Individual decision · SEC · 24 Aug 2016
The Division of Corporation Finance grants Enersis Americas S.A. an exemption from Exchange Act Rule 14e-5, permitting the purchase or arrangement to purchase Endesa Americas Shares outside the Tender Offer. This relief applies to the Merger and the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights under Chilean law, which might otherwise be deemed prohibited purchases. The exemption allows shareholders to choose between participating in the Merger, exercising dissenters' rights for a formula-based cash payment, or tendering shares for a fixed price of Ch$ 285 per share. The relief is strictly limited to this transaction and contingent on the representations and facts provided in the August 24, 2016 letter.
UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549
DIVISION OF
CORPORATION FINANCE
August 24, 2016
Response of the Office of Mergers and Acquisitions Division of Corporation Finance J. Allen Miller Chadbourne & Parke LLP 1301 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10019 Re: Enersis Americas S.A. Tender Offer for Shares of Endesa Americas S.A. Dear Mr. Miller:
We are responding to your letter dated August 24, 2016, addressed to Ted Yu, Christina Chalk, and Jennifer Lopez-Molina, as supplemented by telephone conversations with the staff, in regard to your request for exemptive relief. To avoid having to recite or summarize the facts set forth in your letter, we attach the enclosed copy of your letter, as well as a copy of the accompanying letter from Chilean counsel, Cariola Diez Perez-Cotapos & Cia. Unless otherwise noted, capitalized terms in this response letter have the same meaning as in your August 24, 2016 letter. On the basis of the representations and the facts presented in your letter, the Division of Corporation Finance, acting for the Commission pursuant to delegated authority, by separate order is granting an exemption from Exchange Act Rule 14e-5. This exemptive relief permits the purchase or an arrangement to purchase Endesa Americas Shares subject to the Tender Offer, other than pursuant to the Tender Offer, to the extent that the Merger and the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights under Chilean law could be deemed to be a prohibited purchase or arrangement to purchase Endesa Americas Shares under Exchange Act Rule 14e-5. In granting this relief, we note the following:
J. Allen Miller
Chadbourne & Parke LLP
August 24, 2016
J. Allen Miller
Chadbourne & Parke LLP
August 24, 2016 been determined and fixed pursuant to Chilean law, the Merger exchange ratios will have been determined, and such information will have been disclosed;
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
In the Matter of a Tender Offer for
Shares of Endesa Americas S .A.
August 24, 2016
ORDER GRANTING EXEMPTION FROM
EXCHANGEACTRULE 14E-5
Enersis Americas S.A. submitted a letter dated August 24, 2016 requesting that the Securities and Exchange Commission ("Commission") grant an exemption from Exchange Act Rule 14e-5 for the transaction described in its letter ("Request"). Based on the representations and the facts presented in the Request, and subject to the terms and conditions described in the letter from the Division of Corporation Finance dated August 24, 2016, it is ORDERED that the request for an exemption from Exchange Act Rule 14e-5 is hereby granted. For the Commission, by the Division of Corporation Finance, pursuant to delegated authority. Brent J. Fields Secretary Action as set forth or recommended herein APPROVED pursuant to authority delegated by the Commission under Public Law 87-592. For: Division of Corporation Finance By: j ± Date '8=/ 1-y ( ll 1 ~ ---""---!-( -t----+-1 --
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
100 F Street, N .E.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Attn: Ted Yu, Esq., Chief, Office of Mergers and Acquisitions chadbOurne Chadbourne & Parke LLP 1301 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 1001 9 telephone: (212) 408-51 00 August 24, 2016 Christina Chalk, Esq., Senior Special Counsel, Office of Mergers and Acquisitions Jennifer Lopez-Molina, Esq., Attorney-Adviser, Office of Mergers and Acquisitions Re: Merger of Endesa Americas S.A. and Chilectra Americas S.A. with Enersis Americas S.A. and Tender Offer by Enersis Americas S.A. for All Outstanding Shares ofEndesa Americas S.A. Ladies and Gentlemen:
We are writing on behalf of Enersis Americas S.A., a Chilean company formerly known as Enersis S.A. ("Enersis Americas"), and Endesa Americas S.A., a Chilean subsidiary of Enersis Americas ("Endesa Americas"), in connection with (i) the proposed merger of Endesa Americas and Chilectra Americas S.A. ("Chilectra Americas") with and into Enersis Americas (the "Merger"), with Enersis Americas as the surviving company continuing under the name Enersis Americas S.A. (the "Surviving Company"), and (ii) the proposed dual tender offer by Enersis Americas in the U.S. and Chile for all outstanding shares ofEndesa Americas ("Endesa Americas Shares") (including in the form of American Depositary Shares ("ADSs")) not owned by Enersis Americas (the "Tender Offer") at the tender offer price of Ch$ 285 per share (the "Tender Offer Price"). The Merger and the Tender Offer are both part of a reorganization (the "Reorganization") of certain Chilean electricity generation and distribution companies ultimately controlled by Enel S.p.A., an Italian electricity and generation company ("Enel"), to separate the Chilean and non-Chilean electricity generation and distribution businesses ofEnersis Americas, Empresa Nacional de Electricidad S.A. ("Endesa Chile") and Chilectra S.A. ("Chilectra"). The Reorganization consists of (i) the spin-off by Enersis Americas of Enersis Chile S.A. ("Enersis Chile"), the spin-off by Endesa Chile ofEndesa Americas and the spin-off by Chilectra of Chilectra Americas (collectively, the "Spin-Offs") and (ii) the Merger and the related Tender Offer. The Reorganization is a transaction that involves the planned merger of a spin-off entity (Endesa Americas) that was initially announced on April 22, 2015, before the spin-off had been approved or the spin-off entity existed. Under Chilean law, the merger requires the separate vote of the shareholders following the spin-off, and there was concern that the normal minority protection mechanism in a merger provided by Chilean statute (namely the cash payment upon exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights based on a pre-merger market trading New York I Washington, DC I Los Angeles I Mexico City I Sao Paulo I London I Moscow I Warsaw* I Istanbul I Dubai I Johannesburg
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -2- August 24, 2016 formula), would not provide adequate protection for the minority shareholders who wished to dissent from the merger because Endesa Americas did not have an established trading market for its shares before the Spin-Off. The cash amount payable upon exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights is based on the weighted average trading prices ofEndesa Americas Shares during a specified period prior to the shareholders' meeting to vote on the Merger. As a result, the transaction was structured to add the Tender Offer to the Merger to address these concerns. The Merger and related Chilean component of the Tender Offer are Chilean transactions (i) among Chilean companies, (ii) governed by Chilean statutory provisions, (iii) involving Chilean minority shareholder protections, (iv) scrutinized as related party transactions under Chilean law and (v) overseen by the Superintendencia de Valores y Seguros, the Chilean securities commission (the "SVS"). The U.S. interest in these Chilean transactions is limited. As discussed in Section LB., based on the analysis of holders resident in the United States under the rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "Commission"), Enersis Americas believes that non-U.S. resident ownership ofEndesa Americas Shares is over 92% of total outstanding shares of Endesa Americas (including as outstanding all shares underlying ADSs and all shares owned by Enersis Americas) or approximately 83% of the unaffiliated free float (excluding Enersis Americas' 59.98% interest). Shareholders of Enersis Americas, Endesa Chile and Chilectra approved the Spin-Offs of Enersis Chile, Endesa Americas and Chilectra Americas as the first step of the Reorganization in December 2015. The distribution of the shares in the Spin-Offs was completed, and trading of the spin-off company shares began, on April 21, 2016. In the second step of the Reorganization, the shareholders of Endesa Americas would be provided with three alternatives with respect to their Endesa Americas Shares in connection with the Merger:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -3- August 24, 2016
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -4- August 24, 2016 the Tender Offer, other than pursuant to the Tender Offer, to the extent that the Merger and the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights made available under Chilean law could be deemed to be a prohibited purchase or arrangement to purchase Endesa Americas Shares under Rule 14e-5.
II. Background
A. Enersis Americas
Enersis Americas is a company organized under the laws of the Republic of Chile and is a "foreign private issuer" as defined in Rule 3b-4(c) under the Exchange Act. Enersis Americas' ADSs ("Enersis Americas ADSs") and debt securities are registered under Section 12(b) of the Exchange Act and traded on the New York Stock Exchange (the "NYSE"). Shares of Enersis Americas trade on the Santiago Stock Exchange, the Chilean Electronic Stock Exchange and the Valparaiso Stock Exchange (collectively, the "Chilean Stock Exchanges"). Enel has indirect beneficial ownership of 60.6% of Enersis Americas. B. Endesa Americas Endesa Americas is a company organized under the laws of the Republic of Chile and is a "foreign private issuer" as defined in Rule 3b-4( c) under the Exchange Act. The distribution of the shares of Endesa Americas in the Spin-Off from Endesa Chile was completed, and the trading of its shares and ADSs commenced, on April 21, 2016 as part of the Reorganization. Endesa Americas' ADSs are registered under Section 12(b) of the Exchange Act and traded on the NYSE. Since April 21, 2016, Endesa Americas Shares have been trading on the Chilean Stock Exchanges and Endesa Americas ADSs have been trading on the NYSE. Enersis Americas has direct beneficial ownership of 59.98% of Endesa Americas. In accordance with the instructions to Rules 14d-l ( c) and ( d) under the Exchange Act, Enersis Americas, with the assistance of Georgeson Inc., a shareholder consultancy firm, performed an analysis of (i) the holders of shares and ADSs of Endesa Chile (the company from which Endesa Americas was spun-off) resident in the United States ("U.S. Residents") as of November 20, 2015, the most recent practicable date before public announcement of the Tender Offer on November 24, 2015, and (ii) the U.S. Resident holders ofEndesa Americas Shares and Endesa Americas ADSs as of April 29, 2016, the most recent practicable date after the initial trading of Endesa Americas Shares commenced. Based on such inquiry, as of November 20, 2015, Endesa Chile shares represented by ADSs represented approximately 3.99% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Chile shares. Approximately 3.1 % of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Chile shares were held by U.S. Residents in the form of shares and not ADSs, almost entirely through Chilean custodial
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -5 - August 24, 2016 accounts required for foreign investors in Chile for tax purposes. Excluding Endesa Chile shares held by Enersis Americas, which represented 59.98% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Chile shares, and treating all ADSs as held by U.S. Residents, U.S. Resident holders ofEndesa Chile shares and ADSs represented approximately 17.84% of the unaffiliated free float. Of the 17.84% of the unaffiliated free float, approximately 9.96% are in the form of ADSs and the remaining 7.88% are in the form of shares. Based on such inquiry, as of April 29, 2016, Endesa Americas Shares represented by ADSs represented approximately 3.5% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Americas Shares. Approximately 3 .1 % of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Americas Shares were held by U.S. Residents in the form of shares and not ADSs, almost entirely through Chilean custodial accounts required for foreign investors in Chile for tax purposes. Excluding Endesa Americas Shares held by Enersis Americas, which represent 59.98% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Americas Shares, and treating all ADSs as held by U.S. Residents, U.S. Resident holders ofEndesa Americas Shares and ADSs represented approximately 16.5% of the unaffiliated free float. Of the 16.5% of the unaffiliated free float, approximately 8.74% are in the form of ADSs and the remaining 7.76% are in the form of shares.
C. Chilectra Americas
Chilectra Americas is a company organized under the laws of the Republic of Chile. The distribution of the shares of Chilectra Americas in the Spin-Off from Chilectra was completed, and the trading of its shares commenced, on April 21, 2016 as part of the Reorganization. Since April 21, 2016, Chilectra Americas shares have been trading on the Chilean Stock Exchanges. Chilectra Americas' shares are not registered under the Exchange Act, are not represented by ADSs and not traded on any U.S. stock exchange. Enersis Americas has direct beneficial ownership of 99 .1 % of Chilectra Americas.
III. Description of the Merger and the Tender Offer
A. The Merger
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -6- August 24, 2016 shareholders ofEnersis Americas, Endesa Chile and Chilectra and the SVS, prior to the shareholders' meetings held on December 18, 2015 to approve the Spin-Offs. At the time, the shareholders were advised that the Merger would be subject to separate shareholder votes of the shareholders of the parties to the Merger, including Endesa Americas and Chilectra Americas, which, as spin-off companies, had not yet come into existence. As disclosed in the Registration Statement, the Merger will be conducted by means of a statutory merger under Chilean law but requires the approval of the shareholders of Enersis Americas, Endesa Americas and Chilectra Americas at their respective shareholders' meetings. In addition, the Merger will only be consummated if:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -7- August 24, 2016 exercise period. A shareholder that elects to exercise statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights must provide a written notice of such intent to the company during the prescribed exercise period. Statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights may only be exercised by a shareholder of the Chilean company. Holders of ADSs must withdraw their shares from the ADSs and become shareholders of the Chilean company in order to exercise statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights. At the time the final Prospectus/Information Statement and other materials for the shareholders' meetings to vote on the Merger are distributed, the statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights prices will be known and will be included in those shareholders' meeting materials. B. The Tentler Offer and the Tender Offer Price
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -8- August 24, 2016 the future contemplated Spin-Offs were completed, and as such there was no trading market at the time the proposed Reorganization was announced to serve as a point of reference for shareholders. There was concern raised by certain minority shareholders of Endesa Chile, before the approval of the Spin-Offs in December 2015, that the market price ofEndesa Americas Shares could be more vulnerable to market fluctuations and uncertainties because of, among other reasons, its expected lower liquidity due to the pendency of the Merger. In response to such concerns, the Board of Directors ofEnersis Americas proposed in November 2015 to include the Tender Offer as an ancillary transaction to the Merger to provide additional protection to the post-Spin-Off minority shareholders of Endesa Americas in connection with the Merger. Specifically, the Tender Offer Price establishes a fixed cash value that minority holders ofEndesa Americas Shares and Endesa Americas ADSs could obtain if they preferred a cash alternative to the consideration to be provided in the Merger. The initial proposed tender offer price of Ch$ 236 per share of Endesa Americas that was announced on November 24, 2015, was determined based on the average share price ofEndesa Chile for the prior three months and weighted by the relative contribution of the non-Chilean businesses (that would be contributed to Endesa Americas in the Spin-Offs) to the value of Endesa Chile estimated by the financial advisor to the Directors' Committee of Endesa Chile. The Tender Offer Price of Ch$ 285 per share was determined following requests by Chilean minority shareholders of Endesa Chile that were made public and represents a premium of approximately 20% over the initial proposed tender offer price. In November 2015, the Board of Directors ofEnersis Americas agreed and publicly announced that Enersis Americas would conduct the Tender Offer at an initial proposed tender offer price of Ch$ 236 per share. The Tender Offer Price was subsequently increased and the increased price was announced in December 2015, immediately prior to the shareholders' meetings held on December 18, 2015. Preliminary information regarding the Tender Offer (including the Tender Offer Price), as well as the Merger, and Enersis Americas' commitment to conduct the Tender Offer at the Tender Offer Price, was provided to the market, the shareholders ofEnersis Americas and Endesa Chile and the SVS prior to the shareholders' meetings held on December 18, 2015 to approve the Spin-Offs. At the time, Endesa Americas had not yet come into existence. The distribution of Endesa Americas Shares in the Spin-Off was completed, and the trading in the Endesa Americas Shares and ADSs commenced, on April 21, 2016. As of August 4, 2016, the closing price of Endesa Americas Shares on the Santiago Stock Exchange was Ch$ 310.67 per share; the Tender Offer Price is Ch$ 285 per share.
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -9- August 24, 2016
2. Regulation of the Tender Offer
A. Chilean Law
Chile has adopted laws governing tender offers for Chilean companies. The SVS has authority to regulate the Chilean Offer. We have been advised that pursuant to Chilean law, tender offers must be addressed to all shareholders of the subject company on equal terms, and therefore, Enersis Americas cannot exclude U.S. Resident holders ofEndesa Americas Shares from the tender offer in Chile (the "Chilean Offer"). We have also been advised that Chilean law requires that any person seeking to acquire shares of a Chilean listed corporation by means of a tender offer must make the offer to all shareholders on the same conditions and must comply with other applicable requirements of the Chilean Securities Act. B. Dual Tender Offer Structure Under Tier II Relief Enersis Americas has determined to conduct the Tender Offer by means of (i) the Chilean Offer in Chile to all minority holders ofEndesa Americas Shares (including U.S. Resident holders) regardless of residency and (ii) a tender offer in the United States to U.S. Resident holders of Endesa Americas Shares and any holders of Endesa Americas ADSs, regardless of residency (the "U.S. Offer"). The Chilean Offer and the U.S. Offer will have substantially identical terms and will be conducted, subject to limited exceptions, with substantially identical procedures. Based on its analysis of U.S. Resident shareholders ofEndesa Americas, Enersis Americas believes that the U.S. Offer would be eligible for Tier II Relief.
IV. Proposed Timing of the Merger and Tender Offer
As described in the tentative timetable attached hereto as Exhibit A, Enersis Americas proposes to launch the Tender Offer contemporaneously with the distribution of the Prospectus/Information Statement included in the Registration Statement. The purpose of the timing is to provide Endesa Americas shareholders with information with respect to the Merger, the Tender Offer and the Chilean statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights before they vote on the Merger. Furthermore, both the U.S. Offer documents and the Prospectus/Information Statement will contain information regarding the relationship between the Merger and the Tender Offer, including the three alternatives that are available to Endesa Americas minority shareholders in connection with the Merger.
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -10- August 24, 2016 Specifically, these alternatives are for Endesa Americas minority shareholders to:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -11- August 24, 2016 any securities subject to a tender offer or any related securities. This prohibition applies from the time the tender offer is first publicly announced until the tender offer expires. We understand that the Staff has expressed the view that filing a definitive proxy statement for the solicitation of shareholder approval for a merger during the pendency of a tender offer may under certain circumstances constitute an "arrangement to purchase" securities and a potential violation of Rule 14e-5. In the context of the Merger, by analogy to the Staffs definitive proxy statement position, we understand that the Staff may view the effectiveness of the Registration Statement and the distribution of the final Prospectus/Information Statement included in the Registration Statement to shareholders and ADS holders of Enersis Americas and Endesa Americas in connection with the Merger as an "arrangement to purchase" Endesa Americas Shares and Endesa Americas ADSs. Similarly, we understand that the Staff may view the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights by Endesa Americas shareholders as an "arrangement to purchase" Endesa Americas Shares by Endesa Americas, as an affiliate of Enersis Americas subject to Rule 14e-5. Based on such views, Rule 14e-5 could be interpreted to prohibit (i) Enersis Americas from having the Registration Statement declared effective and distributing the final Prospectus/Information Statement in connection with the Merger contemporaneously with the launch of the Tender Offer and holding the extraordinary shareholders' meetings to vote on the Merger, as Enersis Americas proposes to do, and (ii) Endesa Americas shareholders from exercising their statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights pursuant to Chilean law prior to the end of the Tender Offer period. B. Exemptive Relief for the Merger and Exercise of Chilean Statutory Merger Dissenters' Withdrawal Rights Enersis Americas believes that the Merger and the exercise of the Chilean statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights merit deference to Chilean laws applicable to the Merger, the Tender Offer·and the statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights in the same manner as the Commission has provided for deference to home country laws in certain exceptions to Rule 14e-5, such as the exceptions provided by Rules 14e-5(b)(10) and (11). The Merger and the Chilean Offer are governed by Chilean law. We are advised that Chilean tender offer rules include a rule similar in many respects to Rule 14e-5 that prohibits purchases of shares outside of a tender offer in Chile. We are also advised that under Chilean law, the Merger and the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights would not be considered prohibited purchases that would be restricted while the Chilean Offer is open. Moreover, the actual exchange of the shares under the Merger and purchase of shares under the withdrawal rights will
occur only after the Tender Offer is closed.
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -12- August 24, 2016 In addition, even if the Merger and the exercise of the statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights were subject to Rule 14e-5, the Merger and the Tender Offer do not implicate the discrimination or manipulation concerns Rule 14e-5 was adopted to address. As noted in the Rule 14e-5 adopting release, Rule 14e-5 is designed to prevent fraudulent, deceptive or manipulative acts or practices in connection with a tender offer for equity securities "by preventing an offeror from extending greater or different consideration to some security holders outside the offer, while other security holders are limited to the offer's terms."2 The Merger, the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights and the Tender Offer do not implicate concerns related to fraudulent, deceptive or manipulative acts or practices because, in the proposed transaction all minority holders of Endesa Americas Shares and Endesa Americas ADSs (i) will be able to participate in the Tender Offer and the Merger, (ii) will be able to exercise statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights, if they choose to dissent, and (iii) will receive disclosure about the Merger and the Tender Offer before they vote on the Merger. In addition, the Tender Offer was introduced to the Reorganization by Enersis Americas at the suggestion of minority shareholders to provide additional protections for all minority shareholders. Furthermore, the underlying policy concern of Rule 14e-5 that purchases outside the tender offer could manipulate the market price in a manner that could have negative impacts on the tender offer are not applicable in connection with the Tender Offer and the Merger. At the time the Tender Offer is launched, the price to be paid to shareholders exercising their statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights will have been determined and fixed pursuant to Chilean law, the merger exchange ratios will have been determined and such information will have been disclosed. As a result, there would not be the same manipulation concerns that underlie the policy rationale of Rule 14e-5 because the investing public will have received information as to the "true state of affairs."3 2 See Section II.C.l of the "Cross-Border Tender and Exchange Offers, Business Combinations and Rights Offerings", Release Nos. 33-7759, 34-42054; 39-2378, International Series Release No. 1208 (the ''Cross-Border Release"). See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 34-8712 (October 8, 1969) (adopting Rule lOb-13, the predecessor rule to Rule 14e-5): "[I]rrespective of the price at which such purchases [outside the tender offer] are made, they are often fraudulent or manipulative in nature and they can deceive the investing public as to the true state of affairs."
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -13- August 24, 2016 The fundamental purpose of the Tender Offer is to serve as a protection for the minority shareholders of Endesa Americas by providing them a fixed cash alternative for their Endesa Americas Shares, given the fact that at the time the Reorganization was announced Endesa Americas did not exist and had no trading market. Unlike typical tender offers, the Tender Offer is not intended to allow Enersis Americas to acquire (i) additional control in order to avoid the need to obtain shareholder approval for the Merger or (ii) additional voting power in order to influence the shareholder vote regarding the Merger. The Merger and the Tender Offer are not structured as a typical two-step acquisition with an initial tender offer followed by a short-form merger. Shareholder approval of the Merger will be required under Chilean law regardless of the outcome or progress of the Tender Offer. In fact, acquiring Endesa Americas Shares in the Tender Offer would not allow Enersis Americas to influence the shareholder vote on the Merger because it would not acquire any additional shares or voting power in Endesa Americas until after the shareholders' meeting to vote on the Merger, given that the closing of the Tender Offer occurs well after the date of the shareholders' meeting. In addition, there is little risk for shareholder confusion because Enersis Americas and Endesa Americas have been transparent about the inclusion of the Tender Offer as part of the overall Reorganization. Preliminary information regarding the Tender Offer and the Tender Offer Price was presented to shareholders of Endesa Chile as part of the shareholder approval of the Spin-Offs on December 18, 2015, before Endesa Americas (the target company) even existed as a post spin-off entity. There will be disclosure about the interconnections between the Merger and the Tender Offer, including the alternatives that are available to Endesa Americas shareholders, in all relevant documentation, and such information will be provided to holders of Endesa Americas Shares and Endesa Americas ADSs in the Prospectus/Information Statement and U.S. Offer documents distributed before Endesa Americas shareholders vote on the Merger. Although the Commission did not adopt an exception from Rule 14e-5 for Tier II offers similar to the exemption provided for Tier I offers, the Staff indicated that it would continue to review requests for relief from Rule 14e-5 for non-Tier I offers. The Staff has enumerated certain factors that it considers important in considering Rule 14e-5 exemption requests in cross-border transactions, including (i) the proportional ownership of U.S. security holders of the subject security in relation to the total number of shares outstanding and to the public float; (ii) whether the offer will be for "any-and-all" shares or will involve prorationing; (iii) whether the offered consideration will be cash or securities; (iv) whether the
offer will be subject to a foreign jurisdiction's laws, rules, or principles governing the conduct of tender offers that provide
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -14- August 24, 2016 protections comparable to Rule 14e-5; and (v) whether the principal trading market for the subject security is outside the United States.4 Based on the analysis of holders resident in the United States, Enersis Americas believes that as of April 29, 2016, non-U.S. Resident ownership ofEndesa Americas Shares is over 93% of total outstanding shares of Endesa Americas (including as outstanding all shares underlying ADSs and all shares owned by Enersis Americas) or approximately 84% of the unaffiliated free float (excluding Enersis Americas' 59.98% interest). Endesa Americas Shares represented by ADSs represented approximately 3.5% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Americas Shares. Approximately 3. I% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Americas Shares were held by U.S. Residents in the form of shares and not ADSs, almost entirely through Chilean custodial accounts required for foreign investors in Chile for tax purposes. Excluding Endesa Americas Shares held by Enersis Americas, which represent 59.98% of the total issued and outstanding Endesa Americas Shares, and treating all ADSs as held by U.S. Residents, U.S. Resident holders of Endesa Americas Shares and ADSs represented approximately 16.5% of the unaffiliated free float. The level of U.S. Resident ownership is not substantially above the 10% ownership level that would have qualified Enersis Americas for almost complete relief from the U.S. tender offer rules in a Tier I offer under Rule 14d-l(c) under the Exchange Act. The Tender Offer will be a cash tender offer for any and all Endesa Americas Shares and ADSs. The Merger and the Tender Offer will be made on the same basis to U.S. and non-U.S. holders ofEndesa Americas Shares (including Endesa Americas Shares represented by Endesa Americas ADSs) and will be subject to extensive Chilean regulation. Under Chilean law: (i) the same price must be paid to each shareholder on a per share basis; (ii) the offeror cannot withdraw the offer except for predetermined and disclosed termination conditions (that can be waived); (iii) the tender offer is subject to the supervision of the SVS; (iv) the offeror cannot buy shares outside of the tender offer; (v) the individual directors of the target company have to issue a formal statement about the terms of the tender offer; (vi) the tender offer terms may only be changed to improve the price, increase the amount of shares offered to be purchased or extend the tender offer period to a maximum term of 45 days; (vii) the offeror must comply with information obligations; (viii) the target company and its directors may not (x) buy target shares, 4 See Section 11.C.1 of the Cross-Border Release. See also No-Action and Exemptive Letter:
Tender Offer for Shares of Chemoil Energy Limited (December 14, 2009).
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission -15- August 24, 2016 (y) sell assets representing more than 5% of total assets or (z) increase indebtedness by more than 10%. In addition, the primary trading market of Endesa Americas Shares is in Chile. In view of the relatively low level of U.S. Resident ownership and the significant protections provided under Chilean law, Enersis Americas believes that considerations of international comity with Chilean law should be taken into account. We note that the Staff has shown flexibility when applying the U.S. tender offer rules in situations where, as here, the level of U.S. interest is low and the constituency making an investment decision consists primarily of non-U.S. Residents.s Enersis Americas, a Chilean foreign private issuer, seeks relief in a situation involving a business combination with Endesa Americas, another Chilean foreign private issuer, in a transaction that is regulated by and subject to minority protections established under Chilean law and overseen by the Chilean SVS. Based on the foregoing, we respectfully request on behalf of Enersis Americas that the Staff grant exemptive relief from the provisions of Rule 14e-5 under the Exchange Act to permit the purchase or an arrangement to purchase Endesa Americas Shares subject to the Tender Offer, other than pursuant to the Tender Offer, to the extent that the Merger and the exercise of statutory merger dissenters' withdrawal rights made available under Chilean law could be deemed to be a prohibited purchase or arrangement to purchase Endesa Americas Shares under Rule 14e-5. The foregoing request for relief would be subject to the following conditions:
See No-Action Letter: Reuters Group PLC and Thomson Reuters PLC (February 29, 2008).
Except for the exemptive relief requested herein, Enersis Americas will comply with all applicable provisions of the Exchange Act and the rules thereunder in connection with the Merger and the Tender Offer, including Regulations 14D and 14E and Rule 13e-3. Attached to this letter is a letter of Chilean counsel stating that the descriptions of Chilean law, regulation and practice applicable to the Merger and the Tender Offer in this letter are accurate. If you have any questions or require additional information, please contact J. Allen Miller at (212) 408-5454 or amiller@chadbourne.com or Sey-Hyo Lee at (212) 408-5122 or shlee@chadbourne.com. cc: Lisa M. Kohl, Esq., U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Michael Kennedy, Esq., U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission TSY/tsy CPAM: I 0080841.6
December 18,
2015
April 21.
2016
August 5,
2016
September 8,
2016
September 13,
2016
Tentative Timetable of Dates for Tender Offer" Action Shareholders ofEnersis S.A., Empresa Nacional de Electricidad S.A. and Chilectra S.A. approve the Reorganization, consisting of:
September 26,
2016
September 28,
2016
September 29-
0ctober 28,
2016
October 28,
2016
October 31,
2016*
November.2,
2016'
November 3-4,
2016
November 5-27,
2016
December 1,
2016
Action
ADS voting cutoff date
Extraordinary shareholders' meetings to vote on the merger Chilean statutory merger dissenters' "withdrawal rights"t exercise period (for each party to the merger) Tender Offer period ends (at the close of trading on the Chilean Stock Exchanges) Announce results of Tender Offer Certification that all conditions to the merger have been satisfied Tender Offer payments made and purchase of tendered shares completed Payment to holders exercising statutory merger dissenters' "withdrawal rights" and purchase of shares completed Merger effective Comment 30 calendar days from date of shareholders' meetings Maximum period of 45 days from launch under Chilean law, assuming an extension of 15 days from initial 30 day period (i.e., for launch on September 13, period ends October 28, 2016) Must be publicly announced in Chile within 3 calendar days of end of Tender Offer period After conditions have been satisfied Chilean practice is to pay 2-3 days after announcement of Tender Offer results Payment must be made within 30 calendar days of end of statutory merger dissenters' "withdrawal rights" exercise period (i.e., by November 27, 2016) Merger effective on first day of calendar month following the month in which the merger conditions were certified as satisfied Right of dissenting shareholders to receive cash payment equal to the weighted average closing price of the shares during the 60-trading-day period between the 30th and 90th trading days preceding the applicable extraordinary shareholders' meeting. Note: October 31 and November 1, 2016 are public holidays in Chile. 2 CPAM: 9605522.12
CARJC)Lt\ DIEZ 1?EREZ--COT1\POS
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Attn: Ted Yu, Esq., Chief, Office of Mergers and Acquisitions .-;' ;'I ·~I) , l;i I n ~ ·11 r1 ;l ., ; .1.:~'\ t' Oi\i!): ~ ~1~~-.11 "~ i rJH1f !f! l~..-!.·2~rJ -.1.1_ :I.I August 24111 , 2016 Christina: Chalk, Esq., Senior Special Counsel, Office of Mergers and Acquisitions Jennifer Lopez-Molina, Esq., Attomey Advisor, Office of Mergers and Acquisitions Re: Merger of Endesa Americas S.A. into Enersis Americas S.A. and Tender Offer by Enersis Americas S.A. for Shares ofEndesa Americas S.A. Ladies and Gentlemen:
We are acting as special Chilean counsel to Enersis Americas S.A., a corporation organized under the laws of the Republic of Chile ("Enersis Americas"), in connection with its proposed tender offer (the "Tender Offer") for all outstanding (a) shares of common stock, no par value ("Endesa Americas Shares"), and (b) American Depositary Shares ("Endesa Americas ADSs") of Endesa Americas S.A., a corporation organized under the laws of the Republic of Chile ("Endesa Americas"), other than any Endesa Americas Shares owned by Enersis Americas, as described in the Registration Statement on Form F-4 (the "Form F-4"), as amended, filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the "Commission") (Registration No 333- 211405). In such capacity, we have reviewed the letter, dated August 241 h, 2016, prepared by Chadbourne & Parke LLP on behalf of Enersis Americas requesting certain exemptive relief in connection . with the Tender Offer and the proposed merger of Endesa Americas and Chilectra Americas S.A. with and into Enersis Americas (the "Merger") as described therein (the "Letter"). We confirm that in our opinion the descriptions of Chilean law and regulation in the Letter are fair, complete and accurate, in all material respects, as regards the aspects of the Tender Offer and the Merger described in the Letter for which exemptive relief has been requested therein. We also confirm that in our view the descriptions of Chilean practice in the Letter are fair, complete and accurate, in all material respects, as regards the aspects of the Tender Offer and the Merger described in the Letter for which exemptive relief has been
requested therein. The foregoing confirmations are limited to matters involving the laws of the Republic of Chile and are not to be read as extending by implication to any other matters not referred to herein. This letter is provided at the request of the staff of the Commission solely for the benefit of the addressee in connection with the request for relief for the transactions contemplated in the Letter and may not be used or relied upon by any other person or for any other purpose. Sincerely yours, 2 CARIOLA DIEZ PEREZ-COTAPOS &CIA TD.// Fron[.~~ ~~/ If
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from SEC
SEC published 7 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Securities and Exchange Commission — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and reviewed before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated