amount equivalent to S/ 5,165.00 was required by the IGSC.
Subsequently, as indicated in his writing of November 16, 2018, Mr. Vargas states that on November 15 and 16, 2018, he voluntarily proceeded with the sale of 215,061 common shares of the Issuer, which were acquired through Continental SAB, including the shares subject to a capital increase; and, that on November 16, 2018, he voluntarily proceeded with the return of S/ 107,824.13, an amount equivalent to the profit derived from the aforementioned transactions.
Furthermore, he considers it important to refer that, although there was a time difference when proceeding with the sale of shares of the Issuer acquired by Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB, this would have been due to the change of securities custodian, from Continental SAB to Credicorp SAB, which is why the settlement of the Issuer's shares initially occurred for those acquired through Credicorp SAB.
In this way, Mr. Vargas reiterates that the sale of the Issuer's shares and the delivery of the profits to it, he made voluntarily when he became aware that his previous brokerage firm, Continental SAB had acquired shares of the Issuer during the validity of the reserved fact.
In this regard, it is necessary to take into account that although literal f) of article 27 of the New Sanctions Regulation contemplates as a condition exempting from responsibility the voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of charges, it should be noted that said norm must be read systematically with the others that make up said Regulation.
In this sense, it should be specified that article 28 of the New Sanctions Regulation indicates the assumptions in which remediation as an exemption from responsibility is not applicable, one of them being the contravention of market abuse norms, referring to the improper use of privileged information and market manipulation, so this class of infractions are not subject to remediation, in accordance with literal b) of the aforementioned article.
Consequently, it is possible to state that the second argument of Mr. Vargas's defenses is not admissible, since the application of the principle of benign retroactivity does not favor him and places him in the same situation as with the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time the events occurred.
In this framework, we consider it necessary to explain that the rules of voluntary remediation as an exemption from responsibility are not applicable for this type of case, so there would be no elements of judgment to determine the retroactivity alleged by Mr. Vargas, according to the following:
Despite the returns of short-term profits having been made before the formulation of the Charge Official Letter, this return is not applicable as voluntary remediation, given that this sanctioning procedure does not deal with an infraction for not having made the return of said short-term profits, but rather with the improper use of privileged information.
Therefore, the return made does not exempt Mr. Vargas from responsibility, because there is no correlation between the imputed infraction (improper use of privileged information) and the return of short-term profits. However, it is reiterated that this circumstance will be analyzed in the mitigating assumptions of the infraction.
This sanctioning procedure deals with the improper use of privileged information, specifically in those cases where the directors and managers of the issuer make use of privileged information within the term of a reserved fact. This typical conduct is related to an action that specifically adjusts to the budgets established in the norm;
On the other hand, it is appropriate to point out that voluntary remediation is a figure that has been incorporated into the so-called exemptions from responsibility, in the understanding that its inclusion would obey a punitive policy that has as an incentive the protection of legal assets through reparative actions for committed infractions and consequently, incentivizes the non-exercise of sanctioning procedures with the costs they involve.
However, before applying this exemption from responsibility, the Administration is obliged to evaluate whether its application corresponds to all infringing conduct or only to those that meet certain admissibility requirements, since, otherwise, the administrative sanctioning procedure would become an incentive for the commission of all kinds of infractions and the Administration would be vulnerable to exercise its sanctioning power. In that order of ideas, a reasoning that means the recognition of a situation that incentivizes —or does not prohibit— that administered parties can commit all the infractions they wish, because they have the possibility of remedying them voluntarily, lacks foundation and is also not admissible, which is additionally extremely dangerous for the proper functioning of the market and even more so for the securities market that has transparency and integrity as fundamental and necessary bases.
Likewise, it must be taken into consideration that remediation derives from the verb remediar, which according to the Royal Spanish Academy, means: "to excuse or excuse a mistake or crime; to repair or remedy a defect or compensate for damage"[13]. Consequently, from the definition of literal f) of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, as well as from the meaning given by the Royal Spanish Academy, it follows that remediation must contain, in addition to the cessation of the improper action, the reversal or restitution of the effects that it has generated as a consequence of the damage caused.
That is, for voluntary remediation to apply, two actions must concur on the part of the infringer, before the notification of the imputation of charges: i) the cessation of the conduct, that is, the adaptation of the conduct to the norm; and, ii) the reparation, remediation of a defect or compensation for damage caused, in this case, to the Administration or a third party, derived from the improper action (correction of the effects derived from that infringing conduct).[14] [15].
According to these budgets, the SMV in the development of an administrative sanctioning procedure, before applying the exemption from responsibility, must not only observe that the cessation of the conduct or omission that is classified as an infraction has occurred, but also take into account whether it is possible to reverse, repair or compensate the damage produced as a consequence of the commission of the infraction.
In cases of infractions for the improper use of privileged information, such as the case under analysis, it follows that with the sale of the shares that have been purchased with possession of privileged information, the prohibition is repeated and it could be considered that said conduct ceases or is not repeated as long as a purchase or sale operation of securities is not made again, however, it could not be maintained that the damage caused to the market has been reversed, repaired or compensated, since the mere improper use of privileged information is already a conduct that has generated damage to the integrity and transparency of the securities market and that said damage is not repaired in any way by the return of what was gained.
Indeed, this infraction directly affects the transparency of the market, a legal asset that is protected and that cannot be compensated or reversed with the cessation of the infringing conduct. The damage caused and the repercussion on the market occurred at the moment of improperly using the information that was classified as reserved by the Issuer and that according to the LMV had the character of privileged information.
It should be noted that, if voluntary remediation were admitted for this class of infractions, it would generate a perverse scheme, since for the obligated subjects it would be indifferent to comply or not comply with the obligation to abstain from making improper use of privileged information, with the return of possible profits.
Consequently, regarding the second argument as part of Mr. Vargas's defenses, it is not applicable, since for this class of infractions, it is not possible to maintain that the affectation to the legal asset has been repaired or remedied, which has already occurred and is materially impossible to repair.
In relation to the same point, Mr. Vargas states that: (i) He has not been sanctioned by the SMV within four years prior to the date; (ii) He has not committed an infraction for improper use of privileged information in the past; (iii) He maintains commercial relations with Credicorp SAB and maintained relations with Continental SAB for investment portfolio management, so when he became aware of the transactions of purchase of shares of the Issuer during the validity of the reserved fact, he proceeded with the transfer of the shares and returned all profit derived from them; (iv) The transfer of the shares was carried out before the detection by the SMV and before it required the sale of shares and/or return of profits; (v) There has been no damage to the public interest; (vi) There has been no intentionality, nor benefit for himself or third parties, since when he became aware of the acquisition of the Issuer's shares during the validity of the reserved fact, he proceeded with the sale of the same and delivery of the resulting profits to the Issuer.
Regarding these arguments, it must be noted that they will be analyzed in the corresponding part of the Resolution when the sanction criteria mentioned by Mr. Vargas are evaluated.
Considering that Mr. Vargas reiterates his argument presented in his defenses of February 18, 2019, which has been the subject of analysis in this Resolution that includes the evaluation carried out by the IGCC in its Report, to the argument formulated by Mr. Vargas referring to the fact that the requirement regarding obtaining a benefit is not met since he voluntarily sold the shares acquired during the validity of the reserved fact and returned the profits obtained to the issuer, we consider it pertinent to refer to the evaluation of his defenses carried out in this Resolution.
In this regard, it should be noted that the prohibition provided in article 43, subsection c) of the LMV is incurred when operations are carried out with securities regarding which one has privileged information, which has been demonstrated in this case; therefore, Mr. Vargas's argument about the habitual nature or frequency of buying and selling shares of the Issuer is not an element that exempts him from responsibility. Without prejudice to the foregoing, it can be stated that a General Manager of an Issuer who carries out operations with the securities of his issuer must be more diligent than any other investor each time he carries out an operation of that type, and even more, he should be one of the first market participants to ensure that operations are not carried out with the securities of his issuer using privileged information.
According to the Report, it has considered that in this case there is economic harm, illicit benefit from the commission of the infraction and affectation to the legal interest of market transparency; therefore, it has recommended to this instance that it was not reasonable to lower the classification of the fine in accordance with article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time of the commission of the infraction[16], a conclusion that this Deputy Superintendency also shares.
Likewise, the Report states that the determined fine was reduced by ten percent (10%) for application of the mitigating circumstance of the offender's contribution to the clarification of the infraction, insofar as Mr. Vargas provided the information at the preliminary proceedings stage, voluntarily sold the acquired shares, as well as returned the profits generated, facts that will be evaluated by this Deputy Superintendency when determining the sanction to be imposed for the commission of this non-compliance. In this regard, it should be noted that article 26, literal b) of the New Sanctions Regulation does not establish a parameter or indicator to measure or determine the mitigating circumstance referring to the offender's contribution to the clarification of the infraction; therefore, the 10% percentage mentioned in the Report is only a proposal formulated within the framework in which the IGCC considers the existence of said mitigating circumstance;
It should be noted that in the case of Continental SAB, there is even a recording of the order via telephone, in which Mr. Vargas identifies himself with his names and with his national identity document; therefore, said evidence has given conviction to this Deputy Superintendency that it was Mr. Vargas who carried out the purchase operations of the Issuer's securities.
