Enforcement · SMV · 31 Jan 2022
The Superintendent of the Securities Market resolves the appeal filed by Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret de Mola against the sanction resolution that fined him 100 UIT for improper use of privileged information. The resolution confirms the sanction, rejecting arguments of lack of typicity, absence of intent, violation of reasonableness and proper motivation, and non-application of mitigating factors. The fine of 100 UIT (S/ 405,000.00) is upheld.
Superintendent's Resolution
No. 011-2022-SMV/02
Lima, January 31, 2022
The Superintendent of the Securities Market
WHEREAS:
File No. 2019003060 containing, among others, the appeal filed by Mr. Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret de Mola (hereinafter, "Mr. Vargas") against Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 010-2020-SMV/11 (hereinafter, the "Sanction Resolution"), Report No. 963-2021-SMV/06 issued by the Legal Advisory Office, the brief of arguments and the supplementary brief of arguments submitted by Mr. Vargas, as well as having heard the oral report of his attorneys;
CONSIDERING:
That, on April 4, 2017, the Board of Directors of Andino Investment Holding S.A.A. (hereinafter, the "Issuer") held a non-presential meeting in which Mr. Vargas participated as secretary, and in which, after an evaluation and discussion, the Board of the Issuer unanimously decided:
That, by Official Letter No. 94-2017-SMV/02 of April 7, 2017, the Superintendent of the Securities Market required the Issuer to expressly indicate the period during which the fact or ongoing negotiation would maintain its reserved character;
That, in response to the aforementioned communication and on the same date, the Issuer indicated that its Board had agreed that the period during which the fact or ongoing negotiation would remain reserved would be one hundred (100) calendar days counted from April 4, 2017, the date of the agreement;
That, by Official Letter No. 96-2017-SMV/02, the Superintendent of the Securities Market, in accordance with article 34 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, "LMV") and numeral 15.3 of article 15 of the Regulation of Material Facts and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, the "Regulation of Material Facts"), ordered that the requested reservation would be maintained until July 3, 2017;
That, subsequently, and upon successive requests for extension of the reservation period of the aforementioned agreement by the Issuer, the Superintendent of the Securities Market ordered that the requested reservation of the agreement be extended until May 16, 2018, and that it would cease at the time when the assumptions referred to in article 16 of the Regulation of Material Facts occur;
That, on March 18, 2018, the Issuer informed, as a material fact, that its represented company signed a "Stock Purchase Agreement" with DP World Perú, through which it had been agreed: (i) the transfer of the shares owned by the Company in the subsidiary Cosmos Agencia Marítima S.A.C., and indirectly the transfer of its shares in Tritón Transports S.A., Neptunia S.A. and Terminales Portuarios Euroandinos S.A.; and (ii) the transfer of the property called Centro Logístico Gambetta registered in Electronic Entry No. 70060596 of the Callao Property Registry;
That, the Issuer also informed that through the "Stock Purchase Agreement", Inversiones Santa Orietta S.A.C. committed to transfer the shares it owns in Cosmos Agencia Marítima S.A.C. and the property called Sucursal Paita registered in Electronic Entry No. 11137286 of the Piura Property Registry. Furthermore, the agreed purchase value amounted to US$ 315.7 million;
That, according to the foregoing, it is appreciated that the agreement reached by the Issuer and to which the reserved classification was granted, remained in such condition from April 4, 2017 until March 18, 2018, the date on which it was reported as a material fact to the market, as indicated in the preceding recitals;
That, by Official Letter No. 4485-2018-SMV/11.1 of August 16, 2018, the General Superintendency of Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, the "IGSC") communicated to Mr. Vargas that it had been observed that in the period between February 6 and May 2, 2018 – while he held the position of General Manager of the Issuer – he carried out purchase and sale operations of shares of the Issuer, generating short-term profits in the amount of S/ 5,165.00 (Five thousand one hundred sixty-five and 00/100 Soles); therefore, he was required to proceed with the return of said profits.
That, by brief submitted to the SMV on September 3, 2018, Mr. Vargas indicated that on May 11, 2018, he deposited with the Issuer the total amount of S/ 18,354.97, which included the S/ 5,165.00 required and corresponded to the entirety of the profits obtained, derived from operations carried out prior to May 2, 2018. To prove this, Mr. Vargas attached to his brief a copy of the voucher or deposit receipt in favor of the Issuer dated May 11, 2018;
That, by Official Letter No. 5325-2018-SMV/11.1 of September 28, 2018, the IGSC requested Mr. Vargas to specify how he made the calculation by which he determined that the amount for short-term profits amounted to S/ 18,534.97;
That, in response to the aforementioned communication, Mr. Vargas, by brief submitted to the SMV on October 4, 2018, states, among others, that he carried out various operations with the Issuer's shares during October 5, 2017 to February 13, 2018, while the reserved fact mentioned above was in effect. He also states that he proceeded to sell said securities on May 2, 2018 and to deposit with the Issuer the profits obtained amounting to S/ 18,354.97, on May 11, 2018;
That, by Official Letter No. 6234-2018-SMV/11.1 of November 9, 2018, the IGSC requested, among others, that Mr. Vargas indicate the reasons why he sold the Issuer's securities on May 2, 2018 and the reason why he only considered the shares acquired through Credicorp Capital SAB (hereinafter, "Credicorp SAB") for the determination of the calculation of return of S/ 18,354.97;
That, by brief of November 16, 2018, Mr. Vargas indicated that the sale of the Issuer's shares made on May 2, 2018 through his stockbroker Credicorp SAB and the voluntary deposit to the Issuer of the profits obtained as a consequence of said sale, had as its "sole purpose to minimize the impact of the unintentionally committed infraction (...)";
That, likewise, Mr. Vargas added that being his usual stockbroker Credicorp SAB, he made an involuntary error by considering only the Issuer's shares acquired through said stockbrokerage firm. However, having reviewed his stock market operations, he also proceeded to the total sale of the Issuer's shares that he had acquired through Continental Bolsa SAB (hereinafter, "Continental SAB") between May 5, 2017 and January 9, 2018 and to deposit the total profits obtained to the Issuer for an amount of S/ 107,824.13, on November 16, 2018;
That, subsequently, by Official Letter No. 481-2019-SMV/11.2 charges were imputed to Mr. Vargas for having made improper use of privileged information, by making purchases of shares of the Issuer during the period in which a material fact was classified as reserved; requesting his defenses;
That, by brief of February 18, 2019, Mr. Vargas submitted his defenses to the aforementioned Official Letter No. 481-2019-SMV/11.2;
That, the General Superintendency of Conduct Compliance (hereinafter, the "IGCC"), through Report No. 567-2019-SMV/11.2, recommended, among others, to sanction Mr. Vargas with a fine amounting to 60 UIT, equivalent to S/ 243,000.00 (Two hundred forty-three thousand and 00/100 Soles), for having made improper use and directly availed himself for his own benefit of privileged information;
That, the aforementioned report was brought to the attention of Mr. Vargas, who formulated arguments in his defense. Due to this, the Deputy Superintendent of Conduct Supervision of Markets (SASCM) requested the IGSC to evaluate said defense arguments against the aforementioned report;
That, the IGSC, through Report No. 1151-2019-SMV/11.2, concluded to maintain the proposal to sanction Mr. Vargas with 60 UIT, for having made improper use and directly availed himself for his own benefit of privileged information;
That, by Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 010-2020-SMV/11, Mr. Vargas was sanctioned with a fine of 100 UIT, for having incurred an infraction of a very serious nature, typified in numeral 1.11, subparagraph 1 of Annex I of the SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by Conasev Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events (hereinafter, the "Sanctions Regulation"), for having improperly used privileged information;
That, Mr. Vargas filed an appeal against the aforementioned Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 010-2020-SMV/11;
That, through Report No. 963-2021-SMV/06, the Legal Advisory Office issued its opinion on the appeal filed by Mr. Vargas;
