Enforcement · SMV · 15 Nov 2012
Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is declared to have committed six very serious, six serious and three minor infractions; Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortés two very serious infractions; and Carmen Espinoza Vargas one very serious infraction. The infractions include misusing client funds, providing false information, intermediating without meeting requirements, using global accounts improperly, failing to register clients or obtain orders, and not updating guarantees. The resolution consolidates sanction proceedings and follows the prior revocation of Intercapital's operating authorization.
| Lima, November 15, 2012 |
|---|
Summary: It is declared that Intercapital S.A., in its capacity as a Stock Brokerage Firm, has incurred six very serious infractions, six serious infractions and three minor infractions. Likewise, Mr. Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortés has incurred two very serious infractions; and Mrs. Carmen Espinoza Vargas has incurred one very serious infraction.
| Administered parties | : | Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. |
|---|---|---|
| Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortés | ||
| Carmen Espinoza Vargas | ||
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2011023799 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
Whereas:
The administrative file No. 2011023799 and Reports No. 583-2012-SMV/10.3 and No. 614-2012-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance.
Considering:
In relation to File No. 2011023799
By Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal No. 250-2010-EF/94.01.3 of August 19, 2010, rectified by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal No. 285-2010-EF/94.01.3 of September 16, 2010, hereinafter, TAC Resolution, the then Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. (hereinafter, Intercapital) was sanctioned for the commission of a serious infraction and the interim individual financial statements and the annual audited financial statements submitted by it, both as of December 31, 2009, were rejected, ordering that within a maximum period of twenty (20) business days, they be submitted with the adjustment, for the amount of S/. 914,520.00, corresponding to the concept called "Others" of the Cash and Banks account of the Balance Sheet as of December 31, 2009. This, in accordance with the provisions of paragraphs 41 to 49 of IAS 8 "Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors";
By CONASEV Resolution No. 047-2011-EF/94.01.1 of June 17, 2011, the appeal filed by Intercapital against the TAC Resolution was declared unfounded;
The SMV, by Official Letter No. 3112-2011-EF/94.06.1 of July 20, 2011, granted Intercapital a period of five (5) business days to submit the Interim Financial Statements and the Audited Financial Statements, both closed as of December 31, 2009, with the adjustment required by the TAC Resolution. The aforementioned period expired on August 1, 2010;
Upon expiration of the period granted for Intercapital to make the adjustment of its financial information, by Official Letter No. 3856-2011-EF/94.06.1 dated September 20, 2011, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against said company for having failed to comply with the provisions of Article 3 of the TAC Resolution, which constitutes an infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, the Sanctions Regulations), according to which it is a serious infraction: "Not complying with what is specifically ordered by the SMV, in the exercise of its functions";
Intercapital did not present defenses as required by the aforementioned Official Letter No. 3856-2011-EF/94.06.1;
By Report No. 614-2012-SMV/10.3 of August 10, 2012, submitted by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, the charges formulated against Intercapital for non-compliance with the provisions of the TAC Resolution were analyzed, which has been submitted to the consideration of this Deputy Superintendency;
In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated in the General Administrative Procedure Law and its amendments (hereinafter LPAG), by Official Letter No. 3243-2012-SMV/10 dated August 13, 2012, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 614-2012-SMV/10.3 was made available to Intercapital for its review;
In relation to File No. 2012006893
As part of the supervision work of this Superintendency, by Official Letters No. 4414-2011-EF/94.06.1 of October 28, 2011 and No. 5038-2011-SMV/10.2 of December 19, 2011, Intercapital was informed of the initiation of inspections in order to verify compliance with the current regulations of the securities market, which were carried out between October 28 and December 12, 2011, as well as between December 19, 2011 and January 26, 2012, respectively (hereinafter, The Inspections);
As a consequence of the aforementioned inspections, a series of observations were determined regarding the activities carried out by Intercapital. For this reason, by Official Letter No. 1622-2012-SMV/10.3 of April 27, 2012 (hereinafter, Intercapital Charges Letter) an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against said company for the following charges:
a) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Destining funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted".
b) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Presenting to CONASEV, to the Exchange, to the Products Exchange, to the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, to the investor and in general to any other subject of the securities or products market, inaccurate, false or tendentious information; or disclosing such information in the market (...)".
c) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations".
d) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Providing its clients with false and inaccurate information, or allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inaccurate information to the detriment of its clients".
e) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a serious infraction: "Using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations or for purposes other than the corresponding one".
f) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a serious infraction: "Not having manuals, procedures, policies or internal control system, in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations; or not complying with their provisions or not supervising their compliance".
g) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a minor infraction: "Not registering its clients in the corresponding client registration form".
h) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a minor infraction: "Not obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible of subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene".
i) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a minor infraction: "Not Communicating Relevant Facts, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations".
j) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a serious infraction: "Denying or delaying the delivery of books, documents and other information required by the SMV during inspections or investigations, not granting the facilities that the SMV requests in the execution of the supervision and control actions it orders; as well as presenting documentation for the purpose of delaying the procedure, or in any other way obstructing the supervision and control actions".
k) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.8 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a serious infraction: "Not carrying out, with the periodicity established in the regulations, the calculation of liquidity and solvency indicators, as well as the limit per activity".
l) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations".
m) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a serious infraction: "presenting to SMV, to the Exchange, to the Products Exchange, to the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism, to the investor and in general to any other Participant of the securities or products market, financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru, the technical pronouncements issued by the country's accounting profession, accounting standards established by the supervision and control bodies and the norms contained in the Financial Information Regulations".
n) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Not constituting guarantees, not replacing them or not updating them, in the form, amount, term and conditions that the regulations establish for each case";
a) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Destining funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted".
b) Having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Presenting to CONASEV, to the Exchange, to the Products Exchange, to the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, to the investor and in general to any other subject of the securities or products market, inaccurate, false or tendentious information; or disclosing such information in the market (...)";
Similarly, in view of the facts and indications of possible infractions detected in the aforementioned inspection carried out on Intercapital, by Official Letter No. 2179-2012-SMV/10.3 of June 4, 2012, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against Mrs. Carmen Espinoza Vargas (hereinafter, Mrs. Espinoza) in her capacity as Director and Operations Manager of Intercapital, for having incurred the commission of the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Destining funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
By brief of July 16, 2012, Mrs. Espinoza presented her defenses; on the contrary, neither Intercapital nor Mr. Higueras presented the requested defenses;
The charges formulated against Intercapital, Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza as well as the defenses presented by the latter, have been evaluated in Report No. 583-2012-EF/94.06.1 of August 2, 2012, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, subsection 1, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title, general principle, and in Article 230, subsection 2, special principle, of the LPAG, by Official Letters Nos. 3154-2012-SMV/10, 3155-2012-SMV/10 and 3157-2012-SMV/10 dated August 8, 2012, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 583-2012-EF/94.06.1 was made available to Intercapital, Mrs. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras, respectively, for their review; likewise, by Official Letters No. 3528-2012-SMV/10 and No. 3596-2012-SMV/10, Mrs. Espinoza was granted the use of the word requested, which she exercised on September 6, 2012;
On the other hand, by Resolution No. 010-2012-SMV/10 of November 14, 2012, it was resolved to accumulate the administrative sanctioning procedures initiated against Intercapital contained in files Nos. 201123799 and 2012006893;
For its part, in exercise of the attribution contained in numeral 14 of Article 3 of the Concorded Single Text of the Organic Law of the SMV, Legislative Decree No. 26126 and its amendments, by Superintendent Resolution No. 090-2012-SMV/02 of July 20, 2012, the operating authorization of Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. was revoked;
a) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 195, literal a), of the Securities Market Law, approved by Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV), for destining funds or securities received from its principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, because it would have destined the funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities on behalf of clients for the purchase of shares issued by Golden Dawn Minerals Inc. (hereinafter, Golden Shares) in favor of persons other than their real owners.
b) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of numeral 66.2 of Article 66 of the Intermediation Agents Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, RAI) and paragraphs CC4 and CC12 of the Conceptual Framework for Financial Information issued by the International Accounting Standard Board in September 2010[1] and in force as of January 1, 2011 (hereinafter, Conceptual Framework), for not complying with sending to the SMV transparent accounting and financial information which must comply with the requirements of veracity, sufficiency and timeliness thereof.
c) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of subsection 37.4.1, numeral 37.4, of Article 37 of the Rai, for not complying with signing with each of its clients the respective contract for the intermediation of securities or financial instruments abroad.
d) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of subsection 66.2.1, numeral 66.2 of Article 66 of the Rai, for not complying with sending to its clients transparent information and that it complies with the requirements of veracity, sufficiency and timeliness thereof.
e) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of subsection 37.4.2, numeral 37.4, of Article 37 and Article 90 of the Rai, for using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations.
f) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of subsection 37.4.3, numeral 37.4 of Article 37 of the Rai, for not having a specific section in its manual that includes the minimum content requirements regarding the agent's participation in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad.
g) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 75 of the Rai, for not registering its clients who bought Golden Shares in the corresponding client registration form.
h) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 175 of the LMV and numeral 37.5 of Article 37 of the Rai, for not obtaining orders from its clients, who ordered the purchase of Golden Shares.
i) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Articles 62 and 98 and numeral 24 of Annex 9 of the Rai, for not communicating the relevant facts referred to informing extemporaneously the resignation of its Internal Control Officer and for not communicating the celebration and resolution of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties.
j) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 196 of the LMV and Article 71 of the Rai, for not allowing the inspection of its books, records and operations by the SMV and for carrying out actions that hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of the SMV.
k) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 172 of the LMV and Articles 116, numeral 116.6 and 117 of the Rai, for not calculating the limit of positions in foreign accounts and not informing the SMV thereof.
l) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 36, numeral 36.1 of the Rai, for not obtaining a declaration from its clients purchasing financial instruments in which they state they are aware of the type of security they are acquiring, as well as its nature, characteristics and payment risk, among others.
m) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 2 of the Financial Information Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Financial Information Regulations), for presenting to the SMV financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru.
n) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 136 of the LMV and 140 of the Rai, for not complying with updating the amount of the guarantee within the period established by the SMV.
o) Whether Intercapital incurred or not in infraction for non-compliance with the provisions of Article 3 of the RTA Resolution.
p) Whether Mr. Higueras incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 195, literal a), of the LMV, for destining funds or securities received from its principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, because it would have destined the funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities on behalf of clients for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of persons other than their real owners.
q) Whether Mr. Higueras incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of numeral 66.2 of Article 66 of the Rai and paragraphs CC4 and CC12 of the Conceptual Framework, for not complying with sending to the SMV transparent accounting and financial information which must comply with the requirements of veracity, sufficiency and timeliness thereof.
r) Whether Mrs. Espinoza incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Article 195, literal a), of the LMV, for destining funds or securities received from its principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, because it would have destined the funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities on behalf of clients for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of persons other than their real owners.
s) Whether it corresponds or not to sanction Intercapital, Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza for the aforementioned;
Regarding Intercapital
1. Destining client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
Of the regulations
Article 195 of the LMV establishes the list of prohibitions that stock brokerage firms are impeded from carrying out within the framework of their intermediation activities. In this regard, subsection a) of said article includes within said prohibitions the destining of funds or securities received from its principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
The non-observance of the prohibition to destine funds or securities to different purposes is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1, of the Sanctions Regulations), according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Destining funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
Of the defenses and allegations of the Administered Party
Regarding the Infraction detected
A. In relation to the private placement process of Golden Shares carried out in the month of September 2010.
This is the first private placement process of shares carried out by Golden Dawn in which Intercapital intervened on behalf of its clients, as observed in the documentation obtained in The Inspections;
According to the documentation related to said process, Intercapital received from five (05) clients, between August 27 and September 9, 2010, a total of US$ 263,000.00 for the purpose of purchasing Golden Shares in the private placement process of these securities carried out in September 2010. However, said amount was used in its entirety for the purchase of said shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Indeed, the total quantity of Golden Shares that Intercapital reported as subscribed in favor of those five (05) clients through documents called subscription confirmation, purchase confirmation or acquisition confirmation (hereinafter Confirmation Letters), coincides with the total quantity of shares that were subscribed in favor of Mr. Higueras, Managing Director of Intercapital, according to instructions given by letter of September 13, 2010 signed by Mrs. Espinoza, Operations Manager of Intercapital, addressed to the Executive Director of Golden Dawn; this despite the fact that through the Confirmation Letters it was expressly stated to said clients that the funds they delivered to Intercapital were used according to the instructions given by them, inducing them into error by making them think that the indicated funds materialized in the purchase of said shares in their favor;
For this purpose, through letters signed by Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, Banco Scotiabank Peru (hereinafter Scotiabank) was ordered to make money transfers (corresponding to the deposits made by the five (05) mentioned clients) to Golden Dawn's account at the Bank of Montreal of Canada from Intercapital's administrative current account at Scotiabank, current account Dollars No. 000-3047787 (hereinafter Administrative Account). Said amounts came mostly from transfers from Intercapital's operating account at Scotiabank, current account No. 001-0121075 (hereinafter Operating Account) and other credits made directly by clients to the Administrative Account;
On the other hand, through receipts of income of money to Intercapital (hereinafter Income Receipts), it is evidenced that the contributions received from its clients for the purpose of acquiring the Golden shares were recorded by Intercapital as if they were a shareholder loan made to said company by Mr. Higueras. The figures recorded by Intercapital match the information contained in the Confirmation Letters in which the amounts received by Intercapital from the clients were ratified to them.
According to what was stated by the treasurer of Intercapital in the "Record of situation derived from the review of the documentary collection constituted by the activities and functions performed by Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa SA. and the results of the interviews with its personnel" of January 12, 2012 (hereinafter Record of Documentary Collection), the indicated operations were carried out by express instruction of Mr. Higueras and that the clients' credits were made both in operating and administrative accounts. These credits were transferred to the administrative account to finally, from said administrative account, all remittances abroad were made for the purpose of buying the Golden shares, which were registered in the name of Mr. Higueras. The information of client names and amounts credited in Intercapital's accounts has been verified with the Income Receipts that have the same or approximate dates as those shown in the Table "Shipments to GDM" collected in the Inspections[2];
The foregoing is corroborated by the fact that the total quantity of Golden Shares that Intercapital reported as subscribed in favor of those five (05) clients and that coincides with the total quantity of shares that have been subscribed in favor of Mr. Higueras, appeared, at the end of the months of December 2010 and January 2011, in custody in an account with number 1B5-SZ0A in the name of Mr. Higueras at the foreign intermediary Raymond James Ltd. (hereinafter, Raymond James), according to the account statements of said periods, that is, this confirms that the Golden Shares were registered in an account in the name of Mr. Higueras and not in the name of Intercapital's clients;
The foregoing evidences the irregular action by Intercapital in having disposed of the funds delivered by its clients and destined them for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of a person other than such clients;
B. Regarding the private placement process of Golden Shares, carried out in April 2011.
This is the second private placement process carried out by Golden Dawn in which Intercapital intervened on behalf of its clients, as observed in the documentation obtained in the Inspections;
According to said documentation, the money that Intercapital received from ten (10) clients for a total of US$ 474,368.00, between February 18 and April 4, 2011, for the purpose of buying Golden Shares in the private placement process of these shares carried out in April 2011, was used mainly for the purchase of the majority of the 5,007,682 Golden Shares in favor of two (02) clients other than the ten (10) mentioned. One of these two clients did not contribute money for these purchase operations (despite this, 3,755,762 Golden Shares were subscribed in his name) and the second contributed an insufficient amount to buy the shares that according to Intercapital he acquired (1,251,920 Golden Shares were registered in his name). For these acquisitions, Intercapital made money transfers in favor of Golden Dawn for a total of US$ 439,850.00, between February 22 and April 4, 2011, through Scotiabank;
The foregoing is documented in: i) Confirmation Letters through which Intercapital communicated to each of the ten (10) clients that it received from them a determined amount with which a quantity of Golden Shares was acquired, ii) Letter of April 5, 2011 signed by Mrs. Espinoza and addressed to the Financial Director of Golden Dawn, through which Intercapital attached the share subscription forms in favor of the two (02) mentioned clients, iii) Letters from February 22 to April 4, 2011, signed by Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, through which Intercapital ordered Scotiabank to make money transfers to Golden Dawn's account at the Bank of Montreal of Canada charged to the administrative account, in addition to operation notes and bank account statements for a total amount similar to the subscription amounts of the letter of April 5, 2011, and iv) Income Receipts that support the credits of the ten (10) clients, which are reflected in the respective bank account statements of Intercapital and have the same or approximate dates as the money transfers from Intercapital to Golden Dawn
Thus, from the proximity of the dates of income of money in the operating and administrative bank accounts of Intercapital, verified with the income receipts as well as with the Confirmation Letters and other documents, with the dates of outflow of money from Intercapital to Golden Dawn that was used for the acquisition of shares in favor of two (02) clients, it is evidenced that Intercapital improperly used the funds of another ten (10) of its clients, which had as purpose the acquisition of Golden Shares, having been destined for the purchase of shares in favor of two (02) others different from them;
The foregoing accredits the particular behavior that Intercapital had regarding the management of the funds delivered by ten (10) of its clients, who entrusted such money to acquire Golden Shares, however, such investment decision was not executed by Intercapital, which demonstrates the non-compliance with the provisions of the securities market regulations, so much so that such funds served to acquire Golden Shares for two (02) different clients, instead of being in favor of the referred ten (10) clients;
C. Regarding the purchases of Golden Shares in the secondary market through Raymond James
According to the documentation obtained in the Inspections, the funds that Intercapital received from seven (07) clients between January 6 and May 6, 2011, for the purpose of buying Golden Shares in the secondary market, was used in its entirety to credit an account at Raymond James in the name of Mr. Higueras for the realization of share purchases in favor of the latter;
It should be noted that the foregoing in the preceding recital is supported by the following:
The amount of money that Intercapital received from seven (07) clients for an amount of US$ 157,688.53, between January 6 and May 6, 2011, for the purpose of buying Golden Shares, was destined mostly to the money transfers, between January 7 and May 10, 2011, that Intercapital made to Raymond James in favor of Mr. Higueras's account for a total of US$ 146,195.00 for the purchase of Golden Shares.