For this Deputy Superintendency, it is complex to accept this last statement as true, since Mr. Vargas had knowledge from the moment the fact that constituted privileged information was classified as reserved, and furthermore, because it has been identified that the change of custodian from Continental SAB to Credicorp SAB did not occur successively, but rather in a determined period of approximately four months Mr. Vargas was a client of both brokerage firms.
Thus, it can be identified that the operations corresponding to 10/24/2017, 11/09/2017, 11/14/2017, 12/13/2017, 12/28/2017 and 01/09/2018 were made by Mr. Vargas through Continental SAB, but while already being a client of Credicorp SAB, with whom he also made the operations of 10/05/2017, 10/24/2017 and 11/16/2017.
In other words, between 10/24/2017 and 01/09/2018 Mr. Vargas was a client of both Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB, which highlights the implausible nature of having requested the purchase record of only one of the brokerage firms.
These circumstances are considered in this sanctioning procedure in order to propose an administrative sanction to Mr. Vargas.
In accordance with the provisions of numeral 13 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
Register, communicate and publish,
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision
By material event of August 9, 2018 (File No. 2018032057), the Issuer's General Shareholders' Meeting unanimously agreed: (i) to increase the Issuer's share capital to the sum of S/ 403,406,088, through the capitalization of the entire additional capital account and part of the accumulated results account as of June 30, 2018 for a total of S/ 268,937,392 and, as a consequence thereof, to amend article five of the Issuer's bylaws. ↑
The text of the Sanctions Regulation is: "1.11 Improperly using and availing oneself, directly or indirectly, for one's own benefit or that of third parties, of privileged information one possesses.". ↑
The text of the New Sanctions Regulation is: "1.11 Improperly using and availing oneself, directly or indirectly, for one's own benefit or that of third parties, of privileged information one possesses.". ↑
"Article 16.- Cessation of the status of reserved information
16.1. The classification of reserved information assigned by an Issuer to an event or ongoing negotiation ceases upon the following events, whichever occurs first: (i) disappearance of the causes or reasons that motivated the reservation; (ii) expiration of the reservation period that has the conformity of the SMV; or (iii) decision of the Issuer to make public the information subject to the reservation.
16.2. Once the reserved status of the information ceases, it must be reported by the Issuer to the market as a material event. If the Issuer fails to comply with this obligation, the SMV shall proceed with the dissemination of such information, without prejudice to any liabilities that may arise. Prior to such dissemination, the SMV may require that it be carried out by the Issuer.
16.3. The provisions of the preceding paragraph do not apply to ongoing negotiations in which no agreement has been reached, without prejudice to the Issuer being able to communicate it as a material event if it so determines.
16.4. Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraphs, the existence of news in the media related to the fundamental content of the reserved event, or the presence of atypical movements in the price or volume of the security during the reservation period constitute reasonable indications that the reserved information has been disseminated prematurely, partially or distortedly and that its confidentiality and reservation has not been duly assured or guaranteed by the Issuer.
In this case, the SMV may require the Issuer to proceed with the dissemination of the information as a material event. Such requirement is not appealable. In the event of the Issuer's non-compliance and without prejudice to any liabilities that may arise, the SMV shall proceed with its dissemination." ↑
"Article 6.- Prohibitions
6.1. Within the framework of the provisions of article 43 of the Securities Market Law, in addition to natural persons, institutional investors that manage third-party resources to be allocated to investment in publicly offered securities, issuers, price providers, valuation entities, risk rating companies, brokerage agents and other legal persons that possess privileged information are prohibited from using privileged information.
The prohibition of use provided for in article 43, paragraph c) of the Securities Market Law is incurred when transactions are carried out with securities regarding which one has privileged information.
6.2. The sanctions established by virtue of the provisions of article 43 of the Securities Market Law apply regardless of whether the person who has revealed, recommended or used privileged information has obtained a profit or avoided a loss. Likewise, such sanctions apply to all natural or legal persons that have revealed, recommended or used privileged information obtained through any means, whether because it was voluntarily or involuntarily transmitted to them or because they obtained it lawfully or through illicit, improper or fraudulent means." ↑
"Article 41.- Presumption of Access
Unless proven otherwise, for purposes of this law, the following are presumed to possess privileged information:
a) The directors and managers of the issuer and of institutional investors, as well as the members of the Investment Committee of the latter, if applicable;
b) The directors and managers of companies related to the issuer and to institutional investors;
c) Shareholders who individually or jointly with their spouses and relatives up to the first degree of consanguinity possess ten percent (10%) or more of the capital of the issuer or of institutional investors; and,
d) The spouse and relatives up to the first degree of consanguinity of the persons mentioned in the preceding paragraphs." ↑
"Article 13.- Reserved Information
(...)