That, by briefs submitted on September 30, 2021 to the SMV, Mr. Vargas presented his brief of arguments and requested the use of the floor before the Superintendent of the Securities Market;
That, on October 13, 2021, the non-presential oral report was held before the Superintendent of the Securities Market, in which the attorneys designated by Mr. Vargas made use of the floor;
That, finally, on October 26, 2021, Mr. Vargas submitted to the SMV a supplementary defense brief to his arguments;
That, below, the arguments contained in the appeal filed by Mr. Vargas, in his other defense briefs, as well as those presented in the oral report made by his attorneys, are succinctly presented;
VIOLATION OF THE PRINCIPLE OF TYPICITY
That, Mr. Vargas states that the acquisitions of shares of the Issuer that are the subject of imputation are not extraordinary for him, because he actively participates in the market acquiring instruments issued by the Issuer or other issuers. Mr. Vargas indicates that all acquisitions were made with his own funds;
That, Mr. Vargas adds that when he realized the error he incurred in acquiring the Issuer's shares during the time in which a material fact was reserved, he returned the profits obtained without any requirement from the SMV, both from Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB;
That, additionally, he states that the delay in the return of the profits obtained through Continental SAB was due to the fact that he did not remember these purchases, because he had changed custodian;
That, Mr. Vargas indicates that in accordance with the principle of typicity, not any conduct prohibited in a regulatory norm qualifies as an infraction, but rather said conduct must be typified – clearly, completely and comprehensibly – in the Annexes of the applicable Sanctions Regulation;
That, in that sense, he points out that the conduct typified for cases of improper use of privileged information is that established in numeral 1.11, subparagraph 1 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation, which is made up of the following elements:
i) The administered must possess privileged information;
ii) The administered must have improperly used said privileged information; and
iii) Said use, direct or indirect, must have been made for his own benefit or that of a third party;
That, Mr. Vargas indicates that in the analysis of the typification of the imputed conduct, it is not discussed whether or not the administered committed a transgression of the provisions of the LMV or a regulatory norm (such as the Regulation against Market Abuse), but rather it corresponds to determine whether said transgression adjusts to the conduct typified in numeral 1.11, subparagraph 1 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation, since only the latter conduct is that which can be sanctioned, in accordance with the principle of typicity;
That, Mr. Vargas adds that the Sanction Resolution imposes a sanction on him without having analyzed the scope of numeral 1.11, subparagraph 1 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation, but rather limits itself to highlighting the fact that Mr. Vargas's conduct has contravened express provisions of the LMV and the Regulation against Market Abuse, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2012-SMV/01, without considering that, by express provision of article 3 of the Sanctions Regulation, said contravention is not enough, but it is also required that said conduct has been considered in the Annexes of the referred regulation;
That, Mr. Vargas alleges that the Sanction Resolution incorrectly considers that the charge imputed to him is that established in literal c) of article 43 of the LMV. Likewise, he points out that the Sanction Resolution maintains that the benefit for himself or third parties is not a constitutive requirement of the infraction conduct of improper use of privileged information, in accordance with a joint reading of the provisions of article 6.1 of the Regulation against Market Abuse and literal c) of article 43 of the LMV;
That, in accordance with the foregoing, Mr. Vargas concludes that the Sanction Resolution has improperly made an extensive interpretation of the conduct typified in numeral 1.11, subparagraph 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, by having considered elements established in other regulations such as the LMV and the Regulation against Market Abuse, which violates the principle of typicity, reason for which he considers that the Appealed Resolution must be revoked;
ABSENCE OF INTENT OR INTENTIONALITY
That, likewise, Mr. Vargas points out that the infraction type imputed to him contains a subjective element: intent in the administered's action. In that sense, he indicates that the use of privileged information is not sanctioned per se, but the use of said information by persons who seek to generate a benefit for themselves or for third parties;
That, in accordance with the foregoing, Mr. Vargas states that he never had the intention (intent) to generate a personal benefit or generate a benefit in favor of a third party at the time of carrying out his purchase and sale operations of the Issuer's shares, but rather these were operations that he habitually carried out in order to align his interests with those of the Issuer;
That, in that sense, Mr. Vargas adds that he did not notice the reserved fact at the time of carrying out said operations since he saw nothing extraordinary in them, even more so considering that the reserved fact was in force for almost a year, so he points out that it is not surprising that he continued operating as he habitually did without noticing said exceptional situation;
That, Mr. Vargas maintains that if his intention had been to obtain benefits at the time of carrying out said operations, he would not have proceeded to return the profits obtained to the Issuer, as soon as he became aware of his error, without any requirement from either the SMV or the Issuer;
That, Mr. Vargas states that in the Sanction Resolution the meaning of this return is confused by indicating that reference is being made to the return of short-term profits. In this regard, Mr. Vargas indicates that since the notification of the Charges Official Letter it was clear to him that the present sanctioning procedure does not deal with short-term profits but with the use of privileged information;
That, in line with the foregoing, he adds that what is relevant is that the return to the Issuer of the profits obtained proves that it was not his intention to generate a benefit for himself or in favor of a third party, since otherwise the reason why he returned the benefits he allegedly sought to obtain would not be understood, when no one required it;
That, Mr. Vargas indicates that in the Sanction Resolution, although it is expressly recognized that the infraction type for which he has been sanctioned has a subjective element, it does not relate his conduct to said element, without evaluating whether it is common for an infracting administered to return, without anyone requiring it or having detected it, the benefits that he improperly sought to acquire;
That, Mr. Vargas adds that on the point indicated in the preceding recital, the Sanction Resolution has only limited itself to relating said conduct to an assumption that is not part of the present procedure, such as that referring to the return of short-term profits;
That, due to the foregoing, Mr. Vargas expresses that the return of the profits to the Issuer proves that there was no intent in his action and that, in the absence of the subjective element of the infraction type, it is not legally valid for him to be sanctioned, and the Appealed Resolution must be revoked and the present administrative sanctioning procedure must be ordered archived;
VIOLATION OF THE PRINCIPLE OF REASONABLENESS AND DUE MOTIVATION
That, Mr. Vargas also argues that the Sanction Resolution does not comply with the legal requirement of due motivation, since initially the instructing body recommended the imposition of a fine of 60 UIT, which included a 10% reduction of the sanction to be imposed, in attention to the existence of mitigating factors. However, Mr. Vargas points out that he requested to know the detail of how the instructing body arrived at recommending the imposition of a fine of 60 UIT, as well as the application of a 10% mitigating factor of the sanction to be imposed, a request that he points out was not only not taken up by the sanctioning body, which by itself evidences insufficient argumentation, but even a higher fine amounting to 100 UIT was imposed on him, without adequately assessing the existing mitigating factors;
That, in this regard, Mr. Vargas states that although the sanctioning body is competent to increase or reduce the fine proposed by the instructing body, it has the duty to substantiate said decision, which has not been fulfilled in the Sanction Resolution, even disregarding the 10% mitigating factor of the sanction to be imposed recommended by the instructing body;
That, likewise, Mr. Vargas alleges that the Sanction Resolution has infringed the principle of proportionality because the sanction criteria established in the regulations have not been timely assessed:
That, Mr. Vargas points out that by not having considered the sanction criteria indicated above, nor having developed them in detail, the Sanction Resolution violates the principle of reasonableness and the right to due motivation;
NON-APPLICATION OF SANCTION MITIGATING FACTORS
That, on the other hand, Mr. Vargas maintains that the Sanction Resolution has also not taken into account that in the present case, the sanction mitigating factors indicated in the new SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, were applicable, which although it was not in force at the time of the events, is applicable because it is more favorable to the administered;
That, in that sense, Mr. Vargas states that the mitigating factor referring to the infractor's contribution to the clarification of the infraction was applicable, since he timely delivered the information requested by the SMV, through his briefs of October 4 and November 16, 2018, which the SMV itself recognizes in the instruction report as contributions to clarify the facts linked to the alleged infraction. Mr. Vargas indicates that the sanctioning body has differed from this position, but does not substantiate the reasons why the mitigating factor proposed by the instructing body is not applicable;
That, likewise, Mr. Vargas alleges that the mitigating factor for correction is also applicable, since prior to the requirement or the initiation of a sanctioning procedure by the SMV, he voluntarily returned to the Issuer the profits obtained from operations with its shares. Due to this, Mr. Vargas indicates that the instruction report recognizes that a mitigating factor of 10% reduction of the fine should be applied. However, he points out that the sanctioning body departs from said proposal without further foundation.
That, due to the foregoing, Mr. Vargas maintains that he has demonstrated that the SMV itself recognizes that the aforementioned attenuating circumstances exist, and that despite this it does not choose to apply any percentage of reduction on the sanction that is reasonable and proportional, taking into account that sanctions for very serious infractions in the securities market can be up to 50 UIT, in accordance with article 20 of the Sanctions Regulation and article 33 of the new Sanctions Regulation.
NON-APPLICATION OF THE EXEMPTION FROM LIABILITY FOR VOLUNTARY REMEDIATION
That, in the oral report made by his lawyers before this Office on October 13, 2021, as well as in his last supplementary brief of his arguments, Mr. Vargas has stated that the Sanction Resolution has failed to evaluate and apply the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation established in literal f) of numeral 1 of article 236-A of the General Administrative Procedure Law – LPAG, Law 27444:
“Article 236-A.- Exemptions and attenuating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following are exempting conditions of liability for infractions:
(…)
f) The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 235.
(…).”
That, in that sense, Mr. Vargas states that the Sanction Resolution affects the right to due motivation, in that it does not rule on his defense arguments regarding the application of the exemption from liability;
That, Mr. Vargas indicates that the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation was incorporated into article 236-A of the LPAG on December 21, 2016 by Legislative Decree No. 1272;
That, Mr. Vargas adds that said exemption from liability for voluntary remediation is applicable to his case, due to the following reasons:
That, in accordance with the foregoing, Mr. Vargas argues that the Sanction Resolution has infringed the right to due motivation and the principle of legality, by not having evaluated and applied the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation recognized in the regulations; therefore, he requests that said resolution be revoked and the aforementioned exemption from liability be applied;
That, finally, Mr. Vargas reaffirms the non-existence of malice in his conduct, because: i) he is a long-time participant in the securities market, ii) considering the period in which the reserved fact was maintained (almost a year), it is reasonable that he did not notice that it was in force at the time of carrying out the operations with shares of the Issuer, iii) as soon as he noticed his error, he proceeded to return the profits obtained, before charges were imputed to him, and iv) he has never been previously involved in an administrative sanctioning procedure for facts similar to those that generated the imputation of charges in this procedure;
ANALYSIS OF THE APPEAL
That, from the evaluation carried out, it is appreciated that the appeal filed by Mr. Vargas complies with the requirements established in articles 124, 218, 220 and 221 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law[1], approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (TUO LPAG), given that it was filed within the term of fifteen (15) days of notification of the administrative act, it indicates the act being appealed and it is founded;
That, in the first place, it must be noted that we agree with the Sanction Resolution regarding that: i) the information classified as reserved by the Issuer's Board of Directors on April 4, 2017 constitutes privileged information in accordance with article 40 of the LMV[2], ii) Mr. Vargas had access to said privileged information since, among others, in his capacity as General Manager of the Issuer he participated in the Board meeting of April 4, 2017, and iii) Mr. Vargas acquired shares of the Issuer, through the stock exchange, between May 5, 2017 and February 13, 2018, while the aforementioned reserved fact was in force;
That, Mr. Vargas has acknowledged the foregoing, indicating in his defense that: i) the Sanction Resolution has infringed the principle of typicity by having made an extensive interpretation of the infraction type indicated in numeral 1.11, subsection 1 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation, concluding that own benefit or that of third parties is not a constitutive requirement of the infraction conduct of improper use of privileged information, and ii) that in his case there has been no own benefit or that of third parties when acquiring the Issuer's shares, since he returned the profits obtained from said operations, upon noticing his error and before being required by the SMV, which also demonstrates that he acted without malice;
REGARDING THE VIOLATION OF THE PRINCIPLE OF TYPICITY
That, in relation to the alleged infringement of the principle of typicity, it is considered that said non-compliance has not occurred, since in the Sanction Resolution, at the time of analyzing the infraction type attributed to Mr. Vargas, all the elements that configure said type are indeed taken into account. It must be taken into consideration that in the Sanction Resolution it is concluded that Mr. Vargas has infringed the prohibition of use of privileged information established in literal c) of article 43 of the LMV, which is typified in numeral 1.11, subsection 1 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation:
| Securities Market Law | Sanctions Regulation |
| Article 43.- Prohibitions Persons who possess privileged information are prohibited from: c) Making improper use of and availing themselves, directly or indirectly, for their own benefit or that of third parties, of privileged information. | Annex 1 Of General Infractions They are common infractions to Participants and liquidators, as applicable: 1.11 Making improper use of and availing themselves, directly or indirectly, for their own benefit or that of third parties, of the privileged information possessed. |
Own elaboration
That, as can be seen from the foregoing comparative table, the prohibition of use of privileged information provided in literal c) of article 43 of the LMV is textually reflected in numeral 1.11 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation. Likewise, it must be taken into account that, despite what Mr. Vargas states, the Sanction Resolution does take into consideration the element referring to the fact that the use of privileged information must be carried out seeking to obtain, or with a view to obtaining, a benefit for oneself or for third parties. Indeed, on page 20 of the Sanction Resolution it is textually stated as follows:
“In this sense, it does not follow that the norm requires that there has been a benefit in favor of the person who carried out the transactions making improper use of privileged information, but rather that the improper use of privileged information be made seeking to obtain or with a view to obtaining a benefit for oneself or for third parties, which is logical since a person who uses privileged information will seek to benefit themselves or benefit third parties in the short, medium or long term.” Underlining added.