The purchases of Golden Shares of the month of January 2011 that are recorded in an account statement of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James coincide with the purchases that Intercapital confirmed to its clients as acquisition for them;
39. For the first fact, it was observed that between January 6 and May 6, 2011, through Confirmation Letters, other letters indicating securities portfolios at a determined date, also signed by Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director, and emails, Intercapital indicated to each of the seven (07) clients that it received a determined amount of money, with which a quantity of Golden Shares was acquired. The total amount of money that the amounts indicated in these documents sum, verified and completed with the Table of Income and Outflows of Funds prepared with the Treasurer of Intercapital, amounts to US$ 157,688.53 and the total quantity of Golden Shares amounts to 934,088 shares;
40. Likewise, letters were issued between January 7 and May 10, 2011, signed by Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, by means of which Intercapital ordered Scotiabank to make money transfers to the Raymond James account at the Royal Bank of Canada from the administrative account. The beneficiary of the credit at Raymond James is Mr. Higueras with his account number 1B5 SZ0B 0;
41. On the other hand, the clients' credits are supported by income receipts that have been verified in the respective bank account statements of Intercapital and have the same or approximate dates as the money transfers from Intercapital to Raymond James;
42. Therefore, the proximity of the dates of income of money to the operating and administrative bank accounts of Intercapital, verified with the income receipts and with the Confirmation Letters, with the dates of outflow of money from Intercapital to Raymond James indicate that Intercapital used the money of seven (07) clients, which had as purpose the acquisition of Golden Shares, to transfer money to Mr. Higueras's account at Raymond James, for the purpose of acquiring shares for this client;
43. The foregoing reflects the infringing conduct of Intercapital that consisted in disposing of the funds of its clients delivered for the purchase of certain securities, however, this did not occur in the facts and is accredited with the accounting and banking records of said brokerage firm, which were destined for different purposes such as the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
44. On the other hand, in the documents collected in the Inspections, the account statement of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James was found, in which purchase and sale movements of securities of January 2011 are recorded. The information recorded in this account shows equal quantities and approximate dates to those corresponding to the purchases made by some clients of Intercapital, as indicated by this intermediary;
45. The correspondence between the shares that Intercapital reported to have acquired for certain clients in the month of January 2011, with the records of purchases made that appear in the account of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James, indicate that the money that the clients deposited in Intercapital for the purpose of acquiring Golden Shares were destined by the intermediary to buy shares in the name of Mr. Higueras;
46. In this sense, the facts exposed, the information and documentation indicated above support the inadequate behavior on the part of Intercapital in the treatment and management of the funds delivered by its clients for the purchase of Golden Shares, which reflects the non-compliance with its main function as intermediary and the prohibition established in literal a) of article 195 of the LMV, that is, the realization of operations in the Securities Market and the responsibility in the due care of the funds delivered by its clients for such purpose;
2. Presenting false and inexact information to the Superintendency of the Securities Market
From the regulations
Article 66, numeral 66.2, of the RAI establishes that all information that the intermediation agent provides or issues must be transparent, for which it must comply with the requirements of veracity, sufficiency and timeliness of the same. Likewise, subsection 66.2.1 of said numeral 6.2 considers that information is true when it reflects in a reliable manner the reality or essence of the facts, transactions or manifestations that it is intended to express or represent through it. This requirement does not admit the distortion or simulation of reality or of the essence of the facts;
On the other hand, the Conceptual Framework in its paragraphs CC4 and CC12 states that financial information is useful if it is relevant, and faithfully represents what it intends to represent, that is, it must not only represent the relevant phenomena, but must also faithfully represent the phenomena it intends to represent. To be a perfect faithful representation, a description must have three characteristics: Complete, neutral and free from error (...). Likewise, the usefulness of financial information is improved if it is comparable, verifiable, timely and understandable;
The non-observance of the obligation to present financial information that meets the requirements demanded by the regulations is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex I, numeral 1 subsection 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a very serious nature: "Presenting to CONASEV, to the Exchange, to the Products Exchange, to the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, to the investor and in general to any other subject of the securities or products market, inexact, false or tendentious information; or divulge said information in the market (...)";
From the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
From the Accounting Records used to reverse the equity deficit (Purchase of Golden Shares) that supported Intercapital's financial information as of September 30, 2011.
On November 8, 2011, Intercapital presented a new reformulated version of the financial information closed as of September 30, 2011 that it originally presented on October 31, 2011. Based on the information contained in the Balance Sheet, Intercapital attempted to support that it would have reversed the equity deficit incurred, exceeding—in appearance—the amount of the minimum capital required by the regulations for the 2011 fiscal year;
In order to verify the support of the reversal of the aforementioned equity deficit, an inspection visit to Intercapital was ordered, issuing as a result of this, the document called "Verification Record of November 14, 2011" (hereinafter, Verification Record);
In the referred Verification Record it was evidenced that from the comparison of the Balance Sheet closed as of September 30, 2011, presented on October 31, 2011 with respect to the version presented on November 8, 2011, there are differences in the items Negotiable Securities (S/. 981,912) and Accumulated Results (S/. 981,912). Likewise, it was verified that as of September 30 Intercapital entered into its records two journal entries signed with numbers 09 and 10, in a handwritten document; in which it is observed, first an increase in the balance of the Cash and Banks item and a decrease in the negative Accumulated Results and secondly a decrease in the Cash and Banks item and an increase in the Negotiable Securities item;
As support for the modifications made in Intercapital's financial statements, Intercapital's accountant delivered the corresponding documentation and information that would support them and that supposedly had allowed the reversal of the equity deficit. In this way, an attempt was made to demonstrate how it would have reversed the equity deficit situation, through the increase in the balance of the account "593 Accumulated Results" and generating greater availability of funds, thus increasing the balance of the account "108 Other deposits";
For this purpose, Entry D009 was recorded, which includes a comment as a gloss in the record which would be related to Office No. 3846-2011-EF/94.06.1 (by virtue of which Intercapital was informed of the equity deficit and was required to reverse it), which reflects that the movements recorded in said entry were made with the intention of reversing the equity deficit in which Intercapital had incurred;
Additionally, the accountant presented the accounting record corresponding to Entry D0010 that reveals the supposed acquisition in the name of Intercapital of 5,007,682 (five million seven thousand six hundred eighty-two) Golden Shares on August 9, 2011, at a price of US$ 0.07 (07/100 United States Dollars) per share;
Likewise, an increase in the account "31413 Negotiable Securities" and a decrease in the balance of the account "108 Other deposits" is observed, with a comment indicating "Acquisition of Golden Minerals INC Shares". It should be noted that through the referred entry, Intercapital sought to support that with the funds supposedly available in the account "108 Other deposits" the cited Golden Shares would have been acquired;
In this regard, when Intercapital's accountant was consulted about the support of the indicated records, she stated (as recorded in Annex C of the "Record of Documentary Collection") that she has not had access to the documents that support these records, especially the acquisition of Golden Shares and mentioned that said documents would be delivered by Mr. Higueras;
As a consequence of what was stated by the accountant, in the Verification Record it was recorded that as of said date, that is, as of November 14, 2011, Intercapital did not have the information required to support the indicated records;
Subsequently, on November 16, 2011 during the inspection initiated through Office No. 4414-2011-EF/94.06.1, Intercapital presented a letter dated November 14, 2011, signed by the Chief Financial Officer of Golden Dawn addressed to Intercapital in which it informed regarding the placement of 5,007,682 (five million seven thousand six hundred eighty-two) shares issued by said company in April 2011, at a price of CAD 0.085 (85/100 Canadian Dollars) per share. In this regard, it should be noted that from the communication presented by Intercapital, it is not established whether the referred shares were placed in favor of Intercapital itself (as holder) or on behalf of some principal;
From the review of the content of the basic financial information as of September 30, 2011 presented by Intercapital, it is concluded that said information does not reflect the reality of the economic facts such as the greater availability in the balances of the accounts "108 Other deposits", "31 Negotiable Securities" and "593 Accumulated Results".
Likewise, it should be noted that it has been accredited that the accounting records provided by Intercapital on November 8, 2011 (referring to demonstrating the greater availability of funds and the acquisition of 5,007,682 Golden Shares), do not have the documentation that allows justifying or supporting said records, as has been expressly declared by Mr. Higueras in the Verification Record;
Thus, the financial information presented by Intercapital would not have complied with the characteristic of veracity and accuracy, so it is not reliable;
Similarly, the economic facts reflected in Intercapital's accounting records (relating to the greater availability of funds and the acquisition of negotiable securities) do not comply with the qualitative characteristics of the Conceptual Framework referred to above since they do not faithfully represent the reality of the same;
On the other hand, the intentionality related to the falsity of the financial information provided by Intercapital to the SMV would also be accredited through the statements of the representatives of said entity (in particular, in the statement of the treasurer of Intercapital, as recorded in Annex D of the Record of Documentary Collection), from which it can validly be maintained that the form of acquisition of the Golden Shares and the registration of the same were part of a constant and systematic operation carried out by Intercapital;
Registration of the funds used for acquisition of Golden Shares in the account "463 - Shareholder Loan".
As a result of the Inspections, sufficient elements were obtained that prove that the acquisition of the Golden Shares by Intercapital was made with funds from the clients of said intermediary, however, the income of money that was used for said transactions—as will be explained in the following recitals—were recorded under Account "463 – Shareholder Loan", that is, as if said funds corresponded effectively to loans made by the shareholders of Intercapital to this latter company. Likewise, the remittances sent abroad were recorded as repayment of said loans to the shareholders;
The operations of Intercapital in the purchase of Golden Shares and the respective recording of money movements both in Intercapital's operational dollar current account at Banco de Crédito del Perú (No. 193-1423576-1-64), in the operational account and in the administrative account, are set out below:
A) Client deposits in current accounts and accounting record:
As a result of the inspection carried out, the existence of twenty-nine (29) deposits in the aforementioned operational accounts and nineteen (19) deposits in the administrative account was determined, in the period between January 6, 2011 and May 6, 2011 for the purchase of Golden Shares through Raymond James and directly from the issuing company.
As proof of the money received and deposited in the aforementioned accounts, Intercapital issued the respective deposit vouchers in favor of its clients.
The amounts paid deposited in the aforementioned current accounts by the clients were recorded in the account "463 - Shareholder Loans" as an increase in loans payable to the shareholder.
B) Remittances abroad for the purchase of Golden Shares and accounting record
The existence of seventeen (17) letters containing transfer orders abroad, addressed to Scotiabank for the withdrawal of amounts from the administrative account, has been determined. Ten (10) of said transfers were directed to Raymond James' accounts at the Royal Bank of Canada and seven (07) to the Golden Dawn account.
The amounts withdrawn and remitted abroad were recorded in the account "463 - Shareholder Loans" as if it were a repayment of loans previously received from shareholders.
The letters mentioned in the previous section were found attached to the "accounting vouchers" for the recording of the outflows of funds that supposedly would have come from loans granted by shareholders, that is, under the concept of "dev. Ptmo acc. Envío RJAMES".
In this sense, the documentation presented by Intercapital in the Inspections does not allow explaining or supporting the operations that prove that the amounts deposited in the current accounts actually corresponded to "shareholder loan".
Likewise, from the referred documentation it is evident that the repayments of the supposed "Shareholder Loan" were not transferred to any account owned by Intercapital's shareholders, but were transferred abroad without documentation that effectively proves the supposed loan and its repayment. On the contrary, from the information reviewed as a result of the Inspections, it was corroborated that there were documents that proved the deposit of money by clients; the subsequent purchase of the Golden Shares with said funds for clients other than those who deposited them; and finally, the confirmation of acquisition of said shares supposedly in favor of the clients, as explained in the following paragraphs.
In the inspection carried out on Intercapital, pre-printed and numbered forms with the Intercapital logo corresponding to the so-called Income Receipts were found, by virtue of which the receipt of funds for the concept of "Shareholder Loan" or "Share Loans" was recorded.
As mentioned above, as a product of the Inspections, monthly accounting files called "Cash - Banks" were found, in which ten (10) letters issued by Intercapital and addressed to Scotiabank were found so that said banking entity transfers funds (which had been credited by its clients) from Intercapital's administrative account to Raymond James' bank account at the Royal Bank of Canada.
The amounts and dates appearing in the aforementioned Income Receipts coincide with the information incorporated in the Golden Shares Confirmation Letters. Likewise, the names and surnames of the persons who received the referred Confirmation Letters also coincide with the data recorded on the back of each of the Income Receipts, which allows relating the income of said funds to Intercapital with the transfer of said funds to the Raymond James account.
On the other hand, it was corroborated that there were also seven (7) communications of direct transfer of the funds credited in the administrative account to the bank account at Bank of Montreal owned by Golden Dawn.
69. Thus, the information indicated in the preceding recitals allows concluding that the money that entered Intercapital's accounts and that was used for the purchase of Golden Shares did not correspond to "shareholder loans" but to funds of the clients themselves for the acquisition of said shares. That being so, Intercapital presented false and inexact information to the SMV by having made an improper accounting record of said funds in the account "463 - Shareholder Loan", despite knowing (as has been reflected in the documentation mentioned in the previous recital) what was the true origin and destination of the same;
70. Another element that allows verifying the intentionality in the improper accounting record of the income and outflows of money for the acquisition of the Golden Shares is contained in the contradictory statements of Intercapital's treasurer and Intercapital's accountant, as indicated in the following recitals;
71. As indicated by the accountant in Annex C of the Document Collection Record, the credits in account 463 corresponding to Shareholder Loan represent the income of funds for the concept of shareholder loan and that the debits referring to the same account represent the withdrawal of funds for the concept of loan repayment;
72. Regarding the movements recorded in the account "463 - Shareholder Loan", the accountant in numeral 1.3 of the referred Annex C states that the charges and credits in said account are related to shareholder loans, and adds that she does not analyze the nature of said records, she only limits herself to recording and if there were any doubt, she consults with the treasurer;
73. In contradiction with the statements made by the accountant, the treasurer in numeral 1.2 of Annex D of the Document Collection Record stated regarding the operations of the Golden Shares purchase transactions, that it began when Mr. Higueras notified her about the deposits made by the clients contacted by him for the purchase of Golden Shares abroad and that upon confirming the credits in the bank accounts, the administrative documentation required for such purpose was issued, which was then transferred to the accounting area for review;
74. Therefore, it has been verified that the funds deposited for the acquisition operations of Golden Shares carried out in the foreign market between the months of August and September 2010 and between January and May 2011, were recorded in the account "463 Shareholder Loans", despite the existence of sufficient documentation proving that said funds were delivered by the company's clients for the acquisition of said securities in the name of the referred clients;
75. In this sense, Intercapital did not reflect in its financial information the reality of the facts linked to the operations with Golden Shares, nor would it meet the characteristics of veracity and faithful representation in the accounting record of such facts. On the contrary, Intercapital recorded the income of said funds as supposed "shareholder loans", undermining the characteristics of reliability and transparency of the interim financial information of the indicated periods, presented both to the SMV and to the market in general;
76. What is indicated in the preceding recitals is corroborated when reviewing Intercapital's financial information corresponding to the periods of the analyzed operations, in which it is verified that even though the General Ledger of account "463 shareholder loans" has credit balances, said information is not reflected in the Balance Sheet or in the respective Notes to the Financial Statements;
77. Finally, Intercapital's behavior both in the form of reflecting the record of the operations abroad that it has intermediated and the fact of not having informed the SMV of said operations, denotes intentionality in concealing them and in the consequent presentation of untrue financial information, which constituted the non-observance of the provisions contained in article 66 of the RAI and paragraphs CC4 and CC12 of the Conceptual Framework;
3. Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations
Of the regulations
Article 37 of the RAI states that for the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with several conditions;
Likewise, numeral 37.4 of the cited article 37 states that if the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 of the referred article is in its own name (but on behalf of the client), the Agent must additionally comply, among other requirements, with signing a contract with each of the clients who wish it to intermediate this type of operations, in accordance with the provisions of article 40 of the RAI;
The non-observance of intermediating securities or financial instruments in the foreign market on behalf of its clients and where the intervention of the intermediary is in its own name, and without signing a contract with each of its clients who wish it to intermediate this type of operations, is punishable in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a very serious nature: "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations";
Of the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
82. According to the information obtained by the SMV in the Inspections, it has been evidenced that Intercapital participated, on behalf of its clients, in the intermediation of operations in the foreign market through the purchase of shares, mainly of Golden Dawn, not having for this purpose contracts signed for such purpose;
83. Indeed, the Confirmation Letters —letters indicating securities portfolio and emails mentioned in numeral 3.1 of this resolution— prove that Intercapital received funds from its clients for the realization of purchase operations of Golden Shares in the foreign market;
84. According to what is indicated in the previous paragraph, the referred persons, upon requesting Intercapital's services for the intermediation of such securities, acquired the status of clients of said intermediary in attention to the fact that only stock brokerage companies authorized by the SMV can provide this intermediation service;
85. In this order of ideas, it has been proven that Intercapital should have signed with each of the aforementioned clients, the respective contract as established in numeral 37.4.1, of subsection 37.4 of article 37 of the RAI and in this way establish the contractual conditions to which both parties were to submit, that is, both the clients and the agent company itself, in the intermediation of operations in the foreign market through the purchase of shares, issued mainly by the Canadian mining company Golden Dawn;
86. Therefore, it is concluded that Intercapital infringed the securities market regulations by not observing the provisions of the cited numeral 37.4.1, of subsection 37.4 of article 37 of the RAI;
4. Providing its clients with false and inexact information
Of the regulations
Article 66, numeral 66.2, of the RAI establishes that all information provided or issued by the intermediation agent must be transparent, for which the requirements of veracity, sufficiency and timeliness must be met.
Likewise, subsection 66.2.1 of said numeral 6.2 considers that information is true when it faithfully reflects the reality or essence of the facts, transactions or manifestations that it is intended to express or represent through it. This requirement does not admit distortion or simulation of reality or the essence of the facts;
The non-observance of providing information to its clients that is not transparent or is false or inexact, is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a very serious nature: "Providing its clients with false and inexact information, or allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inexact information to the detriment of its clients";
Of the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
91. Regarding Intercapital's participation in the intermediation for the purchase of Golden Shares and according to the information obtained in the Document Collection Record, it was observed that said former stock brokerage company provided false and inexact information to its clients;
92. Indeed, this is seen in the Confirmation Letters —letters indicating securities portfolio and emails mentioned in numeral 3.1 of this resolution— that have proof of receipt by the client, through which Intercapital confirmed the acquisition of Golden Shares to a group of twelve (12) clients. These communications confirm the existing commercial relationship between these persons, who acquire the status of clients, and Intercapital;
93. Likewise, according to what is described in numeral 3.1 of this resolution, it has been observed that Intercapital received money from its clients for the purchase of the Golden Shares; however, the referred funds were applied for the purchase of such shares in the name of persons other than those who delivered the funds, while the clients who delivered the money did not appear as holders of the purchased shares;
94. Indeed, and as explained in numeral 3.1 of this resolution, the Golden Shares acquired in a private placement carried out by Golden Dawn in September 2010, were registered in the name of Mr. Higueras; in another private placement carried out by Golden Dawn in April 2011, in the name of two (02) clients other than those to whom the acquisition of shares was confirmed; and in the name of Mr. Higueras, in purchases made in the secondary market through Raymond James;
95. Therefore, it is observed that the information provided by Intercapital to its clients in the Confirmation Letters —letters indicating securities portfolio and emails mentioned in numeral 3.1 of this resolution that have proof of receipt by the client— qualifies as information that does not conform to reality in the purchase of the Golden Shares, because it reflects an acquisition of securities in the name of persons who would not be those who were really recorded as holders of said shares;
96. What is indicated then proves the non-observance by Intercapital of the duty to send or provide its clients with information that, at all times, must faithfully reflect the reality of the transactions and operations that they order to the agent company, in particular, the veracity and sufficiency of such information;
5. Using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations or for purposes other than the corresponding one
Of the regulations
Article 37 of the RAI states that for the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with several conditions;
Likewise, numeral 37.4 of the cited article 37 states that if the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 of the referred article is in its own name (but on behalf of the client), this company must additionally comply, among other requirements, with having control records of global accounts as established in the RAI;
Likewise, article 90 of the RAI establishes that the Agent for each Global Account in its name, to which numeral 37.4.2 of article 37 of the RAI refers, must implement control records that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts. Likewise, the aforementioned records must allow the immediate generation of the following information: (i) Movements of securities and financial instruments in the global account; (ii) Movements of funds related to the global account; (iii) Balances of financial instruments and funds consolidated and at the level of the Agent's clients; and, (iv) Consolidated record of financial instruments and funds related to global accounts;
Similarly, the cited article 90 of the RAI specifies that the aforementioned records must contain information updated on the day and be supported by the confirmations and account statements received from the foreign intermediary that executes the operations corresponding to each account, and if applicable, in the information provided by the entity in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, according to the operability of each account. Likewise, they must be consistent with the policies that the Agent must issue for this type of operations;
The non-observance of intermediating securities or financial instruments in the foreign market on behalf of its clients without having the respective Global Account, is sanctioned with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 1.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a serious nature: "Using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations or for purposes other than the corresponding one";
Of the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
103. As established in the RAI, a stock brokerage company that participates in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments abroad must additionally comply, among other requirements, with having control records of global accounts;
104. In the case of the acquisition of Golden Shares, it has been proven that Intercapital used foreign intermediaries such as Lek Securities Corporation (hereinafter Lek Securities) and Raymond James, for the acquisition of said shares supposedly in favor of its clients, in particular, the clients mentioned in numeral 3.1 of this resolution, which evidences that Intercapital used Global Accounts for such operations;
105. Likewise, it has been evidenced that in the acquisition of such shares, Intercapital did not observe the minimum conditions related to the use of global accounts, such as identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts; that such records allow it the immediate generation of information referring to movements of securities and financial instruments and funds, among others;
106. Likewise, it is opportune to mention that these records are of vital importance since they must contain information updated on the day and be supported by the confirmations and account statements received from the foreign intermediary that executes the operations corresponding to each account and, if applicable, in the information provided by the entity in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, according to the operability of each account.
