Guidance · HKMA · 13 Aug 2001
Exempt AIs must ensure their securities dealing staff meet all SFC Fit and Proper Criteria requirements, keep records of staff in the 6-month transitional period, and declare annually in the Return of Securities Related Activities (MA(BS)14) that all securities dealing staff completed the requisite CPT hours in the preceding calendar year, first for the period ending 31 December 2001. Corporate licensees must ensure staff meet the 5 CPT hours per calendar year, keep attendance records and CPT records for three years, and declare compliance in annual returns; excess CPT hours cannot be carried forward. Requirements apply from 1 April 2001. False declarations may lead to licence revocation or suspension.
Our Ref : G16/1C
B1/15C
13 August 2001
The Chief Executive
All authorized institutions that are exempt dealers Dear Sir / Madam, Amendments to Guidance Note on Competence and Guidance Note on Continuous Professional Training issued by the Securities and Futures Commission We wrote to you on 21 March 2001 regarding the Guidance Note on Competence and the Guidance Note on Continuous Professional Training (collectively referred to as “Guidance Notes”) issued by the Securities and Futures Commission (“SFC”). These Guidance Notes are also applicable to authorized institutions that are exempt dealers (“exempt AIs”). The SFC has recently revised these Guidance Notes (see Annex 1), and has issued its responses to some frequently asked questions (“FAQ”) in this regard (see Annex 2) which are published in the SFC Bulletin April – June 2001. This circular aims to draw your attention to the amendments to the Guidance Notes. In addition, Annex 3 provides explanation on certain administrative arrangements that the HKMA expects exempt AIs to adopt in complying with the Guidance Notes. Major changes to the Guidance Notes are in the following areas:
Guidance Note on Competence – paragraph 28 Under the earlier version, the SFC may license a director applicant who has yet to pass the local regulatory framework paper on condition that the person must pass this paper within three months. The same treatment is now extended to representative applicants, and a more flexible time frame is accepted. In this connection, the same approach would be adopted for the securities dealing staff 1 of exempt AIs. For more details, please refer to Annex 3 paragraph 1. …/2 Securities dealing staff is defined in our circular of 21 March 2001.
Guidance Note on Continuous Professional Training – paragraph 15 The Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee has decided that it will not pre-endorse internally organized training provided by corporate licensees. The latter are expected to organise appropriate training for their staff and to notify the SFC of the details of the training. The SFC may attend training so organised for quality assurance. Adopting a similar approach, the HKMA will not seek to pre-endorse internal training organized by exempt AIs. It may however choose to attend an exempt AI’s internal training session if it is not satisfied with the quality and professional knowledge of the exempt AI’s securities dealing staff. Unless otherwise notified, such training will be deemed to meet the CPT requirement. The HKMA will monitor compliance with the CPT requirement during on-site examination of the securities activities of exempt AIs. With regard to the requirement set out in paragraph 26 of the Guidance Note on Continuous Professional Training, exempt AIs are required to declare once a year in the Return of Securities Related Activities (MA(BS)14) that all their securities dealing staff have undertaken the requisite CPT hours in the preceding calendar year. The first declaration will be required in the forthcoming Return for the period ending the last day of December 2001. The respective amendments to the Return and the Completion Instructions will be issued in due course. The SFC may issue announcements and FAQ in respect of the Guidance Notes from time to time. Exempt AIs are therefore advised to visit the SFC web-site (http://www.hksfc.org.hk) regularly for various updates. Please feel free to contact Mr. Neville Ng (2878 8283) or Miss Alice Lee (2878 1603) should you have any question on the above. Yours faithfully, (Raymond Li) Executive Director (Banking Development) Encl.
Annex 1
Guidance Note on Competence
Hong Kong
June 2001
CONTENTS
Page(s)
Purpose 1
Introduction 2
Assessment of Competence 3
Test of Competence for Corporate Applicant 6 Test of Competence for Directors and Representatives 7 Points to Note 10 Role of the Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee 12 Summary of Options 12 Date from which Effective 12 Appendices
Appendix 1 13
Appendix 2 19
Appendix 3 20
Appendix 4 21
Appendix 5 22
Purpose
Introduction
3. Under section 23 of the Securities and Futures Commission Ordinance
(“SFCO”), section 121G and 121H of the SO and section 7 of the LFETO respectively, the Commission is obliged to refuse to grant a licence unless the applicant satisfies the Commission that they are fit and proper to be licensed. The matters that shall be considered in assessing fitness and properness include:
(a) financial status;
(b) educational or other qualifications or experience having regard to the nature of the functions to be performed; (c) ability to perform such functions efficiently, honestly and fairly; and (d) reputation, character, financial integrity and reliability.
4. The Fit and Proper Criteria, published by the Commission, sets out the
Commission’s general expectation of what is necessary to satisfy the licensing requirements that an applicant or licensee is fit and proper. Among the requirements are paragraphs 3.3(f) and 3.4(g) which state that corporations and individuals applying for licences will generally not be considered fit and proper unless they can demonstrate that they are competent to perform their functions efficiently and effectively.
5. Paragraph 5.2 of the Fit and Proper Criteria provides that the SFC will consider
revoking or suspending a licence if the licensed person is no longer fit and proper. In this regard, a licensed person is expected to remain competent in order to remain licensed.
Assessment of Competence
6. An applicant applying for a licence will be expected to demonstrate
competence by showing the knowledge, skill and ability necessary to discharge the functions as a licensed person effectively and efficiently. A licensed person is expected to remain competent at all times.
7. The expectations set out in this Guidance Note are not exhaustive.
8. An applicant may be able to satisfy the Commission that they are fit and proper
to be licensed even when they cannot satisfy the particular expectations set out in this Guidance Note.
9. Without compromising investor protection, the Commission will administer the
competence criteria flexibly. For applicants or licensees that are businesses, it will take into account the size and the nature of the business and accept alternate arrangements, whether in Hong Kong or elsewhere, be it at local company or group level, that are likely to achieve the objectives of effective management of risk and satisfactory internal controls. Similarly, for applicants or licensees who are individuals, the Commission will take into account the applicant’s responsibility, position within the organisation, and qualifications or experience gained locally or overseas.
10. For the purposes of this Guidance Note, corporate licensees refer to businesses
carrying on licensed activities and include sole proprietors, corporations and partnership. Individual licensees refer to directors 1 or representatives who are required to be licensed under the relevant Ordinances.
1 These are : directors under sections 48 and 49 of the SO, approved directors under section 121I of the SO, directors under sections 26 and 27 of the CTO and responsible directors under section 8 of the LFETO
Corporation
Entry Assessment
11. For corporate applicants, competence must be considered by reference to the
applicant’s organisational structure and the combined competence of its personnel.
12. An applicant should satisfy the Commission that it has proper business
structures, good internal systems and qualified personnel to enable it to properly manage the risks it will encounter in carrying on its business as detailed in its business plan. Continuous Assessment
13. A licensee must remain competent. The Commission must therefore be kept
informed of material changes in a licensee's business and structure.
14. Change in business and structure may be regarded as material if the change has
material impact on the nature and operation of the corporate licensee and may affect its ability to remain fit and proper. By way of example, the Commission will generally consider the following to be material:
(a) changes in key personnel;
(b) significant alteration to capital structure (whether debt or shareholder capital); (c) changes in services or products provided; (d) major modification to risk management policy; and (e) key changes to internal control procedures.
2 One reference point is “Ethics in Practice – A Practical Guide for Financial Practitioners” published jointly with the Independent Commission Against Corruption, SAR in October 1999.
Test of Competence for Corporate Applicant
19. Examples of matters that will be considered by the Commission in assessing
the competence of a corporate applicant are listed in Appendix 1.
20. Absence of the matters set out in Appendix 1 will not necessarily lead the
Commission to conclude that the corporate applicant is not competent but it will call for some explanation. In particular, the Commission will want to be satisfied in the particular case, either that the matter is unnecessary for an intermediary of that size or one conducting that type of business or that the objective to be served by a particular arrangement, is addressed in some other way.
21. For businesses in which the scale of business operation and the staff numbers
are relatively small, it is appreciated that sometimes in practice segregation of duties may not be possible. Under such circumstances, the Commission may consider alternative arrangements if the corporate applicant can demonstrate competence to manage risk exposures and to exercise effective control over operations. Clear written operational and compliance procedures should be available.
Test of Competence for Directors and Representatives Directors
22. In assessing the competence of a director, the Commission will ensure that the
director possesses appropriate ability, skills, knowledge and experience to properly manage and supervise the corporate applicant’s proposed activities. An applicant applying to be a director will normally be expected to meet one of the following options. (a) Option 1:
(b) Option 2:
obtain passes or above in English or Chinese, and Mathematics in
HKCEE or equivalent;
obtain a pass in one of the recognised industry qualification as set
out in Appendix 2 not more than 3 years prior to the date of application; and
pass one of the recognised local regulatory framework papers as
set out in Appendix 3 not more than 3 years prior to the date of application. (b) Option 2
in a position of responsibility in the relevant industry 3
for a period of not less than 2 years over the immediate past 5 years;
obtain a pass in one of the recognised industry qualification as set
out in Appendix 2 not more than 3 years prior to the date of application; and
pass one of the recognised local regulatory framework paper as
set out in Appendix 3 not more than 3 years prior to the date of application.
3 The specific types of responsibility in the relevant industry generally accepted by the Commission as compensating the lack of HKCEE or equivalent and relevant for licence as a representative are listed in
Appendix 4 (B and D).
Points to Note
24. The recognised local regulatory framework paper and the industry
qualifications mentioned above should be relevant to the activities to be performed by the applicant. For example, a securities dealer's representative applicant who relies on the HKSI Foundation Programme Examination should pass both the core paper and the securities elective paper. An applicant for licence as a securities dealer who is an Exchange participant in securities will be expected to pass both the paper on the Commission’s regulation and the paper on rules of SEHK of the HKSI Financial Market Principal Programme Examination.
25. There is currently no recognised industry qualification for persons engaging in
securities margin financing and leveraged foreign exchange trading. Depending on the level of responsibility and the type of licence sought, to demonstrate competence, applicants are generally expected to be able to display an understanding of the matters listed in paragraph 17. Completion of relevant industry courses or examinations will be favourably considered by the Commission.
26. Recognised industry qualifications are expected to be completed not more than
3 years prior to the date of application. However, the Commission will recognise qualification gained more than 3 years ago if the applicant has substantial relevant working experience and has remained in the industry (either in Hong Kong or overseas) or can prove recent registration with a relevant overseas regulator.
Role of the Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee
30. The Commission’s Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee
(“AAAC”), which comprises representatives from the Commission, the industry and academic institutions, will approve industry based qualifications and local regulatory framework papers for meeting the competence requirement.
31. The AAAC will from time to time amend the list of approved qualification that
it has endorsed for meeting the competence requirement.
Summary of Options
32. A summary of the options for directors and representatives is attached in
Appendix 5.
Date from which Effective
33. The requirements set out in this Guidance Note shall apply from 1 April 2001.
Appendix 1
Examples of matters that will be considered by the Commission in assessing the competence of corporate applicants:
I. Organisational Structure:
(a) Corporate Governance
(c) Risk Management and Control Strategy
4 The Commission will not insist that an independent risk manager or independent information technology manager be appointed if there is alternate arrangement in place which is sufficient to manage business risk exposures and exercise effective control over operations. This is irrespective of whether the alternate arrangement is undertaken in Hong Kong or elsewhere, at the local company level or group level. In any cases, there should be clear segregation of duties; the responsibilities of the risk manager should be clearly separated from that of front office personnel. Clearly, in most circumstances, more than 1 person will need to be appointed.
(e) Reporting and Control Functions
(g) Internal Control System
Proper documentation of all operational and control procedures is essential for providing employees with the necessary guidance in running the business in accordance with the company’s business objectives, professional standards and regulatory requirements.
II. Personnel :
(a) Qualified Staff
6 Relevant experience refers to practical experience gained in both front and back office, preferably at supervisory level. 7 Appropriate academic qualifications include degrees in related disciplines, relevant professional qualifications or completion of settlement or compliance related industry courses. Examples of “related” and “relevant” degrees or professional qualification include degrees or professional qualifications in law, accounting, business management, or risk management.
(ii) For existing staff
Recognised Industry Qualification for Directors and Representatives Country Organising Body Recognised Industry Qualification Directors Representatives Hong Kong Hong Kong Securities Institute (HKSI) HKSI Diploma Programme Examination Securities Brokers Examination HKSI Foundation Programme Examination Broker’s Representatives Examination The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (SEHK) Securities Brokers Examination Securities Brokers Course Broker’s Representatives Examination Broker’s Representatives Course US The National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc (NASD) General Securities Principal – Series 24 National Commodity Futures Examination – Series 3 General Securities Representative – Series 7 Australia The Securities Institute of Australia (SIA) Diploma Courses provided by SIA Certificates provided by SIA UK The Securities and Futures Authority (SFA) SFA Registered Persons Examinations Canada Canadian Securities Institute (CSI) The examinations conducted by the CSI Japan Japanese Securities Dealers Association (JSDA) Representative of Public Securities Course Note:
(1) Recognised industry qualifications for director are also applicable to representative. (2) The above list of recognised industry qualifications will be updated from time to time by the Commission.
Appendix 2
Appendix 3
Recognised Local Regulatory Framework Paper For Director HKSI Diploma Programme Examination – Paper 2 HKSI Financial Market Principal Programme Examination For Representatives HKSI Foundation Programme Examination – Paper 1 HKSI Diploma Programme Examination – Paper 2 HKSI Financial Market Principal Programme Examination Note:
The above list of recognised local regulatory framework paper will be updated from time to time by the Commission.
Appendix 4
Types of Industry Experience relevant to Representative A. Securities Margin Financier’s Representative who is approved as a director under
section 121I of the Securities Ordinance
Relevant industry experience would include margin financing, treasury and credit control at securities houses or financial institutions. B. Leveraged Foreign Exchange Trader’s Representative who does not handle discretionary account activities Experience in a related field such as treasury function in banking or corporation, or in a money broking industry would be recognised.
C. Leveraged foreign Exchange Trader’s Representative who handles discretionary
account activities and Leveraged Foreign Exchange Trader’s Representative who is a responsible director under section 8(b)(ii) of the Leveraged Foreign Exchange Trading Ordinance Relevant industry experience would include direct foreign exchange trading experience in the inter-bank foreign exchange market or currency futures market, or its equivalent. D. Representative other than Securities Margin Financier’s Representative and Leveraged foreign Exchange Trader’s Representative Experience in a related field such as banking, or accountancy, or in a broker’s back office will be regarded as relevant.
Appendix 5
Test of Competence for Directors
Option 1 Option 2
Educational qualification
Relevant degree
Or
Recognised industry qualification
Pass in
Chin/ Eng + Maths in HKCEE
Local regulatory framework paper Pass Pass Relevant industry experience At least 3 yrs over past 6 yrs At least 5 yrs over past 8 yrs Management skill & experience 2 yrs 2 yrs Test of Competence for Representatives Option 1 Option 2 Academic qualification Pass in Chin/ Eng + Maths in HKCEE
Recognised industry qualification
(specific to the functions to be performed ) Pass Pass Local regulatory framework paper Pass Pass Relevant industry experience
At least 2 yrs over 5 yrs
Guidance Note on
Continuous Professional Training
Hong Kong
June 2001
CONTENTS
Page(s)
Purpose 1
Introduction 1
Objectives of Continuous Professional Training 2 CPT Requirement 3 Obligation of the Corporate Licensees 3 Minimum CPT Requirement on the Individual Licensees 4 Means of Achieving CPT 5 Role of the Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee 7 Maintaining CPT records and Monitoring of CPT Compliance 7 Consequence of Non-Compliance 9 Date from which Effective 10
Purpose
4. This Guidance Note is applicable to all persons registered or licensed under the
Securities Ordinance (“SO”), the Commodities Trading Ordinance (“CTO”) and the Leveraged Foreign Exchange Trading Ordinance (“LFETO”). They are collectively named as “licensed persons” in this Guidance Note.
5. This Guidance Note aims to provide general guidance for licensed persons to
comply with the Commission’s Continuous Professional Training (CPT) requirements as stipulated in the Fit and Proper Criteria.
6. This Guidance Note does not have the force of law and should not be
interpreted in any manner which would override the provisions of any applicable laws, codes or other regulatory requirements. However, a failure to follow this Guidance Note may reflect adversely on the fitness and properness of a licensed person to continue to be licensed. Introduction
7. Licensed persons are required to be and to remain competent in that he or she is
expected to have the ability to perform the functions of a licensed person efficiently.
5. The securities, futures and leveraged foreign exchange industries are
characterised by rapid change and innovative financial products. In a changing technical and professional environment, licensed persons are required to continuously update their knowledge and skills through CPT in order to maintain their professional competence and to remain fit and proper.
Objectives of Continuous Professional Training
6. CPT is the systematic maintenance, improvement and broadening of
knowledge and skill to enable licensed persons to successfully carry out their duties competently and professionally. The objectives of CPT programme are:
(a) to maintain and enhance the technical knowledge and professional expertise of licensed persons; (b) to provide reasonable assurance to investors at large that licensed persons have the technical knowledge, professional skills and ethical standard required to perform their licensed functions efficiently, effectively and fairly; and (c) to maintain and enhance Hong Kong’s international reputation for high standards amongst licensed persons.
7. The Commission believes that the objectives of CPT will not be achieved
purely through work experience or “on the job” training. The Commission believes that it will generally be necessary for a licensed person to undertake CPT if they are to remain fit and proper.
8. The requirements for CPT will vary according to the size and nature of the
business and the nature of the responsibilities undertaken by a licensed person. Rather than mandating particular programs, this Guidance Note describes the general attributes of the CPT program.
CPT Requirement
9. The obligation to conduct and maintain CPT will be imposed upon all licensees,
that is both corporate licensees and individual licensees.
10. For the purposes of this Guidance Note, corporate licensees refer to businesses
carrying on licensed activities and include sole proprietors, corporations and partnership. Individual licensees refer to directors 8 or representatives who are required to be licensed under the relevant Ordinances. Obligation of the Corporate Licensees
11. Corporate licensees are held primarily responsible for designing and
implementing a continuous education programme best suited the training needs of their licensed directors and representatives and to enhance their industry knowledge, skills and professionalism.
12. Corporate licensee should at least annually evaluate its training programme and
prioritise the training needs of its staff.
13. In developing the training programme, consideration must be given to the
corporation’s size, organisation structure, risk management system, scope of business activities as well as prevailing regulatory framework and development.
8 These are : directors under sections 48 and 49 of the SO, approved directors under section 121I of the SO, directors under sections 26 and 27 of the CTO and responsible directors under section 8 of the LFETO
The training programme can be provided internally or make use of appropriate
available external sources. Where internal training courses are provided, corporate licensee should ensure that the content of such courses is structured and of benefit to staff in the performance of their functions. Subjects relevant to the licensed persons’ functions and which may enhance the licensed persons’ performance of their functions would meet the CPT purpose.
Internally organised training provided by corporate licensees will not be preendorsed by the AAAC. Corporate licensees are expected to notify the
Commission in advance of the date and details of the training to be conducted. An attendance record should be kept for persons who have completed the training. The Commission may attend any such training to ensure quality assurance. Minimum CPT Requirement on the Individual Licensees
Individual licensees must remain fit and proper at all times. One of the criteria
to assess the fitness and properness of a licensee is that he is continuously competent to perform his licensed functions. The Commission believes that such assessment can be made based on the CPT hours undertaken by the individual licensee.