That, in that sense, in the Sanction Resolution it is not maintained that for the infraction of improper use of privileged information to be configured, it is not necessary that said conduct have been carried out with the purpose of obtaining a benefit for oneself or for third parties, but rather that what is not necessary is that said benefit have materialized in the facts. Indeed, it is not necessary that the offender have obtained a concrete benefit, for themselves or for third parties, from the use of privileged information, since for the infraction type to be configured, it is only required that privileged information have been used with the purpose of obtaining a benefit for oneself or for third parties;
That, the foregoing is consistent with the legal interest protected by the prohibition of improper use of privileged information, which is represented by market transparency. Damage to said legal interest occurs from the moment the person who possesses privileged information carries out operations in the securities market using said information, regardless of whether the benefit they intend to obtain materializes or not, since they participate in the market in a position of greater advantage compared to other investors who do not possess said information. In this sense, Serra Puente-Arnao, citing Cachón Blanco and Verchik, states that:
“Insider Trading are the operations carried out on such security by those persons who have privileged information. In this sense, legal systems in general establish rules prohibiting these operations with the purpose of avoiding inequality of opportunities among investors.[3]”. Underlining added.
That, likewise, it must be highlighted that it is not appreciated that the Sanction Resolution, when referring to article 6 of the Market Abuse Regulation, has used the content of what is stated in said article to make an extensive interpretation of the prohibition of improper use of privileged information indicated in literal c) of article 43 of the LMV. On the contrary, as can be seen from the Sanction Resolution, the citation of article 6 of the Market Abuse Regulation is only used as an additional reference to demonstrate that the prohibition of use of privileged information is incurred when operations are carried out with securities regarding which one has such information, regardless of whether or not a benefit has been obtained.
That, it is relevant to note that the effective obtaining of an economic benefit or avoiding a loss of this type is an element in which the typification of the use of privileged information as an administrative infraction differs from the use of privileged information as a criminal type[4]. In the latter case, the existence of said benefit or having avoided said economic loss is required, unlike the administrative infraction of improper use of privileged information, which, as stated, does not require it;
REGARDING THE NON-EXISTENCE OF OWN OR THIRD-PARTY BENEFIT
That, Mr. Vargas has stated as another defense argument that in his case there has been no own or third-party benefit in the acquisition he made of the Issuer's shares, since he returned the profits he obtained from said operations, which also demonstrates that he did not act with intent;
That, on this matter, it is appreciated that Mr. Vargas confuses two different moments related to the improper use of privileged information: i) the commission of the infraction itself, which materialized at the time of acquiring the Issuer's shares, over which he had privileged information, and ii) the return of the profits obtained as a consequence of the commission of said infraction;
That, it must be taken into account that the commission of the infraction of improper use of privileged information did generate profits for Mr. Vargas, precisely those that he himself acknowledges, and that he ended up returning to the Issuer. In this sense, the return of the profits obtained as a consequence of the commission of the infraction of use of privileged information does not in any way extinguish liability for said infraction, even more so when, as mentioned, the effective materialization of an own or third-party benefit is not a necessary element for the infraction type of privileged information to be configured. In accordance with the foregoing, on page 24 of the Sanction Resolution it is textually stated that:
“(…) however, it could not be maintained that the damage caused to the market has been reversed, repaired or compensated, since the mere improper use of privileged information is already conduct that has generated damage to the integrity and transparency of the securities market and that said damage is not repaired in any way by the return of what was gained.”. Underlining added.
That, the improper use of privileged information constitutes one of the market abuse practices that most damage the confidence and transparency of the securities market, since they break good faith and generate a serious inequality of opportunities among investors participating in the securities market; therefore, the mere return of the profits obtained cannot in any way extinguish liability for the commission of said infraction. Without prejudice to the foregoing, and as acknowledged on page 21 of the Sanction Resolution, the return of profits must indeed be taken into account as an attenuating circumstance at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed:
“In this way, it can be concluded that for the purposes of determining the infraction corresponding to the prohibited conduct established in subsection c) of article 43 of the LMV, it is not relevant that Mr. Vargas has proceeded to return to the Issuer the profits obtained under the terms of article 44 of the LMV that regulates the return of short-term profits. However, said return will be taken into account at the time of analyzing the attenuating circumstances of the case.”. Underlining added.
That, notwithstanding the foregoing, it is taken into account that Mr. Vargas only proceeded to return to the Issuer the profits obtained from operations carried out through Credicorp SAB, without any kind of request, amounting to S/ 18,354.97. The majority of the profits obtained, from operations carried out through Continental SAB, amounting to S/ 107,824.13, were returned to the Issuer after the SMV sent Mr. Vargas Official Letter No. 6234-2018-SMV/11.1, in which it requests Mr. Vargas to explain the reasons why he had proceeded only with the sale of the Issuer's shares acquired through Credicorp SAB and not with those acquired through Continental SAB, when the latter represented 77.76% of the total shares acquired from the Issuer, while the reserved fact was in force;
That, in relation to this aspect, Mr. Vargas has indicated, both in his appeal and in the oral report, that due to an involuntary error arising from a change of custodian from Continental SAB to Credicorp SAB, he only requested the purchase record of Credicorp SAB. In this regard, we agree with what is stated in numeral (iii) of recital 44 of the Sanction Resolution regarding that:
“(…) it is complex to accept this last statement as true, since Mr. Vargas had knowledge from the moment the fact that constituted privileged information was classified as reserved, and furthermore, because it has been identified that the change of custodian from Continental SAB to Credicorp SAB did not occur successively, but rather in a determined period of approximately four months Mr. Vargas was a client of both brokerage firms.”
