Guidance · HKMA · 8 Feb 2019
AIs must assess CSRBB for fair value items such as debt securities, measure IRRBB at least quarterly with continuous monitoring, and not engage in window dressing. They must use 10 years of NMD data where available, notifying supervisors for 7–10 years and seeking approval below 7 years. Non-performing loans (net of specific provisions) are interest rate-sensitive assets; CNH and CNY must be reported separately. The Hong Kong branch of a parent bank must implement the new local IRRBB standards by July 2019.
Banking Policy Department
Our Ref: B1/15C
B9/187C
S4/7C
8 February 2019
The Chief Executive
All Authorized Institutions
Dear Sir/Madam,
Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book: Frequently Asked Questions On 14 December 2018, we issued a revised version of the Supervisory Policy Manual (SPM) IR-1 “Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book” (IRRBB) and the two related returns, (MA(BS)12A and MA(BS)12B). Following this publication, the HKMA has received a number of questions related to the local IRRBB implementation. As the answers to some of these questions may be of interest to the industry as a whole, we would like to make them accessible to all interested parties. Regarding the general exemption for some Authorized Institutions (AIs) incorporated outside Hong Kong, as set out in our circular dated 31 August 2018, the revised version of the SPM IR-1 and the related returns, we consider the exemption criteria sufficiently clear to allow all AIs to ascertain whether they are exempted from the new local IRRBB standards or not. Therefore, no separate notifications will be issued to individual AIs. In case of any remaining potential doubt, an AI should contact its case officer to verify whether or not it is exempted from the new local IRRBB framework. To help ensure a consistent implementation of the new local IRRBB framework across the industry, we have provided answers to a range of frequently asked questions (FAQs) on the HKMA’s Supervisory Communication Website (https://www.stet.iclnet.hk). They can be found under the main items “Reporting Requirements” and “Supervisory Policy” (see the sub-item “FAQ” under these main items and the links to the relevant subjects “MA(BS)12A” and “IRRBB”, respectively). All AIs subject to the new local IRRBB framework are encouraged to make reference to these FAQs for their firm-specific IRRBB implementation. The FAQ list will be updated on an ongoing basis to reflect the most recent status on questions we receive from AIs.
V.1, 8 February 2019
Supervisory Communication Website > Supervisory Policy > FAQ > IRRBB Item Question Answer 1 Regarding the general exemption of AIs incorporated outside Hong Kong from the new local IRRBB framework set out in HKMA’s circular dated 31 August 2018, will the exempted AIs be notified? No, there will not be any firm-specific notifications. As the exemption criteria and requirements have been clearly set out in the circular to all AIs dated 31 August 2018 as well as in the finalised IRRBB policy documents published on 14 December 2018, all AIs should be able to ascertain whether they are exempted from the new local IRRBB standards or not. In case of any potential remaining doubt, an AI should contact its case officer to verify whether or not it is exempted from the new local IRRBB framework. 2 Regarding the general exemption of AIs incorporated outside Hong Kong from the new local IRRBB framework set out in HKMA’s circular dated 31 August 2018, will the parent group of an AI be considered “additionally represented in Hong Kong through a locally incorporated AI” if the parent group only If the locally incorporated AI is part of the parent group according to the scope of regulatory consolidation in the home jurisdiction, then the parent group will be considered “represented in Hong Kong through a locally incorporated AI” even though the locally incorporated AI may not be fully owned by the parent. This also means that the Hong Kong branch of the parent bank will not be exempted and has to implement the new local IRRBB standards by July 2019. Whether the Hong Kong branch of the parent bank and a locally incorporated AI owned by the parent group are completely independent in terms of structure and business decision is not a condition for the exemption. This will therefore not affect whether the Hong Kong branch of the parent bank will be exempted from implementing the new local IRRBB standards.
partially owns the locally incorporated AI?