107. In conclusion, the aforementioned supports that Intercapital did not have a control record of its global accounts regarding the operations it carried out in the foreign market with the Golden Shares, which constitutes the breach of subsection 37.4.2 of numeral 37.4 of article 37 as well as article 90 of the RAI.
6. Not having manuals, procedures, policies in accordance with the provisions of the regulations
Of the regulations
Article 37 of the RAI states that for the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with several conditions;
Likewise, numeral 37.4 of the cited article 37 states that if the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 of the referred article is in its own name (but on behalf of the client), the Agent must additionally comply, among other requirements, with having in its Manual of Operating Procedures and Internal Control System of the Agent, a specific separate section describing the procedures, mechanisms and control activities corresponding to this type of operations;
The non-compliance referred to as not having a specific section describing the procedures, mechanisms and control activities corresponding to the execution of operations abroad, as established in numeral 37.4.3 of numeral 37.4 of article 37 of the RAI, is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a serious nature: "Not having manuals, procedures, policies or internal control system, in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations; or not complying with their provisions or not supervising their compliance";
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
112. As part of the supervision tasks, during the Inspections, Intercapital was requested through Memorandum No. 001-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL SAB of November 4, 2011, a copy of the Manuals issued by said intermediary, among which is the Operating Procedures Manual;
113. The aforementioned Procedures Manual was delivered by Intercapital as shown in the Inspection Completion Record of December 12, 2011;
114. After reviewing said Operating Procedures Manual, approved in a Board session on April 2, 2008, it was observed that it does not have a specific section that includes the minimum content requirements regarding the agent's participation in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad;
115. The observation indicated in the preceding recital ratifies the non-compliance by Intercapital with the duty to have a specific section in its Operating Procedures Manual referring to operations that the agent carries out abroad, as required by the aforementioned article 37 of the RAI;
7. Not registering its clients in the corresponding registration card
On the regulations
Article 75 of the RAI states that for each client the Agent will obtain or determine the information detailed below, in order to record it in its respective registration card;
Likewise, article 72 of said Regulation establishes that the Agent must have certain records, documentation, reports and books, among which is the Client Registration Card;
The non-compliance for not registering its clients in the respective client cards, as required by the aforementioned article 75 of the RAI, in accordance with article 72 of said normative body, is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.4 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a minor nature: "Not registering its clients in the corresponding client registration card;"
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
120. According to the information gathered in the Inspections and as explained in numeral 3.1 of this Resolution, it was determined that the persons who delivered funds to Intercapital for the purchase of Golden Shares had a commercial relationship with said stock brokerage firm, thereby acquiring the status of clients;
121. As indicated in this resolution, since August 2010 Intercapital has been receiving money from various persons through deposits in both the operating accounts and the administrative accounts of the brokerage firm and, subsequently, with said funds Golden Shares were supposedly purchased, which was informed to said clients through Confirmation Letters, letters indicating a securities portfolio and emails;
122. In this sense, having described the collection of resources by Intercapital for the acquisition of Golden Shares, the commercial relationship of the latter with respect to the aforementioned persons has been accredited, who acquired the status of clients of Intercapital, thus generating the mandatory obligation to issue the corresponding client cards for each of them; however, this did not occur, resulting in the non-compliance with articles 72 and 75 of the RAI by said intermediary;
8. Not obtaining orders from its clients
On the regulations
Article 175 of the LMV, in force at the date of the events, states that intermediation agents are obliged to obtain written orders from their principals, except for other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that the SMV establishes through general provisions. Likewise, they must deliver a policy that accredits the operations carried out on their behalf;
Likewise, article 37 of the RAI states that in order for the Agent to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with, among other conditions and for each intermediated operation, having the corresponding client order;
The non-compliance for not obtaining orders from its clients, as required by article 175 of the LMV, in force at the date of the events, as well as article 37 of the RAI, is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a minor nature "Not obtaining orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene;"
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
127. According to the provisions of numeral 73.1 of article 73 of the RAI, a natural or legal person, national or foreign, who initiates or maintains any commercial relationship with the agent for the provision of any service that its operating authorization empowers it to provide, is considered to have the status of a client of an Agent. In this same sense, numeral 73.2 of article 73 of the RAI states that the status of client of an Agent is determined by the nature and evidence of the relationship established between the Agent and the client, regardless of the formalities established or whether such relationship is habitual or occasional;
128. On September 22, 2010, Intercapital issued five Confirmation Letters to its clients, which proves that said intermediary received money from its principals for the purchase of Golden Shares, thus evidencing the existence of a commercial relationship, thereby acquiring said persons the status of clients;
129. Likewise, it should be noted that despite the request made to Intercapital in the Inspections, no documents have been found that prove that said intermediary complied with obtaining orders from these clients;
130. Similarly, in the period between February 22 and April 6, 2011, Intercapital issued Confirmation Letters and letters specifying a securities portfolio (similar to an account statement) in favor of its clients. In this way, it is proven that Intercapital received funds from these persons for the subscription of Golden Shares, thereby ratifying the existence of a commercial relationship and consequently the status of clients.
131. Regarding these operations, Intercapital was requested to prove that it had obtained orders from its clients in accordance with the regulations; however, said intermediary did not comply with such request. Thus, Intercapital has not left a record of compliance with such obligation in the Documentary Collection Record;
132. Likewise, in the period between January 19 and May 5, 2011, Intercapital issued Confirmation Letters, letters specifying a securities portfolio (similar to an account statement); it should be noted that during the Inspections emails and a Table of Income and Outflows of Funds were found;
133. In the aforementioned documents, it is evident that Intercapital carried out intermediation operations with funds from its clients, thus concluding that Intercapital maintained a commercial relationship with these persons, since it carried out intermediation operations on their behalf, receiving funds and purchasing securities.
134. Likewise, from the documentation provided by Intercapital, no evidence has been found that this intermediation agent obtained orders from its clients for the execution of the aforementioned operations, therefore, taking into account that for each securities purchase operation detailed in the preceding tables, Intercapital should have complied with obtaining instructions from its clients beforehand;
9. NOT COMMUNICATING RELEVANT FACTS OR NOT DOING SO WITHIN THE ESTABLISHED DEADLINE
On the regulations
Article 98 of the RAI establishes that Agents must inform the SMV of their relevant facts within the following business day of the agreement or decision being taken, of the occurrence of the fact or act or of having become aware of it, as appropriate, in accordance with the means and forms established by the SMV. Likewise, said article states that the General Manager is responsible for timely communicating the relevant facts of the Agent;
Likewise, said article 98 states that the situations detailed in Annex 9 of the RAI, which occur in relation to a certain Agent or its economic group, constitute relevant facts that the Agent must communicate to the SMV with sufficient detail and documentation; without prejudice to the fact that by their nature, other situations not listed in said Annex also have such qualification and must be reported to the SMV;
In this sense, numeral 24 of Annex 9 of the RAI considers as a relevant fact that related to the execution and termination of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or on behalf of third parties;
On the other hand, article 62 of the RAI considers as a relevant fact the decision of departure or change of the Agent's Internal Control Officer, which must be reported to the SMV within the period established for the communication of relevant facts;
It should be noted that the non-compliance for not communicating relevant facts or for not communicating them timely to the SMV is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a minor nature "Not Communicating Relevant Facts, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations;"
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
Not communicating to the SMV the departure of the Internal Control Officer.
On December 28, 2011, Mr. Eric Paredes Mauriño (hereinafter, Mr. Paredes) sent a Notarial Letter to Intercapital requesting his disassociation from the position of Internal Control Officer because at that date he was owed six months of remuneration, also indicating that he would not present the internal control report corresponding to the fourth quarter and that these circumstances be communicated to the SMV;
On January 12, 2012, Intercapital sent a letter to the SMV informing that Mr. Paredes had ceased to be the Internal Control Officer (FCI) of this intermediation agent, explaining that it was due to his resignation;
On January 12, 2012, Mr. Paredes sent a letter to this Superintendency informing his disassociation from Intercapital since December 28, 2011, attaching to said communication the Notarial Letter of resignation;
Taking into account that from December 28, 2011 to January 12, 2012, nine business days have elapsed, it is evident that Intercapital complied late with its duty to inform the departure of its FCI, since it should have complied with this duty on December 29, 2011, therefore Intercapital breached the provisions of article 62 of the RAI in accordance with the provisions of article 98 of the same normative body;
Not communicating the execution and termination of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or on behalf of third parties.
145. From the documentation collected during the Inspections, it was evidenced that Intercapital entered into multiple contracts with MF Global Inc. Thus, there are contracts called "Exchange Listed Options Brokerage Agreement", "Customer Agreement", "Solicitation and Referral Services Agreement", signed between Intercapital and the aforementioned foreign intermediary, for the purpose of carrying out intermediation operations;
146. On the other hand, on January 19, 2011, Intercapital entered into a contract called "Client Account Agreement" with Raymond James, through which it obtained a client account at said foreign intermediary number 1F6-KA0A-0, which according to the account statements, which were collected during the Inspections, maintained securities and funds deposited at the close of June, July, August and September 2011;
147. In relation to Lek Securities, there is documentary evidence of a report, "Statement Trade Date Report" (period from January 6 to 11, 2009) and letters (from March 1, 2010 and February 24, 2011) referring to communications in which the foreign intermediary confirmed to Intercapital the receipt and disposition of funds for the purpose of carrying out transactions with shares and stock options in the North American market or in the foreign market;
148. For the above, it is concluded that Intercapital entered into contracts with MF Global Inc., Raymond James and Lek Securities, all intermediation entities located abroad and whose respective contracts entered into with these entities had as their object the carrying out of intermediation activities on behalf of Intercapital itself and in other cases on behalf of its clients. However, this was not reported as a relevant fact, Intercapital infringing the provisions of article 98 of the RAI in accordance with the provisions of numeral 24 of Annex 9 of said normative body;
10. Denying or delaying the delivery of books, documents and other information requested by the SMV during inspections
On the regulations
According to article 196, literal e), of the LMV, it is the obligation and responsibility of stock brokerage firms to allow the inspection of their books, records and operations by the SMV;
Likewise, article 71 of the RAI establishes that the Agent must provide SMV officials with the information, documentation and facilities they require during inspections and other supervision and control actions and that, consequently, the Agent is prohibited from carrying out any action that could hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of the SMV;
In this regard, it is necessary to highlight that the non-compliance with the information and documentation requests made by the SMV as part of its supervision work is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a serious nature to "Deny or delay the delivery of books, documents and other information required by the SMV during inspections or investigations, not grant the facilities that the SMV requests in the execution of the supervision and control actions it orders; as well as presenting documentation for the purpose of delaying the procedure, or in any other way obstructing the supervision and control actions;"
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
On this matter and as mentioned in numeral I "Facts" of this Resolution, through Official Letter No. 4414-2011-EF/94.06.1 of October 28, 2011, Intercapital was informed of the start of an inspection scheduled for November 2011, which concluded through a Record dated December 12 of the same year;
Likewise, through Official Letter No. 5038-2012-SMV.10.3 of December 19, 2011, Intercapital was informed of the start of a new inspection in order to evaluate its intermediation activities;
Within the framework of said inspections, various documentation and information was requested from Intercapital, and in some cases these were not presented as shown in the following table:
| INFORMATION AND | REQUIREMENT MEMORANDUM | OBSERVATION |
|---|---|---|
| DOCUMENTATION REQUESTED | ||
| Copy of the contract or equivalent document signed with | Numeral 7) of Memorandum | Information not delivered. |
| each Foreign Intermediary that executes its | No. | This was recorded |
| instructions, as a client or for any | 002-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL | in the Inspection Completion |
| other, as well as the communication sent to CONASEV | SAB of 11/21/2011 | Record of |
| regarding the contracts signed. Indicate whether it is | 12/12/2011. | |
| the custodian of securities and/or funds, also indicating | ||
| the respective account number. | ||
| Copy of the account statements issued by the foreign | Numeral 7) of Memorandum | Information not delivered. |
| entity Reymond James regarding account No. | No. | |
| 1F6-KA0A-0 in the name of Intercapital SAB corresponding | 001-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL | |
| to the months of October and November 2011. | SAB of 12/19/2011. | |
| Copy of the lease contract of the premises where | Numeral 21 of Memorandum | To the extent that the |
| the offices of the stock brokerage firm operate. | No. | lease contract |
| 001-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL | of the premises where the | |
| SAB of 11/04/2011 | SAB operates expired on 10/14/10, it was | |
| recorded in the Inspection | ||
| Completion Record of | ||
| 12/12/2011 | ||
| that the respective current | ||
| lease contract had to be presented. | ||
| Prove the payment of CTS of its workers, | Numeral 3) of Memorandum | Information not delivered. |
| corresponding to the semesters of April and October of | No. | |
| 2011, whose settlement expired in the months of May and | 001-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL | |
| November 2011, respectively. | SAB of 12/19/2011. | |
| Prove the payment to the AFPs for the pension | Numeral 4) of Memorandum | Information not delivered, which |
| contributions of its workers, corresponding to | No. | was recorded in |
| the last 6 months. | 001-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL | the Inspection Completion Record of |
| SAB of 12/19/2011. | 12/12/2011. | |
| Payment receipt proving the settlement of | Numeral 2) of Memorandum | Information not delivered. |
| fees to the Internal Control Officer of the SAB | No. | This was recorded |
| for services provided during the months of January | 002-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL | in the Inspection Completion Record of |
| to October 2011. | SAB of 11/21/2011. | 12/12/2011. |
a. 386 Income Tax Prepayment. b. 411.01 Employee Remunerations Payable.
c. 412.01 Employee Vacations Payable.
d. 463 Shareholder Loans. e. 635 Rentals f. 666 Administrative and Tax Sanctions g. 759 Other Miscellaneous Income;
157. The information mentioned in the preceding recital was not delivered in a timely manner, leaving a record of this in the Inspection Completion Record dated December 12, 2011;
158. On this matter, the failure to present the information and documentation in a timely manner hindered the identification of the operational processes applied and prevented verifying whether these were carried out within the regulatory framework, in particular, the account "463 Shareholder Loans" which is related to the infraction indicated in numeral 3.2 of this resolution and which, in essence, represented transactions related to the intermediation of operations in the foreign market on its own account and on behalf of third parties;
159. Similarly, upon the reiteration of the request for the presentation of the information in question by the SMV officials who formed the team in charge of the Inspections, it was only presented in the inspection initiated on December 19, 2011 and concluded on January 12, 2012, that is, late, which hindered the exercise of supervision tasks in a timely manner regarding said information;
160. In this sense, the non-compliance by Intercapital with its obligation to allow the inspection of its books, records and other documentation related to its intermediation work has been verified, thereby not observing the provisions of article 196, literal e), of the LMV and article 71 of the RAI;
11. Not calculating the position limit in foreign accounts and not informing the SMV thereof
On the regulations
In accordance with Article 117 of the RAI, the Agent must keep timely control of its margins and liquidity and capital solvency conditions, in order to prove compliance with the prudential levels or limits established for each of them. For this purpose, the Agent must implement in its information system the necessary mechanisms and procedures;
Likewise, the second paragraph of said article states that for the respective compliance control, the Agent must submit to the SMV the final position of each day of its margins and liquidity and capital solvency conditions, by the following day, in accordance with the general specifications on information submission established by the General Management of CONASEV;
The Manual of Specifications for the submission to CONASEV of information from Intermediation Agents, approved by General Management Resolution No. 049-2008-EF/94.01.2, establishes i) the specifications that the information on the Agents' liquidity and capital solvency margins must meet in order to be submitted to the SMV, and ii) that the calculation of the end-of-day position of said margins and the frequency of submission thereof is daily and must be submitted within a maximum period not exceeding the business day following the date of the information;
It should be noted that Article 117 of the RAI is consistent with Article 116 of the same regulation, which states that in accordance with the provisions of the LMV, the margins and liquidity and capital solvency conditions are the prudential levels and limits that Agents must comply with regarding, among other concepts, the Limit of positions in foreign accounts (subsection 116.6);
Article 137 of the RAI states that the valuation of securities and financial instruments and the funds owned by its clients in the name of the Agent registered in the global accounts of the foreign intermediaries with which it has signed contracts for operations abroad must be at all times less than 10 times its net equity, this being the limit of positions of an Agent in foreign accounts. The information on said valuations, funds, net equity, according to the aforementioned Manual, must be calculated by the Agent on a daily basis and submitted to the SMV no later than the business day following the date of calculation;
It should be noted that non-observance of such rules is classified as an infraction in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.8 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is a serious infraction to "Not carry out, with the frequency established in the regulations, the calculation of liquidity and solvency indicators, as well as the limit by activity";
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered Party
Regarding the Infraction detected
Regarding the Foreign Accounts
169. As mentioned in numeral 3.9, Intercapital signed contracts and established a commercial relationship with MF Global Inc., Raymond James and Lek Securities, all of them foreign intermediaries, for the purpose of carrying out operations abroad;
170. In the case of MF Global Inc., the documentary evidence shows that Intercapital maintained up to three (03) accounts with said company. At the close of October 2009, said accounts showed balances fluctuating between US$ 703.29 and US$ 4,450.00. On the other hand, with Raymond James it maintained one account that at the close of September 2011 showed a balance of US$ 375,456.11 and with Lek Securities, one account in which at the close of December 2010, Intercapital as a client of the foreign intermediary, held deposited US$ 349,434.80;
171. For the foregoing and given what is stated in numeral 3.9, it is clear that Intercapital maintained global accounts abroad with the aforementioned foreign entities for the purpose of carrying out transactions in foreign markets, that is, MF Global Inc, Raymond James and Lek Securities, and that said global accounts held securities and funds of Intercapital and its clients, for which reason it had the obligation to carry out the calculation of positions in foreign accounts and to report it to the SMV; however, Intercapital did not comply with said obligation;
172. In that sense, the funds and securities that were in said accounts should have been calculated and valued daily in accordance with the provisions of Article 117 of the RAI in order to report to the SMV regarding Intercapital's positions in foreign accounts;
12. Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations
On the regulations
Article 36 of the RAI establishes that for an Agent to be able to intermediate the cash purchase of a financial instrument not registered in any centralized mechanism of the country, it must verify that there is no specific prohibition preventing the negotiation of that financial instrument on its part, after which it must request from the selling Agent the information of the instrument's data sheet, as indicated in Article 35 of the RAI, except in the case that it is the same Agent;
Additionally, the aforementioned Article 36 states that for the specific case that said purchase is made with respect to securities other than those qualifying as negotiable securities, the purchasing Agent, for each purchase operation it intermediates, must, among other requirements, obtain a declaration from the purchasing client in which the latter states being aware of the following: i) The type of security being acquired, as well as its nature, characteristics and payment risk; ii) Who is the principal obligor for payment of the security; iii) That the agents intermediating the operation do not assume responsibility for the solvency or compliance of the principal obligor for payment of the security; iv) That it has had at its disposal all the information gathered from the selling client, in accordance with the provisions of Article 35 of the RAI; vi) That the security has been acquired in co-ownership, where applicable;
Likewise, the aforementioned Article 36 states that said declaration must be attached to each order corresponding to this type of purchase operations;
Failure to comply with obtaining a declaration from the purchasing client of financial instruments referred to in Article 36 of the RAI is classified as an infraction in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is a serious infraction to "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations;"
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered Party
Regarding the Infraction detected
178. In accordance with the provisions of the aforementioned Article 36 of the RAI, through Requirement Memorandum No. 001-2011-INSP.INTERCAPITAL SAB, numeral No. 9[3], dated November 4, 2011, information was requested from Intercapital regarding operations with financial instruments intermediated outside the centralized negotiation mechanisms by said company between June and October 2011, in accordance with the list of bills of exchange contained in Annex 2 of the aforementioned Requirement Memorandum;
179. In this regard, the sworn declarations of the purchasing clients of the bills of exchange listed in the aforementioned Annex 2 were not submitted, a fact that was recorded in the Inspection Completion Record dated December 12, 2011;
180. It is appropriate to mention that in the Documentary Collection Record, the non-delivery of the aforementioned information was recorded;
181. In that sense, Intercapital has not proven to have the aforementioned sworn declarations of its purchasing clients of bills of exchange, which reflects a breach of the regulations applicable to this type of operations, also taking into account that for a brokerage firm the information it provides to its clients must be, at all times, truthful, sufficient and timely so that they can make adequate investment decisions. In this way, Intercapital breached the provisions of subsection 36.1 of Article 36 of the RAI;
13. Submitting to the SMV financial information prepared without observing international accounting standards in Peru
On the regulations
Article 2 of the Financial Information Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/943.10 (hereinafter, Financial Information Regulation), establishes that financial statements must be prepared and presented in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, accounting standards established by the supervisory and control bodies and the standards established by said regulation. Likewise, the aforementioned article states that Generally Accepted Accounting Principles are contained in the International Accounting Standards (IAS) officialized and in force in Peru and also comprise the technical pronouncements issued by the accounting profession in Peru;
Likewise, said article states that in those circumstances in which certain accounting operating procedures are not specifically regulated in any of the IAS, the criteria set forth in the conceptual framework of said standards must be applied, and support may be drawn from similar or specific procedures considered in the Accounting Principles applied in the United States of America;
Likewise, the Conceptual Framework (in its paragraphs 60 and 4.15, versions in force for the years 2010 and 2011, respectively) established that "An essential characteristic of every liability is that the entity has a present obligation. A liability is a commitment or responsibility to act in a certain way. Obligations may be legally enforceable as a consequence of the execution of a contract or of a mandate contained in a legal norm. This is normally the case, for example, of accounts payable for goods or services received. However, obligations also arise from the normal activity of the entity, from customs and from the desire to maintain good commercial relations or act equitably (...)";
Also, paragraphs 91 and 4.46 of the aforementioned Conceptual Framework, applicable according to the versions in force for the years 2010 and 2011, respectively, state that: "A liability is recognized in the balance sheet when it is probable that the payment of that present obligation will derive the outflow of resources embodying economic benefits, and furthermore the amount of the disbursement to be made can be reliably evaluated. In practice, obligations derived from contracts that are unexecuted by both parties in the same proportion (for example debts for inventories ordered but not yet received) are generally not recognized as such obligations in the financial statements. However, such debts may meet the definition of liabilities and, in the event that they satisfy the conditions to be recognized in their particular circumstances, they may qualify for recognition in the financial statements. In such circumstances, recognizing the liabilities also imposes the recognition of the corresponding assets or expenses";
Additionally, IAS 39 in its paragraph 58 establishes that: "(...) an entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or group of financial assets measured at amortized cost is impaired (...)";
For its part, paragraph 59 of the aforementioned IAS 39 states that: "(...) objective evidence that an asset or group of assets is impaired includes observable information that requires the attention of the holder of the asset on the following events that cause the loss: (a) financial difficulties of the issuer and the obligor, (b) breaches in contractual clauses, such as defaults or delays in the payment of interest or principal";
Finally, paragraph 63 of the aforementioned IAS 39 indicates that "when there is objective evidence that an impairment loss has been incurred on financial assets measured at amortized cost, the amount of the loss shall be measured as the difference between the asset's carrying amount and the present value of estimated cash flows (...). The carrying amount shall be reduced directly, or through an allowance account. The amount of the loss shall be reduced as a result of the period";
Non-observance of the cited regulatory provisions is classified as an infraction in Annex I, numeral 2, numeral 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is a serious infraction to "Submit to SMV, to the Exchange, to the Products Exchange, to the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism, to the investor and in general to any other participant in the securities or products market, financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru, the technical pronouncements issued by the country's accounting profession, accounting standards established by the supervisory and control bodies and the standards contained in the Financial Information Regulation";
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered Party
Regarding the Infraction detected
On this matter, it has been evidenced in the Inspections that Intercapital intermediated in the negotiation of promissory notes, among which there were 07 (seven) promissory notes issued by VASA (hereinafter, Promissory Notes):
Said Promissory Notes matured in the months of July, August and September 2009; however, as recorded in Annex F of the Documentary Collection Record, the aforementioned Promissory Notes were not paid on the maturity dates;
Likewise, it is important to mention that Intercapital's participation in the intermediation of financial instruments not registered in centralized negotiation mechanisms, as is the case of the Promissory Notes, is an activity permitted for intermediation agents, in accordance with the provisions of Article 36 of the RAI;
Regarding the accounting record of the intermediation of financial instruments by a brokerage firm, this is done through the Account "12113 - Negotiation Desk Operations" with the detail of the clients' names, in accordance with the provisions of the Chart of Accounts, Financial Information and Control Annexes of Brokerage Firms approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 0305-1995-EF/94.10.0 (hereinafter, Chart of Accounts), the account "12 Commercial Accounts Receivable" being [4].
In that sense, taking into account that in this type of intermediation activities, those who assume responsibility for the non-payment of said instruments are the clients that instructed the intermediary to acquire them, it is appropriate for the brokerage firm to record such activities in the aforementioned Account "12113 - Negotiation Desk Operations", that is, in accounts corresponding to principals;
According to the information and documentation gathered in the Inspections, it is evidenced that Intercapital directly acquired the account receivable corresponding to the Promissory Notes and that, despite the fact that through a judicial mandate the payment of the promissory notes was ordered, said payment was not complied with. There are three important elements to consider that allow us to sustain that Intercapital did not adequately record the accounting information corresponding to the aforementioned securities:
i) Intercapital's intent to directly assume responsibility for the payment default by VASA of the Promissory Notes issued, as was stated by the treasurer and Mr. Higueras, through a letter dated December 20, 2011, in which they state that Intercapital directly assumed the obligations derived from said securities.
ii) The judicial process for obligation to give sum of money initiated by Intercapital against VASA, by virtue of which the Seventeenth Civil Court of Commercial Subspecialty of the Superior Court of Justice of Lima – through a resolution dated October 5, 2009, ordered VASA to pay the amount corresponding to the Promissory Notes in favor of Intercapital plus interest, costs and expenses of the process. It is important to emphasize that in the framework of said process, the judicial authority stated that the endorsement made of the Promissory Notes in favor of Intercapital was an endorsement in property, and thus, Intercapital (in its capacity as direct creditor of VASA) was legitimized to initiate actions in its own name to obtain the collection of said securities, since it was the holder of said promissory notes.
iii) As of the closing date of the Documentary Collection Record, that is, as of January 12, 2012, and despite the judicial sentence issued, VASA had not complied with paying the amount of the Promissory Notes;
197. Accordingly, the sum of money corresponding to the Promissory Notes should have been recorded by Intercapital as an account payable (liability) to its clients and an account receivable from VASA in its Balance Sheet and not as an account receivable from principals, as was recorded by Intercapital. However, the unpaid amount corresponding to the Promissory Notes was not reflected in that manner in the accounting records of said brokerage firm;
198. In this way, Intercapital should have reflected the amount of S/. 84,430.00 (Eighty-four thousand four hundred thirty and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) for the Promissory Notes (amount that does not include interest and other concepts) in the Account "12321 Negotiation Desk Operations with Unregistered Securities", in order to reflect that it was said entity that acquired the Promissory Notes. Likewise, Intercapital should have reflected a similar amount in the Account "428-Other Accounts Payable";
199. In that sense, and in relation to the basis for recognizing the amount of the Promissory Notes as a liability of Intercapital, it should be noted that Intercapital should have observed the provisions of the Chart of Accounts and paragraphs 4.15, 4.46, 60 and 91 of the Conceptual Framework (versions in force for the years 2010 and 2011, respectively[5]) as well as paragraphs 58 and 59 of IAS 39, standards referred to in recitals 182 et seq. of this resolution;
200. Likewise, from the review of the basic financial statements as of September 30, 2011 submitted to the SMV by Intercapital, it is observed that said brokerage firm did not include information regarding the collection status of the Promissory Notes, nor has it been evidenced that the amount of accounts payable to clients or accounts receivable from VASA is recorded accounting-wise;
201. Finally, Intercapital should have made a provision of S/. 84,430.00, as a doubtful collection account. This taking into account the time elapsed and the non-payment condition of said debt;
202. For the foregoing, it has been verified that Intercapital (i) directly acquired the accounts receivable corresponding to the Promissory Notes; and that (ii) they became uncollectible. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Intercapital did not comply with recognizing as Liabilities the amounts corresponding to the aforementioned Promissory Notes, with which the breach by said company of the IAS, the provisions contained in the Financial Information Regulation, Conceptual Framework and the Chart of Accounts has been verified;
14. Not updating the amount of the guarantee within the established period
On the regulations
In accordance with the provisions of Article 136 of the LMV, in order to operate on an exchange, brokerage firms must guarantee compliance with the obligations derived from their participation in the securities market;
Likewise, Article 140 of the LMV establishes that the Agent must at all times have all the guarantees required by the Law and applicable regulations, at the established levels and conditions;
It should be noted that non-observance of the obligation to update the amount of the guarantee within the period established by the LMV is classified as an infraction in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is a very serious infraction to "Not comply with updating the guarantees in the amount and period established by the regulations;"
On the defenses and arguments of the Administered Party
Regarding the Infraction detected
207. On January 2, 2012, the General Superintendency of Entity Supervision of this Superintendency sent to all intermediation agents Circular No. 001-2012-SMV/10.2, through which it requested them to comply with updating their minimum capital and with updating the amount of the guarantees referred to in Article 136 of the LMV[6], granting them a period of 15 business days;
208. The minimum amount, determined by the aforementioned circular, for the individual guarantees of brokerage firms amounted to the sum of S/. 727,745.00 (Seven hundred twenty-seven thousand seven hundred forty-five and 00/100 Nuevos soles);
209. Regarding Intercapital, the aforementioned circular was notified on January 3, 2012, as appears in the Constancia de Recepción de la Notificación extracted from File No. 2012000081. Consequently, the deadline for Intercapital to update its guarantee expired on January 24, 2012;
210. It is appropriate to note that Intercapital, on the date it was notified with Circular No. 001-2012-SMV/10.2, had a guarantee consisting of a Letter of Guarantee issued by Banco de Comercio No. 2010/00479-06, which was valid from November 28, 2011 to February 23, 2012, for an amount of S/. 684,861.00;
211. As stated in the preceding recitals, Intercapital had to comply with updating the amount of its individual guarantee, since the one it maintained in force as of January 2, 2012 — date of issuance of Circular No. 001-2012-SMV/10.2 — was for a lower sum;
212. The deadline that Intercapital had for this purpose was 15 business days, which expired on January 24, 2012 without Intercapital complying with presenting to this Superintendency a guarantee for the sum established in the Circular cited in the preceding recital;
213. On February 23, 2012, Intercapital presented an individual guarantee to the SMV for the amount established in the aforementioned Circular, that is, with a delay of 20 business days, thus infringing the provisions of article 140 of the RAI.
15. Not complying with what is specifically provided by the SMV, in the exercise of its functions
From the regulations
Resolution TAC sanctioned Intercapital for the commission of a serious infraction for having contravened the Financial Information Regulation, the Conceptual Framework, Accounting Standard No. 1 and the RAI, for having prepared financial information without observing the International Accounting Standards;
Likewise, article 3 of Resolution TAC dismissed the interim financial statements and audited financial statements presented by Intercapital, both as of December 31, 2009. Consequently, it was ordered that within twenty business days following the notification of Resolution TAC, these financial statements be presented with an adjustment for the amount of S/. 914,520.00, corresponding to the concept called "Others" of the Cash and Banks account of the Balance Sheet as of December 31, 2009;
Although Resolution TAC was subject to challenge, it was resolved through CONASEV Resolution No. 047-2011-EF/94.01.1 of June 17, 2011, which declared the appeal filed by Intercapital unfounded;
In view of this, through Official Letter No. 3112-2011-EF/94.06.1 of July 20, 2011, the SMV granted Intercapital a period of five (5) business days to present the two (02) financial statements mentioned above with the adjustment required by Resolution TAC. The aforementioned period expired on August 1, 2010 without Intercapital presenting said adjusted financial information;
The non-observance of the obligation to comply with what is provided by this Superintendency in the exercise of its functions is typified as an infraction in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a serious nature to "Not comply with what is specifically provided by the SMV, in the exercise of its functions";
From the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
According to article 96 of the RAI, the Administrative Tribunal of the then CONASEV, now SMV, could dismiss the financial statements of an intermediation agent in any of the following situations: (i) non-compliance with the rules governing their preparation and (ii) lack or non-existence of the source documentation, evidence, or records that should support the prepared financial statements;
As stated, the SMV through Resolution TAC required Intercapital to reformulate its Interim Financial Statements and its Annual Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2009, in order to adjust the "Others" item in the Cash and Banks Account, for the amount of S/. 914,520.00 (Nine hundred fourteen thousand five hundred twenty and 00/100 Nuevos Soles);
It should be noted that as recorded in the charge letter, Official Letter No. 3856-2011-EF/94.06.1, the SMV required Intercapital on several occasions to comply with the provisions of Resolution TAC. This can be seen in Official Letters No. 3112-2011-EF/94.06.1 of July 20, 2011, No. 3257-2011-EF/94.06.1 of July 27, 2011 and No. 3365-2011-EF/94.06.1 of August 8, 2011;
Thus, the deadline granted for the presentation of the financial information incorporating the adjustment required by the SMV expired on August 1, 2011. However, Intercapital did not comply with presenting said information within the granted period, thereby configuring Intercapital's refusal to comply with the provisions of this Superintendency;
As stated above, Intercapital did not present the information that had been ordered, failing to comply with the mandate issued by the Administrative Tribunal of the SMV;
Likewise, it should be noted that the non-compliance incurred by Intercapital has affected transparency in the market, since its financial information was made available to its clients and the general public without reflecting the real financial situation of the company. The importance of this information should be remembered because its purpose is to show the investing public that agent companies comply with having the necessary financial resources as well as the other requirements demanded to participate in the market;
For the reasons stated in this numeral, it is proven that Intercapital incurred in the infraction of a serious nature, typified in subsection 2.11 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation by not complying with what is expressly provided by the SMV in the exercise of its functions;
Regarding Mr. Higueras
From the regulations
According to the provisions of article 152 of the General Corporations Law, the direction or administration of a company is in charge of the Board of Directors and the Management;
Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, knew the responsibilities derived from such functions, therefore, compliance with the provisions of the regulations governing the securities market is required of him;
Within these regulations, as stated in numeral 3.2. of this resolution, article 66, numeral 66.2 of the RAI, and paragraphs CC4 and CC12 of the Conceptual Framework, establish that the information provided or issued by an Agent must be useful, truthful, sufficient, and timely; and for this it must be comparable, verifiable and understandable, in addition to faithfully representing the phenomena it intends to represent in a complete, neutral and error-free manner;
The non-observance of the obligation to present financial information that meets the requirements demanded by the regulations by the participants[7] in the Securities Market is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex I, numeral 1 subsection 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is an infraction of a very serious nature: "Presenting to CONASEV, the Exchange, the Products Exchange, the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, the investor and in general any other subject of the securities or products market, inaccurate, false or biased information; or disclosing such information in the market (...)";
From the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
A. Of the Accounting Records used to reverse the patrimonial deficit (Purchase of Golden Shares) that supported Intercapital's financial information as of September 30, 2011.