That, indeed, as indicated in the aforementioned recital of the Sanction Resolution, it has been identified that the operations corresponding to 10/24/2017, 11/09/2017, 11/14/2017, 12/13/2017, 12/28/2017 and 01/09/2018 were made by Mr. Vargas through Continental SAB, when he was already a client of Credicorp SAB, with whom he also made the operations of 10/05/2017, 10/24/2017 and 11/16/2017. Therefore, between 10/24/2017 and 01/09/2018 Mr. Vargas was a client of both Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB, so it is questionable that Mr. Vargas only remembered to request the purchase record of Credicorp SAB, even more so when the majority of the operations of acquisition of the Issuer's shares, during the validity of the reserved fact, he carried out precisely through Continental SAB;
REGARDING THE NON-EXISTENCE OF MALICE OR INTENT
That, likewise, Mr. Vargas has maintained that he did not act with malice at the time of acquiring the Issuer's shares, since he involuntarily did not notice the reserved fact at the time of carrying out said operations, because he carried out these operations regularly to align his interests with those of the Issuer, seeing nothing extraordinary in them;
That, in this regard, it must be indicated that although Mr. Vargas states that he did not notice that he had reserved information at the time of acquiring the Issuer's shares, said statement belongs to his subjective sphere; however, in the file there are various evidentiary elements that allow concluding that Mr. Vargas had knowledge of the reserved fact and that therefore, he should have abstained from carrying out said operations;
That, in that sense, we do not share what the appellant alleges, in the sense that he saw “nothing extraordinary” in the operations with the Issuer's shares and that it is reasonable that he did not notice that it was in force taking into account that the fact was kept reserved for almost a year, since every General Manager of an Issuer must consider, at all times, that any operation that involves him, directly or indirectly, with operations related to shares of the Issuer of which he is General Manager, whether to align his interests with those of the Issuer or for any other reason, must always be considered by him an extraordinary operation that requires special attention and care, since the position he holds allows him, precisely, to have permanent access to sensitive and privileged information;
That, likewise, regarding that the reserved fact was in force for almost a year, this is not a basis to excuse his conduct, as the appellant suggests, but rather reaffirms that the reservation was reiterated or reminded to him each time the Issuer requested an extension of the term to maintain it as such, of which Mr. Vargas was aware in his capacity as General Manager of the Issuer; as will be detailed below;
That, it is important to take into account that Mr. Vargas's access to the Issuer's reserved fact is not based solely on the presumption established in subsection a) of article 41 of the LMV[5], in his capacity as General Manager of the Issuer, but also, he participated as Secretary of the Issuer's Board meeting of April 4, 2017, in which the agreement of the reserved fact is taken and it is arranged to request the SMV for the reservation of said information;
That, likewise, it must be considered that according to the tables presented in recitals 6 and 8 of the Sanction Resolution, Mr. Vargas acquired shares of the Issuer on a total of 18 occasions, through two brokerage firms, between May 5, 2017 and February 13, 2018, while the reserved fact was in force; therefore, it is questionable that Mr. Vargas had not noticed in all that time that he had reserved information about the Issuer's shares, especially when there were various requests from the Issuer to the SMV to extend the validity of the reserved fact;
That, it is important to note that initially the Superintendent of the Securities Market ordered that the term of validity of the reserved fact would be until July 3, 2017. However, subsequently, by agreements of the Issuer's Board of Directors, the SMV was requested to extend the term of validity of the reserved fact on three (3) occasions, with the Superintendent of the Securities Market ordering that said information would be kept reserved until May 16, 2018[6]. In this regard, we agree with what is indicated in recital 33 of the Sanction Resolution, regarding that Mr. Vargas, in his capacity as General Manager of the Issuer, should have acted with greater diligence at the time of carrying out operations with the shares of said company:
“Without prejudice to the foregoing, it can be stated that a General Manager of an Issuer who carries out operations with the securities of his issuer must be more diligent than any other investor each time he carries out an operation of this type, and even more, he should be one of the first participants to ensure that operations are not carried out with the securities of his issuer using privileged information.”. Underlining added.
REGARDING THE VIOLATION OF THE PRINCIPLE OF REASONABLENESS AND DUE MOTIVATION
That Mr. Vargas has stated that the Sanction Resolution has failed to provide proper reasoning for the 100 UIT sanction imposed on him, especially when the instructor's report recommended a fine of 60 UIT, recognizing a 10% reduction of the fine due to the existence of mitigating circumstances. Mr. Vargas has indicated that although the sanctioning body may depart from the sanction recommendation indicated in the instruction report, it must justify that decision, which has not happened in the Sanction Resolution, which also does not take into account the parameter of a 10% reduction of the fine to be imposed due to the existence of mitigating circumstances of the infraction;
That, in this regard, it should be noted that the infraction of improper use of privileged information is classified in numeral 1.11, subsection 1 of Annex 1 of the Sanctions Regulation as an infraction of a very serious nature, and therefore, in accordance with article 33 of said regulation, a fine of no less than 50 UIT and up to 700 UIT may be imposed for its commission;
That, likewise, it is noted that the Sanction Resolution has carried out an analysis of the determination of the sanction to be imposed in its Section V, and therefore an evaluation will be made as to whether it has complied with properly assessing the sanction criteria and the mitigating circumstances established by the applicable regulations, also taking into account the arguments raised by the defense in light of the evaluation thereof;
That, it must be taken into account that the sanction criteria are established in article 348 of the LMV, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, as well as the provisions of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the commission of the facts (hereinafter "Sanction Criteria");
That, in accordance with the foregoing, the Sanction Criteria refer to: (1) the offender's antecedents, (2) recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, (3) the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, (4) the economic harm caused and its repercussion on the market, (5) the illegally obtained benefit, (6) the probability of detection of the infraction, (7) the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, and (8) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction;
That, in relation to the offender's antecedents, the Sanction Resolution states that it has been verified that Mr. Vargas has no sanction antecedents. Likewise, it is recognized that there is no recidivism on the part of Mr. Vargas in the commission of the same infraction;
That, regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, Mr. Vargas states that the imputed facts are not serious, considering that he complied with returning the profits obtained before the imputation of the charges and that the amounts involved in the acquisition of the Issuer's shares are not relevant;
That, on this particular matter, we agree with what is mentioned in the Sanction Resolution, in the sense that the transparency of the market has been affected by the improper use of privileged information by Mr. Vargas, which likewise affects the integrity and confidence of the securities markets when this type of market abuse practices are carried out;
That, as previously indicated, the return of profits to the Issuer of the benefits obtained by said practice does not exempt from liability for the commission of the infraction. Likewise, it must be considered that the affectation to the transparency and integrity of the securities market has occurred, regardless of the amount involved, from the moment Mr. Vargas made the acquisition of the Issuer's shares over which he had privileged information, since he breached good faith and acted with an advantage over other investors, by having material non-public information;
That, regarding the economic harm caused, the Sanction Resolution indicates that this harm is the counterpart to the profit that Mr. Vargas would have obtained from the purchase and sale operations of the Issuer's shares through Continental SAB, which would have amounted to S/ 107,824.13. The Sanction Resolution states that had it not been for the preliminary inquiries carried out and the request made through Official Letter No. 6234-2018-SMV/11.1, it would not be certain whether said profits would have been returned to the Issuer;
That, in this regard, Mr. Vargas has indicated that there is no economic harm caused, since he returned all profits to the Issuer, and no economic benefit in his favor materialized.