The Commission will unlikely be satisfied that an individual licensee can
remain competent if that individual undertakes less than 5 CPT hours per calendar year. The Commission will regularly review the requirements for CPT hours to ensure that such requirements meet general market needs and international standards.
The Commission may impose higher CPT hours requirement by way of
condition on individual who is found by the Commission not able to discharge his licensed functions efficiently. Means of Achieving CPT
CPT hours are time spent by the individual in undertaking CPT activities. The
CPT activities should be of relevance to the functions to be performed by the individual licensees and be of significant intellectual and practical content which involves interaction with other individual.
Attending courses, workshops, lectures and seminars, long distance learning
and self-study which requires submission of assignments or assessment organised by recognised institutions, industry research, publication of papers, delivery of speeches and providing comments to industry consultation papers are considered to be acceptable CPT activities. The Commission will also recognise the time spent in giving relevant lectures or teaching as CPT activities although repeatedly giving the same lecture will not satisfy this requirement.
Normal working activities, general reading of financial press or technical,
professional, financial or business literature and activities which do not involve interactions with other individual will generally not be regarded as acceptable CPT activities.
By way of example, relevant topics for CPT activities with regards to directors
who play a crucial role in ensuring effective corporate governance and control may include the following topics:
(a) applicable compliance, legislative and regulatory standards; (b) business conduct and ethical standard; (c) new financial products in the industry and associated risk system; (d) general law principles; (e) business management; (f) trade practices; (g) risk management and control strategy; (h) general management and supervisory skills; (i) computer knowledge; (j) macro and micro economic analysis; and (k) financial reporting and quantitative analysis.
Representatives are required to remain fit and proper to perform the functions
of a representative at a professional level. Relevant topics for them include, amongst others, updates on:
(a) applicable compliance, legislative and regulatory standards; (b) business conduct and ethical standard; (c) new financial products in the industry and associated risk system; (d) business communication skills and trade practices; (e) general law principles; (f) computer knowledge; (g) basic accounting theories; and (h) fundamental economic analysis.
The Commission would like to stress that the above topics are examples only.
These are not mandatory subject matter and are by no means exhaustive.
Role of the Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee
25. The Commission’s Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee
(“AAAC”), which comprises representatives from the Commission, the industry and academic institutions, will scrutinize and may give recognition to those professional bodies and tertiary institutions which provide CPT. The AAAC will from time to time publish a list of recognised institutions that it has endorsed for providing CPT. Maintaining CPT records and Monitoring of CPT Compliance
26. Corporate licensees should have in place a continuous education programme
and be actively involved in arranging, organising or sponsoring training to promote and improve the professional competence and continued fit and proper standing of its licensed personnel. Sufficient records should be maintained to record the programme and the CPT activities undertaken by staff. In addition, a corporate licensee will be required to file a declaration in the annual return confirming that all its directors and representatives have undertaken the requisites CPT hours in the preceding calendar year.
27. Individual licensees are expected to comply with the 5 CPT hours per calendar
year, and the required reporting is done by means of declaration of compliance in his annual return submission. An individual licensee is required to report on his attainment of CPT hours on a preceding year basis, i.e. 1 year after implementation of the CPT requirements or 1 year after they obtain licences.
28. For example, after the CPT requirement is implemented in April 2001, the first
reporting will be for those individual licensees whose registration anniversary falls in April 2002. The first reporting period for CPT compliance will cover period April 2001 – December 2001 and the requisite pro-rata CPT hours 3.75. For those who are licensed after April 2001, say July 2001, they will have to
report CPT compliance in July 2002 covering the period July 2001 to December 2001. The requirement will be on a pro-rata basis: 2.5 hours of CPT for the 0.5 calendar year period.
29. Directors and representatives are also required to retain appropriate records of
all CPT activities completed in a calendar year. Documentary evidence sufficient to support their attendance or completion of the CPT activities should be kept by the individual for a minimum of 3 years, and these should be produced when required by the Commission.
30. Several practical issues regarding the accumulation of CPT hours are set out in
the following paragraphs:
(a) the CPT hours required for an individual, who is first licensed during the year, can be applied pro-rata with reference to the licence period; (b) the training courses attended prior to the date of grant of licence but in the same calendar year of licence can be counted as CPT hours; (c) when an individual licensees changes his employer within the same calendar year, he can carry forward his CPT hours earned at the old employer to the new employer. The new employer does not need to get the CPT information from the old employer. It can rely on declaration made by the staff; (d) it is not necessary for individual licensees to apportion his CPT hours earned with reference to his periods of employment with the old and new employers;
(e) new employers will not be penalised if the employee has not earned enough CPT hours at his old employer. However, they have to ensure that the new employee meets the yearly 5 CPT hours thereafter; and (f) excess CPT hours accumulated in one calendar year cannot be carried forward to the following year. Consequence of Non-Compliance
31. Licensees (corporations or individuals) are reminded that the onus is on them to
maintain CPT records. Failure to produce the CPT records required will raise questions about their fitness and properness and may lead to disciplinary action by the Commission.
32. An incorrect or false declaration made to the Commission by licensees
(corporate or individual) will raise serious concerns about whether the licensee is fit and proper, and may lead to revocation or suspension of the licence following disciplinary inquiry.