During Mr. Higueras's management as Managing Director of Intercapital, irregularities have been detected in the preparation and presentation of the financial information corresponding to said company;
According to the provisions of article 37 of the Financial Information Regulation, the preparation and presentation of financial statements is the responsibility of the Board of Directors and/or the management of the company. Likewise, article 35 of the Financial Information Regulation provides that — as part of the interim financial information — companies must present a management report, through which the management explains the main characteristics of the financial information and the financial performance of the company. Thus, the Board of Directors and/or the management of the company must know the financial situation of the company and report the financial events that occurred in a given period through the preparation and presentation of financial statements;
On November 8, 2011 — the day after Intercapital was notified of Official Letter No. 4489-2011-EF/94.11 which initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against said company for not having a patrimony that is equal to or greater than the minimum capital required by the LMV — Mr. Higueras in his capacity as General Manager of Intercapital presented a reformulated version of its financial information closed as of September 30, 2011. In the Balance Sheet of said information, it is observed that the patrimony would exceed the minimum capital amount for the 2011 fiscal year, with which Mr. Higueras tried to prove that he had reversed the patrimonial deficit in which his represented company had incurred;
In order to verify the support for the reversal of the patrimonial deficit, an inspection was carried out at Intercapital, in which the document called Acta de Verificación was issued, which was prepared for the purpose of verifying the support of the financial information referred to in the preceding recitals;
In the aforementioned Acta de Verificación, it was recorded that in the versions of the Balance Sheet closed as of September 30, 2011, presented on October 31 and November 8, 2011, there were differences in the items negotiable securities (S/. 981,912) and accumulated results (S/. 981,912), the differences are shown in the following table:
| Balance Sheet as of 09.30.2011 - changes made by Intercapital | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Presented on | |||
| 10.31.2011 | 11.08.2011 | Difference | |
| ASSETS | |||
| Cash and Banks | 399,743 | 399,743 | |
| Negotiable Securities | 0 | 981,912 | 981,912 |
| Accounts Receivable | 33,949 | 33,949 | |
| Other accounts receivable | 381,113 | 381,113 | |
| Current Assets | 814,805 | 1,796,717 | 981,912 |
| Property, Plant and Equipment | 17,672 | 17,672 | |
| Total Assets | 832,477 | 1,814,389 | 981,912 |
| LIABILITIES | |||
| Bank Overdrafts | 206 | 206 | |
| Trade Accounts Receivable | 420,788 | 420,788 | |
| Other accounts payable | 75,361 | 75,361 | |
| Total Liabilities | 496,355 | 496,355 | |
| EQUITY | |||
| Capital | 2,237,185 | 2,237,185 | |
| Legal Reserve | 399,488 | 399,488 | |
| Accumulated Results | -2,300,551 | -1,316,639 | 983,912 |
| Total Equity | 336,122 | 1,320,034 | 983,912 |
| Entry D009 | 09.30.2011 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Account No. | Description | Debit | Credit |
| 108 | $ 316,662 | 914,520 | |
| 593 | 914,520 | ||
| 108 | US$ 32772 | 66,691 | |
| 593 | 66,691 | ||
| 108 | 701 | ||
| 77601 | 700 | ||
| 593 | 1 | ||
| Official Letter No. 4489-2011-EF/7.11.11 | |||
| Reversal of Official Letter 3846.2011 | |||
| 09.21.2011 |
With the record indicated in the preceding table, Mr. Higueras, representing Intercapital, sought to demonstrate how he would have reversed the patrimonial deficit situation, through the increase in the balance of the account "593 Accumulated Results" and generating greater availability of funds, thereby increasing the balance of the account "108 Other deposits";
Likewise, in the record there is a comment as a description relating it to Official Letter No. 3846-2011-EF/94.06.1 mentioned in the preceding recitals (by virtue of which Intercapital was informed of the patrimonial deficit and was required to reverse it), with which it is maintained that the movements recorded in Entry D009 were made with the intention of reversing the patrimonial deficit in which Intercapital had incurred;
Additionally, the accountant presented the accounting record corresponding to Entry D0010 whose detail is indicated below:
| Entry D0010 | 09.30.2011 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Account No. | Description | Debit | Credit |
| 31413 | 981,912 | ||
| 108 | 981,912 | ||
| Acquisition of shares | |||
| Golden Dawn Minerals INC | |||
| 5,007,682 | $ 349,434.80 |
From the preceding table, it can be seen that Entry D0010 reveals the supposed acquisition on August 9, 2011 of 5,007,682 (five million seven thousand six hundred eighty-two) Golden Shares in the name of Intercapital at a price of US$ 0.07 (07/100 United States Dollars);
Likewise, an increase in the account "31413 Negotiable Securities" and a decrease in the balance of the account "108 Other deposits" is observed, with a description indicating "Acquisition of Golden Minerals INC Shares". Through said entry, Intercapital tried to support that with the funds supposedly available in the account "108 Other deposits" the aforementioned shares would have been acquired;
In this regard, Intercapital's Accountant was consulted about the support for the records indicated in the two preceding tables, and stated (as recorded in Annex C of the Acta de Acervo Documentario) that she has not had access to the documents that support these records, especially the acquisition of Golden Shares and indicated that said documents would be delivered to the SMV by Mr. Higueras;
Notwithstanding what was stated by Intercapital's Accountant, in the Acta de Verificación it was recorded that as of November 14, 2011, Mr. Higueras declared that he did not have "the information that allows him to prove the subscription and payment of the investments in Golden Dawn Minerals INC, as well as the origin of the funds used for said investment, both recorded accounting in the interim financial information closed as of September 30, 2011";
Subsequently, on November 16, 2011 during the inspection initiated through Official Letter No. 4414-2011-EF/94.06.1, Mr. Higueras presented a letter dated November 14, 2011, addressed to Intercapital and signed by the Chief Financial Officer of Golden Dawn, in which he informed regarding the placement of 5,007,682 (five million seven thousand six hundred eighty-two) shares issued by said company in April 2011, at a price of CAD 0.085 (85/100 Canadian Dollars) per share;
Therefore, from the summary of the facts indicated in the preceding recitals, it is noted that Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as General Manager of Intercapital, did not support the way in which he would have reversed its patrimonial deficit regarding: The income of available funds to Intercapital, recorded in the account "108 Other deposits" and the acquisition of the 5,007,682 (Five million seven thousand six hundred eighty-two) Golden Shares in favor of Intercapital and recorded in the account "31413 Negotiable Securities";
Finally, Mr. Higueras representing Intercapital provided false and inaccurate information related to the registration in favor of Intercapital of the ownership of the 5,007,682 (Five million seven thousand six hundred eighty-two) Golden Shares without the support of the respective documents that prove they were its property. For this, it must also be taken into account that according to the financial information as of January 31, 2012 presented to the SMV, said company did not include the referred Golden Shares as part of its assets, returning its patrimonial situation to the date prior to the adjustment presented in its financial information as of September 30, 2011[8], which shows that the records were made with the sole purpose of showing a supposed reversal of the patrimonial deficit;
Thus, in the aforementioned financial information as of January 31, 2012, Intercapital reported that its net equity amounted to S/. 185,691.00 (One hundred eighty-five thousand six hundred ninety-one and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) showing a patrimonial deficit with respect to the current minimum equity requirement amounting to S/. 1,364,523.00 (One million three hundred sixty-four thousand five hundred twenty-three and 00/100 Nuevos Soles);
In this sense, the intervention of Mr. Higueras in the exposed facts demonstrates his participation and responsibility in the presentation of financial information intended to supposedly remedy the patrimonial deficit that the company he represented maintained, and intentionally making accounting records of supposed operations that did not have the corresponding documentary support;
Likewise, it has been proven that the accounting records provided by Intercapital on November 8, 2011 (referring to demonstrating the greater availability of funds and the acquisition of 5,007,682 Golden Shares), did not have the documentation that allows justifying or supporting it, a situation that was known and the responsibility of Mr. Higueras as can be seen from the various documentation in the file;
Thus, the financial information presented by Mr. Higueras did not comply with the characteristic of truthfulness and accuracy required by article 66 of the RAI, so it was not reliable;
Likewise, the economic facts reflected in Intercapital's accounting records (related to the greater availability of funds and the acquisition of negotiable securities) did not comply with the qualitative characteristics of the Conceptual Framework referred to above because they do not faithfully represent the reality of the supposedly occurred facts;
On the other hand, the intentionality of Mr. Higueras in providing false financial information to the SMV in the name of Intercapital is also proven through the statements of the representatives of said entity (in particular, in the statement of Intercapital's treasurer, as recorded in Annex D of the Acta de Acervo Documentario), from which it can validly be maintained that the form of acquisition of the Golden Shares and their registration were part of a constant and systematic operation carried out by Intercapital;
Likewise, it is necessary to reiterate that according to article 37 of the Financial Information Regulation, the preparation and presentation of financial statements is the responsibility of the Board of Directors and/or the Management of the company. That being so, and given that Mr. Higueras was General Manager and Director of Intercapital, he knew the financial progress of the company and the content of the financial information presented, so he was responsible for its content;
For the reasons stated, it has been proven that Mr. Higueras — in his capacity as General Manager of Intercapital — did not support the changes made in the accounts corresponding to "Negotiable Securities", "Accumulated Results" and "Other Deposits", by virtue of which he tried to prove the reversal of the patrimonial deficit of said company, as he declared in the Acta de Verificación and that he was responsible for the presentation of Intercapital's financial information that was not reliable because it did not comply with the requirements of truthfulness and accuracy;
B. Registration of the funds used for the acquisition of Golden Shares in the account "463 - Shareholder Loan".
According to the information incorporated in the Acta de Acervo Documentario corresponding to the inspection carried out at Intercapital during the months of November and December 2011 and January 2012, it was learned that said agent company carried out purchase and sale operations of Golden Shares between January and May 2011;
Likewise, Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as General Manager, participated directly in the activities related to the purchase and sale of Golden Shares such as in the orders for transfers of funds abroad, purchase confirmations, among others;
According to the information incorporated in the Acta de Acervo Documentario, the purchase operations of Golden Shares were carried out under three modalities:
Sixteen (16) operations were carried out through transfers of funds by Intercapital to Raymond James accounts.
Twenty-three (23) operations corresponded to the subscription of shares via primary offering by Intercapital, supported by income and deposits in the current accounts of said entity (02 operating accounts and 01 administrative account).
Six (6) operations were carried out through Lek Securities;
As a result of the Inspections, elements were obtained that demonstrate that the acquisition of the Golden Shares was made with funds from Intercapital's clients. However, the income of money that was used for said transactions — as will be explained in the following recitals — were recorded under Account "463 – Shareholder Loan", that is, as if said funds had actually corresponded to loans made by the shareholders of said agent company. Likewise, the remittances sent abroad were recorded as repayment of said loans to the shareholders;
The manner in which Intercapital operated in the purchase of Golden Shares and the respective recording of money movements both in Intercapital's operating Dollar current account at Banco de Crédito del Perú (No. 193-1423576-1-64), in the operating account and in the administrative account, is detailed below:
i) Client deposits in current accounts and accounting record:
As a result of the Inspections, it was determined that in the period between January 6 and May 6, 2011, Intercapital's clients made twenty-nine (29) money deposits in the aforementioned operating accounts and nineteen (19) deposits in the administrative account, for the purchase of Golden Shares through Raymond James and directly from the issuing company.
As proof of the money received and deposited in the aforementioned accounts, Intercapital issued the respective payment receipts to its clients.
The amounts deposited by clients in the aforementioned current accounts were recorded in the account "463 - Shareholder Loans" as an increase in loans payable to the shareholder.
ii) Remittances abroad for the purchase of Golden Shares and accounting record
These letters were found attached to the "accounting vouchers" for the recording of the outflows of funds that supposedly would have come from loans granted by shareholders, that is, under the concept of "dev. Ptmo acc. Envío RJAMES".
In the inspection carried out on Intercapital, pre-printed and numbered forms with the Intercapital logo corresponding to the so-called Income Receipts were found, by virtue of which the receipt of funds for the concept of "Shareholder Loan" or "Share Loans" was recorded.
As mentioned above, monthly accounting files called "Cash - Banks" were found, in which ten (10) letters addressed to Scotiabank by Intercapital were found so that said banking entity would transfer funds from Intercapital's administrative account (which had been deposited by its clients) to Raymond James' bank account at the Royal Bank of Canada.
The amounts and dates appearing in the aforementioned Income Receipts coincided with the information incorporated in the Golden Shares Confirmation Letters. Likewise, the names and surnames of the persons who signed said Confirmation Letters also coincided with the data recorded on the back of each of the Income Receipts, which made it possible to relate the income of said funds with the transfer of said securities.
On the other hand, it was corroborated that there were also seven (7) communications of direct transfer of the funds credited in the administrative account to the bank account owned by Golden Dawn;
262. Thus, the information indicated in the preceding recitals allows us to maintain that the money that entered Intercapital's accounts and that was used for the purchase of Golden Shares did not correspond to "shareholder loans" but to funds provided by clients for the acquisition of said shares. Regarding this point, according to the statement made by Intercapital's Treasurer collected in Annex D of the Documentary Collection Record, the funds entering Intercapital's bank accounts came from deposits made by clients contacted by Mr. Higueras, despite which they were recorded under the concept of "Shareholder Loan";
263. That being so, Intercapital would have made a bad accounting record of the referred funds in the account "463 - Shareholder Loans", despite knowing (as has been reflected in the aforementioned documentation) what was the true origin and destination of the same;
264. Additionally, another element that supports the intentionality in Mr. Higueras' action in the bad accounting record of the income and outflows of money for the acquisition of the Golden Shares is contained in the contradictory statements of Intercapital's Treasurer and Intercapital's Accountant, as indicated below;
265. According to what was indicated by Intercapital's Accountant in Annex C of the Documentary Collection Record, the credits in account 463 corresponding to Shareholder Loans represent the income of funds for the concept of shareholder loan and the debits referring to the same account represent the withdrawal of funds for the concept of loan repayment;
266. On the same point, regarding the movements recorded in the account "463 - Shareholder Loans", Intercapital's Accountant in numeral 1.3 of the referred Annex C states that "...the charges in the referred account (of a creditor nature) represent the withdrawal of funds for the concept of repayment of shareholder loan and are recorded on the date they occur, while the credits in said account represent the income of funds to Intercapital SAB for the concept of shareholder loans and are recorded accounting-wise in a grouped manner (for each bank account) at the close of the month in which they were made...;
267. Additionally, when Intercapital's Accountant was consulted about the documentary support of the account "463 - Shareholder Loans" and the movement of said account, the referred person in the cited numeral 1.3 stated that "...she does not analyze the nature of the aforementioned accounting records, but rather limits herself to recording the documents generated administratively and if she has doubts about the references or observations of the accounting entries, she asks the treasurer who in turn consults Mr. Higueras...";
268. In contradiction with the statements made by the Accountant, Intercapital's Treasurer, in numeral 1.2 of Annex D, indicated regarding the operability of the Golden Shares purchase transactions that "...they began when Mr. Higueras notified her about the deposits made by the clients contacted by him for the purchase of Golden Shares abroad and that upon confirming the credits in the bank accounts, she issued the income receipt for the concept of "Shareholder Loan...";
269. Likewise, Intercapital's Treasurer indicated in the referred numeral 1.2 that "under the instructions of the General Manager or the Operations Manager, the treasurer prepared the letter requesting the transfer of funds for Scotiabank (from Intercapital SAB's administrative account at Scotiabank)..." and that "...the instruction letters sent to the bank are filed with the voucher for the outflow of funds generated by the treasury area and then transferred to accounting for review...";
270. From the information set forth in the preceding recitals, it is verified that the funds used by Intercapital for the acquisition of the Golden Shares for the period from August 2010 to May 2011 corresponded to funds from the clients of said company and not to funds from shareholder loans;
271. Notwithstanding this and despite the fact that Mr. Higueras knew and participated in said operation (such as contacting clients for the receipt of money, notifying the Treasurer when deposits were made and signing the confirmation letters and bank transfer orders), in Intercapital's financial information, signed by Mr. Higueras, those funds were recognized under the concept of Shareholder Loan, that is, in account "463 - Shareholder Loan", in clear breach of the securities market regulations, especially regarding the characteristic of truthfulness of information;
272. Likewise, it is necessary to recall that according to article 37 of the Financial Information Regulation, the preparation and presentation of financial statements is the responsibility of the Board of Directors and/or the Management of the company. That being so, and given his capacity as General Manager and Director of Intercapital, Mr. Higueras is responsible for the content of the financial information presented.
273. Finally, it should be mentioned that in his capacity as Director and General Manager of Intercapital, articles 152, 177 and 190 of the General Corporations Law are applicable to Mr. Higueras, since according to said provisions, having the capacity of administrator of a corporation, he responds unlimitedly before the company itself and third parties for the damages and losses caused by agreements or acts contrary to the law, the bylaws or those carried out with fraud, abuse of powers or gross negligence;
17. Destination of funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
From the regulations
According to the provisions of article 152 of the General Corporations Law, the direction or administration of a company is in charge of the board of directors and the Management;
Given his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, Mr. Higueras is required to comply with the provisions governing the securities market;
Article 195 of the LMV establishes the list of actions that brokerage firms are prohibited from carrying out within the framework of their intermediation activities. In this regard, subsection a) of said article provides within said prohibitions the destination of funds or securities received from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
The non-observance of the prohibition of allocating funds or securities to different purposes by the Representatives and by any person who directly or indirectly is related to the Intermediation Agent, is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1, of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "Allocating funds or securities received as a consequence of their intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
From the defenses and allegations of the Administered
Regarding the Infraction detected
According to the information obtained in the Inspections, detailed in this resolution in the analysis of Intercapital's infraction regarding improper destination of funds, it has been evidenced that Mr. Higueras has direct responsibility in the commission of the infraction under analysis;
As will be developed below, Mr. Higueras participated in the disposal of the funds delivered to Intercapital by its clients to allocate them to the purchase of Golden Shares, which were not acquired in the name of the clients who provided said funds but in the name of third parties. In this sense, having been proven his irregular action and his direct participation in the imputed facts, Mr. Higueras has responsibility in the infraction under analysis;
A. Regarding the private placement process of Golden Shares carried out in the month of September 2010.
In this private placement process of Golden Shares, Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, contacted Intercapital's clients for the purchase of the aforementioned shares in the foreign market. For this purpose, said clients deposited the money in Intercapital's accounts in order to buy said shares;
In this same process, Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, representing Intercapital, signed letters by which they ordered Scotiabank to transfer funds from an administrative account of Intercapital to an account of Golden Dawn;
Meanwhile, Mrs. Espinoza, representing Intercapital, signed a letter dated September 13, 2010 addressed to Golden Dawn in which she indicated to said company that the amounts of money transferred to Golden Dawn — which were transferred by orders of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza — served for the purchase of shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Finally, Mr. Higueras signed documents by which he confirmed to five (05) clients that he received money from them for the purchase of Golden Shares in the private placement process of these securities, carried out in the month of September 2010;
Consequently, the participation of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza in the operability of the purchases of Golden Shares in the foreign market, as well as the concordances of the amounts entered by the clients with the amounts that Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza ordered to transfer to Golden Dawn, indicate that Mr. Higueras (together with Mrs. Espinoza) did not comply with the instructions of Intercapital's clients, relating to the purchase of Golden Shares and on the contrary allocated the funds provided by them for different purposes, in this case for the purchase of the same shares but in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Indeed, the above is supported by the following:
The amount of US$ 263,000.00 that Intercapital received from five (05) clients, between August 27 and September 9, 2010, with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, coincides with the amount that Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, in their capacity as Managing Director and Operations Manager of Intercapital, respectively, ordered to transfer to Golden Dawn to complete the amount paid for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras.
