Guidance · HKMA · 30 May 2007
An AI must maintain a documented disclosure policy approved by its board by 30 June 2007 or six months after becoming an AI, whichever is later, and must issue a bilingual press release and publish its disclosure statement within 4 months of financial year-end for annual disclosures and 3 months for interim disclosures, lodging copies with the HKMA beforehand. Disclosures must be displayed at the principal place of business and local branches, available for inspection until at least the next equivalent reporting period, and must not be false or misleading in any material respect. An AI using a prescribed summary must not change the stated access means without amending the summary and lodging it with the HKMA.
Circulars
30 May 2007
Supervisory Policy Manual (SPM) CA-D-1 "Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules" Our Ref: G10/1/2C 30 May 2007 The Chief Executive All authorized institutions Dear Sir/Madam, Supervisory Policy Manual (SPM) CA-D-1 "Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules" I am writing to inform you that, following consultation with the two industry Associations, the Monetary Authority is issuing the above SPM module today. This module is a new guideline and is non-statutory. The purpose of the module is to assist AIs (locally and overseas incorporated) in complying with the Banking (Disclosure) Rules (hereafter referred to as "the Rules"). It does not introduce any new disclosure requirements other than those already contained in the Rules which came into effect on 1 January 2007. Rather, the Guideline provides AIs with supplementary guidance concerning the application of the Rules, particularly on how certain of the requirements should be interpreted; as such it does not aim to be comprehensive. In developing the module, the HKMA has responded to requests it received during the consultation process on the Rules for an explanation of certain provisions in non-technical language. In response to requests by both the industry and the accounting profession, the HKMA has also included an annex to the Guideline which contains a complete set of definitions of terms used in the Rules including relevant terms from the Banking (Capital) Rules. Illustrative examples or sample disclosure templates have also been included in the Guideline to assist AIs in complying with specific requirements of the Rules. To further assist AIs in implementing the requirements of the new Rules, we are also enclosing:
two tables (Table 1 applicable for locally incorporated AIs and Table 2 applicable for overseas-incorporated AIs) which highlight major differences between the disclosure regime under previous Financial Disclosure Guidelines and the new regime under the Rules; and a number of questions and answers ("Q&As") relating to the Rules.
Encl. c.c.
The purpose of these Q&As is to provide supplementary guidance on certain subjects which are already covered in the Guideline. Like the Guideline, the Q&As do not introduce any new requirements or replace any requirements specified in the Rules. Moreover, the answers given in the Q&As are general in their scope and do not take into account the particular circumstances of any individual AI. In consequence, reading the Q&As is no substitute for reading the Rules themselves or obtaining, where necessary, legal and other professional advice on particular aspects of the Rules. We will keep under review the need to update or add to these Q&As as appropriate, having regard to AIs' practical implementation of the Rules and any issues arising therefrom. On-line access to the SPM module as well as the Q&As is available to AIs under the "Supervisory Policy Manual" and "Basel II" icons in the HKMA's public (http://www.info.gov.hk/hkma) and private (http://www.stet.finnet.hk) websites. Should you have any questions relating to this module, please feel free to contact Ms Theresa Kwan at 2878-1093 or Mr Raymond Tsui at 2878-1623. Yours faithfully, Simon Topping Executive Director (Banking Policy) SPM CA-D-1 DRs Guideline (PDF file, 804KB)
Table 1 (PDF file, 92KB)
Table 2 (PDF file, 57KB)
Q&As (PDF file, 73KB)
The Chairman, The Hong Kong Association of Banks The Chairman, The DTC Association FSTB (Attn.: Ms. Angelina Kwan) Last revision date : 01 August 2011
Highlights of Major Differences between the disclosure regime under previous Financial Disclosure Guidelines and the new regime under the Banking (Disclosure) Rules – applicable for Locally Incorporated AIs (“Local AIs”) Local AIs (SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference Application and Exemption Criteria Annual financial disclosures: FD-1 Application FD-1 applies to all AIs other than exempted AIs. De minimis exemption The AI is a DTC or RLB; and the AI has:
(i) total assets less provisions of less than HK$1 billion; and (ii) total deposits from customers of less than HK$300 million. HKMA’s assessment of exemption criteria Based on the average of relevant figures reported in the 12 months up to and including August of each financial year. Annual financial disclosures: Part 4 Application
Part 4 applies to all AIs other than exempted AIs.
De minimis exemption
Same exemption criteria apply.
HKMA’s assessment of exemption criteria Based on the arithmetic mean of relevant figures 3 reported in a period of 12 calendar months ending on and including the 5th calendar month preceding the close of the AI’s financial year. s.3(1) & 3(7) of DRs; paragraphs 7.1 & 7.2 of Guideline4 s.3(10) & 3(17) of DRs; paragraph 7.3 of Guideline 1 Previously issued by the HKMA and apply to an AI’s financial year up to and including 2007. 2 Referred to “Disclosure Rules” or “DRs” in the table. 3 “Relevant figures” means the figures as at the end of each calendar month relating to the AI’s total assets less provisions and total deposits from customers, as set out in the return relating to assets and liabilities submitted by the AI to the HKMA for each calendar month pursuant to section 63 of the Banking Ordinance. 4 Guideline means SPM module CA-D-1 Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules.
Table 1
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference Interim financial disclosures: FD-2 Application Other than exempted AIs, FD-2 applies to all AIs to which FD-1 applies. De minimis exemption The AI is non-listed in the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and is wholly-owned subsidiary of AIs incorporated in Hong Kong. Interim financial disclosures: Part 3 Application
Part 3 applies to all AIs other than exempted AIs.
De minimis exemption
Same exemption criteria apply.
Additional interim & annual disclosures: Parts 3 & 4 An AI shall disclose a breakdown of its Mainland exposures to non-bank counterparties, if the exposures are material, into the categories in the return for non-bank Mainland exposures submitted by the AI to the Monetary Authority pursuant to s.63 of the Banking Ordinance in respect of the interim/annual reporting period. Additional annual disclosures: Part 5
Part 5 applies to an AI to which Part 4 applies and which uses
the STC approach to calculate its credit risk for non-securitization exposures (including non-securitization exposures the subject of exemption under section 12(2)(a) of the Banking (Capital) Rules). Additional annual disclosures: Part 6
Part 6 applies to an AI to which Part 4 applies and which uses
s.3(2) & 3(8) of DRs; paragraphs 8.1 & 8.2 of Guideline s.28 & 49 of DRs paragraph 14.6 of Guideline
Part 5 of DRs
Part 6 of DRs
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference the BSC approach to calculate its credit risk for non-securitization exposures. Additional annual disclosures: Part 7
Part 7 applies to an AI to which Part 4 applies and which uses
the IRB approaches to calculate its credit risk for non-securitization exposures.
Part 7 of DRs
Approval for
Exemption
AI determines whether it is exempted from or subject to the disclosure guidelines based on the de minimis exemption criteria. For those DTCs and RLBs which have previously subject to the disclosure guidelines, they should continue to make disclosures notwithstanding they may meet the de minimis criteria in subsequent financial years. The HKMA will give notice in writing to AIs which are exempted from the application of the Disclosure Rules. Where the HKMA determines that an AI is not exempted from the annual financial disclosures under Part 4, the AI will not subsequently be exempted unless the HKMA makes a subsequent determination that the AI is exempted. The HKMA will only consider granting new exemptions where an AI can provide it with a business plan that indicates that the AI intends to reduce its business to levels that will permit it be able to meet the exemption criteria for an appropriate period (at least several years depending on the particular circumstances of the AI). s.3(7), 3(8) & 3(11) of DRs paragraphs 7.5 of Guideline Notice of Cessation of Exemption Not applicable. If the HKMA is satisfied that an exempted AI ceases to meet the exemption criteria, the HKMA will give notice in writing to inform the AI that it ceases to be so exempted from the date specified in the notice. If an AI wishes to be exempted or to continue to be exempted from compliance with the Disclosure Rules, it should request its usual supervisory contact to conduct a review of its exemption status. s.3(12) & 3(13) of DRs; paragraphs 7.6 & 7.7 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference Disclosure Policy No explicit requirement. A clearly documented policy should be in place not later than 6 months after the commencement of the Disclosure Rules (i.e. on or before 30 June 2007) or after the date on which the AI became an AI, whichever is the later. The disclosure policy has to:
(a) set out the approach used by the AI to determine the content, appropriateness and frequency of the information it discloses to the general public relating to its state of affairs, profit and loss or CAR; and AI’s internal controls over its process for making such disclosures (including internal controls for verifying or reviewing the accuracy of the information disclosed); and (b) be approved by the AI’s board of directors. s.5 of DRs; paragraph 13.2.1 of Guideline Disclosure Statement - Form (see “Disclosure Statement – Publish and Issue of Press Release” below) Pursuant to section 6(3), a disclosure statement should contain:
(a) all the disclosures required by the Disclosure Rules; or (b) a prescribed summary of the required disclosures. The prescribed summary should inform users of the disclosure statement the location at which and the means by which the general public may readily access all the disclosures (e.g. certain disclosures may be found in an AI’s annual report and accounts, its internet website; or internet website of the AI’s parent bank or any combination of the above means). s.6(3), 6(9), 6(10) & 6(11) of DRs; paragraphs 13.3.1,
13.3.2 & 13.3.3 of
Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference An AI which publishes the disclosure statement in the form of prescribed summary must not change the means as stated in the summary by which the general public may readily access the relevant complete disclosures unless the AI amends its prescribed summary accordingly. AI is required to lodge a copy of its revised prescribed summary with the HKMA, which will be kept in the register. An AI should ensure that neither the disclosures in (a) above, nor the prescribed summary in (b) above, nor any information published with the prescribed summary, is false or misleading in any material respect. Disclosure Statement – Publish and Issue of Press Release An AI should issue a press release in both Chinese and English within 4 months from the end of each financial year (for annual disclosures) or 3 months from the end of each interim financial year (for interim disclosures). An AI is encouraged to include in the press release as much as possible of the information required by the disclosure guidelines. It is not sufficient to issue a press release or advertisement which informs members of the public that a full set of accounts is available at the principal place of business or local branches of the AI without disclosing any information required. An AI should lodge a copy of the press release with the HKMA prior to issuance. The disclosure statement should be in Chinese and English languages. An AI should publish the disclosure statement:
(a) not later than 4 months after the end of the reporting period for annual disclosures; (b) no later than 3 months after the end of the reporting period for interim disclosures. An AI should make clear in the disclosure statement which information contained in the statement has been audited and which has not been audited. An AI should, at the same time as it publishes its disclosure statement, issue a press release to the press in Hong Kong, in the Chinese and English languages containing the statement or consisting of the statement. s.6(1), 6(2), 6(4) & 6(5) of DRs; paragraphs 13.3.4 &
13.3.5 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference A press release is said to “contain” the disclosure statement if it contains other information that is not subject to the disclosure requirements of the Disclosure Rules. A press release is said to “consist” of the disclosure statement if it only contains information that the AI is required to disclose under the Disclosure Rules (i.e. it does not include disclosures made under other requirements such as Hong Kong Financial Reporting Standards). An AI should lodge a copy of its disclosure statement with the HKMA before it publishes the statement. Location of Disclosure A copy of the disclosure statement should be displayed in the AI’s principal place of business in Hong Kong and if applicable in each local branch. The disclosure statement should be made readily available to members of the public upon request. The HKMA will keep a copy of the press release in its register. Same requirements under the Disclosure Rules. The disclosure statement should be made available for inspection by the general public during the business hours of the AI at the place where the relevant copy is kept. The HKMA will keep each copy of a disclosure statement lodged with it with the register. AI which publishes the disclosure statement in the form of a prescribed summary should ensure the complete disclosures are readily accessible by the general public:
(a) on a Hong Kong internet website;
(b) if applicable, in the AI’s annual reports and accounts; s.6(6), 6(7) & 6(11) of DRs; paragraph 13.3.7 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference (c) if applicable, on an internet website of the AI’s parent bank; or (d) any combination of the means above. Period and Time Available for Inspection No explicit requirement. The disclosure statement must be available for inspection until at least the next equivalent reporting period. s.6(8), 6(9) & 6(10) of DRs paragraph 13.3.8 of Guideline Interaction with Other Requirements The disclosure guidelines supplement and does not replace any other disclosures required under the relevant legislation or accounting standards or which are necessary to show a true and fair view of the financial state or affairs of the AI. If an AI makes a disclosure (“external disclosure”) pursuant to a requirement other than the Disclosure Rules (“external requirement”) where the external requirement is similar to a requirement by the Rules and the external disclosure is available to the general public in Hong Kong, the AI may rely on the external disclosure as complying with the requirement of the Rules provided that the AI demonstrates to the HKMA’s satisfaction that it meets the conditions specified under s.7(d) and (e) of the Disclosure Rules. s.7(d) & (e) of DRs; paragraphs 13.4.1,
13.4.2 & 13.4.3 of
Guideline
Group-wide
Disclosures made by Parent
Bank
Not applicable. An AI may rely on the disclosures made by its parent bank as complying with the requirements of the Disclosure Rules provided that the AI demonstrates to the HKMA’s satisfaction that it meets the conditions specified under s.15(a) to (g) of the Disclosure Rules. s.15 of DRs Verification No explicit requirement. AI’s senior management must ensure that the information is scrutinized and subjected to internal review before being so disclosed, to ensure that the information is not false or misleading in any material respect. s.8 of DRs; paragraphs 13.5.1 &
13.5.2 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference “Internal review” means the review is carried out by AI’s adequately qualified personnel who are independent of the AI’s staff or management responsible for preparing the information which the AI is required to disclose. Proprietary and Confidential Information Not applicable. With the HKMA’s prior consent, an AI may decline to disclose proprietary or confidential information pursuant to the requirement of the Disclosure Rules if the AI discloses general information relating to the subject matter of the relevant requirement and includes a statement in the disclosure statement stating what information it has declined to disclose. “Proprietary or confidential information” means information - (a) which, if it becomes publicly available, will cause serious prejudice to the competitive position of the AI; or (b) in respect of which the AI has legally binding obligations to its customers or other counterparties which prevent the AI from disclosing the information. s.9 of DRs; paragraphs 13.6.1 to
13.6.4 of Guideline
Materiality An AI is not required to disclose items which are not material. An item should be regarded as material to an AI if the omission or misstatement of that item could have changed or influenced the judgement or decision of a user relying on the relevant information. Senior management of an AI should ensure that a disclosure made pursuant to the Disclosure Rules contains all the material information. “Material information", means information – (a) which is required to be disclosed under the Disclosure Rules; and (b) which, if it is not disclosed or is misstated, can change or influence the assessment or decision of a person relying s.10 of DRs; paragraphs 13.7.1 to
13.7.3 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference on the disclosure concerned for the purposes of making investment or other economic decisions. An AI should, at a minimum, also observe materiality as defined and interpreted in applicable accounting standards (HKAS 1 and HKAS 8). Consolidated Group Level Disclosure For disclosure in relation to capital adequacy framework, it should be made on a consolidated basis if the AI is required to calculate its CAR on a consolidated basis. Otherwise, the disclosure should be on solo basis. If an AI only presented consolidated financial statements, the disclosure of supplementary financial information needs only be made on the basis of the consolidated financial statements. However, disclosure of additional information on a solo-basis is encouraged. The Disclosure Rules applies to the AI on a consolidated basis (i.e. the basis of consolidation for capital adequacy purposes) except for exempted provisions under s.11(4) of the Disclosure Rules, unless the AI is only required to calculate its CAR on a solo basis under the Banking (Capital) Rules. However, the AI may include disclosures on a solo basis in addition to a consolidated basis to provide greater clarity in understanding the AI’s state of affairs, profit and loss or CAR. For exempted provisions under s.11(4), the basis of preparation is left to the AI’s discretion to choose the most appropriate basis for providing clarity in understanding for users of disclosures, including the consolidated basis used for the purposes of financial reporting. For provisions specified under s.11(6) of the Disclosure Rules in relation to disclosures of non-bank Mainland exposures, currency risk and liquidity ratio, an AI should make disclosures on the same basis as that used by the AI in preparing the regulatory returns reported to the HKMA. s.11 of DRs; paragraphs 13.8.1 to
13.8.3 of Guideline
Basis of
Disclosure
Not applicable. AI should make disclosures on the basis of the approach it uses to calculate its regulatory capital for credit risk, and capital charges for market risk and operational risk. s.12 of DRs; paragraphs 13.9.1 to
13.9.3 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference If an AI uses a combination of 2 or more approaches to calculate its credit risk, market risk or operational risk, it should make disclosures on the basis of the respective approach it uses for each of its exposure classes, business units, risk categories or parts of its business. If an AI under any one reporting period has used different approaches to calculate its credit risk, market risk or operational risk for the same exposure classes, business units, risk categories, or parts of its business, it should make disclosures on the basis of the respective approach it uses as at the reporting date for that period. Comparative Information Except for profit and loss information and liquidity ratio, the corresponding amounts for the immediately preceding financial year-end should be given. For profit and loss information and liquidity ratio, the amounts for the corresponding period of the preceding financial year should be given. Where the disclosures are applied for the first time, and it is impractical to apply the disclosures retrospectively, the comparative disclosure need not apply for the first year. Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. Notwithstanding that the requirement of comparative disclosure does not apply to an AI for a reporting period, the AI should, if it is practicable to do so, ensure that the disclosure is accompanied by comparative disclosure. s.13 of DRs; paragraphs 13.10.1 to
13.10.5 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference If an AI uses, in 2 consecutive annual reporting periods, different approaches to calculate its credit risk, market risk and operational risk for the same exposure class, business unit, risk category, or part of its business, the comparative disclosure is not required for the last of those periods if the AI provides reasons in the disclosure statement. An AI should notify its usual supervisory contact if it intends to use any of the exceptions permitted under the Disclosure Rules. Where there has been a material restatement of the comparative disclosure, the AI should provide the nature and reason of the restatement in the disclosure statement. Frequency of Disclosure An AI should make annual disclosure in accordance with FD-1 and interim disclosure in accordance with FD-2. An AI should make annual disclosure in respect of its last financial year in accordance with Part 4 and Part 5, 6 or 7 of the Disclosure Rules, as applicable, and interim disclosure in respect of the 6 months period immediately after the close of AI’s last financial year in accordance with Part 3. s.14 of DRs; paragraphs 13.11.1 &
13.11.2 of Guideline
Compliance The Seventh Schedule of the Banking Ordinance includes adequate disclosure of financial information as one of the criteria for continuing authorization. Failure to meet the authorization criteria in the Seventh Schedule would be a ground for revocation of authorization. Any non-compliance with the Disclosure Rules will constitute a criminal offence by the AI’s director, chief executive and manager under s.60A of the Banking Ordinance. Where it is not practicable for an AI to make a disclosure required by the Disclosure Rules for reasons not related to proprietary and confidential information, the AI should, after consultation with the HKMA, include in its disclosure statement:
s.16 of DRs; paragraphs 13.12.1 &
13.12.2 of Guideline
Local
AIs
(SPM modules FD-1 and FD-2) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference (a) a statement that it is unable to make the disclosure and the reasons why it is unable to do so; and (b) information which is the closest available alternative to that required to be disclosed under the Disclosure Rules. In these circumstances the AI should also obtain the prior consent of the HKMA before publishing its disclosure statement. Statement of Compliance AI is required to issue a statement of compliance stating the extent of its compliance with the disclosure standards set out in the disclosure guidelines and the reason of any non-compliance. Issuance of statement of compliance is no longer applicable under the Disclosure Rules. However, an AI will be required to state whether or not, during the reporting period, it was in contravention of rules made under section 60A(1) (i.e. Disclosure Rules) in the return relating to certificate of compliance with the Banking Ordinance. n/a
Highlights of Major Differences between the disclosure regime under previous Financial Disclosure Guidelines and the new regime under the Banking (Disclosure) Rules – applicable for Overseas-Incorporated AIs (“Foreign AIs”) Foreign AIs (SPM module FD-3) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference Application and Exemption Criteria Application FD-3 applies to all AIs other than exempted AIs. De minimis exemption The AI has:
(i) total assets less provisions of less than HK$10 billion; and (ii) total deposits from customers of less than HK$2 billion. HKMA’s assessment of exemption criteria Based on the average of relevant figures reported in the 12 months up to and including August of each financial year. Application
Part 8 applies to all AIs other than exempted AIs.
De minimis exemption
The following criteria must be met by the AI:
(i) its local branches, together with its principal place of business in Hong Kong, have in aggregate total assets less provisions of less than HK$10 billion (or the equivalent amount in any foreign currency); and (ii) its local branches, together with its principal place of business in Hong Kong, have in aggregate total deposits from customers of less than HK$2 billion (or the equivalent amount in any foreign currency). HKMA’s assessment of exemption criteria Based on the arithmetic mean of relevant figures 3 reported in a period of 12 calendar months ending on and including the 5th calendar month preceding the close of the AI’s financial year. s.3(6) & 3(9) of DRs; paragraphs 12.1 &
12.2 of Guideline4
s.3(10) & 3(17) of
DRs; paragraph 12.2 of
Guideline
1 Previously issued by the HKMA and apply to an AI’s financial year up to and including 2007. 2 Referred to “Disclosure Rules” or “DRs” in the table. 3 “Relevant figures” means the figures as at the end of each calendar month relating to the AI’s total assets less provisions and total deposits from customers, as set out in the return relating to assets and liabilities submitted by the AI to the HKMA for each calendar month pursuant to section 63 of the Banking Ordinance. 4 Guideline means SPM module CA-D-1 Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules.
Table 2
Foreign
AIs
(SPM module FD-3) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference Approval for Exemption AI determines whether it is exempted from or subject to the disclosure guidelines based on the de minimis exemption criteria. The HKMA will give notice in writing to AIs which are exempted from the application of the Disclosure Rules. s.3(9) of DRs; paragraph 12.3 of Guideline Notice of Cessation of Exemption Not applicable. If the HKMA is satisfied that an exempted AI ceases to meet the exemption criteria, the HKMA will give notice in writing to inform the AI that it ceases to be so exempted from the date specified in the notice. If an AI wishes to be exempted or to continue to be exempted from compliance with the Disclosure Rules, it should request its usual supervisory contact to conduct a review of its exemption status. s.3(14) of DRs; paragraphs 12.3 &
12.4 of Guideline
Disclosure
Statement -
Form
(see “Disclosure Statement – Publish and Issue of Press Release” below) Pursuant to section 88(2), a disclosure statement should contain:
(a) all the disclosures required by the Disclosure Rules; or (b) a prescribed summary of the required disclosures. The prescribed summary should inform users of the disclosure statement the location at which and the means by which the general public may readily access all the disclosures (e.g. the AI’s internet website while the required consolidated group level disclosures may be found in an AI’s consolidated accounts). An AI which publishes the disclosure statement in the form of prescribed summary must not change the means as stated in the summary by which the general public may readily access the relevant complete disclosures unless the AI amends its prescribed summary accordingly. An AI is required to lodge a copy of its revised prescribed summary with the HKMA, which will be kept in the register. s.88(2), 88(8)(b) & 88(10) of DRs; paragraphs 19.2.1 to
19.2.3 of Guideline
Foreign
AIs
(SPM module FD-3) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference An AI should ensure that neither the disclosures in (a) above, nor the prescribed summary in (b) above, nor any information published with the prescribed summary, is false or misleading in any material respect. Disclosure Statement – Publish and Issue of Press Release An AI should issue a press release in both Chinese and English within 3 months from the end of each financial period. It is not sufficient to issue a press release or advertisement which informs members of the public that a full set of accounts is available at the principal place of business or local branches of the AI without disclosing any information required. AI should lodge a copy of the press release with the HKMA prior to issuance. The disclosure statement should be in Chinese and English languages. An AI should publish the disclosure statement no later than 3 months after the end of the reporting period. An AI should, at the same time as it publishes its disclosure statement, issue a press release in Hong Kong, in the Chinese and English languages containing the statement or consisting of the statement. A press release is said to “contain” the disclosure statement if it contains other information that is not subject to the disclosure requirements of the Disclosure Rules (for example disclosures made under the relevant accounting standards). A press release is said to “consist” of the disclosure statement if it only contains information that the AI is required to disclose under the Disclosure Rules (i.e. it does not include disclosures made under other requirements such as the relevant accounting standards). An AI should lodge a copy of its disclosure statement with the HKMA before it publishes the statement. s.88(1), 88(3) &.88(4) of DRs; paragraphs 19.2.4 &
19.2.5 of Guideline
Location of
Disclosure
A copy of the disclosure statement should be displayed in the AI’s principal place of business in Hong Kong and if applicable in each local branch. Same requirements under the Disclosure Rules. s.88(5), 88(6) & 88(10) of DRs; paragraph 19.2.7 of Guideline
Foreign
AIs
(SPM module FD-3) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference The disclosure statement should be made readily available to members of the public upon request. The HKMA will keep a copy of the press release in its register. The disclosure statement should be made available for inspection by the general public during the business hours of the AI at the place where the relevant copy is kept. The HKMA will keep each copy of a disclosure statement lodged with it with the register. AI which publishes the disclosure statement in the form of a prescribed summary should ensure the complete disclosures are readily accessible by the general public on an internet website or by any other means or combination of means. Period and Time Available for Inspection No explicit requirement. The disclosure statement must be available for inspection until at least the next equivalent reporting period. s.88(7), 88(8), 88(9) of DRs; paragraphs 19.2.6 of Guideline Materiality An AI is not required to disclose items which are not material. An item should be regarded as material to an AI if the omission or misstatement of that item could have changed or influenced the judgement or decision of a user relying on the relevant information. The chief executive of an AI should ensure that a disclosure made pursuant to the Disclosure Rules contains all the material information. “Material information", means information – (a) which is required to be disclosed under the Disclosure Rules; and (b) which, if it is not disclosed or is misstated, can change or influence the assessment or decision of a person relying on the disclosure concerned for the purposes of making investment or other economic decisions. An AI which adopts International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) or equivalent accounting standards in preparing its financial accounts should, at a minimum, also s.89 of DRs; paragraphs 19.3.1 to
19.3.3 of Guideline
Foreign
AIs
(SPM module FD-3) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference observe the materiality concept as set out in the IFRSs or equivalent accounting and financial reporting standards. Comparative Information Except for pre-tax profit disclosure, profit and loss information and liquidity ratio, the corresponding amounts for the immediately preceding financial period should be given. For pre-tax profit disclosure, profit and loss information and liquidity ratio, the amounts for the corresponding period of the preceding financial year should be given. Where interim consolidated information is not provided by an AI as a whole, annual figures should be provided as comparatives. Where the disclosures are applied for the first time, and it is impractical to apply the disclosures retrospectively, the comparative disclosure need not apply for the first reporting period. Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. Where the disclosures did not exist prior to the Disclosure Rules coming into effect, and it is not practicable for the AI to apply the Rules retrospectively, no comparative information is required. However, this exception only applies for the first year of the operation of the Rules and AIs should include comparative information if it is practicable for them to do so. An AI should notify its usual supervisory contact if it intends to use any of the exceptions permitted under the Disclosure Rules. s.90 of DRs; paragraphs 19.4.1 to
19.4.4 of Guideline
Frequency of
Disclosure
AI should make disclosure on a half-yearly basis.
Same requirements as previously required by the financial disclosure guidelines. s.91 of DRs; paragraph 19.5.1 of Guideline Compliance Not specified. An AI’s disclosure statement should also contain such other information as is necessary to ensure that the information contained in the disclosure statement is not s.92 of DRs paragraphs 19.6.1 &
Foreign
AIs
(SPM module FD-3) Banking (Disclosure) Rules2 Section Reference false or misleading to any material respect, and that the operations of the AI are clearly explained. Where it is not practicable for an AI to make a disclosure required by the Disclosure Rules, the AI should, after consultation with the HKMA, include in its disclosure statement:
(a) a statement that it is unable to make the disclosure and the reasons why it is unable to do so; and (b) information which is the closest available alternative to that required to be disclosed under the Disclosure Rules. In these circumstances the AI should also obtain the prior consent of the HKMA before publishing its disclosure statement.
19.6.2 of Guideline
Statement of
Compliance
AI is required to issue a statement of compliance stating the extent of its compliance with the disclosure standards set out in the disclosure guidelines and the reason of any non-compliance. Issuance of statement of compliance is no longer applicable under the Disclosure Rules. However, an AI will be required to state whether or not, during the reporting period, it was in contravention of rules made under section 60A(1) (i.e. Disclosure Rules) in the return relating to certificate of compliance with the Banking Ordinance. n/a
Questions and Answers on
Banking (Disclosure) Rules
Part Content Reference
I Introduction
II Questions and Answers
These questions and answers (“Q&As”) relate to the Banking (Disclosure) Rules (“the Disclosure Rules”), which came into effect on 1 January 2007. The purpose of these Q&As is to provide supplementary guidance on certain subjects which are already covered in the Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules issued by the Monetary Authority (“HKMA”). The Q&As are general in their scope and do not take into account the particular circumstances of any individual authorized institution (“AI”). Certain sections of the Disclosure Rules contain exceptions or qualifications which, although not covered in these Q&As, may still apply to particular AIs. In the case of any discrepancy between the Q&As and the Disclosure Rules, the Disclosure Rules prevail and reading these Q&As is no substitute for reading the Disclosure Rules themselves. The Q&As should not be regarded as, or be considered a substitute for obtaining, legal advice and AIs should consider obtaining legal and other professional advice before taking any action on any of the matters covered by these Q&As, particularly if they have any doubt as to how any aspect of the Disclosure Rules might apply to them. Unless otherwise stated, the terminology used in the Q&As follows that used in the Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules and the Disclosure Rules themselves.
Part I - Introduction
Approach to Exemption
Q1: How will an AI know if it qualifies for an exemption from having to make disclosures under the Disclosure Rules? Ans: An AI is required to make all applicable disclosures under the Disclosure Rules, unless it receives written notification from the HKMA informing it that it is exempt from having to make such disclosures. If an AI believes that it meets the exemption criteria stipulated in sections 3(7) or 3(8), in the case of a locally incorporated AI, or section 3(9), in the case of an overseas incorporated AI, it should ask its usual supervisory contact to review its exemption status (see the Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules (paragraph 7.7)). If the usual supervisory contact is satisfied that the AI meets the relevant exemption criteria, the HKMA will issue an exemption notice to the AI. The exemption notice will state from which Parts of the Disclosure Rules the AI is exempt. Any exemption granted to an AI can be withdrawn by the HKMA if subsequent assessments show that the exempted AI no longer meets the exemption criteria specified in the Disclosure Rules. It should be noted that it is not possible to exempt an AI from making semi-annual disclosures under section 3(8)(a) unless the AI is also exempt from making annual disclosures.
Disclosure Policy
Q2: According to section 5 of the Disclosure Rules, an AI incorporated in Hong Kong is required to establish a clearly defined disclosure policy not later than 6 months after the commencement of the Disclosure Rules (i.e. on or before 30 June 2007) or not later than 6 months after the date on which it became an AI, whichever is the later. The disclosure policy should be documented in writing and be approved by the AI’s board of directors. Is an AI required to submit its disclosure policy to the HKMA for review or approval?
Ans: No. The Disclosure Rules do not require an AI to submit its disclosure policy to the HKMA for review or approval. However, an AI’s disclosure policy should be made available for inspection when required by the HKMA (e.g. during on-site examination).
Part II - Questions and Answers
Proprietary and Confidential Information Q3: Under what circumstances would an AI incorporated in Hong Kong be able to rely on the exemption from disclosing proprietary or confidential information under the Disclosure Rules?
Ans: An AI incorporated in Hong Kong is required to disclose proprietary or confidential information unless it has received the HKMA’s prior consent to decline to give such disclosure under section 9 of the Disclosure Rules. An AI may, under section 9 of the Disclosure Rules, with the prior consent of the HKMA, decline to disclose proprietary or confidential information which it would otherwise be required to disclose under the Disclosure Rules, if :
(a) the AI discloses general information relating to the subject matter of the relevant disclosure requirement in its disclosure statement instead; and (b) the AI includes a statement in its disclosure statement stating what information it has declined to disclose. The HKMA expects AIs only to request this exemption in exceptional circumstances. The HKMA will only be willing to give its prior consent to an AI to use this exemption, if the AI can demonstrate to the HKMA’s satisfaction that there are good reasons for such exemption being used. AIs are discouraged from seeking to use this exemption unless disclosure of the relevant information would cause contractual obligations to be breached, or would have a serious and detrimental effect on an AI’s ability to profit from specific business opportunities. Prescribed Summary Q4: If an AI’s disclosure statement contains a “prescribed summary” (pursuant to section 6(3)(a)(ii) of the Disclosure Rules, in the case of an AI incorporated in Hong Kong, or pursuant to section 88(2)(a)(ii), in the case of an AI incorporated outside Hong Kong), does the “prescribed summary” have to include a summary of the AI’s disclosures? Ans: No. A prescribed summary is only required to specify clearly where the AI’s complete disclosures can be found and how they can be accessed by the general public (see the definitions in section 6(11) and 88(10) of the Disclosure Rules). Where an AI uses a prescribed summary, its disclosures must be readily accessible to the public by one of the means specified in
section 6(11)(b), in the case of a AI incorporated in Hong Kong, or section
88(10)(b), in the case of an AI incorporated outside Hong Kong. If, for example, the disclosures are readily accessible to the public on the AI’s Hong Kong Internet website, the AI’s prescribed summary should provide the relevant website address and specify the relevant link.
Verification and Internal Review of Disclosures Q5: Do the Disclosure Rules require information disclosed under the Rules to be the subject of statutory audit? Ans: No. Disclosures (including financial disclosures) made under the Disclosure Rules are not required to be audited by an external auditor, (although such information may in any event have to be audited by reason of the requirements of other legislation, accounting standard setters, securities regulators, or other authorities.) However, section 8 of the Disclosure Rules does require the senior management of an AI incorporated in Hong Kong to ensure that the information to be disclosed is scrutinized and subjected to an internal review to ensure the information is not false or misleading in any material respect. Such review should be conducted by adequately qualified personnel of the AI who are independent of the staff or management responsible for preparing the information to be disclosed. Q6: If the CEO and CFO of an AI incorporated in Hong Kong review the AI’s disclosures to ensure that the information is not false or misleading in any material respect, can such review form part of the internal review required by section 8 of the Disclosure Rules, given that their teams are responsible for preparing the disclosures? Ans: No. Section 8(2) of the Disclosure Rules states that “the internal review should be carried out by adequately qualified personnel who are independent of the institution's staff or management responsible for preparing the information ........”. In practice neither the CEO nor the CFO is likely to be sufficiently independent of those preparing the disclosures to meet this requirement. Q7: Will the HKMA consider issuing guidance on how the internal review should be conducted? Ans: No. The HKMA does not intend to issue such guidance. It is up to an individual AI to ensure that the degree of scrutiny employed and the scope of the internal review undertaken, are sufficient to ensure that the disclosures are not false or misleading in any material respect. Q8: Is it necessary for the internal audit staff of an AI incorporated in Hong Kong to carry out the internal review referred to in section 8(1) of the Disclosure Rules? Ans: No. The Disclosure Rules require only that the internal review be carried out by adequately qualified personnel of the AI who are independent of the staff or
management responsible for preparing the information which the AI is required to disclose (see section 8(2)). The Disclosure Rules do not specify that the personnel carrying out the review must be drawn from an AI’s internal audit staff. The review may be carried out by personnel drawn from different teams within the AI (for example, personnel from the AI’s internal audit staff might review the internal controls in place for compiling the information to be disclosed, whilst personnel from compliance might review the information itself), provided such personnel satisfy the criteria in section 8(2) of the Disclosure Rules. Q9: Do the Disclosure Rules require the senior management of an AI incorporated in Hong Kong to scrutinize and review the information to be disclosed by the AI? Ans: No. Although the Disclosure Rules require the senior management of such an AI to ensure that the information to be disclosed is scrutinized and subjected to internal review to ensure that the information is not false or misleading in any material respect, the senior management itself is not required to carry out such scrutiny or review (or indeed its own additional review). However, under section 6(3)(b) of the Disclosure Rules an AI is required to ensure that the disclosures made are not false or misleading in any material respect. If an AI fails to comply with the Disclosure Rules every director, chief executive and manager of that AI commits a criminal offence under section 60A of the BO (as amended by Banking (Amendment) Ordinance 2005). Accordingly, the senior management may in any event wish to review the disclosures before they are issued. Specific Provisions Q10: Why is the term “specific provisions” still used in the Disclosure Rules when it is no longer applicable under the Hong Kong Accounting Standard (HKAS) 39? Ans: The term “specific provisions” is defined in the definitions section of the Banking (Capital) Rules (section 2) and has been incorporated into the Disclosure Rules, by virtue of section 2(2) of the Disclosure Rules. The definition of “specific provisions” closely follows the definition of “individual impairment allowances” contained in the accounting standards and is intended to have the same meaning.
Impaired Loans
Q11: Separate disclosure of information relating to impaired loans is required by the Disclosure Rules. Although the term “impaired loans” is not defined in the Disclosure Rules, the conditions in which an asset is impaired are explained in the accounting standards (HKAS 39, paragraphs 58-70). Is it correct to adopt the concept of “impairment” applied in accounting standards for the purpose of the Disclosure Rules? Is the term broadly equivalent to “classified and non-performing loans” used for prudential reporting purposes? Ans: The term “impaired loans” is not intended to be limited to the scope of “impairment” applied in HKAS 39. The policy intention is that the term “impaired loans” as used in the Disclosure Rules extends to all loans recognized as non-performing for prudential reporting purposes. Disclosure of Regulatory Reserve Q12: Sections 20 and 36 of the Disclosure Rules require an AI incorporated in Hong Kong to disclose its reserves, broken down into regulatory reserve, revaluation reserves where maintained, and other material types of reserves. If an AI earmarks a certain part of its general reserves as a regulatory reserve will it have to disclose this as a regulatory reserve? Ans: Yes. An AI is required to make appropriate disclosure of its regulatory reserve regardless of the methodology (i.e. appropriation or earmarking) it uses to maintain such reserve. Section 36(2) specifies that an AI should (in its disclosure statement for its annual reporting period) also disclose the nature and purpose of the reserve. An AI which maintains a regulatory reserve should make reference to the sample disclosure note published by the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Sample Disclosure Templates for IRB Banks Q13: The SPM module entitled “Guideline on Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules” includes a sample disclosure template for AIs using the STC Approach. Will the HKMA consider providing a similar template for AIs using the IRB Approach (referred to here as “IRB AIs”)? Ans: The HKMA considers it inappropriate to provide disclosure templates for IRB AIs at this stage because the majority of AIs that intend to adopt the IRB Approach are subsidiaries of major international banks whose home country regulators may issue their own disclosure templates in due course. If the HKMA issued templates, and those templates differed from those of an AI’s home country regulator, this would merely serve to increase the reporting
burden on the AI concerned. Rather, it is the HKMA’s intention to allow an AI to make use of group-level disclosures to the greatest extent possible provided always that the criteria under s.7(d) and (e) of the Disclosure Rules are met. Nonetheless, the HKMA will keep the situation under review and will reconsider the issue in the light of any further guidance provided by relevant home country regulators. In the meantime, if any AIs encounter any difficulties in preparing their disclosures in accordance with the Disclosure Rules, they are welcome to consult the HKMA.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“In determining the materiality, reference should be made to the principle laid down in paragraph 13.7 of the Supervisory Policy Manual module “Guideline on the Application of the Banking (Disclosure) Rules” (CA-D-1).”
“AIs (unless they are subject to the de minimis exemption) are required to disclose publicly information in relation to their state of affairs, profit and loss and capital adequacy in accordance with the standards set out in the Banking (Di…”
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 5 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added