That, in relation to this aspect, we agree with what is maintained by the Sanction Resolution, since as previously indicated, Mr. Vargas returned only the profits obtained through Credicorp SAB without any requirement from the SMV, which did not occur with the profits obtained through Continental SAB, so there is no certainty that he would have returned these profits had there been no prior requirement from the SMV;
That, as regards the resulting illicit benefit, Mr. Vargas states that it does not exist, since he has returned to the Issuer all profits derived from the alleged improper use of privileged information. Notwithstanding the foregoing, we agree with what is mentioned by the Sanction Resolution regarding the fact that said illicit benefit was configured from the moment Mr. Vargas sold the Issuer's shares acquired through Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB, which were purchased making improper use of privileged information, generating profits of S/ 18,354.00 and S/ 107,824.13, respectively, without prejudice to the fact that, as indicated in the Sanction Resolution, it is taken into account, at the time of analyzing the mitigating circumstances of the case, that Mr. Vargas returned said profits to the Issuer.
That, in relation to the probability of detection of the infraction, the Sanction Resolution considered that it is low, taking into account that the detection of cases of improper use of privileged information is in principle quite complex, since it requires not only the use of internal control systems, but also the use of additional means and tools, so the probability of detection is low and, therefore, should increase the sanction imposed. Notwithstanding the foregoing, and despite what Mr. Vargas stated, the Sanction Resolution does take into account that "Mr. Vargas was the one who, in response to the first official letter sent by the IGSC – which requested the return of his short-term profits – indicated that they had already been returned in a higher amount, since he carried out said operations in possession of privileged information";
That, in this sense, in the Sanction Resolution, without prejudice to taking into account that the response of Mr. Vargas indicated above allowed the preliminary inquiries to continue and to identify the charge that was subsequently formulated, it concludes that the probability of detection of the infraction is low, since it was detected as a consequence of a specific supervision action carried out by the SMV, related to the returns of short-term profits and the proceedings subsequently carried out;
That, regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, the Sanction Resolution states that there has been willingness in the commission of the infraction, especially during the time in which the offender instructed operations intermediated by Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB. In this regard, Mr. Vargas has maintained that there was no intentionality in his conduct since otherwise he would not have returned the profits obtained to the Issuer.
That, notwithstanding the foregoing, as has been stated in this resolution, the return of the profits obtained as a result of the infraction does not negate the commission of the infraction and does not prove that it was not committed with intentionality. On the contrary, the file contains various evidentiary elements that allow concluding that Mr. Vargas was aware of the reserved fact, and that, therefore, he should have refrained from acquiring the Issuer's shares, whatever the reason for doing so;
That, in relation to the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, Mr. Vargas has maintained that the main circumstance is that the imputed facts were not committed with intentionality, since otherwise he would not have returned the profits obtained and would have instead occupied himself with keeping said facts hidden. On this point the Sanction Resolution has stated that:
i) As part of his defenses, Mr. Vargas stated that the questioned purchase operations of the Issuer's shares would have been involuntarily carried out, since he had brokerage firms that directly managed, advised and administered his investments.
However, as a result of the proceedings carried out, said arguments were disproved since it was corroborated that the orders for said operations were formulated by Mr. Vargas himself with knowledge of a reserved fact, and therefore, in possession of privileged information, in addition to verifying that neither Credicorp SAB nor Continental SAB had a discretionary portfolio management contract with Mr. Vargas, but only securities intermediation services. Furthermore, in the case of Continental SAB, there is even a recording of the order via telephone, in which Mr. Vargas identifies himself with his names and his national identity document.
In this regard, it must be stated that Mr. Vargas has not questioned these conclusions indicated in the Sanction Resolution.
Without prejudice to the foregoing, it must be taken into account that the signing of a portfolio management contract, whether discretionary or not, can in no way be considered a valid argument to exempt oneself from liability for an eventual use of privileged information or any other improper practice in accordance with the rules against Market Abuse. In these cases, and in attention to compliance with a duty of diligence, the investor is responsible for disclosing to the Agent the securities or financial instruments in which he could have privileged information, due to his position or office, without prejudice to applying other diligence measures that the Agent must also develop to avoid Market Abuse conducts, in accordance with the provisions of subsection b) of article 72 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01[7].
ii) As previously indicated, Mr. Vargas only returned the profits obtained through Credicorp SAB without any requirement from the SMV, since the profits obtained through Continental SAB were returned after the notification of Official Letter No. 6234-2018-SMV/11.1. Mr. Vargas has maintained that due to an involuntary error arising from a change of custodian from Continental SAB to Credicorp SAB, he only requested the purchase record from Credicorp SAB. However, as has been stated, said affirmation is questionable since Mr. Vargas for approximately four months was a client of both Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB and furthermore 77.76% of the acquisition operations of the Issuer's shares, during the validity of the reserved fact, he carried out precisely through Continental SAB;
REGARDING THE NON-APPLICATION OF SANCTION MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES
That, Mr. Vargas has alleged that in his case the mitigating circumstances indicated in the new SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, referring to the offender's contribution to the clarification of the infraction and remediation, were applicable. In this regard, it should be noted that the Sanction Resolution has complied with carrying out an analysis of both mitigating circumstances in order to determine the sanction to be imposed on Mr. Vargas;
That, in this sense, regarding the offender's contribution to the clarification of the infraction, the Sanction Resolution concludes that in view of the facts exposed and the arguments formulated by Mr. Vargas, it is considered that there has been no contribution by the offender to the clarification of the infraction.
That, in this regard, we agree with what is indicated by the Sanction Resolution on this aspect, since although in the preliminary inquiry stage, Mr. Vargas acknowledged that he had acquired shares of the Issuer through Credicorp SAB, in possession of privileged information, he subsequently denied the commission of the infraction of improper use of privileged information, because he had not obtained profits from said operations;
That, this position is supported by the fact that although Mr. Vargas initially indicated that said operations had been carried out involuntarily, since he had brokerage firms that directly managed, advised and administered his investments, this was subsequently disproved, by virtue of the proceedings carried out by the SMV;
That, likewise, it must be taken into account that Mr. Vargas did not initially inform about the operations carried out through Continental SAB, which represented 77.76% of the acquisitions of the Issuer's shares made by Mr. Vargas while he possessed privileged information;
That, on the other hand, in relation to the mitigating circumstance for remediation, it should be mentioned that although remediation does not constitute an exemption from liability for infractions of improper use of privileged information, in accordance with the provisions of subsection b) of article 28 of the new Sanctions Regulation[8], the Sanction Resolution has taken into account, as a mitigating circumstance, at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed, the fact that Mr. Vargas returned the profits obtained from the improper use of privileged information to the Issuer, in accordance with the provisions of its recital 45:
"(…) On the other hand, this Deputy Superintendency considers it appropriate to point out in this part, that in order to establish the corresponding sanction, the return of the profits made by Mr. Vargas has been taken into account, as a consequence of the transactions he made with the Issuer's shares through Credicorp SAB and Continental SAB, in possession of privileged information."