3 How should AIs investigate
Credit Spread Risk in the
Banking Book (CSRBB) within the IRRBB framework and which products are in scope for CSRBB? In line with Section 1.4 in the Annex of the Basel standards on IRRBB, in particular Figure 1 on p. 34, AIs must assess CSRBB for items at fair value, that is, for example, debt securities. It is the AI’s responsibility to develop a suitable methodology for CSRBB. 4 At which frequency does the HKMA expect AIs to measure and monitor IRRBB? AIs should measure their IRRBB at least quarterly and monitor their IRRBB exposure on a continuous basis. Whether an AI needs to measure its IRRBB more frequently (on an ongoing basis, or specifically after certain events) will depend on the information it gathers from the continuous monitoring process (e.g. whether the information has any material impact on the AI’s IRRBB) and the buffer between the IRRBB exposures and the AI’s internal IRRBB exposure limit. To ensure internal control and regulatory supervision are not undermined, AIs are expected not to engage in ‘window dressing’, i.e. lowering their quarter-end interest rate exposures temporarily in a systematic manner. 5 Are there any guidelines on how AIs should monitor IRRBB exposures? As different AIs have very different interest rate risk profiles, AIs should set up their own monitoring frameworks that are commensurate with their firm-specific interest rate risk profiles. 6 Are there any requirements for AIs to monitor and test As long as the AIs have not engaged in window dressing, such monitoring or testing will not be necessary.
whether the month- or quarter-end aggregate IRRBB positions are systematically lower?
V.1 8 February 2019
Supervisory Communication Website > Reporting Requirements > FAQ > MA(BS)12A Item Question Answer 1 Can an AI whose local/overseas subsidiaries are insignificant in terms of the size of total assets and liabilities exclude these from the consolidated IRRBB return? It is possible to exempt certain insignificant subsidiaries from the scope of the consolidated IRRBB return. An AI can contact its supervisor to apply for such an exemption, provided that the aggregate notional positions (the interest-rate sensitive positions on the assets or liabilities side of the balance sheet, whichever is larger, plus off-balance sheet interest rate-sensitive positions) of all the relevant subsidiary entities do not account for more than 5% of its total consolidated notional interest rate-sensitive positions on the assets or liabilities side of its balance sheet, whichever is larger. The HKMA will consider approval on a case-by-case basis, having regard to the specific circumstances of the applicant AI. An AI that has been granted such exemptions would potentially be considered as an outlier if its IRRBB exposure exceeds 14% (rather than 15%) of its Tier 1 capital. 2 Which products are in scope for the IRRBB framework? Are credit card receivables, nostro and vostro accounts in scope? All products not excluded in paragraph 10 of the IRRBB Return Completion Instructions are in scope. Products in scope therefore include credit card receivables, nostro and vostro accounts. 3 Does the HKMA waive the need to address optionality for products that are not material to the overall IRRBB profile of The Basel standards do not feature any materiality thresholds. Therefore AIs must assess all interest rate-sensitive assets and liabilities to monitor and report their interest rate risk.
the AI?