There was a difference of US$ 12,000.00 to complete the US$ 275,000.00 that were allocated to the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras, which was taken from a balance retained in Golden Dawn in the name of Intercapital. After that, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital indicated having received US$ 275,000.00 from the referred five (05) clients, according to the sum of the shares recorded in the Confirmation Letters, issued in favor of said clients.
The total quantity of Golden Shares that Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital referred as subscribed in favor of those five (05) clients through Confirmation Letters, coincides with the total quantity of shares that were subscribed in favor of Mr. Higueras, as indicated by Mrs. Espinoza, representing Intercapital, through a letter dated September 13, 2010 addressed to the Executive Director of Golden Dawn.
The total quantity of Golden Shares that Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital referred as subscribed in favor of those five (05) clients and that coincides with the total quantity of shares that were subscribed in favor of the aforementioned director, appeared, at the end of the months of December 2010 and January 2011, in custody in an account in the name of Mr. Higueras at the foreign intermediary Raymond James, according to the account statements of those periods;
The above evidences the irregular action of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza by having allocated the funds of Intercapital's clients for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of a person other than them. The facts and documents that support this action are detailed in this resolution, in the evaluation of the intermediary's infraction;
Likewise, it should be noted that the cited facts and documents evidence that Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza acted irregularly since they did not respect the instructions of Intercapital's clients, improperly disposing of the funds delivered by them for the acquisition of Golden Shares;
In the operation developed, which had the objective of irregularly and improperly disposing of the funds of Intercapital's clients, the intentional, direct and preponderant participation of Mr. Higueras in the signing of the Confirmation Letters is observed, which indicate that funds were received from clients for the purchase of Golden Shares;
The direct participation of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza in the signing of the letters to Scotiabank is also observed, by which the transfer of the clients' funds to Golden Dawn from Intercapital's administrative account is ordered, which served for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Likewise, it should be added that Intercapital's Treasurer indicated that the clients acquiring Golden Shares abroad were contacted by Mr. Higueras and that he himself notified her when the deposits had been received, which reaffirms the direct participation of Mr. Higueras in this irregular conduct of disposal of the clients' funds;
B. Regarding the private placement process of Golden Shares, carried out in the month of April 2011.
According to the documentation obtained, Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, contacted several clients for the purchase of Golden Shares in the foreign market. Then, the clients deposited the money in Intercapital's accounts for the purchase of said shares;
Likewise, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital and Mrs. Espinoza, in her capacity as Operations Manager of Intercapital, signed letters by which they ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an Intercapital account to a Golden Dawn account;
Meanwhile, Mrs. Espinoza representing Intercapital signed a letter dated April 5, 2011 addressed to Golden Dawn in which she indicates to said company that the amounts of money transferred to Golden Dawn - which were transferred by order of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza - served for the purchase of shares in favor of two (02) clients, of which one of them did not contribute money for the aforementioned purchase operations and the other contributed an amount that was not enough to buy the quantity of shares that Intercapital acquired and subscribed in the name of said client;
Finally, Mr. Higueras signed the Confirmation Letters and other documents by which he stated to ten (10) clients, different from the two (02) clients indicated in the preceding recital, that he received money from them for the purchase of Golden Shares in the private placement process of these securities carried out in the month of April 2011,
Consequently, the participation of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza in the operability of the purchases of Golden Shares in the foreign market, as well as the proximity of dates and amounts of the clients' deposits with the dates and amounts of the money transfers to Golden Dawn ordered by Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, which will be explained below, indicates that Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza did not comply with the instructions of Intercapital's clients, which were the purchase of Golden Shares and on the contrary allocated the money provided by them for other different purposes, in this case for the purchase of the same shares but in favor of two persons different from those who delivered the money;
Indeed, the above reflects a conduct contrary to the securities market regulations and is supported, as already mentioned, by the fact that the amount of money that Intercapital received from ten (10) clients for an amount of US$ 474,368.00, between February 18 and April 4, 2011, with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, was mostly allocated to the money transfers that through Scotiabank Intercapital made in favor of Golden Dawn, by order of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza, for a total of US$ 439,850.00, between February 22 and April 4, 2011. With this amount, most of the 5,007,682 Golden Shares were acquired in favor of two (02) clients different from the ten (10) indicated (for 3,755,762 shares and 1,251,920 shares, respectively);
The above reflects the irregular and intentional action on the part of Mr. Higueras and Mrs. Espinoza by having disposed of the funds delivered by their clients and improperly allocating them for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of two (02) clients different from them. The facts and documents that support this conclusion have been detailed in the evaluation of the infraction that was formulated on the matter to Intercapital;
In this irregular operation, the direct and intentional participation of Mr. Higueras stands out from the moment the clients' funds are received. Indeed, according to what was declared by Intercapital's Treasurer, the aforementioned director contacted the clients for the purchase of Golden Shares and notified her when the clients' deposits had been made. The foregoing is reaffirmed by the fact that Mr. Higueras signed the Confirmation Letters that indicated the receipt of money from clients with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, as well as by the fact that he signed, together with Mrs. Espinoza, the letters by which Scotiabank was ordered the transfers of money from the administrative account to the Golden Dawn account, amounts that served for the purchase of shares in favor of other clients different from those who delivered the funds;
C. Regarding the purchases of Golden Shares in the secondary market through Raymond James
According to the documentation obtained in the Inspections, Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, contacted clients for the purchase of Golden Shares in the foreign market. Then, the clients deposited money in Intercapital's accounts for the purchase of said shares;
Likewise, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital and Ms. Espinoza, in her capacity as Operations Manager of Intercapital, signed letters by which they ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an Intercapital account to an account in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James, which was intended for the purchase of shares in the secondary market in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Finally, Mr. Higueras signed documents by which he confirmed to seven (07) clients that he received money from them for the purchase of Golden Shares;
Consequently, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Manager of Intercapital and Ms. Espinoza did not comply with the instructions of the clients of this intermediary, referring to the purchase of Golden Shares. On the contrary, they used the money delivered by these clients for a different purpose, such as the purchase of such shares but in favor of persons other than those who delivered the money;
As indicated in the corresponding section on Intercapital, the foregoing is supported by the following:
The amount of money that Intercapital received from seven (07) clients for an amount of US$ 157,688.53, between January 6 and May 6, 2011, with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, was mostly used for money transfers totaling US$ 146,195.00, ordered by Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, between January 7 and May 10, 2011, from Intercapital's accounts to the account in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James, for the purchase of Golden Shares.
The purchases of Golden Shares in January 2011 recorded in an account statement in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James coincide with the purchase confirmations that Intercapital communicated to its clients as acquisitions made in favor of the latter;
In this sense, the above demonstrates the irregular action by Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, who disposed of the funds delivered by Intercapital's clients for purposes other than the purchase of Golden Shares, since such funds were destined to the account in the name of Mr. Higueras. The facts and documents supporting this statement are extensively supported in the evaluation of Intercapital's infraction;
These facts again reflect the infringing conduct of Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, which consisted of disposing of client funds delivered for the purchase of Golden Shares. Mr. Higueras's direct participation in this infringing conduct is evidenced by the signing of the Confirmation Letters and the letters indicating the securities portfolios, which state that funds were received from clients for the purpose of acquiring Golden Shares, as well as by the signing of the letters by which he ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an Intercapital account to his account at Raymond James;
Therefore, the facts presented and the information and documentation indicated in the analysis of Intercapital's infraction support the intentional, inappropriate behavior of Mr. Higueras in the treatment and management of funds delivered by his clients for the purchase of Golden Shares, which reflects the breach of his main duties, in his capacity as General Manager of the intermediary, to respect the instructions of his clients and the due care of the funds delivered by them;
Thus, it is concluded that Mr. Higueras is responsible for disposing of client money for purposes other than those entrusted by them. Therefore, he has breached the provisions of Article 195, numeral a), of the LMV;
Regarding Ms. Espinoza
Of the regulations
According to the provisions of the cited Article 152 of the General Corporations Law, the direction or administration of a company is in charge of the board of directors and the Management;
Given her capacity as Operations Manager of Intercapital, since May 3, 2004, and as Director, since February 26, 2007, Ms. Espinoza is required to comply with the provisions governing the securities market;
Article 195 of the LMV establishes the list of prohibitions that brokerage firms are impeded from carrying out within the framework of their intermediation activities. In this regard, subsection a) of said article provides within such prohibitions the use of funds or securities received from their principals for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
The non-observance of the prohibition to use funds or securities for different purposes by Representatives and any person directly or indirectly related to the Intermediation Agent is sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1, of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it is a very serious infraction: "To use funds or securities received as a consequence of their intermediation activities for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
Regarding the Infraction detected
According to the information obtained in the Inspections, detailed in this resolution in the analysis of Intercapital's infraction regarding improper use of funds, it has been evidenced that Ms. Espinoza, due to her direct participation in the facts related to the intermediary's infraction, is responsible for the commission of the infraction referring to disposing of the funds delivered by Intercapital's clients for the purchase of Golden Shares to use them for the purchase of these same shares but in the name of persons other than the clients who entrusted their money;
In this sense, Ms. Espinoza's participation in the disposal of Intercapital's client funds for purposes other than those instructed by the clients is developed below;
A. Regarding the private placement process of Golden Shares carried out in September 2010.
In this private placement process of Golden Shares, Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, contacted Intercapital's clients for the purchase of the aforementioned shares in the foreign market. For this purpose, the clients deposited the money in Intercapital's accounts in order to buy said shares;
In this same process, Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, representing Intercapital, signed letters by which they ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an administrative account of Intercapital to a Golden Dawn account. The credits made in said account were transferred from Intercapital's operating account and from direct credits to it;
Meanwhile, Ms. Espinoza, representing Intercapital, signed a letter dated September 13, 2010 addressed to Golden Dawn in which she stated to said company that the amounts of money transferred to Golden Dawn - which were transferred by orders of Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza - served for the purchase of shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Finally, Mr. Higueras signed documents by which he confirmed to five (05) clients that he received money from them for the purchase of Golden Shares in the private placement process of these securities carried out in September 2010;
Consequently, the participation of Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras in the operation of the purchases of Golden Shares in the foreign market, as well as the coincidences of the amounts entered by the clients with the amounts that Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza ordered to transfer to Golden Dawn, indicate that Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras did not comply with the instructions of Intercapital's clients, relating to the purchase of Golden Shares and on the contrary used the funds provided by them for different purposes, in this case for the purchase of the same shares but in favor of Mr. Higueras.
Indeed, the above is supported by the following:
The amount of US$ 263,000.00 that Intercapital received from five (05) clients, between August 27 and September 9, 2010, with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, coincides with the amount that Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, as Managing Director and Operations Manager of Intercapital, respectively, ordered to transfer to Golden Dawn to complete the amount paid for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
There was a difference of US$ 12,000.00 to complete the US$ 275,000.00 that were used for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras, which was taken from a balance retained in Golden Dawn in the name of Intercapital. After that, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital stated that he received US$ 275,000.00 from the aforementioned five (05) clients, according to the sum of the shares recorded in the Confirmation Letters issued in favor of said clients.
The total amount of Golden Shares, which Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital referred to as subscribed in favor of those five (05) clients through Confirmation Letters, coincides with the total amount of shares that were subscribed in favor of Mr. Higueras, as indicated by Ms. Espinoza, representing Intercapital, through a letter dated September 13, 2010 addressed to the Executive Director of Golden Dawn.
The total amount of Golden Shares that Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital referred to as subscribed in favor of those five (05) clients and which coincides with the total amount of shares that have been subscribed in favor of the aforementioned director, appeared, at the end of December 2010 and January 2011, in custody in an account in the name of Mr. Higueras at the foreign intermediary Raymond James, according to the account statements of those periods;
The above evidences the irregular action of Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras in having used Intercapital's client funds for purposes other than those entrusted, that is, for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of a person other than them. The facts and documents supporting this action are detailed, in this resolution, in the evaluation of the intermediary's infraction;
Likewise, it should be noted that the cited facts and documents evidence that Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras acted irregularly because they did not respect the instructions of Intercapital's clients, improperly disposing of the funds delivered by them for the acquisition of Golden Shares;
Similarly, the direct participation of Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras in the signing of the letters to Scotiabank by which the transfer of client funds to Golden Dawn from Intercapital's administrative account is ordered, which served for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras, is observed;
Likewise, Ms. Espinoza participated in the signing of the letter by which she stated to Golden Dawn that the money credits transferred to this company's account from Intercapital's account, an amount that coincides with the money that the clients deposited in Intercapital's accounts, served for the subscription of 5,676,340 Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Therefore, Ms. Espinoza participated directly in the transfer of money entered by Intercapital's clients to the Golden Dawn account and was aware that these amounts would serve for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras, as stated by her to Golden Dawn in the letter of September 13, 2010, which implies a different use of the funds from those entrusted by the clients;
B. Regarding the private placement process of Golden Shares, carried out in April 2011.
According to the documentation obtained, Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, contacted several clients for the purchase of Golden Shares in the foreign market. Then, the clients deposited the money in Intercapital's accounts for the purchase of said shares;
Likewise, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital and Ms. Espinoza, in her capacity as Operations Manager of Intercapital, signed letters by which they ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an Intercapital account to a Golden Dawn account;
Meanwhile, Ms. Espinoza representing Intercapital signed a letter dated April 5, 2011 addressed to Golden Dawn in which she states to said company that the amounts of money transferred to Golden Dawn - which were transferred by order of Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza - served for the purchase of shares in favor of two (02) clients, of which one of them did not contribute money for the mentioned purchase operations and the other contributed an amount that was not enough to buy the number of shares that Intercapital acquired and subscribed in the name of said client;
Finally, Mr. Higueras signed Confirmation Letters and other documents by which he confirmed to ten (10) clients, different from the two (02) clients indicated in the preceding recital, that he received money from them for the purchase of Golden Shares in the private placement process of these securities carried out in April 2011;
Consequently, the participation of Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras in the operation of the purchases of Golden Shares in the foreign market, as well as the proximity of dates and amounts of the clients' deposits with the dates and amounts of the money transfers to Golden Dawn ordered by Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, which will be explained below, indicates that Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza did not comply with the instructions of Intercapital's clients, which were the purchase of Golden Shares and on the contrary used the money provided by them for other different purposes, in this case for the purchase of the same shares but in favor of two persons different from those who delivered the money;
Indeed, the above reflects conduct contrary to the rules of the securities market and is supported, as already mentioned, by the fact that the amount of money that Intercapital received from ten (10) clients for an amount of US$ 474,368.00, between February 18 and April 4, 2011, with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, was mostly used for money transfers that, through Scotiabank, Intercapital made in favor of Golden Dawn, by order of Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, for a total of US$ 439,850.00, between February 22 and April 4, 2011. With this amount, most of the 5,007,682 Golden Shares were acquired in favor of two (02) clients different from the ten (10) indicated (for 3,755,762 shares and 1,251,920 shares, respectively);
The above reflects the irregular and intentional action by Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras in having disposed of the funds delivered by ten (10) of their clients, and improperly using them for the purchase of Golden Shares in favor of two (02) clients different from them.
In this irregular operation, the direct participation of Ms. Espinoza in the signing of the letters by which Scotiabank was ordered the money transfers from the administrative account to the Golden Dawn account stands out, amounts that served for the purchase of shares in favor of other clients different from those who delivered the funds;
Likewise, it should be added that Ms. Espinoza signed the letter by which she stated to Golden Dawn that the deposits made served for the purchase of shares in favor of two (02) clients different from those who actually made the contributions for said purposes, which proves the knowledge that the aforementioned executive had of the operation carried out to make irregular use of client funds;
C. Regarding the purchases of Golden Shares in the secondary market through Raymond James
According to the documentation obtained in the Inspections, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital, contacted clients for the purchase of Golden Shares in the foreign market. Then, the clients deposited money in Intercapital's accounts for the purchase of said shares;
Likewise, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as Managing Director of Intercapital and Ms. Espinoza, in her capacity as Operations Manager of Intercapital, signed letters by which they ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an Intercapital account to an account in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James, which was intended for the purchase of shares in the secondary market in favor of Mr. Higueras;
Finally, Mr. Higueras signed documents by which he confirmed to seven (07) clients that he received money from them for the purchase of Golden Shares;
Consequently, Mr. Higueras in his capacity as General Manager of Intercapital and Ms. Espinoza as Operations Manager, did not comply with the instructions of the clients of this intermediary, referring to the purchase of Golden Shares. On the contrary, they used the money delivered by these clients for a different purpose, such as the purchase of such shares but in favor of persons different from those who delivered the money;
As indicated in the corresponding section on Intercapital, it should be noted that the foregoing is supported by the following:
The amount of money that Intercapital received from seven (07) clients for an amount of US$ 157,688.53, between January 6 and May 6, 2011, with the purpose of buying Golden Shares, was mostly used for money transfers totaling US$ 146,195.00, ordered by Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, between January 7 and May 10, 2011, from Intercapital's accounts to the account in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James, for the purchase of Golden Shares.
The purchases of Golden Shares in January 2011 recorded in an account statement in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James coincide with the purchase confirmations that Intercapital communicated to its clients as acquisitions made in favor of the latter;
In this sense, the above demonstrates the irregular action by Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras, who disposed of the funds delivered by Intercapital's clients for purposes other than the purchase of Golden Shares, since such funds were destined to the account in the name of Mr. Higueras. The facts and documents supporting this statement are extensively supported in the evaluation of Intercapital's infraction;
These facts again reflect the infringing conduct of Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, which consisted of disposing of client funds delivered for the purchase of Golden Shares. The direct participation of Ms. Espinoza in this infringing conduct is evidenced by the signing of the letters by which she ordered Scotiabank to transfer money from an Intercapital account to Mr. Higueras's account at Raymond James, which proves her participation in the transfer of money deposited by clients to an account in the name of a person other than the clients,
Of the defenses and arguments of the Administered
Ms. Espinoza presented her defenses on July 16, 2012 and, through her lawyer, made use of the word before this Deputy Superintendency on September 6, 2012. In her defense, she stated that the sanctionable type imputed requires the existence of objective elements, in this case that instructions have been received from clients, and that one acts differently from them, which is not observed in the participation of her person in the imputed facts, nor in the imputation of charges, nor in the statements of the persons required by the inspection commission. Thus, she indicates that the atypical nature of the imputed charge is evidenced. She also states that this is reflected in the fact that, since there is no regulatory responsibility attributable to her, legal responsibility provided in the General Corporations Law is forcibly and erroneously attributed to her;
Likewise, Ms. Espinoza states that her participation is reduced to the execution of acts proper to her function, and that since she did not receive instructions from clients, nor participated in communications with them, it is not possible to impute to her the fact that she acted against them. Furthermore, the reading of Article 190 of the General Corporations Law must be made in concordance with Articles 185 and 188 of the same, from which it follows that when the aforementioned law refers to the Manager, it is referring to the General Manager, so it is legally impossible to attribute responsibility derived from the General Corporations Law to her;
On the other hand, Ms. Espinoza states that with regard to Articles 152, 177 and 190 of the General Corporations Law, the attribution of responsibility due to her status as director of Intercapital is impracticable, since the entire review of facts considered infractions refers to her status as operations manager. She also specifies that it must be taken into account that according to Article 153 of the General Corporations Law, the Board of Directors is a collegiate body, that is, it exists as long as it expresses itself as a corporate body, in accordance with the requirements and formalities of law. Thus, except for the functions provided for the president in some statutes and in very few cases for the vice presidents, there is no possibility that a personal act be attributed to the status of director of a corporation. Even less if the directors, with the mentioned exceptions, only express themselves in a collegiate manner;
Evaluation of the discharges and arguments presented by Ms. Espinoza
In relation to the non-existence of objective elements:
With regard to the discharges referring to the non-existence of objective elements that allow linking Intercapital's conduct in the improper use of its clients' funds with the conduct of Ms. Espinoza in her capacity as Director and Operations Manager, the actions or omissions, it must be indicated that it has been verified that Intercapital improperly used its clients' funds, which were deposited in the accounts of said brokerage firm, whether administrative or operational. Such funds were used for the purchase of Golden Shares which, instead of being acquired in the name of the clients, were registered in the name of third parties, that is, the funds in question were used for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
The operation through which Intercapital improperly used its clients' funds for different purposes also resulted in the failure to observe a series of legal requirements established in the LMV and the RAI. Likewise, in the different activities that together materialized the improper use of funds for purposes other than those entrusted by the clients, Ms. Espinoza had an active participation, not only through the joint signing with Mr. Higueras of the communications ordering transfers of the funds deposited by the clients in Intercapital's operational and administrative accounts to the accounts of Golden Dawn and the one in the name of Mr. Higueras at Raymond James, but also in the knowledge that the Golden Shares acquired with those funds were in favor of Mr. Higueras.
Thus, Ms. Espinoza, in her capacity as Operations Manager, had the duty to know the origin of the funds involved in the brokerage activity of the brokerage firm and therefore knew that the funds deposited in Intercapital's administrative and operational accounts belonged to clients. Despite this, she signed the transfers of funds abroad and confirmed the allocation of these funds to the subscription or acquisition of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras. In this way, Ms. Espinoza's participation in using the funds delivered by Intercapital's clients for different purposes constitutes an express breach of the prohibition established in Article 195, paragraph a) of the LMV;
For this, it is not necessary that the person be the one who personally received the funds from the clients, but rather that they know that the funds within the sphere of control of the SAB, and consequently of its officers, originate from having been delivered by the clients of said intermediary for the purpose of carrying out operations. Likewise, using such funds for different purposes is configured by the knowledge that such funds belong to clients and that the destination of the same has no correlation with the orders received from such clients, as occurred in the present case by using such funds for operations in favor of Mr. Higueras, a fact that was within Ms. Espinoza's knowledge;
In the previous framework, it must be specified that the prohibition established in literal a) of Article 195 of the LMV is a prohibition referring to the conduct of the brokerage firm and its officers, since it is to this firm that clients deliver the funds (which are deposited in its respective bank accounts) and securities, and not to its officers personally. It should be noted that the officers or representatives of a firm act on behalf of the legal entity, which is why the breach of the prohibition in question is attributed not only to Intercapital but also to Ms. Espinoza and Mr. Higueras, given their conduct as representatives of Intercapital in the process of purchasing Golden Shares;
In this sense, the argument referring to the fact that, given the non-requirement of orders from Intercapital's clients in accordance with the LMV and the RAI, there is no infraction on the part of said intermediary and therefore on the part of its representatives, understood as Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, regarding the charge of improper use of funds, is not admissible, since that would mean that the funds received could be used for any purpose for the benefit of the intermediary or third parties other than the clients who provided such funds;
On the other hand, it is appropriate to note that Ms. Espinoza's participation in the acquisition of the Golden Shares is corroborated by the Confirmation Letters and the money transfer letters to Scotiabank and letters addressed to Golden Dawn (the latter two signed by Ms. Espinoza), which support the improper use of Intercapital's clients' funds, which has already been extensively explained throughout this resolution;
The documents signed by Ms. Espinoza are summarized below:
Letters requesting money transfers from Intercapital to Scotiabank.- Letters of August 27, September 3 and 9, 2010, by which Scotiabank was ordered to make money transfers to the Golden Dawn account at the Bank of Montreal of Canada from Intercapital's administrative account at Scotiabank, current account Dollars No. 000-3047787.
Letter of subscription of Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras.- Letter of September 13, 2010 signed by Ms. Espinoza and addressed to the Executive Director of Golden Dawn, by which Intercapital sent to said company the Subscription Agreement in favor of its client, Mr. Higueras, for the amount of 5,676,340 Golden Shares at $0.05 per share.
Letters requesting money transfers from Intercapital to Scotiabank.- By letters from February 22 to April 4, 2011, in which Intercapital orders Scotiabank to make money transfers to the Golden Dawn account at the Bank of Montreal of Canada charged to the administrative account.
Letters of subscription of shares in favor of two (02) clients.- Letter of April 5, 2011, signed by Ms. Espinoza and addressed to the Financial Director of Golden Dawn, Intercapital indicates that it attaches the share subscription forms in favor of two (02) clients, one for 3,755,762, and another for 1,251,920 shares, for a total of CAD 425,652.97 (Canadian Dollars). Likewise, as indicated above, one of said clients did not contribute money for the acquisition of said shares and the other contributed an amount that was not enough to buy the number of shares that Intercapital acquired and subscribed in the name of said client.
Letters requesting money transfers from Intercapital to Scotiabank.- By letters issued between January 7 and May 10, 2011, signed by Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza, Intercapital ordered Scotiabank to make money transfers to the Raymond James account at the Royal Bank of Canada from the administrative account. The beneficiary of the credit at Raymond James is Mr. Higueras with his account number 1B5 SZ0B 0;
In relation to the non-receipt of instructions
Ms. Espinoza states that her participation in the imputed facts was circumstantial based on the position she held and given that she did not receive instructions from the clients, it is impossible to impute that she acted contrary; In this regard, it must be specified that the charges formulated do not focus or have referred to Ms. Espinoza being the one who personally received the instructions or orders from Intercapital's clients;
In the present case, Intercapital received funds from its clients to carry out certain operations and Ms. Espinoza, as Operations Manager, had the obligation to ensure the execution of using said funds as ordered by its clients;
In this sense, her participation in the processes of acquisition of Golden Shares evidenced by the aforementioned letters signed by her, accredit her participation in the imputed charge, that is, using funds for different purposes;
Likewise, it is important to specify that what has been stated above is that it was Intercapital who received such funds and that both Mr. Higueras and Ms. Espinoza participated in the improper use of these;
In this way, Ms. Espinoza's participation is part of a sequence of interrelated facts explained throughout this resolution, and in which not having received the instructions from the clients directly does not constitute an exonerating element;
Additionally, it is appropriate to recall that Ms. Espinoza, in her capacity as Operations Manager, knew that the transfers of significant amounts of money from the intermediary's accounts to accounts of companies and intermediaries abroad came from clients and were destined for operations of purchase of securities abroad and that the destination of the funds had to be executed as ordered;
In this way, the allocation of shares was made with the letters signed by Ms. Espinoza addressed to Golden Dawn with the indication of which clients were the holders of the securities acquired with the funds that she herself ordered to transfer; therefore, she knew that such shares should correspond to persons who actually delivered money for these operations and that shares were not bought in favor of other clients, as occurred in this case;
It is important to highlight likewise that Ms. Espinoza, by reason of her function, knew and had control of the entire operational flow that involved the acquisition of Golden Shares, especially since these were operations with securities issued abroad that are subject to special regulation and supervision regime as provided by Article 37 and following of the RAI;
Likewise, it is appropriate to note that Ms. Espinoza as Operations Manager of a brokerage firm must ensure compliance with the regulatory prohibition established in Article 195, literal a), of the LMV;
In relation to her status as Director and the nature of the Board of Directors
With regard to the discharges referring to the fact that the legal responsibility established in Articles 152, 177 and 190 of the General Corporations Law cannot be attributed to Ms. Espinoza, since the imputed facts refer to her conduct as Operations Manager and not as Director, it must be indicated that the referred legal norms specify the organs on which the administration of a corporation falls and what is the degree of responsibility of these before the company itself and in particular to third parties;
Indeed, the mandate theory contained in Article 152 of the General Corporations Law is aimed at demonstrating that, in addition to justifying the conduct of administrators before third parties in the interest of a patrimony alien to them, it is a guarantee for these third parties that any commercial operation concluded with them also binds the company they represent;
In this sense, what has been imputed as a charge to Ms. Espinoza is having participated in the operation aimed at committing the infraction and having signed various documentation in her capacity as Operations Manager and also exercising the position of Director of Intercapital, regardless of whether or not she had delegation from the Board of Directors of said brokerage firm;
Likewise, it must be indicated that the exclusively collegiate conduct of the Board of Directors invoked by Ms. Espinoza seeks to dilute her responsibility by alleging that, being a collegiate conduct, only the decisions that appear in agreements and not others are attributable to the board. This would be denying responsibility before the company and third parties as well as for the actions they carry out by agreements or by statutory or legal mandate. In this sense, the responsibility of directors is clear and this is corroborated by the fact that directors can individually exempt themselves from this responsibility in the cases provided in Article 178 of the General Corporations Law;
In this way, the imputation made to Ms. Espinoza for her participation in the improper use of client funds has been formulated taking into account the functions she exercised at Intercapital, by reason of the positions she held and that she herself invoked at the time of signing various documentation (Director and Operations Manager). Within this context, she participated in the acquisition of Golden Shares, that is, by signing the documents indicated in the preceding recitals which she signed as Director and Manager of Intercapital. The specific fact observed is that her participation in the facts was made on behalf of Intercapital and that such conduct or exercise of functions has not been discussed or left without effect subsequently by the brokerage firm itself;
In relation to the scope of the term "Manager"
With regard to the argument referring to the fact that the provisions of the LGS referring to managers are only circumscribed to the general manager, so that no responsibility derived from said law could be attributed to other managers, it must be specified that Article 152 of the cited General Law refers to one or several managers of the company and that the express mention of the general manager provided in Article 188 of the LGS is only to grant a presumption regarding certain powers unless otherwise agreed by corporate agreement. In this way, it is not possible to maintain that the reference to manager in various articles of the LGS is only limited to the general manager, since the contrary would imply recognizing that any other person with the position of manager would be exempt from any responsibility not only before third parties but also before the company itself;
For the foregoing, the arguments expressed by Ms. Espinoza have not dismissed the charges imputed regarding the non-observance of the provisions of Article 195 paragraph a) of the LMV;
Consequently, after the evaluation of the facts presented and the discharges presented, as well as the information and documentation indicated in the analysis of Intercapital's infraction, it is observed that Ms. Espinoza had an intentional and inadequate behavior in the treatment and management of the funds delivered by Intercapital's clients for the purchase of Golden Shares, and consequently, in her capacity as Operations Manager of the intermediary, she breached the duties of respecting the instructions of its clients and the due care of the funds delivered by them;
In this way, it is concluded that Ms. Espinoza has responsibility in the disposition of the clients' money to use it for purposes other than those entrusted by them. Therefore, she has breached the provisions of Article 195, numeral a), of the LMV;
IV. Evaluation of the sanction
i) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, paragraph 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a serious nature "Not complying with what is specifically provided by the SMV, in the exercise of its functions";
ii) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Using funds or securities received as a consequence of its brokerage activities for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
iii) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 1, paragraph 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Presenting to CONASEV, the Exchange, the Products Exchange, the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, the investor and in general any other subject of the securities or products market, inaccurate, false or tendentious information; or disclosing such information in the market (...)";
iv) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations";
v) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Providing its clients with false and inaccurate information, or allowing or facilitating third parties to provide false or inaccurate information to the detriment of its clients";
vi) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, paragraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a serious nature: "Using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations or for purposes other than the corresponding one";
vii) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, paragraph 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a serious nature: "Not having manuals, procedures, policies or internal control system, in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations; or not complying with its provisions or not supervising its compliance";
viii) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, paragraph 3.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a minor nature: "Not registering its clients in the corresponding client registration file";
ix) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, paragraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a minor nature: "Not collecting orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene";
x) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, paragraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a minor nature: "Not Communicating Relevant Facts, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations";
xi) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, paragraph 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a serious nature: "Denying or delaying the delivery of books, documents and other information required by the SMV during inspections or investigations, not granting the facilities that the SMV requests in the execution of the supervision and control actions it orders; as well as presenting documentation for the purpose of delaying the procedure, or in any other way obstructing the supervision and control actions";
xii) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, paragraph 2.8 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a serious nature: "Not carrying out with the periodicity established in the regulations, the calculation of liquidity and solvency indicators, as well as the limit per activity";
xiii) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations";
xiv) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, paragraph 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a serious nature: "not presenting to SMV, the Exchange, the Products Exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism, the investor and in general any other Participant of the securities or products market, financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru, the technical pronouncements issued by the country's accounting profession, accounting standards established by the supervision and control bodies and the norms contained in the Financial Information Regulations",
xv) That Intercapital incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Not constituting guarantees, not replacing them or not updating them, in the form, amount, term and conditions that the regulations establish for each case";
xvi) That Mr. Higueras incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Using funds or securities received as a consequence of its brokerage activities for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
xvii) That Mr. Higueras incurred in the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 1, paragraph 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Presenting to CONASEV, the Exchange, the Products Exchange, the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, the investor and in general any other subject of the securities or products market, inaccurate, false or tendentious information; or disclosing such information in the market (...)";
xviii) That Ms. Espinoza incurred in the infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, paragraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, which describes as an infraction of a very serious nature: "Using funds or securities received as a consequence of its brokerage activities for operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
With regard to the evaluation of the sanctions to be imposed for the infractions committed by Intercapital, it must be noted that Intercapital's operating authorization was revoked by Superintendency Resolution No. 090-2012-SMV/02 of July 20, 2012 in exercise of the attribution contained in numeral 14 of Article 3 of the Single Ordered Text of the Organic Law of the SMV, Legislative Decree No. 26126 and its amendments;
However, the foregoing does not prevent the SMV from imposing sanctions on a legal entity for acts committed during the validity of its operating authorization or on natural persons who, acting on its behalf, may have committed an infraction, even when the operating authorization of that legal entity has been revoked or cancelled. This is because the SMV's authority to impose sanctions is determined fundamentally by subject matter, if the conduct and infractions imputed are materially within the SMV's competence; and by timing, it being necessary to observe that the alleged infractions were committed during the period in which the company was under the control and supervision of the SMV and before the authorization of the brokerage firm was revoked and that the statute of limitations has not expired;
In addition to the foregoing, it should be noted that according to Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, the imposition of a sanction by the SMV on an offender is recorded as a prior record and constitutes a criterion to be taken into consideration in the event of future infractions. In line with the foregoing, Article 1 of Law No. 29660, the Law establishing measures to sanction price manipulation in the securities market, establishes that persons who exercise direct or indirect control, management or representation of persons authorized by the SMV to act in the securities market, products market and collective funds must not have been sanctioned for serious or very serious infractions related to those markets;
From the foregoing it follows that, unlike the revocation of an operating authorization as a consequence of a sanctioning procedure, the revocation ordered in exercise of the authority indicated in numeral 17 of the recitals does not generate accessory effects such as the recording of a prior record and the impossibility of participating in the securities market under the terms set forth in Law No. 29660, which is indeed observed in the case of the imposition of a sanction;
Consequently, it is possible to impose a sanction on Intercapital for acts committed during the validity of its operating authorization even when, at the date of imposition of the sanction, that company does not have a valid operating authorization;
With respect to the criteria to be taken into account for imposing the sanction, we must note that Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in Article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of Article 230 of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the offender's contribution to its clarification and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in Article 236-A of the LPAG;
Within this framework, the assessment of the sanction must consider a) Prior records of the offenders; b) The seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or the protected legal interest, included within the LMV criterion referring to the repercussion on the market of the harm caused; c) The harm caused, whether economic or of another nature; d) Repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegal benefit obtained; g) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct; h) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification; i) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to notification of the corresponding charges; and j) Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
a) Prior records of the offenders
In accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time the events occurred[9], sanctions imposed during the three (03) years prior to the date on which the infraction was detected are considered prior records of the offender. Likewise, that provision states that until the resolution imposing the sanction becomes final, it shall not be considered a prior record;
In the case of the infraction referring to non-compliance with the provisions of RTA Resolution, Intercapital has a prior sanction record, in view of the sanction imposed through CONASEV Resolution No. 019-2010-EF/94.01.1 dated February 4, 2010, for having incurred two (02) serious infractions, classified in numerals 1.1 and 2.12 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation;
As for the other infractions analyzed in this Resolution, Intercapital has two prior sanction records, (i) the one corresponding to CONASEV Resolution No. 019-2010-EF/94.01.1 and (ii) the one corresponding to the sanction imposed through Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal No. 250-2010-EF/94.01.3 of August 19, 2010, which was appealed and resolved by the Board of Directors of this institution through CONASEV Resolution No. 047-2011-EF/94.01.1 dated June 17, 2011, for having incurred one (01) serious infraction, classified in numeral 2.12 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation;
As for Messrs. Higueras and Espinoza, it should be noted that both persons have no prior sanction records according to the aforementioned regulations;
b) The seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or the protected legal interest, included within the LMV criterion referring to the repercussion on the market of the harm caused
In the case of the disposition of money or securities owned by clients, the irregular conduct of Intercapital and Messrs. Higueras and Espinoza affected investor confidence in the functioning of the Securities Market, because the investor turns to the intermediary granting it the confidence that its money will be safeguarded and used according to its instructions; therefore, if the funds are used for purposes other than those instructed, confidence in the conduct of brokerage agents, who are important actors in the Securities Market, is diminished;
As for the infraction referring to the presentation of false and inaccurate information to this Superintendency, it reveals that Mr. Higueras, in his capacity as General Manager, and Intercapital, by incorporating economic and financial facts into its accounting records in a manner different from the reality of the brokerage company, has the consequence that the financial statements of that intermediary as of September 30, 2011 reflect distorted values in its balance sheet;
Indeed, the dissemination of distorted balances in the financial statements can mislead users of financial information, in particular potential investors seeking to choose a brokerage firm that has the necessary solvency to intermediate their operations in the securities market, and affects the SMV's supervision objectives aimed at preventing risks generated by specific agents in the market as well as the eventual impact on other participants;
Thus, Intercapital's conduct affects the principle of transparency of the securities market, a legal interest recognized in Title II of Chapter I of the LMV. Likewise, by failing to comply with the provisions of the Financial Information Regulation and the Conceptual Framework, the confidence of clients (actual and potential) was also affected, as they validly assume that the financial information presented by that brokerage company complies with the applicable regulatory and accounting provisions. The latter, in turn, negatively affects the integrity of the securities market;
Likewise, intermediating securities without complying with the requirements established by the regulations, providing false and inaccurate information, not registering its clients in the corresponding registration file, not collecting orders from the latter, all in the particular case of the foreign purchase of Golden Shares, reflects the irregular and informal conduct of Intercapital and unfair behavior against its clients, which undermines the principle of transparency in the execution of operations in the securities market, also taking into account that every brokerage firm must comply with the rules governing the exercise of its activities, in order to promote the best interests of its clients and the integrity of the market;
On the other hand, Intercapital has violated the principle of transparency by using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations, that is, it acquired securities abroad through two intermediaries, Lek Securities and Raymond James, for the acquisition of Golden Shares using global accounts for such purposes; however, to date it has not shown the corresponding records that would allow identification of the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in those accounts, which also directly affects the transparency with which brokerage firms must act;
Likewise, Intercapital's lack of transparency in its conduct as intermediary in the acquisition of Golden Shares is confirmed by its not having in its Operating Procedures Manual a specific section including the minimum content requirements regarding its participation in the intermediation of securities traded abroad, as required by the RAI;
On the other hand, Intercapital, through its conduct, has generated harm to the public interest by hindering the SMV's supervision work, since by not having carried out the daily calculation of its positions in accounts abroad, it sought to prevent the SMV from knowing Intercapital's situation with respect to the limits established by the RAI, limiting the effectiveness of its supervisory actions;
Regarding the lack of timely communication of relevant events referring to the communication of the execution of contracts with foreign entities and the resignation of Intercapital's Internal Control Officer, it should be noted that this affects the public interest because a duty was breached that affects the regulator's supervision work, depriving it of information necessary for effective control of the intermediary agent's activities. At the same time, it affected information transparency by violating the framework that allows adequate protection for investors who decide to invest abroad through these entities with which Intercapital contracts, since they did not know exactly the terms of the contract binding that brokerage company with the foreign intermediary and will not be able to make a correct risk assessment regarding investing through these foreign agents;
Likewise, the fact that the person responsible for the internal control system resigned and this was not timely reported to the SMV, nor were the necessary measures adopted to ensure the continuity of internal control work, generated a risk in the internal oversight of the brokerage company that could potentially affect Intercapital's clients;
As for the fact that Intercapital did not timely update the amount of its guarantee, this generates harm to the market and investors, since it creates a lack of protection for them, especially considering that Intercapital had been in equity deficit since September 2011, and its equity would not be sufficient to cover obligations incurred mainly in the securities market and with third parties entitled in the event of liquidation;
On the other hand, the fact that Intercapital did not comply with the mandate issued by the SMV through RTA Resolution, in which it was ordered to adjust its financial information so that it reflects the financial reality of that company, constitutes harm to market transparency, since financial information delivered to the supervisor and disseminated to the public lacked support and did not reflect the company's reality vis-à-vis its clients and the general public;
Thus, Intercapital, by not having made adjustments to its financial information without observing the applicable international accounting standards as ordered by RTA Resolution, caused the market to access information that does not reflect the financial reality of that company. This, in turn, means that clients or potential clients of a brokerage firm did not have the necessary and sufficient elements of judgment to decide whether to engage that brokerage firm as intermediary in their operations;
c) The harm caused, whether economic or of another nature
Because Intercapital and Messrs. Higueras and Espinoza did not comply with their clients' instructions for the purchase of Golden Shares and used the funds delivered by them for purposes other than those instructed, a risk and eventual harm has been generated for those clients to the extent that those securities were registered in the name of third parties;
Likewise, intermediating securities without complying with the requirements established by the regulations, providing false and inaccurate information to its clients, not registering them in the corresponding registration file, not collecting orders from the latter, all in the particular case of the foreign purchase of Golden Shares, also constitutes harm against them since they traded without having the necessary information for the proper adoption of their investment decisions, which becomes more relevant in the case of securities purchase operations in markets outside the scope of the SMV's supervision;
Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be noted that to date no complaints have been reported regarding the return of securities or money or other irregular conduct against Intercapital;
As for the infraction referring to the presentation of false financial information, it is observed that harm has been generated both to the market and to Intercapital's clients (actual and potential), to the extent that the company managed by its General Manager altered its financial information, recording the Golden Shares as its own securities, notwithstanding that they had been acquired with funds provided by its own clients. Thus, the false information provided by Intercapital through its financial statements concealed the company's real financial situation;
Regarding non-compliance with the provisions of RTA Resolution, no economic harm has been evidenced;
d) Repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction
e) Circumstances of the commission of the infraction
As for the circumstances in which the events occurred, we must note that the Golden Shares purchase operations, through which the infraction referring to the destination of funds was configured, were executed within the framework of two private placements of shares issued by the company Golden Dawn and purchases in the secondary market. In these operations, Intercapital, through Mr. Higueras, contacted investors so that they would buy shares of the aforementioned mining company, efforts in which there is supposed to be an interaction between clients and the brokerage firm to learn the advantages and disadvantages of participating in an operation of this nature and to make an adequate investment decision;
After receiving the clients' instructions and the funds delivered by them, Intercapital, through Mr. Higueras or Ms. Espinoza, delivered letters confirming the purchase of Golden Shares, but they were misled because these shares had not been purchased for them, but for third parties who had not delivered money for these operations. Likewise, letters were sent to the issuer of the securities indicating the names of the purchasers of the shares, who were persons different from those who had delivered the money;
The foregoing is consistent with Intercapital's conduct in relation to non-compliance with the other obligations generated by the purchase of Golden Shares, that is, intermediating securities without complying with the requirements established by the regulations, providing false and inaccurate information to its clients, not registering them in the corresponding registration file, not collecting orders from the latter, using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations, not having an exclusive section dedicated to foreign operations in its Operating Procedures Manual, in addition to the failure to communicate as a relevant event the execution of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties, as was the case of the foreign intermediaries MF Global Inc., Raymond James and Lek Securities;
For the foregoing reasons, the process and obligations generated by the foreign purchase of Golden Shares evidence a deliberate irregular and informal conduct by Intercapital, even though it entailed non-compliance with several provisions regulating the intermediation of securities traded abroad, and unfair behavior against its clients, all of which had as its main objective to benefit Mr. Higueras and two other persons, different from those who contributed the funds for such purchases;
Finally, a sequence of improper actions by Intercapital is observed, tending to harm investors who had placed their trust in the transparency of the private placements of Golden Shares and the purchases of these securities in the secondary market;
On the other hand, according to the information found in the framework of the Inspections carried out on Intercapital, it was corroborated that said entity had been carrying out purchase and sale operations of Golden Shares between January and May 2011, which were being carried out with money from Intercapital's clients. Without prejudice to this, it should be noted that the entry of those funds into the company's accounts had been recorded under the concept of "Loans to Shareholders" and the aforementioned Golden Shares had been recorded as owned by Intercapital when in reality they corresponded to its clients;
Likewise, from the statements given by Intercapital's treasurer and accountant, it is established that the company knew it was improperly recording the acquisition of the Golden Shares and that the company had an operation to make such records;
Similarly, Intercapital has omitted to perform and report the calculation of the position limit in foreign accounts referred to in Article 116 of the RAI, with which it sought to prevent the SMV from supervising and controlling the activities carried out by this brokerage agent in the foreign market, in order to be able to carry out operations in these markets with greater flexibility and without the legal requirements and thus avoid supervision by the SMV over the dispositions of funds it had been making against its clients;
As for non-compliance with RTA Resolution, it should be recalled that said resolution required Intercapital to make an adjustment to its Interim Financial Statements and its Annual Audited Financial Statements, both as of December 31, 2009. It should be noted that said decision was appealed, being confirmed by virtue of CONASEV Resolution No. 047-2011-EF/94.01.1, exhausting the administrative remedy;
In order to comply with RTA Resolution, Official Letters Nos. 3112-2011-EF/94.06.1 of July 20, 2011, 3257-2011-EF/94.06.1 of July 27, 2011 and 3365-2011-EF/94.06.1 of August 8, 2011 were sent to Intercapital, reiterating to said brokerage company that it comply with making the corresponding adjustment to its Financial Statements. Despite the repeated requirements, Intercapital did not comply with making the modification of its financial information;
f) The illegal benefit obtained
From the foregoing, it has not been possible to evidence that Intercapital obtained an economic benefit with respect to the infraction referring to the destination of funds received from its clients for operations or purposes other than those entrusted to it;
In the particular case of Mr. Higueras, it should be noted that he obtained a benefit materialized in the registration of the Golden Shares issued in his favor, which were acquired with the money of Intercapital's clients;
In the case of Ms. Espinoza, no economic benefit has been evidenced as a result of her actions in this case;
Regarding the other infractions mentioned in this resolution, it should be noted that it has not been evidenced that in committing said infractions Intercapital obtained any economic benefit. However, by not providing transparent information to the supervisor, it hindered the detection of a situation of non-compliance and postponed the adoption of prudential measures against it in its capacity as brokerage agent, both for incurring a situation of undisclosed equity deficit and for carrying out operations in the foreign market without complying with the regulatory requirements;
As for non-compliance with the provisions of RTA Resolution, Intercapital's continued refusal to comply with the order of Article 3 of said resolution, which provided for the adjustment of the interim and audited financial statements as of December 31, 2009, allowed it to attempt to delay incurring an equity deficit and therefore continue operating without correcting its financial information with the adjustments ordered by RTA Resolution, from that date until September 19, 2011, the date on which the SMV ordered the ex officio adjustment of said financial information;
Likewise, Intercapital — by presenting financial information that was not real — avoided incurring costs associated with a capital increase that would allow it to comply with the minimum capital requirements demanded by the applicable regulations;
g) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct
Regarding the infraction for improper use of funds, it is considered that the infraction committed by Intercapital is at the level of willful misconduct, since the disposal of funds was configured through the use of its clients' money to buy Golden Shares in favor of Mr. Higueras and third parties;
As has been pointed out, Intercapital disposed of its principals' money to buy Golden Shares in favor of its general manager, Mr. Higueras, and he, in his capacity as general manager, ignored all the requirements established in the LMV and in the RAI to participate in the intermediation of these securities abroad, that is, providing false and inaccurate information to its clients, not registering them in the corresponding registration card, not collecting orders from the latter, using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations, not having an exclusive section dedicated to operations abroad in its Manual of Operating Procedures, added to the failure to communicate as a relevant fact the execution of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties, among others;
This reflects that Intercapital's conduct was systematic and intentional, as described in the preceding recitals, since it willfully breached the provisions of the regulations and hindered the SMV's supervision work;
Likewise, it has been evidenced by the statements of Intercapital's accountant and treasurer that appear in the Documentary Collection Record that Mr. Higueras's conduct was clearly intentional;
It is worth highlighting the statement of the treasurer, who indicated that "(…) the operation of these transactions began when Mr. Higueras notified her about the deposits made by clients contacted by him for the purchase of Golden Shares abroad and that upon confirming the credits in the bank accounts, she issued the income receipt for the concept of 'Shareholder Loan…';
The foregoing shows that Intercapital and Mr. Higueras knew in detail the irregular record they were keeping and, additionally, that such records were made systematically;
Regarding the particular actions of Mrs. Espinoza, it must be indicated that her intentionality in the infraction of improper use of funds has also been proven, since, in her capacity as Operations Manager, she had within her sphere of control and collaboration the knowledge of these operations and the responsibility to prevent them, especially if it was evident that the requirements established by the regulations mentioned in this resolution were not being observed, especially the one referring to the destination of funds delivered by the intermediary's clients;
In this sense, the joint action with Mr. Higueras in several of the actions that constituted infractions of the regulations is an essential element in determining the degree of responsibility of Mrs. Espinoza in the acts incurred;
On the other hand, the intentionality related to the falsity of the financial information provided by Mr. Higueras as Managing Director of Intercapital to the SMV is also proven through the statements of the representatives of said entity (in particular, in the statement of the treasurer, as recorded in Annex D of the Documentary Collection Record), from which it can be maintained that the modifications to the financial information did not correspond to the economic and financial facts that actually occurred in the entity, nor to the conditions in which it operated;
Regarding the breach of the provisions of Resolution RTA, it is considered that Intercapital's conduct was intentional, to the extent that there was an express mandate ordering it to adjust its Interim Monthly Financial Statements and its Audited Financial Statements, both closed as of December 31, 2009. Additionally, the requirement contained in said resolution has been reiterated through various official letters issued by the SMV, as recorded in this Resolution;
According to the provisions of Resolution RTA and the aforementioned official letters, Intercapital knew exactly what the obligation it had to comply with consisted of. However, Intercapital did not express any interest in reversing or remedying the situation of non-compliance in which it had incurred;
h) Voluntary declaration of the commission of infractions and the contribution of the offenders to their clarification
i) Voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 235
j) Error induced by the administration by a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision
In the present case, it has not been evidenced that the infractions imputed as charges were generated by error induced by the administration by a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
Finally, it must be noted that because there are several infractions committed by Intercapital in accordance with the provisions of article 15[10] of the Sanctions Regulations, the sanction for the most serious infraction must be imposed;
That in accordance with article 342 of the LMV, the persons included within the scope of application of said law who incur infractions to its provisions and to the general provisions issued by the SMV are subject to sanction by the SMV; in this sense, it corresponds to sanction Intercapital and Messrs. Higueras or Espinoza for the actions that constitute infractions and that were carried out during the period of validity of the operating authorization of said intermediary;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
It is Resolved:
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature, typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for allocating the funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature, typified in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for presenting inaccurate or false information to the SMV and to the investor.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in two infractions of a very serious nature, typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations, referring to intermediating securities in the foreign market without signing a contract with each of its clients who wish to have this type of operations intermediated and to not obtaining the declaration of the buyer client of financial instruments referred to in article 36 of the RAI.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for providing false and inaccurate information to its clients.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not updating the amount of its guarantee within the established term.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not having a specific section in its manual that includes the minimum content requirements regarding the agent's participation in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not allowing the inspection of its books, records and operations by the SMV and for carrying out actions that hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of the SMV.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.8 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not calculating the position limit in foreign accounts and not informing the SMV thereof.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for presenting to the SMV financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in a minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not registering its clients who bought Golden Shares in the corresponding client registration card.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in a minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not collecting orders from its clients.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in a minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not communicating the relevant facts referring to informing late the resignation of its Internal Control Officer and for not communicating the execution and termination of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties.
To declare that Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not complying with the provisions specifically established by the SMV in the exercise of its functions.
To declare that Mr. Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortes has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for allocating funds or securities received from its principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
To declare that Mr. Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortes has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.4 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for not complying with sending transparent accounting and financial information to the SMV.
To declare that Mrs. Carmen Espinoza Vargas has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, for allocating funds or securities received from its principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
To sanction Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. with the revocation of its operating authorization for the very serious infractions mentioned in articles 1 to 5 of this resolution.
To sanction Mr. Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortes with a disqualification for five (05) years from exercising activities linked to the securities market or that require authorization from the SMV, for the commission of the infractions mentioned in articles 15 and 16 of this resolution.
To sanction Mrs. Carmen Espinoza Vargas with a disqualification for three (03) years from exercising activities linked to the securities market or that require authorization from the SMV, for the commission of the infraction mentioned in article 17 of this resolution.
Considering that the operating authorization of Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is revoked in accordance with the provisions of Superintendency Resolution No. 090-2012-SMV/02 of July 20, 2012, the provisions of article 18 of this resolution shall take effect as of the date, with respect to the accessory effects resulting from the imposition of a very serious sanction.
This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration appeal or before the Superintendent of the Securities Market by filing an appeal submitted to the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
In the event that this resolution is not challenged by reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 3 of the Rules relating to the publication and dissemination of resolutions issued by the decision-making bodies of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 073-2004-EF/94.10, and by the provisions of article 10 A of the Sanctions Regulations.
To transcribe this resolution to Intercapital Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., to Mr. Ernesto Federico Higueras Cortes, to Mrs. Carmen Espinoza Vargas, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register and communicate.
[pic]
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
[1] In accordance with the provisions of article 1 of CONASEV Resolution No. 102-2010-EF/94.10; a norm that "Regulates Full Application of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)", intermediation agents must prepare their financial statements in full observance of the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), issued by the International Accounting Standards Board, internationally in force.
[2] On folio 23 of the Treasury file "Golden Dawn Minerals Inc." of Intercapital. Such information was recorded in the Documentary Collection Record in Table No. 5 entitled: "Sending of Funds to Intercapital SAB by its clients, for the acquisition of Golden Shares" (page 7 of Annex A).
[3] Through the referred numeral, the following was requested: "Supporting documentation of the operations intermediated by Intercapital outside centralized negotiation mechanisms, indicated in Annex No. 2 (orders, sworn declarations of buyer clients according to the provisions of article 36 of the RAI, policies, vouchers, receipts, settlement documents and control report of the financial instruments under custody)".
[4] They group the subdivision accounts that represent credits originating from intermediation operations, purchase and sale of securities on behalf of third parties and own account.
[5] It should be noted that the recognition of the amount corresponding to the Promissory Notes should have been evaluated by the general management of Intercapital. Since the Promissory Notes matured in the months of July, August and September of 2009, it is reasonable to consider that the recognition of the liability should have been made in the financial information corresponding to the year 2010. Likewise, since the debt remained unpaid during 2011, it should also have been recognized in the financial information of that period. Thus, the provisions of the Conceptual Framework in force for each of those periods are applicable, which maintain identical wording in the cited paragraphs. [6] Circular No. 001-2012-SMV/10.2 (…) In the event that your represented entity has a current guarantee constituted for an amount less than the minimum indicated, Intercapital must adopt the pertinent measures so that within a term not exceeding fifteen (15) days counted from the date of notification of this document, CONASEV has a Guarantee in its favor that is not less than S/. 727,745. [7] According to subsection o) of article 4 of the Sanctions Regulations, a participant is understood as natural or legal persons who directly or indirectly participate in the Securities Market (…). [8] Information presented on November 8, 2011. [9] Which is applicable taking into account the provisions of the Principle of Non-Retroactivity contained in numeral 5 of article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered party incurred the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable to it. It should be noted that article 17 of the Sanctions Regulations has been modified through SMV Resolution No. 006-2012/SMV.10.1, which provides that sanctions imposed by the SMV and that have become final within four years prior to the commission of the infraction are considered antecedents. Consequently, article 17 of the Sanctions Regulations that was in force at the time of the events is applicable since it is the most beneficial scenario for the administered party. [10] Article 15.- Concurrence of Infractions.- In the case of concurrence of infractions, the provisions of numeral 6 of article 230 of the Procedure Law apply. Likewise, when several conducts qualify as more than one infraction, the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction is imposed.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
A newer document in RegAlert amends this one; it applies as amended.
“That, by Superintendencia Adjunta Resolution SMV No. 11-2012-SMV/10 dated November 15, 2012 (hereinafter, the RESOLUTION), it was resolved...”
“approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 073-2004-EF/94.10, and by the provisions of article 10 A of the Sanctions Regulations.”
“In accordance with the provisions of article 1 of CONASEV Resolution No. 102-2010-EF/94.10; a norm that "Regulates Full Application of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)", intermediation agents must prepare their financial …”
“In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.”
“By CONASEV Resolution No. 047-2011-EF/94.01.1 of June 17, 2011, the appeal filed by Intercapital against the TAC Resolution was declared unfounded”
Amended 1 time · last 2013-09-06
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added