That, although the Sanction Resolution does not specifically establish a percentage of mitigation of the sanction to be imposed for the return of profits to the Issuer, as is done in the instruction report, this does not mean that said factor has not been effectively assessed, as expressly recognized by the Sanction Resolution;
That, therefore, in accordance with the foregoing, we consider that the Sanction Resolution has complied with carrying out a due analysis of all the sanction criteria and the application of the mitigating circumstances recognized by the regulations to the present case, at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed on Mr. Vargas for the commission of the infraction of improper use of privileged information, and therefore the principles of reasonableness or due motivation have not been infringed. It should be noted that the sanction imposed on Mr. Vargas of 100 UIT is within the parameters required by the regulations, taking into account the seriousness of the infraction of improper use of privileged information, which may be sanctioned with a fine of no less than 50 UIT and up to 700 UIT;
That, likewise, it must be taken into account that the sanctioning body may depart from the sanction proposal indicated in the instruction report, as long as it justifies said decision, which has been done in the present case, in the Sanction Resolution;
REGARDING THE NON-APPLICATION OF THE EXEMPTION FROM LIABILITY FOR VOLUNTARY REMEDIATION
That, in the first place, it should be noted that in the appeal, it is observed that Mr. Vargas alleges that the Sanction Resolution has not taken into account the return he made to the Issuer of the profits obtained from operations with its shares, as a mitigating circumstance of the sanction; due to this, in the present resolution, said defense argument was analyzed, concluding that in the Sanction Resolution said act of return was indeed taken into account as a mitigating circumstance at the time of imposing the corresponding sanction;
That, in relation to the application of the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation, it should be indicated that, in the first administrative instance, in his defense brief of February 19, 2019, Mr. Vargas requests, in application of the principle of benign retroactivity, the exemption from liability established in subsection f) of article 27 of the new SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01;
That, in this regard, it is noted that the Sanction Resolution does rule on said request of Mr. Vargas, on pages 21 to 24. In this regard, it is stated that literal f) of article 27 of the new SMV Sanctions Regulation must be read systematically with the other norms that make up said regulation;
That, in accordance with the foregoing, the Sanction Resolution mentions that article 28 of the New Sanctions Regulation establishes the cases in which remediation is not applicable as an exemption from liability, one of them being the contravention of market abuse rules, referring to improper use of privileged information and market manipulation, so this class of infractions are not subject to remediation, in accordance with literal b) of the aforementioned article;
That, without prejudice to the foregoing, the Sanction Resolution indicates, on page 24, that infractions regarding improper use of privileged information, in fact, are not possible to remediate because:
"(…) it could not be maintained that the damage caused to the market has been reversed, repaired or compensated, since the mere improper use of privileged information is already a conduct that has generated damage to the integrity and transparency of the securities market and that said damage is not repaired in any way by the return of what was gained.
Indeed, this infraction directly affects the transparency of the market, a legal interest that is protected and that cannot be compensated or reversed with the cessation of the infracting conduct. The harm caused and the repercussion on the market occurred at the moment of improperly using the information that was classified as reserved by the Issuer and that according to the LMV had the character of privileged information."
That, in this sense, it is not observed that the Sanction Resolution has infringed the right to due motivation, since it does rule on the application of the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation, in accordance with the foregoing;
That, without prejudice to the foregoing, and in attention to the fact that Mr. Vargas, in the appeal stage, has again requested the application of the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation, in this case by direct application of literal f) of numeral 1 of article 236-A of the LPAG, it is appropriate to evaluate whether said exemption from liability should be applied or not in his case, in order to guarantee in an unrestricted manner his right of defense;
That, the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation, contained in literal f) of numeral 1) of article 236-A of the LPAG was incorporated by Legislative Decree No. 1272, on December 21, 2016, and therefore was in force at the time of the occurrence of the facts subject to the present administrative sanctioning procedure:
"Article 236-A.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following constitute conditions exempting from liability for infractions:
(…)
f) The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 235.
(…)."
That, in relation to the elements that must be met for the application of the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation indicated above, Torres Sanchez states the following:
"Indeed, according to the provisions of the normative text, to achieve exemption from punishment by virtue of remediation, three requirements must be met: i) that the conduct be remediated, ii) that the administered party has not been notified of the charges imputed (which determines the start of the administrative sanctioning procedure), and iii) that the remediation be done voluntarily[9]."
That, regarding the remediation of the conduct, Mr. Vargas alleges that this would have occurred with the return of the profits obtained to the Issuer for the operations with its shares;
That, notwithstanding the foregoing, and as has been repeatedly stated in this resolution, the return of the profits obtained in no way negates the commission of the infraction of improper use of privileged information, which affects the transparency and confidence of the securities market and which materializes from the moment Mr. Vargas carries out operations with the Issuer's shares, being in possession of privileged information;
That, as regards the possibility of remediating an infracting conduct for the application of the exemption from liability, Mori Torres states that "(…) the exemption for voluntary remediation should apply if we are before an infraction whose effects can still be reestablished[10]";
That, in this sense, the effects generated by the infraction of improper use of privileged information cannot be reversed, since the damage to the confidence and transparency of the market remains upon having breached the good faith and equal opportunity of the investors participating in the securities market, who expect that no person acts with undue advantages to which he has been able to access by reason of his position or office, even more so when this refers to an executive of the highest hierarchy of the Issuer;
That, without prejudice to the foregoing, it is taken into account that although the new SMV Sanctions Regulation entered into force after the occurrence of the facts subject to this sanctioning procedure, it cannot be ignored that it has only provided greater predictability to the reality indicated above, regarding the fact that remediation of an infraction of improper use of privileged information is not possible;
Whereas, it is important to note that Article 236-A(1)(f) of the LPAG itself states that for said exemption from liability to apply, the act or omission constituting the imputed infraction must be voluntarily remedied. In this regard, the regulation itself does not merely state that for the exemption to apply or for the infraction to be considered remedied, it is sufficient to return or give back the benefits obtained unlawfully;
Whereas, the foregoing is precisely because there are infractions that affect public interests and/or protected legal assets of an intangible nature, such as trust or transparency in the securities market, which are not remedied by returning the unlawful benefits obtained, without prejudice to the fact that this may be considered a mitigating factor for the sanction, as considered by the Sanction Resolution[11];
Whereas, therefore, it agrees with what was stated by the Sanction Resolution regarding the fact that infractions concerning the misuse of privileged information are not materially remediable because they affect the trust and transparency of the securities market from the moment they are incurred; regardless of the fact that subsequently, and for purposes of greater predictability, the new SMV Sanctions Regulation has recognized this;
Whereas, without prejudice to the foregoing, regarding the requirement that the remediation of the conduct be carried out voluntarily, Morón Urbina states that:
"(…) it must be carried out without originating from a mandate of the authority. That is, it would not be voluntary if there already existed a requirement or corrective measure of the authority or another similar document through which the administered party is requested to remedy the act or omission that may be classified as an infraction" [12]
Whereas, as previously stated, Mr. Vargas only proceeded to return to the Issuer the profits obtained from transactions carried out through Credicorp SAB, without any kind of request, amounting to S/ 18,354.97;
Whereas, notwithstanding the foregoing, the majority of the profits obtained, from transactions carried out through Continental SAB, amounting to S/ 107,824.13, were returned to the Issuer after the SMV sent Mr. Vargas Oficio No. 6234-2018-SMV/11, in which it requested Mr. Vargas to explain the reasons why he had proceeded only with the sale of the Issuer's shares acquired through Credicorp SAB and not with those acquired through Continental SAB, when the latter represented 77.76% of the total shares acquired from the Issuer, while the reserved fact was in force;
Whereas, it was only after the aforementioned Oficio No. 6234-2018-SMV/11 was sent that Mr. Vargas proceeded to return to the Issuer the majority of the profits obtained from transactions with the Issuer's shares, while a reserved fact to which he had direct access was in force;
Whereas, in that sense, even in the denied assumption that the return of profits to the Issuer would remedy the infringing conduct of misuse of privileged information, it must be taken into account that Mr. Vargas returned the majority of said profits after Oficio No. 6234-2018-SMV/11 from the SMV was sent;
Whereas, due to the foregoing reasons, it is considered that the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation, indicated in Article 236-A(1)(f) of the LPAG, does not apply to this administrative sanctioning procedure; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numeral 26 of Article 12 of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011 EF;
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- To declare unfounded the appeal filed by Mr. Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret de Mola against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 010-2020-SMV/11.
Article 2.- To consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Article 3.- To transcribe this resolution to Mr. Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret de Mola, to Andino Investment Holding S.A.A. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.
Article 4.- To order the dissemination of this resolution on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV (https://www.smv.gob.pe).
Register, communicate and publish.
José Manuel Peschiera Rebagliati
Superintendent of the Securities Market
"Article 124.- Requirements of writings
Every writing submitted to any entity must contain the following:
1. Full names and surnames, domicile and National Identity Document number or foreigner's card of the administered party, and where applicable, the capacity of representative and of the person represented.
2. The concrete expression of what is requested, the factual grounds supporting it and, when possible, the legal grounds.
3. Place, date, signature or digital fingerprint, in case of not knowing how to sign or being impeded.
4. The indication of the body, entity or authority to which it is addressed, understood as such, as far as possible, the authority of the grade closest to the user, according to the hierarchy, with competence to hear and resolve it.
5. The address of the place where notifications of the procedure are to be received, when different from the real domicile stated under numeral 1. This designation of domicile takes effect from its indication and is presumed to subsist, as long as its change is not expressly communicated.
6. The list of documents and annexes accompanying it, indicated in the TUPA.
7. The identification of the file of the matter, in the case of procedures already initiated.
Article 218. Administrative appeals
(...)
218.2 The term for filing appeals is fifteen (15) peremptory days, and they must be resolved within thirty (30) days.
Article 220.- Appeal
The appeal shall be filed when the challenge is based on a different interpretation of the evidence produced or when it involves questions of pure law, and must be addressed to the same authority that issued the act being challenged so that it elevates the proceedings to the hierarchical superior.
Article 221.- Requirements of the appeal
The writing of the appeal must state the act being appealed and comply with the other requirements provided in Article 124." ↑
"Article 40.- Definition
For the purposes of this law, privileged information is understood as any information referring to an issuer, its businesses or one or several securities issued or guaranteed by them, not disclosed to the market; and whose public knowledge, by its nature, is capable of influencing the liquidity, price or quotation of the issued securities. It also includes the reserved information referred to in Article 34 of this Law and that which is held regarding the acquisition or disposal operations to be carried out by an institutional investor in the securities market, as well as that referring to public acquisition offers." Underline added. ↑
SERRA PUENTE-ARNAO, Gerardo. "The Securities Market in Peru". Second Edition. Cultural Cuzco. Lima. 2002, p. 111. ↑
"Criminal Code, Legislative Decree No. 635
Article 251-A.- Whoever obtains a benefit or avoids a detriment of an economic nature directly or through third parties, through the use of privileged information, shall be punished with imprisonment of not less than one (1) nor more than five (5) years.
(…)". Underline added. ↑
"Article 41.- Presumption of Access
Unless proven otherwise, for the purposes of this law, it is presumed that they possess privileged information:
a) The directors and managers of the issuer and of the institutional investors, as well as the members of the Investment Committee of the latter, where applicable;
(…)." ↑
Finally, the Issuer informed the market about the reserved fact on March 18, 2018, as previously stated. ↑
"Article 72.- General conditions
For the Agent to be able to provide the portfolio management service, it must previously comply with the following requirements:
(…)
b) Have Internal Conduct Rules that allow foreseeing conflicts of interest and the misuse of privileged information in the development of this service;
(…)." ↑
"Article 28.- ASSUMPTIONS IN WHICH REMEDIATION DOES NOT APPLY AS AN EXEMPTION FROM LIABILITY
(…)
They are not subject to remediation for the purposes of the provisions of Article 27(f):
(…)
b) The contravention of market abuse rules, referring to the misuse of privileged information and market manipulation.
(…)." ↑
TORRES SANCHEZ, Tessy. Every man for himself! The elusion of voluntary remediation as an exemption from punishment by the Administration. Themis Magazine No. 74, 2018, Lima, p. 97. ↑
MORI TORRES, NATALIA. Incentive to legality or impunity? About the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation. Derecho y Sociedad Magazine No. 54, 2020, Lima, p. 394. ↑
In relation to the misuse of privileged information, it must be taken into account that said conduct could even constitute a criminal offense, in accordance with Article 251-A of the Criminal Code, Legislative Decree No. 635. ↑
Comments to the General Administrative Procedure Law.- Volume II – Gaceta Jurídica –Twelfth Edition, page 513. ↑
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“in accordance with article 34 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, "LMV")”
“Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011 EF”
“Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (TUO LPAG)”
“appeal filed by Mr. Carlos Rodolfo Juan Vargas Loret de Mola (hereinafter, "Mr. Vargas") against Deputy Superintendent Resolution SMV No. 010-2020-SMV/11”
“numeral 15.3 of article 15 of the Regulation of Material Facts and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01”
“new SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added