13.2. Reserved information must be communicated to the Superintendent of the Securities Market within the day following the adoption of the board resolution that assigns the reserved status to the event or ongoing negotiation. The respective communication must contain the following:
13.2.1. Detailed explanation of the event or ongoing negotiation, as well as its situation in the respective process.
13.2.2. Declaration that the event or ongoing negotiation has been the subject of a reservation resolution adopted with the favorable vote of at least 3/4 of the members of the board of directors or equivalent social body. 13.2.3. Grounds for the adoption of the reservation resolution, specifying why the premature disclosure of the event or ongoing negotiation, subject of the resolution, may cause harm.
13.2.4. Indication of the expressly determined period during which the event or ongoing negotiation will maintain the reserved status; and
13.2.5. Declaration of the Issuer to the effect that it is responsible for assuring and guaranteeing the reservation and confidentiality of the information. In addition, it shall identify and state the measures adopted by the Issuer for such purpose, and must attach: (i) The complete list of persons who know the information subject of the reservation resolution, whether or not they work for the Issuer; (ii) the declaration of having complied with requiring a confidentiality commitment from persons outside the Issuer who know the reserved information and who are not bound by the Issuer's Internal Conduct Rules; and (iii) Declaration of undertaking to permanently inform any significant act related to the information subject of its communication during the reservation phase.
The aforementioned list does not affect the presumption of access provided for in articles 41 and 42 of the LMV.
(...)" (Underlining is ours) ↑
Board Meeting, in which they decided to classify an event as reserved. Said meeting is explained in detail in Section III of this Report. ↑
Brokerage Agents Regulation
"Article 71.- Definition
Portfolio management, as referred to in paragraph i) of article 194 and paragraph b) of article 207 of the Law, is understood as the activity of managing cash resources or Financial Instruments received from a client, to be managed for the account and risk of said client through investments in Financial Instruments. Including deposits in the financial system.
Portfolio management may be discretionary or non-discretionary.
Discretionary portfolio management is that management by which the client grants the Agent a general authorization for the latter to act without prior instruction or confirmation from the client for each transaction and according to the investment policy.
Non-discretionary portfolio management is that management by which the client grants the Agent an authorization to act in accordance with the instructions or confirmations given by the client prior to each transaction and according to the investment policy." (Underlining is ours) ↑
"Article 44. Return of short-term profits
Any profit realized by directors and managers of the issuer, as well as the directors, managers, members of the investment committee and persons involved in the investment process of management companies, investment fund management companies and pension fund management companies, arising from the purchase and sale or sale and purchase, within a period of three months, of securities issued by the issuer, must be delivered in full to the issuer or to the estate, as applicable. The provisions of this paragraph are independent of the improper use of privileged information.
Through general provisions, Conasev may regulate the provisions of this article, as well as the exceptions to the obligation to return the profit." (Underlining is ours) ↑
Political Constitution of Peru
"Article 103.- Special laws may be issued because the nature of things so requires, but not by reason of differences between persons. The law, from its entry into force, applies to the consequences of existing legal relations and situations and has no force or retroactive effects; except, in both cases, in criminal matters when it favors the accused. The law is repealed only by another law. It also becomes ineffective by a judgment declaring its unconstitutionality. The Constitution does not protect the abuse of rights." ↑
"Article 248.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(...)
5.- Non-retroactivity.- The sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered party incurs the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable.
Sanctioning provisions produce retroactive effect insofar as they favor the presumed offender or the offender, both with regard to the classification of the infraction and the sanction and its prescription periods, even with respect to sanctions in execution upon the entry into force of the new provision.
(...)" ↑
In this regard, see "Practical Guide on the administrative sanctioning procedure—Guide for legal advisors of the State". Second Edition, p. 47. ↑
MORÓN URBINA, Juan Carlos, Comments on the General Administrative Procedure Law, Tenth Edition, Gaceta Jurídica Publishing House, 2014, pp. 809-810. ↑
"Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation: Criteria and mitigating factors to consider for the imposition of sanctions
(...) When the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria and mitigating factors leads to the conclusion that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the facts imputed, by exception and through a reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided for may be imposed. (...)" [↑](#footnote-ref-16]
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Regulation of Material Facts and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01”
“Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF”
“Rules for the return of short-term profits, approved by SMV Resolution No. 018-2015-SMV/01”
“appeal filed by Mr. Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret de Mola (hereinafter, "Mr. Vargas") against Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 010-2020-SMV/11”
“New Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01”
“Policy on publicity of regulatory projects... approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01”
“Policy on publicity of regulatory projects... approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added