SEC Division of Investment Management staff letter: Malaysian Central Depository Sdn. Bhd.

MAY i l'19
... .1....

"-:, '

Our Ref. No. 92-728-CC

Malaysian Central
RESPONSE OF THE OFFICE OF CHIEF COUNSEL Depository Sdn. Bhd.

DIVISION OF INVESTMENT MAAGEMENT
File No. 132-3

Your letter dated December 10, 1992, as supplemented by your

letters dated January 25, 1993, March 19, 1993, April 13, 1993,

and April 28, 1993, and supporting materials, requests our

assurance that the Malaysian Central Depository Sdn. Bhd. ("MCD")

qualifies as an "eligible foreign custodian" pursuant to

subparagraph (c) (2) (iii) of Rule 17f-5 under the Investment

Company Act of 1940 (the "Act") and that we would not recommend

enforcement action to the Commission if the MCD serves as an

eligible foreign custodian for securities listed on the Kuala

Lumpur Stock Exchange ("KLSE"). 1./ The MCD is a subsidiary of the KLSE, the only securities

exchange in Malaysia. ~/ There is no over-the-counter market in

Malaysia. The MCD began operating the Central Depository System

("CDS"), an electronic book-entry system, on March 2, 1993. You

represent that the CDS is the only central depository system for securi ties listed on the KLSE. 1/ You further represent that the 1./ Section 17 (f) of the Act provides that every registered

management investment company shall maintain its securities

and similar investments in the custody of (1) a bank meeting

certain requirements, (2) a member of a national securities

exchange, (3) the company itself, in accordance with

Commission rules, or (4) a system for the central handling

of securities pursuant to which all securities of any

particular class or series of any issuer deposited within

the system are treated as fungible and may be transferred or

pledged by bookkeeping entry without physical delivery of

such securities, in accordance with Commission rules. Rule

17f-5 provides an exemption from Section 17 (f) permitting a

registered management investment company to deposit foreign securi ties in the custody of an "eligible foreign custodian." Rule 17f-5(c) (2) (iii) defines the term "eligible foreign custodian" to include "a securities

depository or clearing agency, incorporated or organized under the laws of a country other than the united States, which operates the central system for handling of securities

or equivalent book-entries in that country."

~/ You represent that the KLSE owns 55% of the voting stock in the MCD, the Association of Banks Malaysia owns 25%, and a

government foundation owns 20%.

1/ You note that trades in securities that are not part of the CDS are settled through physical delivery through the

Securi ties Clearing Automated Network System ("SCANS"). The

SCANS is 99% owned by the KLSE. The SCANS collects all of (continued. . . )

CDS is the only central system for handling book-entry transfers

of securities in Malaysia, with the exception of certain

government bonds and mortgage securities that are not listed on

the KLSE and are transferred by a book-entry system operated by

Bank Negara Malaysia (Malaysia's central bank). ~/

You represent that investment company portfolio securities

in the MCD typically will be held in the custody of a bank that

is an "authorized direct member" of the MCD. fl/ Authorized

direct members have direct access to the CDS through their own

MCD accounts as well as through MCD accounts established for

their Wholly-owned subsidiaries and nominee companies.

Generally, a bank will establish an MCD account in the name of a

wholly-owned, locally incorporated nominee company through which

the bank's foreign clients' assets, including those of a

registered investment company, will be held and through which their trades will be settled. The KLSE prescribes the securities to be deposited with the

MCD. £/ Generally, a prescribed security cannot be traded on the

KLSE until the investor deposits the scrip representing it, along

wi th the instrument of transfer, in an MCD account or with a

1/ ( . . . continued) the physical scrips of securities to be traded and nets the

trades per broker at the end of each trading day. The SCANS

is not a depository.

~/ You represent that the Bank Negara system permits scripless trading in certain federal government securities and

mortgage securities between participating banks and between

those banks and the central bank, that none of those

secur:ties is listed on the KLSE, and that there will be no

overlaP between the securities handled by the MCD and the

securi ties handled by Bank Negara.

fl/ The MCD may appoint banks and other financial institutions as authorized direct members. See Rules of the Malaysian

Central Depository Sdn. Bhd., Part III, Ch. 14 and Part IV,

Ch. 33. Of course, because such a bank would be deemed to

have custody of the investment company's assets, it too

would have to be an eligible foreign custodian wi thin the

meaning of Rule 17f-5 (c) .
£/ You state that the MCD is implementing scripless trading gradually. The KLSE will prescribe approximately ten to

twelve securities per month to be deposited with the MCD,

beginning with securities of smaller companies. You

represent that within three to five years, all securities

listed on the KLSE will be traded through the MCD book-

entry system.

broker who is an "authorized depository agent" of the MCD. 2/

When a security owned by a registered investment company is

prescribed, the authorized direct member that has custody of the

security will give the scrip and the instrument of transfer to

the MCD, which will lodge the scrip and the instrument of

transfer with the issuer. ~/ After validating the scrip and

certifying the instrument of transfer, the issuer will cancel the

scrip and issue jumbo certificates in the name of the Malaysian

Central Depository Nominees Sdn. Bhd. ("MCD Nominees"), a wholly-

owned subsidiary of the MCD, which will act as custodian of the

deposited securities and bare trustee for the depositors. Thus,

the original scrip will be removed from circulation and

cancelled, and the jumbo certificates on deposit with the MCD

will become the only remaining physical representations of traded

securities. The MCD Nominees will hold physical custody of the

jumbo certificates and treat them as fungible.

All transactions in deposited securities will be executed by

the CDS, which will treat all securities of a given class or

series of an issuer as fungible. Physical transfer of

certificates for those securities will be unnecessary. ~/ The

CDS will facilitate and record all transactions in connection

wi th prescribed securities, including transfers of securities

between the MCD accounts, public offerings, bonus issues, rights

offerings, options, share splits, consolidations, and capital

restructurings. The CDS also will permit investors to pledge or

otherwise encumber their securities.

Your letters also describe the Malaysian government' s

regulation of the MCD. The MCD is regulated by the Securities

Commission, the Ministry of Finance, and the Registrar of

1/ Under Malaysia's Securities Industry (Central Depositories)

Act 1991, an "authorized depository agent" is a person

appointed by a central depository to act as its agent for

certain purposes, including facilitating the deposit of

securities into the CDS. See Sections 2 (1) and 13 of the

Securities Industry (Central Depositories) Act 1991; see

also Rules of the Malaysian Central Depository Sdn. Bhd.,

Part II, Ch. 2.

~/ We understand that the MCD will provide an official receipt for the scrip to the authorized direct member, which will

break down the receipt by customer and provide individual

receipts to each customer. The MCD each day will send to

the issuer a list of scrips lodged with the issuer and the

issuer will acknowledge receipt of those scrips. Telephone

conversation with Steven A. Hirsch, counsel to MCD, on

May 12, 1993.

~/ Investors may request and receive certificates for a fee.

Companies. The MCD was incorporated in accordance with the

companies Act of 1965 and received permission from the Minister

of Finance to operate the depository pursuant to the Securities

Industry (Central Depositories) Act 1991. As described in more

detail in your letter dated December 10, 1992, the Minister of

Finance has broad regulatory authority over the MCD, including

the power to approve or disapprove amendments to the MCD' s rules

and to adopt additional regulations regarding the operation of

the central depository. The Registrar of Companies is empowered

to inspect the books and records of the MCD, the MCD Nominees,

and others in connection with the operation of the MCD system, to

investigate violations of the Central Depositories Act, and to

levy fines against, or prosecute, violators. As further

described in your letter dated March 19, 1993, the Securities

commission is empowered to supervise and monitor the MCD, to

adopt regulations, to investigate violations of the Securities

Industry (Central Depositories) Act 1991 and other laws, 101 and

to inspect records and gather evidence with respect to violations

of those laws.