Annex 3
Application of the Guidance Notes to exempt AIs
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Guidance Note on Competence (“GNC”)
Test of Competence for Representative:
Option 1 Option 2
Before
1 April 2001
After
1 April 2001
Before
1 April 2001
After
1 April 2001
Educational
Qualification
Leveraged
Foreign
Exchange
Trader’s
Representative:
Pass in Chin /
Eng + Maths in HKCEE
Others:
Form 5
All:
Pass in Chin /
Eng + Maths in HKCEE
Do the competence requirements apply to exempt persons and its staff?
The requirements on competence are only applicable to persons licensed under the Securities Ordinance, Commodities Trading Ordinance and Leveraged Foreign Exchange Trading Ordinance. The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (“HKMA”) however expects authorised institutions which are exempt persons to comply with the Commission’s Fit and Proper Criteria and the GNC. The HKMA has issued a circular on 21 March 2001 to all authorised institutions that are exempt dealers drawing their attention to the competence requirement and that staff of exempt dealers who become securities dealing staff on or after 1 April 2001 must meet, among other things, the competence requirement.
Is there any exemption of examinations available to previously licensed
applicant?
An applicant who had previously been licensed and now applying for the same licence type within 3 years of their resignation will not be required to obtain the recognised industry qualification and pass the regulatory framework paper.
If a person is engaged in dealing in securities with an exempt person and no
licence is required, would he need to obtain recognised industry qualification and pass the local regulatory paper if he applies for a licence as dealer’s representative with the Commission after 1 April 2001? Yes. He will need to satisfy the competence test just as any other applicants.
Does a representative applicant who is a degree holder need to obtain a pass in
the industry based examination? (Remarks: For a director applicant, he will be exempted from this requirement if he is a degree holder in financial discipline.) Representative with relevant degree (such as law, finance, economics, accounting) needs not complete the industry based examination.
For an applicant who satisfies all licence requirements except the passing of the
local regulatory framework paper, can conditional approval be granted to him? Yes, conditional licence of 6 months duration may be granted to both director and representative applicants pending the passing of local regulatory framework paper.
Does an existing licensee applying for a change of employment need to meet
the competence requirements?
The competence requirement applies to all applicants after 1 April 2001. Applicants who were previously licensed in the same licence type had already demonstrated that they met the competence requirement at the time of their prior application, and they are deemed to meet the competence requirement if they apply again within 3 years of their resignation. Naturally, the applicants will also have to remain fit and proper in all other respects in order for their new application to be approved.
Will current licensee applying for other types of licences after 1 April 2001 be
“exempted” from passing the recognised industry qualification and the local regulatory framework paper? Each applicant’s competence is assessed in relation to the activities and functions he will perform. In other words, different types of licensed activities call for different industry knowledge and knowledge about different rules and codes of conduct. Therefore, an applicant may be required to complete particular examination papers of the recognised industry qualification and the local regulatory framework paper relevant to the functions he will perform under the new licence he is applying for. See also Q18.
If an applicant has no HKCEE qualification and never worked in the relevant
industry (e.g. an owner of a trading firm, a supervisor of a restaurant etc), can he obtain a representative licence after 1 April 2001 if he has passed all the required examinations? No.
Which industry based courses will be recognised by the Commission for
competence purpose?
The list of industry based courses currently recognised by the Commission are shown in Appendix 2 of the GNC. The list will be updated on a monthly basis. Interested parties should go to the SFC’s website under “What’s new” to look for the latest list.
Will the Commission accept the HKSI Foundation Programme Examination
completed prior to 1 April 2001 and not more than 3 years prior to the date of application as a recognised industry qualification for director applicant? Yes.
Does an applicant need to complete the local regulatory framework paper if he
has already passed the Securities Brokers Examination / Broker’s Representative Examination? Not required. However, these examinations are still subject to the 3 years recency test.
What examination does the Commission expect local commodity dealer’s
representative applicants to take?
Currently, the Commission would expect these applicants to complete the HKSI Foundation Programme Examination Paper 1 and 3. See also Q18.
What is actually expected from leveraged foreign exchange trader’s
representative (“FXTR”) and securities margin financier’s representative (“SMFR”) under paragraph 26 of the GNC? How are they going to demonstrate that they understand the matters listed in paragraph 17 of the GNC? FXTR and SMFR are generally expected to have a basic understanding of the rules and regulations applicable to them. In addition, they should be familiar with the products and markets they deal with. Until appropriate industry qualifications are recognised as meeting the competence standard for FXTR and SMFR by the Commission, competence will be assessed in light of relevant working experience.
What are the procedures required for seeking competence recognition from the
Commission’s Academic and Accreditation Advisory Committee (“AAAC”) and what kind of information should be submitted for consideration? Submission should be made to the Secretary of the AAAC in the “Application Form for Approval as Recognised Industry Qualifications”. Supporting documentation and details on organiser, objective and learning outcome of the course, admission requirements, course syllabus, study hours, question types, examination hours, passing marks, completion criteria, external assessment, reciprocal recognition, how the course will meet licensing requirement, any ongoing evaluation of the course and fees should be provided. The said application form can be downloaded from the Commission’s web-site or obtained from the Licensing Counter.
Paragraph 31 of the GNC states that AAAC will from time to time amend the
list of approved qualification. How often will the list be updated and where can industry participants find the updated list? The Commission will update the list of approved qualifications on a monthly basis and post the list on its web-site.
Will certificates issued by overseas secondary schools be accepted as evidence
of achieving an educational level equivalent to HKCEE?
All high school public examinations (such as university entry examinations) will be recognised as equivalent to HKCEE.
What types of examination are applicable to different licence types?
Please refer to Appendix 1 and 2.
Will the requirement for local regulatory framework examination apply to short
term licence applicant?
No.
Will application need to be accompanied by evidence of passing the industry
based qualification?
Yes, otherwise the application will be returned.
What is the Special Examination Arrangement for HKSI Financial Market
Principal Program Examination?
The HKSI, in addition to their regular schedule for sitting the Financial Market Principal Program Examination, also offers special examination arrangement for candidates who request an alternate examination date for sitting regarding the said examination. The exact examination date and time will be mutually agreed between HKSI and the candidate. For enrolment procedures and details, please call HKSI at 3120 6220 for information.
Recognised Industry Qualification Vs Licence Category Recognised Exam DPE 1 SBE/SBC 2 FPE 3 BRE/BRC 4 Directors DD-SEHK participant Paper 1+2+3 Pass - - DD-non-SEHK participant Paper 1+2+3 Pass - - IA Paper 1+2+3 Pass - - CD-HKFE participant Paper 1+2+3 - - - CD-non-HKFE participant Paper 1+2+3 - - - CTA Paper 1+2+3 - - - Representatives DR-SEHK participant Paper 1+2+3 Pass Paper 1+2 Pass DR-non-SEHK participant Paper 1+2+3 Pass Paper 1+2 Pass IAR Paper 1+2+3 Pass Paper 1+2 Pass CDR-HKFE participant Paper 1+2+3 - Paper 1+3 - CDR-non-HKFE participant Paper 1+2+3 - Paper 1+3 - CTAR Paper 1+2+3 - Paper 1+3 - OR Note: There is currently no relevant examination available for SMFR and FXTR. Key:
DD Securities Dealer
IA Investment Adviser
CD Commodity Dealer
CTA Commodity Trading Adviser
DR Securities Dealer’s Representative
IAR Investment Representative
CDR Commodity Dealer’s Representative
CTAR Commodity Trading Adviser’s Representative SMFR Securities Margin Financier’s Representative FXTR Leveraged Foreign Exchange Trader's Representative SEHK Stock Exchange of Hong Kong HKFE Hong Kong Futures Exchange DPE : HKSI Diploma Programme Examination SBE/SBC : Securities Brokers Examination/ Securities Brokers Course FPE : HKSI Foundation Programme Examination BRE/BRC : Broker’s Representatives Examination/ Broker’s Representative Course PPE : HKSI Financial Market Principal Programme Examination
Appendix 1
Recognised Local Regulatory Framework Paper Vs Licence Category Regulatory Framework Paper DPE 1 PPE 5 FPE 3 Directors DD-SEHK participant Paper 2 Paper 1+2 - DD-non-SEHK participant Paper 2 Paper 1 - IA Paper 2 Paper 1 - CD-HKFE participant Paper 2 Paper 1+3 - CD-non-HKFE participant Paper 2 Paper 1 - CTA Paper 2 Paper 1 - Representatives DR-SEHK participant Paper 2 Paper 1+2 Paper 1 DR-non-SEHK participant Paper 2 Paper 1 Paper 1 IAR Paper 2 Paper 1 Paper 1 CDR-HKFE participant Paper 2 Paper 1+3 Paper 1 CDR-non-HKFE participant Paper 2 Paper 1 Paper 1 CTAR Paper 2 Paper 1 Paper 1 OR OR 14 June 2001
Appendix 2
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Guidance Note on Continuous Professional Training (“GNCPT”)
The AAAC has also determined that seminars given by the Commission pertaining to regulatory updates and other relevant topics can be recognised for CPT purposes.
4. Will all the courses organised by Hong Kong Securities Institute (“HKSI”) be
recognised for CPT purpose?
Generally, training courses organised by HKSI for continuous professional development and which are relevant to the performance of the licensee’s duties can be recognised for CPT purpose.
5. Paragraph 20 of the GNCPT states that the carrying out of industry research and
publishing of papers will be counted as CPT hours. Does it mean that a research analyst will be able to fulfil his CPT requirements in the performance of his ordinary research duties? The requirement for 5 hours of CPT is generally expected to be met by work conducted outside the ordinary everyday work as a registered person. In this regard, AAAC has determined that such requirements should be met by attending seminars and/or courses that meet the description outlined in paragraphs 22 and 23 of the GNCPT.