4 How should AIs treat the optionality in managed rate products like prime rate loans? The following is the reporting procedure for floating rate mortgages subject to prime rate caps:
6 How does the interest rate floor, used for the ΔEVE and ΔNII calculations, affect interest rate shocks? Application of the −2% floor slightly differs between assets and liabilities: on the asset side the risk-free rate is floored at −2%. AIs taking spreads into account add this spread to the floored risk-free rate. On the liability side the sum of the risk free rate plus the negative spread (if taken into account) is floored at −2%. This approach is reflected in paragraph 5.3.2 of the SPM. For example, if the risk-free yield in the time bucket ‘Next day or less’ before the parallel downward shock is −0.1%, then applying the formula from paragraph 5.3.2 of the SPM results in a post-shock interest rate of −2%. That is, the floored shock in the time bucket ‘Next day or less’ is −1.9%. 7 Does the HKMA provide yield curves used in the IRRBB framework? How can AIs construct the yield curve used in the IRRBB framework? The HKMA does not provide AIs with risk-free yield curves because these differ by currency and tend to change over time. It is the responsibility of AIs to construct appropriate yield curves based on the market conditions of individual currencies. 8 Can on- and offshore Renminbi be treated as a single currency in the IRR reporting template? There still can be significant divergence between CNH and CNY interest rates, as could be observed in the last couple of years, and therefore CNH and CNY should be reported separately for the time being. 9 Do net positions used for ΔEVE calculations have to be the same as net positions used for ΔNII calculations? Are zero coupon bonds and credit card In general, net positions for EVE and NII calculations should be coherent. For the cases of zero coupon bonds and credit card receivables, these products are in scope for the ΔNII calculations. Including them reflects scenario-induced changes in accrued interest rate income or fee-generated income. However, notable exceptions include products with embedded optionality. An optional treatment for such products is outlined in paragraph 42 of the IRRBB Return Instructions.
receivables in scope for the
ΔNII calculations?
10 How are non-performing loans treated under the new IRRBB framework?
Non-performing loans (net of specific provisions) must be included as interest rate-sensitive assets. 11 Should loans and trade finance products be reported gross or net of provisions on MA(BS)12A? Notional reporting of loans and trade finance products in rows A to S on Form 1 of MA(BS)12A should be made net of specific provisions, while book value reporting of total interest rate-sensitive assets in row T on Form 1 should be made gross of provisions. It should be noted that all (both specific and general) provisions should be reported as other non-interest sensitive liabilities (book value) in row V on Form 2. 12 Should the mark-to-market value of derivatives recorded on balance sheet be excluded in Form 1 and Form 2 of MA(BS)12A? The mark-to-market value of derivatives recorded on balance sheet should be excluded for notional reporting (rows A to S) on Form 1 and Form 2 of MA(BS)12A, but they should be included for book value reporting (row T) on Form 1 and Form 2 of MA(BS)12A. 13 Should the accrued interest receivables and payables recorded on balance sheet be excluded in Form 1 and Form 2 of MA(BS)12A? Accrued interest receivables and payables should be excluded for notional reporting (rows A to S) on Form 1 and Form 2 of MA(BS)12A, but they should be included for book value reporting (row T) on Form 1 and Form 2 of MA(BS)12A. 14 Should a product with fixed Yes, that is correct.
rate cap/floor be reported as fixed rate if the fixed rate cap/floor is triggered? For the basis risk calculation, should the same calculation logic as floating rate assets subject to managed rate cap be followed? 15 Are AIs permitted to construct the risk-free yield curve (without spread components) for discounting purposes even if the AIs slot coupon cash flows including spread components? Yes, that is allowed (see footnote 23 in MA(BS)12A). 16 Do AIs need to go through the entire automatic interest rate options valuations procedure for all currencies (including currencies that will not be major) before arriving at the conclusion that which currencies are major and AIs are expected to be fully aware of their interest rate exposures through options for all currencies. If the AIs can show that a currency is not major by any alternative method without going through the entire automatic interest rate options valuations, it will also be acceptable provided that the alternative method is reasonable.
whether the sum of all non-major currencies exceed the 10% threshold?
17 If an AI has less than 7 years of historical data and intends to use the data for identifying core deposits, how can they compare their assumptions and results with the “peer banks” which are usually not disclosed? The AI may make reference to the assumptions and results of their parent banks or other banks in the same group. In case this is not possible then perhaps they can propose their assumptions for HKMA's consideration, and the HKMA will advise whether the assumptions are acceptable based on its observations from the peer banks. 18 How to obtain implied volatility or market price of rarely traded option? AIs are expected to identify proxies for the purpose of option valuation or estimate the value of illiquid/non-existent options themselves.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from HKMA
HKMA published 5 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Hong Kong Monetary Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added