On the basis of the facts and representations contained in

your letters and supporting documents, particularly your

representations that (1) the MCD is a securities depository and

clearing agency that will, when fully implemented, operate the

only central system for the handling of securities or equivalent

book-entries listed on the KLSE, (2) there will be no overlap

between the securities handled by the MCD and the government and

mortgage securities handled by Bank Negara, (3) all securities

listed or proposed for listing on the KLSE will be prescribed for

deposit with the MCD within three to five years from the date the

MCD begins to implement the CDS, and (4) the MCD (including the

CDS) is subj ect to the supervisory and regulatory control of the

Malaysian government, we would not recommend that the Commission

take any enforcement action under Section 17 (f) of the Act, or

Rule 17f-5 thereunder, if the MCD acts as an eligible foreign

custodian as defined in Rule 17f-5(c)(2)(iii), for securities

listed on the KLSE. You should note that any different facts or

representations might require a different conclusion. Moreover,

this response expresses the Division's position on enforcement

action only and does not express any legal conclusions on the

questions presented.

¡J7c4~
Richard F. Jackson

Attorney
101 The Securities Commission also has the authority to

investigate violations of the Securities Commission Act

1993, the Securities Industry Act 1983, and the Futures

Industry Act 1993.

, ~
~
(A Subsidiary ofKLSE)
Lot 2.4. 2nd Floor. Bangunan B\H. Off Jalan Sl'mal1an. Damansara Heights. :-0490 Kuala Lumpur. Telephone O:i2:i10Rjj (General Line), 0:i2j49222 (Operations I FaXtlti~.i9ó1Rliili~t), i'1j12~~ Ipgyt2)) (i)

10 December 1992

Thomas S. Harman, Esq. ~_"'-C"""''''''' j

Chief Counsel f~ .2(-+
Division of Investment Management

united states Securities and
Sact10n
Exchange Commission

450 Fifth street, N. W.
¡Suia i 7Ç-~(() (2) (/í) Judiciary Plaza !PubliC' Washington, D. C. 20549 !,¡v.;ilabll1ty S )1'5/92 united states of America '" _.... ~,.."...:
Dear Mr. Harman:

I am an American attorney acting on behalf of the Malaysian

Central Depository Sdn. Bhd. ("MCD"), a subsidiary of the Kuala

Lumpur stock Exchange ("KLSE"). The MCD requests your assurance

that it qualifies as an eligible foreign custodian pursuant to

SEC Rule 17f-5(c) (2) (iii), 17 C.F.R. 270.17f-5(c) (2) (iii),

promulgated under the Investment Company Act of 1940, 15 U.S.C.

§ 80a-1 et seq. (lithe 1940 Act"), and that the Division of

Investment Management ("the Di vision") will not recommend that

the Commission take any enforcement action under section 17 (f) of

the 1940 Act, 15 U.S.C. § 80a-17(f), or Rule 17f-5 thereunder, if

the MCD acts as an eligible foreign custodian for securities

listed on the KLSE.

j
The KLSE is Malaysia's only securities exchange, and there is no

over-the-counter market. When fully operational, the MCD will be

both a clearing agency and the only central securities depository

for securities listed on the KLSE. As such, the MCD will operate

"the" central system for handling of book-entry securities

transfers in Malaysia (except for certain Malaysian federal

government bonds and mortgage securities transferred by a book-

entry system administered by Bank Negara Malaysia, the Malaysian

central bank).

We believe that this request is factually and legally

indistinguishable from that of the Mexican central depository,

S.D. Indev?l, S.A. de C.V. ("Indevaili).1 In that case, the

See No-Action Request of S.D. Indeval, S.A. de C.V.

(Mexico), Response of the Office of Chief Counsel, Division of

Investment Management, Ref. No. 90-448-CC (Oct. 19, 1990) ("Indeval

Division found that Indeval operated lithe" central system for handling of securities or equivalent book entries in Mexico,

despite the fact that the Mexican central bank operated a book-

entry system for transferring certain Mexican government securities. Background The KLSE

The KLSE is the only stock exchange in Malaysia, one of the

fastest-growing economies in the world with annual GDP growth

rates of nearly 9% over the last five years.2 The U.S.-based

International Finance corporation has rated the KLSE as one of

the world's top five emerging securities markets based on market

capitalization, which has climbed steadily from US $ 52.7 billion

at year-end 1990 to US $ 79.8 billion at the end of August 1992.3

From having only four brokers at its inception in 1960, the KLSE

by year-end 1991 boasted 54 member brokers and 324 listed

companies with a nominal paid-up capital of almost US $ 17 billion.4 The KLSE operates a "Main Board" for companies with a minimum

capitalization of US $ 8 million and a "Second Board" for

companies with a minimum capitalization of US $ 2 million.5

Matching of trades was computerized on May 15, 1989.6 Now, with

the advent of a scripless trading system designed to boost

trading volume and eliminate the problems of lost scrips,

forgeries or registration delays, the KLSE is poised to become an

even more attractive capital market for U. s. investment

companies.
No-Action Letter") .
2 "Country Outlook: Malaysia," Bank of America World

Information Services (May 1992), at p. 1.
3 Ministry of Finance Malaysia, Economic Report 1992/93

(1992) at p. 265.

4 Id. at pp. 264-65.

5 Id. at p. 263.

6 Id.

'
The MCD and MCD Nominees

The MCD is a private company incorporated under the Companies Act

1965 (Act 125) and regulated by the Malaysian government7

pursuant to the Securities Industry (Central Depositories) Act,

1991 (Act 453) ( "the Centra i Depos i tor ies Act"), annexed hereto as Exhibit A.8 The KLSE is the MCD's controlling shareholder,

owning 55% of its voting stock. The Association of Banks

Malaysia owns another 25% and a government foundation the

remaining 20%.

Malaysian Central Depository Nominees Sdn. Bhd. ("MCD Nominees")

is a wholly-owned subsidiary of the MCD which acts as custodian

for deposited securities and as bare trustee for the depositors.9

At present, the MCD's activities are limited to the establishment

of securities accounts (hereinafter "MCD accounts") with

deposi tors. In mid-February 1993, the MCD will start to operate

the central Depository System ("CDS"), a book-entry system for

the transfer of "prescribed securities" -- Le., securities

listed or proposed to be listed for quotation on the Official

List of the KLSE. 10

with respect to such "prescribed" securities, the primary

purposes of the CDS will be (1) to immobilize and take custody of

scrips, and (2) to provide book-entry clearance and settlement of trades. The CDS will operate as follows: The KLSE will prescribe that a

security which is listed or proposed to be listed on the Exchange

be deposited with the MCD.11 The prescribed security cannot be

traded on the KLSE until the investor deposits the scrip

representing it, along with the instrument of transfer, in an MCD

account or with a stockbroker who is an "authorized depository

7 See "Legal Analysis," infra.
8 The Central Depositories Act became effective by publication in the Gazette on July 15, 1992.

9 See Rules of the Malaysian Central Depository Sdn. Bhd.

("MCD Rules") 6.12 & Appendix I, "The Memorandum of Association of

the Malaysian Central Depository Nominees Sdn. Bhd."

io Central Depositories Act § 14; MCD Rules 6.01, 6.02, 1.01

(def ining "prescr ibed secur i ties" ) & 2 7 . 0 1 . 11 Central Depositories Act § 14; MCD Rules 18.01 & 27.01.

agent" of the MCD.12 The MCD or its authorized depository agent

then will lodge the scrip and the instrument with the issuer.13

within seven market days, the issuer will (where appropriate)

validate the scrip by confirming that it is genuine and capable

of being transferred to MCD Nominees. 14 The issuer also will

certify the instrument of transfer as having been lodged for

registration in the name of MCD Nominees. The issuer then will

cancel the physical scrip and issue to the MCD appropriate

replacement certificates,15 known as "jumbo certificates,"

representing large numbers of deposited securities of a given

class or series of an issuer. 16 Using the CDS computers, the

MCD, acting on the issuer's instructions, will designate the

validated securities in the depositor's MCD account as being

"free," i. e., capable of being traded. 17

Thus, original scrip will be taken out of circulation and

cancelled, and the jumbo certificates on deposit with the MCD

will become the only remaining physical representations of traded

securities, which thenceforth will be treated as fungible.18 It

is these jumbo certificates that will remain in the physical

custody of the MCD.

Subsequently, al 1 transactions in connection with the securities

will be effected by CDS, an electronic book-entry system which

treats as fungible all securities of a given class or series of

an issuer, rendering physical transfer of the deposited scrips

12 Central Depositories Act § 17 (1). The MCD derives its

statutory power to appoint authorized depository agents from

Central Depositories Act § 13, and the procedures for appointment

and suspe~sion of such agents are set forth in MCD Rules Chapters

2.0 & 3. OJ. The MCD also may appoint "authorized direct members,"

large institutional investors who do not have to go through an

author ized depository agent to effect their trades in the CDS. MCD

Rules Chapter 14.0.
13 Central Depositories Act § 18 (1) .
14 Id. § 18 (3) & (4); MCD Rule 18.03.
15 Central Depositories Act § 18(4) & (7).
16 Id. §§ 11 (defining "jumbo certificates"), 20 & 63 (p).

17 MCD Rule 18.03 (2) .
18 Should the investor wish to withdraw the scrip, the MCD

will issue him new scrip for a fee. MCD Rules Part VII.

19 unnecessary.
In a typical KLSE trade between different depositors, the

authorized depository agent will submit to the MCD computerized

instructions detailing the trade in question, including the

identity and quantity of securities and the account number of the

buyer.2o Within five market days of the sale date, and after the

computer system confirms that the seller's MCD account actually

contains the securities being transferred,21 the securities will

be transferred electronically to the buyer's MCD account and

"earmarked" as being "under suspense" pending confirmation of

payment from the buyer's broker. n After seven market days, the

MCD will assume such payment has been made unless it receives a

computerized message to the contrary. 23 At that time, the MCD

will redesignate the transferred securities electronically as

"free securities" in the buyer's MCD account.24

The CDS will facilitate and record all transactions in connection

wi th prescribed securities, including: on-market and off￾market25 transfers between MCD accounts of the same26 and

differentV depositors; public offers28; bonus issues, rights

issues and other rights or options29; and share splits,

consolidations and capital restructurings. 30 The system also

will provide Pledged Securities Accounts for securities which

have been pledged, charged, mortgaged or otherwise encumbered by

19 Central Depositories Act § 29; MCD Rule 10.05(1). 20 See generally ide 10.05. 21 If the account contains insufficient securities to effect the transfer, automatic buying-in will occur. MCD Rules Chapter

11.0.
22 rd. 10.05(3) .
23 Id. 10.06(1) .
24 Id.
25 Central Depos i tor i es Act § 31.
26 MCD Rules Chapter 8.0.
27 rd. Chapter 9.0.
28 Id. Chapter 20.0.
29 Id. Chapter 21. O.
30 Id. Chapter 22.0.

any depositor in favor of the account holder. 31

Cash settlement between the KLSE and member brokers acting as

authorized depository agents will be done through the KLSE in accordance with its rules. n Bank Neqara Malavsia33 Bank Negara Malaysia ("Bank Negara") is the Malaysian Central

Bank. It operates a system known as sistem Pemindahan Elektronik

untuk Dana dan Sekuriti ("SPEEDS") for book-entry trading and

funds transfer between member banks in connection with certain

non-prescribed Malaysian federal government securities and

mortgage securities which are not traded on the KLSE.

SPEEDS has two components:

(1) a Scripless Securities Trading System ("SSTS") to

effect and record the trading of Malaysian Government

papers and Cagamas (mortgage) bonds between

participating banks, or between those banks and Bank

Negara, as well as the associated settlement of

payments; and

(2) an Inter Bank Funds Transfer System (" IFTS") to

effect and record transfers of funds between Bank

Negara and the participating banks, or among the

participating banks.

SPEEDS governs trading .only of a limited group of government

securi ties: Malaysian Government Securities; Cagamas bonds,

Malaysian Government Treasury Bills, Government Investment

Certificates and Bank Negara Malaysia certificates (collectively,

"SSTS Securities"). None of the SSTS Securities are listed on

the KLSE. Thus, there is no overlap at all between the

securi ties handled by the MCD and those handled by Bank Negara.

31 Central Depositories Act § 40; MCD Rules 26.08 & 33.04. 32 MCD Rule 10.11.

33 The source of the information in this section is the Code of Conduct and Market Practices for Scripless Trading in the

Malavsian Securities Market (Bank Negara Malaysia, undated), at pp.

1-2.

Legal Analysis

The MCD Is an Eliqible Foreiqn custodian

Rule 17f-5(a) provides that a u.s. investment company which is

registered under the 1940 Act "may place and maintain in the care

of an eligible foreign custodian the company's foreign

securities, cash and cash equivalents in amounts reasonably

necessary to effect the company's foreign securities

transactions ( . ) ,,34 Rule 1 7f-5 (c) (2) (iii) defines "eligible

foreign custodian" as

(a) securities depository or clearing agency, incorporated or organized under the laws of a country

other than the united states, which operates the

central system for handling of securities or equivalent

book-entries in that country ( . ) We will show that the MCD meets all of the requirements of this

def ini tion as it has been interpreted by the Division in previous no-action requests. The MCD is a Securities Depository and Clearinq Aqency . Although

the 1940 Act does not define the term, the MCD clearly is a

"securities depository" within the ordinary meaning of those

words. As discussed above, no security can be traded on the KLSE

unless the "jumbo certificate" which constitutes the sole

surviving physical representation of that security has first been

deposited with the MCD for safekeeping.

The MCD also is a "clearing agency" because it operates as a

custodian for a book-entry system for the central handling of

securities in which all deposited securities of a particular

class or series of an issuer are treated as fungible and may be

transferrèd without physical delivery of the scrips. As such, it

falls squ¡9rely within the definition of "clearing agency" which

the Division has adopted for these purposes. 35

34 (Emphasis added).

35 That definition, contained in section 3 (a) (23) (A) of the

Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. § 78c(a) (23) (A), defines "clearing agency" as

any person who acts as an intermediary in making payments

or deliveries or both in connection with transactions in

securi ties or who provides facilities for the comparison ; of data respecting the terms of settlement of securities transactions, to reduce the number of settlements of

securi ties transactions, or for the allocation of

securi ties settlement responsibilities. Such term also

The Men is Incorporated and Orqanized under the Laws of Malavsia.

The MCD is incorporated under the companies Act 1965 and

permission to operate the depository was granted by the Minister

of Finance pursuant to the Central Depositories Act §§ 3-5.

The Malaysian government extensively regulates the MCD. 36 The

Central Depositories Act, §§ 3-7, 36 and 63, confers vast

regulatory powers upon the Minister of Finance. Those sections

permit the Minister to, inter alia:

Approve or deny applications to establish a

central depositoryD (a factor the Division

appeared to consider relevant in the Indeval

case) ;38

Approve or disapprove any amendments to the MCD's

Rules; 39

Dictate whether and under what circumstances the

MCD may act as principal in connection with

means any person, such as a securities depository, who

(i) acts as a custodian of securities in connection with

a system for the central handling of securities whereby

aii securities of a particular class or series of any issuer deposited wi thin the system are treated as fung ible and may be transferred, loaned, or pledged by bookkeeping entry without physical delivery of securities

certificates, or (ii) otherwise permits or facilitates the settlement of securities transactions or the hypothecation or lending of securities without physical delivery of securities certificates. 36 We note that, in processing recent no-action applications under Rule 17f-5, the Division has found it "useful to consider

whether and to what extent a foreign government operates or

regulates the foreign securities depository or clearing agency(.)"

Hong Kong Securities Clearing Co. Ltd. No-Action Request, Response

of the Office of Chief Counsel , Division of Investment Management,

Ref. No. 92-170-CC (Sept. 8, 1992), at p. 4 n.7; Reserve Bank of

Australia No-Action Request, Response of the Office of Chief

Counsel, Division of Investment Management, Ref. No. 92-47-CC

(Sept. 2, 1992), at p. 4 n. 10.

37 Central Depositories Act §§ 3-5.
38 Indeval No-Action Letter at pp. 1-2.
39 Central Depositories Act § 7.

I
I ~ MALAYSIAN CENTRAL DEPOSITORY SDN BHD transactions regarding a deposited security;~

Make "such regulations as may be necessary or

expedient for carrying out or achieving the

objects and purposes of" the Central Depositories

Act,41 including , without limitation, regulations

(a) prescribing forms for the purposes of the Central Depository Act;

(b) prescribing fees to be paid in respect

of any matter or thing required for

purposes of the Act;

(c) prescribing the manner and form in which

MCD accounts are to be opened,

maintained or closed by the MCD and its

authorized depository agents, including the manner of making entries in such

accounts;
(d) prescribing the circumstances when a

deposited security in a securities

account may be specif ied by the MCD as

being in suspense;

(e) regulating the appointment of authorized

deposi tory agents and nominee companies

and the imposition of duties,

obligations and sanctions on such agents

and companies;

(f) regulating the setting-up and operation

of the computer system including

computer terminals which form part of

such system;

(g) regulating the manner in which deposited

securities shall be kept for safe

custody by the MCD;

(h) regulating all matters relating to the

deposit of unlisted securities with the

MCD and its authorized depository

40 Id. § 36.
41 Id. § 63.

MALAYSIAN CENTRAL DEPOSITORY SDN BHD , r agents ;42 (i) prescribing other purposes for which the MCD may appoint authorized depository

agents;
(j) prescribing the types of bodies

corporate which may be appointed to act

as authorized depository agents;

(k) regulating the activities of, and the

standards to be maintained by, the MCD

and its authorized depository agents;

(I) prescribing the time and manner in which

statements of account shall be issued by

the MCD to its depositors;

(m) prescribing the manner in which records

shall be kept and maintained by the MCD,

its authorized depository agents and MCD

Nominees under the Act;

(n) prescribing the purposes for which, and the manner in which, the Registrar may

conduct a stock count of scrips held in

custody by or in the name of the MCD or

MCD Nominees;

(0) prescribing all matters relating to the

maintenance of insurances, and the

establishment and maintenance of

compensation funds, by the MCD, MCD

Nominees and authorized depository f..j agents for the purpose of settling claims by depositors against them;

(p) matters relating to te issuance of jumbo certificates; (q) prescribing such other persons who may

have access to the computer system of

the MCD;

(r) prescr ibing the extent to which any user

or class of users may have access to the

42 Notwi thstanding the Minister's power to permit the deposit or unlisted securities, the MCD's rules do not permit such

deposi ts to be made (MCD Rule 6.02) and there is no intention to

alter that policy.

, , MALAYSIAN CENTRAL DEPOSITORY SDN BHD computer system of the MCD;

(s) matters relating to linkages between the MCD and other securities depositories

established outside Malaysia; and

(t) all matters or things which are required by the Act or permitted to be prescribed

or which are necessary or expedient to gi ve effect to the Act. sections 10, 28, 53-54, 56-57 and 60-61 confer various regulatory

powers upon Malaysia's Registrar of Companies. Those sections

require the MCD, MCD Nominees (and numerous other persons) to produce their depository-related or statutorily-required business records to the Registrar upon demand;~ require the MCD, its authorized depository agent, or any depositor, to furnish information about the parties and accounts involved in specific securities transactions;M require the MCD to provide all reasonable assistance to the Registrar in performing his regulatory duties, including giving him full access to its premises ;45 require the MCD to submit a quarterly inventory of deposited stock scrips, which the Registrar may audi t independently if he finds the report unsatisfactory ;~ authorize the Registrar, to investigate "as he thinks expedient" any person suspected of violating or preparing to violate the Act;47 authorize the Registrar, where he suspects that the Act is being violated, to enter and search the premises of the MCD or any user and to seize any 43 Id. § 53. M Id. § 56. 45 Id. § 10. 46 Id. § 28. 47 rd. § 57.

evidence of such violation;a

demand payment of fines in lieu of instituting a prosecution under the Act;fi and criminally prosecute violators of the Act. 50

Numerous sections of the Central Depositories Act create criminal

penal ties for violations of the Act or for impeding the Minister

and the Registrar in their efforts to enforce compliance with it.

section 58 confers jurisdiction on the High Court to enter

various orders in connection with alleged violations of the Act.

The MCD Operates "the" Central System for the Handlinq of

Securities or Equivalent Book-Entries in Malavsia. with the

exception of the Bank Negara book-entry system described above,

the MCD operates the only central system for the handling of

securities or equivalent book-entries in Malaysia. It handles

all the securities listed on the KLSE, which is the only stock

exchange in Malaysia. There is no over-the-counter market.

The existence of the Bank Negara system presents no obstacle to

granting the MCD' s no-action request. In the Indeval case, the

Division determined on the basis of the facts presented to it

that Indeval, the Mexican central depository, was "the" central

system for the handling of book-entries in Mexico. In that case,

as here,

Indeval recorded transfers of securities through a

book-entry system;

all securities traded on the nation's only stock

exchange were deposited with Indeval;

no over-the-counter market existed; Indeval handled all publicly-traded securities in

Mexico (with the exception of certain government

securities ("CETES") cleared by a book-entry

system operated by the Mexican central bank);

Indeval kept all deposited securities in its own vaults. 48 Id. § 54. 49 Id. § 60. 50 Id. § 61.

r MALAYSIAN CENTRAL DEPOSITORY SDN BHD The final paragraph of the Division's no-action letter stated

that the Division had placed particular reliance upon Indeval' s

representation that "Indeval is both a clearing agency and the

only central securities depository for securities of Mexican

issuers and, as such, operates the central system (for handling

of securities or equivalent book-entries in Mexico) (except for

certain Mexican Government securities)". 51 That representation

equally describes the instant case. Accordingly, we believe that

the MCD is an eligible foreign custodian under Rule 17f￾5(c) (2) (iii).

If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact

me at the following telephone numbers (bearing in mind that

Malaysia is twelve hours ahead of Washington).

Home: 60-3-756-9750
Off ice: 60-3-757-1066 or -1236; extension 231

Office Fax: 60-3-757-3239

Thank you for your patient consideration of this request.

Sincerely yours,

• / l

~~/, Jf-: l
ßji 75_;.~ (/ ) steven A. Hirsch

Member of the Bars of

New York, Washington, D. C.

and Connecticut
.,
"-.
51 Indeval No-Action Letter at p. 2 (footnotes omitted).