6. Will a licensee be regarded as having fulfilled the CPT requirement if he has only
completed a single training course which lasts for more than 5 hours in a calendar year? If the course meets the CPT requirement, then yes.
7. Will the CPT hours be counted with reference to the number of licences that a
licensee possesses at the year end? For example: Does a representative holding both securities dealer’s representative and commodity dealer’s representative need to complete 5x2=10 CPT hours a year? Yes, as securities and futures are 2 different fields. However, if the licensee can show that a particular course is relevant to more than 1 licensed activity, he may claim it as CPT in respect of all the relevant licences.
8. Will the attendance of training courses prior to the CPT effective date (ie 1 April
2001) be recognised for CPT purpose? For example, if a licensee attends an 8 hours
training course on 5 January 2001, has he already fulfilled all the CPT requirements of calendar year 2001? Yes, but not those courses attended before 2001.
9. How should the licensees report the number of CPT hours undertaken during the
year?
Corporate licensees are required to declare in the annual return that all its directors and representatives have undertaken the requisite CPT hours in the preceding calendar year.
Individual licensees are also required to report their number of CPT hours and the subject matter in their annual return.
10. Corporate licensees and individuals need to declare CPT compliance in annual
returns. Will there be a special declaration form to complete? Both corporate and individual are required to declare their CPT activities in their annual returns. The revised annual return forms will be mailed to the licensees one month prior to their anniversary dates. Blank copies will also be available for collection at the Licensing Counter of the Commission.
11. If a corporate licensee has a Common Anniversary Date on 1 October, when should it
report CPT compliance and what is the first reporting period? The licensee should report CPT compliance in October 2002 in respect of the period from 1 April 2001 to 31 December 2001.
12. If the licensee leaves his principal before the anniversary date, will his principal need
to report his CPT compliance in its next annual return?
No.
13. Will viewing training video tapes and self-study of materials provided by the principal
meet CPT requirement?
If the training video tapes and self-study materials meet the criteria stated in paragraphs 22 and 23 of the GNCPT, they will be recognized for CPT purposes.
14. Does corporate licensee need to submit all CPT attendance evidence to the
Commission?
Not required. However, corporate licenses are expected to satisfy themselves of the CPT compliance and when necessary, able to produce record to evidence the CPT compliance.
15. How long should licensees keep their CPT compliance records?
The records should be kept for three years.
16. What CPT records will the Commission staff inspect during their field visit?
For corporate licensees, the Commission staff may inspect the relevant records. The Commission staff may also request individual licensees to provide documentary evidence supporting their attendance or completion of CPT activities. Example of documentary evidence includes certificate of attendance issued by the course providers, examination results …etc.
Corporate licensees are obliged to arrange and sponsor training courses. Does the
Commission expect the corporate licensees to pay for the training activities? Will the Commission take action against them for passing the training costs to the staff? Does the Commission have any channel to handle the complaints lodged by staff against their principals in this respect? The corporate licensee is obliged to ensure that its staff meets the CPT requirement and to advise and organise such training as appropriate for their staff. As to who is to bear the costs of training, this will be a matter between the corporate and individual licensees.
Will study hours used in preparing for industry based qualification be counted for
CPT hours?
Yes, provided that such study hours are accumulated after the grant of licence and a pass in the relevant examination is proven.
Will AAAC give endorsement to internal training organised by corporate licensees?
The AAAC will not endorse internal training organised by corporate licensees but corporate licensees are expected to notify the Commission prior to the holding of the training session. The Commission may sit in at such training session. Corporate licensees are required to keep proper attendance record at each training session for those staff who completed the training. Although pre-endorsement is not given by AAAC, it does not mean that internal training will not meet CPT.
Please advise on the organisations the AAAC will consider approving as “recognised
institutions” for CPT purpose.
The AAAC will consider only application as “recognised institution” from professional bodies and tertiary institutions for CPT purpose. It will not entertain applications from external consultants or professional firms.
How will the AAAC view training organised by external consultants or professional
firms?
Although the AAAC does not endorse training conducted by external consultants or professional firms, it does not mean that these training do not meet CPT. If these firms organise training for corporate licensee, the corporate licensee will be responsible to ensure that the training so arranged by the external consultants or professional firms are of appropriate relevance and standard for CPT.
What are the application procedures to become a “recognised institution”?
Submission should be made to the Secretary of the AAAC in the “Application Form for Professional Bodies and Tertiary Institutions for Approval as Recognised Institution”, which can be downloaded from the Commission’s web-site or obtained from our Licensing Counter.
“Course fees, training time and membership requirements are so different for training
offered by different organisers. Can the Commission centralise training program and standardise course fees, training time and dispense with membership fee?” The training offered by different organisers may have require different training time due to the complexity of the subject matter and how in depth the topic is covered in the session. The course fee is very often a reflection of such, and the amount charged is a commercial decision made by the organiser. This is not within the jurisdiction of the Commission. However the Commission does conduct regulatory updates for interested parties to attend, which can be counted towards CPT requirements. And the Commission will continue to organise such sessions when appropriate. 14 June 2001
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 5 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated